united states supreme court florida v. georgia no. 142 ... · jx015 paula viveros bedoya, impacts...

Ex. # Joint Exhibit Description Date Mentioned Date Offered Objection Date AdmittedJX001 Apalachicola, Chattahoochee, and Flint Rivers, GA. And Fla., H.R. Doc No.

342, Letter from the Secretary of War Referred to House Committee on Rivers and Harbors

JX002 Mark Berrigan, Management of Oyster Resources in Apalachicola Bay Following Hurricane Elena, J. Shellfish Research Vol. 7, No. 2

JX003 Mark Berrigan, Biological and Economical Assessment of an Oyster Resource Development Project in Apalachicola Bay, Florida, J. Shellfish Research Vol. 9, No. 1

JX004 Memorandum of Agreement - Alabama, Georgia, Florida, and the U.S. Department of the Army

JX005 Estimated Use of Water in the Apalachicola-Chattahoochee-Flint River Basin during 1990 with State Summaries from 1970 to 1990. USGS. Water-Resources Investigation Report 93-4084. - Marella, R.L., Fanning, J.L., & Mooty, W.S. (1993).

JX006 ACT-ACF RIVER BASINS COMPREHENSIVE STUDY: AGRICULTURAL WATER DEMAND TECHNICAL REPORT (PREPARED BY USDA)

JX007 Ground-Water Resources of the Lower Apalachicola-Chattahoochee-Flint River Basin in Parts of Alabama, Florida, and Georgia - Subarea 4 of the Apalachicola-Chattahoochee-Flint and Alabama-Coosa-Tallapoosa River Basins (Open File Report 95-321)

JX008 ACT/ACF Comprehensive Water Resources Study, Volume 1 - UIFJX009 Georgia House of Representatives - HB 1362 Flint River Drought Protection

ActJX010 Speaker notes re: "For presentation at the ACF Navigation Window Public

meeting 11/20/2000"JX011 Behzad Mortazavi et al., Dissolved organic nitrogen and nitrate in

Apalachicola Bay, Florida: Spatial distributions and monthly budgets, Mar. Ecol. Progr. 2001

JX012 Water Issues White paper, Board of Natural Resources JX013 J. Chanton & F. G. Lewis, Examination of Coupling Between Primary and

Secondary Production, Limnol. & Ocean. 2002JX014 Declaration of Harold ReheisJX015 Paula Viveros Bedoya, Impacts of Temporal Shifts in River Discharge on

Phytoplankton Biomass in Apalachicola BayJX016 Putland, J.N. 2005. Ecology of phytoplankton, Acartia tonsa, and

microzooplankton in Apalachicola Bay, Florida. PhD Dissertation, Florida State University

JX017 Ag Water Pumping Project Report Final ReportJX018 Jones, L.E., and L.J. Torak. Simulated Effects of Seasonal Ground-Water

Pumpage for Irrigation on Hydrologic Conditions in the Lower Apalachicola – Chattahoochee – Flint River Basin, Southwestern Georgia and Parts of Alabama and Florida, 1999–2002, U.S. Geological Survey Scientific Investigations Report 2006-5234.

JX019 Office of Management and Budget Standards and Guidelines for Statistical Surveys (Cantor Dep. Ex. 13)

JX020 Status of Drought Monitoring in Flint River Basin - INTERNAL DRAFT - Memorandum from I. Kim and D. Hawkins to C. Couch

JX021 Flint River Basin Regional Water Development and Conservation Plan

JX022 Ten-Year Resource Management Plan for the Tate’s Hell State Forest – Franklin and Liberty Counties, Florida Dept. of Ag. and Consumer Services – Division of Forestry

JX023 Jennifer Putland & R. L. Iverson, Ecology of Acartia tonsa in Apalachicola Bay, Florida, and implications of river water diversion, Mar Ecol Proc Ser 2007

UNITED STATES SUPREME COURTFLORIDA v. GEORGIA

No. 142, ORIGINALJOINT EXHIBIT LIST

1

Ex. # Joint Exhibit Description Date Mentioned Date Offered Objection Date AdmittedJX024 Press Release: Citing Historic Drought, Georgia EPD Bans Most Outdoor

Water Use in North GeorgiaJX025 Press Release: Governor Perdue Orders Utilities, Permit Holders to Reduce

Water Use by 10 PercentJX026 Final Report - Conservation Innovation GrantsJX027 Mazzotti et al., UF/IFAS, Stressor Response Model for Tape Grass

(Vallisneria americana)JX028 Lee Edmiston et al., Tropical Storm and Hurricane Impacts on a Gulf Coast

Estuary: Apalachicola Bay, Florida, J. Coastal Res. 2008JX029 Edmiston, H.L., A river meets the bay: A characterization of the Apalachicola

River and bay system. Apalachicola National Estuarine Research Reserve, Florida.

JX030 Oyster Resource Assessment Report Apalachicola Bay 2008JX031 Georgia Comprehensive State-Wide Water Management PlanJX032 Ken Moore, SJRWMD, Appendix 9B, Submerged Aquatic Vegetation in the

Lower St John'sRiverJX033 Hook, JE; Hoogenboom, G; Paz, J; Risse, M; Bergstrom, J; Mullen, J.

"Assessing agricultural groundwater needs for the future Identifying irrigated area and sources." In Proceedings of the 2009 Georgia Water Resources Conference. University of Georgia, Athens, GA.

JX034 Oyster Resource Assessment Report North Spur/St. Vincent/Dry Bar Apalachicola Bay, April 2009

JX035 Draft-ag-water-use-summary.PDFJX036 MNG Wastewater Management PlanJX037 Water Supply and Water Conservation Management Plan, Metropolitan

North Georgia Water Planning District, May 2009.JX038 Hook, JE; Conger, S; Horak, A "Agricultural Irrigation Water Demand:

Procedures for measuring irrigated acreage for the baseline year and mapping of individual irrigation fields and water sources." (http://www.nespal.org/SIRP/waterinfo/State/AWD/AgWaterDemand_IrrArea_Detail.htm).

JX039 Agricultural Irrigation Water Demand Forecast: Procedures for Estimating Monthly Irrigation Demands - Hoogenboom, G., et al. (2009)

JX040 Water Contingency Planning Task Force - Appendix IIIJX041 Water Contingency Planning Task Force Final ReportJX042 State Water Plan - Surface Water Availability Resource Assessment -

PowerPoint PresentationJX043 Surface & Groundwater Water Demand by Local Drainage Areas (LDA’s) -

NESPAL; Hook, J.E. (2010). SJX044 Senate Bill 370 - Georgia Water Stewardship ActJX045 Georgia Water Conservation Implementation PlanJX046 USACE, ResSim User’s Manual: Version 3.1, U.S. Army Corps of Engineers

(November 2010) - HEC-RsSim Reservoir System Simulation

JX047 Guidelines for Preparing Economic Analyses JX048 Metro North Georgia 2011 Water Metrics ReportJX049 Summary of the Georgia Agricultural Water Conservation and Metering

Program and Evaluation of Methods Used to Collect and Analyze Irrigation Data for the Middle and Lower Chattahoochee and Flint River Basins, 2004–2010. USGS Scientific Investigations Report 2011–5126 - Torak, LJ; Painter, JA. 2011

JX050 Oyster Resource Assessment Report, Apalachicola Bay 2011JX051 Year 2011 Flint River Drought Protection Act - Memorandum from Wei Zeng

and Inchul Kim to Allen BarnesJX052 Assessment of Recently (2008-2010) Planted Oyster Bars in Apalachicola Bay

JX053 Operational Plan for Black Pearl II

2

Ex. # Joint Exhibit Description Date Mentioned Date Offered Objection Date AdmittedJX054 Gordon, DW; Peck, MF; Painter, JA. Hydrologic and Water-Quality

Conditions in the Lower Apalachicola–Chattahoochee–Flint and Parts of the Aucilla–Suwannee–Ochlockonee River Basins in Georgia and Adjacent Parts of Florida and Alabama During Drought Conditions, July 2011. USGSScientific Investigations Report 2012–5179.

JX055 Email from David Heil to Steve Geiger and Mark Berrigan re: Meeting with NOAA, and attaching document from Mississippi Dept of Marine Resources Flood Operation Plan

JX056 Email from Marc Glatzer to Rob Beaton re: "File Review"JX057 Technical Memorandum on Dougherty Plain Sustainable Yield Groundwater

ModelJX058 Florida Fish & Wildlife Conservation Commission Order - Order No. EO 11-

21 Apalachicola Bay Oyster Harvesting RestrictionsJX059 Status of the Eastern Oyster on Florida's Gulf CoastJX060 October 2011 Assessment of Minor Bars in the Western End of Apalachicola

BayJX061 NOAA. Global Sea Level Rise Scenarios for the United States. In: NOAA

Technical Report OAR CPO-1, National Climate Assessment, Climate Program Office (CPO), Silver Spring, Maryland.

JX062 The Oyster Fishery of the Gulf of Mexico - A Regional Management Plan - 2012 Revision, GSMFC, p. 16-39

JX063 Contemplated ACF Operation Alternatives and Suggested Performance Measures

JX064 Pederson, N., A.R. Bell, T.A. Knight, C. Leland, C. N. Malcomb, K.J.,Anchukaitis, K. Tackett, J. Scheff, A. Brice, B. Catron, and W. Blozan. A long-term perspective on a modern drought in the American Southeast. Environmental Research Letters, 7(1).

JX065 Jerry Hausman, Contingent Valuation: From Dubious to Hopeless, Journal of Economic Perspectives, Vol. 26, No. 4 (Fall 2012), 43-56

JX066 USACE. Apalachicola-Chattahoochee-Flint (ACF) Remand Modeling Technical Report. 2012.http://ww3.sam.usace.army.mil/2012ACF_technicalanalysis.pdf

JX067 Oyster Resource Assessment Report, Apalachicola Bay 2012JX068 Briefing for Jud Turner, Director of Georgia EPDJX069 Press Release: "Georgia EPD Declines Drought Declaration for Flint River

Basin"JX070 Year 2012 Flint River Drought Protection Act - Memorandum from Wei Zeng

and Inchul Kim to Jud TurnerJX071 Jones, L.E., Effects of Groundwater Pumping in the Lower Apalachicola-

Chattahoochee- Flint River Basin. Presented at the AWRA 2012 Spring Specialty Conference, NewOrleans, LA. 26-28.

JX072 USFWS Biological Opinion on the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers, Mobile District, Revised Interim Operations Plan for the Jim Woodruff Dam and Associated Releases to the Apalachicola River

JX073 Georgia DNR Announcement from Judson Turner to Interested Parties re: Suspension of Consideration of Agricultural Withdrawal Permits in Portions of the Lower Flint and Chattahoochee River Basins

JX074 Summary of Oyster Resource Assessment for Apalachicola Bay, September 2012

JX075 Oyster Resources in Apalachicola Bay September 2012JX076 CDM Technical Memorandum - Claiborne and Cretaceous AquifersJX077 Letter from Rick Scott to Secretary of Commerce Blank Requesting Fishery

Disaster Declaration, with AttachmentsJX078 Email from Palmer to Knickerbocker re FW: Oyster Landings, Attaching Gulf

Franklin Oysters spreadsheetJX079 Email from David Heil to Mark Berrigan re Oyster Disaster RequestJX080 CDM Technical Memorandum - Clayton AquiferJX081 FWC Presentation Entitled "Apalachicola Bay Issues - Oysters"

3

Ex. # Joint Exhibit Description Date Mentioned Date Offered Objection Date AdmittedJX082 Application of the Precipitation-Runoff Modeling System (PRMS) in the

Apalachicola-Chattahoochee-Flint River Basin in the Southeastern United States (Scientific Report 2013-5162)

JX083 Peck, MF; Gordon, DW; Painter, JA. Ground-Water Conditions and Studies in Georgia, 2010- 2011." USGS Scientific Investigations Report 2013-5084.

JX084 NWFWMD 2013 Water Supply AsssessmentJX085 Emails between David Heil and Jim Estes re: "Final dep revisions" and

"Oyster Draft; Florida Fish and Wildlife Conservation Commission's 2012-2013 Florida Gulf Coast Oyster Disaster Report (May 2013)

JX086 State of Georgia’s 2013 Water Supply Request with Attached 2013 Affidavit of Judson Turner -Letter from Nathan Deal (Governor, State of Georgia) to Jo-Ellen Darcy (Assistant Secretary of the Army for Civil Works)

JX087 FDEP, February 2011 Addendum to Fish and Wildlife Coordination Act Report

JX088 FDEP, Appendix III to February 2011 Addendum for Fish and Wildlife Coordination Act Report

JX089 Emails between David Heil and Multiple RecipientsJX090 Email from David Heil to Steve Branstetter (NOAA) re: FWC ReportJX091 FWC Florida Gulf Coast Oyster Disaster ReportJX092 Supplemental Document - Appendices, 2012-2013 Florida Gulf Oyster

Disaster, Florida Fish and Wildlife Conservation CommissionJX093 Q #’s - Email from Wei Zeng to Russ PenningtonJX094 Statement of Judson H. Turner - U.S. Senate Committee on Environment and

Public WorksJX095 Derivation of Water Demands in Georgia's January 2013 ACF Water Supply

Request to the Army Corps of Engineers - Memorandum from Wei Zeng to File

JX096 Email from Jim Estes to Roy Crabtree (NOAA) Attaching Letter from Nick Wiley, FWC Report, and Supplemental Appendices

JX097 Email from Jim Estes to David Heil Fowarding NOAA Email Declaring Fishery Disaster

JX098 Florida FWCC Executive Order 13-32, CH 68B-27 FACJX099 Order No. EO 13-33 Rescinded: Delayed Opening of the Season for

Commercial Oyster Harvest for Apalachicola BayJX100 Email from Rob Beaton to Melissa Thompson et al. re FWC enforcement

concernsJX101 Email from Rob Beaton to Melissa Thompson re: Final StatisticsJX102 Development of Model Selection Criteria and Model Recommendations for

Assessing the Environmental Effects of Changes in Freshwater Discharge into Apalachicola Bay - INTERA 2014

JX103 USACE (2013) Incorporating Sea Level Change in Civil Works Programs, U.S. Army Corps of Engineers, ER 1100-2-2013, 18 pp., December 31, 2013

JX104 USGS Georgia Agricultural Water Conservation and Metering Program Website

JX105 Senate Bill 213JX106 Analysis of Stream Inflows to Apalachicola Bay from the Apalachicola River

and Tate's Hell Forest - NWFWMDJX107 Three-Dimensional Hydrodynamic Model Development, Calibration and

Verification of Circulation and Salinity in Apalachicola Bay, FL (Intera 2014)

JX108 Turner Unfounded Concerns Albany Herald JX109 Smit, Reuben. Using sonar habitat mapping and GIS analyses to identify

freshwater mussel habitat and estimate population size of a federally endangered freshwater mussel species, Amblema neislerii, in the Apalachicola River, FL.

JX110 Florida FWCC Executive Order 14-11, CH 68B-27 FACJX111 Order No. Eo 14-12 Restrictions for June 1, 2014 through August 31, 2014 for

Commercial and Recreational Oyster Harvest from the Apalachicola Bay System

4

Ex. # Joint Exhibit Description Date Mentioned Date Offered Objection Date AdmittedJX112 Corps of Engineers' Request for Additional Information for the State of

Georgia's January 11,2013 Water Supply Request - Letter from Judson Turner to Col. Jon Chytka

JX113 Appendix E - HEC ResSim Modeling ReportJX114 Florida FWCC Executive Order 14-18, CH 68B-27 FACJX115 Question on Recent ACF operation - E-mail from Wei Zeng to James Hathorn

JX116 Climate Change Adaptation, Comprehensive Evaluation of Projects with Respect to Sea Level Change - USACE [E.g., McAnally Dep. Ex. 8]

JX117 NWFWMD Consolidated Annual Report 3/1/2015 (http://www.nwfwater.com/Data-Publications/Reports-Plans/Consolidated-Annual-Reports)

JX118 Presentation "Reservoir Management in the Apalachicola-Chattahoochee-Flint Basin"

JX119 Florida FWCC Executive Order 15-13, amendment to 14-18, CH 68B-27 FAC

JX120 Order No. EO 15-14 Restrictions for June 1, 2015 through August 31, 2015 for Commercial and Recreational Oyster Harvest from the Apalachicola Bay System

JX121 Metropolitan North Georgia Water Planning District, Amendments to the Water Supply and Water Conservation Management Plan (through June 16, 2015) (http://northgeorgiawater.org/wp content/uploads/2015/05/Amendments-to-District-Water-Supply-Conservation-Mgmt-Plan June-16-2015.pdf)

JX122 Draft Fish and Wildlife Coordination Act Report on Water Control Manual Updates for the ACF Basin in Georgia, Alabama, and Florida

JX123 Florida FWCC Executive Order 15-18, CH 68B-27 FACJX124 USACE, Draft Environmental Impact Statement (Volumes & Appendices),

Update of the Water Control Manual for the Apalachicola-Chattahoochee-Flint River Basin in Alabama, Florida, and Georgia and a Water Supply Storage Assessment

JX125 GSWCC Metering ProgramJX126 State of Georgia's Updated Water Supply Request with attachmentsJX127 NOAA Mean Sea Level Trend, 8728690 Apalachicola, Florida - NOAA Tides

and Currents Website [E.g., Douglass Dep. Ex. 7, McAnally Dep. Ex. 14]

JX128 USGS Groundwater and Surface water data (http://waterdata.usgs.gov/usa/nwis/)

JX129 (UNDER SEAL)

Wetted Acreage Database 2016

JX130 Figure 9_Monthly SW+GW Withdrawals.xlsxJX131 (Redaction)

NRCS 68-3A75-4-200_CPerry_2004 VRI CIG Final Report2

JX132 (UNDER SEAL)

Georgia’s Agricultural Permit Database

JX133 Tate's Hell State Forest Hydrologic Restoration Plan (Executive Summary, Vol. 1, Vol. 2) [Available Online]

JX134 Operational Plan for Black PearlJX135 Population Estimates from Field Surveys on Selected Winter Harvesting

Apalachicola Bay Oyster BarsJX136 National Estuarine Research Reserve System (NERRS), Centralized Data

Management Office (CDMO). Apalachicola nutrients and water quality datasets (http://cdmo.baruch.sc.edu)

JX137 U.S. Army Corps of Engineers Apalachicola-Chattahochee-Flint River Basin Data

JX138 (UNDER SEAL)

Georgia’s Agricultural Metering Database

JX139 (UNDER SEAL)

Georgia’s Municipal and Industrial Water Permits Database

5

Ex. # Joint Exhibit Description Date Mentioned Date Offered Objection Date AdmittedJX140 GA MIL Data.xlsxJX141 GWPPC Mapped Pivots_Flint Basin.xlsxJX142 Estabrook, R.H., Phytoplankton ecology and hydrography of Apalachicola

Bay. Masters thesis, Florida State University, FL. JX143 USACE. Extended Unimpaired Flow Report January 1994 – December 2001

for the Alabama-Coosa- Tallapoosa and Apalachicola Chattahoochee Flint (ACT/ACF) River Basins. Mobile District, U.S. Army Corps of Engineers, Mobile, Alabama.

JX144 Letter from Couch to Taylor re Corps ACF OperationsJX145 Letter from Couch to Taylor re Request for final decision on IOPJX146 Memorandum from W. Zeng to Couch re FRDPA Declaration JX147 Press Release: No Drought Declaration This Year for Flint River Basin, Says

Georgia EPDJX148 Synopsis Report - Surface Water Availability Assessment.JX149 The impacts of reduced flows on the Apalachicola River and Bay Ecosystems.

Attachment to February 22, 2011 Letter to Imm re Fish and Wildlife Coordination Act Comments

JX150 July 2012 Input for Mark's ReportJX151 Email re Draft oyster management options memo for discussionJX152 Letter from FDEP to Tetra Tech re Comments on ACF Master Water Control

ManualJX153 J. Turner OpEd Draft JX154 EPD Drought Protection in the Lower Flint Basin Stakeholder Meeting

Summary JX155 Talking Points re FRDPA Amendments JX156 Letter from Corps to Turner re Request for Additional Information JX157 American Association for Public Opinion Research, “Standard Definitions

Final Dispositions of Case Codes and Outcome Rates for Surveys"

JX158 July 19, 2016 Letter from P. Singarella to A. Pruitt responding to June 20, 2016 re issues during May 11, 2016 deposition of George Hornberger

JX159 Performance Audit: Combined Sewer Overflow Consent Decree Impact JX160 Groundwater Availability Resource Assessment, Georgia State Water Plan

(www.georgiawaterplanning.org)JX161 Georgia Drought Management Plan JX162 Georgia DNR Release: Level Four Drought Response Continues for Most of

North GeorgiaJX163 Oyster Cultch data (2010-2015)JX164 Memorandum from W. Zeng to J. Turner - Technical Evaluation of Georgia's

2015 Updated Water Supply RequestJX165 Georgia's EPD Consumptive Use Database (M&I Withdrawals, Returns)

JX166 Population Estimates from Field Surveys on Selected Winter Harvesting Apalachicola Bay Oyster Bars

JX167 Edward V. Camp & William E. Pine et al., Collapse of a historic oyster fishery: diagnosing causes and identifying paths toward increased resilience. Ecology and Society 20(3):45 (2015)

JX168 USFWS Biological Opinion on the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers Update of the Water Control Manual for the ACF Basin

JX169 Shellman Farm Data 01-15.xlx

6

Ex. # Florida Exhibit Description Date Mentioned Date Offered Objection Date Admitted

FX-1 Letter to William Westermeyer from Harold ReheisFX-2 Agricultural Wells in the Flint River Basin in Southwest Georgia - Letter to

James E. Butler, Jr. from Harold F. ReheisFX-2a Agricultural Wells in the Flint River Basin in Southwest Georgia - Letter to

James E. Butler, Jr. from Harold F. ReheisFX-3 Response to Letter Regarding Irrigation in South Georgia - Letter to James E.

Buter Jr. from Harold F. ReheisFX-3a Issues of irrigation in South Georgia - Letter to Mr. James E. Butler, Jr. from

Harold F. Reheis FX-4 Talking Points: Future Agricultural Water Use in Southwest Georgia Authenticity; HearsayFX-5 Reheis Statement for Southwest Georgia SummitFX-6 Fisheries Section Comments on Georgia ACF Allocation Formula - Memo to

Harold Reheis from Richard GenningsAuthenticity

FX-7 Water Messages - Circa 2001 Statement by Georgia Environmental Protection Department (“EPD”) Director Harold Reheis

Authenticity; Hearsay

FX-8 Memo to Governor Roy Barnes from Harold ReheisFX-9 Irrigation and the Flint River - Memorandum from Harold Reheis to Governor

Roy BarnesFX-10 Conservation and Natural Resources Legislative Review - GA State University

Law Review (FRDPA History) [Reheis Dep. Ex. 19]Authenticity; Hearsay

FX-12 Questions About Permitted Versus Unpermitted Irrigation Systems - Letter to James Reynolds, III from Harold F. Reheis

FX-14 Southwest Georgia Farm Credit ACA, Memorandum to H. Reheis and B. Kerr re: Water Policy Initiative Meeting


FX-15 Press Release from K. Chambers, re: "Debate over water in the Chattahoochee and Flint River Basins"

Authenticity

FX-16 Information Requests Regarding Flint River Water Issues, Memo from D. Word to Board of Natural Resources with Appendicies

Authenticity

FX-17 The Temporary Suspension of Consideration of New Agricultural Withdrawal Permits in the Flint River Basin in Georgia and the Flint River Drought Protection Act

FX-18 Georgia Water Conditions - Email from N. Caldwell to H. ReheisFX-19 Streamflows - Email from N. Caldwell to K. Chambers, H. Reheis, et al.FX-21 GA WRD Flint River Basin Research and Survey Summary - Presentation by

Rob WellerAuthenticity

FX-22 Review of the Draft Recommendations for the Flint River Basin Regional Water Development and Conservation Plan - Draft Letter to Rob McDowell from Dan Forster

Authenticity; Foundation; Hearsay

FX-23 Letter to Rob McDowell from Dan Forster RE: Review of the Draft Recommendations for the Flint River Basin Regional Water Development and Conservation Plan


FX-24 Lower Flint Ochlockonee Regional Water PlanFX-26 LFO Surface Water Availability Forecasts Authenticity; HearsayFX-27 Memoradum from Hailian Lang to Wei Zeng re: Analysis of Flow Gaps at

Bainbrdige FX-27a Flow Gap at Bainbridge - EPD Presentation FX-27b Analysis of Flow Gaps at Bainbridge - Memorandum from Hailian Liang to

Wei Zeng

Gaps in the FX numbering in the State of Florida's exhibit list reflect documents that became joint exhibits or were removed from Florida's list. Florida did not renumber its exhibits following such changes.


No. 142, ORIGINALFLORIDA EXHIBIT LIST

7

Ex. # Florida Exhibit Description Date Mentioned Date Offered Objection Date AdmittedFX-28 Analysis of Flow Gaps at Bainbridge (2050-NMP RA) - Memorandum from Wei

Zeng to Hailian LiangFX-29 Derivation of Flow Gaps at Bainbridge - Memorandum from Hailian Liang to

Wei ZengFX-35a Letter from G. Carmody to Commissioner ThomasFX-35b Letter from J. Hankinson to Commissioner ThomasFX-35c Letter from J. Hankinson to Commissioner ThomasFX-36 James W. Evans and Russell H. England, "A Recommended Method to Protect

Instream Flows in Georgia," Georgia Department of Natural ResourcesHearsay

FX-37 Flint River Basin Plan Meeting Summary AuthenticityFX-38 Final Recommendation Minumum Stream Flow Work Group AuthenticityFX-40 Letter to M. Windom and H. Lange from L. Hartt re: "Science and Engineering

Advisory Panel (SEAP)"Hearsay

FX-41 Instream Flow Policy in Georgia: An Overview and Recommendations for Reform

Hearsay; Authenticity

FX-42 Estimation of Mussel Population Response to Hydrologic Alteration in a Southeastern U.S. Stream by James T. Peterson, Jason M. Wisniewski, Colin P. Shea, and C. Rhett Jackson

Hearsay

FX-43 About the Director: Judson H. Turner, Director, Environmental Protection Division [Turner Dep. Ex. 1]

FX-45 USGS Flint River at Bainbridge, GA AuthenticityFX-46 Comments on the December 16, 2005 Version of "Recommendations for the

Flint River Basin Regional Water Development and Conservation Plan" - Letter to Rob McDowell from Sandra S. Tucker


FX-46a Comments on the December 16, 2005 Version of "Recommendations for the Flint River Basin Regional Water Development and Conservation Plan" - Letter to Rob McDowell from Sandra S. Tucker


FX-47 Concerns Relating to the Lack of Implementation of Water Resource Management in the Flint River Basin as Outlined in Georgia's Environmental Protection Division's (EPD) Flint River Basin Regional Water and Development Plan (Plan) Finalized in March 2006 - Letter to Carol Couch from Sandra S. Tucker

FX-47a Cconcerns Relating to the Lack of Implementation of Water Resource Management in the Flint River Basin as Outlined in Georgia's Environmental Protection Division's (EPD) Flint River Basin Regional Water and Development Plan (Plan) Finalized in March 2006 - Letter to Carol Couch from Sandra S. Tucker

FX-48 Comments re: the Initial Draft Regional Water Plans Released May 9, 2011 - Letter to Amettia Murphy from Sandra S. Tucker

FX-49 Declaration of David "Woody" Hicks (Jones Center) HearsayFX-49a Email from W. Hicks to R. Royal, M. Masters, D. Wilson re: "Fw: Pending

Drought" (Hicks Decl. Ex. A)Hearsay

FX-49b Water Resources and Security Issues in the Fling River Basin, Georgia EPD Stakeholders Meeting Presentation (Hicks Decl. Ex. B)

Hearsay

FX-49bb Email chain from Woody Hicks to Mark Masters, Cliff Lewis, and Lisa Cowart re: "Fwd: presentation information" (Hicks Decl. Ex. BB)

Hearsay

FX-49c Email from W. Hicks to B. Moore, M. Masters, B. Turner re: "Re: Water Demands Report Approval" (Hicks Decl. Ex. C)

Hearsay

FX-49cc "Crop Data Prepares Drought-Stricken Farmers to Get by with Less" by Suzanne Goldenberg, Mother Jones (Hicks Decl. Ex. CC)

Hearsay

FX-49d Impacts of Agricultural Pumping on Selected Streams in Southwestern Georgia - David Hicks & Stephen Golladay, JW Jones (Hicks Decl. Ex. D)

Hearsay

FX-49d1 Impacts of Agricultural Pumping on Selected Streams in Southwestern Georgia - David Hicks & Stephen Golladay, JW Jones (Hicks Decl. Ex. D1)

Hearsay

8

Ex. # Florida Exhibit Description Date Mentioned Date Offered Objection Date AdmittedFX-49d1-a Impacts of Agricultural Pumping on Selected Streams in Southwestern

Georgia by David Hicks and Stephen GolladayHearsay

FX-49d1-b Impacts of Agricultural Pumping on Selected Streams in Southwestern Georgia by David Hicks and Stephen Golladay

Hearsay

FX-49dd "Stakeholders' proposals might settle tri-state 'Water Wars' dispute out of court" by Terry Lewis, Albany Herald (Hicks Decl. Ex. DD)

Hearsay

FX-49e Stream Flow Changes Associated with Water Use and Climatic Variation in the Lower Flint River Basin, Southwest Georgia - Stephen Golladay, David Hicks, & T.K. Munez (Hicks Decl. Ex. E)

Hearsay

FX-49e-a Stream Flow Changes Associated with Water Use and Climatic Variation in the Lower Flint River Basin, Southwest Georgia. In re 2007 Proceedings of the Georgia Water Resources Conference. Rasmussen, T.C., Carroll, G.D., & Georgakakos A.P. (eds.). - Golladay, S.W., Hicks, D.W., & Muenz, T.K. (2007)

Hearsay

FX-49ee "Water plan based on false projections, hydrologist says " by John Oxford, The Moultrie Observer (Hicks Decl. Ex. EE)

Hearsay

FX-49f Effects of Irrigation Withdrawals on Streamflows in a Karst Environment: Lower Flint River Basin, Georgia, USA - Kathleen Rugel, C. Rhett Jackson, Joshua Romeis, Stephen Golladay, David Hicks, & John Dowd (Hicks Decl. Ex. F)

Hearsay

FX-49f-a Journal Article "Effects of Irrigation Withdrawals on Streamflows in a karst environment: Lower Flint River Basin, Georgia, USA" by Kathleen Rugel, C. Rhett Jackson, J. Joshua Romeis, Stephen Golladay, David Hicks and John Dowd

Hearsay

FX-49ff "River advocates oppose Flint reservoir expansion" by Jim Wallace, WALB.com (Hicks Decl. Ex. FF)

Hearsay

FX-49g Indicators of Long Term Hydrologic Change in the Flint River - Stephen Golladay & David Hicks (Hicks Decl. Ex. G)

Hearsay

FX-49gg "Whose Water Is It?" by Barbara Fairchild, Klamath Bucket Brigade (from AgWeb) (Hicks Decl. Ex. GG)

Hearsay

FX-49h Hydrologic Change in the Lower Flint River Basin and Responses of Freshwater Mussels to Drought - Stephen Golladay & David Hicks (Hicks Decl. Ex. H)

Hearsay

FX-49i Stream Habitat and Mussel Populations Adjacent to AAWCM Sites in the Lower Flint River Basin: Project Report - Stephen Golladay, David Hicks, Nathalie Smith, & Brian Clayton (Hicks Decl. Ex. I)

Hearsay

FX-49j Effects of Land-use on Groundwater Quality in Springs of the Upper Floridan Aquifer - Stephanie Allums, Stephen Opsahl, Stephen Golladay & David Hicks (Hicks Decl. Ex. J)

Hearsay

FX-49k Water Monitoring Network in the Chickasawhatchee Swamp, Southwest Georgia - Brian Clayton & David Hicks (Hicks Decl. Ex. K)

Hearsay

FX-49l Assessment of Stream Habitat in the Flint River Basin - Stephen Opsahl, Stephen Golladay & David Hicks, Brian Clayton, & Kimberly Cressman, JW Jones (Hicks Decl. Ex. L)

Hearsay

FX-49m Use of Historic Data to Evaluate Effects of Pumping Stress on Streams in Southwest Georgia - Kathleen Rugel, Joshua Romeis, C. Rhett Jackson, Stephen Golladay, David Hicks, & John Dowd (Hicks Decl. Ex. M)

Hearsay

FX-49n Mussel Population Surveys and Estimation of Potential Stream Withdrawals at Selected Sites in the Lower Flint River Basin - Stephen Golladay & David Hicks, JW Jones (Hicks Decl. Ex. N)

Hearsay

FX-49n-a Mussel Population Surveys and Estimation of Potential Stream Withdrawals at Selected Sites in the Lower Flint River Basin. Dep’t of Nat. Res., Envtl. Prot. Div., Ga. Geol. Survey - Golladay, S.W., & Hicks, D.W. (2003).

Hearsay

9

Ex. # Florida Exhibit Description Date Mentioned Date Offered Objection Date AdmittedFX-49o Letter from Paul B. Krebs & Associates, Inc. to Jerry Usry re: "Report

Manuscript for PBK Project 00647," enclosing Distribution of Permitted Agricultural Water Use and Water Availability in the Flint River Basin, Southwestern Georgia, Flint River Water Planning & Policy Center (Hicks Decl. Ex. O)

Hearsay

FX-49p Using Sustainable Boundary Approach (SBA) to Assess and Develop Flow Guidelines: The Flint River, Georgia - Stephen Golladay & David Hicks (Hicks Decl. Ex. P)

Hearsay

FX-49q "The Natural History of the Flint River" by David Hicks and Stephen Golladay, Sherpa Guides article (Hicks Decl. Ex. Q)

Hearsay

FX-49r Email from Kristin Rowles to Stephen Simpson re: "Fwd: Flint Model" (Hicks Decl. Ex. R)

Hearsay

FX-49s Email from Kristin Rowles to Woody Hicks, cc'ing Bradford Moore; Aris Georgakokus; Steve Simpson; and ACF Stakeholders Administrator, re: "UIF Report Conclusions" (Hicks Decl. Ex. S)

Hearsay

FX-49u Email from Woody Hicks to Mark Masters re: "Re: acfs" (Hicks Decl. Ex. U) Hearsay

FX-49v Email from Aris Georgakakos to Mark Masters and Bradford Moore, Woody Hicks, cc'ing Steve Simpson; Robert Osborne, re: "ARC Comments on UIF Report" and attaching ARCMemo-UIF-090514Final.pdf (Hicks Decl. Ex. V)

Hearsay

FX-49x Email chain from Woody Hicks to Gordon Rogers, cc'ing Dan Tonsmiere; Laura Hartt; and ACF Stakeholders Administrator, re: "Re: Lower Flint Drought Flows" (Hicks Decl. Ex. X)

Hearsay

FX-50 Effects of Reduced Summertime Stream Flows on Instream Habitat in the Lower Flint River Basin, Georgia, USA. In re Proceedings of the 2015 Georgia Water Resources Conference. McDowell, R.J., Pruitt, C.A., Bahn, R.A. (eds.). Univ. of Ga. Inst. of Ecology. Athens, Ga. - McCormick, P.V. & Cowart Baron, L. (2015).

Hearsay

FX-51 Stream Habitat and Mussel Populations Adjacent to AAWCM Sites in the Lower Flint River Basin. In re Proceedings of the 2015 Georgia Water Resources Conference. McDowell, R.J., Pruitt, C.A., Bahn, R.A. (eds.). Univ. of Ga. Inst. of Ecology. Athens, Ga. - Smith, N.D., Golladay, S.W., Clayton, B.A. & Hicks, D.W. (2015).

Hearsay

FX-52 ACT/ACF Briefing Georgia Congressional Delegation Questions and Answers Authenticity; Foundation; Hearsay

FX-53 Assessment of Feasibility of Augmenting Lower Flint River Stream Flows With Groundwater - Memorandum from James L. Kennedy, Ph.D., P.G., State Geologist to F. Allen Barnes Director, Environmental Protection Division

FX-54 EPD - Strategy Memo (w/ Handwritten Notes)FX-55 Lower Flint-Ochlockonee Regional Water Planning Council: Camilla, GA

Chamber of Commerce Meeting SummaryHearsay

FX-56 Current Conditions - FRDPA Memorandum (2012) Authenticity; HearsayFX-57 Governor's Water Supply Program: Evaluating Round I Foundation; HearsayFX-58 FRDPA Policy Analysis NotesFX-60 Crop Advisors Talking PointsFX-61 Georgia's State Water Plan, Lower Flint-Ochlockonee Regional Water Council,

Meeting Summary: June 28, 2013Authenticity; Hearsay

FX-62 Gonzalez-Alvarez, Yassert, et al. "Farm-Level Irrigation and the Marginal Cost of Water Use: Evidence from Georgia", Journal of Environmental Management 80 (2006) 311–317.

Hearsay

FX-63 Evaluation of Options for Managing Groundwater Withdrawal Reductions in Lower FRB - Memorandum from James Kennedy

Foundation; Hearsay

FX-65 A Report on the Third State Advisory Committee Meeting Submitted to the Environmental Protection Division by the Fanning Institute

FX-66 The Link Between Science and Policy in Water Management in Georgia by Nap Caldwell

10

Ex. # Florida Exhibit Description Date Mentioned Date Offered Objection Date AdmittedFX-67 Flint Studies Work Plan - Draft Agenda for Kickoff Meeting (Attachment:

Kickoff Meeting Sutline 06272014.docx) - Emails Between Gail Cowie and Jud Turner (cc: Mary Walker and James Capp)

FX-68 Flint Studies Work Plan (Attachment: Lower Flint Action Items and Schedule 06232014.docx) - Email from Gail Cowie to Jud Turner (cc: Mary Walker and James Capp)

FX-69 Drought Meeting With Stakeholders 11.21.14 – Jones Center, Cliff Notes (Cowie Annotated)

FX-69a Drought Meeting with Stakeholders 11-21-14 - Jones Center, Cliff Notes

FX-70 Email from Gail Cowie to Nap Caldwell, Jim Kennedy, Wei Zeng, Russ Pennington, and Cliff Lewis - Flint Studies Plan (Attachments: Flint Studies Potential Contractors 09082014.docx; Lower Flint Studies Plan.docx)

FX-72 Flint Basin Streamflow Letters (Attachments: List of affected permits.xlsx; low_flow_drought_letter_vS.doc) - Email from Cliff Lewis to James Capp, Gail Cowie, and Nap Caldwell

FX-73 USGS Ichawaynochaway at Milford Gage Data AuthenticityFX-74 USGS Spring Creek Reynoldsville Gage Data AuthenticityFX-75 USGS Spring Creek Iron City Gage Data AuthenticityFX-76 Assessment of Biological Integrity Requirements - Memorandum from

Georgakakos to US EPAFoundation; Hearsay

FX-77 Pending Drought (w/ attachment: Fw: Pending Drought.txt) - Email from Tim Cash to Cliff Lewis and Wei Zeng

Hearsay

FX-78 Year 2011 Flint River Drought Protection Act - Memorandum from Wei Zeng and Inchul Kim to Allen Barnes

FX-79 Preparations for Flint River Drought Protection Act Auction - Email from T. Cash to T. Jackson

FX-81 Georgia EPD News Release - EPD Declining Use of FRDPA 2011 - Email from Tim Cash to Clay Burdette and others

FX-82 Groundwater Conditions in Southwest Georgia and Low Flow in the Flint River in the Apalachicola-Chattahoochee-Flint River Basin - Memorandum from Wei Zeng to Allen Barnes

FX-83 Year 2012 Flint River Drought Protection Act - Memorandum from Wei Zeng and Inchul Kim to Jud Turner

FX-84 Fodder for BC Memo to Director Re FRDPA '12 ActionsFX-85 Fodder for BC Memo to Director Re FRDPA '12 Actions Authenticity; Improper Compilation of

Multiple DocumentsFX-86 Fodder for BC Memo to Director re: FRDPA '12 ActionsFX-87 Kennedy's Modifications (18 Feb) AuthenticityFX-88 Wei's Modifications (18 Feb '12)FX-89 Year 2012 Flint River Drought Protection Act - Memorandum from Wei Zeng

and Inchul Kim to Jud TurnerFX-93 Status of Drought Monitoring in the Flint River Basin and Potential

Implementation of the Flint River Drought Protection Act - Memorandum (Draft) from Wei Zeng and Inchul Kim to Carol Couch

FX-94 GDNR Draft Press Release: "No Drought Declaration This Year For Flint River Basin, Savs Georgia EPD"

FX-95 Georgia EPD Declares Level Two Drought Statewide with Attachments - Email from C. Couch to T. Irvin, et al.

FX-96 Major Disaster Request From Gov. Sonny Perdue to President George W. Bush re: Drought

FX-97 Critical LFRB Mussel Reaches (Attachment: LFRP High Priority Mussel Reaches.docx) - Emails from M. Harris to N. Caldwell and G. Cowie, cc: B. Albanese, D. Forster, J. Wisniewski

Hearsay

FX-98 Critical LFRB Mussel Reaches - Email from Jason Wisniewski to Mike Harris

11

Ex. # Florida Exhibit Description Date Mentioned Date Offered Objection Date AdmittedFX-99 Impacts of Federally Listed Mussels to Georgia - PowerPoint Presentation

FX-100 Sensitive Biological Sites - Email from James Peterson to Mike Harris and Rhett Jackson

FX-101 Radium Aprings Fauna Count - Email from Kelly Jessop to Rob Weller and C. Mathis

Hearsay

FX-102 The Effects of the 2000 Drought on Freshwater Mussels in the Lower Flint River Basin. In re 2003 Proceedings of the Georgia Water Resources Conference. Hatcher, K.J. (ed.) - Golladay, S.W., et al. (2003)

Foundation; Hearsay; Authenticity

FX-103 Email from Mike Harris to Tim Cash and Linda MacGregor RE: Sawhatchee Creek - Help Needed

Hearsay

FX-104 Monitoring of Endangered Freshwater Mussels in Southwest Georgia - Project Statement for Project Title

FX-105 Handwritten Documents by Jason Wisniewski dated Mar. 9, 2004 and Mar. 8, 2005

Authenticity; Foundation

FX-106 Protecting a Spring on the Flint River in Order to Enhance Habitat for the Gulf Striped Bass - Letter to James from John Kilpartrick

FX-107 Information Paper from Field Supervisor, FWS-Georgia Ecological Services to Director, Georgia EPD RE Spring Creek and Irrigation in Southwest Georgia

FX-108 Email from Jason Wisniewski to Mike Harris (cc: Andrew GaschoLandis and Brett Albanese) RE: Flint HCP Documents (with attachment: Bibliography for Technical Advisory Committee_amgl.docx; Conservation options for LRFB mussels_02.docx)

FX-109 Ensuring Sustainable Water Supplies into the Future: Perspectives on Managing Consumptive Use by N. Caldwell, S. Udvardy, K. Jacobs, D. Jenkins and M. Smith, 2007 Georgia Water Resources Conference

Hearsay; Authenticity; Foundation

FX-110 6995 River Road 311712.89 841832.75 (2) Foundation; Authenticity; Relevance; Not Produced in Discovery

FX-111 Small RH 305755 844634 Foundation; Authenticity; Relevance; Not Produced in Discovery

FX-112 Small GM 310547845143 Foundation; Authenticity; Relevance; Not Produced in Discovery

FX-113 Small DM 31.266620, -84.148633 Foundation; Authenticity; Relevance; Not Produced in Discovery

FX-114 Picture 4 Foundation; Authenticity; Relevance; Not Produced in Discovery

FX-115 Small GM 31 11 29 N, 84 34 7 W Foundation; Authenticity; Relevance; Not Produced in Discovery

FX-116 022.jpg Foundation; Authenticity; Relevance; Not Produced in Discovery

FX-117 Cordell GA Authenticity; Foundation; Relevance; Not Produced in Discovery

FX-118 IMG_0104 Foundation; Authenticity; Relevance; Not Produced in Discovery


12

Ex. # Florida Exhibit Description Date Mentioned Date Offered Objection Date AdmittedFX-120 Albany 52 Foundation; Authenticity; Relevance;

Not Produced in Discovery



FX-123 Picture 2.jpg Foundation; Authenticity; Relevance; Not Produced in Discovery

FX-124 Small Wright Farms 312703.02 840606.88-E Foundation; Authenticity; Relevance; Not Produced in Discovery


FX-126 IMG0099 Foundation; Authenticity; Relevance; Not Produced in Discovery

FX-127 Small DM 31.179006, -84.393335 Foundation; Authenticity; Relevance; Not Produced in Discovery

FX-128 Sumter County Ordinance re: Irrigation Systems Hearsay; Authenticity; FoundationFX-129 Sumter County Ordinance Discussion Hearsay; Authenticity; FoundationFX-130 Sumter County Ordinance Repeal Hearsay; Authenticity; FoundationFX-131 MIller County Irrigation Resolution Hearsay; Authenticity; FoundationFX-132 Miller County Minutes Hearsay; Authenticity; FoundationFX-133 Seminole Irrigation End Gun Ordinance Hearsay; Authenticity; FoundationFX-134 Seminole County Irrigation End-Gun-Shutoff Ordinance (Seminole County

Code Sec. 42-130 et seq.)Hearsay; Authenticity; Foundation

FX-135 Miller County Resolution 15-1012 Hearsay; Authenticity; FoundationFX-136 E. Robinson, "Some Georgia Center Pivots Pulsing with Precision" HearsayFX-137 Proposed Designation of the Upper Apalachicola River as an Outstanding

Florida Water FX-138 UNESCO, Biosphere Reserves: The Seville Strategy & The Statutory

Framework of the World Network Foundation; Hearsay

FX-139 Fulfilling the Three Functions - UNESCO Hearsay; Foundation; AuthenticityFX-140 Florida Dept. of Environmental Regulation, Report on Special Streams Foundation; AuthenticityFX-141 Resolution of the Florida Board of Trustees on Aquatic Preserves Hearsay; Foundation; AuthenticityFX-142 Florida Inter-Agency Advisory Committee on Submerged Land Management, A

Proposed System of Aquatic PreservesHearsay; Foundation; Authenticity

FX-143 Map of Conservation Lands, Florida ACFFX-144 Phaneuf Report - Land Transaction TableFX-145 Collected History of Apalachicola River Land Projects in CARL, P-2000 and

Florida ForeverHearsay

FX-145a Florida Department of Environmental Protection, "Florida Forever" - Background

Hearsay

FX-146 ANF Map (https://catalog.data.gov/dataset/u-s-forest-service-land-units) Not Produced in DiscoveryFX-147 Proposed Hydrologic Restoration Plan for the Apalachicola River Wildlife and

Environmental Area ReportFX-148 Florida Fish and Wildlife Conservation Commission. 2014. “A Management

Plan for Apalachicola River Wildlife and Environmental Area 2014 - 2024.”

FX-149 Mobile Irrigation Lab (MIL) Program - Summary of Results, July 2009 - September 2015

FX-150 Mobile Irrigation Lab (MIL) Handbook

13

Ex. # Florida Exhibit Description Date Mentioned Date Offered Objection Date AdmittedFX-151 Apalachicola National Estuarine Reserve - Management PlanFX-152 Hydrologic Restoration Activities in Apalachichola River Wildlife and

Environmental AreaFX-153 Listed Species of Apalachicola National Estuarine Research ReserveFX-154 UNESCO, Biosphere Reserve Information: Central Gulf Coast PlainFX-155 FDEP Organizational ChartFX-156 Farr, J. and Brock, O. (2006). "Florida’s Landmark Programs for Conservation

and Recreation Land Acquisition," Sustain, Vol. 14 (Spring/Summer 2006)

FX-157 Georgia EPD Program DirectoryFX-158 Watershed Protection Branch Contact Information - September 2015FX-159 Watershed Protection Branch Contact Information - July 2016FX-160 Permit Breakdown by RWC Counties and SubbasinsFX-162 Agricultural Water MeteringFX-163 FYl5 Ag Water Metering Program - Email from Gail Cowie to Turner, Jud;

Walker, MaryFX-164 Managing Agricultural Water Use During Drought: An Analysis of

Contemporary Policies Governing Georgia's Flint River BasinHearsay

FX-165 Soil Distribution Table: Irrigated Parcels in Georgia ACF (Developed from USDA SSURGO Database V. 2.3.2, Combined Tabular ("Horizon", "Component", and "Map Unit" tables) and Spatial ("soilmu_a_xxx" ESRI shapefile) Data - http://www.nrcs.usda.gov/wps/portal/nrcs/detail/soils/survey/geo/?cid=nrcs142p2_053631)

Foundation; Authenticity; Hearsay

FX-166 AWC Maps for Georgia ACF Counties - Flint River Basin Counties and Irrigated Areas [E.g., Irmak Dep. Ex. 16, 18] (Developed from USDA SSURGO Database V. 2.3.2, Combined Tabular ("Horizon", "Component", and "Map Unit" tables) and Spatial ("soilmu_a_xxx" ESRI shapefile) Data - http://www.nrcs.usda.gov/wps/portal/nrcs/detail/soils/survey/geo/?cid=nrcs142p2_053631)

Foundation; Authenticity; Hearsay; Not Produced in Discovery

FX-167 Soil Distribution Tables for Georgia ACF Counties [E.g. , Irmak Dep. Ex. 17, 19] (Developed from USDA SSURGO Database V. 2.3.2, Combined Tabular ("Horizon", "Component", and "Map Unit" tables) and Spatial ("soilmu_a_xxx" ESRI shapefile) Data - http://www.nrcs.usda.gov/wps/portal/nrcs/detail/soils/survey/geo/?cid=nrcs142p2_053631)


FX-168 Shellman Farm Data Irrigation Depths Authenticity; FoundationFX-169 Tifton is State Soil RelevanceFX-170 NRCS AWC DefinitionFX-171 Geospatial Data GatewayFX-172 Welcome to Web Soil Survey (WSS)FX-173 Geospatial Data Gateway - Order by CountyFX-174 Screenshot of Available Soil Data for Georgia from USDA Geospatial Data

GatewayNot Produced in Discovery

FX-175 Screenshot from Web Soil Survey Showing Area of Interest for Parcel in Baker County


FX-176 Screenshots of Mapped AWC Values and AWC Values Reported for Selected Area of Interest in Baker County, GA


FX-177 Description of SSURGO DatabaseFX-178 USDA NRCS Web Soil Survey (Sample Screenshot Provided As Exhibit;

Florida Is Using Data From WSS)FX-179 USDA NRCS - Web Soil Survey 3.0 - New FeaturesFX-180 Florida AWC Distribution Table (Developed from USDA SSURGO Database V.

2.3.2, Combined Tabular ("Horizon", "Component", and "Map Unit" tables) and Spatial ("soilmu_a_xxx" ESRI shapefile) Data - http://www.nrcs.usda.gov/wps/portal/nrcs/detail/soils/survey/geo/?cid=nrcs142p2_053631)

Hearsay; Authenticity; Foundation; Not Produced in Discovery

14

Ex. # Florida Exhibit Description Date Mentioned Date Offered Objection Date AdmittedFX-181 Florida AWC Maps with ACF Boundary (Developed from USDA SSURGO

Database V. 2.3.2, Combined Tabular ("Horizon", "Component", and "Map Unit" tables) and Spatial ("soilmu_a_xxx" ESRI shapefile) Data - http://www.nrcs.usda.gov/wps/portal/nrcs/detail/soils/survey/geo/?cid=nrcs142p2_053631)

Foundation; Authenticity; Not Produced in Discovery

FX-182 Florida AWC Maps without ACF Boundary (Developed from USDA SSURGO Database V. 2.3.2, Combined Tabular ("Horizon", "Component", and "Map Unit" tables) and Spatial ("soilmu_a_xxx" ESRI shapefile) Data - http://www.nrcs.usda.gov/wps/portal/nrcs/detail/soils/survey/geo/?cid=nrcs142p2_053631)

Foundation; Authenticity; Not Produced in Discovery

FX-183 2014 State Map Water Management Status: NRD Groundwater Regulations Across Nebraska

Relevance; Foundation

FX-184 Cornhusker Economics, University of Nebraska-Lincoln Extension, Republican River Dry-Year Plans


FX-185 Republican River, Rapid Response Integrated Management Plan Relevance; FoundationFX-186 AWC Maps in Nebraska Counties (Developed from USDA SSURGO Database

V. 2.3.2, Combined Tabular ("Horizon", "Component", and "Map Unit" tables) and Spatial ("soilmu_a_xxx" ESRI shapefile) Data - http://www.nrcs.usda.gov/wps/portal/nrcs/detail/soils/survey/geo/?cid=nrcs142p2_053631)

Relevance; Foundation; Not Produced in Discovery

FX-187 AWC Distribution in Nebraska Counties (Developed from USDA SSURGO Database V. 2.3.2, Combined Tabular ("Horizon", "Component", and "Map Unit" tables) and Spatial ("soilmu_a_xxx" ESRI shapefile) Data - http://www.nrcs.usda.gov/wps/portal/nrcs/detail/soils/survey/geo/?cid=nrcs142p2_053631)

Relevance; Hearsay; Foundation; AuthenticityNot Produced in Discovery

FX-188 Nebraska's Climate Assessment Response Committee (CARC) Drought Mitigation and Response Plan

Relevance; Hearsay; Foundation; Authenticity

FX-189 N-CORPE Nebraska Cooperative Republican Platte Enhancement. Relevance; Authenticity; HearsayFX-191 Draft Presentation for GA Chamber Board Meeting - January 11, 2010 with

attachments - Email from Katie Kirkpatrick to Tim Lowe IIIHearsay

FX-193 Water Contingency Planning Task Force Comments Received from Task Force Members and Other Interested Parties

Hearsay

FX-194 Water Contingency Planning Task Force Submissions Received from Task Force Members and Other Interested Parties

Hearsay

FX-195b Supplemental Memorandum of Agreement between Alabama, Florida, Georgia and The United States Department of The Army

FX-196 1983 Memorandum of Agreement Among Alabama, Georgia, Florida and the United States Army Corps of Engineers, Mobile District Regarding the Apalachicola-Chattahoochee-Flint River System

FX-197 ACT-ACF Comprehensive Study, Municipal and Industrial Water Use Forecasts, Final Report, Summary Report

FX-199 Primary Statements of ACF River Basin Commission Meeting Authenticity; HearsayFX-200 MEMORANDUM FROM REHEIS (GA DNR) TO GRAHAM BARR ET ALL

RE: ACT AND ACF COMPREHENSIVE STUDY AGRICULTURAL WATER DEMAND ADDENDUM

FX-201 Press Release from State of Georgia 1-3-92FX-202 ACF/ACT Comprehensive Study - Agricultural Water Demand Executive

SummaryFX-203 ACF/ACT Comprehensive Study - Memo from H. Reheis to S. WhiteFX-204 Concerning Request for the Mobile District, USACE Approval Actions for

Water Withdrawals from Lake Lanier, Georgia - Letter from W. Vogel to R. Seder

FX-205 Remarks of Gov. Zell Miller at the Inaugural Meetings of the Apalachicola-Chattahoochee-Flint Compact Commission

FX-206 Handwritten Notes of ACF - "How do we get range?"

15

Ex. # Florida Exhibit Description Date Mentioned Date Offered Objection Date AdmittedFX-207 MOA Extension ACT/AGF Comprehensive Study - Memorandum from Nolton

G. Johnson to Harold F. ReheisFX-208 Letter to Honorable Henry J. Hyde, Chairman from G. Robert Kerr, Director

RE: presentations on behalf of Georgia to the House FX-209 Apalachicola-Chattahoochee-Flint River Basin CompactFX-210 Letter from Robert Bomar to Perry Odom and William Cox 11-4-96FX-211 Methods Used In Estimating Municipal/Industrial and Agricultural Water

Demands in the Georgia Portions of the ACT/ACF BasinsFX-212 Strawman for ACF Basin - Letter from D. Barr to H. ReheisFX-213 Comparison of Different Municipal and Industrial Demand Projections Being

Utilized by the States for the ACF Allocation FormulaAuthenticity; Foundation

FX-214 Consumptive Use Data Support for Governor's Briefing of 5/5/99 - Planning Unit WRMP Form 1.1 Document Log-In

FX-215 ACF & ACT Compact Water Allocation Agreements - Letter from N. Johnson to H. Reheis

FX-216 Email from Dee Ann Miller to Multiple Recipients, Attaching Press Release and Q&A

FX-217 Exiting the Apalachicola-Chattahoochee-Flint Rivers Water Allocation Compact, Statement by David Struhs


FX-218 Press Release, "SECRET PLAN ILLEGAL - Florida condemns closed-door water deal"

FX-219 ACF Compact Commission Meeting with Attachments - Letter from H. Reheis to T. Glen and D. Struhs - Verification of Irrigated Acreage and Associated Water Use in the Chattahoochee and Flint River Basins, 1999-2003 (Draft status report). Environmental Protection Division (GA EPD), Agricultural Permitting Unit.

FX-220 GDNR Tax Form from J. Rockamore to T. Silliman (April 2003 Correspondence from Governor Riley and D. Struhs)


FX-221 Memorandum from G. Robert Kerr & Harold F. Reheis to Governor's Advisory Council on Tri-State Water Issues & Georgia Stakeholders RE: ACF Commission Meeting; Notes from "4/29/03 Meeting w/ EPD"

FX-222 Turner's Handwritten Notes of 4/4/2012 Georgia's Meeting with FloridaFX-224 Georgia’s Water Resources: A Blueprint for the Future (Revised Draft

12/5/2007) - EPD's Draft Submission to the Water CouncilFX-225 Flint River Basin Agricultural Water Withdrawal Permitting DRAFTFX-227 Draft Suspension Statement for Review - Emails from Gail Cowie to Cliff

Lewis, Kevin Chambers, and Nap CaldwellFX-228 Draft - Temporary Suspension of Ag Withdrawal Application Consideration in

Lower Flint - Email from N. Caldwell to L. MacGregor, G. Cowie, et al.Authenticity

FX-229 Info on Pending Permits in Suspension Area - Emails between Gail Cowie and Cliff Lewis

FX-230 Surface Water, Groundwater,and Well-to-Pond Ag Water Use Permits and Applications in the FRB Suspension Areas of 2012 - Data Request for Gail Cowie and Cliff Lewis of EPD

FX-231 Proposed Revised Protocol for the Flint River Drought Protection Act Severe Drought Declaration - Memorandum (Draft) from James L. Kennedy, Ph.D., P.G., State Geologist to F. Allen Barnes


FX-232 Value of Drought Prediction for the Management for the ACF River Basin - Technical Report by The Georgia Water Resources Institute/Georgia Tech

Hearsay

FX-234 Changes to Flint River Drought Protection Act - Emails Between Glenn Cox and Cliff Lewis


FX-235 Email from Gail Cowie to Jim Ussery RE: Legislation?FX-237 Potential Revisions to Flint River Drought Protection Act - DRAFTFX-238 Metropolitan North Georgia Water Planning District, Governing Board

Meeting Notes and MinutesAuthenticity; Foundation; Hearsay

16

Ex. # Florida Exhibit Description Date Mentioned Date Offered Objection Date AdmittedFX-239 Stream Flow Forecasting Capability as Part of Potential Revision to FRDPA

and Beyond - Zeng to Ussery MemorandumFX-240 Action on Proposed Amendments to Rules for Flint River Drought Protection,

Chapter 391-3-28 - Memorandum from Judson Turner to Board of Natural Resources

FX-241 Assistance by Revising the Flint River Drought Protection Act - Letter to Judson H. Turner, Director from S. Gordon Rogers and Glenn Dowling

FX-241a Assistance by Revising the Flint River Drought Protection Act - Letter to Judson H. Turner, Director from S. Gordon Rogers and Glenn Dowling

FX-241b Assistance by Revising the Flint River Drought Protection Act - Letter to Judson H. Turner, Director from S. Gordon Rogers and Glenn Dowling

FX-242 Dirty Dozen 2011: A Call to Action, Georgia Water Coalition Hearsay; AuthenticityFX-242a Dirty Dozen 2011: A Call to Action, Georgia Water CoalitionFX-244 Projected Future Treated Wastewater Returns for the Chattahoochee River

and Lake Lanier System - Memorandum from Katherine Zitsch to Jud Turner

FX-246 Response to Army Corps of Engineers Request for Additional Information dated 2/11/2014 - Memorandum from Wei Zeng to Jud Turner

FX-248 ACF Water Supply Request Demand - Email from Hailian Liang to Dongha Kim

FX-249 Bainbridge Climate and Streamflow in Notable Drought Years (NOAA Weather Data for GA ACF; USGS Bainbridge Gage)


FX-250 flint_at_bainbridge.xlsx - Bainbridge Gage Chart Backup Foundation; Authenticity; Hearsay; Not Produced in Discovery

FX-251 Streamflow Characteristics at Selected Sites in SW Georgia (2010) - USGS 2011-1278

FX-252 Climate and Streamflow in Notable Drought Years (NOAA Weather Data for GA ACF) - Chattahoochee Gage

Authenticity; Foundation; Inadmissible demonstrative

FX-253 Irmak_depo_hydro_table_ac_20160721.xlsx - Source of Stavins Ex. 21 Foundation; Authenticity; Hearsay; Not Produced in Discovery

FX-254a Jones Center - Flint River Pictures #1 Foundation; Authenticity FX-254b Jones Center - Flint River Pictures #2 Foundation; Authenticity FX-254c Jones Center - Flint River Pictures #3 Foundation; Authenticity FX-254d Jones Center - Flint River Pictures #4 Foundation; Authenticity FX-254e Jones Center - Flint River Pictures #5 Foundation; Authenticity FX-255 Declaration of Paul Gagnon (Jones Center) HearsayFX-256 Declaration of Stephen W. Golladay (Jones Center) HearsayFX-259 USGS Surface-Water Monthly Statistics for 02356000 Flint River at

Bainbridge, GA Foundation; Authenticity

FX-260 USGS Surface-Water Monthly Statistics for 02357000 Spring Creek near Iron City, GA (Historic)

Foundation; Authenticity

FX-261 USGS Surface-Water Monthly Statistics for 02353500 Ichawaynochaway Creek at Milford, GA (Historic)


FX-262 Email from James Peterson to Mike Harris and Rhett Jackson RE: Flint River Fish Modeling


FX-263 ACF Compact - Memo from D. Waller to H. Reheis and B. KerrFX-264 Claiborne Aquifer Map Foundation; Authenticity; HearsayFX-265 Elliott Jones Explanation - Emails Between Elliot Jones and Menghong Wen Authenticity; Foundation; Hearsay

FX-266a ANERR Facebook Archive: Image of Apalachicola Bay, West Pass Authenticity; FoundationFX-266b ANERR Facebook Archive: Image of Apalachicola Bay seagrass Authenticity; FoundationFX-266c ANERR Facebook Archive: Image of Apalachicola Bay sunrise Authenticity; FoundationFX-266d ANERR Facebook Archive: Image of Apalachicola City and bridge Authenticity; FoundationFX-266e ANERR Facebook Archive: Image of Apalachicola City and Bay Authenticity; Foundation

17

Ex. # Florida Exhibit Description Date Mentioned Date Offered Objection Date AdmittedFX-266f ANERR Facebook Archive : Image of ANERR Trawl Authenticity; FoundationFX-266g ANERR Facebook Archive: Image of Apalachicola Bay beach and sunrise Authenticity; Foundation

FX-266h ANERR Facebook Archive: Image of Grassy Creek Authenticity; FoundationFX-267 Permit and Permitted Acreage Counts Not Produced in DiscoveryFX-268 State Water Plan - Surface Water Availability Resource Assessment -

PowerPoint PresentationFX-269 Irrigated Ag Area.xlsx (Spreadsheet of Dr. Flewelling's GA ACF irrigated acres

estimates 1970 - 2014)Hearsay

FX-270 Irrigation by Farm Size (in 63 Georgia Counties) - 2012 USDA Data Hearsay; Authenticity; FoundationFX-271 State of Georgia Budget Summary Chart Foundation; Hearsay; AuthenticityFX-272 GA Budget Fiscal Year 2004FX-273 GA Budget Fiscal Year 2005FX-274 GA Budget Fiscal Year 2006FX-275 GA Budget Fiscal Year 2007FX-276 GA Budget Fiscal Year 2008FX-277 GA Budget Fiscal Year 2009FX-278 GA Budget Fiscal Year 2010FX-279 GA Budget Fiscal Year 2011FX-280 GA Budget Fiscal Year 2012FX-281 GA Budget Fiscal Year 2013FX-282 GA Budget Fiscal Year 2014FX-283 GA Budget Fiscal Year 2015FX-284 GA Budget Fiscal Year 2016FX-285 Flint Riverkeeper, “Running Dry: Challenges and Opportunities in Restoring

Healthy Flows in Georgia’s Upper Flint River Basin,” 2013.Authenticity; Hearsay

FX-285a Running Dry: Challenges and Opportunities in Restoring Healthy Flows in Georgia's Upper Flint River Basin - American Rivers and Flint Riverkeeper


FX-286 Upper Flint River: Resiliency Action Plan - American Rivers Authenticity; HearsayFX-287 Georgia Governor Declares State of Drought Emergency - Perdue Declares

State of Emergency Due to Drought - Atlanta Journal-Constitution ArticleHearsay

FX-288 Governor, EPD Ease Outdoor Water Use Schedules - Email from B. Dykes to Soil and Water Conservation Commission, et al.

FX-289 Letter dated 2-15-10 from the Georgia Department of Natural Resources to Hightower Farms, LLC

FX-290 Memo from E. Rooks to G. Cowie re: "Exemption for Groundwater Withdrawals for Farms in Capacity Use Areas for Backlog Applications"


FX-291 Permit No.: 030-1295-04FX-292 Caldwell Additional Reductions to Red Zone Floridan Aquifer Withdrawals Authenticity; Foundation; Hearsay

FX-293 Application and Permit No.: 022-1217-01FX-294 Permit No.: 058-1290-12FX-295 Permit No.: 060-1209-02FX-296 Permit No.: A88-128-0001FX-297 Permit No.: A00-125-0508FX-298 Permit No.: 022-1217-01FX-299 Permit No.: 141-1292-02FX-300 Permit No.: A03-100-0660FX-301 Permit No.: A08-060-0015FX-302 Permit No.: A91-120-0023FX-303 Permit No.: A91-101-0528FX-304 Permit No.: 106-1293-05FX-305 Permit for Farm Use of Ground And/Or Surface Water for Tillett Groves, Inc.

18

Ex. # Florida Exhibit Description Date Mentioned Date Offered Objection Date AdmittedFX-306 Permit for Farm Use of Ground And/Or Surface Water for Tillett Groves, Inc.

FX-307 Application for a Letter of ConcurrenceFX-308 Flint River Basin Irrigation System Certification of Efficiency Form -

Introduction & SummaryFX-309 Nespal/Irrrigated Acreage Map From Brattle - Albany Authenticity; HearsayFX-310 Nespal/Irrrigated Acreage Map From Brattle - Bainbridge Authenticity; HearsayFX-311 Examples of Unpermitted Irrigated Acres in Wetted Acreage Database Foundation; Inadmissible

Demonstrative; HearsayFX-312 Flint Basin - Permit for Farm UseFX-313 Filling the Water Gap: Conservation Successes and Missed Opportunities in

Metro Atlanta - 2012 UpdateAuthenticity; Hearsay

FX-313a Filling the Water Gap: Conservation Successes and Missed Opportunities in Metro Atlanta, Upper Chattahoochee Riverkeeper, March 2011.


FX-319 Lower Flint River Basin Mussel Habitat Assessment and Monitoring Project - Final Report - Peterson, Jackson et al. (USGS, UGA)

Hearsay

FX-320 Summary of Lower Flint River Basin Project Meeting Hearsay; Improper Compilation Multiple Documents; Authenticity

FX-322 Historic Distribution of Wet Savannahs in the Tate's Hell State ForestFX-324a FDEP Website: Image of Apalachicola Bay (AB_Sunset_01.jpg) Authenticity; HearsayFX-324b FDEP Website: Image of Apalachicola Bay (ApalachicolaBaysunrise-CB.jpg) Authenticity; Hearsay

FX-325 Atkins Instream Flow Assessment for ACFS Authenticity; HearsayFX-326 Valuing Nature-Based Recreation in Public Natural Areas of the Apalachicola

River Region, Florida - Shrestha et al., Journal of Environmental Management 85 (2007): 977-985.

Hearsay

FX-327 2012 Census of Agriculture - Georgia: State and County Data - Volume 1

FX-328 2012 Census of Agriculture Appendix A - MethodologyFX-329 2014 Kern County Agricultural Crop ReportFX-330 Army Corps, Interim Drought Management Plan for the Apalachicola-

Chattahoochee-Flint River BasinFX-332 Apalachicola Bay National Estuarine Research Reserve, Effects of Near-Term

Sedimentologic Evolution on the Lifetime of Estuarine Resources, NOAA Tech. Mem. NOS SRD 27 - Donaghue & Tanner, NOAA

FX-334 Highways in the Coastal Environment: Assessing Extreme EventsFX-335 USGS Guidelines and Standard Procedures for Continuous Water Quality

Monitors, Techniques and Methods 1-03FX-337a NOAA Chart 11401 - Apalachicola Bay to Cape San Blas Authenticity; FoundationFX-337b NOAA Chart 11404 - Intracoastal Waterway Carrabelle to Apalachicola Bay;

Carrabelle RiverAuthenticity; Foundation

FX-339 Climate Change 2013, The Physical Science Basis, IPCC - Chapter 13, Sea Level Change

FX-340 Demirpolat, S., Tanner, W.F., Knoblach, M.A., and Orham, H. (1987) Historical Florida Shorelines: an Atlas, Franklin County, 1856-1979, Florida State University

Hearsay; Foundation; Authenticity

FX-341 Clark R. (2006) St. George Barrier Island System, Unpublished Manuscript Hearsay; Foundation; Authenticity

FX-343 Letter to Matt Thomas from Robin Goodloe re ACF Water Control Manual Updates - Request for Information (Planning Aid Letters - Fish & Wildlife)


FX-344 Letter to Curtis Flakes from Robin B. Goodloe RE: Planning Aid Letter, Apalachicola-Chattahoochee-Flint Water Control Manual Updates


FX-346 Impact of Upstream Water Use on Salinity and Ecology of Apalachicola Bay - Preliminary Results, by B. Villegas and J. W. Roberts

Hearsay; Foundation

19

Ex. # Florida Exhibit Description Date Mentioned Date Offered Objection Date AdmittedFX-347 Impacts of Upstream Water Use on Salinity and Ecology of Apalachicola Bay -

Villegas and RobertsHearsay; Foundation

FX-348 Impacts of Upstream Water Use on Salinity and Ecology of Apalachicola Bay - Villegas and Roberts and Georgakakos

Hearsay; Foundation

FX-349 Draft Manuscript, "A Mathematical Model of Apalachicola Bay Salinity and its Potential Effects on Oyster Harvesting" by B. Villegas, P. Roberts, and A. Georgakakos


FX-350 CV of Philip J. Roberts FX-356a Pictures of the Bay and River: IMG_0140FX-356b Pictures of the Bay and River: IMG_0141FX-356c Pictures of the Bay and River: IMG_0144,FX-356d Pictures of the Bay and River: IMG_0150FX-356e Pictures of the Bay and River: IMG_0176FX-358 Glibert et al. 2007- Harmful Algae Pose Additional Challenges for Oyster

RestorationRelevance; Foundation; Authenticity

FX-359 Edward Phlips - Mass Oyster Mortality and Phytoplankton Composition in Apalachicola Bay: Is there a Link?

Hearsay; Not Produced in Discovery

FX-360 Sheldon and Alber 2011. Recommended Indicators of Water Quality for GA Hearsay; Foundation; Authenticity

FX-361 Caffrey et al. 2014. Seasonal and interannual patterns in primary produciton, respiration and net ecosystem metabolism in three estuaries…


FX-364 Coastal Lagoons: Critical Habitats of Environmental Change, Chapter 5 Blooms and Lagoons, Patricia M . Glibert , Joseph N . Boyer , Cynthia A . Heil , Christopher J . Madden , Brian Sturgis , and Catherine S . Wazniak


FX-365 Effects of Nutrient Enrichment in Nation's Estuaries - Bricker - NOAA Report

FX-369 Apalachicola National Estuarine Research Research Water Quality Metadata, July - September 2014

FX-371 Asterionella Glacialis, Algaebase Website Hearsay; Foundation; AuthenticityFX-372 M. Elliott & A. K. Whitfield, Challenging Paradigms in Estuarine Ecology and

Management, Est. Coast & Shelf Sci 2011FX-375 Comparison of Major Drought Indices Website Hearsay; Foundation; AuthenticityFX-377 Influences of Environmental Settings on Aquatic Ecosystems in the

Apalachicola-Chattahoochee-Flint River Basin - USGS, Water Resources Investigations Report 95-4278

FX-379 Robert Livingston, FDEP Report, Importance of River Flow to the Apalachicola River-Bay System

FX-381 Leitman, HM et al. 1984. Wetland hydrology and tree distribution of the Apalachicola River flood plain, Florida. U.S. Geological Survey water-supply paper; 2196-A

FX-382 Dutterer et al. (2012), Fish recruitment is influenced by river flows and floodplain inundation at Apalachicola River, Florida, River Res. Applic.

FX-383 Anne Wakeford, Florida Marine Research Institute Technical Report, State of Florida Conservation Plan for Gulf Sturgeon (Acipenser oxyrinchus desotoi )

FX-384 Andrew Marbury & Doug Peterson, Assessing Juvenile Gulf Sturgeon Recruitment in the Apalachicola River, FL


FX-385 FWC Fish Analyses Authenticity; Foundation; HearsayFX-386 Christopher Anderson & B Graeme Lockaby, Forested Wetland Communities

as Indicators of Tidal Influence along the Apalachicola River, Wetlands 2011Hearsay

FX-387 EnviroScience (2006b), Draft Report, Swift Slough Population (Abundance) Estimate for the federally endangered Amblema neislerii (Fat Threeridge) and federally threatened Elliptoideus sloatianus (Purple Bankclimber)

Authenticity

20

Ex. # Florida Exhibit Description Date Mentioned Date Offered Objection Date AdmittedFX-388 EnviroScience (2006a), Freshwater Mussel and Habitat Surveys of the

Apalachicola River, Chipola River and Selected Sloughs/Tributaries, Final Report to FDEP


FX-389 Gangloff (2012), Population size and depth distribution of three federally-protected mussels in the Apalachicola and Lower Chipola rivers, Final report to USACE


FX-390 Kaeser & Herrington (2011), An investigation of movement, exposure, and mortality of fat threeridge mussels (Amblema neislerii ) at Apalachicola and Chipola River sites, Summary Report

FX-391 USFWS, Final Rule, Desgnation of Critical Habitat for Five Endangered and Two Threatened Mussels

Legal Document; Hearsay

FX-392 USFWS, Recovery Plan for Endangered Fat ThreeridgeFX-393a Historical Mussel Survey Data and Field Notes Authenticity; Foundation; Improper

Compilation of Multiple Documents

FX-393b Historical Mussel Survey Data and Field Notes Authenticity; Foundation; Improper Compilation of Multiple Documents

FX-394 Cover to the Florida Board of Trustees Minutes Hearsay; Foundation; AuthenticityFX-395 Florida Board of Trustees of the Internal Improvement Trust Fund Meeting

Minutes (Oct. 28, 1969)Hearsay; Foundation; Authenticity

FX-396 Golladay et al. (2004), Response of Freshwater Mussel Assemblages (Bivalvia:Unionidae) to a Record Drought in the Gulf Coastal Plain of Southwestern Georgia, J. N. Am. Benthol. Soc.

Hearsay

FX-397 Movements of Hatchery Raised Gulf Sturgeon in Lake Seminole - Executive Summary of Findings by Robert R. Weller

FX-398 Evaluating the influence of land use, drought and reach isolation on the occurrence of freshwater mussel species in the lower Flint River Basin, Georgia (U.S.A.) by Colin P. Shea, James Peterson, Michael Conroy and Jason Wisniewski

FX-399 Restoration of Gulf Striped Bass: Lessons and Management Implications by Eric A. Long, Charles Mensing, Karen Herrington, Robert Weller, and Isaac Wirgin - American Fisheries Society Article

FX-400 Wilber (1994), The influence of Apalachicola River flows on blue crab, Callinectes sapidus , in north Florida

Foundation; Not Disclosed in Discovery; Hearsay

FX-401 Garwood et al., ANERR, Season, Salinity, and Bottom-Type Characterize Post-Larval and Juvenile Nekton Community in Apalachicola Bay


FX-402 R.L. Gandy et al, SWFWMD, Review of the Biology and Population Dynamics of the Blue Crab, Callinectes sapidus , in Relation to Salinity and Freshwater Inflow

Foundation; Not Disclosed in Discovery; Hearsay

FX-403 Florida Department of Environmental Protection (FDEP) 2005(a). Letter from J. Llewellyn, Dept. of Environmental Protection, to P. Taylor, USACE, re Permit Modification Denial, dated April 13, 2005.

FX-404 Florida Department of Environmental Protection (2005). Consolidated Notice of Denial of Wetland Resource Permit and Authorization to Use Sovereign Submerged Lands, Apalachicola River Maintenance Dredging, Applicant Curtis M. Flakes, U.S. Army Corps of Engineers, Mobile, Alabama.

FX-405 Hoehn, T., and S. Leitman. Undated (approximately 2001). History of navigation improvements on the Apalachicola River. unpublished report.

FX-406 Florida Department of Administration 1975, Division of Planning Comments to Draft EIS, December 31, 1975.

Authenticity; Foundation; Improper Compilation of Multiple Documents

FX-407 FFWCC Executive Order 15-31

21

Ex. # Florida Exhibit Description Date Mentioned Date Offered Objection Date AdmittedFX-412 Email From Brianne Smith (NOAA) to Other NOAA Employees Attaching

Petes Analysis and 2012 Input to Florida Gulf Coast Oyster Disaster Declaration - Memorandum by L. Petes

Foundation; Hearsay

FX-412a Input to Florida Gulf Coast Oyster Disaster Declaration - Memorandum by L. Petes, NOAA Climate Program Office

Foundation; Hearsay

FX-413 Memo from Roy Crabtree (NOAA) to Sam Rauch III (NOAA) Recommending Declaration of Fishery Resource Disaster

FX-414 Testimony of Jonathan Pl. Steverson, Executive Director of NWFWMD, "Effects of Water Flows on Apalachicola Bay: Short and Long Term Perspectives" US Senate Committee on Commerce, Science and Transportation Field Hearing

FX-414a Testimony of Jonathan Pl. Steverson, Executive Director of NWFWMD, "Effects of Water Flows on Apalachicola Bay: Short and Long Term Perspectives" US Senate Committee on Commerce, Science and Transportation Field Hearing

FX-423 Written Testimony of Emily Menashes (Acting Director of Office of Sustainable Fisheries, NOAA) for field hearing on "Effects of Water Flows on Apalachicola Bay: Short and Long Term Perspectives" before the Committee on Commerce, Science, and Transportation (US Senate)

Foundation; Hearsay

FX-425 Size Distribution of Oysters in FDACS Surveys at Cat Point Bar Foundation; Authenticity; Not Produced in Discovery

FX-426 Size Distribution of Oysters in FDACS Surveys at Dry Bar Foundation; Authenticity; Not Produced in Discovery

FX-427 Salinity Anomalies for Eight Apalachicola Bay Oyster Bars between July 2012 and December 2012

Foundation; Authenticity; Not Produced in Discovery; Hearsay

FX-428 Daily Salinity Anomaly for Eight Apalachicola Bay Oyster Bars during 2011-2012 Period

Foundation; Authenticity; Not Produced in Discovery; Hearsay

FX-430 Email from Rob Beaton re: Operation Black Pearl participantsFX-435 Oyster Enforcement - Warnings and CitationsFX-437 Annual Reshelling in Apalachicola Bay from 1949 through 2013 Foundation; Hearsay; Not Produced in

DiscoveryFX-438 Anomaly of Oyster Shelling Planting by the State of Florida from 1970-2015 Foundation; Hearsay; Not Produced in

DiscoveryFX-440 List of Pounds from Tommy Ward HearsayFX-442 Preliminary Oyster Resource Assessment Report Summer Bars, Apalachicola

Bay, April 2009FX-444 Oyster Resource Assessment Report Apalachicola Bay 2010FX-445 Memo from Virginia Vail to Apalachicola Sanctuary Advisory Committee re:

Apalachicola Oyster Resources, attaching oyster resource assessment report

FX-446 Oyster Resource Assessment Report Apalachicola Bay 1999-2000FX-447 Oyster Resource Assessment Report Apalachicola Bay 2001-2002FX-448 Oyster Resource Assessment Report, Apalachicola Bay, November 2002FX-449 Oyster Resource Assessment Report Apalachicola Bay 2002-2003FX-450 Explanation of FDACS Data MethodologyFX-459 Summary Chart Based On Documents Provided By T. Ward Foundation; Hearsay; Not Produced in

Discovery; Authenticity

FX-459a Summary Chart Based On Documents Provided By T. Ward - Summary of Oyster Harvest Purchases from Public Bars from 2010-2015

Foundation; Hearsay; Not Produced in Discovery; Authenticity

FX-459b Summary Chart Based On Documents Provided By T. Ward - Summary of 13 Mile Oyster Harvest from 2010-2015

Foundation; Hearsay; Not Produced in Discovery; Authenticity

FX-460 Winter Oyster Bar Surveys (Summary_Aug2016.xlsx) Authenticity; Foundation; Not Produced in Discovery

FX-461 Summer Oyster Bar Surveys (Summary_May2016.xlsx) Authenticity; Foundation; Not Produced in Discovery; Hearsay

22

Ex. # Florida Exhibit Description Date Mentioned Date Offered Objection Date AdmittedFX-462 Summary_Oct2015.xlsx Authenticity; Foundation; Not

Produced in Discovery; HearsayFX-463 Easthole_Mar2015.xlsx Authenticity; Foundation; Not

Produced in Discovery; HearsayFX-464 Copy of SummerPreSeason_May2015.xlsxFX-465 SummaryWinterBars_Aug2015.xlsx Authenticity; Foundation; Not

Produced in Discovery; HearsayFX-466 FWC Commercial Landings Data (Screenshot & Excel Datasheet)FX-469 Summary Documents Generated From Dr. Marcia Greenblatt's Salinity Model

Output (FL-ACF-04142484)FX-469a Dr. Marcia Greenblatt's Salinity Model Output (FL-ACF-04142484)FX-470 Final Navigation Maintenance Plan for the Apalachicola Chattahoochee Flint

Waterway, Volume 1, Main ReportFX-472 Florida FWCC Executive Order 13-17, CH 68B-27 FACFX-481 Florida FWCC Executive Order 16-17, CH68B-27 FACFX-482 Florida FWCC Executive Order 16-28, CH68B-27 FACFX-484 Sloughs and Conn Flows by Waterbody Type (Spreadsheet) Foundation; Authenticity; HearsayFX-485 Havens Deposition for Congressional Field Hearing, Apalachicola, Florida, Hearsay; Foundation

FX-490 Molles, Ecology Concepts and Applications (Excerpt of Chapter 14: Exploitative Interactions Predation, Herbiory, Parasitism and Disease)

Foundation; Not Produced in Discovery

FX-491 Stenseth et al. "From Patterns to Processes: Phase and Density Dependencies in the Canadian lynx Cycle," Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. Vol. 95, pp. 15430-15435

Hearsay; Relevance

FX-493 Correction to Expert Report of J. Wilson White - Correspondence from A. Mangones to Z. Avallone

Hearsay; Foundation

FX-494 Bedient BI, Release-Observed, and Release-Difference data by Date chart Foundation; Authenticity; Hearsay

FX-495 Graph Dated 2012 Showing 7-Day Woodruff Local Inflow, Basin Inflow, Observed Chattahooc Flow, Flow from Flint River Basin, and Minimum Release per RIOP


FX-496 Email from Gary Mauldin re ACF Basin Drought Teleconference Foundation; Authenticity; HearsayFX-497 Corps Responses to Question Foundation; Authenticity; HearsayFX-501 Augmentation Days by Year Document #1 FoundationFX-502 The Nine Values Closest to a BI of 4,000 cfs (2007-present) chart Foundation; Authenticity; HearsayFX-503 The Six Values Closest to a BI of 4,250 cfs (2007-present) chart Foundation; Authenticity; HearsayFX-504 2012/2013 Flow Volume Differentials (Chattahoochee) chart Foundation; Authenticity; HearsayFX-505 "Figure 35 as in Dr. Bedient's May 20, 2016 Report with Daily Observed

Flows for 2007 & 2011Added to the Figure by Florida" ChartFoundation; Authenticity; Hearsay

FX-506 Dr. Bedient's May 20, 2016 Report at 69: Table 6. Annual Flow, Change in Storage, and Consumptive Use Difference (cfs) Comparison Between Baseline 2011and 1992 Condition (2000-2011)


FX-507 Percentage of Consumptive Use Growth Between 1992 and 2011 that Could Be Recovered at State Line for Dr. Bedient's Drought Periods and Dr. Bedient's Res-Sim Analysis chart


FX-508 "2012 Flows Observed at Chattahoochee Gage Between May and December 2012" Chart


FX-509 July-October 2012 Flow amounts Chart Foundation; Authenticity; HearsayFX-510 "Detailed hydrographs for July-October 2012" Chart Foundation; Authenticity; HearsayFX-511a USACE ACF Basin Composite Conservation and Flood Storage Graphs (2007)

FX-511b USACE ACF Basin Composite Conservation and Flood Storage Graphs (2008)

FX-511c USACE ACF Basin Composite Conservation and Flood Storage Graphs (2009)

FX-511d USACE ACF Basin Composite Conservation and Flood Storage Graphs (2010)

23

Ex. # Florida Exhibit Description Date Mentioned Date Offered Objection Date AdmittedFX-511e USACE ACF Basin Composite Conservation and Flood Storage Graphs (2011)

FX-511f USACE ACF Basin Composite Conservation and Flood Storage Graphs (2012)

FX-511g USACE ACF Basin Composite Conservation and Flood Storage Graphs (2013)

FX-511h USACE ACF Basin Composite Conservation and Flood Storage Graphs (2014)

FX-511i USACE ACF Basin Composite Conservation and Flood Storage Graphs (2015)

FX-511j USACE ACF Basin Composite Conservation and Flood Storage Graphs (2016)

FX-515 USGS, Rodriguez Letter to Chelette, NWFWMD re: Sumatra Gage Foundation; Authenticity; Hearsay; Not Produced in Discovery

FX-516 USGS 02358754 Apalachicola River Near Wewahitchka, FLA (Main Channel Only), Water Data Report

FX-517 Summary of the Historical Flow and Precipitation Analysis for ACF and Part of OSSS

FX-518 Population that Could Be Served and Acres that Could be Irrigated Using Georgia's Reported Values


FX-519 Groundwater Contour Maps of the Upper Floridan Aquifer Authenticity; Foundation; HearsayFX-520 Emails between [email protected] and [email protected] re: Sumatra

Simulated Flow Hearsay

FX-523 Executive Summary - Current Conditions Model Runs - by A. Georgakakos, M. Kistenmacher, and C-J. Chen

Hearsay

FX-524 Executive Summary – First Round Scenario Assessments Draft. Georgia Water Resources Institute, Georgia Institute of Technology, Atlanta, Georgia. August 13, 2013 - Georgakakos, A. P., M. Kistenmacher, and H. Yao

Hearsay

FX-525 Columbus-Columbia - Email from Aris Georgakakos to Martin Kistenmacher Foundation; Hearsay

FX-526 From NIWR Website, Sustainable Water Management Plan for the ACF River Basin [Kistenmacher Dep. Ex. 7]

Foundation; Hearsay

FX-527 Improvement and Uncertainty Assessment of ACF Unimpaired Flow Datasets Foundation; Hearsay

FX-528 Aris P. Georgakakos CVFX-529 Emails between Aris Georgakakos and Stephen Simpson RE: ACFS

QualificationsHearsay

FX-530 Letter from Sandra S. Tucker to Brad Moore RE: requested review of the Apalachicola-Chattahoochee-Flint (ACF) River Basin Sustainable Water Management Plan (SWMP): Recommended Environmental Flows, Final Report (December 3, 2012)

FX-531 ARC Comments on UIF Report - Email from A. Georgakakos HearsayFX-532 Technical Report, "Water Management Scenario Assessments for the ACF

River Basin" by The Georgia Water Resources Institute/Georgia TechHearsay

FX-533 Water Management Scenario Assessments for the ACF River Basin, Technical Report

Hearsay

FX-534 Unimpaired Flow Assessment for the Apalachicola-Chattahoochee-Flint River Basin by The Georgia Water Resources Institute/Georgia Tech - Draft Technical Report

Hearsay

FX-536 Kennedy's Modifications (18 Feb) Authenticity; FoundationFX-537 Water Withdrawal Permitting Associated With Agriculture: Overview of

Operations - PowerPointFX-539 Year 2001 Interbasin Water Transfers Equaling Less Than Annual Average of

One Million Gallons Per Day FX-540 Interbasin Transfer Permit Application

24

Ex. # Florida Exhibit Description Date Mentioned Date Offered Objection Date AdmittedFX-541 Graphic/Map indicating location of rain gages in Chattahoochee National

Forest and vicinityHearsay; Foundation; Authenticity

FX-542 Graphic with table indicating Global Historical Climatology Network ("GHCN") Precipitation Stations in the ACF Basin


FX-543 Graphic with table: 5 NOAA COOP Stations with Complete Data Records in the Immediate Vicinity of the 098935 Gauge


FX-544 Comparison of Dr. Panday's "Baseline" Station ("098935") with Neighboring Stations

Hearsay; Foundation; Not Produced in Discovery; Authenticity

FX-545 Theil Slope Analysis of Dr. Panday's Precipitation Data: 1975-2015, 1975-1992, 1992-2015


FX-546 Post-1992 Trend Analysis: Dr. Panday's "Baseline" Station ("098935") Wetter Than Neighboring Stations


FX-547 Conversion of Water Accumlated in Storage During 180-Day Warmup Period in Dr. Panday's Model from Cubic Feet to CFS

FX-548 Comparison of chart plotting trendline from 1975-2015 by Dr. Panday in Figure C-24 with chart plotting trendlines by Florida for the pre- and post-1992 periods


FX-549 Document partially titled Comparison of Chart Plotting trendline Hearsay; Foundation; Not Produced in Discovery; Authenticity

FX-550 Comparison of Charts Document Hearsay; Foundation; Not Produced in Discovery; Authenticity

FX-551 Pre- and Post-1992 Trend Analysis of UFA Water Wells Reviewed by Dr. Panday


FX-552 Average least-square linear-regression slopes for the 1975-2015 period of record (Panday) and the pre-1992 and post-1992 periods (Gradient) for the 20 wells evaluated by Dr. Panday.


FX-553 Table 2 of Exhibit 34 with yellow line addedFX-554 Period of record for baseline rain gauge 09893 Hearsay; Foundation; Not Produced in


FX-555 ACFS - Performance Metrics Assessments, Baseline Scenarios Dry Years Hearsay

FX-557 "Correlation of Rainfall to Streamflow on Apalachicola River at Gage Near Chattahoochee, FL (1929 - 2014)" chart


FX-558 "1954 Versus 2008" Document Hearsay; Foundation; AuthenticityFX-559 "Correlation of Rainfall to Streamflow on Apalachicola River at Gage Near

Chattahoochee, FL (1929- 2014)" DocumentHearsay; Foundation; Authenticity

FX-560 "Correlation of 2-Yr Ave. Rainfall to Streamflow on Apalachicola River at Gage Near Chattahoochee, FL (1929- 2014)" Document


FX-561 "2year runoff ratio using Theil Slopes, 2-year Average Ratio of Streamflow to Rainfall on Apalachicola River at gage near Chattahoochee, FL" Chart


FX-562 "Annual runoff ratio using Theil Slopes, 1-year Average Ratio of Streamflow to Rainfall on Apalachicola River at gage near Chattahoochee, FL" Chart


FX-563 "Annual precipitation using Theil Slopes, 1-year Average Ratio of Streamflow to Rainfall on Apalachicola River at gage near Chattahoochee, FL" Chart


FX-564 "2year precipitation using Theil Slopes, 2-year Average Ratio of Streamflow to Rainfall on Apalachicola River at gage near Chattahoochee, FL" Chart


25

Ex. # Florida Exhibit Description Date Mentioned Date Offered Objection Date AdmittedFX-565 "Annual streamflow using Theil Slopes, 1-year Average Ratio of Streamflow to

Rainfall on Apalachicola River at gage near Chattahoochee, FL" ChartHearsay; Foundation; Authenticity

FX-566 "2year streamflow using Theil Slopes, 2-year Average Ratio of Streamflow to Rainfall on Apalachicola River at gage near Chattahoochee, FL" Chart


FX-567 Breakdown of ACF Watershed Area Above the Chattahoochee Gage by Climate Division for CDs 2, 4, and 7 Only (Georgia) chart


FX-568 Breakdown of ACF Watershed Area Above the Chattahoochee Gage by Climate Division (Alabama, Florida, Georgia) chart


FX-569 Annual Precipitation Chart Hearsay; Foundation; AuthenticityFX-570 Graph Titled "2-year Average Ratio of Streamflow to Rainfa (cfs) on

Apalachicola River at gage near Chattahoochee, FL (1929-2014)"Hearsay; Foundation; Authenticity

FX-571 The Flint River Basins: Technical Summary of Hydrogeology, Farm Water Use, and Ecology

FX-575 Georgia Irrigation 1970-1980: A Decade of Growth, Water Resources Investigation Report 83-4177

FX-577a Aerial Image of Apalachicola River (1) Foundation; Authenticity; Relevance

FX-577b Aerial Image of Apalachicola River (2) Foundation; Authenticity; Relevance

FX-577c Aerial Image of Apalachicola River (3) Foundation; Authenticity; Relevance

FX-577d Image of Apalachicola River Slough (1) Foundation; Authenticity; Relevance

FX-577e Image of the Apalachicola River Main Channel (1) Foundation; Authenticity; Relevance

FX-577f Image of the Apalachicola River Main Channel (2) Foundation; Authenticity; Relevance

FX-577g Image of Mary Slough Foundation; Authenticity; Relevance

FX-577h Image of Exposed Rocks in Apalachicola River Foundation; Authenticity; Relevance

FX-577i Image of Apalachicola River near Point Poloway Foundation; Authenticity; Relevance

FX-577j Image of Apalachicola River Main Channel (3) Foundation; Authenticity; Relevance

FX-577k Image of Apalachicola River Main Channel (4) Foundation; Authenticity; Relevance

FX-577l Image of Apalachicola River Slough (2) Foundation; Authenticity; Relevance

FX-577m Image of Swamp Trees in Apalachicola River Foundation; Authenticity; Relevance

FX-577n Image of Swift Slough Foundation; Authenticity; Relevance

FX-577o Image of Dead Mussels at RM 44.3 Foundation; Authenticity; Relevance

FX-578 Future Water Supply Demands and Returns for the Atlanta Metro Area Water Utilites from Lake Lanier and the Chattahoochee River

FX-579 Withdrawal Limit vs. Current Amounts - Email Between Wei Zeng, Jeffrey Regan, and Nap Caldwell

FX-580 Big Water, Little Water: Identification of Small and Medium-sized Reservoirs in the Apalachicola-Chattahoochee-Flint River Basin with a Discussion of Their Ecological and Hydrological Impacts. Fl. State Univ. Coll. of Soc. Scis. - Ignatius, Amber

Hearsay

FX-581 Dr. Bedient-Reported Streamflow Reductions (1994-2013) (Average Monthly AG Streamflow Reductions for Bedient Drought Periods) Chart


26

Ex. # Florida Exhibit Description Date Mentioned Date Offered Objection Date AdmittedFX-582 Basin Total Consumptive (1994-2012) chartFX-583 Basin Total Consumptive (1999-2012) chartFX-584 "Compute Flow Rate" document Authenticity; Foundation; HearsayFX-585 Dr. Langseth Pumped Water Source Notes HearsayFX-586 Stream Aquifer Flows and Changes by Menghong Wen FX-587 Groundwater Conditions in 2014, 2011, 2007 and Long-term StatisticsFX-590 Kennedy Memorandum re: Evaluation of Options for Managing Groundwater

Withdrawal Reductions in the Lower Flint River Basin (Draft)Foundation; Authenticity

FX-593 Supplemental Table 2: Kennedy Baseflow Estimates - Additions by Langseth (Langseth Dep. Ex. 45)


FX-594 Transient Modeling Response of Groundwater and its Interaction with Surface-Water Features as a Result of Seasonable Pumping in the ACF River Basin

Hearsay

FX-595 June 25, 1999 Memo from GA State Geologist to Reheis, "Reassessment of Florida's Application of the USGS's Subarea #4 MODFE Ground-Water Flow Model"


FX-596 Memo Dated September 24, 1998, from the Northwest Florida Water Management District, Doug Barr, to Director Reheis


FX-598 Judith Curry CV (Curry Dep. Ex. 2)FX-599 USFWS, Instream Flow Guidelines for the ACT and ACF Basins Interstate

Water Allocation FormulaFX-600 FDEP BudgetFX-601 Florida House of Representatives, Committee on Environmental Protection,

Final Analysis, SB 908FX-602 Contract for Reimbursement of Costs Incurred to Retrofit of Systems -

SRWMD Contract #12/13-182Relevance

FX-603 Jennifer M. Jacobs and Michael D. Dukes, "Revision of AFSIRS Crop Water Simulation Model," St. Johns River Water Management District


FX-604 Evaluation of Reference Evapotransiration Methodogies and AFSIRS Crop Water Use Simulation Model (Final Report)


FX-605 Technical Manual - Agricultural Field Scale Irrigation Requirements Simulation (AFSIRS) Model, Version 5.5


FX-606 River Margins Photo (Sloughs) (Stavins Ex. 43) (Allan Report p. 42) Authenticity; Foundation; Relevance

FX-607 River Margins Photo #2 (Sloughs) (Stavins Ex. 42) Authenticity; Foundation; Relevance

FX-608 Video of Franklin Board of County Commissioners Meeting, September 6, 2012 Hearsay

FX-613 Determining Crop-Water Production Functions Using Yield-Irrigation Gradient Algorithms - Kelly Brumbelow and Aris Georgakakos

Hearsay

FX-614 Development of Irrigation in Georgia - Letter to Robert Glennon, UAz Law from Dr. James E. Hook

Hearsay

FX-615 Question - Emails between Jim Hook and Cliff LewisFX-616 Research Proposal - Ag Water Demand Forecast - Email from Dave Eigenberg

to Bent Dykes Forwarding Jim Hooks' EmailHearsay

FX-617 LFO Plan - Water Conservation Technical MemorandumFX-618 Managing Agricultural Water Use During Drought: An Analysis of

Contemporary Policies Governing Georgia's Flint River BasinHearsay

FX-619a Jaramillo and Destouni - “Local Flow Regulation and Irrigation Raise Global Human Water Consumption and Footprint”

Hearsay

FX-619b Jaramillo and Destouni - “Local Flow Regulation and Irrigation Raise Global Human Water Consumption and Footprint” - Supplementary Materials

Hearsay

FX-620 20100416_FlowGap_Bainbridge_Hailian_demand.xlsxFX-621 Soil and Water Conservation in Georgia Fact Sheet

27

Ex. # Florida Exhibit Description Date Mentioned Date Offered Objection Date AdmittedFX-622 PROJECT PROPOSAL - Real-Time Estimation of Monthly Agricultural

Pumpage and Predictive Simulation of Stream-Aquifer Effects in the Middle and LowerChattahoochee and Flint River Basins, Georgia. U.S. Geological Survey in cooperation with Georgia Soil and Water Conservation Commission, December 2011

FX-623 Impact Statement 2009 Water Projection - UGA Prepares Georgia's Water Use Projections for Agriculture Irrigation through 2050

FX-624 Livneh_daily.xlsx (Source for Revised Irmak_S Excels) Foundation; Authenticity; Hearsay; Not Produced in Discovery

FX-625 Alternative Water Supply Measures per 2009 Water Contingency Planning Task Force Report and More Recent Work

FX-626 Back to the Bay: Apalachicola National Estuarine Research Reserve Hearsay; Authenticity; FoundationFX-627 Chattahoochee Flow Target Calculator and COE Compliance - Email from Wei

Zeng to Menghong WenFX-629 PowerPoint Presentation, "Estimate of Agricultural Water Use and

Consequent Reduction in Stream Flow" by Georgia EPDFX-632 Wayne Landis, Charles Menzie et al., Ecological Risk Assessment in the

Context of Global Climate Change, Envtl Toxicol & Chem 2013FX-633 Final Environmental Impact Statement, Apalachicola River and Bay

Estuarine Sanctuary, U.S. Dep’t of Commerce, NOAA, and State of Fla., DER, at 3 (Final EIS)

FX-635 Nap's Initial Edits to Draft Drought Rule - Email from Nap Caldwell to Ted Jackson, Bennett Weinstein, Becky Champion, Lebone Moeti, Kirk Chase, Bill Frechette, Wei Zeng, and Tim Cash

FX-636 Resource Asssessment Questions; Flow Gap at Bainbridge charts (Apr. 16, 2010); Memo from H. Liang to W. Zeng and F. Jiang re: "Update on Derivation of High Flow Gaps at Bainbridge" (Apr. 16, 2010); Agenda for Initial Future Assessment Briefing for Linda

Authenticity

FX-637 "Number of Days Where Dr. Bedient' s ResSim Output Indicates the Corps Would Release 5,050 cfs or Less from Woodruff Dam" chart

Hearsay; Authenticity; Foundation

FX-638 Climate Division Boundary (Alabama, Florida, Georgia) Hearsay; Authenticity; FoundationFX-639 Breakdown of Suwannee River Watershed Area Above the White Springs Gage

by Climate DivisionHearsay; Authenticity; Foundation

FX-641 Georgia Consumptive Use_Final.xlsx (Spreadsheet of Dr. Flewelling's GA ACF consumptive use estimates 1923 - 2013

Hearsay

FX-642 Report: Baseline Conservation Analysis for Agricultural Irrigation in Priority Watersheds of the Lower Flint River Basin by Mark Masters

FX-643 Agricultural Water Conservation: Economics and Policy ACF Stakeholders Governing Board

Hearsay

FX-644 Mapping Surface Irrigation in the Ichawaynochaway Sub-Basin in Georgia -Technical Report and Summary Results Georgia Soil and Water Conservation Commission

FX-645 Fax Letter from Mark Masters to Paul Hollis re: Bid Options During Flint River Drought Protection Program slides

Hearsay

FX-646 Rose & Peters: Effects of urbanization on streamflow in the Atlanta area (Georgia, USA): a comparative hydrological approach

Hearsay

FX-648 Article from Environ. Sci. Technol. 2005, 39, 9023-9032, titled "Learning from the U.S. National Assessment of Climate Change Impacts"

FX-649 Response Rate for Prior Resident Surveys, Prior Fisherman Surveys, and Current Report

FX-652 UNF Public Opinion Research Laboratory - Final Disposition Codes, Bay/River Counties


FX-653 Ecosystems and Human Well-Being Health Synthesis - Millenium Ecosystem Assessment (Cantor Dep. Ex. 15)


FX-659 GA Wetted Acreage Database, "WettedAcres_Deliverable_20160211.xlsx"

28

Ex. # Florida Exhibit Description Date Mentioned Date Offered Objection Date AdmittedFX-660 FFWCC - Fisheries Independent Monitoring Data and ReportsFX-661 ConvertFlowtoStage_AllGages_Low-MedFlows Hearsay; foundation; AuthenticityFX-662 ConvertFlowtoStage_AllGages_HighFlows Hearsay; foundation; AuthenticityFX-663 Irrigation Management Technology for Water Conservation in Georgia. - A

Proposal to the Natural Resources Conservation Service, Conservation Innovation Grants Program - Project Description

FX-664 ACF GA Water Use Request Annual Demand Tables FX-666 Florida DEP, Florida State Parks, Annual Attendance (FY 2009-2010). AuthenticityFX-668 NWFWMD 2014 Consolidated Annual ReportFX-670 NWFWMD 2016 Consolidated Annual ReportFX-671 Water Use Permit Applicant's Handbook, Northwest Florida

Water Management DistrictHearsay; Authenticity; Foundation; Not Produced in Discovery

FX-672 Transactions in Florida - Nature Conservancy Hearsay; Authenticity; foundationFX-673 Florida Natural Areas Inventory, "Florida Conservation Lands Map Viewer"

[Slipsheet Showing Website; Florida Will Use Data From It]Hearsay

FX-674 Estimating Florida Statewide Agricultural Irrigation Demand (FSAID) using Economics and Engineering Models, Final Report

FX-675 Apalachicola River & Bay: A Connected Ecosystem Hearsay; Authenticity; foundationFX-676 ACF Basin Active Individual Water Use Permits.xlsx Not Produced in Discovery; Foundation

FX-677 ACF Basin AFSIRS Output Summary.xlsx Not Produced in Discovery; Foundation

FX-678 ACF Basin Agricultural Pumpage Comparison (2011 and 2014).xlsx Not Produced in Discovery; Foundation

FX-679 7507 Greenwood Oaks Farm, Inc.xlsx Not Produced in Discovery; Foundation

FX-682 NWFWMD Water Use Technical Staff Report, Application 107507 (WUP_261_3 (2).pdf)

Not Produced in Discovery; Foundation

FX-686 Surface & Groundwater Water Demand by Water Planning Regions - NESPAL; Hook, J.E. (2010).

FX-687 Projected Crop Acres – Details and Data - NESPAL. (2010). FX-689 Atlanta Journal Constitution, Georgia ratchets up drought alert, Dan

ChapmanHearsay

FX-690 How Smarter Irrigation Might Save Rare Mussels and Ease a Water War (National Geographic)

Hearsay

FX-691 With Big Data, IBM Helps Create A Sustainable Food Supply - FRB Video Hearsay; Foundation; Authenticity

FX-692 Dataset - Irrigation Depths by Crop, Month, & Probability Within WPRs

FX-693 Tim SW Questions on PermitFX-694 11-221 Flint River Soil and Water Conservation District PDFX-696 Irrigation Schedule Methods, UGA Bulletin 974 HearsayFX-697 11-221 Flint River Soil and Water Conservation District AFX-698 Lenny Wells, Biography Webpage (Stavins Dep. Ex. 30) Hearsay; Foundation; AuthenticityFX-699 Lenny Wells, Irrigation Water Management for Pecans in Humid Climates

(Stavis Dep. Ex. 31)Hearsay; Foundation; Authenticity

FX-700 A Reduced Early-Season Irrigation Schedule for Southeastern Pecan Production (Stavins Dep. Ex. 32)


FX-701 Table: ACF Georgia Agriculture GRP Relative to Total ACF Georgia GRP Foundation; Inadmissible Demonstrative

FX-702 Environmental Quality Incentives Program (EQIP), Gulf of Mexico Initiative FY 2015 - NRCS [From Bottcher Works Cited]


FX-703 Environmental Quality Incentives Program (EQIP), Gulf of Mexico Initiative FY 2016 - NRCS

Hearsay

FX-704 Senate Research Office, Final Report of the Long-Term Aquifer Storage Senate Study Committee (2014), p. 2.

FX-705 Sherwin Rosen (1974), “Hedonic Prices and Implicit Market: Product Differentiation in Pure Competition,”

Hearsay; Relevance; Foundation

29

Ex. # Florida Exhibit Description Date Mentioned Date Offered Objection Date AdmittedFX-706 Southwest Florida Water Management District Strategic Plan 2014-2018,

Updated January 2016.FX-707 Average Irrigation Depth of Surface Water Users Not Produced in DiscoveryFX-708 Georgia Unpermitted Acres Not Produced in DiscoveryFX-709 Low Flow Permits Not Produced in DiscoveryFX-710 Georgia Dept. of Labor, Workforce Statistics & Economic Research, Quarterly

Census of Employment and Wages Program for Landscaping Services SectorNot Produced in Discovery

FX-711 DSSAT Webpage -- Overview Hearsay; AuthenticityFX-712 DSSAT Webpage -- Contact Us Hearsay; AuthenticityFX-713 Survey of Apalachicola Communities - UNF Public Opinion Research

Laboratory, Prepared for FDEP and Dr. Steven ScyphersFX-714 Milon, J. W. and Scrogin, D. - Latent Preferences and Valuation of Wetland

Ecosystem Restoration. Ecological EconomicsHearsay

FX-715 Brown, A. and Shi, P. (Apr. 2014). Valuing the Economic Benefits of Florida's Conservation Lands. Duke Univ.

Hearsay

FX-716 Steven Shavell, Contingent Valuation of the Nonuse Value of Natural Resources Implications for Public Policy and the Liability System

Hearsay

FX-717 Robert Stavins, How to Stop Squandering Water? Raise Its PriceFX-718 Robert Stavins, Incentive-Based Environmental Regulations: A New Era from

an Old IdeaFX-719 Peter Diamond and Jerry Hausman, Contingent Valuation: Is Some Number

Better than No Number? The Journal of Economic Perspectives, Volume 8, Issue 4 (Autumn, 1994), 45-64

Hearsay

FX-721 News Release, Crop Insurance Deadline Nears in GeorgiaFX-722 OMB Executive Order 13563FX-723 OMB Executive Order 12291FX-724 OMB Executive Order 12866FX-725 OMB Executive Order 13422FX-726 OMB Circular A-4FX-727 Science, Is There A Role for Benefit-Cost Analysis in Environmental, Health

and Safety Regulation?FX-728 Robert Stavins, Economic Thinking About the EnvironmentFX-729 National Research Council, Valuing Ecosystem Services HearsayFX-731 Precipitation Variation Response to FLE.xlsx Hearsay; Authenticity; FoundationFX-732 Modified Irmak Figure 45 With NOAA nClimGrid Data Authenticity; Foundation; HearsayFX-733 Comparison of Irmak's Precipitation Values - MIller 2012 Authenticity; Foundation; HearsayFX-734 Comparison of Irmak's Precipitation Values - Mitchell 2011 Authenticity; Foundation; HearsayFX-735 Modified Irmak Table 5 With Gridded Data Authenticity; Foundation; HearsayFX-736 Modified Irmak Figure 16 #1 Authenticity; Foundation; HearsayFX-737 Modified Irmak Figure 16 #2 Authenticity; Foundation; HearsayFX-738 Modified Irmak Figure 16 #3 Authenticity; Foundation; HearsayFX-739 Modified Irmak Figure 20a Authenticity; Foundation; HearsayFX-740 Modified Irmak Figure 20b Authenticity; Foundation; HearsayFX-741 Modified Irmak Figure 41b Authenticity; Foundation; HearsayFX-743 Irmak S_GA_Long-term Calculations of ETo and ETr and Associated

Variables_Decatur.xlsxAuthenticity; Hearsay

FX-744 Irmak S_GA_Long-term Calculations of ETo and ETr and Associated Variables_Dooly.xlsx


FX-745 Irmak S_GA_Long-term Calculations of ETo and ETr and Associated Variables_Miller.xlsx


FX-746 Irmak S_GA_Long-term Calculations of ETo and ETr and Associated Variables_Mitchell.xlsx


FX-747 Irmak S_GA_Long-term Calculations of ETo and ETr and Associated Variables_Sumter.xlsx


FX-748 NOAA nClimGrid Precipitation Data (Vose et al. 2014) Foundation; Authenticity; HearsayFX-749 Irmak_nClimGrid_precip_counties_growing.xlsx (Source of Modified Irmak

Figure 45)Foundation; Authenticity; Hearsay; Not Produced in Discovery

30

Ex. # Florida Exhibit Description Date Mentioned Date Offered Objection Date AdmittedFX-750 Livneh Gridded Precipitation Data Foundation; Authenticity; HearsayFX-751a Picture of Tommy Ward Private Leases (IMG_8573.jpg) Foundation; Hearsay; Not Produced in


FX-751b Picture of Tommy Ward Private Leases (IMG_8569.jpg) Foundation; Hearsay; Not Produced in Discovery; Authenticity

FX-751c Picture of Tommy Ward Private Leases (IMG_8565.jpg) Foundation; Hearsay; Not Produced in Discovery; Authenticity

FX-751d Picture of Tommy Ward Private Leases (FullSizeRender.jpg) Foundation; Hearsay; Not Produced in Discovery; Authenticity

FX-751e Picture of Tommy Ward Private Leases (FullSizeRender (1).jpg) Foundation; Hearsay; Not Produced in Discovery; Authenticity

FX-752 ne_county_precip_Livneh_summary.xlsx (Nebraska County Livneh Data) Foundation; Hearsay; Not Produced in Discovery; Authenticity

FX-753 Livneh_precipitation_data_by_county.xlsx Authenticity; Foundation; Hearsay; Not Produced in Discovery

FX-754 Livneh_precipitation_data_by_HRU.xlsx Hearsay; Foundation; Authenticity; Not Produced in Discovery

FX-755 Nclimgrid_precipitation_data_by_county.xlsx Hearsay; Foundation; Authenticity; Not Produced in Discovery

FX-756 Nclimgrid_precipitation_data_by_HRU.xlsx Hearsay; Foundation; Authenticity; Not Produced in Discovery

FX-757 Irmak S_GA_Long-term Calculations of ETo and ETr and Associated Variables_Decatur_revised.xlsx

Authenticity; Hearsay; Not Produced in Discovery

FX-758 Irmak S_GA_Long-term Calculations of ETo and ETr and Associated Variables_Dooly_revised.xlsx


FX-759 Irmak S_GA_Long-term Calculations of ETo and ETr and Associated Variables_Miller_revised.xlsx


FX-760 Irmak S_GA_Long-term Calculations of ETo and ETr and Associated Variables_Mitchell_revised.xlsx


FX-761 Irmak S_GA_Long-term Calculations of ETo and ETr and Associated Variables_Sumter_revised.xlsx


FX-764 Estimate of Agricultural Water Use and Consequent Reduction in Stream Flow at Bainbridge Presentation

FX-765 Georgia EPD Press Release, Georgia EPD Declares Level 1 Drought Response, Encourages Water Conservation

FX-767 Cowie Working Notes with Handwritten NotesFX-768 Press Release: "Georgia EPD Declines Drought Declaration for Flint River

Basin" and Emails re: Flint River Drought Protection Act Auction Program

FX-769 Concerning Southwest Georgia Irrigation and the Apalachicola River - Letter from H. Reheis to O. Jackson

FX-770a IMG_9018.jpg Foundation; Not Produced in Discovery

FX-770b IMG_9022.jpg Foundation; Not Produced in Discovery

FX-771 ACF Fact Sheet #4, Subject: Lake Lanier Water Quality. Mobile District, U.S. Army Corps of Engineers, Mobile, Alabama. November 26, 2007.


FX-778 Letter from Munson to Hathorn re: Deficiencies in the ACF Unimpaired Flow Dataset and Call for Revisions

FX-781 State Water Plan - Surface Water Availability Resource Assessment - PowerPoint Presentation (Nap's Presentation)

31

Ex. # Florida Exhibit Description Date Mentioned Date Offered Objection Date AdmittedFX-782 Fishing Communities of the United States, 2006. U.S. Dept. Commerce, NOAA

Tech. Memo. NMFS-F/SPO-98 - National Marine Fisheries Service. 2009. Not Produced in Discovery; Foundation

FX-783 Expert Report of Adelbert (Del) Bottcher HearsayFX-784 Expert Report of David Sunding Hearsay; Inadmissible Expert Report

FX-785 Expert Report of George Hornberger Hearsay; FoundationFX-786 Expert Report of Sam Flewelling HearsayFX-787 Expert Report of Marcia Greenblatt HearsayFX-788 Expert Report of Scott Douglass Hearsay; FoundationFX-789 Expert Report of Pat Glibert HearsayFX-790 Expert Report of J. David Allan Hearsay; Foundation; Inadmissable

Expert ReportFX-791 Expert Report of Daniel Phaneuf HearsayFX-792 Expert Report of Gerrit Hoogenboom Hearsay; FoundationFX-793 Expert Report of Dennis Lettenmaier Hearsay; FoundationFX-794 Expert Report of Peter Shanahan Hearsay; FoundationFX-795 Expert Report of Dave Langseth Hearsay; FoundationFX-796 Expert Report of G. Mathias Kondolf HearsayFX-797 Expert Report of David Kimbro HearsayFX-798 Expert Report of J. Wilson White (Corrected) HearsayFX-799 Expert of Steven Scyphers HearsayFX-800 Recreational Use of the Apalachicola River: A Survey of Residents of Alabama,

Florida and Georgia - David SundingHearsay; Inadmissible Expert Report

FX-801 Defensive Expert Report of David Sunding Hearsay; Inadmissible Expert Report

FX-802 Supplemental Letter from David Sunding Hearsay; Inadmissible Expert Report

FX-804 Defensive Expert Report of George Hornberger Hearsay; FoundationFX-805 Memo from Dr. Langseth to Dr. Hornberger re: "Dr. Panday Water Budget

Evaluations"Hearsay; Foundation

FX-807 Lake Seminole Model Correspondence – Singarella June 1, 2016 Letter Hearsay; FoundationFX-808 Lake Seminole Model Correspondence – Dr. Hornberger June 1, 2016 Memo Hearsay; Foundation

FX-809 Defensive Expert Report of Dennis Lettenmaier Hearsay; FoundationFX-810 Lettenmaier Feb. 29 Expert Report Errata - lettenmaier_updated_figures.pdf Hearsay; Foundation

FX-811 Defensive Expert Report of Peter Shanahan Hearsay; FoundationFX-812a Actual Hog Slough_080216_00132.MTS Foundation; Not Produced in Discovery

FX-812b Actual Hog Slough_080216_00134.MTS Foundation; Not Produced in Discovery

FX-812c Actual Hog Slough_080216_00135.MTS Foundation; Not Produced in Discovery

FX-812d Actual Hog Slough_080216_00137.MTS Foundation; Not Produced in Discovery

FX-812e Actual Hog Slough_080216_00138.MTS Foundation; Not Produced in Discovery

FX-812f Actual Hog Slough_080216_00139.MTS Foundation; Not Produced in Discovery

FX-812g Actual Hog Slough_080216_00140.MTS Foundation; Not Produced in Discovery

FX-812h Actual Hog Slough_080216_00142.MTS Foundation; Not Produced in Discovery

FX-812i Actual Hog Slough_080216_00144.MTS Foundation; Not Produced in Discovery

FX-812j Actual Hog Slough_080216_00145.MTS Foundation; Not Produced in Discovery

32

Ex. # Florida Exhibit Description Date Mentioned Date Offered Objection Date AdmittedFX-812k Actual Hog Slough_080216_00146.MTS Foundation; Not Produced in Discovery

FX-812l Actual Hog Slough_080216_00147.MTS Foundation; Not Produced in Discovery

FX-812m Actual Hog Slough_080216_8194.JPG Foundation; Not Produced in Discovery

FX-812n Actual Hog Slough_080216_8199.JPG Foundation; Not Produced in Discovery

FX-812o Actual Hog Slough_080216_8200.JPG Foundation; Not Produced in Discovery

FX-813a General River Footage_After Hog Slough to Before Old Moccasin Head_00153.MTS


FX-813b General River Footage_After Hog Slough to Before Old Moccasin Head_00154.MTS


FX-814 Wewahitchka - Before Swift Slough_00103.MTS Foundation; Not Produced in Discovery

FX-815 Moccasin Slough at Mouth of River Styx_00174.MTS Foundation; Not Produced in Discovery

FX-816a New Moccasin Head_080216_00165.MTS Foundation; Not Produced in Discovery

FX-816b New Moccasin Head_080216_00167.MTS Foundation; Not Produced in Discovery

FX-816c New Moccasin Head_080216_00169.MTS Foundation; Not Produced in Discovery

FX-816d Old Moccasin Head_080216_00157.MTS Foundation; Not Produced in Discovery

FX-816e Old Moccasin Head_080216_00158.MTS Foundation; Not Produced in Discovery

FX-817a Small Slough Between Swift and Hog Slough_08-02-16_00122.MTS Foundation; Not Produced in Discovery

FX-817b Small Slough Between Swift and Hog Slough_08-02-16_00124.MTS Foundation; Not Produced in Discovery

FX-817c Small Slough Between Swift and Hog Slough_08-02-16_00126.MTS Foundation; Not Produced in Discovery

FX-817d Small Slough Between Swift and Hog Slough_08-02-16_00130.MTS Foundation; Not Produced in Discovery

FX-817e Small Slough Between Swift and Hog Slough_08-02-16__8180.JPG Foundation; Not Produced in Discovery

FX-817f Small Slough Between Swift and Hog Slough_08-02-16__8181.JPG Foundation; Not Produced in Discovery

FX-817g Small Slough Between Swift and Hog Slough_08-02-16__8182.JPG Foundation; Not Produced in Discovery

FX-817h Small Slough Between Swift and Hog Slough_08-02-16__8187.JPG Foundation; Not Produced in Discovery

FX-818a Swift Slough_08-02-16_00107.MTS Foundation; Not Produced in Discovery

FX-818b Swift Slough_08-02-16_00110.MTS Foundation; Not Produced in Discovery

FX-818c Swift Slough_08-02-16_00112.MTS Foundation; Not Produced in Discovery

FX-818d Swift Slough_08-02-16_00113.MTS Foundation; Not Produced in Discovery

FX-818e Swift Slough_08-02-16_00115.MTS Foundation; Not Produced in Discovery

FX-818f Swift Slough_08-02-16_00117.MTS Foundation; Not Produced in Discovery

FX-818g Swift Slough_08-02-168155.JPG Foundation; Not Produced in Discovery

33

Ex. # Florida Exhibit Description Date Mentioned Date Offered Objection Date AdmittedFX-818h Swift Slough_08-02-168163.JPG Foundation; Not Produced in Discovery

FX-818i Swift Slough_08-02-168166.JPG Foundation; Not Produced in Discovery

FX-819a Upstream Douglas Feeders_00180.MTS Foundation; Not Produced in Discovery

FX-819b Upstream Douglas Feeders_00188.MTS Foundation; Not Produced in Discovery

FX-819c Upstream Douglas Feeders_00191.MTS Foundation; Not Produced in Discovery

FX-820a Dog Slough - 08-31-16- 00026.MTS Foundation; Not Produced in Discovery

FX-820b Dog Slough - 08-31-16- 00028.MTS Foundation; Not Produced in Discovery

FX-820c Dog Slough - 08-31-16- 00030.MTS Foundation; Not Produced in Discovery

FX-820d Dog Slough - 08-31-16- 00034.MTS Foundation; Not Produced in Discovery

FX-820e Dog Slough - 08-31-16- 00037.MTS Foundation; Not Produced in Discovery

FX-820f Dog Slough - 08-31-16- 00038.MTS Foundation; Not Produced in Discovery

FX-820g Dog Slough - 08-31-16- 00040.MTS Foundation; Not Produced in Discovery

FX-820h Dog Slough - 08-31-16- 00045.MTS Foundation; Not Produced in Discovery

FX-820i Dog Slough - 08-31-16- 00046.MTS Foundation; Not Produced in Discovery

FX-820j Dog Slough - 08-31-16- 00048.MTS Foundation; Not Produced in Discovery

FX-820k Dog Slough - 08-31-16_IMG_8490.JPG Foundation; Not Produced in Discovery

FX-820l Dog Slough - 08-31-16_IMG_8497.JPG Foundation; Not Produced in Discovery

FX-820m Dog Slough - 08-31-16_IMG_8498.JPG Foundation; Not Produced in Discovery

FX-820n Dog Slough - 08-31-16_IMG_8501.JPG Foundation; Not Produced in Discovery

FX-820o Dog Slough - 08-31-16_IMG_8505.JPG Foundation; Not Produced in Discovery

FX-821a Approaching Florida River - 08-31-16 - 00118.MTS Foundation; Not Produced in Discovery

FX-821b Florida River - 08-31-16 - 00121.MTS Foundation; Not Produced in Discovery

FX-821c Florida River - 08-31-16IMG_8623.JPG Foundation; Not Produced in Discovery

FX-821d Florida River - 08-31-16IMG_8626.JPG Foundation; Not Produced in Discovery

FX-821e Florida River - 08-31-16IMG_8627.JPG Foundation; Not Produced in Discovery

FX-821f Florida River - 08-31-16IMG_8628.JPG Foundation; Not Produced in Discovery

FX-821g Florida River - 08-31-16IMG_8629.JPG Foundation; Not Produced in Discovery

FX-822 Hook and Bay - 08-31-16 - 00113.MTS Foundation; Not Produced in Discovery

FX-823a Approaching Mussel Tagging Site after Unnamed Slough - 08-31-16- 00077.MTS


34

Ex. # Florida Exhibit Description Date Mentioned Date Offered Objection Date AdmittedFX-823b Mussel Tagging Site after Un-named Slough - 08-31-16- 00082.MTS Foundation; Not Produced in Discovery

FX-823c Mussel Tagging Site after Un-named Slough - 08-31-16- 00087.MTS Foundation; Not Produced in Discovery

FX-823d Mussel Tagging Site after Un-named Slough - 08-31-16- 00092.MTS Foundation; Not Produced in Discovery

FX-823e Mussel Tagging Site after Un-named Slough - 08-31-16- 00094.MTS Foundation; Not Produced in Discovery

FX-823f Mussel Tagging Site after Un-named Slough - 08-31-16- 00103.MTS Foundation; Not Produced in Discovery

FX-823g Mussel Tagging Site after Un-named Slough - 08-31-16IMG_8548.JPG Foundation; Not Produced in Discovery

FX-823h Mussel Tagging Site after Un-named Slough - 08-31-16IMG_8551.JPG Foundation; Not Produced in Discovery

FX-823i Mussel Tagging Site after Un-named Slough - 08-31-16IMG_8553.JPG Foundation; Not Produced in Discovery

FX-823j Mussel Tagging Site after Un-named Slough - 08-31-16IMG_8554.JPG Foundation; Not Produced in Discovery

FX-823k Mussel Tagging Site after Un-named Slough - 08-31-16IMG_8555.JPG Foundation; Not Produced in Discovery

FX-823l Mussel Tagging Site after Un-named Slough - 08-31-16IMG_8556.JPG Foundation; Not Produced in Discovery

FX-823m Mussel Tagging Site after Un-named Slough - 08-31-16IMG_8557.JPG Foundation; Not Produced in Discovery

FX-823n Mussel Tagging Site after Un-named Slough - 08-31-16IMG_8564.JPG Foundation; Not Produced in Discovery

FX-823o Mussel Tagging Site after Un-named Slough - 08-31-16IMG_8565.JPG Foundation; Not Produced in Discovery

FX-823p Mussel Tagging Site after Un-named Slough - 08-31-16IMG_8569.JPG Foundation; Not Produced in Discovery

FX-823q Mussel Tagging Site after Un-named Slough - 08-31-16IMG_8572.JPG Foundation; Not Produced in Discovery

FX-823r Mussel Tagging Site after Un-named Slough - 08-31-16IMG_8574.JPG Foundation; Not Produced in Discovery

FX-823s Mussel Tagging Site after Un-named Slough - 08-31-16IMG_8576.JPG Foundation; Not Produced in Discovery

FX-824a Unnamed Slough after Dog Slough - 08-31-16- 00053.MTS Foundation; Not Produced in Discovery

FX-824b Unnamed Slough after Dog Slough - 08-31-16- 00054.MTS Foundation; Not Produced in Discovery

FX-824c Unnamed Slough after Dog Slough - 08-31-16- 00055.MTS Foundation; Not Produced in Discovery

FX-824d Unnamed Slough after Dog Slough - 08-31-16- 00056.MTS Foundation; Not Produced in Discovery

FX-824e Unnamed Slough after Dog Slough - 08-31-16- 00059.MTS Foundation; Not Produced in Discovery

FX-824f Unnamed Slough after Dog Slough - 08-31-16- 00060.MTS Foundation; Not Produced in Discovery

FX-824g Unnamed Slough after Dog Slough - 08-31-16- 00061.MTS Foundation; Not Produced in Discovery

FX-824h Unnamed Slough after Dog Slough - 08-31-16- 00064.MTS Foundation; Not Produced in Discovery

FX-824i Unnamed Slough after Dog Slough - 08-31-16- 00066.MTS Foundation; Not Produced in Discovery

FX-824j Unnamed Slough after Dog Slough - 08-31-16- 00068.MTS Foundation; Not Produced in Discovery

FX-824m Unnamed Slough after Dog Slough - 08-31-16_IMG_8524.JPG Foundation; Not Produced in Discovery

35

Ex. # Florida Exhibit Description Date Mentioned Date Offered Objection Date AdmittedFX-824n Unnamed Slough after Dog Slough - 08-31-16_IMG_8533.JPG Foundation; Not Produced in Discovery

FX-824o Unnamed Slough after Dog Slough - 08-31-16_IMG_8534.JPG Foundation; Not Produced in Discovery

FX-824p Unnamed Slough after Dog Slough - 08-31-16_IMG_8535.JPG Foundation; Not Produced in Discovery

FX-824q Unnamed Slough after Dog Slough - 08-31-16_IMG_8536.JPG Foundation; Not Produced in Discovery

FX-824r Unnamed Slough after Dog Slough - 08-31-16_IMG_8537.JPG Foundation; Not Produced in Discovery

FX-824s Unnamed Slough after Dog Slough - 08-31-16_IMG_8538.JPG Foundation; Not Produced in Discovery

FX-824t Unnamed Slough after Dog Slough - 08-31-16_IMG_8539.JPG Foundation; Not Produced in Discovery

FX-824u Unnamed Slough after Dog Slough - 08-31-16_IMG_8540.JPG Foundation; Not Produced in Discovery

FX-824v Unnamed Slough after Dog Slough - 08-31-16_IMG_8541.JPG Foundation; Not Produced in Discovery

FX-825 IMG_8598.JPG Foundation; Not Produced in Discovery

FX-826a CP_historical_fit.pdf Hearsay; Foundation; Authenticity; Not Produced in Discovery

FX-826b DB_historical_fit.pdf Hearsay; Foundation; Authenticity; Not Produced in Discovery

FX-826c CP_historical_sal18_badfit.pdf Hearsay; Foundation; Authenticity; Not Produced in Discovery

FX-827a Fishing_posteriors_CP.pdf Hearsay; Foundation; Not Produced in Discovery

FX-827b Error_posteriors_CP.pdf Hearsay; Foundation; Authenticity; Not Produced in Discovery

FX-828 CP_sizedist_example_fits.pdf Hearsay; Foundation; Authenticity; Not Produced in Discovery

FX-829a salinity_unimpacted_CP.pdf Hearsay; Foundation; Authenticity; Not Produced in Discovery

FX-829b salinity_unimpacted_DB.pdf Hearsay; Foundation; Authenticity; Not Produced in Discovery

FX-829c salinity_remedy_CP.pdf Hearsay; Foundation; Authenticity; Not Produced in Discovery

FX-829d salinity_remedy_DB.pdf Hearsay; Foundation; Authenticity; Not Produced in Discovery

FX-830a CP_biomass_change_unimpacted.pdf Hearsay; Foundation; Authenticity; Not Produced in Discovery

FX-830b DB_biomass_change_unimpacted.pdf Hearsay; Foundation; Authenticity; Not Produced in Discovery

FX-830c CP_biomass_change_remedy.pdf Hearsay; Foundation; Authenticity; Not Produced in Discovery

FX-830d DB_biomass_change_remedy.pdf Hearsay; Foundation; Authenticity; Not Produced in Discovery

FX-831 Revised_Posterior_Parameter_Estimates.docx Hearsay; Foundation; Authenticity; Not Produced in Discovery

FX-832 Oyster_cultch_time_series.xlsx Hearsay; Foundation; Authenticity; Not Produced in Discovery

FX-833a Chattahoochee Flow Totals.xlsx Hearsay; Foundation; Authenticity; Not Produced in Discovery

FX-833b Chattahoochee River Flow_DK.xlsx Hearsay; Foundation; Authenticity; Not Produced in Discovery

FX-834 CTD data (ctd_23June2016.csv) Hearsay; Foundation; Authenticity; Not Produced in Discovery

36

Ex. # Florida Exhibit Description Date Mentioned Date Offered Objection Date AdmittedFX-835 YSI data (gulf_ysi_4Feb2015.csv) Hearsay; Foundation; Authenticity;

Not Produced in DiscoveryFX-836a Sumatra Flow Data_29Aug2016.xlsx Hearsay; Foundation; Authenticity;

Not Produced in DiscoveryFX-836b Sumatra Flow Totals.xlsx Hearsay; Foundation; Authenticity;

Not Produced in DiscoveryFX-837 Growth trajectories of individual oysters in Apalachicola Bay Hearsay; Foundation; Authenticity;

Not Produced in DiscoveryFX-838 Juvenile Oysters Growth Data (juvenile_oysters_9July2016.csv) Hearsay; Foundation; Authenticity;

Not Produced in DiscoveryFX-839 Fl Landings.xlsx Hearsay; Foundation; Authenticity;

Not Produced in DiscoveryFX-840 Data collected from annual population surveys and predation experiments

(reef_biomass_8July2016.csv)Hearsay; Foundation; Authenticity; Not Produced in Discovery

FX-841 Relationship between Predation on Oysters and Amount of Ambient Oyster Reef Structure

Hearsay; Foundation; Authenticity; Not Produced in Discovery

FX-842 Survivorship of oysters in experiments on oyster reefs with different amounts of structure (reef biomass)


FX-843 Data from Kimbro annual surveys of Apalachicola Bay oyster populations (Apalach Obay Surveys 2016 NC.MR.xlsx)


FX-844 Data collected from laboratory experiments on snail predators (TaskB2I_ii_laboratory salinity magnitude and duration feeding rate update 9_2_2016.csv)


FX-845 Seasonal Relationship between Predation on Oysters and Water Salinity Hearsay; Foundation; Authenticity; Not Produced in Discovery

FX-846 Effect of Salinity and Duration on Snail Feeding Rates Hearsay; Foundation; Authenticity; Not Produced in Discovery

FX-847 Data collected from Apalachicola Bay experiments (apalach_subtidal_22Aug2016.csv)


FX-848 Summary Tables of Statistical Results for Apalachicola Bay experiments Hearsay; Foundation; Authenticity; Not Produced in Discovery

FX-849 Summary Tables of Statistical Results for Apalachicola Bay and Ochlockonee Bay experiments


FX-850a Table of Statistical Results from Apalachicola Bay experiments, part 1 Hearsay; Foundation; Authenticity; Not Produced in Discovery

FX-850b Table of Statistical Results from Apalachicola Bay experiments, part 2 Hearsay; Foundation; Authenticity; Not Produced in Discovery

FX-851 Table of mean water salinity, temperature, and predatory snails during Apalachicola Bay experiments


FX-852 Table of Statistical Results from Apalachicola Bay and Ochlockonee Bay experiments


FX-853 Size Distributions of Oyster Populations in Apalachicola Bay 2013-16 (Kimbro_survey_sizedistributions.pdf)


FX-854 Data collected from Apalachicola Bay and Ochlockonee Bay experiments (gulf_subtidal_1July2016.csv)


FX-855 Relationship between Predation and Water Salinity in Apalachicola Bay and Ochlockonee Bay


FX-856 taskC4.gulf.figures.2015.pdf Hearsay; Foundation; Authenticity; Not Produced in Discovery

FX-857 Data collected from surveys of disease and parasite prevalence in Apalachicola Bay (taskC4.gulf.parasite.2015.csv)


FX-858 Florida reserves the right to introduce additional FRE 1006 exhibits.FX-859 Florida reserves the right to introduce rebuttal, impeachment, or

demonstrative exhibits.FX-860 Florida reserves the right to introduce as an exhibit any document listed in

Georgia's exhibit list. FX-861 ACF Basin Water Savings Summaries – October 2006 through September 2015

– Florida Mobile Irrigation Laboratories

37

Ex. # Florida Exhibit Description Date Mentioned Date Offered Objection Date AdmittedFX-862a Florida Statewide Agricultural Demand (“FSAID”) Final Report & Appendix A

FX-862b Florida Statewide Agricultural Demand (“FSAID”) Appendix B - Irrigated Acreage Estimates Projections by County

FX-862c Florida Statewide Agricultural Demand (“FSAID”) Appendix C - Projected Acreage Graphs by County

FX-862d Florida Statewide Agricultural Demand (“FSAID”) Appendix DFX-863 Final Fish & Wildlife Coordination Act Report on Water Control Manual

Updates for the Apalachicola-Chattahoochee-Flint River Basin in Georgia, Alabama, and Florida, and Appendices

FX-865 Letter from G. Carmody to D. Struhs re: Florida Proposal for ACF Water Allocation Formula

FX-867 NRD Groundwater Quantity Regulations Across Nebraska (September 2015)

FX-868 S. Irmak & K. Djaman, Basic Soil and Water Resources and Irrigation Engineering/Agricultural Water Management and Related Terminology

FX-869 May 3, 2016 Letter to Georgia re: Kimbro ReportFX-870 Darst, M.R., and H.M. Light, Drier forest composition associated with

hydrologic change in the Apalachicola River Floodplain, Florida. U.S. Geological Survey Scientific Investigations Report 2008-5062.

FX-871 FWC. Summary Report for Franklin County Coastal Waters. In: Seagrass Integrated Mapping and Monitoring Program, Mapping and Monitoring Report 1.1, FWRI Technical Report TR-17. Yarbro, L.A. and P.R. Carlson Jr., eds. FWC, Fish and Wildlife Research Institute

Georgia Blanket Objection #1: Georgia reserves the right to modify or assert additional objections to documents Florida seeks to introduce during the cross-examination of Georgia’s witnesses, or on re-direct of any Florida witnesses.Georgia Blanket Objection #2: Georgia has put forth its objections based on what it believes are the correct versions of Florida’s exhibits. Georgia reserves the right to modify its objections upon seeing the final, stamped versions of Florida’s trial exhibits. Georgia may also assert additional objections on completeness grounds should Florida attempt to introduce excerpts of documents, instead of complete versions.

38

Ex. # Joint Exhibit Description Date Mentioned Date Offered Objection Date AdmittedGX0001 USACE, Mobile District Apalachicola-Chattahoochee-Flint Basin, Water

Control Plan. Draft. U.S. Army Corps of Engineers, Mobile District, Mobile, AL.

GX0002 Leitman, Steve, A Review of the Sikes Cut Navigation Channel and Its Impacts Upon the Salinity Regime of Apalachicola Bay.

GX0003 Torak, L.J., G.S. Davis, G.A. Strain, and J.G. Herndon. Geohydrology and Evaluation of Stream-Aquifer Relations in the Apalachicola-Chattahoochee-Flint River Basin, Southeastern Alabama, Northwestern Florida, and Southwestern Georgia, U.S. Geological Survey Water-Supply Paper 2460.

GX0004 GAEPD Flint River Basin Management Plan.GX0005 Kondolf, G. M. Hungry water: effects of dams and gravel mining on river

channels. Environmental Management 21, No. 4: 533-551. FRE 802 (Hearsay)

GX0006 Draft comments on oyster manuscript FRE 802 (Hearsay)GX0007 Light, H.M., M.R. Darst, and J.W. Grubbs. Aquatic habitats in relation to

river flow in the Apalachicola River floodplain." U.S. Geological Survey Professional Paper 1594. Florida.

FRE 802 (Hearsay)

GX0008 USACE Draft EIS Appendix A, Letters and Memorandums of Agreement and ACF Basin Compact FRE 802 (Hearsay)

GX0009 Affidavit of Harold Reheis, 2003 Water Supply Request of the State of Georgia to USACE FRE 802 (Hearsay)

GX0010 2002 Water Supply Request of the State of Georgia to USACE FRE 802 (Hearsay)GX0011 Fax note from Gail Carmody to Jim Estes re Drought and Apalachicola

River FRE 802 (Hearsay); FRE 106 (Completeness)

GX0012 Letter from Allan Egbert to Dr. Joseph Westphal re coordination of navigation windows with State officials and Corps

GX0013 Letter from Allan Egbert to Dr. Joseph Westphal re coordination of navigation windows with State officials and Corps

GX0014 Clean Water Initiative, Final Report of the Clean Water Initiative FRE 802 (Hearasy)GX0015 ACF discussion of new, revised Florida proposal FRE 802 (Hearsay); FRE 403 (Prejudicial)GX0016 NWFWMD Staff Report, Memo to Governing Board from Regulatory

Division re Request for Renewal and Modification of Individual Water Use Permit No. 19910121; Standard Water Use Permit Application No. I05944

GX0017 1998-2000 Georgia Drought Report (GA EPD)GX0018 Georgia EPD, Water Planning Standards prepared for the Metropolitan

North Georgia Water Planning District.GX0019 SJRWMD Annual Water Use Data 2001

(http://www.sjrwmd.com/technicalreports/pdfs/FS/SJ2005-FS2.pdf) FRE 401 (Relevance)

GX0020 Memo fron Ted Hoehn to Brad Hartmen re ACF Water AllocationGX0021 Press Release: EPD Declares Drought for Flint River Basin GX0022 Email from Graham Lewis to Ernest Estevez re Oysters FRE 802 (Hearsay)GX0023 Presentation re Apalachicola River, Floodplain and Bay FRE 802 (Hearsay)GX0024 Senate Report 107-338. Restore the Apalachicola River Ecosystem (RARE)

Act of 2002. FRE 802 (Hearsay); FRE 403 (Prejudicial)

GX0025 SJRWMD Annual Water Use Data 2002 (http://www.sjrwmd.com/technicalreports/pdfs/FS/SJ2005-FS3.pdf) FRE 401 (Relevance)

GX0026 Master_table_for_interbasin_transfer_2001.xlsGX0027 Press Release: Severe Drought Declared for Georgia’s Flint River Basin


No. 142, ORIGINALGEORGIA EXHIBIT LIST

39

Ex. # Joint Exhibit Description Date Mentioned Date Offered Objection Date AdmittedGX0028 Memorandum from Reheis to Governor's ACT/ACF Advisory Council re

ACF Compact FRE 802 (Hearsay)

GX0029 Year_2002_Interbasin_Water_Transfers_both_tables.xlsGX0030 Year_2003_Interbasin_Water_Transfers_both_tables.xlsGX0031 Year_2004_Interbasin_Water_Transfers_both_tables.xlsGX0032 Spreadsheets - Flows FRE 106 (Completeness); FRE 403 (Confusing)

GX0033 C.M. Hobson, GA Power letter to GA EPD FRE 802 (Hearsay)GX0034 Email from Doug Barr to Jerrick Saquibal et al. GX0035 C.M. Hobson, GA Power letter to GA EPD FRE 802 (Hearsay)GX0036 Email from Graham Lewis to Lee Edmiston re River FlowsGX0037 GADNR Press Release: Rainfall Offsets Need for Flint River Drought

Protection Declaration GX0038 2003 NWFWMD Water Supply Projections Report (Table A1, A-5)

(http://www.nwfwater.com/content/download/6026/41755/water_supply_projection2003.pdf)

FRE 106 (Completeness) - Complete report should be an exhibit; Georgia only has designated part of the document.

GX0039 Hook, J. E., E. R. Blood, R. McDowell, D. Betts, and D. Fussell. Agricultural Water Withdrawal Permits: A GIS-Based Permit Management System and Permit Mapping in Dougherty Plain. In: K. J. Hatcher, Ed. Proceedings of the 2003 Georgia Water Resources Conference, University of Georgia, Athens, Georgia.

FRE 802 (Hearsay)


GX0041 Letters from Governor Perdue to Governor Bush and Governor Riley GX0042 Zhang, Yi; Hawkins, David; Zeng, Wei; Wen, Menghong; "The Framework

of GIS-based Decision Support Systems for Water Resources Management at the Flint River Basin."

FRE 802 (Hearsay)

GX0043 Letter from Governor Riley to Governor Perdue re equitable ACF Allocation Formula FRE 802 (Hearsay)

GX0044 Email from Edmiston to Andrews re apalachicola (sic) issues with attachments FRE 802 (Hearsay); FRE 408

GX0045 Northwest Florida Water Management District Water Supply Projections 2005-2025

GX0046 Memorandum from Ted Hoehn to Brian Barnett re ACF MOU - Agreement of Principles for the Water Allocation

GX0047 Memorandum from FDACS to Mark Berrigan re Role of Apalachicola Bay Oyster Advisory Committee

GX0048 "Tri-State Water Talks Face Setback" FRE 802 (Hearsay)GX0049 Memorandum from Faraj to Interested Media re Letters to Governor

Perdue and Governor RileyGX0050 Letter from Governor Riley to Governor Bush re MOU FRE 802 (Hearsay)GX0051 Circular No. A-4 Regulatory Impact Analysis: A Primer

(https://www.whitehouse.gov/sites/default/files/omb/inforeg/regpol/circular-a-4_regulatory-impact-analysis-a-primer.pdf)

GX0052 Metro District Water Supply and Conservation Plan GX0053 Ron Word, "Deal Goes Down the Drain" FRE 802 (Hearsay); FRE 901 (Authentication)

GX0054 Torak, Lynn, Water Availability and Competing Demands, Southwest Georgia Sound Science Initiative FRE 802 (Hearsay)

GX0055 Email from Edmiston to Hoehn, Mesing, Lewis and Tonsmeire re Apalachicola restoration plan

GX0056 Jones, LE; Torak, LJ. Simulated Effects of Impoundment of Lake Seminole on Ground-Water Flow in the Upper Floridan Aquifer in Southwestern Georgia and Adjacent Parts of Alabama and Florida. USGS Scientific Investigations Report 2004-5077.

40

Ex. # Joint Exhibit Description Date Mentioned Date Offered Objection Date AdmittedGX0057 SJRWMD Annual Water Use Data 2004


GX0058 2004 National Crop Residue Management Survey (CTIC)GX0059 Email from Edmiston to Andrews re shorter version of restoration plan

with attachments FRE 802 (Hearsay); Foundation

GX0060 Memorandum from Hawkins to Couch re FRDPA Declaration GX0061 GADNR Press Release: Rainfall Washes Away Need for Flint River

Drought Protection Declaration GX0062 Email from Travis to Edmiston et al re 2004_aqua_sys.htm FRE 802 (Hearsay); FRE 40GX0063 Apalachicola Dredging Coalition Meeting Summary FRE 802 (Hearsay); FRE 106 (Completeness)GX0064 Comprehensive State-wide Water Management Planning Act GX0065 Florida's Rebuttal to Arguments against DeauthorizationGX0066 Letter from FDEP to FERC with attachment FRE 802 (Hearsay)GX0067 Letter from Doug Blankenau re Notice of Intent to Commence a Civil

Action in Accordance with Section 11(g) of the endangered Species Act, 16 USC 1540(g)

FRE 802 (Hearsay); FRE 403


GX0069 Water Use in Georgia by County for 2005 and Water Use Trends 1980-2005 USGS Scientific Report 2009-5002.

GX0070 Letter from Colleen Castille to Col. Peter Taylor re Corps' Operation of Dams, Reservoirs and Related Facilities in the ACF Basin FRE 802 (Hearsay)

GX0071 Presentation "Apalachicola River Damage" FRE 802 (Hearsay); FRE 901 (Authentication); Foundation

GX0072 Presentation "Apalachicola River Damage" FRE 802 (Hearsay); FRE 901 (Authentication); Foundation

GX0073 USACE, Mobile District. Reservoir Regulation and Coordination for Fish Spawn Management Purposes Standard Operating Procedure (SOP 1130-2-9), USACE, U.S. Army Corps of Engineers, Mobile District, Mobile, AL.

FRE 802 (Hearsay); FRE 901 (Authentication); Foundation

GX0074 Memorandum from Hawkins to Couch re FRDPA Declaration GX0075 GADNR Press Release: Rainfall Offsets Need for Flint River Drought

Protection Declaration GX0076 Current Requirements for Water Conservation in Georgia FRE 802 (Hearsay)GX0077 Flint River Irrigation Water and Crop Management Technology

Integration ProgramGX0078 Zeng, Wei; Wen, Menghong; "Constructing a Hydrologic Model of the

Ichawaynochaway Creek Watershed." FRE 802 (Hearsay)

GX0079 NWFWMD Staff Report, Memo to Governing Board from Regulatory Division re Request for Renewal and Modification of Individual Water Use Permit No. 20000038; Standard Water Use Permit Application No. I06502

GX0080 Hook, J.E. Irrigation depths for water use planning in the Lower Flint River Basin, Memo to Flint River Basin Plan Technical Advisory Committee.

FRE 802 (Hearsay); FRE 901 (Authentication)

GX0081 NWFWMD Staff Report, Memo to Governing Board from Regulatory Division re Request for Renewal and Modification of Individual Water Use Permit No. I06374

GX0082 NWFWMD Staff Report, Memo to Governing Board from Regulatory Division re Request for Renewal and Modification of Individual Water Use Permit No. I06500

GX0083 Zeng, Wei; McMahon, Georga; Hawkins, David; "Modeling for Conflict Resolution Using Parameterization of Operations and Strong Stakeholder Initiatives."

FRE 802 (Hearsay)

GX0084 GSWCC Contract with Albany State University

41

Ex. # Joint Exhibit Description Date Mentioned Date Offered Objection Date AdmittedGX0085 Email from Outland to Munson, Sole, and Palmer re Apalachicola River

Research by USGS

Email from Outland to Munson, Sole, and Palmer and October 2011 FDEPartment of Environmental Protection Regional Water Supply Planning Annual Report

FRE 802 (Hearsay)

GX0086 Apalachicola River and Bay Ecosystem Management Area Implementation Plan

GX0087 Apalachicola - Chattahoochee - Flint (ACF) River Basin Compact with MOU

GX0088 Light, H.M., K.R. Vincent, M.R. Darst, and F.D. Price. Water-level decline in the Apalachicola River, Florida, from 1954 to 2004, and effects on floodplain habitats: U.S. Geological Survey Scientific Investigations Report 2006-5173.

FRE 802 (Hearsay)


GX0090 Torak, L.J., and J.A. Painter. Geohydrology of the Lower Apalachicola-Chattahoochee- Flint River Basin, Southwestern Georgia, Northwestern Florida, and Southeastern Alabama, U.S. Geological Survey Scientific Investigations Report 2006-5070.

GX0091 Florida's Memorandum in Support of Motion to Preliminary Injunction on Endangered Species Act Claims in Alabama/Florida v. US Army Corps of Engineers, CV-90-BE-1331-E (N. D. Ala.)


GX0092 CatPointAllData2005.xlsGX0093 Memorandum from Johnson to Couch re FRDPA Declaration GX0094 GADNR Press Release: Georgia EPD Will Not Make Flint River Drought

Declaration This Year GX0095 Press Release: Georgia EPD Will Not Make Flint River Drought

Declaration This YearGX0096 Lower Flint River Habitat Conservation Planning FRE 802 (Hearsay); FRE 403; FoundationGX0097 2010 Interbasin Transfers tables.xls FRE 802 (Hearsay); FRE 901 (Authentication)

GX0098 Interbasin_transfer_summary_w_mgd.xlsGX0099 Year_2005_Interbasin_Water_Transfers_both_tables.xlsGX0100 Year_2006_Interbasin_Water_Transfers_both_tables.xlsGX0101 Year_2007_Interbasin_Water_Transfers_both_tables.xlsGX0102 Year_2013_Interbasin_Transfers.xlsGX0103 Email from Bruce Buckson to Rob Beaton re FW Questions FRE 802 (Hearsay)GX0104 Declaration of Wei Zeng, Ph.D. FRE 802 (Hearsay)GX0105 Email from Donald Duval to Buckson et al. forwarding QuestionsGX0106 Email from John Hunt to Luiz Barbieri et al. re Marine life Meeting? FRE 802 (Hearsay)GX0107 D.E. Radcliffe, L.T West, L.A. Morris, and T.C. Rasmussen, Onsite

Wastewater and Land Application Systems: Consumptive Use and Water Quality

FRE 802 (Hearsay)

GX0108 Letter from Carol Couch to Col. Peter Taylor re Corps ACF Operations FRE 802 (Hearsay)

GX0109 Presentation "Hydrologic Modeling Workshop, HEC-5 Modeling of ACF Interim Operation by Mobile District" FRE 802 (Hearsay)

GX0110 Letter from Couch to Taylor and Carmody re ESA Consultation on Coprs of Engineers' Operation of Jim Woodruff Dam FRE 802 (Hearsay)

GX0111 Letter from Couch to Taylor and Carmody re Updated SImulation of Corps of Engineers' Interim Operations Plan FRE 802 (Hearsay)

42

Ex. # Joint Exhibit Description Date Mentioned Date Offered Objection Date AdmittedGX0112 Letter from Colleen Castille to Gail Carmody & Curtis Flakes re

Apalachicola-Chattahoochee-Flint River Endangered Species Act Consultation

FRE 802 (Hearsay)

GX0113 Email from Carol Couch re Convening of the State Drought Response Committee FRE 802 (Hearsay)

GX0114 Letter from FDEP to Carmody Proposed Modificated to Interim Operations Plan.pdf FRE 802 (Hearsay)

GX0115 Declaration of Wei Zeng, Ph.D. FRE 802 (Hearsay)GX0116 Press Release: Georgia Declares Level One Drought Across the StateGX0117 Declaration of Wei Zeng, Ph.D. FRE 802 (Hearsay)GX0118 Declaration of Wei Zeng, Ph.D. FRE 802 (Hearsay)GX0119 Letter from Colleen Castille to Gail Carmody re Section 7 Consultation

Concerning the Corps of Engineers' "'Interim Operations Plan" for the ACF River Basin

GX0120 Letter from Colleen Castille to Gail Carmody re Section 7 Consultation Concerning the Corps' of Engineers' "Interim Operations Plan" for the ACF River Basin

FRE 802 (Hearsay)

GX0121 Letter from Carol Couch to Col. Taylor and Gail Carmody, Attaching Memorandum of Douglas L. Peterson re data on 2005 and 2006 Gulf sturgeon spawning activity

FRE 802 (Hearsay)

GX0122 Email from Lee Edmiston to Graham Lewis and Scott Nixon forwarding oyster articles

GX0123 USFWS. Biological Opinion and Conference Report on the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers, Mobile District, Interim Operating Plan for Jim Woodruff Dam and the Associated Releases to the Apalachicola River. U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service, Panama City, Florida.

GX0124 USFWS. Questions and Answers. Biological Opinion on U.S. Army Corps of Engineers’ Interim Operations Plan (IOP) for Jim Woodruff Dam and associated releases to the Apalachicola River.


GX0125 Email from Grahm Lewis to Christina Bosch forwarding Critical Habitat meeting notes FRE 802 (Hearsay)

GX0126 Email from Beaton to Pridgen et al. re Previous email on oyster task force FRE 802 (Hearsay); FRE 106 (Completeness)

GX0127 Email from Chelette to Gowens re Port St. Joe FRE 802 (Hearsay)GX0128 Email from Chelette to Flores and Dettle, cc Gowens, re Port St. JoeGX0129 Email from Joanne Brandt to Jerry Ziewitz et al. re FW ACF volumetric

calculation (UNCLASSIFIED) FRE 802 (Hearsay); FRE 901 (Authentication)

GX0130 Georgia EPD, COE/USFWS Workshop FRE 802 (Hearsay); FoundationGX0131 Jim Woodruff Dam Interim Operations Plan; Section 7 Consultation

Biological Opinion - Reasonable & Prudent Measures, Terms & Conditions, and Conservation Recommendations (Section 7.3 thru Section 8)

FRE 802 (Hearsay); FRE 106 (Completeness)

GX0132 Memorandum for Record Subject: Jim Woodruff Dam Interim Operations Plan, Biological Opinion RPM3 - Drought Provision Workshop FRE 802 (Hearsay)

GX0133 CatPoint_All_Data_1995.xlsGX0134 SJRWMD Annual Water Use Data 2007


GX0135 Letter from Michael Sole to Gail Carmody and Peter Taylor re Comments on Reasonable and Prudent Measure No. 3 (Drought Provisions) FRE 802 (Hearsay)

GX0136 Email from Raffington to Barr re Federal Issues for Northwest Florida Water Managment District

GX0137 Email from Michael Sole to Doug Barr re Meet on ACF modeling FRE 802 (Hearsay)

43

Ex. # Joint Exhibit Description Date Mentioned Date Offered Objection Date AdmittedGX0138 Letter from Michael Sole to Gail Carmody re Response to Georgia and

ARC et al's Comments on Reasonable and Prudent Measure No. 3 (Drought Provisions)

FRE 802 (Hearsay)

GX0139 Composite Zones in AC-FT (2000 - 2001)GX0140 Email from Zettle to C. Hrabovsky and J. Hathorn re Zine Discussion

(UNCLASSIFIED) FRE 802 (Hearsay)

GX0141 GADNR Press Release: No Drought Declaration This Year for Flint River Basin, Says Georgia EPD

GX0142 Corps-7day.xls (EPD Woodruff flows spreadsheet) FRE 802 (Hearsay)GX0143 Corps-7day.xls (EPD Woodruff flows spreadsheet) FRE 802 (Hearsay)GX0144 Email from Joanne Brandt to Trey Glen, Michael Sole, et al. forwarding

Jim Woodruff Dam IOP Biological Opinion - RPM3 Drought Provision

GX0145 Email from Chelette to Dettle, Flores and Gowens re 20 yr permits FRE 802 (Hearsay)GX0146 LiDAR digital elevation map data for all the 53 sub-watersheds of the

Apalachicola River watershed (HUC8: 03130011) and Douglas Slough sub-watershed (HUC12: 031300120606) of the Chipola River watershed.

FRE 106 (Completeness); FRE 403 - Florida is unable to determine the location of this website; the link provided by Georgia is broken.

GX0147 Letter from FDEP to Gail Carmody.pdfGX0148 Letter from Sole to Carmody re USFWS February 28, 2007 letter

approving USACE Concept 5, with attached Memorandum from Barr to Sole

GX0149 Understanding the Interim Operation Plan in the Apalachicola-Chattahoochee-Flint River Basin (Zeng 2007) FRE 802 (Hearsay)

GX0150 HEC-ResSim Reservoir System Simulation (User's Manual)GX0151 HEC-ResSim Reservoir System Simulation, User's Manual, Version 3.0 FRE 802 (Hearsay)

GX0152 Memorandum from Dan Tonsmeire to Florida Stakeholders re Situation/Update of ACF Water Wars FRE 802 (Hearsay)

GX0153 Letter from Couch to Taylor re Corps ACF Operations under the IOP FRE 802 (Hearsay)GX0154 Press Release: Georgia EPD Declares Level Two Drought StatewideGX0155 Press Release: Georgia EPD Declares Level Two Drought StatewideGX0156 Letter from Sole to Geren, Strock, Taylor, Kempthorne, Hall and Carmody

re 60-Day Notice of Intent to Sue Pursuant to the Endangered Species Act

GX0157 Email from Jonathan Ashley to C. Hrabovsky et al. re Nugget of the day FRE 802 (Hearsay)

GX0158 Relative Percent of Flow of the Lake Seminole Water Budget (2000 and 2001)

GX0159 "Ag Water Conservation Through Irrigation Reservoirs (Ponds)"GX0160 Letter from Michael Sole to Taylor re Corps' Continued Withdrawals of

Water from the ACF Basin Under the Live and Let Live Provisions FRE 106 (Completeness)

GX0161 Draft Management Plan options for Recovery of Oyster Resources in Florida

GX0162 NWFWMD Staff Report, Memo to Governing Board from Regulatory Division re Request for Renewal and Modification of Individual Water Use Permit 1980209; Individual Water Use Permit Application I06454

GX0163 FY2007June 07.25.07 -Budget Report.xlsGX0164 Letter from Jackie Llewellyn to Gail Carmody re Corps Violations of the

Volumetric Accounting Procedure in the September 2006 Biological Opinion

FRE 802 (Hearsay)

GX0165 Memo from Zeng to Couch re Review of USFWS's Draft Economic Analysis of Critical Habitat Designation for the Seven Mussels FRE 802 (Hearsay)

44

Ex. # Joint Exhibit Description Date Mentioned Date Offered Objection Date AdmittedGX0166 Letter from Jackie Llewellyn to Gail Carmody re Corps Violations of the

Volumetric Accounting Procedure in the September 2006 Biological Opinion

FRE 802 (Hearsay); Foundation

GX0167 Apalachicola River Restoration Meeting Summary FRE 802 (Hearsay)GX0168 Letter from Couch to Jones re IOP FRE 802 (Hearsay)GX0169 Email from Graham Lewis to Kyle Hubbard et al. re oyster info FRE 802 (Hearsay)GX0170 Email from Brian Zettle to J. Hathorn re Additional Figure Regarding

Drought FRE 802 (Hearsay)

GX0171 Letter from Michael Sole to Byron Jorns, ACE Mobile District, re Georgia's "Request for Immediate Alteration of IOP Release" FRE 106 (Completeness)

GX0172 Email from Brian Zettle to J. Ziewitz, G. Carmody, et al. re Signed Suspension of Downramping Letter FRE 802 (Hearsay)

GX0173 Letter from C. Flakes to G. Carmody re options to temporarily modify existing Jim Woodruff Dam Interim Operations Plan protocols FRE 802 (Hearsay)

GX0174 Email from Brian Zettle to Douglas etal. re FW Signed Suspension of Downramping Letter FRE 802 (Hearsay)

GX0175 Letter from C. Carmody to C. Flakes responding to October 19 letter re temporary revision to the Woodruff Dam Interim Operating Plan FRE 802 (Hearsay)

GX0176 Letter from C. Flakes to C. Carmody re options to temporarily modify existing Woodruff Dam Interim Operations Plan protocols to preserve composite storage

FRE 802 (Hearsay)

GX0177 Email from Couch to Glenn and Sole et al. re Conference call in lieu of meeting FRE 802 (Hearsay)

GX0178 Email from Cheryl Hrabovsky to J. Ashley, A. Houston et al. re FW Volumetric Balancing FRE 802 (Hearsay)

GX0179 Email from Brian Zettle to Gail Carmody re FW Updated Modeling Results FRE 802 (Hearsay)

GX0180 Email from J. Hathorn to B. Zettle, G. Carmody, et al. re Updated Modeling Results FRE 802 (Hearsay)

GX0181 Presentation with graphs for Buford, West Point, WF George, Chattahoochee storage and flow FRE 802 (Hearsay)

GX0182 Email from J. Hathorn to B. Zettle, G. Carmody, et al. RE Chattahoochee Flow from Updated Modeling FRE 802 (Hearsay)

GX0183 Email from Douglas Barr to Julie Fishman and Jennifer Fitzwater re Query for today Foundation

GX0184 Letter from Michael Sole to Gail Carmody & Curtis Flakes re ESA Section 7 Consultation on Proposed "Exceptional Drought Operations" FRE 802 (Hearsay); FRE 901 (Authentication)

GX0185 Email from Kay Buchanan to Michael Sole & Kelly Layman re Carmody Letter re ESA Section 7 Consultation on Proposed "Exceptional Drought Operations"


GX0186 Amended Biological Opinion and Conference Report on the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers, Mobile District, Exceptional Drought Operations for the Interim Operating Plan for Jim Woodruff Dam and the Associated Releases to the Apalachicola River

FRE 802 (Hearsay)

GX0187 Email from M. Vaughan to J. Brandt, B. Zettle, et al. re Reduction in Flows at Woodruff FRE 802 (Hearsay)

GX0188 Email from B. Zettle to M. Vaughan, J. Brandt, et al. re Reduction in Flows at Woodruff FRE 802 (Hearsay)

GX0189 7-Day Moving Average Inflow versus 1-Day Chattahoochee Flow FRE 802 (Hearsay)GX0190 Email from Layman to Sole re FW: ACF with Tallahassee Democrat blog

post and ACF Talking Points & Facts FRE 802 (Hearsay)

GX0191 Email from Heil to Edmiston et al re water war FRE 802 (Hearsay); FoundationGX0192 Model Elevations with 10% Hydrology and Lowering of Woodruff Release

Target FRE 802 (Hearsay)

45

Ex. # Joint Exhibit Description Date Mentioned Date Offered Objection Date AdmittedGX0193 Letter from Michael Sole to Gail Carmody and Curtis Flakes re

Endangered Species Act Section 7 Consultation on Exceptional Drought Operations, November 21, 2007, Proposed Reduction Triggers FRE 802 (Hearsay)

GX0194 Email from M. Vaughan to J. Hathorn, et al RE Draft ltr for 4500 Trigger FRE 802 (Hearsay)

GX0195 EDO Incremental Reduction in Flow to 4,750 cfs - ACF Reservoir Storage Conserved FRE 802 (Hearsay)

GX0196 EDO Incremental Reduction to 4,500 CFS Trigger Components, Status of Basin Indicators FRE 802 (Hearsay)

GX0197 Email from Joanne Brandt to G. Carmody & J. Ziewitz re ACF Exceptional Drought Operations - 4,500 cfs Incremental reduction - 7 Dec 2007 Letter to USFWS

FRE 802 (Hearsay)

GX0198 Hydrological Data and Modeling - ACF Basin Status, Trends and Forecasts - EDO Trigger for Reduction of Flows to 4,500 cfs FRE 802 (Hearsay)

GX0199 Letter from USACE to G. Carmody providing supplemental information to previous letter dated Nov. 21, 2007 and updating trrigger to be used to determine additional reduction flows

FRE 802 (Hearsay)

GX0200 Email from Joanne Brandt to D. Morgan, W. Smallwood, W. Fuller, T. Jangula et al. re FW EDO Reduction in Apalachicola River Flows to 4500 cfs - Monitoring for Incidental Take of Mussels

FRE 802 (Hearsay)

GX0201 Email from Joanne Brandt to G. Carmody, J. Ziewitz et al. re FW Clarification of Impacts to Mussels Avoided by Implementation of the 4 500 cfs Reduction Under EDO

FRE 802 (Hearsay)

GX0202 Email from M. Vaughan to Douglas et al re FW REVISED ACF 10 day forecast FRE 802 (Hearsay)

GX0203 Email from Edmiston to G. Lewis forwarding information requested on Dec-13 ACF drought call with attachment FRE 802 (Hearsay)

GX0204 2008 NWFWMD Water Supply Assessment Update (http://www.nwfwater.com/content/download/7478/56759/WSA_Final2008.pdf)

GX0205 2008 SJRWMD Annual Water Use Survey (http://www.sjrwmd.com/technicalreports/pdfs/FS/SJ2009-FS1.pdf) FRE 401 (Relevance)

GX0206 Georgia Irrigation Survey (http://www.nespal.org/sirp/agwateruse/facts/2009.0122.IrrSurvey08_misc_pub.pdf)

FRE 802 (Hearsay)

GX0207 NOAA Commercial Fisheries Statistics Total Commercial Fishery Landings at Major U.S. Ports Summarized by Year and Ranked By Dollar Value

GX0208 USACE, Mobile District Supplemental Environmental Assessment, Modifications to the Interim Operations Plan for Support of Endangered and Threatened Species andTemporary Waiver from ACF Water Control Plan, Jim Woodruff Dam, Gadsden and Jackson Counties, Florida and Decatur County, Georgia. U.S. Army Corps of Engineers, Mobile District, Mobile, AL.

GX0209 "Urban Agriculture Industries in Georgia, USA Respond to Outdoor Watering Ban" FRE 802 (Hearsay)

GX0210 Georgia Comprehensive State-Wide Water PlanGX0211 GA Center for Urban Agriculture - Layoffs Increase and Losses Accelerate

in Response to the Drought FRE 802 (Hearsay)GX0212 Memorandum from Mollie Palmer to Secretary Sole re ACF Stakeholders

meeting report - Blountstown/Calhoun CountyGX0213 Habitat Loss - Florida's concrete footprints FRE 802 (Hearsay); Foundation; FRE 901

(Authentication)

46

Ex. # Joint Exhibit Description Date Mentioned Date Offered Objection Date AdmittedGX0214 Letter from Sole to Jorns re State of Florida's Comments as requested on

Proposed Reduction of Flow from Buford Dam FRE 106 (Completeness)

GX0215 Fax from USDOI to Turner, Attaching February 29, 2008 letter to Governor Perdue re MOU FRE 802 (Hearsay)

GX0216 Memorandum from W. Zeng re FRDPA Declaration FRE 802 (Hearsay)GX0217 GADNR Press Release: Conditions for Lower Flint River Basin Drought

Declaration Not Present, Says Georgia EPD GX0218 Corp's Order, Finding of No Significant Impact re Georgia Environmental

Protection Division Proposal for a Temporary Reduced Minimum Water Quality Flow in the Chattahoochee River at Peachtree Creek for Drought Contingency Water management Operation in the ACF River Basin and Temporary Waiver from ACF Water Control Plan

FRE 802 (Hearsay)

GX0219 NWFWMD Staff Report, Memo to Governing Board from Regulatory Division re Request for Modification and Renewal of Individual Water Use Permit No. 19830039; Individual Water Use Permit Application No. I06806

GX0220 Email from Gowens to Chelette re 6806 PSJ.doc FRE 802 (Hearsay)GX0221 USACE. Description of Proposed Action Modification to the Interim

Operations Plan at Jim Woodruff Dam. FRE 802 (Hearsay); FRE 901 (Authentication)

GX0222 Memorandum for Record SUBJECT Apalachicola, Chattahoochee, Flint Basin (ACF) Low Flow Analysis FRE 802 (Hearsay); FRE 403

GX0223 EDO Consultation Forecast Modeling - Revisions to IOP/EDO FRE 802 (Hearsay)GX0224 Letter from FDEP to USFWSGX0225 Letter from Sole to Carmody and Flakes te Endangered Species Act

Section 7 Consultation on Proposed Revision to the Interim Operations Plan

GX0226 Letter from Michael Sole to Gail Carmody & Curtis Flakes re opposition to the proposed revision to the Interim Operations Plan FRE 802 (Hearsay)

GX0227 NOAA Drought Public Fact Sheet. FRE 802 (Hearsay)GX0228 Findings of No Significant Impact - Georgia Environmental Protection

Request to Continue the Temporary Reduced Minimum Water Quality Flow in the Chattahoochee River at Peachtree Creek Until May 31, 2008 for Drought Contingency Water Management Operation in the ACF River Basin and Temporary Waiver from ACF Water Control Plan

FRE 802 (Hearsay)

GX0229 Letter from Noah Lockley/Franklin County to Gail Carmody and Curtis Flakes re Comments on Proposed Revision to the Interim Operating Plan at Jim Woodruff Dam

GX0230 Letter from Dan Tonsmeire to Gail Carmody re Modifications to the Interim Operations Plan (IOP) at Jim Woodruff Dam - April 15, 2008 FRE 802 (Hearsay); Hearsay Within Hearsay

GX0231 USACE. Finding of No Significant Impact for Modifications to the Interim Operations Plan for Support of Endangered and Threatened Species and Temporary Waiver from ACF Water Control Plan, Jim Woodruff Dam, Gadsden and Jackson Counties, Florida and Decatur County, Georgia.

GX0232 USFWS. Biological Opinion on the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers, Mobile District, Revised Interim Operating Plan for Jim Woodruff Dam and the Associated Releases to the Apalachicola River. U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service, Panama City, Florida.

GX0233 USFWS. Biological Opinion on the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers, Mobile District, Revised Interim Operating Plan for Jim Woodruff Dam and the Associated Releases to the Apalachicola River. U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service, Panama City, Florida. June 1, 2008.

GX0234 USFWS_FWC Aneis.xls

47

Ex. # Joint Exhibit Description Date Mentioned Date Offered Objection Date AdmittedGX0235 USACE. Revised Interim Operations Plan Q&As. FRE 802 (Hearsay); FRE 901 (Authentication)

GX0236 Press Release: Water Conservation Urged as Drought Conditions Worsen

GX0237 Email from Jonathan Ashley to M. Eubanks et al. re ACF Composite Storage FRE 802 (Hearsay)

GX0238 USGS. Water Use in Florida, 2005 and Trends 1950-2005. FDEPartment of Environmental Protection and the Florida Water Management Districts. Fact Sheet 2008-3080.

FRE 802 (Hearsay)

GX0239 Email from B. Zettle to J. Ziewitz, G. Carmody, et al. re September RIOP Operations at Jim Woodruff Dam FRE 802 (Hearsay)

GX0240 Email from Salz to Barr, with attached Utility/Water Management District/FDEP Partnership document FRE 802 (Hearsay)

GX0241 Email from Barr to Drew and Llewellyn re NWERP Budget FRE 401 (Relevance)GX0242 Environmental Assessment - Georgia Environmental Protection Division

Proposal for a Temporary Reduced Minimum Water Quality Flow Requirement in the Chattahoochee River at Peachtree Creek for Drought Contingency Water Management Operation in the ACF River Basin and Temporary Waiver from ACF Water Control Plan

FRE 802 (Hearsay)

GX0243 Email from Rebecca Prado to multiple individuals re Final Primer and Meeting, Attaching Havens, et al. The Effects of Climate Change on Florida's Ocean and Coastal Resources, A Special Report to the Florida Energy and Climate Commission and the People of Florida.

GX0244 Catpoint Jan-Jul 2007wq-dayave.xlsGX0245 2009 SJRWMD Annual Water Use Survey


GX0246 Florida Climate Center, Office of the State Climatologist, Climate Summary (https://climatecenter.fsu.edu/products-services/summaries/climate-summary-for-florida-april-2009)

FRE 802 (Hearsay)

GX0247 Hook, J.E. Agricultural Irrigation Water Demand, Georgia's Major and Minor Crops, 2011 through 2050 (http://www.nespal.org/SIRP/waterinfo/State/AWD/AgWaterDemand.htm)

GX0248 Kondolf, G. M. Restoration prospects for the Apalachicola River. Report to American Rivers. FRE 802 (Hearsay)

GX0249 USACE. Final Scoping Report, Environmental Impact Statement, Update of the Water Control Manual for the Apalachicola-Chattahoochee-Flint (ACF) River Basin in Alabama, Florida, and Georgia. Mobile District, U.S. Army Corps of Engineers, Mobile, Alabama.

GX0250 USDA Forest Service (http://www.ncrs.fs.fed.us/fmg/nfmg/bl_hardwood/eco/site/veg.html) FRE 802 (Hearsay)

GX0251 USDA. "Table 1. County Summary Highlights: 2007." AC-07-A-10. In 2007 Census of Agriculture Georgia State and County Data. Volume 1: Geographic Area Series, Part10. National Agricultural Statistics Service. (http://www.agcensus.usda.gov/Publications/2007/Full_Report/Volume_1,_Chapter_2_County_Level/Georgia/st13_2_001_001.pdf).

GX0252 Email from J. Llewellyn to Wehle, Moore, Still, Barr, Green, et al. re Review of draft Climate Change/Water Management report - DUE FEB. 2 with Draft Framework for Action

FRE 802 (Hearsay)

GX0253 2008 Irrigation Survey (University of Georgia College of Agricultural and Environmental Sciences)

GX0254 Harrison, K. "2008 Irrigation Survey."

48

Ex. # Joint Exhibit Description Date Mentioned Date Offered Objection Date AdmittedGX0255 Declaration of Helen Light, In re Tri-State Water Rights Litigation FRE 402 (Hearsay); FRE 403 (Prejudice)GX0256 Declaration of Douglas E. Barr, In re Tri-state Water Rights Litigation

(Case 3:07-md-00001-PAM-JRK, Doc. 193-4)GX0257 Declaration of Michael W. Sole, In re Tri-state Water Rights Litigation

(Case 3:07-md-00001-PAM-JRK, Doc. 193-2)GX0258 Final Scoping Report, Environmental Impact Statement, Update of the

Water Control Manual for the Apalachicola-CHattahoochee-Flint (ACF) River Basin, in Alabama, Florida, and Georgia

GX0259 Memorandum from W. Zeng re FRDPA Declaration FRE 802 (Hearsay)GX0260 GADNR Press Release: Georgia EPD Will Not Issue Drought Declaration

for Lower Flint River Basin This Year GX0261 NWFWMD Consolidated Annual Report 3/1/2009

(http://www.nwfwater.com/Data-Publications/Reports-Plans/Consolidated-Annual-Reports)

GX0262 Press Release: Watering Restrictions Continue, EPD To Allow Water Efficient Soaker Hoses and Drip Irrigation

GX0263 Press Release: Watering Restrictions Continue, EPD To Allow Water Efficient Soaker Hoses and Drip Irrigation

GX0264 Georgia EPD Order to All Water Users in Georgia Counties Under State Drought Response Level 4

GX0265 Conservation Innovation Grant Project Smmary Sheet: Water Conservation through Furrow Diking in Georgia

GX0266 Conservation Innovation Grant Project Summary Sheet: Water Conservation through Shallow Subsurface Drip Irrigation in Georgia

GX0267 Zeng, W. Agricultural water use and its surface water effects in the Flint and Lower Chattahoochee River Basins, Memorandum to file. FRE 802 (Hearsay); FRE 901 (Authentication)

GX0268 Memorandum from Wei Zeng to File re Agricultural water use and its surface water effects I nthe Flint and lower Chattahoochee River Basins

GX0269 Email from Graham Lewis to Tom Gilpin forwarding NOAA grant for Tates Hell FRE 802 (Hearsay)

GX0270 Memorandum to File by Wei Zeng FRE 802 (Hearsay)GX0271 Presentation "Agriculture Water Use in Georgia - An Overview for

Planning" FRE 802 (Hearsay); Document is Illegible

GX0272 Email from Douglas Barr to Tom Beason re Meeting(s) with Mike Sole Foundation; FRE 106 (Completeness)

GX0273 Email from Lee Edmiston to Jennifer Wanat and Graham Lewis re FW: Water wars may take new direction with new administration

GX0274 Email from Ken Haddad to Dan Tonsmiere, N. Wiley and K. Ventimiglia re Meeting(s) with Mike Sole Foundation; FRE 106 (Completeness)

GX0275 Email from Ted Hoehn to MaryAnn Poole re meeting(s) with Mike Sole FRE 802 (Hearsay)

GX0276 Email from Lawson Snyder to Michael Hill, Bill Coleman, Chris Paxton, Donald Eggeman and David Douglas forwarding Meetings June 12 2009 Apalachicola River

FRE 802 (Hearsay)

GX0277 Email from Jerrick Saquibal to Doug Barr re Corp June Model Monlthly Flows at Chattahoochee

GX0278 Email from Mike Allen to Nick Wiley re Apalachicola River Restoration meetings follow-up Foundation; FRE 106 (Completeness)

GX0279 Email from Jerrick Saquibal re forwarding Sending memo again FRE 802 (Hearsay)GX0280 Memorandum from Alia Faraj to Interested Media re Letter to Governor

Perdue and Governor Riley GX0281 2009 Gulf Sturgeon 5-Year Review FRE 802 (Hearsay)GX0282 Project Proposal: Conservation genomics of Gulf sturgeon FRE 802 (Hearsay); FRE 401 (Relevance)

49

Ex. # Joint Exhibit Description Date Mentioned Date Offered Objection Date AdmittedGX0283 First Meeting Deck prepared by Water Contingency Planning Task Force

GX0284 Email from Steve Geiger to M. Berrigan et al. re from our law enforcement division in FL FRE 802 (Hearsay)

GX0285 Water Council Expenditures - Development of Statewide Water Plan 2005-2008

GX0286 Summary of Water Conservation, Water Management and Water Efficiency Projects with Special Focus on the Lake Lanier/ Chattahoochee River Users

GX0287 Catpoint Jan-Nov 2009.xlsGX0288 Second Meeting Deck prepared by Water Contingency Planning Task

Force GX0289 Metropolitan North Georgia Water Planning District - Activities &

Progress Report GX0290 Third Meeting Deck prepared by Water Contingency Planning Task Force

GX0291 Email from Doug Barr to Jerrick Saquibal forwarding Draft Release of the ACT/ACF Unimpaired Flow (1939-2008) FRE 802 (Hearsay)

GX0292 2010 Survey of Estimated Annual Water Use for St. Johns River Water Management District (http://www.sjrwmd.com/technicalreports/pdfs/FS/SJ2011-FS1.pdf)

FRE 401 (Relevance)

GX0293 GEFA Annual Report FRE 802 (Hearsay)GX0294 Georgia Water Stewardship Act, SB 370

(http://www.legis.ga.gov/Legislation/20092010/103008.pdf).GX0295 Letter from Thomas Beason to Brian Zettle re Revision of Scope of

Environmental Impact for Updated Water Control Manual for the Apalachicola-Chattahoochee-Flint River Basin

GX0296 Jim Woodruff Dam Revised Interim Operations Plan Biological Opinion Annual Report FRE 802 (Hearsay); Foundation

GX0297 Email from Jerrick Saquibal to Doug Barr re 2000 GA demandsGX0298 Email from Wei Zeng to Jerrick Saquibal re fyi FRE 802 (Hearsay)GX0299 Email from Jerrick Saquibal to Doug Barr re GA 2030-2050 demands

model simulation flows and elevationsGX0300 Water Contingency Planning Task Force, Findings and Recommendations

,Cobb County Management Retreat FRE 802 (Hearsay)

GX0301 Declaration of James Hathorn in Support of Federal Defendants' "Phase 2" Cross-Motion for Summary Judgment, In re Tri-State Water Rights Litigation, No. 3:07-md-00001 (M. D. Fla.) (filed Feb. 10, 2010) FRE 802 (hearsay)

GX0302 Email from Rachel Poppe to Rob Beaton et al. re FW: Extended Closure - FYI FRE 802 (Hearsay)

GX0303 Email from Donal Duval to Rob Beaton & David Heil re Extended Closure - FYI FRE 802 (Hearsay)

GX0304 Memorandum from W. Zeng to Barnes re FRDPA Declaration GX0305 GADNR Press Release: Georgia EPD Will Not Issue Drought Declaration

for Lower Flint River Basin This Year GX0306 NWFWMD Consolidated Annual Report 3/1/2010

(http://www.nwfwater.com/Data-Publications/Reports-Plans/Consolidated-Annual-Reports)

GX0307 USACE. Updated Scoping Report, Environmental Impact Statement, Update of the Water Control Manual for the Apalachicola-Chattahoochee-Flint (ACF) River Basin in Alabama, Florida, and Georgia. Mobile District, U.S. Army Corps of Engineers, Mobile, Alabama.

GX0308 Declaration of Wei Zeng, Ph.D. FRE 901 (Authentication)

50

Ex. # Joint Exhibit Description Date Mentioned Date Offered Objection Date AdmittedGX0309 The State of Florida and the City of Apalachicola's Consolidated

Opposition to the Federal Defendants' Cross Motion for Summary Judgment on Phase 2 Claims and Reply to the Non-Federal Parties' Opposition Briefs, in In re Tri-State Water Rights Litigation, No. 3:07-MD-1-PAM (M.D. Fla.)(filed Mar. 3, 2010)

FRE 802 (Hearsay); FRE 403 (Confusing/Misleading); see, e.g. , 992 F.2d 1244 (1st Cir. 1993) 910 F.2d 1291 (5th Cir. 1990); 851 F.2d 742, 745-46 (5th Cir. 1988) (all discussing admission of briefs and distinguishing between briefs and factual pleadings in court)

GX0310 Year_2009_interbasin_water_transfers_summary_rev.xlsxGX0311 Updated Scoping Report, Environmental Impact Statement, Update of the

Water Control Manual for the Apalachicola-Chattahoochee-Flint (ACF) River Basin, in Alabama, Florida, and Georgia

GX0312 National Environmentally Sound Production Agriculture Laboratory (NESPAL). GIS Map of Irrigated Land in Georgia. University of Georgia, College of Agricultural and Environmental Sciences (http://www.nespal.org/sirp/waterinfo/state/awd/agwaterdemand_irrarea.htm)

GX0313 NESPAL. "GIS Map of Irrigated Land in Georgia." University of Georgia, College of Agricultural and Environmental Sciences. (http://www.nespal.org/sirp/waterinfo/state/awd/agwaterdemand_irrarea.htm).

GX0314 Fax from Lynn Martina to David Heil re opening summer harvesting areas of Apalachicola Bay FRE 802 (Hearsay)

GX0315 Email from David Heil to Sherman Wilhelm re Apalachicola bay; 5/4/2010 letter from Joseph Parrish to Charles Bronson FRE 802 (Hearsay)

GX0316 Order No. Eo 10-19 Early Opening of the Summer Harvest Season for Oysters In Apalachicola Bay Established in Rule 68B-27.019 (1)(a)1, F.A.C.

GX0317 Email from Wilhelm to Wiley re letter, Attaching 5/20/2010 FDACS Letter to Wiley re early opening of summer harvesting areas FRE 802 (Hearsay)

GX0318 Press release from FACS and FWC re State announces early opening of summer oyster areas FRE 802 (Hearsay)

GX0319 Letter from Joseph Parrish to Gov. CristGX0320 Email from Wilhelm to Wiley re question FRE 802 (Hearsay)GX0321 Email from David Heil to Sherman Wilhelm re Letters FRE 802 (Hearsay)GX0322 Order No. EO 10-25 Additional Oyster Harvest Days for Apalachicola Bay

GX0323 Email from Wiley to Mears re State announces extra harvesting day for Apalchicola oysters

GX0324 Email from Nick Wiley to Sherma Wilhelm re new Request FRE 802 (Hearsay)GX0325 Email from Wiley to Wilhelm re new request FRE 802 (Hearsay); FRE 106 (Completeness)GX0326 Email from David Heil to S. Wilhelm and M. Berrigan re Franklin County

Commission Votes to Support Maximum Utilization of Resources FRE 802 (Hearsay)

GX0327 Letter from Charles Bronson to Nick Wiley re request to allow 7 day harvesting in summer and winter areas of Apalachicola Bay

GX0328 Email from Wilhelm to Wiley and Bud Vielhauer re letter, Attaching 6/16/2010 FDACS Letter to Wiley re early opening of summer harvesting areas

FRE 802 (Hearsay)

GX0329 Order No. Eo 10-32 Additional Oyster Harvest Days and Areas for Apalachicola Bay

GX0330 Press Release - Florida Provides for Increased Apalachicola Bay Oyster Production

GX0331 Email from FDACS to Rob Beaton re PRESS RELEASE: Apalachicola Bay Oyster Production Increased

51

Ex. # Joint Exhibit Description Date Mentioned Date Offered Objection Date AdmittedGX0332 Order No. EO 10-32 - Additional Oyster Harvest Days and Areas for

Apalachicola BayGX0333 Letter from William Teehan to Joseph ParrishGX0334 Email from Rob Beaton to Emergency Operations Center forwarding

PRESS RELEASE: Oyster Harvesting License Application Period Extended

GX0335 Draft Comments of the Environmental Protection Division on the Lower Flint River Basin Mussel Habitat Assessment and Monitoring Project Draft Final Report

FRE 802 (Hearsay)

GX0336 Email from Donald Duval to Bruce Buckson, David Heil, Rob Beaton, Dave Pridgen et al. re Apalachicola Bay

GX0337 Letter from Bud Vielhauer to Curtis Flakes re Fish and Wildlife Coordination Act Consultation on Apalachicola-Chattahoochee-Flint (ACF) Water Control Manual

GX0338 Email from Dave Pridgen to Michael Wiwi et al re Apalachicola Bay FRE 802 (Hearsay)GX0339 Email from Bruce Buckson to Dave Pridgen, Michael Wiwi re Apalachicola

Bay FRE 802 (Hearsay)

GX0340 Collection of correspondence from GOIC, FDACS and ABODA to FDEP of Ag, Franklin County Board of Commissioners, Franklin County OSTF and NOAA

FRE 802 (Hearsay)

GX0341 Email from Bannister to Wiley re Fwc and the oystermen FRE 802 (Hearsay); FRE 403 (Prejudicial)GX0342 Letter from Mike Voisin to Nick Wiley re concerns over undersized oyster

harvesting Foundation

GX0343 Final Report on State Agency Activities (https://epd.georgia.gov/sites/epd.georgia.gov/files/related_files/site_page/SB370%20rpt%20review%20Final.pdf)

GX0344 Email from Rob Beaton to Donald Duval forwarding Florida Oyster Letter FRE 802 (Hearsay)

GX0345 Framework for Action: Water Management and Climate Change in Florida FRE 802 (Hearsay)

GX0346 FDEP October 2010: Climate Change / Water Management Connections

GX0347 Georgia's State Water Plan FRE 802 (Hearasy)GX0348 Letter from Douglas Barr to Mimi Drew, EPA Secretary re FY2010/2011

priority list and schedule update for the establishment of minimum flows and levels in Northwest Florida

FRE 106 (Completeness)

GX0349 Email from Hoehn to G. Lewis et al. forwarding some oyster model results with attachment FRE 802 (Hearsay)

GX0350 MNGWPD Activities & Progress Report GX0351 ANERR Fall 2011 Oyster Catcher (http://apalachicolareserve.com/news-

fll11.php) FRE 802 (Hearsay)

GX0352 FWC, Seagrass integrated mapping and monitoring for the State of Florida: Mapping and monitoring report no. 1. L.A. Yarbro and P.R. Carlson, Jr. (Eds.). FWC, Fish and Wildlife Research Institute, St. Petersburg, FL (http://myfwc.com/media/1591147/fullsimm1.pdf)

FRE 802 (Hearsay)

GX0353 Groundwater Conditions and Studies in Georgia, 2008-2009. Scientific Investigations Report 2011-5048.

GX0354 Email from Joe Walsh to Ted Hoehn re Apalachicola Bay and River Riverkeeper- meeting with Nick

GX0355 Email from Pierce to Edmiston et al re DEP/County Administrator calls FRE 802 (Hearsay); Foundation

GX0356 Letter from Vielhauer to USFWS re ACF Master Water Control Manual

GX0357 Email from Markey to Gowens, et al. re Apalachicola River Flows FRE 802 (Hearsay)

52

Ex. # Joint Exhibit Description Date Mentioned Date Offered Objection Date AdmittedGX0358 Email from Helen Light to Jerrick Saquibal re ResSim Model and baseline

Model Outputs, ACF FRE 802 (Hearsay)

GX0359 Jiang, Feng; Liang, Hailian; Zeng, Wei; "Uncertainty Analysis of Unimpaired Flow and Monthly 7Q10" FRE 802 (Hearsay)

GX0360 The Governor’s Water task Force and The Georgia Water Stewardship Act, David M. Ashley and Katie Kirkpatrick FRE 802 (Hearsay)

GX0361 Email from Lee Edmiston to Erica Seiden re FYI, Attaching article "Activists Appalled by environmental-law changes in Florida" FRE 401 (Relevance)

GX0362 Email from B. Zettle to K. Herrington, D. Imm, et al. re River Level Fall Rates (UNCLASSIFIED) FRE 802 (Hearsay)

GX0363 CatPoint(2011Q1).xlsxGX0364 Email from Leitman to Barr re Florida proposal FRE 802 (Hearsay)GX0365 Email from Wooten to Lucinda Scott, Faith Eidse, et al. re updated

drought fact sheet FRE 106 (Completeness)

GX0366 Email from Ron Bartel to Graham Lewis re Biological Conditions FRE 802 (Hearsay)GX0367 2011 UNC Tables of Water and Sewer Rates and Rate Structures in

Georgia (http://www.efc.sog.unc.edu/reslib/item/tables-water-and-sewer-rates-and-rate-structures-georgia-august-2011)

GX0368 FDACS Oyster Resource Assessment Report GX0369 Email from Janet Llewellyn to Bob Ballard et al re Statewide Drought

Summary - Period ending Aug. 12 FRE 802 (Hearsay)

GX0370 Memorandum from Zeng to Barnes re Recorded and projected water demand in the Upper Chattahoochee River and Lake Lanier FRE 802 (Hearsay)

GX0371 Email from Brooks to Lewis and Cairns, re Fw: DEP SECRETARY ANNOUNCES $700 MILLION IN WATER MANAGEMENT DISTRICTS BUDGET REDUCTIONS

FRE 802 (Hearsay)

GX0372 Middle Chattahoochee Regonal Water Plan GX0373 Email from A. Podney to R. Beaton, D. Heil and W. Teehan re FW Oyster

Harvest Aug 2011.docx FRE 802 (Hearsay); FRE 106 (Completeness)

GX0374 Email from David Heil to A. Podney, K. Purcell, et al. R. Beaton re Oyster Harvest Aug 2011.docx FRE 802 (Hearsay); FRE 106 (Completeness)

GX0375 Email from Teehan to Beaton, Podey et al. re Oyster Harvest FRE 106 (Completeness)GX0376 RIOP Semi-Annual and RIOP Re-consultation Meeting powerpoint

presentation FRE 802 (Hearsay)

GX0377 Email from Marc Glatzer to Rob Beaton, Antonio Kilpatricl et al. re Draft Control of Harvest PEER

GX0378 Email from Munson to Shortelle, re this version addresses your comments

GX0379 Letter from Herschel Vinyard to Goveronor Rick Scott, Senator Alexander, Representative Grimsley re 1st Quarter (Fiscal Year 11-12) Status Report on the Apalachicola, Chattahoochee, and Flint Rivers water allocation litigation

Foundation

GX0380 Regional Water Plans Adopted November 2011 (http://www.georgiawaterplanning.org/pages/regional_water_planning/regional_water_plans_-_adopted_september_2011.php)

GX0381 Letter from Barnes to Corps re Lanier Releases FRE 802 (Hearsay)GX0382 Feasibility Study for Restoring the Apalachicola River in Battle Bend

(Submitted by Mathias Kondolf)FRE 802 (Hearsay); Foundation; FRE 901 (Authentication)

GX0383 Final Report on State Agency Activities (https://epd.georgia.gov/sites/epd.georgia.gov/files/related_files/site_page/SB370%20rpt%20review%20Final.pdf)

53

Ex. # Joint Exhibit Description Date Mentioned Date Offered Objection Date AdmittedGX0384 TetraTech, “Watershed Hydrology and Water Quality Modeling Report for

the Chattahoochee River Watershed, Georgia,” Revision 2. FRE 802 (Hearsay); Foundation

GX0385 Email from Munson to Fitzwater, Attaching Everglades and ACF Update

GX0386 Appendix P3: Nutrient Calibration and Validation for Middle Chattahoochee Watershed Foundation; FRE 106 (Completeness)

GX0387 Georgia's Water Future in Focus: Highlights of Regional Water Planning 2009-2011

GX0388 December 2011 Report: Martin County Oyster Reef Restoration Project - A compilation and summary of four short-term biological monitoring studies FRE 802 (Hearsay); FRE 401 (Relevance)

GX0389 Notes re call to Governor Deal with Explanation of State Line Flow Formula

FRE 802 (Hearsay); FRE 901 (Authentication); FRE 408


FRE 401 (Relevance)

GX0392 ACF Basin Composite Conservation and Flood StorageGX0393 ANERR 2000-2012 Monthly Trawl Data and associated salinity data, as

transformed and produced with this report Foundation

GX0394 MNGWPD Activities & Progress Report GX0395 Oyster Recovery Plan with correspondenceGX0396 USACE, Mobile District Environmental Assessment and Finding of No

Significant Impact, Revised Interim Operating Plan for Support of Endangered and Threatened Species, Jim Woodruff Dam, Gadsden and Jackson Counties, Florida and Decatur County, Georgia. U.S. Army Corps of Engineers, Mobile District, Mobile, AL.

GX0397 Email from Tonsmeire to Edmiston re forwarded Memorandum: Request for Declaration Regarding Florida's Oyster Harvesting Areas with attachments

GX0398 Email from B. Zettle to J. Hathorn etal re RIOP Modifications for USFWS Consultation (UNCLASSIFIED) FRE 802 (Hearsay)

GX0399 Email from J. Hathorn to B. Zettle et al re RIOP Modifications for USFWS Consultation (UNCLASSIFIED) FRE 802 (Hearsay)

GX0400 Email from Munson to Schmalfuss and Nevin, Attaching FDEP, FWCC, and U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service ACF Meeting Agenda, and Letter from Llewellyn to Imm re ESA Section 7 Consultation Concerning "Modified Revised Interim Operations Plan"

GX0401 Gov. Scott talking points DRAFT for meeting with Gov Deal FRE 901 (Authentication); FRE 802; FRE 408GX0402 Petition for a Writ of Certiorari, in In re MDL-1824 Tri-State Water Rights

Litigation (U.S. 11- 999) (Filed Feb. 1, 2012)

FRE 802 (Hearsay); FRE 403 (Confusing/Misleading); see, e.g. , 992 F.2d 1244 (1st Cir. 1993) 910 F.2d 1291 (5th Cir. 1990); 851 F.2d 742, 745-46 (5th Cir. 1988) (all discussing admission of briefs and distinguishing between briefs and factual pleadings in court)

GX0403 Email from Kathleen Greenwood to Catherine Walker, Frost, Chelette, Shortelle, Llewellyn, et al. re cup consistency analysis FRE 802 (Hearsay)

GX0404 Email from Engel to Diaz, Attaching Governor Scott Talking PointsGX0405 Future Water Supply Demands and Returns for the Atlanta Metro Area

Water Utilities from Lake Lanier and the Chattahoochee River FRE 802 (Hearsay); Foundation

GX0406 The Oyster Fishery of the Gulf of Mexico United States: A Regional Management Plan 2012 Revision

GX0407 Hydrograph by USGS pertaining to the Apalachicola River at Chattahoochee, Florida.

54

Ex. # Joint Exhibit Description Date Mentioned Date Offered Objection Date AdmittedGX0408 USACE. Environmental Assessment, Revised Interim Operations Plan for

Support of Endangered and Threatened Species, Jim Woodruff Dam, Gadsden and Jackson Counties, Florida and Decatur County, Georgia. Mobile District, U.S. Army Corps of Engineers, Mobile, Alabama.

GX0409 2012_Interbasin_Transfers.xlsGX0410 Year_2011_Interbasin_Transfers.xlsGX0411 Letter from Janet Llewellyn to Steven RoemhildtGX0412 Email from Heil to Wilhelm forwarding Apalachicola Bay email FRE 802 (Hearsay)GX0413 Environmental Assessment - Revised Interim Operations Plan for Support

of Endangered and Threatened Species Jim Woodruff Dam, Gadsden and Jackson Counties, Florida, and Decatur County, Georgia FRE 802 (Hearsay)

GX0414 Presentation "The Uses and Misuses of River Basin Models in Managing the Apalachicola-Chattahoochee-Flint Basin, United States" FRE 802 (Hearsay)

GX0415 Email from Chelette to Gowens and Eidse re Review please?GX0416 Letter from Manley Fuller to Heather Mason re Maintenance Snagging of

the Apalachicola River portion of the Apalachicola-Chattahoochee-Flint (ACF) Federal Navigation Project File No 07-0129424-008-EI FRE 802 (Hearsay)

GX0417 Stockdale, E. Memorandum to Chief of Engineers regarding authority to provide for municipal and industrial water supply from the Buford Dam/Lake Lanier Project, Georgia. Office of the Chief Counsel, U.S. Army Corps of Engineers, Washington, D.C. (http://ww3.sam.usace.army.mil/2012ACF_legalopinion.pdf)

GX0418 Order No. Eo 12-09 Extension of 2011-2012 License Year for Saltwater Products Licenses associated with Apalachicola Bay Oyster Harvesting Licenses

GX0419 Google earth mapGX0420 Letter from Douglas Barr to USFWS re Comments on the Corps May 22,

2012 Revised Interim Operations Plan

GX0421 Memorandum from Paul Thorpe to Gowens re Water Supply Assessment and Regional Water Supply Planning Recommendations

GX0422 Letter from Barr to Imm re RIOP CommentsGX0423 Email from Lewis to Cairns et al. re FW: District ACF Involvement FRE 106 (Completeness)GX0424 Irrigation Depths for Water Use Planning in the Lower Flint River Basin

GX0425 Email from David Heil to Jessica McCawley, Jim Estes et al forwarding draft copy of AB Oyster Resource Assessment report

GX0426 Email from Jim Estes to David Heil, et al re FW: Draft Apalachicola Bay Oyster Resource Assessment FRE 802 (Hearsay)

GX0427 Email from David Heil to Jim Estes forwarding Draft Apalachicola Bay Oyster Resource Assessment FRE 802 (Hearsay)

GX0428 Email from Jim Estes to Nick Wiley, Louie Roberson, Greg Holder, Jackie Fauls re Apalachicola Bay System - Oyster Resource Conservation

GX0429 Email from David Heil to Estes re Federal FundingGX0430 Email from Estes to Heil, Ventimiglia et al re FW: Draft Apalachicola Bay

Oyster Resource AssessmentGX0431 Email from Wiley to Grayson re Fwd: Apalachicola Bay System - Oyster

Resource Conservation FRE 106 (Completeness)

GX0432 Memorandum from Zeng re Historic and projected water use in the metro Atlanta area FRE 802 (Hearsay); Foundation

55

Ex. # Joint Exhibit Description Date Mentioned Date Offered Objection Date AdmittedGX0433 Email from David Heil to Jim Ester forwarding NOAA Contact FRE 802 (Hearsay)GX0434 Email from David Heil to Rob Beaton et al. forwarding Draft Apalachicola

Bay Oyster Resource Assessment report FRE 802 (Hearsay)

GX0435 Email from David Heil to Luiz Barbieri re FW: Draft Apalachicola bay Oyster Resource Assessment with draft assessment

GX0436 Email from David Heil to Mark Berrigan and Steve Geiger re Oysters and forwarding correspondence and reports FRE 802 (Hearsay)

GX0437 The Water Efficiency and Conservation State Scorecard: An Assessment of Laws and Policies FRE 802 (Hearsay); FRE 403; Foundation

GX0438 Meeting Minutes - Franklin County Board of County Commissioners GX0439 Email from Steve Geiger to David Heil and Mark Berrigan re Oysters FRE 802 (Hearsay)

GX0440 Email from David Heil to Jim Estes re Draft FRE 802 (Hearsay); FRE 106 (Completeness)GX0441 State of Georgia State Entity Standard Contract Form (GSWCC nad

Albany State University)GX0442 Email from David Heil to Andrew Grayson et al forwarding draft

Oyster.doc FRE 802 (Hearsay)

GX0443 Email from David Heil to David Harding, et al forwarding draft assessment report with attached Oyster Value FRE 802 (Hearsay)

GX0444 Letter from Putnam to Gov. Scott, Attaching August 2012 Oyster Resource Assessment Report

GX0445 Email from Herschel Vinyard to Jennifer Fitzwater re Franklin County oyster meeting FRE 802 (Hearsay)

GX0446 Email from Gaskin to Edmiston et al re Ecological Flow Assessment NRDA Project Description

GX0447 Annual Report - Conservation Technical Assistance and Education for Socially Disadvantaged Farmers in Southwest Georgia FRE 802 (Hearsay)

GX0448 Email from Munson to Keenan re Apalachicola Bay FRE 802 (Hearsay)GX0449 Email from Charlie Wood to Cook, Percy; Martin, Terry; Brownell,

Carmon; Allen, John; Ward, James; Carroll, Jason; Cook, Steven; Raker, Ruel; Gore, Matthew et al. re Shellfish Deal

GX0450 Email from Dan Tonsmeire to Greg Munson re MEMORANDUM: Request for Declaration Regarding Florida's Oyster Harvesting Areas FRE 802 (Hearsay)

GX0451 Email from Payne to Morris et al., re oyster problemsGX0452 ACFS TOCWG Meeting Summary FRE 802 (Hearsay)GX0453 J. Turner Direction re FRDPA revisions FRE 802 (Hearsay)GX0454 Email from Depnews re ADDENDUM DEP MEDIA CONTACTS FRE 802 (Hearsay)GX0455 Memorandum to Steverson and Cyphers from Lewis, Wooten, Busen and

Countryman re Water volumes needed to augment Apalachicola River flows for oyster protection

FRE 802 (Hearsay)

GX0456 Email from Leslie Palmer to Jim Estes, Jessica McCawley, Louie Robertson, Rob Beaton, David Heil et al. re Draft oyster management options memo for discussion

FRE 802 (Hearsay); FRE 901 (Authentication); FRE 106 (Completeness)

GX0457 Email from Shortelle to Vinyard and Munson, Attaching Water Management Letter to Governor Scott FRE 802 (Hearsay)

GX0458 Email from Jones to Wiley re Fwd: University of Florida News - UF forms task force to address Apalachicola Bay oyster fishery collapse FRE 802 (Hearsay); FRE 106 (Completeness)

GX0459 Email from Louie Roberson to Jim Estes and Leslie Palmer forwarding Closed area and Night oysterinig arrest FRE 802 (Hearsay)

GX0460 Letter and Attachment from Adam Putnam to Governor Rick Scott FRE 802 (Hearsay)GX0461 E-mail from Pine to Allen re more detail on data needs for the task force FRE 802 (Hearsay)

GX0462 Email from Pine to Havens and Payne re more detail needs for the task force FRE 802 (Hearsay)

56

Ex. # Joint Exhibit Description Date Mentioned Date Offered Objection Date AdmittedGX0463 Email from David Kimbro to Karl Havens re UF Oyster Recover Task

Force FRE 802 (Hearsay)

GX0464 Email from Bill Pine to Jim Estes, Karl Havens and Michael Allen re Email FRE 802 (Hearsay); FRE 106 (Completeness)

GX0465 Email from Bill Pine to Jim Estes re Email FRE 802 (Hearsay)GX0466 Email from Leslie Palmer to Louie Roberson, Clay Martin et al. re One of

the action items from last night … see below FRE 802 (Hearsay)

GX0467 Email from Jim Estes to Amanda Nalley forwarding Report on our findings in St. Andrews Bay

GX0468 E-mail from Bill Pine to Carl Walters re oyster FRE 802 (Hearsay)GX0469 Email from Greg Munson to Thomas Beason et al. forwarding State

Support for the ACF Legislation FRE 802 (Hearsay); Foundation

GX0470 Powerpoint: UF Oyster Recovery Team FRE 802 (Hearsay); FoundationGX0471 Draft Management Plan options for Recovery of Oyster Resources in

FloridaGX0472 E-mail from Estes to Pine re data on size structure FRE 802 (Hearsay)GX0473 Email from David Kimbro to Andrew Kane re UF Oyster Recovery Team

Summarized environmental data with many questions FRE 802 (Hearsay)

GX0474 Email from Douglass Barr to Herschel Vinyard re ACF Reservoir Releases to Apalachicola Bay FRE 802 (Hearsay); Foundation

GX0475 Email from David Heil to Jim Estes re some ideas related to oysters developed on the drive back FRE 802 (Hearsay); Foundation

GX0476 Email from Ted Hoehn to Helen Light re ACFS_FWC Riverine_10_22_12edits.pptx with attachment

GX0477 Email from David Heil to Jim Estes re some ideas related to oysters developed on the drive back FRE 802 (Hearsay)

GX0478 Email from Wiley to Grayson et al re FW: Draft Apalachicola Bay Oyster Resource Assessment with August 2012 Assessment Report

GX0479 Email from Wiley to McManus re Oysters in ApalachicolaGX0480 Email from Estes to Wiley re meeting FRE 802 (Hearsay)GX0481 Franklin County Report GX0482 Apalachicola Bay Issues - Oysters, Review and Discussion GX0483 Email from Pine to Estes with [UF Oyster Recovery Team] comments form

Lake Lanier water groups - points out reports of wide spread changes in oyster populations spatially

FRE 802 (Hearsay); Foundation; FRE 106 (Completeness)

GX0484 Email from Havens to Estes re [UF Oyster Recovery Team] comments from Lake Lanier water groups - points out reports of wide spread changes in oyster populations spatially


GX0485 Email from Karl Havens to Bill Pine re Oyster Funding from sea grant in 2014 FRE 802 (Hearsay)

GX0486 Email from Karl Havens to Bill Pine re Oyster Funding from sea grant in 2014 FRE 802 (Hearsay)

GX0487 Email from Jim Estes to [email protected] re Possible Bay Closure FRE 802 (Hearsay); Foundation; Best Evidence Rule

GX0488 Memorandum to Jessica McCawley from Mark Berrigan re oyster assessments from Cat Point Bar and East Hole Bar

GX0489 ABODA statement re relaying plans FRE 802 (Hearsay)GX0490 E-mail from Pine to Havens re time series of estimated TP, TN and DOP

loads FRE 802 (Hearsay)

GX0491 Email from Pine to Havens re Meeting/Teleconference FRE 802 (Hearsay)GX0492 Email from Munson to Tonsmeire, re ACF Permit FRE 802 (Hearsay)GX0493 Letter from FDEP to Val Perry, Exec VP of Lake Lanier AssociationGX0494 Email from Ted Hoehn to Joanne Brandt re Proposed Navigation Releases

for SNOC Steam Generator Shipment on Apalachicola-Chatahoochee-Flint Rivers - Update and request for comments

57

Ex. # Joint Exhibit Description Date Mentioned Date Offered Objection Date AdmittedGX0495 State of Florida Presentation - USFWS Workshop for Alternatives to

Reservoir Operations in ACF: Seeking a Balance Between Lake Levels in ACF Reservoirs and Flow in Apalachicola River and Bay


GX0496 Email from Pine to Havens re Research Needs for AB - Confidential FRE 802 (Hearsay)GX0497 Email from Steve Geiger to Melanie Parker and Sarah Stephenson re FW:

oyster comments from Friday 11/30 meeting FRE 802 (Hearsay)

GX0498 Email from Mark Berrigan to Steve Brown et al. re Oyster monitoring data

GX0499 Email from David Heil to Steve Brown et al re Oyster monitoring data FRE 802 (Hearsay)

GX0500 E-mail from PIne to Barnett re ACF FRE 802 (Hearsay)GX0501 Presentation "UF Oyster Recovery Team" FRE 802 (Hearsay); FoundationGX0502 Email from David Kimbro to Jim Estes re Apalachicola oyster research FRE 802 (Hearsay)

GX0503 ACF_Individual_Surface_Water_1994-2008-2.xlsx FRE 802 (Hearsay); FoundationGX0504 USGS Presentation (excerpted slides) FRE 403 (Prejudicial/Misleading/Confusing); Best

Evidence RuleGX0505 Email from Estes to Robertson re meeting todayGX0506 “2013 Pecan Budget,” The University of Georgia Cooperative Extension,

available at http://www.caes.uga.edu/commodities/fruits/pecan/budgets/documents/2013_Pecan_Budget012513.pdf


FRE 401 (Relevance)

GX0508 Email from Munson to Llewellyn re Estus Writing to you FRE 802 (Hearsay)GX0509 Email from Duncan Cairns to Guy Gowens forwarding ACF Basin Issues FRE 802 (Hearsay)

GX0510 Email from Munson to Llewellyn, Attaching "Selected Water Management District Performance Metrics" and Memo from Llewellyn to Valenstein, dated January 4, 2014

GX0511 Email from David Kimbro to Andrew Kane re bio-sketch format FRE 802 (Hearsay)GX0512 Email from Carl Walters to David Kimbro re hi, intro, coordination (Oyster

Stock Assessment Model Structure and Assumptions.docx); incorporating Physical Oceanographic Proxies of Recruitment into Population Models to Improve Fishery and Marine Protected Area Management)

FRE 802 (Hearsay)

GX0513 Email from Leslie Palmer to Rob Beaton et al. re FW: shelling/relaying FRE 802 (Hearsay)

GX0514 Email from Munson to Steverson re Center Pivot Replacement with attachment "Center Pivot Replacement.docx" FRE 802 (Hearsay)

GX0515 Letter from Tucker (USFWS) to Roemhildt (USACE) FRE 802 (Hearsay)GX0516 Memorandum from Zeng to Turner re Alternative option in the ACF River

Basin FRE 802 (Hearsay)

GX0517 Letter from Governor Deal to Jo Ellen Darcy re State of Georgia Water Supply Request

GX0518 Ecological and Morphological Significance of Old Growth Deadhead Logs in the Apalachicola River FRE 802 (Hearsay)

GX0519 Letter from J. Turner re Comment of the State of Georgia FRE 802 (Hearsay)

58

Ex. # Joint Exhibit Description Date Mentioned Date Offered Objection Date AdmittedGX0520 Letter from Judson Turner to Tetra Tech, Inc re Notice of Intent to Revise

Scope of Draft Environmental Impact Statement for Updating the Water Control Manuals for the Apalachicola-Chattahoochee-Flint River Basin to Account for the U.S. Court of Appeals for hte Eleventh Circuit Ruling and a June 2012 Legal Option of the Corps' Chief Counsel Regarding Authority to Accommodate Municipal and Industrial Water Supply from the Buford Dam/Lake Lanier Project

FRE 802 (Hearsay)

GX0521 January 14, 2013 email from Jim Estes to Ted Hoehn re FW Support for Federal Legislation requiring Corps to provide needed freshwater flows to Apalachicola River and Bay

FRE 802 (Hearsay)

GX0522 Email from Connell to Gowens, Cyphers, et al. re ACF permitted amounts- quick answer

GX0523 Letter from J. Turner to Corps re U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service ACF Basin Reservoir Operating Plan Proposal FRE 802 (Hearsay)

GX0524 Synopsis of Activities in the Apalachicola-Chattahoochee-Flint Basin

Summary of Apalachicola Bay Modeling Effect

GX0525 Email from Gowens to Carins re ACF Activity FRE 802GX0526 Memorandum to Interested Parties from NWFWMD re Development and

Implementation of Minimum Flows and Levels at the NWFWMD

GX0527 Email from Karl Havens to Jack Payne re FYI OYSTERS FRE 802 (Hearsay); FoundationGX0528 Email from Karl Havens to Carl Walters & Bill Pine re White paper

timeframe and next steps FRE 802 (Hearsay); Foundation

GX0529 Email from Cyphers to Draper re MFL Overview with attachments FRE 802 (Hearsay)GX0530 Email from David Heil to Steve Brown, Steve Geiger and Mark Berrigan

re Oyster Landing Data and forwarding NOAA Disaster .doc and GOIC Request form FWC.doc

GX0531 Email from Gowens to Gowens re newspaper article Former district director defends record on Wakulla Springs FRE 802 (Hearsay)

GX0532 Email from David Heil to Jim Estes re First report for NOAA Fisheries Service FRE 802 (Hearsay)

GX0533 Email from Wiley to Fauls re Apalach - Anticipated Questions and Responses

GX0534 Email from Karen Herrington re mussel movements and dewatering FRE 106 (Completeness)GX0535 Email from Gowens to Engel re Information for article in Florida Specifier

about minimum flow levels in District's Springs FRE 802 (Hearsay); FRE 106 (Completeness)

GX0536 Synopsis of Activities in the Apalachicola-Chattahoochee-Flint Basin FRE 802 (Hearsay)

GX0537 Email from Kelly to Steverson and Noah Valenstein re Fwd: Agency Coordination - Apalach FRE 802 (Hearsay); Foundation

GX0538 Email from Wiley to McManus re Oysters in ApalachicolaGX0539 Apalachicola Oyster Weekly Conference Call (agenda and notes) FRE 802 (Hearsay)GX0540 Email from Jessica McCawley to David Heil et al. re Oyster Landings

AnalysisGX0541 Email from Cyphers to Gowens et al. re Hey (budget items)GX0542 Letters in response to USACE October 12, 2012 NOI to revise WCM EIS FRE 802 (Hearsay)

59

Ex. # Joint Exhibit Description Date Mentioned Date Offered Objection Date AdmittedGX0543 USACE News Release, “Corps Suspends Drought Operations on the

Apalachicola-Chattahoochee-Flint River Basin,” (http://www.sam.usace.army.mil/Media/NewsReleases/tabid/6473/Article/486724/corps-suspends-drought-operations-on-the-apalachicola-chattahoochee-flintriver.aspx)

GX0544 USACE. Final Updated Scoping Report, Environmental Impact Statement, Update of the Water Control Manual for the Apalachicola-Chattahoochee-Flint (ACF) River Basin in Alabama, Florida, and Georgia. Mobile District, U.S. Army Corps of Engineers, Mobile, Alabama.

GX0545 Email from Bill Pine to Karl Havens and Carl Walters re Oyster Decline FRE 802 (Hearsay)

GX0546 Email from Knickerbocker to Lovett and Conti re Sen. Montford, Attaching Oyster Harvesting License by County Summary spreadsheet

GX0547 Email from David Heil to Jim Estes re Possible Draft Letter FRE 802 (Hearsay)GX0548 Email from Gowens to Jon Steverson and Brett Cyphers with ACF Status

Report FRE 802 (Hearsay)

GX0549 Final Updated Scoping Report, Environmental Impact Statement - Update of the Water Control Manual for the Apalachicola-Chattahoochee-Flint (ACF) River basin, in Alabama, Florida, and Georgia (March 2013)

GX0550 Georgia EPD, Georgia Contemplation - A Performance Based Operation Scheme in the ACF River Basin FRE 802 (Hearsay); Foundation

GX0551 Email from T. Hoehn to J. Estes, D. Heil, and S. Geiger re Draft Report for your review FRE 802 (Hearsay); FRE 106 (Completeness)

GX0552 Email from David Heil to Ted Hoehn forwarding Draft Report for Your Review FRE 802 (Hearsay)

GX0553 Email from Cyphers to Alter re Constituent InquiryGX0554 Email from Knickerbocker to Conti re UF Apalach Bay Oyster Rpt FRE 802 (Hearsay); FoundationGX0555 Email from Rob Beaton to Jim Estes, Charlie Wood et al. re Draft Report

for Your Review FRE 106 (Completeness)

GX0556 Email from David Heil to Ted Hoehn et al re FWC Report to NOAA Fisheries

GX0557 Email from David Heil to Ted Hoehn and Lee Edmiston re I Need HELP!

GX0558 Letter from Estes to Havens re Comments on Draft Oyster Situation Report FRE 802 (Hearsay)

GX0559 Email from Bill Pine to Jim Estes (discussing concerns re harvesting violations and oyster recovery) FRE 802 (Hearsay)

GX0560 Email from Karl havens to Bill Pine re talked to DEP FRE 802 (Hearsay)GX0561 Email from Bill Pine to Karl Havens re Talked to DEP FRE 802 (Hearsay)GX0562 Email from Wiley to Payne re Oysters in Apalachicola Bay FRE 802 (Hearsay)GX0563 Email from Nick Wiley to Jim Brown, Jim Estes and Calvin Adams

forwarding Oysters in Apalachicola Bay FRE 802 (Hearsay)

GX0564 Agricultural Impacts of Drought on the Southeast US (Pam Knox, 2013) FRE 802 (Hearsay)

GX0565 Email from Hoehn to G. Lewis et al. forwarding Apalachicola Bay Oyster Situation Report Comments with attachment

GX0566 Email from Jack Payne to Karl Havens re Apalachicola FRE 802 (Hearsay)GX0567 Email from David Heil to Jim Estes re FW: Report with portions of August

2012 Assessment ReportGX0568 Florida Sea Grant Apalachicola Bay Oyster Situation Report FRE 802 (Hearsay)

60

Ex. # Joint Exhibit Description Date Mentioned Date Offered Objection Date AdmittedGX0569 Email from David Heil to Jim Estes re Report with assessment report

included FRE 802 (Hearsay)

GX0570 Email from David Heil to Steve Branstetter re FWC fisheries disaster assistance FRE 802 (Hearsay); Foundation

GX0571 Email from Steve Branstetter to David Heil re FWC fisheries disaster assistance FRE 802 (Hearsay); Foundation

GX0572 Email from Steve Branstetter to David Heil re Report FRE 802 (Hearsay); FoundationGX0573 Email from Joe Shields to Kal Knickerbocker re Weekly update FRE 802 (Hearsay)GX0574 Email from J. Estes to N. Wiley re Need some info ASAP on Oysters FRE 802 (Hearsay)GX0575 Email from David Heil to Luiz Barbieri re need some info ASAP on oysters FRE 802 (Hearsay); Foundation

GX0576 Email from David Heil to Luiz Barbieri re need some info ASAP on oysters FRE 802 (Hearsay); Foundation

GX0577 Email from David Heil to Jim Estes, Forwarding First Draft with attachments FRE 802 (Hearsay)

GX0578 Email from Jim Estes to Nick Wiley et al. re need some info ASAP on oysters FRE 106 (Completeness)

GX0579 Email from Jack Payne to Karl Havens re Details on issue with Apalachicola Bay FRE 802 (Hearsay)

GX0580 Projected Water Withdrawals and Discharages per Georgia's 2013 ACF Water Supply Request FRE 802 (Hearsay); Foundation

GX0581 Letter from Wiley to Roy Crabtree, NOAA Fisheries Service, SE Regional Office re Florida Commercial Oyster Fishery Failure

FRE 802 (Hearsay); FRE 901 (Authentication); FRE 403 (Prejudice)

GX0582 Email from Ted Hoehn to Dan Tonmeire, Charlie Mesing, Michael Hill, Graham Lewis and Matt Kondolf re Apalachicola River Restoration field trip with Restoration Plan attachment

FRE 802 (Hearsay)

GX0583 Email from Nick Wiley to Jim Estes and David Heil re Oyster declaration

GX0584 Email from David Heil to Kal Knickerbiocker et al re DRAFT FWC Oyster Disaster Report to NOAA Fisheries Services, Attaching same (5/2013) and Supplemental Document - Appendices

GX0585 Email from Brooks to Knickerbocker re Review Comments FWC Draft Report FRE 802 (Hearsay)

GX0586 Email from Paul Zajieck to Kal Knickerbocker and Christopher Brooks re FWC fishery collapse comments FRE 802 (Hearsay)

GX0587 Email from David Heil to Steve Geiger re Please Review [Executive Summary, Oyster Fishery Disaster Conclusion]

GX0588 Email from David Heil to Jim Estes re Please Review FRE 802 (Hearsay); FoundationGX0589 Email from Wiley to Estes re Fwd: 3 points you asked for related to AB

oysters FRE 802 (Hearsay)

GX0590 Email from Steve Geiger to David Heil re Please Review with Executive Sumamry FRE 802 (Hearsay)

GX0591 Email from Ryan Gandy to Steve Geiger & Luiz Barbieri re Please Review FRE 802 (Hearsay); Foundation

GX0592 2012-2013 Florida Gulf Coast Oyster Disaster Report Date - May 2013

GX0593 Email from Ryan Gandy to Steve Geiger & Luiz Barbieri re Please Review FRE 802 (Hearsay)

GX0594 Email from David Heil to Steve Geiger re Please Review FRE 802 (Hearsay)GX0595 Email from Conti to Knickerbocker re BOT Agenda Items GX0596 Proposal narrative sections FRE 802 (Hearsay)GX0597 Email from Helen Light to Ted Hoehn re FDACS reports with attachment FRE 802 (Hearsay)

GX0598 Memorandum from Zeng to Turner re Analysis of ACF River Basin operational alternative proposed by USFWS FRE 802 (Hearsay)

61

Ex. # Joint Exhibit Description Date Mentioned Date Offered Objection Date AdmittedGX0599 Email from Louie Roberson to Jim Estes re Fwd: Summer Harvest in

Apalachicola Bay FRE 802 (Hearsay)

GX0600 Email from R. Beaton to C. Wood, D. Massey, & V. Johnson re FW Oyster Closure in Apalachicola Bay FRE 802 (Hearsay); Best Evidence Rule

GX0601 Email from Bill Pine to Jim Estes re Weekend AB closure FRE 802 (Hearsay); FoundationGX0602 Information Memorandum for the Regional Director FRE 802 (Hearsay)GX0603 Letter to Representative Southerland re S. 601, Water Resources

Development Act of 2013 FRE 106 (Completeness)

GX0604 Information Memorandum for the Regional Director FRE 802 (Hearsay)GX0605 USFWS. Information Memorandum for the Regional Director. From:

Leopolda Miranda, ARD ES. Subject: Potential to Downlist the Endangered Fat Threeridge Mussel.

FRE 802 (Hearsay)

GX0606 20130610-ACF-flow-augmentation-from-Chatt-reservoirs-WeiZeng.xlsx FRE 802 (Hearsay); FRE 901 (Authentication)

GX0607 ACT-ACF GA Withdrawal Returns 1990-2012-updated-June2013.xlsx FRE 802 (Hearsay); Foundation

GX0608 Email from Wei Zeng to James Hathorn RE Unimpaired Flow Update - Water use Request (UNCLASSIFIED) FRE 802 (Hearsay); Foundation

GX0609 GA-ACF-water-use-agr-1970_2012.xlsx FRE 802 (Hearsay); FoundationGX0610 Email from James Hathorn to Wei Zeng re Unimpaired Flow Update -

Water Use Request (UNCLASSIFIED) FRE 802 (Hearsay); Foundation

GX0611 Email from Chellette to Steverson et al. re DEP Request for Utility data regarding water loss with attachment

GX0612 Letter from Kal Knickerbocker to ABODA re Expiration of Contract 19428 -Processed Shell Collection

GX0613 Email from Wei Zeng to James Hathorn re Unipaired Flow Update - Water Use Request (UNCLASSIFIED) FRE 802 (Hearsay); Foundation

GX0614 Letter from Cheryl Sanders to Nick Wiley FRE 802 (Hearsay)GX0615 Email from Munson to Arison and [email protected],

Attaching PWS Water Loss by DistrictGX0616 Email from David Heil to Jessica McCawley, Jim Estes and Calvin Adams

re Cheryl K. Sanders - Harvesting in the Apalachicola Bay on Friday and Saturday.pdf


GX0617 Memorandum from Zeng to Turner re Analysis of ACF River Basin operational alternative proposed by USFWS FRE 802 (Hearsay); Foundation

GX0618 Email from Wei Zeng to James Hathorn re Clarification of Georgia Contemplation State Line Flow Language (UNCLASSIFIED) FRE 802 (Hearsay); Foundation

GX0619 Email from Zeng to Hathorn re clarification of Georgia Contemplation State Line Flow Language FRE 802 (Hearsay); Foundation

GX0620 Email from Cyphers to Alter re Constituent Inquiries FRE 802 (Hearsay)GX0621 Email from Steve Brown to Lee Edmiston re FW Oyster Landing Data FRE 802 (Hearsay)

GX0622 Executive Director's Report, Division of Marine Fisheries Management - Updates: Apalachicola Oyster Status Update FRE 802 (Hearsay); Foundation

GX0623 Email from Rama Shuster to Rob Beaton forwarding Undersized Oysters FRE 802 (Hearsay)

GX0624 Email from Melissa Samet to Vinyard, Roemhilddt, Munson, Littlejohn et al. re Apalachicola Riaver Snaggng Permit FRE 802 (Hearsay); Foundation

GX0625 Email from Tonsmeire to Munson and McManus, dated July 16, 2013, Attaching ACF WRDA Amendment and ACF Map FRE 802 (Hearsay)

GX0626 Analysis of Flow Effect on Oyster Landings FRE 802 (Hearsay); Foundation; FRE 403GX0627 Email from Christopher Brooks to Kal Knickerbocker re Difficulty with

seizing oysters violating 5L and the Model Ordinance FRE 802 (Hearsay); Foundation

62

Ex. # Joint Exhibit Description Date Mentioned Date Offered Objection Date AdmittedGX0628 Memorandum to File from Wei Zeng re Derivation of water demands in

Georgia's January 2013 ACF Water Supply Request to the Army Corps of Engineers

FRE 802 (Hearsay)

GX0629 Forwarded email from Cyphers to Steverson re WMD ACFS Status FRE 802 (Hearsay)GX0630 Email from Wei Zeng to James Hathorn and N. Caldwell re GA ACF

Water Request (UNCLASSIFIED) FRE 802 (Hearsay)

GX0631 Email from Adam Kaeser to Donald Imm, Catherine Phillips, Karen Hennington, Channing St. Auibin and Sandra Pursiful re Fat threeridge listing meeting Friday

FRE 802 (Hearsay)

GX0632 Email from Lisa Conti to P. Zajicek et al. re FWC News Release - Pair arrested for illegal oyster harvesting FRE 802 (Hearsay)

GX0633 2013 UNC Tables of Water and Sewer Rates and Rate Structures in Georgia (http://www.efc.sog.unc.edu/reslib/item/tables-water-and-sewer-rates-and-rate-structures-georgia-august-2013)

GX0634 Email from Jackie Larson to Jim Estes re final dep revisions FRE 106 (Completeness)GX0635 Email from David Heil to Doc Kokol re PDF of Report FRE 802 (Hearsay); FoundationGX0636 Florida Fish & Wildlife Press Release: FWC submits status report on

Florida Gulf Coast Oyster Disaster to NOAA Fisheries Service FRE 802 (Hearsay); Foundation

GX0637 Email from Steve Branstetter to Chris Wright and Seema Balwani re Fwd Oyster Report FRE 802 (Hearsay); Foundation

GX0638 Email from David Heil to Graham Lewis, Forwarding Oyster Report and Attaching Crabtree letter, Final 8/2/2013 Disaster Report to NMFS, and Supplemental Document for Report to NMFS

GX0639 Email from Nick Wiley to Mike Joyner, Heschel Vinyard, Greg Munson, Lisa Conti et al. forwarding Gov. Scott: FWC Report Underscores Need for Commercial Fishery Failure Declaration

GX0640 Email from Joni Scott to Brandy Smith et al. re Secretary's copy of letter from Daniel Tonsmeire to Col. Stephen Roemhildt FRE 802 (Hearsay); Foundation

GX0641 Email from David Heil to Jim Estes re Gov. Scott and forwarding Report Underscores Need for Commercial Fishery Failure Declaration FRE 802 (Hearsay)

GX0642 Email from Doc Kokol to Jim Estes re Fwd: Gov .Scott: FWC Report Underscores Need for Commercial Fishery Failure Declaration FRE 802 (Hearsay); FRE 401 (Relevance)

GX0643 Email from Graham Lewis to Guy Gowens forwarding Oyster ReportGX0644 E-mail from Bill Pine to Jim Estes FRE 802 (Hearsay)GX0645 Email from Bill Pine to Jim Estes FRE 802 (Hearsay)GX0646 Tallahassee Democrat Article: Apalachicola River Water Woes Take

Center Stage Foundation

GX0647 Memorandum from Roy Crabtree to Samual Rauch re Florida Request for Federal Fishery Disaster Relief - Draft Decision Memorandum

GX0648 Email from Karl Havens to John Cirino re Apalachicola River water woes take center stage FRE 802 (Hearsay); FRE 401 (Relevance)

GX0649 Email from Pine to Cirino and Havens re Apalachicola River Water Woes Take Center Stage FRE 802 (Hearsay)

GX0650 Email from Reena O'Brien to Greg Munson, Herschel Vinyard and Matt Leopold forwarding Commercial Fishery Failure Declaration for the Florida Panhandle Oyster Fishery

GX0651 Email from David Heil to Jim Estes re Oyster Recovery with attachments Draft Comp Manage Recovery Options for Discussion 09 17 and Thoughts on Federak Assistance Request

GX0652 Statement of Dan Tonsmeire before US Senate Committee on Commerce, Science, and Transportation Field Hearing: Effects of Water Flows on Apalachicola bay: Short and long Term Perspective

FRE 802 (Hearsay)

63

Ex. # Joint Exhibit Description Date Mentioned Date Offered Objection Date AdmittedGX0653 Atlanta Journal-Constitution Article: Enough Blame to Go Around for

Decline of Florida's Oyster FisheryGX0654 Annual Oyster Landing charts FRE 901 (Authentication); FRE 106

(Completeness)GX0655 NMFS Landings Query ResultsGX0656 Letter from ABODA to FWC re request 10/1/2013 to be close date for

summer areas and open date for winter areas FRE 802 (Hearsay)

GX0657 Letter from FCSWA to Nick Wiley, Jim Estes and Louie Roberson re request for 9/31/2013 as close date for summer bars and 10/1/2013 as open date for winter bars

FRE 802 (Hearsay)

GX0658 GA EPD Testimony before the U.S. Senate Committee on Commerce, Science, and Transportation (Aug. 23, 2013) at 4 FRE 802 (Hearsay)

GX0659 GAEPD. Letter from Judson H. Turner, Director, to Committee on Commerce, Science, and Transportation, U.S. Senate. re Submission to Record of Committee Hearing on “Effects of WaterFlows on Apalachicola Bay: Short and Long Term Perspectives, August 13, 2013.”

FRE 802 (Hearsay)

GX0660 Letter from Jud Turner to US Senate Committee on Commerce, Science and Transportation re Submission to Record of Committee Hearing on "Effects of Water Flows on Apalachicola Bay: Short and Long Term Perspectives"

FRE 802 (Hearsay)

GX0661 Email from David Heil to Jim Estes re Oyster Recovery Considerations FRE 802 (Hearsay); Foundation; FRE 401 (Relevance)

GX0662 Email from Rob Beaton to Christopher Brooks re Law enforcement perspective on the oyster issues in Apalachicola Bay

GX0663 J. Turner Lecture Distinguished Lecture, Jones Ecological Center at Ichauway Plantation FRE 802 (Hearsay)

GX0664 PowerPoint from J. Turner Lecture FRE 802 (Hearsay)GX0665 Email from Jackie Fauls to Jim Estes & Louie Roberson re Summer Oyster

Bar extension Request FRE 802 (Hearsay); FRE 401 (Relevance)

GX0666 Letter from ABODA, SMARRT and FCSWA to Wiley requesting delayed start for winter season FRE 802 (Hearsay)

GX0667 Email from Kal Knickerbocker to Jim Estes re Fwd: Bay acres to restore FRE 802 (Hearsay)

GX0668 Redacted Email from Elizabeth Orr to Doug Beason re Media Advisory: For Immediate Release: Riverkeeper Seeks Changes to Corps of Engineers Permit


GX0669 Letter from Karl Havens to Shannon Hartsfield re low Oyster Harvests

GX0670 Memorandum from Karl Havens to Shannon Hartsfield re response to request and concerns for extremely low oyster harvests suring summer 2013

FRE 802 (Hearsay); FRE 401 (Relevance)

GX0671 Letter from Cheryl Sanders to Gov. ScottGX0672 Email from David Heil to Jim Estes re Oyster Resource Assessments

(Winter areas) FRE 802 (Hearsay)

GX0673 Email from David Heil to Steve Geiger re Oyster Resource Assessments (Winter Area) FRE 802 (Hearsay); FRE 401 (Relevance)

GX0674 Email from David Heil to Steve Geiger re Oyster Resource Assessments (Winter Area) FRE 802 (Hearsay); FRE 401 (Relevance)

GX0675 Email from David Heil to Steve Geiger re Oyster Resource Assessments (Winter areas)

GX0676 Email from Joe Shields to Kal Knickerbocker re FW: small oysters with attached color photos FRE 802 (Hearsay)

GX0677 Email from David Heil to Jim Estes re Apalachicola Bay FRE 802 (Hearsay)

64

Ex. # Joint Exhibit Description Date Mentioned Date Offered Objection Date AdmittedGX0678 Email from Christopher Brooks to Joe Shields re Historical document

comparison FRE 802 (Hearsay); FRE 106 (Completeness)

GX0679 Email from Jim Estes to Rama Shuster re FW Passing along an urgent request for a limited entry oyster fishery from a concerned fisherman FRE 802 (Hearsay)

GX0680 Email from Christopher Knight to Kal Knickerbocker re FW Major illegal harvesting issues FRE 802 (Hearsay); Foundation

GX0681 Email from Rama Shuster to Jim Estes re Major illegal harvesting issues FRE 802 (Hearsay); Foundation

GX0682 Email from Rob Beaton to John Burton Forwarding Op Plan CONFIDENTIAL (DO NOT DISTRIBUTE)

GX0683 Presentation "An evaluation of the Supreme Court lawsuit filed by the State of Florida against the state of Georgia in 2013" FRE 802 (Hearsay); FRE 401 (Relevance)

GX0684 Contract between the Georgia Environmental Protection Division and the Georgia Water Planning and Policy Center and Albany State University FRE 106 (Completeness)

GX0685 Email from Hathorn to Zeng re clarification of Georgia Contemplation State Line Flow Language

FRE 802 (Hearsay; Hearsay Within Hearsay); Foundation

GX0686 Email from Kal Knickerbocker to Jim Estes et al. re FW: Catpoint follow-up survey with attached spreadsheet, The Big Three_Plus One.xls

GX0687 Turner EPD Strategy Memo GX0688 Ritchie, Bruce, Apalachicola seafood dealers call for plan to protect bay,

seafood industry, The Florida Current, Nov. 5, 2013 FRE 802 (Hearsay); Foundation

GX0689 Email from Rob Beaton to Bruce Cooper re As requestedGX0690 Email from Carl Walters to Bill Pine & Jim Estes re Oyster Cultching FRE 802 (Hearsay)

GX0691 Email from Ed Cake re Apalachicola Bay Weekend Commercial oyster harvests halted for winter

FRE 802 (Hearsay); Foundation; FRE 106 (Completeness)

GX0692 Email from Kal Knickerbocker to Joseph Shields re Summer Oyster Bars FRE 802 (Hearsay); FRE 401 (Relevance)

GX0693 Email from Gowens to White re Board Memo MFL Introduction 2013-12-03.docx

GX0694 Email from Keller to Knickerbocker re Apalachicola Bay oyster industry.msg FRE 802 (Hearsay)

GX0695 Email from Joe Shields to David Heil re Data with attached Population Estimates Form

GX0696 INTERA. Three-dimensional Hydrodynamic Model Development, Calibration and Verification of Circulation and Salinity in Apalachicola Bay, FL. Prepared for Northwest Florida Water Management District, Havana, FL; model and related data.

GX0697 MNGWPD Activities & Progress Report GX0698 NOAA Commercial Fisheries Statistics Total Commercial Fishery

Landings at Major U.S. Ports Summarized by Year and Ranked By Poundage

GX0699 USDA. "Table 1. County Summary Highlights: 2012." AC-12-A-10. In 2012 Census of Agriculture Georgia State and County Data. Volume 1: Geographic Area Series, Part 10. National Agricultural Statistics Service. (http://www.agcensus.usda.gov/Publications/2012/Full_Report/Volume_1,_Chapter_2_County_Level/Georgia/st13_2_001_001.pdf).

GX0700 Letter from Knickerbocker to Beckham re Cedar Key Osyterman Association Request

GX0701 Email from Knickerbocker to Hutchinson re Nice Job! FRE 802 (Hearsay)

65

Ex. # Joint Exhibit Description Date Mentioned Date Offered Objection Date AdmittedGX0702 Email from Richard Hutchinson to S. Brabant et al. re FW oyster cases

1/12/14 FRE 802 (Hearsay); FRE 401 (Relevance)

GX0703 Email from J. Payne to T. Irani and A. Lamm re NAS and FDACS FRE 802 (Hearsay)GX0704 Email from Kal Knickerbocker to P. Sapp, R. Hutchinson & K. Norgren re

FW: Top 5 News Exclusively for Subscribers FRE 401 (Relevance)

GX0705 News Article: FWC Officers Nab 2 Tons of Illegal Oysters, First Coast News Foundation

GX0706 Email from Rob Beaton to Nick Wikey et al. re From Naples Daily News: 2 tons of illegally harvested oysters seized in Florida

GX0707 Georgia Department of Natural Resources, Water Use Data Inventory Report (March 10, 2010)

GX0708 NWFWMD Contract Review Routing Sheet (Contract No. 13-039)GX0709 Email from Havens to Gray, Attaching 'Climate Change and Estuaries: A

Case Study in Apalachicola Bay Presentation"GX0710 Metro Planning District Climate Resiliency Plan, Proposal FRE 802 (Hearsay)GX0711 GADNR Press Release: No Drought Declaration for Lower Flint River

Basin This Year GX0712 Email from Wooten to Gowens et al. re Center PivotsGX0713 Apalachicola Times Article: County Seeks Answers on Disaster Funding

GX0714 Email from Gowens to Cyphers, et al. re ACF water use and center-pivot info FRE 106 (Completeness)

GX0715 Email from Jim Estes to Nick Wiley forwarding Landings Information

GX0716 USACE. Alabama-Coosa-Tallapoosa and Apalachicola-Chattahoochee-Flint Water Control Manuals Update. PowerPoint slide show.

GX0717 Email from David Heil to Lee Edmiston, John Gunter, Joe Shields and Graham Lewis re 1985 Hurricane Elena Oyster Disaster with attachment

GX0718 Restoration Program for the Apalachicola River FRE 802 (Hearsay)GX0719 DACS length frequencies by year 1990-2012.xlsx FoundationGX0720 Email from Wei Zeng to James Hathorn re Unimpaired Flow Update -

Water Use Request (UNCLASSIFIED) FRE 802 (Hearsay); Foundation

GX0721 Unsigned note "Bay Restoration vs Ag Opinions" FRE 802 (Hearsay); FRE 901 (Authentication)

GX0722 Email from Thorpe to Gowens et al. re Apalachicola Legislative Appropriations Projects, with Apalachicola Bay Strategic Plan and Current Status - Apalachicola River and Bay Projects funded through 2013 Legislative Appropriation

GX0723 Email from Havens to Gray and Cullen re Oysters, Apalachicola Bay & Climate Change

GX0724 Email from Conti to Knickerbocker et al., re Resource improvement vs. social work program FRE 802 (Hearsay)

GX0725 Email from Micheal Allen to Karl Havens re UF Oyster Recovery Team journal article on long term history of droughts in the ACF basin FRE 802 (Hearsay)

GX0726 Email from Lee Edmiston to Tommy re oyster stuff with attachment FRE 802 (Hearsay)GX0727 Memorandum from Zeng to Turner re Water Supply Alternatives FRE 802 (Hearsay)GX0728 Email from Karl Havens to Angela Lindsey re UF Oyster Recovery Team

Apalachicola Oyster Industry Report FRE 802 (Hearsay)

GX0729(Redacted)

Email from Laura Hartt to Gordon Rogers, Woody Hicks, Bradford Moore et al. re TOCWG Call today - Chairman's Thoughts FRE 802 (Hearsay)

GX0730 Simulations of RIOP, USFWS, Revised Proposal & GA Contemplation FRE 802 (Hearsay); Foundation

66

Ex. # Joint Exhibit Description Date Mentioned Date Offered Objection Date AdmittedGX0731 Smit, Reuben, Using sonar habitat images and GIS analyses to identify

freshwater mussel habitat and estimate poulation size of a federally endangered feshwater mussel species, Amblema neislerii, in the Apalachicola River.

FRE 802 (Hearsay)

GX0732 Memorandum from W. Zeng to J. Turner re Analysis of USFWS Revised Operational Alternative

FRE 802 (Hearsay); Foundation; FRE 901 (Authentication)

GX0733 Email from Lewis to Hull re Apal Bay modeling with attachment; Final Report to the Damayan Water Project (February 2004); email from Graham Lewis to Mark Gosselin re Apal Bay meeting with with attachment

FRE 802 (Hearsay)

GX0734 Letter from ABODA, SMARRT and FCSWA to Estes FRE 802 (Hearsay)GX0735 Geomorphic Assessment and Pilot Restoration Projects for the

Apalachicola River FRE 802 (Hearsay)

GX0736 Letter from J. Turner to Corps re Response to Request for Additional Information for Georgia’s 2013 Water Supply Request FRE 802 (Hearsay)

GX0737 Email from Kane to Havens re draft email for your edification FRE 802 (Hearsay)GX0738 Email from Havens to Payne et al., re Apalachicola FRE 802 (Hearsay)GX0739 Fisheries-Independent Monitoring Program 2013 Annual Data Summary

ReportGX0740 Karl Etters "Cabinet Approves Wakulla County Oyster Leases" FRE 802 (Hearsay)GX0741 Email from Havens to Kane et al., re Nick Wiley FRE 802 (Hearsay); FoundationGX0742 Email from Birch to Knickerbocker et al. re Yesterday's meeting FRE 802 (Hearsay); PrivilegeGX0743 Email from Estes to Edmiston et al re Recovery Team Meeting with

attachment FRE 802 (Hearsay)

GX0744 Memorandum from Judson Turner to Board of Natural Resources re Briefing on Proposed Amendments to Rules for Flint River Drought Protection, Chapter 391-3-28

GX0745 Email from David Heil to Jim Estes et al re Recovery Plan Meeting - Follow-up Oyster Population Data FRE 802 (Hearsay)

GX0746 Letter from Katherine Zitsch & Boyd Austin to James Capp re Drought Management Rule - Stakeholder Meeting #2 FRE 802 (Hearsay)

GX0747 Email from Lauren Engel to Jon Steverson forwarding article re deregulation under Gov. Scott FRE 802 (Hearsay); Foundation

GX0748 Email from Kal Knickerbocker to Jim Estes re FW: resource assessments

GX0749 GEFA Press Release: Georgia Communities Receive Infrastructure Loans Totaling $73 Million, (http://gefa.georgia.gov/press-releases/20140826/georgiacommunities-receive-infrastructure-loans-totaling-73-million)

GX0750 E-mail from Pine to Graham re $ FRE 802 (Hearsay)GX0751 Understanding high resolution space-time variability of rainfall in

southwest Georgia, United States (September 2014)GX0752 Email from Havens to Payne et al., re Apalachicola FRE 802 (Hearsay)GX0753 E-mail from Rachel Bouchillon to Pine re AB mgmt recommendations,

Attaching "Apalachicola_Bay_oyster_resource_management_recommendations.docx" FRE 802 (Hearsay)

GX0754 Leitman, Pine, and Kiker. An Investigation into the 2012 Drought on the Apalachicola River. FRE 802 (Hearsay)

GX0755 Email from Andy Kane to Karl Havens re in Confidence FRE 802 (Hearsay); FRE 401 (Relevance)GX0756 Email from Lauren Kirikiti to Joe Shields re brief blurb on oyster radio FRE 802 (Hearsay)

67

Ex. # Joint Exhibit Description Date Mentioned Date Offered Objection Date AdmittedGX0757 Email from Karl Havens to Jack Payne re Apalachicola Bay may need to

be closed to oyster harvesting … indefinitely, with attachment from Tallahasseee Democrat "Bay may need to be closed to oyster harvesting" FRE 802 (Hearsay); Foundation

GX0758 Letter from Shannon Hartsfield to Nick Wiley re support for ABODA FRE 802 (Hearsay)GX0759 Letter from Tommy Ward to Wiley re recommendations and requests for

actions by Florida FRE 802 (Hearsay)

GX0760 Email from Knickerbocker to Lynch et al, re Barge Shelling Funds FRE 802 (Hearsay)GX0761 Letter from ABODA to Nick Wiley re Oyster Dealers Association

Emergency Meeting FRE 802 (Hearsay)

GX0762 Email from Bill Pine to Karl Havens, Andrew Kane, Jack Payne re Today's News FRE 802 (Hearsay); FRE 401 (Relevance)

GX0763 HEC-ResSim Reservoir System Simulation - Kiev, Ukraine & Chisinau, Moldova

FRE 802 (Hearsay); Foundation; FRE 901 (Authentication)

GX0764 Draft "The Curious Case of Eastern Oyster Stock Status in Apalachicola Bay, Florida" FRE 802 (Hearsay)

GX0765 Memo from Turner to Board of Natural Resources re Action on Proposed Amendments to Rules for FRDPA

GX0766 E-mail from Camp to Pine re paper on Apalach issues - take 4 FRE 802 (Hearsay)GX0767 Email from Edward Camp to Bill Pine re Paper on apalach issues - take 4 FRE 401 (Relevance)

GX0768 Council Member Applicant and Proposal Information Summary Sheet: Appalachicola Bay Watershed Restoration FRE 802 (Hearsay)

GX0769 Flint Stakeholders invitation package FRE 106 (Completeness) GX0770 E-mail from Pine to Hellgren re Apalachicola oyster paper FRE 802 (Hearsay)GX0771 E-mail from Bill Pine to Sturmer, et al. re next Apalach paper, Attaching

"Camp_et_al_Ecol_and_Soc_SUBMITTED_HD.pdf" FRE 802 (Hearsay); FRE 106 (Completeness)

GX0772 Pamphlet re Georgia Soil and Water Conservation CommissionGX0773 ANERR Juvenile fishes and macroinverts.xlsxGX0774 Methods accompanying the trawl sampling dataGX0775 Email from Wei Zeng to Jeffrey Regan re Intra-Annual precipitation

patternsFRE 802 (Hearsay; Hearsay Within Hearsay); Foundation

GX0776 Meeting notes for Apalachicola Riverkeeper and Florida Wildlife Federation meeting FRE 802 (Hearsay)

GX0777 FWCFreshwaterMusselDatabase_Apalachicola_12-16-2014.xlsx FoundationGX0778 E-mail from Bill Pine to Jack Payne, Eric Hellgren, and Karl Havens FRE 802 (Hearsay)GX0779 Email from Jack Payne to Bill Pine re Apalachicola: Not for distribution FRE 802 (Hearsay)

GX0780 S. Leitman, W.E. Pine III, and G. Kiker, Draft "Management Options During the 2011-2012 Drought on the Apalachicola River: A Systems Dynamic Model Evaluation"

FRE 802 (Hearsay)

GX0781 Memorandum from J. Turner to Board of Natural Resources re Drought Management Rules

GX0782 Email from Bill Pine to Jack Payne and Eric Hellgren re Thanks for the meeting today FRE 802 (Hearsay)

GX0783 Email with GSWCC FY15 Budget RequestGX0784 Georgia Water System Audits and Water Loss Control Manual

(http://c.ymcdn.com/sites/www.gawp.org/resource/resmgr/Water_Loss_Audit_files/GA_Water_Loss_Manual_V2.0.pdf)

GX0785 MNGWMD Utility Climate Resiliency Report (http://northgeorgiawater.org/wp-content/uploads/2015/05/MNGWPD_Utility-Climate-Resiliency-Study.pdf)

FRE 802 (Hearsay). This is not listed in materials considered or relied upon by Dr. Mayer, and therefore anyr reliance by him on this report is improper. Florida also objects on hearsay grounds.

68

Ex. # Joint Exhibit Description Date Mentioned Date Offered Objection Date AdmittedGX0786 MNGWPD Activities & Progress Report (http://northgeorgiawater.org/wp-

content/uploads/2015/05/MNGWPD_AnnualReport_2015.pdf)

GX0787 NOAA. National Geophysical Data Center, U.S. Coastal Relief Model, (http://www.ngdc.noaa.gov/mgg/coastal/crm.html) FRE 802 (Hearsay); FRE 901 (Authentication)

GX0788 NOAA. Shoreline Data Explorer, NOAA, NGS (http://www.ngs.noaa.gov/RSD/shoredata/NGS_Shoreline_Products.htm) FRE 802 (Hearsay); FRE 901 (Authentication)

GX0789 Pine III, W. E., et al. The curious case of eastern oyster Crassostrea virginica stock status in Apalachicola Bay, Florida, Ecology and Society. FRE 802 (Hearsay)

GX0790 Smith, A., et al., UGA Extension Economists, Department of Agricultural and Applied Economics, UGA College of Agricultural and Environmental Sciences Crop Comparison Tool, Summary of South Georgia Crop Enterprise Estimates, April 2015 update, Conventional Tillage (http://www.agecon.uga.edu/extension/budgets/cct/index.html), provided as “Exhibit 10. Estimated Returns per Acre for Irrigated and Non-Irrigated Farms, Georgia.xlsx.”

FRE 802 (Hearsay)

GX0792 Water Audits in the United States: A Review of Water Losses and Data Validity FRE 802 (Hearsay)

GX0793 Water Sense Awards GX0794 Net_Interbasin_transfer_for_2001_to_2013.xlsGX0795 Email from Bill Pine to Eric Hellgren re 2014 Evaluation FRE 802 (Hearsay)GX0796 Email from Adam Kaeser to Mike Gangloff re Apalach mussel manuscript FRE 802 (Hearsay)

GX0797 Email from Brian Zettle to Adam Kaeset and Heather Bulger re Apalachicola - Fat threeridge data FRE 802 (Hearsay)

GX0798 Email from Havens to Pine, Attaching Draft Florida Fish and Wildlife Conservation Comission: Apalachicola Bay System Comprehensive Oyster Resource Management Plan, January 2015

GX0799 Email from Havens to Cammen re Supreme Court Case Florida vs. Georgia FRE 802 (Hearsay); Foundation

GX0800 2015.02.26 FL Responses to GA 1st IROGS FRE 106 (Completeness); FRE 802 (Hearsay); Florida reasserts the objections made in response to the RFAs and Interrogatories

GX0801 Email from Adam Kaeser to Webber, Pursifull, Mitchell, and Cantrell re Mussel mapping manuscript FRE 802 (Hearsay)

GX0802 Georgia Contemplation and Its Basin-wide Beneficial Effects FRE 802 (Hearsay); FoundationGX0803 2015.04.06 FL Supplemental Responses to GA 1st IROGs FRE 106 (Completeness); FRE 802 (Hearsay);

Florida reasserts the objections made in response to the RFAs and Interrogatories

GX0804 2015.05.01 FL Second Supplemental Response to GA 1st IROGS FRE 106 (Completeness); FRE 802 (Hearsay); Florida reasserts the objections made in response to the RFAs and Interrogatories

GX0805 "All USGS groundwater level data that can be stored in NWIS has been entered into NWIS, USGS anticiates no further response"

FRE 802 (Hearsay); FRE 106; FRE 403 (Misleading/Confusing)

GX0806 Presentation "A discussion of several issues associated with consumptive demands in the ACF Basin" FRE 802 (Hearsay)

GX0807 Amendment #1 to the Contract between the Georgia Environmental Protection Division and the Georgia Water Planning and Policy Center and Albany State University

FRE 106 (Completeness)

GX0808 2015 UNC Tables of Water and Sewer Rates and Rate Structures in Georgia (http://www.efc.sog.unc.edu/reslib/item/tables-water-and-sewer-rates-and-rate-structures-georgia-july-2015)

69

Ex. # Joint Exhibit Description Date Mentioned Date Offered Objection Date AdmittedGX0809 Picture of Drop NozzlesGX0810 Letter from Imm to Chytka re Draft Fish and Wildlife Coordination Act

Report GX0811 2015.10.02 FL Second Supplemental Response to GA IROG 7 FRE 106 (Completeness); FRE 802 (Hearsay);


GX0812 Biographical Information re Bill Pine, Ph.D. FRE 802 (Hearsay)GX0813 Fax from Carmody to Estes re GA ACF Proposal GX0814 Table re closures "1995 to present closures (dates, days, reasons)" FoundationGX0815 2015.11.05 FL Third Supplemental Response to GA 1st IROGs FRE 106 (Completeness); FRE 802 (Hearsay);


GX0816 2015.11.09 FL First Supplemental Response to GA 2nd IROGS FRE 106 (Completeness); FRE 802 (Hearsay); Florida reasserts the objections made in response to the RFAs and Interrogatories

GX0817 2015.11.09 FL Response to GA 3rd IROGS FRE 106 (Completeness); FRE 802 (Hearsay); Florida reasserts the objections made in response to the RFAs and Interrogatories

GX0818 2015.11.09 FL Responses to GA RFAs FRE 106 (Completeness); FRE 802 (Hearsay); Florida reasserts the objections made in response to the RFAs and Interrogatories

GX0819 Response to Georgia's Third Set of Interrogatories to Florida FRE 106 (Completeness); FRE 802 (Hearsay); Florida reasserts the objections made in response to the RFAs and Interrogatories

GX0820 Memorandum from Katherine Zitsch to Jud Turner re Projected Future Water Supply Demands for the Chattahoochee River and Lake Lanier System

FRE 802 (Hearsay)

GX0821 Commercial Regulations for Oysters DocumentationGX0822 Letter from Judson Turner to Col. Jon Chytka re State of Georgia's Water

Supply Request FRE 802 (Hearsay)

GX0823 Bay River Data Anonymous.savGX0824 Commercial Fishing Data Anonymous.savGX0825 Final Report: FWC Alligator Snapping Turtle SurveyGX0826 Final Report: FWC Barbour's Map Turtle SurveyGX0827 GEFA Press Release: State makes investment to promote regional benefits

of Richland Creek Reservoir (http://gefa.georgia.gov/press-releases/2015-12-29/statemakes-investment-promote-regional-benefits-richland-creek-reservoir)

GX0828 2015.12.30 FL Supplemental Responses to GA RFAs FRE 106 (Completeness); FRE 802 (Hearsay); Florida reasserts the objections made in response to the RFAs and Interrogatories

GX0829 2016 Comments of the State of Georgia: ACF Water Control Manual and Draft EIS with Exhibits A-K FRE 802 (Hearsay)

GX0830(Under Seal)

Database or shapefiles, 2016 Wetted Acreage Database

GX0831(Under Seal)


GX0832(Under Seal)


GX0833(Under Seal)


70

Ex. # Joint Exhibit Description Date Mentioned Date Offered Objection Date AdmittedGX0834(Under Seal)


GX0835(Under Seal)


GX0836(Under Seal)


GX0837(Under Seal)


GX0838(Under Seal)


GX0839(Under Seal)


GX0840(Under Seal)


GX0841(Under Seal)


GX0842(Under Seal)


GX0843(Under Seal)


GX0844(Under Seal)


GX0845 Database or shapefiles, 2016 Wetted Acreage DatabaseGX0847 Water Audits and Loss Control Programs, 4th Edition FRE 802 (Hearsay); FRE 106 (Completeness)GX0848 2016.01.25 FL 4th Supplemental Response to GA 1st IROGs FRE 106 (Completeness); FRE 802 (Hearsay);


GX0849 2016.01.25 FL Second Supplemental Response to GA 2nd IROGS FRE 106 (Completeness); FRE 802 (Hearsay); Florida reasserts the objections made in response to the RFAs and Interrogatories

GX0850 2016.01.25 FL Second Supplemental Response to GA 3rd IROGs FRE 106 (Completeness); FRE 802 (Hearsay); Florida reasserts the objections made in response to the RFAs and Interrogatories

GX0851 GEFA Press Release: Georgia communities receive infrastructure loans totaling $13.5 million (http://gefa.georgia.gov/press-releases/2016-01-25/georgiacommunities-receive-infrastructure-loans-totaling-135-million)

GX0852 State of Florida's Second Supplemental Response to State of Georgia's Third Set of Interrogatories

FRE 106 (Completeness); FRE 802 (Hearsay); Florida reasserts the objections made in response to the RFAs and Interrogatories

GX0853 Letter from Governor Scott to Jonathan Severson affirming inconsistency of Draft Environmental Impact Statement, Update of the Master Water COntrol Manual for the Apalachicola-Chattahoochee-Flint Rivers, Alabama, Florida, and Georgia and a Water Supply Assessment

71

Ex. # Joint Exhibit Description Date Mentioned Date Offered Objection Date AdmittedGX0854 Comments on Draft Environmental Impact Statement: Update of the

Water Control Manual for the Apalachicola-Chattahoochee-Flint River Basin in Alabama, Florida, and Georgia and a Water Supply Storage Assessment (www.atlantaregional.com/File%20Library/Environment/Tri-State%20Water%20Wars/Water-Supply-Providers-Comments---Final.pdf)

FRE 802 (Hearsay)

GX0855 File listing - Transmittal GX0856 2016.02.12 FL Fifth Supplemental Response to GA 1st IROGS FRE 106 (Completeness); FRE 802 (Hearsay);


GX0857 State of Florida's Third Supplemental Response to State of Georgia's Third Set of Interrogatories

FRE 106 (Completeness); FRE 802 (Hearsay); Florida reasserts the objections made in response to the RFAs and Interrogatories

GX0858 2016.02.19 FL Fourth Supplemental Response to GA 3rd IROGs FRE 106 (Completeness); FRE 802 (Hearsay); Florida reasserts the objections made in response to the RFAs and Interrogatories

GX0859 2016.02.19 FL Sixth Supplemental Response to GA 1st IROGs FRE 106 (Completeness); FRE 802 (Hearsay); Florida reasserts the objections made in response to the RFAs and Interrogatories

GX0860 Expert Report of Philip Bedient FRE 802 (Hearsay); FRE 403GX0861 Robert M. DeConto and David Pollard, Contribution of Antarctica to past

and future sea-level rise, NATURE, VOL 531, April, 591-597. FRE 802 (Hearsay)

GX0862 Letter from Richard Monson to Mark Masters FRE 802 (Hearsay); Document Prepared for Litigation;

GX0863 Memorandum from Metro Water District to Georgia EPD re Chattahoochee-Flint River Basin Population Served.

GX0864 Chattahoochee - 2010-USGS-daily-data.txtGX0865 Chattahoochee - 2010-water-year-USGS-daily-data.txtGX0866 Defensive Expert Report of Philip Bedient FRE 802 (Hearsay); FRE 403GX0867 Expert Report of Robin Cantor FRE 802 (Hearsay)GX0868 Expert Report of Suat Irmak FRE 802 (Hearsay); FRE 403; FoundationGX0869 Expert Report of Romuald Lipcius FRE 802 (Hearsay)GX0870 Expert Report of Peter Mayer FRE 802 (Hearsay); FRE 403; FoundationGX0871 Expert Report of William McAnally FRE 802 (Hearsay)GX0872 Expert Report of Charles Menzie FRE 802 (Hearsay)GX0873 Expert Report of Sorab Panday FRE 802 (Hearsay); FRE 403GX0874 Expert Report of Robert Stavins FRE 802 (Hearsay); FRE 403GX0875 Errata and Corrections to P. Bedient Report FRE 802 (Hearsay); FRE 403GX0876 Revisions to Defensive Expert Report of Philip Bedient FRE 802 (Hearsay); FRE 403GX0877 ACF Water Control Mnual Update Supplemental Information for Final

Fish and Wildlife Coordination Act ReportGX0878 Reigstad letter to Perry re Stavins Errata FRE 802 (Hearsay); FRE 403; FoundationGX0879 Supplemental Bedient Memorandum FRE 802 (Hearsay); FRE 403GX0880 Letter from C. Maner to J. Wine re Corrections to Mayer Report FRE 802 (Hearsay); FRE 403; FoundationGX0881 Memo re Non-UFA Aquifer FRE 802 (Hearsay); FRE 403GX0882 Errata for Expert Report of Sorab Panday FRE 802 (Hearsay); FRE 403GX0883 Memo from Sorab Panday to Dr. Phillip Bedient re Review of Dr. David

Langseth's Memo to Dr. George Hornberger on 28 June 2016 titled "Dr. Panday Water Budget Evaluations"


GX0884 Supporting files for Supplemental Memorandum of Suat Irmak FRE 802 (Hearsay); FRE 403; FoundationGX0885 Supplemental Memorandum Suat Irmak FRE 802 (Hearsay); FRE 403; FoundationGX0886 Irrigated Acreage Methodology Suat Irmak FRE 802 (Hearsay); FRE 403; FoundationGX0887 Irrigated Depth Methodology Suat Irmak FRE 802 (Hearsay); FRE 403; FoundationGX0888 McAnally ACF Errata and Corrections FRE 802 (Hearsay)GX0889 Menzie Errata FRE 802 (Hearsay)

72

Ex. # Joint Exhibit Description Date Mentioned Date Offered Objection Date AdmittedGX0890 FAQs re ACF Biological Opinion FRE 802 (Hearsay)GX0891 News Release - U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service Issues Biological Opinion

for Apalachicola-Chattahoochee-Flint River Basin FRE 802 (Hearsay)

GX0892 ACFBasinMap.pdf FRE 802 (Hearsay)GX0893 USFWS Fact Sheet re Mussels: Endangered and Threatened Mussels I

nthe Apalachicola-Chattahoochee-Flint BasinGX0894 MediaImages1.pdf FRE 802 (Hearsay)GX0895 MediaImages2.pdf FRE 802 (Hearsay)GX0896 FAQs re Gulf SturgeonGX0897 Declaration of Don Laing, Sr.

Florida objects to this untimely produced affidavit, which Florida received on October 11, 2016, after the close of discovery. Florida has not had an opportunity to depose Mr. Laing regarding his affidavit or the photographs he took, and lacks metadata to confirm any of the location information provided by Mr. Laing.

GX0898 Pictures of FL Irrigation FRE 403; FRE 802 (Hearsay); Lack of Foundation; Authentication. Florida objects to these late-disclosed documents, which were in Georgia's possession since August 2016 and were not produced to Florida until October 11, 2016, after the close of discovery. Florida further objects to these as misleading/confusing. They also lack any metadata and information to allow Florida to confirm the location and time these photographs were taken.

GX0899 Pictures of GA Irrigation FRE 403; FRE 802 (Hearsay); Lack of Foundation; Authentication. Florida objects to these late-disclosed documents, which were in Georgia's possession since August and were not produced to Florida until October 11. Florida further objects to these as misleading/confusing. They also lack any metadata and information to allow Florida to confirm the location and time these photographs were taken.

GX0900 Award Winners Save Water for Future Generations (Watersense) FRE 802 (Hearsay)GX0902 2010.0416.Baseline._Crop_area_in_LDAs.xls (downloaded from NESPAL)

GX0903 20130319-Ag-GW-Rate-Pattern-2008-2012.xls FRE 802 (Hearsay); FoundationGX0904 20160302-ACF-FL-incremental-flow-decline.xlsx FRE 802 (Hearsay); FoundationGX0905 Gulf Experiment Adult Data_9Jun2016.xlsxGX0906 Panhandle_all_spec_qry.xlsxGX0907 U.xlsx FRE 802 (Hearsay)GX0908 "Flint River Basin Irrigation Performance Evaluation Report" FRE 802 (Hearsay); FRE 901 (Authentication)

GX0909 0151117-ACF-LSPC-flow-analysis-Bainbridge.xlsx FRE 802 (Hearsay); FoundationGX0910 1_Monthly average streamflow reduction from total

(SW + GW) agricultural withdrawals.xlsxGX0911 1000cfsCapinJune&Baseline2011_Chattahoochee_Sumatra.xlsx FRE 802 (Hearsay); FoundationGX0914 1988 USDA Farm and Ranch Irrigation Survey.pdfGX0915 1998 USDA Farm and Ranch Irrigation Survey.pdfGX0916 2003 USDA Farm and Ranch Irrigation Survey.pdf

73

Ex. # Joint Exhibit Description Date Mentioned Date Offered Objection Date AdmittedGX0917 2008 USDA Farm and Ranch Irrigation Survey.pdfGX0918 2009_Water_Usage_GSWCC.xls FRE 802 (Hearsay); FoundationGX0919 2010.0416.Baseline_Crop_area_in_LDAsGX0920 2010.0416.Map_Fields_in_LDAsGX0921 2011-2015 Hydrograph by USGS pertaining to the Apalachicola River at

Chattahoochee, Florida.GX0922(Under Seal)

2011-acf-surf-water-meter-w-crops-counties.xlsx FRE 802 (Hearsay); Lack of Foundation; FRE 403 (Confusing/Misleading); FRE 901 (Authentication)

GX0923(Under Seal)

2011-subarea4-gw-meter-with-crop-counties.xlsx FRE 802 (Hearsay); Lack of Foundation; FRE 403 (Confusing/Misleading); FRE 901 (Authentication)

GX0924 2012 & 2013 ACF Basin Composite Conservation and Flood StorageGX0925 2012 Usage for EPD.xlsx FRE 802 (Hearsay); FoundationGX0926(Under Seal)

2012-acf-surf-water-meter-with-counties-crops.xlsx FRE 802 (Hearsay); Lack of Foundation; FRE 403 (Confusing/Misleading); FRE 901 (Authentication)

GX0927(Under Seal)

2012-subarea4-gw-meter-with-crops-counties.xlsx FRE 802 (Hearsay); Lack of Foundation; FRE 403 (Confusing/Misleading); FRE 901 (Authentication)

GX0928 2013 USDA Farm and Ranch Irrigation Survey.pdfGX0929 2013_Water_Usage_EPD.xlsx FRE 802 (Hearsay); FoundationGX0930(Under Seal)

2013-acf-surf-water-meter-with-counties-crops.xlsx FRE 802 (Hearsay); Lack of Foundation; FRE 403 (Confusing/Misleading); FRE 901 (Authentication)

GX0931(Under Seal)

2013-subarea4-gw-meter-data-with-counties-crops.xlsx FRE 802 (Hearsay); Lack of Foundation; FRE 403 (Confusing/Misleading); FRE 901 (Authentication)

GX0932 2014 FRDPA AmendmentsGX0933(Under Seal)

2014-acf-surf-water-meter-w-counties.xlsx FRE 802 (Hearsay); Lack of Foundation; FRE 403 (Confusing/Misleading); FRE 901 (Authentication)

GX0934(Under Seal)

2014-subarea4-ground-water-meter-data-w-counties.xlsx FRE 802 (Hearsay); Lack of Foundation; FRE 403 (Confusing/Misleading); FRE 901 (Authentication)

GX0935 2015 Drought Management Rule, 391-3-30.01 - .08. (http://rules.sos.ga.gov/nllxml/georgiacodesGetcv.aspx?urlRedirected=yes&data=admin&lookingfor=391-3-28 )

GX0936 2015_GA_Model_Chattahoochee_Flow_Baseline2011&1992 FRE 802 (Hearsay); FoundationGX0937 20150406-acf-ag-water-use-effect-summary-2008-2013-hl-rev.xlsx FRE 802 (Hearsay); FoundationGX0938 2015-10-01_Pine_excel_files.xlsx FRE 802 (Hearsay)GX0939 20160203-ACF-summary-GA-water-use-1980-2013.xlsx FRE 802 (Hearsay); FoundationGX0940 20160223-ACF-GA-total-consumptive-monthly.xlsx FRE 802 (Hearsay); FoundationGX0941 20160223-ACF-GA-total-consumptive-monthly-WeiZeng.xlsx FRE 802 (Hearsay); FoundationGX0942 20160225-ACF-GA-total-consumptive-monthly.xlsx FRE 802 (Hearsay); FoundationGX0943 20160225-ACF-GA-total-consumptive-monthly-WeiZen Modified.xlsx FRE 802 (Hearsay); Foundation

GX0944 20160225-ACF-GA-total-consumptive-monthly-WeiZeng.xlsx FRE 802 (Hearsay); FoundationGX0945 20160302-ACF-ChatQ-Excd-Hornberge.xlsx FRE 802 (Hearsay); FoundationGX0946 20160429-ACF_SW-Ag_GW-Ag-Pumping_time_series.xlsx FRE 802 (Hearsay); Lack of Foundation; FRE 403

(Confusing/Misleading); FRE 901 (Authentication)

GX0947 20160429-ACF_SW-Ag_GW-Ag-Pumping_time_series.xlsx FRE 802 (Hearsay); FoundationGX0948 2016-ACF-GA-consumptive.monthly.xlsx FRE 802 (Hearsay); FoundationGX0949 2016-ACF-RIOP-flow-thresholds-analysis_02.26.16.xlsx FRE 802 (Hearsay); Foundation

74

Ex. # Joint Exhibit Description Date Mentioned Date Offered Objection Date AdmittedGX0950 30(b)(6) Testimony for Brett Cyphers, Executive Director, NWFWMD

GX0951 4198_APP E_Tables E-2 to E-5_Back-up.xlsx FRE 802 (Hearsay); FoundationGX0952 4198_HookvsLULC.xlsx FRE 802 (Hearsay); FoundationGX0953 4198_ModelComparisons_heads_v1.xlsx FRE 802 (Hearsay); FoundationGX0954(Under Seal)

4198_MODFE_InputFiles_IrrigationPumping_28Jan2016.xlsxFRE 802 (Hearsay); Foundation

GX0955 5-1 - 5-3_4198_MainText_Tabs_5-1 to 5-3.xlsx FRE 802 (Hearsay); FoundationGX0956 8728690 Apalachicola, Florida (Chart)GX0957 A Complex Relationship between Freshwater Discharge and Oyster

Fishery CPUE in Apalachicola Bay, Florida: An Evaluation from 1960-2013

FRE 802 (Hearsay)

GX0958 AB Landings86-2013.xls FRE 802 (Hearsay)GX0959 ACF_GA-Request_621mgd_Demand_cal_20160111.xls FRE 802 (Hearsay); FoundationGX0960 acf-ag-water-use-effect-2002-2013.xlsx FRE 802 (Hearsay); Lack of Foundation; FRE 403


GX0961 acf-ag-water-use-effect-2002-2013-added-summary-tab.xlsx FRE 802 (Hearsay); FoundationGX0962 ACF-Hornberger-40percent-SprIch-mb.xlsx FRE 802 (Hearsay); FoundationGX0963 ACF-Hornberger-flow-target.xlsx FRE 802 (Hearsay); FoundationGX0964 ACF-Hornberger-Sumatra-meas.xlsx FRE 802 (Hearsay); FoundationGX0965 ACF-Hornberger-Table10-color FRE 802 (Hearsay); FoundationGX0966 ACF-incremental-flow-loss-in-FL.xlsx FRE 802 (Hearsay); FoundationGX0967 acf-sub4-mete-utilized-frequency-statistics_TABLES.xlsx FRE 802 (Hearsay); Lack of Foundation; FRE 403


GX0968(Under Seal)

ACT-ACF GA Withdrawal Returns 1990-2014-missing-20151029- Baseline-2011-hl-20160203.xlsx. FRE 802 (Hearsay); Foundation

GX0969 Agr_irr_growth.xls FRE 802 (Hearsay); Lack of Foundation; FRE 403 (Confusing/Misleading); FRE 901 (Authentication)

GX0970 Agricultural Irrigation Water Demand - Georgia's Major and Minor Crops 2011 through 2050

GX0971 AlandGA_wu80-93_02012016.xls FRE 802 (Hearsay); FoundationGX0972 Amendments to the Water Supply and Water Conservation Management

Plan. GX0973 Analysis Summary.docx FRE 802 (Hearsay)GX0974 Analysis_Years_Baseline2011_2013_RIK_AVE.xlsx FRE 802 (Hearsay); FoundationGX0975 ANERR GIS data (http://cdmo.baruch.sc.edu/get/gis.cfm)GX0976 ANERR Monthly Trawling Surveys

(http://www.dep.state.fl.us/coastal/sites/apalachicola/science/trawling.htm)

GX0977 ANERR SAV Monitoring database (http://www.dep.state.fl.us/coastal/sites/apalachicola/science/sav.htm)

GX0978 ANERR_Trawls_LWR_20160121_1435.csv FRE 802 (Hearsay); FoundationGX0979 Annual_Ratio_Plots_FAK.xlsx FRE 802 (Hearsay); FoundationGX0980 Annual_Temp_CD-2-4-7.xlsx FRE 802 (Hearsay); FoundationGX0981 Apalachicola Gage Data.xlsx FRE 802 (Hearsay); FoundationGX0982 Apalachicola_FIM_data.mdbGX0983 Apalachicola-Chipola Basin Lakes, Rivers, Streams, and AquifersGX0984 Article X - Post Development Stormwater ManagementGX0985 BarDataForFigs.xlsx FRE 802 (Hearsay)GX0986 Baseline2011_ScenB_1992_Results_Annual_Monthly_Seasonal_Specific_Y

rs_FAK.xlsx FRE 802 (Hearsay); Foundation

75

Ex. # Joint Exhibit Description Date Mentioned Date Offered Objection Date AdmittedGX0987 basin_yield(07.19.2016).xlsx FRE 802 (Hearsay); FoundationGX0988 BioticData mdb FRE 802 (Hearsay); FoundationGX0989 BlueCrabLandingsTrip.xlsx FRE 802 (Hearsay)GX0990 BlueCrabReportCreatorResults-County-5.xlsx FRE 802 (Hearsay)GX0991 Box2012.xlsx FRE 802 (Hearsay)GX0992 Box2013.xlsx FRE 802 (Hearsay)GX0993 BrattleGroup_FloridaAndGeorgiaSurvey_Main_Client_update.dta FRE 802 (Hearsay)GX0994 BrattleGroup_FloridaAndGeorgiaSurvey_Main_Client_update.sav FRE 802 (Hearsay)GX0995 BrattleGroup_FloridaAndGeorgiaSurvey_Main_Client_wgtd.dta FRE 802 (Hearsay)GX0996 Buford Rainfall Data GX0997 Bureau of Economic Analysis, Regional Economic Accounts: 2009-2014

(http://bea.gov/)GX0998 Cantor Exhibit 10, Comparison of Sunding’s G1A and G1B. FRE 802 (Hearsay)GX0999 Capacity_Stats.docx FRE 802 (Hearsay); Lack of Foundation; FRE 403


GX1000 CatPoint_survey_index.xlsxGX1001 CatPtBarAnalysis.docx FRE 802 (Hearsay)GX1002 CatStone.xlsx FRE 802 (Hearsay)GX1003 Central Data Management Office, National Estuarine Research Reserve

Program, 2015 (http://cdmo.baruch.sc.edu/mobile/)GX1004 Chattahoochee_Baseline2011_Simulated_Results.xlsxGX1005 Chattahoochee_Flint_Unimpaired Flows_v3 (1).xlsx FRE 802 (Hearsay); FoundationGX1006 City of Atlanta Municipal Code § 74-501

(www.municode.com/library/ga/atlanta/codes/code of ordinances?nodeId=COORATGEVOII CH74ENARTXPODESTMA S74-501IN)

GX1007 Clayton County Water Authority, Water Reuse (http://www.ccwa.us/water-use).

GX1008 Common Conversion FactorsGX1009 Conservation_Stats.docx FRE 802 (Hearsay); Lack of Foundation; FRE 403


GX1010 Consumptive Use_Final(GA Edits).xlsx FRE 802 (Hearsay); FoundationGX1011 ConsumptiveUse_GA00309613_Confidential ACT-ACF GA Withdrawal

Returns 1990-2013-01072015-Jeff Regan.xlsx FRE 802 (Hearsay); Lack of Foundation; FRE 403 (Confusing/Misleading); FRE 901 (Authentication)

GX1012 Conversion from High P Impact Aprinklers to Low P Sprinkler Data_Lower Flint RIver Basin.xlsx FRE 802 (Hearsay); Lack of Foundation; FRE 403


GX1013 Copy of 2015_GA_Water_Supply_Request_Model_Sumatra_Flow_Baseline_ScenB_1

FRE 802 (Hearsay)

GX1014 Copy of oys_frank_fishers_8614.xls FRE 802 (Hearsay)GX1015 Cover photo and Figure 16 photo

(http://www.cbf.typepad.com/bay_daily/page/25/) FRE 802 (Hearsay)

GX1017 Crop Comparison Tool (http://agecon.uga.edu/extension/budgets/cct/index.html)

GX1018 Curriculum Vitae - Karl E. HavensGX1019 CV of Charles MenzieGX1020 CV of Mark MastersGX1021 CV of Peter MayerGX1022 CV of Philip BedientGX1023 CV of Robert StavinsGX1024 CV of Robin CantorGX1025 CV of Romuald Lipcius

76

Ex. # Joint Exhibit Description Date Mentioned Date Offered Objection Date AdmittedGX1026 CV of Sorab PandayGX1027 CV of Suat IrmakGX1028 CV of Wei ZengGX1029 CV of William McAnallyGX1031 DACS Population Estimates Aug 2014-ask1.xls FRE 802 (Hearsay)GX1032 DACSbarAnalysis.xlsx FRE 802 (Hearsay)GX1033 Data Bar densities pre post collapse.xlsx FRE 802 (Hearsay)GX1034 doit.mGX1035 Draft Operational Plan - FWC Division of Law Enforcement Carrabelle

Field Office GX1036 Drill size and abundance_mod.xlsxGX1037 Drought Chronology - June 21, 2006 thru December 31, 2009 FRE 802 (Hearsay); FRE 901 (Authentication);

FoundationGX1038 E:\ACF\Lake Seminole\RESMOD\resmod_v2.mGX1039 EFDC Model Results (Results.zip) FRE 802 (Hearsay)GX1040 ETa vs ETpot_Mitchell Co.xlsx FRE 802 (Hearsay); Lack of Foundation; FRE 403


GX1041 Exceedance_CD7_03022016.xlsx FRE 802 (Hearsay); FoundationGX1042 Excel showing Monthly precipitation between 1895-1974 and 1975-2013

GX1044 FDACS, Tate's Hell State Forest fact sheet (http://www.freshfromflorida.com/Divisions-Offices/Florida-Forest-Service/Our-Forests/State-Forests/Tate-s-Hell-State-Forest)

GX1045 FDEP of Health, Blue-green Algae (http://www.floridahealth.gov/environmental-health/aquatic-toxins/cyanobacteria.html)

GX1046 FDEP website entitled Submerged Aquatic Vegetation Monitoring Apalachicola National Estuary and Research Reserve

GX1047 FDEP website re monthly trawling surveys at Apalachicola National Estuarian Reserve

GX1048 Figure 26, photo (http://www.houstonpress.com/restaurants/invasivorism-hits-texas-eating-thesnails-that-eat-our-oysters-6423115) FRE 802 (Hearsay)

GX1049 Figure 29, photo (https://www.flickr.com/photos/wfsumedia/8697012360/) FRE 802 (Hearsay)

GX1050 Figure 34, photo of blue crab (http://splendidwallpapers.com/blue-crab-wallpapers.html) FRE 802 (Hearsay)

GX1051 Figure 34, photo of brown rock shrimp (http://naturewatch.org.nz/observations/862824) FRE 802 (Hearsay)

GX1052 Figure 34, photo of pink shrimp(http://voices.nationalgeographic.com/2010/02/01/shrimp_trawl_excluder_cuts_bycatch/)

FRE 802 (Hearsay)

GX1053 Figure 34, photo of white shrimp (http://www.ncfishes.com/families/aquaticinvertebrates/litopenaeus-setiferus/)

FRE 802 (Hearsay)

GX1054 FIM StoneCrab Rept 2006.pdfGX1055 FIM StoneCrab Rept 2007.pdfGX1056 FIM StoneCrab Rept 2008.pdfGX1057 FIM StoneCrab Rept 2009.pdfGX1058 FIM StoneCrab Rept 2010.pdfGX1059 Final Bar Densities.xlsx FRE 802 (Hearsay)GX1060 Final Data Bar densities pre post collapse.xlsx FRE 802 (Hearsay)

77

Ex. # Joint Exhibit Description Date Mentioned Date Offered Objection Date AdmittedGX1061 Fisheries Independent Monitoring (FIM) Monthly Trawl Data for

Apalachicola bay, Tampa Bay, and Charlotte Harbor, as transformed and provided with this report


GX1062 FL searchable database of bloom records (http://b3.caspio.com/dp.asp?AppKey=cb8a10004879ebb2e9ce40ec9371)

GX1063 Flewelling Response Calculations.xlsx FRE 802 (Hearsay); Lack of Foundation; FRE 403 (Confusing/Misleading); FRE 901 (Authentication)

GX1064 FL-GA Water Use Database.accdb FRE 802 (Hearsay); Lack of Foundation; FRE 403 (Confusing/Misleading); FRE 901 (Authentication)

GX1065 Florida Oceans and Coastal Council (http://www.dep.state.fl.us/oceanscouncil/)

GX1066 Florida Statewide Agricultural Irrigation Demand (FSAID) – Final Report FRE 802 (Hearsay); Lack of Foundation; FRE 403 (Confusing/Misleading); FRE 901 (Authentication)

GX1067 FlowData.xlsx FRE 802 (Hearsay)GX1068 Franklin County Shell Planting (1/2010 to 11/2010) FRE 106 (Completeness)GX1069 Franklin County Shell Planting (2/2013 to 8/2013) FRE 106 (Completeness)GX1070 Franklin County Shell Planting (3/2012 to 11/2012) FRE 106 (Completeness)GX1071 Franklin County Shell Planting (4/2011 to 11/2011) FRE 106 (Completeness)GX1072 Franklin County Shell Planting (5/26/2014 to 7/26/2014) FRE 106 (Completeness)GX1073 Franklin County Shell Planting (8/9/2015 to 10/9/2015) FRE 106 (Completeness)GX1074 Functional response for Will.xlsxGX1075 FWC Commercial Fisheries Landings

(http://myfwc.com/research/saltwater/fishstats/commercial-%20fisheries/landings-in-florida/)

GX1076 FWC Fish Kill database (https://public.myfwc.com/fwri/FishKillReport/searchresults.aspx)

GX1077 FWC Florida Fish and Wildlife Research Institute GIS and Mapping Data Downloads, manatee recovery locations in Florida 1974–2014; accessed on 2/10/16, filtered by county (http://geodata.myfwc.com/datasets/ba5b92ec509f48f38c61aa542e96236f_1?orderByFields=COUNTY+ASC&where=COUNTY+like+'%25Franklin%25'&filterByExtent=true&uiTab=table).

GX1078 FWC stone crab 2013.pdfGX1079 FWC stone crab 2014.pdfGX1080 FWC Value of Freshwater Fishing in Florida

(http://myfwc.com/conservation/value/freshwater-fishing/) FRE 802 (Hearsay)

GX1081 FWRldata.xlsx FRE 802 (Hearsay)GX1082 GA water_basin_map.PDFGX1083 GA_2050_Future_Use_19Feb2016.txtGX1084 Georgia 2011 Validated Water Audit Results July15.xlsx FRE 802 (Hearsay)GX1085 Georgia 2011 Validated Water Audit Results.xlsx FRE 802 (Hearsay)GX1086 Georgia 2012 Validated Water Audit Results.xlsx FRE 802 (Hearsay)GX1087 Georgia 2013 Validated Water Audit Results.xlsx FRE 802 (Hearsay)GX1088 Georgia Analysis.JNB FRE 802 (Hearsay)GX1089 Georgia EPD, Guidance regarding local and regional management of water

supply, water conservation, wastewater, and watershed impacts for the District’s 2016 Plan updates.

GX1090 Georgia Water Efficiency Rule, 391-3-33-.05.GX1091 Gulf Sturgeon Fact Sheet. United States Fish and Wildlife Service

(http://www.fws.gov/panamacity/resources/SturgeonFactS08.pdf) FRE 802 (Hearsay)

78

Ex. # Joint Exhibit Description Date Mentioned Date Offered Objection Date AdmittedGX1092 HAB Monitoring Database. FWC

(http://myfwc.com/research/redtide/monitoring/database/).FRE 802 (Hearsay); FRE 403 (Prejudicie/Confusing/Misleading) - Florida does not object to the extent Georgia means the actual database or the website. Florida does object if Georgia is referring to a .csv file in the production of Dr. Menzie

GX1093 Habitat_acres_20160330_nontidal_only FRE 802 (Hearsay); FoundationGX1094 Handwritten notes of Nov. 13 conference call with FDEP, FWC, and

NWFWMD FRE 802 (Hearsay); FRE 901 (Authentication)

GX1096 Hornberger data_USGS_ACFBasin.xlsx FRE 802 (Hearsay); FoundationGX1097 Hornberger_figs_3a&4a.xlsx FRE 802 (Hearsay); FoundationGX1098 Hornberger_v_USGS.xlsx FRE 802 (Hearsay); FoundationGX1099 Hornberger's June-September "Streamflow Depletion" vs. Flewelling's

June-September UseFRE 802 (Hearsay); FRE 901 (Authentication); Foundation

GX1100 Hornberger's Reduction in Inflow (2050 Scenario) vs. Hornberger's Modeled Reduction in Outflow (Lake Seminole)


GX1101 http://ecos.fws.gov/tess_public/profile/speciesProfile;jsessionid=4F3C278B64FA1867A124B618B436D132? spcode=F03O)

FRE 403 - Link provided by Georgia does not work; Florida is unable to determine this exhibit's content.

GX1102 http://iridl.ldeo.columbia.edu/SOURCES/.LDEO/.TRL/.NADA2004/.pdsi-atlas.html. FRE 802 (Hearsay); FRE 106 (Completeness)

GX1103 http://northgeorgiawater.org/conserve-our-water/did-you-know/ FRE 802 (Hearsay)GX1104 http://www.atlantaregional.com/about-us/news-press/press-

releases/metropolitan-north-georgia-waterplanning-district-wins-inaugural-southface-fulcrum-award

FRE 802 (Hearsay)

GX1105 http://www.circleofblue.org/2010/world/the-price-of-water-a-comparison-of-water-rates-usage-in-30-u-s-cities/ FRE 802 (Hearsay)

GX1106 http://www.georgiawaterplanning.org/pages/forecasting/agricultural_water_use.php

GX1107 http://www.greenprints.org/wp-content/uploads/fulcrum-awards-program-sm.pdf FRE 802 (Hearsay)

GX1108 http://www.gwinnettdailypost.com/archive/county-wins-three-awards-for-public-relationswork/article_c4965e96-e27b-572a-9a30-3e5971ec7049.html

FRE 802 (Hearsay)

GX1109 http://www.metroatlantachamber.com/business/data/fortune-500-1000-hq FRE 802 (Hearsay)

GX1110 http://www.nespal.org/sirp/waterinfo/State/awd/agwaterdemand.htmGX1111 https://coast.noaa.gov/digitalcoast/tools/slr FRE 802 (Hearsay); FoundationGX1112 https://epd.georgia.gov/sites/epd.georgia.gov/files/GAWaterLossManual_V1

.2.pdfGX1113 https://epd.georgia.gov/sites/epd.georgia.gov/files/related_files/site_page/20

12FINALSB370_annual_rpt_Dec2012c-1.docGX1114 https://epd.georgia.gov/sites/epd.georgia.gov/files/related_files/site_page/S

B370_annual_rpt_agency_activities_122010_final.pdfGX1115 https://epd.georgia.gov/sites/epd.georgia.gov/files/related_files/site_page/S

B370_annual_rpt_Dec2011.pdfGX1116 https://www.gwinnettcounty.com/portal/gwinnett/AboutGwinnett/YourGov

ernment/StateoftheCounty/2014Honors

FRE 802 (Hearsay)

GX1117 https://www3.epa.gov/watersense/partners/winners 2015.html FRE 802 (Hearsay)GX1119 Investigation of Uncertainties in Surface Water Resource Assessment of

Georgia State Water Plan FRE 802 (hearsay)

79

Ex. # Joint Exhibit Description Date Mentioned Date Offered Objection Date AdmittedGX1120(Under Seal)

Irrigated Acreage.zipFRE 901; FRE 403 (Misleading/Confusing/Prejudicial); FRE 802 (Hearsay). This .zip file includes 127 documents (including technical Excel and GIS files), and Florida has no way of knowing which ones are being used, for what purpose, and how. Florida reserves the right to object when it sees how these are being used by Georgia.

GX1121 Irrigated and Rainfed Yield Data Graphs.xlsx FRE 802 (Hearsay); Lack of Foundation; FRE 403 (Confusing/Misleading); FRE 901 (Authentication)

GX1122(Under Seal)

Irrigation Depths.zip FRE 901; FRE 403 (Misleading/Confusing/Prejudicial); FRE 802 (Hearsay). This .zip file includes 31 documents (including technical Excel and GIS files), and Florida has no way of knowing which ones are being used, for what purpose, and how. Florida reserves the right to object when it sees how these are being used by Georgia.

GX1123 Irrigation in Georgia Portion of ACF Basin FRE 802 (Hearsay); FRE 901 (Authentication); Foundation

GX1124 JimWoodruff Annual Precipitation FRE 802 (Hearsay); FRE 901 (Authentication); Foundation

GX1126 Kingston flyer.pdf FRE 901 (Authentication)GX1127 LakeSeminoleModel_Data_Req_FutureScenario_July_05_2016.xlsx FRE 802 (Hearsay); FoundationGX1128 LakeSeminoleModel_Data_Req_July_19_2016.xlsxGX1129 Landings FWC download 13Dec15.xlsx FRE 802 (Hearsay)GX1130 LandingsDACSshell.xlsx FRE 802 (Hearsay)GX1131 Leitman et al, Management Options During the 2011-2012 Drought on the

Apalachicola River: A Systems Dynamic Model Evaluation, Environmental Management (2016)

FRE 802 (Hearsay)

GX1132 Letter from Lynn Martina/ABODA to Pinki Jackel re Apalachicola Bay Issues FRE 802 (Hearsay)

GX1133 LF Mapping.pptx FRE 802 (Hearsay); Lack of Foundation; FRE 403 (Confusing/Misleading); FRE 901 (Authentication)

GX1134 LicenseHoldersByCounty.xlsx FRE 802 (Hearsay)GX1136 Map of Trawling stationsGX1137 Map of Trawling stationsGX1138 Map: USGS Stations with Streamflow Data In the ACF and Chipola River

BasinsGX1139 Maps/charts re Drought indexesGX1140 Maps_Used_in_Brattle_Survey.docx FRE 802 (Hearsay)GX1141 ModelFitCalculations.mGX1142 Monthly consumptive use for ResSim scenarios (1).xlsx FRE 802 (Hearsay); FoundationGX1143 Monthly consumptive use for scenarios_02.05.16.xlsx FRE 802 (Hearsay); FoundationGX1144 Monthly precipitation graphsGX1145 NASS_Statistics_GA.xlsx FRE 802 (Hearsay); Lack of Foundation; FRE 403


GX1146 NESPAL website data (http://www.nespal.org/SIRP/waterinfo/state/awd/AgWaterDemand_IrrArea.htm)

GX1147 NewGAmodel_Result.xlsx FRE 802 (Hearsay); Foundation

80

Ex. # Joint Exhibit Description Date Mentioned Date Offered Objection Date AdmittedGX1148 Nicholas C. Fisch and William E. Pine III, Draft "A Complex Relationship

between Freshwater Discharge and Oyster Fishery CPUE in Apalachicola Bay, Florida: An Evaluation from 1960-2013"

FRE 802 (Hearsay)

GX1149 NOAA Atlantic Multidecadal Oscillation Index (http://www.esrl.noaa.gov/psd/data/timeseries/AMO/) FRE 802 (Hearsay); Foundation

GX1150 NOAA Harmful Algal Blooms Observing System (http://service.ncddc.noaa.gov/website/AGSViewers/HABSOS/maps.htm)

FRE 403; FRE 106 (Completeness) - Link provided by Georgia does not work; Florida is unable to determine this exhibit's content.

GX1151 NOAA Nutrient Pollution (http://oceanservice.noaa.gov/education/kits/estuaries/media/supp_estuar09b_eutro.html)


GX1152 NOAA Orthometric Height Conversion (http://www.ngs.noaa.gov/cgi-bin/VERTCON/vert_con.prl) FRE 802 (Hearsay); Foundation

GX1153 NOAA Palmer Drought Index (http://www.ncdc.noaa.gov/temp-and-precip/drought/historical-palmers/) FRE 802 (Hearsay); Foundation

GX1154 NOAA Precipitation and Temperature Data for Climatological Divisions (CD) 2, 4, and 7 and 1 in Georgia and Florida.

GX1155 NOAA Southeast Fisheries Science Center, Fisheries Data (http://www.sefsc.noaa.gov/data/) FRE 802 (Hearsay)

GX1156 NOAA_Precipitation.accdb FRE 802 (Hearsay); FoundationGX1157 Note from Woody to Committee FRE 802 (Hearsay); FRE 403 (Misleading - No

Context for Document)GX1158 Notes for Ted Hoehn 30(b)(6) Deposition Topic 24GX1159 NWFWMD LiDAR data (http://nwfwmdlidar.com/) FRE 403; FRE 106 (Completeness) - Link provided

by Georgia does not work; Florida is unable to determine this exhibit's content.

GX1160 obs_impacted.csvGX1161 Operational Plan - FWC Division of Law Enforcement Carrabelle Field

Office (Operation Black Pearl)GX1162 Oyster_Data_Extracted_021516.xlsx FRE 802 (Hearsay)GX1163 oyster_IPM_histo.mGX1164 oyster_IPM_SS.mGX1165 oyster_PP_params.mGX1166 Phase II ANERR Trawling Data.xlsxGX1167 Pine_appendix1.xlsx FRE 802 (Hearsay)GX1168 Pine_appendix1_RNL.xlsx FRE 802 (Hearsay)GX1169 Pine_appendix2.pdf FRE 802 (Hearsay)GX1170 predators.csvGX1171 Presentation "An Evaluation of the Compatibility Between Navigation and

Environmental Releases From the ACF Reservoir System" FRE 802 (Hearsay)

GX1172 Project Description Form - Franklin County Seafood Workers Association (FCSWA) Oyster Reef Recovery & Relay Project FRE 802 (Hearsay)

GX1173 README - Production for Outdoor Use TableGX1174 Report_tables_2-8-16.xlsx FRE 802 (Hearsay); FoundationGX1175 Reservoir Operations Modeling with HEC-RESSIM (Klipsch, et al.)GX1176 Reservoir Operations Modeling with HEC-RESSIM (Klipsch, et al.)GX1177 Restricted_Stats.docx FRE 802 (Hearsay); Lack of Foundation; FRE 403


GX1178 S. Leitman & G. A. Kiker, Development and comparison of integrated river/reservoir models in the Apalachicola-Chattahoochee-Flint basin, UA, Environ Syst Decis (2015) 35:410-423

FRE 802 (Hearsay)

GX1179 S. Leitman & G. Kiker. The effects of reducing agricultural irrigation withdrawals on system-wide water management in the Apalachicola-Chattahoochee-Flint drainage basin.

FRE 802 (Hearsay)

81

Ex. # Joint Exhibit Description Date Mentioned Date Offered Objection Date AdmittedGX1180 Sand Mountain – Google Earth, views from 1/14/1994 and 12/17/2013 FRE 802 (Hearsay); Foundation

GX1181 Sanitary Sewer Overflow Remediation ProgramGX1182 Set Directory to February 2016 Transmittal FolderGX1183 Shelling.xlsx FRE 802 (Hearsay)GX1184 ShellingDataByTimePeriod.xlsx FRE 802 (Hearsay)GX1185 Simulated Flows from 2030-2050 GA demands model simulation FL-

CEPT0121201GX1186 Soniat shell budget JSR 2012.pdf FRE 802 (Hearsay)GX1187 Soniat shell budget JSR 2014.pdf FRE 802 (Hearsay)GX1188 Spreadsheet FRE 901 (Authentication); FRE 106

(Completeness)GX1189 Spreadsheet - FlowsGX1190 Spreadsheet - Municipal and Industrial Water Use in The ACF Basin

GX1191 Spreadsheets - FlowsGX1192 Statement of Tommy Ward, Apalchicola Bay harvester and processor FRE 802 (Hearsay)GX1193 StoneCrabFIMdata.xlsx FRE 802 (Hearsay)GX1194 StoneCrabReportCreatorResults-County-16.xlsx FRE 802 (Hearsay)GX1195 Sumatra Flow 1978to2014.xlsx FRE 802 (Hearsay)GX1196 Summary of 2000 and 2001 Flint River Drought Protection Act Auctions FRE 802; Foundation; FRE 901 (Authentication)

GX1197 Survey notes and station countsGX1198 Survey_Counts.do FRE 802 (Hearsay); FRE 901 (Authentication)

GX1199 Survey_Responses.xlsx FRE 802 (Hearsay)GX1200 Survival and Growth of Clam and Oyster Larvae at Different Salinities

(Davis)GX1201 Table 10 re basal area and number of trees of important species in forests

of the nontidal Apalachicola River floodplain, Florida FRE 106 (Completeness)

GX1202 Table 16.2 Florida culch plant history (FWC unpublished data) (data from 1970-2009) FRE 106 (Completeness)

GX1203 Ted Hoehn 30(b)(6) Outline Topics 11, 14, and 24GX1204 U.S. Drought Monitor - Georgia - May 22, 2012; Feb. 14, 2012; July 5,

2011; Dec. 25, 2007; Aug. 21, 2007; Sept. 3, 2002; July 25, 2000; June 27, 2000

GX1205 U.S. Drought Monitor Classification SchemeGX1206 United States Census Bureau, Annual Estimates of the Resident

Population for Counties: April 1, 2010 to Jul 1, 2015 (http://www.census.gov/popest/data/counties/totals/2015/CO-EST2015-01.html)

GX1207 United States Drought Monitor (http://droughtmonitor.unl.edu/)GX1208 United States Drought Monitor Statistics Graph: Apalachicola HUC8

(03130011) (http://droughtmonitor.unl.edu/MapsAndData/Graph.aspx) FRE 802 (Hearsay); Foundation

GX1209 United States Geological Survey (USGS) historical topographic maps (http://historicalmaps.arcgis.com/usgs/) FRE 802 (Hearsay); Foundation

GX1210 University of Florida Digital Collections (UFDC) (http://ufdc.ufl.edu/aerials/map) FRE 802 (Hearsay); Foundation

GX1211 University of Florida, IFAS News, UF/IFAS recognizes top faculty research(https://news.ifas.ufl.edu/2016/04/ufifas-recognizes-top-faculty-research) FRE 802 (Hearsay)

GX1212 University of Georgia, Statewide Irrigation Monitoring (http://www.nespal.org/SIRP/AWP/AWP_I_Fact_Sheets.shtml)

GX1213 Updated Curriculum Vitae - Bill Pine, Ph. D.82

Ex. # Joint Exhibit Description Date Mentioned Date Offered Objection Date AdmittedGX1214 US_Census.accdb FRE 802 (Hearsay); FoundationGX1215 USACE, "ACF Historic Project Data" GX1216 USACE-Alternatives-monthly-seasonal_02.26.16.xlsx FRE 802 (Hearsay); FoundationGX1217 USFWS T&E species information (http://ecos.fws.gov/ecp/) FRE 802 (Hearsay); FoundationGX1218 USGS GSWCC GA Ag Water Conservation and Metering Program.PDF FRE 802 (Hearsay)

GX1219 USGS Non-indigenous Aquatic Species database (http://nas.er.usgs.gov/default.aspx) FRE 802 (Hearsay); Foundation

GX1220 USGS, Water Use Glossary (http://water.usgs.gov/watuse/wuglossary.html) FRE 802 (Hearsay)

GX1221 USGS_vs_Hornberger.xlsx FRE 802 (Hearsay); FoundationGX1222 USGS312232084391701 08K001GX1223 Water and Sewer Rates and Rate Structures in Georgia as of June 2015

http://www.efc.sog.unc.edu/sites/www.efc.sog.unc.edu/files/2015/GA2015WaterSewerRatesTables_0.pdf

GX1224 Water and Wastewater Rates and Rate Structures in Georgia July 2015 http://www.efc.sog.unc.edu/sites/www.efc.sog.unc.edu/files/2015/GA2015WaterSewerRatesReport_0.pdf

GX1225 Water Audits and Water Loss Control for Public Water Systems (https://www.epa.gov/sites/production/files/201504/documents/epa816f13002.pdf)

GX1226 Water Levels - NOAA Tides and Currents, 8728690 Apalachicola FL (http://www.co-ops.nos.noaa.gov/waterlevels.html?id=8728690)

GX1227 Watershed Modeling Report for Chattahoochee_V9-REV2 (2) FRE 802 (Hearsay); FoundationGX1228 Watershed_Modeling_Report_for_Flint_River_Watershed_V10-REV1.pdf FRE 802 (Hearsay); Foundation

GX1229 Woodruff Rainfall Data GX1230 www.atlantaregional.com/environment/water GX1231 USACE HEC Website (http://www.hec.usace.army.mil/)GX1232 Ga. Comp. R. & Regs. r. 391-3-6-.01 thru .07GX1233 Precipitation Data for USGS 02343801 CHATTAHOOCHEE RIVER

NEAR (http://nwis.waterdata.usgs.gov/ga/nwis/uv?cb_00045=on&format=gif_default&site_no=02343801)

GX1234 Precipitation Data for USGS 02356000 FLINT RIVER AT BAINBRIDGE (http://nwis.waterdata.usgs.gov/ga/nwis/uv/?cb_00045=on&format=gif_default&site_no=02356000)

GX1235 University of Nebraska Lincoln Plant & Soil Science eLibrary, Soils - Part 2: Physical Properties of Soil and Soil Water (2016) (https://passel.unl.edu/pages/informationmodule.php?idinformationmodule=1130447039&topicorder=10&maxto=10) (2016)

GX1236 USDA-NRCS, Saturated Hydraulic Connectivity in Relation to Soil Texture (http://www.nrcs.usda.gov/wps/portal/nrcs/detail/soils/survey/office/ssr10/tr/?cid=nrcs144p2_074846)

GX1237 UGA Extension Bulletin 882, Factors to Consider in Selecting a Farm Irrigation System (2015)

GX1238 Flint River Soil and Water Conservation District Summary of USDA-NRCS Contracts for EQIP and AWEP between 2005 and 2014

FRE 403 (Confusing/Misleading) - Florida does not know what this document is; it is not freely available online and was not produced with any expert testimony.

83

Ex. # Joint Exhibit Description Date Mentioned Date Offered Objection Date AdmittedGX1239 Georgia Soil and Water Conservation Commission, Georgia Agricultural

Water Conservation Initiative, Mobile Irrigation Lab (2014) FRE 403 (Confusing/Misleading) - Florida does not know what this document is. If Georgia simply is referring to the GSWCC website on mobile irrigation labs, Florida does not object.

GX1240 L. Mark Risse, et al., Georgia’s Water Conservation Efforts: Cooperative Extension’s Banner Effort, 2009 Georgia Water Resources Conference (2009)

FRE 802 (Hearsay)

GX1241 2006 GSWCC-ASU ContractGX1242 2006 GSWCC-ASU Contract AmendmentGX1243 2013-05-07 Email from K. Knickerbocker to L. Conti re DRAFT FWC

Oyster Disaster Report to NOAA Fisheries ServiceGX1244 2013-05-08 Email from K. Knickerbocker to L. Conti re DRAFT FWC

Oyster Disaster Report to NOAA Fisheries Service FRE 802 (Hearsay)

GX1245 McDowell, Robin, Status of the Flint River Regional Water Development and Conservation Plan, Proceedings of 2005 Georgia Water Resources Conference (April 26-27, 2003)

FRE 802 (Hearsay)

GX1246 USDA, National Engineering Handbook Chapter 2: Irrigation Water Requirements at 2-147 (1993) FRE 106 (Completeness); Georgia is citing solely

to one page of this exhibit, while Florida believes the full document should be used. Florida has no objection if Georgia uses the full exhibit.

GX1247 Upper Flint Regional Water Plan (2011) (http://www.upperflint.org/documents/UFL_Adopted_RWP.pdf)

GX1248 FWC Oyster Landings & Trips - Annual, County, 1980-2016.csvGX1249 2014.10.22 Water Resource Planning: Georgia Update FRE 802 (Hearsay)GX1250 U.S. Senate Committee on Environment and Public Works FRE 802 (Hearsay); FRE 106 (Completeness);

FRE 901 (Authenticity)GX1251 GSWCC Metering Program WebsiteGX1252 FDEP, Site-specific information in support of establishing numeric

nutrient criteria in Apalachicola Bay. FDEPartment of Environmental Protection, Report of Division of Environmental Assessment and Restoration, Standards and Assessment Section.

FRE 802 (Hearsay); Authenticity

GX1253Memorandum re revisions to Draft Flint River Drought Protection Act.

GX1254 FWC. Summary Report for Franklin County Coastal Waters. In: Seagrass Integrated Mapping and Monitoring Program, Mapping and Monitoring Report 1.1, FWRI TechnicalReport TR-17. Yarbro, L.A. and P.R. Carlson Jr., eds. FWC, Fish and Wildlife Research Institute.

FRE 802 (Hearsay); Authenticity

GX1255 Final Report, Hydrologic Restoration of Tate's Hell Swamp: A Comparative Watershed Analysis of Ecosystem Response and Recovery, A

GX1256 The Apalachicola Project Phase 1: Restoring Apalachicola Bay and Region FRE 802 (Hearsay); FRE 901 (Authenticity)

GX1257 T. Ward 2008 Business Summaries of Oysters Harvested from Public Bars and Private Oyster Leases

GX1258 T. Ward 2009 Business Summaries of Oysters Harvested from Public Bars and Private Oyster Leases

GX1259combine-aoi&au_desktop_excluding_aoi-excl.xlsx FRE 901 (Authenticity); FRE 106 (Completeness)

GX1260 Encouraging Voluntary Water Conservation and Enhancing the State's Water Supply, Annual Report on State Agency Activities

GX1261 2006 Amendments to the Flint River Drought Protection Act GX1262 Letter from Carol Couch to FDEP and ADEM re NRC Study FRE 802 (Hearsay)

84

Ex. # Joint Exhibit Description Date Mentioned Date Offered Objection Date AdmittedGX1263 Email forwarded from Kelly Layman to Michael Sole re NRC Study FRE 802 (Hearsay)GX1264 Email from Carol Couch to Steve Parker (NAS) re Potential ACF Basin

Study FRE 802 (Hearsay)

GX1265 2001 Georgia Laws Act 27 (S.B. 130)GX1266 FDEP Memorandum from J. Abendroth to D. Struhs re April 30 ACF

Water Allocation Formula Technical MeetingGX1267 Email from D. Miller to large distribution list attaching Apalachicola-

Chattahoochee-Flint River Basin Interstate Compact Background Information

FRE 802 (Hearsay)

GX1268 Email from L. Bolen to T. Hoehn, L. Edmiston, G. Lewis, and H. Light re FW: Text of ACF MOU and Statements by Governor Bush and Secretary Struhs

FRE 802 (Hearsay)

GX1269 Summary of Oyster Resource Assessment for Apalachicola Bay, September 2012

Florida Blanket Objection #1: Florida reserves the right to modify these objections upon reviewing Georgia’s pre-filed direct testimony and the use of exhibits with certain witnesses. Florida also reserves the right to assert additional objections to documents Georgia seeks to introduce during the cross-examination of Florida’s witnesses, or on re-direct of any Georgia witnesses.

Florida Blanket Objection #2: Florida has put forth its objections based on what it believes are the correct versions of Georgia’s exhibits. Florida reserves the right to modify its objections upon seeing the final, stamped versions of Georgia’s trial exhibits. Florida also reserves the right to assert additional objections on completeness grounds should Georgia attempt to introduce excerpts of documents, instead of complete versions.

85

No. 142, Original

In The Supreme Court of the United States

STATE OF FLORIDA,

Plaintiff, v.

STATE OF GEORGIA,

Defendant.

Before the Special Master

Hon. Ralph I. Lancaster

__________________________

CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE

This is to certify that the TRIAL EXHIBIT LIST which reflects the parties’ agreed-upon Joint Exhibits, Florida Exhibits, and Georgia Exhibits, has been served on this 26th day of October 2016, in the manner specified below:

For State of Florida For United States of America

By Email By Email:

Gregory G. Garre Counsel of Record Latham & Watkins LLP 555 11th Street, NW Suite 1000 Washington, DC 20004 T: (202) 637-2207 [email protected]

Donald J. Verrilli Solicitor General Counsel of Record Department of Justice 950 Pennsylvania Avenue, N.W. Washington, DC 20530 T: 202-514-7717 [email protected]

Jonathan L. Williams Deputy Solicitor General Office of Florida Attorney General The Capital, PL-01 Tallahassee, FL 32399 T: 850-414-3300 [email protected]

By Email Only

Michael T. Gray [email protected] James DuBois [email protected]

2

By Email Only Pamela Jo Bondi Craig Varn Christopher M. Kise James A. McKee Adam C. Losey Matthew Z. Leopold Philip J. Perry Abid R. Qureshi Claudia M. O’Brien Paul N. Signarella Donald G. Blankenau Thomas R. Wilmoth [email protected] [email protected]

For State of Georgia By Email Only Samuel S. Olens Britt Grant Sarah H. Warren Seth P. Waxman Craig S. Primis K. Winn Allen Devora W. Allon [email protected]

/s/ Craig S. Primis ___________________ Craig S. Primis Counsel of Record KIRKLAND & ELLIS LLP 655 Fifteenth Street, NW Washington, DC 20005 T: 202-879-5000 [email protected]