working with private sector to deliver energy …...working with private sector to deliver energy...
TRANSCRIPT
Working with Private Sector to Deliver Energy Savings in Manufacturing
1st October 2015
Agenda
› Background to the Carbon Trust
› UK Industrial Emissions and Key Drivers for Energy Efficiency
› Industrial Energy Efficiency Programme
2
Agenda
› Background to the Carbon Trust
› UK Industrial Emissions and Key Drivers for Energy Efficiency
› Industrial Energy Efficiency Programme
3
The Carbon Trust has accelerated sustainable, low carbon development for more than 13 years
4
Advice Footprinting Technology
We advise businesses, governments and the public sector on opportunities in a sustainable, low carbon economy
We measure and certify the environmental footprint of organisations, products and services
We help develop and deploy low carbon technologies and solutions, from energy efficiency to renewable power
By leveraging the Carbon Trust’s integrated service offering , we have Helped our clients save £4.5bn and 47m tons of CO2
Catalysed over £300m of investment into low carbon technologies and businesses
Agenda
› Background to the Carbon Trust
› UK Industrial Emissions and Key Drivers for Energy Efficiency
› Industrial Energy Efficiency Programme
5
UK Total emissions from industry are c.190Mt. 51% comes from the most emitting industries, but other industries are still important
Note: 1 Consists of direct process emissions, combustion and electricity emissions, and non-energy use of fuels .2 The DUKES analysis used for the data above uses a narrow definition of steel related emissions which does not include the emissions related to sintering and coking. In the analysis in this report we have used a broader definition and hence emissions are greater than those shown here for steel.
Source: Digest Of UK Energy Statistics (DUKES), Office of National Statistics' Purchases Inquiry (PI)
% CO2 emissions
% CO2 emissions
18% 9% 7% 4% 2%5% 5% 1%
c 51%
49%
Mid-energy intense industries have fewer drivers to deploy energy efficiency measures
› Energy efficiency can help increase competitiveness
Mid Energy Sectors
High Energy Sectors › Energy efficiency can help increase competitiveness
› High cost of energy (as a % of product cost)› EU ETS requirements› Energy managers and directors in place
Drivers Barriers
› Energy costs low (2% and 5% of product cost) › Limited understanding of process specific
energy use› Lack knowledge of innovative energy efficiency
measures› Policy measures that impact them (CCA, CRC)
will not drive investment
› High investment in capital with 20+ year life› Risk averse industries less willing to deploy new
solutions› Retrofit opportunities have less impact on
reducing CO2
Agenda
› Background to the Carbon Trust
› UK Industrial Emissions and Key Drivers for Energy Efficiency
› Industrial Energy Efficiency Programme
8
A £15m Industrial Energy Efficiency Accelerator (IEEA) set up to identify near market innovation to reduce energy use.
Investigation and Solution Identification
Demonstration
Replication
Examination of specific processes in depth to understand energy use and interfaces with other systems.
Demonstration of the cost-effectiveness and carbon saving potential of innovations, such as equipment upgrades and process optimisation.
Dissemination of best practicesthroughout the industry sector.
Identification of solutions that improve energy efficiency based on this investigation.
Engage with key influencers in industry to overcome barriers to adoption of innovations.
x 14 sectors
1 2
3
9
100% Government Funded
40% ‐ 60% Government Funded
100% Government Funded
We worked with 14 sectors with a range of emissions
10Total carbon footprint of 14 sectors is over 12 MtCO2
Sector Annual emissions(estimation in 2010)
Paper 4,700,000 tCO2
Contract Catering 1,300,000 tCO2
Bricks 1,000,000 tCO2
Dairy 860,000 tCO2
Asphalt 830,000 tCO2
Microelectronics 710,000 tCO2
Animal Feeds 620,000 tCO2
Industrial Bakery 570,000 tCO2
Metalforming 450,000 tCO2
Brewing 450,000 tCO2
Plastic Bottle Blow Moulding 400,000 tCO2
Malting 340,000 tCO2
Laundries 280,000 tCO2
Confectionery Stoving 60,000 tCO2
Collaboration was key, with 100 manufacturers, trade associations, equipment suppliers and start-ups involved
11
Manufacturers Equipment Suppliers and Start‐ups
Trade Associations, Academia and Consultancies
Stage 1
Each of the 14 sectors presented with massive opportunities for innovative energy reduction
Opportunities in Animal Feeds Cost / Plant
Payback Sector CO2Savings (t)
Active Energy Management £30,000 < 1 year 30,000Collecting, analysing and reporting comprehensive energy management informationProcess Optimisation £10,000 1 year 20,000Sophisticated analysis leading to optimisation of process parametersMoisture Control £30,000 < 1 year 5,000Advanced moisture control systems to improve moisture level
Energy Efficient Formulations £30,000 < 2 years 30,000
Choose formulations to minimise raw material cost and energy cost to process
Energy Efficient Presses £100,000 4 years 10,000
Newer energy efficiency models claim energy savings of 25%
EquipmentInnovation
Product Innovation
Process Innovation
12
Stage 1
13
But even best practices are not being deployed (shown in green for the Dairy sector)
Over 150 best practice opportunities yet to be fully deployed
Stage 1
0%
10%
20%
30%
40%
50%
Min Max
Sector Carbo
n Savings
Potential
Average energy savings of 29% identified, totalling 3-4mtCO2
14
"Good Practice"
"Innovation"
Stage 1
18%
11%
Average
4 sectors with 5 projects that are in demonstration phase
Asphalt/AggregatesDevelopment of low temperature asphaltsHybrid turbocharger for quarry vehicles
Animal feedOptimising formulations for energy efficiency
DairiesUse of ice pigging for cleaning pipes
BakeriesImproved combustion efficiency and heat recovery
Dissemination and replicationTechnical case studiesStandards & specificationsSite visitsBest practice guidesIndustry steering group & roadmapArticles in trade press
15
Stage 2 and 3
Lead Organisation: Lafarge Tarmac
Partners: Nynas, Atkins, MIRO, TRL
Project Cost: £620k
Carbon Trust Funding: £275k
Project Objective › Hot mix asphalt is generally produced at 180°C
› Develop low carbon asphalt (90°C) through demonstration of the technical viability in situ
Status› Project demonstrated on a road in England› Specification now developed so that local authorities
can use in procurement tenders› Estimated Savings: £46m over 10 years (assumes 20%
adoption in 10 years (from 1% today) › Estimated UK CO2 savings: 246,000 tonnes over 10
years (equivalent of taking 345,0001 cars off the road for 1 year)
Note 1: Assuming average car drives 5,000km/year
Lefarge Tarmac project on Low Temperature Asphalt is complete and a technical specification produced
Case Study
A number of high level findings emerged from the IEEA
› Wide collaboration with trade associations and the sector enables the greatest chance of wide sector replication
› The innovations require projects to be financially de‐risked in order for companies to consider deploying them as they are as yet unproven
› Equipment suppliers are often willing to share the risk of deploying new technology to benefit from future sales
› Total energy savings potential of over £150m annually across 14 sectors
17