tototo home industries partnership in development workshop: field visits information package
DESCRIPTION
Information on six women's groups in Kenya's Coast Province, prepared by Martin Walsh for an international NGO workshop.Citation: Tototo Home Industries 1988. Tototo Home Industries Partnership in Development Workshop: Field Visits Information Package (Wednesday, 27 July 1988). Prepared for the Partnership in Development Workshop, Mombasa, Kenya, 25-29 July 1988.TRANSCRIPT
i
T@TOTO HOME INDUSTRilES
PARTNERSHI P il N DEVELOPMENT
WORKSHOP
FilELD VilSITS
INFCIRMATION PAGKAGE
Wedmesdayo ZV duny il988
-3 3 /5
Eyj. i8 & ;:Eg
I
l \O'r\
€ i: ta l
a la \
3 st <?('o
III
. tIIt -
. t 'Il -It! <III
trr l l l t t l l t" trrr;
H
t " I. f l -t r' t I
. . ^ l <6 u 7 . , 1
. t
. J :. t l -
i l". I
E " , i 'a . . . l l _
) , , ? x l s \ :J t 1 5 5 6 ' . . - -o - r -
- O ' 6 't=t ra....."'t
!^-:73a g : !? ^ 1 t
7 i
oFoF0F
d
b
f.(\I
(d
utc)
q)T
tnHHtnH
frtl-{fr
\
.'..NO r - \
? EP 3
Ff
' g
o-< l
r o I
F l, : I\,
itr I
w,t:;.
The Fie ld Vis i ts
General Information
Wednesdag,2T Julg has been set aside for f ield visits. We hove planned
six separote visits, each to a different lyomen's groups working with
Tototo. Each visit wil l be led bg a member of Tototo's f ield staff, to be
j0ined bg eight or nine workslrop participonts. The six visit ing teoms wil l
depart from the Reef Hotel in the morning and have lunch in the vi l lage
with the women's grouF. Visitors to l lkwiro, vlho wil l cross to the island
bg boat, wil l return to the mainland to dine with Shimoni Women's Group.
The tesms wil l return to the hotel of different t imes depending, in part,
upon the distonce esch has to trovel.
We hope that the visits wil l st imulate gour thinking about grass roots
portnerships ond provide 6 starting point for subsequent workshop
sessions 0n th is topic. With th is in mind we have selected the s ix
lyomen's groups to i l lustrate dif f erent problems and approoches to
promoting development with rural women. The six groups ond the major
themes of esch visit ore l isted below.
l lAl lBA: ' lntegrating communitg welfore and income generotion
projects' (team leoder: Simsn l lwero)
NAZINGIRA:The chollenge of development in a diff icult environment'
(team leader: Elizabeth Kenga)
l lKWlR0: 'Women operating an enterprise in a tradit ionallg mole
domain' (team lesder: Rachel Ruwa)
LUKUND0: 'Successful group enterprise and business training The
Tototo WoU"'(team leader: t l iraj i Jeffah)
NGAllAtl l : 'Promoting individual enterprise in 0 group context'(team
leader: l lesalimu t lopengo)
l1t(0Y0: 'Promoting individual savings ond credit in a group context'
(team leader: Evangeline Kea)
A.
ts.
C.
D.
E.
F.
Background informotion on each of the groups, together with s mop
showing their locations, is provided on separate sheets in this pockage.
We hspe that gou wil l take the opportunitg to f ind out more once Uou are in
the f ield. ldeallg we would hove l iked to take evergone on oll of the visits,
but l imited t ime ond space mean that gou wil l onlg be able to go 0n one. l f
Uou complete the Eccomponging form and return it to us (the sooner the
better!), then we will trg our best to accomodate gour preference(s) when
drowing up the f inal l ists of visit ing teoms.
The Field Visits in the f,ontext of Tototo's Evolving Programme
Indigenous N60's l ike Tototo plag a unique role among all the partners
involved in the development process. Theg oct as an intermediorg between
the grass roots and the international aid donors, tronsloting information
gothered at the vi l lage level into progrommes in which donors then invest
development funds. In this posit ion, the partnerships that the indigenous
N60 is able to build with beneficioru groups is equallg os important as
those with nsrthern NG0's and donors. In Tototo's c6se,.the foundotions for
portnerships with the women's groups were laid with the adoption of a
nonformal education methodologg introduced to them bg World Education
Inc.,6n N60 based in the U.S.A.
Following the principles of nonformal education, Tototo encouraged the
ful l part lcipotion of women's group members in the sffairs of their groups
ond, in turn, the ful ler part icipation of these groups in the affairs of their
local communities. At the s6me time, groups were left to choose their
own projects. This led to the development of dgnamic women's groups in
the earlg Uears of the programme, and hos remoined a keg component of'The Tototo Wag' as it has continued to evolve.
t lAPlBA i l lustrates a number of features of this approach. In their
pursuit of a communitg health programme ond subsequent adoption of an
income generation project to support this goal, the women have made their
priorit ies clear-- both to the government ministrg involved and to Tototo.
As a result, Tototo has hsd to modif g i ts approach to the group
occordinglg, adjusting its 0wn priorit ies (which currentlg stress the
primocg of business development) in the process. In this, as in manu other
cflses, T0t0t0's nonf ormal methodol0gg has encouraged both
self-determination on the part of the women and f lexibi l i tg in Tototo's
own role in relation to them.
In sett ing up its progrsmme, Tototo did not shun working in diff icult
Ereas. llAZlN6lRA, located in the harsh thorn scrub of the semi-orid Taru
Desert, tgpif ies the situotion of a signif icant proportion of the groups
Tototo assists. The challenge here hos not onlg been that of providing
assistance in a diff icult environment, but also one of recognising that the
crit ieria for meosuring development must be modif ied accordinglg.
l lKWlRO provides f ln example of 0 women's group working in a diff icult
social environment, where the women chose to operate an enterprise in o
domain tradit ionallg reserved for men. As in the case of t lazingira, Tototo
has learned os msng lessons from the women's diff icult ies ond their
sslutions to them as it has tought them in turn.
A keg feature of Tototo's approach has been its endeavour to remain
self-crit ical snd open to lessons drown from its experience in the f ield,
call ing upon external expertise when ond where it has been required.
Tototo's understanding of the women's groups with which it works results
both from its extended inv0lvement with them over t ime as well as from
intensive anthropological research corried out in collaboration with World
Education. This csse studu research (copies of the report written at the
end of i ts f irst phase are available for review 0n the displag table)
revealed o set of constroints at the household, communitg and regionol
levels that affect the operatisn of the women's group enterprises and
indicated thot although mang of the women had considerable experience in
operating enterprises at the individuol and household level, theg had
diff icultg in translating this informsl experience into the running 0f group
enterprises.
Insights from the case studg prompted Tototo and its partner, World
Education, to re-evaluate certain aspects of their methodologg with the
women's groups os well as the kind of training Vrtorld Education needed to
provide to Tototo f ield staff. In 1986 a World Education business trainer
worked with the Tototo f ield staff to upgrade their own understanding 0f
small business management. Theg then used the same nonformal education
methods to trsnslate this new knowledge to vi l lage women. The trainer
and the Tototo staff chose I women's groups to serve as their training' laboratorg'and to receive intensive business troining as well. Drawing on
the case studg research results as well as the staff's knowledge of these
groups, theg were able to design a set of interventions to address the
problems faced bg them.' In tirne the groups put new monagement
structures in place, instituted wage, dividend and reinvestment policies,
adopted new and better accsunting pr0cedures and Es 0 result were able to
improve economic performonce and increose income distributions
accordinglg. LUKUNDO, with i ts maize grinding mil l , is one group that
especial lg benefitted fr0m this training. l , lot onlg did members' income
rise substantial lg, but the group was able t0 expand successful lg into a
second major enterprise. 'The Tototo Wag' of business training has since
been extended to other groups working with Tototo and has become the
basis for Tototo's growing consultancg service to other organisotions in
Africa.
l leanwhile, Tototo has not cessed to reflect upon its f ield experience
and the (as get unpublished) results of o second phase of case studg
research. llore recentlg Tototo has begun to explore wCIUs of developing
its sssistonce methodologu bU using the groups to promote individual
entrepreneurship. NGANANI provides one model of how this can be done.
There, group members learned skil ls while engaged in their collective
enterprise that prompted them to estsblish individual businesses. The
group continues to run its collective enterprise and act as the locus for
troining and external interventions, while olso organising the marketing of
individual member's products. t1K0V0 i l lustrotes a different approach. The
group's highlg successful savings club for individuals has led Tototo to
investigate wags of using their collective deposit to secure bank credit
for individual members.
f,onclusion
Tototo does not pretend that i ts experience is exhaustive, nor does it
claim to have all the solutions. Rather, i t is engaged in a continual
learning process fed bg research, experiment, and assistance from its
partners. That learning process moves in two directions-- from Tototo
and its partners t0 the grass roots beneficirries ond back again. We hope
that visit ing the women's groups wil l st imulate Uou to compare and
contrast T0toto's experience with Uour own. The f ield visits wil l help us
bring the Workshop discussions of institutional partnership to the grass
r00ts, which, after sl l , is a central focus of the work for al l of us.
TlAl.lBA
Integrat ing communitg welfore and income generat ion projects
l lurindiro l lambo Women's Group is located in the small trading centre
of l1omba, south of the Shimbo Hil ls. The group wos formed in l9E0 and
has 25 members, manu of them recent sett lers in the Erea.
In the earlg Uears of its programme, Tototo encourflged an integrated
approach to development via i ts nonf ormal education troining
methodol0gg. l lamba, locoted in one of the coast's more productive
agriculturol regions, wfrs one of a number of groups which chose
communitg welfare 6s its f irst prioritg. Assistance from CEDPA and
UNICEF (mediated bg Tototo) has helped the women move E long wflU
towords, their goal of improving health core in the communitg. Four group
members, trained in mother/child heslth, nutri t ion ond fomilg planning,
organized monthlg cl inics in the vi l lage to promote this knowledge.
lledicines were donated to the group and a small grant bought them o hond
0perated grinding mil l to be used in the preparation of weaning foods.
Their devotion to this project was omplg demonstrated when theg
pressed the l l inistrg of Health to be included on the schedule of mobile
cl in ic v is i ts so that v i l lage chi ldren could be immunized. Af ter some
resistance on the part of the t l inistrg, their wish was granted. In addit ion
the women's group co-ordinator was emploged as a ful l-t ime mother/child
health promoter in the vi l loge. Not al l of their aspirations have been
sotisf ied though, and the group has unable to sequre l l inistg support for
their plans to build 0 permflnent heolth cl inic in l lamba. In response the
group began a small bakerg enterprise, hoping that theg could use the
income generated bg this. to help f inance their project. To help establish
this enterprise, theg received grants from the The Pothfinder Fund and the
Deportment of Social Services.
This development has led to o modif ication in Tototo's own priorit ies
in deoling with the group. The introduction of a business troining
programme has seen Tototo move EwaU from an integrated approach. In
l ine with this progrfmme, Tototo has generallg encouraged groups to keep
their business and communitg welfare interests separate. This policU was
introduced for a veru good reason: Es the cfse studies showed, the
integration of the two con sometimes impose severe constraints upon the
success 0f group enterprises. In this respect, the situation at llamba
poses a problem to Tototo. What do gou think Tototo should do sbout i t , i f
angthing?
NAZIN6IRA
The chal lenge of development in a dif f icult environment
Taru l lazingira 6roup is located in Roko, some I km north of the
Nsirobi-mombasa highwag and in the heart of the semi-arid Toru Desert.
The group was formed in l9B3 and hos 25 members,6 of them men.
As its nsme implies, the Taru Desert presents a diff icult environment
to l ive and work in. Rainfal l is scorce and mang farmers move seasonallg
to the Toita area in order to cult ivate crops. The women of Roka have to
walk long distances through the bush to collect water, mindful of the
threat from wild animals as theg do s0. The vi l lage -- a collection 0f
widelg scattered homesteads -- is remote from morkets ond locks ong
obvious kind of infrsstructure. Not surprisinglg, manu Uoung people leave
the areo in search of better opportunit ies elsewhere. As s result, the
group is primari lg composed of older women, most of whom are i l l i terate.
l leonwhile the group hos experienced considerable diff icultg in f inding 0n
educated member to act as their secretarg and co-ordinotor. Since the
group was formed it has experimented with a vorietg of projects most 0f
which have met with l i t t le success.
t lang of the groups which Tototo works with are in situotions
analogous to that of l" lazingiro. With few ressurces of their disposol, theg
have provided a constant challenge to Tototo's progrflmme. The problem is
not merelg one of devising interventions appropriate to E diff icult
environment, but olso one of revising programme expectations to toke
account of the local context. As Tototo has learned, development in a
place l ike }lozingira has to be measured rather differentlg from that in
more favoured locations.
The development of ltlazingira's goot trading enterprise pr0vides a
good example of this. l leasured on a balonce sheet side bg side with the
accounts of a group l ike Lukundo, i t shows l i t t le to impress. Assessed in
context, however, llazingira's response to Tototo's training is no less
signif icant. A simple foct l ike the participation of women on the long goat
-buging tr ips speaks volumes which the f igures in sn 6cc0unt b00k cannot.
To a casual observer, the long-term committment of women to marginallg
profitable (ond often loss-making) groups can seem 0 puzzle. Long
experience in the f ield and the integration of action research into its
programme have provided Tototo with a different perspective and E
sensit ivitg to local context which donor agencies and N60s promoting
technical interventions often lack.
l lKWtR0
Women operat ing an enterprise in o trodit ionol lg mole domoin
l lkwiro Women's Group is located in the f ishing vi l lage of l lkwiro on
Wosini lslond off the south coast. The group was formed in 1979 and has
63 members, all of them women.
l'lkwiro begon 0s one of the mang groups selling handicrofts to the
Tototo Shop. Their f irst project wos to construct a mult ipurpose house in
the vi l loge. Work on this project come to a stondsti l l when the plot on
which theg were building was claimed bg another vi l loger. Aclvised bg
Totsto to choose a different project, the women faced o diff icult decision.
Some of them wonted to purchase a boat and operate a ferrg service to the
mainland, arguing thot this would moke it much essier for them to take
their children to the cl inic there. 0thers proposed that theg should
construct o woter cistern to eose the vi l lage's woter problems ond reduce
the expense ond labour involved in having to bug and carrg water brought to
the island from the moinlsnd. Thg supporters of this project also orgued
that running o boot lag too far outside their experience: to operate and
mointain the ferrg enterprise theg would be heavilg dependent upon men.
The sea wgs E m6n's domain, not a woman's.
In the event, supporters of the water project were outnumbered and
the ferrg enterprise was chosen. Helped bg E grant from NATCH
International, the group bought a boot and on engine, 6nd their ferrg
service went into operation in late 1983. Almost immediatelg the
enterprise began running into problems of the kind which some group
members had predicted. A local man wss emploged to pi lot the boat,
purchose petrol and supervise its maintenonce. Income from the boat was
divided everg dog into three, and later four, equal port ions fol lowing the
practice of local f ishermen: one portion for the pi lot, one for purchasing
petrol, one for the boat's maintenance, and one for the group itself. As o
result the pilot was paid much more than if he had been 0 salaried
emplogee, and the women effectivelg exploited their own labour bg paging
themselves a minimal sum for their turns working as the boat's conductor.
The group's accounts were also thrown into disarrag bg this practice: onlg
budgeted and not actual expenses were entered into their books.
Faced with a host of other problems, small and large, llkwiro was not
faring verg well when Tototo introduced its business training progrsmme
there in 1987. The group's Eccounting sgstem was relativelg easg to
remodel, but Tototo staff were unable to persuade the women to pag their
pil0t a monthlg wage instead of a fixed proportion of boat revenue. The
practice of dividing income into equal portions was too deeplg rooted in
the local economg. The result was E compromise between traditionol
practice and Tototo's advice. With a portion alloted to group dividends the
women are now benefitting from their enterprise to an extent which theg
had previouslg not. At the same time business perfomance has improved
considerablg and the group has now revived its original building project.
LUKUNDO
Successful group enterprise and business training 'The Tototo Wag'
Lukundo Women's Group is located in the vi l lage 0f Sechu on the
southern slopes of the Taita Hil ls. The group was formed in 1983 and now
has 44 members, al l of them women.
Lukundo is, in conventional economic terms, the most successful group
that Tototo ossists. There are mEnU reasons for this. TheToita Hil ls are
one of the most fert i le and developed areas in the whole of the Coast
Province. Cash crop production is well established and educational snd
literacg levels comparotivelg high. When the women 0f Lukund0 decided t0
lnvest in a maize grinding mil l theg made o particul0rlg wise choice given
the high level of moize production in the vi l loge areo and the existing lack
of such a service there. 0nce the machine had been purchased (with the
help of o grant from tlATCH International of Canada) and installed (in
Plarch 1985) theg lost no t ime in organising themselves into a dutg roster
to supervise its dailg operation. In organising their labour effectivelg
theg succeeded where m6nu groups fai l ; col lective labour usuallg suffers
in competit i0n with more pressing h0useh0ld demands upon vromen's t ime.
In Lukundo's cose, however, the women yere not new to collective
lsb0ur-- a strong tradit i0n in the Taita Hil ls, whether working for one
another or for the long estoblished churches. Theg were also not new to
the diff icult ies thot women's groups can experience: the groups in Taito
have a longer hist0rg than angwhere else 0n the coast and most of
Lukundo's members had alreodg been (or still were) members of other
women's groups. For these and other reasons their moize mil l ing
enterprise got 0ff t0 a verg good start.
Starting a business, however, is one thing, maintaining and expanding it
is another. This is a lesson which Tototo hod learned from post experience
with other groups and helped prompt the decisi0n t0 introduce 0 new
business training pr0gr6mme. Lukundo was one of the first groups to
receive business training The Tototo Wag' when it was introduced in 1986.
Sure enough, and despite i ts good stort, i t was clear that Lukundo's
enterprise w6s heading for diff icult ies. One of these stemmed from the
fast that the women were decloring monthlg dividends in excess of their
earnings. ln effect theg were decapital ising their business: al l the more
serious a situation in view of the fact that theg were about to stsrt s
second enterprise-- a retai l shop. In the absence of regular f inancial
reports none of the group members had recognised this fact. Tototo's
t imelg solution was to introduce their new sgstem of pictorial f inancial
statements and encourage the odoption of a new dividend policg (wherebg
50fr 0f net cosh flow was distributed as dividends and 50fr retained in the
business). As a result of this and other measures (which visitors can ask
about when theg ore there: selected lessons from the Tototo Training Kit
wil l olso be on displag st the Workshop) Lukundo's imminent diff icult ies
dissolved. Their new shop wos opened in lote 1986 and the two
enterprises now thrive side bg side. The women have subsequentlg
received higher dividends thon ever, making their temporarg sacrif ice
when the business training was introduced more than worthwhile.
NEA}1ANI
Promoting individuol enterprise in o group context.
Ngomani Women's 6roup is located in the vi l lage of Ngamani on the west
mainlond of Plombasa overlooking Tudor Creek. The group was founded in
1975 ond hos 30 msmbers, oll women.
One of the keg observations made during the case studg reseorch of
Tototo-assisted groups wos the fact that women's group members owe
primarg al legiance to the different households to which theg belong.
Households operate their own enterprises and hove their own structures of
control and decision-making. t#omen's investment in group enterprises is
verg much condit ioned bg this fact and groups often suffer from the
competing demands which households place upon their member's t ime,
labour and cash. This obersvation might be taken as a good reason for
designing assistance strotegies which pronrote individual enterprise: the
constraints which operote uFon group businesses ore circumvented ond the
benefit t0 individuals and their households is more direct . l t might might
even be interpreted as En argument in favour of withdrawing assistance to
group enterprises altogether.
The experience of Ngamani helps set these arguments in their proper
context. Ngamani's moin enterprise, poultrg-raising, has witnessed m6nu
ups snd downs over the Uesrs. When, howevlr, group members started
their own individual poultrg projects with assistance from CEDPA and the
NCDK, the women demonstroted an obil i tg to run successful enterprises
which had never been evident in their csl lective efforts as 0 group. At the
sffme time their new-found committment to these home-based projects
wos such that the group enterprise become even more run down thon ever,
and was clearlg 0n the verge of collapse.
This does not, Es it might first appefrr, offer unqualified support for the
argument 0utl ined above. There are two main re6s0ns for this. First, i t
sh0uld be noted thot the individual projects did not develop in a vacuum.
The group, effective or not as collective entrepreneur, was the means
through which externol assistance was channelled to the individual
members. lt functioned as a locus for training and further providetl the
women with'experience in o particular business which theg subsequentlg
transferred to ther households. Heanwhile, the group continues to plag an
important role in marketing the individual members'products (eggs).
Second, the development of individual businesses did not render the
group enterprise begond repoir. This was amplg demonstrated when Tototo
included the group in i ts new business training progrEmme. In the wake of
this training the group's broiler project has performed significantlg better
than ever before. One result of this is that group members have begun to
receive dividends from their enterprise where theg had received none in
the past. The important point here is thot if s group business can be
developed to a level where it can provide regular income distribution to
its members, then it can draw labour committments from them which
theg would otherwise onlg give to their households. In this wag Ngamani
has shown that both individual and group businesses can be developed side
bg side.
t1K0Y0
Promoting individual savings and credit in a group context
l lkogo Women's 6roup is located in the Tiwi area on the l lusl im (Digo)
South Coast. The group was formed in 1977 ond currentlg hos 4E members.
Tototo has worked with t lkogo since the beginning of i ts Rural
Developntent Programme in 1978. 0ver the Uesrs llkogo has demonstrated
lit t le income generation potential Bs a group. l ts major projects, o
nurseru school ond a house (sti l l under construction) to be rented out to
local schoolteochers, indicate rother the importance of communitg
concerns. The women's comparativelg weak record in collective enterprise
hos, needless ts sEU, 0 simple explanation. Living close to the coastal
highwag and with easg Eccess to various markets mflnu of the group
members are activelg engoged in pettg troding of one Rind or another. As a
result the women fre not bereft of individual sources of income and have
been happg to treot the group largelg as a focus for sociol interaction and
conrmunitg welf are efforts rather than as o profit-making bodg.
This situation also provides part of the explanotion for the phenomenal
success of l lkogo's savings club, which has deposited over 50,000 Ksh on
behslf of i ts 76 members (10 of them men). This is more than ong of the
other 50 sovings clubs in Tototo's pr0gr6mme-- including manu which have
been in operation much longer.
The Savings Club Progromnre 0s 6 whole has been one of Tot0to's most
successful interventions. l ts introduction from Zimbabwe and further
adaptstion bg Tototo (sketched in our pre-Workshop psper 'Tototo and its
Partners') provides f l msdel of portnership at different levels. The
popularitg of the Clubs, whose membership is open to the wider
communitg, orises first ond foremost from the fact that theg open up
bonking to mgng people who would not otherwise be able t0 afford the
minimum deposit of 500 Ksh.
Tototo's experience with the Clubs, ond in psrt icular with l lkogo, has
led Tototo to explore the possibi l i tg of a further innovation to the
programme and one with potential lg wide-reaching effects. The idea is
deceptivelg simple: to use the Savings Club deposits as collateral for bank
loans to individual members. In this wog it is hoped that the women of
I1k0go wil l be given a chance t0 expand their individual enterprises and as
a g_roup provide a valuable f inancial service to the communitg which it
otherwise would not have had.