towards a panarchy meme map
DESCRIPTION
A presentation of a network analysis of tags on panarchy-related books (Paul B. Hartzog)TRANSCRIPT
Towards a Panarchy Meme Map
MotivationMotivation
Panarchy as an interdisciplinary challenge.
What are the key relationships between panarchy’s core concepts and works?
Who cares?Syllabus constructionResearch designEtc.
Panarchy as an interdisciplinary challenge.
What are the key relationships between panarchy’s core concepts and works?
Who cares?Syllabus constructionResearch designEtc.
Concepts and Related Work
Concepts and Related Work
Literature analysisCitation networks
Price, D. J. de S., “Networks of scientific papers”, Science, 149 (1965), pp. 510–515
Collaboration networksNewman, M. E. J., “The structure of scientific collaboration networks,” Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA, 98 (2001)
Literature analysisCitation networks
Price, D. J. de S., “Networks of scientific papers”, Science, 149 (1965), pp. 510–515
Collaboration networksNewman, M. E. J., “The structure of scientific collaboration networks,” Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA, 98 (2001)
Concepts and Related Work
Concepts and Related Work
Information networksMeme maps
Tim O’Reilly: P2P meme map, Web 2.0 meme mapConcept maps
Motter, A. E., de Moura, A. P., Lai, Y. C., and Dasgupta, P., “Topology of the conceptual network of language”, Phys. Rev. E 65, 065102 (2002)
Semantic networksFerrer i Cancho, R. and Sole, R. V., “The small world of human language”, Proc. R. Soc. London B 268, 2261-2265 (2001)
Knowledge networksChen, C. and Paul, R. J.. “Visualizing a knowledge domain’s intellectual structure.” IEEE Computer, 34(3): 65–71, 2001.
Information networksMeme maps
Tim O’Reilly: P2P meme map, Web 2.0 meme mapConcept maps
Motter, A. E., de Moura, A. P., Lai, Y. C., and Dasgupta, P., “Topology of the conceptual network of language”, Phys. Rev. E 65, 065102 (2002)
Semantic networksFerrer i Cancho, R. and Sole, R. V., “The small world of human language”, Proc. R. Soc. London B 268, 2261-2265 (2001)
Knowledge networksChen, C. and Paul, R. J.. “Visualizing a knowledge domain’s intellectual structure.” IEEE Computer, 34(3): 65–71, 2001.
SFI Complexity Map (2002)
SFI Complexity Map (2002)
ApproachApproach
DataPrimary
TitlesTags (keywords)
SecondaryPublishers, Authors, Dates, etc.
Main VisualizationTitles and Tags
DataPrimary
TitlesTags (keywords)
SecondaryPublishers, Authors, Dates, etc.
Main VisualizationTitles and Tags
Network VisualizationNetwork VisualizationCentral Titles
MultitudeTerritory, Authority, RightsCathedral and Bazaar
Central TagsComplexityNetworksTechnologyInformationIR
Tags Degree DistributionTags Degree
DistributionTags Degree Distribution
0
10
20
30
40
50
60
Degree
Tags Degree Distribution
0
10
20
30
40
50
60
Degree
complexity
networkstechnologyinformationI.R. (international relations)politicssociology
ResultsResults
Community structure (Girvan/Newman)Dense core around central themesIsolates: IP, sharing economy, anarchism
Useful Notions:Degree centrality along dimensions (incomplete)
BetweennessHeterarchy :: The Logics of Social StructureSteal This Idea :: I.P. (intellectual property)
Resilience (to .5 of the giant component)Degree 7%, (failure-to-read factor)
Community structure (Girvan/Newman)Dense core around central themesIsolates: IP, sharing economy, anarchism
Useful Notions:Degree centrality along dimensions (incomplete)
BetweennessHeterarchy :: The Logics of Social StructureSteal This Idea :: I.P. (intellectual property)
Resilience (to .5 of the giant component)Degree 7%, (failure-to-read factor)
Discussion and BeyondDiscussion and Beyond
More dimensions?Growth over timeIssues
HeterogeneityDensitySensitivity to data (cf. actor network)
More dimensions?Growth over timeIssues
HeterogeneityDensitySensitivity to data (cf. actor network)