uspas course on 4th generation light sources ii erls and...

41
USPAS 4 th Generation Light Sources II Krafft/Bazarov 20 October 2002 CHESS / LEPP CHESS / LEPP USPAS Course on 4 th Generation Light Sources II ERLs and Thomson Scattering G. A. Krafft and I. V. Bazarov Jefferson Lab and Cornell University Thomson Scattering Sources

Upload: others

Post on 24-Sep-2020

1 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: USPAS Course on 4th Generation Light Sources II ERLs and ...casa.jlab.org/publications/viewgraphs/lecture/bazarov_uspas_day3.pdfCHESS / LEPP USPAS 4th Generation Light Sources II Krafft/Bazarov

USPAS 4th Generation Light Sources II Krafft/Bazarov 20 October 2002CHESS / LEPPCHESS / LEPP

USPAS Course on4th Generation Light Sources IIERLs and Thomson Scattering

G. A. Krafft and I. V. BazarovJefferson Lab and Cornell University

Thomson Scattering Sources

Page 2: USPAS Course on 4th Generation Light Sources II ERLs and ...casa.jlab.org/publications/viewgraphs/lecture/bazarov_uspas_day3.pdfCHESS / LEPP USPAS 4th Generation Light Sources II Krafft/Bazarov

USPAS 4th Generation Light Sources II Krafft/Bazarov 20 October 2002CHESS / LEPPCHESS / LEPP

Thomson Scatter Sources & Related Proposals

1. Thomson Scattering vs. Undulator Radiation2. Thomson Scattering Sources (TSS):

1. JLAB2. BNL3. Duke4. Berkeley5. Idaho Accelerator Center6. Naval Research Lab

3. Other proposals:1. Small-Angle Geometry2. Laser Electron Storage Ring

Sir J.J. Thomson

Page 3: USPAS Course on 4th Generation Light Sources II ERLs and ...casa.jlab.org/publications/viewgraphs/lecture/bazarov_uspas_day3.pdfCHESS / LEPP USPAS 4th Generation Light Sources II Krafft/Bazarov

USPAS 4th Generation Light Sources II Krafft/Bazarov 20 October 2002CHESS / LEPPCHESS / LEPP

Thomson Scattering vs. Undulator Radiation

λp

N N

N

S

SS

γ/K θ

λ

λe–

• Undulator radiation can be looked as Thomson scattering (and vice versa)

• Same signature: polarization, harmonic content when a0, K ≥ 1

cmkeBK

ep

0=20

0 cmeAa

e

=

Page 4: USPAS Course on 4th Generation Light Sources II ERLs and ...casa.jlab.org/publications/viewgraphs/lecture/bazarov_uspas_day3.pdfCHESS / LEPP USPAS 4th Generation Light Sources II Krafft/Bazarov

USPAS 4th Generation Light Sources II Krafft/Bazarov 20 October 2002CHESS / LEPPCHESS / LEPP

Thomson Scattering Same as Short Undulator Radiation

)1(2

222 θγ

γλ

λ +≈ peptotph NNKN 2

, α≈For K ≤ 1:

1371

=e

erD

Scaling with undulator period of the formulas above:2~ γλp• to keep radiation wavelength the same:

• to keep the number of photons the sameif undulator length is kept the same: γ/1~0Bif number of periods is kept the same: 2

0 /1~ γB

B0 in undulator is limited to ~ Tesla, thus, electron energy is constrained to some multi-GeV, and undulator period to ~ cm for hard x-ray production.

~ (∆ω/ω)×(ε⊥/εph)2

useful fraction

πλ 4/

Page 5: USPAS Course on 4th Generation Light Sources II ERLs and ...casa.jlab.org/publications/viewgraphs/lecture/bazarov_uspas_day3.pdfCHESS / LEPP USPAS 4th Generation Light Sources II Krafft/Bazarov

USPAS 4th Generation Light Sources II Krafft/Bazarov 20 October 2002CHESS / LEPPCHESS / LEPP

Different Thomson Scattering Geometries

λ

e–

φθ

φθγ

γλλ

cos11)1(

222

2 −+≈ L

Θ′=Ω′

22 sineT r

ddσ

66538 2 == eT rπσ mbarn

• possible advantages include compact design (small γ), fs x-ray pulses

• we’ll look at different examples of TSS: φ = π/2, φ = π and φ << 1

φ ′φ

S S′

φcoskk z =yk yy kk =′

)cos( φβγ −−=′ kk z

Page 6: USPAS Course on 4th Generation Light Sources II ERLs and ...casa.jlab.org/publications/viewgraphs/lecture/bazarov_uspas_day3.pdfCHESS / LEPP USPAS 4th Generation Light Sources II Krafft/Bazarov

USPAS 4th Generation Light Sources II Krafft/Bazarov 20 October 2002CHESS / LEPPCHESS / LEPP

Photons Wanted

kTh /~

Page 7: USPAS Course on 4th Generation Light Sources II ERLs and ...casa.jlab.org/publications/viewgraphs/lecture/bazarov_uspas_day3.pdfCHESS / LEPP USPAS 4th Generation Light Sources II Krafft/Bazarov

USPAS 4th Generation Light Sources II Krafft/Bazarov 20 October 2002CHESS / LEPPCHESS / LEPP

Reality Check Against Photon “Starvation”From undulator:

Thomson scattered x-rays: eLphT

totph NNN ,, areaspot focused~ σ

mostlyincoherent

photons

204)µm 100(

2, 10~

mbarn 665~areaspot focused~

2

πσ

αT

pLph NKN

Laser pulse needed:

~1

or ~ 10 J / pulse (TW laser)or:

)W/cm()µm(1085.0/ 29200 LLe IcmeAa λ−×≈=

218 W/cm102.2 ×≈LI1~0a for

• can be tough to match laser and electron beams in space-time, i.e. only a fraction of electrons or photons will participate in scattering

• rep rate is limited to ~ kHz (don’t need more for pump probe exp.)

eptotph NNKN 2, α≈

Page 8: USPAS Course on 4th Generation Light Sources II ERLs and ...casa.jlab.org/publications/viewgraphs/lecture/bazarov_uspas_day3.pdfCHESS / LEPP USPAS 4th Generation Light Sources II Krafft/Bazarov

USPAS 4th Generation Light Sources II Krafft/Bazarov 20 October 2002CHESS / LEPPCHESS / LEPP

Outline

1. Thomson Scattering vs. Undulator Radiation2. Thomson Scattering Sources (TSS):

1. JLAB2. BNL3. Duke4. Berkeley5. Idaho Accelerator Center6. Japanese Tohuku Group

3. Other proposals:1. Small-Angle Geometry2. Laser Electron Storage Ring

Page 9: USPAS Course on 4th Generation Light Sources II ERLs and ...casa.jlab.org/publications/viewgraphs/lecture/bazarov_uspas_day3.pdfCHESS / LEPP USPAS 4th Generation Light Sources II Krafft/Bazarov

USPAS 4th Generation Light Sources II Krafft/Bazarov 20 October 2002CHESS / LEPPCHESS / LEPP

… …

Page 10: USPAS Course on 4th Generation Light Sources II ERLs and ...casa.jlab.org/publications/viewgraphs/lecture/bazarov_uspas_day3.pdfCHESS / LEPP USPAS 4th Generation Light Sources II Krafft/Bazarov

USPAS 4th Generation Light Sources II Krafft/Bazarov 20 October 2002CHESS / LEPPCHESS / LEPP

peak

peak

0.1 % bw

Page 11: USPAS Course on 4th Generation Light Sources II ERLs and ...casa.jlab.org/publications/viewgraphs/lecture/bazarov_uspas_day3.pdfCHESS / LEPP USPAS 4th Generation Light Sources II Krafft/Bazarov

USPAS 4th Generation Light Sources II Krafft/Bazarov 20 October 2002CHESS / LEPPCHESS / LEPP

Outline

1. Thomson Scattering vs. Undulator Radiation2. Thomson Scattering Sources (TSS):

1. JLAB2. BNL3. Duke4. Berkeley5. Idaho Accelerator Center6. Japanese Tohuku Group

3. Other proposals:1. Small-Angle Geometry2. Laser Electron Storage Ring

Page 12: USPAS Course on 4th Generation Light Sources II ERLs and ...casa.jlab.org/publications/viewgraphs/lecture/bazarov_uspas_day3.pdfCHESS / LEPP USPAS 4th Generation Light Sources II Krafft/Bazarov

USPAS 4th Generation Light Sources II Krafft/Bazarov 20 October 2002CHESS / LEPPCHESS / LEPP

Duke FEL γ-production

Page 13: USPAS Course on 4th Generation Light Sources II ERLs and ...casa.jlab.org/publications/viewgraphs/lecture/bazarov_uspas_day3.pdfCHESS / LEPP USPAS 4th Generation Light Sources II Krafft/Bazarov

USPAS 4th Generation Light Sources II Krafft/Bazarov 20 October 2002CHESS / LEPPCHESS / LEPP

Machine Description

Page 14: USPAS Course on 4th Generation Light Sources II ERLs and ...casa.jlab.org/publications/viewgraphs/lecture/bazarov_uspas_day3.pdfCHESS / LEPP USPAS 4th Generation Light Sources II Krafft/Bazarov

USPAS 4th Generation Light Sources II Krafft/Bazarov 20 October 2002CHESS / LEPPCHESS / LEPP

Measured γ-rays

Note: γ-ray polarization is ~ 100 %

Page 15: USPAS Course on 4th Generation Light Sources II ERLs and ...casa.jlab.org/publications/viewgraphs/lecture/bazarov_uspas_day3.pdfCHESS / LEPP USPAS 4th Generation Light Sources II Krafft/Bazarov

USPAS 4th Generation Light Sources II Krafft/Bazarov 20 October 2002CHESS / LEPPCHESS / LEPP

Future Plans

Page 16: USPAS Course on 4th Generation Light Sources II ERLs and ...casa.jlab.org/publications/viewgraphs/lecture/bazarov_uspas_day3.pdfCHESS / LEPP USPAS 4th Generation Light Sources II Krafft/Bazarov

USPAS 4th Generation Light Sources II Krafft/Bazarov 20 October 2002CHESS / LEPPCHESS / LEPP

Outline

1. Thomson Scattering vs. Undulator Radiation2. Thomson Scattering Sources (TSS):

1. JLAB2. BNL3. Duke4. Berkeley5. Idaho Accelerator Center6. Japanese Tohuku Group

3. Other proposals:1. Small-Angle Geometry2. Laser Electron Storage Ring

Page 17: USPAS Course on 4th Generation Light Sources II ERLs and ...casa.jlab.org/publications/viewgraphs/lecture/bazarov_uspas_day3.pdfCHESS / LEPP USPAS 4th Generation Light Sources II Krafft/Bazarov

USPAS 4th Generation Light Sources II Krafft/Bazarov 20 October 2002CHESS / LEPPCHESS / LEPP

Page 18: USPAS Course on 4th Generation Light Sources II ERLs and ...casa.jlab.org/publications/viewgraphs/lecture/bazarov_uspas_day3.pdfCHESS / LEPP USPAS 4th Generation Light Sources II Krafft/Bazarov

USPAS 4th Generation Light Sources II Krafft/Bazarov 20 October 2002CHESS / LEPPCHESS / LEPP

h ≈ 4 eV·fskT ≈ 1/40 eV

?

Page 19: USPAS Course on 4th Generation Light Sources II ERLs and ...casa.jlab.org/publications/viewgraphs/lecture/bazarov_uspas_day3.pdfCHESS / LEPP USPAS 4th Generation Light Sources II Krafft/Bazarov

USPAS 4th Generation Light Sources II Krafft/Bazarov 20 October 2002CHESS / LEPPCHESS / LEPP

Page 20: USPAS Course on 4th Generation Light Sources II ERLs and ...casa.jlab.org/publications/viewgraphs/lecture/bazarov_uspas_day3.pdfCHESS / LEPP USPAS 4th Generation Light Sources II Krafft/Bazarov

USPAS 4th Generation Light Sources II Krafft/Bazarov 20 October 2002CHESS / LEPPCHESS / LEPP

Page 21: USPAS Course on 4th Generation Light Sources II ERLs and ...casa.jlab.org/publications/viewgraphs/lecture/bazarov_uspas_day3.pdfCHESS / LEPP USPAS 4th Generation Light Sources II Krafft/Bazarov

USPAS 4th Generation Light Sources II Krafft/Bazarov 20 October 2002CHESS / LEPPCHESS / LEPP

Experimental ResultsR.W. Shoenlein et. al, Nature (274) 5285

e– beam50 MeV, 1.3 nC, 90 µm, 20 pslaser beam800 nm, 100 fs, 60 mJ, 30 µm

x-ray beam produced2 × 105 ph mm–2 mrad–2 s–1 in a 15% bandwidth

Page 22: USPAS Course on 4th Generation Light Sources II ERLs and ...casa.jlab.org/publications/viewgraphs/lecture/bazarov_uspas_day3.pdfCHESS / LEPP USPAS 4th Generation Light Sources II Krafft/Bazarov

USPAS 4th Generation Light Sources II Krafft/Bazarov 20 October 2002CHESS / LEPPCHESS / LEPP

Outline

1. Thomson Scattering vs. Undulator Radiation2. Thomson Scattering Sources (TSS):

1. JLAB2. BNL3. Duke4. Berkeley5. Idaho Accelerator Center6. Naval Research Lab

3. Other proposals:1. Small-Angle Geometry2. Laser Electron Storage Ring

Page 23: USPAS Course on 4th Generation Light Sources II ERLs and ...casa.jlab.org/publications/viewgraphs/lecture/bazarov_uspas_day3.pdfCHESS / LEPP USPAS 4th Generation Light Sources II Krafft/Bazarov

USPAS 4th Generation Light Sources II Krafft/Bazarov 20 October 2002CHESS / LEPPCHESS / LEPP

Page 24: USPAS Course on 4th Generation Light Sources II ERLs and ...casa.jlab.org/publications/viewgraphs/lecture/bazarov_uspas_day3.pdfCHESS / LEPP USPAS 4th Generation Light Sources II Krafft/Bazarov

USPAS 4th Generation Light Sources II Krafft/Bazarov 20 October 2002CHESS / LEPPCHESS / LEPP

The Layout

Page 25: USPAS Course on 4th Generation Light Sources II ERLs and ...casa.jlab.org/publications/viewgraphs/lecture/bazarov_uspas_day3.pdfCHESS / LEPP USPAS 4th Generation Light Sources II Krafft/Bazarov

USPAS 4th Generation Light Sources II Krafft/Bazarov 20 October 2002CHESS / LEPPCHESS / LEPP

Interaction Region

Page 26: USPAS Course on 4th Generation Light Sources II ERLs and ...casa.jlab.org/publications/viewgraphs/lecture/bazarov_uspas_day3.pdfCHESS / LEPP USPAS 4th Generation Light Sources II Krafft/Bazarov

USPAS 4th Generation Light Sources II Krafft/Bazarov 20 October 2002CHESS / LEPPCHESS / LEPP

Indirect Laser Pulse Measurements

Page 27: USPAS Course on 4th Generation Light Sources II ERLs and ...casa.jlab.org/publications/viewgraphs/lecture/bazarov_uspas_day3.pdfCHESS / LEPP USPAS 4th Generation Light Sources II Krafft/Bazarov

USPAS 4th Generation Light Sources II Krafft/Bazarov 20 October 2002CHESS / LEPPCHESS / LEPP

X-ray Measurements

Page 28: USPAS Course on 4th Generation Light Sources II ERLs and ...casa.jlab.org/publications/viewgraphs/lecture/bazarov_uspas_day3.pdfCHESS / LEPP USPAS 4th Generation Light Sources II Krafft/Bazarov

USPAS 4th Generation Light Sources II Krafft/Bazarov 20 October 2002CHESS / LEPPCHESS / LEPP

Outline

1. Thomson Scattering vs. Undulator Radiation2. Thomson Scattering Sources (TSS):

1. JLAB2. BNL3. Duke4. Berkeley5. Idaho Accelerator Center6. Naval Research Lab

3. Other proposals:1. Small-Angle Geometry2. Laser Electron Storage Ring

Page 29: USPAS Course on 4th Generation Light Sources II ERLs and ...casa.jlab.org/publications/viewgraphs/lecture/bazarov_uspas_day3.pdfCHESS / LEPP USPAS 4th Generation Light Sources II Krafft/Bazarov

USPAS 4th Generation Light Sources II Krafft/Bazarov 20 October 2002CHESS / LEPPCHESS / LEPP

Page 30: USPAS Course on 4th Generation Light Sources II ERLs and ...casa.jlab.org/publications/viewgraphs/lecture/bazarov_uspas_day3.pdfCHESS / LEPP USPAS 4th Generation Light Sources II Krafft/Bazarov

USPAS 4th Generation Light Sources II Krafft/Bazarov 20 October 2002CHESS / LEPPCHESS / LEPP

Outline

1. Thomson Scattering vs. Undulator Radiation2. Thomson Scattering Sources (TSS):

1. JLAB2. BNL3. Duke4. Berkeley5. Idaho Accelerator Center6. Naval Research Lab

3. Other proposals:1. Small-Angle Geometry2. Laser Electron Storage Ring

Page 31: USPAS Course on 4th Generation Light Sources II ERLs and ...casa.jlab.org/publications/viewgraphs/lecture/bazarov_uspas_day3.pdfCHESS / LEPP USPAS 4th Generation Light Sources II Krafft/Bazarov

USPAS 4th Generation Light Sources II Krafft/Bazarov 20 October 2002CHESS / LEPPCHESS / LEPP

… ≈ 3°

Page 32: USPAS Course on 4th Generation Light Sources II ERLs and ...casa.jlab.org/publications/viewgraphs/lecture/bazarov_uspas_day3.pdfCHESS / LEPP USPAS 4th Generation Light Sources II Krafft/Bazarov

USPAS 4th Generation Light Sources II Krafft/Bazarov 20 October 2002CHESS / LEPPCHESS / LEPP

Page 33: USPAS Course on 4th Generation Light Sources II ERLs and ...casa.jlab.org/publications/viewgraphs/lecture/bazarov_uspas_day3.pdfCHESS / LEPP USPAS 4th Generation Light Sources II Krafft/Bazarov

USPAS 4th Generation Light Sources II Krafft/Bazarov 20 October 2002CHESS / LEPPCHESS / LEPP

βx, y = 4 mm?

Note: state-of-the-art peak brightness from 3rd

generation light sources approaches 1024 photons s-1 mm-2 mrad-2 per 0.1% bw, and average fluxis 1015 photons s-1 per 0.1% bw.

Page 34: USPAS Course on 4th Generation Light Sources II ERLs and ...casa.jlab.org/publications/viewgraphs/lecture/bazarov_uspas_day3.pdfCHESS / LEPP USPAS 4th Generation Light Sources II Krafft/Bazarov

USPAS 4th Generation Light Sources II Krafft/Bazarov 20 October 2002CHESS / LEPPCHESS / LEPP

f104 per 0.1% bw

per pulse

should be 1018

Note: different laser parameters were used for different Thomson scattering sources

Page 35: USPAS Course on 4th Generation Light Sources II ERLs and ...casa.jlab.org/publications/viewgraphs/lecture/bazarov_uspas_day3.pdfCHESS / LEPP USPAS 4th Generation Light Sources II Krafft/Bazarov

USPAS 4th Generation Light Sources II Krafft/Bazarov 20 October 2002CHESS / LEPPCHESS / LEPP

Peak brightness alone can be misleading

Single photon peak brightness: 33 )2/()2(1hπ

=peakB

3o

24221 ))A(/(104.2bw) 0.1%per mradmmsphoton ( λ×=---peakB

or in conventional units:

peak brightness @ 1 Å when photon degeneracy is 1

SummaryThomson scattering sources can provide ~ 103-4 shorter pulses than that of 3rd

generation light sources, with peak brightness lower by at least ~ 103-4 and average flux lower by at least 109-10 assuming state-of-the-art rep rate for laser. Even if the rep rate of Thomson scattering event were somehow improved to some sub-GHz (c.f. next project), average flux would still be ~ 103-4 when compared to a 3rd generation light sources.

Page 36: USPAS Course on 4th Generation Light Sources II ERLs and ...casa.jlab.org/publications/viewgraphs/lecture/bazarov_uspas_day3.pdfCHESS / LEPP USPAS 4th Generation Light Sources II Krafft/Bazarov

USPAS 4th Generation Light Sources II Krafft/Bazarov 20 October 2002CHESS / LEPPCHESS / LEPP

Outline

1. Thomson Scattering vs. Undulator Radiation2. Thomson Scattering Sources (TSS):

1. JLAB2. BNL3. Duke4. Berkeley5. Idaho Accelerator Center6. Naval Research Lab

3. Other proposals:1. Small-Angle Geometry2. Laser Electron Storage Ring

Page 37: USPAS Course on 4th Generation Light Sources II ERLs and ...casa.jlab.org/publications/viewgraphs/lecture/bazarov_uspas_day3.pdfCHESS / LEPP USPAS 4th Generation Light Sources II Krafft/Bazarov

USPAS 4th Generation Light Sources II Krafft/Bazarov 20 October 2002CHESS / LEPPCHESS / LEPP

Page 38: USPAS Course on 4th Generation Light Sources II ERLs and ...casa.jlab.org/publications/viewgraphs/lecture/bazarov_uspas_day3.pdfCHESS / LEPP USPAS 4th Generation Light Sources II Krafft/Bazarov

USPAS 4th Generation Light Sources II Krafft/Bazarov 20 October 2002CHESS / LEPPCHESS / LEPP

General Idea

phase space damping rate:

phase space excitation rate:

EPphε∝ 2

4

ρEPph ∝ due to bends alone, i.e. small

ringphph HENE

22

1 &∝

Page 39: USPAS Course on 4th Generation Light Sources II ERLs and ...casa.jlab.org/publications/viewgraphs/lecture/bazarov_uspas_day3.pdfCHESS / LEPP USPAS 4th Generation Light Sources II Krafft/Bazarov

USPAS 4th Generation Light Sources II Krafft/Bazarov 20 October 2002CHESS / LEPPCHESS / LEPP

Damping From Thomson “Undulator”

Page 40: USPAS Course on 4th Generation Light Sources II ERLs and ...casa.jlab.org/publications/viewgraphs/lecture/bazarov_uspas_day3.pdfCHESS / LEPP USPAS 4th Generation Light Sources II Krafft/Bazarov

USPAS 4th Generation Light Sources II Krafft/Bazarov 20 October 2002CHESS / LEPPCHESS / LEPP

Theoretical emittance & energy spread

Note: large initial emittancecan hinder the damping

Page 41: USPAS Course on 4th Generation Light Sources II ERLs and ...casa.jlab.org/publications/viewgraphs/lecture/bazarov_uspas_day3.pdfCHESS / LEPP USPAS 4th Generation Light Sources II Krafft/Bazarov

USPAS 4th Generation Light Sources II Krafft/Bazarov 20 October 2002CHESS / LEPPCHESS / LEPP

Fabry-Perot resonator & Projected performance

laser peak power: 0.2 TW (transient)6 GW (steady)

rep rate: 0.1 GHz (steady)

laser power req.d: 200 W