themysteryingredient - files.meetup.com ingredient.pdf · , , ,, 1 themysteryingredient...
TRANSCRIPT
![Page 1: TheMysteryIngredient - files.meetup.com Ingredient.pdf · , , ,, 1 TheMysteryIngredient Cai,Kjaer,,April,2012, Presented,at,the,KMLF,in,Melbourne,](https://reader034.vdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022052019/60330486ba6fa04e9666a4b1/html5/thumbnails/1.jpg)
www.optimice.com.au 1
The Mystery Ingredient
Cai Kjaer, April 2012
Presented at the KMLF in Melbourne
![Page 2: TheMysteryIngredient - files.meetup.com Ingredient.pdf · , , ,, 1 TheMysteryIngredient Cai,Kjaer,,April,2012, Presented,at,the,KMLF,in,Melbourne,](https://reader034.vdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022052019/60330486ba6fa04e9666a4b1/html5/thumbnails/2.jpg)
www.optimice.com.au 2
![Page 3: TheMysteryIngredient - files.meetup.com Ingredient.pdf · , , ,, 1 TheMysteryIngredient Cai,Kjaer,,April,2012, Presented,at,the,KMLF,in,Melbourne,](https://reader034.vdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022052019/60330486ba6fa04e9666a4b1/html5/thumbnails/3.jpg)
www.optimice.com.au 3
Balance in Relationships
Too few
“…who was likely, over time, to become a lower performer and occasionally even fired—these people often had very underdeveloped networks (poor connections on networks of information flow, decision making, problem solving, and career advice) compared with others of similar organizational tenure, and they also tended to be less-‐efficient collaborators, thus taking valuable time from their peers. “
Too many
“The least engaged individuals (small circles) were those who were both (a) heavily sought out for information and (b) whose colleagues indicated that they needed greater access to them in order to be effective.”
Ballinger et al, California Management Review, Vol 53, No 4, Summer 2011
![Page 4: TheMysteryIngredient - files.meetup.com Ingredient.pdf · , , ,, 1 TheMysteryIngredient Cai,Kjaer,,April,2012, Presented,at,the,KMLF,in,Melbourne,](https://reader034.vdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022052019/60330486ba6fa04e9666a4b1/html5/thumbnails/4.jpg)
www.optimice.com.au 4
Exercise #1 -‐ Can you work this out?
6 simple statements:
• Belinda knows Louise
• Louise knows May through Dennis
• Don knows May
• Anna knows Louise, but not Don
• Tony knows Anna and Belinda
• Don knows Louise through Dennis
![Page 5: TheMysteryIngredient - files.meetup.com Ingredient.pdf · , , ,, 1 TheMysteryIngredient Cai,Kjaer,,April,2012, Presented,at,the,KMLF,in,Melbourne,](https://reader034.vdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022052019/60330486ba6fa04e9666a4b1/html5/thumbnails/5.jpg)
www.optimice.com.au 5
Exercise #1 -‐ Can you work this out?
• So, what has Belinda, Louise, Anna, Tony and Dennis in common?
– The answer is obvious, right?
![Page 6: TheMysteryIngredient - files.meetup.com Ingredient.pdf · , , ,, 1 TheMysteryIngredient Cai,Kjaer,,April,2012, Presented,at,the,KMLF,in,Melbourne,](https://reader034.vdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022052019/60330486ba6fa04e9666a4b1/html5/thumbnails/6.jpg)
www.optimice.com.au 6
Visualisation of relationships
• We are basically not very good at thinking quickly! • Visualisation shifts the balance between perception and cognition • Take fuller advantage of the brain's abilities to quickly and precisely process information
![Page 7: TheMysteryIngredient - files.meetup.com Ingredient.pdf · , , ,, 1 TheMysteryIngredient Cai,Kjaer,,April,2012, Presented,at,the,KMLF,in,Melbourne,](https://reader034.vdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022052019/60330486ba6fa04e9666a4b1/html5/thumbnails/7.jpg)
www.optimice.com.au 7
A little bit of history – unscientific selection!
• Social maps invented in the 1930’ies – Dr J. L. Moreno mapping ‘Like’ and ‘Dislike’ relationships among 500 schools girls in the New York State School for Girls in the 1930’ies.
• ‘Six degrees of separation’ Stanley Milgram in 1967 -‐ http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Small_world_experiment
• The Strength of weak ties – by Mark Granovetter in 1973
• The Kevin Bacon game -‐ http://oracleoaacon.org/index.php
• 2011 Champions League –FC Barcelona vs Manchester United http://www.fas-‐research.com/cases?id=158&view=detail
• Musician map -‐ http://www.liveplasma.com/
• …etc
![Page 8: TheMysteryIngredient - files.meetup.com Ingredient.pdf · , , ,, 1 TheMysteryIngredient Cai,Kjaer,,April,2012, Presented,at,the,KMLF,in,Melbourne,](https://reader034.vdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022052019/60330486ba6fa04e9666a4b1/html5/thumbnails/8.jpg)
www.optimice.com.au 8
Relationships and Business Performance
Efficiency Minimise inefficiencies
Effectiveness High capability and competency
Innovation Connecting disparate worlds
![Page 9: TheMysteryIngredient - files.meetup.com Ingredient.pdf · , , ,, 1 TheMysteryIngredient Cai,Kjaer,,April,2012, Presented,at,the,KMLF,in,Melbourne,](https://reader034.vdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022052019/60330486ba6fa04e9666a4b1/html5/thumbnails/9.jpg)
www.optimice.com.au 9
Efficiency: Hierarchies and Speed
• Command and Control vs Side-‐ways collaboration
What’s good/bad about
hierarchies?
![Page 10: TheMysteryIngredient - files.meetup.com Ingredient.pdf · , , ,, 1 TheMysteryIngredient Cai,Kjaer,,April,2012, Presented,at,the,KMLF,in,Melbourne,](https://reader034.vdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022052019/60330486ba6fa04e9666a4b1/html5/thumbnails/10.jpg)
www.optimice.com.au 10
High Trust = High Speed
UK Facilities Manager: Trust Index = 32% (n = 762) Private Sector Rail Engineers: Trust Index = 24% (n = 74)
International Petroleum: Trust Index = 14% (n = 644) Australian Engineering Trust IndexTrust Index =
18% (n = 231)
![Page 11: TheMysteryIngredient - files.meetup.com Ingredient.pdf · , , ,, 1 TheMysteryIngredient Cai,Kjaer,,April,2012, Presented,at,the,KMLF,in,Melbourne,](https://reader034.vdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022052019/60330486ba6fa04e9666a4b1/html5/thumbnails/11.jpg)
www.optimice.com.au 11
Efficiency – reaching out
• How fast does information and knowledge flow between BUs?
![Page 12: TheMysteryIngredient - files.meetup.com Ingredient.pdf · , , ,, 1 TheMysteryIngredient Cai,Kjaer,,April,2012, Presented,at,the,KMLF,in,Melbourne,](https://reader034.vdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022052019/60330486ba6fa04e9666a4b1/html5/thumbnails/12.jpg)
www.optimice.com.au 12
Efficiency: Are you receiving more than you are giving?
Value Sink RECEIVES more
than it gives
-‐200
-‐150
-‐100
-‐50
0
50
100
Value Source GIVES more than
it receives
Give/Receive BALANCE
What’s good/bad about sources and sinks?
![Page 13: TheMysteryIngredient - files.meetup.com Ingredient.pdf · , , ,, 1 TheMysteryIngredient Cai,Kjaer,,April,2012, Presented,at,the,KMLF,in,Melbourne,](https://reader034.vdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022052019/60330486ba6fa04e9666a4b1/html5/thumbnails/13.jpg)
www.optimice.com.au 13
Efficiency: Health Innovation Network
“In the last 12 months who did you go to for new ideas or innovative solutions to a challenge you were working?”
Program Office
![Page 14: TheMysteryIngredient - files.meetup.com Ingredient.pdf · , , ,, 1 TheMysteryIngredient Cai,Kjaer,,April,2012, Presented,at,the,KMLF,in,Melbourne,](https://reader034.vdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022052019/60330486ba6fa04e9666a4b1/html5/thumbnails/14.jpg)
www.optimice.com.au 14
Efficiency: Health Innovation Network
Program Office X
“In the last 12 months who did you go to for new ideas or innovative solutions to a challenge you were working?”
![Page 15: TheMysteryIngredient - files.meetup.com Ingredient.pdf · , , ,, 1 TheMysteryIngredient Cai,Kjaer,,April,2012, Presented,at,the,KMLF,in,Melbourne,](https://reader034.vdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022052019/60330486ba6fa04e9666a4b1/html5/thumbnails/15.jpg)
www.optimice.com.au 15
Organisational Performance -‐ Effectiveness
![Page 16: TheMysteryIngredient - files.meetup.com Ingredient.pdf · , , ,, 1 TheMysteryIngredient Cai,Kjaer,,April,2012, Presented,at,the,KMLF,in,Melbourne,](https://reader034.vdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022052019/60330486ba6fa04e9666a4b1/html5/thumbnails/16.jpg)
www.optimice.com.au 16
Effectiveness: Working…
• Experts are colored RED
0%('!1"22!
QQQP*NE-D-)'P)*DP$%! d! !
A*Q!-(I-C-I%$MH!-(E'&$)E!$(I!)*MM$G*&$E'!-(!
'DNM*B-(K!EA'-&!-(I-C-I%$M!)*DN'E'()'P!!
! ! ! ! !
!
`-K%&'!1!a!9&K$(-H$E-*($M!)*DN'E'()Bf)$N$G-M-EB!
:H!-MM%HE&$E'I!-(!`-K%&'!1L!E&$I-E-*($M!E*N!I*Q(!
)*DN'E'()B!$NN&*$)A'H!)$((*E!'JNM-)-EMB!
I-FF'&'(E-$E'!G'EQ''(!9&K$(-H$E-*(!:!$(I!
9&K$(-H$E-*(!3P!<A'!F*MM*Q-(K!D$N!N&*C-I'H!$(!
'J$DNM'!*F!$!)*DN'E'()B!D$N!EA$E!-I'(E-F-'H!
I-H)-NM-('!)M%HE'&H!F*&!$!D$/*&!N'E&*M'%D!
)*DN$(BP!6*I'!)*M*%&H!-(I-)$E'!I-FF'&'(E!
)*DN'E'()-'HP!R'(H-E-'H!-(I-)$E'!HE&'(KEA!*F!
)$N$G-M-EB!-(!$!I-H)-NM-('P!
!
!
`-K%&'!c!a!R-H)-NM-('f,$N$G-M-EB!('EQ*&+!D$N!
@H-(K!86:!E')A(-O%'H!Q'!)$(!)A**H'!E*!D'$H%&'!
EA'!)*((')E'I('HH!G'EQ''(!-(I-C-I%$MH!HA$&-(K!
H-D-M$&!I-H)-NM-('HL!A*Q'C'&!Q'!)A**H'!E*!I'F-('!
EA'DP!9%&!N&'F'&'()'!-H!E*!-I'(E-FB!&')-N&*)$M!
M-(+H!*(MB!$(I!EA'(!D'$H%&'!EA'!I'(H-EB!*F!EA'!
&'H%ME-(K!I-H)-NM-('!G$H'I!)M%HE'&HP!!
<A'!$NN&*$)A!)$(!G'!%H'I!-(!)*()'&E!Q-EA!E*N!
I*Q(!E')A(-O%'H!GB!D'$H%&-(K!EA'!
)*((')E'I('HH!*F!-(I-C-I%$MH!QA*!HA$&'!E*N!I*Q(!
-I'(E-F-'I!)*DN'E'()-'HP!`*&!'J$DNM'L!-F!$(!
*&K$(-H$E-*(!-H!K*-(K!EA&*%KA!$!D$/*&!E&$(H-E-*(!-E!
D-KAE!M-+'!E*!+(*Q!A*Q!Q'MM!)*((')E'I!HE$FF!
&$E'I!Q-EA!A-KA!^)A$(K'!$K-M-EB\!-(!$!#*D-(K'&!
H%&C'B!$&'P!5DN&*C'I!'FF')E-C'('HH!)*%MI!
EA'&'F*&'!G'!$)A-'C'I!GB!F$)-M-E$E-(K!$!E-KAE!
)*DD%(-EB!*F!A-KA!^)A$(K'!$K-M-EB\!HE$FFP!
5669_:<596!
<A'!EA-&I!)*&'!G%H-('HH!*G/')E-C'!-I'(E-F-'I!GB!
R$C'(N*&E!$(I!Y&%H$+!-H!5((*C$E-*(P!
9&K$(-H$E-*(H!)$(!G'!'FF')E-C'!$(I!'FF-)-'(EL!G%E!
Q-EA*%E!&'('Q-(K!-EH!N&*I%)E!*&!H'&C-)'H!N*&EF*M-*L!
-EH!M*(K'&aE'&D!H%))'HH!Q-MM!G'!O%'HE-*($GM'P!!
9%EN%E!D'$H%&'H!*F!-((*C$E-*(!$&'!EBN-)$MMB!
)*%)A'I!-(!E'&DH!*F!EA'!M'C'M!*F!H%))'HHF%M!('Q!
N&*I%)EH!*&!H'&C-)'H!M$%()A'IP!<&$I-E-*($M!E*N!
I*Q(!$NN&*$)A'H!E*!-((*C$E-*(!'DNM*B!EA'!^-I'$!
F%(('M\L!QA'&'!GB!-I'$H!$&'!H*M-)-E'I!F&*D!HE$FFL!*&!
&'H'$&)A!-H!)*(I%)E'I!GB!EA'!4gR!I-C-H-*(P!
?$($K'D'(E!^K$E'H\!$&'!'HE$GM-HA'I!E*!O%$M-FB!
-I'$H!$H!EA'B!$&'!I'C'M*N'I!*C'&!E-D'P!6'Q!
N&*I%)EH!*&!H'&C-)'H!$&'!-I'$H!EA$E!H%&C-C'!EA'!
&'C-'Q!K$E'H!$(I!'D'&K'!EA&*%KA!EA'!F%(('M!F*&!
-DNM'D'(E$E-*(P!<A'!N&*)'HH!-H!M$&K'MB!M-('$&!$(I!
M'C'MH!*F!)*MM$G*&$E-C'!I'C'M*ND'(E!EBN-)$MMB!*(MB!
F$)-M-E$E'I!EA&*%KA!H'(-*&!D$($K'D'(EP!
<A'!M-D-E$E-*(!*F!EA-H!E&$I-E-*($M!$NN&*$)A!A$H!
G''(!'JN*H'I!-(!EA'!D*I'&(!')*(*DB!GB!EA'!
M'C'M!*F!D$&+'E!-((*C$E-*(H!G'-(K!H*%&)'I!F&*D!
(*(aE&$I-E-*($M!H*%&)'HP!;HE$GM-HA'I!
*&K$(-H$E-*(H!$&'!(*!M*(K'&!&'MB-(K!*(!EA'-&!
-(E'&($M!4gR!F$)-M-E-'H!$H!EA'-&!D$/*&!H*%&)'!*F!
-((*C$E-*(H!$(I!$&'!(*Q!$)E-C'MB!H*%&)-(K!('Q!
-I'$H!$(I!I'C'M*ND'(EH!F&*D!*%EH-I'!EA'-&!F-&DHP!!
<A-H!9N'(!5((*C$E-*(!$NN&*$)A!-H!G'-(K!A'&$MI'I!
$H!EA'!D$/*&!-((*C$E-*(!-(!EA'!-((*C$E-*(!N&*)'HH!
-EH'MFP!9N'(!5((*C$E-*(!-H!$!('EQ*&+'I!$NN&*$)A!
E*!-((*C$E-*(P!5E!-H!EA'&'F*&'!(*E!H%&N&-H-(K!EA$E!
86:!A$H!$!&*M'!E*!NM$BP!<&$I-E-*($M!-((*C$E-*(!
$NN&*$)A'H!NM$)'!M-('!D$($K'D'(E!-(!EA'!&*M'!*F!
-((*C$E-*(!F$)-M-E$E*&P!<A'!&'H'$&)A!*F!Y&*F'HH*&!
4*(!3%&E!F&*D!EA'!@(-C'&H-EB!*F!,A-)$K*!$(I!
*EA'&H!A$C'!-(I-)$E'I!EA$E!H%))'HHF%M!-((*C$E-*(H!
$&'!D*&'!&'K%M$&MB!F$)-M-E$E'I!GB!*&K$(-H$E-*($M!
G&*+'&H!EA$E!HN$(!HE&%)E%&$M!A*M'H!-(!EA'!
*&K$(-H$E-*(P!='!A$C'!G%-ME!*%&!*Q(!D*I'M!F*&!
-((*C$E-*(!G$H'I!*(!('EQ*&+-(K!N&-()-NM'HL!QA-)A!
Q'!)$MM!\EA'!c;\H!*F!-((*C$E-*(\b!
!"#$"%&"'()*%($"+&"#,)
-./+'"#+,"0')1) -./+'"#+,"0')2)
• *+3()'435(.)06)#%($"+&"#,#)+'7)#+3()"'7"8"74+&)#9"&&)&(8(&#)+'7)(:%(."('$(;)• <="$=)0./+'"#+,"0')=+#),=()#,.0'/(#,)$+%+5"&",>?)
What’s good? What’s bad?
![Page 17: TheMysteryIngredient - files.meetup.com Ingredient.pdf · , , ,, 1 TheMysteryIngredient Cai,Kjaer,,April,2012, Presented,at,the,KMLF,in,Melbourne,](https://reader034.vdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022052019/60330486ba6fa04e9666a4b1/html5/thumbnails/17.jpg)
www.optimice.com.au 17
![Page 18: TheMysteryIngredient - files.meetup.com Ingredient.pdf · , , ,, 1 TheMysteryIngredient Cai,Kjaer,,April,2012, Presented,at,the,KMLF,in,Melbourne,](https://reader034.vdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022052019/60330486ba6fa04e9666a4b1/html5/thumbnails/18.jpg)
www.optimice.com.au 18
Effectiveness – How exposed are you?
Lose the 12% most connected people and you lose 50% of relationships.
![Page 19: TheMysteryIngredient - files.meetup.com Ingredient.pdf · , , ,, 1 TheMysteryIngredient Cai,Kjaer,,April,2012, Presented,at,the,KMLF,in,Melbourne,](https://reader034.vdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022052019/60330486ba6fa04e9666a4b1/html5/thumbnails/19.jpg)
www.optimice.com.au 19
Over to you…what’s your profile?
![Page 20: TheMysteryIngredient - files.meetup.com Ingredient.pdf · , , ,, 1 TheMysteryIngredient Cai,Kjaer,,April,2012, Presented,at,the,KMLF,in,Melbourne,](https://reader034.vdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022052019/60330486ba6fa04e9666a4b1/html5/thumbnails/20.jpg)
www.optimice.com.au 20
![Page 21: TheMysteryIngredient - files.meetup.com Ingredient.pdf · , , ,, 1 TheMysteryIngredient Cai,Kjaer,,April,2012, Presented,at,the,KMLF,in,Melbourne,](https://reader034.vdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022052019/60330486ba6fa04e9666a4b1/html5/thumbnails/21.jpg)
www.optimice.com.au 21
Innovation: Will new ideas be supported by management
![Page 22: TheMysteryIngredient - files.meetup.com Ingredient.pdf · , , ,, 1 TheMysteryIngredient Cai,Kjaer,,April,2012, Presented,at,the,KMLF,in,Melbourne,](https://reader034.vdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022052019/60330486ba6fa04e9666a4b1/html5/thumbnails/22.jpg)
www.optimice.com.au 22
Innovation: 3 Es of Innovation
Explore
Engage Exploit
Identify brokers across disparate network clusters to assist in
introducing new ideas / inventions
Facilitate engagement with the core network
players
Use the cohesive core to exploit innovation
opportunities
![Page 23: TheMysteryIngredient - files.meetup.com Ingredient.pdf · , , ,, 1 TheMysteryIngredient Cai,Kjaer,,April,2012, Presented,at,the,KMLF,in,Melbourne,](https://reader034.vdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022052019/60330486ba6fa04e9666a4b1/html5/thumbnails/23.jpg)
www.optimice.com.au 23
Innovation Analysis
The 3E’s Model of Innovation views innovation from a ‘networks’ perspective. It promotes the view that successful innovations result from ideas traversing the network of Explorers,
Engagers and Exploiters within organisations
![Page 24: TheMysteryIngredient - files.meetup.com Ingredient.pdf · , , ,, 1 TheMysteryIngredient Cai,Kjaer,,April,2012, Presented,at,the,KMLF,in,Melbourne,](https://reader034.vdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022052019/60330486ba6fa04e9666a4b1/html5/thumbnails/24.jpg)
www.optimice.com.au 24
My own ‘disconnected’ worlds
LinkedIn (Inmaps)
Twitter (NodeXL)
![Page 25: TheMysteryIngredient - files.meetup.com Ingredient.pdf · , , ,, 1 TheMysteryIngredient Cai,Kjaer,,April,2012, Presented,at,the,KMLF,in,Melbourne,](https://reader034.vdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022052019/60330486ba6fa04e9666a4b1/html5/thumbnails/25.jpg)
www.optimice.com.au 25
![Page 26: TheMysteryIngredient - files.meetup.com Ingredient.pdf · , , ,, 1 TheMysteryIngredient Cai,Kjaer,,April,2012, Presented,at,the,KMLF,in,Melbourne,](https://reader034.vdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022052019/60330486ba6fa04e9666a4b1/html5/thumbnails/26.jpg)
www.optimice.com.au 26
Resources
• Reading material – www.optimice.com.au/publications.php
– The Hidden Power of Social Networks
• Trying out – NodeXL (free)
– ONA Surveys
• Training • Consulting
![Page 27: TheMysteryIngredient - files.meetup.com Ingredient.pdf · , , ,, 1 TheMysteryIngredient Cai,Kjaer,,April,2012, Presented,at,the,KMLF,in,Melbourne,](https://reader034.vdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022052019/60330486ba6fa04e9666a4b1/html5/thumbnails/27.jpg)
www.optimice.com.au 27
Key Take-‐Aways
• Relationships are a key differentiator. • Become more resilient:
– Efficiency: Optimise your relationship interfaces -‐ are they out of balance?
– Effectiveness: Build connected competence. It is more than the sum of the individuals
– Innovation: Use your relationships wisely to generate ideas and get them implemented
• Download from www.optimice.com.au: – Bringing Social Network Analysis into Mainstream Business
– 3Es of Innovation • Contact me
– Twitter @caikjaer
![Page 28: TheMysteryIngredient - files.meetup.com Ingredient.pdf · , , ,, 1 TheMysteryIngredient Cai,Kjaer,,April,2012, Presented,at,the,KMLF,in,Melbourne,](https://reader034.vdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022052019/60330486ba6fa04e9666a4b1/html5/thumbnails/28.jpg)
www.optimice.com.au 28
KMLF Twitter Map
• Map based on ‘follow’ between people who tweeted using the #KMLF hashtag during the session.