unsupervised classification of remote multispectral ... · i (f t , lt tr-220-1075 april 1972...

102
lt I (F t , TR-220-1075 APRIL 1972 UNSUPERVISED CLASSIFICATION OF REMOTE MULTISPECTRAL SENSING DATA 172-27204 Ic.AS C 1 237s9e Aa)1AsXPEaISED , Prepared for: NATIONAL AERONAUTICS AND SPACE ADMINISTRATION GEORGE C. MARSHALL SPACE FLIGHT CENTER Aero-Astrodynamics Laboratory UNDER CONTRACT NAS8-27364 i l, ,) / I> NORTHROP SERVICES. INC. P. 0. BOX 1484 HUNTSVILLE, ALABAMA 35807 TELEPHONE (205)837-0580 REPRODUCED BY NATIONAL TECHNICAL INFORMATION SERVICE U.S. DEPARTMENT OF COMMERCE I. SPRNGFJELD, VA. 2216 . _ _-- . -- 1K I i .... 0 '? https://ntrs.nasa.gov/search.jsp?R=19720019554 2018-07-08T16:18:12+00:00Z

Upload: truongdiep

Post on 11-Jun-2018

218 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: UNSUPERVISED CLASSIFICATION OF REMOTE MULTISPECTRAL ... · i (f t , lt tr-220-1075 april 1972 unsupervised classification of remote multispectral sensing data 172-27204 ic.as c 237s9e

ltI (F t ,TR-220-1075APRIL 1972

UNSUPERVISED CLASSIFICATION OFREMOTE MULTISPECTRAL SENSING DATA

172-27204

Ic.AS C 1237s9e Aa)1AsXPEaISED ,

Prepared for:

NATIONAL AERONAUTICS AND SPACE ADMINISTRATION

GEORGE C. MARSHALL SPACE FLIGHT CENTERAero-Astrodynamics Laboratory

UNDER CONTRACT NAS8-27364

i

l,

,)

/I>

NORTHROP SERVICES. INC.P. 0. BOX 1484

HUNTSVILLE, ALABAMA 35807

TELEPHONE (205)837-0580

REPRODUCED BY

NATIONAL TECHNICALINFORMATION SERVICE

U.S. DEPARTMENT OF COMMERCEI. SPRNGFJELD, VA. 2216

. _ _-- . -- 1K

I i

....

0

'?

https://ntrs.nasa.gov/search.jsp?R=19720019554 2018-07-08T16:18:12+00:00Z

Page 2: UNSUPERVISED CLASSIFICATION OF REMOTE MULTISPECTRAL ... · i (f t , lt tr-220-1075 april 1972 unsupervised classification of remote multispectral sensing data 172-27204 ic.as c 237s9e

TR-220-1075

UNSUPERVISED CLASSIFICATION OF REMOTE MULTISPECTRAL SENSING DATA

15 April 1972

by

M. Y. Su.

PREPARED FOR:

NATIONAL AERONAUTICS AND SPACE ADMINISTRATIONGEORGE C. MARSHALL SPACE FLIGHT CENTER

AERO-ASTRODYNAMICS LABORATORY

Under Contract NAS8-27364

REVIEWED AND APPROVED BY:

A. L. Grady, anager :

Advanced Engineering Analysis

,Detail Ijiusirations intahiSs ooturnt ma'o be bethehis dcumed .o n oh0% studied on mIor

NORTHROP SERVICES, INC.HUNTSVILLE, ALABAMA

Page 3: UNSUPERVISED CLASSIFICATION OF REMOTE MULTISPECTRAL ... · i (f t , lt tr-220-1075 april 1972 unsupervised classification of remote multispectral sensing data 172-27204 ic.as c 237s9e

TR-1075NORTHROP SERVICES. INC.

FOREWORD

This study was undertaken by Northrop Services, Inc., for NASA/MSFC,

Huntsville, Alabama, under Contract No. NAS8-27364. This will constitute the

interim report for the period of 12 months ending on April 15, 1972. The

program was under the direction of MSFC Aero-Astrodynamics Laboratory, Flight

Data Statistics Office, with Mr. R. R. Jayroe, Jr. as the project monitor.

ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS

The author wishes to thank Dr. F. R. Krause, Mr. R. E. Cummings and Mr.

R. R. Jayroe, Jr. for their helpful discussions in completing this work. The

author wishes also to acknowledge Dr. H. W. Smedes, U. S. Geological Survey,

Denver, Colorado, for supplying the remote multispectral data over the

Yellowstone National Park, through the Flight Data Statistics Office, and for

his comparison of the unsupervised classification maps with the associated

ground truth map and to the Purdue University, Laboratory for Remote Sensing

Applications, for Supplying the Purdue C-1 Flight Line data. Assistance with

data processing from Jerry Durret, NASA Co-op student, was also appreciated.

ii

Page 4: UNSUPERVISED CLASSIFICATION OF REMOTE MULTISPECTRAL ... · i (f t , lt tr-220-1075 april 1972 unsupervised classification of remote multispectral sensing data 172-27204 ic.as c 237s9e

NORTHROP SERVICES. INC. TR-75

SUMMARY

This report presents a new automatic processing technique for unsuper-

vised classifications (or clustering) for multispectral remote sensing data.

This technique has been implemented into a digital computer program. Appli-

cations of the computer program for actual multispectral scanner data from

the aircraft survey will also be presented.

Up to the present, main approaches are based on supervised maximum

likelihood classification techniques which require reference spectral target

signatures from training areas on the ground. One of the most serious draw-

backs of the supervised classification techniques is associated with the high

variability of the spectral signatures.

The unsupervised classification technique avoids the above drawback by

not requiring the reference signatures. Essentially, the technique will group

the data sets into a number of classes based on the intrinsic similarity with-

in each class. The physical identification of each class is done by checking

a small area belonging to each class after the data processing. In this

respect, the application of unsupervised techniques is in the reverse order

of the supervised technique. The advantage of processing the data in the

former order is that the investigator shall know better where to select the

ground truth. Another advantage is for on-board data compression to minimize

the rates of data transmission from future spacecrafts to the ground receiving

stations. The third advantage is that automatic change analysis of earth

resources study can be more logically carried out by the unsupervised technique.

The new unsupervised classification technique for classifying multi-

spectral remote sensing data which can be either from the multispectral

scanner or digitized color-separation aerial photographs consists of two parts:

(a) a sequential statistical clustering which is a one-pass sequential variance

analysis and (b) a generalized K-means clustering. In this composite

iii

Page 5: UNSUPERVISED CLASSIFICATION OF REMOTE MULTISPECTRAL ... · i (f t , lt tr-220-1075 april 1972 unsupervised classification of remote multispectral sensing data 172-27204 ic.as c 237s9e

NORTHROP SERVICES. INC. TR-1075

clustering technique, the output of (a) is a set of initial clusters which

are input to (b) for further improvement by an iterative scheme.

Applications of the technique using an IBM-7094 computer on multispectral

data sets over Purdue's Flight Line C-1 and the Yellowstone National Park

test site have been accomplished. Comparisons between the classification maps

by the unsupervised technique and the supervised maximum liklihood technique

indicated that the classification accuracy is comparable to each other.

iv

.1

Page 6: UNSUPERVISED CLASSIFICATION OF REMOTE MULTISPECTRAL ... · i (f t , lt tr-220-1075 april 1972 unsupervised classification of remote multispectral sensing data 172-27204 ic.as c 237s9e

NORTHROP SERVICES. INC.

TABLE OF CONTENTS

TitleSection

FOREWORD . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .

ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .

SUMMARY . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .

LIST OF ILLUSTRATIONS .................

LIST OF TABLES .....................

I INTRODUCTION ......................

II THE COMPOSITE SEQUENTIAL K-MEANS CLUSTERING TECHNIQUE

2.1 STATISTICAL SEQUENTIAL CLUSTERING . . . . . . . . .2.2 GENERALIZED K-MEANS CLUSTERING . . . . . . . . . .2.3 MERGING OF SEQUENTIAL AND K-MEANS CLUSTERING . . .

III UNSUPERVISED CLASSIFICATION OF AGRICULTURAL REMOTESENSING DATA ................. .....

3.1 DATA DESCRIPTION . . . .. . . . . . .......3.2 PRELIMINARY DATA ANALYSIS . . . . . . . . . . . . .3.3 UNSUPERVISED CLASSIFICATIONS . . . . . . . . . . .3.4 COMPARISON WITH SUPERVISED CLASSIFICATION . . . . .

IV UNSUPERVISED CLASSIFICATIONS OF NATURAL TERRAIN TYPES

4.1 DATA DESCRIPTION . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .4.2 PRELIMINARY DATA ANALYSIS . . . . . . . . . . . . .4.3 UNSUPERVISED CLASSIFICATION OF TERRAIN TYPES . . .4.4 COMPARISON WITH SUPERVISED CLASSIFICATION . . . . .

V CONCLUSIONS . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .

VI REFERENCES . .. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .

Page

. . ii

· . ii

. . iii

. . vi

. . ix

. . 1-1

. . 2-1

. . 2-1

. . 2-4

. . 2-9

. . 3-1

* . 3-1. . 3-1. . 3-3* . 3-6

. . 4-1

. . 4-1

. . 4-1

. . 4-3

. . 4-5

. . 5-1

. . 6-1

v

TR-1075

Page 7: UNSUPERVISED CLASSIFICATION OF REMOTE MULTISPECTRAL ... · i (f t , lt tr-220-1075 april 1972 unsupervised classification of remote multispectral sensing data 172-27204 ic.as c 237s9e

TR-1075NORTHROP SERVICES. INC.

LIST OF ILLUSTRATIONS

Title

FLOWCHART OF STATISTICAL SEQUENTIAL CLUSTERING . . . . . . .

COMPARISON OF THE PRESENT AND GENERALIZED K-MEANS ALGORITHMS.

3-1 AIR PHOTO OF PURDUE FLIGHT LINE C-1 (SCAN 587-797).

3-2 PROBABILITY HISTOGRAM OF CHANNEL 1 (0.4-0.44 im). .

3-3 PROBABILITY HISTOGRAM OF CHANNEL 6 (0.52-0.55 im)

3-4 PROBABILITY HISTOGRAM OF CHANNEL 10 (0.66-0.72 pm).

3-5 PROBABILITY HISTOGRAM OF CHANNEL 12 (0.8-1.0 im). .

3-6 GREY-LEVEL PLOT OF CHANNEL 1 (0.4-0.44 m) . . . . .

3-7 GERY-LEVEL PLOT OF CHANNEL 6 (0.52-0.55 m) ....

3-8 GREY-LEVEL PLOT OF CHANNEL 10 (0:66-0.72 m) ....

3-9 GREY-LEVEL PLOT OF CHANNEL 12 (0.8-1.0 m) . . . . .

3-10 SCATTER PLOT OF CHANNEL 1 VERSUS CHANNEL 6 . . . . .

3-11 SCATTER PLOT OF CHANNEL 1 VERSUS CHANNEL 10 . . . . .

3-12 SCATTER PLOT OF CHANNEL 6 VERSUS CHANNEL 10 . ...

3-13 INVENTORY BOUNDARIES BY THE BOUNDARY ENHANCEMENTTECHNIQUE FOR PURDUE C-1 FLIGHT LINE . . . . . . . .

3-14 CLASSIFICATION MAP BY THE STATISTICAL SEQUENTIALTECHNIQUE WITH 18 CLASSES . . . . . . . . . . . . . .

3-15 CLASSIFICATION MAP BY THE STATISTICAL SEQUENTIALTECHNIQUE WITH 17 CLASSES . . . . . . . . . . . . . .

3-16 CLASSIFICATION MAP BY THE STATISTICAL SEQUENTIALTECHNIQUE WITH 16 CLASSES . . . . . . . . . . . . . .

3-17 CLASSIFICATION MAP BY THE STATISTICAL SEQUENTIALTECHNIQUE WITH 15 CLASSES . . . . . . . . . . . . . .

3-18 CLASSIFICATION MAP BY THE STATISTICAL SEQUENTIALTECHNIQUE WITH 14 CLASSES . . . . . . . . . . . . . .

3-19 CLASSIFICATION MAP BY THE STATISTICAL SEQUENTIALTECHNIQUE WITH 12 CLASSES . . . . . . . . . . . . . .

3-20 CLASSIFICATION MAP BY THE GENERALIZED K-MEANSTECHNIQUE WITH 18 CLASSES AND NO ITERATION . . . . .

3-21 CLASSIFICATION MAP BY THE GENERALIZED K-MEANSTECHNIQUE WITH 18 CLASSES AFTER ONE ITERATION . . . .

3-22. CLASSIFICATION MAP BY THE GENERALIZED K-MEANSTECHNIQUE WITH 18 CLASSES AFTER 2 ITERATIONS . . . .

..... 3-8

..... 3-9

..... 3-10

..... 3-11

..... 3-12

..... 3-13

..... 3-14

..... 3-15

..... 3-16

..... 3-17

..... 3-18

..... 3-19

. .... ·3-20

..... 3-21

..... 3-22

..... 3-23

..... 3-24

..... 3-25

..... 3-26

...... 3-27

..... 3-28

. .... 3-29

vi

Figure

2-1

2-2

Page

. 2-2

. 2-7

Page 8: UNSUPERVISED CLASSIFICATION OF REMOTE MULTISPECTRAL ... · i (f t , lt tr-220-1075 april 1972 unsupervised classification of remote multispectral sensing data 172-27204 ic.as c 237s9e

NORTHROP SERVICES. INC.

LIST OF ILLUSTRATIONS (Continued)

Figure Title

3-23 CLASSIFICATION MAP BY THE GENERALIZED K-MEANSTECHNIQUE WITH 17 CLASSES . . . . . . . . . .

3-24 CLASSIFICATION MAP BY THE GENERALIZED K-MEANSTECHNIQUE WITH 16 CLASSES . . . . . . . . . .

3-25 CLASSIFICATION MAP BY THE GENERALIZED K-MEANSTECHNIQUE WITH 15 CLASSES . . . . . . . . . .

3-26 CLASSIFICATION MAP BY THE GENERALIZED K-MEANSTECHNIQUE WITH 14 CLASSES. . . . . . . . . .

3-27 CLASSIFICATION MAP BY THE GENERALIZED K-MEANSTECHNIQUE WITH 13 CLASSES . . . . . . . . . .

3-28 CLASSIFICATION MAP BY THE COMPOSITE CLUSTERINGWITH 13 CLASSES AND WITHOUT ITERATION. . . . .

3-29 CLASSIFICATION MAP BY THE COMPOSITE CLUSTERINGWITH 13 CLASSES AFTER ONE ITERATION . .. ..

. . . .TECHNIQUE

TECHNIQUE. . . . .

TECHNIQUE

3-30 CLASSIFICATION MAP BY THE COMPOSITE CLUSTERING TECHNIQUEWITH 13 CLASSES AFTER 2 ITERATIONS . . . . . . . . . . .

3-31 CLASSIFICATION MAP BY THE COMPOSITE CLUSTERING TECHNIQUEWITH 14 CLASSES AND WITHOUT ITERATION . . . . . . . . ...

3-32 CLASSIFICATION MAP BY THE COMPOSITE CLUSTERING TECHNIQUEWITH 14 CLASSES AFTER ONE ITERATION . .. . . . . . . . .

3-33 CLASSIFICATION MAP BY THE COMPOSITE CLUSTERING TECHNIQUEWITH 14 CLASSES AFTER TWO ITERATIONS . . . . . . . . . .

3-34 CLASSIFICATION MAP BY PURDUE UNIVERSITY LARS'S SUPERVISEDBAYES CLASSIFICATION TECHNIQUE (Ref. 10, p. 40) . . . ..

3-35 TABULATION OF CLASSIFICATION RESULTS OF TEST FIELDS(Ref. 10, p. 41) . ...... . . . . . . . . . . . . .

4-1

4-2

4-3

4-4

4-5

4-6

4-7

GRAY-SCALE VIDEO DISPLAY OF REFLECTANCE FOR CHANNEL 9 . . . . 4-7

PROBABILITY HISTOGRAM OF CHANNEL2 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 4-8

PROBABILITY HISTOGRAM OF CHANNEL9 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 4-9

PROBABILITY HISTOGRAM OF CHANNEL 10 .............. 4-10

PROBABILITY HISTOGRAM OF CHANNEL 12. . . . . . . . . . . . . . 4-11

DIGITAL GRAY-LEVEL PLOT OF CHANNEL 2 . . . ... . . . . . . . . 4-12

DIGITAL GRAY-LEVEL PLOT OF CHANNEL 10 . .. .. . . . . . . . 4-13

vii

TR-1075

Page

3-30

3-31

3-32

3-33

. . 3-34

· · 3-35

. . 3-36

. . 3-37

. . 3-38

. . 3-39

. . 3-40

3-41

3-42

Page 9: UNSUPERVISED CLASSIFICATION OF REMOTE MULTISPECTRAL ... · i (f t , lt tr-220-1075 april 1972 unsupervised classification of remote multispectral sensing data 172-27204 ic.as c 237s9e

TR-1075NORTHROP SERVICES. INC.

LIST OF ILLUSTRATIONS (Concluded)

Figure Title Page

4-8 SCATTER PLOT OF CHANNELS 2 AND 9 ................ 4-14

4-9 SCATTER PLOT OF CHANNELS 2 AND 10 . ..... . . .. . . . . . 4-15

4-10 SCATTER PLOT OF CHANNELS 2 AND 12 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 4-16

4-11 SCATTER PLOT OF CHANNELS 9 AND 10. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 4-17

4-12 SCATTER PLOT OF CHANNELS 9 AND 12 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 4-18

4-13 SCATTER PLOT OF CHANNELS 10 AND 12 . ... . . . . . . . . . . 4-19

4-14 THE INVENTORY BOUNDARY MAP BY THE BOUNDARY ENHANCEMENTTECHNIQUE . . . ............ ........... 4-20

4-15 UNSUPERVISED CLASSIFICATION MAP AFTER ONE ITERATION WITH18 CLASSES . . .... .... . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 4-21

4-16 UNSUPERVISED CLASSIFICATION MAP AFTER TWO ITERATIONS WITH17 CLASSES . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 4-22

4-17 UNSUPERVISED CLASSIFICATION MAP AFTER FIRST MERGING WITH16 CLASSES . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 4-23

4-18 UNSUPERVISED CLASSIFICATION MAP AFTER THE SECOND MERGINGWITH 15 CLASSES . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 4-24

4-19 UNSUPERVISED CLASSIFICATION MAP AFTER THE THIRD MERGINGWITH 14 CLASSES . ...... . . ............... 4-25

4-20 UNSUPERVISED CLASSIFICATION MAP AFTER THE FOURTH MERGINGWITH 13 CLASSES .................................... 4-26

4-21 UNSUPERVISED CLASSIFICATION MAP AFTER THE FIFTH MERGINGWITH 12 CLASSES . ...... . . ... . . . . . . . . . . 4-27

4-22 UNSUPERVISED CLASSIFICATION MAP AFTER THE SIXTH MERGINGWITH 11 CLASSES . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. . . . 4-28

4-23 UNSUPERVISED CLASSIFICATION MAP AFTER THE SEVENTH MERGINGWITH 10 CLASSES ........................ 4-29

4-24 UNSUPERVISED CLASSIFICATION MAP AFTER THE EIGHTH MERGINGWITH 9 CLASSES . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 4-30

4-25 GROUND TRUTH SURVEY MAP ...................... 4-31

4-26 LARS CLASSIFICATION: YELLOWSTONE NATIONAL PARK(CH-2, 9, 10 AND 12) .. ........ . .......... . 4-34

viii

Page 10: UNSUPERVISED CLASSIFICATION OF REMOTE MULTISPECTRAL ... · i (f t , lt tr-220-1075 april 1972 unsupervised classification of remote multispectral sensing data 172-27204 ic.as c 237s9e

TR-1075NORTHROP SERVICES. INC.

LIST OF TABLES

Title

SPECTRAL BANDS OF MICHIGAN MULTISPECTRAL SCANNER. . .

SUMMARY OF MEAN SPECTRAL RADIANCES OF 14 CLASSES BYTHE COMPOSITE CLUSTERING TECHNIQUE (Figure 3-33)..

SUMMARY OF UNSUPERVISED CLASSIFICATION AND MERGING OFTHE ESTABLISHED CLASSES FOR YELLOWSTONE NATIONAL PARKTEST SITE (SCAN 200-500) . . . . . . . . . . . . . .

MEAN SPECTRAL VECTORS FOR 18 CLASSES - YELLOWSTONENATIONAL PARK . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .

Page

. . . . . 3-2

. . . . . 3-7

. . ... 4-32

. . . . . 4-33

ix

Table

3-1

3-2

4-1

4-2

Page 11: UNSUPERVISED CLASSIFICATION OF REMOTE MULTISPECTRAL ... · i (f t , lt tr-220-1075 april 1972 unsupervised classification of remote multispectral sensing data 172-27204 ic.as c 237s9e

NORTHROP SERVICES, INC. TR-1075

Section I

INTRODUCTION

Applications of nonsupervised clustering techniques have recently

attracted more attention for processing and analyzing multispectral data

obtained by remote sensing of the earth's resources and environment (refs. 1-7).

In the past, main approaches in dealing with these types of data were based on

supervised classification techniques which required reference spectral target

signatures from training areas (ref. 8).

One of the most serious drawbacks of the supervised classification tech-

niques is associated with the high variability of the reference spectral sig-

natures. These signatures depend not only on different physical targets of

interest, but also on the following factors (some known and some unknown in

the process of data gathering):.

* Background materials

* Atmospheric and meteorological conditions

* Different physical location and orientation

* Time of day, different reason of data collection

* Sensor scan angle and sun elevation and azimuth

* Different stages of plant growth

* Different land use practices.

With so many variable factors affecting the remote sensing data, it is

very difficult, if not impractical, to set up an operational system for estab-

lishing the reference spectral signature (or ground truth) library. So far,

the users of the supervised classification methods mainly obtain the reference

spectral signatures directly from training sets which form parts of the test

areas. Even with this practice, it still requires much human judgment and

intervention to select proper training areas for obtaining sufficient accuracy

of classification.

The nonsupervised classification, or clustering, techniques avoid most of

the above difficulties and operational impracticability. The clustering

1-1

Page 12: UNSUPERVISED CLASSIFICATION OF REMOTE MULTISPECTRAL ... · i (f t , lt tr-220-1075 april 1972 unsupervised classification of remote multispectral sensing data 172-27204 ic.as c 237s9e

NORTHROP SERVICES. INC. TR-1075

technique does not require the reference spectral signatures. In essence the

technique will group the sample data into a number of classes, all of which

are statistically homogeneous. Finally, the physical identification of each

class is accomplished by collecting the ground truth from a suitable size area

belonging to that particular class. In this sense, the applicationof cluster-

ing techniques to the multispectral data analysis is in the reverse order of

the supervised classification technique. The advantage of processing the data

in the order according to the clustering techniques is that it will be known

better where to select the reference ground truth.

Another advantage of the clustering technique is for data flow compres-

sion in the telemetry of data from the spacecraft to the ground data receiving

station. It is quite clear now that the data rate collected by the satellite-

borne sensors will be so large that present telemetry systems can not handle

it. However, Dr. A. Park indicated that if the data can be compressed to 1/50

or greater of the present volume, then the presently available commercial TV

receiving station can be used for space data collection. It is quite feasible

that the clustering techniques can process onboard the raw data and compress

it into the acceptable reduced volume for this purpose. It is also possible

in the hydrological applications to augment a relatively few number of ground

sensors by the remote sensing data with the clustering techniques.

Under the present contract, a new composite sequential K-means clustering

algorithm has been developed with actual applications to two sets of remote

sensing data; the Purdue agricultural field (Purdue C-1 Flightline) and the

Yellowstone National Park test site. The latter test site is actually in

natural wilderness with various terrain types, forest cover and parts of it under

cloud shadow. According to Dr. A. Park, NASA Headquarters, Earth Resources

Program, this set of remote sensing data is about the most complex data

collected under the NASA Earth Resource Program. Thus, it may offer themost

critical test to date of the capability of the unsupervised clustering

technique. If the technique can obtain an acceptably accurate classification

map, then it may be safe to apply to other remote multispectral sensing data

for earth resources and environment survey.

1-2

Page 13: UNSUPERVISED CLASSIFICATION OF REMOTE MULTISPECTRAL ... · i (f t , lt tr-220-1075 april 1972 unsupervised classification of remote multispectral sensing data 172-27204 ic.as c 237s9e

TR-107?5NORTHROP SERVICES. INC. TR-1075

The principles behind the composite clustering technique will be pre-

sented in Section II. Detailed mathematical algorithms, computer programs and

users manual will not be given in this report, but will be included in the

final contract report. Applications of the technique to the aforementioned

two sets of data together with some supporting processing by other computer

programs developed under previous contracts (ref. 9) will be given in Sections

III and IV, respectively. A comparison of the unsupervised classification

maps with Purdue LARS' results (refs. 8 and 10) will be made. Finally, some

future developments and concluding remaks will be made in Section V.

1-3

Page 14: UNSUPERVISED CLASSIFICATION OF REMOTE MULTISPECTRAL ... · i (f t , lt tr-220-1075 april 1972 unsupervised classification of remote multispectral sensing data 172-27204 ic.as c 237s9e

TR-1075NORTHROP SERVICES. INC. TR-1075

Section II

THE COMPOSITE SEQUENTIAL K-MEANS CLUSTERING TECHNIQUE

The composite clustering technique developed essentially consists of two

independent clustering techniques. The first is called the statistical

sequential classification technique (SSC) (refs. 11 and 12) and the second is

called generalized K-means techniques (GKM) (ref. 13). Therefore, each tech-

nique will first be described, and then how they can be merged into one will

be described.

2.1 STATISTICAL SEQUENTIAL CLUSTERING

The sensor collects multispectral data from a target which forms an image.

An image can be composed of m scan lines of n resolution elements per scan

line. Each resolution element yields a K-dimensional observation vectorth

x(.i), i = 1,2,... K, where X. indicates the i h spectral band.

The purpose of the SSC program is to classify the given sequences of

multisectional data into a specified number of subclasses; each of which is

statistically homogeneous or similar in their spectral characteristics. To

accomplish this goal, the program consists of four main steps:

* Establishing new classes

* Classifying new samples into established classes

* Merging excessive classes

* Displaying classification results and statistics.

A flowchart of the main steps of the algorithm is depicted in Figure 2-1.

Step 1 - all control parameters and statistical tables are read in. Step 2 -

M (M = 6) samples are read in, which shall be tested to decide whether they

come from the same population. If they do, they will be designated as the

first population. If they do not, then the first sample will be dumped into

a null-class, which contains all the samples unidentifiable, and then read in

a new sample as shown in Steps 6 and 7. These new M samples will be tested

once again in Step 3 to see whether they constitute a new population. The

2-1

Page 15: UNSUPERVISED CLASSIFICATION OF REMOTE MULTISPECTRAL ... · i (f t , lt tr-220-1075 april 1972 unsupervised classification of remote multispectral sensing data 172-27204 ic.as c 237s9e

NORTHROP SERVICES. INC. TR-1075

I-

tj Lii

'A M

I--

LU~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~i

i~i

ct

C)I.--I

ui i-

z ~ I-'

®1~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~c:'a. C 0

U-~~~~0

·.I ...J (4n L"

~~~a.~~ I!

P-C(-A

2-2

Page 16: UNSUPERVISED CLASSIFICATION OF REMOTE MULTISPECTRAL ... · i (f t , lt tr-220-1075 april 1972 unsupervised classification of remote multispectral sensing data 172-27204 ic.as c 237s9e

NORTHROP SERVICES. INC.

above process will be repeated until the first population is established. The

statistical parameters of interest for this population are calculated in

Step 5.

Next, one proceeds to check whether the end of the entire sample sequence

is reached. If it is, the program will print out the final results of the

number of samples in that population; the corresponding sample mean vector,

covariance matrix, and classification map. The latter map represents a 2-

dimensional spatial location of samples from each population. After this

printout, the program will terminate itself. If there are still samples left,

the program will proceed to check whether the total number of established

homogeneous populations exceed the prescribed number. If the answer is yes,

the program will proceed to Step 11 in order to reduce the number of estab-

lished populations back to the prescribed number. This is accomplished by

combining two populations that are most similar to each other into a enlarged

population encompassing all those samplesbelonging to the two original popu-

lations. Subsequently, the program will also recalculate the corresponding

sample mean vector and covariance matrix in Step 12. If the answer is no,

then the program proceeds to Step 13, to read in a new sample. The sample

is then subjected to another test to see whether it belongs to any established

population in Step 14. If the answer is yes, the sample is added to that popu-

lation where it belongs, and the corresponding sample mean vector and covariance

matrix are updated. This process is repeated until anew sample is encountered

which does not belong to any of the established populations. This new sample

will be held in a temporary hold location until M such samples have been

accumulated. These M samples are then tested to see whether they constitute

a new population as was done for establishment of the first population. If

the test is affirmative, then a new population will be set up for them and then

continue to Step 5. If the test is negative, the sample which is held first

in the temporary hold will be dumped into the class of unidentifiable class,

then proceed to read in a new sample. This process is repeated until all the

sample sequences have been processed. The final outputs of the whole algorithm

is to print out the number of samples, the mean vector and covariance matrix

2-3

TR-1075

Page 17: UNSUPERVISED CLASSIFICATION OF REMOTE MULTISPECTRAL ... · i (f t , lt tr-220-1075 april 1972 unsupervised classification of remote multispectral sensing data 172-27204 ic.as c 237s9e

NORTHROP SERVICES. INC. TR-1075

for each population, a divergence matrix among all the populations, and

finally a 2-dimensional map of spatial locations of samples for each popu-

lation.

2.2 GENERALIZED K-MEANS CLUSTERING

The generalized K-means algorithm essentially consists of three steps

plus an additional step for displaying the 2-dimensional map of clustering

results. This algorithm is an improved version of the existing K-means

algorithms (refs. 14 through 17).

2.2.1 Step 1 - Estimation of Initial Cluster Centers

Let the sample sequence be denoted by {xi(Aj), i = 1, 2, ..., M and

j = 1, 2, 3, ..., N}. Here i denotes the sample number and j denotes its

components. The first initial cluster center C1 will be the first sample, i.e.,

C (X.) = x1(A.) (2-1)

The second initial cluster center C2 will be the sample which has the fartherest

distance from C1, i.e.,

C2(Xi) = xi(%j) with the maximum of

N 2X [xi(

j) - xl(Xj)] over all i. (2-2)

j=l

thThe (k+l) initial cluster center Ck (for k > 2) will be the sample which

has the maximum of the minimum distances among all with respect to the estab-

lished k initial cluster centers, i.e.,

Ck+(Xj) = xi(Xj) with

max inL [xi.(.) - Xk (2-3)i3)

ma mkn j=1

2-4

Page 18: UNSUPERVISED CLASSIFICATION OF REMOTE MULTISPECTRAL ... · i (f t , lt tr-220-1075 april 1972 unsupervised classification of remote multispectral sensing data 172-27204 ic.as c 237s9e

TR-1075NORTHROP SERVICES. INC. TR-1075

The results of the above procedure is to plant evenly the initial cluster

centers whose number will be prescribed over that part of the measurement space

occupied densely by the given input sample sequence. The step of estimating

initial centers is relatively time consuming. The computer time requirement

will be proportional to

(K-i) (K-2) 1 3 2MN (K-l (K-2) =1 MNK2(1 _3 + 2) (2-4)2 2 ( K+K+K

where K is the total number of cluster centers. Clearly, the computer time

required is linearly proportional to the total sample M and number of components

per sample N, respectively, but almost to the square of the required number of

cluster centers, K. Usually, N is fixed, but in general one would expect,

without any prior knowledge, that K would increase with M.

2.2.2 Step 2 - Preliminary Improvement of Cluster Centers

This step of improving accuracy of the initial cluster centers is exactly

the same as used in the present K-means algorithm. "Preliminary" is used here

because another improvement to the cluster centers will be made after this

step as discussed in Step 3. The minimum distance criterion is employed. The

entire sample sequence is classified into K groups by calculating the distances

of each sample with respect to each cluster center and classifying the sample

into that particular center that yields the minimum distance, i.e.,

xi(Aj ) + Ck(Xj ) if

N[xi(Aj) - Ck(j)] is the minimum over all k. (2-5)

j=l k

This classification is equivalent to set up a system of hyperplane decision

boundaries to separate K clusters. Once this is done, the sample belonging to

each cluster center is used to calculate its mean measurement vector (or center-

of-gravity). These updated K centers will now be regarded as the initial

cluster centers for the next iteration- The procedure will be repeated until

the difference (or distance) between two successive iterated values of every

2-5

Page 19: UNSUPERVISED CLASSIFICATION OF REMOTE MULTISPECTRAL ... · i (f t , lt tr-220-1075 april 1972 unsupervised classification of remote multispectral sensing data 172-27204 ic.as c 237s9e

NORTHROP SERVICES. INC. TR-1075

cluster center is smaller than some prescribed threshold value. In general,

one would expect that smaller threshold values result in better (or more

accurate) results, but it also requires a larger number of iterations. Some

compromise is thus obviously called for and no general rule can be specified.

2.2.3 Step 3 - Final Improvement of Cluster Centers

The reason for requiring some further improvement to the cluster centers

as obtained from Step 2 can be illustrated by using Figure 2-2. In this figure

there are three natural clusterings in 2-component scattering diagrams.

Further, these three clusters are clearly linearly separable, thus it is de-

sirable to separate the samples into three clusters. Using Step 2, the best

results obtainable, after a sufficient number of iterations, is shown by the

linear minimum-distance decision boundary as indicated by the solid lines.

Parts of samples actually belonging to cluster No. 1 are mis-classified into

clusters No. 2 and 3. This resulted from the fact that inter-distance between

clusters No. 1 and 2 (similarly for cluster No. 1 and 3) is about equal to the

sum of the two intra-distances of the individual clusters of which one is much

larger than the other.

This hypothetical example is actually a very common case in the multi-

spectral observations of earth resources and environments. Investigators of

spectral signatures have pointed out this difficulty many times.

One way to deal with this difficulty and thus improve the power of the

present K-means algorithm will be proposed. To the first approximation, the

intra-distance of samples within one cluster will be the sample standard devia-

tion vector that is the square roots of the diagonal elements of the sample

covariance matrix. Except for the very elongated cluster, this sample standard

deviation vector may be characterized by a single scalar, i.e., the root mean

square of the standard deviations of the components. This characterization is

completely correct if each component has the same standard deviation. With

this basic understanding, the minimum-distance criterion used in the present

K-means algorithm can be replaced by a more general similarity criterion with

the standard deviations as weights to better locate the decision hyperplanes.

2-6

Page 20: UNSUPERVISED CLASSIFICATION OF REMOTE MULTISPECTRAL ... · i (f t , lt tr-220-1075 april 1972 unsupervised classification of remote multispectral sensing data 172-27204 ic.as c 237s9e

NORTHROP SERVICES. INC. _

LEGEND

- MINIMUM-DISTANCE DECISION BOUNDARIES

- GENERALIZED DECISION BOUNDARIES

MISCLASSIFIED SAMPLES BY USING MINIMIM-DISTANCEDESCISION BOUNDARIES

0

Figure 2-2. COMPARISON OF THE PRESENT AND GENERALIZED K-MEANS ALGORITHMS

2-7

Xm- x

Page 21: UNSUPERVISED CLASSIFICATION OF REMOTE MULTISPECTRAL ... · i (f t , lt tr-220-1075 april 1972 unsupervised classification of remote multispectral sensing data 172-27204 ic.as c 237s9e

NORTHROP SERVICES. INC. TR-10 75

The proposed similarity criterion can be expressed as

xi(Aj ) + Ck(Aj) if

1 N2-12 ji [xi(j) - Ck(j)] 2is minimum over all k. (2-7)2 ~ x~j klj]S j=l

k

thHere, Sk is the characterized sample standard deviation for k cluster center.

The rest of the step will be the same as in Step 2.

Three important points germaine to the added step will now be discussed.

First, one might ask why not use Step 3 with the more general similarity measure

exclusively, i.e., eliminating Step 2 altogether. The answer is that the

sample standard deviations for K cluster centers may not be accurate enough

at the first few iterations in improving the cluster centers and that their

evaluations are more apt to the influence of misclassified samples than the

centers-of-gravity of clusters. Hence, there is no clear indication to

expect better performance from Step 3 than Step 2 at the first several

iterations. Therefore if Step 2 is employed to its utmost capacity, then

the best possible estimate of the sample standard deviations is obtained,

and the true power of the more general similarity will prevail.

The second point is concerned with whether Step 3 with additional evalua-

tion of sample standard deviations will be very time consuming. The answer is

no, since in Step 3, as well as Step 2, the square of the distance of each

sample with respect to each cluster center should be calculated and classify

it to the cluster center with the shorter distance. Theevaluation of sample

variance for each cluster center can make use of the above calculation by

adding a simple updating routine for accumulation. Therefore, each iteration

of Step 3 will take only slightly more time than that of Step 2.

The last point is that Step 3 will not degrade the results from Step 2.

As has been demonstrated the misclassification may occur by Step 2 only if the

intra-distance of samples in any cluster center is greater than half of the

2-8

Page 22: UNSUPERVISED CLASSIFICATION OF REMOTE MULTISPECTRAL ... · i (f t , lt tr-220-1075 april 1972 unsupervised classification of remote multispectral sensing data 172-27204 ic.as c 237s9e

TR-1075NORTHROP SERVICES. INC. ,__

inter-distances between the two clusters. Further, the proposed Step 3 can

remedy this difficulty. Step 3 will do just as well as Step 2 for the cases

that Step 2 can do perfectly, i.e., the cases in which the inter-distance

between two clusters is much larger than the sum of the intra-distances for

individual clusters. This can be easily shown by noting that the intra-distance

for each cluster center should be shorter than only one-half of the inter-

distance between the associated pair of cluster centers in order to have a per-

fect (i.e., completely correct) classification. Consider the most trying but

still completely separable clustering by the minimum-distance criterion,

namely, the larger of the two intra-distances is equal to one-half of the

inter-distance between clusters and the shorter one is much smaller. For such

a case, this generalized similarity criterion will set the hyperplane decision

boundary at a distance twice the shorter intra-distance from the cluster center.

So, a perfect classification will also result.

It is worthwhile to note that the cluster centers established by Steps 1

through 3 can be joined or merged together in order to reduce the total number

of cluster centers. However, with regard to saving of computation time, it

will be better to start off using fewer clusters than merging the established

clusters.

The results of clustering by Step 3 can be displayed in a 2-dimensional

map for the multispectral observations such as the multispectral line scanner.

In addition, all the statistical parameters and sample probability density

functions can also be calculated at the last iteration of Step 3 and printed

out together with the 2-dimensional map.

2.3 MERGING OF SEQUENTIAL AND K-MEANS CLUSTERING

Before describing how the statistical sequential clustering technique and

the generalized K-means clustering technique can be combined into more power-

ful clustering techniques, the merits and drawbacks of each technique will be

discussed. This review then points out a natural way for combining these two

techniques.

2-9

Page 23: UNSUPERVISED CLASSIFICATION OF REMOTE MULTISPECTRAL ... · i (f t , lt tr-220-1075 april 1972 unsupervised classification of remote multispectral sensing data 172-27204 ic.as c 237s9e

NORTHROP SERVICES. INC. TR-1075

The single most significant advantage of the SSC is that it requires

only one pass of the entire data sequence to achieve fairly good clustering of

the given data. This truly sequential feature, to the author's knowledge, has

never been accomplished in any existing clustering techniques. This feature

also permits fairly fast computation. However, because of only one pass of

the data sequence, the null class of unidentifiable data samples that resulted

from establishing new classes can not be reexamined, which is the main drawback

of the SSC technique.

The most significant advantage of the GKC technique is that it possesses

the capability for repetitive correction and updating of the establishing cluster

centers. Its main-drawbacks is that the procedure for choosing the initial

cluster centers is quite arbitrary and requires as many passes of the entire

data sequence as the number of cluster centers. Furthermore, because of these

rather inaccurate initial cluster centers, many iterations of the entire data

sequence will be further required to achieve good clustering accuracy.

From the above comparison of these two techniques it is clear that they

can complement each other, since the drawbacks of each technique can be elim-

inated by properly merging the two techniques. The composite clustering

technique is then composed of two main steps:

(1) The given data sequence will be processed by the SSC technique withonly a single pass of the entire data sequence. The outputs of theprocessing will be the mean spectral vectors of clusters.

(2) The mean spectral vectors from (1) will be used as the initial clustercenters to the KGC technique. In order to allow for extra clustercenters from the null class of the SSC in (1), the original KGCprocedure for establishing extra initial cluster centers can beused as many times as desired. Next, the initial cluster centerswill be iterated about 2 to 3 times to obtain the final clustering.

In short, the above composite clustering technique can accomplish good

unsupervised classification of a given data sequence with about four passes of

the entire data set regardless of the preset number of clusters.

2-10

Page 24: UNSUPERVISED CLASSIFICATION OF REMOTE MULTISPECTRAL ... · i (f t , lt tr-220-1075 april 1972 unsupervised classification of remote multispectral sensing data 172-27204 ic.as c 237s9e

NORTHROP SERVICES. INC. TR-1075

Section III

UNSUPERVISED CLASSIFICATION OF AGRICULTURAL REMOTE SENSING DATA

In order to test and demonstrate the capability of the non-supervised

clustering technique, a set of computer programs has been developed. The pro-

gram to process and analyze a set of most well-known multi-spectral data which

was made available by the Purdue University's Laboratory for Applications of

Remote Sensing was employed.

3.1 DATA DESCRIPTION

The data were obtained by the University of Michigan multispectral scanner

over an agricultural experiment test site near Lafayette, Indiana, from a

flight altitude of 2600 feet on June 28, 1966. This set of data was designated

as Purdue Flight Line C-1. In particular, only the results from scans 587

through 797 are presented for the purpose of comparing our nonsupervised

classification results with LARS's supervised classification results of the

same area (ref. 18).

3.2 PRELIMINARY DATA ANALYSIS

Figure 3-1* shows the aerial photo of the target area (about 1 square

mile) with the ground truth designation superimposed. The multispectral

scanner recorded simultaneously 12 channels of spectral bands reflecting from

the earth's surface between 0.4 and 1.0 pm. These spectral bands are listed in

Table 3-1. Again for the purpose of comparison with LARS results only 4

channels were used, i.e., channels 1, 6, 10, and 12. These 4 channels have

been determined by LARS to be the optimal 4-channel feature selection (based

on the divergence measurement) for the flight line C-1 data (ref. 18).

Figures 3-2 through 3-5 show the probability histograms of each indi-

vidual channel, respectively. These histograms clearly show that the

majority of resolution elements (or target) having the spectral radiance

between 140 and 200, with the total radiance range being 0 to 256. Further,

*Figure 3-1 through 3-35 are presented folZowing the text at the end of thisSection.

3-1

Page 25: UNSUPERVISED CLASSIFICATION OF REMOTE MULTISPECTRAL ... · i (f t , lt tr-220-1075 april 1972 unsupervised classification of remote multispectral sensing data 172-27204 ic.as c 237s9e

TR-1075NORTHROP SERVICES. INC.

Table 3-1. SPECTRAL BANDS OF MICHIGAN MULTISPECTRAL SCANNER

CHANNEL NO. SPECTRAL BANDWIDTH CHARACTERISTIC(microns) COLOR

1 0.40 - 0.44 Violet

2 0.44 - 0.46 Blue

3 0.46 - 0.48

4 0.48 - 0.50 Blue-Green

5 0.50 - 0.52

6 0.52 - 0.55 Green Visible

7 0.55 - 0.58

8 0.58 - 0.62 Yellow

9 0.62 - 0.66 Red

10 0.66 - 0.72 Red

11 0.72 - 0.80 Reflective

12 0.80 - 1.00 near infrared

several distinct peaks were observed in each histogram which indicate the

mixing of several different populations as expected. However, these peaks are

not completely separate. This fact implies that more than one channel out of

these four would be required for discrimination between different populations.

Figures 3-6 through 3-9 show the corresponding grey-level plots of the

channels used. The road running in the flight direction in the middle of the

area is indicated by a blank. Several other rectangular agriculture fields can

also be observed from these plots. In particular, one can see the close

correspondence of the two wheat fields in Figures 3-1 and 3-8. It should be

noted that the complement of the numerical value with respect to 256 is pro-

portional to the spectral radiance received by the scanner. Hence, the larger

the numberic used in the grey-level plot, the smaller the spectra] radiance.

Figures 3-10 through 3-12 show three scatter plots between channels

1, 6, and 10, The number 1 through 8 used indicates the number of samples in

3-2

Page 26: UNSUPERVISED CLASSIFICATION OF REMOTE MULTISPECTRAL ... · i (f t , lt tr-220-1075 april 1972 unsupervised classification of remote multispectral sensing data 172-27204 ic.as c 237s9e

TR-1075NORTHROP SERVICES. INC. ___

each spectral cell, while number 9 indicates the number of samples to be 9 or

greater. Two things can be observed from these plots. First, the scatter

patterns of Figure 3-10 with Channel 1 versus Channel 6 and Figure 3-11 with

Channel 1 versus Channel 10 are alike. This indicated that Channel 6 and

Channel 10 are possibly linear related. This prediction is further confirmed

by the scatter pattern in Figure 3-11 with Channel 6 versus Channel 10. Second,

the scatter pattern in each figure does not indicate clear cut clusters, which

implies the impossibility of completely correct discrimination basing on any

two-channel pairs out of channels 1, 6, and 10. That is, three or more chan-

nels of data are needed simultaneously for discrimination between different

crops in this set of data.

Figure 3-13 shows an inventory boundary map by the boundary enhancement

technique (ref. 7) for the target area. One can see the very clear correspon-

dence of the boundaries of different crop fields between this map and the

aerial photo (Figure 3-1). One purpose of generating the boundary map is to

establish the spatial registration between the multispectral data and the

ground scene based on the aerial photo so that the training set can be selected,

if needed, as in the supervised classification by LARS. So much for the

preliminary data analysis of this particular target area. In the following,

the results from the non-supervised classification techniques will be discussed.

3.3 UNSUPERVISED CLASSIFICATIONS

In order to see more clearly the advantage of the composite clustering

technique, the results employing, separately, the SSC technique and GKC tech-

nique was presented first.

Figures 3-14 through 3-19 show the classification maps by the statistical

sequential clustering technique for the numbers of 18, 17, 16, 15, 14, and

13 classes, respectively. Actually, only Figure 3-14 with 18 classes was

processed from the data directly. The other classification maps were obtained

consecutively by merging the two most similar classes based on the minimum

distance criterion. It is interesting to examine the merging process in this

series of classification maps. The 18 classes in Figure 3-14 are designated by

3-3

Page 27: UNSUPERVISED CLASSIFICATION OF REMOTE MULTISPECTRAL ... · i (f t , lt tr-220-1075 april 1972 unsupervised classification of remote multispectral sensing data 172-27204 ic.as c 237s9e

TR- 107 5NORTHROP SERVICES, INC. TR-1075

alphanumeric symbols 1, 2, ... , 8, 9, A, B, C, E, F, G, H, and I, respectively.

The class (I) appears in the last scan 797 from sample numbers 115 through 221

in Figure 3-14. This class was merged into class (1), as shown in Figure 3-15.

Next, the class (H) scattering in the rectangle defined by scans 645 and 699,

and sample numbers 1 and 45 in Figure 3-15 was merged into class (4) as shown

in Figure 3-16. Next, class (G) occupies the rectangle defined by scans 707

and 797, and sample numbers 1 and 19 in Figure 3-16 were merged into class (C)

as shown in Figure 3-17. Next, class (F) occupies the right side of scans 791

and 793 in Figure 3-17 were merged to class (1) as shown in Figure 3-18. Up

to this stage, four classes (I, H, G, and F) have been merged into other

classes. It was noted that the number of samples for each of these four classes

is relatively small compared with the total number of samples in the target

area. However, in the next merging, the very large class (2) in Figure 3-18

was merged into another large class (1). Comparing the classification maps of

Figures 3-18 and 3-19 with 14 and 13 classes, respectively, against the aerial

photo, it clearly shows that classes (1) and (2) should be two separate

classes. Thus, one may conclude that 14 classes may be the most natural

classification of this set of data. Among these 14 classes, the smallest class

containing only 19 samples is designated by symbol E in Figure 3-18 or symbol

2 in Figure 3-19.

Next, Figures 3-20 through 3-27 show the classification maps by the

generalized K-means clustering technique alone on the same set of data.

Figures 3-20 through 3-22 give the classification maps with 18 classes for

three stages of clustering, i.e., no iteration and after one and two iterations,

respectively. The rest of the classification maps were generated consecuitvely

by merging the two most similar classes based on the minimum distance criterion

down to 13 classes.

By comparison of the corresponding classification maps by the statistical

sequential technique and by the generalized K-means technique, with regard to

the ground truth map (Figure 3-1), it seems that the performances by both

techniques are about the same with about 70 to 80 percent correct classifica-

tion accuracy (or clustering). It should be noted that for the same accuracy

3-4

Page 28: UNSUPERVISED CLASSIFICATION OF REMOTE MULTISPECTRAL ... · i (f t , lt tr-220-1075 april 1972 unsupervised classification of remote multispectral sensing data 172-27204 ic.as c 237s9e

TR-107 5NORTHROP SERVICES. INC. TR-1075

of clustering it took only one pass of the data set by the statistical

sequential technique, while it took 20 passes (18 passes for establishing

initial cluster centers and 2 passes for updating these cluster centers) by

the generalized K-means technique.

The results by the composite sequential K-means clustering technique will

be discussed next. Figures 3-28 through 3-35 show the classification maps of

the same target area (Figure 3-1) by the composite technique. Figures 3-28,

3-29, and 3-30 give the classification map with 13 classes. The classification

maps were generated by using the mean vectors of the four channels l, 6, 10,

and 12 of the 13 most populous classes obtained by the statistical sequential

technique (Figure 3-18) as the initial cluster centers into the generalized

K-means technique. Figure 3-28 gives the classification without any updating

of the cluster centers, while Figures 3-29 and 3-30 give the classification,

respectively, after one and two iterations. One can see clearly that even

without any updating of the cluster centers, the simple reclassification by the

K-means technique has produced great improvement in accuracy. After only two

iterations (or updating) of the cluster centers, the classification map cor-

responds very well with the ground truth map (Figure 3-1). From Figure 3-30,

one can see that the wheat fields are classified into three classes (6, 8,

and C); corn fields into 3 classes (1, B, and D); oats into two classes (9

and 7); soybeams into 2 classes (A and 4); while hay, alfalfa, red clover,

and pasture are collectively into two classes (2 and 7). The fact that each

of the four crops - wheat, corn, oats, and soybeans are grouped into more than

one class simply implied that there existed variations within each spieces of

crop. The important point is that the three classes (6, 8, and C) representing

wheat, for example, do not mingle with the other crops. Hence, the clustering

results for these four crops should be considered correct. On the other hand,

lumping all the other crops - hay, alfalfa, red clover, etc., together into only

two classes (2 and 7) is due to their very close resemblance in the spectral

signature in the four channels used. The difficulty of distinguishing these

crops has also shown up in the supervised classification results by the LARS

program which will be discussed further later when a comparison is made with

these and LAR's results.

3-5

Page 29: UNSUPERVISED CLASSIFICATION OF REMOTE MULTISPECTRAL ... · i (f t , lt tr-220-1075 april 1972 unsupervised classification of remote multispectral sensing data 172-27204 ic.as c 237s9e

The road running vertically through the center of the target area will

now be discussed. In Figure 3-30,-the road is designated by class symbols 8,

B, A, D, 4, and C. Certainly, this designation is not correct. This mis-

classification of the road, however, can be easily corrected. This is accom-

plished by increasing one more class, i.e., from 13 to 14, using the K-means

technique prior to updating the initial cluster center. The results of this

processing are shown in Figures 3-31 through 3-33. Figure 3-31 is obtained

without updating, while Figure 3-32 and 3-33 are obtained, respectively, afterth

one and two iterations. This 14t h class (E) unmistakably indicates the road

as one can see in the middle part (vertically) in Figure 3-33.

Table 3-2 summarizes the quantitative results from the last classification

map (Figure 3-33). It may be noted that there are 2 small classes, i.e.,

classes (3) and (5), with samples 5 and 28, respectively. Both of them belongs

to the wheat field at the left of the map in Figure 3-33. They show much

stronger spectral radiances in channels 6 and 10 compared with other classes.

The causes for this fact is not clear, because of insufficient ground truth

information available. Note that only four passes of the data set were required

for the classification map by the composite clustering technique.

3.4 COMPARISON WITH SUPERVISED CLASSIFICATION

As mentioned earlier, the reason for choosing the particular data set for

testing our composite clustering technique is for comparison with the super-

vised classification results obtained by LARS using the maximum liklihood

classification technique. LARS's classification map is reproduced in Figure

3-34 employing the same four channels as were used for the composite clustering

discussed above (ref. 18). The training fields used in the classification

program are outlined with asterisks (*) and the test fields are outlined with

plus (+) signs. The tabulation of classification results of the test fields

is also reproduced in Figure 3-35. The test fields chosen in LARS classifi-

cation covered only about 5989/11660 = 51.5 percent of the entire field. The

overall performance of correct classification is 87.5 percent. Actually, the

entire field has been classified by the LARS program, as is evidenced by the

classification symbols covering the entire field. The so-called test fields

3-6

TR-1075NORTHROP SERVICES. INC.

Page 30: UNSUPERVISED CLASSIFICATION OF REMOTE MULTISPECTRAL ... · i (f t , lt tr-220-1075 april 1972 unsupervised classification of remote multispectral sensing data 172-27204 ic.as c 237s9e

TR-1075NORTHROP SERVICES. INC.

Table 3-2. SUMMARY OF MEAN SPECTRAL RADIANCES OF 14 CLASSESBY THE COMPOSITE CLUSTERING TECHNIQUE (FIGURE 3-33)

CLASS CLASS NO. OF CHANNEL 1 CHANNEL 6 CHANNEL 10 CHANNEL 12CLASS CLASS NO. OFNUMBER SYMBOL SAMPLES .4-.44 rm .52-.55 pm .66-.72 vim .8-1.0 pm

1 1 1575 174.2 173.0 183.8 177.9

2 2 3103 179.5 171.3 175.0 150.0

3 3 5 162.8 114.8 88.8 160.2

4 4 1798 166.5 160.5 165.9 172.6

5 5 28 166.8 127.8 106.5 163.7

6 6 523 178.2 166.2 152.3 182.3

7 7 768 181.9 176.3 182.2 163.8

8 8 318 174.2 152.7 138.3 176.2

9 9 255 180.4 172.6 165.0 172.2

10 A 2134 159.3 154.8 159.4 181.1

11 B 852 169.0 167.3 172.4 184.9

12 C 165 168.6 140.9 127.8 170.6

13 D 1736 172.1 165.8 169.4 169.8

14 E 49 140.7 142.5 149.4 178.7

Total No. of Samples = 11,766

on the map are just the "selected" areas for computing the accuracy of correct

classification. One can see clearly that the overall performance would be less

than the cited 87.5 percent, but about 80 percent or less, if the overall

performance is based on the entire field. It is also noted from the LARS

classification results, as well as the map, that red clover, hay, and alfalfa

are fairly similar to each other, with very little discrimination among them.

Comparing the classification map by the composite clustering technique (Figure

3-33) with the LAR's results and with the ground truth aerial photo (Figure

3-1), the overall performance by the composite clustering technique over the

entire field is close to 80 percent. That is, the overall performance by the

LARS supervised classification technique and by the unsupervised composite

technique are comparable. However, it is important to recall that no training

fields or any other ground truth information has been employed in applying the

unsupervised technique.

3-7

Page 31: UNSUPERVISED CLASSIFICATION OF REMOTE MULTISPECTRAL ... · i (f t , lt tr-220-1075 april 1972 unsupervised classification of remote multispectral sensing data 172-27204 ic.as c 237s9e

NORTHROP SERVICES. INC. TR-1075

SAMPLE NUMBER 115

SCAN NUMBER

LEGEND:

A - A l f a l f a , S C - Corn T H - Hay W 0 - Oats DA P - Pasture RC R - Rye

Soybeans Timothy Wheat Diverted Acres Red Clover

Figure 3 -1 . AIR PHOTO OF PURDUE FLIGHT LINE C-1 (SCAN 587-797)

This page is reproduced again at the back of

this report by a different reproduction method

so as to furnish the best possible detail to the 3-8

user.

Page 32: UNSUPERVISED CLASSIFICATION OF REMOTE MULTISPECTRAL ... · i (f t , lt tr-220-1075 april 1972 unsupervised classification of remote multispectral sensing data 172-27204 ic.as c 237s9e

NORTHROP SERVICES. INC.

Figure 3-2. PROBABILITY HISTOGRAM OF CHANNEL 1 (0.4-0.44 Am)

3-9

TR-1075

Page 33: UNSUPERVISED CLASSIFICATION OF REMOTE MULTISPECTRAL ... · i (f t , lt tr-220-1075 april 1972 unsupervised classification of remote multispectral sensing data 172-27204 ic.as c 237s9e

NORTHROP SERVICES. INC. -

3200

2800

2400

2000

PROBABILITYDENSITYFUNCTION

1600

1200

800

400

0

60 80 100 120 140 160 180 200 220 240 260

DATA RANGE

Figure 3-3. PROBABILITY HISTOGRAM OF CHANNEL 6 (0.52-0.55 pm)

3-10

: f

TR-1075

Page 34: UNSUPERVISED CLASSIFICATION OF REMOTE MULTISPECTRAL ... · i (f t , lt tr-220-1075 april 1972 unsupervised classification of remote multispectral sensing data 172-27204 ic.as c 237s9e

NORTHROP SERVICES. INC.

1

1

PROBABILITYDENSITYFUNCTION

60 80 100 120 140 160 180 200 220 240 260

DATA RANGE

Figure 3-4. PROBABILITY HISTOGRAM OF CHANNEL 10 (0.66-0.72 pm)

3-11

i

TR-1075

Page 35: UNSUPERVISED CLASSIFICATION OF REMOTE MULTISPECTRAL ... · i (f t , lt tr-220-1075 april 1972 unsupervised classification of remote multispectral sensing data 172-27204 ic.as c 237s9e

NORTHROP SERVICES. INC.

2800

PROBABILITYDENSITYFUNCTION

60 80 100 120 140 160 180 200 220 240 260

DATA RANGE

Figure 3-5. PROBABILITY HISTOGRAM OF CHANNEL 12 (0.8-1.0 vm)

3-12

TR-1075

Page 36: UNSUPERVISED CLASSIFICATION OF REMOTE MULTISPECTRAL ... · i (f t , lt tr-220-1075 april 1972 unsupervised classification of remote multispectral sensing data 172-27204 ic.as c 237s9e

TR-1075NORTHROP SERVICES. INC.

303U315T I 503f*C4.. .S C . 3 33 I33I3Ifl

313233 13.3.. ¢1 - aT3 .. e / .3/.3

- t I~ .0 .I .Ic.0331 O..0 . 0.33

I Ilq:t . i .3

1. .7 .1.1

3 I..., I 116.;

I ,"... - 3 3,l2. 1 3 3. 3 3 .

0 0 3 0 0 3 3 0 0 3 3 3 0 0 3 0 3 3 0 00a 3 0 0 3 3 0 3 3 3 311 31 1 II 1 3 31I I 31 I 1 3 3I1 3~ 1 I 0 0 0 0 I ' ll33 3 3 3 33I 3 5 4 .. 3 0 2 2 2 3 3 4 33I3 1 3 3 3 3 3 . 2 5 5 3 3 3 3 3 32" I3 3 3 3 0 1

3330333333.33.355%555633333033i33 33223i222232222223229

233753S3333s53345533S 3.&3707;0I37S0719817871971181999.7 3335&& & 533343535555SS & 343 y l1 71 7 7 ? Y 71 1 ?le2323 1263 .3 . .U . 3 .

97~~S S~I~$$ I )?Tpl~19IV~~v~99I I

30I.....33.33333............. .. 3

1q?;slss$s I~sss32033333 . 33333 , 5203(0... 2330333 3 0 3 3 5 5 3 S 3 3 5 3 3 3 3, 0 3 2 0 3 f Y ' 3 .2" 3 f l, 93 .. . 3 3 3 3 3 2 3 6 . . . 3

3 3 3 0 5 4 3 3 3 5 . 3 5 . 5 I s 5 3 3 02 1 3 332 3 3 . 3 2 3 0 2 .

323333333333335 3 S3. 3 3 I 23 3 732 123 3 23333231312306533333355053333553 3.2206322099322 99121 . 232222,33 3033453333533353353333333 3336?32233323323233326.262260333 3330353353.333#5##.553335???;333333333326 3 02243303 3323 F0 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 5 5 3 3 6 5 3 3 3 5 0 0 0 2 3 3 2 . 3 .. 3 5399 9 s ~ l t l ~ l3 4 5 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 5 3 5 3 3 5 5 3 1 1 ? f 3 0 9 l30 3 3l32 0 2 0 3 3 3 11732 .. 733533353353533335325 53 333303232133222323300 . 323233 913I

iSSSSS533SS&SqS5SSSSS5k33000320622363221·t;I~i;I32999991;3833653333333333345335353 3002333332336333223333433333 53,990033533333335335335533 330607307032989I7 3,391I 2315

?T*~Sq~~~~zqsq0 2002 34.3 3335 232 3327! I1 1 $ 9 7 9l ~ 1 I i 9 933303333333333533333335 5333333.333333333;3333345575333135300333353333533*3353534 333333333333333333333334333333 35

33033;4$435333354333352l333333333333333333)033333523333,$333(04353??&355552&35355?3 33333(39333333333333533333q~~q~ 335

233333e 9 933 &3 . 535&& q 33333 33~333633 3#333333333335335333306 04335333335 . 553469 S e l 33333]J J 3 33363 333 933333 q3 s33 q33 q 330334555553255553333533.3333333333])333333333333333553333 333033333333333035353&454 33333333qq393·q3333333333353353 i53353&63153535303&5&33333 533333333333343333533qq~~lqqsqSq 5J3

335535235 666 & e & $s 6 ·l J & J ;)q3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 ). ] q3 53 3 3· q q .3 32·

306 3335335 33433354 . 333 q 3 333 333) 3333333 333333555553~q 23?877;66696&Y6&$&&SS 3553353 333333333333333333333335555&6 3504333243653533325534453 5332333333333333~$$33333333335$33?3

334,3.233 . *Y& && 73333333333 ~333 33 13 333 3 3~& q 33 333633335 153

3333335535533433335555& P 3333333 333313 3333 3 3 3 333 33q] q & q 3333233305333533535353356 33333333333333333334333333 3333 33

3052335333335353333222 52333333333333333333333333333433333035055553522t625336 &&SI33333&333]Z&333333·Sq3q3s33$99$43,5

2333535533333333335555 337333333233333333333333335555359 323I&3& 3~iqZq)JjS b#;)&])JZ3z-q·q $3'qt

33333533'

03555333'

(3043353'30330324'

33335$33'23055353!33533535'24355313'

03553333'3333533$'23355553'23333335'

22354353'3223Y553'

333335569

333335333

3233S5323

?7?355 5223335532

I9191S99323374253304335533355555 33332333322335355235353343333633533$23333552333255333033335320335232333552!

33055

3433333 3

331 33333333333333333333333333333333333333333.

122t IIZZ 11?l121Jt~' f~~1 1 21121J1$

!3 I 3333333333333333333333333333333333333333332

I I 2 f11111%%ZZ;. III1ZIlt.1I

illllz%%z%% ......... ll.llil filll139

2 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 ;33 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 l33 3 3 1 1 1 1 1 1 13 3 3 3 3 3 %3 3 37 3 3431 33333333733333333333333333333 I333333333333 ~ % % z % % 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 6 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 33

33333333333333333333333333333 I33331.11% I1%%3 3 1 % % % % 1 % 3 3 3 3 3 3 7 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3

333333333333333333333333 33333333333333332%%3 333333733333333333333333333333333333333733 1%33333313133313373133333123333313133333*)I3 333333333333333333233333333333333333333333* 33333333I3333333333333333333333I1111333%3 3333 1%%3 % % % Z % %% 1 1 1%2 11133 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 I33333 343 I31133133133333333333323333311313i1333*33(333 33333333733333333333333333333333333333333553 33333373333333333333!ll33333l3333lll331933 3333213333333333333333333333333331333333333 I3333333733233333333333333333333333333333354

111333333371333313331332333333333I33333333333 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 1 3 3 3 3 3 3 1 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 331% 1 21 1 1 1 1 / ) 1

11%!2ZZZ%%%%l/11%11%1133333 33.33333 3333333333 333713332333I33 3033I331333I333313333333331333333333333333333I33433333333333333333334

II % 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 33 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 2 3 1 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 2 3 I 3 I I J ) % 3 2 3 2

3i 333231233333333334333333333333333333331%%%%

71 .I. .099 I$ ~1 1I I . .. II II I I...I; I I I I 7I

999911 II99991i911~iII97

191III9 ··$999I.....III',"91

................ l..... .............

339 9 9 9 9 9 9 33332 233 2 339 I ~ i ~ 33 2?23 3 32 2 2 3 3 2 31999·999999997992 33322333332333222333333 9 1 99 33232 0333 9 9 9 9 9 99 9 i 9 9 1 32 i 3 2 3 3 3 3 2 0 3 3 3

*22323332023323230;20232/ Z3r2))Soq ]033I I

322230 323I32 0230373,32 30~Z] 3 z q ~ 3333333323333;23 33333223z q 3z z ~2333323

333 333 J nqfz l 3 , t (333333qz z z l l t zq qq

.$3 * 9 33) fl3' 3 3 3 US] 3 *]&233· ZO; 3]&Z q 2L 932

3322333333333333333333333333332IIIP3 177Z ? 2333333433333 9 9 9 9 · 9 393333339 8 83

333333333339··· I I9 · II I 3l · 333l 333??l 33i 35i 35 I9939·5 35·991·1 333 i 33333 3333333333 3333

33:33:::533: 33:3:3:33:333:3:3333::3 :3533333343333337333333333333333333333333333333I5233553333333433333373333333333353333333$7Z?;3333(339399···9399993399999932439339333

1719999999999999·999933333339333333373333;·999·999··99·999·$9999·9·999999···999933333333333373333333333333333333333333333333333333334333333333333333435

i,3.23 33,1

'33223$, 1e

,11911 ll.e327111 5*71

e,,,,, 013

'77I?? II?'~?111& P731'37233 4ib6

50322~ FII

::,:2....33

792010 3*23,11771 *?1

7II$79' *3. . .....777709' 3

* .I , o 9

32733 1171

5551503332553333323?l373331 3 24

2 5$&$33??2i·I23I3919I3i2332!I00327173?i32 33337623333 36403333,3$7,23233333,332233333223;33333 3533337224

O, *533333002·?237323322233233333030330733 3333330239

$J77YY$?i7 ill~071 i 7 16971S$SS&77919

3 5 3 02 330 322.......

q Ji&?? 3334??? 43??·l? 3$?77; 53455323I3I 33.3535563?7

??I7 7II~ 7" 797176;ii?? ..... &&?$SS%

? ?? 5 33336 3 5

r~ l ? 333505350,S~ 6 7&3333433333333233353535332343354533433.53 3335332533;3$3&&33$334373?35??43&4333?;;&6 233333443 5335535333336133373&37??I&?$?????6S???5?7535566363 3532533333533343333333225533555253335353335553555?354555535337

4 ( 5 4 4 3 3 3 3 3 5 3 27 5 2 5 7 1 7 2 2 3 0 3 3 3 4 3 3 5 .5 5 ...7~ I S & $ 6346 43 -7?Y36770&??7;?337; 332337777 3 33433455$$ 333

J*&&7777???$&&6??&I&$f?7?I?76?&Y&676J1669~S33$&&4 3 6 3 0 3636 7 3 32? 3 326263&$ $ 3 21 3 2 33? 3 3 3 336 3 2 5 2 3 3 5 3 2 5 3q&16667&?166?I&I ?72 $16&7661;Y;$7622 ??2 2 ?& 53 53 31 5

Figure 3-6. GREY-LEVEL PLOT OF CHANNEL 1 (0.4-0.44 im)

3-13

333

s33

433

*hi*4.5

*os

607

'os

6[7333

zi,

its

333333

373

~73

$65333

333

633

6t7

3*$

36#

'6.

333333

'.3

- --- _ I-1-1-11-1 -----I.... I'll -- ....li-1 ..... 11

r-.

LL

II

I

iii

II

L__:

iI

;i

II

I

II

II

I

II

II

I

II

IIa

7I

Ir

4I

II

I

II II II I

II �i

I :

II :

I �; "II .: I

11:

11:

:11

_r

1+

rl

Page 37: UNSUPERVISED CLASSIFICATION OF REMOTE MULTISPECTRAL ... · i (f t , lt tr-220-1075 april 1972 unsupervised classification of remote multispectral sensing data 172-27204 ic.as c 237s9e

TR-1075NORTHROP SERVICES. INC.

OO(1 LEVEL -LOT

#0L7 I10'C73 AL SCA#... C. 0* 100000(!

7L3740 LI#0.. Cl 07.., 41/ 11/& 0300..I(* 3330 4L737t. 0400 FT.

C I.OMOL 43arl LbSGT 0 C, ~ s 101(005 0.1 0.11

$V0 40L IN¢c V.L0.0 - 41443

I l31.: - t141S* 344o6 - 10~.0

3 304.3 - 4I1.114I1.4 - I**.6

II : "11*7 - I4#,!

i 330. - 17344

O 10.0 -

00003004700000000070000077070 1f1331 ~11l~lI111t 1 1111311i11~11~11311111111113733300373000.. ~001 I1070033330301 . 770000000000l IIIoooooooooonooo . ...333 lmm.341l ... I...I....... nii

33171317.131741'I4073 I0307 3 7035 I 37 137117 47131034310 30 314350I14773

4070077~7414444747744*

40.007740006'6640144111

4047777777711667617019&040417446140001&446S7S

040077714000011774410404107600111011666S?44

0047S77 70$011141114196

4097774444404141404414

0077770014*S011S1101100

114 .06k? J S6 1 017S

40 67467S4614044141111S

I IS 6 43 II 13

3043 7 30 7300 II

3 3 373330. . . .. . .. . . .. . . . . . 7 . .

'00'0773 IZ

19 Ilq qq z ZZ IIlT4 # ) 7 9 33 3 1 3Z 0

409333321544,333

71014403

7&100033

70454003

70414033

77495193477&1003

7711415907014033#

0705404400744040

077&$&40000114440 71111040 044$114

00010443q00400440004444440074004540e7600900070451q0074440q

.77777?701777;707777776766F674S641404077?77471777??7YT?7477767??47476&S?

770770777Y77.?77&yT774777177407106er3177074~77044077700777P?7740774403Of471773777777077777770474~774474747,40077777 04774?004'774777?YT7671y74

3477~77477704&77774%777777777017747377737747440444444707q&7~7'77777747447467?77774747777777707777770761,34777774747?&674i&7477077 73047707

)?7?7?'77, Wldk/? &f 47747777744377777777 ?7 17 ~¶ 6; 0477677741

40 77 7777?? 7?7 0Y777 4 447746 77744407~7774777707?7777477411&&6677717,00771777447177617 77&7744414447707%

?7177774774744717767474&T747777707474&704i7777%777477377419744147707

4777774747770&077761.771%7ST6&iT70

4y7477774777700347774470004777701

I 54474777704777704??i14?077&03777

140&7&7??77747777717777&T707340771440470 177471104407o?4?YT78710#7

00467476717034 4774

004404434q343443334400010401401

3333330333033)2333 33043340403

33J343033)33330337333433445440033333303330))?2330033400010]3043333700303334)J334043303040444404

344q934033034~3037334440401440304

333q33323003373033~373033340013

333033100030730333377)3333434347

333 3303313 3030730333031333703

3tIl]283 71 ,]Zl1 3ZPlI?]q3 3 3 7 ~ 33 7 7 3 3 3 7 0 3 ,3 3 3 1 4 l3 3 3 3 q3 4 7 3 33Z303733330333733037333133330034

I 7 3 3 3l 3 0 I 11113 3 3 3 3 0 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 4 3 3 0

]~ 17,1,1 t 111 "I'ltrl l, I 1 1 1 :,z I'lq,q

73 JJ~ l 3 33 7 30 3 3 373 1333 3 43] 944

0 3311 133 31 3 3 37111 3 Ii3334

I1311~ ,I:I1 i I~11 1:;I I'l l,~

3337773 Ii 70 33 33 3303 30

3 72 0 3 3 3 3 I 3 3 3 I I I I I3 3 32

23 I 33 I 3I3I 3 7 3 7 II I 3I 1

IJJIIJ11Z z1111 1 I 1 ~~ZI 3 73 3 7 1 31 33I 0%1 3 313 3 I217 2

71 1 3 0 37 3 3 0 3 3 7 3l 1 13i t3 0 0 333I~111 11~%lZ21 tl I I ....

I i Ii ''l1 11iiI I 2 Jl111;11121 221J/ J,ll ~ II I 2223,q

3 3 3 0 3 0 0 0 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 ~ ~ ~~ ~ ~~30 3 4

0) 333110030313 3I 3 31133333

13 3 0 7 0 3 7 0 3 7 3 3 3 3 I 3111 113 1 137 4

I 330033333 3033333

3 3 31 7 7 3 3 3 3 1 II3 333I2 333

%'Z%3112 11fl111%Ill

I 3333233I13733 I 3I 37 3373

3 0 3 7 0 2 7 0 7 7 7 0 I l 1 313 070 2%%% %7 33 3 1 I 'l I 2 13 1 3113 3

3 3 331% % 1 7 3 % 11 i 0 3 3 3 3 3 I 3 3 7 3 3 7 3 3 0 3 3

333 371 34 3311 11 3 I I 1/ 11 1 1 3l 1 3

2212S/2 l211 l 111I111 11 /:111JI1:1.111111 5.

3737103731 1133337330 1111 I3 I 3 i 1 1 33333

3 0 3 3 3 3 3 3 i 0 7 3 2 3 0 7 3 0 3 33 1 3~l ~ I 3 0 3 3 3 3 2 4

37033333l13373333333333 I I I l'3 3343333 7371733033133333333 3 333 30331 33 413330333337133117737111 33 333 033 3330 3

313133377033713JJJ177110733 371711133337773

3307303333031 II 333 304 11333 33303333

3 433333033333 3 333 I 3 390 0093

40 l 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 )3J 3 3 2 7 1 4 230 3l 333 3J 3 3433 30003304430073301713307300373313I03 23

L!

304440

I

70079777777707779740~i07000707700700770070970704777770797704040030707i800107000

077774777077704044707000707070070007404

470777777t7007770704w17;0117177700370074776097407440704770074007017~;l87011700,07

3 1 43 3 37 3 3 3 3 7 3 3 3 3 3 ? & 7I ; 3 4 41 1 3 3 0 4 10 3 0 4 1 0

3414400044390334041404914414004979911191114

3 0 0 4 5 4i 0 7 0 7 7 7 709; 1 9 9 i 0 7 87 77 7 7 7 7 0 0

17 0709 9 1 14 7 4 4 7 0 0 0 0 0 0 4 0 40 0 0 7040191 9 9 8 9 9 9

10199891097 07 19 E 9 77 0 00 0 00 0 0044 004 04019t1174417771000041040010004004774400044000

417411i1770917e4*000000r0447704094404073 4 4 4 7 4 0 9 9 1 8 1 1 17170 0 tD f % 0 v04 4 40 0 4 0 4 4 4 4

11 477 70009 1 0 10404 70 409 70 00 044 00 00

44 03 007 7 7004404447q40 07700700 070774 4407 7770004470407407000040700744474000700441400770000470000444700070700744470404744004 0 0 4 0 0 4 7 0 4 4 0 4 0 4 4 4 4 4 4 0 4 7 0 0 0 4 . q q q q ~ q0 4 0 4 7 4 4 4 4 0 - * . ' 9 4 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 4 7 4 7 03~ql ) ) q q

, q z 4 17 4 4 4 7 4 77l ! 4 0 4 7 7 4 7 0 01 7 7$ 7 7 7 0 7 0 1q

44774774079

4477777 00

46741714 7004411610 039

4100110 7400741104 7404 1 1 1 1 7 7 4 7

4411147 000

144667 040~

4477 040

441%7700

4414 04090157% 004

4 $7840000000040404090040740449

Zqqs S .......... 6 &SS .... &~?i3$671 79999,)zqqgs6 sqq A:&1&s$4s's = s666 ss.7 9199

7z1 qqgqq3 l Sts.g&J1SSsq?1 ... 999

::::::::::::::::LI : : ... .......

I~q~qqqss~sq~J~&77

Figure 3-7. GREY-LEVEL PLOT OF CHANNEL 6 (0.52-0.55 im)

3-14

S"7100S13S10S11S$7

401

400

01*

437

403

011

703

701

6;'

737

7106~1

007

31~703

711

701

750

674747

773773

707'004

703003740

I

qIq

I

~ &&A... axs M&I..3i..I.'T..A&

JRs;F

LA

j

w

h.

ja

A

II

III

I

II

A.

1^1

U

II

IIIIIIII II :

I II II II I; 11I SII II IIIIIIIII

II :II :

: .1: .1I SIIII

:I: I

I

I

I

I

1.

-a

F

X4

24

II

q :I4

31I

1,j

S I

III

99

JI1

11I

II

IT

qq

II

I I

I

IIII

I

I

I

II

I

II

IS

q

I

I

I

Page 38: UNSUPERVISED CLASSIFICATION OF REMOTE MULTISPECTRAL ... · i (f t , lt tr-220-1075 april 1972 unsupervised classification of remote multispectral sensing data 172-27204 ic.as c 237s9e

1Y.8OL

I

IS

RI

4IU .41422 3 *I 3*222 34 171OT

.ULTI!PIC~lmA S.l#( D*& P~eU!

7L4447 1142.. CI 0219..- 3 / 71/& 2 l t... 4224 334441** &00 2 T.

el.4( 103*2 324&?2 13(NC04S1 O..3 * 0.1.

I-'[R3-'

4. .I 13*.3

I#T(ll:

1 .7- 134.1

124 - 179.3

.7oo44044444 o744444o427o244442442420400 4334....... o 11 I 1411111 .11 111111 11 1111 11111.11111 1252,2II1121220o0o111 z))q~~S&122233.;3,007?4777332399599o2oo41 11z1111525223333333&6&&6377747&&&33&9594oo0oo1I1112

1495195 4.0~ 4911 .......... 741661 9 3 t

R ... ......... 73.*.3333 3.5-33 3

.C.333 ~~..3 . .... S... S

.91595.I9'159 ......... 76 .....Jall ... llJJ&&qI

95'151334394335919117761766&7370.74IIS&&I&'IS#SSS&!J$

.. 3.. 3333... 33. 4 3333.3,334032*4433*773, I

4423t45919329~98 .&%y17.7&G0723&&lq69161&qqJ$1S&&Y~

.... 3..33,, ..... 2 3

11S91591954994119~991:3:::l11 '11117161&~1qliSI'

34433343444330*.3 3S, 0 134342237,32213.03--33,233, 3

9*94444431134114#* 1 . 331361617 .611 1111 1,3 "S; ............................ ::::::::::::::::::::::::::::~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~........11.113

99444343344. 433 ~33~***3I 2 2 4

9 *. 325.1611&1723222311;3193)ss5' T

,23223042222222 t2432222331 3

91911A433317111111 522&21 22224332933446131 3T

w91!16117171'7617676 S~76111lq#

77*3433447033330*43337*40*3

.47,4.334

3277733.4

377*3343]

933i177401

4il737334I33030944

933473434933*47341

3177*311

32317073

93377770

393,7117

49273077749*3471664334377343473V173

43433773

9991¥&l&

4337,,,1.73173,1911117,1

33 1711123111212..... II I ] 1 1711711111131'41 II1%1111ZZ71122 I i III 1222225233I IS$171/$Z13 71111121 111121 I II 12222 II11123311I

.1111)111133711 111111111111111 I 1111112

2 11))2/1)211 1111%1 I Ill I 11125 It23.

.121122211 11311311 11 I III

Ill 111132517 11111II112 2: I

171 2133321 11122111 31111 I 23I22l $111231211111 1111's I

111117217111111221111111 III I I I1~1227115133222122121111221111 1 t 11111122.

2 11 22711 1111 1111121 III I I!2 11112333 32711)11111 III 2331 1723223111171) 111171 11 I Il I II13

12133112 1321132121 1 I I I ]11224I 124222 313121121411 1111222223

33 123233111343222211311111 IIII1222

I1131911111311111111 II ill 1222333

ii11249323311 21111141 2I 11111)3I

..11333333331111 I I112122

G a11111)1111 31 I II 12123I

122343 3.132221 I 12122 I;I : 11 2 I 22 31132

7113311113111811 i 1121111 I I I11

1 )11)33 1111111111111 I I II II 21111211I142333232 112111111111 IIII111111 11I1I112228

I 111 2222111 11111 221111I 1111 1 Ili1

I 13331111111211111111 111112 1 it III 11 111 i$13 31111211 12111111q!11111 I I 11111222;

I IJ$22111171171141111111111 I I Ill III!;I 42222122 I1111221111111111 Ii1111121

I 14 2121222232332223222111 I 2 113

I 11124111111111111 21111 11 I I 121 II I I I]

2 32232334233222%31111111i 111111 II I IIIII 1111q111111171111121111111 12111 I I 11122I 2 . S# 33222222212121215/1111i 111311111112]

Iq11111111)!11111112221111111 1112221111111211

I 1313233333043322235111111111 1212111111 I11J

11123411111411331111111 III 11211 111111243I11111113311111111111111111 11221 111112121Ill)Jlq1131111212122111111111 IIII 112I 2I12

i111111332111il 1121111 1211121131 I Ii 2232

311111114121111 II 1211 11 1111 1III

fl239324l331431211 111121 II 111 I 1114

Il111114122344411 11111111111 1IIIII I 2123

42 223493$33144242122211111111112211 II 1123

7 4731323333432221 1243&& ... 4# ])1461J$

31211 11311Sij11112 *3 IqS631 112216 S216113

21*2 111s 12 21&qt111 I $q11321242312711

I 22221661J .. 1 42 2... 13so 22 . . so43....

I3fqt4433144211 I $2122322311S2b1 I 19816134

..........2322 ..................... 3*3

I q*$ 806116776711 I 911~lll&q6

I167173311~~* J 78631311)~3S 732*23 4 33IJ 37~tt~? Y1 .71787 18

31.....................

* 3~~~ 3303733.433383444.31.

*112237,1 &1231321 3310 711111113* 111.34 3 Sf77&iY~~~I?0*1, 77 ofll d 1 1119

i6iiiiiio?767&76 771~ .. 17Jy"I 7

761777107171671877881 7i118:9700801l

*0le3l~l7 402 ,3,lll%?01094491000il39ll409

Il17117...~Z33

SSJ323 3 I#11133 34 11111993 444111111 3' S

21333%313111 911194 443lll ... 11R

* 744334994.39444494294494949*3

,S]!1 1 .... ... M* 2111, I oqq17

21444

II 344

I iv44

2 2~942 444Z9.44

2'143

'145

I ,$49

II 949

II 945

* 299921144

Figure 3-8. GREY-LEVEL PLOT OF CHANNEL 10 (0.66-0.72 1m)

3-15

NORTHROP SERVICES. INC. TR-1075

334$44

393373

347

634

30,

t074

333

334

31t337

*619

&12

343071

41143]

6)$*4734471'

743

690

&$1

713'I,

'&19&&l&&)

727729

671

&7437;$673744

793

611

6'3031

7344*1

673

7447.3

I39

744

714

793

:�l

,I� I

! I, I.I

I �� II

I

: i11

I

II

II

I

1I1

1 ~I

Page 39: UNSUPERVISED CLASSIFICATION OF REMOTE MULTISPECTRAL ... · i (f t , lt tr-220-1075 april 1972 unsupervised classification of remote multispectral sensing data 172-27204 ic.as c 237s9e

TR-1075NORTHROP SERVICES. INC.

00L73003 7?*L sc&#0l0 0303

ILI3-' 33.( 3 0.. .¢1II.. 3330 I/77/i. 23300 '..

C.N&#. I7I7.,0 -IC3T . ..fC00S. 0.00 1.00

0?0 00L I.V70.AL

I I 0.5. - 39.0O

Iz I :.I 6

3 171.7 1 61.0

3 37..9 - 37.0.I I..,. il.7 l 70.3 i 303.y IF9,3 i llof3

oooooooooooo1ooo1oooooooooo1ooo1ooorl1i,' 13331I 3333111 33331~111 1~111?,72273702000033337222333. 9953**377~ 7090000000333333.222333 .3393..-3070999...I ... zil 2

3070330330,370090333031,130S. 3033.....33.39,1-I0330 ..73) 0 3003 a03303370310

.797eeI Y 303IO 71SJ!0 0 . 0e 7 7 0? 7 3 3 9 7 7 7 3 ?0 390 7 0 3 3 3 . 9 7 3 3 3 3 . 3 7 3 .733333030333307333930t7737330.30i30$37933030 ?O7 9 7 7 & i0 3 . 3 9 3 3 3 3 3 0

7333393003333073303379376,003337339773730070

00037&e07.0733300399900

.0733739330YS333903933..0070330033033993333993,#7003330303370330333007

7373333370037307373339~

3 0 1 60 3 3 3 0 0 7 3 3 0 3 3 3 3 2 2 7 03073333333309393073333009307e9779930933332230.7

*00037.03073&00333330N000073070EJ. 320330373303

00370773.0003303303)33000 0 7 3 3 9 0 9 3 0 3 3 9 3 3 9 0 3 333e ~ ~000333000,l~79733330390

· ee007000090073933&s339

000007003 3!e&7OS.SS337

3 0 0 347 0 0 0 0 # 9 3 0 07$9& 3 5 0790s9,e0$0 07333303303

00000999*30700333399039

?e397&i&030A720337N&0A07

0059300030033030303393,)q3J

3395.900 0

030993333333300033939030030

03993090397.99.00,39903909

33!33930033930333

73930333379.5335000393330333305.00332330

99900033

39990900

9333 33 0909233939709930t

7033099033333009333009097333.s994363999477073937370Y73370307777779009)337900600 70 3009&90799

I II I I I I1 I I I

I'll ~I i11I

I% 1 11 % , 93 i7 73333331 31 1 1 1 11i] 73 ii i iii

:110111

II

3733

3373

I333ll . I 3 it I3 3

3 3 3 3 3 3 l l l t i3

3 1 2 3 3 7 7 3 3 1 1 0 3 3 3 731 333733230302323733l3333070300030333333333373203337323700333773 III0II03003337000333333 3332333333335300330093333

333 33337 )32700030333~,l*l33233) ~ 2j2..33.0n3W00

jyS. 33?79&33333 73930 33330 703&90 7lo 0 9939 390 33i313333339 9A 3393 30

79339339333990333&0353933333333I 6 & S i S J3 S3 3 3 3 #3 0 3 3$ 3 0 0 S9 3 3 9 ;.00

q J 5 6 3 3 3 3 3 0 3 3 3 i 3 9 3 3 9 3 3 3 3 &3 i3 3 9 3 3!

30335309333333333090939307933333353503 9993333 309933 933 7 33 0

~ S S &3 3 9 3 3s 3 3 e &3 3 3 9 0 3 3 0 3 9 3 3 3 9 3 3 3JS;ST$&TY$&J&$&J9q0qJ&6J9i0399993330733075333&3393090333O969530!33&73039373333330300033339739390

.3337033333333393033333339393099I$;i$&si9303s333 9330033303593330

303333370.93393 3353.9333003333)

.3353333033333330333.33033330030

.33039033330333030300300033003333

.3399939933993 3050000003323.32373339.333330.33330330903333033333~33 73 393 30 30 3330 33000$009 3733 0 33939309039333333300000323032230*339333.9393&93.33s9050330033.03&33903 33& 0 033393 330 093 0 33 3 0 390 7i3 39539 09 399 33935 0 35 03 90 3 90 3,330.00903.033033003030707093373

3300003993939933333337377733370970330099379330&7990933333333393330439333733&0373337930011900730,

39003703339033393330333&&S&&~66733&37030$9070003 9093033977099393039.039377399777??790903903900.09377030&9333930039399373300001707700099309773.&

7377373790333990739099339330703090309777035793'670933&37790072037990933333337770007007&707973&9&.

,007007379037333?939&9.7330&33769007900907 7773&3,

0!90033307933330333579337363?7090000007799330333379300937733&737970 393397790&33770070000797009733370000330397793737999730999 77&&ll90000,9901770079!

0907377900376?$9033330669703009909079003993390336

009597333737.079.33.3339337700090709890003733930!

79000003?7930007333379070770&07700y.90030997?63

09900o90770373395ys lt7909?$$elA0070l00l%??yt073700003737973739707333933090~~il70911930079337377900007073&70303733930533979333090090007777377379

1559Yj?6?67&?60&e$1SI 760,9090399Y?.?7.&?!

00000970003303993233330937&%7019000990173073336

70007.77?70,9?707,97377090199il0090090090703990~

00009907707933337000197799079097770997977733306S

7000073077730097370900009993033030377373090079300009 7917/009$7 7 7 977 09977 0099 911 70 9 01917 0 90 %07339900009037?90000937703700099779019080970i90733373' 7 0 0 9y 7 17 7 9 0 0 0 0 3 3 7 3 ? 2 7 3 7 7 2 0 3 0 0 7 7 9 7 3 0 0 0 0 0 3 3 3 9 7

07007000909993,73306170777770900000700008773&30?,0 00$ 091 1 7 7 3 3 0 3 0 3 3 7 7 607 3 3 9 097 0 3 3 01 9 0 9i 09 3 0 7 7 9 7 3 7

,07t9090,i09,3,9,lyl70,70,3,93ii099009991t,,/?&,00900907901¥707 73907997y??11?~y903007309000333,000000071700107307897771&1?16?l00l$911Y???&t661q'07000070703073933y6&6Y7777739790309009073377079'9fI07?,70000y7,,,97,,,3,,&?7?7730097?7,973&I.3!f,099/1990076t0773yl&?61&lsy7yy3yl09703e979766&!0 *9 9 5 0i 7 5 3 7 7? 7f 7 7 9 9 7 7 9 9 7 36 7 0 3 3 ?7 7 0 f o o e3 9 y7 9 9 9 5

l900/?$037073966&0i99736i3903?97037/yo777739339300977373770773973379777737703i~9000909773773336

33339030I.Iq

II

II

I:q

II

1,q

35

Io73)6

~Y3&Ps)*?)?)

J)41I13~)3)Yle

17

q9q*

sosY*oql

s9*t6e6;707;~sso~qqqqq

t;s)Sl

1J))iq

11qJ

oz11

6~tqqqq6

);7)9)?)yq

yq

?F7q

6oqy

&P6P66y~7?!67

1q

1

q

]S4qq3q

S'q,

74q

I:

7?7

I

Y

7)

)

I

I

1

I7

q

Ii

)

I)q

z

)))

·

?

?

?

o i)%IS 1 qq1 q])J%)qJ21r1 I67~ e

3. kql3qqq1qqqi2I)q31111 Pn77? q

S1,elq 13)#))%313'S 1171 $YTY &

I~ .. 5.....

s~~~~qI 13112, )~)3)lzJl~i&T& s'S

); )~1311)111311)13 1 I)311 s7&67I - I31%%1% 11 ISl .. ...... )gqT&A qq

Y , 11FZ ii) l IIM &l2 I 11&&&

~l~~q))Jq ~ ~.l11l i 77 Sdi 1 1 ? $'?"T'&

9%11113111111111 111113 3111 12%q~~1qi?"gt ...

211"111 ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ 213 i1 1%~

J I ~ ~~~~~~~~~ ..........

, 731%~~~~~~~~.....

117~sssq ~ ................ sq6~$7S4871B~q

9~SSSS#))qqs#q, T&JeO&ISq~~qsJI746,67Nb76

~ls~q])~s~~qqs~~s$~sq~qqJ sqq~qq I~ S & 187fII~S ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ 07098.~sqq]~q&~~SS&~ ~qq~S &?F?)~q qq~qqq1~S~qbsbqb~s6~qSS&~l 71 7&$I

e~~~~ IN~qsSS~S~ Sqq~S~~S&I SJl~7

Figure 3-9. GREY-LEVEL PLOT OF CHANNEL 12 (0.8-1.0 um)

3-16

303

303

*03

*9)

s*3

3,n

*os

.3s

.03.

* 73

337

300

66s

303

733

003

000

033

033

773773

720

'o3,oe

739737

703

%93

050

0]9

yqy

733

733

Fit

773

''7

7ye

79,

091

11

II

II

III

IIII

� 11

I7

I

II

SI

SI

II

Page 40: UNSUPERVISED CLASSIFICATION OF REMOTE MULTISPECTRAL ... · i (f t , lt tr-220-1075 april 1972 unsupervised classification of remote multispectral sensing data 172-27204 ic.as c 237s9e

NORTHROP SERVICES. INC. TR-1075

2.4 . .1.4 88 LCC0U83C~A#N[Lb u~tO mAtt-L&~INI (MIC~ONS1

, 0.8# -2 .68 D&uII2A4438 CO31ut[84A3

20.17000 C1I~~~~,~.^~,,·0o 1[ A COROIA

197.212 IQ5.444144.&87343.524# I ala I

1Z.16 .I I I I JIl11

le.88 !i Ii I Il # I I . II18t.&3&* I 'l ' I a11 s+ +tfi iiiI.38 .I I I i I I I* J123 32a3.184481

,62 0*, , I t 1l ,1 1111t*2iz2 + ; + + 2z2 2

18.1,11l -aIakLia Jl@8886444493i

l85.R48 . I 2 , *86t8488fl1,,733,,.,8* .s Ill sl 9Im.323 . II I II j3. 031199VI99Y99 945

1ie2061 .! I ' I *1 1&/Tegee411 91,+ ,999

l0.78 . I 4· I iqlJ3468884te 0st 4tte

,,~~~ ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~a 1 2 2 2696946'

17.535 32 I 33 1Il 9111I 813l87299Ygt, ee,9994 ev93, 378P0~~~~.27- . I I III .. .3648999YV4tl 69YYV4931

1?77010 . I I I 12264684&99vgeveevgv9463 3e99&I

11#*#. ' II2 37?2 12348*939914494994944V7949I 419821

* '3.227 il II 3I 3119699899949494489999Ygy99999088lI171.960 . I 32 12 &lq344746447S94994999*9Y*79Y9999&&2

zxs.*-^ , ,, ,,22Z,"~~~~~1 1* &112 * 1w tfi+ W 1

I 0I6I7 I ill s a3868973899,91,9&1,99999egv4v99993lI16e.34' I 234l$$ l3497egtg I'1I4,44849999,9t09Yg9913l14 a17Z I I I I 12 22q441 4.423 42J9999 98*9v 49931I1

1*3 09. I 11122 31131 112II21* I 4I6S94999 *7 9932I*.,6# . III I1,3 242 l11 412 I 3 *I,%9999999999 8 6,I6,38, 2,1i2 4331, 1 lq4422i 2112z8Ie7999999999999eS9&8

1&3.1 Ii Il

3*3.183 II III I I I I ,21 12 * &*8999999Y999ei2431610.0S . 21 ,, III I, 3 , I 3II128 99,,,8,4,46a49*j 42.1,0.e9, I II 3 all2 I 2 122 1172 · J 1 4Jf¥9 ** 49999999qq 1159.333 ] I i I I I 114 I &1 9,49999V*2tJ311I '

,,,.0 2

I18.471 .* 2 I 21 I2199991i1166ll2lJ *1356.4086 2 3J I IJi799J999997iqj1 hilli15.585 I I I I I I I ,38789JtJ4t8JI3. II$.263 . I I I 3 I II i2 J78 927; ' I

, :.a,,:,,,:,:, ,

163.020 I I I I III 2I I8*438874411,1 I I

1S.758 . I I 3 1 266944 6 4 I380.445 8. 334 32, ,, I*4894748

150.#S 13 ,11 2 1 3 1 4#q 91 II

IQ0.I07 .I S 9e 3 I I

348.844 . 2 I 2127816833648281313&J I

,44.l&Z 3 03143& 3,21q 21 I

1 I2.19 I I Il121 I

I31A .85a . ,

380.48# 321 tl3lI1Z3l3l31I 3 I I I

136.131 I 11 I Ill I I

i]?,e&9 I I I II 3III136l&06 I 3A IOL 2l I VE SU C13&*38. I I 3

13,.081 . 2132.81A 'I$1.516 I I130*291

l

323.4e0

120.192338.9241137.&73I&.404118.181.

2134.87e11;.61* 331*.354110.01.l06.828

107,S66

10*. 308.I06,]05

303.7T7102.515 ,01.287

,,0202-Vq.9389

93.677*2.-1-

Ie3.s,? .

66.301 -

83.57*.*2.31383.010.79.76!

78.525

77.263t&,ooo . I

74.737 8 .. A...8. 1. .8 . ... 8. 1..

60.647 73,723 81*756 48.388 ll2.6I8 388.s48 138.674 I*I.e134 164.834 177.970

Figure 3-10. SCATTER PLOT OF CHANNEL 1 VERSUS CHANNEL 6

3-17

Page 41: UNSUPERVISED CLASSIFICATION OF REMOTE MULTISPECTRAL ... · i (f t , lt tr-220-1075 april 1972 unsupervised classification of remote multispectral sensing data 172-27204 ic.as c 237s9e

NORTHROP SERVICES. INC.

299.737i2,8.?7

197.213296,999

2?3.243

290,&99289.634

-- 82*06198 ,-teo,?68.,

279.636

27n.797 ·

I: O .qO 09 o1¥011t8 A 0(Q9INATL10 0.66 -0.72 HORIZONTAL COO00NATt

-2 12

I 2 I I 2222

- 2232 22 I2 2 II 29S 22'G*I 22 2 2 2 2322I t

2 2 2 32262 23122 2 tll 22221 88932

I2313 12312.111 Z96969q9qo8iJ

2 2l937i.9999q8o8.29999999999999Y.9999tl2 3.2 9,99l99 7 a. 9 9S9999999999899 99

I 3119&2g9?lb bgt ??t19;1 171~ 9~32 69999999929#99q9999999999999~9999.22

.2 22 2333 66999999999999999999999999999999999999..... ~ ... . .....LJ23131A'AJ3_99f_110t9'999999999"9999999'99'9999&I I 2 ]216199999 9"""989'979999'9'9 '9"9 999'9999 2

lalJ72 99J???999111119 I~T~9119.??f 1fi??~Jt?.99.?1tflp ti ...-

2 2 2 2)2 2 .29..89999999999999399..9Z9.9999979o99999999 999 9I .9.

I 123 21264979999998692?72925363533.289999999999999 9.29999939tL S1L122~~]7.9127 #~37#231qlq~2l l1.7E~9999;9'99 9p~~mm&

I49.93'. I 2 2 22 3 4364994

248.273 . - I 2 211 I: 212226&*l09 * I 2 2222 2ilt 2 2222

249.386 * . 2 22 32222223 32272 2 33

- 6--i.)lq.J2- · - 2 1-. )liti? llZJ 12J

I 1 242,869 · 2 2 3 2 Ill 2 · 2140,194.. 22 33 32 2 11 I 21 .169.333 * I 2 1

IS6,& a I Ii14.t07. 2 . ....

214.804*

1219.3 919

212. 68* . ...........

2'.3, , -

0.279703

294.707

24.2.

23.23 .2137.84.2 8

236.6062,

232.I1031.1....

230.293 , I

I20.293

.. 9~,.9.e1,

l228.17 .*-

117,6&7

122.441

110.09i2*

108,$&68 ,

207.94A

203.2

97.946

9.2.939 .,

93.9679

94,202 .-__9JLS1.....

8.17.........

87997&4992 727 9'373& S96299 9. 9'999999999999 999.222

22I a 2 IZ 23 qll2t3999V99999999999.2y,6.32

3. -Z2L224 - I.k979~08, I 97.L2 -11 -2 211 232133332273999999991V 99V999693#3 I

1__1--~l~Z:.I.2199999 * 9 2979863 22Z 3232 q9'999999999999999 2311

232 2t I 113 99 9!999?tIXI9.977?3 _. a .....2 12 26 99999999999999199962

2 .- - 2 .,Z 999 909¥Vg 9,~~J999.Z ........t 31 59999999999999999373 1

I 2332173932 791. 9992311 62I I

1 2 23312723iA~,9th 22~

....2 IIt3 29137199&oq49 99192& 33!

13 - 1221 lll63 ~9949 S? 32

2 .. a 22 *18232qOg342 2-[2 -

2 23 3273 )Z6 J3323223 I I I

q2 2 234 & .t . . ....

I 22 2 2 2 2

2 ~ ~ ~~~~~~I a

…..... t.............

- 2 -t .. … --

78.136n-- .43 ?9fi · 2

76.000 ~~~~~~~~~~~~ ..0. .3. -. . . .~ ............

. .6 . . . . 81.... .9.8.9.2.9.. . .3.A. . 2.3.3..2.7.4.7 .7.......... 64

56, S, 1 11 4 33~~~ I 2il izl.778 1 q ioZ221 IS7*7 . lll 186ljS67

Figure 3-11. SCATTER PLOT OF CHANNEL 1 VERSUS CHANNEL 10

3-18

TR-1075

~~~~~~~~~~~...... . W..I...... I ....~1 . ......... ----- ---- -----------------

I

I- ---

I

............. i ................~~~~~~

Page 42: UNSUPERVISED CLASSIFICATION OF REMOTE MULTISPECTRAL ... · i (f t , lt tr-220-1075 april 1972 unsupervised classification of remote multispectral sensing data 172-27204 ic.as c 237s9e

TR-1075NORTHROP SERVICES. INC.

C.AN'NL$ USE0 WA¥e.LgNG i#T 191(9NS)

.... " .0 ..... .... 'k1I-.1A O.. O l._ A, u

1l1,000 8

I 9I497

188s.39l8I'1 3s,

1ISF88 . - -

jS*.*I5

S13.12

141,679

'3 75.4-_3! *.3..........

179.041'172.o61

172,7S8

J67.S53144.~2214q,9398

142,333t1,1030l49.7/7

iS?*12]

tsq.515.

153.Z21.1S1.909 0

1q9.303.

194.4971*4oJ9'199,091

192,788

l#OI.I2

li8.i79 4137,176

l13.,42O132,i ...4

131.041 1Z$.7S7

IIitt32

2*494&

9999l

- 1 I 49999'I l34 1939

21 989899 9I II I l{ I 3 92vb999999999999t

2 I { 4799'99,999999213l

a ...99949999999s9999999999921la, I9992I1199999999199989999Og3

I999 99 9999'''99991I

3999 99 999 27 3sgvv99 99999999 9 99s9l1 21 9?799i12biJ 9l9g9J i9 99$ 8 _.

57993994994/V99$V999999999993

I 63439a& 8981t99999999998352

2I h3949 989999 . 9. 9999.9999 1S

I I 2S69&979198999999999999..31 Z- - I I O 92 1 *5 1711999182 = ""tI .Z 91902 -.J

1142*9999979999999999999s*q

I 2Z7999979946995999999IO99993I I I

''llI999999999999899999999999985934 I_. I _ 122* S99 ?I.7 L SJ9 Yt.!A lJ .........-

136481999950155999999,99999351 t I.. - ,,ZsI99ti,9491_I9.999I9953 22. -

I I 3298996q73lqlS&99996999923 Is I''l lsA l~tl fL_ _

I 1112 91Sl34SsSq33*5 .58399.833 3 I 1I 1.129394098l49* IO 0itUI.397-319 Ias .-- 01 I . ........ . ..........

1121191829 13 1II 92129142 I -

.1 31 191429 I1 %3-132. t7- 122I I- 1I-II I 9.A l'36073432II77127 q9?7431 I III II

211ill 231l41332 I 2998s393 3 I I2 3213111 I /II X,2I 239 . i I..

31811 Il 6 sl16141 *7*99792 It I

I 3 2 I I 11112 I3'l. I - 01211_ 31 122 2 II I%.031 _ -0-- I -..

1I I 32 22a11 12 11,3766413 3 3 I 21AllI tit11l I 1 10 ............-

I 2 I 2 211.__" -21 E~lZ_ ~ I- 2 1- 21L I 12

I!III q 2 I 12 II .

lq'$q490 321 I I I I ti' I Jill I tI. III1 2 I

1 .3' * I I -_III2

119.333 * I3 I III a 93 0 *I114.727 I I

lzl11,939 , I

119.121 * I 21 I_LU2 -.i -L ...-. I-_ _ . . . .....108.909 ~ ~ ~ ~ Il 3 I I1167.7I. , I I

10 l.303 I I

10239.4

Ill,SIS , I I -2-- - ___

101,091 I I -9 9o61- ·

99*574 ~ I -- . . ..

910*9709Sel779 - I

84.999

lg]& t88.06l . -

77 & 43 6,it. 7l.aI.

63.3030

... !~,t._., .......................................... ......... .........

- ~ ~ ~~~~~7~o -- ".a - ------------- - 12.1

* 4 9 . 4 0 4 , - - - - - - - - - - -

0.47 .3. 8_.8.8... .TIo050 7. 00 8.* 949 1933 -I8.? 3i: l'4 77 .I 8.4

Figure 3-12. SCATTER PLOT OF CHANNEL 6 VERSUS CHANNEL 10

3-19

Page 43: UNSUPERVISED CLASSIFICATION OF REMOTE MULTISPECTRAL ... · i (f t , lt tr-220-1075 april 1972 unsupervised classification of remote multispectral sensing data 172-27204 ic.as c 237s9e

TR-1075NORTHROP SERVICES. INC.

llooooooaooo°o° ooOO° u°ooooooo°° oo0o0o00oo7o°J° oooooa o 2222 2222 222 2 22 72 *7 7 ,a7 *7222124iik 7 z72222 222222

.................................................................................................. ;......@~~~~~ i I

I

C

2

* z lZ~cIiZZ~ ,Z

I II 1 21I2222..' ~~~121121Z}

. 12,,1 122122. 2 22222

· 2 I 22 22222Z

. 1 I J2 242

. I I 22,222

.1,

.~~~~~Jz,

· $l It

. 111 I I* nf 2212221

II I ti 22l

. ~~~~~1222

. , ~ ,: , ~ 7 ,,;

. 1,1 2 I. 2 2z 2222111

. .. . '77' "

., ..... 7 ' .... ?, ,:?

:D.A.7

: III

II

.~

II I

2I II1

22

a I

P - RIC.'I ,2

2 II

I2

II

I

2 2 11 22

I I I a2

I~~~~~~~~~~~

I 2 22 ., 111 1 222

{il

JZI,,

2I 11,I 112]

i22221 22222 I I2II I 22 sa~ i

7lll 'lI

S7

I

2

I!I

I

I

.I

iI

J

dZ

t

,J

Z7i7,J

J

Z

Z

17

I

Z

27

aIZ22

22Zla

22!al

22222a

22

22

I2

22

2I22

22a2

2222

2222

aIa,

.aI

22

22a

I i

22a

22

,2

22

22~

222

2 .0 I

aI III

1 2 I 2

2222 2 a 2~~~ I 1 2,I 2 II I 1~1 I 1 11I

:2.:. D,A. - R.C. I' , H-R.C'. , I

I2 2 I

I

I1 21I

I I 221 I I

I 2{lll23

a IZ III {

{l D.A. -'TI I1

I ] 2 12711721

I I 72 I 212777 ?I 7 I 17772.71'177 I2.77.777

17121

P ~ A -R.C7:7 7

222777277212 2~7

I 7 177 2 2 72 77 2 17 22

{q117717~11 ' 7

II 1211 I A '2717 2~ I 22 22

]111 1 7

I I I7

I I I 1 1 17 1 1777171Z,2'77~1111i

' I

177?777277111

17177771 , , I 7 ?~

7717 I 1 Z I 1 { 71

Figure 3-13. INVENTORY BOUNDARIES BY THE BOUNDARY ENHANCEMENT TECHNIQUEFOR PURDUE C-1 FLIGHT LINE

3-20

W

C:

III ·

S.0

.1,0

.- 3e

.i2

.UO

.&2

,*2

.id

.110

.23

.2.

.w0

.20

'.7

.]l

,Jo

.go

.'0

.17

.7%.

z 4

_

1

C

S:

I

Z

I

IaI

.1

11

{1

?I

L.:

II?1

7 1

I7

7

II

II

II

II

I

Z2

3,aaa

,I~

I I

Z3I

IIt

Z,I

I aZa

I a

I .

31a

A33

I

a

,132

I

1"

I II

I

I{

2

I

I

II

II

IIII

7777,

277717I

17

77

77

77

Ii ! I I

Page 44: UNSUPERVISED CLASSIFICATION OF REMOTE MULTISPECTRAL ... · i (f t , lt tr-220-1075 april 1972 unsupervised classification of remote multispectral sensing data 172-27204 ic.as c 237s9e

TR-1075NORTHROP SERVICES. INC.

"o"o0n1n1n0o1o1oIII1~00I110111110 DOO1O1a ODIOD1I I1i10tMODO ......I303730..0I070I0300700000000400I0030303000040032 2222212222222222222222222222222222222222222222727270337072Is' 3 : I -llI 2773333I'' 1I'1" S :'3? 3TI3? 333344544777449443002227977333 I33444I4I55 I594444413777S9 %9544444301Ia030I222227

.00OO0~00-n0O~000000n

-0onoonnnO1~ 1 1.a

0noo~nOI~oon ~ o

I--One"Ooonnnaonoo-onn

or000nOOOOO~OOOOon'n

~nO-Onoonlgnoo oon

~vonnonnl000~OooOOOa'

Iooon .. oooooooo ono

~IIIOnOqnOOOOOo~ncn

nOO~OO~nOO0 00-011

aOO0aO0no00000000 0OO~,

1 2 1 2 2 2 2l 1 1 12 2 21 1 2112l 3 2 2 l 2 2 1 2 2 2 2

II 2l22l l2l l lllll212222 2 2 122244

qqq#Mq~qq~qqqq tlll 121111111112

22222222212222221122212222221 III

2 2 2 2 2 2 2 21 1 1 1 I I 2 I I M I 1 l l l 1 l 22 1 2 2 2

2l1221 11Zrl~llllllf l~fl22l12l22II

I 1 1 1 1 1 1 2 1 2 21 1 2 211 2 211 21 212 21 2

2I1~121221121'2221222221211122221

Il1l 1 2 2l22ll2l 22l l 21212l2111

07 2222121122221121###22222211##23 7 2 1 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 1 2 2 1 q ~ q q q q q q q

t1221221224444434473334344444~q4

72333333cc( 2 c3c- .3 .. " 3:

3 313e7 g q ~ c c .

37 5CCq 3??7777777773I

$s 55SSSS$SSsss890S 885

aSIS~ssss %~Scc C ¢C9S S S3 s SS73 3 3 3 3 7 7 ' C C 7 4 9 27S3SS7S37S3SS3ccSr43343

4 3 3 3 4 4 7 4 4 2 4 4 7 7 7 3 3 41 3 3 :

SS~SSS.......a ......

333 433 4S 74777777774 "

SSSS~S~S~S~SSS¢C1CC1rCC

m~ 3¢ c 593c3433343345 4 5 4 s ls7 3377ma g e 7 377 3

45545445455559544555445

SscS~cc~cc Ic(c1ccc¢¢cr545555455~1 7774 77777 44

55544455555545533333333

45555535573443334337733

73I0I0I00I

733373374743 44444noooooool

0OGGGGGGGI

6CGOG&6nl

MOOO&663

GGGIGGGG1OGI GGGC.G40000&GGG3IDOO0M0on

nOOOIIII3

407&4373,4

GGGiG&GGG

nOOG&OGG&

730044430

7373&G31!

334012320

7377033A'

30304443

COODOODe:

cooooMooe

73772222

443444442

444434442

00I00fi$9.

00 0 11090·I

IoIoIo70oI 1

OO034443433744433732493332

70ooonoam03309444'

33333133333333333333333333333313

37333333333333333333333333. 333333

333333333333333333333333333343333333333333333333333533333333333333333373333373333333333333333333 37333333733333333333333333333 43

3333333333333333343343~33333313333733333333333333333333333333333 333333333)3333333333333333333333334433333333333133333333333133333123333333333343333333433333333343315454553 3333 33 3 3 3333 3 33 35333 433

333333334333333 333333333333333

333333333333333 ft333333333333333'53334334333333332~333333333334333333333333333333333333333333333333 3333 33 3 3 7 3 3 33333 3333 33 332 33132 3

:37333133333331333333353333733333422333333433~3333333333333333~3133:333 2343333333 3]33 I33333333333 24

.733334337437)33333433333333434352333334333133333333333333133333331 3331333333333333333333333333333

2433333333313)3333~33333333333333333334373333333333 333333]]33333

2 3 3 3 3 43 3 3 3 I I I I 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3

:33333333342333333313333333334332133333333333133333333333333331333343333333333333333333343343

I

~33

33

4343

33

34

33333):

.7 .... i''i'i ..... '3

[734444444444444444444444444444474444744444333333444444444444444444444474444494444444444700077

3 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 . 4 4 . 4 4 . 4 .4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 3 3 4 1 33 4

#999199.9 ... .......·9999·9··9·9··

III 99·99999~9999· 9·9 ·9·9 ·· 9· ··9

4 444949999·44·49 74· 444· 449949999 4 ·· 49··99··11

444· 44449 44 4444444 4444999·444 4444·4444444444;449494494444 44444·444449444 44 44444494444444444444·4494944 44444944 44444444.944494744444·4444479444

3444444444474444444444444444444474444444444444444444444444444444494444494444444444444944444470

4 4· 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 9 ·7 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 ·4 4 94 4 7 4 4 4 4 3 · 4 4 4 4 4 ·4 4 4 4 7. 4 9 4 4 4 4 9 9 9 · 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 49 49 4 4 9 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 ·4 43444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444744444444444444444444444444442223

·4444447444474474444444444444444444444444774447

44·94444449444444744444444444444444494444444443444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444·429959··99999994344444444444444440444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444:444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444

44444444444444444444444474444444444444444444047:

·459449··499494444·44444.4444444449944444333333.

·l~te99 199e999 44444444444444444444999·· 44999 ~9··99 ··9·9 44444444444444444· 444·9 47479

4444444444444444449444444444444444444444'999····

44444444444444444444444444444444444444444444477;44743444444444444444444444444444444444444444343.4444344444444444444444444444444444444444444444444 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 49 4· 4 9 4 94 4 4 4 4 9 94 4 4 4 4 · 4 4 4 4 4 4· 4 49 4 4 4 4 9 4 49· 4 3 44·4·9···99·4···4·9·4444449444444444444444444944 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4· 4 4 4· 4 4 4 4 4 4 449 4 4 44949 · 4 4· 4· 9 49 · 4 4 49 4 4 4· 4& 4444444444444444444444444444444444444444447494449

99999···999·9·9·99··449444···4··449444444444444

$9·999·999·$494·444444·444·44444444444444444444

4444444444444449.444994444494999449444444999444·4444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444

3

,3

3

:3

i3I

I7

i

Z1

II

3 3

3

3

3i3

Is.

I I

I3

I~

II

2222I 22I 22 I I I I2 42422I22I

4q421 2 3444444434443 4 254.4.44444 2

2 .4.4....44..,.I 4l04 013 l 4544444444

33311313331223223233333323323222322333222

222222~q~qqqq 22222222222222222222212W4

2222 2222222 3337333333312222 r'22lI4

2222222222 4 2.... 222222222

222222222222222222222222222222222 22422222222222222222222222222I

344 3333333333333333333433331qqqqq....4

33333333333343333333333333333333333333313333333333333333333333333333333333333333133333333333333333333333333333333345

3333434333333333333333333335333333

3333I33333333333333333333333333333333333

333333333333311133333311333333333335!llq

333333333333333 33333333333333333332

33333333333333333 333333333333333333321

## 42 4q42 . 44444444*4443q

44444444444444444444444444444444444444444

233222222222222 44444344443344444413445441

3211212212222 2222 14444444444444444444444

2 222222221222 222244444444444444444444444

22222222222222224444444444444444444445443fl224 222222 44.222222223*25931352223

)3444444444 jJfj444 ']44444444444]223244444 Z4 4 444444444444

L323~3 2 22 222222 I222224444444444449

34222222222 3 3 444 444 4444 4444444 44444 44 444444414 44

444444444444444444444444444444444444649B8

344 4I4lll 4 l 4 4 4 44 6 4444 4444 60307070 6377303330l0l0333003 643666.4.6444444444444

4 4441111 .47444444444444444444444444444

4443444444444443444444444I44444222222222

2Z~?ZP2;4z7 WZ 771707777O~flZ~z~Z~ Z~ f3 000303330' ~~~~~ .......... ...... oooo........ .DO.' ' 77' 77' ' f l ~ ' t ~ 7 I 0 0 3 3 3 7 3

* 77777777 777770777 7027222 777. 722 727222222 3000003333* 727727277Z 7777177077772 777707777l 77777 I7 7 00000330 3

4 7777777777777777777777777777777777777700303333042 IIa" 77 1 7I77 2 7272 ,1 ]0 OOO OO O0

777071711 77777112 110 17277777700 300 3332 ~~~~~~~~~~~00000000002Z 222l 72 ? 22 2222 2222 222 222222120 2000000000

2 2 7 7777771Z,22777722 72 7772 777377772 77777Z 0030 333337222222222222 1222 2 2 1222222121 2222222 10 0300333

4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 1 4 14 1 1 1 14 4 4 4 4 4 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0

44444444444434444444444444444444344444444l 444O4O003O

A A 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 A~ i A 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4o o o o o ooo00 0 0

4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 l 4 4 4 44144 4 4 4 4 4 I 4 4II. . 4 4 4 4 I 4 4 4 4O O O4O4 4 6

444444434444444444442444444444444444444 444400030

Z ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ 2 %ZZ]22OO

4444444&444444444444&4&44& 2222 & 49443 0003

702A&& 7&V&&A& F&&JA&&AA AA& V&FA A V&FAOO 300003 00 00vJAAArArrAA&AAA,&&ArA&vr&r&&rAv& &9 A&&A&ror0000030

XA& A&AA.AAA.AA.AA A& &AAA&A&A&AAAAAA&&Ag&A .A.&&AAIII

F g eAAAA3- 4IAAAFCA TAI OAAANBAATASAATAAAATAAAUAL A EA A C H N I Q U

· AA&&A A&A&&AA'AAAA AAA&&&A&-A&IIOA&A A&& ... OO0.

l.::A AJA&& AAA&4&A&&AAAAAA1AA& AA1A&AAA&AAAO,:AA&AIAIAg& AAAAIA&AA& AAg.AA&gAAAAA&:1.:A1:AA.1 A&AA&AIO01

,AA& A&AA&AAAA&A&&&AAAAA.A. : 'A &AA AI A .... AI&AOO00

,gJ.A.AAA&AAA&&AA&1A"&'''A&& :A& ::IAIl 'A.gA&AA0000

!A21 IFFFFFF F?~rro OOOOO

&&~~ ~ ~ ~AA A:.A&A:&:A000000

A iiAi:iii iiI Ai iA 1 1T l 111111AA . . )11 1 1I II

11tlll~~~~~llllllltZ~~~~~l]JI31JI~~~~~l11 :11) ] T t 01 11a,10 1 1!,l, '1!

Figure 3-14. CLASSIFICATION MAP BY THE STATISTICAL SEQUENTIAL TECHNIQUEWITH 18 CLASSES

3-21

704444, 444244444 7qq 00

)0oO

,::qOD mooo

) 11 "IOO

9 9 9 5 0 3 4 0

114132 2033

~qsSSS n1OO

25555q4 305q

244444444

iqtloO Ino'49970~ 773

4 5 0 3 30 03

95554 3330

44550 30

33444 744

333333 3333945a 919SSSO I'

SI I

595q4 444~

* 332333 $39

*354589 594J

933 3~e 377

]) 1 Lb

3 S mugS ,SC

9545S ,S3

* & S9 9 4 5 q 4 4 4

4555 44!1l

* UtSSI 584

33631090844 *lIAI

030oooo4CC

0 3000033oC

597

541

543

.17

&ll

&11

473

477

471

443

434

443

742

443

47~

47647337?

7Y72

Y72

?·l

Y72

..... qq 3 qqq11.3 3 .... · lq11

....##O-nOonfOOOOOwO~n

�000000303-. , ...- 5 � 3 I 3 1 1 14) 3 I; 31; 1 I 3-111-11 A:I 11 111E.. � I 1. i I 1. 1. I 1. i-11 _.1.1.

JO

I -

x

Li-,.4E

CI

III

I

4

I

1,

?2

]]G

I

_y_

#.

III

II

I

I

.1

II

IIIIIIA

I#

I#

%:

Page 45: UNSUPERVISED CLASSIFICATION OF REMOTE MULTISPECTRAL ... · i (f t , lt tr-220-1075 april 1972 unsupervised classification of remote multispectral sensing data 172-27204 ic.as c 237s9e

II 0.I 00 IT, I III 00t000000000I 0000 000"I I "I I II'l1Ii...i 11 121111 112 21 12 2.2773..0.

0oo00o0000000o OOOO0 000000000000000000000000

0 0 0 00 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0

0030~00900000022o0~0000

noeonno.nooooon~lOI00 I00 0n t0o 0 00no o noo0000000000OO0000 0002 06900000069600991 00n

000000O OO00002000010

00000000-000022200I000

InlnoIoeloononooo~noon

0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0n O. 0 00 0 0 0 0 0 2

o0n000000anoooooooo0oo

000000o000o000o0o000 20

0000000000O00or000000000

' c o 2 0 ' 0 0 0 0 0 0 00 0 0 0 0 0 0 0

n oo-o -ooooooomo0oo(

22990000600090003090090

o00000000000~00~0o000020000000000009000000022:0000000000000000000222n

IIsSr~c~cl~ccs( ......

I'll "I see~7?ccccn!

ISS5%55S SS~%sc08~S$~n~0313)SCKS C S. aCCCCC¢113

0~SS~0~ ~¢CC777 333

.4 0 .. 30 0 00 04 0AI 4

3 9 4 3 . . . .4 30 0 0 0 40fr r 4 0 0

3333320 0 9 f99 9990000 06

333 4ftt0097 60020000324!

ftftft4 Cft C 420040332353

] % 1) % t % 4 1 1 0 0 0 C 0 0 0 :

Ioo.OIOOl

GGGG3GGI0n000S0G00000000G0000010G2

GOGOG~nm

~GGGGGGIG00GG0GGG0

91000000I000044002

no on O. O

O,,IOIGG3

.O0O11 11I

S00G0G11

40ool0o0

Iil6GGGG000c04ot

000000042

0000066400400,0o

00000000

0000&013

.00002211210000900

ooootnooo

00060004?

ooooncoaa00006o000

I'000603,

...

t111222212122211111111011 12I111L6 22222221112211112lll224192112992292 229222111112~1112921991ql299229

0222112221222192111129#1211112212193914222212111122111399439499949

III12222222221111122211111111111........ .... ' ....

~11I'1l" 1 ..t11 11 33 13 1311111 1 1 1IIIIII .... ..... ....IIII 1 1 1 1 ~1

I )11 1111 131111111 1 1 1l ll l

COO III 111111111111111 li~11 ~11 I

2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 1 2 2 . . . 2 23 2 2 2 23 3 2 2 2 2 2 I

(O .. lllltlllllllllq q I'q lq AI'll

IIIT$111 11 1131#### q#~ 1~11~ 1113

k]3]))}))1333)}3]33))23))3]]~$33

I)33)]333331) 13333) 3313])33)}])])31

0 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 32 31 2 2 32 2 31 32 2 1 33 2 2 2 2 2 3

2 2 2 232 2 3 32 332 1 3 32 2 32 I2 3 3 12 2 2 32 2 2 2 2 2

2223 22211 333322 1 13322 2 22 22 322 2 2.2 22 322 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 1 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 0 2 2 2 2 22- - - -

430293949049945955$99490994$94934099949959932333

00999495.9559990944999559594949940499,94479,99709 00499 929 949991 59939 99599499404 9 459904999 349 399049999909990909994 44 09 9 9459994 094939944394991

099049 919099099 90990999 09 949 09 40594495 990900 7945999 99491949999 99449 9559 9 99149994990 09 994 49944

0959999449999000559999999999094909949444999999912399994959949499999491194594449999994494490190909

4999049909909340999949499409599995994444994060791t594044494909999195999449944040997095945040979

09199040999594090919090049999999004990494V449992

4*9590904999959494495955199599599999159999955194599999919909094949199994094904994099499495999922

#9199151919995999991915''~''9999199959959997497999959909S9909494999'9 049 99995549994959500149 495991959399999599190595909944430999994404940999949495999

2944999994999590499490449499944949409900994949469199199994 949 49999999 4499 5 9199499945999494449994

4949949099909410999645994 90999994409999 49 09495 9t999

4449999499949499995999999599099995994949499~99007949019999999095.999949944449909994599909003345333

94999999449999999999999959994905999494909499499

,99999194999999999949909949999049995999999909407A

9959439999599499909455999999494459999044999999399091949404491999940904994999599449599993909099400995919959094999995949999999594999999990499099999199

595999999999999999944440999995994949049551919951

4395999999999 9999999990999994 4 4 04 9490400 9999 9599

499959954994999999999494999599999094909404459909449k99994904419490949449009049940009949044990999999J'99999999994949999949090449999099494449499499094,999499499 99 919 99999449 99 941999 909994909499 449999

0495 99999 409049 44909499999999449909999499 949904999'994999999999949999999949994919599999494909999999*

.9594999999994999$9099949909999999909099441999909'95999995999995999999991999999494949499999999290

,99,9999995999999999999595099999999599999990999V q1

1999994999940999499999999099999009941909900499 91I994999990499099999991999999449009949904909042999t 4

22 2 1 1 20I iI I I I i i 9qq q 4qq q l I l l 1 9 1 2292922 09 49 949qqq q

9~ 21ll91 1221 9 99 2 3 4 39 4 9 9 943429 449999q~ 200~qq q ~ q q ii # q w q

040000#000 # I # 0 90 12 90 1 001#0122IIO q IG I I I1 1 99 99 o q q 0 90

0 9 9 9 9 0 9 9 9 9 9 ~l qq 3990944939~qq q lt ql q q q94 09 99 099000G 000

I 400999499902999299#q 24Ill q l lq qq lll l 1l 2l 2920 l 2111 10 1 000

992999*399999334993999240990999929999944 6664 00

22 22222222222022222222212122222 1 222 111 22 1226 0 05 00 000S....... . . S ,. 10

!~~~~~~~~~~~~~x: ...... I....I~ .S. .... I .....

............ 22? ..... 21 I2.1. .... : .I I 0IIII2 SoI l9 :1116619300

I I2 I I I2I2I2I1I2I I I I I II I111111111 1 1 1 2On

211 IIIIIIIIOIII I 1 11 11 12 990000~002 2 2 I 2l l l 2 ll ll i l l ll2 l l2 l lJJf l 2 2 2 2 2 9610 0 0000

2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 1 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 221 1 1 1.60 0 9 0 0 03# 3 222222222222222222222221 2212222112222922 133 ) 3 )3)9 9 ) 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 3 22 2 2 2 1 2 1 22 ) 2 522 1 2 2 2 2 1 2 2 2 4 4 1 9 6 9 l J

63 213132112222 22122 3211213333 3 211 11 1000 I 0l l6 .. 3 ...333 ... 3 3 43335 )33333333333 333. . 33 3494. 0..

133 33333113333133331 333333333333 33333333 23 6 33333 33

343 ~ 3 ... 333 .3 . .3333I.3 33333333333333133 % 36111 666

3 33~33333333333333333333333333333333333314 4141 41433 1433 436313 33333 33333333 3 } 336I333 3 )333 1639' S161

3 .3 3333333333333333333333.3333333)3333 3 333" 3 "I69 633333 033331333333333 13333 33333 23313 333333333 1S116 989339 33133333333333333333333313333333233333333 33333 464

3 3 33)33333433333333333 333 433 33 3 33 3333 36 9 964& S 0

33 3 3433331 3 32 43 333 333 333 qq3313 393 33q 669 9691& 0 S( S3 33 43 33 33 333$ ~ 333 3 3 3 3 33 3 3 33413333 6SS 919 1) 00

4 ... 3 .3 i333 333 .. 3333333333333 I 3 9191 S 1 :C$C4333343333 94944449499 9146344336 9l99422499~99949'~~~"9999999 11116 414

6J 2222222I22122222266 ~ 6666066 06666666 06 996 6696 691080118S33 3222 2 22222222222266606S6666 6406666 466 666 969 4SS

22 222222222222232220Ii Ii 1 666 06 06 &6 066666 06& 666 646 61 94 1 1 953

34 2222 2221266 21 J d666 066446 066&6666&666&66 6999 I II6&34 V .I 9962999 I I 6666 99 3 116 3

* 2 16324666I 6 I I6 4666666&6666666666 1191S k I660

3 33666&6&61,66666666666666666666666 16666 3393 6A93 6666666&6&&666666666566666&6&&06666060616ei leleee

03 ,066666666466666666666666000000000 . ..00300000000000 0 00D 0 999494 9 c000000 9 c0

33 244 444494944449994994999999 00 0 00 000 03 3 9 9 6 9 4 9 4 9 4 42 90 0 0 4 4 9 3 9

71

121

22

72

# 4 4c 0000003032 994332333994994999994949949494499994994q991000002000

2:' 0 7 0 7 3 0 7 7 0 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 0 7 7 7 7 0 0 0 7 0 7 0 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 0 7 7 2 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 907 07? 03 70777 37770 7777772 Z 2 307077772 072 20 )00000000 0

]'221 7777077 J277 27073 2 2222222220)000000000

7 7 0 7 77 7 7 7 7 2 2 ? 2 5 ~ 0 J 7 0 2 7 0 7 0 0 7 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 97 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 0 7 7 7 3 7 7 3 7 1 7 0 3 l 1 2 1 00 0 0 0 9 9 ~9

~' ~ ? 772 2222 222 22Z2 2~2~tI? 2~1 ~I OOOOOOOOO

],70707?77777770770232222Z27212227222227222 00000O00007 7 0 3 7 0 7 7 3 7 7 7 7 0 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 3 7 7 7 0 3 7 0 772 2 7 0 7 7 72 7 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 00 20277 7 2 0072 2 072 2 707222 2 22 2 2I7 I 000000000

iZ22222 222222222 "2 2222222 :00 00040000222:2222 227 2 22222212222 121211212 1222220 000000

090I0**62 *4022 0 IITII IIIIIII O 2000000000

4 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 6 0 6 20 0 2** * 0 . . . 6 1 * 6 0 6 0 6 0 0 0 0 0 0 0

DoooDooo~ooo

IIIi11111111111111111111111111160000600 60 0000000000.qqqqqq#!1#qqqqqq~qqq qqqqqqqqtqqqqII qII qqlOO O~o .OoO

222223022727222222211 4qqqqqqq........* A11 0000000000

o oo ooooIII. II.. I, 22H , 222,A 2221222z2222,22222:o t)D)0IOO "020i 1111111i11*1 I ... 1111111111122211 0000000000

1 9 9 0 0 6 0 4 0 0 0 0 * * * 0 0 6 6 * 6 0 0 0 40.. . . . . . . . . . . I4 0 t *0 *0 60 6000 o

l 11111111111 2 11 21 11111111122211 00003O000 0

277 I111 Illll)111Ll '11 ]1111 IIIIIIII I " I IIII''" IllI 000000000022 22227212222 2222 2 22 2 222 r22 2222 22 12200OO0O

I II2 ItA it 3)))) 3333 AA l A: .AIAl A: A3&AA&&&OA

'::IA AAAAA AAAAAAAA A AlA &l l A.A & AAA A&& A &A AA&A AAOOI A&AA.AA:AAA .A::AAAJA&A ,AA AIAAA&A AAA&.A AIA AA &'A: AA&AOOOE

AAA A AAAA& AA&A&A AAlA .... &AAAA AA&A0.61&A.A.&&A"A:AAAA : :AA .AAA&AA AA& AAA&...AA&&J& AA&AAAOCQS

&AA:&AAIA. AAAI A AA A A AAAA& A AA & A&A&&AA&&II~O.

99&AAAAAAA& ~ ~AAAA&&~ AA&AAAAAIA:AA&A&AAAO9&AA:AAA&A&AAA&.AAAA AA&AAA&&J&AI&AA~Q

k.AAA 'AA A AAA& A&A.AAA AAAAAAAIAAAA&AAAAA & A AAA& AAAO.- A -AAAJ A AA&J Al~IAA&A AAA AAAA AAAAAAA & IAJ&& &OfiOO

tA&&&A&AA&A~&AAA&A:A 1 1 1AA A&I&AAA AAAAA & & :'A&& A OOIAAA ...A& A&A lAAA&&&& AA:A:A&A':A& .AAAAAA& AA&AA.A&..I

LI .. A&. AAAAA AAAAAAAi&A & & A J A .. A....A0kIA'A&AAAA .A & A & &A&AAA.A11 1 IA & &O 0

I000 0001

II ~1111111111tllllllllllllllllllI'l llll I I `1tlIlI

Figure 3-15. CLASSIFICATION MAP BY THE STATISTICAL SEQUENTIAL TECHNIQUEWITH 17 CLASSES

3-22

NORTHROP SERVICES. INC.TR-1075

S16

392

ft.,

122*2%

620

629

072

&67

630

641

.47

699

603

&II

602

600

600

692

602

693

002003

009711

022

7)1

071

'73004*

'7.032

033

039

012

013061

S10

069

062

063

966

777

711

''9

#qqq.qq.q . .qqqq.qqqqqqqqqqqqL11, ��j

I

IA

A

AA

Page 46: UNSUPERVISED CLASSIFICATION OF REMOTE MULTISPECTRAL ... · i (f t , lt tr-220-1075 april 1972 unsupervised classification of remote multispectral sensing data 172-27204 ic.as c 237s9e

TR-1075NORTHROP SERVICES. INC.

Ooo0 11111I722)3 33~3#q#SSS$3366 *4.. 707?gm ma99 000700001111' 272273 $333 #qq &6&977?260 8 9:998 3 0300000 311711,i1ij3e0 31?el3979133?03$?90I&?91~S ~ ?9~3$~9~)S?913~9~]6?9~S?9 ? ? 7 2 73 S?91S?9 21?915S79 SI

"O0030000000000 00fl000n .111 1t11t1tl I I T11 1 1 11 1 1 1 1 1 1

1' 0 00 000000O O O 00000O 0~ 1111111111l1t1111l11l1811 ] 11111l-7 72202020370002200007 31l1l111111111111111112121111221000000000200000000 a00 22 1101111111127211121271170110p0000020000000 300000o 0111111111III1ll121171l ilIIII II

0000007ol000oo00000000 221211112111111111llt22722222222

27~27220700720022022272 2702722777722?222111171111111111110000n00 00'IO 00" 0I II 1111111111111111111111111122111110~0~030077700772727022 2772777707222722722121 11111111711.

00000000000001 1OI00I00 1 l t l l I I1I1 1 111 I1 II,0000 a00000000000000000 . 1 11111111] ltll11 ll1 lli2 l11 l11i

a0000 00000000000000000 lt0l 1 l1 11111 J1l lllll1 ll1 l11l1 lJ

0000~0000 000000PtO 0n l Illlllllp' Iml~ml WI11 11lllilll11-00 0 0 0 0 0 00 0 0 0 0 0 0 IIl l I f 1 1 1 R I l O'l:l l0 0 0 0 ~00 0 0 0 3 0 0 0 I 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1

0.0.000I000I00 000 I0I. ItllIIIIl lllll llllllIIllllllll

0000'000000-00000000O 011111111111111111111l1111ll111ll

0110000000"0o00o o00ooo lIlIIIIIIIlIIl IllI lIll

072000020002oL0I), 0070 III IIll lllIlIll]11 Illlllllll00 0 0 3 0 00000OOO O O ~00 11 I 111 I111I1I111111 illllllllllllllllOO00110000iOOO00~00O0011 IIIllIllll~lIIIllIIlllIllllllllll

000000000OO00000000111 lIIIIllllllllltIIlltlllIIll~lllltl1o00ooOooooOooooOoo00o0 0 111l11on1llllllllllllllllllllll0o00000 000000 0oo0 00 11111111111. 17220. . 22A2207222000000000000000~OO072 77722027272220027222222227222212J22~0oooo00000000oo00'oo0 I1119111111 I727227071133323222772 2

o000(000n0 0O noo3 00 o00o 3372222 132731 333 27022 7,00 0 00 00 0 00 00221 3 33127?22 313000(00000 -.... * 3 3333l33333331333 33131 3333331 3 211 3 3 3 ( 3C 0C C 3 3 3 3 C CC 0 3 3 0(% 1 1 3 31 3 3 2 3 3 3 3333 3 . . . . 3 3 3 3 .33 3 0 33

"13 30(((000rC%(C 033- 0 .. .... 333 0 11 3333 31 33333.........1831S3(0 030001000(00013 33323333113~113133313333333331 1131

C800 0 80 *0 0 00 00 8 3333333133 13313 333333333 3 3331 131..3 ......008 C("0 8 313 13 3 33 33 33 3 3 3 3 3

10003((000 00000.a .. 0- 133333313 13 33333313 133 133 333 3 313I'S33003033330386 113 333313331331333331331313333333313

Icepi 33%3 3%........1............31 3113 3 ...... 13.

33330 333 3001 1311 31 33111313113 ,333314330333333311133

~~ W ~ ~ ~S 133113S!333333333 333333333331333%3330%3%%%333033%33 133 3 .... '131 3031 ,1 ..33 3333133333 1 3

030 353 303 38 000 0 3 13 13333333333333333131333333313333333%3333%333*333300 331 33 33313 3313333 3333133331 33131133033333333 %33 CCCCC0 C 113333 33333333333 3333331333331321

8333%33 3333383 3S3"38 3331 1331113111 2111033..313333333

%83333333CCS3f0c0rc 'IC 303 3 3 1 13 3 3 313333333431341, 1

&3 1333 C00 00C 80 00 0 C 33 33333113333131111 1 1 1 1 113333313. 33133

03 0 3 0 ( 0 0 ( 0 ( 0 ( 0 0 ( 0 ( 0 ( 2 C C 1 1 1 1 113 3 13 31 ( 3 3 3 31 1 3 1 31 3 31 3 3 3 31 1 3( ( 0 0 0 CS C C ( ( C r C1 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 .3 3 3 3 3 3 33 3 3 3 3 3 3 33 3 3 3 3 1 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3

((((( C O 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0(0 0 1 3 313 1 13 1 1 31 3 331 3 1 3 3 3 3 3 331 3 3 3 31 3 3 3.

-. 30*3 EtEF11fr(03CC313 3333331331)33133333133323333 333331 133 j30007rE(Ot(3 3333 101333313131333313133333330233132

3313303

0000noooo00G466660

fnonlGI II

~004100 I 2'

n 01 0. 0 4

onnnr, G~ 1n-o26o33

300000o039

0o0000110000404000000 30G0 0

0& 0G G 0&0 008470000 r0 0n 4 4

000G4000100400003000000001

0000*4*0~00300000

77277o27

J3003000009300000300000030000030000000000033333

000009000090000' 0003000000 300000000' 0000022 70221~03000000000030033000000303000000000000000333331

· 999·9 9·999999999 999999999999999920300003000000000000990000090009309000900900900000092

000000030000000 09 3 000009 00903903000 0000000000,9'900000030000000300000000000000000000000000300079

0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 09 3 0 0 0 0 9 0 09 0 0 0 3 09 0 0 0 09 0 0 9 0 0 0 0 0 90 0 0 03 000903900000000000000000 300090000900000 00039002 20 00 00000090000000090000900000000000700000009 209

00000003000000000000003000000000000000000000009

00000303000000000000000000000000003030000000003

00033000300000000300000000003000000000009270007.000003030330303033000300003000000000000000000

10000000000000000300900000030330000030000303000I1903033300330000030300000003030003,00000300000

030030003300300300030030030300000000000093 31333:

0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 3 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 O 9 O9 O9 O9 O O O O # I 3 0 · 9 0 0 0 0 3 39 9 9 ~ 999 ~· 9. 9 9000000309 0000130009 0330e0·9 9 99 999 9 99 9 9~030010000000000000000209 2.99 ~2

00000009010 00000000090000000 000 030000000300 03 0 70000·30090003.000000 009393930 0003000 90 00000300030 3003300000000000003000000000 00·3990099903000000:0099939900099.909 03030000309390009000090900399490000000300300000000000000000000030000300000400420 0 0 3 0 3 0 0 3 0 0 3 3 0 0 0 3 0 0 0 3 0 0 0 0 0 3 0 93 .0 0 · e·0 0 03 0 0 3 9 &*000000003000300300000000000030000000009000003080

300000303303000330300000000000300003000000000001

0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 3 0 9 39 0 0 0 9 9 9 9 9 9 0 0 09 0 09 0 0 0 3 0 0 0 0 93 0 90

300300000,30009909000900000,00900090930999300903t00303333000333003030000300000000000003000000000

0003000000030000000000000300000000000000000000003003030000003030330300000000003099099990930009*&

000900099000909909009009899903300000030009990*A&

000.0300000330000030033000000003000000000003000300030000000000000300330300000000003000030000000300000000000009089.99e·90999090000009903

300030009300000000,330033.000090909990000003111700 70909 030000390090 003 0000000 000 00 00000 00 00

=33

II

I

3

3'3

'3

II

7,1110

2a

II22

IIII

21

2t

32

.33

32

~3~302

32

32

32

IlI

I2

I]I2

I3

II3

I2

IJI I

1111111 1111 287227I 11717117 '111117l11121722 2222 222027222 22722272277127 22 022222 22272227222722 22212022~2211722722232221222322212722222722172211 22A000270002217122022221 10221100111111 2

72277222022272227722 2720272222223202222I1712227222227222722 S222J2l722222272772222222222112227 21212211222211111112102

71722272222272222222202222722222222722I 22222272222227222722272272722~222227722

7327227277222227227222222272222Z22222720272722222227772022722272273222

111 111 111 111111 2l11111110111111111111II111t1

322...... 33333333333333333.333.

13333333333013331303133333)33)*43333013*3)3 333Si3333 3 ) 33 )33333333333 3333 3333333 ....

11 .... I 1 3 1 1 1 111 444444*44* 3 443 443 44448*

1133 3 331 33 33 333333333333333333)331333333

1)33)3)3 333333333333 23)33233323333 333)S3~

33333333333033332333 333313233}33 3]333)33,33333)333)3333333333~3 333333)3S333333335!3111311111111113111 111 44444343443*33 44343 03333333... 3333 333)3 333313 33132333444*44444

~3333033) 33330333 333033333333333 33IJ0 33 !

3333333333133313333333333333 333

33333333330 0 70722 22

7722222227222222 2227222

722722722227272222222f2222222222222222222:

311212 ... - " 11 11111116 .66 6 1266666i..ij669 1~111111&111116 666 A6666i666666i6666J

322222722 11 i2~2 32222223~622222:T: ........------

222723227222227722

2772223022000

1433302

7722272

Ssi3000

I 3 3 I3

23232233 6 363301333i007

IOOI100770.000000000

770020

722

020070000003

272~000

272200100

888

030

000soo

000c00

072333

'IOSS Sjla:Si'll one

'33333 3 33s

ijij1oe 0"233333 383j

83318 300

.33338i 3JCC

338848 666

6 3 8 6 8ij i 3 3 386686 833j33333 33i368668j 888i

3888~i6 220j

33838& 686

I 21 33733377227271 12222 222221 212 022 71 12227 27 00 0 0 02222227277272227I727022220272222 0I220722 00000000

77222227227277227022222722222227222777270 000000000

J 222222227222 342 L

27277 I I222222720 0OO000000

* 722227220222 227I212 222 ?? 3722211 11 00000009 0

2 I "' 2222222222222?27222722 2 32222221 12122722 0000000002 72227722702272272272222237222227222027227 000000000

* 22222222722220272222222222222222222222220 000000000* 277272 7277222027272222272227227 222 0000 0

212222272277Z22722222222772272222 272 2277272 0000E0010

1111111 1111 11111111111111000 0000000002177 7227722272722222227277727277727222 02272 00000ooo00Voa

**4 6 * * * 0 * 0 * 8 * 4 8 8 0 6 0 0 4 4 8 * 4 4 0 * 4 80 0 0 n 0 0

8111132* *111 111111* 1 11*111* 122*111* 406000000

2r2;1222772z222~7~ 722222z27P2272z2722222722 1Vn

23~))33331333335 ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ I A I A IAA Ia llO

&AAAA ... A

020*&*AIA&A0***4&&A 4*8 *. A *AAAAAAAAA&A0 * 8AA& &.0000

,&A.AtIA4 AAAAA&&4&AA~A&A A AO AAA&00&:A&&A&IA AAA& IIAAA&~A SA -&& A&AIAAAAAA&AAAA :A4AA&AOgl

99&AA &..&..A. & AAA& .. AAAA*A A AA&&A O&4AO

...&A&A&&A&A&A1AkAAA~A&A & AA&&aAAA&&A:A&&aA AAA 3&010009AlAAAAAAA&A&AAAAAAAA &IAA.1 .. AaAA&AA- AA &AA&JO

9AA~kAA&AAAAAAJ AAAA&:A 11.A&J& A AA AA 0000

A. AA AA ... A&.. AooAAon00***1*A . . . A - *A A * * * * * * 0 * * * 0 * * 0 * 0 * * 8 4 * V.

0 **0o0 00ooono* 4ooooooo00

Figure 3-16. CLASSIFICATION MAP BY THE STATISTICAL SEQUENTIAL TECHNIQUEWITH 16 CLASSES

3-23.

8j33

4036431

407

400

413

*t?

*)9672

673

*67?

429

311

433433*63?

432433

e33

430630

442

4436654?3

463

?33

&?2

6e3

&33

002

003

7Ol

7113

21~

073073

'27

039

?et

?i13

S30

'57

0*3

713

042043

049

0*1

04

002

-m

il

a

I:

2

I II

I

1,I

30

3

I

TV

b

7

I

II

13

3

1-7

I

~ 2

p2

2

,2

21

II

TV

3 N

Z2

im

AI

2-1

II

II �: i

I �i

I :

I I

III11

1 2

t

I1

3

I

3

2

9

2

2

1 2

, 2

27I

Page 47: UNSUPERVISED CLASSIFICATION OF REMOTE MULTISPECTRAL ... · i (f t , lt tr-220-1075 april 1972 unsupervised classification of remote multispectral sensing data 172-27204 ic.as c 237s9e

TR-1075NORTHROP SERVICES. INC.

00000~ ~ ~ ~~1117110000.40000000iIIL t7]2;r3.ZZZ210 080000 0 211I 00I)%01010900110100 0030109309301003010000030100301003 . ........ 0 091,0 '

o n o, n O , 'Oo10 00000070 I IIIIl Il IIIII IIII l III lIl ll 1ll l l0 0 0 0 0 00 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 I I IllI I1 I 1 llOl l l l I Il0 l 1 1 I 11 702

07270 070 0700 0 1111111111117O1171 00 0 0 7 0 0 0 0 0 7 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 21 1 0 1 1 II I 1 111t l i ? 2 7 1 21 1 /1 i7 1 7 0 1 1 l

n~n o3~o~no cloootoo"O lllll lll llllt llln0 o f 0 Co n n0 7 0 00 0 0 0 0 1 7 21 21 - 11 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1t 1 1 1 1.1... . . . . . 2

7 ?077 7770077027777I07 7322777..."Il7211110711111111111 00o0n0,o00o0 00OO1ll I II t111 1111 11111111 11 111711 II

?000700 ? 77710 7777 7770 07? 7 70?? 7 2?? 3 72 77 ? 2 1 1 1 1 117 11II ~ ~ l 7270 OoOI0oo0 10pi1O0PO I1111111111l l IIIl lllilII III 70

OO000nO 0100 7O00010010'' Il~lll IIlllIl11I1 IllII tl~l tlI 770000nO 0 00no 0 OOO 0 Il I llII0ll l l lll Ill 77

00o0 000 0 o ooo o ......... I. I I f11 11111111 II7000"00I0 000000000 III 11111011110070oolo oooe 07 oo oqonl Illl lllll l tl00o 000o 0I0 o07 ooo0 o0007 1 il tt1 1111 11 1111l111111 illl 11lllll I

onc0l07OfponlflOOOO(O[l'O 111110111 1 111111 111 11 111 IT

000 coo oi00l00000t0000 allllll lI1l I

~??o~~oo~ooo~hoo~o?0OOl iI~i 1 1 1111lllli l1121111t II0000 '0 00100007007000011 1 11111t 11111ll 211 111111111111 111 I

COC0o000o 00000000001a1111 Ii3111111111 011 1111111111111 II

700070000O000000000000 0 ~1l II IItl lll lIll llll ll l I

3 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 1 1 1 111113 1 1113 l 3 3 17 7 7 312 7 7 71 7 7 2 7 11'

0000"000000000000000777 7??22332227732777727?22227772 70;ZZ

07070000700000000o000 o7 tl t11 77 77 77 23.33 3 3 Z) ]3? 33.f 3.02 7 0000 0000O 300000000i ] 2 2 Z ~ ) !3 77773 3 7 2 7 07 713

100000000000007000000 3 331133331331333333113 3333 311111113

10000000707070007000000 131]30313 3))1 333333333)3]3)1333 37)

00000000900000070000000 3333131133333)333)33133333333333 3))

10000000000000010000007 33333333333333133333S3331303171 7lo,

Ss .. 0 00000SI 000 0 I 1133 1~13 3 01 )1 3113 30... 3....3104 3 1

0101 00377000 00 73)33313 33 333133333 0)03 3331333 3)3 3 333 3

10 0S0S7Bs?0? Y?77730303 '3313)3333133 0 ..3331 ....33333133 .

1331330000000000007 0033 1)33)33311..33.3 113]3333)33333133 )

1SS00 S00s0ss0070000000 3333333 33101 3331313.3133133313333.

P000000000000000000 0 01~6333 133 133 03 1 33 1 )3 3133131113 333 3.

00 0 0000,06~6qS0,0 ,00 0111313131133 11)3)1333 13)331 331311

000040 (E76 0(r33733 ]]3331333.333 13333103 133733333303331 3!

I 3) 1000000001(((377 30 ] 33 333 33333331 333 33 3313...3.33 7311 1

576SSS666~6~S7 1]]33 )33331333)133333 I7 366761767773 3333333 3333I3333333333337J33: 12;

;KSI~S~67~663777 .. ...................... 1331]3 ....

L67Y7777777777777 13 33111133333 37]33333 13 1 3])33)) 3]~)

33 ]~~r~r~g~g3113 131 1,33333333333~33333333332333323 3~) I 1]11 I 130II. 3013]003 evi0e- -------e --] ....

I3 1 3 1) 3

)000 00000

'OIOCOICCIIoccO OCe,oCo.C"noI

)OCCC0303*CC C CC C CC¢cCC] CCC007CC? 03

0CCI leCrCIOenolcc]

ono~o, o'07000n0ee

1000CC? 30'000111111e777777?:meetoc,¢COOcCCC¢'OC 00 CCC C C

000cn 3ccc'

010CC3330'00000]010

.7 ,0I7C C..0

CCC 7CCC(~000 0030!00003¢0090oo00n00

00070000

I 0 C I OC I 3i0000000

1000000000000h0809o0000003

OO0o&&A,0000000

,707ooo77

33009009900900900309000000099009900999999331303

090999999090990099900990009930309990009999220220000000009030090300000093009009099900900005331130~$900c90000509090999999900990090900009909900000 C'ee0909009000099000050900999999999999099999000722

900000000000990003399090999009900009999030009009000090000000 0900990339009300000909009090990090200e00000900000300000000000030009030333909909003

090300 0509000309 0 0 000 0 300000000 90 9 0 0 09 9 00009 9 397999 22

0ee000000000000000990999999000990037030900393370e0 90 00090 0 0 3 0 0 0 00090000033099 0000q 0 0 9 0 39990300000900009009 00000000339000000000909009000090990303

e0090000000039009009000909 0099900999939999901111I

90000 0 00 000900990900099090003090909000030 0720937

30090000.000309009000099990030,0999900000300009700000033000030000009000009093300000099990039000

03e00000300000300000000990900000003900090300307077

009039900030000099000900000000000300000303311001

33e003000000300 0 01 0000 09 099030 300 330 0 3030 0003 3 03 33

309000300900009000000 930099909009999909999 00

90000000300003099900000900303030000999903070722

30009000000000990900030000990990003000903900007700030.000000000000000000030030090099000009003033

0e33300090*0099309000000900999990009090090300003

3000000000900303390903003003909090030000000000400000000030009000000900000000090030009009003800440000903000000000009090000030000000090000000000.88

000009000009039009000000050900303999000900039099

0,0000090090099000000909009009900009000000990900

99090909990009900990099909990000000930090900309030009000909009900903009900900090000093090900990003

e093090909009090990090000999090090009900009300408e000090000000099003309099000099399000999009000308

3900903000000009030000990993300099030099093003A

9999000000000009999030009009000090039099090099

09903300909000009003993009090330090003009909 0090 0 0 0 0 0 0 9 0 009 9009 9 09 9 00 00 00 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 9 009 009 0009 9 0

009000009909999999900099000009500030999999901 99

091000000090099993993990991999990999w993000999

I1t 1 1 11 1 Z, 11111 i, if 2,,2I II 22I11iiIt 2 111 I

Z 1f1 1717Oo 2 2 22?I 2II O22 07 1 I 72 7772 0 7 L

p7772 l2 2777I 717 2 71l 77 I 27 IIIII'll,. .2 I

0703023 00?? 110 12 1077/I 1 7 10 1 100111111 I

I7 7I27 1 0 2 0 7 7 1 lo t 7 I I I I I I I II0 I I2

Il 1 2 1 7 7 02 1 7 7 1? 72 7 7. 2 7! J2 1 7 1 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 27~ ! 2 1 1 7 7;

!I2770711 1 7213 72 7Z13121 21 3 21 211 13 11110130fZZZI)727;2773Z3Z;7)Z]727?7Z?;3.ZZ1Z30)!2 I

"3 3 1 .... I " , " , 3 .........

33337 3333 23 33323 3)3 3.20 3 3 , I

3 ......... 11111 ........11111111 111111 'IIIIIII113 1 11 11 111 111 311111117 111111 1

~11111111111011l1lI111111]111 11I1III 1111. 111) l

1I11 l1l1 ll I I 1 1 I I Il1111 1 1111 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 7 1 1

Le081111It l I I IIlIti~ I IIt ~~ IlIIl It II 0lIIIIIIII 111 J1 1111111 t [1 I 1111 11111011 I

3l33l131 III) 3IIIIllIIIIIII IIIlllIIIII12111111311111111111 11111 0

. . . 3 . . .3 3 3 333" 33 I . 33 33 3 3 3 3 3 3 .3 . .3

r3333333)333333333333033333333333]3)S3333

i3333))) 33333 331333333333333033 33333000*13))003 0033)3)) 33333) 333 33 3333 )3 ) 3 013) 3303 t33

13)313333333333333)0303)))33333))3S36)3333

I)33 33) 33)3 3)2 3 33333)3 2 3333333)33333

3333))311)3333)31)33)333)33)))313)33)33)30

*13 3 3 30) 3 3 3 33)33 3333) 333)3 )3333 3 0 3) ) 31 03 1 3 1I)33333133)33013333333333)))))3633)33033)3

103)303) 3 33353) 33) 313333333)3 ) $ 3 S 3 3I]333)33)))33 )3)3))3))))3)3)

,, , , ,: )33,,) ,))I........ . . .'2 12 7 7 7212 2 723 2 17 2023. 0772 2 77 77 2 77 00

III II I I III II I II II 16,0 66·66·666666·61666614

t I 1I1I11II I II 11666666656·666666··6666166

11I11I11111 I 0 I4 011.11112

6 44 6, ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ 8 4 4 444 ....~~~I 2 ..... 28A40--2k 4 3.& 3 3........I ·311611111161166666666661666666666666666!

l00&·666 066 06 00060666 9666660000000 70 7 1 0

0 77~ 0 30 0 -n O O O O . , 7 7 7 7 1 0 7 0 7 7 7 7 2 7 7 ? 2 73.3. 223. Z 3.Z 212 27?. .2771.27 Z21Z1111. .2170

222272722222220 227 2227 22227 22222222222222

122277770227222277777707177777770777700OOOOOOo00

11I1 II I p 111 111111111111111000 0000000001710727707177I 723322202222227222220270 0 0000000

3 I1122 221 111 1.. ... ......1 ... I 22 111 1 200 0000000002 022 I....8222 I22 24 222 .2 802822 08222,220 004*00000

0*.23 *2 2 34P .e 3. Z0l0 g* i 00 .3. 00 . 304 . (4800000072;*?800* 0*? 0003. 88*000008083.0003.3.3.3.3. 02.ZZ]. 0 I 0000999908000000000*08008*0 0000*0?00800I I 8I0*I 00000000

80040040*0 ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ :A:~~~~~~00 300,10

0040*00 080844048800400808** .... I* 800*000

0080808008880*4*0*0408000000800808880880 233332..332Q080000000O

I200020Z*0280008I0 I0I0I0 I ....... 080*0*000C0

00040400800841 01111111111123 3 12 000000000

;~ ~~~~~~~~~~r 2ZZ.3Z22?]Z33333..3ZZ]3;....Z. 3 I : 0000 §0no

I VII PI F7Illll T 11 ....... il00 a 000000000

Illlll t111112 ill I 2 lit I 2 I 1111 I Illtil OlO at 300 000I

Illll0lll0llllil77lllll00llllltllllllllJ 3000000000

Figue 3-7. CASSIICATON MPHBYTHE TATI.ASTICA SEQ .E'NT ' TECHNIQU

.A.A. AA.?A IIIItI IIIIIItI 11.A. A 'A '.".'OlO

AAA t t I AItiA AAt Ill1 It:il :Al il &1 &ODD400000

ia.A&AA- AA&&AAA&AAAA.AA .A&&&JAAAAAAA AA 'A A AA:.AAO&C

kAAAA&iAA. AA A&&.·&AAA..&:::::::A4: A.AAIA & AAAA.AOO0O

-AAAA ...A AAA.L&A&&AAI&A~AAAI A·A&A10nO O

'gAA& &A k *A&AAAAA···A&~ &&A~&A·&&A&&A&AAAA~~~~~D aOD &· ·A000

'i&&AAI~ ~ ~~~~IF 1 A&AAAAAA&& ·&A&A&A&&A&A AAO'§

Figure 3-17. CLASSIFICATION MAP BY THE STATISTICAL SEQUENTIAL TECHNIQUEWITH 15 CLASSES

3-24

07211771212 077 27 100012 I 70

II7III 000I0I1717 00012I0I I0i 0

11I101 000

17l0177 20

800 000

sasoono oD

100000:0,0

1030061 000

1005000017207 I17

110000 0100

160000 000

1615056(000

O... ...

'1.300 000

06000 000

311000 03g

r$6oooo

01008800037170!072

00001(000

000004000

00000 1O0

3303)3 000

03336:300

100 110600006167300000q000

000001600000001000

00000310000001156130010110000000164030111106000ll00l0

00000120000000007?

1000l170l

300000303

00,000600

003000

090

6001471

7,s

013

/,10410

471

413070

.7,010

030

4)0

003

000

0.0

001

001

·00

800

400

&lI

00y

'76

003

070

603

?010

TO7

7010

'16

019

300070

670

019001011

000

360

010

003

~00

001

000

'00003

~03040

I................................

2Z

Z~2

2

2

II2

X

13.� -24

L-

I

II

II

I

I

T"

I112221

0

111I

III

III

III

II

III

II3

2

1 11

1 11

: 113'

I rIF31"

--L

I:I

prjI

,j

:1;

,I

I

III

II

F-�

.4t

AA

IIAI

I

Page 48: UNSUPERVISED CLASSIFICATION OF REMOTE MULTISPECTRAL ... · i (f t , lt tr-220-1075 april 1972 unsupervised classification of remote multispectral sensing data 172-27204 ic.as c 237s9e

001301 I I 01,2253~"'o ~q%11154...n,2. asaa...a...n.... t4 ,112l1233333000301 514 21!5...)...z0001 11112

000000000100I0000000l tl11111 11111 1 1 2 1 2111 111 111l ?

0000n001n0000 0 00ttCO000 0000020O00000?0002 llI 1 1tI lI tt 11 I?1I1112l 1?2 111 2

01o01ot1000 00 o0oi00 1 I II 1I 11l ;1111111111111tII3111 III I I1?ZaO010 -01-fl1?nn????? ?' ????Z?22 Z.2l...1711 1111111t1711 ..

ooOoo~ ooonoo olnto ooo0l' it i l t 1111t111 1 11 1111 I11t l III 21lone ' o 0....111.....1 Il III Illllllll I

OV0000000000. 0 000 d0 OI i l l l ll2t t l ~ t t t I 1

00 0 0 0 0t~I0oi O O O0Ct011O iltl 1i 1111 Tl4 1 llfrl flltl11 III II

"ofno Ono '' lO 1nfl 0 0 20?72l00022C7 11 11 l ir 3 ". lIlt. t l l l

ocoonior A.onoooooPOoo,'otrtii Istllllltllltllltltt llno0 . IO O`,... 0 1 000or 0 tl l tlll itlt11111 1 1 1t1 1111 11 II110 it"0 01t' , n O n (1l000 1 11111? 111111 1 11 11111111111 111 1 III

l00 o n _ n no,00 0 0 0 00 1100 0 1 1l 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1l1 1 1 1 1 1 1 11 1 1 1 1 1 1 11l

0 2 1 0 0 0 h 1 2 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 2 0 0 2 l i ttl l l 1 1 1 1 1 l lt 1 1 1[11 1 t ll l l l l ll l l l l l1

00tfl '0l0000t,'~00 00'00I Ijlllit l lIlllli lllllll l tl Illl1111111 I

'norooooon-onoooootIoo.o.t I1 11111 1 [111111111111111 IInto = 0 0011000000001 1u1:101 11l12l tllt ?Z1]1Z1111 1 2;'11 I

on r I_ _ ~ n'r Z

21

o0 o10 n0 oo - ,,100n0-0 n0' 31221 1 11 1112 3 I 13.. 33177 37 ?

0000010100010l000IlllI~III02211l13311 11 211

1ZZ%& 0 %)77%?)))31 ))))))31)))(077r7)1)) 7l )) )33))))77)) 311

31112111 %J1 77777 '01 13 1) 1 31) _11 )13 1)3330 331333333333 33 33)1 5 5 % 1 5 1 1 l 5 5 1 l . . . . . . 1 1 1 0 3 0 3 31. . 1 3 3 3 3 1 31 1 33 3 3 3 3 3 3 3

........... .. . ... .1 0 I.01 03 11 13 33133 13)3133 3" I'll, 13

3 1%S3 111100S S 710 l31 )3 131 11333333331 3)I)) T3 I I 130S%11311% 05%i 52K0)SS&K$0015),10 0 ........... ).. 3.......I 13

)55531 5)7777777 5 57 . 1. 1 103133 33233$33)37) 13333333333 33

*I 7)777)7777)777771, 712 I 71 1)))7 33 331)) 333 33 I) )13333 33 32

7777778S55%5e 5*4 777... 1.1).... ....11)3 )333) )33 31) 33131) 1A A

S5%S55 55555 %5111 111) 3313111331333 333331333 3333 333 13 1

777 S 7777777777771770 13333330133 " )333313 313)331 3)3

773 51%501[2 1111 ) 333] 333 ))))3 1333) 33337 33333343335433

) 3 3 , 2 1 1 1 5 3 1 0 1 33[C ) 1 1 3?0 3 3 3 0 3 3 3 0 1 3 3 3 3 3 1 3 3 3 333 .. .3 ?3 !3 3";I 311112121 1130333133333333333 3

311111 311111ll1311111233333331333333311333333333333233333- - -2 ................................... - -23 I33

1103331

3000000o30

0010c0000c

,o~n¢¢nn~nonocIoIo

0nono00no

o0oo0occ0

~0o111

¢00 (CC (002000(0031

0000, I(0

eooccccc¢A~c¢C))Ib

00tCCC 0000 00I C I

0000¢c I I I&CC01¢&aA

00001000

000000332

n00ool3330ooo0o033

0000OOOO0

oonotocc~00000001

o00ooo0no

0000o0o0000000000

000000203330i: iii ii!i~fiii io000000000e*9

0

00003 00000000900e000999090111011

0009¢000000330 3 0.09 0.00090,000.009.0033333110000000000000000009090000e0000000090000900000 I~99e0000000000030000090909999999e999990099999eg99.00.00000000300303000 ,000.0009.090999999990eeg0

00000000000000.000010000000100000000900993919300000000003000000000030090000000000000000000~

.00 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 2199 9 9 e 19*0000000000090990000000000900990000100090000399

100090009000090 000000000090000000000000000.00993000010000090000090000010000991e0001009900001000

000033 00009000001000e000099 0900000000000000t9Il'9 0 0 0 0 0 0 0e 9 9 0 09 0 0 0 0 0 0 9 0 0 0 09 0 0 0 0 0 1 0 0 09 0 0 0 0 0 1 99 0 1 20000330030 . 0000500000000000000000000099e9 0

3 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 3 9 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 09 0 0 0 0 0 09 9 0 0 09 9 0 91030000310300 0l00l*00900000 0 . 0000000000909910 0000 0000000000900000000 00 099000 000000000000

0 0 0 0 0 00e0 09 9 0 0e 1 0 0 099 9 09 0 0 0 0 3 009 . 0 0 ,0g Z00e009000900090009009000000000000000099000001012

30000000.000000000.000000000000000000000133333,000009000900009009100U0009000090000000000003393)

0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0eg 9 9 5 9 9 9 9 0 0 0 0

pg9999*9009000000000e0000009000999999®9999999®99)9 9 e90 9 93900 0 90 0 9 9090 0 900 900 90000900 0 0900.0 900 0 0 0 00 3 322'00930099090000000009,,OOO99nOOOOOO..,000900090

P9 0 0 90 0 0 0 0 0 9 0 0 09 0 0 0 0 0 9 0 0 0 0 0 0 09 0 0 0 0 0 9 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 09 9 4 4 1,00.0000900.e090000090000099900090009099000*44~,09 0 0000 000099 00 . 0000000000000009999 049 9 4949 4P90000 91 00 0003000000 00000000000000 00 000900 000w0009000,909009 00000050000000000000000000000000*090090000900999000e0 0000050000000000000000000900009~9 00 0 0 0 0 0000 00 e000000000000 00 0,0000 00.00.0000000000000000000000000000000000000090090000000000093e090000900000000e99ee99ege99999e999

* 00$00000000$000 0000 00 500 00 00090000 000e0000004900909090e00e000000000009000000000000000000000AA

0000000000000000300000000000000000000000000000A9000000e00000 000000090000000 00000909000 00 000 00

*00009000900990000090000 009990009099000990009,,0000900000090909000000000090000090009009000 .00.0000000.000000000000000000000000000000090000000000000099090090099999000099009999e009999e90

00000000000099000909990009009000999009009090l ·I7 009100000000 000000 00090000000 0000000 000009000 00

2;

CC

22

2;

Z222IIt

2

I2

121 2I li 11111121112 121I 122 121 I 21111122l12 111122311211Z 2I. . I . I I 2121)1 1~22

,221 7 212 211 ,11,1212 211211211221l 21 I ,

2 00.2 I 011l 111 " II111 10"II1 101 11111 I2

'12 11 1172 12122 2 21 7211 11 ,

It Z 2 111 7212221f?!1ilfl!???22212; 1ll2??1

It1.1 213 1111212111l1 1111111I I11211l1111 2111 1

1333111332 12211 2 .1..........211.....1.. .il1l2211f222 Z?272? l22Z113121112211 21 21 211Z 3

211Z111131,I22 3I2 2Z2 2Z11 22?11, 21 2 2 2 Z 2ZI33 3

III1 31111111 1111111 1 1 Ill lll Ill ,~11111 I1 11l 1 ]0111 It t i ll tll It Ill ill l~l I~ ~ tilt I !

t till i l ti li iil l ti i l l)[l l

I IllIIIIII I l III Il Il I l Il IllIllll l l

133 3333 3333 '33 03 33313I) 3 12 2 13I 3.. .... 33Ill333333333313)33 3 I3333333 13333 31131111

03 3 1 1 33333333333333331 3333333333 . .3... 3I' l333111111311111133333 I 111113333331333ll31I.. .. . 3 13111111 IIIl33 33333333333333323

3IIII II~i . [ i ~II Illllll .. l l ~ . TI12.I1, I I I I I .I I I Ii I .I I I I II I II IJ . I .. I

717~?72 ~ ~ ~ 3333 33?3 2733?33333 31

333333333333) 3 $)333333333333 ) ~) ) )1 3

11,1112111121122,111 1-I 1111111? 21211712111

I11 111 AI ~ l 44A 44444 444A 4 444A4

O5 .I I A I I I I I I 4 . .A A 1 1 1 1 : 1 1 4 6 1 ,

3 2I 1 1 2A 1 1 1 2 2 2 6 316 jd4 yl1 3 210 D 2D2

I I4t444444 ))))44)) ))4.)l)4)) $)))))))441$31) ) ) ) ) ) ) ) ) )))))))))))7))))))7)44 44 444 444 50

7)) .) )) Z?22 ? S)222 2;f e12 22 2 2l1

7l111711?211111121111t ItIIIII 66&6666&66666(6

21I11 I000212172 Z00

112000 000

atl I 000O)Z1lOI 171

Is11o1 020III101 010

ISSOI~5 000

Z22112 "7

stsoo oln

127772! "I.ssss: I0o

bbssss Ill

415151 100so 0 non

ooson nonn040000 noo

111351 000

deW11 012

0895 011

11531 0*

csss eeI) 51 5

SIlell e1S

mama. ace

masse ISSSsasaS'aSS

05111 447

)]lid 6ll11lll 442

33OO034 .

000000007

'12333 )03 33 ZZlZS12l717 1 1 11 1 1 2 1 12 112l27 00000~0030

111? 211112211P27I 72.. . .21?D)?)ZI 2 12212 000000300

Il ........ l 2 1Z 2 1~ 21121212 21 122 2 21210 000000000

?122l7272Z22ll212 1 hf2212 m '22f I22tl111 00 000000?)7)Z)Z211112111112 2 222 221122t11tIll: 1 11t 0OOO0000

111?27?S??21112111112?)SZ212l~Sl11l21122 000000000

12 222 2? 2 ?22 2 22211l212I7 1?2 122 7222 1?1??2 0000000

1112 ?2 2211 11 1 2121111 211 2 l1 112?!Z0 03ISZ11012 1272 1?2 27)ZS?? 222 211122211 0000 Eoho

t i l l ~ ~ 1 11 11 1 III Il IllIIIIIIII I000 00000000000000oo

i1211212211 111t1211 211 2 21221211111 110 o000000000

1111l1111111111111111211111111I1.11111000 00000o000iiit1111 1 11 1 11 11111111111;11I11 aooo o

44444444444444*444444*4444444444444444414 4444400000

!? I1 1 TI t 111 l't 1 11 11'1 1221 .000000 o0o

r)ZI11t11 ~ ~ ~ ~ 11)t t l l l l l~ ~ l 1 .. .2tl 0 0 000 0

44444444444422222Z S 0 000000"O

4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 44l4l400 0 0 0 0 0 m 0 I

2 2 2222 22 44 4*4 III III I I44 444 4442 444 &0- - 0---

00444444444444444A4444444444 I444*4400a

44344444444444 101~~1111111II11 01. 1a 0003000000

l i l 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 i l I l l i t t ~ t It O lI 0 0 0 0 0 0 a0 0 0

l i t IZ ~ i ~ l l t l t I ~ t I I t l l llZ0 I 0 0 00A 0 00A A 0A 0 0I)))))))))) AA&&A~~~~~~~~A~kA&:'AA&AO

,&&A&AIA::AA& AAA 1A.AAAA AAA AA& AAAA. 1 1AAAA&1A&& IAA&AAIAC4

~& & AAA A A A A & & AAAA% .AA AA&A AAI A& kAAA&O O

A&A.A&IAAAA&&& AAA&&& AAA&A&AAA&A&AJAA&AAAAA AA&AAOO60

· AAAA&AAAAA&&AI &&A&AA&A A&&A.&A&~AO00A&AAAIA&' A &&A &J&. A AAAA &A1 &AAAA A&AA&A & & A A &A

AA :A&AAA A&A &A AAAA. A. A1 AA&A. .A& A& AIA&A&AA.A &AAA&000CC

1 : .AI& ::A&&A A ,A&A& A.AAAA & AJ & A &A A & AAdAA&&A& 00&A&&AAIA&&AA& A&&A A A 4 A AAAAA&A AA lAA & A AAOfO

.9 AAAAAA. . AA. .. AAAAA.A AA&A.A& AAA& A A.A&A A&l&&A i&00

9AAAAA&&AAA .A:AAAAA& & & AAIII %A&AAA&100.AA .A& A .AA AAA.A AA A. AAA II I1I11IO CDOOA A 000

~~~~~~~IIII I II I I II I I I II1 1I ~11 0000o0000000

IIIIIIIIIIIIIIII1~11111111111111 0~1 1 C 01 1 1111 1 1 11,1

Figure 3-18. CLASSIFICATION MAP BY THE STATISTICAL SEQUENTIAL TECHNIQUEWITH 14 CLASSES

3-25

NORTHROP SERVICES. INC. TR-1075

IS.

5.3

401

617

Ar t

411

430

6&1

*6?6&9

4?l443)

649

4~7

601

4014*3&9)401

693

70%

?he

?IS71)

711

?eS?q?

010

'6)

'33?3e

7?$

7''

'.0

795797

~DOlODO]p

X

2;;P I

L:-

2

2

2

Z

d

� 11:11I:

IIIIII

3

11

11

II

II

IA

c_.

12

22

2:

Page 49: UNSUPERVISED CLASSIFICATION OF REMOTE MULTISPECTRAL ... · i (f t , lt tr-220-1075 april 1972 unsupervised classification of remote multispectral sensing data 172-27204 ic.as c 237s9e

TR-1075NORTHROP SERVICES. INC.

0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 1 1 11 1 1$ 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 11 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 0 0 0 0 2 7 0 3 1 0

II,10103 303 e,00010001 1

0000000000000000003l

11113 3111101t l 110 tl l00003000000I0000000011

100030000r0000000 IIi

11O03030111031111 1111

3 0000 e0000 0 tooI100 100

30003037noon0o ooooo300

00o 00 3 0 3 0 0 70 0 0 70, 00 0 0I l

On0o00003000I110000000

coV0t coo0P ooat,01a0to

3 0 3 0 0 30000n ' ,t O o03 0 0 1 070003073OO003000030011

00ooo0oo70o0o0o00o01III001000070000000000003O

oo3o30070o7o730030o0300000o0ooo0300007300ooIl

9000300030000000000330000070031l090o00ooo003o

331333373 379333033313 "3I777 ll3337 ? 3 373793337337777737373393~7

30333573737771777777773. 083337 17? 93e 3 BS 9 7737 30 ,

03333 37?73033A3077777 3~333033673399933077333333

3S)))I~SS)~3)

33303179317717170993)

33313333753553373777))

3953356S575733177715 35

6939760773951373733733S

5777397777773?777957753

)1)17)7333161333?137)3)

3795773 7766773777 77 7153

777777011733903973377,

111111111 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1

IlIIlIIII lII~llIII1311J 111111111111111111111111111111111111

IIII~lll l~lilll~ l Illll 11lllll 1

Jl l i l ll l l l 1111J11ll1

1 1 1 1 1 1 1 I4 1t 1 1lllllll 1 1 1l 1 1 1llllI

3333373I'13 11111 13 3 3 3I 33IIIIIIIIIIl 5l

3 '131111111111111111113111111111111

3 33 33)3133 333 3) 3 33 1333 11133 I

031 1114311133 11 111111111111111 I1

IIIII .... 1111111 I-1333313111 I 1131

33111111S3 1333 3 33 1 133 3 3

1 1 1 1 1 1 1113 11333133133311113 31

73330333303333333333 33 333333733 33

O I IIIIII" III" l IIIIIII3 111 ilIII I I

* 333337333333333033393393333 33:

IIIII111111..111111131111111113

I-IIIII3IIII1-ll ............. l 3(

III I Allll l l l l l l l l l

71333333333333 3 301133 33 133 31313 3 1

0333333333337333333333333333333 33

)33333333333373033333333333333933

7 3 31 9 5 5 3 3 3 3 3 3 333) ) ) 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 33333333333339333433330)33333333 3)))q 3)333333333))))) 3)) 3) 373333333033)]30333333))3)3)37333

333333333033333333333333)3337333)

703))3333033333373303333)1 301311I

1)313097303333330933133033343934101 3 3 1 0 3 3 3 17 3 3 3 3 3 7 3 3 3 3 3 0 3 6 3 3 3 3

110733173))33133 07 3333J333 33 9 33

1 0 , 1 7 0 7l 7J) 7) 1 3 3 1 3 7I l3a13 3 3 3 3 3 9 3 3 9 9 3 3 7 9 3 3 3 3 3 3 0 5 3 3 3

0000030170f 0 3 3 3 39 3 3 3 3 3 3 0 7 3 7 09 3 3 0 3 3 39 3 g93 9 9 3 9 39 1 19 1 0 1 1 1

7 7 7 7¢ 3 7 .7 l 09 3 33¥ 3 3 3 3 0, ~ 9 9 9 9 3 3 3 3 3 39 39 3 39 3 3 39 333333309 ,

001100¢ ¢ ~ N1 390 3003333 7 0 3 3 3 3 9 90 9 7 39 3 3 3 3 3 7 3~ 9 39 9 9 * 3 399 9

700 1( 070c 91 3 39339 9 193 393 3993.. .0399 39 3099 3993..

V0710 117 ' I e s ~ 9 '' '' '' ' - 3 3 99 37 3 9 9 9 9 93 49 (1

(( c ¢I ~I ~ .I' )00 0 3 0 3 3 3 7 7 3 3 3".3 339 39 3 9 33?A Ig eI9 I + I I9 3I39I'IIl

011II01109

0 0 0 0 0 n o V9

eo5 ooo99

'000073933VOnlnQA$3

noon..n

Inooono0711009009

003337397~~g9333093097073330 33333399390311A~k

3379973739 333,0379 7 03033333303339 0339 313A~4

'33330073090339933707333931933303337979397901~g(90933933399303337343399333309399333399933333

(333933033339793393 ?9.93 993 99933 393990339399IA'39703339 7'9~97 303333731303993333339 33933999q'3333393333030393933393333 903999~93993333339919 '393.39333333333333333039 333999999333993933399(~99309333339933393333933991939333973333930309019

'~9330309399393393333~9333933333333993333099 1S

13993333339333993393399333399339339399993999y9 90~9933933333933933339999995999993393333793391111

93I33339339 333 3 3 3 3 3 3 333 333 9993 33 999993 3 3 33

,if"I11"I11

.1111I I

J

t

I

0111 i 11 11111o: It 1 11 111111 1111 ll "Il III111115 1111 1 1 511111 1000

01llllllllll0 lll11 1 lllll 11111111101111 Illl- lIlllIllllIllllIlIl I 11 11111 00001000I1001111111 10111.111011110011111111 1 1 11 0i01111111101111111111NVII1 0IIII1 olI 10110011 1c~~111

OI~lI~lI11111 UII IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIII 111 110

I 011111111111111111111111111111111111110 11 III1111111111 1111 1111111 10111 1111 11111 1 0I 11 11 0I

I IIIIIIIIIIIII111111111111111 1111111 11111111010

I IIII1111111111111111111111 1110100011111I IIIIIIIII11I1111 1001

IIIII111 I-II1110111111111111111111111111111 1110 000

lIIIlIIIII IIIIIIlIlIlII11111i11I11111I11111 II III

III11 111111 1 I I IIII rrrltii¶p I I111111101 0 0 000l100

11 II 1I 1111111 I l111=I I 111111111111 0 00

II 111111111 1 11 IIIII1I11111111111 0I ~lI 11 111111111111111111111111111111111113 IS00

II IIIIll~lllll I 3llllllllll11311 1110 00

3 I-lll l333333 =3l33333333333333333 31! 1 lI13 I33333i33333333333 333333333�13333333333313 33133 II3 3 3 333333 333 3311il1 1

3 3311 )]$ 31)333 333333333333333]133 333 3333 3 11100003 .333333 33333333333333333333333333333 0 0S S3S3 3333333333333533333353333333333333333331111111 a00

3 ...... 3333 333333333333]33333333333 3 3133333~3333333333333 333333333333333333331 33 3333333333333333333333333333333333333333 83338 3

3 333333333333333233333]333 33333353333333 300000 O

3 33333333 1333333 3333333333333333333311333 11111 177

33333333333333333333333333 I 1 I

33 I3 I33 I3I3O333333 33 3 3333333333 1161S131 I

I 11111111111111111111 11005 000

3 11111111111 "111+144 IT]44 444440444414 008'3

3 111111111111111 114404404444044&&664&&444 0040011111111l11t1l11I1l 44400444444400444444444& 0196 313tI 111111111111111 1404444444444444444444404 0800 0I;3111111111111oJ.I..I.I.1141 1.1 I 4444 1 o o"II 1 ?1 I

Il11 1 11 11 lll~O~l 00 0

3111.J JT~~IllIIIII1111111100404444440 08 i

3I33111111111111l~JllllllJllll ~OSSoOOO44

.3.4.44444.4.. 4044444............ 44 0R3 004444444404l4444~4444470970

D 1D11: 00700,133

II Ill1111l Jl II IlJIIO to O0 O0I

O0 10110 011

IIII111111I 1 1111111"T' I 11111111111 1 1 0711111aoon~

I I11111111111111111111111111111111111111 1 OJ0000303

* 113331333111111111111111111111111111111 00000000

I 111111111 I11111111 I110i1111yIII 1111111 10 }0000000

I11111111111111111111111111111111111111110 000 00000

C Illill~l~ll II 111111117 07000100n"11111111111 11 It l''11111111 1 ' ..000 00330

I1IIII"~ I I I lll I I I I Ill lI l II II 1 I I I I lI II I01,00000

lljllj11111tljlj 1 1Jj111J11! (11111i1 005000000

I'11~11111111 JII 11111111 I illIllil11111110 I(100 0o

nooOooheo

Jl11111 111III1I1i1iiii1...111111iI... IIIn 00000000II1111111111111~1111 1111 111111111100010007 000

(111111l! 1111 1 1l, 1111I I111I11111,11111 (ll 3II II 00o70nnn11111111111111111111111110llll0l000llll0lll7lll0oooo

I~lllII 111111111111111111211111111111111111~00000004 1 1 1 1i~~llillll~lJ~ll 00000000

,IIllIIlIIIlIIlII alIlliIII llIIIII~IlllIII 0000700000I IIIJ11111 1111111111111llll. 111"111 11110 0700 0000O"11111111111 1111A 11111 1111111113111111 10l00000077

A AA&AAA AAAAAAA&&AAAAAAA&A&AA ~&&O313333 3'A&&A'AA0~ioAo&AA&AlA&i&iT&&OAOOO3 3014040070400A4000000404000000&Ai&OAAAl&AAA&&AAA00 004004000

0 A7040&407A000404A&A00 00 AOOOAO&&&AJ 0000440

AA&AAAAAAAAAAA&A&AAAAAAAA&AAAA&AA&AAAA AAAA& AA&AAACnCJAAII& lA1&I1k&AIAA &J& A:A~IA I&&

&AA&&&AA&AAAAAAA.1A&IAAAAA- &A&I iA d:AAA eAA'&&&00AA AA& A 0A0A AA&A4A0 AA0 AA00 &AA&AAAA A40400000

0A0A&AA&A& 0AAA 40&3AAAA43AAAA0000 0AAA&0001

A.A.AAA& ...AA .A AA. A& A A&A& IIIIIII:A- Al..AOonV

i:i:l111A1111:1A111111~tl AA$1 AAl AAAA$1515 A'::1A5Ono113010 00000 110on

0u 44440440440000000040440.0. 40 o" 000000040400*000 4..........0......

:A44304400000000000oao40440

004740040044004040000000000,000004004004*40404 04400

40000090001401111O0000

4004084911111110000000

I::::::::::::::::A:::00::::::::o....

Figure 3-19. CLASSIFICATION MAP BY THE STATISTICAL SEQUENTIAL TECHNIQUEWITH 12 CLASSES

3-26

53338m9

S131

399

53I

031

407

433

411

413

013

017

411

403

473

~77

439

437

433

401433

031

093433

433

433

641

;,91

433

17;

6111''3

0j 0

&7(

107

?Il

761

377

Vo)

3771

177??70

7e71

'33

741

911

--------- -- -- I- 3A

L.If- - - - - . - - -........................I I I I I I I I I I I I I . 2 , I I , �2-7'� 7-. , -- -7W -- , .I

�J

I

iI

]L

I ;3

C ,A

A A

9

9

N

AAA

Page 50: UNSUPERVISED CLASSIFICATION OF REMOTE MULTISPECTRAL ... · i (f t , lt tr-220-1075 april 1972 unsupervised classification of remote multispectral sensing data 172-27204 ic.as c 237s9e

TR-1075NORTHROP SERVICES. INC.

(.2966 3I I U 4II6 7 1 33 L4.t7L1 I 735

L 4 A L I I 7 U I UL ,

.uaouou~uuuuu~uuuoooauu~.ououuuu.u~Ou~uooou nuao IUU"U U I I zI *I Il I I I IA dil~Z ilizi~

Io0gIu I � IQ.0III I I ,400-4444400 11 IUI4YI I :I I 34U4U43 3 I I333 3 1 1131111II" I 113/q11 11 11,33l I 133/4I4tIUIU4UUU 4 I I I 1 4 I4044gi,111144 je44 319$JbreAL S lJ iJ

7

UUI7913331314443333397¥ 3b19 A 77 777t99SS7b UU043J l 31

d)2I(~L U UUUOU - O,))C. U 0LC "U OUO£UlLtLL LLL- .... 1qG 1b~b47li4UU4OUooU44(404Lin0 044tti~t t~b~ttL t7UA4qq4*7 3t6q3Uu43

44UC4OO4 OCU0L LUCC4O4UU3"U34 et t. /L03 .'E Lk -" 470A77 0£UUE %4

47 4 ((iUU0CLL(.OU4UOt'U'O.tt 1 A0LA7At4 tL[U

4A444UOO44(LUUOLOU40 at OL .L .I... . .. L t, L q3

0l0CUO 4OO 4LtU-ttL LOI4 ::U40 Ott IL U, (44 t A t77 0L 00 O77397444444440ii4434 (

44O04U( 0 3,7.A 7A 773[7t7 [Aq494q44q4qq~[ bt Lq

4343440 [UU OOLJ,4343.4OLL( U~iiit tOLLtAAA77A t L tt10 A i.L t.t

tltLU.tO UU.-I.o{LU l U UUUtIL ti t ?faq 4

'tLLL(UL~JdN~'Jl 0lii q074q7q044 .A3~ tA LAt 3AAt AA33A

C ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ I U11 I IIIU.~Udt~lU~~ IIttl~'a~~tt tL I U ~/L~I I U I I 0 U 1 t U u tU dl lll U Ull~I~q44tLc l *(~nU~

C~ ~ ~ ~~~ ~~~: (:1 Od lU~tglo dwl Lt i I ~ { ~ l II q 1 11 a 1b L, gtmUUl t atJI l II

I I ( U U oUuu I U d lU,.1 I. L L U . L Uq L L . . U . .]/ . U U]' L ~l~

773 COlC~JO~f~l, 77UUA377 3370Li0 4 L0 4,77773 U7 EUU.A9 9 7704 UOLU04U

A 9 U I uuAu Au 7 , ',,AA u3 tloA uu (7U L, 0 L 7 t L t I7U7II UnII 9uL U4n

IC C U Ut OU I II 11 gU IO UlU,.,,ll I-t ,t t l- L L I I UuUI LIOO U dlOU AI

I f C 1 U II ( IIIU II I C 1 I~ U 0 : I IuO IO Lb I , LGD U (*b& UUII1 IIII1 L~II1

U774,0 I4 I I I7L7IA IU IAAAA777 I 43AA0

l...333...4..A~i0l40 7 4 9 9 9 37 7 77 7 A33AA37770 7.A4.A.Au.AOut7(UAL373 97707hA4U U LA 3.7U O

7,73 L70 L L 330 U333AA3 3.377U7ULI7A777UAL .7I A7LA, .AU .0U3 L UI IIIU

7C.i4333330d333Li3JUi, 77U77A777707A(UU

(O4U 7 79U7AAAA77.AA Ut 47. AI7AA3

u nu bOtt

UnUUUOU~u

I.nUO ,U UO.

UI.UU UOUU.

U.ILUUUU.UI

uUU U01UU

(nOuU-gtCfUUOI)U-

uoou~o~uuouuoouu

nU~u UOUU

U~uuouaou

¢cIO~ououucOOujuuu

UoOOhOO..InOuUOO.U

.OOOOOOua

,0003004i,

04OOUOOO

o0o0oo004

,oOOUOOO

4I ii(0 O3,0

¢rUOUUO40U-OU3O4A7

004034304

000(0oii 00404034404

IllLCtUu

¢(34400000434440404

374363A7777.777777.77737707 .....477 .7.7977

A7677777907777 ......... 7770OS977977O77......

* 347A777707A7777777........... 7440477

* ~~ 0444777...........

.... 6.A77......... 77777707 "O777UD--7"

I's6777.77677~~7774477777797

.6646 A7777770773777777 .......... 444...7.7A

077 - ... 9 ~7 7 7 9 7 . 9 A7'797.777977

3..6 A9 A.7 O 7 7 0 7 7 A77 7 A3 ............... 777907

bul

D.

.5-U

30

173777

37

3'

3'

L I)9

u -

o~Ie

5a

0 9

. I

.oI

U.r

GO

At.L

I,!93

I

31.

Ii

01

(I

Li9

71

03

A 9

79

aSI

LI,

,00QU4OUO0O44E3UI376737L394t00L 4UUOUL0 1 7777773

AUU-EU.UUUIULEtUt tlt lt ULE£ULUtOULUtOUOOU 717717

tUi, tLt.t0 ttUUtUtOIUttUt UU4 gtUUOUUUUUt UOLL 7l77A~UU0 LIOI OO, UOuG;71ttUuOUUOOOUf UOUttLU 777777

it LIoI iOULILUA - "Uo Ot ttUUttOUt uLtOUUtOtt 1117777

,tt,UttLt L It~Att7ttUtU t tUUt4737

iUUU~UUU&?_u ULUIU i IUU UUU UUGU UUOUU I1? 11

-UUI UO Utt UlAUI l tUt tUUUUUtIt UUUUOU U 777,377'Ou~)O0UUUUULU0UUUb~.uOOUO00UU0UUU[L££&bU 11111

OU -',UuUU uOO*U'IkI'UII.UUOUUUOlUkLUO.b I 7171111jtLtt.ILLO ttEbi711 aIOOLUU~OUUUVIUOUk 7111111

AO.tut.tt UUtL~tA-t~tU.tU UUtUttUOOU4U 3377u. 7la~~~~~t~~~uttuuouuL'L111 L ti" I'll

LUU~L~LLU"LL'L EL(LLL . .....

II LL LLLL-tLtLLLLL L LU t£LLLLLLL[LiI111

tt Ittut LtdJt LL LLL7111

UlqILLLUCLLklt f 'Et£LL 1 L107744LI,777A0677LL7777 LL7 7 7I 17

,U E AOLLI3iL33 A"I'll ULAALL AA7LLU 77171j~LILL~L)LL1tLI~LLLLLLEL££L ELLLLL LLLE UU r17... LULILLLLLLLLLL £L_ L£LLLCIILU UU. UO 1 11

ILuttLILtttLLULL tLL£L£LU£ULLuELLUUULUO 11'1

,~ ltkLLLLLUtL£LLLLL.~.LZ . . 7

A7

AA7

.3

47A7A7

7777933A 7777M774.H4477M77777M~mM 17737

3 7 7 A7 AA 7. 7777 7..7... 7. ....................7 7... C1717

U U777 ,t07'-33 7 '777 .A777O .fI7 A , 77A .7I7"I, U I, 7 37373

A97.A7777A7777A77f7A7A77... 777- 777 777

AAA7 A3A7A74...AAAA77'7AA777999799777A794 737

A747 7 7 7 777797777A~0~777A977797UO7 I'7777

0U..U...A77....9 .- 99................4(t 1

.. m~rtm U...m. .M....N.... .......

A 737,377 77770777 34 O77477397U U O O U UUUUU- O UU4

UOUL~&LUUUOUUUUUUUOUU.UUUUUOoU~U4 O0u0UUL4044UOO4u03UOUU0UUUUUU.LLU404U

uUUbU"uU.UOLLUGUU`UUfOUO"U"U"U~OLUULUO'd"4U44 LU9LLLLIL0... U£UO0UU4ouoo4U44UUUO40ou

Ub4-UG.U£L££LLL£UUkLEUUOUUUUO~UUU-U~UOUU-[JOU .. 4..L4L [ILL L £O11 .... L22020 22ULOU4

(.OUt.0ItLLLtot 4 Lt&L 4TUUoUUUuoU4 uu4,

UUUOOU"UELLE I L££OOUUUOUUO&UUL.O&UU

UOUnUOuLLL£L[LLL£££['"O 2.2£LLO£OUUUUUOE0O£

(UUU 9U tLL£Et L&LWLtUtOUtLUUUt UU£4 4L4 UL4.4U

uOUULUkLLLLLL£LL£O[OdOUL£OLLL0UUZULLU£LLL/UOULE£LLELLE££LL atZL~OULUatLLELLIZIZ&ZLL

UOUOLU9LL2LL~Z2~z~22~Z2L2zlUL£O~

.O2uuLtttLtLOLt 4t~t404t4-tt04LtUL4UOLUU I4 4 4 4 ( 4 4 ( 4 I t 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 1 4 4 4 0 ( 0 3 L L ~ b -

I- .1ull.UU~1. -.. LOL u ..&~b~v~bbb~b~U~bU~k& II IeU UU6t ccLCCZZZ2

&&~bG~GUU~~~kkb~kUGUG~Gbb~~bO~k~~bUUOO 'IL LUUCC L2a

..- aa -b 'I'Ik1-1akbGI, 1. b1. b-1 UAAUd au- LU~LL~

A~a~k~b~b~G~a~aG. -lb-a 11lII~aOllU`IaL lLLLLLCLLt

II-1b1ba 4,11a.a& 1 ..... - -~UubkUOUUU cLL¢c C¢J*~kak -OlalGUUU-kUUDUULElC.OUULl L~c~C

a~~~~~~q ~ ~ ~ tULqU LLLLULLCd

UOLO UULCLLLCIC

.11-11 uluu L I, IL U 01 UU, CU CLL£

1-IIIIIIII4,1-1 .. "L" I EIUUUUOUU LUCOLCCLL

CLLCLCCCL

C-CL(CCIL-C C CC~~L¢Cc¢¢ ~

C O (LCCCCC

LCILLC(ILCLLL IUC0LL(CCLL

II IL . CLCLLCCCCLLIC CCL LLCCLCCCC ..CCC C£¢C£

"Ill" I'l,'ILL----C-CCC--C 1 ML C:ccL

C((C(L(DUI COCCcCccLc

-- ccLLICCC WQU,~ , ¢UIUI'llCC

a IuLlcclc~c

7737;77l7777777II7;7

II11 11

I1171

1~1111

11111

171111

77/777

77777

777777747

77377,77777I

77777L77777 CC

Figure3-209 CSFAO ABT GNK T

Figure 3-20. CLASSIFICATION MAP BY THE GENERALIZED K-MEANS TECHNIQUEWITH 18 CLASSES AND NO ITERATION

3-27

Uoa

LOU444

Ut LU

4

U.,

444

3UU"U'

444444

444

444

44U

244

444

4(4

444

444

444

ULU

(44

444

'44444

Ill

444

444444444

4ol

u04

tLLi

(Li4

I( di

CCZ ~a

cc~

e39

O 69

943

9.13

6 94

94¥

937

Al I

933

A 36

Al'

Ai 7

Ju.$3,U

346

IUtI,t,

ILI

r's

713316337 1

3 III

I346

343 1

737

3.6

343r63

r~.7

151

1.lb

7611.6

I.,

i70

333

91eAA3

3963el

397

373

r.

Lr

1� ..........IJI:DI-IUU-0.61 . . .5---- . . . . . .. . . . .I, - . . � . 9;Z.- � . . . . . . .

m

I IT;

Udu

II

II

-3

L

I)

TT1:11.I

.1

11I-

1,11

L

.1ILL

.I

,IU

II

I

I

UI

UI

UUUa

�1-

.m-

Page 51: UNSUPERVISED CLASSIFICATION OF REMOTE MULTISPECTRAL ... · i (f t , lt tr-220-1075 april 1972 unsupervised classification of remote multispectral sensing data 172-27204 ic.as c 237s9e

TR-1075NORTHROP SERVICES. INC.

76'. O' C11*600 . to 7*1. U,7 J171777307 *

11*10 I 2 0 I * .I 7 001122116.11,0'IL .1 11 I20 0* a B p I t 6 7

200*(0001000000020012000o00227600 11111 1111111((1111111''111111112222222

o~~~~o~~~~g~ J I -~J~J qq ~ll tJg tO~ I LJlJJqqqJJlll I I ~ ~ llJJ JOU I J U 0. 773 U70 I I I II ,llJ200 I I 0777000. 171777 770077772u21 Illl2

1760107' 071370307'36737'10,70671071770367307137706on671377207'0673 I7I 07II 77

2722 U((11(111(1CCLOUU122 C~ulCCCII(((C(((fu

27221(0oC¢~o(I1CC¢o0ou00

2 2 O2 C(-1OC CCCC(uO00I"2 22100(CUL(O0((0000

2721o¢CC0C11¢¢CC0C0rO2,20ocu00o¢lcllC¢¢0unO

2j22202oC(1C oCICCCoC102OC(.CC-ccuUUOUco1u

27211111(10" .....C (70

127221CCU((0(1J,(OCC(00

2721tc((OC¢¢CC UOc0OOU0272(211 1(111"0C(((

212aC~0C¢C(u.. uccco00ozIIcICC~ccccLcLOUCcncc.l

"U n~u U~C OOUCCo,

Z2C2¢112 CLCOCLC0U,,OOI72C20C(u1((60(1(U(00600

IrLCUOcJcc-L¢~ccuOm u(:

27CCULCUU1CL-b100c60011U0

270(((1((((6o011aJa0a00

;C 1U C (CuL CLu 0 ( C0 00 U:0127C(1(11((..( 11-0U1 ,oC

2711(1 (u(1u(10 u((1C

In 1(111~ .11.1... CLo01

enz~~~~U110~1uuu~

I(CII1(60I Lu(111CI.-0L

777010110010011100*133707

I 111~7ZIIO ODOO

SOI1111110110ulloo oOOue

:7o-600uIgu2*o3uuaO3u,

11 110UO~) a J;IOU,~ l

!777 0070 13~ 1 1D0 U0

7771((.....Uiu,0IUI 32 133

7771 171? 77111 .:OI(00U1

0(11110 ( b '77)UA171(0.$

P,1IC771709L'007o1DD2o07

77 ,711(11 7707000 1ut0

,717oo7777o77 .. 0,0CuoD

(nUuu.-~.,...-. --~..

UUuuuu-ouoUu.UuouO

0 (( 0 U0 0 0.

U11U00000

clcUUUOO.(O10Uuuo0

nU(UuOru.

C,,uuuL0,uu

znOUuO.-I

ZcOUaUIOu

CD(ou0oou

)oIIOUO

o 0 100U0I

¢~00uouoo

1(0 (6 (O~ o

2(0000(1...

un1(1(OOOU

6O0OUO1u060006UO061(70061(0o0

20U0060u00

20C000000~

,00600D..2, Cco0 000

21CCC¢CCO

271 (CCO1021C(11C00

I0 6 CE E 1

L 7 7 1- I C C 7 7 7 7 7 o 7 7 .o 1 1 6 1 '.'

1 0 ( E( 1 1117 7 ( L 7 1 6 10. 7 7 '. '.'. 7 I E0 ( 6 ( 0 7 I

I 0LC CC7 :III I C C u 7L '.,E'E ' 1 . EIlloI,,

E~LULtLLL~ LLLN q G G~

~G~b~q4qqq ~q~qqL Lqq Iq

[vqLGL~bq4EL~[EEqLLNL~. q4[uq£G[#~1E

££EL4444E4444EU4£4LUEF~£EbU4444L4

Cn4 4qL 4_ 4t £L 'EO UOLOU " L CO £IU EU OO(~[

*o (LC 1,7ULLE7 LU'. £ 000E - LO(u7 7 uuO77 ( 0

I 1t[C LLL6 LuOOO7 7 Un70 OLDoI U7( 7 O77 I77( L1 ('44[ 0LLLUuOOO UU(.(7 7 1cOOU7n s510

i7 "" 167..7. 71"C. * O.10(¢C C 'C.. . c7

C '. 7 ( 1 t * ( 6 7 1. 4 C *-- q q I O jj . . 7C. (O. '.w '. 7

1 1 L 7'. o . 7 7 7 7 7 7' 7 7'. 7 7 0'.. l , M CE "1 , N ,7 l 0

0 1 1 C 1 7 '.M 7 7 7 7M M 7 C 7 E . 7 L 1. 6 ( C 1 '' . 0M 6

fl(.(( ~''.'.~' E1(11E77C*C7770C U

707M 070717,00777,7717o7070000700 0

H*""......"""""" *000." (0007*..oooooooo*2%o71*o71 1mm#37,77710#

7 77

7*

7 7 1 7 777

7, 7 77,'W7,71'*7177o

70U0**71

0777*0000000777,07,000*0070717,600007,077,07,7,7,,77177177,700771760101¢O6

071007M070* *00A70 ,7m,0770 7070

70

10 0

7707*7,7,00067,07,777,70*7,7,7100*76[*

0 0 0 7 7M M M 0 * 0 7,M 7 7M M 0 7 0 M * 0 0 6 0 7 1 6 6 7 C

7 7 , 7 7 ( 1 7 7 7 7 0 0 7 7 1 7 7 M .0M 6 170~ A A A ~ 00 * 7 100771o77777117077,7,7100*7077C1706771

O0

Uo

C 6

A~

HMM7* MMMMMM7717707171*7,0 00 MU 0M I

01 0707107710707771071717o770771777177j7

-55.....5.M............eb "Ne~.M

.~-S.... .5......... 5ve 5eess ,

,~5..5...... ...... M..... SSbS ..... ...

06S. ......"......"55" 5S ".""."

,555."......"."M$~A"S SS SeSS51 ~5- S","""

.~55..... .........5bSA 55"S~555 5sOS........

.555."""."...".""". ..55A~ SS"HS. ....S....'

.55~--..-..".-~.- .~5~5S.M" ...........

.SSSM.MNMNSMM.M....,'.~...~...... "N. "77 607 7 * 1 ....... 07.. 7 6.m.. .S 6 b.171S717 .7 7....,

)556M.MM..MMMMMMM.M S1- ..M..............~~515~ .. M. ....... ......M55~~5MMMM H

~59S...I~........finm.H.mbbm b.".....

~55SS ......... 55 ...... 5........H~MMN~I*S707771*071*7077077177, 677067,717077077

'6 6 0 6 0 7 1 7 .0 7 1 7 1 0 0 0 0 7 1 7 7 0 7 0 0 1 -7 7 7 7 . .6 - 1 6 6 0 . . . . . .'.660I7.. 0*......77 77 - -107 - ..7.71 .7*7 .677.10

'.6066070 .......7 ...... ...........766771001

.6006 Oooooo*6',0077*0710710717 677170'60677,006o0~66067*M6 *o71077100o070077* 0077000..67o'.6071*7,7,706067171o071 7 N0000077*0717171707M6766676*6666700700

7670600700000*00077,717006076066060*6671071770710o7,776077,M10M0*00007o00707,67607606616666 6717,**'.0

71 607'0071007700 0717*07000771070*77 66010 0 6066 6 60o7

B

ElHI

C'

77

7,

A,

I85

e91r

7'

01

0'

0'

0I

eB'

I?

I'

I'

?

e

IFU OUUUUUUUUOOLUbUUVUUUOOOUUOOkLL&OUOUU~UUOLIe 051U1EUEUUU66 U EL6 0 u7 U7 7 6u7UU. 6UU1 6UU6 1OUU I

66 0 6UL CEUUUOU6U0 UUUOUU7 6U67LO6 U UUQUU0 ( UU6 LL* u 6U0 1U6 OU6000067 uu06 lO.t[E.7U6 C U( 00U6U 00 U. 06

6Q U06070uuu06076uu0 U 6I6 UU1LU6UUUQL6UU£ 06I

U 60U0U0UUUU0000060 6 6IU 2U0 UUUUOOU00 U01U9Ull0U0U0UUUOUOO00bU0Ub OwOUUGUL.U00UUUOL~IU6 ~01 0 0U U00UUE 6 U0 0 11.0U6 UU0 00 1UL 0006U0 ( 103uU0 0U0 _U1 O D001LE0 7EO 7"O77 00U161(01(U6 ( 06 000 6U0

OU O 0CoO u(0630£CeLEu 31011011 117 U

~ jg EuLE ELULU LE E E LLLLLLLLL-LULELL

1-k.. 4NLI4qLLOLLLE b A£LL)LLL tjL'LLLLLELLL0 7 E LI-1O [LE. L ELL£ t C ELCL 1 LE E1I

71 LILLC oj'.LE1E qkIE It 11 It I I ELU1 OUUUOZUO I EL U LILL£ £L L££LLLLEL£L

ELLIhd£~LLLE[E- EL~ [ _E£ELLLL LEE.

7 LLLE LO 1 E EL£ £ E L1 L17 7L[L LLE£ L [LL( 1 1L 0UL

7 70111(111 (LL 6L£ L1101E(( 6 CLLLLLLLC LLUL6U0LOO U7 ILLLLLE LL0C[I LE LoL LLLL£ 0UULuOE

a L(7 070* 7* 77U, 7L L7LL£[LLLLU 7[LUU ,UU

9m ~m MmU 0.MM........N...H.......M.M..N

U ].../A&&&A& .....m. .Hmm.". "...

:0 01E11UU61C(UC(t1(60111.2.026622u22.22E0061U

1 u 0 6 ,. 0 1 1 ( 1 1 1 T1*EL E L I tU L * . 6U 2I fl 2 .6 0 6 6 ( .7 1 ( 1 0,II

7 6I U6 0 0 E 1 E E E (E 1CE 1 1 1 0 2 2 1 6 0EUU EL E 0 M1(1 6aEM

7I E 0 6 * 6 11 1 1 (C 1 1 1 6 ( 1 0 6 0 6 2 1 0 0 6 6 0 21 E 1 0 6 6 E 6 1

uQ L O (1 1 1 1 1L E EA ( M M20 2 2 1 0 , O o1U 2 2 ( 6 1 ( 1 1 0

oI aM ".....U U'L JUL ,LUHOUUU.mU..... .C ¢...

7 00100 OELL EEE 1N1A ELLL2 old 2222022626 112 U222

D* U~OUOUI 4LE J[LUbULLUUo JLUOUUuOULLOu UOUUL

Io.OL o~ qqLLE£ LLLUUIELtOIULULLEUOUUU ILUULLUU

3 O0O ULLL( LE0 2 E££[L2222 £221 222(U 22 gZZ62670 OUUU211a. 2( .. E L[2 I U21(L062O6 UA' *o o 0 L666 £££6 E L. LL 6 1*66*1166U 6600uu 6UUU0 11~

7, **61*1661£6611£0716£1606'L61UU66061L00UEUL

9PUU0LLLLL££Z2 LULIL£EUU LULL LLU

lqAA0G ~,G~I L~ .. £L.LL £L LUL

7A 1 66 111 16 I *7 16 6666 6 6 l " " 'EL6(17 I A ,6 I6 6 6 1 1 LiUb B a 1 6 66 6 6 6 1 1 6 6 6 6 6 6 ( L L

* 7 7 * 6 616 6 11b6 1 * * 1 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 b G 1 6 6 6 V'~ b61£L6 L

O - 1 1 ' 7 7 7 '' 7 7 7 1 1 ( 6 1 1 1 0 06"E "

* 1 6 7 6 7 6 61 6 1 1 6 1 1 1 1 6 6 6 0 6 0 1 ( 7 6 0 0 E

71~1 o7 I I 0 ' 0E 00 11 0 06 00 E I 0 116111 0 ICEL* _ I I7*1 ..6 661II .. U 13 77 1066 1(UUU UUO U U1(1((CI

OF677677017 1607U. 0 I7.~Ofl 1C77(11160060710

((I

10 1C ((( 1 CC C(((CCI C (( (CCC ((L (CICC4

7*70(0....(I("(CC(LILL(77(ICCC( ((C(CIICL(C(

77(*100007717T IIICCIC

00* ,00 ,0 777(( (C (( CC (((CCt C ((" (" C CC0-*,070071770 ((7C(71LOCCC3JCL(C(C((

1 6 7 0 - 7 (U 7 7 1 0 1 - -EOL7,77 60 7 7 7 7 E 11 0 (1 ((1 L )OL L l o (. *777777 7EJO~~l( (7 7 6 6

IBF611111-EILE GL£LL L ULL~££

III77UI U2';111;111UU04

777777 222J

'7717777,222

71717771222

7777761 6UC1777777166

7 7 1111U

77777 022

;11;111 lid

7I 77L U IIC

1777777 222

777777 222

777777

(CIC (( C

(CcC((((2I

I(C(Cag((I(

ICC((((22(

(1li4CCC(

1111IC 2CC

((11((1C Cz

I. II.7 Iz

I1111 III"

L(((((CIll

C L(C L CC C

C"11111C ((

11 1D IJLI Ell "IZ

r11;111 2dpl1111 2~lC

1111 ~4l

11111~c111;1 LCCCt71171 IEC17177rzzzI

IL1L1 ILZZ

LLLIL.CCIE

LC(CCgCICCDCLC(2ZZ22

JLIC(LgCZ22

CCICCLCCZL

:(¢I(III2Z

ILCLL(Cd~

Figure 3-21. CLASSIFICATION MAP BY THE GENERALIZED K-MEANS TECHNIQUEWITH 18 CLASSES AFTER ONE ITERATION

3-28

6,3

607

*32

O7(1

027

733

oz0

*1e

*63

*67

*76

?7*

*71

773

673

140

141

751(

1(13'161715e

121

lel126

0308,UIa,0,I,

II0.

I:

II:D

I:

.1

"I

I-1

Li

I �

:z

T:11:11111

11LI

E

C

IIIIII

� 11I

I

LI

II

L�

I

I

III

II

Page 52: UNSUPERVISED CLASSIFICATION OF REMOTE MULTISPECTRAL ... · i (f t , lt tr-220-1075 april 1972 unsupervised classification of remote multispectral sensing data 172-27204 ic.as c 237s9e

TR-1075NORTHROP SERVICES. INC.

90. oF ITImA'T1096 * 2

CLASS I 2 I A 7 I ' oll 1 2 11q I ·1A1C¢1A9ACTLX I 2 I 9 6 37 a 9 0 I a I. II I F 6 4.

sI ,4 I L A B L I L I $A~pLI 601991A

u 6776u 930 3 37396 397U376U9u16 37 61UD 36U79U13u679126791 3iii3$7il ] 67j 36

i~le~~le~7i)......e ~7Sss 7~ ........ b ~)S )~9sea. 19 .. , . I i t e ~1I b~-bOUS~ ~ ~jSeAb

CCIICC¢CCCCCCCCCIoCC c CCCc ~¢cc¢¢CC c 0CCCCnu CC C 7C¢¢CLO(C¢¢CL.C OCCCCCC¢

C(CCCOCOCCOI(CECCCCOO.O0

cccaucCCoO C C o00 0(00oucICccC.c o 3 o0o0o

CCCCC COCCCLCCC00200370CC Cu0cC1 0CCC1C00UOC200

CrO0 C (OCC LCCC 0UO CU

CCC O010C0CCCCCCCCCCC2,cCCOCCC UCCCCCCCCC70CIOCO 0 00 0 0CC .000CCII 0

(0c10I(0CC 7 JO00

00"cc,2

¢COCCOCCOC 0.COOO0¢CC¢CCC CCII CC C0 COC "I'llCrC 1¢0CC 2UUO00CCCU0 ¢

CICCC~(CC(~L~ZOO OOUIUd(CCCl0CCU1_CL0"OU22U(101

LCCC0000CCC0 UO00000

000(000000011(C-U1,00_010C0000C0(0(0C00 U0020 U0((CCULC001COCOCO000UC 0UL,

C0CC(00CC00000UCCO0IL0

(C (10C(CCCC CC CC cc UO

7 7 0:03 0920 9009.1

7172 0 U 101 90,9 0196 0013

/O~/U0D#G~dUU~ UUl)U~aIe

?7)7 201D30 1U..0)01010 16413

51Ob777 o'7 UtU7OU700,33-.

);/O.77'l? 0016930099I'''

093003oo

;111171U7ll 170 DO~)D)877?777711111170)9093731777 177777(7777 (099000109777777717777777000100000

17777.711 ... 0.0010U0U017 ....... O~J)~O] .DJO

/?7I/U09 013)39U09 0U9 3-

711770009 393) 390 3D 09030

0D0110UU 30101e 30139U 7 0D"08D" JJJ~~aIe 6IIDUQdU3J)~SUJb05JU.DDOIn0.O)3333B8933899 I04Do01701,22*29*9194

U,;;,;";"0102220J2200001222.0unzulzi

-002222 220,700021222

I0002222

C ,0 002 i2 2

LqaOu..U

(nOOUoZdZ

I0I0.202I

C OOL02U,

Cc 01022,

UnOU2zZ~Za

I000100012,uc0001202

07, 00222

0100020222

000001222

0,,00U001,00000022,

UaU0 2022

II90U30106

09002272,00000202.

C00U"222,

oCOO.i

00I300222

o((0300012.(0o0022zZ,

0000;2221

C(CC01022

0¢¢001221

C¢0000700,

96966606066669696699999996666&6G69LOtL[LLL£ CLLEL(C. .I ... 4 66666

709LL999961999LL"999.9#4(96(((99I

.... 99..... 9............. .......

LqoE L' L fELt[ [?I qqqq

2LOLLLq "ILLLE£L L ~ttqqqqqqq I

,zqqqqqq111- LL ttqt L'ELtttIU..ttqll,,q:,btlLILLEEtItt~OOOLEEEf[?4qqq -t1LLE..U.L-nOUCUEEE£00I9 0(A( "EL, LIOUIUU02 O 6 (9(oUEO9,

10E(L(LC EL£ILUOCU(C U O UE,0.O(9 O9 99

00199999999999999999 (0( 0(0999

299999999-91 111009(1( .Z(1.C...0.(

Z.H~. ~ -jj2..Z....22. 22Z2

.... . ..H.....2#. Z........

D9999..6CCt 2911(COO 1oOO((9a

.-.... a....~...H........ &&

...... ~.**.. ....... ZZZ~ZZ22c

U ........ .. ..Z2 . 2 .. ~.?to

269996999CCCIO~loOO 2n1000CI00

I.H.~2.".a" -...2 2 ... &MZ~MH,,--~.-~-...,-ZHETZ22Z22 ...

D ....... "......".."22........I2;2

26 L --.1-...C...H0200fl0103000.00

7 429494.. 991," ..2 .....232C2....

,5~%...............%~. .A..Sb .S5.H.....

1~55H.......H......*....Mb. .......... a.M16"66. 9....9 9 9...9....9.*1991Ill99· 9~99.D99I,S66*,9.. ...............999999*1* 19 H. 6..9669*1 SS 99.*199

~55e~.............s..ssbssss..~.. IDS'&Vs s .. H...H..... .55~~~ 5SS .. ...

~Z555................~$~.~SS5 ~."."".HH

.%55........H..~&.S55b&bSS 5 Z.sb~H"....H

Al 6969999999999*199ss99 6 t s66 ....41

.S~b............ S5% A, S'$555..". S s .S..a55. .... H......S1A.1sA~b~ ss~s~sSb~S%- .....

5S~55........5 ~ ~ ~.......%S55 H......#..

~555...................55S 5...........

SSS~Sn..H..~.S.".H"....H.5. 55b.. ..666 ..7*.......99*... .. 9.....*.6596,66$96699.*

55595.....5~..~....".5". sss55~$s ... H~...2665697.1...99.9969.9.9.9..9..699966966699966699

HSSS..... .~ ......... n.H.". b...".. H#

~.~N..MHM~MMMbM.~MHbMH -sHM ss ....MMMM.

5.5...........~"~5."" -HHb ......~H."A....

H555....e..... ........ . I""~" ~...... L.....CICOCCOC.- ... S...6...*.....79 99S*99-9-91*1*9969 -69....

L1

i6

1800

I L

70

20

,U

2C2C

2C

212C2C

2922

~2 2

iia j

IJ

I"1z

IZ

IC

I C

I,

I

IIB

IS

iO

BF4 0OOuu00000UOEO60Z~242Z2Z0OULELLUOUGOOOuL[ 7777;;)CLIBS OU£OE0OOUIOt[UUGR2122ZUGOJUEOU£OUOD 2UU I I 77~C

I9~2OLElUUUUO2O2U2OU~ig209EtUJUOOOUUIIOOLI ~111711UU¢

DA 0uUEUOaZOU224MZ122EU6LUOUUUMOOULOU.LEi /117111JuC£

UUO uOU2all00UZOOI Z 7 J UZOOUUUI.OVLuOOOUUIL 71 J t19d u0DOOu00000 I& l ZbOt)UOJOOOOUL& Z?711J.

Itt O0OOOULUOUEOO%~U 2UUUUUUZ oL u~~ou£ &I &d ??1;77) ?JCO(BS~ OU 1o ?0UL UU .) ?UULOUE 6 7? 77J L

:g 00£02 2#Uh0OOUO02 I2UU6ZOOUUUUUOIVUoL LL 0 7aO 7~1

u2ouL.2 U UEz 2uoutt(oaooZuuUoeuueuubuouuou 1111111JdUU¢.9ZLGOU£O2Id22UEE£UC.IGGOO171103 00I

BPI(UO~BUE LL UUU 4LL~qLLL[LEL ?111717JLJBfe, 11171712J0(C

&%(qqqk~LE qLOtO.ttEtk£LUULqtUtkqEqEkk~ktkL ??111177MucB5iqt-EqL( 4LLOEEULLELLELELL LI£L~fCE-hqOkL 11171713 UUU

E9 ' LOOOLEU£qEL I[t[ LL LLELLLL& L P7711 11CCCL[9 U O1L-LuLEL tL~Ee~LL[E eLt eIwqL£LLLLELLU ;if?7/lLUt(

Ll LLLL£LOUL£LE, LLLE£,' LLLLL tL£L LLIL 7U ~IICUC0 LLL LLLtGELLEELtLL[qE£LEL~LLLL£L EC ELEU/?177?Ic£

U5 L'iLLUULLLLLL£ILLIfUEL[ELULOLLLELOOULU I 1111 I.D. /2LELE t I ELLLLU£LE [OELL LLLUELL UU ?1111 Ill

09 b.qtt, U£Utt1tt .. 2Z...Ill . IS lllJt(L

L, H 71711;1CC

CII ........a.. .. .... &*.""f"" 2.""." 777, III??C

Z7 UOE O EEM2 IgZ Un OOOUUULDUO OOOUOO.U( 71777 CL)CC

Z 'ZUUULuaO£LLO06LODOGO.OOUUUUUUDOOQOULLLO.UO[ '1111Ioc

I.IJOU£EL£ILLL(LELtLOOuOOUOUOU£LOOUOUUOUOOUU( ~77,? r(.Ca0P22,6,11L£EL£££LL 00[£00UCODUOU 0UODDUO.U~L :117 FULC

1Z UOOLL~bL£L£LEELLLUULLEL UOUUUOU UCCCOU£OUULZ11;:C

L0 ID00U[£oL£LEL ££L(i UU0OUUOUO~0IJOLC177 UC

6 O2UQOU LUCIL £ L£OUT UL10UEULU GOL£U,,17 :ULL·'U0UDUDL£LEL£[[£LLEE EEOUUoO ULU-UU UUOEOUL7'1; UUC'a I U0UU £Lt££££LUU£LOUOOU£UE UOUELLLUDU£U 110 71 rU£C

9~u~OUOU£L£L£L££ELL£GO(uOOU£O£L£OGU OEOEELEZ "171 EEO((AUIOLOuLL£L£LELF.LLOUQOUOUOOOOUUOE£LUCCLL££L LI CCCCL:CClauOO0U0UO0£Uc C£ LCEC C DU1O£LU00U1 LLL. LC

,ULLLLELELELL4&A&Ab LbL £I0C £ ZC C~.r~C I;AJA7 GGIWELGLk4Lba£LGLELLLL ILtCCCLICLC

Z,&~~~~~~ I~bbbb~b~~ bIaL4IbIwbo b GL;LC((LC LL

A'A~a Gb~6bZabG U b~~~~ 'LLCILCL£

IE .& .11b.. VI'I G L~b bb£ LLUCCCLI

:AA..qI D I

q 'I"" I II ...qII4q4IqtL" 4t-q LLAkCCCCC 5

I~ ~ ~~~CLq&~G~b~kbqbb~q~~qb~qq tqq tL£ ELELL£U LCL(LCt( LL¢

F I [' (.2C ZII UOUUUOGIeUIQUOUOOUUIt LLLLLL£E CC CL£CCIIC

2~q~waqb"Mu qq qL EE£(LU£L UL C LI C C£C

!~I.6qq~qqqa&qaba OLEq~LEEEL£L.L4EIL tCCItCLCCCC

R.Zk6,&~G6IQqaGGLqG"LI1414OL£LLtELOLEEELU CCCLLCCCC(C

S2rIGGw(aa &~,. aa G & Z2 &ZU U zUUUUQUU ;;.c ,.;;;. , n

(2 £~.£UH~CCCfiC 2H LCH~(CI((CCCC ~CLCC¢L CCLCC(.CL"DHC4LC ChM. CaCICC.CHC CC~C CCC .... C L~ C-C: CC CCLCLCCCCC

IHICHHHHH~HCLHHHZC -ILHHH.CCCC ~CIC.-ICCCCCI :ICC¢ CCC(.CI.C CN ...a..H .~2HHZENZ CICCC LCCC CCLCI CI.C¢¢ CCCCC¢

L~NHm ,`_ __H~HC C C( C£¢CCCCCC&L-CC¢q :CC(¢¢(CC(.

Ic....-H. ...... ct C ¢¢£ II~ ... I... L(-tC t c t (t(; ¢ct

..... ~ H~HNC¢ C HffC1C¢ ~ CCCCCC CC ... ¢~£CCCL . CCISI,

........ M~HHCCII......CC(¢CCI¢£CCC(C¢CCLmaa.HaaCc£¢CC2LCC CCCE¢CCC CCCIC(.C¢LIC¢C¢CC¢L¢¢

a# ¢ HZmLCC¢C¢ CCCLCIC¢CC ¢CC ¢£ Iqq U (C ¢C CCII

I~.aH1h1HNCL1.CCU11Z EE UCLCCCLC.CCI

i~~aqq ~L4q1t1tt El 44 I R , I M4 ¢¢ ICC£,C¢C¢

IEeEEF Iq %qII q ~N££~~b££Lqqq qeqq~ CCCCCCCCCC

~A$91

59

AN9

933*06

·di6

*7

A2I

Figure 3-22. CLASSIFICATION MAP BY THE GENERALIZED K-MEANS TECHNIQUEWITH 18 CLASSES AFTER 2 ITERATIONS

3-29

-II ........ ........ 1-111_.J..

Ml

P.

II

I

I

I

: III

: I.I

: iI

:I

I

I

11I

� I.1IIr

11II

I6I

Ir

II

I

I

I

III

I

I

lI

II

iI

IIj

4 G

A~

,&

II7

IZIa3

Page 53: UNSUPERVISED CLASSIFICATION OF REMOTE MULTISPECTRAL ... · i (f t , lt tr-220-1075 april 1972 unsupervised classification of remote multispectral sensing data 172-27204 ic.as c 237s9e

TR-1075

&ALIC14 · ' B * 0 I 7 B 10 4 I 0 I F I"

"C. OF C(LAS1S ER&LO FRO is TO I7

,O~oogooooooouooooooooonocigoooI7000000000000000I'll, 112121II 1112111111111111111 I222I2

0D ...... .20033 jqq11qS1.777.7i 44.119 0 0Q 12 3& 33311111I4121&S&44&47778#0BB48Y10n00

II079 b7 ]J$9 IS79$7 .~S~&$t~~3 B 7 &7 B i~t~~~7e 7jb7 I 130~&7&~7t

CCCCIO ICCCCCC0CCCCnCC

CCCOCOCCOCCCCCCcOOOO

C (CCOOOCCCCC0CC"CO 0000oCCCCCOCCCCCCCCOOOOO

CCc0¢00OCCCCCC000000onoCCCOCccoCCCCC000CoOOO

C"(((00000(0CC¢¢CCCCOIDU0(CcC0oouc0c~ucc20o ODD~n

CCCCC(C2CC((CC¢CCC¢CC¢O

CcCCOCCc 0oooccCccoCC 0

CcCCCCCCC'¢CCC~0UoCCCnUC£CCCC¢CDCCC OO00COfl2OccCC"CCCCCC CCCUOOOOC00CCCCoCC2OCC20o0oo0nO

CcCCOCOCc~CCCOOOOOcO0oO0C¢CC COCCUC0¢¢C000000 O

CCcc0CC UCC 0000 000n 00CCC¢Cc¢C¢OC(C0 0 0 0CC¢O¢O

CCC~oCCCOCC(CO0o OOOOE

CCCCCCOCCC0UCCCOOCC OCCCCCC00CCCOOCCOOC1(oooo~

C(¢CCCC CC¢CCccCcC0OOOO

CCCCO022OCCCCCC CCC0oCCCCOOZ20¢OCCCCOCcZ220]]

747774404444044443334442

7,777s4A044333B44oB4e4e4

;7 7447B343334A40B4433433

7 7 6 17 0 4 4 4 0 0 3 0 7 0 4 4 3 3 3 3 3

47177747777777 7433*4B834

$;77777717 717044444fi3

777747777777 76U8)01810

777777777447/7773344303

7 7 77J7777777 77 4 44 B 400477777777177777740.444.4

17 77 77 7 1787 7 77 7 74 7 04447777f77774477444S4404044

7,777*6

40B6)J330034

444

34

7 7 7 7 4 40 3 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 0 4 4 4 4 7 7 1 7 4 4 3 3 B 3 3 3 B 3 3 3 4 3 4 4 47 0 4 4 4 4 3 3 o 2 3 4 3 3 4 3 4 4 0 o 47elll333334433443 144.4

trfrfCCCCCCCCCCCCCfOCtrr¢t ,1&ano&&&44i.&4.q41#&G&.&&4444......1 ...................... I

IC L cqcq q q "["~q q q qq.. .4Gc"& &GI

OEEI00(0(E1E1041111112,l114llE00t42

DO0(1 [1E.E 00L00 [[1(011 £1 [112 04l('

ZoEtq qqqq... q4 qqqLE.E 1qqqE

4 E:EEEqq qq q qq q qq~ q~q

qOE.(1 ' E"11 ,[£ 1000( qqqq1ql( 010E 1 E C 'C LLE 1A 0E11-lqll0n( k00 ...4 . . L f ... .. . . GElj .. ..(0 0.. . .

EL E.I......00 11111-l . f12( E111011.

0(I10 1111 0011 (lElE ---- ---- ll

2101It1...2I1..(LE("O1E12000E00(.(E

22 10... S110 E'LE(E0 DOD000000a00 0.00

12 412(14(0(1E E ' U O O(0 0 0 0 U1 0 0 0 U 0 00 0

112111014E0EE00...000007,700C000 lot0[1L oj1E1 E £12A 02O

020 [27 70200c0n

220 2O 0 0000020 02DOO 0 7 0Z0 00iiC0 0 D

00 2 202 0 0ooDoo0 o0o 00702000 a 2 7aP.DOIGZOODDOOODOODOZOOO;DIIII21.£0D 00DODO OD ODDDoD00 ?000 22 2 00DODI 0DD OD00OD000 0002 DO 20 001a

0000DOOD4000000D0020 'D020222 00

0OODDOO 00000D 022D00 202C22 7ZO02

200000000DD200000D 000ZZ02 2CI22002:

0 0 0 00DOD 00 OO 202 U20022 ZC 2 220022ODD0000220DD0220D00000222222D022000D0O0020220D 00D 022;2222C0 Z2Z

2000DI00020 00BDDO ZnD2202222202

0D0FDDO ODDDDD DD00 0022 0D0222220020000000DO000000D 00DDO 02n2ODZ0 & 02

00DO00O0000AA0OZODDUD202022202100

iUOOOOOPOPO DAOOOOOOOOO ZOAI 100&2000 DOO 0D0 ODO, 0 0DOO 0 0 0D 0nO22 22 & 0 C

0 0 0 2 0 0 0 0 P 0 0 0 0 0 0 2 2 2 0 7 2 2 2 04 I 0 2 0 0 0ODDODDOOO·DODUDDDOOOU2nUI2&~ODO,0,00UpoDUA~ODDODDDOOI~nO~& .... &

,000002000OUDUODOZZ2;7222022D02,

Oo 000000000000U 00002 0 A 002Z2 0222D000 000IODO 0OD 00 DO OAD 2 22 2222"

701 COOO2222220000000I *ID2AOODOD OOO ODO. D20A000'2''002II

71I ~)W 7 l f I ,n~n12121,,o no,,onOOrO,b(o, S~oooOO1222n100,OOOoOOOOonO0

00222222.

onoo~2"2

UOuoZZzljunoou1121

q0O, I I 0022202.

0C000222.

OnOO2Z22,CC 0 02022,.

00022222,

C0¢0022Z2

C~000ooZ,

(C0002022.

CCOOOOO 2 .

C n000 002

C C .. DI

((O002222

((002222.

0~000I0III

00002022,

(oO0O0002OCCOOOZ'O

(cC00222

(0¢0o0000.((00022

(((00002((0000O0

(((( 0222

CcCoo00Z,

Cc((((22CCCC¢CZZCcc"c"CC"ZccCC(C22

C CCccCCO

12O 012100000 0OOOD0 00000 0S0 1SS0 00DOD 0000DD0 0 000$ObSOODDODU.DOOODOOOOUD&ODO(,SOOODODDOnODDDDODODOOD1 2SSOOOD11 0 0DOODO0 0DOD 0 00OODO0 1O2 1b 1000000001212 121 0 0 P0 0 D O D0 D0 0C 0D 0 0 0U S 0 00 A 000 201 0 D 0 21 121 0 0 0 4 0 0 0 D1S2122 D00D0 ODD000DOD AO D00S00ooao oSo K$0 1 0001100001 2 1 2 O2 1 0 0 0 0 0 0 1 0 1 2 0 0 0 0 0& 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 1O ? 1 1S 1 2 105 01 2 0 0 04 0 0 0,bbSSO 00OO 0000oOOO 0oU C.oo ... OO .. gtSASOOS 912 0000

IS 0SD0b$$ O 0o 0 00oS$D OOOD. O OUDU0S000~bOb eUSU S000

2S000000000 000000002100R 2D2SS991 b1b20 Sg1 0 0SOO,'IS" UDUODODOODS U PDUUUU$~~~~S DDC....OOUOOOO.OOOOU DUOSUOSSSS.......... OOOUO0D

[bSSgSO~D.DDODODDDODDDODUbSDUS$Sb~$b10S$~90bDDDDO12 12000001ODODDDD0 0 0U1S2u$ 1 4SSS 14 112 22DDD110

)9 121291D00S000DDDOD0D 0UDD 0O 22112121Sb OOS2 DDD!SbbUODDODUDDDDOODO~bDSbS~S bDDDODDDDOU SI105 0 0DD 0 0 0 00DD DODD00 1 1 1 22 22 12S12121S21100D00

bSbS 00 OODOO OSoDo o D 0011 II22211112202 0000000

12121 00D OODO DOODOO D0 DAUO AAS$0SbSSO12 2 OSSOD00OD002S$SDD0DOOO UO0 00000 AOSAS0 Sb bS0 SSS 0S 100000 000004b1SO100ODU0 000 0001DO D2120212S 21 251SS 2$U1 O SS OO1 000

)S$SDDDDOODODOODDDODA OSU1bAS S S$SD SoSSS ODDDgo012S1100DDO 00000000000DDDD0121 2 A 1S 1 1SS 1o20020000

b~$SSODOUDOODSOOODDODO~DbDSASS9bS~bk$ODD.DDOOO

$b$DDOObODOOD DDOUODS SSS6S D DDDOOOD0550$DODDOOuDDODOOD DUDD DO55$SS$SO$$~bbbDDODDOD00.O

1 2 1 2 1 2 0 0 0 00 0 0 0 0 1 1 4 1 4 2 2 2 0 1 1 1 1 4 2 1 1 1 0000 0 0

DSO0S0DOD0 DO0 DOD ODDo0 01 DDSSODODOO$ bObs&&OODPOO

0$ %1 200000D OOD DO0 DO0' 1O0 2S0 1S 20 1$ 012112 00 0ODDD01222DUO D00 D0000020000 0ODD01D 1O1b 0 0SSS SO $ $ 0 0

O~990DPOUODDDCODDOODODOODDOO$SDOPDbobODO"DSOOOOODI

SS1212121212000 0 000 0120D SD 0ODDo0 OODOOD 0 1 SS2 0S1 0 0

$995bDOODDDOuDUODDD DDOODOOOPDIO&SDOSSoOOSODODODDDOSbS$ODDOPUDOS DPOoDDUDPODOOUDDO$OODSb6SODDDOo 0

S$&bDOODOO OnDODDDDD~OOODOUDUDOSS~OS.SDOOUODDOD0

12S1 1 DOO1 OOD10 DOODD0D00000 000 000 DODD00200 0 D00 00 00 0DO01S2121212 OD.DU DDDo0 00 0000 0D0000C012DO&OOD 2n D"ODD

S 121212 212 0 0 0 00 0 12 0 0 0 0 00 0 0 01) 0 0 00 4 012 201 12 21 1 124 0 0 0 0 0 0

S95ODOO.OODUDODDDODDDODDUPOOD"SOOODDobOOSODODOD2

,Ob00 D002000000002120000001DDO ODDOO DO$SOO1 $n4 OO D00

,&$1ODDDDOODOnDODPOSDUDOObDOUUDODSDbO$$~DOUODDDo.D

,SbSSS ODDOOOOOD0OD DODDODD0ODD00S"0D DO&DODD000D

SbDSOOODOOPDDDDOOOODDO&ODDODObbD$$bDSOnODSODDADDD~

01619000000O000D00D1PO0D012DDO1U20DD121PO0012OD00.00 00OI

121110D 000D 000D00000PDSD SO b0001210 D 2D 2121200412000 00

SbSOD00D00000O00000O000000OD0000DOD200000012D0000D0

41212oOgoooOo.ODOOO OOOOOOQ12 00121D000124 412 0S0 0000 0

0 1 2 1 2 4 0 -00 0 . .00 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 . ..20 0 0 .0 0 0 1 2 0 0 4 1 2 0 0 0 .00'L (C(CC£(1CgOD 0UDOODOO 00004 00 P D DD2000700012000 DuaaOOD

I

DI

C

2

II0

72

I0

A

7[01

OC

7

[

.

cml

ID

IA

II

I,

II

10

AI

24

90

EIC

79

EBII

.9

.9

"IDI

Ob0a

Il

ASB

a9*0O0

Z&

.1'2

I8

02

0721

EE

ILZ7

El2a

ZE

22&Z!:

02

U1

0lEl

2O

El

21

II:0

)0

)A

DI

CB

C9

7941

'9

4!

4'CtB,

I

B'

A,

4'

B'

B,

II

i'

91

%a

A,I

S&

SI

DIq

II

I2

9JIfJ

II

9II

a9

Za

OOOOOU. OO O&Z0001102022202 0 EOOOU0010 77777700O£O0 I000O2 E£O&2JI2202060201O00000000O 777777

1~00L[1000002U0020g22200L&102000000&4001:777777tO000OO0O0022 U42 OEOOOOOOOO OG[0000 '007777 7C

1000U02220000022&&7204&[00001&OOO£O0O&[&. 777777

1020022000o0ooo0o1o ~0b000000000dooo&00:777777)00000O~OOO0D000I0I~O400000020000014I0 77777710oo00ooo00000000021ouo22ooo1oooooE110&20 777777

l0000020000O00002200420000000&001114U10 7?77177

O too0022 2 I a01 2 2 7 aE4 0010 00120I000a 01 IL00 7 7 7

OV01211110000az~ y a '002 0O0 [ 2000U22A1020IOOObOOOOOOOOO 77777

O~22U 20 0000Lo 22O[OO&Z& 200 0O0&2OO OU2 r77777ObOUOIIIIZ2ZO' O[UO 2906 &QOGO&OG " LI / 777701~O&&UEL00EEE20 10 . Loooq£ooO[ OI..6rT?7777

OUqqq&[qkE[Uqq00010060SU"[0 0qo[q£1LLOU2 7 7 7 7 1 7 0

E .. IkELOLEOOULEE£E[EELELLLLO££LqiO[(EEC;7717

LO .£EtLEEE 'ttqt t Ot;t;t"£t '/ 17I,,:q~o~ q El ~ ~ t t qtt 177

1O1 IOt~tttqt[t~f ~ t& LI~l~?

£ttUOtDLLt£OttEttttLt"ttE[OtttttoECtECtItW7777

/CtltU.LEEItuICEt££Ot£EEoi.t&"EtL~uUU DU77777778 LE[ [£LEE [[[OEL0£[[ ILE toE777777

I £ 2DO~Z&A&AbDD OOUPUOUDODC I7111

ea, 1,Z0O1:DD4AOO&DO..UDOODOOOO ~ OIIIDDSU

i~O....U·.A.... DOU uDJDOODOO DoZaIDZODUO£00040A0&AA·A.&2 0022UU2OODD000D0000DD0000D

&DODOAAD0 ODDODOODD 00 0 O&AUODOOOODOOOOUO

2Z2UO2 UA&0 ODOO1002 200020O0 0D0DD0OZ(CCZDC0220222OODD2O22DO2 ODOODD0000000002 222CC£CC

4d222DD0202D00422220222202220U222C2222020 0 22 0 Z2 2 2 2 2 0 0 0 4 0 2 2 & g g2 2 22 2 2 0 0 0 0 " . . . , l

GELOOOOEO[OEI[[0U00000UOOOODOUD0 020C00000

ZO1£0000£[0££EEL0E0UO OOOUL000000040000002000000G0(&£01££000000U00000000000110000001201 1111 11E"L1010 P.0 E00 .000001000000 D00 COUP

UD0tttb40 , t... 1Ot OOEEOCUOOOOOOOOEccOEO000

UP UEIOLOLE[ u000000000000(00Ioo 4....ULE ?qLLQ bUOQ tIOLLO0000000LE£L£[OtEO£O£110 4U0ooO0UOO UO1ZO(oOODEO EE Ot tO(OOLEU £o EoooooonooLtuQoGEBEOUOOE10££ EL[[E( (1 OEGU0OU[L0 0 DIC01D0£012 2

00o0ULL&££EL£L LO0OO0U0 0O00D0 LLQCCCLECLC

0ooUooUooGoo£C CLCtCt cOUO&OL 0oDPILE k£L£[CE£[&A&A& L.k f.

&AbG..&G4kG&GGO 'GiE61 G "b1. &G& UL&UGU00

011

PCCCPUCC

ICOC

10CP0CCIEC

lUCC

POOC

7101100Cloon

octEu0CIUOC

00C

;uC0CC

'CCC:CIE

77C77 CC

77777 ICC'77777 0OCC'77777 CCC

77777 C C77777 CCC

'77777 rCCC"'77777 CCC

~77777 fCCC~717777CCC"

77777 0OCC"77770 0CC£'77777,CCC77777 0UCC

'77777 CCC.77777 ~0CC

'77777 CCC.1777ZrC&£

:77777 FOOC77777 0UCC77177r00C777717 0CC

7717 77 CC.

7727 71C C C

IC77 C C C

:co&COt OC

00¢(CCCC¢AAk................ G---------------- L£ i'l£Cl""'

4412111&1II& 1.I01 U&& IILOIO&&IOIIO&&kqGk kk&& OL£ICC(CCCCCIkV 66&G&2 a~bOfbi kQbOG6G6bk. kbk&£LL~CCCLCCCCOA O 4, 1 1 2 0 1 1 I I 2 I0. .2 I 1 2 1 2 1 1 1 1 0 ( ( (C C C

A . ....... .... B .' .R~....... ......Af0&&Gb 11kk&G? &2124 fe 41LE2I~t2 ((CC(C((CCC

k&·b~b (&(((&&&((&&&&OG~bk&&kb~v6 kbA&Z&&. CCOCCCC

AAII0I12 7I01212 120I4I4&& G212 0 4I ( 41 I L ( LC( C C C CC

IA4121 60 411 66 L111 2 1 1 10 2 2 2 1I 2 0 1 12 2 1 22 ( ( (C C CL E

0 C ( C C ( 0 04b 0 ( C (0 C ( 0 C C ( C C O C C O OC C C C C L [ L (( C CC C C C C

0A&Ab...A4&&&&&&GCC00 b&V&GLb&GCGCUCC GkCUC CCC( CCL(

(20002 00000 00 £&20 20& 2( C C C C C C "&L( qC £LI (((((C C C" CCC

2(O O O O O O B O 200000 E00 L L0C C ECC C C E(C C C C C O C(C C1C C C C.

O C 4 0 0 0 0 0 0 4 0II O C C C C C C C q ( C ( C C ( C C C ( C C C C ( C C ((E~ C C C"£ 0 0 0

O O O O O O O O O O C ( ( 1 .C C C C O C ( C C ( C ( ( C C ( C ( ( 0 0¢e I C C C ¢

I 4ObqG&GO GOOOC [&OC&&E(C&ZOZoC oo& L&CICC LCCCCCCC"CC

,I 0& 000 &020U 0000E0&00 C C C ECC 0 0C C C C C C4& OC C C C((C C C CC

0060000 ..0I000CC(CCO(OgUCgC QO[[&%Cc"C £LEE ((CCLC(C((

O&OOOOOO &OO&O&&CC1 :&C&C£&COOO22... 10 2 CCCC"CCCC

12F1111 12111'01I44l&&$ ((1 qqq [ £L U&&0 0 LL0 :CC C LCC CCCC&qCkqqqq)O&&&qqCDC~qqqqqqoCLqqDOECLOCC[L( :CCCLCCC£C

DDCCCCCC CC£ILCCC£

020CDD1COCCCCOCLCCCCCCZC¢CC£COCCCCCCCC£C4¢OCCCCICCC

D"IC"C"CDUOC "¢ oC"OCCOCO o "ZC"C "OC"C"OCC"L C"CC"CC'C'COCDC¢CCO~~O£ODDUCU¢DCO2CC£IC"C" CCOcCC"C"CC"C" C£C"£CCCCC¢

D(D0CPDVO9DCCLDCLCC£C2&CC CCC¢CIICCCLCCCECLfCCCCC¢¢CIC LCCCC¢CCC'C

cgoIoIu I Dooouc o I acocC I oocc ccc ccDcODaU, cUD...D"DIC~U¢££ DCCCCCCCC(CCCCCCC¢LO CCL

UODO~DDDODO BODDDPCC£~ CCECC¢CC00£CCC CC

:

III

c c

CL

DOUDOD2DUODUICC¢CCLCC£C£CCCOCCC C~CCCC£I CC:cCCC3C"Cc..... D.....¢.£. cDD..gCCCC£C£C C"cc£ccc¢ccc

OuDOOL2OOO~Z~COCCCCC£CIC,. ¢CCCO~o£~q CCCLCLCC CC,O00000DaO~aOC~ccc IL"IC"CCQQ, C"L ¢CC¢~CCCCC

Figure 3-23. CLASSIFICATION MAP BY THE GENERALIZED K-MEANS TECHNIQUEWITH 17 CLASSES

3-30

NORTHROP SERVICES. INC.

S 12:7

1I91

C S12312941297

A S.

401

0 40 1

40740

411B1I

BI I. A*II

&JI

I I43

427S

3 3

43I

A43I

A13

4*9

4121

4123SA1A1IAA7

.47

41-

7012707701711

713

7112717

7I�721

7227212

727721

131733

, 312737731

711

71237.127.7'II

71217122

712471277121742

74374470774,771

77377127,7

741743

7412'B,74?

711

'.3

IT, C(T

.................. -'-- ..........-

4

Cb

I ADI

101 U1,

A

II

99

I:

I

t

£O

'0

II

Ij

II

II

I

II

Page 54: UNSUPERVISED CLASSIFICATION OF REMOTE MULTISPECTRAL ... · i (f t , lt tr-220-1075 april 1972 unsupervised classification of remote multispectral sensing data 172-27204 ic.as c 237s9e

TR-1075NORTHROP SERVICES. INC.

CCA74h I 2 9 q 74b 7 0 *S lO II 2l) · lbI~I17 76CHA94CT[R I 2 I q 74 ! 7 · 0 A 6 C 9 L 7 74 .

SAM.'LI7 'U 99CR.

170177177iii 122~23333)3#999 9474$b&&&444?777 7 ?64#69~999G0049 hi1i222)3233qq9q9 bbbbb97?41.. 7777764499999000.II iaO

CCCCC¢CCCCCCCCCCCCCC¢72

C(CCCC2CC2CCCC CCCCC 22

CCCCL 222CCCC 2CC CC22 ICCCCCCC2C CCCCC CCCCC2I2

CCCC CCC CCC¢ CC2CC 22CCCCCCCCCCCCCC2222272

¢CC C 22222 2C C¢ CC C 227222CICCC CCI 2 C aI C Z C 22I2CC C

C¢CCC2C2C2ZCOCCCCCCCC2

C CC C C C C 2 C CC CC CC C C C C C 2

C¢CCC.C2C2C12~222CCCZCC 2( (C C C I I.1 2 2 2 2 C IC C 7 C 7

CCCIICCI C IICC2CCCICC

CC¢CC'CCCCCC 21222~CCC22C C C "C CC CCCI 222 C 222CCCCCIII CCC2222222222CCCCC CICzC.2222222222I

CC CCZC C2C¢CCI 212Z Z2

LC 1C CC2C 22 ( I , 1 C C 1 2 2 2 22 2CCC22CCCCCC1C222C222" IC¢CC¢CCC¢CCCCICC¢2CC 72222

CcCCC CCUC 1CCCL2CCC2272

CCCICCOCI C CLLC 2 CCC22CCCCIII 22 I CCII IIII I2 122(ICC CI."CC CCC C ICC I (222

CC ICC CII CCC- CCC CC 122 21

7 7 6 9 9 6 6· i 6 6 6 9 0 9 3 9 3 3 7 9

7 977 7·6· 68 968 9B 898 33 394777·7 SS7 83s sea 9BD·9 4 9977 747 9 99993 '93 94440 73

/7177 8e ·6·947 33 4 94 33

I7 7677948 4 998s

l 7 4 3433 36a 8894 3 3 49277 7 752 777847 3 4998 1 1UD 3?7~7797~777~7777a3oA4~39

97781747777777809949999

777477777777/799499999377777777799777733493736·7~7777777777777998999099

777777117717777794049079~777777777777784d4d884677771797 7497 7989999949

7777;799903933309893133~7 717798983133993499436

??7779949799444999709998~77 7 79993B99489049 48478

7 9 6 9 7 7 3J 3 3 3 3 0 9 3 3 o 4 9 8 7 0

1 72 2 2 02 2 4~ 22 17 L71 171 171 717

I I 12 ;Z2722222227222Z222

272222222

4C¢2222222I 2 22 2 2 2

(7222222*27 2222247(722;2222

CI I2I2I2III(C2222222

C7222222CC 22222 2

CC 2222222CCC 2 222

C02C2Z22((222Z2217222222

C¢22w22

CC222 222Cr242222

27222222C242 2 2 2

'Cr 2IZZ22(7222222

(¢122222Cr222224

Cc¢CCC C 02

t 1?U£E L [L £E N f £EEEE(( q999 974 9o 00000 9 9

I iC C (E E (E ( C 9 C 9 C ( 99 9 9 9 7 9 ( 4 7 4 9 ( 2 2 0 9 9

1021 ((((9([72CII (..(0q999999917E10(1[9

1)9O ( -(74999 [[[[q[ 2(t(( L ((999 0 179 #[ 7

7r 2 C 9 9 9 9 9 94 74 9 ' 1 7 U (94 9 9 9 9 9 9 ( 9 ((4 ( 94q 4 9q I

E 4LL£E q4414q44q£[[Eq44£[£EOO£O£(qE;J(4qLO( (99949999E01 (C(9999C(9170(0[# 9

I.LLIIL " '* LLCE[ %LE[4 4q q4 4 i.CC(((C9~q 4CL9CLC(4q1C#9i:41 C999 949~ 4

2( ((;~ ~ *C'1'l'C2((CLk[[ q[[I (99999£JL l[ I1

2749~7444 900 0(CCL CC£[ C(L I222222L(( E I[

; 299- .E9 L9 ( FU 22aLC2722C2((E£E(l C2Uq4N9U99 7 EE£L(C 2 E 2 2 ) '272 12 2 C22 77 CC

0CCCCC97~g 4 (C(CC172[ CL Z (C2Z7 (22(r 2Z2O 01 7LL ( CLEL( CC( 22 22 222 72 222L 22(7 ! 22

c OU £ 99(U CI 11EL 22 22 122 722 22i2 LC 7 79

27177C1784 L O L L)A I, 27 754( ~LU- LOLU1UA2 ;S- 1722II222 7 22 7 22 (21 i2 2

7 7I1 17 72 0I70017171711uDO 722Z22CC2C17( 228 201,1 71uDO 0 7DD 1 7DDODDDU0 DD1 0 222220II 2CI DOD VD UDu UDUU0D1 1DUDD7DU "Vol"D DD,2 0 OC

D V 0D 7 1o7U071O 7 1DU 7OUD1 OU1 217 22221 DDD 2C

Ia 1 7 1 7 0 2 1 , 1 7 o 1 7 1 7 1 7 1 o 10 7 7 1 C 7 0 0 1 7 2 70 0 1 ,11 o o CIC O 1 0UU 7U 0 1D DOUD7 OOU1 7 0 DDO1 2 0 0 000I LCJ 1O7 U0 UU U,7OUDO11 7 ) 1 0 0 7 0 C1 02000 a 17

3I0UOOOUOOUUU uO ODOUO7 n21DD7C172027 1D*I 0 01 0 1 7 1 1 7 7 1 1 7 7 0 1 7 7 1 010 0 9 1 7 1 7 1 7 2C02 2 2 0 7i D7

D UU00 01DD U7 1 72 0OO OO 1nDOD 1720202 2

DDDOoOOD[~ZOOUODOODOZn2DZ2CDiDOO0 D0170 1UU7 ODOO L)U2 DO1OO7 1 70 1 2202 92i 0

3oDDoooDzDODOOUOD U gO..02D'O .I:lIDODODUUDDDDUOUDD$OZInD..C22......Z

0 DD010OD1 U00 1 1D1 DO7 nDK017 0220004 2* 7O1 O 001..O 7DOUOUUOD 0nOUD1C 2i2C02O 2* 1 7 1 7 1 1 7 0 0 1 1 0 0 1 7 1 0 0 1

0

0 n 1 7 0 2 1 7 2 2 0 0

1 7

2 A

* D0D0 7 7 01UU 17 7D 17D1OD nO 1,2222 2C22 z1,0DO 1UDU7 OVAU0D7 gooU1D DUDDO a a202 A 2

* DOU7 O1 DO7 0 U00 7 1D U01 01 0220 00D 20 C A

,DDODODUOUDOO.uOODDDOOUUODADI ~DAOL C~* OD7D1 DOOA1 O 0O 0D001 D10n 021 7 &7[1 72 0 U IC

a 717002 7U1DD0 07 O O1 UD7 274 D1 UA2 0017221DI 70 1DUO7 7DDDUODU DDOD1 O2,D1 ·0&017 2 9 I2i2 2

I DOO27 0U 7 7DDO17 D1 DO D0A0 0 D0 20 222 2a 0O1 UDO7 OU 1DD7 .U OD0D1 0 U0D0 2~2 221 2

* 001D1O1D7DOA uUD1 0UD. . Un2 2 D O2222272 22(2170711719027I7177117r-770200417 01

~DOUg~OOOUDOOODD.0DD~DU05SSUDSDDUOOODO.OODODO~O~S.~50OOOOOOOUuOOUDOOOUDUOS$5000DO~nODDOUDDOOD,~%5~OUuU.D DUO-ODOOUP0O00USUDDU~nDUOUDOOOOODOI

*171Ib 4Uko u 0DIO ODID.0 DU0 U 1 U U0 UUOD O USDO1bb7D0O OU

C5,%OUOUD._0UoDOOlU.SUO~UDS.OU500be0SSUDD &On5bSS~DDUDUkU"DUUOUUIO ,UO U II~OOS99bDSD990DUU On0

~S ... UuuU ... SOUUU uuuOUDU.DUvI 1Sb'eeeSbOUl

~DbSSOOD. UO,. ODU DuUU OU UbS 99bs 's e $SOOOO

ASISUSOUDOOOOOOU UD~buDU00UDU59SSSO~Dll SDODUISI'esUDUDUou-noUouou~u~uDuuSDssssssollssuuuooono,

~0565v~UO uDD - UUDODgU W5U D Sb55~b~5S99Sb0DU

U&99SUDUIOD~UDODOOODDDOOUoSb[)SSbSSs5"~SSISUO

7 157 0 U10 0 00D0DDDU7 DO o 7 1DU ... 7 554 5S1 0UU0 S I 0D1 7D12 ... UDULUUU".DD OOOO0oO5OUSS51SSb9S5kSUuDDOOOOD

2s2S5DOUOO~OL*DDOOOOOOVUO 55bUSSSSSSb,~SDoDOODOO0..... DUUDOUhID.ODDDuDO~u550USSS555~m~DSIDOODOO~D

... UUOUODUDnDOUDOODASUSAA &5tSSSSSSSUs$ SS0OODI*UbUDVUOU D bS55b4SSSOA9I0U.0U DU00U,

7s74ooU -0o OO OO9 uO bSSA, 550 SUS7 S74 SS5099 00,

bSDDDODODOD550DOOU S... SSDOUbGQSSSSSODDOOI7474UD4U4 DDUDDO OD5017 U . D0DDOUD 44gD 7S4S7D4D55D00

USS$OUDPODU"DV0UID UUODUU0S5 $SD$5~nUOUUUU ... CSSSS~ODDOuO.USOUDSgOD.UDSOSDS SDOSSSOODOO~D~oo0£~5111IDDDDUDUDO9OOVOODOOUSD OODODOOSSO~ODODUDD0:

074774...71171luUk1700011U O017720474 9 9O47474-4749747474177DC71

...... UUDO UuO~DUODDUOU.0DU.DUIS OSS6Sb5SOODODOO0O

OS bS D4 1 0 0UI D0D0 0 1 70D 0 2OD 7D Doe 7UDD 7 705 0S "7 47OO 0DO1 0

bS'5¥DoO~UOODu'DODoDODODDOOUSbUbOSS" %9~SS500SDDO

0 749 97000 17170 100770 02 7740074 7474 7474 74~b177774711711U770

'USV9UoUU.O UhOOUIDDUOUOU ODUSS DS O DoDO0

'S074 70 0 W. 0D9 0 0D0 OOD DO UuUD0 5744SS -4UU 40 0DDODSe"bbODUDDDO DODDOD UDUOU.UOODISSDUnOnUSDDOODOOO27744027D1770I0D1O 1 00D7U' UD4 77O4 ODD7 OD4 7 7 nO4 0D UDOD117 00094

~55bDUDD0UOUuD OOOUOO)DUOUOOOUDDSI DS0nD OO~OUDaDOD0 7 4 4S74D002 7 0U1OO DO21 4uUUD71 7 OU1 Uo7 SS$4o 7 nD4OU1 DO4 1 7

'SSb~DUDOOaUI)ODOUDoUD ODUODODDSQUOUDnD OUD OD ODC.

leS50UDOODOUUOODUDOD OOQ1ODODUSDSOODOOo$UDoO~DODoD1S· 0UUDOOOOOODD0 0O DOOOO USO 4USS47 O7 4D7444U7 4 O O1 00

"SUODOODUDo.ODDOSODUS VObSUDDDO$OUODDOUD ,00aODD

IS SUDDDUDOU~DOODDOObDSOOD OO~OD 05SDUIDDDOO.DUOD~So "DOOD ODDOD1DOODOOgD DDUUVISOD51"I DDUDOO·DD0£.1UDSSSDOOUlDOUIDDODDDOODDOO OoD$ODDOUDO .DDUSSO....D

S 22(ELE222222(EZ( 022 i2202IIIIL2E2 22221 777777 CCC

59 29 2 LL(24 ,22 Jai3 2AJX2i4 0 E1 i i ~aipo la r7777771 .i4 2 2(22222222 22R 20 2i21(( 2(172 ~222222(617 ( r777 77C 2Z CC74 lI/i 22I22a222IUI 227 2L lIEZ22Z222LiOU,( 77777I .CC9 242 22222 2'aa2 2a�(2£24222 222Ji222 777777 CCC'9 la 2 22222 ( 22 I 3O0Uj 2E 222222 J22Ji10A 777777 CC~c

7S4 22L22122Ci 22L U722072222' 22 1Z 12[2E 0E2OI 777777 CCC

74 22ItL2222200222,22722I2 2221124I244tI7 ID 77777 CICL· 284LL2C12222LEEC( 2772UO222(Z22 2222Z 7ZO£0 7777777 2C(

92 2 t2~ 222222Ct[t20i02 2222iOt202t242 2 [2, 777I7772 CCCo 2a zz2 2222EE22 O(.( .... U20212022 l 7777772 ICC

BO~ IU EL2/ £LL1qELL·LLII F.ll1 E2¢

o 2 ( ( t t 29at C ( 9 9 t ( ( ( 1 9 ( 4 ( ( ;(9 ( t 7 7 7 7 7 37 2 C C

74 * 9 9 9 C ( 9 ( 8 ( 2 tL t ( ( ( IL t ( ([ ( t t C 9 ( 9 t 4 1LL & tE L 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 2 2 C74 9 L(99 L9E1t 7 (( (2 4(4L t(L EC(14 (L 9 (L(L t 1r7777 777 2(2

o L(74~ q4(C(L ( i tL S(C(([LML J J ~ LLLL£(914 C( 777771J2CC

9 12I.22 L?2( ££2II CL £( £ LLC(( 1((L t ( 27[ 377... I 7 CCC9 L1 21-2L2t 9LC 0 jLC1E[1QRE6 (IL £ tL££L[I 777777 CCC

9 ..C(( EI IEL9(9L EL EL E ( I NdL LL £LE4L( 177 7 CCC*I17(LCL(C(LCC((11t1(9CIt(((t19((4(tttE t (77777 CC

9 a C 1 ( I IIIC(( t( L (( L (( 9 9 (((i t t 1 L E t(( 2 2 1 I7 7 7 7 77 1 I A C74 C IE(LC I ELL( ( t L££( CL tC( ELLV(( &2£ C (t 77 77 .. ? CCI

9 L74 LEE17 I [LEL(£LLL £ ££I(£EL EL 2L7EL0 E17777; CCC

9 L[LELELEIIE 0LLL£ELLELL£E 0EL31LL 1C1 717 7 7

9 1D20LE17 2 2LL£LL0 LL2 L, U A0 U0 0 20DO0 7 1177 777 .CC

9 D20 22222AO1,AAAOOOu1OU1U,0 UDO1 22UOO 177777CCC9 UO2021709OAS097OU0OUD4U1 UUu017A1 222U0742 777777 CCC

I 241 D. 4. . U 7.7. 1 1AD7UW 2U 0 OUD 7 00 7 7UU 17021 0 U0U000 7777. CI C9 217D 0OAAA&07 U1U7U0 DUUQUDOUAUD0UDD1D7 700U I777;CCI.

9 2D17 a1 U 01A 7217001' ,2OOD27 A 0 U0 7 U1U7 0002 700D. 77 7 7; "CC2 IOUO1UAOUOUU DO'UAUAO iUA¶01 U02U1OU7 0 D DOOL 7777 Cc(

7s DUOUODOAA01702112U 7,01DOUU 3U2UUUD702002CC2U 77 777CCC

)7 ,U2220201 O400D2ODU1 OU,4 0 D2UUU12A2222CCCCL7L 77 CCC0220000Uq7OAO 1AUA0220 UDU2UO21U12D2DCC4D201 7777?7cCC

2 'D70I002IO01O74U.022DUZi17002g2 7777 7CCC

7D 4 0la0120D0 0 CC CC777 77C LCCla iLII2~ELE~LLLL12t22J[LEZIgXZZCC2LLLE222 77717:LcCI

g'oUgiLEULIIEL EELL E4£Z2222EL£te212£~a222L£22I'llIIIC

l lEIELaEOE[E£ELELLEE££[L21C££CZJCLCCCE[E2 I7'l;lECC.

.A 2E2EL2 LLEL LL£E[£ J E£1& III ZIaIC2LL LLEE77 7717ICOIZuLULOUL LL£L L& LLZZ ~2LE&LLLLZ£ILL 7?7777cc

AO IO / 2/L~LL££[LL££LZC1LZELLLZ2[£271771E C

... 2 .J2 IZE£LE(L E£L£LLL aELL[LZI£EELILL£LECEL ll? ..

F9 J/LLE .. L£E£ELtELLI~a2LEL£LLELZC[ILLL[LL7/77~CC?Aja£at[EL[ECEL£tLkLLLk atL2L~LCLLC LCLL C'L'22 ,ItLZL£C££[LEEC(LCL£Ec¢LELELLC£E202

7ILEELLELkLELEOAAAAOU - L£ --- o-U£OL"IUL LCC CCCC'A3A7 LII'lD5VOOO0L.UELUO£LLtOELLEOLU CLLCECCCC

IaiiZ L"CU~[L['[C¢CEU ULUOUULLLUZL E CCCCCC~&A UOUOUOUUUbUOUUUOL OUOUUU OO0UOUI2E§UUOdL ...CCCCCCC(

:A :&UOUOUU~GOUOOOLUDUUDOUDUUUUUUOOUOLUUOOQL LI(CCCLCCCi& ~A OuOO2U.OO~udU o UqUoUOOU8UUOIOOL£ILICC ICCCCC

·0 aUOuOUOUO2OUO Z~Z~UDUdOOOOU.OOUUuoUUQE[£[CC CC££..

A:AOUOUOUU.UUU Ltk UCORU V U~USOUOOOU~LLCCC

,AOOU.OOOUOU UUOU UOQUU a e, DUU LLOUULLL ICICL¢I

,AOUUOUOUOOOU )UUUO DODOUU~U U UUgU~UUOUQUDUL LLCLC£L

AAUOUOOOOOUUOUUI'U0OLE OUUOUOUUOU~UO&A"UUI "LC""CCCIAAUO~OUUUOUOUOUUUUOOUIOUUOUUUUOOOUOUOZUUUCLLCILLLL£C

I,,UOUOUUOUUOOOLzj2Jga2jU IqUgU # LILL C

2OO~~qqquqqqqq~qkqq[L [ qL LLJCLL eILLLLO£L~~ ~LUIU b~ q LCILLCLLLCC

AU0U. O 0UUIDqUI0IL00011111qqdLLELOLEL[ CCLCCCCCLC(

UO0"'OU DUUIOO LUULuLOU" OOa,112luOZLuOLEIICCICCCCC

1UCOUOUOOOI.O2UU2.OgO~U22I2I2I2Z£OZZ.UEL£ICCICCCC¢C£IQO0 U, go22Za20 asAGOZU19 id24iIILULLLLELL ICCLLLLLLC

U1q1OOquqaU2o1 ~ LqNELLZ~ CCCLCCCCCCC

~U40Collq4I000UqqqqoqqqqqLUO-q4EqELL22ELE CCICCCCCCCI~oUOll'u" llU.OOO1UOOOk2EUIOL44qqLEL£LLE££ ECILECCLCLC

IdZUaoO1OlVLCOOOUUOUOOUOUUI[Lll££g[£LI~£LL !CCLCCC¢CCtUOUQUUOUGIL14GUOULqOULDOO00a2LLE£/££ZL£LELZ LCLCCCCCIL

aUODDououooOoOO"OOOOuO2aII22~zZO222LI ; ; ;;;_~

ICDIC~£ODQCCCOCCOUCODOUDgCLCOOOO@CcDPOCCCI:CLCLCCCLCCCOCICCCDUDeCDECCCCU£CCD~CCL£CIVLEUUC£LCCCCE CILC£CCLCL

IUODUCODUDCIOCCICLCECDCLCCCCLCC£CICCCCCC Ca ~LCCCCIIIIUO~DOOUuOCIIVUOUCVDUDOODCLCLLCLCCCC£CCC¢ .CC CCLCC£I

iCcUU.D.OUOUODODUDO.bDUODC(CCCLCCICCCCC(CCC £CCCLCCCCCLiUC~UDU1 U 9D2DOODODUUDUOULCCL£CCCrC£CCC&~2C£CC CCCII

)LUOVOuOCD OOO aUIC LCIIL c OCCCCCCLCC -cCCCC L:( S II~UtOOUOUDOQeg CC CC¢CCLCCCCCI¢¢CCCCCL¢C IC IL

c

C IC CC¢

)U.OUVODUPO~oDooLCcO~CCOOCLIOC¢CCCCCCCCC¢CCICICCIIIIC

,UUOU-OUOUOOOUOODOUUDUOUcCCCCCICCCCCECCCCCCCCC¢'ICC¢IC',)gg'DUDCUUDDVO£CLLCL3CLCCC£LL£CECLC~C£C C(CCCCC C11ctc

I00 D~OLOUO·DOOCCLLCC¢CCCCCCCCLCCCCECEL~[ 2CLLCCCCCCIOUDU0OUOPOODO CC ECCCC~Cgj22a L CC~ccICC

lpUUDODJ21oIqa£E1. qq,~ LEqO ICC ICCtICCC

[·foqqqqqj~jo 4qJl[[[qL lqqqq I .qq . D C .C

Figure 3-24. CLASSIFICATION MAP BY THE GENERALIZED K-MEANS TECHNIQUEWITH 16 CLASSES

3-31

Ss.9

A 7

.41· O9

:I1

L 1

II

Ds

d,UL

j744

4077

*71j

'C-� ........... �c ....7 1 7. . . . . . . . . I . . . I I. . . . I-4

0

0 DA

D

,D

IIc

A

9

II

Ba9

Page 55: UNSUPERVISED CLASSIFICATION OF REMOTE MULTISPECTRAL ... · i (f t , lt tr-220-1075 april 1972 unsupervised classification of remote multispectral sensing data 172-27204 ic.as c 237s9e

C A 2 9 9 6 7 A 9 0 3 8 C A 7 8

AO. OF CLASSES MAGLO 80 FROM i T7

SAMpLE 90fi8LNUOflOOOOUDDoOOOUOOOOU OOO O~U OOUQOoGUOO oo~ooounooouo) 2)il) )11211)1 Cl1.ii)71i)iII I) ...............2222222a

I,79 67)371379979369369 j~~I36~j379 37137 9

67)37) 571369 379 67 a379 37w 67'369

;ooDooooouo- ~ .vooqoOqo~0 oOnnq'~2UoUo0u~oouoooooooM ... .... oooun#.,

7(c0u0 09. 0o0ouoo90oo009(00ooo9 9 0

-Uooo ... o oooo'ooU400ooooovq.,

m200202900900 Q( 49499OOC0nfi'

p200 099O~Oq900j090 Q999999904000 409

209oo9uU uooo0- a D 0 000..9'.

(0099999999999999009 99'

0000(7999969999 00090 ,'UOo, OUU.0O00~04UU jMMNU444dOOUOnML 4 40

I2~qq -~o q ooouuZo ozu2c.oooonnO-- 0000O{)44 U 9OnO Of o09U 9 9, O9 9''

1- -0200209r 0 0 nUUot, g 2(0099oU9

C-200C-loU'O OOOOa2O22OO2nl (O9(9.9(2'U-U{-U.OUZ02020000Z,12222222000099999(99Q((((( 22202722Cu20000000229UU92U-9C0C0 0 2 0222 120~222227r 2 U

*DODO UU0U00000022227,7221222026

COOOO00 (0o A2A22 27-J~"(CC22¢2gC2CCC (CC~ 2 /22 l0.a0nr2022a2722 72222(22,

178.18SA900799a 33808972r DO12U20DU0D ODO0272222CC2C0DC

7777 78SA08A90999990 930 0200000UDU22200000000O222022200007 7~S11SSA1BBoUU2BUO9#93311 0000U 0002DU 0UU2ODOD DC0022000DO7?111719s29ee311890898930 UOOO OOOOCC2U00022000I0022200D0

p11111118989339099989899 0000D000022o 0000UU 00o71000D 22Z60 2

IT87

7899838)7 3

90989338 0UD000D00OUU00000000OD0020CC0u20D0

;~Oa a.. aee oJ D3~OD.oDuODUOOUUDUOUDUUODOCD 20nO7700999999389989373173 )000200UUODD0UU DOOOOU0D12(20222

77777e1?7BJJBB~99 I

89A 0OO00 0UU0U00U0D2 DO a0D 2CDO0200.02077'08A7)7'11'''7099098(908 000020C000200002070002220207

eOIOB~;;;I~eUa~ae~lODUOOOU2QO.UUO;UUOOOOOZJ~ODO977777771784 7 9j9 0000002020220]U 000027D020000

777777771 79 9'~U' 38 200;00020UUUOU Coo 20U00UU0 D0(00 2022202D

7T117771777777e7998999C99UDOO9O2D00000222000000Do2202 202179717 ?l7 899no9 0000000OUOU 0UUUOAUOUD0OODUPOOO7222A'

7977 79999093e38993933 0 U000000A000U000D 000D0020I020%D o7'~7slylo93e9999988oe9 8 800 00UOU 20000D 2OO 9OO 2A022222200"I .... aU6 UBU~e8 ~UODUODU DUUOOODDOZ ~UI ... D21001

17/;m993uo33o3333A93799 200000D00U0D200000007290200i22222aa869 a 8 13903(99 U7 2 ...00 .UD00DOD0000D0900a0202222

79A83333a38U33994),OS 0 0UUU0D0 0UUU000ODOAn&2U22022222222-;22222.22.22U2OUD0D0 ODO 2022(020 UUODOUAC020 0D20ODUU0 00

ol'r TTY3TT ..... .0SS 0 0 u0(,.0000000000006S 600O2,OD 00u0DbOn7

(2222222

2,22,Z2222222212222

Z29222222

I22II22222C 9l222222

(72222222(7Z222222

(92222222((2222220

Cr2222222(7(122222

((2(Z2222(92222222

(r72222222

((22li2il

Cr222 222

22222~222

22222Z222

C22222222

(2222212

Z;II I II

((C222222((22222

((z22220

((((220Z2C((2(2222C((C1221

(((((122{

(CC(((22

CcCCcCJIS¢C cCLC12j

crC(CCcjz

0UU0760U020 OUUU00 D01000 %666D6 7 0000O0O0UaI20........ - - . .U....U-OO-DDOO"-UOOOOO UOOOOODnO606002002D .0DU002 D0D00 0(DU60 DO07700000009 U DC

IUUODuO~Di ODDOO U'U... AUOOODOOSSOODSO00OD.SSO. OO.OD uOoOOD Oo&UDUOODU0 0S0 069660UOSSA000

66662UUUU0OU( UCOUODU002002UUD D0 999660998SOD00666 66220 O Sb S (00bD 0000 (ob %SS999669 666999 6 6 O &5S,.UDIOUu50fODUOUDbUUOUUDO~SS-99e�S~SSIgSSUOO0{666,62060SU (00D20D 00 ODU(S0bSI..05 6 Ss6 6 . OD

ICD0uODUCDO..ODODUU UU00OC2S.SD0o6S6DU0DOD

9986022000 ,(000000002L0060o00S6S6A.666690000001,960 (OOoUlJ600D (00DU0U01 2,U 0U0S S0%6 SSS66 DU6O6I

'V5DU. 0 UOODDOCOu OUU~UDUOSSbbbSOlbbO~UDDOI

%bb UvUOUvUbOODUUDObU UUUb55¥s"bDUOOUDO0O1I0UDUUUlDODDUUU.DOOUUb~USS .. S55~bSSOOODUODO{

llS~SUUUOUOOOOUUOUD.UQUSU .... I.... 1OSODUUU-nO0(S60I0U0D0010U000U 00 0 U0 ASSi SSS 6S6U S69960 00D

90'1Sb00DUOC.u(ODUUOO00U0SA,50S9SS5%5.SCDS660000000666 UO( UL0000 SCOOoS&SSO SSS'66S6 6 f U60(660 00000

6SS'DOUU0Ou2 0000060056 'S6.......SbSSS6S000090

256S 00000 00UOD UU 00 U6SS6 SS66 666U6 6 SSS0 D0OOD

66SSS0 0UD0U00U00S0 000(DD6DOD$USSD$D0SSUDU0000U090

55~OU.UOUoO500DSUODOOODSDu55SD~SS~bODOUODOUOOD665S0U00 U00 0000 0000(A 6 066SOUS0 O D660000000DDO0

6b66 U00 0000 SOU 0 DUO9DDO69 9DOS6S6S666 .66 600000SbSSOOOOOOOOoSDO(DDU00C0ftSUU50055"Sb6o0DOOD

D6SS000UO0UOS,0 DO06 UU0 D06UOO DDU$0050b6 DD6 6 0000bSb9SODUOUUoSSUODDUOOUOOOSOOUSS5555'SSSIO OOD00oSS 6ISOOOODDUOOOODU020(D0005005060SS6 S600S000SO

666660 00000 0000DOODUDOODOUS 0DDSS0000 SDD000 0ODO866U600OO Do00D0U0OD0U0 OU U0066 6 0S 5 00 0S 0080

S' UOOOuDO.ODOD.DDUOOLDODUUDOSSODOGDOO OOD DODO~066 66000 20000DuODODO0DO0UDO06DO6066 DODO6 O ODOD

~SSbUOUUODODOOOUDUOD0O0UUUDDSSOSD 0000OODODDDO0

06666000000 00 6 00000 1 00 00200006 666665660O000090

S...SUDUOUDDODODOODOODDOPOODCD$OSODUDnD DOD DODOP9...UOUUUOODOODODODOOODDUOODU0 ODDUOOSO DOOOODO 0DI"6U95U0U0O0 j0 0U000000 DOUD0 oo606 600bO6 0000200

900 UOD0OD0OODDO0(00 ODU0600S66 OS6 9 0s660 DOD00D

SSDODO~ODDOUODOODDOObD~DUOUOUuODbbOOl~bDODAOOODO,0S69O9O0 00 000 00 ODDDDOOODU 006O6 O6SS60DOOO60000066SUOSOODOuOD0000D0OD0Q000OS0DS0OOD000 80000002DS6600U(0000 00DO UDo000080 U0000 D0D6600 OOSD O 0 00008666 002V 000 00 00000 00600OPPOOL 20 066I 006 00 000880 00

A

30

A0

BI

Io

:2

z 1Z

iC

W~COOD

O Z2 !O

O

Z1Ijd

7S2

U.9

CIA

6S2

792

'92

(62

]'2

'02

'9,

'9,

'9,

01

oII

2.,CB(

89.

D7.

2.

Ig

100o022222022o2222223~2z2022oo222aa222ooaI02000 222200 2008212222022000000J22U00

2i20002222222I2I2224 0024Zu 22av"Q202

21Z222222I2U202220200a222o22o00ZO0U01a2'22222222222U22 02I 222U 2222U2.UO32222222222222200222000 I 022,a2222202212021

a222z22222U2022222272~222222020220002000

a120222I22002221277200Z22)222U200uUU20OO2900O222 2222090020222222202020~20223220~2

220222222200022222JU2020202)OZOUO .. 2.U"0 0. OO22O000 002UI4uO~U44l0200o299020u920u20 U0990oU 09099

9 9O29

(9O 90202 020 00082UO 90000O29U000099(0

~O09 99U0O2000900uJ 2 000u01&o0A &00o o

J0O(22222oo0U 02 0.0O04 Jm1'ou0 000009U00U02

~222222220U0 9iU9u5A0oj~9il1A OO 2 0 oOOuO

~OU-daU.OUOO~4UOODU~uUOuOOOU-qOU2U.UUOD

J002C02220A992 1

19t00,,01.Am%4 99209002OjoC'0 02OUU00UO OOoU 00000l 220802O0UCD'D"UDUZO~Odu UOUZOUOUUU UUaU.DuOOU00OO 02 D 2A00OD OuDOOULU tUaO UU02022 2 2(0

zUO9122U&AOUAUUO 4LOUDUUOUUUUU.. UoUOU~U

o( AoAu AAo&oo uooOzOOOUoOuO00220UU 0UU0Ou22 0U0200000D0 2(2800 0U0o00AUU02 uU2U2U2

UU, &DluOuOuOOOuu"~.u�u~ AOUOuUDuUD,"uu

U,0OoUOUoAO20U0D UUUU0020 U0 0U00U0U0

O~2 UOoDUOUUUUDUOUUUOuD~uUoUUuDUU2~ZZCC

OOUZUOD2D~gOA~UU2 ....ZD OOgX UUU

U202222ZDOD ... 020 2008080 20000200020

020UJ002322202024200O2702000000200090022~

0020 2D000OODUAD 24O0000000 022 2. 22U060

ZZ.UUqU.. .. UO OIUUUOUOUU.UlD.9U.~ZZOZUD

00208UO2 UOU02OUUU0U0 -00800L0000220000002

280U00808 8AOA 0.. U022 02o802Z222 0200000"

200008.002000 020820UU 00. 80.. 8200 0.0IC 0,

22go9 2uOd 0I0DU UUU02~ ~ZZ~UUU2141OUOU

UZJ22OCOO0UOOOUlO4u22C2DUZO 2U2~O2292020IO

OA2A2UOOOOOOUOOOoOO 2 U9900020U20OOU oo

0020A000000000A8000 1M20008020002000LO00222

02220 92 2 20 00000 0000 00 00000020220g(C C

I20222000000A90A22"2008202002d2220CC0020

".UODUUUOUOOOO*UAU0 uoo~u, I2IuI2I~

000200020000082002200OU22000022222''' 22

0202222UU000 %1'" Qo2 I2222222IdI2222Ca

998A doj0~00U22u~o20(C2c2l2z2222222j2o2UJ2002222000900002222220dj202222C222o22222u

222 2U 2020 20000 0222 L 2C 0(2 22222 2 0000 22 2 2 2 O00000UQ2O0OQU0 2 2L202222200222222L22Q22

12CO0000000000k00C(R'70000 0422C222LL282

27222 200000 00.020 ~0U (2 222102 2 2022

~ ~~~uouO~uOUUOUuUOUOOuUUOoouo~0322220 0800 0002 002 22 02 02 2 200202000

C2200000000000000200C..20000I0022C-2I0030

7777771 ;(C

771777 IC77777C 2CC

7117177 CC717777 (CC0777777?£CC

7~77777 ((C77777 L CCC

77772 2CCII77 'CCC

77I72 2CC11212CLC

I1111'III2a[

77777 7 C

17777 .CC111727 22C

777777 EEC

171111 c

1177777 2CC

777777, 22C

1 77 CL

77777 IC,

171177 (Cc171117 CCC

I1717( CCC

'77777 CCI

777777 ((L

12771 (C L

'71777 I

17111 ((('77711 CCC

/7/7 L((C

'1117 L L¢L

777771 CCC

I7777 aCCL

77777 CCC7777712CCL

'27172 (1C'77717 ccc711171'CCC

17771 [CC

77171l2cc77777 2CC

77777 L'CCL't'

77777 ccc

899908609

C'C7 CCC

C7CCCCC

CC(CC

*A97U2U00 0 UO 0UUUO0 0 2UOuO0 0 UOOUU00 00100u0 0 LLCCCCLCLA'8UO8 020000U73000ZUU 0DZ009 00000A00UOUU CCCLCCCC

A'&OaOuOuOuo OOO bJ a" U f(O UGO OO OououL..LC(AA ...00.0 2..02..22 .2 2 0 .....018 0o (((...CCLC .AAODO U000000 Hu0O DDODO D 6u08o0 u00 UCL(C( ((CC

A.98800UU0UU0 UUUCDO0 fUOSOUU UUfoUAO LOOOUUOO( L(. OCCLL

A

I

AOOUU(000 0UUU0U0 0OUUUOOUU2 UU000A22222 (((CLCCCC(

,CAOUOO2000UOOO2OCOOOOUOUOCC(UCC((CCCCCC(C CCCCCCCCCC

9 2 0 OU 0UUO UOOUUUOUOUU0U000 UU0 UUU0 C UUCUC C(CCCC((C

9 CO~OO(OOOOOOOOOOOOOOUOOUUCCUOOCOCCU(OCCCC 2cCCCc~CC(002000C(00000000(C OCOCCCC(((CC(UIC`C(CCCC CCCC(CC

I, 0AA0UO0UUUU00COUC(CCCCZC C CUUCUC 4.. CCLE E CC:

.C 00020000000C(CU UCCCCC(C(CCC(CC(C(CCC( CC LEECLsC

OOOOO O~OuZ'OUUOOOCCOOCuC '~4~UUOOOOCCCCCCC(CCCC CCCCCC C C

' ,uO4 0UOOUUOUuuuuoZ Z ~ UU"U,~UOOUUUI.U~-ILLLiLL LCL

.0000000000000UU2U00000000((((U((U(OUO( ( CCLC((.C(CCCI UOOAOO(OUOO.OCC((C 2 CCUCCC C:CUUUCOCuCC C ~ LLLC( LC.CCc

IUU0000C00 U,80uU0o(o(o' .( ,(oC UC 0UU 090'~ C ;.CCCC(CCCC

020000000'~ 402 0(CCCCC0002002200' q '00 UO0 2 COCC¢CC ¢¢C

,I~uoU uCoooooouuoDooo-Uuoouu~Oo', ou uouuD o ZUU ,E ... C Ec

IUOU'uOU'4UDOOOOOOUU XlOZjlUUOOOUOZSOUOO02C(CLOLLCLC

0002202209 9eOO9OOOOO99990U}0922 CCCCCCCCCCCI009909~ ~~~~~~~ 909009:999J90 CC(CCLCCCc

99999 99U 99000C 0 20 9 {.C 9 ft90o0.9OuO 2C CCCCC(CCC£

D0 99 9CO9 0 DODO(.9C0C9 0 09 9 099UCCCC(. C CCCLC

CDUUO UO DDDCDU U C CCCCC o o:DCCLC £ CCCLOCCCC:

~CD~OUOOOOO0OOUDUIDOq~U22zUZOCCCC&£ ££C 2.* £C[£CJIL CdU C 00UOULE (CCCL --- - ¢ C. C C C¢CCCC

ic UUUDiUC CLL CC CCCOE CCCCC C CECC CCCC CCCC CC CC

kuObuOUOOUOULOCC(CCCCCLCPCCCCLCCCCLCCCCCCC¢( ¢L CDCC

lUDUOO UO DDDDDUeO OC DO OO ccEC~CC C¢C CCC(C¢ CLCCcLCECCcc

,OUDoUuUOUOlUUDDOUUOOOC¢OCL CCCCC(CCCC( COCLCCCCCCCkOLDUU ODOUDUc.LICCCZ C CLICCCLOCIC¢CLCCICC CC(C(CCL~ CCU UUODD UUaOUD(¢L (L. C C O(. O.CCCCCCLCC CCCCCLCCC(,( C ''

.UUuD OOUDUlD¢CC L¢C.LDDCC DL~22 U OCC~t C ZLCL(CLCIC.LUUIJO D U~ OUDUEDqq UDDqqqq~ cL ICLCCCCCCC

10D044 UU0 DCC404L40L004LCNLC~4qCGU-0q CCCCC. CLCc

°uuu~~u~CCCCC~~z¢CCcLC~CCC~

NORTHROP SERVICES. INC. TR-1075

:CCCCC (CC(CCCCCCC¢¢(Ca a

Cc CCCIC2CcC¢CCCC CCCCCCZCCCCCCCCCCg((CCC CCCC~C

:CCC¢C2¢CC¢CCC(CCCl2CI2L¢ ¢CC L22CC (C C ¢CCC C2 2 a C

C CCCC 2 C CCCCCCCC2 C22(((CCC (CJCCL((CCC 22222

C(CCCLC(ZCC(CCC(2222C22(((C22 222C1CCCC 222222

C 2C2.ILILCC (222 LCCC( C (I(22(2I2C 2C E L(LI CCC ICI( LICCC 2C C L(( CCC ((L2C(¢(( 2(C2C1222211C(? 2(CCCI...E , afl 22L2CC1217I

((C ((CCCLC1CC 2C(CC((L,1 (( (L122 22(( 272I1

(((CCICI(IC2(11 222220222

(C(((CI I(2I2(2222222L 2 122

(lL((( ((((21 (2222122';

cCCC(((C1C1C(1(2 Cc22,2

cCC Cccc ccc C C CC CCC 22 22

6 I8689

69I:)$

C 6931

8(l

807

All

L77

A19

86z827

83986J

863

ASS

867

I ,l

.A I

AA7 1

AA9I 1

866

891

7O1

705

717

'1""23

7261

I2

*1'~

7 .1

I's

799

IA'

I7.)~

;:A5

7.71

/879271,

979178'

186

Figure 3-25. CLASSIFICATION MAP BY THE GENERALIZED K-MEANS TECHNIQUEWITH 15 CLASSES

3-32

jC(C£CCC(£1:&.UOOUU...O.UUOOUUoUUUO(OjOU~UOUUaUdOMUOUI2

I

II

2 ,

r

- I - - - - - - - - - - --L- 1 --- -- -- ----------- I11 11111-4�

I'T

II

L-.:.:

A

IA

; I

I

.L

III

II

III

ii

9-1.T

oj

I

� I

j

UU

UIII

I

I

j

i

Di

wl-

DIIa

III12

5

II

UI

UI

L.

1

:I

m;

I

II

I

IJ

)I

II

II

L

uI

uI

o Z

l

r

)

Do:I

09

8[

ae

II

9*

BI

IEa9

9

a198

II

I[

7

II

II

II

I

II

III

IIa

L

I

I

m

Page 56: UNSUPERVISED CLASSIFICATION OF REMOTE MULTISPECTRAL ... · i (f t , lt tr-220-1075 april 1972 unsupervised classification of remote multispectral sensing data 172-27204 ic.as c 237s9e

TR-1075NORTHROP SERVICES. INC.

(L422 £ 2 9 I I4t I I02 la Aj Al 242 241'

I9.2A42. A I q 2 1 9 A a 0 4 8 . a t F 4 -

90. OF CLASSES 9E(&LD FRO I* 0 D 9

olUoU OUOOGUOuOOOUOOUliOOOOOOUUOOUOuOU~OOOOuOOuOOOOOtIII I lltlllllllllllliilllllllllllkl~tlltlllllllialllllllc2424('a421I1 33' '4S3 S'S 7: 1 1 74 .S 7g 3 o' oU:3 11l222244,0422(224020222I220000444L2000440220is00I0is AI221212222 222 1 ALL ILL £212 LIA IL A422422

LCCCCICCCII II ICC FLC~C III II 2 qq1 qqqqq~qe1 qII

2((2222(222222(2(C((2Cq (b91 19 9 99 19 9940

2784I 40... *2*A42 404.24.....0..7222(20 22.

27(2784C24CC4422494222~ 342244..22400422~22204,222004 .l(8,

CcCILI2CDLL(CIIC L CC I IC~ IIIA~Z~Z2~22~Z~7t~

27702441b4CL3C2~204C42 4424444410Z2242402202220400 29?

CcC72420C443440044424L4 2402442042A24042 4 2024 2 47,I'

7977444204340244444433 240?U44424422020.D24004422202C400 029224444242334244020J3244 002.444404240024404222204(42102! 42'

472727772222044444(48~e3 44044U240U2420D40000202022(42000 02I

5(224822223U~UD~] 222244244.24 400404400044004027402220022 02

272724777222/2224444498~ 4004222024041002040o00442022020oo22

22722722222222442244440 442040241040404042242242242022292 22

2,2277271 7 '244*4244.43 OUOOOD 400244240 24040,420220449 (97

i?7 D~~l4?44 ?40B22]242224DOO444 424722'400442242402DZ294 297

''''74412444*4494444994 24424244440220042002224220224224 227944(222)43323))4234444I204424(24024024244(220.244221 21 22'

244I4I3III.I.III3I323 4241024202222420402004440042142222 2I2

7.442224234~22440242444 D4244OU42U424440204444 b2242421227 22

2II .IDI I I I I IDI I I I I I&I I

;77~auesu3J~uulo3~l DUOOUUOAOU~oOODOO~OOI~q IDO~

C~~eJ3 B3 Ol L ... COAOLICuuDUIII I I I I III ILI&I A

?/t~aee~uu~su~tse~ae UUUU~UO~bUUOUOOUUUOZ~O~*~OUZ~nUL~eA

I;,.u~*au~~ I IUI I I IOID IDODI I IAI I2II I I I

?aBCUU~IC23IIIJ33 1J;1 00uUOOOO~O~&~0Z1,1Ig~ ~ 3s~~)au I I I I I I IUD I LDI I I I I I ii2?I

Ie$J~O~Slue OUD I(IIII IIIIIII I I I I IUU 2 OU2AA 2I ZUZ IT~

I I I L I 1 L I I I I D 1 I I I I I I I I' I' 1nOUI I I' I I' I'

DDS5'UUOO,,UnUDnOUDUDUIUODD~UUDIIUOUUUDO~hOUOO~nnUbSbUUUO Uu ODOPOODuUDUOUU"USSODOUU b50DUOO0~O

`) S'OU~oUDu OOUODUOU&UDUD._ _ U 1bDD UD I OD AODDOC2S, SoUP2 0,UU 00U 0 2uDU 24uU U0U44 U2 U D2 044U22U0 0)(2444UDU44U0D4UOUOUUU4444U,4U44S44U.,400U4004U

2SD..., _UUDU440UUU4UUU4U44U1,D(44 S44S0(S650U2AD4

Saev Duuoou-uo0uu~uuU"Uuvo Duus ~ ~ o~u

... ¥..UUDUPGbUUD'UUUOU Cb~uuOUS.bSS5Sb...SnODD;bbbgbOU..O[)UD1,OOUUb.1,U.SubS bb S e Ufi

22...404424OUuODDDUO444OUD2440(s2S40 2bS4245%002 U

22222S 422 U 4 U.UD4UU442244 UU4 SUUS 55U SS442 SU2229 U224 D2220 U. 2U

_, UP OOCUDOUOD9UUDUPULOCISUb~DS SI Sb5OSOOOODUnD

,bI1DUDOIOD "U~UDD~OOCUPPIbbA VDUDbbb SSS~0UDUOOI

"S. '0U UObOOU UPODO DOD OSS bbu8SS$Uo

JbbbOOUUDODDuuUDDU DbuO.U SbS'SO SS 'SS SVUoO~

1SS~OUSUDUUUUDUUGO~uODUOUDSOOOOUSnOSUS OOUOODL

~S_~U OOO hUU. O DUU0UISO bOIUSb50SS ~SSbUDOD.OoD~b$~5000DOUIUIOUVPOUDOODODSu 515SSbhbUK 5 bODDDODDD,VSSU UUOPOU's nUDOUuOUOOIUSUO' $SSSSO~SoOOO U D.U

4S29UD0O4DUU24 0DD OO, OOO 2O2S42SO22SS22UDOD0042

~eebo... fooooDoo OOU U uOSSSSo'SooSSoooooo~~OUU.O- ,OOODDDSDUO11OUSIS .. OIS.55ODOuOUDOOO

bSS UODUODU~oUOOOOOUODUOOSS uOO ODOOOO

DbUOUOOD OOOOOOOUDUUO0D~1. 1 SOOO11nOOSOOOOO-O-l

eb OODOO D POPOVOOD D S$DD $DOUD ubDODO So5O.oDD oD

bbDUUDUOOD UDDDDUOSDOOuS, 555uusOOsSDDODOODU

bSO,0OODUOUuDDODODubOODUOuOOOOVJUSDOD~ODOOOOOO

5SbSDUPOUDOUODDODUOUODUObDUDOOOO$SSDOSSDOO~DO0OD

4942 G O4D0 440 0DD0O DP 4OOPD4 SSODS2 OOD222222 UPDO

222222444~04000000422422422249222222222224002024

22220044002004 04222422442222 22222222222242004L

2222444000424002422(43D L2D2222DOSS264222224400D

SSU2U2 240442 D04 004 044 04 02 UOD 02 SOPS4 20 4 042 02200

422 22444002442044044 D0 400040 0222262UD 2240 00 0D00

IcA

OA

AA

D79

2 9

C 9

D9

IUA.I

.9I

ISS

P.

a

U(L

Ua

I (

2342192222222242422924222222212~qZ29 2222

~

721~ (4(

22I222222422472442222 7 227722

222222924* 2Z2222222222i2229244qq 2 277111 2(C

2221242222'1d42212124221222d~422212222 27222 (22?1]; r

:224,1,222I1 1992'A9I199"II9 22221 71 4.(azala12 ',"d,,"d',:tad,,laalqa da!~, 11;11111; ",tt

199919'419199291119191199,9l499 222222/zz//a/ 2221, C

2 "9l919IIlll2 ..... I7. 272 222999.191992411*9399 sa. 1 9fl21{9 19999199, 4222221; 222t

9 222222q qq~q2q q4q~Z . q 29 92191f j 9 2 1 1 9q ' 9Z 2' j2 flll;11 222

.2222212lZ~ ou 299991499 ,9tOf 91UOUOUUODUU[112277 :C2

'''222g 2 9l999999&AAUUD'2IM'OOO191219119IO0 2227711 ,(2

1411929991119l99l991,'A999@9991999 229221 222271127 '(

.0......2....9.....9 .00.2.222;22 I22

22444242222L220A2222022,22124" 40,424400. 11 Z1221 222? 22

2110422242220204AA12200i,2242042lZ02242422024 22222 2?22

40444244404400A 402204i242224 2 40022 2/222 1;117; 2CL

UdUVIqqqIqU qq'UIq D.Uq DP q*Z l ogZC J4UCCCDRZ ,d17JCCI

240d.2224A44d U GOOD DDW00L W0 DUVIIOU2I0 U' 2171/72 L((I4..44 ......... A. U'A: ....001 .U0U.U ....... 22272 III2!Z0U4A* 0 VPDD20 242 02442A2204000220020 227/7 (22CL

z2Z222~qq 'A A 'D 00"U2L2LO2P24022222DR2204 222 !72(2

!~IIUGP.C22Z~ U(UCL UOC DOCC DUqDIILC21 7721C(. CIC

44ld992929922299 D9999199999999999 92a 9LI ((L(((222L

4*9212199l29n.219a l92 n9'W%21999A1991'2 222(272..

AAAA9II2999fU 9 2 #22 92f~4,D.29UD 991 1 2(2(22(

02 did 11~~~~~~ccc~~

* A91999929199R11299212999191991999999111 ... ((2LCCC

.... 4999999199.9199 119 199922992 .... 92 ... ( R2(2(2(2

9219 191992 ((2! (

224220400222qqq2020 2 ( 22 I222(.2(2L

q24s004042242220sAq ~ 4 .(200((020((4(2 2((2s22((((2~.~L ( L(.((((2(

220424 ~24402(22(222d2dZ2(2( 222(242~2(q2(2 (2 (2222CC

40*0204d,20Agl2(((2(((((((((((((((2(2 C(((((((2(

12 11 I (.CLCCC CCLCCCCCCC

O~ C DOC CL C 6L OOO~gC .CO DC. O (......... C 'CLC .

A LUCC U£CDCCL C ~LCf C.C- I CC ~.LLCCC

DLDO~aOUOOOOOC ..... L C CCIC £CCCLCCCCCC. Oeec2 CE CCC.

~OOGU~OOUCC CC¢CCCCCCCC CCCC I¢lCC cLc ccc~I11ODD IA1u2UO 1bO I..£ccDL LCC CCC( :~-11 ICLCCC CLC,uauUOUDUOOLCCCC(CCCC A ..... I.. C(.A... UDDUC LL 2(2C CCL£CC~CC(C(....... C

~01~OLO~UuuO~~~~~~~~~~~~~c L C1 C1 CCCCCC CC ~ ~...1 CCCC

0u00444200( (2 2222222l 494999 1222q222CC(LC222422040222222299994' -...22 299999199999999 q(2((2(2(22

99994'' '.999 91999299 9

1~l99 9999 I(22(2C22('94299999999999999999242929 9~9 4199 II22222

S '24 I.,

I.,

144

*32

4.7

442e423

422

422

42z

442

4z?

4.?

743

242

2(7

209

2;;?es

220

I I d 2~2

2222I2222

22 1241144I 421244

C p22242441

(2242442

Cr2441222

22242242((((2222:L¢2r4(222222214222

((22,2222

(c(lidI42

2CC24 2222

((21221222~224 222

2¢4242222

224242222

Figure 3-26. CLASSIFICATION MAP BY THE GENERALIZED K-MEANS TECHNIQUEWITH 14 CLASSES

3-33

I,,IIDD'5'UUD..,,DUIDOUDUOU.USSUOUSD�D��UUDIIUDDUO�U

7�

ilIIIIIIIII

i

I

III

P:

.LI

I

9

Ib

,9

~ 9

U1

I

LI

Iq

III

A

,I

III

IIj

II

[J

L0i

AI

� 11� 11LI

11

A

II

II

I

IIE

I:

I I

Page 57: UNSUPERVISED CLASSIFICATION OF REMOTE MULTISPECTRAL ... · i (f t , lt tr-220-1075 april 1972 unsupervised classification of remote multispectral sensing data 172-27204 ic.as c 237s9e

rR-1075NORTHROP SERVICES. INC. 1

(LASZ q b · IS M A 1o lJJd I Id h 11 1.I . isI.*A.A¢I( I 2 .6 7 7 e 0 A 6 C 7 0 L 6 k

"o. OF CLIISL5 #L~GLU FlKO~ 14 to Is

JnO0bOOOUL)UVUO'UOOUU"i0000UOuOOU OOOUOOUOUU OOOUO''U i .. .. I .... JIIIJIIJII W'Z~,4tZZ1kl0 2 I zz ~ q~45 ~ 55 /aa9etOOOnl I I ..... 2J2J33 ... Iq q q bb b b ...... ) ?7 I /eeeevL(uu I I I I

L ISIV )591J ;9J~1 1179 7~79 ((776(6 7((6 77 i/l 7913 77 77 739IJ,9 59 5¥1b93lJJ; b 9 tl b¥IJI

(((((2(7C (CCcC C(((((72

(((((((2CC¢(((CCC CCC (77

C C((((C(C2( I (CI C C ICC((IIICCC7CC 2CCC ICICC CC?

I¢CC CC(I2(CCC 22CC C2 (2 2CC7CCC 7¢CC(CCCCC¢(CCC 777

Cr CcCC CCC C C C C C72242

IIICCCI212CCC 2222727( ICCC IC2C2C 22CC I2I7CC C

C(CC7 C 4 2( C ¢CC(CCC CCC2

CcCC CCC C ZC CC¢C CCCI (((

C¢(CC 7C C7CZCLZ2224C CCC 7

C7CCCCCC 4 7227CC(CC 2(¢CCC((( tCC7CCCZ C c Cr

((CCC CCC C C 712L~ ~21

C 7CC CC C C ((((1717(271CCC(((((CCC C C 7722747((CCCZ2C (CC¢(72222772)7

(((CC~C C 7(712727274

((7CC ((((CCCCC227(CCCj¢((CCCC(C((((7CCI 2772I¢

(((((((CC LCCCCC 71(C227(CCC SCc((((((42 ...C(7((((I2 I7 I C ( (227 2(17

I(((C CCC (I(I(((27727 I'

7?7 1 11 7*7*77732 33 77 7

l?;/8U8 7(73 73 77s777 7

777/77777*£C33777*77737;7/e£ 777 737 3 77sso 7 #J3

7 7777777337777777337*

777 o77 777 3*7 773s33 77

77;777777777777337777377777777I77711197777777177777777 71C/77 7777*#79

7777777;;77777777779777

777777777777777777B777777777777777777277776877

7777777777777777777777

77777977737333477773777

7 a7 777773733 3o77 3 7777

27274277,

77744222.

77744472.

(7424277(7744722,

7(444774,

C 7422I2,

(7747474

CC7 42242

(7424242.((((7277.(77(2774.

I((C27722Z((277272.

Cr444244.

(7247727273 22222

27224227

III 2 Z,2

27222272

ccczazLz,

22222722.((222222(2224424¢c(274227(7274272

(((42222((774277

2(2 22222((227727'(7 (72222(((27:22

(7¢2(2222((((42(2'

((((((24((((((22

.......... 777777. .. 777777777

......... 77"7--67 - ...2...7

...7,777 -7,7 4277 742242777271-l 1 217221 7 22274I

42,4266b46b272*21,2212 .... I

* 27(2 b7 S66IS 62 72I 2 I2I2III7I2I7

66 77b6612bb..2/2IC22I7 d

* 264766 b(6766SI 66666*6724 227262

IC 2266b b67666Sb6666b67 222222227

Cqqqq~q bb66664666666b 6 7622422226

C 74bbbb A. b66 I, b*77224222682I

C1 226 s7674266b,2 222(2426CSs22 I22 I. A IC I272272

C I64s 666 66b4 A76272242272

C 2b(66b S6( AA7727722272C7

*)qq~ lbbbbb.6bbb66b7767767b272422772

C 666666666(8*6 6767667*.672727242(2

C~q 66bb ,66 6bqq bb 272 466*226474777

.........b:lZ ..... R277...........

* q4qqqqqqq22Z6Z2766b6 7 677222*;2,

C 2676bq~bbb*bbb2.7Z22122ZZ22477,

77777 37b67 77767b776b222772626CC

n6b .6666 666 666666. 6666 *. 666 666662, 5 ', ; lz 2f

'5I SSbe5S5SSSS~55~S55~bSSSSS "

55V¥55... SS'Ssss~,SAS~55 -5 s 555 IS SI5%S5S3S

'Sb555~5%5%555565%SS~ 5%$~s55 5 55 1

,555555 s%55%s$. .5655....S...%.:0,b555

Is v 5555...55sss5�ss s~s SI'$$ 5555-5I5~

)~e 55555 5% S ..... SS5555sss55 5~S...Ss$5%0

666665566666 6 %55%(66 55566556665665557 665665666 6

.6 66 66666 66 6 666(666666.6677. 6 5 .. s ...6 7SS66W

ssvssI5 s, IS55%55's% Ib5,555ssbS I 56555

~%b~b~55555%55 55& 5 55b Asb5s ~~55~5S,555~555SS~55S st, 5, 56e95555s ~ 5q

)55~55555SS~$55555~5bb55b55~555 55 55SS Zz

)55~55 ~s5$55%S~s I555~55~ 555bSs AS bs~

.6 666 6(6666(66666666 66 6 6, 65SS( 56655 6666 66

,S95S SS~SSSSISs~SSSSS55s"5SZZ s'SSSSS55 5AS

.7776666666(666(66666666(66 66 7666~6666(6666(66

.b77(66,6b6..6($6666676666(6666 6S6(*.6 b6 1 6 (SS6S6

.7 (7 6 666 %66 66(6666 666 666,66666 66 6666666 666

766 7666 66(6666666 66666666 66 (6 666 66 6666666 6

766 7 766 6666 6,666 666(666 6666 6 666( $(6796 6666

.77 76(6(66 66666666666 6(666 666 666 666666666

.7$ 76 (666, (( ((6 666 6666(666(6 6(66 666(666666

(6 7666(6 6 6 6666666 66(6 66666667 66666(6&66666266666 666(66666 66666(666 (6666 6(6 6(66 676666 6

(~56(6666666666 66 6 6 66(6666 6666 (66 666 66 66 7

.666(6666 666 6 6 6 666* 6(6 6 7(66666666((66 6 666

7.

2.

q,

7,

q,

7.

79

76

7675

729A

II II I

5'S'

'IVI

,'9

2B1

29a

ICIII:9

a-I

I.tZ 2

a2Z

2 Z12

A I

ZAI

Z?'

21 7

:A

:7

:9

7919

ZS

IZ~ZZ~dR ~ ZZZZZ~i~Z Z I ZZ 1d I qq~Z1 1 lI; 11; 1I'l~ l

2J4771442424774422742447744474424242 77l7771?tCL!~Z~liiZ~l~21Z ~ZI~Z~Z~Z 4 2-q q11 111 PC L

r4/ql11Z1qqqld 21~II lZ 1lZJ124/~z 1 I!1 I'll,

I.n127441122 22474j7J2244244242477 77777 CC

/j q~qqqz qq... q ~ ..... ELLC

12447q2272224 Z444447 4 I777777CCC

424%7477477472444474477444J A A 777774Z bL~l~/1TCCC

llb&A&AS~~~~~~~b~SS~~~~b~~b~ S&S~A~SSS~~~~~~~~bS~S~~~~b~II L17 L

i~Z~ ~ZAAb~b~b~Zb~b~)Ab b2~2C~L 71117;CIL

'j24777777~2427742bS22 abb772 bZ7C77(?777774 7C

72474777 Z&*&&AZZZZZZRZZA5 SaJC 777777 jC(

777777 Zb~ab.77Z7i 422ZC~~ 746 74 7.77 77. 7777 4

S114 Z ' 1 ZZZA1 Z~i iiiC£L

,777777 AA777 . ,A. 6.2 SsI 7 I4 I ...9 7 7i 7777 L7 CC

47qlJ77qj77qd.S.77j¶ZqZ77i777777q777z777777 77(

1277777IIS764777472A 777777747If lI147(

772747724777777 1 4 'tia'H Zf' L7777777777 77787CCC

allz~z3q~ I ILL1z 2ZZZI2ZZC2ZZ~1 111711C¢L

21~q~2~qzqqq1q22qqqq~LC1l2q122/2Iq/I1lly? C[

~4ZZ4q~qqq4Z~Z22ZZ~ZZq~q2Z~q 177777 CCI

2 7I.. 7...... 6 .... I.......24... q274 ,

77 1777 I

* 7~7727742 777727 77777777772,72777 (7((CC

4Z7222LZ7 ZZCCLCZCCCC2 CZC42 77277777777 C(( CCC£CCCLCLCCC(

.................. Jqqq~q~ apanzq CCCCCCCCC

&AA" _:. PgZ2Z2~,qe ~~ _CCLC:.....

A .............P .... A; .... ...........Aa~q qqq qq ~ qqq qqq qq ~ q~q q~q q~q '2L CCLC..I ..

1AAq 1qN 1-qqqqqqq2222 qqqqqq~d 'LLC ICC

A~~ZZZ~L¢¢c I (CCC

qqqq~qqqqqqqqqIqqqqq1qqLCCCC

~qqqqqC qqqqLCCCECCqqqqLqCq&~22~[C(CLCCL[bLC C CCLCL6CELC qqqq qqqLqqztq C( ICC(CCL 7L lC CCC L CCLCL¢CCL

Iqqqq qqq qqqLqLIqqqICqq II qIqqCC II[(CCIILACLC[CCLI

I........ $q555S57'IIq1721Lzqq~qqq CLLCL(CLLC CLCLCCCIc~qb q$qqCqLCqCECqCCEIEL Z ICCLCGCCCC

ECCC¢Cb&ICCC ICL"C IZCtCCCC¢CICC ccCLt tL CCCC'CIIC

bCC SCCC5CCCCCCCL1C'I ICL CCCCC ECCL CCCtCCC¢CCCcCCCCC CCCcCC¢CCC cCCECCCE CICC:CZCLICC¢CCC

LCb 7(~¢CSLCC2CCCC C C& CCCLC;CCL¢CECCCSCS.SbSSSb$5a IbZLTC?7Z¢CCECCICCCICLetCC:CCC(ICC CCCZCSbb~LZS .. CCCCC CCLb(C CC LCCCCCCCC" CC;I CCL(C(CCG

CCCC$bCCCS ~S7CCLCCCCC ICCCI¢CLIIILCC.CC ICCC

~ b~CC b~SS CC~SCCCCCCLC((C(~CCCaCC(C(CCICIbbbbLbS LL£ 2CCCC-¢CC~CC ..... C(IICI

Z2~b ~CC~LLC(~~~ItCCCC¢CI

6 be'

II 672

I6S771

I7 67I

I. I7I6

72C

'Cb,

7.A7?,AC

L'7:

C 773"

I 33

I 77

A 77*37I

767

777

*63

*6'

;is

7.3

;iv

A.r

'716

;Te

Figure 3-27. CLASSIFICATION MAP BY THE GENERALIZED K-MEANS TECHNIQUEWITH 13 CLASSES

3-34

-1

7�

L�l

UIIASI

I52

111

7Z

qi

I

I

1

1111

111

1

I

I

Page 58: UNSUPERVISED CLASSIFICATION OF REMOTE MULTISPECTRAL ... · i (f t , lt tr-220-1075 april 1972 unsupervised classification of remote multispectral sensing data 172-27204 ic.as c 237s9e

TR-1075NORTHROP SERVICES. INC.

N2C. 711- CLASSES - 13 NO. OF I76ER6ION$ * 0

S A. P L E N U6 186E 0C42C 469'O'.COOCCCOOCCOOOCO4COCOOOOU.buOCOCOC40000007L71 ....... L ILt711 L IILIIII I 1LLL711122222222222JOu77 L717?> 2222373 1444444656%6666661777786766999990060.7 J17.222 22333 3 4446..555566666"777776886a 999£000tl,71LL2IJ57913J7')1 J47')1.34973575735797q 7 1579[ 9515L 15979 79195797 )757 9135797 1.79L579L 1S79135763.79/g15797 3679L15791

7777 7777 77 7 7 77l777i7797 77i7777i77l 7l717 77l 7UCi77777777777777777777'C77777777}7177777777747777 777 77i777 77777i77 7 7 7 7 7l 7 7 7 7 l i7 7 l7 7 7 7 7977l7777 l77il 17i717 l 7777777777777777777777772:771777777777917777777

2;}7777777777707777771777177777777 72'2':77177777 77 777 7777i.17 7i77 7 77177777l77ll 7 7777771777

47777177 V1 li7777717i7U l l l l l L 7 7J e 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 1 i

2 : 7 7 7 7 l .17 7 1 7 , 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 77777777771777777777771l

17i771177 i7 7 7 777777777 777 77 174 77 77i77 72777777i7177 77 1777 7777 7777777l777l7l 777l77777 7711777 7.7l7l7i 17 1717 7 7777777 77,77{777l77i777777 177777777717777777777777617777 17 77l7 ii7 7i7777 721117i6117 7l1 7 7 {17i7}17

16 4 9 " 92 C B-.7' 24 5 L1457646649o ,4C4"9,,6HCC,0C711

66761,6CCLZCCuo ... CCCC

6676444444 29 22026CC 4C666999 dCC CA,367 ,LCCC5

06664 6 ,t,7 , 6B C~8 64 4,8 9. 9 cc66- eeLLLcCCLeddfecCcCS

6,,hbI11tL1bIhCCL1CC lebI~6,t 6(,AB~C CC1 CI

9647 467467b 4 6676996894467,76606(, 7ubb76.71qC,.967, 6$ 6666, 7.7, 47, *J 6 9:

4667,7,6467,7,4.7,67,4C7de4

42'7.7'.,b2'SC"CC42C6CCCCCCCt)6bh-1oC LLLHL. '8C,66,,,.,76,766.766CU 94666~~B

67, ' 6 CC sd9 4 U494SU4

II7iu6 9CC.CL. IC"' 9971C

46IICLCCCCCI CC' 35C .. Irla777724I4444444494494664r. 214444 I4 1 ;49939 -I 46A-44606-7714 44I44

71111714477727444

1III714477771744

71777144

L [L444777444:

7777744A

7 1 7 7 7 4 4 477d222?24

711ii7147IIIlII4A

7777777477127777

77177267I

I1II7If.7I1II7I7774177 7*777

722222222Z222222222222222222222222CA122 2222 /222222222ZZ2222222222 6.L2 '2/2222222Z222222 2222222 22222 2A42222222222222222?2222222222222222 6.

2222 222222222222222222222222212222 022. 222/2222,222222222222222222222 2A

6422222222..Y22222222222222222222 9,

72222222',.222~?/2~2?2222222222222!C9l22.222I'I-222222222?222272222222C 6'

222.2/22222 ,2122222222Z2i222222 C?22222222i 2)2 222221 111222222 C'

222?Z2222 2 22222222222222222222 C'22222 * 222 2 222222222d C.2,2 222 2 . ff2~32222~22222t2 C127 2 22t22 2222222222222/222 9

72222/222222222222222222222? 2222 2'.72,Z2,222/22222222222222222222222 C'

422, .'22,'/22)2222222222?222222 2242222222 222 22212222 1222222 2 2IL

4222222222222272722221277Z22z222 22422. 2/2 //22 22777772221111222222 2'422222222, 22227,7771271 777Zd22717 2:

222r,2,22222:2?272721712777271777 79'22 12,22222,2 '£717711q22777117717711£22,2~222222 221//Z294q6I977211 7 4A

2222274 17476712122 IIzz2.z/zzzz~~~~r,~ bAR

~q44qA4~414444~4~44 44J41 444H41~flIo44444444444444444444706 44701 4G 7

14444444444444444444444404444 ; 17444444444444 44444444I45444444 1'

C4I4I4I444444I4q4~4~4I44444444I4 4

5414-444½4-444I4~44444~440441444424C4q4 1"4 -4444444144 4B4440444444Z 41

444444464I44444I444444½484444I4.IIJ

44.4441444644644444444B4B44444/ J4.

44,&41A, ~4*4444I 4444 4? qA 4~½4 Z I;~~A 4444444&4444ZI474 2444A4 NN4441I44 4444444B4A44444 IA

a4A4~4114444~4 44~44444444~44½41J4444~&4I4q4½4444444A44½½4444~44i442q4I4444I4A,,4q44444444½4444444224Z1l

II4I14~4~44464444.4444444441444½ J,

8IAIA4~A44AAAA &&~& 444444 6446424 H4L4

44.1 44 ~144~4~4444444441444444 9

6 4 9AA AA A 94 6 64A6 AA496686666446A A46 AA 6 A A£66 41 64AAIA AAA&&AA AAAAA .AAA A'ZAAAAAAAAAARq

4AA9A. 9AAAAAA44A66AAAA&A&A4 A&A&A.A&A&A&AAA6AA447,A&AAA�AAAAA44&AA6A.A6A&AA~AAA~A&'A&AA6A&AAAAAAq446AAA&446AAAkA667AAA&&A4AA6A&A&66A&AA&AAA&AAAA44

.A9A&AAAA&66&AA&4666664AA&AA&&A&&:A&&&&A&A1AA44A64AA6A 6 5A4AAAA &46AAA 4A&AA AAAA&AAAAAA&AH6A64A

-AA9A 9AAAA9 6AAAA646AA64A 6AAAA6A&95 6AAAA6 6 A6A7 A½49AAAA66699A6AAAAAAA96AAAAAAA6666AA6AA6A66AAA6647

LAAAA&4AAAA&AAAAA&AA.AA&AAA&AAAAAAAA&A&AA&AAAAAA49A6AAAA6446AA6AAAAAA.AA9769664AAA6A6AAAA6AAA6A44444AA4AAAA4A4AA44AAAA4AA66AAAAAA9A446AAAA6AAAA649AAA6AAAA966AA64AAAA96AA6A&56�.A6A967AA66646AA66AAAA6AAAAA66AAAA9AAAAAA6AAAA6A66686A66AAA66AA4

LAAA&AAA~AAAAAAAAAAaAhAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA&&AA*4~ A

,IAAAIAA&AA4&AA&&&AAAA&AAAAAAIAhAAA&AAA6A&&6A&499AA 9AA 6AAAA9 A6 646AAAA6A&AA6AA6A6A6 7 AAA6 AAA3 AA4444

,AAA A&AA&~AAAAAAAAAAA~AA&AAAAAAAA&&&AAAAA.AAA&A44

IAAAA~AAA&AAAAAAAAA AA&AAAA&AAA-A&A.aA&AAAAAA4&~&AAA.AAA4A&&AAAAAAAA:AAA&AAAAA&&AA&AAAAAAAAAAA4414AAAA9 AA4AA446AA6A 0A AAAAA A6AAAAA6 AA 6AA 9AAAAAA44AA61AA9A AA69AAAA69-A66A96A66AA6AAAAAAA6AAAAA44

AAAA9AA6AAAA6A44646A6AA *AA6AAA6AAA8AAAA4AAA644AAA96 6AA696*466*AAA4A6 6 6AA 6AAA&*6AAAAAA6A&68 44AAh&AAAA4 A&&&AA4A&&AA6 3AAAA6 AA6 6AAAA6A6 6AA6 A44

A A&AA4A4A.AA&AAAA&A~AAAAA&A AA A&A&6A&AAAA.&44A6AAA6A6AAAAAAAAAAAAA6AA66AAAA496AA4A66AAAA6A644

AAAAAAA&AA&.AAAA4AAIAA&AA&A'AAAA&.AA~AA&AA&AAAA44AAAAAA6A4AAAAAAAAAA4&AAAAAAA&AAAAAAAAAA6AAAA4446AAA6AAAAAAAA&466966A66A86A6A6464646IA94966AA44

&&&&& AAAAAAAAAAA&4~A&AAAAAAA& AA&&AAAA&AA&AAAA4&4AAAAAA&AAAAA&AA&AA.1AA1AA&AAAA&A A&&&AAAAAAAAAA4

4A.&A6A&6 66AA4A6&AA 69A&AA A&AA6&&&&&&A&&AA&644AA 4AA AAAA6 A&A4 6 AAA6AA AA&AAAA&& & AA&A&A&&A&8&6 44

AAAA6A9AA64AAA7&AAAAAAAA4A6A6A64AA46AAA46AA6A64

AAAAAAAAA&A&A 4AAAA .A A.AA& AAAAA AA&A& AA&&AlA&AAA&&69A9AAAAA6AAA6A6&AAA466AAA666AAAAA66668*666*44446AA6466,A 646A6AA6&A6AA6A6A6A6 AAA8 * 6AAA&6AA8444A

A4A&AAAAAA64AA4AAA&AAA&AA6AAA6A.A&A6A&AA&&AA&A46AA6AAA6 AA46 46&9AAA AAAAA&A&6A9 AA&AA646 6AAA46 6664466666966699662244 * 46644866669*666664666*6866644

AA6A6A&A46 666*6AIA 66666AAAA& AA .A&A&A6& &AAA& &444AAAAR& 4H84&&&&AA&A A&&&4A&A&&A&

AA6,AA743*4469*4A6A6A6AAAAAAAA6AAAAAAAAAAAA6444

6 4A 9 6 6B 6 6 4 4 4 "6 6 6 4 6 8 6 8 6 6 6 16 8 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 A8 6 6 6 8 8 6 6 6A A4 A 44HA966646646II44644466666686AAAA66686686866666686448

{1{4*64

{B .

dd

a8C

6 A6CIC

L~C

BC131

C~

ILC

8~

6{,4

C1

CI

C4

C4AI

&},

A,

.CAA~I4"4AA4&AAAAAAAAAAAAA44L

.A 227772I7799722299999929221122712222222 66666 77ll1A 22777779997727229999622262727222992 66669g lIDA 9177222999999/929999922222922222222222 66669 7776, 922222999992999999222;222299222222222 666666 IL

A 2I4'f92299972~226999992222 291222222722 66666( 71*4 22999q9999799992-9 ?7999272q9997229277 66699 III

A d227712299277212222 9222227222Q622~22 69696 716

A 2g772299222222992g q222d2222222222722g222 66666q 117A 977779421272 7Z29222d9222227222272222 66666 IIItA 2272949q22222 2?2227292222272222222227 66666 ILL

* 222t222722 22?)S¢99222 ' 666661 777.2222~222.47 227722222222222,66h666~ ill

7 2 66666 1i7A S222222.22 7772277227722222222222 S~~y/66666~ 717A422222 2 7 7727772TY2212927771727222 27222 66666~ '11

AŽl2 2 Z)2/ill?j) &22.j¶- '~ Ij g?222 ZZ2o'J66666~ [LA

L2 ....7 . . 27722 I 7'77 2222227 9.6 7

'277777772222214'4ag~2117lT.222222277, 9666 71022777772222Ž22IP22t?272t727227 I96666 7712 222222 7222772722 22222 7 72222227222 7 966666 'IA

2222272.12272222222Z2222227722222272772 ~Z66696 '/lO7222 777,Z /ZSSP22227Z222 I777Z2227771T7777) 66699 (~

A4Z,122?/ZS2117Z~1?Z117110 21171717/tt .666 99~

642222222?772222277222777177777 6266666 6A2'227277772217 4444444 666662100R4 12121 444*2444446*68864444444444A, )6666 71064444 444244444 4444A4444464444444466 96666 100

24444444444444444464444&446A 444444444467 96666 704444444444 A4446444444444&44444446444644A 66669 IL

A M444444 A4A44A ½4444444444464A 444444444444 )6666 170444444464644642444 44444446484444a 44444 .66696 IDA444474446444644 .4..4.4.444444444662 )6666 lID

a 4444444666 446 t864444714446, 6669610

* 44444444 44Z44444 4449444444464444444964A 6669 LID*444444444 44444444444444A4444446444666014 6666 a00

411444444444644444444444A444444446l 161 ,6666 1J0

*444444444444444444444444444444*66666669 6669 I006444444644444444444444444 A6669 600

9444444~44A444AAA447477711117i4T/T444.11.'.,6699. 000

444 ' 722274 77477111i44 777119711777 777171 I 6669 0D042e777422222212I771174727717717777277777166669 001

4L272242222227g27771717777777777771777771- 6666 )760

4666666614467 77/71666661117776 7767616P96, I666II III029617666772209662Z 776477 66 67777777nLT77777 6669I II:

9467666 247176 711176 776 1 666 66 99lLd

I7169 2764676 163666669716 U6666666 6667 76 O6

B?2Z4*446 6 264J 6 4266 6676666667171667 6716L2 6669111L1

6467:266422262461?67 177176771?77?77777777166161?17U

T7427117 77769666n66? 77677771777777777771 6661161 71J47 11646Id92166669,666661711 6 61166 6 66 0 6h211

I467R7777677 777776 77?? 777767777666 777/66U6 L. 71L7647147 346 6 6666770UD U1U7[,DI I OD

76077166UD/7.64667e66 1 ' 6 26Z61 21222 7/ ILILLLllll

1966676.76291666 224 2722i2 i117611iL

8422722161 2 2422 17222222222222222 L716.67IDl

822~22222222222222222222 1 727"2222222 7711L7 I12 - .2222 222222222 222Z~ IIIIIILI

441S222 111i1 222212~1222~2 111l7lllig,

,I47D ZD7?UDZ724.SZZ22ZJZi0 S 22222W227122 lll

:4,22222222,794 22222)i22, 2 22,222) 422,9 4 tl L.llt

:'44422222222''edd22222222d2222?22d2?22 'illll~lt

C8~4122d2222,?d2i2.2d2222222d22222222222122 HIilJil{C44422 2Zd12 222JgZ Zqd2222i222Z 2d222 Jll' ill a0182d?2122 d22 z222Z2�,2 2 2Z22222211}1l} klJ!

44122222212,222d2,22122222222Z/SS2, IlItIlID[

,?42?222e2222ZeiSM2 Pf22/22Z2222222222y/l lliii II,22Z,2222z2ZISZSZZZSZSkZ2,2d222222ZZ221, llillllll{

AH42Z?222Z221Z~2-222 22 22ZSZZSII~212~ZZ22i1 lIIiii.442,222222222222 22222"eii22r212222222, IIIIILlIl

AC244224Z21222272 ~2 2 2Z 22221212422/lillll!Z44Z2ZZZZ222,222ZZ4Z22222d2d 2222222 I lllll

'ZZZ222~ZZZZZZZ2222222Z222e?2222Z21z L::Itlii

22?ZZ221221Z222,122d222ZZY2ZY22222222 lIIi[?2222Z2122222Z2222222221222,e2 2227 222 7, lILIIII~I

ZZ22122?Z222222222221ZZ2422lZ42~lJ2J 2,t I" LIL

22B22R2ii'2112BBiM2U21d21RB122rB2e22B22d 1111mlll

2BBH~UAI:BZ B4 USBR2BR7 IR* d22B4BB2R~8.BIIIIJlI

9fiSUBSBO.BB{IHBB2BRO2?B82BH221eR2BR2R22Z2

~ B B

I I

B [

I

[

II

H"HI", B11I 1:111,

B44O4OP4;OBBRKBSUPBURRDBBR HRR " "B*I~LI ll

48R6&B OH AA4BB dB8448BBBRBBURH{BIBIBaBfi 13 B li 1llII

684A464BU~B§hB~aBSB8BUBH6BBb~BSUbBUBI83 I, L{[ll111L~i

no2H4Mb 881 HI2442 172Ah 22ZZSZSZZKZ(IIISBiIll[

2222Z22 Z222 2 2,1 11111111!9HB ;J BB~8.HKjB F ' IC~~~~o B VOBl' 11' 1

Figure 3-28. CLASSIFICATION MAP BY THE COMPOSITE CLUSTERING TECHNIQUEWITH 13 CLASSES AND WITHOUT ITERATION

3-35

4609

59 7

4C9

6 99960 1

'L 609

6C9

6225

61161

619

t 623

627964 626437

6437

4634963716 39

647566 7645

,649

'653

6645

64

66 1

66

66 566 706 9671671679

66 I

6,45

7051

77,9

77977477

73

735

741,74

749

747I74,3

I77

742,

757

711,

76J3769

747

784

7615

I

II

I

I

-1- ... I.... ... I.- ...... - - .... I-- .......193?r

70- - t

q

, , I I I, I I I ',, i

"I144

H

'I

IA

AI

C

IInH

44h

I C

s so;

Page 59: UNSUPERVISED CLASSIFICATION OF REMOTE MULTISPECTRAL ... · i (f t , lt tr-220-1075 april 1972 unsupervised classification of remote multispectral sensing data 172-27204 ic.as c 237s9e

NORTHROP SERVICES. INC.

NO. OIF CLASSES * 13 NO. OF ITERATIONS I s 1 3 3 31P 3 N I 3 33 1 3 3

OOOOOCOOOOOOOOOOO00OOOOOOOL.(ODOUCOOOOOOOOOCOOOOOOOO11III I IallI1 111111111111111111111111111111111 1111v22112.'22122

oool0131112222333 13444445t$S6666977*7 7st8888899992900000 1111122ZZZ1 391444446ss ebes66677 7 7 988B q 0~. 11,1i l21 i79 1g7 911?791 ,913s57913?355913 7gl 357?9 J913?9l 35 91 35791 715 ?9135?9 ?3.1 3579 3S 91IS791i5191 1S I

DCDDIL llllllllllll lIOCU 311111131 331 31113i iCCDDII 1331111131131311 3

CC llll LllllllI

OCODllIIllllilllllillilOC0 11111311 11 3113ZiDC 0337313313131317373il

oclllllllllllllll~llll

DCDOIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIOCQ1111111113311133111

DIIIIIIII IR3I3 L3111II1lllll333R3316113l17lDDII[IIIIIIIIIIII[111OCDI 313 131111133131 3

DCO III I III IIlll

DCDIIII~Bfil IlI}11

OCO333II 3L 1 11111111111C3I I11 3 8I 811111131131

3333IIIII3333111131334

70231111331811133311133

oc1111111llllllll}1177~

7c03 133 33333333333wil

3111111111131131111313411333311331111111111177

)ill[}111{}1111{[111Z111313333333313331333773I

~11iilllllllilllillllB81311llllllllll33lllllll31 3339813833lil3 lill3l3

31111111111113111113133

hhbdhlu8doc8 aOb5575 355h96668h 8888Cd8888CCCCC88"6866686.888880S8C5585C46666688ece8C8eC888C8654

666 668 hCC5,CC58888C55C4h666666888CdCCC888885534

66866.oCCCCCa88e7838CSCh6d8bCCCCCCLH d8 088CCSC 66O6488888Cdd883CCCCC5586o660664666668C5Cd08CC,8666666bb6663,687888789,86688 66 6668668888C888

6hhlb6 b.68 6688CC 8d8864666646b 66f186888C5C,

666bbd6666"66.88CCE078466666666686666CC 8 CC86.hh66hhhhh66hhhhhCC88CC5566 6666.666 6L6 6 4 98 88 d8666666666666668689888886666666 -b6666668 88986hh6666668668868088868468.6666686668C888e8CCC

.Bbo678d8C8CC5dC8CCCCCC66666988CCCCCSC8C8de8Cu66bbd8.C~888dd88C8 888

66668edCCCd888C 888988268888C'55C CCCCCCC35588C68d888CCCCCC88CC C88E88

68e8ccc55ssss55555ccee88I1319444444144444A4AA4

79044444771313444

7133L4444711144444

ltttll~4

73331344

17144446

II 444444I33444444

IL33444443737434 444

111133444

33314I44

13333444

33337 74 471111444

33333744

13174144

7113134411111344

111133444

117 71714

D171777417111144

1711114

II I II 41111444

31113713

117377334

II17714411II144473333334

D I IIIl4

31134886

71371384

I I, I I I' I

I3163446111I 1184I

73133333I1311313

DIL7,l 1

DI II I

22222222222d2222272222222222222222 197221222222222222222222222222222222 9822222Z2222222222222222222222222 647112222222222222222222222 22277222 A972722222222?22222222Z222222227222 A90722222227222222222222222277222 C4422222222222222222222222222222222 A972222222222222222222222222222222 69222 2222222222222222222222222222 A9

2222222222222222222222222222222 A922222222222222222222222222222222 49

22222222222222222222222222222222 49

2227222Z2 2222 j222222222222 422227722222222222 222222222222 A22Z772222222222222222222722222222222 A272222222222222222222222222222222 802

I7222222222222222222222222222222 427222222222222222222222222222222Z2 2A92222222iZZ222227222222222222222 2C442222222222222222222222222772222 ?C422ZZ2222222722727222227777722722 262222222222222777777777111772d772 2C4

Z22Z2222222Z222717177 71777727717 822722222222227777192271777777177 912222221z22Z271727777127772717777 91A42ZZ2222272277777991177 7711777 982222222222227977777946791172767 8222222d2226489 4 ad6

279499649163191779 76* 44B8444444444444444410R8BHR8H 18444444444444444444484444 448444 1A4844144444444444444444484844444 IC444444-444444446444444444844444 B84444444444444444444484414444484 6814444444444444444444444448444444 884444444444 44444444444448444444 4944444444444444444444,448444444 9q4444444444444444444448444444 494488444844444444444484448444444 41404444484444444444444444884444 41

I444444444444444444484484h44444 4644864444444444 444444448444444 4

444444444444444444444444444444 2E4444444½44844444444444444427 429^444 4-44- *X4' L,444444444444144X29444444444A4444444444444444444437 394444444444444444444444444444 17 19

464444A44A44444444444444444 3484 4

4A4A4AA444444AAA4444444444244442 12444A*4&4A 44444444444444423444464 2444444444464444444444444234AA42 94

444444444444A44444444444444444 244A44444~44 4444 44~44444444444~44 44 A I

44844444444444444444444444444444 8444444444444444444444444444444444 944444444444444444444444444444448 944444444444444A44444444444444444 614244444444644444444444444444444 91aa1q4" ...a AA-aA .aa .a...a',.T lt18

4AAAAAAAA444AA A AA4 AAAAAAAAA8 86 34A64AA6B44AA4AAA&AAAA14AAAAAAAAAAIAAAAA..A.AAA4aA&AA4AAAA 'iBfi8AAAAAAAAAAA8488AAAAAAAAA8AA6A8A6AAAA3&AAA4AAA84AAAA4AAA4A8A&AAAA8AAAA4AAAA4AA8AA8AA8AAAAA88448

AAAAAAAAAAAA8AAAAAAAAAA48AAAAAAAAAAAAAA8AA.AA444

8AAAAAAAAA8AAAAA44AA4AA4AA68A&AAAAAAAAAA&AAA6A44AAAAAAAAAAA&AAAA&AAA0AA8AAAA8AAA&A0AAAAA&AAAA&644AAAAAAA AAAA AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA&AAAAAAAAAAAAAA4,

8AAAAA4AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA&AAAAAAAAAAAA* 444

AAAA8A4A4A448AAAAAAA8AAA8A&AAAAA&AA8AAAAAAAAAA4

AAAA&AAAAA-AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAkAAAAAAAAA,.868888688888808888868686888866866808666886064 a4~AAAA&A AAAAAA4AAAAAAAAAAAAAA&AAIAAAA&AAAAAAAAB

A8AAAAAAAAA8 4 AAAAAA88A8 8 AAAA8&AAA8A 8AAAAAAAAAA444IAAAAA4AAAAA4AA4AAAAAA AAAAAAAA AAAAAAA A A 41,

8AAAAAAAAA4A8 AAA48AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA6AA4 44AAAAAAAAAAA8AA&44AAAAAAAAAAAAA4AAAAA&AAAAAAAA444AAAAAA888AAAAA8AAAAAAAA 8AAAAAAAA 6AAAAAAAAAAA44AAA&AAAA 4A8A4AAAAAAA8A8AA& A AAA6 AAAAAAAAAAA84 4

6AAA444AA440 4A8A48AAA8AA AAA AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA44AAAAAA&A4 A AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA AAAAA AAA AAA AA4444

0A4AA4A8AAAAA4A4AAAA0AA6 AAAAA AAAA8A&AAAA8AA&44kAAA4AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA AAAAA.AAAAA4A&&AAAAAAA~44

38088664600880464868*588888880*668866668666484

AA4A4A4 4AA4A AAA A.AAAA:AAAAAAAAA&A4A½41

IAAAAAA4AAAAAA4A4AIAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA AA'AAAAAAA418AAAA44AA*AAAA4A8AAAAAA8AAA6AAAAAAAAA8AAA&AA444

3AAAAAA8 48AAAAA4A6AA4AAAAAAAA 6AA6AAAAAAAAAA 8444

AAAAA.11AAA ... A.AIIAIA..AA..^AA.A..I..AAA.111

CC8CCC

AI

AL

A

C

a66

8

117771779971199799999999799721771719991'27777717999772 719999999997?99977d77999 79

4 977 72 29/9999999999999997 7 7999729722992 I"@7779 19 9.9999999977?72794999,0777?2Z4I999999999 77999999999 72799979991771772722 c

q 9999999917199991999 0I999919999?991

9997 19999777917974 4999977 799 9998 14 444997777779777777999979499977777177272294

97779999927T499999991999774777929722942297777999712 7799999979977 177421 7 72;1?)ll1797991?Y22117299772977727II777977777!7127999999772V7)99949 27kuiZF71112272777/=lm7 72Z222 Z

2 117 72 177172 222 222Z2271

! 22222222277777772227772277722212222222?e!222222222 7777 722272227?7722d2227772142 22222212 7222 Z 772227 t77 2222222 47

2dZ222222272, 22727 - 7i22 2 2,222

'722222777 271 7777d 1 1724227171

,71777?77271271772?221 7222222227177/1777 I 71 722222 2 ?7 222222272!

,1227.777222222 Z22L,7Z'i,27722272771

'22772272277222222222222127222222722277

'Z222~7227277222222222277772222.7777777'IZ7Z77172227122222 77227 771222 777777727*42222222277722222;7272277177777177~422272T 722/ 7222 21 444

44444449444444444444444444444444446 444444�46444A44 4444A444444A4A444444444444A44468844464444 64444444.484 4444444448A8A44448444 AA44A44444444 AAA444444444484A444444A AA44AA444444444444AA4444444444644

44444444444444 A 444A44 4A 4 44444^44 448488A 1,444AAAAAA4A4AA,&4AA4 AA44444A444444400434444444444444444444 4 44444444444444F844

444448444464444444444444444AA4448888 B8b88444444444444444444444A44464443 BB1 IBB F

8484448BAL44AA4444444444448444 BBOOB(OBn'~444444R*444444444.4-444444U 16444944444447 3 ' 717 1 1 71 7 Iq47

7 727 72777733111 7 77177177117172277772772222277777177177177111111777771177727271227277777717117777777711177771471222222722212777177 7717777 7 7117777711114922227222222222777 77777177777777777777777722122222Z21777722221777700DDUDDD7111174Z 2 2 222222212277l 7 2 2222 77771707D77771479772277211177/77 22~7I71177711170777119772277272227 f 721,777 7777777777727,779777772Z22Z22777122777D777777717777771771471777727227277777777 77777 77377 71777 711777272777 72777777 0777727777770777722 71771172277710777777D777 7777177777UDDDD0UU777 47777 7 77777DOD 7DDD7 7700D7772942927 '?DI1777777272488422227A ... 2222228C864 2722. o2 2227222222222222222/292 22 272 227222222222 22 22222 22 22222272 2

42222222 2222222222222222222d222222222226422222i92222922222222222222222222222227?442222222292229992922922222222222222222242222222222 2 2i 2222 2 2222422222422222222222 2 a" p222 4222222222422222d22 2222222 2222 2 222222222442222222222222222222222222222222222122e4222222222222Z22222222722222222244499944442222222222222222222222222222222922222lC844224222222222222222222222222722222999C84222222222222994999922222222222222792222222Z22222222222222'' - 222222222722222222'' 222222222222 2222222222

t2222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222 2222222222222222222222222222222227722222229222292222222222222222222222222 722222Z22222222222222222222299977227222222i22Z2222229292Z272222779137 177727422222722Z222229999929272272779779397222222222z122Z2222 17727222 2222 2222Z2222942227222222222222222 2~q,,2222~2222 7222722z22222222222222222222222222222222222Z22222222222222222222222222222222222227

222 22222 222222222222222222222242222222Z 7222222222222Z2222222222222222Z277222277

2222222,2Z2222222222224924222479177717768R3888888 136688- 88-- -- ' ..........

,I oaoauO9BBBB688868868R8668 8688B68iB38R8886B8888888BBR6BBSBS6R888888888E 8816BIRB

68868886688R868888RB88R68888688888688888a68888868886H688B838888888886688868688383i

888848486846B48408888B8688B888688BIB6l8 B

fB88888888R8888888R8S889I888R888886888R198s6s8688ss6sBe6886s6i80sBsess8BBBBRSRBBsB6668b8868688888888 8B6888R888R86888BB867

8448848864688888R868H8888868888886888888B

48488A688888888888488886898838888B81866

I4A4BBBBes8sB@BBBes888R88366818SB888llsll16886888668888888688888888668186ssS172222

688B88BB8886BS88883[1L79949 2j888884929992222 z 222222222222

722222 2 222222722 2272z222222

2222222222222222272222 2 2222

066669 OD666666 ,1

h6666 7D666669 DO666668 30D6669669 ID

666966 13666669 ID

666669 DO

666669 116h6667 I33666667 711OOhh9 I 11

666669 It666669 313666666 711666666 71166669 711

666661 7766U66713I

966O66 7D966666 D00

66666666 66 66

6666661D&6 6666 38

66666 D1

66666b 0.066666 0066666 3O0

6666 IO0

6666 30066666 300

66666 10066666 1OD

66666 300

66669 0066669 D0

66666 IDD

66669 DO0

66669 DD0066A666 00

66666 70866666 10066669 D00

66699 IDO

66666 3DO

)66669IOD

Ohhhh ODD

66666b 00

66666 700

66666 7D0

6666 3ID

313310100

131131l00113100DD0

313030000

hhhh9 DOD

331100000hhh9 ODDD

1111OO0D

1131007Do76666h7DD

331310DD0

331330000

111111DODOkl:I~DDOD

111100DO

hh99i DO

1111 30

MItDDODD

31131DO0

331313100333311300

3313111I00

311131DiO131331180

3331110011

IIIIIIDD

11113311013IDD1D13

lil3 D00

IIII0IIDD

IILIIIDD

3Ill13ll3

388111113D

IIIIL8ID1D

iIIIIIDIDD

IIIIIIIID

188111113

11I11illD

Bilitillol

3llllll11

1163iill3138*3113131I

188111111

1313311111D

ell1ll3ll3

13138BIIIID

8I113BI I I ID

R181111,111,

8BIIIIIII

llllml,,..

Figure 3-29. CLASSIFICATION MAP BY THE COMPOSITE CLUSTERING TECHNIQUEWITH 13 CLASSES AFTER ONE ITERATION

3-36

TR-1075

S 587589

599C 593

59S597

6 599601

60 h605607609601

h136l5

I. bl7

I 623625627

6336336 63563763I641

645

647649

653

653655657859663663

6h6

6676hh6736l36756776796816836856876h96936936956976947017C3705707709733711735

71372172372572772973173373573773974 1743745747749751753755757759761763765

767

7h169

771*7737757777797 3

787I7

769

791793795

l8AAAAAAAA8qA.AA&&.4.444AAAAA&A&AA....&&AAAAA4..I^AiAAAAAA;AAA.;A'A 4AA4AAAAAAAAA&&AA-AA&&A.AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA&AA444AAAAAAA&AAAAAAAAAAAAAA4,AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA4A.44AAAAAAAAAAAAA AAAAAAA A44,A 8A 8 6AAAAAA 6A 8 8AA4A 8AAAAAAAA&8 6 6AAAA66AAA6A8 44.AA 4AAAAAA'AAAA4& 4AAAAAA&AAAA&A4AAAAAAAAA6AAAAA44AAA8AAAAA8 AAAAA44AAAAA6 AAAAAAAA6AAAAAAAAAAAA8A4886*6888668666886848688866888*68*66688666688841X

86 6 6AAAAA A86A4AA8AA 6AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA4.8A4AAAAAA4& 4A4 6A4AAAA6AAAAAAAAAAAAAAA A& AAAAAA444,

AAA8A6 A 44A4AAA8 AAAAAAAAAAA8A8AAAA AAA AAAAAAAA86A8A&AAA4484&8444AAAAA&AA&&AAA&&A&AAA&AA&AAAA441

6AAA8AABA44AB84AAAAAA4AAAAAAAAAAAA&AAAAAAAAAAA4,

AAAAAA448BAA&4AAAAAAA&AAAA&AAAAAAAAAA&8AAAAA443AAAAAA8 484A88&&AAAAA88AAAAAA AA&AAA A AAA&A& A4444AAAB4 Ai A * A4AAiAA AAA i A AAAAAiA A 4*

_8648%46 8__ 6 _88886A 44AAAA44A BA44AAAAAAA&AAAAAA&AAAAA&A AAAAAAAA4~41AA&ABAA14'4AS4A&AAAAAAAAA&AAA&&AAA AAAAAAAAAA4A4411

8AAA 4AA6 8 444 444AAAAA6 AAAAAAA& A AAAAAAAAAAA 64 4A86AAAAA44444844486AA8A&6886668AAA& 6&6 86 AA 6A4A A8 6 6 6 8 6 4 4 4 4 * 8 8 6 8 8 8 6 6 8 6 8 6 8 6 _ _ _8 6 6 6 6 8 8 63-k A A AA3= - - , - -- - ,- 4 A-

J

.4.4.4 il~sli LkLILRNALQ

A AAA AAAAAAAA~A4 A&4AAAAAAAAA AAAAAAA AAAAAA44448.7T

JA I-

M&ttl&l&-. I _ _ _ _!- _ _1 --- 3A_ __ ___ . .- _vv? I

, I

I

L�

II

II

II

II

II0C0I00

D000000

0n

11

-ST-171

4

LAA

;4

4

a8

1A~C3C

:CC3Ca:lA

t

It

t

t

t

I

C

j,

6j,I,

3

II

4I

oI.I

11-1

5-T

le,

99

1

II

I

4

I

II

II

II6

14

44974

11

7

I..'

71

&"f

, 2

II

I

I

VI"q

I

A

E

IIAAAAAAA

's

2 1

III

IIII

.. S... -. .

I

I

I

II

II

I

II

II

I

id�IZZZZ222222ZZZZZZZZZZZ222ZZ2127221227,2 I- - - - - --

Page 60: UNSUPERVISED CLASSIFICATION OF REMOTE MULTISPECTRAL ... · i (f t , lt tr-220-1075 april 1972 unsupervised classification of remote multispectral sensing data 172-27204 ic.as c 237s9e

TR-1075NORTHROP SERVICES. INC.

NO. OF CLASSES 13 NO. OF ItER6t1lONS * 2

S A M P L E N U N Ri E RooooOcoooooooooooooooOOOCOOOOOOcOOOOOOOCOCOOOOOOo0 l IO I t I I t lt II l II I ILI illl Itti ll l ll I I ill Ill 122222Z222222E00000 ILI 1 1212 ?2 2233 J3344444555556666677 7 77888B89999900000 I1 11122222 3333 3444445555566666777'78888899999000001 111 2

135791357qi 35741357913579 1 35T9 3579579 1 s 3l ]791157913S79t 35791 357913579135791 357913579135791357S 115 91 qISc791t35791

III I11 I I I II1I lI II D 1

li}11111111LII11|t1111llllilllllll ?

lllllillllllllll~llllil

1lllilll1llllill1710 II

11111 I 11111111i i110llllllllllllllltttllll

111 11111111112IDIIOOII I

111111111C111UDU110

11111111171118b111 IIID

lllllllllrbB~llllllllO

LIIIIII II I^ IUIIIIII11111111~131111077110111111111 Hlil 70II 7II)I

111111 111111I1 I 1111 I1D1111 I I ~ IDDOOODIDD11111111118111111111110111111I 1 1 111 IIDD1D7DI

Illllllil lDiIl~lllll

ILIIIIII6IIIIIIIDIDDDO

111111 b11111111111177 i

1111111111111111111113

11 1 1111111 1111111IDIO1111111111111111111111I l11 Cl )l l lllU II I I ID/D

3I .

66686Nd Cdh88 N83dhCCCC8

66666.6C8HC88dC8NddCB

66466 8CCCSC58778C 56686664 H88CLC8898Hd5566 866 8CCCCC 88833 'C566d88CCCLCC9870388CCSC

66.6 b~dSHCHHNdbCCCCCC'.66668666666.68CSC888C8

8666660-6666669iddUdd8866866P666-666s8~8~8e866666"6066 668888NCC58666666_6W 6888CC88866668 6 666(6666886eC8

66 6660i'-66 oB6CC~dCLL666646646-6"688C888NC66666666,6564 6840 88366666666656666e66d788

656B66666_666HCBHSMMCCC$61,69eeScdcCsecScLCCC.6 ... dbCCLCC5C BC 888C466680C484 H884 88C8d936668d4 4CCCd4h0C4888 38

5 84 884CC 0CCL3S 3 38C4HH8RHLLCCSLL8CLCC 8CC

68H CCCC5555555555CC833ICOnOC(414444448A44448AA

7 7 ( ( 0;?ODODUDU

1 7010 I 0CD4?CUODDDDDO

7,IDOOCGD~4711IDCLD471DIDDDO4

II I0DCb4IC(DCD44

I 1DDC41I4

I I I7 C) 44

I 1111D4114

111(0(0(0111 IC Ol

11 71 loCOIIII C0CD0

IIIIDCUD~

11?11[CDf(0tLIICDCUO

I11II0DD(

I 00 0V

11 I[)DCD404111IDDD4IIIIID4D44

777111Dl1II 7700Ul

11770172711 *CDDCt

III 10(001LILDCDD[1117D(DD171707D0D

IIID 7CD14

tIIIIIIID41110110[

1L1I18h84

1111 1880^,I1 IIBBi1111B

i2222222222222222222222222222222Z2 8D722222z222222222222222222Z2222 AD8222222222 222222222222222222222222 AOk1722222222Z22222222222222277222 A9127 Z222222222 222222222227222 AD8722222272222222222222222277222 Cl02Z2222 2222222222222 22222222222222 A2722Z2222222222222222222222222222 89D22 2222222z222222222222222222222 A922Z2 222Z2222222222222222222222222 22Z2 2 A2 a

222222222Z2222222222222222222Z2 49222222ZZZ222222222222222222222 22 2222 C4

f227222 222222 222222222222 4222272?222 22222 22222222222 C?,27722212 2222222I2'2227222"222222 83.I22. 22Z2222222222222222222222222 822O 2222222222222222222222222222 2 C4.

D222222Z22222222222222222222222 28D222222222 2Z222227222222222222Z22 2CLD22Z22z ?2z222zz22222222222227722Z2 7CD22222Z222227227272222277777227ZZ 2A82222222222222171 7777001I II7227 72 2CP

I2222222222222737777771777727777 2322l722222Z2222777779227777777777 9A22z22272222277727777277727777?t7 91'2222222271277?779(11777771 1777 9322Z2222222227DO 77CD94609117727A8 8822122222260BO7 83S

l 2ZZZ22222? )BDD7U7)tA~ o

rO 44848444444444D400D00088B88RB 18 444444444444444 4444444404BDDBDU ICA

5C 844444444444444444440444404BD44 44 C3S 444444444444444444440440DDD4444 88,SC 4444444444444444 q 444484400DD444HC 88

)4444444444444444444444U444444 B8

C 444444444444444444446 44444 495 444444444444444444444484q½44444 89I 444P444444444444444444O80D44 C 49

C 44HH44~4444444444444448404D4I) Dd 4b444447104444444444D4)4DOi4440 41,

?9 4444~44444~444403448½N4440C 44,C 44H8L1444444444 444 444040D444 9 ,43 444444D444444444411444480"44444& 833 444444444444444 4J444444D4D00444 405 44444444444444444444444044DI Ul 2)d 4444444444A844444444444 COD4 (0nl1 1d 4444444444444444444444404D110D 17I7 44A4444844A44444444444444444420D3 2O 4A4 4AA4448A8A4444444444444424l 1 7

44444A4A4 44444444444440400[4442 2C 444A4848444444444444444442 34AA8 278 4444444444A43A4444444444O4D218DU2?d 44A444 4444444444404444044411044A8 44A 44444444444444400D4444044D047IC 444444 44444444444444444444444(4 LI3 4449444444 44444444444444904000401S 4444444444 444A4444440444OD D0 004 07 44 42D4444444A44A444444444444444444 9

O4 88A 88AA 8 444 88 4 88 8 3 83 88AA A848A,88884 8438834 4 3

8AAAAA4AAAA4AAA.AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA4qAAA44AA4BB38AAAAAAAAAAA44 4AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA4 AAAAAAAAAAAAA441

84AAAA8AAAAA8AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA844AA AAAAAAA'AAAAAAAAAAA4AAAAA8A88AAA 8 8AAAAAAAA44'

,rAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAqA44AA4AAAAAAAAAAAAaAAAAAAAAAA4A8AAA8AAAA8A8AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA48AAAAAAAAA88AAA84

tAAA&AAAA AAA&AAA &AAAA AAAAAAAA'AAA AAA&AAAA 4AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA&AAA AAAA AA AAAAAAAA AA44

,A AAA4AAAA4 AAA AAAAA14AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA~AAAAAA48AAAA4A4AAA4AAAAAAAA8AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA444

,AAAAAAAAAAAAAqAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA&AAAAa4AAAAAAAAAAAAA848AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA8AAAAAAAAAAA44

,AAAAA4AA&A%4A A AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAhAAAAAA414,AAAAA4AAA~A AAAAIAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA AAAA AAA4P*4

lAAAAAAAAA4AAaAAAA4AAAAAAAAAAAaAAAAAAAAA&AA4 444AAAAAAAAAAA8AAAAAAAA8AAA8AAAAA8A8AAAAAA8AAAAA4488AAAAAAA4A4AA4AAAAAA4AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA8A4A84

8AA48448AA444A84A4AA88AAAA8A8AA8AAAAAAAAA84444AAAA44A4AA4444AA4AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA8A8484

)88843488^44448848888888888888888^A88888888344 4AAAAAAAA4AA4A8AAAAAAAAA8AAAAAAAA8AAAAAAAAAAA444

8483AAAAAA84A8A8AAAA8AAAAAAAAAAAAAAA8AAAAAA8A44

88848888388388888888 8883888888888888838888^444,AAA4AAAA&AAA.AAAAAAAA AAA^AAAA&A^A&AAAAAAAAAA

4AAAA4A44A84 4AA8AAA8AA88 AAAAAA AA AA8 AA8 A AA84448AA&AAAA8AAAAA48AAA q888A88A8A88888AA888AAAA8844

,AAAAAA4AAAAAA&A444A8AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA&AAAAA4A4,AAAAA4AAAAAAAA4AAA4AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA44

8AA38A4AA 48 A4AA8A AA AAA88AAA8AAAAAA3 AA388AA3AA444

AAAAA84484AAAAAAAAA84A44A8AAA88AAA&AAAA8AAAA84

8 8 8 8 4 8 84 8 8 8 8 8 88 8 4 8 8 8 8 8 8 8 8 8 8 8 8 8 8 8 8 8 8 8 3 8 8 8 84 4 8

388A884848888848^4888888888888888888388888834848388888888448888483888888888888888883888888888 88i4

AAAAAAAAA4AAAAAAA4A4AAAAAAAAAA&AAAAAAAAAAAAA4

8AAAA888444AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA4

,AAAAAAAAAAA&AAAOAA4A4AAA&AAAAAA&AAAAAAAAAAAAAAJ

844AAAAAAAAAAAAAA8AA4AAAAAAAAAA8A3AAAAAAA4AAAA4

AAAAAA4AA4AAAA&AAAA4AAAAAAAAAAAAAA&AAAAA AA6AA~A*4AAAAAAAAA4AAAAA4AAA&AAAA&A AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAJAAAAAAAAA~AAAAA~AA4AAAA&AAAAAAAAA&AAA&AAAAAAAAAA~

AAAAA4A38484A A 8AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA444A4

AAA8 AA8AA4A4A48AA&AAAA'AAAAA A 8AAAAAAAAA8AAAA44AAA.ABA4~4AA4B~4AAAA6AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA6AA~AAA

8AAAAAAA4438A4 8 8AAAA8AAAAAAAAA&A8AAA88AAAA8 8434

AAAAA4848B4A AAAAA4 8AAAAA AAA&AA3 AA3 AA 8AAAAA8 448AAAAA44A A A A A AAAAA6A6AAAA4A A

BA&AA4AA4~½ 4. 44AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA&&A6AAAAAAAA~44A

IT(I 77777779?9971727999999992999r 277172779 99977,

9777279999999999999999777999972972299273 77797999999999997777q~2799999977722229

O 9999990999799999999997279979997777?2722[]9 9999997?99997999f?9 997g 79997q9?97711

999779999 77977977 999977799799722299977?/97971777/ 99997998997777777 Z17297

1 9777939992779999999799977779q2977229222OU977779997729??O9779999977?q r92777927229W7777999772227729977291772772777077777998772799999077297090992727 9

7 97227277777 7722222222 f222

2~~~~~~~~~~~~~~22

2!222ZZZOZ 7777722222222777222222222222172 22222222277777r77222777722;7372222222d2222227222222,227777772227222777722222277722

22222222272 22 ~22 72227L277j.122222227,

202&~~~~~~~~

D222222227722I2 27Z&2 2122221221D722222777727W1127 ?772 rl2~7222277l7

! 7l 7 7l7l~ 7121' 7 1.222 1 7~j22..222 ....7r77777777 21222 2231 12222222222127

2 ~~~~~~.~

0277772 222222 722 P8?2772?727?

A22772272277222222222222272222222722277

12222722272772222222222277772222277777777

1 22277722?77222227722777772227777777727D02222222 2722 22277 1777777777

4O22Z7~7 7772277222 ~4444

0~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

A~4½DUOD~O4~4~444~D0 6~44488884944444444A444440(0044 444444441,49444444444444484A4,44nDD4LDO~444~44444444444AAA44444~O4444½A,

444004DA044444AA4444444444AA444D40444AAA4

2222222222000024442444440AAA47444004444 '

x444A~AA444444AA&4O4A AA4A4A44q41q44414AR

~444 A.AAAA4A4AAA4AA4 AAA4q4444A44444&44b,,½4444~44444444~444444~444~44444444444BBI)D

241444q44½4 444444444444444 42444AA44 D2B,4D84444½444444444½44 444& 4444448½8 BAbBRB,

,4D04Bab 444 A444DD"448 DA4UH4048BR31BBHB UB'i440444 L4444444 44DD44 4044 42O

,8C8 0102444 72222 21122 7

22722Z2Z227ZZ2 7? 1771IIl 7fl9I 17

171T7I~~~~~~

17 2222721222277771222772 772 It 2272272

)27 ??27222l22jtZ2117711718Z 71117 2 71;272 I70??27ZZ?7772???72 71?Z???1772/O

177727 7 277777777777777777777 11711rT

77777227777711777177777777777~77197772

711f7779197?t9999 9772 77777791709D49 22

77999779?U99994,9999it 79?..,9C~66 2 22 Z92OZ22?iJ22/2

2fZ2Z299?Z222222222292222Z22Z222ZZ7/4222D2,22f222 222212 222222Z22222722722

8422222222?2DZ222222Z22Z222222 22z2!4Z22Z22D222D0qo2222D22202'2222222ZO222Z2

U22222222 ~ 2 .i2m2. 2 2 22D2222 2022222Z2222 212 2 2 A 2 2222222.2Z

2 P ADA 2ZOZ2 2227 Z222222Z22ZZ2222 2728422222ZOZ22ZZ2 222222 iZ7222 42222222247DD27177222222 22 22Z2222 2222227272

2S 2227221DZ222222Z22222222212227222224222Z22212Z2222222222222?22222272Z4477

4 227 ?2227722222 2222?ZZ2220z202222/2

2222~2222Z722Z2Z2272222Z22ZZ OZ2277:Z

D 2Z22 Z Z2 2ZO2 22000DD2222?222O222Z222222

42 2222222212ZZ22Z222 2U, 2O

2222ZZZZZ20DOOZ272220DOIOO7Z?2222112

2Z2 "2^OZDDOODOD,227277q77~0722Z22222Z~

22Z2222D10222 222222 222222222 200222

!22222222�2ZO2Z2222ZZ22Z222Z222222i 0222,17~2 22 22 2 222 222ZZZZ222222 Z2 2Z22222221222222722Z222Z2222222222222222222222222D272Z02Z2277

424222422DD220D44Z27422220ZD44444444?72227

22222OZ22 2222Z2ZDOOZO0771

44DBBBSBBB 2BRIBS 2RMan44242?22.4oCooo.2

}BBBBB4848BBBB FB4BBBBBB888tB~

~SBU~~~BO~BBB BIBR BB K.1RBBBRRSI

10BB ABBBBBBBSBBSBBS aBB BeBS ROBBB88BBBBB{

44B48BA4BSBSBBSBBB4BBBSHBBSBRBSBRB4BB~ {

,4A4BB(BB.BBBB~BB~BSBBBOBB$88B618UB~ttSI~iU ,BBBBBORROCROBSBOBSBBBSF80RBIBISBt?2222]

4B888BBSiRSROBORBBR 8RtIDDUDD2 I

4BB058DDiDOOD222 2222Z22222221]2Z222222222222 2222 1

CA22222Z2g22"_j 22 O 2~22222'22722zd

:6666 1t'l966666 6 11

868868617188888911119666668 111

668 698 III66666: 11l

866 66 II666669]1.1

666669 II866669 II

66666 r LI

666687 711866669111

666666 7It

666666 711666669 711

6666966 71666

966666 71lq66666 711966666 71188888 I

66666 '6 66661r,6666]17166666 111

86666 Ill

S66666 Ill86666 III

86666 Ill86666 Ill

86666 ILL

86666 Ill86666 I.

86666 ail866669 Il86669 Ill86666 Il6666" l l

86669 711

66666 Il8666 711

8 6666 I6669 III6999 IL

6699 I6666Il86668 Ill666671

6666 71186666 ll

11111 711

.........Llllll~lll

111111111

2 ilillilLl111ll11llllllll

11lllll11111111il"llllllllLllll1111

L11l111117 lilllill

L llllllll

l lllltllll

Ll11 11

7[lillillllltilllll901 t tI| I I

111111111l111111111

31111111111111111i1111111l1

11111111111l1i111l

111111111

B18BIIIII

111111t1l

1l11l1111

111111111

8BBBIIIII

IB LlLILB 1111111311LI 11 11 1

1111111111

I IIIBIIIII

3118BIIIII

IBBBIIIII8

11811111111888811111

IlliIS lIt

I111111111

IllBlllll.11111t1l1

.1l111 1111

-11

Figure 3-30. CLASSIFICATION MAP BY THE COMPOSITE CLUSTERING TECHNIQUEWITH 13 CLASSES AFTER 2 ITERATIONS

3-37

c

A

IL

N

595 5B9

II609693

59 7

6598I1803

805815681

6 2 97

61I623635

8217829

6 33 9

641643

8464784965165I

655657659661t63

66166 669671b7387

6BI677

681683

687689

691693

695897697

701

7C570 1709711013*1571771972172372S7277297317 2735737739741743745747749751753755

757759761783i65787769771.7737757777791BI1783

i857877B9791793795

Di w rr II??7? o97 99 9 · ssssssss r 2 77 1 Q 79 Y9 I /-.. .. . . . .. . .1.A7rI

Ill

X-C

L.

114444444

14:4:4A:

I8a4;

4

, SA

L:

I Di

148(

,CC

,A(

'AC

,A,C

~C

,ILIC

IC

C A

BACA

BA

BA

4C

Page 61: UNSUPERVISED CLASSIFICATION OF REMOTE MULTISPECTRAL ... · i (f t , lt tr-220-1075 april 1972 unsupervised classification of remote multispectral sensing data 172-27204 ic.as c 237s9e

TR-1075NORTHROP SERVICES. INC.

N0. (IF CLOASSLS 7 14 N0. OF I71R977ONS - 0

S A # P L E N U # Bs E ROO01uOUGOOIuOOOOOOOOOOOOOjo vu tl)OOOOUOUOUOOCOOGOOOOOOO011I 1 t11 I 11I1 1 III1IIIIt1 222222

00000 11]1(, 22, 3 I04444.O550 5566666777?77d88 A949090003006 1 II 112222 ]J7 1 7J44½447 5s 56661 6 77?7777817R2Sq 2q O01 1112 273I ]79 7 7b 77'57l) 7 I7 qL J57gt 57(71 lb 792L/{ 791 ]791347*775791 ]77aI721 ]5 771]'7ql]'791

11117111711i11111111111

7 11171 7 It II 77717 7C I II 111 771 i 1i iI1171 117

[11777777771777111111ill

7717771/i777777 7i1771111

11II I B111 11 iit111111

77 I7I7777 1711 11717 1ilI &171iii11 770711 711111 7 7 7 7 7 1 1 7 7 7 7 7i 7,7 1 7 7 7 1 11

777117177477,777711711177CLIIIll17 I2111711212

0121 11 1111177177 7 7111I C 7 7 7 7 7 1~ I I 1 7 7 7 7 1 7 7 7 7D i4 7 7 i t 1 1 1 7 7 7 7 7 7 711 7 7 7

i7 7 1 1 1i7 7 7 . 0 1 7 7 7 7 177 1 7 7 7 7 7 70377 17777 7 1 171 1

l11111111917il 1711171{I L7 I I 7 7 7 1i i 7 7 7 7 7l l7171171111717171177771t

111il1717i11i7 1777177i7

77777 II I IItI t I I III 7711II IIi iI llI tqtl I tII IItII

b64 406,7O~Ct 47,7 7C CC CC 0743 64b46 6,- 36.C CC-05C7

46467,8'(.(CC '.CgCX~CCC

6646 47. ,.C~CC 607 6 6 4 CCC466"OCICCCC 60$U688CC5CC66 4 , d 7,,.C :74 " ,CCL CC b)746 637,6067,69CCC 6 7 , ŽCC76447.C47.7,bb66, d d. 7,700600

bbbo66~(,~c'5~~b b~~664,4t, o6667 6CC07CC4664444447,67,4676Ž6 22C 646_ 464 C,4.744.7 9 0

66 6 (6~6(, ~d8 846 444Cc. 44646O6 0 66 32 6Ap667 4.6 6 4I7.6P6624d000

6HH66b46b,7 oo6n4dAC6 CCC4773'.,44777C07.43CaCCCCCC466647o-,CCLCCCLCuOO3C6

66 47 07CL. 6 2- '. 6 6C6 I3066 64 4,7, 0 A7 I OCI C C 6 67 663 47 01906dlaa3-L4,CCCCC7L345. 79C

.dd,,ccLCL15~LL'~35L~d07112444444444 6A446460

2222~222~2~222222222 22 22222722712112,2122 212222222222222222 2d2.2i222212/222222222222222212

,1212222£2Že/121222222122222222/22,*222e2222.2I12Ž2?1222221221222,212,.. 22'Z2222Iki22221222222 ?222122,2..ZZ1.221.1222I/I22222122222222222,.I2212de2e~211111122222122222I2I2;l2ed122222I222222I22222?22222 2222

71222112 11 12 2212211112221I2,

.1222222221112,2222222222Ž22 22.1211122dl2,122 2122222212d22I22222,2217d222llz222d2222122222122122112 221¢d/22 f2 lZ'422222212222I2717 2i2211111212d !?222Y21212 2212 ,

L2,zl2l2e21222Z2222222222222l22L

/, 2212/1?1 ,11d,12222222222 222422IZd222eI 2222eI 22222222222

422.1/22?22I222222el22277222222I22.2222222.227717272121112212122

I2I222112II 2177?7127171122112l2?2,2212l222/2127.271227712271717212222222121212127172'22112117717

722'212121Z 27771977 117177 717I21211,I22 2222?Z2612L44619172?A21222222224e4,'

I 444½40 4444464464444418RHHHA944444644444444444446444446944 4B444444 444444 44444440410½44½4

54444444444444 444444440444 4 44

44 444l4444444444 4444444 7 644444 04446444444'444944644444440444444444444444444 4444444 4444444 44

444444444444444444444440444444

4477444444444444444464444 44244: 441144464 44 -4141' 4444664.440444 44

441444444444444444444040444444$44664464l444414 4646464048444644

~4~A,,-4AA4.4474 44444A4444444424~644446444444444444444½[4444444444444444.464444444444464424224

I44444444444444444144444444444644440 44 4404464444 4964 46444 44464424464 6464464464,6 644464446446444444217

344A404l64 46444 4444444 444442444 464 21444 444 444 444AA 46444464647444666 04444A4"44446446464644464426424 146I6644A4 ll4644444446446644626444646764444444 44 444441444444444246464444

I4449464444141444444446444644646444 4644A44444444444446444444466464417~

6441444144444444444444446464644644444/4 4144444464494446 144444464l4~44446

466.A746664444040074544600460040006374AAAA74447~AA74A&AA37 AAAAA347 6 AA0A0 AAA7AAAAA'06A AAAAIII644H1

:AAA4A4A4AAA AAAAAA&AA4AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA4AAAA" 'I R0AAAAAAAAAAA444AAAAAAAA0AAAAAAA7AAAAAAAAAAAAAA4

pAAAA4AAAA~AAAA&AA~AAAA&AAAAAAAAAAAA&AAAA&AAAAqq,,AAA'AA.AAAAAAAAAAA-AA~A4AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAaAA,

4AAAAAA6AAAAAA4 0AA4A6 7AAAAAA6A0A3A06AAAAAAA60 4hAAAAAAAAAAAAAA&& AAAAAAAAAAAA AAA AA A AAAAAA A&AR AAAA A4,~AAAA&AAAAXAAAAAA&AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA&AAAAAAAA44AAA&4AA%.AA-AA 7AAAA0&AAAAAAA5 AAA0AAAAAAAAA5444

N^AAA4AAqAA4AAAA.AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA&A&A&&AAAAAAA4,

LAALAAAAAAAAAAA&AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA&AAA,AAAAAAA~AAA&AAAAA&AAAAA AAAAAAAK&&A AAAAAAAAAAAA&AA4,AA&AAA&..A~AAA&AAAAAAAAAAlAAAAAIAAAAA&A&A&AA6AAAA"AtAAAA&AAA4A&AA AAAAA.AANA&AAAAAAAAAAAAAAA~&AAB,4AAAAA0AAAAAA6 AA64AAAAAA&AAA4A4 AA AAAAAAA0 AA06 4

,AAAAAAAAA&A4AAA&AAAAAAAAA0&AAAAAAAAAAA&AA6AAA44'4AAAAA&AAAAAA AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA&4AAAA&AAAAAAA44,~AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA~AAAAAAA&AAA AA&AAA&AA'AAA A44

0AA 66 0 67A A 040AAA A4 6AAAAAAAAA0 A6AA 0AAAA0 AA6AAA6 0 4AAA460AA50AAAA0AAAAAAAAAA6AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA7444

AAAAAAAAAA~AA~A4AAAAAAAASAAAAAAAA.AAAAAA&AA&AAAq4AA44AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA AAAAAAAAAA&AAAAAA AA AA&AA4

AAAAAA4AA4AAAAAAAAAA 4AA~AAAAAAAAAA&AAAA6A A~44

AAAAAAAAAAAAA&4A4A~A&A& AAAAAAA&&AAA&6AA&6AA6AAAAAAAAAAAAAA AAA½AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA0AA6AAAA6444

AA4A0AAAA0 0AA 0A4 0AA60AAA0 0AAA AA0 0AA6 0AA0 6A66046.AA000004A AAA AAAAA 0440 AAAAA0A6 'A AA AA6 A0A0AAA64 44

AAAAA~AAA4AAAAAAAAA4A4AAAAAA&AA&AA&AAA6A&AA6&&AAAAAAAAAAAAAA'AA'AA AAAAAAAAA"A&AAAAA&&AAA&AA6AAAI~

RAAAAAA&AA&&A&AA&A4AMqAAAA&AIAA&&A.A&AAAAAAAAA4A00AAAAAAAA&6AA6 0AAAAA0AAA0 066AAA6AA0AAAAAA6 6 44A.AA4AAAAAAAAAAAAAA, AAAAAAAAAA&AAAAA6AAAAAA44,AAAAAAAAAAAfAA44AAAAAA &AAAAA.AAA60AA0AAAA0A00 4

60AA 006AAAAAAAAA&AAAAA&AAAhA6AAAAAAAAAAAAAAA470A0AAAAA4A6AAAAAAAAA&&A06AAAAA&AA&A&AAAA&AA6A444

~AAAAAAA~h"lAA4AAAAAAAA&A&AAA&AA6&A&AA~A& AA AA4~

~AAAAAP&AA44AAAOAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAIAAAAAAAAA AAAA&0AAA&&AA4ARAA444 AAAAA&AAAAAAAAAAAA&AAAAA66AAAA4~A&AAA,%AAB&&&AA4A/,AA44AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA&4~AAAht'44B44&4A4AAAAAAAAAAA&AAAAA&A&&AIAA6A&AA44~

AAAAAAAAKAAAAAAAAAAA&A&&&&AAAA AA.A&.AAAAAAAA A6AAAA6 6A44A0 0 6AA6 AAA 4 0AAAAAAAAAAAAAAA666A64444

A&AH40AA0 466AA0A6AAAAA 0&AAAA0AAA&0&AAAAAA007447

AA AAAAA4440 4A AAA&AAA A&6&&AAAAAAAAAAAAA&A 664&446AAAA077004&A 440 4& 6AAAA&AA0 AA&AA0 AAAAAAAAAAAA'A44A

767660000077604000660000060667006300063006044

72

;2

,C6

CL

2CI2

'2'2~2

1I77

4141

76

74

7A4

IAlI4

CA2

1.4.7C4

Lc;L2,

2C2C

26

2R~

R~

B L

[IA

9*2

42

19

227"7779q997T227999999q 22922 71272702992d97722219 9'9991292999122 22922222222222 7

91122299I 94I2 799999222 7222299222222222dI2d 9//'79712229949292222212792222222121k~22~999'2799'7929v~ 74991729v9722'7277e11277,9'T277272222 9222" 7222922222.22277221.1277772222271i292122772772222I9277220492'222112q9992222222222222222222

!9777?7 7227.72'999'd22922212722222722221221474~422221222222 72222227122e122222272222222122272I229912222222'!222'22,'77 722212222222I1

!22e222~I227777722212227 72 I222222221,*22221 I222d77712277 717272 22222722!..22222272272 77222222?217777222Z7222222?7222772.Yl2?L2222 ?2 1222 2227,!71222177 72l7qYt~T7772tYP~P~49222227777

~777777772272772J22 211..,7 22212222727777777717¢222222.2.i2.?/ . 31272222272712777177122727217~22222 77 72222222777722222272 227212222222222222222212272227Z!222272Ž222722222212221222777222122?7Z71277'2227?7.122221222227222?7777722271777177721,4222222277722227d7222. 77777777777 2

0462272,7 2177217722 44444

4 . 444644400060AA44744444.44,

444444424444444444464444444444444648644464444½44446646644444446AA04644446464446444444446440A4444444446AA46044444444 A6044444 4446A444A64444464466AA 444444444 '04644444A4A64A4.4444 4A44444A4AA4446644464444 4 4 4 66 44 4 A 4 4 4 4 AA4 A0604A464444 4 467441A 6

644400360 4A40AA44AAAA4A 444A4444444B644444464 44444444 4444444444444444 776446644446446444444444444644444644466440660A71144464444444444664440A4464444001100B10&4444647h444444444446444444464BR0009067

444447744444 4744444 77': .

2227?774242722277.7717177177717117171777

i.277d'22/1227271771717771777171777771I2ZZ227 77 22 2112727777777 777777777127777777472272l22222e22222777717771717777771 777777776212722Z222722Ž12 7217777277777 7 77177 77777 777&21221222k22727 7777777 1177771?777777727722/2I22272 ,177 22 7777 7777774211221.2121e2 22II 111211. 7777177777

227227222777 2777 777777777777/772 22772222222227772Z 7 771 7717 77117177771?77417177722127277777777777777.77777777777

177 72I 277772777771777777/7777717777227197717727 77.7.77.77 .7.77777 .77777 77 700000:/7777 7 7 7 7 000011DDDDO ,OD DODUE 001 I 76242'707fJ7741. D17724o74222 …' . Ž,122222222

6C06'_'_- .. ,/12227121221122222111~C62421121l22227122222222222222722/1

4 46222/22e 2121222222222222222222122 2222 72~,2 8422222,22?Z22222222222d?2?222222222?22

4412222 22122224221222212212222122222222 !41222/1222 1222..22222K .t , 22241222.

7!42222122121 L~24? 2 .I 41222222227 4212221212122 222 2222" '222222222e46122122 22i211222222e2122212222222222e22, 84,222212222122222222222222222222244222,4

C 444ZZI2k22221222222222222222222222222.' 1

L C844224,2212d2212222.22z222222222222221I'C441221i722222229422222122222222?22222IL22Zd22222222 22222,7

121122 22222222222222222222

222222/222222122222222~2221222222122222,22222d2/?2222222272222k22222222222212227

2222212 ?z2e2?222 I2222222222117222222222222222I12222222222222222211 27722222222¢

222222122992222222e12227971t92222222Z22II id22 I 12 2 12 122 J2 22277 719222 12,24222222

222122/2222221222222222£22222222224222,

2Z222227222dMZ2222 1121 22221 2222 22222d22 21 2IZ2i22?2WWW2 22 222e22227222?22222221222222222222222222222222222222222222222 2 222222L22222212222?222222222222?2221211222222122222222222622421777?777

0 6 0 7 0 7 77t 0S 0 0 6 46H 6 6 0 7 6 1 66 6fi6 00R 0 0 0 0 6 6 0 6 6 .7760006607700"00600666R00h06K66666360B0660006

8 IIfiSBU f§U fiRUB~fBBHBB" SBSIRBB

UB~h4A4h~4H H~4H$4U4BRI~BBBBBSUHRHURSURf,:BHIB {1 1~BUB4B~kBUKH4K4½B~bSBhUD§ISBBROOUBR B [U 8

dRBBUHHBmbD36 fUfiRRR0~iHUOBB~SH

RR44KHtfdhBHHBUS~St ROB8 BH1 U a JI88HURBHRi!IB44RB4Ahb&4ASBBBBH~BBBKf8~I:R3B .. B HU~RfiC,46ROAABB" A&AORBBBA440B . " . B .It ~ iBR. .. lR~b:~ 44~'48RRth4ftRAWKIMORPRHBUHI 9RIRBB6688hFSBI ~1 I

4B abHSBtbB4KdBB0BRHBI Itd"'BBBIR188RBI222 I

~BHSR~lBSBBfiBBI22?7 Z2Z20{,~UB~u~q~24Z22 2222222 1222 {

0 6 0 0 02 2260 2 0 0 206 0 6 0 0 ' 0 0 0 0 6 0 · 0 206 6 6 6 0{

06f0067',000677666007660066660 41

LII

~666669!III

.666699 1701666696' 771.666609 11I

1666669 777666996 117

66966 1666669qI7666669'III666669 171666667 777

666667 I1l666669 11I66"'69 I II

66666 1 11666669 111666 11:668666 77

666 7116~66666 717,:6::, 717966666 770

966669 710

96666"9 11666999 0{666996 ID666666 1

66669 10066666 1oo66666 10066666 110666666 I166666 1I7

~66666 11066669 I1~66699 100

66699 110666669 10066669 700666q9 1OU

r6669q LDr66999 00006669 D0O6669 0006669D100

F66669 70Dr66669 T7UI66999 000L66699 110166666 I1I66666 11066666 I77I6666 117,66666 771I

71171111111111117i1

1111110111111110

71111i11111111101D

1711111101711177107711171711

1.111j111I11111111

1171111111711I177

11117171i711711117107111171717t71717117!

7117117711

171711711i

LI0111i117{

111177111117171711111

76617171111

7911117117l77I1711111l

70000111111

70070711111

70077071111

77781fi1111110811111111707B1117117

77811111111

LII 11617111110007111!

1711131111

1171171711i181111777

Figure 3-31. CLASSIFICATION MAP BY THE COMPOSITE CLUSTERING TECHNIQUEWITH 14 CLASSES AND WITHOUT ITERATION

3-38

59

59149597

601603

60 5607

609611613

615

1667I6 19627

7 620.62 46 2

9 6291637633

6 1643

645

64 IF649

651653

65

I59

661

665

667664677673

67167?

67966160 36805

7118

60?6941693

64970 I70,70470?7703

711

I1377471? 7 17

723

7 2

7271437

734

747743764

74174-7

7479

76 1

76 7

76"767

7671

773

779S

IL144,44771741447

777777 14474

l 17t444I

17174m44

7177144'l~

LII It4

711171174717777L44'

1117114'

I11117774Illl 142

1111Blll4

I1i1111

ItilI 14

17777444777717747III4164

777777477I.7..7.74977II244777777L44

II7174 117777604477I72I77

777777 I14

7771477

.1177 1� III) j III I MTrr4.1.111.1 ..... .....IR222, 2�222 Z22222222222222 ?222222 1 2

IF

II t . � I , . It d H A "I I I I I I I t .1

.........l{Z{~{/ZI~dZ~~dd~[d2~d~22Z11,A&AAAA44~444K4A&AA~A4AAA~AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA~AAA~&Ai I I I B I I L I-1

r.

AL

d

III �II �I II� I

0

! I

! II

I� 11III

IIf

II IIIIIIIIAIA6h6

Fr

I ILI.

I

I

I

&t ,

,t

I

ii

U

ICCI

C

C

8C

t

CC

C

E

L

r,

2

IF,

LILbb

34,4

IC

C.

C

.E

I

i

4:

fIC

II

MI

1=

J·I

i

I

III

I

rzT

I.,

4l4

AAAAAAAAA

A

AA

A

IT,

21

1 a

1 421

Ir,

i

LZ

I

I

I

I;I

I):I

CI

CI

4 t8I

8C

I`]

Page 62: UNSUPERVISED CLASSIFICATION OF REMOTE MULTISPECTRAL ... · i (f t , lt tr-220-1075 april 1972 unsupervised classification of remote multispectral sensing data 172-27204 ic.as c 237s9e

TR-1075NORTHROP SERVICES. INC.

'66. 66F 6165566 * 14 Nil. (It 36336666657 '(A M P 6'J IN U 3 E 14

OaoOCOC,.`OcWOOOOOO.O0O00O ,,CO GO OuO OO ~OO I (C onOO00 1 I tI I I tIIttI I I t!IItIttIItfttlt!I~tII!tIItIIIIIIIIII/ / ? L /

I~ (' [ l I I I Z zZ/] If t1 f 144{ 44, 4~')'>)~ ,i~666 J I ? 17{ARBl- ~,qa9 on]00u I I[! I 1?242 t It) t~,13 4,,4. %55Sbb66h61I I7?/H M q''h C O I[J!2[ ") "[ ' I'~ t' I'~ I J')qIql I'?ql I')?g I~s ?NIJ )') "N % 1 5! ,r 1 I"t'7l J Is 1 L I I') ?7l b tl J, 1 I Lq J )I, {$ II, [9 I I~I,) t I' I1i t~'I I"

0 C;U rI I I I IIli I I I Il I I 1 I l

I):Cl }III II IIIII I l IIIII{

:C l IIIII III I II lIlI iIIl

Ul~ IC {i l l ~{ l il ~

I Il IIiiI I ~H l'{II i I14,

t£. L II I ~1, '1l i I I I I II I I 1

> 3 7 6 3 6 6 6 > 6 1 > 6 6 6 I I 74 7. I I

U II II': I I Il I,, I I I I I I {I I I 7

6>6,l 3 6I 6 > > >'6.6 i I I I I ½ I 6I 6> >636663> 6>6>13666ll

6;663>6>66666>36136II3il l 3 6 3 3 6 3 6 6 > 6 3 6~ i i /

' 36i>6>36I66666i6I16I6 /I0 3 > >J i 3 6 3 6 >3 ~ 6 l i l >6 " 6 66 }6i:11{336 66666 66 636>366 }5I', 333>3>63>66663366636l liJ

6 3 6 6>:6 1 6 > l I II I I I> I I i l

> 6 6 >6l l >l l >l > 6 3I I ll/-. L I I > > > > 6'6,7 > 6 6 6 6 i i l l6

>,60,6," ) '6~ (dCL.6.L )6636. 6

R66 t,,t>.>t66 ,6,6,>,c6t,6L SL6s,18

66-,6.6>.,6 6.¢,.',366,663 , > 5'>666,,t ..66-.6,6, ",I 6c, qdq556

>66l;,h6.,4,4-446 A 4,-.6Co66N AA

t66., H~C('-~s',%-.>f'JL(..a,6666

111114I4

766666666

-L66/666

I11-lt4ll4l1' 4

373666666

DI}IIJ ~1

II11I1-4

63>6I66>4

76, I 6>666

36>36>666

62,2r 21/22, 22...2222?22222/22222

,?///22/////2//2Z?22?2/22?;'/222322

t272222,1122I2222222222/2222222`22I6,7,2,'222/7,2.'2L2?2 2 I.....2/77?,

62.' 22/22.,,//22222>

2 22,//Z // .'/ZZ 2SZ/ .Z / 222.'21//

/22, 2.'22/I/, 2./.'2222/2I 222224 ,'

/LLZZ~'~Z//.Z/ZZZ222/22?2.22/g~/'Z~Z/,Z/'L 2LZ/Z/?Z2.'222

3//2,I//?//. //I/2?/?22/ZZ2Z.ZZ/722, /.>22,'ZZLZ/,', I >222 /, 2/.A/2/2/Z722./ *///,///> ,'.2/2/22222L/Z/2?'/2 /Z

6,2,/,'/?2222.22/2??222/222/Z, /2//24/2.I 1 422 422'//// 4? 4////2/4I ??7` / I62.//,22./'//,'72/?tgl?/?2/7737/27,.2

622. .'.'.'2/2/// 2//3lltt > 77372337714

11/? 44,' 4,4Z? 4,?ZII 4II?1414441411t

-" I __.'.'Zt/72// ?lll/ _ 4 I41 4I I4 4 ...ll

Z//Z//I'_, _44 "II 4? 4' 4II)[ 44-/

6//,/,'22.7'/////b *,*>6776 73

2/2. 44 *2 42222I36 44 7 43 466 44'4 667 44

22 _B_222-,'. _-6 _44 41 ,64.I

I44 ..66436666I46666664 4444 3/366644

4".4-46', -46 -444 I4I666666661446661

* 446444.4446666666444144466666.66. -6666666.66666666644444444463444.46

466444.66 41414111444444-4444,3 I 6666

6666 664.666 4 46 446 66646666 6664.' 2466444646644444444466444444444 63i4

66444 ',3-46664-6666666662>644I466646666666666666666666644424662

.~A~A4aA.AqIAAAA~AmA AA^^AAAA~..A4AAqA.AAAb&~pHa6 aaaAA3 > 6a666 66A6 AaA. 0 AAaA6a3 aa6A6a AA6a6AA6 6 A Al

*Aa-A~AAaa,~A~AAA.4aa4.Aaaa~A~AaLLAA.AA~AAa~AA4I~aaaAaaAa,..'AAA.a~aaAAaaaIA.AFLIA~AaA~aa~a.AAaa

~,ta.AIAaaa4AaAAAaAAaaa~AAAAAaaaaaaaa,tA~A~.A~>,,6a6166Aa6aaaaA6A6AAAa6A6aaIAAaAA7AAAa ... AA6aI

uatIaa~A.AA.AAAAaaaaIAaAaaaaalA~l~AAA~aAAla.aAlI~AIALaaaa~aaaaaaaaaaaaaa.Ia.a.aaaAaAAaAAAlAaa.AI,

A6363 A 6> .33aa~ A 6633 AA6A6A33.6 .666 A3 AAA6 6 AA6 a a6,343.6 A66 A76A7 a .A6A6A6A .A I ^>a,6A I II 6 666666666666666666

',Aaaa.3 6 6 A .63 6 A0 4A66 .66 63 66AaA6 aa6A6 AA6 6 A3 6 0 641

/~aaIaaaaaaAaA8.aa~A~AIAxaaAaAaa.aaaa..A.AA.aal

4AA336AAA33AAA66AAA6A53AA63666736.6AAAAAAA36AAA6I

66A06A6A6 6A4.66AAAAAaA3 Aaaaaaa>5aaA6aaaaaaaa4a66 36aaa6l>66a-46~aa6A-a63 a 6aaaAaaaa6 6 AAAAAA 66656

33a6aaa53aaa66a66A6566a6a6aa6a6a6366666666663606AAAAA3A 'A A4AAAA3AA3 AIIIIIIIII6ii 66fl....6A6666666.6

~aAAa~AAAAA4~Aaaaasa~a.IAA~a.AAAA~AAAAlAAAIAaaaa6A66, 6 aaaa AAaaaaa.666 >6AA6 AA.6.> 673 AAa aa6A6l 66

666633666a66a6666>3a6.666636663a6666363666666663

IAAA414A4aaAaIA~AAA aaAAAAAAA.AAAAAtAA~AAA4A4maaaaAAAAa~AAA4AAA~AAA.AAaaaa~AAAAAAAA.AAAIa4

mtIaa~AAAAAAAAaAAsA~a-aaaa1aaaa.AAAaA1AAa1AAA4

sA",AA.AAAAAAAA~aaAaaaAa AA aa AaAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA

A^L~AAAAAaA.aAAI4aaAAAAAAAAAAA AAAAAAAAAlAAA AAAl

ALLLAA4A4AAAaA4a~AAAAAAAAaaaAA4AAAAA&AlAAIAl~A,

>3663357363" 6664A4AAAAAAAAAAA6AAAAAAAAAAAAA AA636664

LA.AAA~ahA4ABIaI~A4AAqAAAAaAAAAAAIAaa~AA.AA~AA,

EALAAAABA &' A.s1AA~AA4A~AaAaAaA~AAA AA&AAAAAA44

AAAA.44mb.AAAAAAAAAAA&AA&AAAAa&AAAAAA& AAIAAAAA4

~AA A. AB84AA ''AaIAAAA AA AAAA&a a &AA AAaAalAlAAA44AAAAII l1B4AAAaqSRqAAA&AA.IAAAAAIAAAA A&AaA&A.AAIsA

IsAAAA44H4�a~au AAAAAaaAAA AAAAAaaaa~AaAAAaaA'A,............. diii. .... ... ...... &AiAAAAAAAAAAAA~A

6L

6>66

?.626

:a

41

6>

4C:

i 4

46

64

>6

63

>6

Itc

it

E4

It

2 22//2 1 /11 2111 2222'7999999/" ?It2q'q ??A* q r 12 I, 19 '1gg9199999~q9II I 1 7999, .Z 12/99/Ii

7773 1117333 322///29999qq4qqlll g.t,1I. .l.

N9171?''t11127l1999997491777111q2 lt21t,,,tt773 3/�72>2?/227179q?721l1f??lfll9Ill

6 ?222227/? 73272776226666667,6

??ZZZ//??77tI 1tIZ?2711?2 ,1?1.?Z2?Z'Ii

~ 4444?II 44?? 44Z 444 ? 44Z 4444147ZI 44441,

L??i/?t4~?4I4Z4/?4??4Z44444??4111414447I/A

44,~~,~ "" 1 A4 qq4Aqqqq4 R AAIA q&~q144 qI4 AH

_44fI"44l4 417244 4 II,4lt4 ll 4444-414lllt44

&lI_4tI4//z214.414111144444A?1411111711Il(I

4II 4-/ / 14.)/4Z 444I? 44.Z 444/IIIIIO II'IDDUDIt?

4-'44-Z 11?-4444444 ,~l 444 1 1741t1A

* .666666636666366666666.6 ;

67'6666 II6 I666666 6 116666 6666666 11763 6

?11771Z ??7722111?7If7)771r77 7777I7771III,~I1I?11 117l17ii, ot,111u711 17(

6i66 6l6O666?6lII66??65666/ 66676.666' 63

666fl,666666666666 6666 666666666666670f]L)6667

6 6 6666666 7'I 'l 'I I1 7 l /t7) /72777 ̀,77 7/2, 7/7 22 7> 733 7733733> 77777 33I36

3737,7.7722727777776731; ;77737777377'73>I

611'22//./22277 7r773377>7T17I7 7r37772,ifi,,

3?3tZZII//Z I,'2,2//. 2 33722/3 7736 7306 I777 7173

222222/227/2 42?/ 2/J 2/?j373?33736777736

3>73'Z22,'3/777 I,57.3M?22/?ZZi? /2???/2 Z

C~I~,~,~ ?~,· Z2 ZLL/?~Z/L?,i`?Z 2z?)? )

6 77'233,7t//,2'z//z 22272 / /2/,3 2

77 67 77 72 2/ 2277 72 77 76 777 773 77777377 73

4.......t.'It77>t3t32t266?622 22e/222t.'2

/?,C ]/ 2//'¢ 22]?Z 2722'2t2 II/?/22222 22 ./26>2222/27722122222222/222222222? 7.

?26/222,922Z~Z/29?LL/LZ/22?Z?2/2/2?L22/2/,

A62. '22,`'1tuZ2Z?)i11? Z/?` 2 22222/222,2/2

CI-2/.'. 2I22 jz / ? I

662,/22.2 /222 ?/??L222/2//22??22/?9/2272 2166?222/2222122222222/2222/26669'.6LZ*' I1[1~

666222.222. 2222 I2222/ .2222.2291222 .6

>/222/ 72 22i 22 2222 I22222223

2.''22, /.. //222 222 222 2,2/22,22 "/,I

j2Z/2 /2//2/2222II?21,??.'2222Z22/222222,3

i.HMBH B IIBI6fH ltBb j3t' -6797/HRBB R222R2.,.H

h BI IsBA3 A~ I"l R fiBU H RB Ih H H B1 B ll H H P. B H RtH I B t0 H II (I~ 8B1

H,,BUA&4~RrH~UB~R I A 0RHBB~P~BMHfitBB~HA I id6bfiBBtBAi, qB dBO R Rt~BU BI)lf B RIOB H.

242 II/ , 322I'A 2t HUE 2/22 B2I/2RH2B 7B

Ii A4I.BIB~ it AABRSaH4H1S, L RHIHR 1B

BBa4U GLR tBjfi n RtSBtKiB BRIBBH6 "Btle l"~eB l1 1,222222/2/ /R222222222R2222/22222222292. I B

22222/222222222222222/22222222/2 722222.2222222222.'2222222222/,z I

I ~ ~ ~ ~ ?2

Z2222222 222??2 22L ? 2L?22 722271

22?22222,22222Z22222227 >222tZ2679 3Z77 ,

636,66663 .33666336>6~~~~~~~~~~~~~

366033 6696333>333366666133336667.67763366666667~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~6>J

6636366666663,66366666663366667636',666633666>-

2666336633.63 33666333636633366666666663366633666.

6663666666,63 696666336633663366636663366>36667663>.'~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

6133733363633666336336336>66>6666666166B333366663366636666 I 3~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~,,6666663366,3636666666666666763663333637,66667 66'~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

3336>336,36>.6 66666666636666336666666336376636336736,.~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~J

76336666 666'33339666333366636 7673333733660603336666,6 3~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

3333633666666666636B633366336 133666673363330663666633,6 3~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

63636366636366>36333666666336666336637676>3333333666636J 6

566669

6,6966

5669666b6666

66666'666966

6666166.6669

66606q,66666666666

6669

66.66

66,6666

,66666

9666

o~66-06,-6

66666L3ID

IODI

IIDULDU

Ill

LI 760LI6

717

iDU

360

UI>U

O DD

1 DDIOD

LDO

6 6>66I

1.1,63.9 3UU>

6 66669~ I)0i,

t 6666; 663>,66666066(

366h66(736>66I,666 6>6>6

6,69 6616

3.6b999 360666699 60

I666666If6666 6 0>

6666 ;606666 76D

c66606661 6

6/66606036u

iI 1I~ 1 1, IIOD

I LICUlO

II1J LOUOO0

II I IDI IjUO

II I 1DODOD

6666606330II III IUL)U

IIIIIOUU

I IIII 101)00

II I I IIIoil

7111111LII)

6llllllo0

III I I LI ID)

lllilil

3666630>336666606>6066l66660>6666603360

336666633336666663>663

3636 llJ03>lllL~6i0

636663l66>36i66666636>I6 [L6666636366>U

6366666>3>66

6666l666,6

66636663336363666666666666663>

366666666I>6116660>66666666>366666366666i6666666661

6336l6666663366666666

6666666666

Figure 3-32. CLASSIFICATION MAP BY THE COMPOSITE CLUSTERING TECHNIQUEWITH 14 CLASSES AFTER ONE ITERATION

3-39

5636S 9r

3, 596

66 I

667I

6 60I60 6

3"0

3,6I

6633

3 6633,I6

62 3

'6 626636I

657,

-653

667

646

;636

639

695

6-7

10 9

709s

-7-

.U

V

A

a,

8

8

c8c

cI

EC

It,E

I

I

41

1II

I

III

I

I

II

It

I

__r

L=

LI

L A

IA

It

I

44

i

It

a

Page 63: UNSUPERVISED CLASSIFICATION OF REMOTE MULTISPECTRAL ... · i (f t , lt tr-220-1075 april 1972 unsupervised classification of remote multispectral sensing data 172-27204 ic.as c 237s9e

TR-1075NORTHROP SERVICES. INC.

.40. nf CLASSES - L4 No. OF I TERATIONS ' 2

5$&#PL0 NUNIOLR.

IC551ii23 225 33/ 444Q5l55666667? ? ~?888Rg999 (J iLi11ZZZ z2~j34 46555666667l?7?-B88q99 i0 iALZ135l913 M3?9~ 1315 1 i3?9L359135791~1579i35193,79 13571357L3~i 57i 9i1 u1~S 59135913iS5q1JST91 3,713S~T91359 13.,9i

1111:1? 111 11 1 1 ??

I1?? 1 11 ? ll 1llll?{

1111l?? ll l11111)? 10171 ? IIlill Ill i 11111? ll I? ?I

I I ? ? ? ? 1 1 1 1 1 1 11 ? ? 1 1 1 1 1 0 1

llllllliI n~1011001171111l1i11(111?lll10111110)

I llll ? ll I1Ill111I1110)

I1111i1??)ll? 1111 loll

I I I I IIi I I i I I~~ I I IiIll I01L

I I II I Ihl~l~l I :LU~ I I I

I~~~~~~ U ~~ U10?I {

IlliiI I1IllIIIDIID 11 /I l

i L ll1Ii 11 1L l11 11020'

61181 b83L1,1OCLL73811111816

616660d.GCMdCdUdC88J.C8S I

II166 LI8C1CC1115u,4SCI

6661 --- dCCC 39 55

68d1.64dLLCLLC89 . S1- 5166 14 CLCCCL9888BbSC5C1 586116.1 112 "e738geCCCCCS54

.6b6Z66 b IIhoo~C C L~C91144 6e18 8111 14,5 719 38118H

988-11A868688 ,81138.1488

66 6666666 6 c81 11s16666-6-666.6968d~C6L8

1168668I.,,8881666CCCC 9CCSS

16666 ..8.8 6 66188888 d H88

6666661 66148 010 8893

6666 1'CLL.,IL,,0II36HC2

hdd dLI5LC'ICCCCI91131CbjSe2 C LC(LL"0LC8C- 88

U84,14L,-LL% ',5 4',35L4338a

hc rn4ctIz iAAEA AAgA A aA A & A A

7C71110DC,UI

I IILI 0 JUL)iI 11, 112)

7I O0 ,LULIUI I? IU)Ul11/)10)0l

III 1614D'

II I IL L.4'

II I2'c40'l

III ?IILIU'I? I226)U

liiL 01CDOII ?LUCUD[II IiI U I UIL

iil? i") 1111401UIll? i)1841

I I I I 1104111?111110l4

I 10/244

T7? IILDD

II/DCUD[ll ?llD4IU?Ill? llbO{

I71? LO 0.

II I 1IO1111

111110401Ill 101601II IIL020?II ILOU101

II 11001111

I11111011?1

T22212221212222222222222222222222,,22i222222212122222222222222212222.TTIf222122222222222222222222l2212~

72TN222222222222222222222222T2222olT22222122122222222222222 121i2021212222/2222222222222222222222W221222222/21222222/22222222222/221/,

212/12122122221222222222222221,'.2211Z2/22222 221/2221222122222222'221222WI/12 122?22222222222222,2WWI WI"2.222?? 227222222I222222222/

2122d2212d2122 . . ..... 22222222212

/ 2./.. 2&" .. 2122212222"I2l, '/21222 /222 I22 2212/"222/222I22, 22 2/I/22/222 222222222222

?L2W//22/iII/11 '22112221222222 2

II2I.22/1222 //2/ 12 22222222222/22I1/.'/22/Z22L//2/?/22 222222112212U(12/I22L2(L/.?/]2T222222T12227f22

D22 112W2W21W2WI7 1 1221 2111?? T22112UL2Z2jj22L22LL2L I 711 I111722222

)2271222221122L7117771792271771771

2111//222LL2/1112TT71221T122211T1)~22,'2222122l71lt7T0?g~17T1111ITT1!L11.12212222//?[IIICO946D'8ITIf121

412212/22L22.LbBIIH)

114444444444~44444 48B744 VOe 0 10444444444444444444L44401B1044 74144444~44444444444441044U40~044411/

44½4444444444444444044D8404444

444114414444444444414 444 U844 "4

44444444444444444144444UB44444

444444444 4444 4444444o4o40844}444 4A4494 4"44444444444 8444444 474,-,444404-44444444?40444089044 41,

4444444A 44½4A44444114444444I444444484444441144444441140841100044A40044118304444-4444144441)4468344444)14441144444.44444 ;44I4444401I404444444444444 1444144X44444B404LI~4 4444444444444444444444444 04410 U4444441444448844114444444004011022?

44 44444444_-114444444404014l,10IO Il

4A4114444114444444444444444442I0"?*48481444274044444444444.444/"ILL1

4448A44 48 44 14A4 44444444444 04110444?,~441048A84A4.4 4A48444444 4444428 4A08AA11444444444-4-4144444444~4114(I121 ?.

441.444-411' 447,-'44404444U444O044 ~44744444411444444~444)1fl4444n440[1414444444444444~4414444444444444 4n1

!444444 44149444-444 4444444400111`)4)4044444444 4A44441414~444044440004014

2C

Fl.

'9

CA

CS

II

HII

2I

W2C

),I9.I

)?L

21

81

8~

£1

C,

4I

31

De

)4

1E

,I

L

E

El

~4

LC

[

Id

T9

<

LI

L

I?

L(

,.',

L'

A[

4.<

2,

24.

t7Lr

7 1111997lf211999q99992997712 717 f 911.

P9.... 219999999 99q99999 7719q99729122422

P917~19 999~9992999qIll 7274 9 qq9g7?222/'l6p9qgq9 99gw9 9f~q99q9qq 912 1997I999I111;72;I,9199 ~9 99199 9 7 99 799~ 9729 IP99 qll99llgf9f ,qgflgq92I

il179~qlf22f;2gl191191211~fll9~l111~"

!lZ.19'19111 1 1 1'2~21222221/

!272222 9 2211ff21722f1122222I29222~/.'

'22222.2211;1;11111~2112271111 222112/.M

!222222 72 ·1 1~221 1 1liz~222211

PiW22WZ22 I?0I fIK TI2 I~11~ 122227W11

P211I ;212/Wt27~fPI /12212721!!22122W1 I MI21112222722222222121!72272.. '7~11122 2222221 172W . 712

..... I22 I221~277 1722112721112 1

)i2Z222222f?1222227222 7777,W?1;722

L~d222?/77~IZ 27227 ,4**

,444004.44444AA444444a4A. 6444 OD& 44AAA,

414qAAAAA4A4AAA46A~4 AAA~44,4A444~444 r1444444~ ½444444444 4~44444444444444 HBLI

14044-4444A4444444444444040444AAB4DRBO~

44oUO~4.' 177L, 4~4l1144-4.?

712D2 1711121T7 111;7171711 1711171I11

17722 W222 122IW 7112212717177777I71?7T7117IU,22eZZ~/~,Z2Z7Z7;721777777J17~TflII????;711D771272W22I W~27 7T7 2d 2 ? Ill 71 IT I17 11

222222/2222077A l22222T177rlTT?1I7771L'IL)IT 72W`.2TTTI EI Z A1d. I ..III...IIIT1...7/ 11/1 2 ... fil7 2?7f117111I?]~12t7foTTll1T222177TdIIff7TllT7TT?7T1TII1

TUTI777I2211?Z2IT?? ITI? TT I T T??1f ?7?IlL 7I 7IT, 211 TTTIIT ITTI? T? 2i T??9

7227I177fllfllllllllflll7177771771 TT71111777777171T77T ?TT

01711lIIITIZ?71??- 27TT71T7.'2

819 22222 T222112/?/1/2222I//[)21./2T22122/11222/2222222/72W'2

842222 22222 2222221222222221 12222212402220/U 2/22222222 I2/22,22 /22?22221.2

81'2/~2022./2202222~222221221222/2/222227/.T4D[222 W,220/22U0909/2022?WZI/I/222012/.2

42/22112/12 2 /212 /222 i2 22W 2221/2

022222222122222 2222,22222 222222/,2

8642122/12/22111Z22211, 1/12 2Z22/1224400l'lC442D2//Z2222222222222..221222111)1222.:/?C8402 WIW2222222222222222222 22'222201)ll

C802221,2222222000000022222/2222Z2022222222212222222 2 ,22222/I

2222 22 2222222l222172222222/222222 I2z2222222222222 1222222222. i7. C22222/1222222222222222,2222222Z222222/17

422222211222222222222222221222??22222201I

U22Z 222/22rD000D17222I0UTOI222?2221?2221/n222222.D0flqU22D722711Tq?74707222222222/21

1222222/Ilr)12021, ~22224 2222212222210222711221222/ 22~2222 ,2172~ 21222222220022?,7!2222222,222222222222222,22222222222202221]2222222W22222222222W 22222222222I222222 1?2222222 222n22222222222222122202I222222,7

222222222222222222222 2022i2222272222D 1122122/2222222022222204 2OCJ200200????27

?dI2?2? eBBB, BBRPZ BBURRR22d SB2 RRR2 1122.I

a888BUAb. 8 4B½BHBB 88B8BIB 1lBRR ?B6RH,4RFIHBfiHBHO61BOBBUSRB BAK fiRBe AIRAB K ih

A 44A88ARt BA8A 4618 88BBRBbBB 118 1BB1 R18IR 119

IA BAU q4BBRRBhBB fi8R,1BIBHRIO8.98 BAK88aA888B MBRR? BR?881188 B8fiSBOBBBBLRi 88"

AHABaB haRB '8 "BO AIRBBILDU 2222dBBR~tA

l4438480(14 84B6A888811888H88A"'11 888BelL,411AAHAA????, 8 814818888488 888l8??a. IRA??

48 4888 0 0 88 118 8888 8881 8 11 8 188 IB 111.I I

ARM A 18110888IIU222

,88880(2OO~0022 212222222222222I

222 ' Z22222222122 22ZZ2k 2222

C*Z0222222222U22222207222222 Z~222ZZ 222

61666

.. 68

66115

11166966.66

,66965696616666r66A66

8661189.6666f

:6666/

66666:

16 66

66~6666b~6

bb1686666666

0.6666.66666~66666066.66I166648688

II

11II

TI

LII]I1II

II

IIII7'T1TI7.

II

II71

11

1]

11 t

: 1 1

11II

IIII

II

.1

II:I?I1

:11II'I

IITII1

6.. 666 Ii

I,66666 I?

66666 11166669 ill

I6666L1LI

566666I1!

56669 Ill

I60??????

?6669 1?16666 I11

I???~ ?ll?

66666 111FS6666 IL'

F66669 711

16661 1119

I6I6?????

II6???I}1

1666661??

FI6666IIl1666611

F5I666/1

I6666 Ill

II1111????

Ill???l??ll8l11???888l?????

II1II111

"IRI111

8881111???

888 18 ??I III 1L8??11?111is1 I II

ILLII I1?

IaI11It11115 'I

111 I 1 11 L1.111

11111111111

4 AL.AA AAA q441AAA A AlAA AAA AA NAA IAA AA&A A4AAA H~A41tLIAAAA&4AAAA~6AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA AAAA&AA~A4AA&JA.RAI)~4AAAAA AA*AAA44AAAAAAA'AAAAA&AAA'A0A&AAAAA& AAAAA441

*AAAA&AAAA&AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA0 AA6AAAAAAA.AA1

,AAAAAA AAAAAA&AAAAIAA.44A AA A1A&AAAAA&A&AAAAAAq0A*AAAA8 AA1AA&A* A44AA4A0A &AA&AAA411 AAAAA& &AAAA4q

IAA&EA&&AAAAAAA&AAA&AAAAAAAA&AEL£6AAAAAAAA6AAAAAA~AAAAAAAAIA&A&A&AAAA&AAAAAAAA~LE&6AAAAA&A&AAA.4kL[EA'4AA A'&&A.AAAAAAAA'AAA AAA~AAAA&A&AAA'A"6&414L&~LA4A4A4AA4AAA&A6A&AA&AAAAA&~A&AA&&&AAAA.IAAA

ILLA&&AAAA&&&A&AA&AAAA"AAAAA&AAA&AAAAAAA&A&A&AAAA"AIA&AA&AA&AAA4AA AAAAAAA&A AAAAAAAAAA&AAAA6AA&AAAR

,AAE AA&&A&A&&A&A&A.AA&&A&&&&AAA&&&&&AAAAAAAAA.A4

8LL 0A40A&A0A0A &0AA0AAA1AAA&AA1 AAA A AAAAA&A&AA4i0 A&AAAAAAA 1A A 8 4 01AA1AAA0AAAA 0AAAA0AAAAAAAA004'

)AA&A.AA6AAAAI&A&.AA&'AAAA&&&A&A&A&A&AAAAA6A&A&&44

!O&&AA&AAAAA&&AAAAAAAA&&AAAAA&&A6AA&AAA&AAAAA&~4 x

,AAAAAA&AA44AA4AA&AAAA&AAA&AAAA&AAAAAAA6AA&AAA449fAAAl4. 84AA4444A1 44AA AAAAAA&AAAA4 &AA&A8A,&A&AAA 4 44

8AAAAAAAAAA&*AA 8AA 01AAA1AA0AAAA 0AAAAAAA&A&1 A408 *IAA&A½AAAAAAA64AAAA&A&AAAA&AAAA AAA~A6AAAAAAAAA14IA.A4AAAAAAA&&A&A&6AA AAAIAAIA&AAA^AAAAAAA&AAA4

kAAA4A4A444AAA4AA&AA6&&AAA AAAAA.AAAA6AA&A&AAA~4

,AAAAA&4A&&AA1.A&AA&AAAA&Aa&A&AA66AAA&AAAAA 4A4AEAAA444&&AAAIAA&&AAII&AAAAAA&AIAAA&AA&&AAAAAA4 4LA&AAA&AA4AAA&AA&AA4&AAAAAA&AA&&AA&&AAAAAAAAAAA44

AAA 4AAAAAA&A&AA&AA&4A½4AAAA&A.&A&&A&A&A&AAAAA&AA44LAAAAAA4A&&AA&&&AA4A&½AAAAAAAA.&A&A~AAAA&&AA A&A4

ALI AAAAAAAAAAAAAAA A4A4A&AAA&AAA. AAA&A-AAA&AAAA AA44AELA4AA&A&AAAAAAAA4AgA&AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA AAA AA A

ALAAAAAAAA&AA&AA'&&4A&A&AA&AAAA&AAA&AA&AA&AAA&A AA&&LLA4AAAAA&AA&AA4A&A&AAAA&AAA&AA&&AAAAAAA&AAAA44AE AA A &AAA&A 44A&AA&AAA&A&AAA&&AA1AA1AAAAAA~4

&EA AA4S~ A~&A AA&&&&A &A&&A&AAAAA AAAA AA~AlA&A&&A4AA4A&AAA AAA.AAA&AA A AA&&AA&A&A4

AIIkAAAAAA~AAAAA4AA44A&A&A AAAAA&AAA&A&AA&&AAAAAA4c 4AAA4A81A1A84AA *&A½A&A AAAA 1 881 *AA AAA AA AAA4 44

AAAAARH66B4 "A &&A'AAA&&AAAAAAA&A&&AAAA&A&A6AA4AA.A&AAAA4½S&A&&A&4AAAA&A&A&AA&&&&A6AAAA.AAAA AAAA~4

AIAAAA&&AA&6A&BB4AA44A&&AAAA&AAAAAAAAAAA&A&AAA444&&AARA464BA&6&&AA&AAA&&AAAAA&AA&A&A&AAAA&AA&A4A

AA AB4AA4* 40* 4*11 AA08A8811AAAA81144'A8 *AAAAAAAA*AA811 84

AAA&fBAA444eaBF14AAA&AAAAAA&&&AAAA6A&A&A&AAA&4A44110AA4AA4014*4 111AAA& 000 *88AAA1AAAAAA **8AAAAAA 1A&1

RA&&&&A4* 444844A*A AAAAAAA&A&AAA AA*AA AA&A AAA4&

Figure 3-33. CLASSIFICATION MAP BY THE COMPOSITE CLUSTERING TECHNIQUEWITH 14 CLASSES AFTER TWO ITERATIONS

3-40

O51-589

595

A,- 599

603

80 1

809

1611

I?.82 8825

' I 81

1133

84 1114

115 36535

6157

8611

1111A118

8 11

6111

11a?

8) 1

89 1

89910 I

105I71

IU3

127

71 IS

71 1235

125

472

37

7131

1451

149

7143171591

18?

11177a?113 115 7191

tshh/ ~/~I I

� 440013� LO 344 4444 A 4 A 44 � 444 &AA 4. 444004 444 4 ArId

4 I

CLU

4 Li

4 Z

CL

~L

I F

C,I

E~

EC

EEd

66�8 A.k,8�81C,16814555 rn-6�U44(i4B4444444�44444t)C)061)KB AR ugly HII I I II" III II II L II R LI 1111-3- . . .7 -m 1.�r�.A6�5111

7 -0 ']II I

q

ZA

II

-A

0

!; -I

'A,

66616(61

6666

646.616,

61

616664

61

61,o~6d

6(61

X�

�r

,IIIIIIIIII4IIIIII1I7

II

7

11

I.

I

II

II

II

II

II

tI

II

II

II

II

III

lI

F

i

I

II

I

7

Page 64: UNSUPERVISED CLASSIFICATION OF REMOTE MULTISPECTRAL ... · i (f t , lt tr-220-1075 april 1972 unsupervised classification of remote multispectral sensing data 172-27204 ic.as c 237s9e

NORTHROP SERVICES. INC. TR-1075

~ ~9~G ~ ~a ~ Q~~i~iii~tii~i&~l~iiii~ll~HIi~iltlitlliL~i~~ZzzO00000000C?0000 00000OO0000OO00000000O* .000 9O000l..II~111311111111 1131I1111111IlUU

0000111.32d~d~)j 44333504CS1DIRR.,999900 0 *11 O*#i)3 eee eeeee eee~e~teeeeeeeRooU9~O*O Ue ¥# J)............................ .O000OOUCOLUOdO.O.tIOU~DUU*OOO000atU0BOe 0O** * U : ~ eWeOCCOCCICC CCCCCLCCCCCC. *a~ua& R&Aeeeeeeee..aR.;U&MasA *UoGAk". 0e...

19a * ccC:CaCCoCCL CCC CCC.eeA £# AAg Rd eRkAA.AW *O.RRROUOUU.UUOUCOOUUOOOROIOOUOOQOJCUMO'w .......

~~~ :~~~~~~" (COCOCCC ~e e e e e e e * e e e e e e le K ~ e O * " ~ #&)eCeCCCCCCCC~CeCCCee0...AR#"#*ea SAQRMSR#**B RK*e&*KRR* *OOUSORuCOQUCUOUOCOOOUOOOUOUUOOOUUU*eUU*#S#.¥*.

603.C. e~ecCLCCeCC e 00 *&#aage#. #HeaaR..SRA** ReRR**.A *C0OR0COUCUOR0OCOOOUO0U0OU00U3~UOUK#RIeO#$eeeeef.05 e.C00eCCCCC0CCCCC.eCCCC..R.*RRa,.&'R..RRRSaa~KRgSeRR*#Ra.a* eeee~eee~e~ae~~e**®ee e#$C

601 *C C~cC"CCCCC Lc C.C 0C. SS sRAA. R RR .. RAR~R kR-O..W

'0' *30CCC CCCCCCeCC* ..**-RRAA..RR.S ASRSRAMR.R. *&*R 3ORROU OOOCOIARA~OOOJOUOOUUOUCOUUOOOOOSOS$.SRICk'1ei . .CCCCCCCCe cCC''....R ..ell' S ............ *aa .. , R R RoR R 01...... .. ' .

*3S$e33L33CCA.CLCC . J*C*CRewKuR*ReRMRRa*Wke& #* .R 4.4 *A*HRRR#ROIURAHaRRKBA.RH**Oi*.RA*RKO1...R

60) ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ AARASR.AR...... AR AR.A&RR.h .RifRRRRPRKRRRRARRSRRRScluou40RARRRRR RRR.uw..W..WRRC

e3C~CCCCCeeo$e0eC*CCCC.e**R,.AR*SARaP*RMAA.ARRA*RARaR*KRa&O&URR* 0 **eeeeeReee***e******eee**eeeARa*&Ob..WIR1*...CCr..0CCC CCCC0CC.CLCe& ##R..AQ .RRARRRR #RgRReR$ .4RA

*~ .C~CC*CCCLCCCCC~CCC.CC00e***HKRAA4. AAA AR*K SRARAR#HC Ca#~Rb*A Ue~RRRRRRRRRR*9RaaRaa.aRa**K*R#R*~RRRaSeR4Rbe3mN.*R*.3 (CCC.CCCLCCCCOCCCCCCCCU..* * ,e e ,. e AR. * * AS e R e eRMS * * * * * * * * * * * * *C0 OeaR*¼KRMONRRRRRR ,SRk* R*RRa~R*RR**Rg*R..RA R....SRC

Ill C c *CCC C. CCCC.RARARflRAARS.UOA3R. .~..... li34.29 * C COCCCCCCCCOCCC..CC0C 0. .5555.. AAARAAP5R5~~R.5,uuau~~uR.RRU.RR .5lSRRRRR..SR ARRSRRRRRR5RR R3RRR~R.CRta a. ....4.0 CC0CCOCCCOC~CcccCCC...s As.RRR R Cs0u3SAAA:RCORR*a5kRRRRRRRRQRRRRR a .R ..... 9 S.4.3.3C CC.CC C Cc0 SRA,04&RIROURC40 A A.............R..................B.... RR 3...wlkf

639 *CCCCCCCCLCCCCCCC e.AA&AA &AAAAAAOUA&03L.CCC3CCCRRCC. ee* e e * e * * 0$&4 *SSCCCCC(CC.CCCCCCCCCeCAA*RAN,.OAUU* jOC.W00uu3CJOU5R0N.R[.O¥ ee*RI

4 *eCC*CCCC*CCCCCCCCCCCCCCeAARA.AAAACAAA&O&O U,073J0100 0000$001 S3COUOOOO0OO3U aOOOOAOO 0 R3303ARS S.*RAm.MbUa

e& .s,.9. e.¥~..m~ h.m.Rbm#~eeS333U.¶.33$33333S..1tC110 33103eU OeCO.OUJ 0 33 3 3CC 333 0 333 CC0333 *$.RR.O$3Rr4.*3 . m~mwmw~. . 33#* 3* 333333S33 333. 3 ISSOe* 31 30.SSC*W $O*U0 U3 3313133335S30 3330333333 e*34...$CC 3633 *~e"5 e . . 33333eee3333*$S55 35S$ 3SSS .SSS**S 3%S 3555S* 30*33U SI 333330 3SSSSSSS 33 313 333 33S*. 0e.OSe*3 e~.53 . YR-~ . 33w3333331e310Q.t)333 SSSOSS$SSO0eSO SS w 0.$00 $0300000OOSSOSS 33133$3 333SSS$O$SS*.-.*$URI651 4WW.. 333313333S..0..e3U33..33eUeS 3.$30033S30$OSOS3e*USS$S$$$U3 3*3$SOOOSSOOS$ $$U$SSS333S$SS* .ewi.e4.39 *¥Yk7 N~alR IIm. . 3313333133333 S33303,.33e333SU3333 *Cw 3033OC000 03300300 3 3S 013 3S3333SC4$.we.iSIWA

e# Wg *. YwV~a~w . 3333333333e333S55 333SSSS 'S3eeSUCg*.e . CC .00 0UCOOCUO....... s. CuCe RIC......... ... As

. 3333..33331330S0..333303 $3t £ARORARRRRSRSRRR"' aR" RSSORRCO0S .R.. .SW. S.

& 1 R . , .. 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 e Y ~ ~~ I I m d i u e~ S S ~ S S S S S ~~ * . S O S S C C*O o O. 0 0 & &C C OaA OR 5 R* R~ A R C~ 0 K C R R R S C *CR R CR K S R 0 . R * O e e U *R . R S

619 *Rs.YV. ~ ~ ..333333133333 a333.300003 ROAARRS9SRRSYRIR.R&Ri. ... ,.

.3 3 3 0 00 As.o ,s...v.......**.*ssNssussssssoss I A~aC":ba.O.......aCC· CCCLCLCC C~fCCCCCA33333333 3 33 AAR 0CSe03 O~e & C.R".e eeeR A e&eeSAe *R*e*AeeS eieta.eUR

611 * . * .1S3~333~3i33 ~ 33300000 C0~A.0Ss~s44SsS1~s..s~sCCss.AA .... ........

4 ¥.6 .. 3133333333333330033.00 33SSO$*OSOSO004~ 0R*k0~eA&AA R*.*5AM.e*RMgkKR *RRSSR4R*.U0wWN.eR#693 .¥.33 303333 Y33333303.030 13003330 30C*RARgCSRSH*SS S0RRRS C S'aSKRSC

I9.Y3 .3 . 3333 .. 03.003~ .. RARR SSaRRRaSRSS.R * R3' St.3

699 ·.1.313333.0 O30A0Ss'sC0 Ss RRAe RSSS RSR OAfRk~RS*SO(SSS RSSS

~5 *ebedee~~~~elee~~eeedM~~~w~ee¥*SSS SSSUS$SSSS ~C* OSS OClSSC (CCR**a:RC g**~ta~a** * SS$ S~5S S% 5S Slbql ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ l I Wm~e*ee*e-*#StSSS$SSSO*G0SSO SSIGuSS ************************,

10..*****e$****************~$e~e***** *** *$*0C01$.$.C SICC¥ 5.sOUAAsAUUOORR0#SRSsSs SS *AARSRA SRSS C33$ 33370) ~OOD(JU..3O0C0U3 . 1***03333303e*33 OS$ 3O3C$.bSS$~S3333 LO&&AS.C3UURA*0..3l5R.*Wda~RARA~*HOAsORRO*$3$333$OC$CS1 ubCUSS S*3.333SSS3333$3 313 3S $S 3SS3SS$SS$O3 &&RASSAR&S*SSO SOA~SRSSsAO&AGA O AU $S $ 33333S313

?U C.CCC.*CC313 3.3133333333SS11 .3 3 $3 SS3333333S C$$*SS O BAS50SU* A&S1KOR&A1a.A..R&**aR*&RA 4C$$$SS$$S109 0CCCCCU33033 *1S33331$ S3~SS$$*$.$3 33331133$3S3$3$3$33S 0 UUASA&OaIUA&OAAUAA&&A&AUSAAAAAAS&I~AS4.R$CC$~$$66 OR CCCCCC333 3.3$3$333$$ 3 '3'S$$S3333 0 .RC #OA3A&, [J" C0ASS A'.S LAS0AOAAA&&ARRaIRsS$3 i31

l ¢COC:CIC C.$$3$$S$S$S$3S$3 .333313 33 S$ 3$~ C$~S 0 A 0CA&U&AOA3A&&&AAb&&..&&&AAA&A.tAskU&&&*&C33$$3$

6........ 5 S*$$S$ SS* MS$ SS$$ SsC SA S&&&&00Aa&&& Ss& *R#SSS$i

~t~CCCCCCS S*$S~SSS$S 3133~$$ 3b 331 0&A&U&UAARAO&&A&&&A A AAAA&&*A&A AA&£C03CSS$I ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~~~3 1 33C3G~$ E$$$SS$$$S$$ $ R&AAAASR&A &CO0SSAA .AS&A&&&A&U&SA&AA&CC$$3$$$W. S CCCC C S*S$$$ $S3333 SS Ss*3 ' $1.33 * 1330 I& A&SAAAAA&&RSASA&S& AAAA S0 00SSUCCCC(0$3123 ~CCCIC3OOQ 3.333133333 313333.3333 33 S 3 3333133 W A&&&ASSSRAW&-&S sSAA&ASA&SAOO4A&&oCCCCCL33333312 3300301031 3.*S$SS$3SS 3S3S1SS$SS $ S 3 $$1$$3 $$¥ W AAC 0 *KRR&AR&&RARARAAA&SRA&A&AA&&SU0UL)0C1 $C335121 £$CCC~C¢¢$ *$3.3333SS 3 3. $e $$$.S~ $SS *3*** ** * ,, c .~129 3 COCCOCCI 3.33133333:::::::::1::::3::: ...... .~(I

, : ~ ~: ~[IC $

131 I300300C3O .33331333333313333 33333 3333$ 33 SS3C *&&A*A&AA&&AAA&&&AAASS&A&ARA&SA&&&&&A&&A& A.A& 33C030 W.. .W.....C.ss3 sssss s . 1 $ 3ssss3 3......:::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::

1I~ ~ 003. d. ~ ~ 31333330 AA tan 3 A

143 OOCCCCCCU3 33.3 333333333 S · $ 33333333¥ *&A&AA&A OO3OO&AAAA& & &&AAA&&A&&&&&&&&O A*&CS$3C0C$$

141 33CC003 3.333333 3*!3 33 1.5 *A11'AR .AAAA.A£AR 0033

191 *$C30C0*SS 31e333.333$333333 * 3 33 3 33 $$5U0 I**e$RS&S$A&&$&$1&&bl$%$$1$$**e****eRAe,&eO$$$3033131 C 3CL*03 .... 3333. 33 s3SSS3 S$3$$31 S 33 31SS 3 $$$SSS *SSS*SssAAhA $$$65 SS$S S$$RAAARR$$SS R.A 3 .. $StA

133 11000......3 ..03. Y.13S3331331133.3 SsSSs3313 33331 33133, *C"AUARSAAAAAa mat ARCA*SAROSA.U..'3 3

113 1(.CCC*CCCO 3.333 3SSS3 *S33SS. $ $SS3 CS 5UK 3331a

9 u"9 """ssa Ss31333 333.33 3SI 1N-0 SSldO.1 :10 (it 33.33R333331333333 33111 31..00003 .313333333333 3.33333333 33333331333w. 3:330;k3133333R 333113333333.'.3a s33pq 333k3333111 ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ C A A RR 1A

119 f ?w .....C .. $ $'..... .. 33.33333333333333 $$$$ 3.33&3 U&A&&&.& & &&&&& 33$133

BAYES CLSSIFCTOTEHIU Re. lp 0

181 300001133 $3.1 33133311333331.33M3R33t 1331 1333333337-3.033",A"R S SSSSS.91 .... w$~$ . 333..............3133.3331333311 Ss Ss, St Ss 333S33I3333333333333C'1o~lu.s...... sessSC3SSSSSl30 .......31333S 3 .J33 311 31 S IS 33 UOA33I3CROUUSSAASAAAARAQkAAAAAAAA 5 5 5 03333333

I IC3CC(3LC 13 33iS ~ S I SS.0l1hR A4.UA44:A&A.AAAAAR AA ... A5AAA&A&AAAAS R3C331133

Figure 3-34. CLASSIFICATION MAP BY SPURDUE iUAUO.,AAAU4AUNIVESITALAR'S UPERVISED109ccscr BAYE -S C.SSLASSIFICATIONsSS TECHIQUC(Rf. 1, p 40

3-41

Page 65: UNSUPERVISED CLASSIFICATION OF REMOTE MULTISPECTRAL ... · i (f t , lt tr-220-1075 april 1972 unsupervised classification of remote multispectral sensing data 172-27204 ic.as c 237s9e

TR-1075NORTHROP SERVICES. INC.

LABORAIORY FUR AGRICULTURAL REMOTE SENSINGPURDUE UNIVERSIIY

*0* LARSYSAA ILLUSTRATION *e

CLASSIFICATION STUDY .. SERIAL NO. 105807300CLASSIFICATIION DAIE .. JULY 5, 1968

RUN NUMBER -----26600061

FLIGHT LINE---- CL

TAPE NUMBER---- 102

CLASSES CONSIDERED

SYMBOL CLASSS SOYBN IC CORN I0 OATSW wHEAT IR RD CL IA ALFALFAv RYEA BR SOIL

W WHEAT II

THRESHOLDS14.90014.90014.90014.90014.90014.90014.90014.90014.900

GATE ------ 6/28/66

TIME ------ 1229

ALTIIUDE-- 2600 FEET

FEATURES CONSIDERED

CHANNEL NO.I6

1012

SPECTRAL BAND0.40 0.440.52 0.550.66 0.720.80 1.00

CLASSIFICATION SUMMARY BY TEST FIELDS

CLASS

7-27 SOYB

1Z-7 SOYB

IZ-2 SOYU

12-3 SOYB

7-23 SOYB

12-9 CUORN

7-1 OATS

7-2 WHEA

12-10 wHEA

12-6 RED

1-29 RED

7-28 RED

RED

7-24 ALFA

7-24 . ALFA

TOTAL

NO OFSAMP S

401

513

ISU152

546

58c

310

260

546

713

12a

£ b5

385

19U

266

5s'uY

PCT.CORCI

63.4

19.3b8.2

91.3

94.0

84.9

93.5

90.1

80.2

96.9

98.9

86.8

93.2

83.d

NO UF SAMPLES CLASSIFIED INTO

SOYB

258

456

119

671

531

25

0

0

0

2

0

0

0

0

0

2062

CORN

12

4

11lL

8

4

553

0

0

0

3

0

0

17

0

4

OATS

84

31

18

0

0

l

314

17

0

27

4

2

S

2

19

wHEA RED ALFA RYE

O 0 0 0

O 0 0 O

0 0 0 0

O 0 0 0

I 0 O O

0 1 0 0

0 56 0 0

243 0 .0 0

492 0 0 48

0 572 109 0

u 124 0 0

0 173 0 0

O 334 24 0

O .11 177 0

0 18 223 0

616 524 736 1289 533

SOIL

0

0

0

0

10

0

0

0

0

0

0

0

O

0

0

O

0

0

0

0

THRS

53

22

2

73

0

8

0

0

6

0

0

0

5

0

2

48 10 171

OVERALL PERFORMANCE z 87.5

Figure 3-35. TABULATION OF CLASSIFICATION RESULTS OF TEST FIELDS(Ref. 10, p. 41)

3-42

_ ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

Page 66: UNSUPERVISED CLASSIFICATION OF REMOTE MULTISPECTRAL ... · i (f t , lt tr-220-1075 april 1972 unsupervised classification of remote multispectral sensing data 172-27204 ic.as c 237s9e

'/

NORTHROP SERVICES. INC. TR-1075

Section IV

UNSUPERVISED CLASSIFICATIONS OF NATURAL TERRAIN TYPES

To give a more critical test and establish the capability of the un-

supervised clustering technique, the most complex remote sensing data ever

collected by the University of Michigan Multispectral scanner under NASA's

sponsorship was chosen - the aircraft survey data over the Yellowstone

National Park test site. These data have been kindly made available by

Dr. W. H. Smedes, U. S. Geological Survey, Denver, Colorado.

4.1 DATA DESCRIPTION

These particular data were collected by the multispectral 12-channel

scanner onboard an aircraft at the altitude of about 6,000 feet (ref. 7). The

scanner resolution is 3 milliradians. Each scan line contains 220 ground

resolution cells about 20 feet square. The multispectral scanner recorded

simultaneously 12 channels of spectral bands reflecting from the earth's

surface between 0.4 and 1.0 pm. These spectral bands are listed in Table 3-1.

For the purpose of comparison with Purdue LARS's supervised classification

results, only four channels were used, i.e., channels 2, 9, 10 and 12. These

4 channels have been determined by LARS' feature selection program to be the

optional channels (based on the divergence criterion) for this particular set

of data (ref. 10).

4.2 PRELIMINARY DATA ANALYSIS

Figure 4-1* shows a gray-scale video display of reflectance for channel 9

(0.62-0.66 pm) over the area. Also shown in the figure is the ground truth

survey. Containing water, bedrock, forest, kame, till, talus and cloud shadow

over forest. Detailed physical descriptions of these terrain types are given

in reference 10. It is clear that the terrain feature is very complex, and

that many parts of the test site do not have clear-cut boundaries between

F'igures 4-1 through 4-26 and Tables 4-1 and 4-2 are presented foZZllowing thetext at the end of this section.

4-1

Page 67: UNSUPERVISED CLASSIFICATION OF REMOTE MULTISPECTRAL ... · i (f t , lt tr-220-1075 april 1972 unsupervised classification of remote multispectral sensing data 172-27204 ic.as c 237s9e

NORTHROP SERVICES. INC. TR-1075

different terrain types. This is quite different from the Purdue C-1 Flight

Line in which the boundaries between different crop types are very clear (see

Section III).

Figures 4-2 through 4-5 show the univariate probability histograms for

these four channels for the data set from scan 200 through 500. Very few

distinct modes show in each histogram, which indicates that the spectral signa-

tures from different terrain types overlap each other, and that more than one

channel would be needed for discrimination among different terrain types.

Figures 4-6 and 4-7 show the corresponding digital gray-scale plots of

the test area in channels 2 and 10, respectively. Comparing these gray-scale

plots with the gray-level video display, one can see clear correspondences for

several main areas with large contrast. It should be noted that the complement

of the numerical value with respect to 256 is proportional to the spectral

radiance collected by the scanner. Hence, the larger the numerical number as

indicated by the interval, the smaller the spectral radiance. Figures 4-8

through 4-13 show the scatter plots between channels 2, 9, 10 and 12. The

numeric 1 indicates the number of samples in each spectral cell to be between

1 and 9; numeric 2 is between 10 and 19 and so forth. From these scatter

plots, one can note that channels 2, 9 and 10 are linearly correlated, while

channel 12 is not correlated with the other three channels. This implies that

the terrain types possess quite different reflectance characteristics in the

visible and reflected IR ranges. It is also noted that no distinct cluster

is visible in these scatter plots, which, in turn, indicates the overlapping

of spectral signatures of different terrain types as observed from the

invariate probability histograms.

Figure 4-14 shows a boundary map of the test area obtained by using the

boundary enhancement principle (ref. 8). In this map, the symbol (-) indi-

cates that the enhanced spectral difference among adjacent resolution elements

lies between the mean enhanced value over the entire target area plus one

standard deviation and the mean plus two standard deviations. The symbol (+)

4-2

Page 68: UNSUPERVISED CLASSIFICATION OF REMOTE MULTISPECTRAL ... · i (f t , lt tr-220-1075 april 1972 unsupervised classification of remote multispectral sensing data 172-27204 ic.as c 237s9e

NORTHROP SERVICES. INC. TR-1075

indicates that the enhanced difference lies between the mean plus two standard

deviations and the mean plus three standard deviations. The symbol (x) in-

dicates that the enhanced difference is greater than the mean plus three

standard deviations. Finally, the area with the enhanced difference smaller

than the mean plus one standard deviation is left blank. In other words, the

blank area implies a relatively homogenous region, while the area indicated

by the symbol (x) has the largest spectral contract between adjacent resolu-

tion elements. These boundaries are found to be in good correspondence with

the gray-level video display in Figure 4-1.

4.3 UNSUPERVISED CLASSIFICATION OF TERRAIN TYPES

Figures 4-15 through 4-24 show the intermediate and final unsupervised

classification maps of the test area by the composite statistical and K-mean

technique. The purpose of presenting the intermediate results is to show

how the composite technique performs at its various stages so that some types

of automatic decision logic may be formulated and built into the present com-

puter program to achieve a more autonomous unsupervised classification scheme.

For processing the set of data, a maximum of 18 classes was initially

specified for the statistical sequential clustering. The output from this

processing after only one pass of the entire data set is a set of mean spec-

tral signatures for 18 initial classes. (Note: If the K-mean clustering had

been used, 17 passes of the entire data set would have been required to

estimate the 18 initial cluster centers. Further, these initial cluster

centers would not be as accurate as those obtained by the statistical sequen-

tial technique). The choice of a maximum of 18 classes for the data was based

on a rough examination of the video display of the test area (Figure 4-1),

and 18 classes were believed to be sufficient. Actually, the number is twice

as large as the main terrain types indicated by the ground truth survey map

(Figure 4-25) supplied by Dr. W. H. Smedes, U. S. Geological Survey. The

study is presently underway on how to decide on a suitable number of initial

classes for any given data set. This study will be presented in the final

contract report.

4-3

Page 69: UNSUPERVISED CLASSIFICATION OF REMOTE MULTISPECTRAL ... · i (f t , lt tr-220-1075 april 1972 unsupervised classification of remote multispectral sensing data 172-27204 ic.as c 237s9e

TR-1075NORTHROP SERVICES. INC. TR-175

The above mean spectral signatures of the 18 initial classes were input

to the K-mean clustering program for further improvement. Figures 4-15 and

4-16 show the classification maps after one and two iterations, respectively,

of these initial classes. A comparison of these two maps shows that the

majority of class 7 is grouped into class M in the second iteration. Other-

wise, no noticeable change has occurred in the second iteration. From the

ground truth map, one finds that classes M and 7 both belong to the same class

forest. The very few changes between the first and second iteration classifi-

cation results indicates that the cluster centers have very rapidly converged

to their true locations in the color space. In turn, this may imply that the

initial cluster centers obtained by the statistical sequential clustering

using only one pass of the data are quite good indeed. Hence, by only three

passes of the data sets, i.e., one for the statistical sequential clustering

and two for the K-mean clustering, good classification of the data set has

been accomplished. By the K-mean clustering, more than 20 passes of the data

set would have been required and the clustering results would not be as

accurate as those obtained by the composite technique.

The ground truth map (Figure 4-25) does not give a resolution element-

by-resolution element terrain type specification. Instead, it shows only the

average percentage descriptions of terrain types. For example, one area at

the upper left-hand corner shows 80 percent rubble and 30 percent forest (i.e.,

.7 R, .3 F). Thus, it is not possible to make an exact assessment of the

classification accuracy. Furthermore, the ground truth map gives only nine

terrain types. For the easier comparisons, the 17 classes resulting from the

K-mean program were further reduced one class at a time to nine classes. The

criterion used for merging classes is the simple Enclidean distance in the

color space. In other words, first the pairwise distances of all the 17

classes are calculated, and then the two classes which have the shortest

distance among all possible pairs are combined. This process is repeated on

the resulting 16 classes and so on. The classification maps for each of these

merging processes are shown in Figures 4-17. through 4-24. The actual merging

processes are summarized in Table 4-1. Two meeting arrows denotes the merging

4-4

Page 70: UNSUPERVISED CLASSIFICATION OF REMOTE MULTISPECTRAL ... · i (f t , lt tr-220-1075 april 1972 unsupervised classification of remote multispectral sensing data 172-27204 ic.as c 237s9e

NORTHROP SERVICES. INC. TR-1075

of two classes at that particular stage of merging with the new symbol for the

merged class given above the arrows. The single arrow denotes the change of

class symbol, for example, from class 2 to class = at the 3rd stage of merging.

The latter change of class symbol is due to the computer program coding and is

of no significance.

The physical identities of each of the nine classes are determined for

this case by comparing the unsupervised classification map (Figure 4-24) with

the ground truth survey map (Figure 4-25). The result is shown also in Table

4-1. In actual operation, the physical identities will be established by

checking a small percentage of each class on site. As mentioned earlier, it

is not possible for this set of data to make an exact assessment of classifi-

cation accuracy. The overall accuracy is about 80 percent. This comparison

was made by Dr. W. H. Smedes who has the detailed knowledge on this test site

(ref. 4). The main misclassification came from mingling two terrain types -

water and talus even prior to merging classes. The mean spectral signatures

of water and talus are given below, as obtained from small areas in the test

site,

Ch-2 Ch-9 Ch-10 Ch-12

Water 85.3 84.2 81.7 67.2

Talus 77.3 75.5 82.1 50.1

which are quite similar to each other for comparing with the mean spectral

signatures of the other 16 classes before merging of classes (Table 4-2).

4.4 COMPARISON WITH SUPERVISED CLASSIFICATION

For a better appraisal of the performance of the composite clustering

technique, the unsupervised classification map (Figure 4-24) is compared with

the supervised classification map obtained by Purdue University's LARS using

the maximum likelihood method over the same test area (refs. 4 and 10). The

supervised classification map is shown in Figure 4-26. The accuracy of the

classification is found to be about 86 percent as also reported by Dr. Smedes.

This accuracy is higher than the 80 percentby the composite clustering tech-

nique. However, to obtain this higher accuracy, much human intervention and

4-5

Page 71: UNSUPERVISED CLASSIFICATION OF REMOTE MULTISPECTRAL ... · i (f t , lt tr-220-1075 april 1972 unsupervised classification of remote multispectral sensing data 172-27204 ic.as c 237s9e

NORTHROP SERVICES. INC. TR-1075

manipulation were needed by (a) knowing where to pick the typical training

areas for every type of terrain of interest, (b) classifying the entire set

of data and calculating the classification accuracy, and (c) new training

areas were selected when the accuracy was found to not be good enough. In

contrast to this iterative processing with close human supervision, the unsu-

pervised classification map (Figure 4-14 or Figure 4-24) were obtained with

very little human intervention, only specifying the maximum number of initial

classes to begin with the processing. The computation time required for both

the LARS supervised and unsupervised composite classification methods are

about the same.

4-6

Page 72: UNSUPERVISED CLASSIFICATION OF REMOTE MULTISPECTRAL ... · i (f t , lt tr-220-1075 april 1972 unsupervised classification of remote multispectral sensing data 172-27204 ic.as c 237s9e

NORTHROP SERVICES. INC. TR-1075

This page is reproduced again at the back of this report by a different reproduction method so as to furnish the best possible detail to the user. 4-7

Page 73: UNSUPERVISED CLASSIFICATION OF REMOTE MULTISPECTRAL ... · i (f t , lt tr-220-1075 april 1972 unsupervised classification of remote multispectral sensing data 172-27204 ic.as c 237s9e

TR-1075NORTHROP SERVICES. INC.

tuhawt--- dO4 60 t00 fRo t40

CATA

160 tOo too

:1

a30 to 40 tR

RANGE

Figure 4-2. PROBABILITY HISTOGRAM OF CHANNEL 2

4-8

14GO

IEUU

800

600

p

0

Aa

L

I

T

N

U

N

T

N

UF

N

300

I -

D

-1

_ .

so

Page 74: UNSUPERVISED CLASSIFICATION OF REMOTE MULTISPECTRAL ... · i (f t , lt tr-220-1075 april 1972 unsupervised classification of remote multispectral sensing data 172-27204 ic.as c 237s9e

TR-1075NORTHROP SERVICES. INC.

III I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I ........ ~~ I, ,, [I IIIlI~

,oo I itIl III II , ,

IFiitFIIII I Irll 1I' ------ II I I I I I ! I I! It1l rl V I I ,lll _llI I I I I i' I I

*eo_ __ __ __i__ r lir' ! I I I I I ! I II1

,oo~~~ li i r I I I! ! I i I! 1 __ I I I IIIIIIIr NT r _ ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ I I L_____---- I1-111111.00 _Iiiiiil iirlL- iiii!1

.00~ ~~~i ! i ! ! t l I I 111zLL_________T I I I I I IilliT 10111 i i i i ii ilLiLi

1 ii I I I ii r i I I I I I I I

.oo ~ ~ r Il I lllTI Ih I I.i' I I I I I ] I 1I12!r !~I If .;.ll 1 1111 I I I I I111.- r T _ X X | t I ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~I I 1111_________ I 111

o T 4II|I I I I1 1J.~'111 I I I I I I I 1trl T I ! I ~, I I I I I I~u I I I 1 lIII

'w _ _ _ rr -r _ I l' 1I I I I I I I ____ __ s ~_ III I I I Iil I I I I_________ I I r '

III i I IITII Il I I I I IA _ l I~l 1soe_ __ __ __ nIll I I I I IR kl l I I I I

rrlTl II i lf .11 I I I I I I I ,,, Ill I I I I I I L _II I I I I I ! I

_~~~~I _ _ _I I I I I I I~ltf 1 1 I ! 1111 I.' _T 7 _ |Ilgl II I I I I l I i l v_> 1111

I11 I I_ I I I In _I S 0z i!11 ii eIete*

DATA RANCE

Figure 4-3. PROBABILITY HISTOGRAM OF CHANNEL 9

4-9

0

BAaILITv

C

N

s

TV

r

U

N

CT

0

mI

~~~~I I I~ll I I I I I I 1 I IIII IIIIL IIIII IIII II I I I I I I I IIII? I I I I I I I I I I I I I 1 I I I_.1 I I II ! l I ..IlIIl I I I- I I I - -I I I. " -. I - I L L L.. I L. ~~~~~~~~~~~~~I I I i-__I

!I ~~~~~~~~~~~~-iil~ I I II I I I I I i11 411 1 - -vi-~ ~~~~~~~~~~ I I

_4~~ I ~i! I I I I_ I I I 'II I

too

&.v40 so au sw lw .. _ .

*wu Ki _ .. _....

v to

Page 75: UNSUPERVISED CLASSIFICATION OF REMOTE MULTISPECTRAL ... · i (f t , lt tr-220-1075 april 1972 unsupervised classification of remote multispectral sensing data 172-27204 ic.as c 237s9e

NORTHROP SERVICES. INC.

II I 1 1 I I I 1I1 ! 1 1 I I I II If E I . . . . . . . .

II I I I I 10 1 I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I 114I 1 FI 111111

t tt- t I I li 1 1 Ir 1 1 I 1 1 11 I - I -I I -f 1 1 1 1 1 _ _ _ _ _1 _1 _I

_~~~~~~L _I 1P ]I11 _e__________

Too

too Xllllll1

IH~ ~ ~~~~IY

I ~ ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ VT

-, - III1111111' , r 1111 ' ,,

." ll~.rS lflYt Il, 111

- eo so 1 to 140 t ISO Ito tL_

oe_ __F it[ t24 J44 224 22 ll _t__ __ __ __ I II 1 L l II II II II II I1141

_, _O It 1......1L 1111Ll1 lIIII ______

0 40 60 tO 100 110 140 tir, tri Dn son _ _n 0___e__ 'gOATA RANGE

Figure 4-4. PROBABILITY HISTOGRAM OF CHANNEL 10

4-10

see

pR0Ya

aI

L

CIN

Ty

FU

N

0m

8

I

I

TR-1075

I

5

4

1

Page 76: UNSUPERVISED CLASSIFICATION OF REMOTE MULTISPECTRAL ... · i (f t , lt tr-220-1075 april 1972 unsupervised classification of remote multispectral sensing data 172-27204 ic.as c 237s9e

- ~~~~1 ; I : I I J i H i I l ! I i #I IC_. . . . .. . _ m . . ._ i i i . . . . _ I ! i · ! ! ! I I ! ! I ! i i · a J. .I.· _ _

11I iil],111111111111II1llil ll!111111 I! 111~ I I I I I I I I I I I I t IJ I J1 1 J- IJ I I I . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .

. . . . . . I I I I I I a I11 I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I ] I I I I I I I I I I J I l

_j ~ ~I11I11I11111II11LIJ 11111 1111111111- _IL II11111I' .H i l11111 -J 111111111111II1Ilill! 1 1 1 11111I1.111111

·l i l

I I I_ I I _I I _ I _ _ I _ _ _ r _I _I l Illlll ;.;;;l;;. _ _ I I I I I 1

I I I IfIl I I I I 1 I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I .I

I I Il il l IJ I I IJJ J I IJ J I I I I Il l I IJ J

[ f i l l I r i Il l l lin

,DO I l i l 1 1111111l 1111lll1

~~~~illl111llllliAllllllt11

-A ~ ~ 111~1111111llliilJl I1LI401 1111111111 1111111.111111It 1 1 1 II

DATA RANGE

Figure 4-5. PROBABILITY HISTOGRAM OF CHANNEL 12

4-11

NORTHROP SERVICES. INC.

soeeo

tSoo O

TR-1075

1O00

t00

p

r

0

L

VYT

C

N

S

I

YT

r

F

UN

T

N

_ _ _Illlllllllllllllll!111111111111 I_Il lII ll!1lilllLTllllllllllllllllllJilll _llllliillllllllllllllllli11111

ii l 11111111111_ _ lll !: L 1111'11_1!l mll ll l l I I , ll il.! l Ill I I Ill l J J JJ J Xgl

~~~~? Y ---- IlIlI 1-1 1 1 1 1 1 111111111111111111I1 1t_ _ _ _ l l '11II!111111__ _ lllilll tlll!111 11lllllT_

14 I

I I

I Ir

lo0

S400

so

SO

40

20C

4

~Vla0

Page 77: UNSUPERVISED CLASSIFICATION OF REMOTE MULTISPECTRAL ... · i (f t , lt tr-220-1075 april 1972 unsupervised classification of remote multispectral sensing data 172-27204 ic.as c 237s9e

TR-~1075NORTHROP SERVICES. INC.

,,,,, ,,,, ,,.h^,. O.,, ~~......... N. draWl .,liT.|~~~~~~~~~~ ..|t.. t0* ~ s...............................le c

*LI~.T ~1 ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ .....,. J . . .) I.L...l. *,O.........,

.......... .......

,.............. .. O.. -.. , ..... 0

......... . . .....

...... .........

. ~, , ,~.0

ill h s..q~l~lx*~-, .~.~ ........ Sl ss lsao ooao0//,o/ /;o.o,......./..........H. *om.*

J l A & J I & . ............

XOOOOOOOOOOOCOOO~OO@Oo~babOOO~ *-.............. ......................... . ........... . ...- . -.-. --....... --. -..--- .---. --.--

:: *'°" *~Ae *st '~ s)' lJ " '" 'l 's* *t wX X s'|| 4as'* ~ a *°0/~;;' ''; */;/'" H//'00*' )f * *' ---'°1';'0

.. l. .................... 1 ,. ......S ~S..-~.-*;0/0;/ o'* D0;'*.;/ *e;0. . ~. J.~2/

.. . ,dE, @..-..-... .... *I I . I *- ............... 0.... -.1 ) e..*4.80/.

........~e,* ~,~~* o* ......... lo o. o-... *~o-/ /;;/o0./H H /Q/~~']ooHo*0

* ., ,,...-,,, ..-. .s *.-.. ..o . .o -,oo . o ;. , oc,,- .. )-.. S...

~ro~ ., ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~.......H ...,,,.,., .,,- -*..o.Go..~~Ho//~ ..-.. . /,/o -...-. ,)~.o.

... ........ ....... ,..,-..I, ........./...''0 0'..'.' '''

~~~~~~. . ......... ........ ....... |. 0 .1.........}n'''".'.. o '''

1w ,,,,,,, ., ,,.. .,,, ,................................. r|. "''''''

i, .,,.,," ,,.,,..,..,,. ,....... ...... ,.,, , .................. ,.u

:: , , ............... . ............. ................

It' ... .. . t^ ~. .... .. .... q.. .. X .. -. ... oo.S .......

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~...... . |..., ,+F.... ll.{ .

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~..1.,, .. ,,........... ,,,... .. , ,,.,. ,,...... .. ............. ,,.,,,,

~~~~~~~~.. .... . ,,: ... . , / .. i.. .: o ....... s......

::% ; ,`;,; 2 2::?' .. ............. :. ............... :;.; : .:::-.;..

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~...... ....... ..... .. ...............ns.,1;~rltt. ... ..r

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~. ; . ., ,... !,,,,al.,,,, , .,._...a~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~......... .*,j|$; !1S,!|~. v .

Figure 4-6.7i.......... DIGITAL GRAY-LEVEL. PLOT.OF.CHANNEL.2............ ..... ......... 2..

i7iii!i ~ ~iii~ ii i~ ~i! i!:ii iii!!i!i~ iiii!iil ii:

.. s~~~~~~~.....

'.' `.~~~~~~~~~~~..:..."XX.XX:`~;;`:X:;;;:X.. X;~~X"~X~~X.'............."x

.,, X;X2L'2;~XXY~~~ ~~~. 'Uf; ;iX [ ;2L3 .i:% i] % iC i:X 2 :c...... .*...'... X. . ....;;, ~X.;::;;::::','.;:;.;:;;;;;:;~:;;'.? :::: : ..::...:....:..:....:.::::..::::::: .;'":.".:

Figure 4-6~~~..................T F CANNL

4~~~~~~...... ..... 2

Page 78: UNSUPERVISED CLASSIFICATION OF REMOTE MULTISPECTRAL ... · i (f t , lt tr-220-1075 april 1972 unsupervised classification of remote multispectral sensing data 172-27204 ic.as c 237s9e

TR-1075NORTHROP SERVICES. INC. TR-1075

....

a .. ,~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~.. l

. .i,,,,,,e,,,, ,,,~~~~~~~~~~~~..,,.,........ .

i .i1,1 - I,°I ,i

3M. ~ ~~~~ l"tM"1No i; illl l~llt'~tl ~ !~ f l t ...1 i ........

. tGOO-....l.l.l..... ........ 1111....l....lllfi/l/ / / # 11ll l..... lal I .

G 0 j'Il 00'1I*b l **t O0 0 ag O04j, ih~Ig Slatst Ilhh,0itlI ,',',1 lzhbI I ",|:.:: ,A:,aIta;S,

tl b*4*Z @S--|-fiK| *aiSIFkaI4r~o~vn#o2

Is*on atflif 7£|_*f** *.*7i a@¢

.a~ta.0 1 00*Ia~.Is......... .Is ..a........ 4.. ............. **,0fl*Q0......370

................ *~nh..o.O.o.n.. ,)...a0 50.:l'i * *. -0 ...... ........................

i............/, / /o"/3Oi'0*0o4/

l l, .~*~* ~ ~ *1*~*, 1* "Ia/a~//~?~g**/~*//./ *: = 11, 1//11tliii. Iii!

.I a50.W..**3)I 0 ,Ouus .................. .o.-.|.0..III Ksi&i ~ *igaII-bl----l--*-l--o|U ---~--itiA~ill§D-*/ ~ ~//§#S /~/~=// lS/j~ l? A -- 4ER-b

*003t3 A*0-b34 00o,.3.. .I hap...0 . ...................'0..a..o

,, 1111111111. ~ K ~J~~/ *~*~///~/~/ ~/ ~///~/ ~ /f i

0$- 88a

00 ;*;00 -05, .00fl0,,000I . " .IG-;-,° a Q 0 3* S b .@---

,a ,............. 0 000*Il...00a x~e*.1 oe§S*##o++ve~r*Kew**.v~. .............................. ................ ¢1b eS

Iitlltlljllll llllllllll.llll....-iI;; °-'ollllo//ll ll;lll/////iII ** -0~a. Ool////-/ *11...................

a jl bab& ** l F@*+v a I w ~~........................... o~oeo §fE......... 8 ~fwv4ooe-|*-f~ t*a b @| l-- .s.*ol ...................... l -o.lo¢.-- -OGzo*va B *.o-............. b.>e{

t;I aWlfi|4z* *ss ss.o*z~oo--l : u 1v.S 1.f ....................................................... 1.1 ...... - 1o8

l~ t&& -.s-. .IOvllS §w................ ................ I I *|./o.{. ............ . .1. X01 o8

Oil ;0, ~** t I; -; t t ; l ; ; ihX O0 .//laS 8@o *-

o41 RiB iA iB ..............h&oFIB .i*~+~/~/~... ozwo o I{RbI1 .. ~ /~J*.................

*1:1-11111 llll-ll-,,,,1111 I I ,-.....I*.101*.,/J/OO ,*O,,/./,,,lI.iI.O ,,.,,.Il I/OTI,,, li.I,.11.,::

* 1}fx~1................... , v.v......... .. .. 8#.*.] .8.t@............................... ... .II................ .010.1.,........ s0 01.t/a

ats$K>~i8X*X~s&[ I.| P} j--Parooo.§bowI v/zS~o~v ..................................-...-. o-1--............... 0.0..0~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~.... ..

~~~0 .000 a~~~~~~.... . .

.................. 0i/'40,..0a.

0.................................... *1- . 1b8.*eesE,1-0..b|.0/..>.8O.o K @,*|E,.

J13 ;.. ;.°. ab ~*...........a...$-..*/.../ ....Goi~J/

a...0....

~ .* ~ ~ * ~ 6~`~Q~; ~ /~................. ...... ......a1IIIIIll111...............

.. ......... Q~~ ~ " *~= .* Q/~/ .. /... .l//./.. ......

.00 .. .~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~.....

*-- * . *X1. ...... W@.*.bE1 1#w•s.1 .................. 1 11t.111l. ......... .. / 011..... ........ . ........

.00. .0 . 0~~~~~~~~~~~~.;.... ......

14% W~~~~~~~~~~~~~~. .. o *.11 ................. ......... 0. 11s... o/#.*1.0f.1 .0.b........ o 1 ./.111 --

lll1111111111 lllllll.*/*oe~aWS~0¢ llla oI .. I ~]11* lllllloO* ,11111 I110 1- 0 / / 1*l0/~1/IIIII/} '0 II011

.' ' *- -- - - - - 00- ' U * .- * **'e'400o 00...0n.0.. .. ...... ......

**;. *;. ;%g|0X/O....... ......1. ... v. .. 1 . . .*.. 4..... ...... . d ,1 D ,,,... .. , ...................... .. ... Dn,......

' 7 ''.....4.' .' * 01 11bK .. . b%........... 20 ........

,1i,,,.,,0.0.--'.1'''"*- .................... '*-

,, . ... .3z ; S0**0 §o bloo/#................................. .......

4?,Z.,4,,,,,,,,............... . ..... ,, .. ,~%.... 1.11...0'/.#'.---''............' *w S j6~~~~~~.w.z.8 ..... ,,1. IIl,,I/.%.,........., §.§.o.. s.. ..... . .. 1...

Figure 4-7. DIGITAL GRAY-LEVEL PLOT OF CHANNEL 10

4-13

. ~ -~"~&~.-~** ~ *.~*] ~ ~/G~x~**~//*//////~*~*//~*/~/////

&~&B ~ &~&i~J~mi~i~[~d~*G~j ~ x~x~BS~*~/.~*~* ~ //~/~/~/~/~e~*~*G~/

Page 79: UNSUPERVISED CLASSIFICATION OF REMOTE MULTISPECTRAL ... · i (f t , lt tr-220-1075 april 1972 unsupervised classification of remote multispectral sensing data 172-27204 ic.as c 237s9e

NORTHROP SERVICES. INC. TR-1075

03$Ck[T8 SC*TT70 #E# 03*6#&# 0U69t0 O 560P9L0 YH#OM L

KULTIhsVCTAL SCA##[n o&T& I T#NU ' &^ft£LLGSTOht NATIO#&^L P^tK TKST Sl?[ :' F~ I0 84*U 0 I

5CA~ Li ht~ ZOO ThNU 94L SHPL7S I T HRU '(C #0 ?*#U 0· #· ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~o T##U S·

. 6~~~~~~~~~~0 78794 6· a

Cl7ANNrLs USLU iAvILENGHT INCRo~SI 70 ?nvu 39 3

2 Olqq i O^q& V[RlTZCL COUROl~I#T ~O TNRU 9t · O.66 - 4.00 KO#IZONV A L CT003 32200

2390000 9

23S e0t1

Z3). I *Z

ZZS~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~6 797341*.

J22,~8,~~~~~~~ 0.I-00 (76U60036k0 04 9

zte.&o6 I

2133.362.23?.2&y

2oe.003

227.,3J

tII."Sz .~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~I

200.^ s03

200.093 . 33 3

242.oSl . I l3l I

300,,343. 3 3 3

30o.33t. I3l~ 3

380.7,3 6 I I I3

I1nH/Vi I11 11 I17&*.93 ll A.I II It I

i00.6s 7 . oI 1 1

I171.1ZI l l l l l II37*,03 7 3 O 3 i373.0,1 . 1111111 3373.323. 3333333 1 1

360.344 I I 1111111 1

I'?.!°' * I 111'11il

]s3*&i; It 1 11 1111 11 1lil

I36%. 303h . I 3333

I3l7.30 0 I I 1 11 1111111 3

IMS /' A.I IIII I I I Ii I~ililllJl I

I4.l I I . Jl t lllJ .

137,.37. 7 33 n .3333

Iq2.OJn . ix I l l l J l ll 'l i sljl lj1 j

14-.0¥1 .I I I i 1111 111. 1111111I)#.1%1 I t I I I 1~ 111IlllllllllllllliJJ I '

133.,, . I 3 111 1111111111111 1 13

I0J.04 I I I III I 3 3I I I I3 I3 I3I3I3I3I

12^651N * I~~~~~~~~~~J 1111 Illl l JJll lJ2l-S-I J" lJIJIIII I 111

303.330 . . I 11 1111 31111j5^-4221 11 333 1 1

J~*~%% ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ i i i I,,lllJlllliJ2 JJJsJl iJ~lJq llJllllll;~.~1% . Il1l11i1 1 Illl~ll~lJ]b JqJJJJl~l.,Ss4.................. ,,I,, II

304.3J 3 ,I I3 1311 13 l llz qbq&&b~4J33333333 1 333

" I " *I I I I I II It I 112 t9i"-lZI1S~t& qg1ql l l l lll I I3m.on . I I 3ltil3333l3l33333333333333333 1 131

}i~.Y1 j J lllll|| lj 9 9 9 V 3llltl|&Vv.Jsql iJl J I J II.a, I" I I1 11 11{lII121Tq9996-@i5WJI211111 l

0Jl2.'J I Jt111 I~ ill IlliilZ' bq' v'~'JIIIIIi i 11J{LI.O~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~a~~ " I i1213Zq2 II I Il 2 J 1?1 171 1 1 l~ 1& 11

l~*Is I2 11111 ,lillillltsjl 4m&~v llelllq ljl I 5v 510?7 Illtlll I2 lllii41qbs 998&J A42|1 1 J l} Ii

q-@.~bq lll IlllilSlS ljlS~-]qJII{~bql~l lJlI q7,qZ~ ~112 251t St---36bJeq]Sq{2{t ll1e%.4#~ I tll2 't'-tltllqs ~q9 &q-e ~JJZ 1 1 1 1 Iv).sqr I [2 ilti~ZJ13Jq2S-;599esee1 1 1 1 dI9t*&O 12 12)J-s- q6&S89V*q~.Sel qlI itl

us.?m# 11 tl3- qZqsev@v9 -7S699eb63q2{11 {AjBq tl siqee&99v~99^e~-' 9v.'S7 97 6z l l{ I

7997 iZ II59vq26783~'b966SJ~~q21 11

330.473S. 3333 3333 3333 3333 3333 3333 333

3A0.30. {133333339333433933333 3 3

7q hl ? 11--7 q97999)q9799M67622L77,2l) 115tq.'d 99999)99b43111117027S l~~ ¥9~~~&){IS I1 9299 2 11111111

.n64 X.4 Il14~eVtme5211 11il 16{Si LS C I{VVe aZItI I-s7S11

S~.697 .tqevvv.V)53{l1 1 sN.7s# ZVVVVVqIZltII I52,~L~ le9eevv"tll 1

so3a;* 22I e"1I ti

,?,ocn . Ill

1wZ1 s ' -0 v I{'SN. VJ'lh) JO 8 * v i - IZ~'hl & 149'Z4J I { { q - 1 0 II-. 6 4 b 1-7.~2- Ilb.UOU

-Figure· 4-8. SCATTER PLOT OF CHANNELS 2 AND g

4-14

Page 80: UNSUPERVISED CLASSIFICATION OF REMOTE MULTISPECTRAL ... · i (f t , lt tr-220-1075 april 1972 unsupervised classification of remote multispectral sensing data 172-27204 ic.as c 237s9e

NORTHROP SERVICES. INC.TR07

7I4SttATA SCAATE4IAO 04A&.At"NOAUjA 0F SA#PL[S %YASOL

1104T411DAAT0L SCANNER DATA .TtLLOI.0 T AAAAL AICIANL *AAK AI£T Slt I TAAO 114

20 TOAU 2~ 2SCAN .41(5 200 TOAD 4114 S AAPLES I YARD 24 0OAD 3

310 ToAD oN

&0010 9 &

710 ITAU 797o 0.1 - 0.Ot VERTICAL NA0ORIAATL A0 1T.KU 49 A

40 0.00 0.12 H O ARIZONTAL COOROAAATL *0 THAU0 IT

231.0&1.03S.112

231.la2

220.0O3

221. 3611

221.11e1

2o1.11o% .

200.~; IDI

202.4%? . 4 i4 l ll l ~ 1 l l

110.114.. 4 I41Ill I ml l J

)410.0 4l III4I I l t I I * I4I2.4011 . III ~ll&l I1)1l llm 44.l I I 11.lllll1lill .~l 1 :4 4

13. 2 7. I l I III II l t l l ; 1 1 1 1 1 I I I ; i

IA2~, A.i l~l IL~lllllllllll I 44 44 li Ii

i//A i iII I I II Illll l h+~ qZII lll I

,,'-.~,y IiI ~1: iltl 11ill~~~~~ll4lI b 1lu1414 444111114444I I

1I4.,14' 4l4l1ll4L141tllINII41¥114441111141 ii 1 i

All00 . 44 44 4 IIII144 14,1 II~i~l% ~ llllll 4II 4114.071, 44 4 Ill1ll 44111111vvi~)t l I i 11

4110.014 Jil 4I444l 111441441141,4441114111111, 4

I )1.l44 . II l I 44lllll1l444114444444illlll 41441 I I

14.41.4II~ I141141 4111141114,~l~~llllllll

t~,1~, Illlllltll~~~~1411l/%ss t11111141 4 1 4 1112 1 i412 44111141I7.01.. i4141llll; l2~~l~Sl11I1.~11I1 44 .1011 4441114111 I l

i~,~ ~ ~~~ ~ ~~~ 44 11111qlll~,glSlilllI1ll442 41I10l 214 11 11 4 i

¥~~~~ ~~1,144 i li1li4114444,1l444144441A144lllll I ''.4l .4 4 4 4

~.I~41 i i llll~l~l~I/114 ¥&1/71¥?11¥14442411111o011IA 0I i 24444 .

~~~~~111.070.¥Y 144l761444 ) 111144.2 I 1 Soil241444I 4 4

4,40.1"?.h 4 4444e4~tS311114 l4i 4)1 221o444,124444 4

IDI.1744lJ1111ll .4444442?24131111 iA4444144

II0.41,. ~1111114412 40221 11A.1111424144441

i1¥,.½o . ¥ 141141111 22-A201AA46712444 I

~i.'IIo .14141l12TT1101 01%1A0111 144

77ur .4-9. $CTE ILO OF,1 CHAHNEL$.I 101201 ^HD1 11,244 4

4-15

Page 81: UNSUPERVISED CLASSIFICATION OF REMOTE MULTISPECTRAL ... · i (f t , lt tr-220-1075 april 1972 unsupervised classification of remote multispectral sensing data 172-27204 ic.as c 237s9e

NORTHROP SERVICES. INC. T- 7

2303$3(ET SC60TE9[NG 2304909039066 UP 6007166 9/93OL

9ULO36VCCTAL 60093.09 26TAHYLLUOWSToSE NATIONAL PAR. TEST SiTE oo

io T3900 39 2

63h~.L33.E6 200 TONI, 497 SAMPLES i TONI, 23230TOU 3]0 TM#U3 ~9

00 THOU 09 0

0 .99 - 0.04 VEHOICAL CUOOOIOOTE[oTHU 812 o .00 -]3.0 HORIZONTAL COHORINiAT! OTHU 9

237.0&1

231.293

226.·Z9

239.60.

233. 30223o3.00n

20,.U~~~~~~~~~~~i ~ . 3 It3

232.362 . 3 3 3 ]07.,2; Al 33

193.023 . I 33399.39. . 3 III3

392.966 . 3 3 33 3 3 3~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

390.636~~~~~~~~~~~~~j . 3 33 :300.634~~~~ ~ ~~~ ~~~~~~~~ .3 I

70~.339 .I 3 3~ tI I

176.939 .333 106.000 .t 373.0.3. I I3331333 3~ 3

369.38; i I 3l 3 l 33 33 3 3

340.092 .I it 3 I 333 '3

363.349. 3 3 3 3 3 l 3333 3363.929, [ 3I 333333

360.~~~~~~~~~H6.~~~ ~ 3 !3l~ 3i 3ttltl3333333636'.*e i3ii3333i33333333ililll

366.604. I 31 33 333 l33333333 I I I363...,. 3 3 33 3 3 3l3333333333333l3333353.723. 333 3 3 l333333l3ll Jill3ll 33q.7.30' ] J I3 3 33 i 3333311i333 33 3

396eH09 . 3 II I 3 tl3l3333i33333333333 i303.900 . 3 3 3 3 33l33 lli3l3I JJ392.3300 33 3333 lil Il ll3 III 3 390.003. 33 33 33 II 33333333-3333131333333333l

330.7233 3 3 i 11311111111111 3333333333333333t

322.43.. 3 I i 11333311111 1111 32lllillt 61223l/2333333333 33233.40. 3 333 333333 3333333236l933930793.33232333333333lJJ 333

12q.~1. ~ ~ 3333333 333 29309069 233333 3 336.030.I I I iJ i331 33 33333333332,600290333 3392*233333333333 j

339.939. 33333 Ill tit it 3333326 29909903099 1112 36~~/2333llll3333 3

332.929.~ ~ ~ 3333313333333333333296i30909000360333333333333333333333 3333.000. ~ ~ ~ ~ II 3333 333333333323366969323233333333333333333333 l

33.9.003.til 3333333333333333333322960332006696322223323333333333333I323.323. ~ Il 333 1333333 3333333399433904769399322333233333333333331111 333

306.382. ~ l il 333333333333333333333399769069' 63232J,333333333333333l 333303.292. ~ ~ I~ 333 333333333333333333333996,96699933232323333333333333

303.903. 33 lll 3333313333 333333 3333 6/¥3233H ~A.933933333333332333333333333 33

09.6.$&3333331 33323333333332394lliltlJ300307346699 3922211333333llii3333 l 3 I03.320 . 3333333333333323333233322692700003060 ·$q.39323Zl233333333333I333i 3l

02.090 33333333l3I33llll2222l22J906T09990S9663q)3312122222333l333tlll3~ 3 3

/0,2'2 3333331111213269690673 300HH93a99904,39 322333333333333333 Jil3 00.423. 33333331i322233699600.9033990/09963669321263]23333331113333l Illl

3l.30.. I 3313313l33l2l29996903300901l9999¥U63662222?3131333 1133llll I

62.636. .3~lll333322329030900 ~/393 Qt3007399932I J~~llll3Il 33311 3

00.633 . ll333 l231233323 3 93/H9 0990020903636009323333333331333q.3 .63,.332931293.36b~90309900,93 9l922 ~qJ~lJ~~J 3333333 I60.693 3133939903030303 779903 99900133.632l3333133331 I3J 6n...6,33.293 3]] 0JlJ3J7090q33663 ul3133133333 JJJI jl

Figure 4-10. SCATTER PLOT OF CHANNEL 2 AND 12

4-16

Page 82: UNSUPERVISED CLASSIFICATION OF REMOTE MULTISPECTRAL ... · i (f t , lt tr-220-1075 april 1972 unsupervised classification of remote multispectral sensing data 172-27204 ic.as c 237s9e

NORTHROP SERVICES. INC.TR07

IlhSCREV? 9$A&T(C1I9 0349299NUH8,# 0F SAMffLOS SN~OOL

911LJPICOAL $C.914(# 04T 0 9 694[LO9iSOON NtlI09&L PARK 7£s! biT[ I 91.2U 9'

l0 9,15U 19I20 01'90 29 2

SCAN LIN£S 2CO TMRU19*9 SAMPLES I T0H1U 222Z o 92 3

50 T9H1U 39 j

COOSNEL S US£D 900¥[-LENG.9T 191895,-#6ONS.I*7 0 T.19U ?99

9.062 -G0.& ' V(RTICAL COORDITAAT£ sO TH.U .9 10 9.46 - O., 7Z O#hZONT&L C00D0N9T( 90 THRU 9, 9

207,9429.I II

209.394 .I II II I Il202.92, I I I II II 1111 12200.969 . I I 1111 Illllll12

199.091 . II~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~1 I II18II11197.323 11I I 11 I I1 1111131111I q

190.,8.. I I-I Ill 1 I1 1111 1111 I IZ192.07 . -I I I IIIIIIIIIIlllill I

89.48%.~~ ~ ~~~~~~~~~~~~1 I I II I I I IllIIIIIII IlIll IJJ4.919 Illillli &I IIIIIIII 11 11118,.999 I I I l II I IIIlIIlIIl IIll Jil 18&.1737 I 1 1 1 IIIIII-III I I

191.41.. I~~~~~~~~~~~~I II Il iI IIiIIII llllllIII I IlIq,9.40 il IiIIIiii Ii i iI l l

199.109. I 1 I I 1 I I Ill ll~llllIl~llll I I I 1111041,11 .II I I Il III 1111ill I Il I1794.39] I I 11 11 Ill~lllllll II I 111

00.809.l I I I I1111 1111221111 lII I I149.030 I I II I IllIllIll~lllllll I 111114?.,19. · II I -IIIII9III Illlllllll I147.0 ... i iII I 1 1111 III {.I1 liliillllll {11 li l49.039. I 'I I il 11 1111139 31111 I III141,1;4 I* I I I I I, III1112221111 lll IIl14020.~O II I t ill 11111112205992111 11111 til 11&9.979. Il I I 111 11111132 1431I1111 I I

i~~~lV~~~~~n ~ I1 I I I 11 1 {12992211111 II.I I I Ilsn9.o; . II I i l lllllI lJ71220 zlll I III IISASJ1. I I II 111 l l1111 liJSJ9055 1111 I - II&,b {I II i Il11111iZ9791bZ1111 II1 I 1154.5W9. II l I 1111134022211111l~ {I I It91.l$. II II il 1 111111 11111 i T999909 llll '111 I II 19,.016 . II IiI 111112894112 1#7bqlll III

1 90.1S,. ~ ~ ~~~~~i I IIIlllt1259 43q2J?&J1111 II II .I 119,999.l I ii1111 Illlll&Zqb611111I

121.221. - I I~~~I ''il 111112illi&799811111111 Il I i.115.o....I II I l 11 l111 111294999821111111111 II i I

120.9,1. l 11.-%1111 111111 7999.]1&J{{ll}111{l I1917,ZZ I I II iiii i2ittz/6731111tllll1 II II), it15 I I tI 11 ltl112 ?26*492992l liltlllll tl {

i~J,~n7~~~~~~ II l{1111121 'Jltltll 3t 21111gJl111ll II I

12..2,.l I 11111111 112359390% 2111l1111 I IJ11.91 1 1 11 1 11363l11 I Il } liIl{~Jg{lJJ~l~~

111#,l%. IIII II~i 11t 59llllli 2 11111111111 tlIllI I11/ 1,.t it II l tl tJJll.2122900999'121111 lll IJ J

i~~m~n ~ l i 11111111122 I23S35113111I1 I II

121.911.I 111 111111111195 199940 111Ill Ill~l ~ 111.101. i Il~l lll lll 11 2204,9 909711l111l11lllL II t127,?/9 A 1l11 ll1112 24 s889J3111 11 1 1111 I ilk1.gin I1111121 I9999192/ 111111111 III II 1 ~

tlq.7~l ~ ~ ~ 111 I1tlltllllJJ9 h999 VV85111111 II ilit I I

101.929. II {llllllll?12AJq Jill}791111 111 I~ J

lU~.~lq ~ ~ ~ 11111 It129'92 ~ltfq&VlIll lIll I l29.14.1 II Iil:12 lt02919495 9V21 *)11, I illll I .

90.0,. ~ It 111 11117591999N 921111] i III i

*ui.2l1l t 1112 0'99li24f9992111111111111

99.191 . I 21 12912 1111 lllZ Jvv Nq1Itl I II I ii

AO.,%A, . I 1112699991250~~V~6tlil 111 iI IX I

10.121 . l'tlll1 JTgV29¥9lJ5lllll 1111 I 15.o51n I llllltIZ1115302111 llll I 1

Av1q.59, I 12049t1,2qbm9Vvv82llll il01.91,. I l~llq99qN111111111291421111

S1*q1n t 19950111J~ 19 Sll lt li I

99.291 . I lll/.89999192211l11 1ll1l1

eo1294119921111 116¥gqm~lltlI ?2.9011 i 111l294 &v151 3111111 ; I91.21, 111119999VA9 aSJ1111 { lI I99,,.1% 11109 l//92¥391 3Jlli51..,, . 11299991601 lllltlll

7n.1o1 19l29999211 ll11 1 i

90.90n . 029111 I I -llll

99.422 . 1,222%1 i tit/11 . 99 vv211 I

99.,01. 1291¥5111

Figure 4-11. SCATTER PLOT OF CHANNELS 9 AND 10

4-17

Page 83: UNSUPERVISED CLASSIFICATION OF REMOTE MULTISPECTRAL ... · i (f t , lt tr-220-1075 april 1972 unsupervised classification of remote multispectral sensing data 172-27204 ic.as c 237s9e

NORTHROP SERVICES. INC. T-17

UlS¢.[TL~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~0M 0 07 SAMPLE S 0977V

7LL'L77*57 07 qAT70"7L P&RK 7057 079 7M7

*o 79777 29 2077707.7070 07 09977 79 SAMPLE S 7M90 222 . 7 IOMu 79

.o T77U0eM

779,kV 79 77.02 - 3.0 V*& ERTICAL COo#OV7Io7r * 7090 77

72 0.79 7.99 HOMIZOOTAL (VV0077177E - O 0097U 799

277.900n .17 7

209.&Q7 . 7 7 7 7J

207.920 . 7 7 7

200.707. 7 77 77 7 7 77 7~~~~~~~~~~~~~~Il2797i .7 777 77 77 71167 7 2772.027. 77 77 777777777777777Ill I17

.207.009.# I I11717771i77117ill779U .7'. 11 77777 7777 7777l 7 I

797.727, 7 77 77777777777777777777777 77 7 7 779O,007 . 7 7ll 711177i 77777777 77 7 7

19900917 I Ill1ll7l77 l I 111 77777 777...9.9 . II 7 7777777 77777llil~~ i II 7777.702. 7 777f7l777l777777777777777 77 I7717.976 . . 117777 777l7777777 l7I7 11717 ,

790.777. 77 77777777 7lliIiii~l IJ18#.N~ ~ ~ ~~~~ i 777777777777777777777777ll 1

lt2.0F. I 7777777777777777777777 77l

777.9977 7 I7 777 llll I I111777777777 I 7777.777. I I 77777777777777777777777777 7 7 I00.030. i7 77777777777777772277777777 71777..7 ii 7 7 7771111221272227777777777l777.0707 7 7 7 7777I7 777l7l77l 7ll7l 7 777 7

700.202. 7 7 7 777777717777 7233222777777777777 7 7,~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

Oili~O . 7 i i 77 717777777270799277277777l77l 7 7

i'0~.077 7 7I 777777777223 22127777777777777777709.27/7 77 7 77 777772 l9~Al9l2727777777i7 77 77lI792.070 . It I7llll~JJ~~lllll 71 77 7772777372777777777977.708 77 77777200.0 77l tJI~tl~JJJ27777777777777777

77.77.7 7777 7777723727771777777

7i.07&. 7 i i 777777 lllllll2l2qJ2I77qJ7I7llI lllJ IillII720.777 17 7 7 7 71 77 2l9llli0J5097 S222777lli7777777 I77 II27.739 I 7 7 777 l77O29 i~q70092'2 ill2777l 27777777777 7 :77.0791 7 77777777772 I7I00l77I237777777777I77777777 Il129.790 i 77i 7777 7777777723779909222 2777777777 l 7777777 7727.707.I 7 771 1 7 177772722&777&7717777777777l7I777777

i7.777 77n 77ll 7777777770l700773922222771777777777777777 77 i70*'¥'0i 7177777777 27900 0 1711 211777777l777i77171777l77771777.77, ' : 777 7 I77777777 ]JII009J07272227277I7IIIIJI I 777777777

0Je . 77ill 77777777 22723qb#S/1777771177777 7717777777,.7.7i 77 777777772 3I 00077~7II7l#4%SS111IIlI7II77 7777 777 7 772l070. 7777 777 7777 ][ Il 0lI 3222]/ 2777I 7I77777i7777.771J7i70.7777 7777 7177717V .00070i9l 7997272772777771777l77l77.7J77JJ 7

17770.7i7I . 7 777l 7777777777777722272377727llll J777777:07.773. 777 777 Iii77ii7i 2l 229I7J 0 037sJ~Jl32222777 JJ~llJ 777771 7777700.0J2,. j I 7Jl 7L777777777 2277009797770322717l777717777777ll77777707.,.t 7777177777 772207I 7077097937222222777777777777777777ll 7777.797 7177i I II11771777700007~7~ 32q~~~277i27l777777l1777777 i71

iiv7.107. i 77777777711 1177ll727722392722127 717J7l7777l7777777777l97.777.ill 1 -jl 77777q~~qJ J~]JllJl 777777711 2220777092272777777777

]l&*qlfi ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ 7777223990777 I3322277llJ7771 7J~l~~Jl lilllllll 7l ]i79~.799 777771777777777717722759500702972772272777777777777747777

901.3779 I 71I1l77l771717 77777272732277777777777777777777777777llII.277, Ill7771.7 77772720997072 Ill717 7 7777717777~JJJlJ~lJJJ 77JJ~I79.9~ 7 L 7 ] 777 [7I7777772777[]222270770007 '3033237727277777777777777777.,/727. i l 77777777777772 7ll999790 079,277~&~&SJ J227777777777777777777

704.77. 777777 I177177l77777 72223022&332777727777177l777777 777 l7'I9C 77.V 717771777777772777737 I239997779799792I72722277717777777I7777

/77.92,O .111111 7717177777772272 200000937/72272777777177l777 777 7 1

77.779. 77 J 777l17777777l 7772222272qb72727 JJJJl7l7l7777lli7 7777 7

73.~97~ 77777717777972'222311122277~3&2 i772777777777i7777 l JJ' 7 l99.277 7l1111111777IIIII220 J07997700770&2 32 q21177 117 lll777 77 II

07.272 .lJlJ~JlJJ J S~~)l~jlllljJ J I 77771722977099070J7 7717

,.77.]o * l7777/7777171 2 397227277277 ~~qq/21?llJll 777777

0277.sd 7I1277112 1'91g77l9l9ql 7277#7&%&7 S2Z~llJ i77Il7l

00.77, [ I 7772233997793070799227777777 11illlitI

&97.107. 77277700,9 l7922Zq %#R777&& 777721111t60.o7 .7 770.9777777 12777777 i&¥i&~222]l~ti i 797*020 . 777l0l1107777372777777 1 1 ll11111.7.7, .77277 727ll114~$61V99l~~~l~111

s 73709,79 0tlllll33Jq 72.89M772.79&S 32.79 0l.l721777.2 77.77 77.3

Figure 4-112. SCATER PLT$OF CANNELS98&i2tll AND'1

S~,qG~ I ~ ~ ~ 4 1811lllJ/]8~mJZ1111

Page 84: UNSUPERVISED CLASSIFICATION OF REMOTE MULTISPECTRAL ... · i (f t , lt tr-220-1075 april 1972 unsupervised classification of remote multispectral sensing data 172-27204 ic.as c 237s9e

NORTHROP SERVICES. INC.TR07

UINCkOTT NCAo12EI160 090003

NO.099 0' SAMPLES SYMOOL

MULZSPECTAL 9C&NNE0.OATAH LN

TEL9.49STHHE NATIONAL PAIN TINT SITE HA

20 THOU 29 7

1A 1930 19 I'

33 1340 79 Z5CAN ~ ~ ~ I 00 .I ~ 00.3 EMCL OITIATE oH HA 0

211.100 . I I IIIIIIIIIII2III2II.IIIIIIII I 3I TH#U 39I

252.T90 . II II III I I~~~~~~~~~~~~~O'HMJO~~sAT. . I III III A I II ~ ~ ~ ~ ~

29A.399 ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ .HK I9 I SI I2'4.192 ~ ~ CARiL .SE IRELhM IhHIIION$

730.370~~~ ~~~1 .le I,0 .HORIZONTAL CQNIN

320SoOO0 . I IIIIII Il~lll~l2llll I l Il

12,791T .11IIIII II li II I

229.,2 I& I I 111IIIl I I 11221.TTI. h III IIIIIII I I h i I Zq&,194 .I11 1111 II l i Il

ZI13A9 9 . I I II I llhill I1 II I S

700.50. I& I lIll hlIl~ h iI

ill4.IA.lII&I 911I1111111Ih J I I

2093%7, 1I II I~III 11 11111h

2H715,. ll~ll IIJ 1111191il Il

I232,11a I I 111 IIIIIII 111lIIII I

15.5?;# - I Il ll IIIIII 1l1

lJ2.o 3. I I II llIIl~lIIII~ll I I

08.03., Iilll I 1191112121II111 I I 204.317. I l Illllll I11111121111 Ih

90/I535. I I I11I11123229llllil1h II 2197.131 I l I1111l1122222111 h i I I

931.9Ž9. I II .l9l II 1121906 371 11I11

l1S,)2T . .h I 1 1111 1111h33333 hi1111 I I

IT1],1'1 IhllllIllllh I J11272232II111

171.,3? - I I II 1 lll23393l2llll hi I Ill

944&997A I 11 i 111i2l 96550llll321l11lilll II II

12.%15b . I II II113193221I1991 111111 9 1Jil

IAJIsII.. I 11h 98 I NllhlhllIllJl~lill9 ll I I

110911.9 I I 11111l1lllllll 3949922911 h111 I I

JJ61%q~~~~~ IJ 11111733h3 hllillllhll 1l 1 l lJ Ill

969.535. 1I1I99 IN395s69'37I911i 9lJ 9il I

1991,979 99 11 9 I73IIII3~2l~IIII9lll~l~lll JlI

99.4.I 111&117111760%9 I 2lillll 1l 91l 1111Il Ill

189.193. IJ 91911129 *7 llllllli322I99IlI9ll~lII 99

99?.591 . I 11122399 llllll2211119911hl9111 II9

I~OI~~~~~~~ ~ I II lllll2JJllllill?5o574999Z911111 hl1111 I1713392v 11111 .11I1121 SlAANll212919 1911911lIll~li~llll I

17b,?17 ~ ~ ~ 11 11 9l9I9222il'53SlllJJl2JIJJJ9lJJll9i~l II~~~~I I I 99l19 l ll33506%12 2121Z111Jlll11lll11lJ II

171.99. 11 111119 3.9Il I 333l222191111199919iilhh 1h I

975.099. I 191191111191112 I I1A 7l7J0i,,,qq332l2I1l9lJlllI'll111

9111 .Al7 9199 ~ ~ il 11111{91129543321 Iiq S& #Jlll~l lll~ll~lIll I1

I999.99.II III 11111121111 1359A58 32 27Ill~lllll 11111 191 II

199.771.~~~~~~~ II l1l11l&J111111#J9ll34l537l32221 2111111

111.349~~~~~~. III IlllJqlq{ll~lllllll ~ 23939. 9933129911 11111 11

ISI25.1111 IIi II Ill ll~lqq~qilllllI 391.3977111 lhl~l~ll~lll III

1111.051. ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ J {I 191111911111121 %%% 8855932 2222122111lllllI99llII 9

{1110.94 1111111 llll I 722.,2219 112111 ~7&JJ~~Jl9I~lll9II9I Jll

L"7.181 1111191111199232598 '2l3ll 121& 111 111111 hlltl~ll.I II

Hs,,.599 IIIIIIIIII9I1922 3 323 &.21 &6211))1111l1111l111111 I·

Iq~~~~e~lIVl99ll I 21111II3399 I3l23.92l~l2121111111911111 11 119III

9 7O.,vo i l I 1111111Z# ]..11. 9l111911111 72395AH909332222111919 Ill

H9SHV{ '1111119 11422I 8 3l339l33272~21212221h11111111111 IllIT1

H9~.A9H I 11 111111191211191212222395ll3992223l221219111 l ll19191

15.93.. I 11111121?92223392322221211191 IIII

09.0.9 . I ~ ~ ~ 111119111121 l?32&9~9%A55554393222 111111111111 tI ll

739ls 11*111 Il i I21 1399A 3II ~ 79I 1111191 I I

11~~ ~ ~1111 11 2Z2] 211J~111911;1111111 JiIll

177.73.~ 1111 11 1111932996%%EA9991931 I lZ~lllllllll l

l/q,~l I II 111191Ž I t9H19 809710331481.9 &bu3321111111 1191191 9 JI~

L??.029 I I I 9111191122223993855A96lA455l3922111I11h11l99I

05.0,. 91111I1I111III233 3 354T17AA 5E9/9991217111 111 ' 1 11191 9

03.97.. I I 1111 12133lA98 7NAA%9223 911119JqJ/J~~11l llilhl Ill

59.72? . 11111 1'171 39145393413927 192Z&6.~l~ m~~~~lllih1119111119

IllBAY ll{ll I2 li23l3s{lsA]3{903 999H9JJJ971,99l{9119lIJ}1J191

5109.6, 191912415911A940.40T931 Iif3~1 J)Z2119191111llllll I

l95,99. 99999 I33.5747l10591 1111 11 119 1111lJA~l~11111lJill

102o.999. I 111211291l4479I 5[3291111150.777 .911232191199 6TAOH.93997131%11111111111111I I

.9l.~ II13 399999931111 11111191 9lZ2'~?ZlllII1111ll{1

95R349. 1 1139999A6321911111111 liJ/JqqJZll11 111911 1 II

99.9%49.{9993,{999{953]J~~l~J~{{J{19{JlJi I1

39.77? .IlilhT9{ 12 J3qqJZ11977221911llllliJI

lIR i9 8.42 '2., 2.9 7.4 0~l1111111992qqJJJ 2.390 Z11911.992933.3 99.54915749}.1

Fiue -3 SATR LTOFCANES1 AD1

4-19

Page 85: UNSUPERVISED CLASSIFICATION OF REMOTE MULTISPECTRAL ... · i (f t , lt tr-220-1075 april 1972 unsupervised classification of remote multispectral sensing data 172-27204 ic.as c 237s9e

TR-1075NORTHROP SERVICES. INC. _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _

,: a... o - l

It - 1o.o - I.oo

*4.44~ ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~'" ........... 7 I...... ...............

:: .............

..............

: ;·..;:·:.-. .....

,, .; ... ; . . .:.; ... '. .. '.:.;;:. : .. .::

to~~~ ~ ~~.. .:;";''....;:;; . .. :.,:, .. ;:;:..:.: .......... ~~~~~~.

....... ,......: ;'..::

;;;:-::.-: ...: . .;·.;;7: . : . "' . .:..;......

'.,:'.. ;.:-;:': . -..... .

.~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~.: . :. -

;;', ::. ': : ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ..~: . . ... :: . ..;'::.::;...;.:. :...

Figure 4-14. THE INVENTORY BOUNDARY MAP BY THE BOUNDARY ENHANCEMENT TECHNIQUE~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

:-',' ~ ~ ~ 20i: i .....

Page 86: UNSUPERVISED CLASSIFICATION OF REMOTE MULTISPECTRAL ... · i (f t , lt tr-220-1075 april 1972 unsupervised classification of remote multispectral sensing data 172-27204 ic.as c 237s9e

NORTHROP SERVICES. INC. - TR-1075

~u ~ ~ u ~~ lii lz1 lli~lli~lliillliil11~liiiil~ il~1 11 1 ?J2222 ?227OOOOO1I1il~Z2 Z~3 )44~~S$~6 6I 7 701 359 0 80047 58 870 ??357 l

S2.0 I/V*1)4-1131*IlV[31131) l V---33-33# I1WYVI*/-I* *)VW-W)).7..~,.~,.HHH.#----~*oW-#* 202 '.I0)$$f%¥/tI*+VII)3133))W 1133¥33[V*+¥+*4 0130)*I i2.3-.0M.oMI7.oo?...)I./M.214 H)..86.0*.I-N -.- I- ,.0.204 1/.00)41 V1 II *)13)1)-)3 3 3 - VI 2 ¥ V V--.-).W.*77 .7.70.033 .7 08... .3

200 ).. 540))¥1*1.,)¥¥V*]¥i3033113336*)0) )) l** I**,*V¥*0-WWW-W.I3o?.8o??o? eol-e.. .0... 600.III~lIW~'#'lpf.)06 )*0+%0$$)))I***IV )IV)V)01313100¥+))3VI[I*+t IV*+t+V **-30##..1.77oM.?#P ei-o .07 .. 6.).870o .20V 212 VI) -1-.-0 7......... -l.

)21 4V)61.40)~**V[¥ VI0V0 W33-3 V V ::-.VI IVI*VII V+V-)-l, . )7,'M.?? TIM ..M?.)?.7o*?7.-W)33WW -;.::-!,I2,°, 00)000*.......................I J I,133¥**..1I1. 8.1.1..I...80.77..-l0..3. ..... ........ ?...........[.....20 )*))00000010 33 333-13 YV V!41*081-2. 00'*l.4*.. . .778..810.I.03 0.-.3I

22216.006$$ 0$$ I4 .$)0$+ ovV*))303.0)v.O)0V[)$0+*)3V+.I/*0-2..0311-77M 771) #H ?. *--M#?7#8--80l..0.) 'I$0-212 / ) lI //S)I33-I)e *IvI) )+I+)/-1e0v.33 …8I7W- I¥W?.HH..M?.- ........ !.-V:'- …264 4I4+/));$1-4j4S 5*l$*V 130333-333 XV++V101 / I- 00 .-. M.M...?.?..? ..- 7... ?.??*1--o.7#)¥V.V--¥W13.-1---e.

220 44 0666)/)S)$*$0))+ *VO 113¥3.333+44) VZVV-3 -.- 0WW/..I,-?M??.0.7?..?..-?77. 77.#-o0M30)V) tV V .. 4)---,......................... )1) ........... I08.2..I.. 0..:..;............. ........ 17:~;.i.. v):? ...........l ......

231 V000002220221 VV11813300) II I V.)*.o .4-22.140*008.--130.7.173. 0 I--- I1 .

I236 i)$)0000$$////2222221///i)*3333¥V)I*V*00*V! WIM2-//I0.Me-MWW--3.0773.----.M)?,??3?M.?M *-.30M-iV 3 V+)0)i,-.3WW).230 )$)0$$0$$00///////////24)I+)3V13)*l$$*))v0.*/-M/7.140 ~-~#??.-2---?7..???871M#8U-M7.*)7V.lV))-*?,3 M-'- .200 }))$$0044)*002/)I*I*s*045WIIV])V333l*))hlbYM0.*3-*..7.MI*'???M?-*)..88. . W#?..-3… #. MM.*-*)#IOVVI.//l.#M,-M

N 20 I + 4)0454. II S 1S I ! II 333 -3)031V"I601#I'83 .?, -. 6W.)??o)-eM8H7mMNI)...?.?..I3..¥¥[.// ®)7?34h-H200 ))$$V64$i4$$*12$I.4Z06vV~)1403)*V)WVV)32.0-#M..*M781400222?).M7///.71.77?7.?W#-Ho?). I)0//2//-3#e-.I?

2662 10046600461111 "Ill) )02410*I )3)00)600I . 300.4...1402.Wll 0.211 I'll *.7808.7.14*)3222-.

O2480 1000&$6$$%0*6$)010)Z,)/*)*$$00))I0.30.0."728?M.M#MtMM-??MM--2//.MM*~W???)Wi/) .07.-0...).1.2*1.---)

252 I $0446%0$)$$$4&$6$$411$/#)0)*W))03"31. )--M . 00M40MM1MM7MM#"-0-00/22.MfM4-71 .… .*M0003#//2/)1---). .256 )$%&(60&&+64$0$$&00%$)21/)$*.]---V-/)- . 0 .7IMIM=!.ml. I)I-/Ii1 ii. )I))?MI?,.?MMWi)./+-) .. *140.3.2* i o H-256 I}00064401460)00$$20)$1*400) 4/#W-0-I)/ …1#1-20-W -.- 7M1"eM 2?M /0[.#MMM1 ?.. 7 ... 8??0-b /82/2)..--.3?7?258 I 066000660*020 Z$4016*.03/24-31-0-?0 ./00e~ ? .0--l4. .- . ?r-...W-*,.#M-.--3.. 7M.

200 S)$$$4064$04$40600)62v/ 05-0-3)0.W WM~ ~W-~ ~ ~e-)Ww)-...8-1.1041..4. 0200280--~-/ /M.~-)....8-.-)- . .262 0lt$0060s)0 $$4000Zll/tl -I)+-400103)EI/) ...--IeeMMIW-[-*3,-W' .0 . 1.MI.-NM/~II/3eM. *H,? 3® -- 8-.)M/.®2M,1--33H)200I ~)00$$4644$0*02W*#4W*-)33430 =~) I / W*388 V V0.00-WW"-080 . .V3-/.--.7W") .?-3*".# ..? ././ ?.--3.*h?.H

270 )))$$4$$$~$$4+)022/IIV)WI))I3-3-))33II.MWI0#-)0V0V).VI 8-V[ *- -*))2I0--2. . 6.84. . .)272 II))00s$00600)$)$2[/)$ 1/)333V-60V-*"0.M{/*#V*0*+V0W.V/)WV-4?. / Wv/W/.//0W)../// ...??* * * I--®Ie-2...27.

276 4Ii" 1

278 1604$$06066$423+/0+300)03-333)) .V 03.M)VW IV V++OI~)000 )V.)V42-//7v7)8"/ / ./2"2//.*7--.*H?.0,-.~200 04 $0600$06++01)/#$ 13WV 3 . 3--8.30..30MWV/ .*V+)VVII . 0I~VW../8.47.4W / .28#2//WW.0~80??..//7?~ W.?.".2202 )4$)$40640/)604S00030)0.3)0))-p.'0eM0W)0) +0VVW*I0.W3-*V+*3I//-M6? .0...?.?.//2./oT--I**.....74°HH220480 04~446$0440/VV{l.204)I[31['3.33'e*.-*-.)V'')¥+++11¥V-0.*43-.0..4-#'¥[4+./M..?.)377...*2////.#.?-.~'.7827.*7.oH706 0)$4$044$0$+20420*ll)*0VI*W3W-3 . 08.02.30W4*VVV)V03.-W'e-088-*UV..6.#W 771H * 8)*?77?....7....-//~~IIII1,6H*

238 $40$4~44)WV101:1V[ [ 3-* -V-*-.331-*333.4 VIW./ /?*WI-?-* ..;:.":;. 3. .-

290 0)$04124+)0}VI+44)$$0)[VW*13/--.I.-V=3V."38]0*V0))"33.8NWI4W"10-e*.M2///"83-.e-#WW*-00.77783?H120H232 6I3V015540$${{1V))I{) *{[)3-)-'--/ '- VVV -M.1W-0003-{0. ---.. 8///W2-..7. … 7 H--W= --.?1? WH,? 1

236 W20)..60 M 7 **7i..A. 6V13

200 666064)4264000420w) 3101) I~-2-))23I03 - "-3*3+--.3 . 0?V0* -- ~~WMw-~////-#..*..0.*0 . 26022022 .… .1H1,02400 216$ 14 44$V1!62 W)-- I SW,,) 3::`[ 7"$)/4W4~M4-~W~V`4211W1/ / *`..-V1133- .- ..- *-.W---0) . 022222 0 . .1.3…3.2211

302 7Z$046*,,II+*4644)Z//W)*3.3~M~3W-333 . 12)''l a- .~.#XW,./3W{VW-M-.V.7W-.//..02. ,--#-*-43.011,660H222?306 1010))$1 1+ 4,4462/-31 … 3+--- 33W- 0MV---3-#-73-*M.MH1WW)$'W-W-0 .W M/.....106 4)6*.).*lvI0.402$Z) /1W)633)- #W-~-'.W. W)043*3*3 .e'~~7M7 )WW3 'W-W'.M-*.3 [mM- -l 4-/''.2.?' -<1) ....?,11*Hl'6hH100 0)0 )$$ 41I0I$40620/-II),/-IW0)tWI-I-)W~*…--WW -]¥' 004*-3)MM -0--I-'3..2....1'/,.…~', ......'. ,*H8'HHH )l*10 4611$ *.14{I,,)0422*/V*l--30)131 il--.]*+vve-0..1*.. {WpMI-I)yM~M{-0. . )...?I2//..oHW--#-- oH.??H*22)I)2?HH*1244* I)2*)461)$ 3.,l*)W.33-)6W0-.-)w*lV*V.3)-03..--W#400*0 -.0 -. #'.8..--)#)8. '/22#-l1..--.-8 .)-H#.hlI*H,22l0,I~11 6164*Iw$4+$4144402/--I|/]W3)3)I[~)-=W3./--{V1- 1).80*...IWWI-*M*711.-1[V-?.82////,H.-)---...).0101I.*16 4*)$I*WV)*~4l1 4l~WI/ VW*[W-v1*)W. -[WI *V)).31*I.[3) I) 10000 . .~`*-~-W-.W-, `8/22/4HHH00W3-**H*.`.H168HHI1,2

120 04*+*t*422) 164)01$*/k*/[*0VV4)I#0.3+*}))+VV1) . ) )-* 8*V` ?` M#?0 -. 0W-#)""*/// .. H."-.)`..`6`h 1,)31)`22?~V{~/)$12201*601{40101 21. !)--IVI{+)1I)) **VVV[3-.++V[[..8*?7e....--3..e-*U1W1..-#=I,//0..----3 M)1)11,01,1,,I.1,2

320 10114444Z46$$4 10642#VV.)*][W.3+)}++11)) ),.V+V..~VV'W0.6o.)8*3M 7-*I0.3--4-]W.'W .8-WW //-370.1,.8.?,?H,.?P*HHH24

240 $+6444 S46242401/1 /){$+)l IV)$$))0001 I) )IV **+). 1 ¥VVI2W#H-* 7 . . .. *...W- .. ,-3-*.I..*l1,11.H 6*? *2H832 $)4~444/$?/Z44[/*/*/! *. 01.11$ *)$) +)4I[V0VVVI*.3...4*..1,.I~ V= 10*0* W =.6* V. .Hh,7,)-'.).11)0,HH +HHH,'211213& 06444214 4 014$) 04.21W)0)33.I$)))$)+)*)))) )4*)400IVl1-**Wl.14 H--.ll. WmV4W0 "WW=0 .?. --...2.*??71,11).*.).[ll21,)'3b %0444'/,4042)4 4 50,22*W %{)t)4-l +0)11$1*))}*14*++VV+.3..U.0IM.H. I-VWVV) )**.01.). 7.*-.0.1711,11,1h1) }'H364 104$ $4',44 l)VI+4/W I/ * )/W- I })010* S))$ ) 1') ) *)+/IWV*MW{ I38. )# .0*,H-{V{{-W) .W-W2,1.. .1, ,"IH?, 711HH l.),).*"H 1,*lf'h)I,

16 S4042444, 1160 12-4.V01.*)20 IVI))1**1 1) . .*1)16 . 16..7.*.3 .11,18.W0,201,W

324 $64444422 + )244.V / - w1 )- )1$ 101)I )W) * I) V3-I -lll.*. .... W[ IV 0=-*-0 . 1.1, 7. .* N H.IHIf+Hl~I',H, l'2H** )444/441414-,1 ¥Z44*w- I.,.lloll)) t I W ) 3 :M43 WW.-k -M.H.. 011 I*V I... 1,1.ml.)-1,1HlHHI.{Pk'h$

ISO 144442?2l/22.++2VV+$$//{)$WI0)}$0$)))l).})$+)I-3.WW . I 40*)). 3*.l. ~V V]VV-=I~*H 7.-.61* 1..,l0.2.l).HH11,0H002t 12'* 15 2446144444444 {42/Z/-IV)$V+$$$0)$){))))) 1.,)' …/)W 7k)/ .0.-~oMV*V...0...../hH. 7-V*M. 7. l I4Ht.,p1t.1,,, l1,2,8021,2154 204274Z41Z44/I4 1$440- 141.))))$1$$$)1 III)) ,o+l*I))3 3-834--.¥.*.¥¥011 ......- --./-.~7*/I* H.l o.HHI,)l*.HHH

1{6544/ 2444244400++[V42*.3+{)0I)IS$$1))))ll){++++¥2)-M3 --.3. .. H)80V* { =WV... 4..10H. H7HHHHMTHH14HH-iHHH[,l)l]22260 ~4422?444$444$$14{S2//*.).)W $$$$$31)I)})*3+W+.[--IV.2-.. .¥ V .* ...... l....? .. ...... 2Y.HH){1 1,160 4??4242/464*4I)4002//2, })+$1$$$I ))))) 1e*+V- * 00oI;.)......51,2 0//2)22440VV14*$)/22)*3 l*++$0$$0)1)*)) )4*881.3).+W-,M00Wi0.#=.IV{..*...*3.2=WH*.8.1MMM)1kHH2h1HhH4H}+4?144 4422)/Z444041$'V*V)//W[$+][)6**I+4%$S))l)*))I**VW'0 . 03-../VV={''=W..0.030* * .4W70.*.*1,1,*)4122HH14H2H,$4}{, '110 4 *4244004004**14] 4 2.).) 2*01)) { )40S)0)),*l.**)+*0V--e,=e.3...e VVV NW .. 00)20. 0.04.)? 7*"-* 7.I;,l,-T1.M?322

10026444 2$04 172+ -42-,214+)110&$$%) ))*)4**1*++V13 . 00.4*.00 .-k*V.lV01)0'~=VW Z?#-" ?~.0 PH~.1211 8,,21-1,1,13?

127 444SIS444.442 S4440) 221.11[3]33 .4544.4/ IVfwl~lOfl -13)1 *..WW-68...1).t.Wl -.. !.24*V0 . .72.11,1,,,,W0167

2o 04464*44)44 , 3*1I ) -+VV¥I* VV . V II .0..72 ..W-. ] )H-1 N.H /

2781 04 6IS44*444.422*2I/3 02)I)2144*., 0:33----l-W-*). .*..o00W0M104043. 02IWIW.7i17.M....10,,,~l*1)2,;1

1200 0000644444242$)*./{])VW 4.)$%}))}))))t+)l )-..-.. . 0000V+ 200*mIV2 .... *).)111.1)811I,11,.2-*.HH 1,HT),)1,l.~H[

282 0*11141,44 ,*444 31*W}W "11 ! 14 *++V-I-..-[ I )*1W 3V10VVV ...... 737....-,.121H1T,1H2).,+1il,1)i1

2'74 0.004S- 4444 l2*2-64.13I0420)3W l 11*04.8.-;W.0*V02V*4 I … 8. .1.81,10l,6,*

II6 ... W..V$.4.3.2IZ//{VV*+)400$$$)W)%I45'++W+'{-,)W.8*-VIO¢))V4VV{7777.7...7*.7TlHW 1I'Pl77'1-1::7 ' ??18* *)40004'.442422*0ll*4I)030)0)S08))4))++**1.)3.1).6)-I-+V 00VV*0V.... W- ….- .**- .1,*H2660.1,.?1,,1.171,82210 4 VI V4$44 1. II,.10')$.0l04)$)) 3)4$)11{*+.*.3}Y .'~.¥V¥*VV¥¥¥¥VVV.....--.*MM7.?,*HHlH.hPHl.oh.,

1224 ))$44~464/Z+/I-+++{t46000$0$$$40$)I)+)+*V2*-,8..-WVVV*I0+)*VOVV..7.4017.).WM.011I~T~,HH,7)HH~.,~2111, 2$0$04$1$-22Z441*1* 1440V44 5545)33 )/ I.0l)2OV . .0. w+{vvvvv....W. 7-?. .*'H 7777.7.l,,)3?222

44041)4$442441222220*4'.$444144$%$4$$$)00 **12**/ 8-*VOVO)VOO . 4....'..M-"-. W7???-.*"8813H,1,I1 ???.?) H.?*h22~224C2 4$$)44/4',) ZZ/VV4$0040)l4600$11$)) l++/88.014*3VV VVIVWV.W.'W7*1_…*...880.ll.8.*8111.21,11,72).1_6. l.?2I404 II $4464422)210//+)Il)044045 I5 1)4$)}++**.* .*+ +{WI V)*VVVV0VV40.-k---3,1,,.71.."NtI??H? I'olH?.2222.27

406,*)0$444472f/2)/0.6400$S4$040$)S)¥I*}V o.obV¥¥+Y....40461#w Ov..7. 8.6.17~M I-,.17.71,H1711?1,...222272??400 110$4$4/42//$)/I$)?4$$)$$441 5)$ 0*++).*i..iW-#V4V*0V0 -VVV i-WW.7..*~~-~e~N.*)1H.721,HH17000~*). H211)4)*1444)[2-0 )06/Z//*014)0$$40))l.)&))+012 *))./.[ V++WV+.0.-=UW.W"u~*-"-Me*M....77.1,6.HZ7Ilk,)22?22?22

4)6 ~*1$0406?62/772V*7$$%%)l$ll+))+0ll'4ll*/V8.00*OVVV.VO.20044.VVVW8e.037???-)-7-1.1,Illl**181,HHPHHIH122?'.26 2. )$$$6272?q/-4 IIl[*¥$)1$)$)$I{)0+v 212V444*06*..... }+IVVIVVV=-e.30714IW)~I*)0. .... *Hh1HoHHkHH,161.7.)1212221224)0 2**$)$104 $/-,21 22116101 ) )00I)ll2*0280.U01600VV+WW .VO='..8...l....8-'~?'~-~?..1 ?87?1,1?0 .12?7711 ?1,2 ?222y?620 202004))0/Z-$/W=+0,,)))20))$2$4)+}**I/,)3,.14,++04001*00 * .8...,M 7MM.?71V-/*.2).8*#.7o?,.?H.177;{272?y72y,,??422 2V20}{)1/6222 . {1))1 $)-1 2~]')00 . 4V00{*['''M2' ?70 -~-`-'~M'M .~8. * .*.* .7,71o, 11)127222222 22

49I 100$$$23)/2$ 0,)*)$ 1--4)4* -4I~$)*4-.-8-.7.vI0,0I)-'3-V0.6.?. ''??.7 .*--.-..-. .~'H'~.1,,HHl?221,??2/

430 * $$$44Z22/)/-00+)W)$1S$4004q4W-0*I) .- 68.,410=M )+¥3V'+. T?.71V- ...2.81881471. 178*)16H.1,112))'22222ZlI42 1+V)444 2WW64- 010) 044$$ 4$$ 4 0)-0*+-0 .)+ . V *3I *-#-- .7111111#W1W2-.-~3H22h? 2212?22 22/2"

424 +i064)2222/-114V$$)00444104-*I*3- 3.~{ )! .. V-.e)-.43.0l.0-.?H7.7.6...??/.7#~71?--1,1,0)?,#?.H ,1,?2??2~?2?2222

~48 *VSW$$/422-+VI+* $$)0140472-Il ).1*20.*IV -1... [V+I3''M 'W .?.-/.. ?M.WP7-7 .''. .8-.HH** H2l1,22?)22222277*.440 1 4V).Z42Uiv*1+0$$$04)4W-).14 S W1331?*10? ? %?3.?----701 .8- . )6h? 22 ?272?2227202

446 0 +)2) ) 1/v- 4441 [ _$ 1 0- . ... 3 ) f/*v. I … * 3),, -[=.*. 1io7.8.) ..).*..M2,2H7HY 222 ?H2?222?11

44) *000024- +)v4//v*¥+) ))$1 1)-/] 0 W4 ¥ I s- -{ I'---' -, .~~.IHHH1H0o 13.-H.2. 7 )7..HHH 227 2222 ~22H ??? 221? ?2

46R 4v* .)$& V "IZ-+}){·)l/ ) )$$/z 3)-/.w-wvv+-I.[-MWIWW V{3WW-) 3'~, .3W, I--Mo,, *;, ?. H.~HHH .... HHhH?27)2HH?2H2~.

4h40~ Z/ 43/0422 *V3)}400V0)$ Z-')-U)W)*/-)IV]VV . .WWW )-PM.?.)77HP)*8.3-..6??'?+~2?27).,2222y2?22 ??222?21.H..

442 I)l$*1011,I*,) Il)$ [-)412 ,64-W*VVVVV--W. )W-..3:,)W * ),,/?7..78l167l7.72... .....HH-71HH72222??2222222222

4441142210)$$$ZZS +Z$"[$ZZ 4w -27602V)40- 33. )vvl*)-.I13=-&)`-. `-H*)7*.7. 7)2 .H81.?1222???? 7?2???? 2???2???)?2??22h2.44 **24 )$$/4Z***))IZZ){I*IllIW-WI)*l+*Il))01+V¥3).5)W0,.WW-W*?.7.7.H.H,,61)?l8. ?Z22.2/22.22?222227227127222777'22.

414* V )44Vll.:11211411100121 16-27I .634212-I )31 *8.Vl 340.3. . 8. III .)l*1,,l1,11,I M 221.112? 211,12

40 441 2)4/*40+W$4*)*I))2) II-3W-W$ 2·e -,MVV)-03M~-).0 -3=WW-.38.. 7177..*1.1,,.611222' ? .1,111222 ? 222?)? 22277Y727;1??.244,414 4122?*1/)W11?400$0112 )4$141$)/v )0--2l3I1w-33 * l)..W 1 .?.?. .Il0? .. 31?.k 1"???261y2?2'2?222??2222??2??22222211,..

... _4 '1 "-41 '. ':W :'":'!!' '--;434 ,)2W11;4).)612-. -704-30)0l).30*3 W114.7.- ,717)I2.2f222222222222

466 W..)2..)4 +.$$W) !y -.-.l $$) )---0 3 -"~.3?4?I-..7..... W-1H .?.1HH..6.H?22. 2?22222222p2222?~22.46* /014/)$1V'21)1{17$41 477W{ -)$ +). V{) 0VV'l3 13..)). .7)..6 -o6oM?'H2t122??2227'2222?2?272???HHo

4)0 t/$/*$$61$$4 I ) $.010 **-3 )V$$)W02-4 ~3'-W1-1W0?0'7. 1 778.-... M7*. w.71,I H?22? HI222222?2222??22??22222222 ~H*72 $$*V42$2$221243)+)*$4$1W-).)4*lI-1310,043).[)3=.H?..?*.?818..??1?177-??.2`.h2,2?22222222?2?2222?22.'2222.2)%4~)4 $441)$$2$$$*~ ) ¥) 0 + 1*1 $$ )) ) -- 40 I -)I I ,Mw ,-. 8??11.3 3.6-.*.67?7. 7??. 1?,6172 2222H?$ 2272272 22222222???2HHH. ;

42244642$$$$$+ ) )$$1220l3-~)$+)$)IWN.-¥UeeIVW.14333 H)o.'. ?Z.7 . 3811* 7777.).60-621-H22H'22272?2272222??2222 ?H'21 H?404 12,1)$$$ 1$$$$$03*W-$).4+1S));M'V-*.1T … 3.7*WW'WM ?.1-.~777.7....0) H H.2222r?222222??2??2'2)????1l.~h,

406 2,,2410 J.)m 2ro01 00C:)01*2)00COOC¢CO)lI) ¥000GG0£001 I . 7I.L8I0I.L I [ I I [ )). .I7I I l [ I I IS1,* II1l2 I11111 {22 }2W7W } Y772 ? ? )? )??7

Figure 4-15.UNSUPERVISED CLASSIFICATION MAP AFTER ONE ITERATION WITH 18 CLASSES

4-21

f I

Page 87: UNSUPERVISED CLASSIFICATION OF REMOTE MULTISPECTRAL ... · i (f t , lt tr-220-1075 april 1972 unsupervised classification of remote multispectral sensing data 172-27204 ic.as c 237s9e

TR-1075NORTHROP SERVICES. INC.

5 ?CO ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ 04 0 5 ,83t I... ....... ............ V 144. ............

Ao~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~~~~~ 1.....C) ...............1~1ll ll .....1 ..... I -.. ...... . . ?~ ..... 131il13

iO00Jil)))Z22 23t3334444,455~55333666733 3R8o3333333 00 0)it 3?222233333441445 5%554o46783738T18883sqqqq')830O331112

?C 20 I.i44, V I{3*.V )I 3333tl V)---33-3 333333¥ I/- 3{- ... . .......... 3-..

'::!V ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ em~i#.HH~I....lhMV-V mIIIH202 4i03$StSV/tI**V)II3334333333503V 3V*V3¥1)V330/---.......20. / 4/.4433;IV))V[+I& 33I-33.3 -33--++*'¥3,/ ¥*VV)}]V-I-3=,.3 . 50H3. 3....3.3.H33i3H

100 3.34... ...h IV 3aV[V3 IV3 ¥) 3V **33 3*VV3'U3, .N*W ..... . ........ 8....720 3/$134434 ) {,,v+¥ I Vl3. I $033-1 33 0134 II]V }+.U+V*, )ae-we...#*M....H.~.o.#.M {H )H...Mi 8. ...8. 8 .oel.Il 23413114 3333.033033)VI]-~-)eI+)+1+I4e+V-333633 - - --- 33V.34..-3. * #.....I.W~....3. - --.8M--- --- #--t..{,-H3. . 3.

3l3/. ) ~~$ *+ 4VI343 )3.3VVet 33331 *31 V]IV I V{ + 333*+/Inl IVI-5.--l 3. #eR.8oooH.....8.33W. '#We. .l .-) 'W3'-H..#$///6 1 131141$14+13.333 333]] 333 V311813t+ 3 . 1111.33 $ I.n..8.. .843., ,,--8w 3.3...I..ww3--.#MI!

222 3*{$4/*4{3$++v303 ]]W3[] / 3,11, 3I33334333,3 3/1 ,...-# $-¥--{{. ..33...3. . 43 I .WH343…83224 $4*$44 }I44 $t111,113 V3***)V)33331W I8 -II VV-13#I- -… - ".#.8.# ....... #.. . .. H' #"1¥'1V"....…226 S44¥)Z)/WI$...+$WI3M333333333~*433 ) V-3-.l.8#/l e"## .... H*.... ........ -. ,WVI{I¥I3- -220 4~*4&14ll33$)3131{+{*¥V{{ 3133*M33}34*I}$VV3e33-8-MNI-W888 . ##8.,~. N.e,-#83,,N3..l-833.#3¥¥VV {1 ''-11 .-2320 14114411 // )+ * 4 ) { 3 ~33133380 ]V 1i/m$*++4-I ...- 8.H- . -.- .8.#.-..33#.3 1 .V I .- 6-,

232 -)23$4 $$///V/// 31311314100000000333 33V ]+I+Vl I WIM4.-//..881.-M433-#4, {---8838, .8-,. 33.. 8--,,--V3¥ { * 3..-8.34 .

3234 311$$141141 /////[.4//003}},¥13333V]18*{+1308...//.8.#..-/3---..8...3.8888..338M-4~--.383.3.8834~-{¥V I [ i / }]I., 8- -

238240 33+)144443.V+ / I+ 1341333lV)++3V 333++·Vl 3/-.e.#-3...34.38..8ke#1#I///#"... .- 3… #..#8#.#833--1V3/11*-3'3--8..244 1,44414430303414 33.383343 . 8 . 838008...3N.3,$.330246 31SV44 S.4$s3)[ 31$ 3434*V+V ) ) I 33l V V ) -- ' '388...· .33}..83#8--/11-- .. #N3 3-.H...1833- 1/11/3…·240 11114)44.141S43133$ .0333eI 333*l333e. .3]34---M-- MN33M. I -®#-H-0.33.NH#M=-lM8. e.H.N-4-.3200 /,-e2520 33)44$1$$$4111i$4ZZ$/){1 ]=3-3/-M * /Z .{- .. o

254 )$1444444.4SZ $44ii)44/ IS.)_,~-_V-/_-,HMe tt~~~k~ ~ ~~M M~W]~ I~...i.

252 3 }}44141314414114Zw1wwt{ 43 W{3 i]WMNMI/333i-W=M]--VV/ Wi--3I.}-..H.M-..8.//.8W8--.13.H. oH--4003 . .. 44603254 )))$$44A$�4$4 13141///4413W[3W3.3- W3 . 8.-W -. VVV = 1/13W0t)//W.WI)8/8.3.0,M8...M.883//.30/.03#-3.M~

254 1$4444444$4i34114//{31,41WI408W3-30 … M-MW 8W.-.8.8=V=~-M-I//-W=8 ///8-- 4 _3../W.h ..--.753 31444444 i4434414121 144- /v 1$/-/ _.....';3.o-w-3H30 3111$44.14414441141$i* .1]¥] 3--V--3333.]-3I33.WM-.VV¥¥VVV Mi,. .I, .{-8..-3{. I00...3........

2I2 I 1114114141414444L?0V 334l333W8,31,...-;.W 383l.3313~- . W33808.-3

232 33 $*)4V441$-*20]])3333]-40 . M)l --)3".1e3'V$V04WV/M 38-8-814l43.04/I.//00 //..I4........ . ...20 33 1111114444134,34343,3331III,3W3-3 . 8W8...343.8 33..34Z03310-.3..8.08.8-.8.0.

2o0 //14/1441${$4.V)/3/{11.8-,-&{333])---33-a/.40-3..4V3{314.-J-l34]-{-0..344801./004////WH.33.I---0!.---e3H*HH.22H

23/ 111 ... 444 '-S S ¥ W. .- .b- ¥---~.. ... 0..8/,.... W........i..3 pHHHH 23 ..

234 1114411" 33I33,3333.. 608.000 443-.4383-3 .. ".-.W. .. 003.-8.8038276 133431444413133 /W40033 33*.33W3~3-V.. 4..M33333 43--8..V8 . .. 33.. .

083 114$4 11W* + 4) / V+ {-I-3,tl.33.)3'' .WI.+VV-' -. ........230 13143.3$444303443313033-3 ...--I / 3W -W.30..3V .. . # 8 ·-V/- .... HW...'.-1. 08.3I..}..

21 313413313433. 3+33k[),4/W/V .)-33-{W{'-IW¥)'.¥+ 338303 I)M{M-38 e8.. meo--.I-48-. W.. 0/0/eo-888.8 …~.H..03.3HHHI*H},?32344413 3344{1+ 31$44U½) 1[W-WV 3-{V} 333 3 .33,V'1k+ *'{1~{")IM'' .WM.I-1W#3 -M--330oW~.8000...8--44. 3030.33H'~'1

328 4 41+44,'04%4 )Z w 3V]33 . 1 we,+11+*l). …*-3V332VV2V-

32& $144~Z. 33f 41V 3 4?4 I/8.31313-33I3 …3 . 30.) VVMVI- /34W-MM-.N.M0.-...8-3- ..... 3H0......... -

304 01311313 333.444000-33 …)+e{i 3+3.3 3}) )) )) )v4 vvv3 .38.*.41338.-4,HM' .{ [38.. .0 . .0.52333H~e-*,HHH}H~HH~{2230.4333 $ 333~llZ+W)w)~$}i*+~*)VV[--WNeH.VWv84W1!0k30 3.3333.--344.33. .8331~ W-336*4 - I-,...HHH)..33 … H}H3*333

30I 1113340/k/q0 $442413 {-)11[33 3.-}3- 3 3- .3-. -VV+--WV-.W-o.. . . ..... H5. … .05533033

330 $43,& 3.3341434!3--)3 3*/] +333*WV)$)))) * +I+*)k')-e,..~V{ V W'~.* v.. 333.3.-.# ..43,.88.3. 3333H00..338 3.3%H, 255303'H

33 44433 s 443-/ 04-111 )3 l / /IV-3WW-H 3...008.3.36........ "'H ........ 3 -38.3,305.3802

"I '4- Z~4Z //Z/! VVV+// +$) W )IS $)))))*)+)$ 7-kW ~ .. VV V{.V-I /H MI H.1.H{hHHH.2}{

334 4l4414 44S'{V141--31)1 1I--'-I.. ....330--V33')%W . ....· .· *t4*HHHHHI.-.33H.H)H ,7

300 440414.1416444V)33W.33330 ..-648 [33 13 3{3/-)-...-./-.V33 ..... .3...8.. .6 -. 3 ...... W .. , .438 . 3033.333333,H

324~ 4333344441444 ) 3 .)** 333 /*] -333 333V/ .4... .. ....- W. ...3.3-0..03*H} 3-30 {

324.. IV 4 ,0 4S 14!'14 .. 14 03V33033333334 'WI'-Il.883,38.333 … 00..3-38..33533333.3

32o 4334/14144443303300$1/-* 4-V)0*113 {33 I,3 )) I4V4V-448.M8...-¥{...4.0.3.- W3-. , 3.Ml/.08,3,.333-

333 14ZIlq444544474133/W-)5, 333.83341133333333,33+VW'4))'3.0 MVVV={.V.48. 4.40.W.4...VW~e.0H.., 3M .. H.hH}{ 3HH['H}3H22413

11 4111441W IV$Z/l"II-4S$1{*+)++*-IV--*'~'"=VVV='=... . . -

332 134410443330 3,.v 3 . 33 3I fI) 5 ) + °* ......... =o* 441%333.3.6IV.W3,3303. 8,3'H? H0V H 22373 444,4404I /V4430400,34433133.61I33313.333333,3IIII ]3W-.V.V V.I0.-+V= V.VV .I.. . . .I 3.v-33MH3HH} 3H 3330 44-.;414043444/434145 .33 i//)3]. 3 l33 )33 i +. 3,, vvvi vvvvl *.3vV. 3.63.4.+ .. ,5...0.333o25{33331544444442~qI,443& 44ZI ,3-4.34 3333)33++eo. VV. ..... 3 3. V..3.8.HHI{H:W +HH '3H33I

'401114$444444433.40,3Z~ 30+),30{4-3 333133133.+.+++e33lI.3.33-4333833. VV .33 0.... N 3333{{{ {,.33H~ .. }*H 5H333385/3401414440~$$44443,342 33-333w+ { 331 33 3,)3 3$$ $}$33I$ ++ +-i- -W3+I+VlVV V¥..3.83.. ~.w333 -3 & ).8ie.3.30 *HP~).~HH)33333 H}20234-0

3433 4444$043$3413)IZ//[VV+*))4$$$1$$)$4$)*+V++=I-*.303030..-3'.V)V)VVVV.3..3.W.--.-00.8-0M.8 .. 3}*3HI)..5330500.30532 3- 2 3,00 0444$40402,341430- +v+3%4353555I1l3 33))+++++) 3I,~-3.43+¥++lVV¥+.- .00083.8033.0.We---.M.HHP..p..I,30000..0H2~2y

0.2b 04444344 f,$002.0-3/3//3311+w333.* 33~$4$$5 $ *+*. .3.334.4-*3.,33*vv~ ).3....0. 0333-MN· HHH. ..M0*33.,20

300 144031400 04444)04140-31.633.,1411- 1.)I33I....H. I,.?IH... 3 .. ~HH.WVbWA..8."0I.... -2-34 30 4444413l 4 8,/300431.3 .3......2 23 .304 440000044//4-4Vm44365 il/-{m lV $ $V4} + / +- 3 {,. . ..... 80000 .. p 030000030

353 3+.64$$4/'.*/.I4{,.I {W40434)3),{3$ S )1) · ) w/-,, Vl,VVV-I V VVV. 3 M...... · .0 , 0 M ,--. -- , ,~...3. HH. H. ..50320.00332-'?2230.0 444444$ 414~*/ZI -I) { 3+$]) 333414{}+133333 +VV+kVV 3 .. ,.3. 30.300., 0-.'#"tW-U.3 .MM,~ .3--..3.8-.332233s.33',H2??Y233044444444404441330003.3330333314331343k+ ·*v ,3,i.·,, ¥v- +v.-....8. MW3VM3 ., M. ,-,. . 3{. M.i 3 .....H...HHZ2222?Y??2

3, 34436444443.436334 V0 $3 , 3133 33 3$) 3-/.. ...33030.00,30I00 . .,=.. 83-3303V,, .00 3o:o30V,77W

3331 44441474414433103-0,133333 2*.3I30883-0V0000V .- *.....3504 .5000300 114443430343.143131 . 3-.-,0030V33..,I,33888535 3050032,82l 133344144,,4441304303- 3,1413V1313311 3~3~ 3 ~ .,38V V55333..633.8.332030003334 14 3414 .......31,3133133*333 ~43410333000. 0.3,0333003332 2

336 3,41414141/144i4 VI, $jI 1I- + 1.0--, - 3e M H,.. .33?,240b.3411/l7$+1440LI)I33 I- 3314131+111III 33..3-3~3. ..........0...8.......2... 22233340 3$4444'41I44VV-3/3$I- 1144I.33$3...4 ] -N3--3833. .8.4030, #000003004 -.;.;;. #.. ?2 2 2030 2?.. ?23

q33 l$$4444/443/-v*)w)$)1441413/ 1144w-+)++½]-*{ 3 0.. 0.¥]=V}=V+*,303,i330o .eMWM#- 888~ .8... W''I'.3.. 0.*MMWHHHH4.V-22-22

33303111114 1404032 0343..344114W4. 413133 . 8.I3..3..VT00033 . .%8.3!331336..MM000 .3. 8.0..30 20200

346 311434303 I.~$~,~ &)+k). ))4421 )k +twiI *'3+ W 4114 113k.Mk#.~~.-o ~ 3,.0..58.00,30 . -. ~.850HH33*.HH~ 2221'22202022

4303 V1344440 V*.)*}l4l/WW1l1l .......8VV...-.303V333'0.. .80k'"~M43M5M.3*3H ...H 222??222?2?22

4433444 3 *vs 0$$ / 0--,v1I+$$) ) 4413313,3---*l+.v{ { 33, ,NW-=W,~ -.. No..403. 0#. . . .=. .33... -*H0,02222Y20202H,

~,'0 +V)V)41144// 1V++{$$$- 7//{/=w=+w13-_';4k==. I'4~..H-M.vv.- ~*J~*M{2~'-=-v'~.-.H.-HH":~2y~2H.~~?2~y ,2??..?H1

4.032 44/ ' + + ] I 11$33/111V3141,3W 33.3.3. .... 0,6433003,0. 83 -0HH..0.53...H .05H ....H~2y , H2.2 22?4.3 /-114* 444040013001.334113114413 1133V3.3.8 I.'- ''4M, -M . ...... HH.HHH. 8 ....H3..2?,222.22H?0??22?2

43 · 3 $33,45 - +)) '} $$ZZ3 0031 /181 3143=I33VV'- { 3088330 8~0V{ 3 3kW I) # -3---3d. .m4.I.H'd}{HH . ...0.HHIH22 02 ~HH ??3333H 200.'.

4b~ 3 {3443333 )00 )3311/1+13 3k)4~+. 1-)w+/3 VI3 V ·..8 003,]w3 -)3.-00.. 03,.-..0H~.88H23 H23 .222 .???2272Z2227222Y22222H(..430)) ) ).3 41 · ) I4)-,[ *$3 $)Im ' 3 ·'-We44113 VYVVV=- W))-3.0330043303-..M. .... H3Hoh 3 .H H .. H0'2723?222 ..222272??2 32272?,'20

1.I $$-14144 1/)I ZSW1t1wtl {~$ --V VVV--W[W-W3V=-= ]3.~H...MH2hH?22222Y2?2p22 7.

433 )I$$ZSVV))'IW[$ZZ+V-]/*IV*-&' VVW W.-. .8 .. ....H3'Z2 2320P.22*2...400 ',)I13S4/)310-3 3II 1333 143 3V VV-+ + .*-.-3_3W0WWWW3._. .. : .....?2...I7I .50???2'2000002

402 00033340 301 I )Z$*V$*. 333331 $1.$sf ~te *3 [ -.I 34U43,....... 8880. *HH . .H.8.3,..02PH23?Z?~222222 22270'222.'.

424 03/44/ I'I)*4 $4' 3/33$$3I3-3 -=.H.. 'I I I-V'!' I 4.'I4. . 5 ..1.2227? 2'2272?? ?II

426 G4~//){VV$1*)W)-]-[')))))· 31310 3330. ... '-)V)W33]M~M3.-38.*..*.8..M*{ H..0...H23f22272 ? ?.2272020222H H-p

423 33311143030031,343{ 314'4'sw4/-w$.; -I- .33.0v3 I-'M*.0...W,..000533?22332220,202022430 *334443003011333 31/4$$$44*)1,3*-.$ ) -VVVV.]).",'VI .... H..,88- 38..H..#. W33..833,?272?22222 0.? I

432.~ 31*3444/303{4033311 4444$*)V$$)''+W3W.4 -W31. ...3-3 4. ~ ....38n.H8.HFH3.-.. ,H33~2222252732262222??022) 20

1q2 $1/)I Sz~++V 4 4·/m ) 4 ) V.W ....~< w. .M .. .. H.. Vf ·N.`4 m}M'v~{I..- --- ko~HH)~??~?2~?72 2 I.~ H

43 144030,34313/*144401 4 4vv$,+¥$)I,-'-&-3 i )'.3MH8. ~uW. .. 3...0.3M0.3HH000322227722272727 222220*

43,I' * 433$1,$ )44+$$41-33} .IV-3 - ¥=*W80 .Mg.3.U....M..-.3MW..H -,---.---222'22.3302222 2 7 2222220

4` 00m-Y'VUVV OOU00C:d')G¢00 C CO )0.0...0..00....M00 'I I' I ' IS I' I I I I I 4 1. ... . MI- .. I1 2 1 I I I IIIIIIlIIIIil)IIII12?7 2 ? :2 '

443. , 11[3?0U~l3,.22]) ! 31344243 -. 6,0 3-11177.83.46033.83.M33..8Rh3~q 00 ?2 {{t~~~' %~~77}BP~'803.3. ¢;CC0222002220I II I

442044,34403033731I3134383333.333 .

443 *VV 411034-.08+:W- 34010 3WlV33..84.V.4-8.....8338...3.'3,3.02220020220,32

450 ,'I ' tJ 303034 3 I303 31411337ql3308303- %'1 5I't5~1t~{ ~71 % ]37.ll. 03 84.4333.83. I..33ql .'303,.--33.5.3..."..7qlm27,t11':7'

45 , V3334434-01 I I454 vvV443 IV.0*33 _;p___33~0333~~3 83- . 0003.W..'..0.....3,0 ...220-232222220

460 133 31430000383, 0311030034...I---/ 3-.33-3." 03- V-3...3.M3.0.,50000-.8333 .-22 200222 20020452 *..344 430,,41 .1.41 8334441143..3 VV333 -33 �-03.3. V3W33 .- I38M.-.M- 3....... W .08...........2222200222202220277222

346 11630033$ 134043.3,1-30V0.4,Z4,-4-----W ......... M-200302202020220?220?2220000

432 140430.3333.3 33233 3333.0033.33.0..,438.038. ., . 2222222020'2?200 -2022222222022222

408 4040 33 310.301.1848.0..I 388 . ,303.00320'222222v2202202340. 343033.43100313. .83--0...38.86..3..3M..022222002022202222

4334 0 !IW ,I3 3*1.4- 13.0 :V1 3-….-.W383"808..I000202220202222222 243330 ;,

4'3" 013131443 33333113 UVU-3 8.308110...203 W_ 2-_ 222- 20,22?22202., 3.043/1103 1444444,,0,11,6 343-!W -.. 3343,33..,3883.8.0033?'22000221200220015200.;.050'

43? 4016431,331.1,331.4113 343-08.8..4.,3..0,. . .... .'.,-O00H222220202203,.,.3

4 411 31311,113.,1,,1 113 3 W3431.31V)l l3. 884 .l43.8. _: .. 3.l5 ." 0.....0332220027'2020222 ~ 22322330

Figur~e 4-16. UNSUPERVISED CLASSIFICATION MAP AFTER TWO ITERATIONSWITH 17 CLASSES

4-22

Page 88: UNSUPERVISED CLASSIFICATION OF REMOTE MULTISPECTRAL ... · i (f t , lt tr-220-1075 april 1972 unsupervised classification of remote multispectral sensing data 172-27204 ic.as c 237s9e

NORTHROP SERVICES. INC. TR-1075

00001000000000000000000 0OOO00 0 I )5 111111l 1111202 224000311111222223 3330&46466565 6646?T7188 0 6044.&4l556& 6 33?7777 6 699900000 tlllZ13%711357.135291291513135? 5q3 ?913o1501s91 "79k. 931832137159i937q371571 2111

200 42V*$)-*V13) 6ll¥1333331v3*--3 1-3 W-- W-38 ..I.... .... -.. ,e*-* HI, .... 8.. -..

202 4IVI..V..31* 13133W I11i3 *V~*v 346IV2-3--**H. .. * S.4204 Z/ 6.14441118I¥ I*131 )311-31233-1*2 6v: +/ 1 v+*VVl.·... 3 . . 1*06.*6..W *1e36l62o206 4V+$4l45&VI)VIV¥......3.13}333[-3.*¥V )*+¥v+6*)¥*1ca*k-a-- ...... W. . . . .206 3V$411)1) +) * IV31V¥13 113330*IIVl I+* V.**- -. S..........--... .......H .-. **6*. .1210 IW6eS$)4I4+4VIVIVlV0*Wf33WVIV3IVVVIIW3V*e+"V}IV6V03-1.I36. .

A H 4/$$1SS$S4j2))VIV l IIiIII - 1131)*iV2¥lklkllH0 ... .......N1 .....144.4$ 61 V[V)YV 3.3..-33 *3I* .l*V · v ./lb........ .. ..e ........e....- -..l

220) 146/lI $$4 I$S445+++$* 33333 -I3+ I*W 6*4l-+ /lI /-. l .......... 222 14S114/*41S) 1*) ... VIVI13W3- W)046)+W./ /m*-. ....... Il.. .. .* .......... I.?W.8lIIhW..*..W.

$2'.64665/*2)2$i)l[- --- .............. N. H 3.. .I V.l......-?24 1444V}l/ *)14)16+ 1*Jt116 1V]333333 3 411 )iV1VV4 3--.-##/ - * ..... .... H. tIVI220 44. 4441 1III).*v 3- vv6 3 .... ..I; 230 S44+$44 2I)Si$*i1*VlII33313463341-IVV . 6 3 . 6....63--*.,.i VIIV l*..-4-....

2 S0 $4t415S////]il**+..I-+LI111333 1 45J*"kll1ol-*--Io. .... *I--- .......232 )1I4662II////lI" )IVJ 1*III3 1 ¥*I+)1$* +*[I/- .. 2. . H .I. ...e-..234 )1S$$4t$6$$////26///// 1V03300316*1*6VI6"// . # .3 -.. -0[0*3. 1.

1236 $11$146$4614//22/////////1 i333331I$3V *.././36--..--- .. ... .. ..-- 41)01323.3..-238 I )S$44$4S,4$///2/I.4//W 1103I0V331¥11)*11'I-V/--/,.l. . .-/---- . ...?40 ))).$4444)+$1/lll6*1.*1$¥llVI V31)*i1 e --.. 3.3WI0¥)-//lt..

N 262 ))&14611444112l16.I61+451$V061'3164)0V81W*..3 - ......... -3"'VI®//to3.,I3-244 ))+S,]44F-12 )..4I..l.l+3**lVI13/---. ....-- 3.l.. e..I V/2///,3....... 3..... ..3 ¥ / ... ..- .

240 )$$V444S646.1)[ I)411Z6+V16V}/31VV¥I- II. 3..............W- .250 )l )444 S' SS 44) $44ZI)/l01tb[-33-3***-3- - .3- . ... . . . ....... …252 I )$44165$16$$6454 26$$ 011$/I*333.*3-"3. . . *162 .- 63//223.-6.k3~Z/254 I1$444644*$44 12*;S44.$)44/I1I* .. ----I3…...* 3 3-756 W644444$)2 b/6-6-I/I ……-----3~----IW.... .4-4-IIV-I .-4.......---/./1..--.3256 lIS44 44642464%Z$44+V3/W-]I-WW-!-.IW.3.*.-W-3-../ ... ..... .-- W--*8*~260 )1164441441444S41 422/01463W--V--33[Vi-3 . I --...... I-------13--.---262 1$1S1414$1414$44½4Z¥/I1--VW-0W03[-1---W.I*#/-6"-6-.*/ …3-. -W!.3..3.--/.-264 I)_44.i4$16$4171///-13[3-33311WI/ .--- W.. .. 3--3. 6 -.3. -246 )II} $$61444W4461.62 0*60m.- )3 *""/-*VV) 3363"V1 /em-*3W."-*/ .3W.. . .2.2 . 326I)) )1$$444411t .4.l///II.I3*333-I*.3. 4 ! /13*)3338;1/#W-~ W3-6/-/ .... //***/. . .06.*e-~*270 ))M)$$S4$14$14+i//[HVIW]33]3-3_-333..kikIV VVV]=V ..- *.4// .... -.- o// ... .H... .2?2 2) 116$$4 $$16$ + /)1ll1 /~3¥-3¥-60 .I.1.[/.*¥+¥++VV.0/3*-..¥$424./*0I.i/./I//.=6....H.../2//. . ...0,0,,~2)4 1)1164644 114*2+/64V6313361-33-V..* *V-V¥++0V¥II3*3o.3¥ 42//tVlV3W///-/. 6.-. 0.. -276 $)6414S44+ /N$$1W11OV 3J--33-oe 3.¥/-+V*VV IVl¥W-/...3444*I I.//.. ......278 )4%4$414$4$~/3))4V3VV)~V3-33~-ie........ W3-¥)+*IVV,.fVIlkw®o*~][-/ ..... I . .. . ./W/®/*-II-el722 '414194141446/1V144013-33.V06*06VWI. 01.2 . 222.l-6,.I20 46O 4 S44})44/00Vl0lVV)*I&.]--3.*.-'-.30.630*+*OI[OIV~]'.~''V/*'/ .. . .. *....//"*,',~ ..262 6141444141*45.. --V]S I31V* VV [-to)* I. . .... ...-- 26284 $1$444414-+l+))+IVli).+131]3-33-T-)--. *VIW-IbvV.VVIW-w-....3--..31.--W .......... I26 ) 1416)441%6$1V/V*62 )*+0V]3-[-W~......WV=..Wi2 ..... . . .. . ..... ... ... .....20 61. 1 4$+41*WV[V44)11 )I*[-]*V3S33--33..V33VV.3-]V0V0V][-.e/* .... ,--...3 . 2. .0.

?230 $$+$116,1401*4411V)I))*1132-]T-130-.3 .*3 0.3. .6/-IV/I-I.VV-[~eeI22.-[~-*I///e.I----k .-- .tHH..HHHHH2?2.41ISS*44SS 111 1)))33[-- …3~[ V/-1V. -e-IVV-V. . .. ...-Vo--...... .. .- 2HH

024441 l$4+~*446646}14/6* +)11336-3213--330.-. [-~e -/3V-3. 01 . l*-*-V*2-.`////2 ~ . ..1J---oe 2HHHHHH2294 142)4$).14414 l2/- )$, -.... 1-6-6.3V-33V- 333--1 .---- . 30.0I*- *-.-eo.*// ee~H. 3…-. ...iH.H2

300 1244++}61)v[V42124211/6))W3-..-31.3 -I---W.vW]W2--.031.-e. *W -61 . 622-22-2`.- ... … 3…2..H..2HpHHWI302 4 II$}l * [$VS44414 S/-I)I*3-IW3.3-33 .- ]-~-./ . ...-.. ..3 6.V. "I..'l//. / ........e.,HHHH222

204 26)16161$I4+ 444452/--3/) …33[3,-.33)*3…333--[¥e*..6.-elee--oelI-.V.,e//3Ho.I.*.~… .it ... H221'1'306 4)46*) l0I044)2[W-21-116333316-~1-*)+*W -[U3-3 3[3v=33 *6e1-* … 6-k-l- --- H~..6.-2~. ..3 … 00000223206 21111) 16066$) 44$-/ */]*33361-.3I6"***6)i+.[I-**V'33 . 3. ."~ =3k*//*/.`H. …-"*.H`H0Ht0HH2HP22

110 4}1,4l.64V1...*./...--3{kI6-- )I+*II}I**V -V V -, i-83.6. 6I .... }W /-/e//.. 0W6-e....*f.0H2l22H--

126 444*1264411)vs2*/-vV0213/-33*80 ))t+VV-VVVW ~ ~u -i-.v--WW*//-" U*026.16... ... 0I...///3.2. }1,2,2002

314 4144*,*4*6.. 44. . IV-.. ..322W.-. 2.-- … 2)2.H6*H,612

2164bl I$*16*444 ./106.))6-$-*W4-3-~*i}6V+[)++603*IV]]~Wee~~-V~VV"WW..33- 13...*4.22..40*4*. ...612.*1.}'I122.2

Io:;:10!WWWW.11

320 t4$4*41642l )v[4411/.[/ I/w10-) ) ) ) ) Il )**+)0 )+11 .- w{I )e oeIV- -I~ ~H.. **33.. f/..e-H. 3...0H.2¾IfHH2~f'6I},H

422 40I$G 6!44441+I ) 0ZZ/-32+ ---- ) )-{IWIW I.o-. ;w3-.VI. . 3...0..:.... WI{HH0k0HH26'I32 4112//6411W VZ+W-6 3W033*I$$$$I))) )11*)1 -l*0l)+W-W.W.-.... . I. .W .. ...e.W ............It 161414444 44¥V¥*/ /-3*I)$llll+)26*1--..... 1+-363… …2/*H......4-0HWHWWH3HW[IW22

I)? 61441426244112VVZ*/--I¥).*i$1~616[$)6))))*++*)+l6-0--=0--.3'.,-.[- ...-. i.]I/ 20*0..V1..3..iH~..},HHH42H}HH.01,622b1

324 64144 W12461442I2*1)-]1*/ 13-))6$} 11}) 1--V/,.... - -... 0. .. ..==-=,-W ...... * HIIH-H"4.H II)64444 2/14'1411*6$$ I$VW))$-1*11))1*))$$ }*+ *+]1)3.6. 00I0 ...... 0.............-.=w-........W-.-- . h2

33} 1444 4[Z4~Z4Zl**2223~l//=)kV *l6+I2$$$)2l)*)e1* V/2*6 3e*41 .ol¥¥V')1.....6..I-I U..00..0.H.eI. .HHHHHkH 1HH2H;

460 665444444 $*VV4I/N.1*21$)1}) *6)I)*V106-.613¥ . IV.. ). V. 0....V24*1. ),,HWWH22VI W

14 46474 464,14126 /11$}VI$/ I0-[3*¥$16$$)) )+)*++V--I-.e~.*¥VYY...W.....II13. . .6e....**.,eH 004.22+2;HH2.)?,22?

344 4$/4614&2Z4$4t4+I?/-k-l0¥{+I0)I&1$$)I})})))~+*)*0)-3**I.-6*VV.i{6V..6*0....V2-24i-.. 222102HH. 0HHH212222344247222 G) *00&0]* 11/21.141*S))1)6) I)))6)1**)VW23-6!. . 600 2.0. 32.6V+VVV=V.===...-II...H .0H0H.,001H060HEH,44) $44442142416*2/-*[-{*+}$4))))))166)l )16)6 2*2-3*632.=03666)V.lVm~=~~e..-.6. }4HH.b16ltH0H2121l1{022?

I /20 44624-121*1*4464)2-1 2)2161*11V )2W 66)iW3- ..'0*00I6I). . .0.tW00)-.01006112

342 244$ 4444 ))$$$q 1$/ *W-W+T)+$4$)$)$)))$$)+++++V-*-,*-]Wre-+) +V2l VI . 20 ..VV0u====-Wb - 66.-e*,HZ~.HHHD2.l2I'l22

244 )+44424*%142.66)0114/{VV .e))45 1$)6$])2)++V*z-eee*6613.-3 . 6)V 0VV ....W--o2-Wee**HHHHH*2210oHH211,2140~ 442114$$4401~/*)+¢) I $22.6 }%)$6666$1})1* 0/+41o-.400 ..*¥06¥V-V .... 0-II.----.oe}.H H 0H*.H**H 0.HHi1220k34442124440 106$42-I-[+ *)$6$)))$)**4611))e*I[Wl6o*ee eVVV¥¥¥.0.1. .*.W.0..--e..i 0...620006060.HH.H*H2H21222

342 )$42221226444*06[***)616631$$S6$)$1))**+-..¥lVY26))*VVVV . ... 33...3.-- - .oHH ...26 ... 2401 ,06.0..m227222

304 44------444)06)12626)-) IV46 1))*/)6*6 V… .. .A0.6-X6.-..H.,H.I ....22222222

340 46)42144 444)446/-4$ /$)*WI sI. )} %l)+ *66*66 -3 . 0l.VVl6V*VVVVY¥ ........... .... *.. W-- .. 22.2222

12 41 4444461 1?ll /[3-$+4V25 42 6$)) .1VVI+VV . ....... /.-00610- -, ....lHlfI.HH...2*2222

132 *1644444Il$)44 I2**10....)$$..)S)l * I7-V.......-.04000.6--ee ..... 0..2pH2H.600002202122237 VV$$*I/mI~$))$}~T+{).I+VV~ V I......4,41.4-.-H.,.eIVI.-.-. .... e....H 1.. .'H2272

31 .14 44464Z44.1)446!-0.4 )12) 14 166.66 0-6... 00)*40 00020622122?

200 " *116444144614226*1046*:141 21)1)) . 66660000. . .. 331.*0604 00)4,220I22

234 )*4 /l/164442=)l2.I21))141$¼)++¥/2**iI.=++VVVVV1 . - . .... ....... H..00H22.2222

226I ~*)466644412/ll 41*,0*)164)$6~)66 6* 2/2-.-.-e~$~~*v~V.. --o-.-o e3--.--w …---e 0200"-*e" I*00h-22,22/220~2,

144 ))*644411442141V14461*)1V4W)14146)4) I .3':*00V0V"'4"0'".6 V.W-[.120.2 222

2)2 1)644$/4//4 [$*k) -0)}1164)161.6) ; -i- i66.0*... . 6)6-04.02-i-..i 11 . 0.)H12;2-2/*02

1)4&I *)24146122*/l,*6)l44}4* 41$ 4461 16).0*/-e-".3WV{ ....- 06006 00,.lel&W'-e.*.-.eee*H,.,012 ./1.022~222

2 .. )1641/4///-V*2 )S)4$ 4 6)-)++ l-3--I[.-....**10 i.02- 6...06042.W; WV222V22

220)66604411*144026666 l}$~Z/)+)))~)k)/-f[~e=+[{~+~**e.6ee*-~/" 2. .0*00000.0.**...HH~22)?H2122'22

400 6644144111122646*4441)6).I00001402.1.4~...22?

432 )11$44444/11244444 4 )V46:_V 1.$....*6-. * 0/.334I -.... 6V "-.VV-6--I .3- - - - 22-2..-:"H-.-I-~ .. 2;.?2221-??40 21)2424/4421121/62-$V 1$t$ 641-***2 -*-"3..v6-001 3.....6..*0 -"00 W"….. 2.222?222222?

14 -+I***1/4 //-4 l1I6$$$))06..[-+* / -3[WV*6+¥6*.3*….-"14**H- ..... .... 422.222222222

42 )6441 Vl)V 2)/ / 2/-I* ) 6644126, . .0-0V-0-WV**¥VI.03 .... …e- .. 200.0)1...** ..e....I-'..le.?22 22H1?2o222

S1R * 4 Iv.41.122*VI**$$)I) 4Z2tV-e* .... IV I ,66-.*,0-. .6. 3..e . ....ee..0eo 622?22?2?6)2*14444V112144*4 $)4 6[41*6)-/3/42120) . 1".06-=[.W..I... *,33.ov.o..6 ..... 0-.. - - *2/H22022?454 **1+4V/444/+2112*2)40I)166612)V66 ). /4'-I .0 .00.. oV ...... 1-2.H22-1,62122.?22

422 /6611-=4_*))I2)$$62 i1)16 ) V*/I]-... - o H H ...... _01 HHH 22,H2222..

1620002426-21. 111146121 2-..600,60. 2 2.6 2212272

422 4011*4412/*2*660.) 2)11)166- )./6*0......03IW "*-:*~---H~-P .... VT.~.HH22.~2 ?22?.... 2..222?22

424 006)1)4421 /2*634 1)6$) 2162-) *0-3-63236/-) 3[V.*046 06*!.36e . .....H4. .0'062?2??7222; 2722727222h22.

42 $11q 14,)1111)01)) 262102)6*2ill -..-..-.-VI31 -, 3,3'3-. .._..2.H7 2?22272?22227

.26 2266*6$2222621*[$1)6124)6/62.262666 . 010*0-e11 ~.-...o .. V.V.6..60220'22?22? 22 02222??22????l?2?2,12 1$Z.*+){444 [010 {2-216+01)& 2)VV*411*4I'4=66*2 … I.3....613 .61.2.??27Z'?Z?2~2P?'20£'22;222o..2

412 I /.4/_14$t1) 2 -- $444...64- 1*$) 00li3*--3H*- .2 ?~? '?22'2222?2. ---

414 1)/1}/}1121t-*)/2)1VSV 4lV --)S*2)V*6 -3-IlW--)eWWW'. l'.3..l0.. . H*kH00000Z2Y2??2 22022 2222227 02??2~.424 11/162/224232*4/)) 2244/2I$2 2623V 6221.6V.-i-*11*1e.2 ..... . . .0H.004HkHtH7?2'27?7??2222202222227410 *6&*/)4111*0 I I.$ 211$tv / -/I%$*to- 223606.0 …-~-v- -,, ....e *.e*40H',H00722222.'02222~2?2~22H..*2440 ~46)// I ).VV$* e V.T-6411- J+) }) ) 3) . 3 Ite .. 3.3...[VW3ee .e*..eeH.H..e.e*H H 0r0~?~~22477227?~?22 l,.'t,

442 -II)4044. [ 2)*1.1146-/ - 2)3v*60.6 ....-w---ooo . ... i2/ 2?2 ? I272222. 2

444b *1/W6*26 JSJWJ)V))1+[6 ~V 12~V--I1662621-*-W160..-.o.IHI.tlIe~I .26.-.......22~242/2~2222 H..,2,2 I

444 Z 0)20) )/V$$$ *)*01V) 26422 +Veh$ )16-I-60**VVV-V0I …--{. . .6..... o. ,~* .H H ) '2- 2222 226' 22..

44~0 * 0*$ )G$ $ Il [ ))~+ 140-6016666)2+42210 … 0*0 3).*-11W.. .. . ...H.HH22.." 6 H'HH 22 2202222227222222o+ . P44*2 24 2l*V/I$$$$ 61++V*$+k2))4}-*W-*-e*k4.1.."..6..H .~..6.ele.0...0...I'.4{2222 222 22??/}722'?2 },,224)52*2/+2*12421*62 26$*)*)1v$$$}*23..3. I-0=- *.*S.0...*.t** .-...40 62200222222722444 6*)21440-10616U6162l41-200/3060130-6663ooIoo3.....*V.0*0.0o..0H2~'22222222222022222~-}+}~

440 */*24 44 22 4):6*0)2 +4 - ii6022,231*V340iiI ... I I. 3. 0 -. ::...6.}.*.0 .*. 2 -222222727 2'2

440.6.) 12:2.01 OUOUuO~3OCC '0*000000000)!LtI 6 221 122-I- 3*0t- t.0.440002, .0)22.0227 ?222??R 2202222224:j [ 202t

442 1**.SI46-22601 26.6)121.1:S S )0.--/l**-2 . ~ .6 .60~26222222222 222

4 2&)2222 l2?2*.- 12644 141 3-62-330. WI0 3.)*W'677%q-1 .i[VV [[ ti~..0.0 -- I2121 I2??Y22222'

40 1-1161242U22)16)24126) 12-2000..66 .-03-3.,iv..4v..22. ....042022/.. 27222272,27 241 26662601) 42116-6-661146-)16 06.6006626)2-. .161'22022222222012272

400 2114012)2 111 6421442216642 . 23-2-3l... .. ... ... .6.62,-VVX.2..,........ 22222222272222222?2222

4340 11l414I4* Z Z0*766014-0I41 4440.6 '.61 .. ..… 1......62..0022222vI72,722'I222-. .2)224C,2 1l24420 17/.4~4%440641**I)212 2*) 226)2..02.220.... ..f. 2020_VV-. .W_,;............ I.'2227222?2222222 2 222...2

4-14 1624 *661644 1) 4.**)1662)I..-*l-26-6V..*I .V V .... :..Wl..6... .............. 2222222.22.I.21242)4226166146 12164)6.zoV-o122222122,22,;?W... 2l2222

Figure 4-17. UNSUPERVISED CLASSIFICATION MAP AFTER FIRST MERGING WITH 16 CLASSES

4-23

Page 89: UNSUPERVISED CLASSIFICATION OF REMOTE MULTISPECTRAL ... · i (f t , lt tr-220-1075 april 1972 unsupervised classification of remote multispectral sensing data 172-27204 ic.as c 237s9e

TR-10 75NORTHROP SERVICES. INC. TR-10_75

SAMPLE 1 3 l~lL6I''B8312??'22

ooo.Uo~oooooooolooaoo000CO9000009o00SAOOAAl1 I I111k8 3111 I

200000111122223333344345S5966666177 18A888983909 00 1113122222331 4 66 6 li 4L

13,s7sss 5391 0515033?9579 37 335II 35 0883al 51083 7 17509157183501?357 13835 13M

5O9l

39I35374351q13 III

$ 2 0 0 4/V+1I4*4]I381*1I¥113HH I141A-H-68.88HA11A8 88/4l1* 8l-* o ...- W- ...-........... ... 2 z...- .. .:

206 41V, v $V/H)00 **lIIl1 1 88* HI **V8*eIv thl-- … ..... ....... 814*....

?04 /A*$41441 *1 v Hv + H -Ii -/ IV¥i l

-l -

V H e W . e1

e eI o ; - ' e ® ® HI .

® l...I. .. * . *8W .A....

230 I~~~~~~lI*II)A)A.4AIAIAI)4*).IWHAAIAIIAAA1 IA)4W8,,.AI3A*AV~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~l-.206.VI444 V. . . . 2 . *A. 1.1..J l~:I.V!-V:11111 ::~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~~IWi.i.#HiWWI~ee. .

A 232.433*4811141). 4A-. ............. ........ :;W 2[0 W$.$+t +vv vV ll~v*¥HV lVV~llw..v*+e~~. ie, ... . . eee lv. . . . . . . ,. ·...

2162 6/.+* ,86.8.4 e)I ..-.A ,, '''I )V 88V.--. l...- . ..... ...... .. I .

220I 4*11 )1l1114 558l.6*8 l88)4 V-l*A8 VI *AAIIV, I * . .AI.8..84

22 $848/$$ )$14*$&*S*+1]l V+ H HH IIl4ll8 l+ + --Ae 1.18 … 6 … . l.......I.I l! .l .I 1

N.28 63141302 $//[ )~~l*+IS *HWH*TV* S II]* / -,4-V[VVH--"*' ..... ...e.#..I-tt.--HlA'a119 .".lV~~- e l

732 l)8.4/126133184'5·HHH ~ I IV ¥¥¥1-8.~*134A311"I IvI-- e ·,.8.... . ... l.~-W..eet0el--¥1--.4-4-'"'.

I~ ~ ~~~* 23 -1181143/23// 118I84 I V·8 8 *~*+ . W"VW / -A ... .*....I.. 81 VH ¥ VIl W

238) 31414$$ ,03//I.6$ · $+*¥V V V 1 HHV[*WI*I¥+IH+V¥,2/W ~ -·.. --.... ·..IAl**A...))

240 II lI.4S

41*81,III*8.4lee....I-le*eA. 61 3 6 *..W. . ... *.A....

$ 24 )),$41/ )4)~lI,5511 HA~l94IHHIlI8+ ¥8IIIV W e.8...tl .A... .- 1ii.Iii I .IVIi. .33.....e2028 4./t1444)14668 ̀ I)432",V" 0, 2)A*I4.IH. . . . -----…

250 )I)145414..II4418645312IV 186 -884,81*8… 8.. .#.I. *l ? -------22 I".,,VI 4 I'll v ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~~VIVIIY ~

324 4)V / *4[8)HH1441311410--1 INH- .4 ... 8 - ..................... I . e

42vlvo : $,$, ,//// ..... *

224 I 1144.4544,4416"IR4II)44311* Wv.....-0.........--.W14* "P-:1:…

286 )$$44.....4...}/2/ /¥ I.… v ./ -WW ....... ......

2583 ,44 4343143348 H8l3 V. &V'-l1. W./.... . . 3.…

262 1,I1153414348438432"'II8VA AlAHA1 llAAeeo·*--o."A8 … ....... I* ------. -2,8 .. 114141 wi Iv1"H....... . ............. W..:. . .. ......

27) )1444-11)1I))I 314t 880.VH .......VAOAA*PW-*81f8113. . . 33

27) 41,51441443)148V. 8)v-4440. . VW.Ifl43lII . If*W,-*.*. . ,,,;P

28 V4444444441 3001I415A)l4II. 8.. 0..38*+01881V V1*.I H32214 4414$4841160 IA31* 3! I..8AA6Al.I= .I-v)4.18 .. Ww...... 2 .22

4 I~ ~ ~ t W"": :::::-:288 18418,44448A144 4113 )),l~l,0A.44A-- vIW lV 4-lvH l . .I .........290' :44 1,) 4 4 4) 0 ,,,

4, 4.. 2 ,s , . . ..--. .. . ...///V ...................

'1s l$&*$ II* 1$[}&j*·vfytl HI VVW/--e-HIo W!eHlee'llee'ee ° I.....

254 4t444144 .44,810144,8))1j44/3.-)4)4I V-/H. . 8910..8-A2.......8AA~ .. 2.

296 1$4)4444.444Z4V0, I3,h4)11l4' ",W-HI. w.*v1IwlvV8l~ ;. .: .vA*.............. 32232 . ,. . 222

50 1$4414 1444 44$ 4$ 4 )2!4 /

I88 [ ....I......... ..... . ....1*H w2 . 4.. . 2.../025 ) $444SI+4$ 4 54)4323/A )* "*- 84…H8--H-WH .----. e----3 A .AiV. ..i.222 222

342*161)$&651 )$S4444$2qZ-$/ … $1'1 v H *lH --- H--H-e**e -ee . 18..·eeeee -1* .-/ee-- 3-.e2 V/ I .22

306 4)14414$Z$ ) I.2 $ W--V-/H-A ·-H… -Is·-)e. ...... e...264 -W444*443.344.12 +N -I/I4-e---H--VI-~ eeee.-ee4el-.. .WA)....P3P .

466 4)4Ie6444 1224!--IWW IeIV-.A-- I 5 H. .,..'.22..

33604 )$$$44$4*)4t 444$ $ I2I e/ 6 l4I40

- -- V - - H H[ ))*V

' - Z * e - l - ' l*l

4 e

e ' e e - - - i) /

e e-1 .. *'' -- e-. A . Ž/ -- . ..?

416 )441 S$$&1$4$$+$44) +3-A- }H k kj ie)H4H4e-*VVI~-IH4--¥e¥+/·I~"II .6-H-*ee... .A.-AA . ... *A. . . 2420 44*4)~~~43f3)l444)1,2433*)I~~~~~v40I*V*e-Hel*.e/e..l3e--H.. 6A..0.V. 2

32268 1.43 144$$ 4)11.1V i//]TIHW[HHWH- lI.)H-.I-Wii[VVA ] [ [ I H Hv ) / "/ H-. /-

/v .... · //ll/..-3 . .-- 33.72..

4260 $ $14$$44 $44·4 3//2I-VOI*HH H-HN-HHIei·*I)),-VVV0VIVIIze-I~/I·-*/o-.A,.*.*4.**/e......e·)4--AA.,,.370 4))$44&&*644· *[/)S[[/[HHH .1-0*11 4),))e e /eV3 +V*VHeVqI'[I~e/~ ' 4)0. ... OA.l-*..3

36 44444 44 1)443*I 4144I,) 13)) ** 041t16ll.VllAS

440 133444.4)4422,2 )A 1))) 4***)*)*1A-1 . .30 .. 0

4ISI1IS4.!4//lIV/l~~~~~~~~~~l-. 1%,W=~// l. . . . . . eeVle--lee--'~

342 14*4443444,44,,) I4' ItIINN **)41)) v. *** )l41*-.~- . ,0) W.

774 4)4S4 $4344$)4+4+/We4V4 H)HHW -1. -V .......4) v)) 3 v ·* )5 v v l I [.HH...*V4Z//I¥ ¥ .l//* .

27, '.lI443 444 4 H)IVHVVHI - - V IVV11)'))--'-1'W ..... ///I/,..--iI.I.- 1.. 4.

27? 1.44,3444444'.1W40*3)44118)44 *. 1)..3/

4 $44444$444 /VV W4*¥. ..4 - V I V V ] ! ....))) *. . . . 0V[/l+V=/ ........... 2227 .....250 4441 0HW 14 $ I*I

-

. .. .?2.2......-/-22

352 14$44$4344 .44440111 ). .3 .H.)4443 4+11 v1134)43 l*4****V2 . 0000W*.. A . 01*.: ;

24 4)S244q 44$ 444 1+ V V $14 ) [ H ] V H- H H- H - ' - W e V I W

-

1 I Y V V e V V w N-

1-We I*. - ¥ .. *.)........ . ...2.2 ..

42. $333/434,:,,$ 133*4V,¥:) *; *.~~-W-~;.;2.40-¥' ..... *......y-' .........

238 .4$$V34H14,4 * $ +H ;… ......... .. . . . . . 22??........290 44433144444.V · _i6* +* . -- 44413 _ -- ***...40400 WWI 0**- . . ..... 2....?

292 414$) 1.444$4[[*+$[15.) ~I- *e6--- 0 " W-"W/..//6e . ... 2? .2.)4222,43? .4444S1I.1:44443445133334)4-- ).o44)1)e .....-6V)0.....4364 44 I8_ 44 44$V))$24'I}$$- H)-4)) * . - AH V

eW - ·...........*

503 2 4 '$++-VV · I-W I*1)__ ..... H-... ...- ... 2W:._:. 222

298 44? 4 V4' $$Z*"$Hl H - [·-e341414)) * * 4/4///4*·...-- .. *277*7222424 $/$4H"""44,442*"I-I$*-1-1 / / / / / / * " " -e4 ........ ::-..A W W' .2,22'02 Z2$4.++4..1444 Z4//HH)4-~-H e H--e*--.e-/H0 - / ...... W..--..*..v

40,4345ll.l II44333,4+.44441 444 )*****33W.*,V W..*0,*0)00.0.02.

4~0b 4)4+,8444[.4 $3Z,] 1/ )H - ... ............. 2..22.

444 4)$],44[$44·,$33 l-4/-*m1441 - V ~ - ¥ H H e l) - H · =.... ... /....... .... .

304 4)34 [, +)4,.44.'/3* f},+* H-4443 W-1 - - H1 + + * V / I H IH1 . ... Wll-l[eH- -k*-IiiIe*.

402 41)644444 H¥+)4/- ] W H-

- - - /.............. 23/- …..2

A04*3[4,- / ... W 3 3...........*0W4V0...2227222

426 * 3) 8444s 33423)313*444111484414.)~49*4*3//..../ .H-. A ....... . .222 22

321 441- I.I+]4031Uv/ V - I ) ) + ) *,.*** v V V · ' e ' w V0 - w ' / ..... 322.4-2 ............ ..2

434 4 /.*4344441+142333¥/0-4 0.4*..-- 005- 22??Ill $)4GV/$/ZZ4 )ZZ)Z,/ / 11[··)+) *I 4*.....-..ee]VV)*-VI-4W 2......2- .

43~6 $*4144 233Z4 5 ) ~ 14 5330144)$ 1146. l $ 1 + ) )) · ·4*44 … 4340000 I' · - ' - ** ' ' V W V " I '2222222

43~ 42*1343/23*34 33)30)6344)3141)) })

*4. *2. 00I0*e/H =.WI .... * 3222 ....22.....'

42421*1414)4433) 444jV*4.) 44344)81)-3 1)1.. ....* 4- .0.l*....28~ ~ ~ ~ ~~~~~•+ 'l- 444-*··.. . . VI = ....

44? ) 13)44433343,31.3 ....544434..41*0V … ) 22 ??32.2.43........ "" 2...! ,.. .......8............... ?22..

114 , -4-14*14) /W// 4 l0 v$$*W$I"$VV $ .)*AI,)-*I-' .* 2.2VIV2-w2....4 4? V/HWW)H/H · ')**1-4114' .*- I 3 .. ..-...... ... ...? 2.222

6144 I*4414413, 44)-S-1)113-0l 1111 ).)I**W-!**- :;2* . . -.;v?2??2?

444 -33424)3343-4 .................... 2 2222

446 /*4/,3133..*0+*1V 435-41 I0*+0 3jj)}4,~/~jl e.... ==iV.= ........ ........ 3??? ...22

440 40//)/IZ.4.4V V S $ 1 " V I t$)

) )}

)} W -' · - H ·W V40 . ........ 2 ??

145 W4.]/-403 ¥*4) .... .... = - V= '''f*' **'.''2? 2 '2'?3?, ''224))4.3.......W.. *42)0)0....WI.·.'.. 2 2.22?2.) ... 2.?2

434 4'.43$3/)4-0)*{ 0*H9* 3- ' v. . ...)4 .. e.-oo.?.?2.2222..2.7.2

.0 ...... 6 1433 I.II.//I44' $ $ V 4$ 4 $ } $ ) 4 * )- H ' + v ' e'.

Il4 444144)4444444 3*3-)I 80)0}$))+*-H ... ?.. 4 2 22***2.?2222?})

W=='·*-·........7

{74 441)40 4343) 44)~IV~4*I//*3 -W-WV)} 3')I&

4S $

-U*) ) ) + +

*+ e

*[ e H H W - ' I W V .. .....V=W-iIee-i...?2 .2 e ....l/...

4401143)4331443 .A.---/3$*0 /H~_hlH¥))4) $ .)}$)1}*+++++ -34-WH-I, VVVVVV* ....2 2.'2 22?? ?322? 222?

'.32 318343*114*34)32*4,3331-7/33)~Vll)*tst'1441441 0*0444)4.4))44l- .22...+~.,2 ....... V?2 ....... 2. ...22.2

434, 441 4&& 44+3.3334)2104/pIV '/)**$$)))))I ) + + ' -... . eVV¢V+'VV-- .-. . . . *==..eAeem. .... . . 222222???2222 ......'.2.~?

,00 ~ ~ )*/+W= 823.' 4))$)*334-,.e,-VVVVVVV.343.2. 431*.4.-.-,.V.).4V'..** ...... 22?22202Z?2? .2......~

I)4 431104..443[$V.34 +1413243- " '11V ''

*' VI4I* V. .. W ... vv--.*** .......... ... .?.?2 '

444434143*2,--*)4 . 0344*4S..`I I2.222?2222?? 222222?222'4

434 $ $ ,4,* 4 3*/ 'V' HI*$1 + +_..8%.-*..!=,W.:V-V . ...... ?H H *'2.....222 ...2 ...?? .'2.2222

4 4- I+0)844../411 -WV1WVJ143)}$) I ll ) )} ......-. ?....

404 2)+42313$1444*3444) / / V *,) ) 34$1*4

5 ) $ )4

% ) +

V + * · ' ·

.9... V).)V*V{VVU ..... 2..302?2222?22.

490 -314*11)4114'14A1 )341**4 - 01133)- .. *-404,43---4'. . ... ?2.2.2222?222)2227223222 ?2.. 2

~H~~~ ~ ~~~ I$$q½eZ·+++i4)~$i t Ii,+·++ .. ·--..=+.vVIVV V*ViVV~W ..... W-"·'-W*·''?''? ...... :..... 1.

45? ;411434113 444,*2...-**4:V4..-W.**.... II2V22.............Ml. .....

454 ...1 ZZZZI-I* 4 **)416) )$ A+wV*** v-v V . A)..--* ... ........22?.. 2 2..'

44 ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~~~~~~e ..... VI--V~9 i$,~4,.1I-)*$ 5$$$$ )),+V/"'.ee-vv)V)VVVVV ....... *·,...2.? ::::v: .. ~I I?

494, $$)4I433/114/34/I+Ve$ 41*4414 S~)$4 ),+/. .* _+V V[==V? .......---.--..2*l · V....434 4**33 1143313140***1 4*5,11143lIZZ . . . 2I77 v272

4,o2 411 .... .,,VV VV........,,.,I14411 IVV .. =.W:.... .. ,v¥.. ......... :2:::2::::::::: l...... ....WW--W*............... . ...

I0 )$./ ZZ$)15 II$.,: ~ III + -· ~ vvvvvv .. ,--V+V*=VV- -W ....... I .. 27: :::.:?l?2

"VVV00 2 3 0 C 00 3 =3 3 3-1·,---3 1 3.23.....3... 1 27222222

`I -4k2 -1.1 . 1)q14ZZ/,SW~$)4$- 11$44V)I1)+*·e W*V+VV ==WWW- W ~ e e l H- l

-e l e * e

.. v. . . . . . . . "~

41 +$$}Z/-+IHV)%$$+)+lll: .... +¥ ,vlvllvlV VYVVW]*¥¥¥V.**·e.w.ee***·.H'. * .......... ........... 27

120 11 111 4VV)$+44/-){W+ 1 %$)WV)·{H'e+VV W~VVVV ... e.,,-W-,-.,· -·- .... ·".............. .- : 22

40 j~ 72 1 1II,1 VVV}) ?$W·W))))$ + ' · v/- - ' = * V ¥ W ' ... *··me·~-=/eV. ............ 27772 2'22

42 4 ... VV, ww /+k }}}}${),Hii//HV ]V[{Ze.i ,--i--.-i--i...... ............ 2......722272:2'22

46 133033 33333509 44+$]:*/ZI ~)]1 3 4509 eI 4 5V 04 403VV H 0VV{3IV452 . -41 - e. -- H--5 --9)-- - · e · . 3) . 55 2534 2223344'I ::H!;], wv ~ ~ II~l'ltl'?..... - -

Fgr W18.NSUEHIED CL4A SSIFICATION -- *-/ ....MAP.AFT.ER.TH ......SN E G I 1S2222222EE

411~ ~ ~ ~~42

'42" ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ V wVt11 .... ........... -w-: ........ 2222 222222~

~50+V~)Z/w1i~)$$$Z~ /w~H={w+*~kH~'~i=WW.~....-' .H/"- ............ 222222'22..22

452 ,·~//* )Z··/WH+V~.·eWV-=..*'e·........eV -·e, .. ,*2.22?2?2222

424 *+l)V~I4147zv-]v$.ll$$Z? /H k V / .} +

V

I H- I ' V-

[ ¥ ·*"- " I.... .. f.....el..·* ....2 7 2?2/77.

156 +*+4v//ve,))//w/[lW vVlm-...ee-I......... . . . . . . . I .......2 2 272277'?222~?.2

4258 +$4$1-Z.-+)) !llI+)It$SZ IZ ~-H k Wv V / [- l = ] ~ H ~ ' - - '........ 2 VI.V1- . --....... 7 22? 22222 1 22222122.

4.6 3 +,11447q)/WVV)VW,))$?{_H. --)+.--V- H~VI- H.eH.. #, ................................ 7?2)22222?2.22.

41h 2 *$ )/W}+$SZZ _·iWH~}._j~-H~~e ..- .. . ·.......... .......'Z2222 7.272 22222222?2?2227..

.h )/Il*)W) $ / ?- - - H ) / H V [ Y I H H k · ' H · I

.... W. .2.....2.22? ?2436~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~'2'?22')222I27774772I777I......2222 2

~'° I 4............I.... ...... 247 8 / v*Ww)[ 1 1 + - - $ l * - l

VV

VW II-IE -- .... 3272"2.. :W[V'V '''Z .... 2.140 ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~~222~2~ 22272227222 2/' 2.22

~82 ~ 1 q~/}V$+V I-I* ))+[e ...W [ [ H H m l ' I * . ........... 22272222222;22222 .....4~ /ZI)~)+~kk+$w~$j-'j·¼-W-H'e'''-'*~·· .. 22.722222222222?2?227...2..

2 ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~~W.'*' ....e....? ..2 e..?..2. 722777722777..........2?1211Il~8 /)/$$$$!~V)~)+,W)$){i~VV=e --{ :H-l . N.....·.........··.·...2.22 7

4gO V //$/11;,$*)~$$~WI))t·+))V$$$)Wl~~l.'"vV'-,'-V[:.H·-== .....·:: .....·.,,.-e......2.21.2222222222222222 2.....21'~22~4q $v)$$$~ + v $ ~ + e

') ) ) v - - W - ) = e ' ~= ~ · ' ' · * ·.?.....,..e,. ....2..2)222221 72222 22227 ... 2

Gg /$$$+V¥$+*¥$11e-YH-*? = 7' l ' - · e ... *.J"e**222727 22222272722 ......

41'? .- 4)Iwlj ... 2_2'~~~~~~~~~~~21272722222727227222 ??'.1...7

411 ............. 2222.2l2'72 l'2 l222?2 l722 22?'?2'~?2?:???

Figure 4~~~~~~~~1/- 1 8 . NUEVIE CLASIFCAIN MA-E TESCN MRI.. . .. . . WITH ,2 2,7 2? 2 ~ 22 7 7 15 CLASSES.

HW - 242.~1'l2il2121211 ,2

Page 90: UNSUPERVISED CLASSIFICATION OF REMOTE MULTISPECTRAL ... · i (f t , lt tr-220-1075 april 1972 unsupervised classification of remote multispectral sensing data 172-27204 ic.as c 237s9e

TR-1075NORTHROP SERVICES. INC.

22*01100000001II11V0. V 1V0 I-l-....... ... .....-........ 1oo00 I I .....204 12+1414400000 V0001000000-0 1--oA o01"0 000"0 01O -n-lIA... . NO. ..l 1011Aur llAU I.0200 H I0041- -V,- H H011110 ¥¥66/] AHIAV.-IM-HU-0 oII-.l....J-- ...... W -- U · 'il

... 21 $/.4$602VV.0l00W68l0I0.V.V.... .. . ............270 ,., , 41.VVVV+A110101I10..VV00...0... ..,. ..... .... .......... 1.0.......,t-.1h,...200 WI.........

2Z14 +1.1114 .......I V1.1 1 / 00.IAO-...... .......... Wj1IjjIlA-....06 VVVV-IV[" 1"N2"H H211Y0 61A+6 W. 'WWW v.1141++++00110 ill. IA.--A … ... ......... V I 6WW226 4W40161414 °",11W0A+0W01A10000 ..10411 IV-.-A... ............. ........ .W ..IVI. ....

220 $440 'tttl6W1 e 6 {Vl iVHH HIIHHH1 et-AII.04Ie++VAeOAO e-A e-HIIiee-III... o...-l-We-0010 WKWl! I llA ..

230 t ,14%)4411 Il ,.oOtIIA 000IOIOA...+.+A--...-l 0 VIA A:.

&232 10/$·0$'.14I))V+VIVIOIIW-HII {0I1100 IWI0VA +I+eie-Wle-e,,··ll. A. A...*..·..A...,met N 0 I/W -'o,-

23. 112...... .A14MI4AI.I0...... ... ... t .....I...,AV .................. . ..-...- I.Vhllt.......IL6 S/$$)$S4$414$[+11222IIIIH H l lHH*M W--III#0........- H W IH-

0 S,460 .,4 IVOAWI IV WIA" ...... ..... ........ . ......................N 262 Il."'1'4'V.6A44011011,011'.2001000+I-1100 OOII 1 '{.....0A.iAA.vm.- . ...... A

?42 I4+$$4/4A400A+144 000100]} $+*¥)H IW-V*eM 001 H¥o/WV¥/ZI·i.A. 2....·.H....Il .... 0A-!!!*110H.2. .. I

24 . .................-.. ...........

2.0...................................... {}-...121.. A*.A..*I I.......................I II…l....

2246 -4VZ/)4l$)¥+IHHHHH4[IVIV¥_-H-IMw//III-II ... . ·.e- I...!le-.Hl~¥H H..

2540 166444404111 4 101602061i --0 -20- .H--W-/. . AOt.;.lI.2.--

256 l S444,.h ¥¥ ....... . ,.it, mA.0.6 -.... . . , .... .... 10.. Ivf..2..-..'It, 4., .S...,, I,,115$/1/11/VINH.IIt SVI WI....... . .. h. .....N......................240 )1AS"4444440+4Z414122140+10001-0I-0-IA-I-.lI.U..h .......... ….

260 1 ]116////V////064444A6}*)2T 40--/A!IA4--!V--I+HVO-0 . I . -I+ II- -I201 . --- A*I-10A *HT-oI. 0 ,

N 242 6 44 - AA0AW24 11.))41444)1+$$/).*.e l.-eO$i OVV III.HAII¥Iwii -·AIII.-0 ...- llI-M i.H.//A.eI.266 2 1111144)41441VIAVS$A-4101VVII-I .VV AVWIH - II--..H.--IV.II*--I· .- .. ® ...---..- V / .---..-200 li1sv64A$44$$e _ZI¥AtV 0 4I¥·AIIHVV -M.I--IIII,..III-44HI0A~l -///I0-A ®- -.... e.250 S1116646A$$$$4+$41&I101/1110WI-H-AHW-.W-H--II-IIVIII III- ...........------ /

274 111$4644+44/1 402 - -- V/-A - H -- tO- . A eI·..-/IW I2-......-+.· .

228 1 14414'4414. QlAAAII0-I0+041I2-00V0V0-.+I44tI.0

200 1444444444Z44 1 /--- ...... W......... .-....... ./../l. ...... ... ..260 I-4W44,4S41+44-1100I/#001A -.-{OI:II#.--/#/. .......262 $)14$44146$I4V40Z~/I{ - Wv-I--A -l MH-IH -I/ I IA.... ... II-IeI-H......264 A11114144$)$$$42 //+ HH/H MlOA"-M/-/l-// .. I4.102.HAAVI.W .

268 1)61$14$44$S664V//I/IIVWHN H-IW-0 -.A-V II]IVVVVI0 I .{/ HHH¥}}I/I . ./-. ....../ / .e----...270 }$111 415 4+//V.441 ¼111111H[H-H -- HHH·I..WIW]-IYVWV0Vi{.I- I-f. A IAIA. ......+. ..2?2 }))~4~}~*~/{~V~/[HHHV-~VH~ - I I I ~~~~~~i l l /IMV+¥+·VVII¥/HM-~ V$4Z41/~V /M/·//~I#M :~...4....... / / / . . . . · .. i-/HW ·4 ·292 401$$$+44,)4+Z+/IW+4V#HIHHWH.-0I-01---0/-IH H ..-V* V- H.*H4Z.//IV¥. / -II. II..i....-// / .....-- .....2748.... ]W4}44$~HIVyHIHHIHei-'¥HVW.W +..VVWI JIMH~I·*+V I/-.-.· ..... //...-·..W..1..

294 $44~45)44/-1V/46110024611A1 06-01 1+4-..I..0...00W:....H////eA6-l.l.! . .

206 4141 10+144140001061114 601V-.NN-+0001 WIV . 0A* . 800-A--12222290 S44444146441/VV+2VI-j.WI N, .-HI0+lA0I V0I-*I-AA V1v02A II.*~I00fI202A2A2

282 SS,44$S40$4S4·&-VVSV.)VH IM · 11.··..AW-1V0VVVV…A W{WWIl . . --m0-AIIw .... ............ //.11304 1$414$ * V · H H - W {{- W I-4·' . ….......i.//...

286 S$4$$+l4 4[V"-.A4-//-e0e0.+ ."-0-* ... . . .

300 ll 21IVI0A444- I+W1-100061-.+A0-A-4006 l-0 … 11*./.+.*

310 4415 )+.16*)VW44)1 )$)ZvAm2/--IW-00.~+-VWHIHV+VWH-e··~-OAW-0-*.-.e'//eeI---MOW**A·.. -04. AI.-..2.. .

32 ... ..444411,,. ¥11,..I .- .-,v-¥v VW...I . ....... .- .................. ..............

31442I))10116+ 1444 W)-I$1$1HA001+-Ie-HH]H -HV-H{~l0+VVV .. ..**eel0~-W#-M .///////..o.--#W.......321, 41114+8444.VW44442)61 )10W010-0I000 W1-OAIIH+0A.OIII .AI-...

211 /4)4$$.+.$441V+VVz+ Wl$) )$0-0 -0HAH00 H0V- -W ..... V).vH- -I -I-HVWVvlW- WWW-l"///* ...........208 144 AS$*4V44$$¥ 1V44I.S1IIH--· -IYHWH -- V IiWW/WW// / .~...· .. 2. ..

02 42$IU440l+444lIZ//W1]·U.HI--H- ...... llI0000...-I......1.....--... . · ...3024 4$)$,$}{1641 /W--IH-Hll-VH,-Illl ,HH"[0 . -M-0AleeAMe../- - -

-....... *..--

524 164244444444 1014 }H-1- I -- -M- M/ .... ....... .206 41414 $I2 IV4 / -I- I-1H¥-+- ..44l0400WI. . +6 e-14-**/./- +... "

330 1+44442441V4246+0001l04112Il 00+IOOIAl6lAU~++.

33 6442 12V1/.4412/2+ )H2 "H+2-2" I.*/ I H "]+-*IW~ ~ ~~e~//-.+-1- 61 111**040*11= .'.-AIVI-"=

334 644444424224612422+21 44W$00-4Z/-l/H 1H~~H- )/"-~v~ W" ~~////.~*~4H 11.1.1. I.. I 11 0I4-.... ... W..........

336064444441424_ 416011404l11111 l++++ WwIl0A . -':-WOO .

310 1444:V44 .)+44141 [[+lll+W:I IW- I-0 WI.. H1· -.-- ·¥1 ///. ...-+1H ............ l* ;.......:14 V 44l W.I$S ) W W -l I-lO·){+11 [-I- e*I-........... ......

32I ·14144 444. I$VI 4421W-I4+l0-l-.16I++V I]Hl®.ee-A . 0101 H0 H.I///I ....- '-1 .............344 4444W41424I44)04414.?-- [ 1 . .1.1........0 .l..322 40 +&4Z2 $$2[)Z{M001 )*HA-+Il11161 )){+ . . . . +11· .............I-------- .............-..

340 4444242411 41++V$+/VI-+104H/-H·))){)))I}I··+V1 ]¥V¥1·eee1e· 20HV---6,/·/l * - -e...'.....-0+0I 1.1..-.-.352 2444144444411401+21111111 11VV0+IA-00141111114

05 ) 44$244 44/+-+· H414+-· W-/VI . ... A - H ·, . . . . . . . . 1·

356 4444 444-1141V2-411111 IIIl+l.00110141111

330 W~~4~~4++VH$)HWl$l})+)VVVVV{ew - -"W]W~WW~~..H~.......-.

32 ,.444.42z.4441)14+1,..,..21 -v.+0 1 1+,,,, , 2.1,11 6) .............4..-1v0 vvv1,6 w1 .. ........-. ................S00 4421144.4 ..444WVW4- V+),··11W1 .- HI I V1111W-4 ...........

S6 2 $S$24Z44)V*41Z4/Wi1-t/*.I- WI+I}4+V1-1111 . . 11 11)·1W ..........20 4142221444,.4 21/.)-+·_ t)$)4 ) ))_··)+.) . ll0-II0WV··- ....... WIVliYV{V{( kH..... ..040414244 4V14}4 Z 1+0-{V 1H4+11$S))))+)o+)e+. VW.-HW-.. I,010...........326 441444 4114Z+.VVV.$-//I+IW 1146111 II) $ -1+ +. -. 02411[00 .... ·- ........ ... ...... ....342 ½44 $ /4414,24414120V -·0V$11116+11111 . +H .- ·..¥V·/*. - . ............

14 Z14444+-4$-[4[ ...4.eeJZ .... .. ...... . 0. 0....156 1441/Z144',4··2V,1)0- II} 1))$.11 . .- -..... IV IVIV - . ......... · ..... ........

62 -4414447044412201.141111 l +++..+.I.400000.40Il 10-.

106 16114114444$ $$/-}41)$0{SV420$$$+1++. . . 0.e0{4VV01V{1 [{[[1] l,,IW .......... ..........

302 44 /111414144V)V1+.Z/0Sl)l + e./1"1VlV[][" I.. .. .. ...... . . . . . . . . .*6I

3ll l40411144444'+:1112600++lW14161111 111411++4I .I..V1201000 1020101 11.WI.~:.: .........

1 40 +.14144.4$. 4/*1$ IVV+*$O$11{4141-11-1 14.....[{0W.. .I. -430 $1-414444 4122 +-ll_+/_+WW14 14 $$$1 { + '... IvIvv{{ll+Vi0Vl{4vw4`.. ..1. .......... .

132 $1144-4444'I +1[ ....... I V4II V I1.....&1.....4 11444$444 2+v/+$}+"-1...-14VVV{4V"{WV+{W- ..........0.,z.=V........

344I ...414/}!. 1, ......... ¥V4VV VV4V11+ . iIv1oIV ....... ...... = .........-

332 1411444......v..........11411141111+2 . ...

4802 1!111,14444444114222144446104 11+lI . .+llII ..VOIVIOII l---6

441 6+ J111111144 1+/-4411) $1441.W1111S +V....0W .1 6….e .............. = .....

401114442 W20116+14111A44166 . 0000+0+VI-OOloll

12+1114 4404 211201j 010411 1114 1111 . 0+001

~8 {,.4$~4~)//~v+*{~$$$$$}s}+v~[-~~- -V~v~vvvvv~v~w~-w--~...~...~... I...... ......-V

42 44)+++*"4V11i".-- .:... _411111 . 24v.::-V V.1~~VoV~~W~fIVVI ........ ...... =......

416 +144 -4121241+4II${W{1*-+· [ . V Vl .-- i-lo I.. ..- ii;. . ... V ....

420 )$$$$,+Z62-ll 0+$ 5 4$1111111- "1 · '- · ' - · - - *I ...............422 00011 1011}-2.l,,,-· IV,+ 1-.1 ............... .000 ......

420 $S)06141/2,/V+,S+$)/ .... ._.4340614411'121 4 1$14 S// $ $1+I - I+. - ........- .......... ... ...416P ;)1G11144-Zj-)j$ $$$.) ${4{+4-.VvVV4211VvV{" .1I+I.... ......~06 +I}-44ZZZ)1/VI$*1-44~4$))++--I-#VVI+V{{WWW ....44Si .- ...._...· ..... I ...

40R S$1+·)·o4+VIVWilI - ....ew.-,--- ....... .. ..............+40 S+Il+12212?0+/-0$1$111)$4 )"...-.· ............ . ...... .

442 4+11444266010-j4+A1142U1+-10++1++0

444 +I++l+24 22-62114161116111 *}I-+/ZIZ/W*-$W$4 [ $4}$ 0$1)$)V)I·+/,.·-{Vk··VV·VV4V I[,:HH114-44.*. .= V ...

0+6 0V+*$2$20?2 Z,/I)/I12242-I)S))+ *w/-.,-+vvI1vvv vvv VVV1III110221**Iv.4 ..... lee*.e0-- . . . . . . .................….410 . $14-1424IH1+·0o-+1V+1V ;o.-·..,-.-.l+.-- I ... .. .

452 +l++112421+l 1+/11 IA).2/{W[- + . 10114H-/HV /HVWV............ ...............

452 6++14 4-21?04++VW )% 112214-21t:.+00:10010..I I-V .40 .+1441-210+111W l1Wl2!I.2IlV0-I++VI+4I .

440 V..141.40+01"11,- 000l-1-00IV. II .v

'4. +$)&7/WVW)} $ )~v)+.)./H-...W- vVHVHV II V]VWe.-e*---~"" e ........ =.....420 )V $/ Z/ {+ ){}{ l$ ) -- . V[V~Vl][{VV{~. . * ~ ~ ~~ ~ ........- ==........

vv )~~ZZ/~~))+~S&)+/~--HkV]VV1[/eeee--e-We"- '...i=..........

42' +++164412r8- V )....040-+ -H---.....3 ............4lb S)))$ZZ/ )*}~{4Z/ ~*HWH ~ee ~+] {H* ~ ~ e -- ~ .... e~e.... .. ........... ......

64 V'[*/ Z W *V }{ {+* H ~V { ~~ {V ~ ~H H ' . ' - k * * '` ~' .= ........VW

424 -1l114 W++11+W0!16 I44 V11~~I~0l 20001I0021 0+004VV0+VV+

430 ]))Z/I+¥S)$/}+---VVV .......·- ..... :...iiilI-Il.1.1. ............. 2.

464 +V11V422$ 11412$121 1,1-S)42124 … 110¥- .... 1141 +-.. [ -+............;...- - ......... .............=....

43 ... ,/...$,, ,./,++. ... . wI,'I~.-.V.................:,::::::::::::.

4 .2 1 1 V+1)+}/1/2 H11 +.......1 .... . ........ ...................

426 V-)$4 4$/-{6})V. 1-/ H · /-[- ..................

444 *+ $~ )W )*Wt}Z-IHk} V--- --~-HH W__*I-Ie* .......=3 .....i ....... ..........~ +)))Z/{/leVI}WV) Z *-e- -HW)*/-HVI -------- eHIH.-I w tt ........:.== ............. ql=.. . . . ,:

Vh }{)I)IV+$Z$--]-r·-·YVIWH-H··H- ·............ == ............. ;

420 622442V+4j] +41+42/H. 0] --H.....· ..

4542 W$ZZ/I~ZHI/[~I++*HH+VHH~'"~I·, ... ".*- .. '............., 456 )~)-V4/1I.$S+{VVW-W$ +·-H. vvH ,--H --............ ....... a..............1-

400 V2)%41122112+4I 102+16.)000I0+

404 22. +01 W) V1/)I - -I.'2+ //[NII … - ..

-4~ Z/])*}VZ.d-W$~*,l-eHHk-~-Hee...e-..=Ie .....-- ............. . . . . . . . ::

436 22//+}1*+{¥$$.J*I$}·¥1 +0W1}2H+W1.0W¥[H-.HH/--I[16 . .

~<,ozZ$/$~)~4~$4 })$*I)Vt$11*,-+W~lW,--W~kW.....*.....,.....·........ ............ . . . . . =4.20 121046144+211++OOll++0 4+-I492 $ /$$$ ~ V+~ +4 )q) -,¼-IW,~{{,· .. ,.......,I.·.. .....................42101114116044++W+1.1.+v-- 1141 .......- VI.11

~q ]/:$ ~$+V V)~ **V S% },*-I4- ,·.Vl]W . ,-.. -.... *.. .,·...- ........... ·..........4. , ,41 )/$$ $ $ ] l $)V $ I %1~, -I-{. .Vlw Il i.· , .............. ,. . .... =... ... V 1........... ..... .. . :~404 I 0.161+40214++ 011.1.-....-..6I

4'.2 41216006411414II1611104...I..0 . 2

~'~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~~.. ~*{$,~~}*+)~$$)],v,.,Wlb-W ....-........... ,........·.................... .=..410 4+,1016',6116610+I.+1l+4+0611 lll+2122]2tililil~ii441116o .1

40C 11'),,'U2)O0021 0UU00.)03 000 CC0'00204J000002C00 1111111l2l11l llll2[Itlll1tllltttltltlt 17272'2 2

l,527135?01357q3 52357q 13 5 q)%7q %?q357q3573349153357ql 57q 07q 29q 357q 3q~ 579 157q357q1 031705$37ql191]510!

Figure 4-19.UNSUPERVISED CLASSIFICATION MAP AFTER THE THIRD MERGING WITH 14 CLASSES

4-25

Page 91: UNSUPERVISED CLASSIFICATION OF REMOTE MULTISPECTRAL ... · i (f t , lt tr-220-1075 april 1972 unsupervised classification of remote multispectral sensing data 172-27204 ic.as c 237s9e

NORTHROP SERVICES. INC. TR-1075

$ AMP L f ' lR0000000000034000GGOO o70'OOCOOOOO OOOOQOOO OOO Ok 0 00 09IlIIktIk Ill littit Iktttttkkt ti ilt22 ZZOIOOO3313Z1,22Z423333340004455550063,6 777T7i'i'k449"IQO4 I' 01 .jif2Z21 . ;jl .v~l~l.S i5l~6ll18l~177 ~leillgliilt

1357913577357 715 31 l 135 913t7913S79 35?7413579 1571ql

4200 4/ v.63.4VIII+VII- W ---Iv . .......WIVV iI+ I-- -,- .I...8-Ill W I I We-o..S0 00617oU+wvst$V vI*,V'i---wlliIkI--vw0-iv+*.4V4.01-,VeI l--e.e. .*..1.433-88J68 118i..? 4.lI... .1!:VIVV 1::.Il vIeI lve.HH -IIW~~kkIIIIII~i..

204 Z/*.)04 I I[VVVVI*V-¥I-'--0- … ... V32I*IIVVIV.-..8k..... . .88,8Wlikb84l1b¥¥¥--.C, 203, 0V~$C.1 I$$IVtlV][V*I18 … VIVV8VI!....]3-V~)~V i*,V1[iW.-WWII.*. . *...!!eet.. . .....8-

204 )~SS}104666 *+V4040 VklV4-I- I---v.)I I**+W88V**+*V88-W-M.-. .*....·,.-··...W-Ij WWWWW! i lt ---..2LO )W6 +$S 1 4163864+·Vl v,. Z VWV*I -38 -l VV8l IW-WV+**V I VV*VV---2 8-V-,e. . ....el 8.li.e . . . ..... 8---26 IIk 141111222,I~o~l031--63,vI~3-8o …. 816, I{. .WV-1IW3IlI It ....A 0 2t2 4/k$$ 11468644V3. … ---{--I-.II.II{WV V.v..W-I---.--......... ....-.. II lIl …III-

2?3812 80618l10VVI8-,W-8418Vl 81340V83828V82IiI II6--274 84VI*$I.3 30$14+V630.V --- I¥---Ii4 *VIVIk e¥+V/ . 3-WI#--'. ...* etI...t.l.. *.*..'-WW[ 1141116----226............ 41V12148610.V48--6,kkV.8..28..IvY.vI~~k8-......../..................

22v04.600048 36616361343,kv~i! … 8k0,336vv8.--2 .. . ....... .. II. UO 84110-1622 -23i ... I'll.·e..-v---1 .l-Il .IIIvVIwwww-.-23? //[4,45 ,4+ ,vS,.....1..-WW.I. $+SIIWIVHW-',... -.. ....43 ) 38/I6041s$44v45++,It+-v-vWIvk/I v/. .. .... · . . I.I......-.- I lI 22; 381 V606$4/ 44222+2 -IVI W::W2--W VI… IW VV./. ... ..... .....--...... I- IliVW.....'·.

228 I 336641111022,44203 W--l,. V. .I, 1 vV.,w..240I141600. 1623)1.14*1 Ivvl-- .v .SVV .!. .. 8.1 40.2-.*

258 3 43 0 W.2k8IWW2---.4iVI … ... ......I.......... . .2..... I ........ .. …

25 6 t44V)Z)/*lS761$+1I)+W*{VWW...W*$IIIIV--IW#/II3·3I......---V -~ . . .(W. !lI- . .*.UI -*.VI V2----

2~8 ~$e$~&$IW)$S)$)$II·I·V¥1II ....~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~,IW...I?34. IS4000440) 00 34k601813 WWW)*)$V8i-8-/… I .-/ ....... .. 8· .... I-.242 $4556////{) 421·)·14*{11? IWIW--VV}WI.$W-...../I..---...... W,,:':

270 2 43 )$$4IfI4S ///V1-[---{ -+I{I -IVe[*6+ + eWIiWee/W/·e/.i-WW ..-. .. 1 8 -- ......

2 242 II 11664040 1111111--1-4·$V VIW/e- .eleo-/-W/--.*0143i,.,-I·,IIIe-,41 W. I234 )$11$454$ 14 / /. V3 I VV-I-- . 4 4 8vW/I.W ...... v i-/ - -W . ....… . iv ....................

·.v 4141)) 4)I 04.... 144WII--,.I--/IW. IvvII .... i-WVI/'·e-o.r22 6 1414 4115441)-$ $6$-1WlVl…V IW.W- .IIvI-uI --... … l.. 2.. W.", .............2*4 61144$ / *4,100133.3-.v….V1......./Iv. vk ..... ....... 2 / -- ..

260 13 4444340434111001630V 1 443l8 … v3V1304V14-- .

2a 4 )$$V%4 40$4554)[ WVI , ..*.……....V...J0/ ..- I Ii..-W.252 } S 4S4"4 ... 4434- 3/W3I $· W-)--V- '- V2-IWW8-;vvvvv2-1........... -I/..6..............

210 } S t$..6444+0Z$4.4086II13&/V$' … …I+. V {---¥-#W/e-I#e l ..lllll2-/IW{8.84-!iiII-I, ill .. ~4 ·,!W{i33/.....,3

36 0$441064340441VI$4$I -tWI…..V/W-- W4-- ---- W. ... 0.t..e4e·11- W I/e·.[--- I-.3...

0500 34~47466604+$40324$Z 1134 …838W/W' … I-{W -l-Il --e.veW--el … II4I' 0ll"/ / l/'Wkll3lel--I ......---- { 222W-3,II.I.,302 } $$404.3I~4003447.22./3I … 8---V. … -...12 .WI'-[ ... 3.e·-e 08-...kWWe·-I ..-... 2.I- [ -{-W/i,.i.3-..i

2404 3 36III4$ I / I /----....eIW[I-$ … … … W-..1 ./.. I.e .- .o

268 ))I1$S414544$4Vq4////J{V-W--W--- IW .-... e-W{lIJVVV{]TII/I:---W-V})//WWIW/I-eW/·/ ........ W/.,//.. I .;I ' W'

703 030,$$4$$10404$$ 331//33 … 3{ -- i.-W~8V-- -*e. .l4W- ~vllW-. l// V"/Z-1"8../Wl.~ .34...--I.

303 1 1$4S0441474$20/$V-/8---wV-/"4*{[//I..... /// ......-

310) 0063,04$4.++Z)/ws$*2v {-w-{-+ - ...-. ,. II-iI-i]/ -{IV+VJV. . /.I*o~wm+ I//i*..22ii..i///.-it.I, .

i?0 $4'0.03~ S2S34.4/I W8 -7"14-,3--...--,,- ..-Ve-¥ . . .{I*V ~ II/e t . ..........

430 $4)04430$6$+~$$-VV32- )V- )W-3-43-.--e-I-.3{W32 VV~ IW I --- '"-{ 3 48~e II.28V3.42......///.*I. W*I.,3104431$ $,.7& 300452$+ ) } [v$ ) · -3 … v-.----. {--i-k¼VlW-W .¥+VVJ1-W{Wl--V{i - .8.2 . - . .3....·, 3/* -- l/ .I.

2}10$ 40301, I0.6V40 V ) }4 ) + - ¥·V-·, .... W.-V3-63,*]- ¥VV-IVWI--·ili.·iI l-- . ... ·/l.il e ·ill-i .... 2. *.......

02d0 $4}*}04414}V*4.4}k)$$)23~IVNl-/-3 12-f"We 3W~VW[ I.... 0I3I8.*.. V. . U--*V

022 403tI4$$)+ 441$V{+$V1}6 {-0 " {W-v "V-=*v/*-81V-/e.e~{--e.~/~/.---"-"..333 3'0-1,II.....-2.....8.4282.,33

324 34*41046$443313 8$4VWWV{-~V--..-3,.33"V 0 "-4033330I84.....*2. .. .......I .. 4020 344 4$44430 14,20I-0}WW-2.-33 III...V00V .. . .W-3--l--/ /..... ..373 ~440415+ 440S +4 $ 370v28 ---28-IVWW .....# -I 0i03)VW. . . WV8.I/I I .....--. . ..-..~...III SS%44031371403343V422I3 -..w3/-.4,63.36/33/34 / / / / / e.0/. . ..... ........ WfI3 1..............

30~ ZZ$44404034.633444)4Z./W31-0---W-"313.333,,WW13.-e-e{~ ~el.e*81 . ~ k~l~~//`.~-3W3, -00 .3...H}H

336 6004!4044 4436,,42Z1)j11W83,4436333433.4 4Ivvll8I . k01 13333

340043441 -V$11VIW/ / 313333-33433-- 8648--.... . - -.. e//I/.,..--· ....... ... 1

I 41$ II4 64,00.732-4360.61313633333343433.32-6/8-2.I/ / / 4040 . . .........240 + $44243*2·.+443, 00143W-34333 I6/-616163 W-e--VI .·v -I....-........33033

3, 7444*VI~ 404404 13.Z I W-30-ky36331466333V } +-II·-1V--.e--lW.·3k W ·/·.4..4*.I-·.3..-1ii1313 2.0..3....3....23

12404 44w4* / " + V {.-'wWW3-W-.3///3 3.. 840k033 1. .-.-- ......

2I4 1445S. V Z/WV -- /%))+)})J+'I VVV- V--·-·, ·.-_I'...VWV[1W~l(WI./o..e- ...... ~H

3',$400340,44/3$+Z+ZV/$+-111 5113 )3 +·3..4 ¥V4V03/i·~·-..334033303333333303 . . .... 0.........302 $33).4/ 0041,0,73/ ... 01,4444141 634-3613 .{V0. .4l0-0003331* 1-..1 . ..363 08 ....... . .I-. - -

33, 34107736444004.,31) 7444608----14W.-I:. 34434+4[.. . . . " IVV{I {V4[3I48 ,·...-·· .. ....... .. ...I4 $$$/.'4.44_)v4W*/2.///w3$3334661363 ... 3W 44j./k 30033031 -....... ·... 3.......... . . H .....

33. 4'.V34444,/4114,,V2II -.-./34 I 3I3W34W6313 3,4,4W{-.3.-:. . 1 T ...... ·. 'I::' 3.............

31 404b 00,./4/3/4V0 $/01W*,$))II*·)*)I- 33-{'. . . . ,vv+v3w 331-/ 3613.444.2.- ........... 34003. 33381.3.......k334034404.l*/.+v?/-$v$$)$))+)))/W-----..e-4vv3V1{3"4-/---*-" 3433334,.3. .00....h0H3303 3.3.....p.H

&43,444. 04/,'4 4233-$.33-4)34 3/3{ 33333303,,,,·,. V--·k-- ...0llV{I tI-'. ....... . . .·7,00041 30.-.. . 3..~ 33. .33143

3.30 414016'.444302 3..-..o4 3344 6313,613303 . ........... W.... .

'3434604,/3,7374-3. /. V 31403133433 6334,4-433.I-.. iII4I40{0040 .i. . ..------- . -.... . .� ......... .,

302 41 I 330448037.4., 31W-1411111'6W 34,82....V04430000k333 . ...W.'

404 33 W/414.. ;4432 '.v* /4)" ) . .4 'VtvI.***-..-.v.......-0 {v 3 W3 V.... -: ..... I............I--,I.

M& 41? J,/,G~~$,./-W- -vJ* })5 ) t IvW )+**I-I-..-+VlIIVVV IIVJ-..e...Vph -- I .... It.~,

8 .144'. 44/3$ 1Z / - .-/- 1)I$.1)/-, .6I ~VVVI2 ... ... ............00H. .... HI.HH. ,I4.0004047444734)3$32/-4 -4V4V44030I4)III44163 ·113 . *.404- ............ …. . .. .... ......33 .H

00, 314400333334 W04MI446! I3 I .. 004IV 3433 -W….

403 S33614041S1134I2 3/31...41 ......3+*....... I3V1 1I4IW[.V{3........... ............ l.....*3'}4414 $4 114 +4w ww7 I 2 )1 340WW 3 1 )1131443 } 1 v--..-V vIw·,-+ +V0 V , v I I .. . . .

430 0.111 $$43qqZZ,/-VW-}. $ q4646634) $) ))$ +**·W- I- ·W'$V} VIVIVV ~-·.243004083...3e.... . 33.......3,I'

42047463031233.413 ll IS1I34733 ...oo wvI vvI III ... .4.33401

~H )~$'.4~~/*.-+V }) q$ $ $$ ))~ I+·+ -·. ·-'V ·¥+IVVVV¥ {-.W. ~W-.-.-·o ' ..... ..... ;............... ~1

47o 0$/443303104,4 331 3 ..3311140,34402 . 0004840,01 8..*.. . ............

020 4,3133443,3?II3).337.3W36 IV34,34 -.. 0-.4046040-080030.....'4,3, ·.'33H,$410 .3 34442?373216-$&6.140443644$.44183033 342 .. .. ....... H}032 1//740`A$4)$$)1+/ 0eI..0 -*VVVV7vVT[8---l/.0*II .. . ... .. H3.

434 }I $36123334/3-31],$$*$}}}+-··.·t MV VVWI ~~k~...o·.·,·'.···. ,..... . . .I.......· ,43tDHIHh4 *

II I ) )1*44/44 -14III) ....1l . . .......... , ......... 4+.3dtDH

400 7433.373230041033131814303 044U4·.3..0-...........p ,...... 0

410 44,,,4 3/3l-$Vq+)$411~·I/I-{/3¥3VW7186]{33 62333 .-... **·3440-···....-. .· 2.-. ....3. .3.3.14.302'.D3$H ,

403,. ~l~l4-/~WV11...4..3I-*$- -sv33 /*-Vw3 … 04. 2l -.~ ~ ..*. .3..32'03'3 .........443 ,7 41814444-1V/ 633S 43360 … 034,033 .¥ I, *· o ....- .. 3.3.. . . . . . . . I*H0 IHH};4506 V·)$$433.- *)W16 - 12-114IIII- / W.. .. ... 3...........

~18 V·*$S$$~//Z+/ /{k~4$1~ } $$}$~*)_IW/-I'·kVVI[VVV{IVVVIVVVI···I·.'*.·.'.,1`--/'·... ' ......, HHHH

442414312 1 36// [ $1)4I--44'[ ... VV {3 ....... VI3 .-. - · ....I·I·vv· 3'3 3 v.,;............

440 44 .). a / .. . J ) ] $ -$ -3V-tJ ++ -eV-V l VI ......- l3- I-[I. ....... 4. V-fillH("

050 +7 //).S1)}.6+)04"6-3~WV~W~m[/--eW-0336333-24-3---0 2-. 3…..3240'31..3.H00HH.03 -HHH

040,4 $$$$ 34710,731/23/-V+I }$ $ 2q-,-0.-/--·&W·-[ '[VI[i·.··,.*"·/....W0.e3… .l..'22003.00334.3..3.3.HHHHD3q'M40+ 4464 }]}$$///. 4/-)$+W l))} .0*4 }t}}/.W-4{33 ~{W[W- l*~ ~ / ~~....*,·…·...I'323383,032,383...,HI' 3H2I+0400 *~~//W+V 4I)3}3I73ZZW-Je64 l/… --WVWIWVVe----.IOe'elledl.lI'.III,2313,'".3.3340032.I33...HH 1-HHHI4D3

4& +))+ 7 /W+VV) $2I/++ .. V j Well- J .VkI--t.' eoee Ie eVVlell ellveIelel Ie H TH HH~

043, 336331401433 342., 3143763-4--I[ * --I I4-6+* 400403…..0-- ''".".·I1i1' 1.'03333.3 '3,0320.3m 3.31313.03'03I.33313230334. +4]1231)81/4//.23-[{%$)$Zt"/-3004{*.V.3,4/.4.-0…4.....32.3'2.3243.43/33l.03.3031-k3,3,33.3.33,.~4430 vI }vI 1z zq/-.I+ Iwv$$) }$ --7 II-v .-- ·WV++VI ....... e W[. .I.·.l, ' 2303,I2l20.33.333.3. II{· o -,· ·3I·II *3HHH i,

40? 361)0}3424"]V033j~$IZ6z7/W-]3{4 Vk"~~~k[W34....4~/~- . ...... 3003'432.-.03...H004H}+HHH.HHHHH.33 H43* + 4 34433 + $}~JZZ~W-I-eVJI*I'[V ]k..v243, I I' .3 4-.1. 31. 4.0--.. . II.1 .. 0...I * * * H * 2337003303433'4304.3'3.I. H433, 43*2)4324/V-IV${430)$)$;<'-,-/-¼V/VI*V[... . ·--43{ 3 … - '· ....'. ...... "'.303.40.43'3204''· ,333,.043...HH*HHHH.~H~40,7 +4k2 33 I,¥~//¥+·¥ ) )DS? I--2311333 … -0VyI-e1-iI-w· ,·-.... .... .. .028.33.3,0....· ........ 0H}$H .HH 23HHH} 3.442 44.43 3$-ll·ISZZk/I-V'-h**~~*-*..714,-.2.'.,* 3. I.-31. ..... H ..3.v3,3-.2143.3.3.3,,.3,3-...2*0HH3~***HH

4 77. 4 +++J}4)/dV),WV)}SJ-4 / -W-V}+/ 33 … 40vJ--3- . i-.'..-Ii ..... ...3 .... . .... H

4733, ) /Z)/ +) V)~q[ -33. . . .W3461. ) +--- Im'1 33v3 {.-I-w7--4 2-3 330 . . l.....3....3,0I.· .3t, H33HI$HJ+HHH .HHH 3HHH4.H3.3 hH,

'.)3 $7 )GI I33616'18 3334.* IS 06Z1-6--I)3 IfVV]J---II-lI..0. 3. ~......3..H* . H 30233'.3,'HHH.3H}HH}DH$H.H.H3333,.,'3 02616 44,73407 <$)34/))Z$J$ZZt*/ -..eV$1--)VVVV-V I WI W·W--- .3 ..3...3.323.i I3H..HIH.HH H 3HHHH 3k3DHHI.HH3 Ht3 H.

0.34 )/,I 4111 4 ,- ' .6131{- ·-I . ..... .'. HHI

z9433101~,/4444)'. V ·WV/ /I6'441 "I ....- W-.-,V.-% . . . ....... .. -. .....HH 333343.3

'IO :::,S/ )I I_$4] IV-' $$ -' ..-- ,I-'''. · ... *·..H.·... H. VHHH}~hH~dDH~~}~ . ·.IT

-'334'4.4I.SS663I44 344613 3,/I.¥$/...323'13+l·--I,3.....--.4.,4, * .......... 3.3Z[4,{)- *Z[,,k., /.-j,...3)-4II-I,34333:03330..,:13 .333'--,03'.. .....333311.33333333317333333311133331........*

1% , -11S3 131222213 /. /1444'.0.44$} I 43'I. .0 4-W{-WI W3/·-{ , .....· ....)',0*J{ 03e I I 24 4 ,3,.+f.3333033l3343H}{Ho3,flfo...*

'HA ZZ,4 4/$$$/~V ~1*~$$*)I·+¥IW-- -*......·...... . . I·. .. H .~HH~tD~k HHN} . .. p

-'~o / / $/. $$ }~$G,.$$wl ~vVV1 IIJI *,))v % })w*-* w 11 ·-w I~ .....·.....,o · · · · ·................. .~ HH }~~}~ H H. .. .. ).

OA 44 /* IS "I ...~~i ~~**}¢$}]i**iI-l··II w.I ·,·........W_ -v V. ill ·*. ,. } VIkP H~I}.II~ p....

Figure 4-20.UNSUPERVISED CLASSIFICATION MAP AFTER THE FOURTH MERGING WITH 13 CLASSES

4-26

Page 92: UNSUPERVISED CLASSIFICATION OF REMOTE MULTISPECTRAL ... · i (f t , lt tr-220-1075 april 1972 unsupervised classification of remote multispectral sensing data 172-27204 ic.as c 237s9e

T-1075NORTHROP SERVICES. INC. TR

SAMPLE UNG TM -R' OODOOOCOOCOOOOO400000000OOCOGOOCOOUOOOOoOOOOVOQUU0O0OVlII l 'Il'~~II1111111111 IIIIIIIO ZN 2200 0000111112-222333314-4 &S55556 l666 V777TB8 77 8 .1 1121 13 &02 .131,+03I 81 ... I......15 7 V......tl, 57 ... 7... . 3111111 5791t111l

$ 06 4/vs4413 VlillVlVAiV ...Iv ........ IlVVM3*/lVM Nll-....o,...-e®l ... M.l--- il II V I-ao 0....135...... ', 3 0 ....... ,-.-8M9 I ..... . -. I. *... ...1..II ..lII 1193V7....

102 I-/+$1l}l[11VVVIlVIVUII-11-Vy3-IAI1VV--'-I...-. . .. 1 I tTI8o'. .--.. .I eUVY¥+¥[8-A- 1--V l-----***.oV,, /if V .. . .e II¥e.

12 4l+.1161IMU+ ~--- -i-i:: IV. I V1 W.VM . . .. JI I140, 4V1 1131.1.4 V..V U... ........ V..--VI ....*.**.*.. .............. ltlh , .106 II*S455111V·VIV*IVIV¥-V--VII--V-IV¥1 1 .V...V·*IVVl-------.....

A210 114I014144 IIIU VMUVI JIU Tl.. ... .. . IIIIIo, ....... I V UII11 .. / ...... ........ …

A IIIUTBIIU134IIMIII+V*V .. .. t,;-t I........ -. ........... t ......

ol 1)4./ ssI$$4S)4+.4*11 - -I--l- I.......3 1 ¥ ........... * 11-1 III I-·. .314 $/$$15S44*$4+$*e}V)¥¥¥eIUl--I-V-ZYIIV/ I.. .... UUVUt .VA 14 114116111I1IIV2II1I1-IUT--eUU .. I. 3UUVl ---. I.M . .- ISIVV -- II-,-..-v V

OV I1141,,,,llUIl11---.VI V+IV-.I. .'.-...--,... .... ................... M.,idUIV-.J I-......2401 1114+/4$441$41½1+++I$*---1UlU-- -+TI V*¥¥ /IV II-.IIl.!o...~..… . .~.e. -·--IVUI.IlviI--..e

42 T+4 VYVI 4I3VIIAVINVUVII---1V1V....I......... ..... - v.VV.V.-------...-.-

44 3l144414413V11111N4UV18 )-UM IMIVII.f. 11 . . .- l114.I …-056 IIIVSSAI4IIUIUIVI ... M.VIUUI-iUl .I....II.M.V./vv/!....M.lM........................…

iS 441111444114134l 1 !1: 1, 111 M/IV)I-++U I … . .- *. . I. /

54 1114446443441A114111144Iy 1Mlll .Tl--1-V.. .. .. .

$M114*45+4SA664 $ $]¥}I+144e-¥l¥-l-!+¥l$¥l-l--I--l-/l---1T. *-*ee.M … .~. I.el* . . ... !ei-I YVII .. l..- M.d..

30 II,$1446141I4444~114A6III-I I1- UV -l I . ilI -i.

2 1111,52414141 4AM4 I4U-I- --V.I....tqI V V.-I/ / …I1 ... I ,.I--VIVVl]-.-.

64 +1116444..…11U1I . //-le/--II…Il 11.1... . . . ti, ....®-[tVVV--206 , 3s41s/4414/.+1....ll.l.---.l.-....-...-ooo .. ........210 IS$411141////V6I1U4 4VI¥*I … -I¥ 1-.e// II/-. ..--- IYV¥lITIl[-I-/II./.

270 3111841......--AI- . V/18* UTV/IMVS 4I/II//III . ~ / .

214 ll$1$*4$4$$/////VII////--I.. Al I 0U+U)lVl"//-~*"...-9l- ¥¥¥¥ TUTU,-I/I-..216 Ii $441441 %I //I/SS44 IVU-IW ///I I I UVVUIUII...- I M.II.;IIl .

Ws S ~~~~I¥*tSV+IV-/*-!I I-//--,i.-eei l-! e*-lflVl--I.-I;

7 11 4$4441 / /"I4 / / ¥ -[----…VI-I /,Z-/ ...........- ·.......I.-· .. // .· -.

306 1644444144.44W/Us4IVIAI.'I-IU I … Ul;"i, -83+VUVV .T VIIV:/* /.

2A4 154$444141+$$/4 1l$+41lV … I … U---lU*VVU-I-Io.-V.I*-....-4W,.e4--//I3 .

26 I$$14114444/AVITV$$&IT¥l……-IYlV1-I---.VII*I-I1. .//i-.f.284 ......44$411010 4V11 }1+ -/"-…"//--U/-UU*. .. M.........

190 11141,141A141+44IIIIIIIVTUT ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ e- -///--.V-.I-I-VVIITMI . 3..--·,.2E2 6 1)$ 44%N4$}6VI4W 4*V.l i~l-¥V.l -lVll-·ee/e-I.---111..//II//.I.. ..

294$44411 +411V41+4~$I-l/I~+ … I* / IAeI-e2 .elvellel-ee-eel"l "e"eI. [¥//I/!,-·..-..~

)61 )414115.$$445V$4lI /¥V$$ .... I----".'- I--Ii// ////]//.. ..... Itl200 I)$44}1148 $4$4U tVI/1 … liI-I ~ --. … ...... …N

302 AA1*..,-.**e.-o*.--.-t///.--I . --- *. oov-I …-/./ I. .. I.Io---II ..-. I .. 33638

306 I1l55444l I.445144 4/vIl-l … 11 … Al … -- l---l l...... --/ II/ i - .i-./....

306))63 313 44V44 V:":: 121V II!4--~~V l.~-l*1 … .... 4.

178 &4S4 VA4444+V4./4554IIV$ I-[/- [- / …- I- ..... I ...

910 444411 '14 4 414A 1/Al-.-l I … V.V-..~. l VVV l---I I . 11U3.// .. 0Y.U

1256 4S411 .+44 V .-.l-. U:/..-IV-ee-I-ell. -l....-- I -. iIII·- ....... /../....·I

286 1411411445,1441,$$4 OI/-/--/---- l I-UVI111......./- ......91 $4.&11&003+444454$n$l4I ¥/ ......-- ~!-VII,-+1t![--IIi I-11 //-111 1 1.. Tl-..../I-.-!-I. I-.U*.~o318 164+41 441 14--44~¥/14 1 / V -1[ ----1V/ l[/!i-¥1-Il ....--- /-II[/e·--1 . ..... ..... ..--. //.. ..1 - - 0 ....

320 4.1Sll, I 1V3444313l1321V.1V08-./-VI/-+ .llIA I..I8v l~I . l *I.322 4VS11141A4441lllVVI.--VI"~l3+VV-V+.VI I III-I.I/ .1364

426 41)$464$64 / / +-)--I-111-44 W4A -·--- / I¥ I 0 VVViI..... .- I.../I...---. .. ..926 l1I4A4$94S454l1V3////l- 3 V --- I----11---.I--I IVVVV II.I/- - -- U--Il//.l/-e/e ......920 4))4 $S+/1441 -- V...V - . I..-I-VYVUI . .-.-. l/llllV- II/.-// I..230 1 $444$44V44$$,-+0/-1$V /-'".-1 V"1/"IeI133/V+ VV .V/ l.ll- ...

}1 - . ..... ¥11+II III3IVV++VVUVI-.-. II// 11-I1-- ·394 14$4$4+,4A +64+/1-1-+I. I .... 439?6 14444444I4. 343/_++ /1 .2.333--I 31111311 .I....// //. .,---l .·-.,1.1*1134264~1544+ 44 4S+*/-)1 ¥V -l+ ----- . . . . ..-.Il-1--1- ---V--- ----.II ¥VV/ · ./---o I

14 46.4.44V1....................... J+ +3+11- .......................}1 ..... 3/34 .................. 33....

" M$ $4i 4$-l ¥ -V)-II ---- ·---I/ V¥¥III-.-*III~' ..........///.tI.I.,~

I4 4464 I14414WVIIV,33.1-11 - 1-- 1 III1++1I I---I3....V309A I34

344 44$$44$4,**1+iVV.i . i¥_.__._[__,._eV¥1_,i-v.+¥iV I .........30 * 644.1/.V4414 -*I 3 '[/ .:; II-/ . .346

4286 $4)4}S84~ $4[44/W*I*·VII+ .......... 3311/,N ¥+ V II- I- I -. .- ,, V11111 o ... ..... ..

444 , 4444 4441 ,141_ Il1 I111133311433+*I . 1 VVI IIIIUI0 333

926 ......$it ....4)I})*I~V*V-' ........

35044844460 $$ * 144v + 84H 2$13 -/-I - ~-v-~ ~V+1V1."1113 e//'.e"/3e1--1-~ 3+.+. . .H.H*. 1111110 . 3443 4V$$4$i4444 II$[V0 ["" ""-IVV/""" 1111/33/"3"le+-./-A[/ . ///*--"[--`I .....I ... .

4?4 4I0V844.$4444t VI/- }0[ - ")l* -+"11v3-"3 *[3 V$V .~/-~..0-2"6 -//.1////////4.3 .......Il . . ... ..

~ .~I$$**$4~VV V~·1}$1S[~- "- ... ...IV'-e¥V+~-·./VVI'1-//////.' ...... i..........HH_:

346 845A+ 44441445¥ 1151 I 1 V1 1..1... -1 . .UvI-! /-///// ..... . . . .................3404 1 4 ,V ')111.......... .... .

130 - -4-44144444W +30 14- -Il 12+0111146111+3 13/3*++3 V . / IIV ! ...·. ..----. .............. H."2 41444444..4413 3 - $·-·-II-V- l 311413111 . .......- V-l-" -- -11811-I- · / ...l ...334 3 4414144II*I I WWI/ tI!:..4644 33... … [ -- [-1 3V]---"---I. -0 4-+V-VVUIlo-lI-Il- - · 3403.... . 3.oH3

,303 1 _114444_ 4,M4Il -... 14 331333.. +3+V0UU4UII3 4 0.3.03

130 - ...11V4444V.$.//.1*/- 11+-I- .. .....-.... l

140 4+3111464448../-*1011 .... I- "- . /V-"I ........ //IOV " "II-[IIII ...........- .

&I~)~II$$~$~k/-/Vl/---]-¥]-~---+*I}/--IV.. Il·!,..l.e./Y- .... //..- ...... ........ H*.

304 3+14¥ 14 UA11444 +,l[ - 413[--[-4-e-¥-I*}+· I1 ....- . VVVVIVIII-........ .303 )41/1444$.6/ 3/4/ - /+34 ,,3I6;A1163...."." - .-... h-./l....

lilY 3I441444444.,.e- ....;.. i . ....... 304

332 314 4...44444,3+ I-0+33314414111111,· ...... 4133 ...... H.-4V0 38;.03 .

391 43314414.436 ......446143l,*+/..- 03330U8V1II4.03

I'll I 11¥* $V~/V**V.**1143A08311++ v ¥ 1* - V *

1431 3+3.32 . I

" '

OUV " -

/ ' '

I 11 1 -* ~ ~

I I { ' / / '

'. .. .~. ~.........'36 4114I44 4I.1-4.111$/V_4 4 1 11 .I . 0*¥ VI 1-- ¥-/-VIIIVIII I [[.I ....... .... . V ,HH

40I 1}4. $4, ¥413V/l4l¥ 1¥ - .-/·VVV¥88O·-.I t111I-… / ...4. 34834334840? 313 1444448A644/1,14464411441113,113 . ...++Il003,VVOIOIVI/·-·.....43'. .. 30.3.08...

4104 $...44/4'-]-4$41I-3 14VA11"*1"413111,/.---....... .......406333144~4~44.8.. 1//41~*·114 4 ·*$1+11 8 )*33 ¥VVYVVVVI.-*'.''.-..I·11¥¥ IV¥1--II--- .... 0I4… …I ... .-.-..-...

640.8 333 1 443.4I-3I1+61114411 13,3.. .-V000 V VUVvIlI- III… 1f-I 44...34

413 $1444,,6-0*1/11/*44--~113431 -V Iv....11 . ......--. 000...8I4 _ *444+ 1+/1 1-148 11 111 . 3+*11V¥1-11I-]¥- -- l I...I ¥1-o.·. ..............

:,4143,4431444,44448,,.21 I l0I0.+11114331.,3 ........V .VVOO vIVVVV.v

tq 4 44 _ZVIV.141+/V/~ $$$1)1)))V- -- I-e... ]VVV¥1.1--1 .oI o'''. ..... H. -;.....H..Hm~vllvl!:::":::

I43 3114 4- $4 -'V 1+04+V /)1*-[- " ...... I.VH...... ,V .I0 4041U0.3+11414444/3311-/1 1 13 1111I--I--I1-' ..... 03.IVVV[1- ... .i.e·/ ....... ..........4330 13341314+4+ 3/-35 113$-411$3-4++ *3 . .--. el.I -H-.l.. ..... 0-.....v* 33

4) 083 144.1q0VV ~/- * IV* --- II .11oe-V¥[.¥ 11 V[V IIIII[VI¥1-.*o......*o 3*oHVVkoo 3... 2604.3)34 *V3*3+,/-0$*[[*1·½[-'*Vl8'VI.. .. .·/V [[VIIIo· .... 09080804833HH6

4'033 4,,41101 11314101 1143 )II .... 180 U IV.V.. .I .... 00833380V3

430 3434'. *4.$./ - -/-2-V3113-Il)$l$1.*4+*1*+/11-313."3-3 .V. 0VV*l0VV ~[U*Ie-. 1- " ...... HH ...... }*....'.....49231 104444,.+4333313031314+44/ 4- -V/~*$*+) e--,…. ..VVVV VVVV I ....... ........... 8......... .434 $ 4W-0 /II.-.+*$144441$+ +*+/·-e....e-3 · V-V¥VV¥¥V¥¥.1 . ........ ............ ............. .3434 333114444.4 .31114 4 4 " ::44 2--$ . 2·+* - .- - V¥)VYV¥¥V V1- . . ................. ,...........440 $ 4 / $$-. -$+_4v444 ..... v ....H*.…... .. ..... *H0V4'HH442 +4$44-V / $$+41411441-I),, I--,l../...--H…... . . .. .0 M34803004 4+ -11 43 ...)S 1)1*++ *~- ~-VlI~-~---... .. . . . ............ .......4++EI.H&'i6) I 33..4k~-I+-3 *+*3$0q1s141$ $ }ql*…*19 t3 e'1… II-..VV*V. . . ..VlVl[ I4I3-- .... k................

48 +331311444-+, 1 3 8. 10…'s1… V /V"" ...... 1...... * .. 600....H6A `3

54j .114144.1-1013 I 1341,+.141-2 10-131 … 111. 40348343.00033.

412 ),, 4$462330W.W+ / 4/ 31131.+4 3--)-Il 1 - ~ ~VvVI V ] - .............. V ....................... I

'i' .s " h. *[~* )~ 4S $$. )$ 1i+***/-e.V -* VVIWvV*V V~1[[ - "-- ........- *.......IHF H

41$ v,31441$-$+330+*/3"3V4v8V8-33-V--*"l"*VI . . 803 0 ............. ...44 3,3333432 / ¥+38 t3A11 1 46A 4l $ tl} +,- … ¥ ¥VI1 … 0...../-… 1*...·... . .................. I10 V., 34 433 })$1 )) }/·-V-..--·l..... . . . .........I

4[2 * W....[}..4$j$$j $ )+ + Ie-VVV*V*VVv -~.~"""e~"~/"~""e:e- ~ ..........................

84 -*13}, - /IV---¥11¥**)t$$$$- I$**I..../.. I+¥VV VVlllI I …JyV· ..- .. 8.3..eeele ............... 1HftHHH}30 IV11/ 1 $.10V--341.1411 .. v-...-"-I 1... . .................

423+1 .¥ 4II$ 1 11115)}$$$4}I…I II .I·I-/-·........*l`.0 M-V... . .. H6,

370 1,'t,//v2l- l$$)-+1 1~-e-l . 0.8¥·l l ·o· l .··e /- .... #· .3433'303344..............3.............

432 .....)33+4111* -"[3111$33 * …- -VII- V[". 3...................HII/lltBH33334444 V 3`}}144 1.+*030.2$}} 3)33 . -))*+v-j- I-/VI.+3[[vV" "0-0/"-...................H.

44b ¥+ !)4*~.~/)III)I$5}[I·/-I-V VVV;:-Vc~~- ee*-ee---I/ - e e e l............................. .

344 .,13.3-3T /1+1301-I[I/30 … 0--I-.43.+ . .3 ...3..H98 _.1A33301W1 v.....34 43/11 -l .Vl--+V3 I .... /&i.eleliiii-.HH,3.83,3.834M0 .342 11834 1 14/.$+} }41 / /-.V-..I.[/......+......,. ..0.3 .0 ..

34~ VII l,1111114/-+1 1143, 391114 1-*¥- +·v v... .... .............. .... el .... e.. ,3.IH.HHHH . .

'36 43i)31 464,1143"- 1)~$$k~ -/"-[*V*~ ~ ~ ''~... e e.-"-~.8 3.331. ....0.03438303.14+.3.0.kF [H ~ I

412~ ~ ~ ~~~42

G[2 *)+Jl I/+l} $1k $1/- [ -·Y-e .*-Vl ... IH.·. .... I/e**........1'vH ~*15~ *)~VI$I}%$N~--V-)V ... *VII-,·.*.,...... *l..e...~HH HH~~~

qb $1,". I. i$VV 114 kl/-¥¢l/- ¥V1 I Il ) _W Il ....... .... ....... ~H H* ItH- H.HtlNhH HH I HHi+i

. 47 I)-$1/) I[ lVv1-/$*$/ i· I .-e......IIl ---- e~, ....H....N'HHH HHdHIH"HfHIbHH., -41 w~/ )v })k...iv/...t /-11V -- V-eI-,.......H .... .* tH,-IHH}}HH N~ HV If I,~ e

480 .w/444 SV~S-* Ill+V-~ }I .-I-I I/-{I---- 1 ....·....1..HI~e. .~.HHJH~H~I~HiHI~IHl iWW )V~~~4*l~IV'$t)--¥VV ..I1-'1.... .......... V.. .. NN ~ HHHk~fHiHH , i

,4101 11/,$$P4t4qtVlI)t*llV$~l ' -*Il ---- {11l:; .... ·...........I....i......i. . .IdHHHHHHH~I ...... .

r'; "V ...... '1$1 .15 le-- ~let lle .I..... H.III, · T :H~~F~Hh.H 41R .tJ ${$SJt*J4$IJ 1 - ii ii I, .. , ..... , ...... I~i........ HFf 'FH}HHHH H..I......

Figure 4-21. UNSUPERVISED CLASSIFICATION MAP AFTER THE FIFTH MERGING WITH 12 CLASSES

4-27

Page 93: UNSUPERVISED CLASSIFICATION OF REMOTE MULTISPECTRAL ... · i (f t , lt tr-220-1075 april 1972 unsupervised classification of remote multispectral sensing data 172-27204 ic.as c 237s9e

TR-1075.NORTHROP SERVICES. INC.

S8VP' ' I N lo' 't '000000000000000000C0OOOGOOOOOOOO OOOOO0 Q0 0OI 1 I lItit[ Ill It III III I I III II 2 ?

/ 202 820 - -......... … V1t*/I *l----[…-- . ....-. e. * ..&4 .---- 11! II I0..I

04o V......................202 %/etSSt lVVVIVI0,Il- + VI*V... 4.- I IVdt . ......

* 012 828~~~~. . . . . . . +.+*Vi*IVV+V VI---I-III 1.-1 IV.I,. . . e.--le..... .... e I t! IIIIIII¥--''..

70' $,I )8 8

,,8 8

,8,,loIO~o V-1 l.)V.2. 1V.. ................. . ............

A 2710 222188888100-II II* 8111110 . .. *.11112201188200ll181141080V.--- I--l-,i I V1!2V . ... ............... VIII …

22I t . ............. I ........ II…::226 8801812.8818081.01.VOIII…8 ),V-V 211. . ...8.V8V0-21,2 ,v,,0, ,, .. ¥ v.--I ... 1.8 .v1 vv-.w.......2...... I.…... . . . . .......234 i)$$th888 * *-V 22I-I-VIVV.VS* **./. ........-- IVZV' I Ill I---.

I 230 1888882/2221 … I.8lV 2 . .-- 1-. .1401716 , ....... ...... . .....

236 /88888/22,2101V10-Il.V .002 .291 188818 8 I8 Vill .......242 ........... 1 10 11001)8$--I -I]I¥¥ I I/ / - el*.··....

2442I l/$$8-I 4$111 I-V-,111001V V00VOOII IV /--. I .. 22.· .. *-11[....

~244t+$/ 1V88.88 $ ¥ ·+,+_¥ 001I-V----I*¥V)I$VII .-- I../II - - --·I~ e... ...-19-22.

1486 .. ll ..…... e..... . 111 t

200 1118888818888888818408120018..l..l... . ......../20 ............ *......././/....-leIl ..........-- ..... .-

2608 l88888888,8...........I.----·"/ .......... .. . ...

20 lit 188888888888212--V--01-lI I......…....2.242 -. ............ …-. ..2.0 .... ..F...*/ * 2'. IV -- II[ I . .. / III---..........

286 .........///IVY V V 'V V· II-let)$$+++11 1 -I- '

-I -- " .... I.e . . e ¥ - .

246 ,1S$$$$$)$// / ///////11Z+-l .....s IIII/ · - oII

e '… ·- -11

' ° -I-.

210 $$5 / / / / IV*/ II¥11 … . v-- I/ v/ /IIfI. ..-..--.- . .I

217". ........ ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~.214 II )1$$s4888)+S$/.1 + OV--V--¥---I. 1----v v V-.eoeI- -/a l.- -2 ............

210 88 l!8888211" 0100101 … IVI-............ II . 19ITT12............200 188888888188820014101lI-I4,I … 'VI. VV400......... 12,0114

284,~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~e --. ·-----V VYV~t.//N~--.e--l·.·

202 18)8$$88$$1,V·V-S0V V- V Ve-- …V VT-IVV' l-I i… t /ll . ..... //..241 }ISV$SS$$$}V[V1 )$$

+ v v )-

V

0 … I… [ 0-·

1vI- ·

8I

0 - -/ * -..... 101.11- ........... / 4

280 *..... $$S+$1.1 /+/+ -.0 1- -- …- L- · ·… 1 I -- -V-...-V,11200 8I $ $ $ - /-1101091SV./-1 11-8… I.[IIV/-1 0/ ......

29081 ,V0884'8 18 ~.-.-~I.I~4*VI1181 . 2 ... S.il I4. 4.292 ------$ttll20$$$$$t 1 /1.11… I--I--V2--- I· ........ -- ;--..I

294 ..... 1108881· ·'e ·---I[///·1 …I·.7400-0--....2$4 M1$11- ,$$t 0$V- 11 $-- -III-…II- . L--* ......... °'-0VI-I-I2..4

290 li88tfill48 2--------l-----/l 4l… . 1_ ......-- Ie//I----1-4.44.044 I*$$tt1814

· $8 $

$ $ } e ] V '

… / --------*

-- -I

-- 1 Il……- - -

- - ·- - /

- -

-[

1 .... 2 2 ...- -- 4444

?00 .,8$$$$$$ 18s $$$$$2-l/ / l-. --IV l 12. ...1.*--I-12L I -/*/I/..8.8. . .- I . . 444444

014 $0$86 111 1V/ II*…… .......-/--.I ..... / . ... I--I*1/.-I . . 8..4

004 ...... 2......... .44.

122 811 .140188420121--IlI…211I II..242

110~~~~~~~~ ......... 811Jtl .... . .../188020-2-JIl … 0-*I-- .. I. I ...222.. 8 I. 444...............

}t28 $t$$$$$8 0 I /e.l l...- ---- I- .-- ¥ …ll/--I- -. . II..e--·.·. 1- .... .4

116 }T. $. ..1 V- .. ... 4"I6 *..-·e-~ [¥¥¥V11*10 1/-I I I;I..V-*.-I......... I.... II-..2./ - .

120 1 - 1IV . - Ill!"! +VJ JT V .... .....I1 VVVV V V -!!-* ...... .. //*.1 .......-.... 14

722 84111888,18881 jS J 1-0-71-V-]-1V/ilI iIIV/0I ¥+Vl//--LI10 IV/ 11 /1· ...///... I-I.-I.~ 4444-''*

82 1T...... 88118- ~ I1011 0,III000-........-- 1. .8 44

52 $S$$$$848$815' .*/1'tVI I-..811111*801890 ... ...V 1 * · V' ¥+VV-*' -I$//Vv--J//--/·2 " °·'//''-- - - ····-'4.44

124 41848s 88 *$t$$ .0$$ 1/-080…[1v-Iv . 0401. ... .100111--·· -v+VVIVI"·e'VV //..e 2. * 44..../e..-ee-·.

00i0 8,$8$$.8tt8.8$$$/ VV *-l ¥ l ~--**-··-I. - Ve*+V¥¥VVYVIII[L·*$V[/I*VlI/·I. . . 10141 1.8.8...4.

112..................... '11 l...I-.8881.llll4 . . . 1 -- Ill.... . . . . . . . .. . .. . . . . . . . . . . . .

..... ·8884,81181 [[[1 ...... 1!!1!0 Il*0 V01.I..IVIOVII. . . 4.................4

140 88888,8844881418..*2I 12.12--Ill 11)1111.1.81 l~l.2 I . .1.........................

1'44'~ V""., ....142 88844 $v$$1 8s0v10$]v ........... 111117 188807-l. .11......11. . . 4... .4. . .......4.........-*......I.IVM

444484.U.008221 $S$$1*1+4$$)VV11$/-*)*)$011-e--I[v-I-Ie-~VV~--e v*---/////e" ..... ] ......... 010111*-2?1411 $888 $$8.*l+ I -,-,111 ..... 1..1v*-*eL+Vee---17-2. o*-Voolhlo¥11-1"/////* ·I...-· . .....w ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~44

I -88,.,4.,481-11188181)118111---I .V*OVOVIIIIIII 11-.4 . -4428$$t. $ $$*]$)--e-l~8 1 ......I·I_111.I .*- 10 -**/1* * /*e·..* 1......... .. 4o~44444

154 4148,188888488~0414,2~. 1111 1188811 111111 l,,8,02 . .11801141111110211L... .. .44444 1 +.l -IV)11/ ..-...... 811. .. ...- 1--- . - ·V - e·L--II* ./ .*- - ....... 4.4.4

16,1 8,tll)¥1 8815VV$1S$$0t//¥1e/-I- -I- I .. 1,0848 1 ...+III-....I *-----*-VI/----L--II 1-/e........... 4 44,4.4.4 4

11.284*44.4 $$$1 1,$$$t02-0/V 1,-1.8-88. -...]-0,-.....`e 80**-11101111* 11[ .L////.. -. ~.-*-4444.4.4....444

044 $88,$,, .888808Il8~l8IIV4~0ll88448 I , ....... ......... 0..--,11111i¥VII . ......... 44.. . .....- 4444-

040 88},4+8**+1*$4$t2I1 V 81/*[v-e - ,* - . - 0"I-****"**-e" 8 ....- -*.. 8.4..4*844444

100$ /ttt /+ vvv./4-v88,822I 1408++11818*I·111+ ··.e·*·.··8e-**--l . 4I - - ·e*//·09110 1..44 . 4...4

V02 488148884*88844 142--e-2- .. .... 4.......44

122, 88888888148411882 … 1 1 $t 0 $It -v-v --- .· .. ·.-.---8I--/11 *-111I/08.e/// 444.... ... 44444...4.

v1~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~.1444

10,8$$1880 44418+[-I*l-[*] 1818111 ·l~~8 VV8-8 .·· . - ¥ ] * l'-[.......-*-"100000V4I 4.4..........

122 1884484484.821I,-00 8811181111 . . 1.80 III40V440"11111V1W . . 44.4402 18081 181 - . I·VV ....... 4...4. 4..... . .4..

1,18 8$$$ttt88 $)8++.8W4 e[8 l ) * e l / v e18} }

l j8 e1 l e + ¥[ **--I[--LI..IIII. VI.III.I --- ....... 4.4 ...

10, .840*88I,2I4~I188181818I,88 I- . IV010 I00402V I.II4 ... 414444444

i114 ~~~ ~ ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~-,VI :...44.. ......... & .4....

100 $ t V8 $+8/8 / e /--I *0~8 ee ·8 8 VI ¥ / - III8.....VII ......... 4··4 0;.. . .. 444441? $11$8 $08*4 - -)11 ) I..84088481..11V*IV*[VII]Ill-0000 I 2 .;. * ........... 44.....44

40.1 18184 $t$ 44$ .0$$vtlv~,_/i88481888888181 I.¢.[+)~ ~* -, oI00 ..11¥*VVV[I[…1[-. ............ 44.4'.0,' 181 4t8$t8.8044**281848+$$//v8 + 11 I. ...............1 .... ..... 44414441/} i/ I-/-***-.04.8 82~II-/..***l884l-. . ...... 44 _44......44.

$1¥1481188884.4 +* t$$/-I,).81888 }8 }+*+11 ..... ·+[-. ..1 1.. . . . . . . . .. .1111 … ..

41 118 4.44-.4881 81, 1111.111.v 180440411 III……… 4414 08 184884$0$,4¥1 114*/0,1111811S)~III)II)**e·*]*I--[--*I--*LL··*~.-- ¥Vl ......· ............. 44..-

4124 ......... .. /-.l1 }l..t44111/- ......*....[IVV44[I-o .......... ...4>6 20$l 8. 2$$ t/-*- ) t$8e+* I - / *--o .v vIIVl8... ........440]-4 8- 18-1 … 2l0I 0IvvvV*...............*4444

42481 II0.4.0$$$t111$/-+-[Ve11 ttll18) ) .+I-e. -- * **-V[VI-.V[[IIIVIVV- * * * o·*-*- . q . 4,44.44 . 4* 44 . 4

40 1 .- 01 18 811 1001 T .. ...44.* ... 4. 1 4-

4 V-71 V$.)8l/- .I1 V+1}8 }$1ll+--!I III..*-- +44¥¥444444444-.40, ........-......$98$)$4I-+++4/-- .. 2-*-**--- 41[ * .... 4.4.4

441VVVl4.-~l2I -V 84 … I..IVI~. ,444444_4444

42YVl.482,I0I,4.88188881108.V-80 . II..9.4 .444 4444444

444 $ 2 91 59~k~$)$+ $/11488- -- V} "Ve+ I …IIv. ....V......8 ...... 4.444844444440.............8*0 … 00 .................. 444 *4144444

412 4412 1840,144l, 181188484411440.1q4442 .18.18148218.110*e....... ........4 44 44444

4U? ~ ~ $.~+- +. .$ e+~+*v-* - --*-e*VIVVVVVVV*11 ...... *e....~*.....I.........& ... 1-4. _4q,4'

44 - [014181$1 $ + +-.**--.*-01eY1… 111-- .-...44 4 .. 444.444..

444, _82412 60.28 11 148,1S I100 .... 1114444444444444611 ~ 11.1114441,4111 .,04I~- 2-I-lll82~- … 1011 … .8 4444444 48444 ..444144.44*4.

4124 ~ ~ ~ ~ ~~ ~~4

41,;$,$81,,,,, 8 · -1t$95 $ $$1..812.III.1. . . . / *,e~¥--/ . . . . . . . . ,., 444444444444444 .,....., ,

$4i. ]¥*VY,4-----------… I44---.** 44444444444444444844448...

41,1 1110481.1184-1 I.,81.1 . 000 . -. …......4 444444444444 -4'.4

410 188844404' + IU +,+I)$9,Il0t}$t,9l++ **-VVV*¥V V¥--e*.*-....44484.........44444444

'.12 188 $$08 w-**)ts$tt%%)oe*¥o.*·*11,W-1vv*)vlvv1v- I [I- * e e *

---· i e

2 o * *.lI-.84.8. . .......... 4444444444448444~44

44 18818,t[$+V ........ 44*18.. 1....4.44'41/ $VI-:1 I.$/-$/v .. ... . .*.....** … .......... 4 ...........44-444 4"444011 .tlb 8})t$%$ 1.k8..)/Is·$.$10$Stt$1…}l I-- 8 Z.*........:..4...4....444444444444 4444444

4.......0/ -- * . ... .... .. 4 4444444 44444444 ...

IIl.[[,4 ll +v;$[ - -11$.*./*-[VI8+¥Ve*¥:*:V:…-*-t[- --1 .l-/-o*·.. .. ..... ,44444444444444444.,

T401, 0402-184,81V888181 14180-81 +*,I-$$12/)IVV + 81 II.$ ] ) I $ + e ) I ,4,,4*+ ,--8-,* * / V V 4IV VI 4V 444- * 44* 44444* 444...4.0 ...... . .... 4.44444444444 4...4q~442 v* $t$}../ - + **Z-*V t8$89*1 111188,1¥481811 -- */**¢Y.II. "................. .4.444444,44444444444444...~

-42 18421888880288848~1418821- 81/14. I_. 1111V_ -:-.::;:.:.1444441,44.,444444444444444 444... 1

444 18**l8)48$8*/2}/l888l8)4$}} I-·VV.I ¥1 ¥*....*. * *.* .,4/· * 44- - * 4* 4 ................ 4 4I4948121884881888 ¥*** $//* * - *11 8 . VII - ¥ * e + I - - * * * + * ¥ V e [ V V I . 4.484844444444' · 44444444 - ....17400$- 882l88888888Il2 8II III.1. ........ 4......44...44444444444444

lO50,,14.I2$0$/-O·--0*,*C00C00$* ] C } · V 0 - - e ·" 00e * 110C0- 11 1111 111 e11411111 *I * - · l · · e............ 11111111Ž222

V-[1 ll222ll4440 4446l0I0V4'99,if~ 112 230444 ,4 1 0494420C0,l~l4&&

I 14111 I, 141 14111_1 v*9$}l.-1441140 43 )t13 /----- -V [ ....-

. I 1-19.....4....0411441141414411441444414141::lFigure 4-22.UNSUPERVISE CME 4WITH*11CLASSE4?R *)V~l~t~k~/-28·/It* J tte / +*4-,-·-*** I [4 444-

.*****-·*--.e*,L....:..,.1.4'4444444 441:Z

~& $$$..k/-+)~ltlg$$1+) + ' l' e l l ' - ¥ * ~-VVV+elIJ.J 1 4 / I.......... 1111e .......... 44.444- -44t411 ..

~&hIJ~t~dk1-1)l~l~l$k)/J) * - - - j - I / · * / * * [ j j l - j' l o * * l l ~e * * ~l - / /*-*....io*..........4:4444 441444 q 44&~&~/

'In ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~~ l~VJJ--11.I- ............ II1-II..... 444 44- 44144.4.4-14

ICU~~~~~~~~~~~~~.o4040~&00&&4o 4 . $*~~..

tI, ))}l$ll)t-JIN**-[-J * - + v V V *- - -. . . . I-.e**l .......2*14~~44~~&4& ~',&I**......... .,,,~,~.... . . .. 1, ...¥~, ..............I, 5 I I 31T~~~~~~~l 11741 15::::::::::::::::::::1::::91 .... 3'

Figure~~~~7 4-2SUNUPEVISE CLSSFIATO MAPa~ AFTER TH SIXTHVVV--*e1-* MERGING WITH. * CLASSES

',72 ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ 42

Page 94: UNSUPERVISED CLASSIFICATION OF REMOTE MULTISPECTRAL ... · i (f t , lt tr-220-1075 april 1972 unsupervised classification of remote multispectral sensing data 172-27204 ic.as c 237s9e

NORTHROP SERVICES. INC. TR-1075

000004400011000O000000 02))) 0C0V4055 oŽŽ6C77 OeCaq 21IOOOO )11 1 11141111 6)7 1?7 81 8gg1qq 0 011 ?

S $0 221v8s0sv¥[Z)V[Vl ...I … .....IIVV2t/I III[VIV-e---I--,ee..*..0.-lltl *4. --- II--211 I[ IVI I -IO

00200088832I0II IMIWill-0-IIlV2V11V8 . .. *.*.88I.[ .i. t.1 l .......

204.2 ...... I..............................[ V*--I ...................................2

OŽ$O)%IIV$IŽIivyVŽVOIIVŽCiI I~I~IVŽIIIIVŽITI 0212Il--I- .e- I II1111VIV-.e ?[ 0-8I$ 11V)[4J422VlV-IVIV-I[--7 I--ll)V Y88V¥)lI VVVV--...- .I I. . .

& " ? ] 9 i 9 /l--I-I-II VI9I ¥13¥V 8VV¥I e " - e-- e.l*l. ... l .l- [ Ilj1 1 I!4 I-l9214 $V,.,,,i$.IIV¥¥VV-----IV¥,,--- ...... IIt .......

22/ $)$14$$I$$I$)V2V1ŽVVVII-¥1I-Io¥*IV¥¥VIV8IVI--V28/ellV¥11 /-e-oe.oe...... . e-e., I ¥V¥V I -oIN 228 82/21888882828I23V28-III-1-8I811812112· 2.1II ... ·..oi. .~·.e--liIIIiI8IIll-- - I210 11})$V/V02$$$$$$$$$2v)1-~----I-VIIlIIl¥¥iVVIvl/// VVI /-*-.... . . . .

222 ....48/ 84222 2I8V2V)0JIIII--IVII)IIII¥V80-¥V_-./IIVV I -...... -.. . . -l----Ž24 I80888/ 2-2188422881022 IV9-f23---'II V . . .... ............-..- .¥1.IV IZ22 ·e. -----2Ž8 8418$8$/)18 II$$$22$-V-I I----IIII2812$$VV[·---/. elI .....

24e $$1$1.8I8 Vv/l } Vv. VI- . ........23 I2888844/2V4/I VIV's lliV0iI2 -- /ll ............ . .... -VVVVII-..-....

Ž40 $$)S$61)$16)11)1 ¥V[1t ....IIIVV lI I)$V ¥ -°/---/----122201··.°. . …*. I .·- . ...ti-·---¥¥V¥¥3V -- I-·*4----L824? $$$$$)$8////IV21034YVVVl1080--10-VV 1lll)llI·[··-·-…-*..1 1..... eI/ .. 11--.2 ¥ ¥ 4V¥ I 8-*..--

Ž44 IS$$$$)///VV[[V)¥VV421 [II30122-IVV[)I)$V[I--·//*2·--·!·.I. I2..~ IIIIt 1~~-- i18vv v.2 t -, …

246 2V888820V148VV1-3V02IVII . I.........Ž8-22I2…23Ž8 )$15 $$$$/8/////I-8 ....V..--¥ /11 1 1-1…-…. --- i-.. - v1vvv1 -.

Ž50 218882884888882448I-I-11/. /Ill///[V. .... s V-//11l.-l/--.I*-OIO~.IIe-IIIII.22222-- --l~-- -

Ž52 IN2888888888488884882242V1-2..…. 1222.

254e2s$S8l$$$s$/////v¥$//4828 12!11--- VV /··/-·/·.leol-/----.· ... l--ei--i·............. V. V/ …368 ... ... VI

Ž$0 I-ol--·-.,··-··- -! ol*--//ilV012-II … Io .. ... I--.IYV..e//V·...I...

262 )$S.......... /.V;[IW/V,//- I- ............ /..24 2 I848$$$ $111$$$$S$$$$kl/VVI- [--T--2--!V2 11011111.1111111 1111-I-l !.…I 82..211 / / ) ... 2. .….12 44)22215 ..$$$$$$$$$WW$./V )--¥ -I - .·--I-II/ … ...422S. ISW ...$.015V Il [--- --- /----···*.....·.1/ /--.... . ... · .228 $$8$s$$)$W4882$- s -V/--1 … ...... · 1l*-8 222..··· ·--.......I .

260 )811488842 .Ž .V.-V/"V--··*.VI2I·-- .'.....

282 888888888882888-VV8V-2V-2'..'2-4 … IV2.1VV530031112 - - --I·--I--I-v//°--I~ I·.,2,442846 48448421242 22-$$S$$S$WVlt/V…'l-' … /, V/·-12V2V-l¥l ~- I. ..- I02 /,*- ./',.- ..... · .4.4.[-/·/··-I.

287 888842VV82 2)Ss$$$$)b)2//-I-- …-- Vll -V-·Vl·--VV]-VIHi-[-l)l-I[--·. ..- ··.....I.·---....25?882188 202$$$$$$VW$////IIV23-2 …-[V-]I -,,.·--I[VV8Vll ./---I //il/ -. /,/ .. . . .4I-./~l/. !-I.4..29Ž I))1558 $$$$$$ V//lVV10 21-…I~--I-.-3-V...·;l-Ž-VVVV[V2-I- ·l.*-2 I$/12- i-/// .·--~·12. /iI.o· . 4....··71o

?24 2$$$)VI/i-$¥I1… I … IVVV4/--.I$ I-I// / ,..4...

218 88888122808888VV081-28222…1Ž11…II I 'o82oIIII///....-I 1- .. ,..,.-i···…444.44

300 SW41 -[2 … 2 V -. . .. VI VI ..22 ............-- . 4.. ...

204 482812122$W$$)/- -ISI VI… -......··-[-.I¥V-I . ..... . . ./o-· 1 444310 4 S--2V0112 4 ¥1 I/-·eSV-2 - I I ... . . ...... /// . -.-. ..'22 480$22 1VV2V28---22-I ---I ----- -- I 2 10..- . ..- 4.. . .. .. /."·4..4

514 $$$$$$$$$$VV))VIYV-2i) -I--*° - · ~

-- ·-222-·-lŽVt-Il2I.I0Vi~ tl""'t1[ -l./*...- 4.....

2120 ...1222088488448241-14-101-2-V-.I .. ////... -I./.VVV .442228 V I$-2$V/ ¥V0iVI./IV¥V2I - ~·'......·.-·.-.. .44?SŽ $$$$$)$$$)lv V1iW$V) -VV,_-- -`-11e2v22-VV--[V -/ 2 1........2../. .. . .224 12 2VV884888¥$$)i$)VI¥V- - /-~2 V IV--·-VIIV. V ¥¥VV I--·····"I··I.I/../I--........4292 if$ ......... 4294 $$$$)III$$$$VVsw$/-I)$)$11--·--*lV-- v~ leIVVV-/ -oVI[I V-II-/.·////// · ....I . . . . . 4226 $$$V$$f- 4--I 28[1122)1222ll--~v ...... ·-¥ ¥--- - ...... 8 .. .4

222 ....... V8 $$$V4$1 2 I-*28 22222lVI s-¥1M ...-. . · ---- I........4 .440234 88884842.88U88244441 2-I 221-2.1822-2822222211 111-331002- ......-. 4444108 8W$$8$S$,88$8V)W$/[V$1[--·.--221122 0i--V-- /-V-Ill - --.i l V/[t/.l,/-/-..........

240 888$$$288[,¥41$8$]422/122 2-I-eJ---·-I-222822822221211·Je[/I[¥-II.4....2V11182 .

342 888844. VI's8122 14,012-IV I0-1122824122222122221001'128-I . IIV0I I-·- -!* --..-... 4.4q.444286 IV Is)$V.llUU2$2ww//-)1---I·I - I-I-- ........ 2··0/--- ..... 44

104 $)$)il)V[¥)$$w)S/ll2-22 -- l[~-[l4[v -- ·---I-·-··-I- ·//- ...... ...IŽ0100I 2-. .044

25 $88 ;48......822V./-I[2 - .- 12 [1111112 .... ¥...4.,.44262 $$$$Vvl221.221 l.$$w- …i-[ 2 2.... 44.444264 v}$$ 4ll$$v2-5%$$w/-/v]/---[-[-·-2-122/ --VVŽ.[ VIO-·e··1·-l VV-II./I ...... ......... 4 4.4216 W44$1}4¥¥ 2 2$$$$W[I/0¥111[1..V[02--V - V--·.///· ....-.... 44212 $$VVI[VSS.4$$$$)W -2¥-IV[-2-V-88221¥122 I-I[-I-. I ---- ·*·-· ·*·v·-- Ill-·11-...

22 o 42884888824 218822222/222 . 0Vl/-V/- VV]2V02i"" ....- . . . ...... 4..4

1? V3 $ 5W$S[~--~I--~l1))VvV-V)vl~~e/*~"--~~[~//*~ .... ·..... . . . . . . 44444

240 88 4 8 ¥1- I22I22222/0....···-02 . . ...... 444,320 88884482484884042.2.2-0228.82228..2...2221 }V[I . .. /41 -`2Ž0 -[V4 T]4002 121/Ž11 … --. . .44.4202 ............8.82 I- 21 1 -{·15 12212Ž …l-¥~- I·.1,...-¥¥¥[[]Vl - . . .. 4-4 ... 44;44

2428I ,$$S$$6$4$$)$2.6022000 /¥2 )))))I})VII-I 8-81'· .. ..lYVt12I20l22-~..,·~2V0 . . . . - ''II I.4........ .4...

S.3.224 44244888608-I I l } I 222-2 28 424428222f.....[-VI VIV¥VI[4I[ II-,,·...·....--.....;..44.4..444

22.' $/$- 88/-·',.-..-I-/...'28888444888488222*22-28'... .'Ž1 2012 0Ž0022 .......... . . . ......4 .'22, 2286888148000222222 /-8,648888848882 2221)l) iV-/-[ .... ··...·20Ž2 00Ž0 [222/2 . .. ....

220,24818842860.4,121 $w$$$$v1w8/-¢l))l)$$4v/-- .... * 12210. .... ·ivyO1 2242 Vll2l . ....... .......... .... 40494220 $$$ 8 $$,$ $//-. ~1.11)$ .... ll. V......I.....4V2..-,W~..200848288824222 . 0 2222..22 …24

08 2222.W'- $$$WV}))iW//8)[V))))$$1$s))2222.)}VlV/-* 0i"v [[IV . ...... ..... 48,24 1214$842.4$$$82-vI$y-4$441884$$1$282Ž2 l242. }[--0 8 - Vi3 V[I**4.*44*..*.*484... $ WW$$$v )/`$[)[$$$)ii)}I..~.~~VV~[~~[~[[[.~..`444...... V",4~

2.20$$W2w"2$$$$$440$W$/8084888 $$$$$881 ))}i021*-Ž-~-'~".VIV2200Ž4V1 [ zIŽ[I12122` ….2&`4.4 . '.44"44444.3 IV4'848224,818822222 21V00240022I . ... 444.402

"IC ........044/$2-V0}$$84$)$1222. )-··-·.*] V l.41444 ... 4 ....II …4 4444

2244? 2080VI $$"-2 lv)8....1.....22VIVV2VvV2V.202 II1[V-IVO... -.:I- .. .. 4:4..44,

014 4844.8.2222 2884881$~W----I)~$)))Il)V/--·,.VYVYVVV 2¥11[¥2Ž ·*,··-·· ..... VŽ20.~ ... 44444404

42Ž02084 $1555555 2222 2224222188282122/-I2-/}$ l IVl-- 24 ....00220 VV0IV0VVŽ VVl... 424 $$$$18$$$$$$$))10/---14)$102224}2.2Ž0ŽŽ012--9`V18VVVV1 VV1VvIIVvM`1.2* .... . .....- 4.. ..2.2 $$$$2$$$$$W$$$WW/--4 -[8 )}$$8 ))-2 %)0)… V)V- - V VVVVV02-.. ........ . . ..V44V.4 48422 22 $$$tw$w/[24$$)$)l$lll/8·,·lvllV)VV.v¥11IIV[ 122 0242 . .... i. .....44 ........ o......

426 $1128$$$$$$.w2-241l2222 $$$1$2$2 )$$1 ))l-·- , ,I*-22.42 11 vvYy¥¥vv)1-12-..... ....4..444....4..444464

42 $)$)$$ 1$$$ $ 2$w8} /-11 $)v---. ,·--··--.. . .... 42... 4.4.444444. 02222. 2. $ $$--$)04l8)ll*,·lo/vvv)…v02.v0ll…/.. .... 4·. .. 442 .4.442..440

4440422.14-$$$$` 8414$W1WW.; $)~$~~V)-.-1VV)VV VV2~`--II0II0. 2.. .·.0.*........4.4444448...4G

~'88 02141$8"..-2028V"14VV44v1v1-vV1--.1...…..... . .-.;..444 .......... 4 ..4.44440, $ $ $ $ %)"V[-2401'284846.,622-22-4-22 200Ž. 222222 .......... . . 4 4444

~. ~ ~ ~ ) ~)%$%$W)[~}~$$$$$)))V/`'-I vV)v)VVIvvVVVVl[lV' ....o .......Z4 214 222 )$$$$,,.2wwww .llYVl.$$$ $$$v-, 2 . vvv-0vv1v.v.22.. .-. ·. .- . ............. 4....... I.41')6 )$$$wwwI)$$$$$$$$}1)/···)vvvvv111¥111~···-. · , · ........ · ...... 414434 $$)2222 $$248.6/0 v$$$$$~)$$s$$$$) v/.o-2v¥¥2I I[...../-.-.-. 20-0Ž1 … 0-2222--. ~.4444444444.444...... 44...443 2 260,2 ....... w--V//V$V-2l$ $ 4$)¥$ -l)) ..- I[...444049........4 .. 4.4.4444430 ....... II 222. / -) $ V VV2)VVVV VVIV4II- .8.4....·4··e··e4e··4o .4 ..... . . .

460 II$1252 WIIVht$$$$$1,)I~,·~IVV1VVIIII.. . . . . ./1····- 228 2.----2 … 02 …. 4. . 4444.4444.4.444444.44444.

46Ž 208414648]2.$$ -$$1Vl/- .. V. .VV.VVVVVV .VVII .....Ii1 41-111--ii i4......4 444....

460 411$$$$wwww1w/*)$1$$$$)4$$-$)-Ž02 l l22-- ·~4/ vvIIIIIIIv- …. 4.-444....·4414--·444·44444o4·44484G.40' 88.4422.2 4684$$ 4l/l4$V$j$~)~))j~]~)~VVVVf-~-2I20I---VŽŽ ./24444442,044444 4494.4....444044...2.22884222,8-0,. 22~~$W./)V~l}$$}$VJV··VVJ~VVVVV-·-1o·,e1o 2o--042. 22 . .. ,-··...4040444444444444444.....q 4

804 414222222 I.0108040-224228120...-2 ¥ $ / -I…¥/ I …VVViVVV-.i.~......4 .....8448444444444446.......4.. 4846444

4Ž0 2v6486$;2122/vi88-V$0220$%i8-v)1i… --"~VVI Vi'/ I-....i ............ ... 4.444 ...4.4444444...44...484444.44Ž4 ....1.......-..-[$/-4v16]20 … 02--I-*. .4.444444. 4.4.4148...,.... 444Ž-,W/"-"4./`V/`vV.1228 "".-" I 'II ................ 44, 44

42? ,[ 224-468-8.880-2-i822022ii82I . .....--- V II .444 44. 484 ,4 444. 4

42I 6$$$8/-I$/-0.I-/-,I.2-)[¥2 ZVV2¥............22.../. ........... 4 4 444448.... 4-444'24 2811551484.1./-4$444} 614488l/ I 2---II/··/I¥]~II-~-I·.· ··I'/ 2121. . ... ·...... .......... .4 .4.4444444

.2.6 222844411[81 2282V)II .'4..*:*.*. .444444464440444444.4..444.

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~...)...~/-)T)$5~k-I1]-yV ·1V)/-I-. ..-··.·.·......·...... ·....... .... 1114414~4~444

b¥1 1v2 k$-[¥ V % $ -VV-,VV ....... ·4- ·-.o.".. ·····*/·.·4*·oo4 ~ ~

420 i]) -$SW1/[Vl¥$ 24 [-40 --412 . . ... .. ...... 4q½444 4444 44442,442.. 44q444222 222222)V) u- I.2..,4 136 /---V[YI -19 1012'--244· .22..6...2.844444402322202CC 2 2' 2)2

22O1222$,2S1%1221'$1¥$222522--/I2}25}/-·VV232V1-,-···-[[1--.-2·2.....· ...... 312223&9233Ž92.62422.l 222222 '2·

"o ' $$/)-$ W ) IV-/ 1 )1) .1--[~ ¥ ........1 o·1 ............. 4,&o4~&4&44~4 ~ & G

4')2 W/$$$$$T)$))V$ *--V-- -. ....'.....' . :1::.* :;.**.. ....,..1444 44q41,4.....Z4~q

4'~ ]$/$$$$$L~d¥ v $vvv ¢$$ ··-i-* -·· ··o·,·**···....e.o- .·...$*q 4:44-~4444 &~&4/,-.....

VI )L$ $%51I [$1$SI))[. V*.1;1···-II·]. ·.--- - ...·o ..·.........···· .....::...4 4414 ~ 4 14 .4~4.~.

Figure 4-23.UNSUPERVISED CLASSIFICATION MAP AFTER THE SEVENTH MERGING WITH 10 CLASSES

4-29 4.

Page 95: UNSUPERVISED CLASSIFICATION OF REMOTE MULTISPECTRAL ... · i (f t , lt tr-220-1075 april 1972 unsupervised classification of remote multispectral sensing data 172-27204 ic.as c 237s9e

TR-1075NORTHROP SERVICES. INC.

9~~~~35100OOOOOOOOO0000GO OOO00 0y0~O000 08yO 8O800yy5L1l 8118111

582 $IV) ...........40 8/I7s)SSyIllIlyVl-VV-VI y.-V-I .. i 1,1)/IV . . -. . . . . .... e~ I ! I

2° , , ll:i 1l... . . . . I ,, ,Iv ....... V … . ... I....C 70$501885551yl111110010--l.lj I 1-......208 i-$)$$)$)S0 IVVVJV y¥{{l- VV----IfVVV -- IVIIA¥1 I--Ieee-e. .lelllle* ... *.·..*. .lt. I..vV"~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~o

770 5/S~~lsSS~lS~l~i~i~~l~y~il-01i-10-IyyylOS 8{{ '{{{{{IV{{i{.. .. *. . .IiI0 I A 212 8 8 5 1 V I -I-I- IV it V...... .... ... .......-l$t VIt$)SI%%IsI1)¥)¥VVVYV-----IV~t1 VV¥V- ....--eleele.,l®e .....-{V---.

20. s/5l05l~l~i lVV~~V1i-O ............ ...214 8018 15518 ...... ,,1-,-l-¥¥,,,--,,,/.,,vlO ,[y .................. {Vi~iV/--SI. ...... IN 278 $////155555l$)$)$$00 ¥v--{Il---l- IVt )155$I)I[I II¥{1ele lveeio..ee.eloo-- e--- I I {0 1------el

200 7)$V/V.............)¥,$1---l--I-V7IlI YIYVYV ...1,/{l~ ........ .......... ......... tvI llv lI 1-......222 $$$/8I$$S1)1}{)$]{yVVVII--1VIllIITT{}V5V-VV-./I{VVl/It t-.- .5.t~...·il.... · --t~d-{{T I Vl l i…..I222 'Vii/V IlisS.,i75l¥liyV¥-01¥---Il1)¥¥ )$$VV-.i--/e.e....e..e-yf .. .22$ S$5¥50I/ 1$$S{1{{)101V[]¥1…I. SiIll)!VO---./ll/ l ·.e..y.¥¥ --226 8$S)$S$111)$$))$ V111[11 II V ....

2283 [1551tlS/IVVll---/I--/--el/--I--.eeeleel I I...I..-e --.l .….*.-lee-VVVVVIV--11.I…232 l 51 I0 ........ . ... ..... ...........230~~~~[ 15155550IY'ti11 19.....I I 10s100l1,*-.///.I…...IvvlI-......................123$$$$$ ///Ii/vI Illiv -- …-V155$l0)} --- .-- ./.. -¥ -- l----2L2IV ly V0-- Ivvvi- .......- y

204 Ill IOS)SSSS/i//VI I 1500 1-0110- i III V..l

240 ) 1 15 - -1 / .I. .................6208 S1! 8.1S11815100I/1000----- llVI … ... . .......- I I ...23B1 . S{$S$$$/f/[/VVf// V{VV IvV---l{)1 }VIZ/Ii/12,.

250 )))$$$$$ $ $$/{ $! -I--- lolw/. .- .. .........-... ¥. // …-...

252 I %1%ss 41 0-…1 I..........M M..... ..24$ 1850$5S555.55$5 IV)5.............t')l . .. ........... …I..../ ..........

230 I}$S$$S,1$5$5555¥IIVVIII/IYV[SV- V)¥f-e--I-ll-.- … oI -I-- ele-/~el-~../-18...e--¥¥//-1--.

e200 15$$S$$5}$$S)S0iI$)Mk0/I//IYVV--VIV--- - -----00 --… I.I -. llIo-I,!-·--/®4l / l. ee.·. -- ¥// e- - e-. .

202 57$$$i$5$$5$$5$S/I{/0$-i/// ........ II'$.I .. ..252 ))S$$ $l$IS')$$/V-l...-I-.l-...-...........-.l-----.-II/l e........./.....

200 {$S$$$S$$V$$$M$$$$I${$/iI{}II--1-V-/- 11/-... --II4VIli ~-·11,I Il/t/l I-IVlt- ill1,11 I/V/ ./....I.. I.070 11$$$$$M$$)$$1M$$$100$1--V-${/{-[-I/1 I.. II/-l-1-oy "ol~lIe.--V"l'ee/--IV--l0l-.-I/.o 5~oli- / l/*. .- I-

2 )$ ISS$$N5M5)4)$I$$SM -. $.../--.---.-.-. -I/.l- …- //11--Ilil-- . ......·1 -... ----------

210 i~I550555505)-)750"0lo … 1010 IYOVlV I- V!y ................7I...

"yo.58......S5...S$$$...$/-I. // . ...260 VI/--IS-0-1- - ---…tl…V-1 ... -I. .... /-------

264 S$$$$$$$8/)17011/1 … /-[-I-- - I// i- -- I.....-/--- - --.....0. ........268 II)55555555 55&IVISV)) / -- t0… l-e.e-- I . / l--1.I......

230 $5511)855)708511185)I~lI-7- .0-:-i::-VI-l'NV00000I . 11.1 . I ...

78 --- H~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~I.*ee //l~*--232 I{555)$6S$S$S$0$$$S $)17 7--7.-0/I0/1 .//.--..-.!. /--- VVVIl-Ill- -vV /e-[ / //. ---il·.... .

294 I$$$$$$551 5505$¥-$////II … 1 .[{--I---II.-.Iol.---II{VYI/--I-¥}//-/¥-I/....I0-/I//l7l/,Ile--.. ..220 {)1{$$$$$$$$$$1{$//IVVI1511…--- IV. 00 . ..I·II--YV1¥I I-01-¥{I$//! -l¥-e-/I/.l--I! .i/i1oi1--I.

200 $~t$$$585))055/41)$¥[/I-----¥-IIV-…I / ..*.e/IV/'-IVV¥1-V!-V/-/-'II$/VI[e/11/II...///...II.111

272 300 $ $ $ ... $$...W/I ) … -{ … … .II .....

'02 0555)$$$$555)50/[$¥I-[7)…¥ l..I..I--'~---lIV-VVVV¥V-/eell-S5Il~e//e.ei .le//.--!.ie..

3?4 5 l$$ 55$$$$$ .$$…/-I …V[… )~-I .......-I-..l / o...

70 7) ) / //// ....... .......28 $$$$$V$$$)¥¥)5011-)-II------I-*-----V- .- IV VV¥ --- I¥. l/ . ..////- -/.2e~$$$$ $${{{VMV ~l1-V)-' ....... :Ivvvv !I V310I.S$$$$V$IV$/Vl))Y-IV ..... tVII)lI0/·~IYVVV¥) I .... I111.-I0-I..…i--.. IIV...77 ) )I-0-VV)- 0 VI-0-t.11)1) 1... 111V11-* ...//·..·....I.........

320 ${$7)115s$$05))¥]&1[$)17 1t¥{5-/--7--))l·-v00I .. 0-111 . ..--!tellll~lI//I..ol/ilo~-)- - - -- 'l..I. ...

2q $$$)~$~V~]~i){--~----V~~~/I/l-vV/-/l "-I/-//"///'`l`-I-. .....

128 $$$-1 )$$$¥¥$ -$/ ------ * / 01)11)) ...--VI / / / 1.1..... .......29~ $$~t$$I.1)$¥$$VV~{)1 11 -[[I . . . . [-[·¥)/s["l--il-l/-i-////I.e ........ , lI.ll,........

324 )U) 1$$$) $V{ ".-"/-..-.I/.....· . .. ..

720 7$)$${$545855)0$$1//-00$)---I-I-,--) )7)71) 00 100 1.I. I[-----·e"l*-ll- --I-l'li'i/".,- - -"---·l.5. ....

30- 8)$ I¥11$V)5 $$) $//VI)/---~ -I 0. . ...-. i-ll--I .

310 $$$505I)V${5$5 ¥]/)I-/--I-{}-"-4-)-) })55 - ··[[-)-) {·01000011 . Ii101 1101)l!///.e- - --. I.....

12" $$¥i))$)/])--{{.. l---I)/l------~{I~il-I-te-,-[~~.//e. -----l---.. .....

Il/ -)-----$$$III$$--/-/-/" `----------)-)))/) "--"70i.///... ..............

11, ~)~{VI$$~I[i~V].--v-VI)V)l{v-~l--le---"-II~l/ / .... I--,..........

776 $$V¥]IV$$$55$$$)55[]-I)5--II-)-7-5)V-])))I))) )-I-VV¥1---·l·. -tl·101-I I-l// 000011-"........100 $$)lf/55,5$)5)$$$$i/)/{IlItVVV'/-Vi/')l))l V~iI ll'··l.le-lIll·-I-.I///I..*..-. ............

{I{)Hv¥¥IyVlII,·.'- V-----/~~/·,,---------- I v.....

740 $555$$5$5)1V4 /--8v)-l"7$$)I{){)))})VI0VlV[[-I."./ ..................

702 555M04555S)5...)W2-I) 07I757I77II)) 104-15) . 110I0111I

74 555005 $)$$$ 05$)0U55-l)//}i{ 78*5})11)1$)~))) 111001 ~"'"~'"~ ~[v--Ill-I.~-`.................3055.0)057 I 77$7$$$5${ 7{)577$))))}l))7 VV7l it..I. .. ..--I- .............. V...0.....).7005........ .$$$$ ),s7-)}Vi5/){{)))))))77-ll-I. OV......... .................370v 5$$$4500t0$$00055/-)) ){$75 $5)5555 ) ){) -/-I .. /IvYiOIiIII . . ,...................

052 $S$%$54$$$5I500804)/-I{{V-)5750)7$)$1)1) ){}I1)V¥-{-I- -I,... I{V ¥ 11[lll ll- .... · .......... '..754 I $$$ 5$SVSIW/-V)I¥ 1/ ))))))))II{))" I¥- . -- ....0)I-.......................

75 50.5.25)007--)5 555 l1l Iv~ v001 . .11000117 11110

I0t 5s54404- 5$W)/-))1$ 1))))) 7-)-]- … .5·-IlYV¥111{l1l7ll{I/ ...."I,%)St, -I...5 050455)7)77l,,Vl~il-70555557)7)I 111)77 … V'vv,::;..50)0000000)07177) 17)171).!:;::::..,...................

17, ~$500555054$5V)4¥)/-)¥700)))]75$$$} )7)71)0)0)]/-i. ...·0.0·140¥100¥1){IV11{1)..... .........

70 $s$11.515550555¥$/-7-l40) 7)$$$$I)W)1))} ){1)07-/-l-....-...0010¥ 1001111- . .......74I 5750550$$5575770/---{7077$$$)7)))}7)7.-7 . 0 04010[-1 [ - ..............

$7 IV IV$$l$i-:.:$/-¥$-{V{{1$$7 $$)).7770 {)) ViI-..-.¥ [I I[VV]-o..,,oo· ...................707 0W5550 $ $ $ $ $ ....I/~ ... 0) 5 )7)77 .I107 777)0.....................

~hZ S$M-~$$)V$$I~[-V$$$I){{v-~~-'VV~V~~[([{~[-~~' ...... .- v....· $~$~$$V$)Vt~V~$$)~))})V"".!VV~IV{{{I1-. ... _ w.,v ..........

704 75)550 I05,0 7-417_V )1707.... 77.- . 070I100 I0 117)70 7)$$00$I%-,0$$v)7/-), vV))i)$$0)7)0))})VV]-s..s .I.......... 70000040 I .......I.720-7555055. 7$$$$$$i-/ 70)7- 7)5I 0$)77 - -5-....-I VVI0vV ] ......... ·-............1~2 $$$$WW a- ${il-SII-/V-VI)$)$$i) -)V/ ---~-""--- V~V~V V HVVVM {vUi

700 $)$5$.$.$$,$4.$-1 ¥¥)0)$$ 7,)71770)) , 5 .......... v v vv,,,v,,l,¥~ ::

>04 77000500047)77)540055155657)71470-5. ......7 4700)00V,` I) V .

75$$0%$$.$$){l$/---{l $){{lll {) ..... ··,·-¥[Il.· ................S17F) $$$ $ /{ - $)050500$57 77770..-0 ivVV0V0V0{t0T0V0-7.0 .................

400 5$$$51$ 00.$ 000 ..... III 7_77).. . . . . ................ *.50 /752 $}7{S$%$$$$%$hI[--)T)])$$$} 1 .){0$$) )]}))V-I-.--I-··-I)VV}¥IVYVVI VVI - ] I I … .s..s...· ... .............

404 $/$-V-

.............. -.. ... .~P6 }$$$$$$.$. )i- ~¥) }~$)$~$$)~ )))vvl-··. ·-· IVV ){¥ VYV "VV -V 1111-o ..... o·..........;...

&q2 )t$$$$~~W~[-~)~t$$$$$$$$$)~})~~V/e*~e-VV~)V~v~vVVV[~[~e~- ~.·........................

~,~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~~~1 ))$$$~)[){V$Y$$$$)))VV-M-ill~~VVV{{{} .......... ·..........I,)~ )$$~$$ "~w[~viiw$~$$~$$~i$~))Vv/-*~'*~VV~VVVVVV~T[I~-. '-- ....... ·.... . Oo......

,qP ~t$$~$$~"{~}}$~t$4}~$t%$$~)i)V/ ~ {~V~VVVV~V~V{~VII-~-~"~.-ll~. ......... ·...·.. ......~0o $$}$$$~ ~./vvv~s$~l~$~{$$~l)V/·*·o,·~-,v"vvv~v¥¥�vv{¥1[Il ... /*·*····......·..

44llt$n./-)l$.$155$ $t )/....vlvvvvvvvl] ........ ···V.v"V.II·I---lI .... ·.....................

Ad]. 771050$0$5.)/l070$$5$5$$5{7¥1)vvl ..... 7../ VII------- -..

474 7 0$$0)4.7 /77070)] $i$$$) }/7-I7 0)0ViI .V.IV-0 - - -/. .............. .. . .....4 7 57,$$ 8/I{7)-· .. 7 05 7I--i l7 ....... . .......470 4$)$$$).0 .../I)777-77) 7051$777 77)7 . 07 7/{4{VVV 0}VV1 . .55.. ""...........I.......I... vl$$$W/)ii$)~$~{ ]/~vvi~VV~vv~lV~V{f .~~l -/~- ............. .............

11i1 VV{_-$/V-~{}{${))V/- )V~VVv-~v~IVV il~~-* * ............. :i .............40 ....)7..0/0)7--O$1S) 77 7-)7707)...)- - /VV [VIIVV. ......................

~h ~${$)~/~{v~])){~)$)VI)!V"'/*-~-~'V~V%$v-IVV~V*~ - - . ~/" ........ ;..........I..570 0)77$.7)7-,v-/7l)$77/5 -7770 …VIN-0 1 .......... I.......

I?4$$ ~~-V)I$S$$$ -){ /--·II-/-IV/IV-IYVIV ......... ·1·..·.... ]11.1tl......................421 {)$)$5w/]-)07)$ ................ 07.. .

'I0_¥ I/SS, v/--~$VV~$ )$$$............. ¥VJ'*1lV ....·*.·*.·"o''·ol····o.'.......................142 75V0I0$$/5)7874)'S)$)7 … 7"-)l-- - */- .

0)0 7V707.4.$-/-{0V7$${5$wk1-7)/77--7V[Iv-5~-007/-5-]-7-* ~'~~~............444 47]7)7.40$--{v]{v$$)57$8)505 {v--I…007) .lY -[ 1 .… ....... [...... ........ ....

04 000)7705.$-)V¥1¥}$$})7704715$ I-- V I.... V . . .................

440 ..........50 705-[0 0)0)…$$7$./- -......... .....450 $$/)V) $ / - 1 o .... ·/- ..... ................. ..... . ...32 VV)$$$$/~{¥7777)) ))$$704051.7-/7-V-'{VV¥/--I[--···{VI '--i----·.. · .......... ..................

055 )070)0 ] --)/,.I 7)0.. IV'. . ...................4 {} 0/-7 }[V$155$1/·T-7- I·--/]IV A......0-·..·- ..-..............................42 )/1-7 IV V0}i 7l- ... I){/--- v--;--·--Il.) .. ........404 77))$T -71 ---…)V -----V I-.--. · .--- ....................400 00$$04.0/)777.$)1 705h$1*/5¥¥}$[/-)VVVV [11, … ..............473 $.o$V¥)))1 / / , - ..... ·.... ..........572 7$$4$.7/7){{00{-IOSSVIII-I)77777I---0700¥1{I7-·l~-··..77. . -. ·.....................,.

470 $04$/7)70I}7770570577//7[55)55707.-.·o·-·-V-0 --..................................476 7477/777775557 ....1077--v)----,, 7...5. ....4.I- .$$$//)]-VV55¥1V--/V7 t)}III)17!·---I·-- ..-. t.......... ............-4q *kI{ )V).$$[-//-$-V)$$)IlV-·-·--{--·I.·.-.,,··, .................'.H2 5/-)$SS${V$$$-7)]I$1{¥7-$){))-·-{VVIV/·.){I...'"·........................

78 57/¥5$5$5$$¥V)I$$11VII$1587l755-7I-¥[--- Ill··. * 7.. ......G,76 07)$$S $V)$¥)V$)I - I...·.. .....................

'.08 t)/755$$$05$$$$] I})$${{$ )5{$$)}I··.·....... ..............

~UC3~<J~9U~G~C~9~C9 ~C~(~C ~;3~u~~~~~~~lI~Il~ltL~i'~l U4'"i tI6~II16il 1111.111111112,2.22.*727~72~70J((7'0400C0030`70077iC0o')000C,)000000JI00"011-0 1'IJ.O4"07777 7777l)77)) 777677)77)111 l77222 77lI04037 7777lr~2272)113741144144 S"'I0500-00........0-5333.00 )172237444050674 0 88A-03T000I 7777 50 509)707797750 90 157737'7350 759 1157'7135l5 713-77970357073570735791777,737)57130) 1* T4l

Figure 4-24.UNSUPERVISED CLASSIFICATION MAP AFTER THE EIGHTH MERGING WITH 9 CLASSES

4-30

Page 96: UNSUPERVISED CLASSIFICATION OF REMOTE MULTISPECTRAL ... · i (f t , lt tr-220-1075 april 1972 unsupervised classification of remote multispectral sensing data 172-27204 ic.as c 237s9e

TR-1075NORTHROP SERVICES. INC.

YELLOWSTONE NATIONAL PARK

.59' .$F

.AT

LEGEND,B- BOG

F -FOREST

K-GLACIAL KAME

R-VEGETATED ROCK RUBBLE

S - SHADOWT- GLACIAL TILL

Ta- TALUS

W-WATER

Figure 4-25. GROUND TRUTH SURVEY MAP

4-31

X-SBEDROCK

Page 97: UNSUPERVISED CLASSIFICATION OF REMOTE MULTISPECTRAL ... · i (f t , lt tr-220-1075 april 1972 unsupervised classification of remote multispectral sensing data 172-27204 ic.as c 237s9e

~~~~~~NORTHROP SERVICES. INC. .TR-1075NORTHROP SERVICES. INC.

:E ..... = O 'O

I'/' ' I... ' - I-- _>-~~~~~ I-- "'-

. CD C sC o C:F <:)=

Ill 0or- 0 O 10

LL 0-I- Ld

LU 0Cli-i n L) ,, L- LU LU ..

CD -1 LU I _. .o _J O cj L () Cp LJ_ CD C 3l

. ~ ~ ~ C .- CD. m U- :c

I-

IE

I-

L--

L0

U)

I-d

CDZN

F-V)

CM0cI-

(1)

(1)

--JU-J

C)

0

uiiCo

Z

ed'

LS)In

to

00

i

>. I b- )C -- t- * + I r-., 11 c'. co) N-

-: - LO N ) d C) '0 '1_ , , .- 00I L13r- - - - - - - - -

F I . c] LL) 'n r- (o n-CJC) )~

) C) 'o.:: 0'::;::) -1 w

'-- "' U 0 .-O 4 i-ic)V) LLI~~~~

4-32

LU.n

I-C

1 0LLJ L

LU~

LLUJ O

j-~

C)

CDL')

ZO_

CD LIJ

(D U

,Z

C)

WZ

LL -4-

>noq

M(1)0

2I)'-'

<D LLS

1-4W

Z>

OLUl

L/)01-

I-

1u-0

0u-

V) C

F-

IJ

Q--

VLL

27 O

U

uj

(1)

V)U-

'-4)

LLO

-ZI

l_

W

ZE

· Z:'

Page 98: UNSUPERVISED CLASSIFICATION OF REMOTE MULTISPECTRAL ... · i (f t , lt tr-220-1075 april 1972 unsupervised classification of remote multispectral sensing data 172-27204 ic.as c 237s9e

NORTHROP SERVICES. INC.

Table 4-2. MEAN SPECTRAL VECTORS FOR 18 CLASSES - YELLOWSTONE NATIONAL PARK

MEAN SPECTRAL VECTORCLASS CLASS NUMBER OF MEAN SPECTRAL VECTORNUMBER SYMBOL SAMPLES CH-2 CH-9 CH-1O CH-12

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

11

12

13

14

15

16

17

)I

W

V

$

/

4

M

+

H

z

2

3

TOTAL = 16,650 Samples

1120

823

836

1625

923

1043

905

1326

433

975

1518

866

1272

319

779

1059

828

-I

110.32

91.45

84.19

62.49

93.29

76.32

116.27

71.94

86.99

121.65

67.15

103.71

57.26

136.69

80.16

53.86

78.89

135.89

107.25

96.25

58.83

115.51

83.36

145.62

75.05

86.66

155.46

67.50

125.70

51.61

175.95

101.62

45.50

89.27

150.51

115.83

103.65

58.65

128.92

88.19

163.33

77.68

89.57

175.72

68.46

138.82

50.94

204.94

116.34

44.74

93.61

83.4

81.89

76.18

58.80

82.11

73.18

86.24

69.70

56.18

88.62

67.66

82.40

53.01

93.73

77.46

42.20

85.93

4-33

TR-1075

Page 99: UNSUPERVISED CLASSIFICATION OF REMOTE MULTISPECTRAL ... · i (f t , lt tr-220-1075 april 1972 unsupervised classification of remote multispectral sensing data 172-27204 ic.as c 237s9e

NORTHROP SERVICES. INC.

. - BEDROCK EXPOSURE$ - VEGETATED ROCK RUBBL

- - GLACIAL TILL

W - WATER

BLANK - THRESHOLD

1 . 1

H - SHADOWS

.E 8 - TALUS

= - GLACIAL KAME

/ - FOREST

110 . 220

. i . I! ji iiliT i.., ...................

.:. ... .: : ':. .. , . . ....':'!" .... ,.! ;i::F'''" !'lliii!ii. ,, ____________:: i

~... ...... ........ .....

480 ................. Figure 4-26. LARS CLASSIFICATION: YELLOWSTONE NATIONAL PARK

(CH-2, 9, 10 AND 12)

4-34

TR-1075

Page 100: UNSUPERVISED CLASSIFICATION OF REMOTE MULTISPECTRAL ... · i (f t , lt tr-220-1075 april 1972 unsupervised classification of remote multispectral sensing data 172-27204 ic.as c 237s9e

NORTHROP SERVICES, INC.

Section V

CONCLUSIONS

In this study, a new composite statistical sequential K-means clustering

technique has been developed. It was applied for automatic unsupervised

classification of remote multispectral sensing data over the Yellowstone

National Park test site and Purdue C-1 Flight line. It was found that the

classification technique is about 80 percent correct on both data sets, com-

pared to 86 and 85 percent classification accuracy, respectively, obtained by

the Purdue LARS supervised maximum likelihood classification method. In view

of the very little human intervention required for the application of the

unsupervised classification, the slightly lower accuracy seems still rather

good. With these two demonstrations on actual data, it seems fair to assert

that the new composite technique may be useful for processing various earth

resources survey data. From the operational viewpoint, it is also believed

that the unsupervised technique is more feasible than the supervised techniques.

There is still some automatic decision logic needed to be developed in

the present unsupervised technique such as (a) to decide the number of classes

merging optimally suited for any given data set, and (b) to examine the homo-

geneity of every class established. These two decision logics are closely

related and are important for establishing a completely autonomous nonsuper-

vised classification system. The investigating of such decision logics and

implementing them into the computer programs is presently underway. Effort is

also underway to integrate the statistical sequential clustering and general-

ized K-means clustering computer programs into a single, more efficient pro-

gram for operation type data processing. The above developments will be

reported in the future.

5-1

TR-1075

Page 101: UNSUPERVISED CLASSIFICATION OF REMOTE MULTISPECTRAL ... · i (f t , lt tr-220-1075 april 1972 unsupervised classification of remote multispectral sensing data 172-27204 ic.as c 237s9e

NORTHROP SERVICES, INC. TR-1075

Section VI

REFERENCES

1. Nagy, G., Shelton, G. and Talaba, J., "Procedural Questions in SignatureAnalysis", Proc. 7 International Symposium on Remote Sensing of En-vironment, May 17-21, 1971.

2, Haralick, R. M. and Kelly, G. L., "Pattern Recognition with MeasurementSpace and Spatial Clustering for Multiple Images", Proc. IEEE, Vol. 57,No. 4, April 1969.

3. Smedes, H. W., Linnerud, H. J., Hawks, S. G., and Woolaver, L. B.,"Digital Computer Mapping of Terrain by Clustering Techniques Using ColorFilm as a Three-Band Sensor", Proc. 7 International Symposium on RemoteSensing of Environment, May 17-21, 1971.

4. Smedes, H. W., Su, M. Y., Jayroe, R. R. et al., "Mapping of Terrain byComputer Clustering Techniques Using Multispectral Scanner Data andUsing Color Films", Proceedings of NASA 4 th Earth Resources ProgramReview, January 17-21, 1972.

5. Schell, J. A., "A Comparison of two Approaches for Category Identificationand Classification Analysis From an Agricultural Scene", paper presentedat the Conference on Earth Resources Observation and Information AnalysisSystem, the University of Tennessee Space Institute, Tullahoma, Tennessee,March 13-14, 1972.

6. Turner, B. J., "Cluster Analysis of MSS Remote Sensor Data", paper pre-sented at the same conference as ref. 5.

7. Su, M. Y., Jayroe, R. R., and Cummings, R. E., "Unsupervised Classifi-cation of Earth Recources Data", paper presented at the same conferencesas reference 5.

8. Fu, K. S., Landgrebe, D. A., and Phillips, T. L., "Information Processingof Remotely Sensed Agricultural Data", Proc. IEEE, Vol. 57, No. 4,April 1969.

9. Su, M. Y., Pooley, J., and Hand, C., "Statistical Algorithms and Com-puter Programs for Multispectral Observations", NASA CR-103182, December1970.

10. Smedes, H. W., Pierce, K. L., Tanguary, M. G., and Hoffer, R. M., "DigitalComputer Terrain Mapping from Multispectral Data, and Evaluation ofProposed Earth Resources Technology Satellite (ERTS) Data Channels,Yellowstone National Park: Preliminary Report", AIAA Paper No. 70-309,March 1970.

6-1

Page 102: UNSUPERVISED CLASSIFICATION OF REMOTE MULTISPECTRAL ... · i (f t , lt tr-220-1075 april 1972 unsupervised classification of remote multispectral sensing data 172-27204 ic.as c 237s9e

NORTHROP SERVICES, INC. TR-1075

11. Su, M. Y., "Algorithms for Sequential Classification of MultispectralObservations into Homogeneous Populations", Northrop-Huntsville Memoran-dum M-794-808, October 1970.

12. Su, M. Y. and Krause, F. R., "Automatic Processing of MultispectralObservations", AIAA Paper No. 71-234, AIAA Integrated Information SystemConference, February 17-19, 1971.

13. Su, M. Y., "A Generalized K-means Algorithm for Clustering MultispectralObservations", Northrop-Huntsville Memorandum M-794-964, June 1971.

14. Gasey, R. C. and Nagy, G., "Advances in Pattern Recognition", ScientificAmerican, Vol. 224, No. 4, April 1971, pp. 56-71.

15. Gasey, R. C. and Nagy, G., "An Autonomous Reading Machine", IEEE Trans.Computers, Vol. C-17, No. 5, May 1968.

16. MacQueen, J., "Some Methods for Classification and Analysis of Multi-spectral Observations", Proc. Fifth Berkeley Symposium Math. Statisticsand Probability, Vol. 1, pp. 281-297, 1967.

17. Ball, G. H., "Data Analysis in the Social Sciences: What about thedetails?", Proc. Fall Joint Computer Conf. pp. 533-559, December 1965.

18. Purdue University, "Remote Multispectral Sensing in Agriculture", LARSVol. 1, No. 4, October 1968.

6-2