waschke et al. - 2004 - regional heterogeneity of cerebral blood flow response to graded...

Upload: istvan-portoero

Post on 03-Jun-2018

218 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

  • 8/11/2019 Waschke Et Al. - 2004 - Regional Heterogeneity of Cerebral Blood Flow Response to Graded Pressure-Controlled H

    1/13

    Regional Heterogeneity of Cerebral Blood Flow Response toGraded Pressure-Controlled Hemorrhage

    Klaus F. Waschke, MD, Martin Riedel, MD, Christian Lenz, MD, Detlef M. Albrecht, MD,Klaus van Ackern, MD, and Wolfgang Kuschinsky, MD

    Background: Little is known aboutthe regional distribution of cerebral blood

    flow (CBF) in nonanesthetized animals

    during periods of lowered blood pressure.

    The present investigation addresses the

    specific reaction patterns of local cerebral

    blood flow (LCBF) in comparison with

    mean CBF during graded pressure-con-

    trolled hemorrhagic shock in conscious

    rats.

    Methods: Conscious rats were sub-jected to graded pressure-controlled hem-

    orrhage (to 85, 70, 55, or 40 mm Hg) by

    arterial blood withdrawal. After a period

    of 30 minutes, blood pressure was stabi-

    lized by withdrawal or reinfusion of

    blood. LCBF was determined autoradio-

    graphically by the iodo(14C)antipyrine

    method in 34 brain structures, and mean

    CBF was calculated and compared with

    the values of nonhemorrhaged control

    animals.

    Results: Mean CBF remained un-changed except for the group with the

    lowest blood pressure of 40 mm Hg (de-

    crease in CBF of 28%). Otherwise, LCBF

    was increased in some brain structures at

    an unchanged mean CBF. Congruently, at

    40 mm Hg, the decrease in mean CBF did

    not show up in all brain structures, the

    local pattern of CBF varying between an

    unchanged and a profoundly decreased

    CBF. The mean coefficient of variation of

    CBF was increased with the severity of

    hemorrhagic shock, which indicates an

    enhanced heterogeneity of CBF.

    Conclusion:Because of the substan-tial heterogeneity in the responses of

    LCBF to pressure-controlled hemorrhage,

    autoregulation of CBF during pressure-

    controlled hemorrhagic shock has to be

    reconsidered on a regional basis.

    Key Words: Local cerebral bloodflow, Autoradiography, Hemorrhagic hy-

    potension, Hemorrhagic shock.

    J Trauma. 2004;56:591603.

    Autoregulation is defined as a constancy of blood flow

    at varying perfusion pressures. For the clinical con-

    ditions of hemorrhagic shock, it is important to de-

    fine the lower limit of blood pressure at which the blood

    supply to the tissue is decreased. Previous studies have

    addressed the responses of the cerebral circulation to hem-orrhagic hypotension with special focus on the lower limit

    of cerebral autoregulation.15 Whereas such studies have

    addressed the global response of cerebral blood flow

    (CBF) to hypotension, other studies have focused on the

    regional distribution of cerebral blood flow.613 Although

    such studies raise an important issue (i.e., variable local

    responses to hemorrhagic hypotension), care must be taken

    in directly transferring these results to severely hemor-

    rhaged patients under emergency conditions for several

    reasons. One reason is that most studies have been per-

    formed in anesthetized animals. The use of anesthetics

    may influence the pressure-flow relationship in the brain

    and may compromise cerebral autoregulation.14 A second

    reason is the use of artificial ventilation, which is applied

    in most studies on cerebral autoregulation to keep thearterial PCO2 constant. An increased airway pressure may

    modify cerebral perfusion pressure to an undefined degree

    by influencing cerebral venous and/or cerebrospinal fluid

    pressure.15,16 Moreover, this approach does not reflect the

    emergency situation of severe uncontrolled hemorrhage. A

    third reason is that blood flow was measured in most

    studies only a few minutes after perfusion pressure had

    been decreased.1 4 Although this approach has the advan-

    tage that secondary effects on CBF because of systemic

    alterations during a prolonged hemorrhagic shock can be

    avoided, the disadvantage is that the results cannot be

    directly transferred to the clinical conditions of hemor-

    rhagic shock. The present experiments were performed

    with the intention of determining the local responses of

    cerebral blood flow to a lowering of blood pressure during

    graded hemorrhagic shock. To come more close to the

    clinical situation of hemorrhagic shock, local cerebral

    blood flow (LCBF) was measured in conscious, nonanes-

    thetized, spontaneously breathing rats after a defined re-

    duction of arterial blood pressure for 30 minutes. The quan-

    titative autoradiographic iodo(14C)antipyrine method17 was

    applied to achieve a high degree of spatial resolution for the

    detection of LCBF after hemorrhage.

    Submitted for publication August 4, 2002.Accepted for publication April 10, 2003.

    Copyright 2004 by Lippincott Williams & Wilkins, Inc.

    From the Department of Anesthesiology, Faculty of Clinical Medicine

    Mannheim (K.F.W., M.R., C.L., K.V.), University of Heidelberg, Mann-

    heim, Department of Anesthesiology, University of Dresden (D.M.A.),

    Dresden, and Department of Physiology, University of Heidelberg (W.K.),

    Heidelberg, Germany.

    Supported by a grant from the Forschungsfonds der Fakultt fr Kli-

    nische Medizin Mannheim der Universitt Heidelberg, Mannheim, Germany.

    Address for reprints: Klaus F. Waschke, MD, Institut fr Ansthesi-

    ologie und Operative Intensivmedizin, Fakultt fr Klinische Medizin Mann-

    heim der Universitt Heidelberg, Theodor Kutzer Ufer 1-3, D-68167 Mann-

    heim, Germany.

    DOI: 10.1097/01.TA.0000075335.35705.E2

    The Journal ofTRAUMAInjury, Infection, and Critical Care

    Volume 56 Number 3 591

  • 8/11/2019 Waschke Et Al. - 2004 - Regional Heterogeneity of Cerebral Blood Flow Response to Graded Pressure-Controlled H

    2/13

    MATERIALS AND METHODSAnimals

    After approval by the authorsinstitutional animal inves-

    tigation committee, the experiments were performed on 36

    male Sprague-Dawley rats weighing 297 to 412 g (Zentralin-

    stitut fr Versuchstierzucht, Hannover, Germany). The rats

    were maintained under temperature-controlled environmental

    conditions on a 14:10 light:dark cycle. The animals were fed

    a standard diet (Altromin C 1000, Lage, Germany) and al-

    lowed free access to food and potable water until starting the

    experiments. The general experimental protocol is outlined in

    Figure 1.

    Surgical ProcedureThe rats were placed in a small box and anesthetized by

    inhalation of a gas mixture of halothane (1.0 2.0%), nitrous

    oxide (60 70%), and oxygen (remainder). Anesthesia was

    maintained during surgery by inhalation of the gas mixture

    through a nose cone. Body temperature was held at 37 to

    37.5C with the use of a temperature-controlled heating pad.

    Polyethylene catheters were inserted into the right and left

    femoral arteries and the right femoral vein. After surgery, the

    animals were placed in a rat restrainer (Braintree Scientific,

    Braintree, MA). Forty-five minutes were allowed for recov-

    ery from the effects of anesthesia. Blood pressure was mon-

    itored continuously by a quartz pressure transducer (Hewlett-

    Packard, Palo Alto, CA).

    Experimental ProcedureAfter recovery from anesthesia, the rats were randomly

    assigned to one of the experimental groups (Fig. 1). Hemor-rhage was induced in all rats except for the six rats of the

    control group, which were subjected to no treatment apart

    from the described surgical preparation. Baseline values of

    physiologic variables (as shown in Table 1) were measured

    after recovery from anesthesia (45 minutes after the end of

    anesthesia). The rats of the hemorrhage groups were then

    subjected to a pressure-controlled hemorrhage by controlled

    arterial bleeding (1 mL/min) through the femoral artery cath-

    eter until the intended mean arterial pressure (MAP) of either

    85 mm Hg (P-85 group), 70 mm Hg (P-70 group), 55 mm Hg

    (P-55 group), or 40 mm Hg (P-40 group) was achieved (Fig.

    1). Blood withdrawal was followed by a state of hemorrhagic

    hypotension of 30 minutesduration. If necessary, additional

    blood was withdrawn or shed blood was retransfused during

    this period to keep the MAP constant. Rats that died during

    hemorrhagic hypotension (two in the P-55 group and four in

    the P-40 group) were not replaced. Blood flow data in these

    groups were derived from the surviving animals. Physiologic

    variables were redetermined in the hemorrhage groups at the

    Fig. 1. Flow chart of the experimental protocol.

    The Journal ofTRAUMAInjury, Infection, and Critical Care

    592 March 2004

  • 8/11/2019 Waschke Et Al. - 2004 - Regional Heterogeneity of Cerebral Blood Flow Response to Graded Pressure-Controlled H

    3/13

    end of the 30-minute hemorrhage state. To achieve similar

    experimental durations, these measurements were performed

    60 minutes after baseline measurements in the control group

    because these animals had not been subjected to the 30

    minutes of blood withdrawal and the following hemorrhagic

    hypotension of 30 minutes duration in the hemorrhage

    groups. These measurements were followed immediately bythe infusion of iodo(14C)antipyrine. Arterial pH, PO2, and

    PCO2 were measured in a pH/blood gas analyzer (AVL Gas

    Check 939, Graz, Austria). The hematocrit was determined

    by capillary tube centrifugation. Plasma glucose and blood

    hemoglobin concentrations were measured spectrophoto-

    metrically by the hexokinase/glucose-6-phosphatedehydroge-

    nase method (Glucoquant, Boehringer Mannheim, Mannheim,

    Germany) or the hemoglobin cyanide method (Hemoglobin

    Merckotest, E. Merck, Darmstadt, Germany), respectively.

    Measurement of LCBF

    The technique used for measurement of LCBF, the au-toradiographic 4-iodo-N-methyl-(14C)-antipyrine method

    (also called the iodo(14C)-antipyrine method) in the present

    investigation was developed in 1978 as a successor to previ-

    ously proven methods for measurement of regional cerebral

    blood flow.17 Methods for quantitative determination of

    blood flow in discrete cerebral components had been reported

    for the first time by Kety and others between 1951 and

    1960.1821 The method was initially based on the principles

    of inert gas exchange between blood and tissues,17 using an

    inert radioactive gas, (131I)-labeled trifluoroiodomethane,

    which appeared to satisfy the requirements as a tracer for

    measurement of blood flow in various structures of thebrain.1922 Because of the short half-life of (131I)-labeled

    trifluoroiodomethane and its lack of commercial availability,

    another tracer was sought, and after experimentation with

    iodo(131I)antipyrine and (14C)antipyrine, which did not fulfill

    the requirements for unlimited diffusion capacities, this tracer

    was found in iodo(14C)antipyrine. The work of Sakurada et

    al.,17 demonstrating the method, showed a close correlation

    between the older measurements of local cerebral blood flow

    with (131I)-labeled trifluoroiodomethane and the new method

    using iodo(14C)antipyrine in cats. In addition, within the

    same publication, the iodoantipyrine method was established

    for rats.

    17

    For the measurement of LCBF in the present investi-

    gation, 25 to 40 Ci of 4-iodo(N-methyl-14C)antipyrine

    (specific activity, 54 mCi/mmol; Amersham-Buchler,

    Braunschweig, Germany) dissolved in 1 mL saline was

    continuously infused at a progressively increasing infusion

    rate for a period of 1 minute through the femoral venous

    catheter. The progressively increasing infusion rate was a

    modification of the method described earlier.17 It was chosen

    to minimize equilibration of rapidly perfused tissues with

    arterial blood during the period of measurement. During the

    1-minute infusion period, 14 to 20 timed blood samples were

    collected in drops from the free-flowing arterial catheterTable

    1

    PhysiologicVariablesin

    theControlandthePressure-ControlledHemorrhageGroups

    Control

    P-85

    P-70

    P-55

    P-40

    Baseline

    60Minafter

    Recoveryfrom

    Anesthesia

    Baseline

    Endof30-Min

    Hemorrh

    age

    State

    Baseline

    Endof30-Min

    Hemorrhage

    State

    Baseline

    Endof30-Min

    Hemorrhage

    State

    Baseline

    Endof30-Min

    Hemorrhage

    State

    pH

    7.38

    0.03

    7.39

    0.02

    7.37

    0.03

    7.36

    0.02

    7.38

    0.02

    7.32

    0.05*

    7.38

    0.02

    7.31

    0.07*

    7.39

    0.02

    6.9

    0.24*

    PO2

    (mm

    Hg)

    93

    3

    91

    2.6

    89.2

    6.3

    97.3

    6.3*

    89

    6.7

    98.8

    9.7*

    88.0

    3.7

    104.0

    6.0*

    88.9

    5.9

    112.4

    9.4*

    PCO2

    (mm

    Hg)

    42.0

    4.0

    41.6

    2.9

    40.9

    3.6

    39.7

    2.4

    42.1

    2.9

    34.2

    4.0*

    43.2

    2.7

    29.8

    4.5*

    42.6

    4.5

    20.5

    5.3*

    Baseexcess(mmol/L)

    1.0

    1.0

    1.3

    1.1

    1.4

    1.3

    2.7

    1.7

    1.3

    1.6

    7.9

    2.2*

    0.0

    1.0

    9.4

    4.4*

    0.5

    1.7

    28.2

    8.2*

    Plasmaglucose(mg/dL)

    169

    20

    173

    18

    158

    17

    201

    46*

    177

    21

    419

    157*

    177

    20

    471

    94*

    169

    26

    468

    118*

    Hemoglobin(g/dL)

    14.4

    0.8

    14.6

    0.9

    15.3

    0.9

    12.2

    1.1*

    15.4

    1

    10.3

    0.9*

    14.6

    1.1

    9.6

    0.9*

    14.8

    1.2

    11.2

    2.4*

    Hematocrit(%)

    44

    2

    45

    2.6

    44.9

    1.7

    38.4

    3.0*

    45.0

    1.1

    31.4

    2.5*

    45.3

    1.4

    30.7

    4.2*

    45.7

    1.9

    33.3

    4.3*

    Heartrate(1/min)

    361

    18

    378

    21

    377

    39

    331

    33

    425

    26

    377

    61

    428

    36

    400

    55

    412

    31

    427

    38

    MAP1

    (mm

    Hg)

    116

    9

    119

    10

    121

    6

    86

    1*

    127

    3

    70

    2*

    124

    8

    55

    1*

    123

    9

    40

    2*

    Shedbloodvolume(mL/

    kgbodyweight)

    0

    16.1

    2.1

    26.9

    1.2

    30.1

    3.0

    37.3

    2.3

    n

    6

    6

    6

    6

    6

    Means

    SD;n,no.ofanimals;*vs.

    baselinevaluesineachgroup.

    Heterogeneity of CBF during Pressure-Controlled Hemorrhage

    Volume 56 Number 3 593

  • 8/11/2019 Waschke Et Al. - 2004 - Regional Heterogeneity of Cerebral Blood Flow Response to Graded Pressure-Controlled H

    4/13

    directly onto filter paper disks (1.3 cm in diameter) that

    previously had been placed into small plastic beakers and

    weighed. The samples were weighed and radioactivity esti-

    mated with a liquid scintillation counter (Tri-Carb 4000 se-

    ries, Canberra Packard, Frankfurt, Germany) after extraction

    of the radioactive compound with ethanol. After the 1-minute

    infusion and sampling period, the animal was decapitated,and the brain was removed as quickly as possible and frozen

    in 2-methylbutane chilled to 40 to 50C with dry ice. The

    frozen brains were coated with chilled embedding medium

    (Lipshaw, Detroit, MI), stored at 80C in plastic bags and

    sectioned into 20-m coronal sections at 20C in a cryostat,

    and the first 3 sections of every 10 were autoradiographed

    along with precalibrated (14C)methyl methacrylate standards.

    Usually, this procedure yielded approximately 70 to 100

    autoradiographed sections per brain. The cerebral regions of

    interest were identified by comparison with Palkovits and

    Brownsteins atlas of the rats central nervous system.23 For

    the evaluation of any brain structure of interest, a series of sixconsecutive autoradiographed brain sections was chosen, rep-

    resenting the optimal appearance of the concerning brain

    structure. These sections were used for measurement of ce-

    rebral blood flow in any structure of interest on both sides of

    the brain, resulting in 12 values for LCBF in any brain

    structure analyzed. The final value for LCBF in each brain

    structure was derived as the mean of the values measured.

    Local tissue concentrations of 14C were determined from the

    autoradiographs by densitometric analysis with a densitome-

    ter equipped with a 0.2-mm aperture (Parry DT1105 R; New-

    bury, Berkshire, United Kingdom). LCBF was calculated

    from the local concentrations of 14

    C and the time course ofthe blood iodo(14C)antipyrine concentrations, including cor-

    rections for the lag and washout in the arterial catheter.17 The

    washout correction rate constant was 100/min. The brain-

    blood partition coefficient for iodo(14C)antipyrine was found

    to be 0.9 in our rats.24 LCBF was determined in 34 different

    brain regions.

    Statistical EvaluationValues are reported as means SD. Mean CBF was

    determined as the arithmetic average of the LCBF values

    obtained from the 34 brain structures analyzed. The mean

    coefficient of variation of CBF (Fig. 2), which was taken asan indicator of heterogeneity of blood flow,25,26 was calcu-

    lated for each experimental group from the coefficients of

    variation of LCBF in each of the 34 brain structures analyzed.

    Statistical differences were evaluated by analysis of variance

    and Students ttest. Bonferroni correction for multiple com-

    parisons was used when appropriate.

    RESULTSReaction to Hemorrhage

    Because of the severity of the hemorrhage, six rats died

    during hemorrhagic hypotension (two rats in the P-55 and

    four rats in the P-40 group). Thirty rats survived the experi-

    mental protocol. Progressive hypotension induced a transient

    excitation of the animals, whereas at the end of the 30-minute

    state of hemorrhagic hypotension the animals of the hemor-

    rhage groups displayed some degree of lethargy, depending

    on the degree of pressure-controlled hemorrhage.

    Physiologic VariablesThe physiologic variables of both the control and hem-

    orrhage groups are summarized in Table 1. Taking into ac-count a total blood volume of the experimental animals of 60

    mL/kg,27 the total shed blood volume in the hemorrhage

    groups was 27% of the circulating blood volume in the P-85

    group, 45% in the P-70 group, 50% in the P-55 group, and

    62% in the P-40 group. In the untreated control group, no

    differences were found between the measured physiologic

    variables obtained after recovery from anesthesia and 60

    minutes later. Thirty minutes after pressure-controlled hem-

    orrhage, profound changes were observed: the graded lower-

    ing of MAP was followed by the development of a significant

    metabolic acidosis with partial respiratory compensation.

    Plasma glucose concentrations were significantly increased inparallel. Hemoglobin concentration and hematocrit were sig-

    nificantly decreased to approximately two thirds of the base-

    line values in the P-70, the P-55, and the P-40 groups.

    Local Cerebral Blood FlowLCBF was determined in 34 brain structures of each

    experimental group. The results are presented in Figures 3

    and 4, which outline the dependency of LCBF on MAP.

    Figure 3 shows the general trends, whereas Figure 4 specifies

    the significant changes after grouping of the data. Figure 3

    shows that, in the majority of structures, LCBF was main-

    tained except for the P-40 group. In Figure 4, the blood flow

    Fig. 2. Dependence of mean cerebral blood flow (CBF) and meancoefficient of variation on mean arterial blood pressure. *Signifi-

    cant changes compared with the control group, p 0.05.

    The Journal ofTRAUMAInjury, Infection, and Critical Care

    594 March 2004

  • 8/11/2019 Waschke Et Al. - 2004 - Regional Heterogeneity of Cerebral Blood Flow Response to Graded Pressure-Controlled H

    5/13

    values of the 34 brain structures analyzed have been grouped

    according to the decrease of LCBF in the P-40 group com-

    pared with the control group. In the top panel, the brain

    structures are shown in which blood flow was unchanged in

    the P-40 group (from left to right). The structures displayed

    in the bottom panel show the largest decrease in blood flow in

    the P-40 group. Instead of grouping the results exclusively

    according to the values of LCBF in the P-40 group, another

    means of classification leads to four circumscribed groups of

    brain structures:

    1. In the first group, those structures would appear in

    which LCBF was significantly increased in the P-85,P-70, and P-55 groups, whereas no significant LCBF

    changes could be detected in the P-40 group. Such

    structures were the superior olive, dentate nuclei, hip-

    pocampus CA 3, mamillary body, and the substantia

    nigra.

    2. The second group contains structures in which signif-

    icant LCBF increases could be measured in the P-85,

    P-70, and P-55 groups, whereas LCBF was signifi-

    cantly decreased in the P-40 group. Such structures

    were the inferior colliculus, lateral lemniscus, medial

    geniculate body, sensory motor cortex, and the parietal

    cortex.

    3. The third group encompasses structures in which

    LCBF was significantly decreased in the P-40 group

    exclusively, whereas no significant changes were

    found in the P-85, P-70, and P-55 groups. Such struc-

    tures were the pontine gray, lateral thalamus, superior

    colliculus, amygdaloid complex, lateral geniculate

    body, nucleus accumbens, caudate nucleus, hypothal-amus, frontal cortex, visual cortex, lateral septal nu-

    clei, and the genu of corpus callosum.

    4. The fourth group contains the remaining structures,

    which all showed unchanged values of LCBF in the

    P-85, P-70, P-55, and P-40 groups compared with the

    control group. These were the vestibular nucleus, hip-

    pocampus CA 2, hippocampus CA 1, hippocampus

    CA 4, ventral thalamus, dentate gyrus, cerebellar cor-

    tex, globus pallidus, cerebellar white matter, corpus

    callosum, and the internal capsule.

    Mean Cerebral Blood FlowA third means of analysis of the data in addition to those

    shown in Figures 3 and 4 is to investigate the variability of

    LCBF in the different experimental groups. To this end, the

    LCBF values obtained from all brain structures were summed

    to obtain a mean value of blood flow in each experimental

    group. The mean coefficient of variation of CBF was calcu-

    lated for each group. Mean CBF and the corresponding mean

    coefficient of variation of CBF are plotted in Figure 2. A

    significant change of mean CBF could only be found in the

    P-40 group. Mean CBF was decreased by 28% compared

    with the control group. The coefficient of variation was

    unchanged in the P-85 and the P-70 group, whereas it in-creased significantly in the P-55 group and in the P-40 group.

    This indicates an increase of heterogeneity of CBF in the

    P-55 group at an unchanged mean CBF.

    DISCUSSIONThe results of the present study indicate a substantial

    degree of heterogeneity in the reaction of regional cerebral

    blood flow to graded pressure-controlled hemorrhage that is

    not reflected when only mean cerebral blood flow is

    measured.2832 These data are based on autoradiographic

    techniques applied to conscious, spontaneously breathing an-

    imals after a period of hemorrhagic hypotension of 30 min-utes duration.

    Regarding the heterogeneity of CBF, previous studies on

    cerebral autoregulation under conditions of hemorrhagic hy-

    potension have revealed conflicting results. In contrast to the

    results of the present study, some authors did not find any

    heterogeneities or indications of redistribution of CBF after

    exposure of the experimental animals to acute hemorrhagic

    hypotension (Table 2). Unanesthetized, spontaneously

    breathing dogs11 showed that at an MAP of 50 mm Hg the

    LCBF response in each brain structure measured by the

    microsphere technique did not differ from the response of

    mean CBF to hemorrhagic hypotension. Laughlin33 did not

    Fig. 3. Mean values of local cerebral blood flow in the 34 brain

    structures analyzed are related to the mean arterial blood pressure

    during graded pressure-controlled hemorrhage.

    Heterogeneity of CBF during Pressure-Controlled Hemorrhage

    Volume 56 Number 3 595

  • 8/11/2019 Waschke Et Al. - 2004 - Regional Heterogeneity of Cerebral Blood Flow Response to Graded Pressure-Controlled H

    6/13

    find any significant changes in LCBF and mean CBF during

    graded hemorrhagic hypotension with a final MAP of 22 mm

    Hg in pentobarbital-anesthetized and artificially ventilated

    miniature swine as measured by the microsphere method. In

    this investigation, CBF even tended to increase at the lowest

    level of hypotension. Ferrari et al.7 reported that CBF was

    well autoregulated down to an MAP of 40 mm Hg in anes-

    thetized, mechanically ventilated dogs. In this study, mean

    CBF and LCBF in all examined brain structures decreased by

    50% when cerebral perfusion pressure dropped to 30 mm Hg.

    Regional variations of CBF could not be detected by the

    microsphere CBF measurements used by the authors of this

    Fig. 4. LCBF specified for individual brain structures in the different experimental groups. The brain structures have been ranked from top

    to bottom and from left to right according to the decrease of LCBF in the P-40 group compared with the control group. *Significant changes

    of LCBF compared with the control group, p 0.05.

    The Journal ofTRAUMAInjury, Infection, and Critical Care

    596 March 2004

  • 8/11/2019 Waschke Et Al. - 2004 - Regional Heterogeneity of Cerebral Blood Flow Response to Graded Pressure-Controlled H

    7/13

    Table

    2

    StudiesObservingNoH

    eterogeneityofLCBFduringHyp

    otension

    First

    Author

    Year

    CBFCompared

    withControl

    Conditions

    Methodof

    Measure

    ment

    Species

    Anesthesia

    Ventilation

    PCO2

    pH

    Hct

    Bloo

    dGlucose

    Con

    centration

    Minimal

    Blood

    Pressure

    (mm

    Hg)

    Durationof

    Hypotension

    Mod

    elofHypotensionand

    Remarks

    Slater

    1975

    Decreased

    Microsphe

    res

    Dogs

    Conscious

    Spont.

    Appr.25

    Appr.7.40

    n.a.

    n.a.

    Appr.50

    0and6h

    Pressure-controlled

    hem

    orrhagichypotension

    Gamache

    1976

    Decreased

    14C-antipyrine

    Rhesus

    monkeys

    Pentobarbital

    Cont.

    2636

    7.357.45

    n.a.

    n.a.

    25

    30min

    maximum

    Hypotensioninducedby

    trim

    etaphan

    Laughlin

    1983

    Nochanges

    Microsphe

    res

    Miniature

    swine

    Pentobarbital

    Cont.

    n.a.

    n.a.

    n.a.

    n.a.

    22

    1015min

    Ferrari

    1992

    Below40mm

    Hgdecreased

    by50%

    Microsphe

    res

    Dogs

    Pentobarbital

    Cont.

    32

    7.12

    Hb13.0

    n.a.

    16

    20min

    Pressure-controlled

    hem

    orrhagichypotension

    Anwar

    1996

    Nochanges

    Microsphe

    res

    Newborn

    pigs

    Alpha-

    chloralose

    Cont.

    35

    7.23

    n.a.

    n.a.

    31

    30min

    Pressure-controlled

    hem

    orrhagichypotension;

    reductionofthenumberof

    perfusedcapillaries

    Komjati

    1996

    Nochangein

    RCBFora

    slight

    reduction

    Microsphe

    res

    Cats

    Chloralose-

    urethane

    Cont.

    37

    7.15

    n.a.

    n.a.

    40

    10min

    Pressure-controlled

    hem

    orrhagichypotension;

    reductionofRCBFonlyin

    hyp

    othalamusandmedulla

    oblongata

    Zaharchuk

    1999

    Constantat

    14050mm

    Hg,below,fall

    Hemodyna

    mic

    magnetic

    resonance

    imaging

    Rats

    Halothane

    Cont.

    28(severe

    hypotension)

    7.29

    29

    n.a.

    26

    1mm

    Hg/min

    Pressure-controlled

    hem

    orrhagichypotension

    Nishimura

    1999

    Decreaseof

    CBFonlyin

    fewregionsof

    interest

    PET

    Humans

    Conscious

    Spont.

    Normocapnia

    n.a.

    n.a.

    n.a.

    Individual

    Afterstable

    induced

    hypotension

    wasobtained

    Hypotensioninducedby

    trim

    etaphan;more

    dec

    reaseatpresenceof

    vas

    cularstenosis;

    som

    etimesCBFinROIs

    withahighreactivityto

    hyp

    ercapniaincreased

    duringhypotension

    Hct,hematocrit;Spont.,spontaneously;Cont.,controlled;Appr.,approximately(expressionusedwhenthevalueonly

    canbefoundasatargetvalueintheMethodssection);Hb,

    hemoglobinconcentration;ROIs,regionsofinterest;n.a.,notavailableinthispublication;PET,positron-emissiontomogr

    aphy.

    Heterogeneity of CBF during Pressure-Controlled Hemorrhage

    Volume 56 Number 3 597

  • 8/11/2019 Waschke Et Al. - 2004 - Regional Heterogeneity of Cerebral Blood Flow Response to Graded Pressure-Controlled H

    8/13

    study. Another study also used radioactive microspheres for

    measurement of CBF during hemorrhagic hypotension inalpha-chloraloseanesthetized newborn pigs.34 At an MAP of

    31 4 mm Hg, Anwar et al.34 found in this study also no

    significant reduction in CBF but a reduction in the number of

    perfused capillaries in all brain regions investigated. Using

    spin labeling and steady-state susceptibility contrast, Zahar-

    chuk et al.31 measured cerebral blood flow during hemor-

    rhagic hypotension in halothane-anesthetized rats using he-

    modynamic magnetic resonance imaging. In the slice of the

    bregma, CBF was kept constant between an MAP of 50 and

    140 mm Hg; below these values, it fell corresponding to a

    falling MAP. Komjati et al.35 measured regional cerebral

    blood flow (RCBF) in thalamus, hypothalamus, pituitary,

    white matter, frontoparietal cortex, cerebellum, and three

    locations of the spinal cord in alpha-chloralose-urethananes-thetized cats during pressure-controlled hypotension (80, 60,

    and 40 mm Hg) and found no change in RCBF or a slight

    reduction. From these studies, it might be concluded that

    LCBF to different brain structures exhibited the same reac-

    tion pattern as CBF to the brain in total. In addition, a recent

    study in humans demonstrated the important role of uniform

    regulatory mechanisms of the cerebral circulation in healthy

    brain structures during hypotension. Nishimura et al.36 mea-

    sured regional CBF in regions of interest (ROIs), mostly

    covering the cortical territory of the middle cerebral artery by

    positron-emission tomography in patients with occlusive dis-

    ease of the carotid or middle cerebral artery during hypoten-

    Table 3 Studies Observing Increased Heterogeneity of LCBF during Hypotension

    First Author Year Higher CBFCompared

    with ControlConditions

    Lower Blood FlowCompared

    with ControlConditions

    Method ofMeasurement

    Species

    Higher CBF in deep brain regions

    Sadoshima 1983 Brain stem Preserved more Cerebrum, cerebellum Preserved less Microspheres Stroke-prone

    spontaneously

    hypertensive

    rats (SHRSP)

    Wistar-Kyoto-

    rats (WKY)

    Tuor 1994 Deep forebrain and brain

    stem structures

    Maintained Cortex and subcortical

    white matter

    Decreased Iodoantipyrine

    (laser-Doppler)

    Rabbits

    Tsutsui 1995 Other brain regions Maintained Neocortex and

    telencephalon

    Decreased Iodoantipyrine Rats

    Niwa 1998 Brain stem regions Increased Supratentorial cortical

    regions

    Maintained Iodoantipyrine Rats

    Higher CBF in hindbrainDe Witt 1992 Posterior cerebral artery

    (posterior brain regions)

    Maintained to

    decreased

    Anterior cerebral artery

    (anterior brain

    regions)

    Maintained to

    decreased

    Microspheres Cats

    ONeil 1997 Hindbrain Increased Forebrain Maintained Microspheres Newborn lambs

    Higher CBF in cerebrum and cortex

    Mueller 1977 Brain stem, cerebrum,

    cerebral gray

    Preserved more Cerebellum, cerebral

    white

    Preserved less Microspheres Dogs

    Bauer 1997 Cortex Increased n.a. n.a. Colored

    microspheres

    Newborn swine

    Komjaty 1997 Cortex Decreased Medulla Decreased H2-clearance Cats

    The Journal ofTRAUMAInjury, Infection, and Critical Care

    598 March 2004

  • 8/11/2019 Waschke Et Al. - 2004 - Regional Heterogeneity of Cerebral Blood Flow Response to Graded Pressure-Controlled H

    9/13

    sion induced by trimetaphan. During hypotension, in brain

    hemispheres without a vascular stenosis, they observed adecrease of CBF only in a few ROIs, but in more ROIs when

    an asymptomatic vascular stenosis was present and even

    more when a symptomatic vascular stenosis was present.

    Sometimes, CBF in ROIs with a high reactivity to hypercap-

    nia increased during hypotension.

    However, other groups presented completely different

    LCBF responses to hemorrhagic hypotension. In these studies

    on cerebral autoregulation, LCBF changes did not parallel the

    changes in mean CBF during hypotension (Table 3). In anes-

    thetized and artificially ventilated dogs, Mueller et al.9 ob-

    served a significant redistribution of CBF when MAP was

    reduced below 65 mm Hg. Blood flow to the brain stem,

    cerebrum, and cerebral gray matter was preserved more than

    flow to cerebellum and cerebral white matter under hypoten-sive conditions. Using staged hemorrhagic hypotension,

    Bauer et al.37 observed a slight increase of regional cerebral

    blood flow in the cortex of isoflurane/nitric oxideanesthe-

    tized newborn piglets at a MAP of 60 and 50 mm Hg (66

    23 mL/min/100 g and 53 12 mL/min/100 g, respectively,

    compared with 42 12 mL/min/100 g at control conditions).

    At 40 and 35 mm Hg, RCBF in the cortex fell below the value

    observed during control conditions.37 Sadoshima and

    Heistad10 described larger reductions of LCBF to cerebrum

    and cerebellum than to brain stem when anesthetized, me-

    chanically ventilated, normal, and spontaneously hyperten-

    sive rats were subjected to hemorrhagic hypotension down to

    Table 3 Continues

    Anesthesia Ventilation PCO2 (mm Hg) pH Hct (%)Blood GlucoseConcentration

    (mg/dL)

    Minimal BloodPressure(mm Hg)

    Duration ofHypotension

    Model of Hypotension and Remarks

    Pentobarbital Cont. 35 (SHRSP)

    36 (WKY)

    7.34 (SHRPS)

    7.36 (WKY)

    n.a. n.a. 109 (SHRSP)

    48 (WKY)

    10 sec Pressure-controlled

    hemorrhagic hypotension

    Chronic sympathetic

    denervation (Removal of one

    superior cervical ganglion)

    Urethane Spont. 45 7.28 n.a. n.a. 20 Several min Pressure-controlled

    hemorrhagic hypotension

    Halothane Cont. 37 7.1 36 n.a. 29 30 min Pressure-controlled

    hemorrhagic hypotension

    Additional groups with

    hypotension by trimetaphan

    and nitroprusside

    Conscious Spont. 33 7.39 43 211 51 2 min Pressure-controlled

    hemorrhagic hypotension

    Isoflurane Cont. 31 6.93 n.a. n.a. 41 n.a. Pressure-controlled

    hemorrhagic hypotension

    Chloralose-

    urethane

    Cont. 40/41 7.30/7.36 17/28 n.a. 30/28 5 min Pressure-controlled

    hemorrhagic hypotension

    Infusion of autologous blood in

    the 2. group to prevent

    anemia

    Isoflurane/

    nitrous

    oxide

    Cont. 37 (acute)

    39 (chronic)

    7.33 (acute)

    7.38 (chronic)

    n.a. n.a. 37 (acute)

    38 (chronic)

    515 min Pressure-controlled

    hemorrhagic hypotension

    Acute and chronic sympathetic

    denervation by removal of

    one superior cervical

    ganglion and the stellateganglion

    Isoflurane/

    nitrous

    oxide

    Cont. 44 7.24 n.a. 60 32 25 min Pressure-controlled

    hemorrhagic hypotension

    Reduction of blood pressure

    step by step every 30 min to

    60, 50, 40, and 35 mm Hg

    Chloralose-

    urethane

    Cont. 35 (medulla)

    33 (cortex)

    n.a. n.a. n.a. 63 (medulla)

    63 (cortex)

    75 min Pressure-controlled

    hemorrhagic hypotension

    Hct, hematocrit; Microspheres, radioactive microspheres; Cont., controlled; Spont., spontaneously; Appr., approximately (expression used

    when the value only can be found as a target value in the Methods section); Hb, hemoglobin concentration; n.a., not available in this publication.

    Heterogeneity of CBF during Pressure-Controlled Hemorrhage

    Volume 56 Number 3 599

  • 8/11/2019 Waschke Et Al. - 2004 - Regional Heterogeneity of Cerebral Blood Flow Response to Graded Pressure-Controlled H

    10/13

    70% and 50% of the baseline MAP values. DeWitt et al.6

    observed no significant changes of mean CBF until MAP was

    reduced to 40 mm Hg in isoflurane-anesthetized and venti-

    lated cats, although LCBF in brain structures supplied by the

    anterior cerebral artery only decreased at a MAP of 60 and 40

    mm Hg. LCBF in most regions supplied by the posterior

    cerebral artery and the basilar artery was preserved even at aMAP of 40 mm Hg.

    In contrast to the above-cited investigations that used the

    microsphere method to measure LCBF, studies that use au-

    toradiographic methods for the measurement of LCBF are

    able to provide a higher spatial resolution, but also demon-

    strate conflicting results. By use of the (14C)-antipyrine

    method, Gamache et al.8 showed that in anesthetized and

    ventilated rhesus monkeys the pattern of LCBF responses to

    a hemorrhagic hypotension at 25 mm Hg did not differ from

    the distribution pattern of LCBF during normotension.

    In contrast to these findings, Niwa et al.12 induced hy-

    potension in conscious rats by hemorrhagic hypotension andmeasured LCBF in 18 brain regions by the iodo(14C)-anti-

    pyrine method 2 minutes after the desired MAP level had

    been achieved. During exsanguination down to a MAP of 50

    mm Hg, they observed that LCBF was maintained in most of

    the supratentorial cortical regions, whereas LCBF in most of

    the brain stem regions showed a tendency to increase. These

    authors characterized this predysautoregulatory overshoot

    of CBF as a defense mechanism against hemorrhagic

    hypotension.12,38

    The present investigation was designed to study the ef-

    fects of graded pressure-controlled hemorrhage on local vari-

    ations of CBF. Therefore, on the one hand, a direct compar-ison of the present results with those of previous reports on

    autoregulation of the cerebral circulation with changing per-

    fusion pressure always has to consider the specific character-

    istics of the present experimental protocol (no anesthesia, no

    maintained arterial PCO2 by artificial ventilation, profound

    systemic effects of hemorrhage such as severe metabolic

    acidosis, autoradiographic measurements of LCBF). On the

    other hand, the presented results have provided additional

    knowledge of the reaction patterns of LCBF during pressure-

    controlled hemorrhage, especially under conditions of severe

    hemorrhagic shock. Although our data and the majority of

    previous investigations on cerebral autoregulation show thatthe response of the cerebral circulation to hemorrhagic hy-

    potension is not uniform, there are substantial differences of

    our results in comparison with those autoregulation studies

    that also reported some degree of heterogeneity and regional

    variations of CBF during hemorrhagic hypotension. The pref-

    erential preservation of CBF to brain stem structures during

    hemorrhagic hypotension as described previously9 could not

    be confirmed in the present investigation. As outlined in

    Figures 3 and 4, there were brain structures in which LCBF

    is preserved even at an MAP of 40 mm Hg, but these struc-

    tures cannot be assigned exclusively to the brain stem. In

    addition, significant decreases in LCBF could be detected in

    some brain stem structures at this level of hemorrhage. The

    phenomenon of predysautoregulatory overshoot of CBF12,38

    could also be observed in our study. However, an exclusive

    limitation of this effect to brain stem structures as described

    by Niwa et al.12 was not obvious in our data (Figs. 3 and 4).

    In general, the described pattern of LCBF found in the

    present study during graded pressure-controlled hemorrhagedoes not conform to any previously described specific reac-

    tion patterns of the cerebral circulation during hemorrhage. In

    addition, there is no obvious concept to explain the observed

    pattern of CBF.

    The present experiments have been conducted in con-

    scious animals. The use of anesthetics in most other stud-

    ies might have contributed to differences in the results.

    Seyde et al.39 reported a decrease in CBF and a redistri-

    bution of LCBF during pentobarbital and chloralose-ure-

    thane anesthesia in rats. Furthermore, Enlund et al.40 mea-

    sured RCBF in frontal, temporal, parietal, occipital and

    cerebellar cortex, striatum, thalamus, cerebellar vermis,and white matter by the use of positron-emission tomog-

    raphy in rhesus monkeys with hypotension at an MAP of

    50 to 60 mm Hg induced by isoflurane or propofol anes-

    thesia. Compared with baseline anesthesia with a low dose

    of either anesthetic, they found an increase of RCBF in the

    majority of brain structures observed during hypotension

    induced by isoflurane anesthesia, but a decrease of RCBF

    in all brain structures investigated during hypotension in-

    duced by propofol anesthesia. Because hypotension in this

    study was induced by anesthetic agents, the increases and

    decreases observed may be because of the combined phar-

    macodynamic effects of the agents on cerebral rate ofoxygen metabolism and on vasodilation of cerebral blood

    vessels and not because of the induced hypotension per se.

    Thus, general anesthetic agents may change the hemody-

    namic response to acute hemorrhage, varying from agent

    to agent and species to species.39,4143 Therefore, to

    achieve identical values of reduced MAP in conscious

    animals, a substantially larger amount of withdrawn blood

    is required in hemorrhage models of conscious than in

    anesthetized animals. Because of this, a degree of meta-

    bolic acidosis has been found in the present study (Table 1)

    that has not been described previously in the literature in

    connection with CBF measurements during hemorrhagichypotension. It remains unknown whether this severe systemic

    acidosis, secondary to low tissue perfusion, has contributed to

    the increase in cerebral blood flow found in some of the brain

    structures analyzed in the present study. The observed fall in

    arterial PCO2 should decrease cerebral blood flow. However,

    previous studies have shown an impaired carbon dioxide respon-

    siveness of CBF during hypotensive conditions.44

    In addition, variations in blood glucose concentration also

    may contribute to heterogeneities of LCBF, resulting in even

    reductions of LCBF during acute hyperglycemia but different

    reductions of LCBF during chronic hyperglycemia.45,46 This

    finding may further complicate the comparison between the

    The Journal ofTRAUMAInjury, Infection, and Critical Care

    600 March 2004

  • 8/11/2019 Waschke Et Al. - 2004 - Regional Heterogeneity of Cerebral Blood Flow Response to Graded Pressure-Controlled H

    11/13

    various studies investigating pressure-controlled hemorrhagic

    hypotension.

    To make all these comparisons easier, two tables have

    been included in this presentation (Tables 2 and 3). These

    tables present many of the characteristics of the cited studies

    at a glance, especially potential causes for the differing re-

    sults mentioned above. However, this presentation is limited,because in a great number of these studies, the values for

    some parameters of interest were not available in the corre-

    sponding study, especially values for blood glucose concen-

    tration or hematocrit. These tables demonstrate the varying

    results of investigations during hemorrhage with respect to

    absolute levels of CBF. Undoubtedly, the cause for the het-

    erogeneity of the results observed are the myriad variations in

    experimental paradigms including but not limited to species,

    anesthesia, duration and depth of hypotension, stress or pain

    in the animals, blood glucose concentration, and other

    factors.

    A cause for the observed differences of the presentfindings compared with the study of Niwa et al.12 may

    consist of the measurement of LCBF after a defined re-

    duction of arterial blood pressure for 30 minutes, whereas

    Niwa et al.12 measured LCBF only 2 minutes after the

    desired level of arterial blood pressure had been achieved.

    Therefore, secondary effects on CBF caused by systemic

    alterations during a prolonged hemorrhagic shock may

    have been missed by the latter approach. In contrast, the

    present study was intended to come close to the clinical

    situation of prolonged hemorrhagic shock and therefore

    used a more realistic model of hemorrhagic hypotension in

    the trauma situation. Thus, the findings of the presentinvestigation may be more directly transferred to the clin-

    ical conditions of hemorrhagic shock than the findings

    from previous autoregulation studies.

    In the period between anesthesia and the onset of

    hemorrhage, the rats obviously were undergoing some

    stress, with consequent cerebral effects. However, this fact

    also may better reflect the clinical situation, when patients

    are conscious and exposed to stresses, even before hem-

    orrhage. Because no values of cerebral blood flow could be

    obtained in the animals that diedtheir ultimate CBF

    would be zerothe higher mortality in the severely hem-

    orrhaged rats may implicate that considerably lower CBFsmight have prevailed in this group as a whole than could be

    obtained by measurement of CBF in surviving animals.

    One could further speculate, therefore, that the heteroge-

    neity of blood flow might have been even greater, as the

    measurements in the surviving animals in the P-55 and

    P-40 groups indicate.

    Strikingly high values for local cerebral blood flow could

    be observed in the auditory cortex. This finding may impli-

    cate sensorial stimulation of this brain region during the

    experiments. Measurements were obtained during the normal

    acoustic atmosphere of a closed room in a physiologic labo-

    ratory. Most noise came from verbal communication between

    the members of the experimental team. Immediately during

    the 1-minute infusion period of iodoantipyrine, the number of

    each droplet from the arterial catheter was announced to a

    technician, who noticed the time of each droplets fall. The

    other type of noise was a quiet humming from the motor

    injection syringe for iodoantipyrine. During the experiment,

    there was no noise from other laboratory machines such ascentrifuges or shaking baths.

    At a whole, during all states of even potentially lethal

    hypotension, LCBF did not decrease to ischemic values for

    brain tissue, known from previous investigations.47 This ob-

    servation may reflect the stability of the cerebral perfusion

    during hemorrhagic shock. However, conclusions drawn

    from the values of LCBF observed in this setting are limited,

    because the reduction of cerebral blood flow that causes

    ischemic depolarization and ischemic sensitivity itself varies

    not only among species but also dramatically among specific

    populations of brain neurons.48

    Although in contrast to other species, blood vessel anat-omy and blood flow distribution in rat brain is very similar

    to blood vessel anatomy and blood flow distribution in

    humans,49 the limitations of this study include further that the

    observations made are preferentially applicable to the ob-

    served animal species, rats. It can only be a matter of further

    speculation and research whether the observed results can be

    applied to larger animals and humans. However, the experi-

    ments in the present study are faithful replications of the

    clinical situation in the animals investigated with the excep-

    tion perhaps of the absence of pain, which is typically asso-

    ciated with traumatic hemorrhage.

    In conclusion, the results of the present investigationindicate distinct patterns of local cerebral blood flow during

    pressure-controlled hemorrhage in conscious rats. The lower

    limit of autoregulation is highly dependent on the cerebral

    region analyzed. The regional variations of LCBF are not

    reflected in the mean CBF which, without values of LCBF,

    would indicate perfect autoregulation.

    ACKNOWLEDGMENTSWe thank T. Lorenz, T. Fuchs, P. Strau, and M. Harlacher for

    excellent technical assistance.

    REFERENCES1. Fitch W, MacKenzie ET, Harper AM. Effects of decreasing arterial

    blood pressure on cerebral blood flow in the baboon: influence of

    the sympathetic nervous system. Circ Res. 1975;37:550 557.

    2. Grubb RL Jr, Raichle ME. Effects of hemorrhagic and

    pharmacologic hypotension on cerebral oxygen utilization and blood

    flow. Anesthesiology. 1982;56:3 8.

    3. Hamar J, Kovach AG, Reivich M, Nyary I, Durity F. Effect of

    phenoxybenzamine on cerebral blood flow and metabolism in the

    baboon during hemorrhagic shock. Stroke. 1979;10:401 407.

    4. Hernandez MJ, Brennan RW, Bowman GS. Cerebral blood flow

    autoregulation in the rat. Stroke. 1978;9:150 154.

    5. Hoyer S, Hamer J, Alberti E, Stoeckel H, Weinhardt F. The effect of

    stepwise arterial hypotension on blood flow and oxidative

    metabolism of the brain. Pflugers Arch. 1974;351:161172.

    Heterogeneity of CBF during Pressure-Controlled Hemorrhage

    Volume 56 Number 3 601

  • 8/11/2019 Waschke Et Al. - 2004 - Regional Heterogeneity of Cerebral Blood Flow Response to Graded Pressure-Controlled H

    12/13

    6. DeWitt DS, Prough DS, Taylor CL, Whitley JM, Deal DD, Vines

    SM. Regional cerebrovascular responses to progressive hypotension

    after traumatic brain injury in cats. Am J Physiol. 1992;263:H1276

    H1284.

    7. Ferrari M, Wilson DA, Hanley DF, Traystman RJ. Effects of graded

    hypotension on cerebral blood flow, blood volume, and mean transit

    time in dogs. Am J Physiol. 1992;262:H1908 H1914.

    8. Gamache FW Jr, Myers RE, Monell E. Changes in local cerebral

    blood flow following profound systemic hypotension. J Neurosurg.

    1976;44:215225.

    9. Mueller SM, Heistad DD, Marcus ML. Total and regional

    cerebral blood flow during hypotension, hypertension, and

    hypocapnia: effect of sympathetic denervation in dogs. Circ Res.

    1977;41:350 356.

    10. Sadoshima S, Heistad DD. Regional cerebral blood flow during

    hypotension in normotensive and stroke-prone spontaneously

    hypertensive rats: effect of sympathetic denervation.Stroke. 1983;

    14:575579.

    11. Slater G, Vladeck BC, Bassin R, Brown RS, Shoemaker WC.

    Sequential changes in cerebral blood flow and distribution of

    flow within the brain during hemorrhagic shock. Ann Surg. 1975;

    181:1 4.

    12. Niwa K, Takizawa S, Takagi S, Shinohara Y. Mild hypothermia

    disturbs regional cerebrovascular autoregulation in awake rats. Brain

    Res. 1998;789:68 73.

    13. Kovach AG, Sandor P. Cerebral blood flow and brain function

    during hypotension and shock.Annu Rev Physiol. 1976;38:571596.

    14. Lassen NA, Christensen MS. Physiology of cerebral blood flow.

    Br J Anaesth. 1976;48:719 734.

    15. McPherson RW, Koehler RC, Traystman RJ. Effect of jugular

    venous pressure on cerebral autoregulation in dogs. Am J Physiol.

    1988;255:H1516H1524.

    16. Luce JM, Huseby JS, Kirk W, Butler J. Mechanism by which

    positive end-expiratory pressure increases cerebrospinal fluid

    pressure in dogs. J Appl Physiol. 1982;52:231235.

    17. Sakurada O, Kennedy C, Jehle J, Brown JD, Carbin GL, Sokoloff L.

    Measurement of local cerebral blood flow with iodo [14C] antipyrine.

    Am J Physiol. 1978;234:H59 H66.

    18. Kety SS. The theory and applications of the exchange of inert gas at

    the lungs and tissues. Pharm Rev. 1951;3:114.

    19. Landau WM, Freygang WHJ, Rowland LP, Sokoloff L, Kety SS.

    The local circulation of the living brain: values in the

    unanesthetized and anesthetized cat. Trans Am Neurol Assoc.

    1955;80:125129.

    20. Freygang WHJ, Sokoloff L. Quantitative measurement of regional

    circulation in the central nervous system by the use of radioactive

    inert gas. Adv Biol Med Physics. 1958;6:263279.

    21. Kety SS. Measurement of local blood flow by the exchange of an

    inert, diffusible substance. Methods Med Res. 1960;8:228 236.

    22. Sokoloff L. Local cerebral circulation at rest and during altered

    cerebral activity induced by anesthesia or visual stimulation. In:

    Kety SS, Elkes J, eds. The Regional Chemistry, Physiology and

    Pharmacology of the Nervous System. Oxford: Pergamon; 1961:107

    117.

    23. Palkovits M, Brownstein MJ.Maps and Guide to Microdissection of

    the Rat Brain. New York: Elsevier; 1988.

    24. Schrock H, Kuschinsky W. Cerebral blood flow, glucose use, and

    CSF ionic regulation in potassium-depleted rats. Am J Physiol. 1988;

    254:H250 H257.

    25. Duling BR, Damon DH. An examination of the measurement of

    flow heterogeneity in striated muscle.Circ Res. 1987;60:113.

    26. Bassingthwaighte JB. Relative dispersion: a characterizing feature of

    specific vascular beds.Anesth Analg Curr Res. 1977;56:7277.

    27. Wang CF, Hegsted DM. Normal blood volume, plasma volume and

    thiocyanate space in rats and their relation to body weight. Am J

    Physiol. 1949;156:218 232.

    28. Schrer L, Dautermann C, Hartl R, et al. Treatment of hemorrhagic

    hypotension with hypertonic/hyperoncotic solutions: effects on

    regional cerebral blood flow and brain surface oxygen tension. Eur

    Surg Res. 1992;24:112.

    29. Verhaegen MJ, Todd MM, Hindman BJ, Warner DS. Cerebralautoregulation during moderate hypothermia in rats. Stroke. 1993;

    24:407 414.

    30. Toyoda K, Fujii K, Ibayashi S, Sadoshima S, Fujishima M.

    Changes in arterioles, arteries, and local perfusion of the brain

    stem during hemorrhagic hypertension. Am J Physiol. 1996;

    270:H1350 H1354.

    31. Zaharchuk G, Mandeville JB, Bogdanov AA, Weissleder R, Rosen

    BR, Marota JJ. Cerebrovascular dynamics of autoregulation and

    hypoperfusion: an MRI study of CBF and changes in total and

    microvascular cerebral blood volume during hemorrhagic

    hypotension. Stroke. 1999;30:21972204.

    32. Bourguignon PR, Shackford SR, Shiffer C, Nichols P, Nees AV.

    Delayed fluid resuscitation of head injury and uncontrolled

    hemorrhagic shock. Arch Surg. 1998;133:390 398.33. Laughlin MH. Cerebral, coronary, and renal blood flows during

    hemorrhagic hypotension in anesthetized miniature swine.Adv Shock

    Res. 1983;9:189 201.

    34. Anwar M, Agarwal R, Rashduni D, Weiss HR. Effects of

    hemorrhagic hypotension on cerebral blood flow and perfused

    capillaries in newborn pigs.Can J Physiol Pharmacol. 1996;74:157

    162.

    35. Komjati K, Sandor P, Reivich M, et al. Regional heterogeneity and

    differential vulnerability of cerebral and spinal vascular CO2-responsiveness during graded haemorrhagic hypotension. Acta

    Physiol Hung. 1996;84:229 249.

    36. Nishimura S, Suzuki A, Hatazawa J, et al. Cerebral blood-flow

    responses to induced hypotension and to CO2 inhalation in patients

    with major cerebral artery occlusive disease: a positron-emission

    tomography study. Neuroradiology. 1999;41:7379.

    37. Bauer R, Hoyer D, Walter B, Gaser E, Kluge H, Zwiener U.

    Changed systemic and cerebral hemodynamics and oxygen supply

    due to gradual hemorrhagic hypotension induced by an external

    PID-controller in newborn swine.Exp Toxicol Pathol. 1997;

    49:469 476.

    38. Shinohara Y, Yamamoto M, Takagi S, Haida M, Hamano H,

    Kametsu Y. Local CO2 reactivity and autoregulation in the normal

    monkey brain. In: Yonas H, ed. Cerebral Blood Flow Measurement

    with Stable Xenon-Enhanced Computed Tomography. New York:

    Raven Press; 1992:244 248.

    39. Seyde WC, McGowan L, Lund N, Duling B, Longnecker DE.

    Effects of anesthetics on regional hemodynamics in normovolemic

    and hemorrhaged rats. Am J Physiol. 1985;249:H164 H173.

    40. Enlund M, Andersson J, Hartvig P, Valtysson J, Wiklund L.Cerebral normoxia in the rhesus monkey during isoflurane- or

    propofol-induced hypotension and hypocapnia, despite disparate

    blood-flow patterns: a positron emission tomography study. Acta

    Anaesthesiol Scand. 1997;41:10021010.

    41. Schadt JC, Ludbrook J. Hemodynamic and neurohumoral responses

    to acute hypovolemia in conscious mammals. Am J Physiol. 1991;

    260:H305H318.

    42. Hoffman WD, Banks SM, Alling DW, et al. Factors that determine

    the hemodynamic response to inhalation anesthetics.J Appl Physiol.

    1991;70:21552163.

    43. Longnecker DE, McCoy S, Drucker WR. Anesthetic influence on

    response to hemorrhage in rats. Circ Shock. 1979;6:55 60.

    44. Harper MA, Glass HI. Effect of alterations in the arterial carbon

    dioxide tension on the blood flow through the cerebral cortex at

    The Journal ofTRAUMAInjury, Infection, and Critical Care

    602 March 2004

  • 8/11/2019 Waschke Et Al. - 2004 - Regional Heterogeneity of Cerebral Blood Flow Response to Graded Pressure-Controlled H

    13/13

    normal and low arterial blood pressures. J Neurol Neurosurg

    Psychiatry. 1965;28:449 452.

    45. Duckrow RB, Beard DC, Brennan RW. Regional cerebral blood

    flow decreases during hyperglycemia. Ann Neurol. 1985;17:267272.

    46. Duckrow RB, Beard DC, Brennan RW. Regional cerebral blood flow de-

    creases during chronic and acute hyperglycemia. Stroke. 1987;18:5258.

    47. Lassen NA. Cerebral blood flow in cerebral ischemia: a review. Eur

    Neurol. 1978;17(suppl 1):4 8.

    48. Pulsinelli WA. Selective neuronal vulnerability and infarction in

    cerebrovascular disease. In: Welch KMA, Reis DJ, Caplan LR,

    Siesjo BK, Weir B, eds. Primer on Cerebrovascular Diseases. San

    Diego: Academic Press; 1997:104107.

    49. Edvinsson E, MacKenzie ET, McCulloch J. General and comparative

    anatomy of the cerebral circulation. In: Edvinsson E, MacKenzie ET,

    McCulloch J, eds. Cerebral Blood Flow and Metabolism. New York:

    Raven Press; 1993:339.

    Heterogeneity of CBF during Pressure-Controlled Hemorrhage

    Volume 56 Number 3 603