the future of work
TRANSCRIPT
All rights reserved, May 2, 2016
THE FUTURE OF WORK
SWEDEN’S SIX HOUR WORKDAY
This year Sweden started on a little experiment that could have a dramatic impact on our world. The way we work, play, live, love, everything. In a bid to increase productivity and increase happiness, the country is experimenting with a 6 hour work day.
Responses to this move range from dismissive “Not for us” to skeptical “Will it work?” to militant “What are they doing to the moral fabric of society?”
ICE, All rights reserved, May 2, 2016
This report explores the before and after of such an idea, the context and implications. It will look at why this is an idea whose time has come and what kind of steps others who seek to emulate it (and even Sweden itself) will need to keep in mind in such an effort.
To understand the move will require us to go back a few hundred years to the industrial revolution, grapple with notions of work and its role in society. How this history is in conflict with the new realities of today’s technology and the information economy. And arrive at a sense of how we would like to shape the future..
THE FUTURE OF WORK
ICE, All rights reserved, May 2, 2016
WHAT IS WORK?
The Fordist paradigm
Alternativeparadigms
UBERFICATIONOF PROCESSES
ChangingWork processes
Company side(Uber)
People side(FOSS, Wikipedia)
RECASTINGOF WORK
Implications?
from Need to Choice
New Systems
21 Hours
Universal Basic Income
THE FUTURE OF WORK
TOMORROW’S TECHNOLOGY
ICT, Computing,AI, Robotics
Automation of Blue Collar andWhite Collar Jobs
ICE, All rights reserved, May 2, 2016
Our story begins about a hundred years ago.
While the industrial revolution of the 18th and
19th centuries made drastic changes to the way
work was carried out, it is in the early part of the
20th century that we see ideas of FW Taylor’s
Scientific Management get entrenched at the
workplace. And more so in the factories of Henry
Ford than anywhere else.
ICE, All rights reserved, May 2, 2016
FORD’S 8 HOUR WORKDAY
In 1925, Henry Ford, in a bid to improve
productivity and also reduce employee turnover,
absenteeism and the accident rate, cut the
working day to 8 hours, and the work week to 5
days. And doubled the wages, while at it.
Other manufacturers were forced to follow suit—
leading to the institutionalization of the 40-hour
work week.
It led to improvement in workers’ health and
productivity. Their rising affluence allowed them to
actually buy the cars (and other goods) they were
making.
Thus was created the consumption-driven American economic system, which has now found resonance and adoption
throughout the world. ICE, All rights reserved, May 2, 2016
The Fordist paradigm of work is first and foremost productive
Work creates or increases value.
It shapes raw material,
cultivates crops, dams rivers to
produce electricity. It moves
things to where they are useful.
ICE, All rights reserved, May 2, 2016
Work as a means to an End
Work is a means to earn money
or status or other benefits. Work
may be mindless, boring, painful,
dangerous, but can be and is
done since it pays for a living or
allows for other benefits.
ICE, All rights reserved, May 2, 2016
Work, in this paradigm, is also a means of keeping people consuming and the economy running
Work. Earn. Consume.
Economy grows, Earnings rise. Consume more. People's worth is
measured by the market value of their labor.
Any threat to this order of things is quickly dispensed with. Policy
is modified and tweaked and bent over backwards to ensure this
system is strengthened and unthreatened. People are kept in this
state of work in order to keep the economy running.
ICE, All rights reserved, May 2, 2016
But work can be more than a means to an end.Work can be a pleasure in itself. It may be seen as a duty, or simply a part of being part of a society.
In his book The Craftsman, Richard Sennet describes people who are driven more often by the
pleasure of their craft than the reward at the end. Another popular example is the Slow Food
movement which highlights the pleasure in making food and talking rather than food quickly
prepared for consumption.
ICE, All rights reserved, May 2, 2016
CURIOSITY / SELF EXPRESSION
Work might be the pursuit of a curiosity or a mode of self expression. And decoupled from monetary reward, a means of building character.
“Character is formed primarily by a man's work.
And work, properly conducted in conditions of
human dignity and freedom, blesses those who
do it.”
EF Schumacher
ICE, All rights reserved, May 2, 2016
WORK AS PLAY *
Similar to the idea of Sennet’s Craftsman, but as opposed to the seriousness of the craftsman’s exploration, play is activity for it’s own sake.The best examples are of course children who are
very serious about their play. But some adults, the
most creative ones are also often ‘playing’ a great
deal.
* Not to be confused with the modern sports
professional where in fact Play as Work.
ICE, All rights reserved, May 2, 2016
WORK AS SOCIABILITY
Work may also function out of a simple sense of society. eg When an accident victim is taken to hospital by people nearby. When a parent bathes a child. When we help out.
That we look out for each other as humans, that
we feed each other, clean each other may not be
classified as work, but is far more important and
valuable and significant.
ICE, All rights reserved, May 2, 2016
WHAT IS WORK?
The Fordist paradigm
Alternativeparadigms
UBERFICATIONOF PROCESSES
ChangingWork processes
Company side(Uber)
People side(FOSS, Wikipedia)
RECASTINGOF WORK
Implications?
from Need to Choice
New Systems
21 Hours
Universal Basic Income
THE FUTURE OF WORK
TOMORROW’S TECHNOLOGY
ICT, Computing,AI, Robotics
Automation of Blue Collar andWhite Collar Jobs
ICE, All rights reserved, May 2, 2016
Two important developments of the last 30 years are recasting our notions of work.
One, the advancement of IT enables truly automatic tasks and processes.
Two, the Internet of Things. As more and more of these machines, robots and people get connected to and communicate with each other, it enables coordination and targeted delivery at a planetary scale.
The combination of these two allow for hitherto unimagined possibilities.
ICE, All rights reserved, May 2, 2016
Computer programs can write newspaper articles and even stories of
a passable quality.
Self Driving Cars: Activity which was considered extremely complex and
therefore human now being automated.
Robotic melon pickers, that can judge ripeness of fruit by smell. Similarly robots
to spray pesticide and fertilizers; Robot shearers tested in Australia.
Complex Supply Chains integrated and managed by software
ICE, All rights reserved, May 2, 2016
Earlier, manual labour was being replaced by machines,
Today’s computers and robots can supplant white-collar work
and complex activities like diagnosis, trading and writing.
Where they don’t completely do the work, they can perform
large chunks of tasks, drastically reducing the number of
people required overall.
Deloitte expects cognitive technologies embedded in products
to provide “intelligent” behavior, natural interfaces (such
speech and visual), and automation. The impact of product
applications on workers ranges from none (robotic toys or
intelligent thermostats), to marginal (robotic vacuum cleaners
may reduce hours demanded of house cleaners), to
significant.
ICE, All rights reserved, May 2, 2016
“People are racing against the machine in media and music, finance and manufacturing, retailing and trade, in short, in every industry. And losing.”Erik Brynjolfsson
The advent of an increasingly
machine run world is one which
humans will finding increasingly
difficult to cope with.
ICE, All rights reserved, May 2, 2016
The use of technology and automation is only speeding up at a rapid
pace. Carl Benedikt Frey and Michael Osborne, in ‘The Future of
Employment: How Susceptible Are Jobs to Computerization’ expect about
half of present jobs to be automated in the next two decades (by 2035).
Gartner forecasts that “one in three jobs will be taken by software or
robots by 2025.”
ABB’s CEO expects European unemployment expected to rise from the
present 10 to 20 or 25 percent in the next decade. The Wall Street
Journal expects corporate re-engineering to eliminate between 1 million
and 2.5 million jobs a year across the entire U.S. economy, for the
foreseeable future.
90% 2.5milOf Jobs replaced by smart
machines by 2030Jobs eliminated in the US every year
by corporate re-engineering
ICE, All rights reserved, May 2, 2016
WHAT IS WORK?
The Fordist paradigm
Alternativeparadigms
UBERFICATIONOF PROCESSES
ChangingWork processes
Company side(Uber)
People side(FOSS, Wikipedia)
RECASTINGOF WORK
Implications?
from Need to Choice
New Systems
21 Hours
Universal Basic Income
THE FUTURE OF WORK
TOMORROW’S TECHNOLOGY
ICT, Computing,AI, Robotics
Automation of Blue Collar andWhite Collar Jobs
ICE, All rights reserved, May 2, 2016
The Internet enables Innovative means of work organization:It is possible now to break up work into tiny tasks that can be performed by people in different parts of the world.
ICE, All rights reserved, May 2, 2016
The Free and Open Source Software movement, which gave us Linux and Wikipedia, is one of the most significant examples of a distributed model of work enabled by the internet.
People across the world connected by the Internet, are able to collaborate and contribute to the creation of something that is useful for millions.The work is done free or occasionally paid a honorarium, it is done at programmers own time, as much as they wish to or can contribute.
ICE, All rights reserved, May 2, 2016
This gives people a lot more flexibility, allowing
different work-life-play balances and dynamics.
People (both companies and individuals) looking to
more ethical ways of being and functioning (green,
sharing, voluntarism/open source models, sourcing
of materials and labor etc) are enabled by this
network.
These then also allow us to imagine alternatives to
the big business model of work.. For instance, the
Exchange economies that were popular during the
aftermath of the 2008 crisis.
ICE, All rights reserved, May 2, 2016
Companies too are outsourcing more and more work to contractors. Like Uber’s ‘independent contractors’ who are summoned and used as and when required, and are kept on standby forever
ICE, All rights reserved, May 2, 2016
While Uber itself will likely shift to completely
automated vehicles and not need drivers, more
and more organizations will adopt an Uber-like
reliance on contract and on-demand workers.
This will result in and be facilitated by an
increasingly large self-employed workforce. Self-
employed will thus likely be the largest section in
the workforce of the future.
This leads to the emergence of micro-task
economies. So "workers" cease to exist in the
same big masses. Even turn invisible.
ICE, All rights reserved, May 2, 2016
WHAT IS WORK?
The Fordist paradigm
Alternativeparadigms
UBERFICATIONOF PROCESSES
ChangingWork processes
Company side(Uber)
People side(FOSS, Wikipedia)
RECASTINGOF WORK
Implications?
from Need to Choice
New Systems
21 Hours
Universal Basic Income
THE FUTURE OF WORK
TOMORROW’S TECHNOLOGY
ICT, Computing,AI, Robotics
Automation of Blue Collar andWhite Collar Jobs
ICE, All rights reserved, May 2, 2016
Imagine an economy in which 1 percent own the machines, 10 per cent manage their operation, and 90 per cent either do the remaining scraps of ‘unautomatable’ work, or are unemployed.
This may seem like a proposition that the 1 percent find appealing, but the very economics that got us to this point where this can happen tells you otherwise. “The reality is that the free market economy, as we understand it today, simply cannot work without a viable labor market. Jobs are the primary mechanism through which income—and, therefore, purchasing power—is distributed to the people who consume everything the economy produces. If at some point, machines are likely to permanently take over a great deal of the work now performed by human beings, then that will be a threat to the very foundation of our economic system.
This is not something that will just work itself out. This is something that we need to begin thinking about.”
Martin Ford
ICE, All rights reserved, May 2, 2016
Simply put, machines don’t buy things.And people who don’t have jobs or income will not be able to buy. So what happens to the economy? Will it lead to a global crash, depression, swabs of wealth destroyed across the globe? More important, what happens to people?The impoverishment to large sections of the globe, entire countries going bankrupt; The possibility of civil wars or simple old fashioned genocide that can be ordered by those in charge of the machines make people especially vulnerable.
ICE, All rights reserved, May 2, 2016
FROM needing to work TO choosing to work
It is also possible to envision a happier world. Where people don’t
abandon their vocation for soul sapping means of livelihood. But
rather one where they indulge in what they most truly wish to do,
their calling.
Like John Lanchester suggests, “The robots liberate most of humanity
from work: we don’t have to work in factories or go down mines or
clean toilets or drive long-distance lorries, but we can choreograph
and weave and garden and tell stories and invent things.”
ICE, All rights reserved, May 2, 2016
Once we do away with the need to work, it is possible that we
choose work. Work of the character-building kind. The kind that is
fulfilling and truly human. The play kind. The social kind.
‘Worklessness’, then, is reframed from a problem to solve to an
opportunity to discover what is most truly human about us.
Or in the words of Ernst Fischer:
“As machines become more and more efficient and perfect, so it
will become clear that imperfection is the greatness of man.”
It is in this context that Sweden’s move begins to make sense.
ICE, All rights reserved, May 2, 2016
This will require a paradigm shift in the way we think about the world, the economy, our notions of work and play, our education system, our infrastructure, everything.
ICE, All rights reserved, May 2, 2016
A NEW EDUCATION SYSTEMTo begin with, something as elementary as our
education system. The bulk of the present
system creates workers for factories, and
managers for them.
The future will require more liberal arts, more
pure science, more explorers. It will have space
for people without a formal education , trained
in the world, on farms, in communities,
through travel, through exploring curiosity like
people, used to in the past.
Large scale reform of the education system will
be the first ask of this new world.
ICE, All rights reserved, May 2, 2016
NEW MODELS OF WORK ORGANIZATIONWe will also need to update our policies around
employee relations and organizational structures. We
would do well to consider seriously proposals like the 21
hour work week.
Paul Mason adds that the transition is not just about
economics. It will have to be a human transition. Our
roles as consumers, lovers, communicators are as
important to this as our role at work.
ICE, All rights reserved, May 2, 2016
NEW ECONOMIC PARADIGMSWe will need to move out of the present neo-liberal
paradigm and tend towards more socialist principles like
Universal Basic Income.
What it will allow is the creation of a security that
allows people to pursue things they would rather, than
be forced to do things they do not like. Allowing a much
freer flowering of creativity, exploration and if one were
to be a little optimistic, a little more happiness.
Let us look at two interesting suggestions mooted in the
recent past.
ICE, All rights reserved, May 2, 2016
21 HOUR WORK WEEKThis proposal comes from the New Economic Foundation, a think tank
based in the UK.
NEF suggests that shifting from the current default of the 40 hour work
week to a 21 hour week could help to address a range of urgent,
interlinked problems: overwork, unemployment, over-consumption, high
carbon emissions, low well-being, entrenched inequalities, and the lack
of time to live sustainably, to care for each other, and simply to enjoy life.
The logic of industrial time is out of step with today’s conditions, where
instant communications and mobile technologies bring new risks and
pressures, as well as opportunities. The challenge is to break the power
of the old industrial clock without adding new pressures, and to free up
time to live sustainable lives.
ICE, All rights reserved, May 2, 2016
21 HOUR WORK WEEKThis move would offer several benefits:
Increased social justice and well-being. A 21-hour ‘normal’ working
week could help distribute paid work more evenly across the
population, reducing ill-being associated with unemployment, long
working hours and too little control over time.
More sustainable habits: Work pressures of today make it necessary to
use a number of ‘time saving’ devices, technologies, and habits.
Similarly, the pressure of the work-week ends up making us consume
on weekends, creating an unsustainable ecological situation.
Improving gender relations: It becomes possible to share childcare
equally between two partners
Break the habit of living to work, working to earn, and earning to
consume.
The Swedish experiment is a step in this direction.ICE, All rights reserved, May 2, 2016
UNIVERSAL BASIC INCOMEBut to make any of these earlier proposals feasible or even thinkable,
requires a guarantee of the basics: housing, food, healthcare. We’ll have
to begin by guaranteeing the trio to the entire population. People can
(and will) work for more, but they also will not be compelled any longer
to do things (like David Graeber calls them, bullshit jobs) in order to live.
A basic income will free up people to pursue what they really love.
A two year pilot is to happen in Finland starting next year. 100,000 Finns
could get up to 1,000 euros a month. For this, they will not need to work
or prove they're in poverty. They will simply get a fixed amount to do
with what they will.
Cities in the Netherlands and Canada are also planning pilots with
Universal Basic Income.
ICE, All rights reserved, May 2, 2016
UNIVERSAL BASIC INCOMEThere are several challenges to introducing Universal Basic Income.
Many governments have such lean budgets that they can’t even try doing
this. Besides the cultural resistance against giving away free money to
people for doing nothing would be huge.
It is important to consider the idea not in the context of our current
economy, but in a context British economist Paul Mason calls
Postcapitalist. Mason explains how capitalism isn't as socially productive
as it's traditionally been. In fact, the 2008 crisis would point to the
opposite. One can also see that the nature of the Information Economy
(based on zero marginal cost) is radically different from the economics of
the industrial age that Capitalism is based on.
ICE, All rights reserved, May 2, 2016
Sources:Paul Mason PostCapitalismJeremy Rikin, The End of WorkJuliet B Schor, The Overworked AmericanBertrand Russel, In Praise of IdlenessEF Schumacher, Small is BeautifulMartin Ford, The Lights in the TunnelSebastian de Grazia, Of Time Work and LeisureDeloitte, Redesigning Work in an Era of Cognitive TechnologiesNew Economic Foundation, 21 Hours http://dupress.com/articles/work-redesign-and-cognitive-technology/ fastcoexist http://www.fastcoexist.com/section/the-new-rules-of-work Anti-Work | 21 Hour Work-Week | Post-Work Economy | Universal Basic Income https://theanarchistlibrary.org/library/bob-black-the-abolition-of-work http://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2013/jun/11/neoliberalism-hijacked-vocabulary
Images from: commons.wikimedia.orgflickr.com freeimages.compexels.compixabay.comunsplash.com
ICE, All rights reserved, May 2, 2016
Pagewise Photo Credits:
12 http://www.loc.gov/pictures, pingnews3 http://www.loc.gov/pictures, pingnews 45 ClkerFreeVectorImages6 ClkerFreeVectorImages7 US Dept of Agriculture8 US Dept of Agriculture9 Tim Gouw 1011 Eddy Klaus12 StockSnap13 Wikimedia 1415 BMW 16 kropekk_pl, Google17 BMW18 Amazon19 kaboompics.com20
21 Tim Gouw22 ubuntu23 StockSnap24 Jim Jackson25 Jim Jackson2627 Jim Jackson28 Jim Jackson29 Paul Proshin30 Paul Proshin31 Paul Proshin32 cherylt2333 Rainbow_Loom_und_Nadel34 Tung Wong35 Shanice Garcia36 Shanice Garcia37 Jesse Vermeulen 38 Jesse Vermeulen3940
ICE, All rights reserved, May 2, 2016
Interested in future trends and [email protected] facebook.com/uxtrendspotting@UXTrendspotting
Author: ANAND VIJAYANSupervised by: DEEPA S REDDY