willis re 1st vie...for over 100 years, willis re has proudly served its clients, helping them...

11
of WILLIS RE 1ST VIEW RUNNING ON EMPTY 1 JULY 2010

Upload: others

Post on 11-Jun-2020

0 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: willis re 1sT vie...For over 100 years, Willis Re has proudly served its clients, helping them obtain better value solutions and make better reinsurance decisions. As one of the world’s

� of ��

willis re1sT view

rUNNiNG ON eMPTY

1 JULY 2010

Page 2: willis re 1sT vie...For over 100 years, Willis Re has proudly served its clients, helping them obtain better value solutions and make better reinsurance decisions. As one of the world’s

� of ��

TABle OF CONTeNTsRENEWALS – 1 JULY 2010Introduction 3Casualty

Territory and Comments 4Rates 5

Specialties Line of Business and Comments 6Rates 7

PropertyTerritory and Comments 8Rates 9Rate Graphs 10

Workers’ Compensation Comments 11Rates 11

1ST VIEWThis thrice yearly publication delivers the very first view on current market conditions to our readers. In addition to real-time Event Reports, our clients receive our daily news brief, Willis Re Rise ’ n shinE, periodic newsletters, white papers and other reports.

WILLIS REGlobal resources, local delivery For over 100 years, Willis Re has proudly served its clients, helping them obtain better value solutions and make better reinsurance decisions. As one of the world’s premier global reinsurance brokers, with 43 locations worldwide, Willis Re provides local service with the full backing of an integrated global reinsurance broker.

© Copyright 2010 Willis Limited / Willis Re Inc. All rights reserved: No part of this publication may be reproduced, stored in a retrieval system, or transmitted in any form or by any means, whether electronic, mechanical, photocopying, recording, or otherwise, without the permission of Willis Limited / Willis Re Inc. Some information contained in this report may be compiled from third party sources we consider to be reliable; however, we do not guarantee and are not responsible for the accuracy of such. This report is for general guidance only, is not intended to be relied upon, and action based on or in connection with anything contained herein should not be taken without first obtaining specific advice. The views expressed in this report are not necessarily those of the Willis Group. Willis Limited / Willis Re Inc. accepts no responsi-bility for the content or quality of any third party websites to which we refer. Willis Limited, a Lloyd’s broker is authorized and regulated by the Financial Services Authority.

Page 3: willis re 1sT vie...For over 100 years, Willis Re has proudly served its clients, helping them obtain better value solutions and make better reinsurance decisions. As one of the world’s

� of ��

rUNNiNG ON eMPTYThe prediction we made after the 1st April 2010 review – that one poor quarter would not be sufficient to drive any general market turn – has proven to be correct. The recent 1st June and 1st July renewals continued the pattern set at the 1st January and 1st April 2010 renewals, namely, a continued gradual decline in pricing, with only a handful of loss-driven classes and territories showing any pricing stability or upwards pricing pressure.

Competition remains fierce with substantial capacity chasing premium volume in many lines of business. This is true most particularly in areas of perceived diversifying risk, such as the Middle East. Casualty pricing remains generally soft and rates continue to decline, though with some territorial variability. The Chile Earthquake and Australia Storm losses, together with other minor catastrophe losses, are probably sufficient to erode the entire 2010 (excluding the U.S.) catastrophe excess of loss premium base. Despite this, in Property catastrophe lines, there have been no general market moves to increase prices. Only Chilean-specific renewals have seen rate increases, between +40% to +70%, driven entirely by loss activity.

With the losses of 2008 now a distant memory, U.S. Property catastrophe excess of loss renewals performed as expected. Buyers achieved significant rate reductions, particularly in Florida, where reinsurance markets treated the better capitalized and more geographically diversified accounts to substantial rate reductions, as high as 25%. However, reinsurers did place added emphasis on the finances of Florida companies due to performance issues in 2009, and it should be noted that there remains a price tipping point below which placements struggle.

In recognition of excess capital, some companies are redistributing their capital through share buy backs and special dividends, but at the same time, major M&A activity remains muted. A number of reasons for this have been proposed. These include unattractive pricing, current low share price multiples reducing the currency of potential acquirers and uncertainties about the impact of Solvency II and other emerging regulation on companies’ capital structures. Whatever the reasons, market hardening resulting from a reduced number of players is not happening.

Reinsurance capacity from capital markets is gradually increasing and the products being structured are increasingly attractive for issuers, both in terms of coverage and pricing. While capital markets are an important diversifying source of risk-hedging capacity for primary companies and a more important capacity source in retrocession markets, the drive for the current softening cycle cannot solely be laid at the doors of capital market investors in ILS products. This can be seen in certain segments, such as the Industry Loss Warranties (ILW) market for U.S. wind where catastrophe bond purchasing has actually reduced available investor capacity. While U.S. wind catastrophe bond pricing seems to have plateaued at the new level, ILS investors are still keen for sponsors to bring diversifying (i.e., non-U.S. wind) risk to the market. The continued downward pressure on catastrophe bond pricing for these other risks may result in relatively more catastrophe bond deals without U.S. wind later this year.

The trio of down cycle drivers, namely, excess capital, stable investment returns and limited growth prospects, continues to weave its magic, obscuring hidden dangers lurking in the quarters ahead. Barring any major industry event which removes a considerable part of the excess capital, it seems that the global reinsurance market is unlikely to see any rating upturn in the near future. In fact, there is a growing nervousness that the longer the wait for any upturn, the more abrupt it will be when it eventually arrives. While not wishing to tempt fate, looking at the current projections of the number and intensity of third and fourth quarter 2010 North Atlantic Hurricanes from a wide spectrum of academic and meteorological organizations, the market upturn may arrive sooner than expected.

Peter C. HearnChief Executive Officer, Willis Re30 June, 2010

Page 4: willis re 1sT vie...For over 100 years, Willis Re has proudly served its clients, helping them obtain better value solutions and make better reinsurance decisions. As one of the world’s

� of ��

CAsUAlTYTERRIToRY ANd CommENTSAUSTRALIA – GENERAL / EmPLoYERS / PRofESSIoNAL LIABILITY

Notwithstanding some loss activity in Professional Lines business, there remains significant capacity for casualty business in the Australian and New Zealand markets. Initial quotations saw considerable variance. Most placements have been well supported, once pricing has been established. Those clients prepared to re-cycle their panel of reinsurers were generally able to obtain better terms. The benefits to buyers of subscription placements were visible this renewal. Once firm order pricing was determined and fixed, most reinsurers were prepared to follow their position.

CARIBBEAN – AUTo / moToR LIABILITY Reinsurers are maintaining price discipline, with only minor reductions in Motor liability excess of loss.

ChINA – GENERAL / EmPLoYERS / PRofESSIoNAL LIABILITYAbundant capacity is available for Chinese Liabililty business. Pricing has increased, but not to the same extent as underlying exposures, so buyers enjoyed risk-adjusted rate reductions.

UNITEd STATES – GENERAL / EmPLoYERS LIABILITYRenewal capacity for most lines of casualty with good loss records remains plentiful. Reinsurers are concentrating on supporting the core covers of companies with consistent buying patterns across the entire market cycle.Placements for new buyers can still find some capacity, though at higher prices with less favorable ceding commissions and tighter terms and conditions.Some Speciality General Liability and Umbrella portfolios have shown loss emergence from the “hard market” years. This, combined with rate decreases, is making the placement of pro rata treaties at reasonable commission terms extremely difficult.Existing Umbrella and Excess Casualty placements are still able to gain support, provided there has not been any meaningful loss activity and renewal as expiring has been achieved for programs running well. For placements with worse than anticipated results, reinsurers have been seeking to drive improvements, but with mixed success.New Umbrella and Excess Casualty placements are able to find support, provided the management team have a proven track record and a credible business plan. For both new and renewal programs, the key remains the ability of buyers to demonstrate how their approach to the current soft market is differentiated from their peers’.Some slippage in reinsurance terms and conditions has been seen, but not on a comparable basis to prior soft markets.Larger carriers are not following the pattern of prior soft markets and are not buying down their retentions, leaving them operating largely unhedged, despite primary market conditions.Those pro rata programs running at or better than expected achieved renewal ceding commissions as expiring to possibly a 1% point increase along with some minor improvements to contractual terms and conditions. Programs performing worse than expected in some cases saw their ceding commission reduced anywhere from 1% to 5% points. Excess of loss – risk exposed programs running at or better than expected saw renewal rates as expiring to possibly -5%. Programs running worse than expected saw rate increases of 5% to 20%. Excess of loss – catastrophe loss-free programs experienced premium reductions of -5% to -10%. Programs with losses saw premium increases up to 10%.

▀▀▀

▀▀

Page 5: willis re 1sT vie...For over 100 years, Willis Re has proudly served its clients, helping them obtain better value solutions and make better reinsurance decisions. As one of the world’s

� of ��

UNITEd STATES – PRofESSIoNAL LIABILITYNew capacity has fueled reduced pricing on original D&O / E&O business in the second quarter. Treaties are renewing as expiring with reinsurance capacity relatively constant.

RATES XL – No Loss XL – With Loss Pro Rata Emergence EmergenceTERRIToRY Commission % Change % Change

Australia – General / Employers / Professional Liability N/A 0% to -10% 0%

Caribbean – Auto / motor Liability 0% -5% Loss Dependent

China – General / Employers / Professional Liability N/A -10% N/A

South Africa – General / Professional Liability N/A 0% +10%

United States – General / Employers Liability 0% to -5% 0% to -5% +5% to +20%

United States – Professional Liability 0% 0% N/A

▀▀

Page 6: willis re 1sT vie...For over 100 years, Willis Re has proudly served its clients, helping them obtain better value solutions and make better reinsurance decisions. As one of the world’s

� of ��

sPeCiAlTiesLINE of BUSINESS ANd CommENTSENGINEERING – GLoBAL

Reinsurance market remains under pressure to improve treaty terms and conditions. New market entrants are increasing pressure for business, both in the reinsurance and direct arenas. There is pressure to increase scope of cover on original business, but deductible levels remain firm. Kleen Energy (current estimate US $150M) and Qatar Petroleum (current estimate US $80M) losses have had minimal effect on market terms. Volume of new project business is expected to pick up later in the year.

hEALThCARE – UNITEd STATESLoss frequency continues to remain at historically low levels. Severity trend is evident, but again, at relatively low levels. There is an increasing number of challenges to state-by-state tort reform and less optimism that all of these reforms will be upheld.There continues to be a migration of physicians into hospital employed / owned practices. Should frequency and severity maintain current trend levels, then the industry can expect a continuation in reserve releases, which will continue to suppress the current rating environment.

mARINE ANd ENERGY – GLoBALMarine, excluding Energy, pricing is now flat, compared to small reduction at 1st January. Retro market is now looking at increased pricing, following loss activity over the past six months. Marine and Energy Industry Loss Warranties pricing increased by approximately 60% following “Deepwater Horizon” loss. Reinsurers now require greater transparency on liability exposure when rating energy-exposed business. Gulf of Mexico wind coverage is available, but percieved as expensive, and there is therefore limited take up.

mEdICAL EXCESS – UNITEd STATESHealthcare reform’s removal of annual and lifetime maximums has sparked significant interest in higher excess reinsurance. Numerous reinsurers are offering unlimited coverage as a result.Medical writers are now buying up to $20M / $25M, up from approximately $5M previously.

NoN-mARINE RETRoCESSIoNTrue worldwide capacity continues to be offered by only a limited number of reinsurers, but pricing is off approximately 7.5% year-on-year for all retrocession business. The effects of the Chile earthquake have not yet been felt, but it is clear that some retrocession programs will be impacted. While the general position in the market has been that retentions have increased and there is more than enough capacity, the last few weeks have seen increased interest in buying. Early signs are that results will be impacted by losses this year and this should have a stabilizing effect on price. The flurry of U.S. wind-exposed Catastrophe Bonds being brought to market at pricing 30% to 40% below last spring / summer has soaked up non-traditional capacity that may have otherwise been deployed in the ILW / Retrocessional marketplace. This, combined with the worst half year for loss activity on record and predictions of an active U.S. Hurricane season, has caused a

▀▀

▀▀▀

▀▀

▀▀▀

▀▀

Page 7: willis re 1sT vie...For over 100 years, Willis Re has proudly served its clients, helping them obtain better value solutions and make better reinsurance decisions. As one of the world’s

� of ��

“technical capacity squeeze” in the ILW market and contributed to approximately a 20-30% price increase for U.S. wind-exposed ILW deals. This has been evident on both a first and second event basis.

PERSoNAL ACCIdENT / LIfE CATASTRoPhE – GLoBALThere were six new entrants into the Accident / Life catastrophe reinsurance market. Softening effect on catastrophe rates is evident.

PoLITICAL RISk – GLoBALPricing remains firm with price increases related to individual reinsured’s loss experience, causing some reinsureds to retain more by way of increased deductibles. Pressure from some reinsurers to switch quota share commission structures from fixed plus profit commission to sliding scale. Frequency of new loss advices easing. Majority of previously advised losses have or are being settled. In some instances, insured recoveries have been realized. Further recoveries are expected. Even though new reinsurers are attracted to the class, capacity remains limited. Greater preference from reinsureds for pro rata protections verses excess of loss. Lloyd’s is tightening up its regulations with regards to the definition of eligible trade-related transactions.

RATES Risk Risk Cat Cat Pro Rata Loss free Loss hit Loss free Loss hitTERRIToRY Commission % Change % Change % Change % Change Engineering – Global 0% to +1% -10% 0% to +5% -10% 0% to +5%

healthcare – United States N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A marine and Energy – Global +1.5% to +2.5% 0% 0% 0% N/A

medical Excess – United States 0% +10% to +20% +20% N/A N/A Non-marine Retro N/A N/A N/A -7.5% N/A

Personal Accident / Life Catastrophe 0% -5% to -10% 0% to -5% -10% to -15% N/A Political Risk – Global 0% to -2.5% +5% to +10% +10% to +20% N/A N/A

▀▀

Page 8: willis re 1sT vie...For over 100 years, Willis Re has proudly served its clients, helping them obtain better value solutions and make better reinsurance decisions. As one of the world’s

� of ��

PrOPerTYTERRIToRY ANd CommENTSAUSTRALIA

The two large catastrophe losses in the Australian market, in Perth and Melbourne, are now generally accepted to be over AUS $1B events. There was a significant amount of capacity at renewal for catastrophe, risk and pro rata business. The catastrophe renewal was reasonably flat. On a risk-adjusted basis, rates have been flat to a small discount, even on loss-affected business. The risk renewal pricing was flat to slightly reduced and there was a willingness to increase event limits. For pro rata, there was still abundant capacity; this was reflected in slightly increased commissions being made available. The adundance of capacity has seemingly suppressed any meaningful rate increases. We have seen real advantage for buyers in subscription placements, particularly for risk and pro rata placements.

CARIBBEAN Property rates continue to come under pressure, with local markets often referring to pressure from international insurers. Overall results remain good, ensuring continued pro rata capacity. Catastrophe excess of loss rates being held to within 5% of expiring.

ChINA Capacity remains more than adaquate for the renewing catastrophe excess of loss programs. While pricing on average increased, it was not to the extent at which underlying exposures increased, leading to risk-adjusted reductions, though total premium spend increased.

LATIN AmERICAChile’s main renewal season is 1st July and the insured/reinsured loss from the 27 February 2010 event has generated a significant increase in reinsurance pricing for Chile catastrophe excess of loss contracts. Excess reinsurance capacity has kept prices in the rest of Latin America relatively flat on a true risk-adjusted basis.

mEXICo Market generally flat and not impacted by the effects of the Chilean quake. Significant capacity still exists for Mexico. None of the major reinsureds have open-market Fire and Allied Perils pro rata treaties. The natural perils quota shares have renewed unchanged.

mIddLE EAST Significant oversupply of capacity from existing and new market entrants. Pro rata reinsurers are keen on offering more commission rather than capacity. Lloyd’s underwriters are showing growing appetite for excess of loss programs from Middle East and North Africa .

UNITEd STATES – fLoRIdACapacity remained plentiful. Several reinsurers increased maximum lines on quality accounts and reduced lines on lesser quality accounts. Wide disparity in quotes due to reinsurers’ differing views on weighting of various catastrophe models in pricing and flight to quality accounts.

▀▀

▀▀

▀▀

▀▀▀

▀▀▀

▀▀

Page 9: willis re 1sT vie...For over 100 years, Willis Re has proudly served its clients, helping them obtain better value solutions and make better reinsurance decisions. As one of the world’s

� of ��

Property quota share market started to gain strength for both catastrophe-exposed and structured deals. Strong multiple year catastrophe excess market.Collateral markets provided traditional capacity, but were strong in supporting aggregate, reinstatement premium protection, and top and drop structures.

UNITEd STATES – LoNdoN mARkETCatastrophe pricing down on a risk-adjusted basis 10% to 15% in Florida. Catastrophe pricing for nationwides down less; capacity is tight. Risk pricing off 5% to 10%. Capacity available for the right risk at the right price.

UNITEd STATES – NATIoNWIdENationwide accounts saw price softening on existing layers. Garnering new capacity on existing accounts came at a cost. European-based reinsurers have reduced capacity due to the dollar strengthening against the euro.

VENEzUELAThe price movement for catastrophe excess of loss followed that of the rest of Latin America, other than Chile, i.e., flat-to-a-small increase. The pro rata treaties have been subject to much negotiation in view of the 100% devaluation on 8th January 2010 of the official rate of exchange; setting maximum net retention levels has been complex in order to allow for devaluation / inflation while still allowing for ceded premiums not to fall significantly.

RATES Risk Risk Cat Cat Pro Rata Loss free Loss hit Loss free Loss hitTERRIToRY Commission % Change % Change % Change % Change Australia 0% to +2.5% 0% to -5% 0% 0% to -5% 0%

Caribbean +1% -5% to -10% +10% -5% N/A

China N/A N/A N/A -10% to -12.5% N/A

Latin America 0% to -2% 0% +5% to +12.5% 0% +40% to +70%

mexico 0% 0% Loss dependent 0% to -3% 0% to +5% middle East +2.5% to +5% -20% 0% -20% N/A

South Africa 0% 0% +10% 0% 0%

United States – florida -1% to +5% -5% to -12.5% 0% to -5% -5% to -25% N/A

United States – London market N/A -5% to -10% +5% to +15% -10% to -15% N/A

United States – National 0% to +1% -5% to -10% 0% -5% to -10% 0% to +10%

Venezuela 0% to -1% 0% +5% to +10% 0% to +3% N/A

▀▀▀

▀▀▀▀

▀▀▀

Page 10: willis re 1sT vie...For over 100 years, Willis Re has proudly served its clients, helping them obtain better value solutions and make better reinsurance decisions. As one of the world’s

�0 of ��

0

100

200

300

400

500

600

1990 92 94 96 98

2000 02 04 06 08

2010

0

100

200

300

400

500

600

1990 92 94 96 98

2000 02 04 06 08

2010

0

100

200

300

400

500

600

1990 92 94 96 98

2000 02 04 06 08

2010

0

100

200

300

400

500

600

1990 92 94 96 98

2000 02 04 06 08

2010

0

100

200

300

400

500

600

1990 92 94 96 98

2000 02 04 06 08

2010

PRoPERTY CATASTRoPhE PRICING TRENdS

AUSTRALIA

The charts on this page display Estimated Year-to-Year Property Catastrophe Rate Movement.

CARIBBEAN

mEXICoUNITEd STATES – NATIoNWIdE

VENEzUELA

Page 11: willis re 1sT vie...For over 100 years, Willis Re has proudly served its clients, helping them obtain better value solutions and make better reinsurance decisions. As one of the world’s

�� of ��

U.s. wOrkers’ COMPeNsATiONTERRIToRY ANd CommENTS

Overall, the market for Workers’ Compensation remains stable. Working layers, especially reinsurance capacity attaching below $5M, has experienced modest hardening, but this is offset with continued softening in the catastrophe capacity. In the working layers, medical inflation trends continue to create modest headwinds for reinsurers. Where there is pricing pressure, reinsurers often will agree to maintain stable up front pricing in exchange for backloading premium (i.e., adding or increasing reinstatement premium). Quite often, in the beginning stages of a hardening market, we would expect to see aggregate limits tightening, however, capacity as well as other terms and conditions, remain stable. The catastrophe market has softened every year since 2002 (the first renewal after September 11 terrorist attacks.) Costs for this capacity continue to drop, although most of the cost decrease at July 1 is in response to decreases in the underlying payrolls. As an industry, this payroll decrease is roughly 5%. The recalibration of the catastrophe earthquake models has had minimal influence on reinsurance pricing, although some buyers have adjusted their catastrophe capacity in response to modeling results. Capacity remains plentiful.

RATES XL – No Loss XL – With Loss Pro Rata Emergence EmergenceTERRIToRY Commission % Change % Change

United States N/A 0% +3% to +10%

Contact Us Ingrid BoothThe Willis Building51 Lime StreetLondon EC3M 7DQ+44 (0) 20 3124 [email protected]

Will Thoretz One World Financial Center 200 Liberty Street, 3rd Floor New York, NY 10281 +1 212 915 8251 [email protected]