the swedish crime harm index (schi)...• ratcliffe, jerry h. 2014. towards an index for...
TRANSCRIPT
1
May-Britt Rinaldo Ronnebro, MSt
Superintendent, National Police, Sweden
The Swedish Crime Harm Index (SCHI)
2
May-Britt Rinaldo
Research Objective
• Comparing Crime Hot Spot versus Crime Harm Spots in a
Swedish City: A descriptive research study.
3
May-Britt Rinaldo
Research Method and Design
• Identify all crimes in Gothenburg City
• Identify crimes against the person in public place and
cluster these crimes onto the Gothenburg City map by
location
• Create the ”Swedish Crime Harm Index”
• Assess all crimes against the person in public place with
the Swedish CHI and cluster the Swedish CHI by location
onto the Gothenburg City map
• Comparing Crime Hot Spots with Crime Harm Spots
4
May-Britt Rinaldo
Crime Data Gothenburg City 2014
38,351 All crimes recorded in RAR
953 All reported crimes against the person in public place
according to the official decision
2,717 recorded crimes against the person in
public place
87 Misclassified
2,630 Crimes against the person in public place
5
May-Britt Rinaldo
Officially 16 Crime Classification Codes
generated 953 violent crimes against the
Person in Public Place
”The Offical
Recording”
Population: 123,594
38,351 Crimes reported
in RAR
953 Violent Crimes
8 Frequent Crime
Addresses
11-25 Violent Crime/
Address during the
period of 12 months
6
May-Britt Rinaldo
2,717 Crimes against person in public
place – Extended Recording
Extended Recording
based on information
from RAR and
presented by Hobit
1.5
In total 74 Crime
Classification Codes
including the 16 official
4 Hot Spots Addresses
25 High Crime
Addresses
7
May-Britt Rinaldo
Crime Harm Index
• The Cambridge Crime Harm Index (CHI) and the US Index for Harm-Focused Policing
uses sentencing policy (Guidelines) to assign a “weight” of severity to each offence
type. It then creates an index based on prison days.
• The Canadian Police Reported Crime Severity Index (SCI) and the Western Australian
Crime Harm Index (WACHI) uses sentences from courts for each crime type to creating
the index based on prison days.
• The Swedish Crime Harm Index is based on estimated sentence for each crime
that the offender can spend in prison. (Guiding verdicts from the Court of Appeal
and precedents the Supreme Court)
• The Danish Crime Harm Index is based on the Director of Public Prosecutions (DPP)
specifying what sentence the prosecutor should ask for in court when having a first time
offender charged without mitigation or aggravating factors.
• These Indexes can be calculated within societies or cities over time, across areas within
cities, and across offenders and victims in their individual crime histories.
8
May-Britt Rinaldo
The ”Swedish Crime Harm Index” (Guiding verdicts from the Court of Appeal and
precedents the Supreme Court)
Crime
Code
Crime Description F/S/C Days
SCHI
Y.M.D
Lowest
Y.M.D
Highest
Y.M.D
0312 Murder, manslaughter or assault
with a fatal outcome with the use of
firearms against woman
6570 18.00.00 18 Years 18 Years
0357 Physical abuse, other than gross,
against man 18 years or older,
unfamiliar with the victim, outdoor
C 60 00.02.00 2 Months 2 Months
0441 Unlawful persecution of boy under
18 “Stalking”
292 00.09.22 6 Months 1 Year
9806 Robbery against an individual, not
functional impairment, under 18
years, without firearms, outdoor
(Mugging)
365 01.00.00 1 Year 1 Year
5 judges, Inter-rater reliability:
Pearson correlations ranging from r = .966 to .994
9
May-Britt Rinaldo
Crime Harm Locations in Gothenburg City
10
May-Britt Rinaldo
Järntorget
Brunnsparken
Drottningtorget
Drottningtorget 5
Heden
Andra Långgatan
Slottsskogen
Nils Ericsson Terminalen
Kungsportavenyn
Drottningstorget Götgatan
Lilla Bommen
Vasagatan
Norra Hamngatan
11
May-Britt Rinaldo
Comparison Crime Harm – Hot Spots
no yes
Count 0 28 28
% within CHI _top 5%0,0% 100,0% 100,0%
% within HOT
SPOT_top_5%0,0% 50,0% 31,8%
Count 32 28 60
% within CHI _top 5%53,3% 46,7% 100,0%
% within HOT
SPOT_top_5%100,0% 50,0% 68,2%
Total Count 32 56 88
HOT SPOTS top 5% locations
Total
CHI_ top
5%
location
no
yes
A sole focus on CHI would
miss 53% of hot spots
A sole focus on
hot spots would
miss 50% of CHI
spots
12
May-Britt Rinaldo
Summary of Findings
• 2,630 crimes against the person in public place
• Swedish Crime Harm Index: 333,871 prison days
• 60 locations make up for nearly half the crime harm (154649 days =
46,3 %) (= top 5% of CHI Harm per location)
• Number of crimes in these top 5% locations ranges from 1 – 45.
• The top 60 CHI spots include the 4 locations that are also hot spots:
– The highest hotspot is also the highest harm spot,
– Two hotspots within the top 1% of CHI spots, 1 hot spot is in the top 2% of CHI
spots.
• A sole focus on Hot Spots would miss 50% of CHI spots
• A sole focus on CHI would miss 53% of hot spots
13
May-Britt Rinaldo
Implication and
Implementation
• Research – Stockholm (2016)
and Malmö (2018)
• Municipality of Helsingborg (2017)
• Establishment of the WACHI
(2018)
• Establishment of the DCHI (2018)
• Expected establishment of Hong
Kong Crime Harm Index (2019)
15
May-Britt Rinaldo
References
• Babyak, Colin, Matarazzo, Anthony, Turner, John and Wallace, Marnie, 2009.
Measuring Crime in Canada: Introducing the Crime Severity Index and Improvements to
the Uniform Crime Reporting Survey. Canadian Centre for Justice Statistics.
• Sherman, L.W., Neyroud, P.W. and Neyroud, E.C., 2013. The Cambridge Crime Harm
Index (CHI) Measuring total harm from crime based on sentencing guidelines,
Cambridge.
• Ratcliffe, Jerry H. 2014. Towards an Index for Harm-Focused Policing”. Oxford
University Press.
• Rinaldo, M-B. V. (2016). Comparing crime hotspots and crime harm-spots in a Swedish
City: a descriptive analysis. University of Cambridge, UK.
• Forsner, Lisa, 2016. Minska brottslighet och öka trygghet. Om att uppnå Polisens två
kriminalpolitiska mål med samma medel. Lunds Universitet, Rättssociologiska
institutionen
• Aagaard Andersen, H. and Mueller-Johnson, K., 2018. The Danish Crime Harm Index:
How It Works and Why It Matters, Camb J Evid Based Polic
https://doi.org/10.1007/s41887-018-0021-7
• House P. D. and Neyroud, P. W. 2018. Developing a Crime Harm Index for Western
Australia: the WACHI https://link.springer.com/article/10.1007/s41887-018-0022-6