two countries one voice_report

65
confidential memorandum VR Research 405 14 th Street, Suite 350 Oakland, California 94612 vrresearch.com 1 CONFIDENTIAL DATE Tuesday, October 16, 2012 TO Interested Parties FROM VR Research RE Two Countries One Voice This memorandum details our research findings on Andres Ramirez, Juan Jose Gutierrez, Two Countries One Voice and Vamos Unidos. ANDRES RAMIREZ Andres Ramirez is a 34 year old Las Vegas, Nevada based political consultant. Ramirez got his start in politics as a legislative aide to U.S. Senator Harry Reid and as deputy director of Governor Bob Miller’s Washington D.C. Office. After a brief stint as a federal lobbyist for U.S. Strategies, Ramirez returned to Nevada and embarked on a campaign consulting career. Ramirez’s primary focus has been field operations with extensive work on voter registration and outreach. Ramirez has consulted for the Obama re-election campaign this election cycle on Latino outreach issues. Ramirez is currently the president of the Ramirez Group, a Nevada based corporation, vice chair of the DNC Hispanic Caucus and a partner with Democracy Partners, a full service political and public affairs firm. Democracy Partners claims to have consulted for many Democratic elected officials, progressive organizations and unions, including the Communications Workers of America. Ties to Grupo Salinas In May 2008, Ramirez appeared at an issues forum sponsored by Grupo Salinas which was broadcast on its Spanish language channel in Colorado.

Upload: tfresearch

Post on 19-Oct-2015

134 views

Category:

Documents


1 download

TRANSCRIPT

  • confidential memorandum VR Research 405 14th Street, Suite 350 Oakland, California 94612 vrresearch.com 1

    CONFIDENTIAL

    DATE Tuesday, October 16, 2012

    TO Interested Parties

    FROM VR Research

    RE Two Countries One Voice

    This memorandum details our research findings on Andres Ramirez, Juan Jose Gutierrez, Two Countries One Voice

    and Vamos Unidos.

    A N D R E S R A M I R E Z

    Andres Ramirez is a 34 year old Las Vegas, Nevada based political consultant. Ramirez got his start in politics as a

    legislative aide to U.S. Senator Harry Reid and as deputy director of Governor Bob Millers Washington D.C. Office.

    After a brief stint as a federal lobbyist for U.S. Strategies, Ramirez returned to Nevada and embarked on a campaign

    consulting career. Ramirezs primary focus has been field operations with extensive work on voter registration and

    outreach. Ramirez has consulted for the Obama re-election campaign this election cycle on Latino outreach issues.

    Ramirez is currently the president of the Ramirez Group, a Nevada based corporation, vice chair of the DNC Hispanic

    Caucus and a partner with Democracy Partners, a full service political and public affairs firm. Democracy Partners

    claims to have consulted for many Democratic elected officials, progressive organizations and unions, including the

    Communications Workers of America.

    Ties to Grupo Salinas

    In May 2008, Ramirez appeared at an issues forum sponsored by Grupo Salinas which was broadcast on its

    Spanish language channel in Colorado.

  • confidential memorandum VR Research 405 14th Street, Suite 350 Oakland, California 94612 vrresearch.com 2

    Union Ties

    In June 2011, Campaigns & Elections reported that Ramirez would be a partner in a new Democratic consulting firm, Democracy Partners, along with Robert Creamer, Heather Booth, Renee Schaeffer, Marc

    Cerabona, Brett C. Di Resta, Carla Engle, Jeffrey Garcia, Ken Grossinger, John Hennelly, Jackie Kendall, Mike

    Lux, Dan Manatt, Donald McFarland, Josie Mooney, Braidy O'Neal, Linda E. Saucedo, Joel Silberman, and

    Cheri Whiteman.

    According to its website, Democracy Partners clients have included Democratic elected officials, unions

    (including SEIU, AFSCME, AFL CIO and CWA) and progressive organizations.

    Political Professional

    From 1999 to 2000, Ramirez lobbied the U.S. Congress on behalf of the City of Las Vegas and Palm Beach

    County as a lobbyist for U.S. Strategies, an Alexandria, Virginia based governmental relations firm.

    On January 22, 2011, Ramirez incorporated Ramirez Group in Nevada. Ramirez listed himself and his wife,

    Jacqueline as the corporations officer. Ramirez Group is active and in good standing.

    On January 24, 2001, Ramirez incorporated Ramirez & Associates in Nevada. Ramirez listed himself and his

    wife, Jacqueline, as the corporations officers. The entities status is permanently revoked, indicating that

    the business is no longer active in Nevada.

    In May 2012, Roll Call reported that Ramirez was a democratic strategist, working on Hispanic outreach for Democratic Nevada U.S. Senate candidate Shelly Berkley.

    In April 2012, as the spokesman for Nuestro Rio, Ramirez called on policy makers and utility companies to

    protect the Colorado River by raising its water flows and introduced a corrido written to honor the river,

    unveiled on the 85th anniversary of Cesar Chavez birthday.

    In February 2012, Ramirez maintained that the Colorado River was not just a river, its our river,

    noting its historical and cultural importance.

    In October 2011, Politico quoted Ramirez in an article on voter registration and mobilization in Nevada and described Ramirez as a Nevada-based pollster.

    In August 2011, the Washington Post, on its website, reported that Ramirez had met with Obama Administration and campaign officials to discuss Hispanic outreach and noted that Ramirez maintained that

    a hyper obsession with immigration issues had resulted in many Hispanic voters overlooking Obamas

    positive Latino accomplishments like appointing Sonia Sotomayor to the U.S. Supreme Court.

    In August 2011, Ramirez said that Hispanic voter frustration with the Obama Administration was

    understandable and warranted but manageable for the campaign.

    In July 2011, The New York Times reported that Ramirez was the leader of the Nevada Latino Redistricting Coalition which sought to ensure that the states new Congressional seat would be competitive for a Latino

    candidate and that Ramirez had said that Latinos were in a pivotal position with redistricting.

  • confidential memorandum VR Research 405 14th Street, Suite 350 Oakland, California 94612 vrresearch.com 3

    In December 2009, Roll Call reported that Ramirez worked on immigration issues while working for Senator

    Harry Reid and that Ramirez had defended Reid as a long time advocate for immigration reform.

    In November 2009 when Lou Dobbs left CNN, the Washington Post reported that Ramirez, who helped

    organize the CNN boycott to pressure the network to remove Dobbs from its lineup, claimed that CNN

    realized that Dobbs was not consistent with CNNs brand.

    In September 2009, the DNC announced that Ramirez had been elected Vice Chairman of the DNC Hispanic

    Caucus.

    In August 2008, the Las Vegas Review Journal reported that Ramirez splits time between Las Vegas and Washington D.C.

    In 2008, Ramirez worked for the Nevada Democratic Party as its Caucus Outreach Director educating Latino

    voters about the states caucus system, an effort which Ramirez characterized as the most significant and

    aggressive outreach effort in Nevada History.

    In November 2004, the Las Vegas Review Journal reported that Ramirez had spent the 2004 election cycle as Nevada State Director of Voices for Working Families, a voter registration effort. Voices for Working

    Families was part of an association of 33 organizations registering voters.

    In February 2004, India Abroad reported that Ramirez had been hired as the campaign manager for Ro

    Khanna who was challenging sitting Congressman Tom Lantos (D CA) in the Democratic primary.

    In March 2004, Maad Abu-Ghazalah, another of Lantos and Khannas opponents in the Democratic

    primary filed a formal complaint against Khanna alleging that Khanna offered him a quid pro quo

    arrangement to get out of the race so that the two would not split the Indian vote.

    In February 2004, the Las Vegas Review Journal reported that Ramirez firm had developed a voter drive strategy for People for the American Way.

    In November 2002, the Las Vegas Review Journal reported that Ramirez ran the Neighbor to Neighbor get out the vote campaign for the 2002 general election.

    In April 2002, the Associated Press reported that Ramirez was serving as chairman of the Hispanic Democratic Caucus.

    In July 1997 speaking as the information manager for Nevada governors office in Washington D.C.,

    Ramirez noted that nobodys a native in Nevada.

    Political Candidate

    In June 2005, Ramirez lost his bid to unseat North Las Vegas Mayor Michael Montandon 59% to 41%. The

    race was nonpartisan.

    The Associated Press reported that despite the races nonpartisan nature, the Nevada Democratic Party spent $34,280 on Ramirez campaign.

  • confidential memorandum VR Research 405 14th Street, Suite 350 Oakland, California 94612 vrresearch.com 4

    In May 2005, Montandon filed a criminal complaint against Ramirez and Ramirez was questioned by

    police after Montandon alleged that Ramirez stole his yard signs. Police found 48 Montandon yard signs

    at Ramirez house.

    In March 2005, Democracy for America, a group run by former presidential candidate Howard Deans

    brother, Jim, announced that it was endorsing Ramirez race for North Las Vegas Mayor, noting that

    Ramirez had done organizing for Howard Deans campaign and that Ramirez had union backing..

    In 2002, Ramirez ran for a place on the Nevada Board of Regents but came in third of three candidates

    running.

    The Las Vegas Review Journal reported that Ramirez was working as a political consultant and pursuing his undergraduate degree in political science from UNLV.

    J U A N J O S E G U T I E R R E Z

    Juan Jose Gutierrez is a 55 year old Los Angeles based immigration rights activist. Gutierrez has a law degree but is

    not licensed to practice law in California; an article from the mid 1990s noted that he had not yet taken the bar.

    Gutierrez has dedicated his professional life to immigration issues. In the 1990s, Gutierrez ran One Stop

    Immigration, a nonprofit organization that provided services to immigrants including citizenship classes. This

    organization was controversial, losing city and state funding, teetering on the brink of insolvency and refusing to

    comply with an NLRB order to rehire two unionized workers. In the NLRB decision, the judge noted that she did not

    believe Gutierrezs version of events surrounding the labor claim and the decision noted that Gutierrez had been

    accused of sexual harassment. Following his work with One Stop, Gutierrez worked as an activist organizing pro

    immigration marches and protests and starting several advocacy organizations. Many of these efforts have been

    union funded, and Gutierrez even served as the political director of SEIU for a period of time. Gutierrez has been a

    guest on many TV programs, including several appearances on FOX shows in which he argued for legalization of

    most immigrants in the U.S.. Gutierrez is extremely liberal. In 2011, he joined a protest outside of an Obama

    fundraiser at which he said that he was very disappointed with the President. Gutierrez began operating Vamos

    Unidos in 2009. The organization provides legal and immigration services and appears to sell legal plans as a kind of

    insurance in the event of the need for immigration services. Vamos Unidos currently has open state tax liens totaling

    at least $13,000.

    Vamos Unidos

    On August 19, 2009, a DBA was filed in LA County to conduct business as Vamos Unidos USA Inc.

    According to is website which is entirely in Spanish, Vamos Unidos USA provides immigration law

    services. Gutierrez bio is the only one contained on the website. Vamos Unidos provides legal protection

    plans with individual and family legal plans costing from $799 to $1,600 annually.

    On April 20, 2009, Gutierrez filed incorporation papers for Vamos EUA Moving Forward USA with the

    California Secretary of State and listed himself as president. The corporation is currently active and in good

    standing.

    According to a Nexis business search, the State of California has filed three tax liens against Vamos Unidos

    USA and Vamos EUA totaling at least $13,000. We will confirm these liens with the LA County Recorder.

  • confidential memorandum VR Research 405 14th Street, Suite 350 Oakland, California 94612 vrresearch.com 5

    In December 2009, Vamos Unidos organized a rally at a Los Angeles Salvation Army store in response to a

    news report that the Salvation Army in Houston, Texas was requiring recipients of Christmas toys to provide

    social security numbers.

    In response to the rally, LA Salvation Army spokesman Robert Brennan said that the organization would

    not require social security numbers and that the information requested was only to detect fraud or

    duplication.

    Gutierrez called on the Salvation Army to compromise on its identification policy, maintaining that the

    policy was intended to intimidate.

    One Stop Immigration Centers

    In February 1999, Administrative Law Judge Mary Miller Craft found that Gutierrez and One Stop had

    engaged in unfair labor practices by retaliating against and threatening employees engaged in union

    activities. In December 1999, a three member panel of the NLRB considered an appeal of the decision and

    affirmed Judge Crafts decision in the matter.

    The decision affected two cases, each brought by a former employee of One Stop Immigration Center who

    claimed he was fired for engaging in union organizing activities. One case was filed by the International

    Union of Electronic, Electrical, Salaried, Machine and Furniture Workers, AFLCIO, District Eleven on

    behalf of Gumaro Oviedo Flores and the other was filed by Hector Alvarado.

    In her decision, Judge Craft noted three instances in which she could not credit Gutierrezs testimony,

    including on the issue of whether Gutierrez promised to give a job back to one of the employees if he

    ceased union activities.

    The case decision noted that Alvarado and 22 other employees had petitioned One Stops board to

    consider workplace issues including allegations of sexual harassment by Gutierrez and union issues.

    Judge Crafts decision detailed anti union actions taken by Gutierrez including asking employees to

    identify union organizers, threatening employees engaged in union activities and attempting to coerce an

    employee to cease union activities.

    In affirming Crafts decision, the NLRB affirmed her original order requiring that One Stop reinstate the

    employees to their old positions or an equivalent position, provide the employees with back pay and

    benefits and post a notice to all employees informing them of the NLRBs decision and stating their right

    to organize.

    In January 2000, the Los Angeles Times reported that One Stop had defied a NLRB order to rehire two workers whose terminations were found to be in violation of union agreements and noted that the

    organization had ties to prominent labor leaders including LA County Federation of Labor political director

    Fabian Nunez who served on the organizations board.

    In response to questions of his ties to One Stop and its defiance of the NLRB order, Nunez claimed that he

    had told Gutierrez to settle with the union and that a decision from the NLRB is as good as a document

    signed by God.

  • confidential memorandum VR Research 405 14th Street, Suite 350 Oakland, California 94612 vrresearch.com 6

    In response to questions from the paper, Gutierrez said that he was not at liberty to discuss the issue but

    claimed that One Stop was not an anti labor organization.

    Nunez told the Los Angeles Times that One Stop was nearly bankrupt due to state and city funding cuts

    and that the organization would have to negotiate a settlement with the terminated employees in order to

    avoid insolvency.

    In July 2000, Gutierrez, speaking as the director of One Stop Immigration, claimed that there was high

    demand from Latinos for services to assist with becoming citizens, but little available funding for nonprofits

    like One Stop.

    In May 1998, the Orange County Register reported that One Stops class rosters, financial and employee records had been subpoenaed by the Clinton Administration and that Gutierrez had confirmed the request

    for the records.

    In July 1994, One Stop Board Member Stephanie Lopez resigned claiming that Gutierrez had denied her

    access to financial records and that the board had not voted on many of the funding decisions including

    center closures that had occurred over the previous 14 months.

    In response to the accusations from Lopez, Gutierrez claimed that One Stop was going through a very

    difficult period, citing funding cuts which required center closures.

    In February 1997, Gutierrez said that he could not in good conscience recommend to his clients that they

    apply for new identification numbers required by the IRS because he was unsure whether the information

    would be shared with the INS.

    Political & Union Activist

    In June 2012, Hispanically Speaking News reported that Gutierrez was the coordinator of the National

    Regeneration Movement of Mexicans Abroad, an effort to ensure that Mexicans living outside of Mexico had

    the opportunity to vote in the countys elections.

    In June 2012, the Los Angeles Times reported that Gutierrez was supporting Andres Manual Lopez Obrador for president of Mexico, claiming he represented true change.

    In September 2011, Gutierrez protested with hundreds of other activists outside a West Hollywood Obama

    fundraiser, maintaining that he was disappointed with the president.

    Gutierrez has long been an organizer of annual May Day marches in Los Angeles and Washington D.C.,

    protesting the treatment of immigrant labor and calling for citizenship for illegal immigrants. These

    marches have varied in size and tone through the years.

    In April 2011, the Los Angeles Times reported that the annual May Day rally turnout could be suppressed due to a dispute between the Full Rights for Immigrants Coalition, backed by the L.A. County Federation

    of Labor and the Southern California Immigration Coalition over who would organize the march and

    noted that Gutierrez was the coordinator of the larger, union-backed group.

  • confidential memorandum VR Research 405 14th Street, Suite 350 Oakland, California 94612 vrresearch.com 7

    Gutierrez has served as an attorney for braceros, workers who came to the U.S. legally as temporary workers

    from 1942 to 1964 and who had a percentage of their paycheck deducted and deposited into Mexican banks

    but were never refunded the money after returning to Mexico. Some braceros fall under a settlement with

    the Mexican government dealing with payments to workers who were in the U.S. during and immediately

    following the World War II.

    In November 1999, the Orange County Register reported that Gutierrez had been involved with the

    braceros lawsuits since the early 1980s when he petitioned the Mexican government to return the funds

    to the braceros.

    In June 2007 after the U.S. Senate failed to pass an immigration reform bill, Gutierrez said that he was

    deeply disappointed and said that the bill failed due to racism.

    In March 2007, Gutierrezs Latino Movement USA organized an anti war protest with Act Now to Stop War

    and End Racism (ANSWER) and Gutierrez stressed that the immigration and anti war movements are

    connected, noting his own nephew who was killed in Iraq after immigrating from Mexico and joining the

    U.S. military.

    In a June 2006 appearance on Scarborough Country, Gutierrez said that a Philadelphia restaurant owners

    decision to put a sign in his window saying speak English and to require customers to order in English was

    outrageous racism.

    In May 2006 while the U.S. Senate debated a bill providing a path to citizenship for some illegal immigrants

    and also authorizing a border fence, Gutierrez, as a leader of the National Capital Immigration Coalition,

    organized and attended a protest of the militarization of the border.

    In May 2006, Gutierrez, representing Latino Movement USA helped to organize a large scale protest by

    illegal immigrants and other immigration reform supporters, asking them to stay home from work that day

    and to attend rallies in support of full legalization of immigrants in the U.S.

    Some immigrants rights supporters disagreed with the idea of asking immigrants to boycott work, citing

    concerns that they might be fired, a position Gutierrez described as paternalistic.

    In April 2006, the Washington Times reported that ANSWER, a group with which Gutierrez organized

    immigration protests in 2006, had ties to the Marxist World Workers Party.

    In October 2004 in response to California Governor Arnold Schwarzeneggers veto of an illegal immigrant

    drivers license bill, Gutierrez organized a protest of Schwarzeneggers office and called on immigrants to

    make all their currency in red ink with 100 percent immigrant and to boycott Red Bull products, which he

    errantly said were made by a company that Schwarzenegger owned.

    In March 2001 in an interview on NPR, Gutierrez, described as a senior organizer for SEIU, maintained that it

    was in the best interest of unions to organize illegal workers.

    In October 1996, Gutierrez was one of the organizers of the Coordinadora 96 March in Washington D.C.,

    which drew between 20,000 and 30,000 people of Latino decent, a result which Gutierrez characterized as an

    unprecedented success.

  • confidential memorandum VR Research 405 14th Street, Suite 350 Oakland, California 94612 vrresearch.com 8

    The Los Angeles Times reported that unions, including the electrical and electronics workers union

    provided funding and office space to plan the event.

    Gutierrez founded Latino Movement USA after the success of the Coordinadora 96 March and told the

    Washington Post that his plan was to make it a membership organization similar in size to the NRA or Christian Coalition.

    In October 1996, the Washington Post reported that Gutierrez was a recent graduate of Loyola University Law School, which he had attended at night and that Gutierrez had not yet had time to take the Bar.

    In October 1996, the Washington Post described Gutierrez as a man of contradictions, noting that while calling for unity with African Americans, Gutierrez characterized the traditional civil rights movement as

    exclusionary.

    In October 1994, Gutierrez led an anti Proposition 187 March in Los Angeles which was later blamed for

    mobilizing support for the proposition due to the wide spread carrying of Mexican flags and other signs of

    Mexican nationalism.

    Political Candidate

    In 1999, Gutierrez came in fourth in the primary for L.A. City Council District 14.

    Gutierrez campaign consultant Rick Taylor maintained that targeted mail, not money would determine the

    winner in the race.

    In April 1999, LA Weekly, while extolling Gutierrezs skills at community organizing and bringing

    important issues to the forefront, declined to endorse Gutierrez for LA City Council citing his erratic

    political judgment and controversies with One Stop.

    T W O C O U N T R I E S O N E V O I C E

    In May 2012, Ramirez and Gutierrez announced the creation of Two Countries One Voice. The first press release

    from the organization included a press contact who is a former Republican Party operative. Two Countries One

    Voice has claimed that it is a coalition funded by about 50 member organizations; the coalitions website list 47

    members (mostly individuals) including three Democratic members of the New York State Assembly. Most the

    members of the coalition are associated with immigration rights groups based in Las Vegas or Los Angeles which

    have worked with either Ramirez or Gutierrez. Several of these groups are work in conjunction with or are funded by

    unions. In August 2012, the coalition claimed in a press release that Yo Soy 132 and the Occupy movements were

    members of the Two Counties One Voice coalition but both organizations contradicted the statement. One report

    claimed that Yo Soy 132 did not join because of the involvement of Democratic Party operatives, in the coalition.

    In May 2012, Two Countries One Voice announced its own formation by a coalition of Latino leaders and

    described its dedication to exposing Carlos Slim, the worlds richest man, and the alleged predatory,

    monopolistic methods with which he has amassed his fortune.

  • confidential memorandum VR Research 405 14th Street, Suite 350 Oakland, California 94612 vrresearch.com 9

    The press release invited interested parties to a briefing on Tuesday, May 8, 2012 at the National Press

    Club with speakers from the coalition including Andres Ramirez, Juan Jose Gutierrez, Arturo Carmona

    with Presente.org and Ricardo Juarez with Mexicanos Sin Fronteras.

    The press release contact, Yohana de la Torre, is a Florida based media consultant with extensive

    Republican and media ties. According to her firms website, De la Torre is currently the owner of YDT

    Media, a media consulting firm and the owner and managing editor of Gulf Coast Times LLC, a monthly

    32 page magazine. De la Torres media clients include Conservative Political Action Conference and the

    Hispanic Leadership Network. De la Torres past work experience includes serving as deputy press

    secretary at the Republican National Convention (2008), serving as a communications specialist for U.S.

    Senator Mel Martinez (2005 to 2006), serving as deputy director of specialty media at the Republican

    National Convention (2004), serving as a freelance associate producer for Univision (1999 to 2004),

    serving as an on air reporter for the Don Strock Show on WTVJ NBC (2002) and serving as a reporter for

    the Miami Herald (2001 to 2002).

    In August 2012, Reuters reported that Ramirez and Gutierrez had claimed that the coalition was made up of

    about 50 organizations which funded its activities. According to the groups website, the coalition has 47

    members, most of which are activists in Los Angeles and Las Vegas who have worked with Ramirez or

    Gutierrez. Several of the groups affiliated with the activists work in conjunction with or are funded by

    unions.

    New York State Senator Adriano Espaillat (D-31) participated in the August 2012 Two Countries One

    Voice protest at Saks Fifth Avenue in New York City. Espaillat was first elected to the New York State

    Assembly in 1996 and served there until he won a seat in the New York State Senate in 2010. Espaillat is

    originally from the Dominican Republic. In 2012, Espaillat challenged New York Congressman Charlie

    Rangel in the newly drawn 13th Congressional district. Espaillat lost the Democratic by a slim margin,

    resulting in court action and Espaillat claiming illegal voter suppression. Espaillat ultimately dropped his

    challenge. The new district is a majority Hispanic district. Since 1998, Espaillats top donor for his

    campaigns has been unions, including the CWA. He has received very little money from the

    telecommunications industry.

    New York State Assemblyman Nelson Castro (D-86) participated in the August 2012 Two Countries One

    Voice protest at Saks Fifth Avenue in New York City. Castro was elected to the New York Assembly in

    2008. Prior to his election, Castro worked as chief of staff for Espaillat. Castro is originally from the

    Dominican Republic. Since 2008, Castros top donor for his campaigns has been unions, including the

    CWA. Castro has received very little money from the telecommunications industry.

    New York State Assemblyman Robert J. Rodriguez (D-68) participated in the August 2012 Two Countries

    One Voice protest at Saks Fifth Avenue in New York City. Rodriguez was elected to the New York State

    Assembly in 2010. Since 2010, Rodriguez received the most contributions from real estate industry

    sources, with unions second with $15,600 in contributions.

  • confidential memorandum VR Research 405 14th Street, Suite 350 Oakland, California 94612 vrresearch.com 10

    New York City Councilman Ydanis Rodriguez (D-10) participated in the August 2012 Two Countries One

    Voice protest at Saks Fifth Avenue in New York City. Rodriguez was elected to New York City Council in

    2009. Rodriguez has been active in the Occupy movement and was arrested in November 2011 in Zuccotti

    Park. Rodriguez was born in the Dominican Republic. During his 2009 campaign for City Council,

    Rodriguez received significant contributions from 6 labor unions totaling $16,000 (each gave the

    maximum contribution of $2,750).

    In August 2012, Reuters reported that in response to Slims son-in law Arturo Elias Ayubs claim that GWU

    protesters were paid to be there, Ramirez maintained that participants were not paid to protest but that some

    were reimbursed for transportation and food expenses.

    On August 2, 2012, Two Countries One Voice announced a four day protest in front of Saks Fifth Avenue and

    announced that Yo Soy 132, Occupy Wall Street and Occupy DC had joined the Two Countries One Voice

    Coalition.

    The contact for the Saks Fifth Avenue protest press release was Melisa Diaz, who has her own Hispanic

    media consulting firm where she provides communications advice, event planning and translations. Diaz

    previously worked for TMG Strategies (now McGinn and Company), served as director of Hispanic media

    for the Democratic National Committee (2004), served as the Washington correspondent for El Vocero,

    Puerto Ricos largest newspaper, served as communications director for Congressman Jose Serrano (D NY),

    served as deputy communications director for the House Democratic Caucus, served as Hispanic outreach

    coordinator at the Democratic Congressional Campaign Committee (DCCC) and worked on Hispanic

    outreach for President William J. Clintons second Inaugural.

    After the press release went out, Yo Soy 132, a Mexican student movement, denied that it had agreed to be

    part of the Two Countries One Voice Coalition and a blog on The Nations website noted a report in La Jornada which claimed that Yo Soy 132 decided not to participate due to the involvement of Democratic

    party operatives.

    Occupy organizer Aaron Black emphasized that he planned to attend the protest as an individual, noting

    that the Occupy movement would not be part of any coalition with elected officials.

  • confidential memorandum VR Research 405 14th Street, Suite 350 Oakland, California 94612 vrresearch.com 11

    ANDRES RAMIREZ 18

    Vital Statistics 18

    Federal Lobbyist 19

    WORKED FOR U.S. STRATEGIES AS LOBBYIST; CLIENTS INCLUDED CITY OF LAS VEGAS, PALM BEACH COUNTY, FLORIDA (1999-2000) 19

    Corporate Affiliations 20

    Ramirez Group 20

    INCORPORATED RAMIREZ GROUP IN NEVADA (2011); CORPORATION ACTIVE AND IN GOOD STANDING (2012) 20

    Ramirez & Associates 20

    INCORPORATED RAMIREZ & ASSOCIATES (2001) 20

    Politics 20

    HAS WORKED ON HISPANIC OUTREACH FOR SHELLEY BERKELY IN NEVADA SENATE RACE (2012) 20

    SPOKESMAN FOR NUESTRO RIO, GROUP CALLING ATTENTION TO NEED TO PROTECT COLORADO RIVER (2012) 20

    Said Not Just a River, Its Our River, Noted Historical and Cultural Importance 21

    POLITICO REPORTED RAMIREZ AS POLLSTER (2011) 21

    REPORTEDLY ADVISED OBAMA CAMPAIGN ON LATINO ISSUES, SAID HISPANICS OVERLOOKING POSITIVE ACCOMPLISHMENTS DUE TO HYPER-OBSESSION WITH IMMIGRATION ISSUES (2011) 21

    Said Hispanic Voter Frustration Understandable and Warranted but Manageable for the Campaign 21

    LED NEVADA LATINO REDISTRICTING COALITION (2011) 22

    REPORTED WOULD BE PARTNER IN DEMOCRACY PARTNERS, DEMOCRATIC CONSULTING FIRM (2011) 22

    Firms Clients Include Democratic Elected Officials, Unions Including the Communications Workers Union and Progressive Organizations 22

    CLAIMED WORKED ON IMMIGRATION ISSUES FOR REID, SAID REID ALWAYS IN FAVOR OF REFORMS (2009) 26

    CLAIMED TO HAVE HELPED ORGANIZE BOYCOTT OF LOU DOBBS (2009) 26

    ELECTED VICE CHAIR OF DNCS HISPANIC CAUCUS (2009) 26

    ARTICLE SAID RAMIREZ SPLIT TIME BETWEEN NEVADA AND D.C. (2008) 26

    APPEARED AT ISSUES FORUM SPONSORED BY GRUPO SALINAS (2008) 26

    TOOK JOB WITH NEW DEMOCRAT NETWORK (NDN) (2008) 26

  • confidential memorandum VR Research 405 14th Street, Suite 350 Oakland, California 94612 vrresearch.com 12

    SERVED AS CAUCUS OUTREACH DIRECTOR FOR NEVADA DEMOCRATIC PARTY, SAID OUTREACH WORK MOST SIGNIFICANT AND AGGRESSIVE OUTREACH EFFORT IN NEVADA HISTORY TO GET HISPANICS TO THE CAUCUS POLLS (2007-2008) 27

    LOST NONPARTISAN RACE FOR MAYOR OF NORTH LAS VEGAS (2005) 27

    Despite Race Being Nonpartisan, Nevada Democratic Party Spent $34,000 on Ramirez Race 27

    Opponent Filed Criminal Complaint Against Ramirez for Stealing Yard Signs (2005) 28

    Endorsed by Group Run by Howard Deans Brother, Ramirez Had Done Organizing for Dean Campaign, Endorsement Noted that Ramirez Had Union Backing (2005) 28

    WORKED AS STATE DIRECTOR FOR VOICES FOR WORKING FAMILIES DOING VOTER OUTREACH (2004) 28

    SERVED AS CAMPAIGN MANAGER FOR INDIAN AMERICAN WHO CHALLENGED SITTING DEMOCRATIC CONGRESSMAN IN PRIMARY (2004) 28

    In Formal Complaint Primary Opponent Claimed Ramirez Candidate Offered Quid Pro Quo If He Dropped Out of Race 29

    DID VOTER ANALYSIS FOR PEOPLE FOR THE AMERICAN WAY (2004) 29

    RAN NEIGHBOR TO NEIGHBOR GET OUT THE VOTE PROJECT (2002) 29

    RAN FOR UNIVERSITY REGENT POSITION, CAME IN LAST (2002) 29

    Reportedly Working as Political Consultant, Pursing Undergraduate Degree in Political Science While Running for Office 29

    SERVED AS CHAIRMAN OF HISPANIC DEMOCRATIC CAUCUS (2002) 29

    AS INFORMATION MANAGER FOR GOVERNORS OFFICE, SAID NO ONES A NATIVE IN NEVADA (1997) 29

    JUAN JOSE GUTIERREZ 30

    Vital Statistics 30

    Vamos Unidos/Vamos EUA 30

    DBA FILED IN LA COUNTY TO CONDUCT BUSINESS AS VAMOS UNIDOS USA (2009) 30

    Website is Entirely in Spanish, Says Vamos Unidos Provides Immigration Legal Services, Includes Legal Protection Plans Costing as Much as $1,600 Annually 30

    GUTIERREZ FILED INCORPORATION PAPERS FOR VAMOS EUA MOVING FORWARD USA, INC. (2009) 31

    STATE OF CALIFORNIA HAS FILED THREE TAX LIENS AGAINST VAMOS UNIDOS USA, VAMOS EUA (2011-2012) 31

    VAMOS UNIDOS ORGANIZED RALLY AT LA SALVATION ARMY IN RESPONSE NEWS STORY THAT SALVATION ARMY IN TEXAS REQUIRED RECIPIENTS OF CHRISTMAS TOYS TO PROVIDE SOCIAL SECURITY NUMBERS (2009) 31

  • confidential memorandum VR Research 405 14th Street, Suite 350 Oakland, California 94612 vrresearch.com 13

    LA Salvation Army Spokesman Said Would Not Collect Social Security Numbers, Only Information Collected to Detect Fraud or Duplication 32

    Gutierrez Called on Salvation Army to Compromise on Identification Policy, Said Intended to Intimidate 32

    One Stop Immigration Centers 32

    CLAIMED LOTS OF DEMAND FOR IMMIGRATION SERVICES BUT LITTLE FUNDING (2000) 32

    ONE STOPS RECORDS SUBPOENAED BY U.S. DEPARTMENT OF EDUCATION (1998) 32

    ACCUSED OF MISMANAGING FUNDS AT ONE STOP (1994) 33

    Gutierrez Claimed Organization Going Through a Very Difficult Period, Cited Funding Cuts Requiring Center Closures 33

    SAID COULD NOT ADVISE ILLEGAL IMMIGRANT CLIENTS TO COMPLY WITH IRS REQUIREMENT THAT THEY OBTAIN TAX NUMBERS, SAID NOT SURE INFORMATION WOULD NOT BE SHARED WITH INS (1997) 33

    NLRB Action 33

    NLRB AFFIRMED DECISION OF ALJ WHO FOUND GUTIERREZ AND ONE STOP HAD VIOLATED FAIR LABOR LAWS BY THREATENING AND RETALIATING AGAINST EMPLOYEES ENGAGED IN UNION ACTIVITIES (1999) 33

    Cases Brought by Two Employees, One Employees Case Filed by the International Union of Electronic, Electrical, Salaried, Machine and Furniture Workers, AFLCIO, District Eleven (1997-1998) 34

    In Decision, Judge Noted Three Instances in which She Could Not Credit Gutierrezs Testimony 34

    Case Included Allegations of Sexual Harassment of Employees by Gutierrez 34

    Judges Decision Detailed Anti Union Action Taken by Gutierrez, including Asking Employees to Identify Union Organizers, Threatening Employees Engaged in Union Activities and Attempting to Coerce an Employee to Cease Union Activities 35

    FINAL DECISION ORDERED ONE STOP TO REINSTATE EMPLOYEES, PROVIDE BACK PAY AND BENEFITS AND POST NOTICE TO EMPLOYEES INFORMING THEM OF NLRB DECISION AND STATING THEIR RIGHTS TO ORGANIZE (1999) 35

    ONE STOP DEFIED ORDER BY NLRB TO REHIRE LAID OFF WORKERS (2000) 36

    Board Member Claimed Told Gutierrez to Settle with Union, Said Decision from the NLRB is as Good as a Document Signed by God 36

    Gutierrez Claimed Not at Liberty to Discuss the Issue, Said One Stop Not an Anti-Labor Organization 37

    Nunez Said One Stop Nearly Bankruptcy Due to City and State Funding Cuts, Said Would Need to Settle With Employees to Avoid Insolvency 37

    Litigation 37

    Politics 41

    COORDINATOR OF NATIONAL REGENERATION MOVEMENT OF MEXICANS ABROAD, EFFORT TO ENSURE MEXICANS LIVING IN U.S. CAN VOTE ABSENTEE IN COUNTRYS ELECTIONS (2012) 41

  • confidential memorandum VR Research 405 14th Street, Suite 350 Oakland, California 94612 vrresearch.com 14

    Supported Lopez Obrador for Mexican Presidency Said Represented True Change (2012) 41

    PROTESTED AT OBAMA FUNDRAISER, SAID DISAPPOINTED WITH PRESIDENT (2011) 42

    LONGSTANDING ORGANIZER OF MAY DAY MARCHES IN L.A., WASHINGTON D.C. 42

    While Serving As Coordinator for Full Rights for Immigrants Coalition, Organized March Backed by L.A. County Federation of Labor; Dispute with Another Group Over Policy Threatened to Dampen Turnout for March (2011) 42

    LEGAL REPRESENTATIVE FOR EX BRACEROS FIGHTING TO GET PAYCHECK DEDUCTIONS REMOVED FROM CHECKS (2008) 43

    Involved in Braceros Lawsuits Since Early 1980s 43

    SAID FAILURE OF SENATE TO PASS IMMIGRATION REFORM BILL RACISM (2007) 43

    HELPED ORGANIZE ANTI WAR PROTEST, SAID IMMIGRATION AND ANTI WAR EFFORTS CONNECTED, CITED OWN NEPHEW KILLED IN IRAQ AFTER IMMIGRATING FROM MEXICO AND JOINING MILITARY (2007) 43

    SAID BUSINESS OWNER REQUIRING CUSTOMERS TO ORDER IN ENGLISH ENGAGED IN OUTRAGEOUS RACISM (2006) 44

    ORGANIZED DEMONSTRATION AGAINST BORDER FENCE BY NATIONAL CAPITOL IMMIGRATION COALITION (2006) 44

    LED WORK BOYCOTT PROTEST BY ILLEGAL IMMIGRANTS (2006) 44

    Said Opponents of Boycott were Paternalistic (2006) 44

    WORKED WITH GROUP WITH TIES TO WORKERS WORLD PARTY (2006) 45

    TOLD IMMIGRANTS TO MARK CURRENCY WITH RED INK TO DEMONSTRATE ECONOMIC POWER, ERRANTLY TOLD THEM TO BOYCOTT RED BULL DRINKS BECAUSE OF TIES TO SCHWARZENEGGER WHEN SCHWARZENEGGER DID NOT OWN SHARES IN COMPANY (2004) 45

    AS SENIOR ORGANIZER FOR SEIU, SAID UNIONS INTEREST SERVED BY ORGANIZING ILLEGAL WORKERS (2001) 45

    RAN FOR LA CITY COUNCIL, CAME IN 4TH IN PRIMARY (1999) 46

    Consultant Said Gutierrez Council Race about Targeted Mail, Not Money (1999) 46

    LA Weekly Did Not Endorse Gutierrez, Cited Issues With Workers, Erratic Political Judgment (1999) 46

    LEADER OF COORDINADORA '96 MARCH IN D.C., CALLED MARCH UNPRECENDENT SUCCESS (1996) 46

    Unions Provided Funding and Office Space to Plan the March 47

    LATINO MOVEMENT USA FOUNDED AFTER 1996 MARCH ON WASHINGTON, SAID PLAN TO BECOME A MEMBER ORGANIZATION SIMILAR IN SIZE TO THE NRA OR CHRISTIAN COALITION (1996) 47

    ATTENDED NIGHT SCHOOL AT LOYOLA UNIVERSITY LAW SCHOOL, SAID HAD NOT HAD TIME TO TAKE BAR (1996) 47

    WHILE CALLING FOR UNITY WITH AFRICAN AMERICANS, CHARACTERIZED THE TRADITIONAL CIVIL RIGHTS MOVEMENT AS EXCLUSIONARY (1996) 48

    LED MARCH AGAINST PROP 187, MARCH BLAMED FOR PROPOSITIONS PASSAGE (1994) 48

  • confidential memorandum VR Research 405 14th Street, Suite 350 Oakland, California 94612 vrresearch.com 15

    TWO COUNTRIES ONE VOICE 49

    Activism 49

    TWO COUNTRIES ONE VOICE ANNOUNCED COALITION, SAID DEDICATED TO EXPOSING CARLOS SLIM (2012) 49

    Said Briefing Would Include Presentations by Coalition Members Including Ramirez, Gutierrez, Arturo Carmona and Ricardo Juarez 49

    Press Contract Yohana de la Torre Runs Media Firm in Florida, Has Ties to Republican Organizations and Politicians, Former Worked for Univision 49

    IN RESPONSE TO SLIMS SON IN LAWS CLAIM THAT GWU PROTESTERS WERE PAID TO BE THERE, RAMIREZ CLAIMED THEY WERE NOT PAID TO PROTEST BUT THAT TRANSPORTATION AND FOOD COSTS WERE COVERED FOR SOME (2012) 49

    ANNOUNCED PROTEST AT SAKS FIFTH AVENUE TARGETED DUE TO SLIMS HOLDING IN SAKS STOCK, NOTED YO SOY 132, OCCUPY WALL STREET AND OCCUPY DC HAD JOINED TWO COUNTRIES ONE VOICE COALITION (2012) 50

    Press Release Contact Former Spokesperson for Hispanic Media for Democratic Party Organizations, Worked for Communications Consulting Firm 51

    Coalition Members 51

    TOLD REUTERS THAT TWO COUNTRIES ONE VOICE FUNDED BY ABOUT 50 ORGANIZATIONS MAKING UP THE COALITION (2012) 51

    TWO COUNTRIES ONE VOICE WEB SITE LISTS 47 COALITION MEMBERS, MOSTLY INDIVIDUALS INVOLVED IN LATINO ACTIVISM IN NEVADA AND CALIFORNIA WITH TIES TO RAMIREZ OR GONZALEZ 51

  • confidential memorandum VR Research 405 14th Street, Suite 350 Oakland, California 94612 vrresearch.com 16

    Javier Trujillo, Chair, Latin Chamber of Commerce (Nevada) 51

    Mario Cardenas, President, COFEM 52

    Miguel Barrientos (NV), Radio Host, Asi se Habla Radio 52

    Vicenta Montoya (NV), Founder, Si Se Puede Democratic Caucus 52

    Edgar Flores, Familias de Juarez Project 52

    Marco Antonio Pacheco, President, Casa de la Cultura Maya 52

    Adelita Grijalva (AZ), Board Member, Tucson Unified School District 53

    Juan Ortega, President, Dream Big Vegas 53

    Art Terrazas, New Mexico State University / Hispano Chamber of Commerce 53

    Antonio Garcia, Organizacion Duranguense 53

    Francisco Morales, Hispanic Student Union UNLV 54

    Luz Mosquera, Executive Director, Hermandad Mexicana 54

    Stavan Corbett, President of the Board, Luz Coalition 54

    Margarita Rebollal, Executive Director, Community Services of Nevada 54

    Jose Melendrez, Co-Founder, Nevada Alliance for Latino Education and Justice 55

    Leo Murietta, President and Co-Founder, Nevada Youth Alliance 55

    Fernando Romero, President, Hispanics in Politics 55

    Michael Flores, Southern Nevada Director, Nevada Reform Immigration for America 56

    Francisco Pacheco, Day Labor Program (East Coast Coordinator) 56

    Bessy Blanco, President, Association of Salvadoran Attorney from DC 56

    Camilo J. Quila, Legal Aid Justice Center 56

    Jose Artiga, Director, SHARE EL SALVADOR 57

    Reveriano Sanchez, Las Americas News 57

    Gil Lopez, SOL UNLV 57

    Loamy Diaz, MeCHA CSN 57

    Roberto Bravo, Director, CBO Comunitarias (Asociacion de Puebla) 57

    Rosa Posadas, Director, Union de Emigrantes Guatemaltecos (UGE) 58

    Francisco Rivera, President, Mesa Redonda Centroamericana 58

    Leoncio Velasquez, President Hondurenos Unidos (HULA) 58

    Daniel Morales, Director, Collective Space 58

    Josefina Herrera, President, Club Juarez, Chihuahua 58

    Baldomero Capiz, President, Asociacion de Ex-Braceros de Los Angeles 58

    Sonia Zaldivar, Treasurer, Salvadoran Corridor 59

    Ricardo Amado Castillo, George Washington University Student Alumni Association 59

    Raul Murillo, Hermandad Mexicana Nacional 59

    George Martinez, Representative of Occupy Wall Street and Adjunct Professor of Political Science at Pace University 59

  • confidential memorandum VR Research 405 14th Street, Suite 350 Oakland, California 94612 vrresearch.com 17

    Lucia Gomez Jimenez, Executive Director, La Fuente, Inc. 60

    Nieves Padilla, Community Organizer, Make the Road NY 60

    Too Little Information Provided, Not Possible to Identify Details on 8 Coalition Members 60

    YO SOY 132 CLAIMED HAD NOT JOINED COALITION, REPORT SAID GROUP DECIDED NOT TO JOIN DUE TO INVOLVEMENT OF DEMOCRATIC PARTY OPERATIVES (2012) 61

    Occupy Organizer Also Said Organization Not Official Part of Coalition, Said Not a Part of Any Coalition with Elected Officials 61

    Elected Officials 62

    NEW YORK STATE SENATOR ADRIANO ESPAILLAT (D-31) 62

    Espaillat Challenged New York Congressman Charlie Rangel in Primary, Lost (2012) 62

    Espaillat Has Received Significant Funding from Unions (1998-2012) 62

    NEW YORK STATE ASSEMBLYMAN NELSON CASTRO (D-86) 63

    Unions Are Castros Top Campaign Contributor (2008-2012) 63

    NEW YORK STATE ASSEMBLYMAN ROBERT J. RODRIGUEZ (D-68) 64

    Largest Contributor Real Estate Industry, Second Largest Unions (2010-2012) 64

    NEW YORK CITY COUNCILMAN YDANIS RODRIGUEZ (D-10) 64

    Received Significant Contributions from Unions (2009) 65

  • confidential memorandum VR Research 405 14th Street, Suite 350 Oakland, California 94612 vrresearch.com 18

    ANDRES RAMIREZ

    Vital Statistics

    F U L L N A M E

    Andres Ramirez Jr.

    D A T E A N D P L A C E O F B I R T H

    March 1978

    Richmond, Texas

    S O C I A L S E C U R I T Y N U M B E R

    466 47 -XXXX

    F A M I L Y

    Spouse: Jacqueline Ferreiro

    Marriage Date: August 5, 2000

    Daughter: Victoria

    C A R E E R T I M E L I N E

    YEARS AND LOCATION EMPLOYER AND POSITION

    2011 to Present Ramirez Group, President 2009to Present DNC Hispanic Caucus, Vice Chair 2008 to 2011 NDN, Senior Vice President 2011 to Present Democracy Partners, Partner 2007-2008 Nevada Democratic Party, Caucus Outreach Director 2004 Voices for Working Families, State Director 2001 to unknown Ramirez & Associates, President 1999 to 2000 U.S. Strategies, Legislative Affairs Analyst Governor Bob Miller, Washington D.C. Office, Deputy Director U.S. Senator Harry Reid (D NV), Legislative Aide

  • confidential memorandum VR Research 405 14th Street, Suite 350 Oakland, California 94612 vrresearch.com 19

    O R G A N I Z A T I O N S A N D M E M B E R S H I P S

    Ramirez claims affiliation or membership with the following organizations:

    YEARS ORGANIZATION AND POSITION

    2011 Nevada Latino Redistricting Coalition, Leader 2001 Latinos for Equal Representation 2004 North Las Vegas Committee, Vice President

    Federal Lobbyist

    WORKED FOR U.S. STRATEGIES AS LOBBYIST; CLIENTS INCLUDED CITY OF LAS VEGAS, PALM BEACH COUNTY, FLORIDA (1999-2000)

    From 1999 to 2000, Ramirez lobbied the U.S. Congress on behalf of the City of Las Vegas and Palm Beach County as a

    lobbyist for U.S. Strategies, an Alexandria, Virginia based governmental relations firm. The chart below provides

    details on Ramirezs lobbying activities and compensation to U.S. Strategies.

    CLIENT SPECIFIC ISSUES LOBBIED BRANCHES

    LOBBIED

    PERIOD

    COVERED

    AMOUNT

    City of

    Las

    Vegas

    HR 2684 VA HUD Appropriations

    HR 2084 Transportation Appropriations

    House, Senate,

    US DOT, US

    HUD

    July 1, 1999-

    December

    31, 1999

    $0 to

    $9,999.99

    City of

    Las

    Vegas

    Multiple bills characterized as

    Labor/Antitrust/Workplace, Housing,

    Transportation, Urban

    Development/Municipalities, Real

    Estate/Land Use/Conservation, Law

    Enforcement/Crime/Criminal Justice

    House, Senate,

    US DOT, US

    HUD

    January 1,

    2000 to

    June 30,

    2000

    $40,000.00

    Palm

    Beach

    County,

    FL

    Multiple bills characterized as Housing,

    Urban Development/Municipalities, Real

    Estate/Land Use/Conservation, Clean Air

    and Water Quality, Agriculture

    House, Senate,

    US DOT, US

    HUD Dept. of

    Agriculture,

    Dept. of Interior

    $40,000.00

    TOTAL $80,000 to

    $89,999,99

    (Year End Report, U.S. Strategies, Filed February 9, 2000; Mid Year Report, U.S. Strategies, Filed August 14, 2000)

  • confidential memorandum VR Research 405 14th Street, Suite 350 Oakland, California 94612 vrresearch.com 20

    Corporate Affiliations

    Ramirez Group

    INCORPORATED RAMIREZ GROUP IN NEVADA (2011); CORPORATION ACTIVE AND IN GOOD STANDING (2012)

    On January 22, 2011, Ramirez incorporated Ramirez Group in Nevada. Ramirez listed himself and his wife,

    Jacqueline as the corporations officer. Ramirez Group is active and in good standing. (Nevada Secretary of State

    Web site, NV SOS Entity Search: Ramirez Group, www.nvsos.gov)

    Ramirez & Associates

    INCORPORATED RAMIREZ & ASSOCIATES (2001)

    On January 24, 2001, Ramirez incorporated Ramirez & Associates in Nevada. Ramirez listed himself and his wife,

    Jacqueline, as the corporations officers. The entities status is permanently revoked, indicating that the business is

    not longer active in Nevada. (Nevada Secretary of State Web site, NV SOS Entity Search: Ramirez & Association,

    www.nvsos.gov)

    Politics

    HAS WORKED ON HISPANIC OUTREACH FOR SHELLEY BERKELY IN NEVADA SENATE RACE (2012)

    In May 2012, Roll Call reported that Ramirez was a democratic strategist, working on Hispanic outreach for Democratic Nevada U.S. Senate candidate Shelly Berkley. (Roll Call, Key to Senate Seat Lies in Battlegroundsville,

    May 17, 2012)

    SPOKESMAN FOR NUESTRO RIO, GROUP CALLING ATTENTION TO NEED TO PROTECT COLORADO RIVER (2012)

    In April 2012, as the spokesman for Nuestro Rio, Ramirez called on policy makers and utility companies to protect

    the Colorado River by raising its water flows and introduced a corrido written to honor the river and unveiled on

    the 85th anniversary of Cesar Chavez birthday. According to Ramirez:

    If we do nothing, the price of water will spike, agriculture and rural communities will become less viable, and

    households will be forced by utilities and governments to make drastic changes in how they use water.

    (Colorado Independent, Latinos Celebrate Cesar Chavez Holiday with Song Calling for Colorado River

    Conservation, April 13, 2012)

  • confidential memorandum VR Research 405 14th Street, Suite 350 Oakland, California 94612 vrresearch.com 21

    Said Not Just a River, Its Our River, Noted Historical and Cultural Importance

    In February 2012, Ramirez maintained that the Colorado River was not just a river, its our river, noting its

    historical and cultural importance. According to Ramirez:

    It's not just 'a' river; it's 'our' river. It has a historical and cultural importance to many groups of people. The

    Colorado River is the lifeline of the Southwest, and not only does the river need to be preserved for generations

    to come, but also the cultural heritage of the river basin. (Las Vegas Sun, Latino Group Expands Efforts to Preserve Colorado River, February 2, 2012)

    POLITICO REPORTED RAMIREZ AS POLLSTER (2011)

    In October 2011, Politico quoted Ramirez in an article on voter registration and mobilization in Nevada and

    described Ramirez as a Nevada-based pollster. (Politico, Western Dems: Go Down the Middle, October 18, 2011)

    REPORTEDLY ADVISED OBAMA CAMPAIGN ON LATINO ISSUES, SAID HISPANICS OVERLOOKING POSITIVE ACCOMPLISHMENTS DUE TO HYPER-OBSESSION WITH IMMIGRATION ISSUES (2011)

    In August 2011, the Washington Post, on its website, reported that Ramirez had met with Obama Administration and campaign officials to discuss Hispanic outreach and noted that Ramirez maintained that a hyper obsession

    with immigration issues had resulted in many Hispanic voters overlooking Obamas positive Latino

    accomplishments like appointing Sonia Sotomayor to the U.S. Supreme Court. According to the paper:

    Andres Ramirez, a Las Vegas-based Democratic strategist who met this month with administration and

    campaign officials to discuss Hispanic outreach, said a hyper-obsession with immigration issues has led

    many voters to overlook other accomplishments - including the appointment of a Puerto Rican woman to the

    Supreme Court.

    Most people forget that he appointed Sonia Sotomayor and how big of a deal that was," Ramirez said.

    (Washingtonpost.com, Obama Team Targets Hispanic Voters, August 22, 2011)

    Said Hispanic Voter Frustration Understandable and Warranted but Manageable for the Campaign

    In August 2011, Ramirez said that Hispanic voter frustration with the Obama Administration was understandable

    and warranted but manageable for the campaign. According to Ramirez:

    The frustration is understandable and ... warranted. "But it's also manageable. [Ellipses in original] (Las Vegas

    Sun, Obama Backers Express Frustration But Are Still Committed, August 21, 2011)

  • confidential memorandum VR Research 405 14th Street, Suite 350 Oakland, California 94612 vrresearch.com 22

    LED NEVADA LATINO REDISTRICTING COALITION (2011)

    In July 2011, The New York Times reported that Ramirez was the leader of the Nevada Latino Redistricting Coalition

    which sought to ensure that the states new Congressional seat would be competitive for a Latino candidate and that

    Ramirez had said that Latinos were in a pivotal position with redistricting. According to Ramirez:

    There is consensus about one thing: that one of these districts is going to give the best opportunity yet for

    Latinos to elect a candidate of their choice, and that puts us in a very pivotal position. (The New York Times,

    New Faces, New Maps, New Battles, July 15, 2011)

    REPORTED WOULD BE PARTNER IN DEMOCRACY PARTNERS, DEMOCRATIC CONSULTING FIRM (2011)

    In June 2011, Campaigns & Elections reported that Ramirez would be a partner in a new Democratic consulting

    firm, Democracy Partners, along with Robert Creamer, Heather Booth, Renee Schaeffer, Marc Cerabona, Brett C. Di

    Resta, Carla Engle, Jeffrey Garcia, Ken Grossinger, John Hennelly, Jackie Kendall, Mike Lux, Dan Manatt, Donald

    McFarland, Josie Mooney, Braidy O'Neal, Andres Ramirez, Linda E. Saucedo, Joel Silberman, and Cheri Whiteman.

    (Campaigns & Elections, Consulting Firms Formed on Left and Rights, June 2011)

    Firms Clients Include Democratic Elected Officials, Unions Including the Communications Workers Union and Progressive Organizations

    According to its website, Democracy Partners clients have included Democratic elected officials, unions (including

    SEIU, AFSCME, AFL CIO and CWA) and progressive organizations. All representative clients listed on the firms

    website are listed below.

    Access Living of Chicago

    21st Century Democrats

    ActBlue

    AFL-CIO

    AFSCME Council 31, Illinois

    AIDS PAC

    Alliance for a Better Minnesota

    Alliance for Excellent Education

    Alliance for Retired Americans

    (ARA)

    America Coming Together

    American Families United

    American Federation of State

    County and Municipal

    Employees (AFSCME)

    American Heart Association

    American Small Business

    Alliance

    Americans Against Escalation in

    Iraq

    Americans for Financial Reform

    (AFR)

    Americans for Small Town

    Values

    Americans United for Change

    Americans United to Protect

    Social Security

    AMOS, Jewish Social Justice

    initiative

    Anne Sumers for Congress (D-

    NJ)

    Arizona Leadership Institute

    Arts PAC

    Association of Community

    Organizations for Reform Now

    (ACORN)

    Association of Trial Lawyers of

    America (ATLA)

    Atlantic Philanthropies

    Benny Kiester for Delegate (D-

    VA)

    Bill Curry for Governor (D-CT)

  • confidential memorandum VR Research 405 14th Street, Suite 350 Oakland, California 94612 vrresearch.com 23

    Blog PAC

    BlueAmericaPac

    Bobby Rush for Congress (D-IL)

    Brady Campaign

    Brian Baird for Congress (D-WA)

    Campaign for a Progressive

    Future

    Campaign for America's Future

    (CAF)

    Campaign for Quality Care,

    Illinois

    Campaign to Renew and Rebuild

    America NOW!

    Carol Moseley Braun for U.S.

    Senate (D-IL)

    Center for American Progress

    Center for Community Change

    Center for Community Change

    (CCC)

    Center for Democracy in the

    Americas

    Change To Win

    Chet Edwards for Congress (D-

    TX)

    Citizen Action/Illinois

    Citizens Information Service,

    Chicago

    Citizens Utility Board of Illinois

    Coalition for Comprehensive

    Immigration Reform

    Coalition for Democratic Values

    Communications Workers of

    America (CWA)

    Communities for Quality

    Education

    Community Renewal Society of

    Chicago

    Congressman John Carney

    Congressman Tim Bishop

    DailyKos

    David Cain for State Senate (D-

    TX)

    David Phelps for Congress (D-IL)

    David Scott for Congress (D-GA)

    David Wu for Congress (D-OR)

    Democracy Alliance

    Democratic Congressional

    Campaign Committee (DCCC)

    Democratic Governors

    Association (DGA)

    Democratic National Committee

    (DNC)

    Democratic Party of Colorado

    Democratic Party of Illinois

    Democratic Party of Maryland

    Democratic Party of Nevada

    Democratic Party of

    Pennsylvania

    Democratic Party of Slovakia

    Democratic Party of South

    Carolina

    Democratic Party of Texas

    Democratic Party of Virginia

    Democratic Party of

    Washington

    Democratic Senatorial

    Campaign Committee (DSCC)

    Demos

    Dick Cranwell for Delegate (D-

    VA,

    El Tinklenberg for Congress

    (MN-06)

    Elaine Bloom for Congress (D-

    FL)

    Elijah Cummings for Congress

    (D-MD)

    Emergency Campaign for

    America's Priorities (ECAP)

    EMILY's List

    Fair Taxes for All (FTFA)

    Families USA

    Florida Consumer Action

    Network Foundation (FCANF)

    Gay and Lesbian Victory Fund

    Generation Green

    Gerry Schipske for Congress (D-

    CA)

    Governor Jennifer Granholm

    Governor Tim Kaine

    Health Care for America Now

    (HCAN)

    Howard Dean for Governor (D-

    VT)

    Illinois Coalition for Immigrant

    and Refugee Rights (ICIRR)

    Illinois Coordinated Campaign

    Illinois Joint Council

  • confidential memorandum VR Research 405 14th Street, Suite 350 Oakland, California 94612 vrresearch.com 24

    Immigration Reform for

    America

    Jan Schakowsky for Congress (D-

    IL)

    Jim Maloney for Congress (D-

    CT)

    Joe Garcia for Congress (D-FL)

    Joe Moore for 49th Ward

    Alderman (D-Chicago)

    John O'Connor for Congress (D-

    MA)

    Joseph Mario Moreno for Town

    President (D-Cicero, IL)

    Lane Evans for Congress (D-IL)

    Larry Suffredin for County Board

    (D-Cook, IL)

    Lauren Beth Gash for Congress

    (D-IL)

    League of Conservation Voters

    Lt. Governor Jim Folsom (AL)

    Maine Peoples Alliance

    Mark Dayton Recount

    Committee

    Mark Green for Mayor (D-NY)

    Maryanne Connelly for

    Congress (D-NJ)

    Mayor Washington Campaign

    (Chicago)

    Media Matters

    Michigan Citizen Action

    Education Fund

    Midwest Academy

    Mike Easley for Governor (D-

    NC)

    Minnesota DFL Party

    Mobilize for Women's Lives

    MoveOn.org

    NAACP

    NAACP National Voter Fund

    NARAL

    National Indian Gaming

    Association

    National Organization for

    Women

    National People's Action

    Natural Resources Defense

    Council

    New Jersey Citizen Action

    New Mexico Democratic

    Coordinated Campaign

    New York Citizen Action

    New York Democratic

    Coordinated Campaign

    North Dakota Health Care

    Reform '09

    Ohio Democratic Party

    One Nation Working Together,

    Senior Advisor

    Oregon NARAL

    Palm Beach County Democratic

    Party, Florida

    Pat Casey for Congress (D-PA)

    People for the American Way

    Phillip Randolph Institute

    Planned Parenthood

    Progressive States Network

    Rebuild and Renew America

    Now Campaign

    Reform Immigration for

    America

    Richard M. Daley Campaign

    Committee (D-Chicago)

    Schiff for Congress (MN-05)

    Sen. Bill Nelson (D-FL)

    Sen. Dan Akaka (D-FL)

    Service Employees International

    Union (SEIU)

    Sheila Jackson Lee for Congress

    (D-TX)

    Shelley Berkley for Congress (D-

    NV)

    Southwest Electric Cooperative

    of Illinois

    Stephanie Tubbs Jones for

    Congress (D-OH)

    Steve Kagan for Congress (D-WI)

    Student Environmental Action

    Council

    The Bulgarian Association for

    Fair Elections

    The Campaign for Competitive

    Electric Rates of Illinois

    The Chicago Housing Authority

    The Committee for Ukrainian

    Voters

    The Environmental Law and

    Policy Center

    The Illinois Association of Social

    Service Executives

  • confidential memorandum VR Research 405 14th Street, Suite 350 Oakland, California 94612 vrresearch.com 25

    The National Committee to

    Preserve Social Security and

    Medicare

    The National Democratic

    Institute for International

    Affairs (NDI)

    The National Women's Political

    Caucus

    The Red Cross of Illinois

    The World Learning Center,

    Washington DC

    Union of Concerned Scientists

    United Auto Workers CAP

    Council

    United For A Fair Economy

    (UFE)

    United Steelworkers Union of

    America (USWA)

    USAction

    Violence Policy Center

    Violence Prevention Campaign

    Voices for Illinois Children

    Voices for Progress

    Voters for Choice

    We Are America Alliance

    Wisconsin Citizen Action

    Women Voices/Women Vote

    Women's Voices. Women Vote.

    Working Assets

  • confidential memorandum VR Research 405 14th Street, Suite 350 Oakland, California 94612 vrresearch.com 26

    CLAIMED WORKED ON IMMIGRATION ISSUES FOR REID, SAID REID ALWAYS IN FAVOR OF REFORMS (2009)

    In December 2009, Roll Call reported that Ramirez worked on immigration issues while working for Senator Harry

    Reid and that Ramirez had defended Reid as a long time advocate for immigration reform. According to the paper:

    This is an issue Reid has believed in for years ... even before political advantageousness became involved,"

    said Andres Ramirez, senior vice president and director of hispanic programs at the New Democrat Network.

    Ramirez, who worked on immigration issues for several years in Reid's office, argued that while Reid's interest

    in immigration reform may have actually hurt him in previous elections, the changing face of Nevada has

    turned the issue into a critical one for the Democratic leader. (Roll Call, Reid Sees Votes in Immigration, December 7, 2009)

    CLAIMED TO HAVE HELPED ORGANIZE BOYCOTT OF LOU DOBBS (2009)

    In November 2009 when Lou Dobbs left CNN, the Washington Post reported that Ramirez, who helped organize the

    CNN boycott to pressure the network to remove Dobbs from its lineup, claimed that CNN realized that Dobbs was

    not consistent with CNNs brand. According to the paper:

    The campaign's organizers, who sought Dobbs's removal from the air, claimed success claimed success

    Thursday. CNN realized its brand was being damaged, said Andres Ramirez, who helped organize the effort.

    It realized that Lou Dobbs's brand of journalism is not consistent with CNN's brand. (Washington Post, As King Enters, CNN Says Dobbs Seeks Freer Forum, November 13, 2009)

    ELECTED VICE CHAIR OF DNCS HISPANIC CAUCUS (2009)

    In September 2009, the DNC announced that Ramirez had been elected Vice Chairman of the DNC Hispanic Caucus.

    (PR Newswire, DNC Announces Newly Elected Hispanic Caucus Leadership, September 15, 2009)

    ARTICLE SAID RAMIREZ SPLIT TIME BETWEEN NEVADA AND D.C. (2008)

    In August 2008, the Las Vegas Review Journal reported that Ramirez splits time between Las Vegas and

    Washington D.C. (Las Vegas Review-Journal, Nevadans Want End to Illegal Residency, August 25, 2008)

    APPEARED AT ISSUES FORUM SPONSORED BY GRUPO SALINAS (2008)

    In May 2008, Ramirez appeared at an issues forum sponsored by Grupo Salinas which was broadcast on its Spanish

    language channel in Colorado. (PR Newswire, Grupo Salinas, Fundacion Azteca America and Azteca America

    Colorado Present The State of Latinos: 2008 Colorado Town Hall Meeting, May 29, 2008)

    TOOK JOB WITH NEW DEMOCRAT NETWORK (NDN) (2008)

    In February 2008, the Las Vegas Review Journal reported that Ramirez had accepted a position as vice president of the New Democrat Network, a policy and strategy think tank.

  • confidential memorandum VR Research 405 14th Street, Suite 350 Oakland, California 94612 vrresearch.com 27

    SERVED AS CAUCUS OUTREACH DIRECTOR FOR NEVADA DEMOCRATIC PARTY, SAID OUTREACH WORK MOST SIGNIFICANT AND AGGRESSIVE OUTREACH EFFORT IN NEVADA HISTORY TO GET HISPANICS TO THE CAUCUS POLLS (2007-2008)

    In 2008, Ramirez worked for the Nevada Democratic Party as its Caucus Outreach Director educating Latino voters

    about the states caucus system, an effort which Ramirez characterized as the most significant and aggressive

    outreach effort in Nevada History. According to Ramirez:

    We have conducted the most significant and aggressive outreach effort in Nevada history to educate Hispanic

    voters about the Nevada caucuses. (Arizona Republic, Nevada Vote to Gauge Latinos Influence, January 18,

    2008; Targeted News Services, State Democrats Roll Out Presidential Caucus Web site, April 5, 2007)

    LOST NONPARTISAN RACE FOR MAYOR OF NORTH LAS VEGAS (2005)

    In June 2005, Ramirez lost his bid to unseat North Las Vegas Mayor Michael Montandon 59% to 41%. The race was

    nonpartisan. (Las Vegas Review-Journal, Week in Review: Rebate Checks on Way But Will Take Awhile, June 12, 2005)

    Despite Race Being Nonpartisan, Nevada Democratic Party Spent $34,000 on Ramirez Race

    The Associated Press reported that despite the races nonpartisan nature, the Nevada Democratic Party spent $34,280 on Ramirez campaign. (Associated Press, North Vegas Mayor Wins Easy Re-Election Over Democratic Activist,

    June 8, 2005)

  • confidential memorandum VR Research 405 14th Street, Suite 350 Oakland, California 94612 vrresearch.com 28

    Opponent Filed Criminal Complaint Against Ramirez for Stealing Yard Signs (2005)

    In May 2005, Montandon filed a criminal complaint against Ramirez and Ramirez was questioned by police after

    Montandon alleged that Ramirez stole his yard signs. Police found 48 Montandon yard sides at Ramirez house.

    According to the paper:

    Ramirez said police called him in for questioning about the incidents. Ramirez said he told police he took

    Montandon's signs down after getting permission from property owners to erect his own signs.

    A lot of people said, 'You can put yours up if you take the other sign down, Ramirez said.

    Police recovered 48 signs from Ramirez's home. (Las Vegas Review-Journal, Campaign Sign Warfare Becomes Police Matter, May 20, 2005

    Endorsed by Group Run by Howard Deans Brother, Ramirez Had Done Organizing for Dean Campaign, Endorsement Noted that Ramirez Had Union Backing (2005)

    In March 2005, Democracy for America, a group run by former presidential candidate Howard Deans brother, Jim,

    announced that it was endorsing Ramirez race for North Las Vegas Mayor, noting that Ramirez had done organizing

    for Howard Deans campaign and that Ramirez had union backing.. According to UPI:

    A North Las Vegas, Nev., mayoral candidate won the endorsement Tuesday of a group headed by Democratic

    National Chairman Howard Dean's brother, Jim.

    Andres Ramirez, a former volunteer in Iowa and New Hampshire for the Dean for president campaign, is

    described as a first-time office seeker with union backing.

    He's one of the first three candidates in 2005 to win the backing of Democracy for America, which says its

    mission is to rebuild the Democratic Party from the bottom up. (UPI, Dean Group Announces First

    Endorsements, March 29, 2005)

    WORKED AS STATE DIRECTOR FOR VOICES FOR WORKING FAMILIES DOING VOTER OUTREACH (2004)

    In November 2004, the Las Vegas Review Journal reported that Ramirez had spent the 2004 election cycle as Nevada State Director of Voices for Working Families, a voter registration effort. Voices for Working Families was part of an

    association of 33 organizations registering voters (Las Vegas Review-Journal, Political Notebook: Politicians Ponder Future Races, November 29 2004; Atlanta Journal Constitution, Rivals Roll Dice in Nevada, September 19, 2004)

    SERVED AS CAMPAIGN MANAGER FOR INDIAN AMERICAN WHO CHALLENGED SITTING DEMOCRATIC CONGRESSMAN IN PRIMARY (2004)

    In February 2004, India Abroad reported that Ramirez had been hired as the campaign manager for Ro Khanna who

    was challenging sitting Congressman Tom Lantos (D CA) in the Democratic primary. According to the paper:

    In the meantime, he has assembled a strong team headed by campaign manager Andres Ramirez who had

    earlier managed the state of Colorado for the Gore-Lieberman Democratic ticket in the last Presidential

    election. (India Abroad, Howard Deans Support Boosts Rohit Khannas Congressional Campaign, January

    9, 2004)

  • confidential memorandum VR Research 405 14th Street, Suite 350 Oakland, California 94612 vrresearch.com 29

    In Formal Complaint Primary Opponent Claimed Ramirez Candidate Offered Quid Pro Quo If He Dropped Out of Race

    In March 2004, Maad Abu-Ghazalah, another of Lantos and Khannas opponents in the Democratic primary filed a

    formal complaint against Khanna alleging that Khanna offered him a quid pro quo arrangement to get out of the

    race so that the two would not split the Indian vote. (San Mateo County Times, Race is Over, But Campaigns Far

    from It, March 6, 2004)

    DID VOTER ANALYSIS FOR PEOPLE FOR THE AMERICAN WAY (2004)

    In February 2004, the Las Vegas Review Journal reported that Ramirez firm had developed a voter drive strategy for

    People for the American Way. (Las Vegas Review-Journal, Political Power: Hispanic Influence Growing, February

    16, 2004)

    RAN NEIGHBOR TO NEIGHBOR GET OUT THE VOTE PROJECT (2002)

    In November 2002, the Las Vegas Review Journal reported that Ramirez ran the Neighbor to Neighbor get out the

    vote campaign for the 2002 general election. (Las Vegas Review-Journal, Election 2002: Hispanic Woes Survive, November 10, 2002)

    RAN FOR UNIVERSITY REGENT POSITION, CAME IN LAST (2002)

    In 2002, Ramirez ran for a place on the Nevada Board of Regents but came in third of three candidates running.

    (Associated Press, Poor Performance by Nevadas Hispanic Candidates, September 5, 2002)

    Reportedly Working as Political Consultant, Pursing Undergraduate Degree in Political Science While Running for Office

    The Las Vegas Review Journal reported that Ramirez was working as a political consultant and pursuing his undergraduate degree in political science from UNLV. (Las Vegas Review Journal, Board of Regents District 12,

    August 22, 2002)

    SERVED AS CHAIRMAN OF HISPANIC DEMOCRATIC CAUCUS (2002)

    In April 2002, the Associated Press reported that Ramirez was serving as chairman of the Hispanic Democratic

    Caucus. (Associated Press, Parties Court Nevadas Growing Hispanic Constituency, April 17, 2002)

    AS INFORMATION MANAGER FOR GOVERNORS OFFICE, SAID NO ONES A NATIVE IN NEVADA (1997)

    In July 1997 speaking as the information manager for Nevada governors office in Washington D.C., Ramirez noted

    that nobodys a native in Nevada. According to the Times Union:

    Nobody's a native in Nevada,'' said Andres Ramirez, an information manager in the Nevada governor's office

    in Washington, D.C. 'Nevada is made of people who move to Nevada.' (Times Union [Albany, NY], Thousands Gamble on Nevada, July 4, 1997)

  • confidential memorandum VR Research 405 14th Street, Suite 350 Oakland, California 94612 vrresearch.com 30

    JUAN JOSE GUTIERREZ

    Vital Statistics

    F U L L N A M E

    Juan Jose Gutierrez

    D A T E A N D P L A C E O F B I R T H

    1957

    Jalisco, Mexico

    C A R E E R T I M E L I N E

    YEARS AND LOCATION EMPLOYER AND POSITION

    2011 to Present Full Rights for Immigrants Coalition 2009 to Present Vamos Unidos, President 2006 to Present Act Now to Stop War and End Racism (ANSWER) 1996 to Present Latino Movement USA 1986 to 2001 One Stop Immigration Centers

    Vamos Unidos/Vamos EUA

    DBA FILED IN LA COUNTY TO CONDUCT BUSINESS AS VAMOS UNIDOS USA (2009)

    On August 19, 2009, a DBA was filed in LA County to conduct business as Vamos Unidos USA Inc. (LA County Registrar Recorder Web site, Fictitious Business Name Search, www.lavote.net/clerk)

    The company is located at 501 West Pico, Los Angeles, CA 90015. (Vamos Unidos USA Web site, Contacto, www.vamosunidos.net)

    Website is Entirely in Spanish, Says Vamos Unidos Provides Immigration Legal Services, Includes Legal Protection Plans Costing as Much as $1,600 Annually

    According to is website which is entirely in Spanish, Vamos Unidos USA provides immigration law services.

    Gutierrez bio is the only one contained on the website. (Vamos Unidos USA Web site, Conocenos,

    www.vamosunidos.net)

  • confidential memorandum VR Research 405 14th Street, Suite 350 Oakland, California 94612 vrresearch.com 31

    Vamos Unidos provides legal protection plans with individual and family legal plans costing from $799 to $1,600

    annually. (Vamos Unidos USA Web site, Legal Protection www.vamosunidos.net)

    GUTIERREZ FILED INCORPORATION PAPERS FOR VAMOS EUA MOVING FORWARD USA, INC. (2009)

    On April 20, 2009, Gutierrez filed incorporation papers for Vamos EUA Moving Forward USA with the California

    Secretary of State and listed himself as president. The corporation is currently active and in good standing. (Nexis Business Search, Vamos Unidos, www.nexis.com; California Secretary of State, Business Entity Search: Vamos

    EUA, www.kepler.sos.ca.gov)

    STATE OF CALIFORNIA HAS FILED THREE TAX LIENS AGAINST VAMOS UNIDOS USA, VAMOS EUA (2011-2012)

    According to a Nexis business search, the State of California has filed three tax liens against Vamos Unidos USA and

    Vamos EUA totaling at least $13,000. We will confirm these liens with the LA County Recorder. The chart below

    provides detail on the liens.

    CREDITOR FILING DATE DETAILS AMOUNT

    State of California 9/2/2011 State Tax Lien $9.264.-00

    California Employment

    Development

    Department

    3/8/2012 State Tax Lien Not Given

    State of California 6/24/2011 State Tax Lien $3,778.00

    (Nexis, Business Search: Vamos Unidos, www.nexis.com)

    VAMOS UNIDOS ORGANIZED RALLY AT LA SALVATION ARMY IN RESPONSE NEWS STORY THAT SALVATION ARMY IN TEXAS REQUIRED RECIPIENTS OF CHRISTMAS TOYS TO PROVIDE SOCIAL SECURITY NUMBERS (2009)

    In December 2009, Vamos Unidos organized a rally at a Los Angeles Salvation Army store in response to a news

    report that the Salvation Army in Houston, Texas was requiring recipients of Christmas toys to provide social

    security numbers. Alicia Molina, a Vamos Unidos attorney, decried the practice:

    No borders should be placed upon happiness for children at Christmastime. (Los Angeles Times, Rally Aims at Charity, December 3, 2009)

  • confidential memorandum VR Research 405 14th Street, Suite 350 Oakland, California 94612 vrresearch.com 32

    LA Salvation Army Spokesman Said Would Not Collect Social Security Numbers, Only Information Collected to Detect Fraud or Duplication

    In response to the rally, LA Salvation Army spokesman Robert Brennan said that the organization would not require

    social security numbers and that the information requested was only to detect fraud or duplication. According to

    Brennan:

    The Salvation Army is in the business of helping people, not in the business of informing on them. (Los Angeles Times, Rally Aims at Charity, December 3, 2009)

    Gutierrez Called on Salvation Army to Compromise on Identification Policy, Said Intended to Intimidate

    Gutierrez called on the Salvation Army to compromise on its identification policy, maintaining that the policy was

    intended to intimidate. According to Gutierrez:

    The question for us is, if they were willing to register families without identification from the get-go, and they

    were clear about discouraging fraud, why institute the policy to begin with? As far as we're concerned, it's

    simply to intimidate. (Daily News of Los Angeles, Salvation Armys ID Policy is Denounced, December 3, 2009)

    One Stop Immigration Centers

    CLAIMED LOTS OF DEMAND FOR IMMIGRATION SERVICES BUT LITTLE FUNDING (2000)

    In July 2000, Gutierrez speaking as the director of One Stop Immigration claimed that there was high demand from

    Latinos for services to assist with becoming citizens, but little available funding for nonprofits like One stop.

    According to the Washington Post:

    In California, the organization One-Stop Immigration once had 56 centers across the state helping

    immigrants become citizens by filling out forms and offering English and civics classes. Now, it has five. The

    demand is out there, but the resources aren't, says Juan Jose Gutierrez, the group's director. I can guarantee

    that if we had more money, we could help more people become citizens. (Washington Post, Naturalization:

    An Unnatural Process, July 4, 2000)

    ONE STOPS RECORDS SUBPOENAED BY U.S. DEPARTMENT OF EDUCATION (1998)

    In May 1998, the Orange County Register reported that One Stops class rosters, financial and employee records had been subpoenaed by the Clinton Administration and that Gutierrez had confirmed the request for the records.

    According to Gutierrez:

    They asked us for the master list of all our citizenship students, our adult students, along with their

    identifying immigration number. They want all the financial records related to the citizenship education

    program. (Orange County Register, Groups Serving Hispanic Immigrants Subpoenaed by Department of

    Education, May 2, 1998)

  • confidential memorandum VR Research 405 14th Street, Suite 350 Oakland, California 94612 vrresearch.com 33

    ACCUSED OF MISMANAGING FUNDS AT ONE STOP (1994)

    In July 1994, One Stop Board Member Stephanie Lopez resigned claiming that Gutierrez had denied her access to

    financial records for the struggle service centers and that the board had not voted on many of the funding decisions

    including center closures that had occurred over the previous 14 months. (Orange County Register, Head of

    Immigrant Service Centers Defends Record, July 7, 1994)

    Gutierrez Claimed Organization Going Through a Very Difficult Period, Cited Funding Cuts Requiring Center Closures

    In response to the accusations from Lopez, Gutierrez claimed that One Stop was going through a very difficult

    period, citing funding cuts which required center closures. According to Gutierrez:

    We're going through a very difficult period. The reason why One Stop is more visible in the face of these

    (funding) problems is we did things to try and maintain our level of services that are affecting us now.

    [Parenthesis in original] (Orange County Register, Head of Immigrant Service Centers Defends Record, July 7,

    1994)

    SAID COULD NOT ADVISE ILLEGAL IMMIGRANT CLIENTS TO COMPLY WITH IRS REQUIREMENT THAT THEY OBTAIN TAX NUMBERS, SAID NOT SURE INFORMATION WOULD NOT BE SHARED WITH INS (1997)

    In February 1997, Gutierrez said that he could not in good conscience recommend to his clients that they apply for

    new numbers required by the IRS because he was unsure whether the information would be shared with the INS.

    According to Gutierrez:

    I cannot in good conscience recommend that people apply for this number based on flimsy assurances that

    the information will not be turned over to the INS. This is creating mass panic. (Los Angeles Times, IRS Tries to Ease Noncitizens Fears of New ID Numbers, February 23, 1997)

    NLRB Action

    NLRB AFFIRMED DECISION OF ALJ WHO FOUND GUTIERREZ AND ONE STOP HAD VIOLATED FAIR LABOR LAWS BY THREATENING AND RETALIATING AGAINST EMPLOYEES ENGAGED IN UNION ACTIVITIES (1999)

    In February 1999, Administrative Law Judge Mary Miller Craft found that Gutierrez and One Stop had engaged in

    unfair labor practices by retaliating against and threatening employees engaged in union activities. In her decision,

    she stated that One Stop had violated the law:

    1. By interrogating employees about their union activities, threatening employees with unspecified reprisals

    unless they ceased engaging in union activities, and offering to reinstate an employee if the employee stopped

    engaging in union activities, Respondent has engaged in unfair labor practices affecting commerce within the

    meaning of Section 8(a)(1) and Section 2(6) and (7) of the Act.

  • confidential memorandum VR Research 405 14th Street, Suite 350 Oakland, California 94612 vrresearch.com 34

    2. By discharging Gumaro Oviedo-Flores and transferring and discharging Hector Alvarado, Respondent has

    engaged in unfair labor practices affecting commerce within the meaning of Section 8(a)(3) and Section 2(6)

    and (7) of the Act. (NLRB Decision and Order, One Stop Immigration and Education Center, Inc. and

    International Union of Electronic, Electri-cal, Salaried, Machine and Furniture Workers, AFLCIO, District 11

    and Hector Alvarado, Cases 21CA32068 and 21CA32280, December 30, 1999)

    In December 1999, a three member panel of the NLRB considered an appeal of the decision and affirmed Judge

    Crafts decision in the matter. (NLRB Decision and Order, One Stop Immigration and Education Center, Inc. and International Union of Electronic, Electri-cal, Salaried, Machine and Furniture Workers, AFLCIO, District 11 and

    Hector Alvarado, Cases 21CA32068 and 21CA32280, December 30, 1999)

    Cases Brought by Two Employees, One Employees Case Filed by the International Union of Electronic, Electrical, Salaried, Machine and Furniture Workers, AFLCIO, District Eleven (1997-1998)

    The decision affected two cases, each brought by a former employee of One Stop Immigration Center who claimed

    he was fired for engaging in union organizing activities. One case was filed by the International Union of Electronic,

    Electrical, Salaried, Machine and Furniture Workers, AFLCIO, District Eleven on behalf of Gumaro Oviedo Flores

    and the other was filed by Hector Alvarado. (NLRB Decision and Order, One Stop Immigration and Education Center, Inc. and International Union of Electronic, Electri-cal, Salaried, Machine and Furniture Workers, AFLCIO,

    District 11 and Hector Alvarado, Cases 21CA32068 and 21CA32280, December 30, 1999)

    In Decision, Judge Noted Three Instances in which She Could Not Credit Gutierrezs Testimony

    In her decision, Judge Craft noted three instances in which she could not credit Gutierrezs testimony, including

    on the issue of whether Gutierrez promised to give a job back to one of the employees if he ceased union activities.

    According to the decision:

    Gutierrez denied that he said he would take Alvarado back if he would quit his union activities. I credit

    Alvarado, Martinez, and Gonza-les regarding the meetings events. (NLRB Decision and Order, One Stop Immigration and Education Center, Inc. and International Union of Electronic, Electri-cal, Salaried, Machine

    and Furniture Workers, AFLCIO, District 11 and Hector Alvarado, Cases 21CA32068 and 21CA32280,

    December 30, 1999)

    Case Included Allegations of Sexual Harassment of Employees by Gutierrez

    The case decision noted that Alvarado and 22 other employees had petitioned One Stops board to consider

    workplace issues including allegations of sexual harassment by Gutierrez and union issues. According to the

    decision:

    By memorandum of May 19, Alvarado and 22 other employees petitioned the board of directors for specific

    solutions to various work place problems. One of the solutions sought was a collective-bargaining agreement

    with the Union. Another was a full investigation of allegations of sexual harassment by Gutierrez. (NLRB

    Decision and Order, One Stop Immigration and Education Center, Inc. and International Union of Electronic,

    Electri-cal, Salaried, Machine and Furniture Workers, AFLCIO, District 11 and Hector Alvarado, Cases 21

    CA32068 and 21CA32280, December 30, 1999)

  • confidential memorandum VR Research 405 14th Street, Suite 350 Oakland, California 94612 vrresearch.com 35

    Judges Decision Detailed Anti Union Action Taken by Gutierrez, including Asking Employees to Identify Union Organizers, Threatening Employees Engaged in Union Activities and Attempting to Coerce an Employee to Cease Union Activities

    Judge Crafts decision detailed anti union actions taken by Gutierrez including asking employees to identify union

    organizers, threatening employees engaged in union activities and attempting to coerce an employee to cease union

    activities. According to Craft:

    I find that Gutierrez questioned employees about the identity of union organizers, twice threatened Alvarado

    with unspecified reprisals in retaliation for his union activity, and agreed to reinstate Alvarado only if he

    eschewed union activity. These findings are based on the credibility resolutions set forth above.

    In addition, I find that counsel for the General Counsel has adduced substantial credible evidence that the

    discharge of Oviedo-Flores and the transfer and discharge of Alvarado were motivated by union animus.

    (NLRB Decision and Order, One Stop Immigration and Education Center, Inc. and International Union of

    Electronic, Electri-cal, Salaried, Machine and Furniture Workers, AFLCIO, District 11 and Hector Alvarado,

    Cases 21CA32068 and 21CA32280, December 30, 1999)

    FINAL DECISION ORDERED ONE STOP TO REINSTATE EMPLOYEES, PROVIDE BACK PAY AND BENEFITS AND POST NOTICE TO EMPLOYEES INFORMING THEM OF NLRB DECISION AND STATING THEIR RIGHTS TO ORGANIZE (1999)

    In affirming Crafts decision, the NLRB affirmed her original order requiring that One Stop reinstate the employees

    to their old positions or an equivalent position, provide the employees with back pay and benefits and post a notice

    to all employees informing them of the NLRBs decision and stating their right to organize. In full, the notice was

    ordered to state:

    NOTICE TO EMPLOYEES

    POST