vcps for staggered prt sebastián torres and david warde cimms/nssl data quality mou – technical...
TRANSCRIPT
VCPs for Staggered PRT
Sebastián Torres and David Warde
CIMMS/NSSL
Data Quality MOU – Technical Interchange Meeting
Fall 2008
2
Outline
• Designing VCPs for Staggered PRT (recap)
– Performance indicators
• Test VCPs 14 and 15 (recap)– Design criteria
• Benefits of using shorter PRTs– Trade-offs
• A new test VCP– Performance analysis
• Recommendation andFuture Work
Staggered PRT
ra = 184 km, va = 45.1 m/s
3
VCP Performance Indicators
• Acquisition time– Dwell times
• Maximum unambiguous range– Surveillance (Z)– Doppler (V & W)
• Maximum unambiguous velocity• Spectrum width saturation• Errors of estimates– Statistical errors– Dealiasing errors
• Clutter suppression
4
PRT Choice
• Shorter PRTs– Larger Nyquist– Larger maximum
spectrum width– More samples for the
same dwell times – Lower errors of
estimates– Lower rate of
catastrophic errors– Better clutter
suppression
• Longer PRTs– Longer unambiguous
range
5
VCP Design Criterion
• Make T1 as short as possible– No-overlay condition
• ra,1 ≥ rmax
– T1 ≥ 2rmax / c
– Algorithm limitation• ra,2 ≥ rmax
– T1 ≥ 4rmax / 3c
• ra,D = ra,1 and ra,S = ra,2
– The no-overlay condition is more restrictive, but not a requirement
– The current SPRT algorithm does not handle range unfolding
6
Test VCPs for Staggered PRT
• 2007: Staggered PRT subcommittee– Two test VCPs based on VCP 12
• Intermediate and high elevations running SPRT ( = 2/3)
• Design criterion
– VCP 14: Same dwell times as VCP 12– VCP 15: Double dwell times as VCP 12 for SPRT
EL < 4 degEL > 4 deg
8
• If we allow some overlay– ra,1 ≤ rmax ≤ ra,2
• No overlay: ra,1 = rmax
• Maximum overlay: ra,2 = rmax
– Shorter PRTs– Must have technique to recover overlaid
echoes
Overlay Trade-off
ra,2
ra,1
rmax
9
New VCP Design Criterion
• We can trade shorter PRT for increased likelihood of overlaid echoes
– Benefits are realized for elevations above 2.4 deg
Solid: oldDashed: new
10
Choosing the Dwell Times
• Dwell times must be chosen to…– Meet error requirements for reflectivity,
velocity, and spectrum width– Meet clutter filtering requirements– Satisfy operational needs
14
Performance of SACHI
• Excessively long dwell times seem to be needed to meet clutter filtering velocity requirements
– Feasible, but operationally not acceptable
• Recommend using dwell times to meet error requirements
– Longer dwell times than with VCP 12, but operationally acceptable
• We have anecdotal evidence of operators switching from VCP 12 to VCP 21 to get what they want
15
Performance of SACHI
• Only Doppler velocities are affected corresponding to gates …
– … with strong clutter contamination and … – … with velocities around 0, ±va/5, ±2va/5 and …– … where SACHI doesn’t pick the right wx “replica” and …
– … where the ORPG velocity dealiasing algorithm fails to fix spatial discontinuity
• This has not been quantified!
• Censoring of “bad velocities” is possible– Reflectivities are still good for rainfall rate estimates
• Standard errors are more than 3x better than with the Batch mode
– Spectrum widths are still good for turbulence
16
Proposed VCP
• T1 for maximum allowable overlay
• Dwell times to meet error requirements
– VCP time ~6 min
17
Proposed VCP Performance• Acquisition time– Longer dwell times lead to VCP time ~6 min
• Maximum unambiguous range and velocity– Great improvement w.r.t legacy VCPs
• Spectrum width saturation– Acceptable
• Errors of estimates– Statistical errors meet requirements– Catastrophic errors effectively handled by ORPG’s
VDA
• Clutter suppression– Meets requirements for Z and W– V dealiasing errors may be handled by ORPG’s VDA
18
Summary
• Staggered PRT provides significant benefits …
– Longer unambiguous range– Larger Nyquist velocity– More accurate reflectivity estimates
• … that must be traded for …– Longer acquisition times (~VCP 21)
• Operationally acceptable
– Increased rate of velocity dealiasing errors• Handled by ORPG’s VDA
19
Future Work
• Recommendation– Implement proposed test VCP– Collect more data cases – Process data using recommended SPRT
algorithm including SACHI and modified ORPG velocity dealiasing algorithm
– Assess data quality
• Future work– Complete evaluation of technique
to recover overlaid echoes for SPRT– Research ways to improve SACHI