the euro crisis, media coverage, and perceptions of europe ... · (new york, praeger, 1996),...

32
The Euro Crisis, Media Coverage, and Perceptions of Europe within the EU Report on Italy

Upload: vokhanh

Post on 18-Feb-2019

215 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: The Euro Crisis, Media Coverage, and Perceptions of Europe ... · (New York, Praeger, 1996), “Comparing Media Systems. Three Models of Media and Politics” with Dan Hallin (Cambridge

The Euro Crisis, Media Coverage, and

Perceptions of Europe within the EU

Report on Italy

Page 2: The Euro Crisis, Media Coverage, and Perceptions of Europe ... · (New York, Praeger, 1996), “Comparing Media Systems. Three Models of Media and Politics” with Dan Hallin (Cambridge

Project Description How has European news coverage portrayed Europe, European institutions, EU members and the Euro, what does that coverage tell us about Europe, and what are the implications of the way the sovereign debt and banking crises has been covered and portrayed? These are the fundamental questions of this European-wide study led by the Reuters Institute for the Study of Journalism at University of Oxford. This project explores how the Euro Crisis has been portrayed in media in EU countries and how differences in coverage and journalistic practices have affected perceptions of the crisis and Europe. The purpose of the project is to determine how Europeans understand the challenges facing the Euro, and the workings of the European Union and European Central Bank, through the news media of their countries. The research is identifying main themes in coverage, choices of events and personalities covered, the extent and nature of the coverage and the scope and balance of the opinions expressed. It is seeking to identify differences among national coverage patterns and to gauge the effect the coverage has on citizens’ view of the EU and its institutions. The project was conducted by a coalition of partners in Greece, Italy, Spain, Germany, Belgium, Poland, Finland and the United Kingdom

Dipartimento Istituzioni e Società – University of Perugia The partners producing this report teach at the Dipartimento Istituzioni e Società, Università di Perugia and Dipartimento di Scienze politiche e sociali, Università di Bologna. In particular: Paolo Mancini is Professor in the Dipartimento Istituzioni e Società, Università di Perugia. His major publications include "Politics, Media and Modern Democracy" with David Swanson (New York, Praeger, 1996), “Comparing Media Systems. Three Models of Media and Politics” with Dan Hallin (Cambridge University Press, 2004) “Sociologie della comunicazione (with Alberto Abruzzese) (Laterza, 2008); “Elogio della lottizzazione” (Laterza, 2009). Donatella Campus is Associate Professor of Political science in the Department of Political and Social Sciences at the University of Bologna. She is the author L'elettore Pigro (2000); Comunicazione Politica: Le nuove frontiere (2008); Antipolitics in power (2010); Women political leaders and the media (2013). Marco Mazzoni is Assistant Professor of Sociology of Communication in the Dipartimento Istituzioni e Società, Università di Perugia. His major publications include: “Le relazioni pubbliche e il lobbying in Italia” (Laterza, 2010); “Nuovi approcci alla comunicazione politica” with Enrico Caniglia, (Carocci, 2011). Giovanni Barbieri is Assistant Professor of Political Sociology in the Department of Institutions and Society at the University of Perugia. Recent publications include: L’uomo comunitario nella società globalizzata (Rubbettino, 2010); Mutamenti della politica nell’Italia contemporanea (editor, with Roberto Segatori, Rubbettino, 2007); Pareto e il fascismo (FrancoAngeli, 2003). His research interests lie in the areas of globalisation, ethno-regionalist parties, communitarianism.

Page 3: The Euro Crisis, Media Coverage, and Perceptions of Europe ... · (New York, Praeger, 1996), “Comparing Media Systems. Three Models of Media and Politics” with Dan Hallin (Cambridge
Page 4: The Euro Crisis, Media Coverage, and Perceptions of Europe ... · (New York, Praeger, 1996), “Comparing Media Systems. Three Models of Media and Politics” with Dan Hallin (Cambridge

Methods

A content analysis using common methods and coding were implemented by the

partners conducting research in the different countries in the project.

4 newspapers in each country were selected for study: the leading financial/business newspaper, two leading papers representing conservative and liberal views, and the leading tabloid. In the absence of a tabloid, the leading centrist general circulation paper was added. This latter accommodation was included to deal with states that do not have major national tabloids, notably Greece, Italy, and Spain, but have

major papers representing liberal, centrist, and conservative views.

Articles were examined and coded for 26 variables.

Content studied

The research team has identified 11 major developmental periods between 2010 and 2012 and selected coverage beginning 7 days before and ending 7 days after each major development as the content of the study. These inclusive dates are:

February 4-February 18, 2010—EU summit (February 11-12) related to role of

European governments and IMF in any intervention

April 25-May 9, 2010—pegged to Eurozone members and IMF agreement for

100bn euro intervention for Greece (May 2).

December 9-December 23, 2010—pegged to EU Contract change 16

December

July 25-August 18, 2011--ECB asks Italy for more austerity measures (August

5)

September 28-October 12, 2011--pegged to Greek general strike against

austerity measures (October 5)

October 19-November 2, 2011—pegged to EU Summit boosting stability fund,

extending new aid, and requiring banks to raise new capital (Oct. 26-27).

November 5-November 19, 2011—pegged to Berlusconi resignation/Monti

appointment (Nov. 12-13), includes French austerity measures

November 19-November 30, 2011—pegged to EC Green Paper on stability

bonds and proposal to bring national budgets under EC control (Nov 23)

May 16-June 5, 2012—pegged to EU summit (May 23) to boost growth and

balance austerity, attention on Spain, and UK governmental meetings to

protect UK financial system.

June 18-July 5, 2012—Spain formally requests assistance (June 25), Merkel

calls the Eurobonds “economically wrong and counterproductive,” (June 27),

EU Summit on Debt Crisis (June 28-29)

Page 5: The Euro Crisis, Media Coverage, and Perceptions of Europe ... · (New York, Praeger, 1996), “Comparing Media Systems. Three Models of Media and Politics” with Dan Hallin (Cambridge

July 8-July 22, 2012—pegged to Merkel affirmation of need for adherence to

budget targets and European monitoring(July 15)

The selection of these periods was made to focus on periods in which significant contemporary developments led to significant amounts of coverage, analysis, and evaluation of involving the topics under investigation. The decision to use this structured sampling, rather than to sample the entire period of 2010-12, was made to avoid potentially missing coverage of some of the most significant events. Sampling before and after these develops also captures coverage not directly related to events and ensure assessment of weekend editions which have significant and extended commentary and opinion sections in many nations.

Searching content

Data base searches used the terms EURO and CRISIS, or their national linguistic equivalents, in order to maintain commonality. The choice of these terms has been made based on test searches made by all partners that show they gather the largest number of articles and the desire to remove duplication of articles that may occur if additional terms are employed. Because of linguistic and database differences the separate coding using EURO and CRISIS and EUROPE is being employed by the

Spanish team.

Page 6: The Euro Crisis, Media Coverage, and Perceptions of Europe ... · (New York, Praeger, 1996), “Comparing Media Systems. Three Models of Media and Politics” with Dan Hallin (Cambridge

The Euro Crisis, Media Coverage, and

Perceptions of Europe within the EU

Report on ITALY

This reports provide a basic descriptive frequency analysis of the results of the research for Italy. It is based on a content analysis of four newspapers, including the largest business daily, Il Sole 24 Ore; and Corriere della Sera (liberal and largest newspaper), La Repubblica (liberal newspaper) and il Giornale (conservative newspaper). In Italy, there are not tabloid papers.

Number of articles by newspaper

Newspaper number

Frequenza

Percentuale

valida

Il Sole 24 Ore 408 43,1

La Repubblica 202 21,3

Il Giornale 107 11,3

Il Corriere della sera 230 24,3

Totale 947 100,0

Number of articles in each period

IT

11-12 Feb 2010_Eu summit-Role of

EU-Governments and IMF

53

2 May 2010_Agreement on 100bn

intervention in Greece

102

16 December 2010_Change of EU

contract 53

5 August 2011_ECB claims more

austerity measures from Italy

80

5 October 2011_Greek general

strike against austerity measures

46

Page 7: The Euro Crisis, Media Coverage, and Perceptions of Europe ... · (New York, Praeger, 1996), “Comparing Media Systems. Three Models of Media and Politics” with Dan Hallin (Cambridge

26-27 October 2011_EU summit-

Boosting stability fund, extending

new aid

101

12-13 November 2011_Berlusconis

resignation-Montis appointment

104

23 November 2011_EC Green

Paper on stability bonds

91

23 May 2012_EU summit on growth

and balance austerity, attention on

Spain, UK governmental meetings

107

28-29 June 2012_EU summit on

Sovereign Debt Crisis

114

15 July 2012_Merkels affirmation of

need or adherence to budget

targets and European monitoring

96

Totale 947

Genres of stories

Genre

N. %

news story 352 37,2

news analysis or background story 292 30,8

feature story 38 4,0

editorial 12 1,3

opinion/commentary 200 21,1

Interview 44 4,6

other 9 1,0

Total 947 100,0

Page 8: The Euro Crisis, Media Coverage, and Perceptions of Europe ... · (New York, Praeger, 1996), “Comparing Media Systems. Three Models of Media and Politics” with Dan Hallin (Cambridge

What was the impetus for stories?

Story impetus

N. %

event-based 224 23,7

request-based 39 4,1

decision-based 135 14,3

statement/pronouncement-based 91 9,6

market development-based 214 22,6

reports in other media 24 2,5

other 77 8,1

not tied to a specific event or

devolpment 143 15,1

Total 947 100,0

What was the story source?

N. %

domestic-based staff writer 567 59,9

foreign-based staff writer 258 27,2

newspaper itself indicated in the byline as

producing the story

2 ,2

newspaper and news agency jointly indicated as

producing the story

1 ,1

news agency 2 ,2

expert writer 97 10,2

writers affiliation not indicated/non-staff writer 4 ,4

other 7 ,7

Total 938 99,0

no writer/source indicated 9 1,0

Total 947 100,0

On what pages were articles placed?

Page 9: The Euro Crisis, Media Coverage, and Perceptions of Europe ... · (New York, Praeger, 1996), “Comparing Media Systems. Three Models of Media and Politics” with Dan Hallin (Cambridge

Page placement

N. %

1 143 15,1

2 116 12,2

3 79 8,3

4 56 5,9

5 53 5,6

6 49 5,2

7 33 3,5

8 39 4,1

9 33 3,5

10 47 5,0

11 28 3,0

12 32 3,4

13 19 2,0

14 21 2,2

15 16 1,7

16 10 1,1

17 18 1,9

18 8 ,8

19 13 1,4

20 7 ,7

21 8 ,8

22 7 ,7

23 6 ,6

24 12 1,3

25 4 ,4

26 13 1,4

27 7 ,7

28 8 ,8

29 2 ,2

30 5 ,5

31 2 ,2

32 3 ,3

33 1 ,1

34 1 ,1

Page 10: The Euro Crisis, Media Coverage, and Perceptions of Europe ... · (New York, Praeger, 1996), “Comparing Media Systems. Three Models of Media and Politics” with Dan Hallin (Cambridge

35 1 ,1

36 8 ,8

37 5 ,5

38 2 ,2

39 3 ,3

40 1 ,1

41 2 ,2

42 3 ,3

43 2 ,2

44 4 ,4

46 4 ,4

48 1 ,1

49 1 ,1

50 2 ,2

51 1 ,1

52 1 ,1

54 1 ,1

55 1 ,1

56 3 ,3

58 2 ,2

Total 947 100,0

In what sections were articles placed?

No detect

What were the sizes of the articles?

Size of article

N. %

short 226 23,9

medium 605 63,9

long 116 12,2

Total 947 100,0

What types of sources were quoted?

Page 11: The Euro Crisis, Media Coverage, and Perceptions of Europe ... · (New York, Praeger, 1996), “Comparing Media Systems. Three Models of Media and Politics” with Dan Hallin (Cambridge

N. %

a

Officials 5 0,1%

European Union Official 268 5,7%

unnamed European Union Official 22 0,5%

foreign government official 25 0,5%

unnamed foreign government

official 9 0,2%

domestic government official 15 0,3%

unnamed domestic government

official 2 0,0%

national government leaders 28 0,6%

prime minister/president with

executive power 821 17,3%

domestic prime minister/president

with executive power 306 6,5%

other foreign government minister 166 3,5%

other domestic government minister 128 2,7%

national political leaders 12 0,3%

foreign political leader 101 2,1%

domestic political leader 113 2,4%

foreign member of European

Parliament 6 0,1%

domestic member of European

Parliament 1 0,0%

bankers/financiers 28 0,6%

European Central Bank official 170 3,6%

World Bank/International Monetary

Fund 52 1,1%

foreign central bank official 56 1,2%

domestic central bank official 54 1,1%

foreign non-governmental banker or

investment executive 58 1,2%

domestic non-governmental banker

or investment executive 48 1,0%

Economists 9 0,2%

foreign non-governmental

economist 128 2,7%

Page 12: The Euro Crisis, Media Coverage, and Perceptions of Europe ... · (New York, Praeger, 1996), “Comparing Media Systems. Three Models of Media and Politics” with Dan Hallin (Cambridge

domestic non-governmental

economist 74 1,6%

Society representatives 44 0,9%

foreign union leader or employee

representative 7 0,1%

domestic union leader or employee

representative 18 0,4%

foreign think tank, interest group,

NGO 47 1,0%

domestic think tank, interest group,

NGO 11 0,2%

foreign business representative 30 0,6%

domestic business representative 30 0,6%

foreign civil society, social

movement/protester representative 31 0,7%

domestic civil society, social

movement/protester representative 24 0,5%

foreign member of the public 19 0,4%

domestic member of the public 13 0,3%

other 319 6,7%

none 1437 30,3%

Total 4735 100,0%

What specific individuals were quoted as sources?

Page 13: The Euro Crisis, Media Coverage, and Perceptions of Europe ... · (New York, Praeger, 1996), “Comparing Media Systems. Three Models of Media and Politics” with Dan Hallin (Cambridge

N. %

a

Silvio Berlusconi 150 7,5%

José Barroso 81 4,1%

David Cameron 20 1,0%

Mario Draghi 110 5,5%

Francois Holland 77 3,9%

Jean Claude Juncker 54 2,7%

Christine Lagarde 23 1,2%

Angela Merkel 342 17,2%

Mario Monti 218 11,0%

Lucas Papademos 13 0,7%

George A. Papandreou 57 2,9%

Mariano Rajoy 57 2,9%

Herman Van Rompuy 52 2,6%

Olli Rehn 59 3,0%

Nicolas Sarkozy 145 7,3%

Dominique Strauss-Kahn 17 0,9%

Jean-Claude Trichet 69 3,5%

José Zapatero 28 1,4%

Other 418 21,0%

Total 1990 100,0%

What do the articles indicate is the main fundamental roots of the crisis?

Page 14: The Euro Crisis, Media Coverage, and Perceptions of Europe ... · (New York, Praeger, 1996), “Comparing Media Systems. Three Models of Media and Politics” with Dan Hallin (Cambridge

Fundamental root of crisis

N. %

Starting conditions and structure of

the Euro system 19 2,0

Euro was a political project not

based on following economic

fundamentals

5 ,5

Incompatibility of one currency and

fiscal and economic national

sovereignty of nations

5 ,5

Crisis country not ready for Euro

membership in economic and

structural terms

4 ,4

National industrial policies and

developments 1 ,1

Countries’ with major sovereign

debt problems inability to build up

competitive industries

2 ,2

Spain’s construction industry

bubble 3 ,3

National fiscal and social policies 6 ,6

Overall high fiscal debt volume of

all countries 12 1,3

Countries’ with major sovereign

debt problems lax debt policies 13 1,4

Countries’ with major sovereign

debt problems grant social benefits

they cannot afford

4 ,4

Countries’ with major sovereign

debt problems voluptuous state’s

apparatus

6 ,6

Germany’s low budget deficits/lack

of expansion policies 2 ,2

Banks’ and financial institutions’

policies 14 1,5

(national/international) banks

having financed too much of fiscal

and/or private debts

4 ,4

Page 15: The Euro Crisis, Media Coverage, and Perceptions of Europe ... · (New York, Praeger, 1996), “Comparing Media Systems. Three Models of Media and Politics” with Dan Hallin (Cambridge

(national/international) banks

unwillingness to further finance

states debt/industries’ investments

2 ,2

ECB’s loose monetary policy, which

helped to finance states and private

debt

1 ,1

National bank supervisory

authorities’ inability/unwillingness to

control national banks’ behavior

1 ,1

Speculation against the Euro 12 1,3

Speculation against a country with

sovereign debt challenges 9 1,0

Political roots 3 ,3

Unwillingness of nations to transfer

power to the EU 1 ,1

Weakness of the central European

institutions 3 ,3

Different political cultures 3 ,3

Failure of the political class in the

problem countries 12 1,3

Maastricht Treaty 3 ,3

Maastricht Treaty concerning

budget restrictions does not match

economic necessities

1 ,1

ECB’s restriction to avoid

inflation/stable currency as the only

goal does not match

necessities/potential of monetary

1 ,1

ECB’s prohibition of financing

national sovereign debt not

adequate in crisis situations/this

crisis

1 ,1

General economic roots 1 ,1

the recession 1 ,1

influence of globalization and the

global economy 3 ,3

Other 11 1,2

None 778 82,2

Total 947 100,0

Page 16: The Euro Crisis, Media Coverage, and Perceptions of Europe ... · (New York, Praeger, 1996), “Comparing Media Systems. Three Models of Media and Politics” with Dan Hallin (Cambridge

Who do articles indicate should bear the main responsibility to solve the problem?

Responsibility to solve

N. %

Countries with sovereign debt

problems themselves 143 15,1

Countries without sovereign debt

problems 35 3,7

Eurozone members as a group 232 24,5

The European Union 141 14,9

European Central Bank 86 9,1

International Monetary Fund/World

Bank 13 1,4

Banks, investors, and other lenders

which hold debt 21 2,2

Other 40 4,2

None 236 24,9

Total 947 100,0

What do articles indicate should be the main specific mechanism for response to the crisis?

Page 17: The Euro Crisis, Media Coverage, and Perceptions of Europe ... · (New York, Praeger, 1996), “Comparing Media Systems. Three Models of Media and Politics” with Dan Hallin (Cambridge

Specific mechanism

N. %

Loans from other countries without

supervision 128 13,5

Loans from other countries with

supervision 126 13,3

European Central Bank loans and

bond purchases 95 10,0

Abatement of existing loan

provision 29 3,1

Reduce of budget deficits 107 11,3

Fiscal stimulus 9 1,0

Growth policies 73 7,7

Other 75 7,9

None 305 32,2

Total 947 100,0

What do the articles indicate should be the primary broader response needed to the crisis?

Page 18: The Euro Crisis, Media Coverage, and Perceptions of Europe ... · (New York, Praeger, 1996), “Comparing Media Systems. Three Models of Media and Politics” with Dan Hallin (Cambridge

Broader response to crisis

N. %

More EU power over national

budgets 99 10,5

Nations with weak economies

dropping the Euro 66 7,0

Nations with strong economies

dropping the Euro 15 1,6

National structural reforms in

nations with problems 190 20,1

Breaking up the Euro zone

altogether 13 1,4

Other 99 10,5

Total 482 50,9

None 465 49,1

Total 947 100,0

What do articles indicate as the main benefit from the existence of the Euro currency?

Benefit of the euro

N. %

Beneficial consequences for the

national economy 18 1,9

Improves the competitiveness of

national businesses 3 ,3

Improves the stability, operation

and competitiveness of national

banks

5 ,5

Improves the position of national

consumers 1 ,1

Improves national monetary stability 6 ,6

Page 19: The Euro Crisis, Media Coverage, and Perceptions of Europe ... · (New York, Praeger, 1996), “Comparing Media Systems. Three Models of Media and Politics” with Dan Hallin (Cambridge

Lowers national interest rates 5 ,5

Beneficial consequences for the

European economy 2 ,2

Improves the competitiveness of

European business 2 ,2

Improves the stability, operation

and competitiveness of the

European financial system

2 ,2

Beneficial European political

consequences 3 ,3

Advances European political

integration 3 ,3

Advances the creation of a single

market 1 ,1

Strengthens the geopolitical

position of Europe 1 ,1

Beneficial national social

consequences 1 ,1

Improves living standards and

general well-being (EU) 1 ,1

None 893 94,3

Total 947 100,0

What country or regions are indicated as main beneficiary of the Euro currency?

Origin of beneficiary of euro

N. %

Germany 13 1,4

Greece 2 ,2

Italy 6 ,6

Latvia 1 ,1

Poland 1 ,1

Spain 1 ,1

United Kingdom 1 ,1

Page 20: The Euro Crisis, Media Coverage, and Perceptions of Europe ... · (New York, Praeger, 1996), “Comparing Media Systems. Three Models of Media and Politics” with Dan Hallin (Cambridge

Southern countries 1 ,1

EU countries in general 8 ,8

Other 3 ,3

No main country beneficiary

indicated 910 96,1

Total 947 100,0

What do articles explicitly indicate as the main harmful consequence from the existence of the Euro currency?

Disadvantage of the euro

N. %

Harmful consequences for national

economy 40 4,2

Harms to national business 17 1,8

Harms to national banks 53 5,6

Harms to national consumers 3 ,3

Harms to national financial markets 8 ,8

National interest rates too low/too

high 9 1,0

Harmful consequences for the

European economy 33 3,5

Harms to European business 12 1,3

Harms to European banks 13 1,4

Harms to financial markets 28 3,0

European interest rates too low/too

high 13 1,4

Harmful national political

consequences 8 ,8

Restricts national control over

economic policy 5 ,5

Restricts ability to regulate and

control financial markets 7 ,7

Diminishes the scope of democratic

decision-making 8 ,8

Diminishes national sovereignty 12 1,3

Page 21: The Euro Crisis, Media Coverage, and Perceptions of Europe ... · (New York, Praeger, 1996), “Comparing Media Systems. Three Models of Media and Politics” with Dan Hallin (Cambridge

Harmful European political

consequences 1 ,1

Restricts ability to regulate and

control financial markets 7 ,7

Creates a mis-match between

monetary and fiscal authority 1 ,1

Diminishes democratic legitimacy in

Europe/ of the EU 2 ,2

Harmful national social

consequences 2 ,2

Worsens national living standards

and national general well-being 3 ,3

Deteriorates national social

services and decreases social

benefits

3 ,3

Increases national inequality 4 ,4

Worsens living standards and

general well-being (EU) 1 ,1

Deteriorates social services and

decreases social benefits (EU) 1 ,1

Other 2 ,2

None 651 68,7

Total 947 100,0

What country or regions receive the main harm from the Euro as a currency?

Origin of sufferer from euro

N. %

Austria 1 ,1

Cyprus 4 ,4

France 6 ,6

Germany 14 1,5

Greece 20 2,1

Italy 47 5,0

Spain 22 2,3

United Kingdom 2 ,2

Page 22: The Euro Crisis, Media Coverage, and Perceptions of Europe ... · (New York, Praeger, 1996), “Comparing Media Systems. Three Models of Media and Politics” with Dan Hallin (Cambridge

Country regions 2 ,2

Southern countries 17 1,8

Northern countries 2 ,2

EU countries in general 23 2,4

Other 15 1,6

Total 175 18,5

No origin of main loser indicated 772 81,5

947 100,0

Who do articles indicate primarily benefit or will benefit (economically or politically) from the Euro crises?

Beneficiary of the Euro Crisis

N. %

One country or region in particular 42 4,4

Political and financial authorities 4 ,4

National Parliament 1 ,1

National Government 9 1,0

European Commission 1 ,1

European Central Bank 5 ,5

Private economic actors 4 ,4

Commercial banks 8 ,8

Large

investors/speculators/hedgefunds 57 6,0

Non-financial industries 1 ,1

Younger people 3 ,3

Other 8 ,8

None 804 84,9

Total 947 100,0

Page 23: The Euro Crisis, Media Coverage, and Perceptions of Europe ... · (New York, Praeger, 1996), “Comparing Media Systems. Three Models of Media and Politics” with Dan Hallin (Cambridge

What country or regions are portrayed as the main beneficiary of the Euro crisis?

Origin of beneficiary of Euro Crisis

N. %

Germany 26 2,7

Greece 3 ,3

Italy 11 1,2

Latvia 1 ,1

Spain 3 ,3

EU countries in general 4 ,4

Other 4 ,4

No origin of main beneficiary

indicated 895 94,5

Total 947 100,0

Who do the articles indicate primarily suffer or will suffer (economically or politically) from the Euro crises?

Suffers from Euro Crisis

N. %

One country or region in particular 562 59,3

Political and financial authorities 20 2,1

National Parliament 5 ,5

National Government 29 3,1

European Commission 1 ,1

European Central Bank 12 1,3

Private economic actors 8 ,8

Commercial banks 40 4,2

Large

investors/speculators/hedgefunds 3 ,3

Non-financial industries 17 1,8

Population 6 ,6

Population in general 25 2,6

Page 24: The Euro Crisis, Media Coverage, and Perceptions of Europe ... · (New York, Praeger, 1996), “Comparing Media Systems. Three Models of Media and Politics” with Dan Hallin (Cambridge

Upper class 1 ,1

Lower/middle class 12 1,3

Younger people 6 ,6

Tax payers 2 ,2

Unemployed people 5 ,5

Other 15 1,6

None 178 18,8

Total 947 100,0

What country or region is depicted as primarily suffering the identified consequences of the Euro crisis?

Origin of Euro Crisis sufferer

N. %

Austria 1 ,1

Cyprus 2 ,2

France 12 1,3

Germany 18 1,9

Greece 145 15,3

Ireland 5 ,5

Italy 175 18,5

The Netherlands 1 ,1

Portugal 1 ,1

Slovenia 1 ,1

Spain 35 3,7

United Kingdom 3 ,3

Country regions 9 1,0

Southern countries 97 10,2

Northern countries 2 ,2

EU countries in general 126 13,3

Other 16 1,7

Total 649 68,5

No origin of main loser indicated 298 31,5

947 100,0

Page 25: The Euro Crisis, Media Coverage, and Perceptions of Europe ... · (New York, Praeger, 1996), “Comparing Media Systems. Three Models of Media and Politics” with Dan Hallin (Cambridge

What are the main geopolitical frames of the articles?

Geopolitical frame

N. %

domestic 282 29,8

foreign 286 30,2

European 325 34,3

Other 2 ,2

Totale 895 94,5

None/no clear frame 52 5,5

Total 947 100,0

What is the main portrayal of European Commission/European Union/Eurozone institutions?

Portrayal of EU

N. %

the article portrays them as

insignificant in addressing the crisis 24 2,5

the article portrays them as lacking

capabilities to address the crisis 108 11,4

the article portrays them as

ineffectual of confused in

addressing the crisis

223 23,5

the article portrays them as central

to addressing the crisis 145 15,3

the article portrays them as strong

and determined in addressing the

crisis

26 2,7

Other 28 3,0

None 393 41,5

Total 947 100,0

Page 26: The Euro Crisis, Media Coverage, and Perceptions of Europe ... · (New York, Praeger, 1996), “Comparing Media Systems. Three Models of Media and Politics” with Dan Hallin (Cambridge

What is the main portrayal of European Central Bank?

Portrayal of ECB

N. %

the article portrays it as insignificant

in addressing the crisis 3 ,3

the article portrays it as lacking

capabilities to address the crisis 99 10,5

the article portrays it as ineffectual

of confused in addressing the crisis 54 5,7

the article portrays it as central to

addressing the crisis 146 15,4

the article portrays it as strong and

determined in addressing the crisis 22 2,3

the article portrays it as acting

within its legal framework 8 ,8

the article portrays it as acting at

the border or outside of tis legal

framework

5 ,5

Other 27 2,9

None 583 61,6

Totale 947 100,0

What consequences of the rescue measures are foreseen?

Page 27: The Euro Crisis, Media Coverage, and Perceptions of Europe ... · (New York, Praeger, 1996), “Comparing Media Systems. Three Models of Media and Politics” with Dan Hallin (Cambridge

Consequences

N. %

Deeper integration/transfer of

national sovereignty to European

institutions

124 13,1

Stronger and stable Euro 15 1,6

Success/Eurozone preserved 40 4,2

Final breakup of the Euro zone to

more than one 59 6,2

Failure/countries with sovereign

debt problems will drop the Euro

finally

77 8,1

Establishment of an enduring

transfer system to countries with

sovereign debt problems

17 1,8

Europe wide inflation 6 ,6

Other 41 4,3

None 568 60,0

Totale 947 100,0

What are the most frequent Metaphors used to describe the crisis?

Metaphors

N. %

713 75,3

"abbraccio" "embrace" 1 ,1

"abisso" "abyss" 2 ,2

"alla deriva" "adrift" 2 ,2

"allarme" "alarm" 6 ,6

"alta tensione" "high tension" 1 ,1

"andare in frantumi" "break into

fragments" 1 ,1

"anno nero" "black year" 1 ,1

"annus horribilis" 1 ,1

"antidoto" "antidote" 1 ,1

"apnea" "apnoea" 1 ,1

Page 28: The Euro Crisis, Media Coverage, and Perceptions of Europe ... · (New York, Praeger, 1996), “Comparing Media Systems. Three Models of Media and Politics” with Dan Hallin (Cambridge

"apocalisse" "apocalypse" 1 ,1

"argine" "river bank" 1 ,1

"arma" "weapon" 1 ,1

"armi spuntate" "blunt weapons" 1 ,1

"assalto" "assault" 1 ,1

"assassino" "killer" 2 ,2

"assedio" "siege" 1 ,1

"assesdio" "siege" 1 ,1

"Atene affonda" "Athens sinks" 1 ,1

"Atene non brucia" "Athens does

not burn" 1 ,1

"attacco" "attack" 1 ,1

"baratro" "collapse" 2 ,2

"barbari" "barbarians" 1 ,1

"battaglia decisiva" "decisive battle" 1 ,1

"battaglia" "battle" 1 ,1

"bazooka" 1 ,1

"Bce=bunker" 2 ,2

"bocciare" "fail" 3 ,3

"bomba atomica sull'euro" "atomic

bomb on the euro" 1 ,1

"braccio di ferro" "arm wrestling" 3 ,3

"briglia" "rein" 1 ,1

"brillare" "shine" 1 ,1

"brucia" "burn" 1 ,1

"bufera" "blizzard" 1 ,1

"bufera" "storm" 5 ,5

"cadere" "fall-down" 1 ,1

"Cambio di stagione" "change of

season" 1 ,1

"campo di battaglia" "battlefield" 1 ,1

"Cancelliera miope" "Chancellor

myopic" 1 ,1

"cardiopalma" "palpitation" 1 ,1

"cartella clinica" "case history" 1 ,1

"cavalleria" "cavalry" 1 ,1

"cicala" "cicada" 1 ,1

Page 29: The Euro Crisis, Media Coverage, and Perceptions of Europe ... · (New York, Praeger, 1996), “Comparing Media Systems. Three Models of Media and Politics” with Dan Hallin (Cambridge

"ciclone" "hurricane" 1 ,1

"codice rosso" "red code" 1 ,1

"colare a picco" "sink" 1 ,1

"collasso" "collapse" 1 ,1

"compiti a casa" "homework" 1 ,1

"congelare" "freeze" 1 ,1

"contagio" "contagion" 34 3,6

"corsa" "race" 1 ,1

"decollare" "take off" 1 ,1

"effetto domino" "domino effect" 1 ,1

"esplosione" "explosion" 1 ,1

"euro sotto attacco" "euro under

attack" 1 ,1

"falchi" "hawks" 1 ,1

"febbre da spread" "spread fever" 2 ,2

"febbre" "fever" 1 ,1

"Fermare il fuoco" "Stop the fire" 1 ,1

"fiamme" "flames" 1 ,1

"Focolai di tensione" "hotbeds of

tension" 1 ,1

"forziere" "treasure chest" 1 ,1

"Francia sotto assedio" "France

under siege" 1 ,1

"fustigatori" "scourgers" 1 ,1

"Gli stregoni dell'Euro" "Wizards of

the Euro" 1 ,1

"golpe" "putsch" 1 ,1

"Greci senza Angela custode"

"Greeks without guardian Angel(a)" 1 ,1

"guarire" "get over" 1 ,1

"guerra" "war" 1 ,1

"guinzaglio" "leash" 1 ,1

"incendio" "fire" 1 ,1

"incubi di Madrid" "Madrid's

nightmares" 1 ,1

"infarto" "heart attack" 1 ,1

"inferno" "hell" 1 ,1

Page 30: The Euro Crisis, Media Coverage, and Perceptions of Europe ... · (New York, Praeger, 1996), “Comparing Media Systems. Three Models of Media and Politics” with Dan Hallin (Cambridge

"L'Europa a marcia indietro"

"Europe in reverse" 1 ,1

"la febbre greca sta contagiando"

"Greek fever is infecting" 1 ,1

"la frittata" "omelette (mess)" 1 ,1

"La lunga catena degli errori" "the

long chain of errors" 1 ,1

"la nave affonda" "the ship sinks" 1 ,1

"lacrime e sangue" "blood and

tears" 1 ,1

"lavata di testa" "berate" 1 ,1

"Le fiamme sono lasciate correre"

"the flames are left running" 1 ,1

"lotta contro i mercati" "fight against

the markets" 1 ,1

"mal di pancia" "stomacache" 1 ,1

"malattia" "disease" 1 ,1

"mazzata" "blow" 1 ,1

"medicina" "medicine" 1 ,1

"mercato ballerino" "unstable

market" 1 ,1

"mettere in ginocchio" "bring sb in

their knees" 1 ,1

"miccia" "fuse" 1 ,1

"mina" "mine" 1 ,1

"missione impossibile" "mission

impossible" 1 ,1

"mostro" "monster" 1 ,1

"muro" "wall" 1 ,1

"Nessuno si aspetta il classico

coniglio estratto dal cilindro"

"Nobody expects the classic bunny

pulled out of hat"

1 ,1

"nubi" "clouds" 1 ,1

"ombrello euro" "euro umbrella" 1 ,1

"ombrello" "umbrella" 2 ,2

"onda lunga della crisi greca" "long

wave of the Greek crisis" 1 ,1

Page 31: The Euro Crisis, Media Coverage, and Perceptions of Europe ... · (New York, Praeger, 1996), “Comparing Media Systems. Three Models of Media and Politics” with Dan Hallin (Cambridge

"organetto" "squeeze box" 1 ,1

"paracadute" "parachute" 5 ,5

"parlasisi" "paralysis" 1 ,1

"partita a poker" "poker game" 1 ,1

"pedalare" "pedal" 1 ,1

"preso il toro per le corna" "taking

the bull by the horns" 1 ,1

"pressing" 1 ,1

"promosso" "passed" 1 ,1

"pronto soccorso" "emergency

room" 1 ,1

"pugno" "punch" 1 ,1

"rally" 1 ,1

"reazione a catena" "chain reaction" 1 ,1

"requiem" 1 ,1

"rete di soccorso" "rescue network" 1 ,1

"scettico" "skeptical" 1 ,1

"Scivolone della Merkel" "Merkel's

slip" 1 ,1

"scossa" "shock" 1 ,1

"scossa" "tremor" 2 ,2

"scudo di vetro" "glass shield" 1 ,1

"scudo" "shield" 8 ,8

"soffrire" "suffer" 1 ,1

"sotto il vulcano della crisi globale"

"Under the volcano of Global crisis" 1 ,1

"sotto pressione" "under pressure" 1 ,1

"sotto tiro" "under fire" 1 ,1

"Spagna nella bufera" "Spain in the

storm" 1 ,1

"spauracchio" "scarecrow" 1 ,1

"stangata" "blow" 1 ,1

"storm" "bufera" 1 ,1

"sull'orlo del baratro" "on the ragged

edge" 1 ,1

"tempesta perfetta" "perfect storm" 1 ,1

Page 32: The Euro Crisis, Media Coverage, and Perceptions of Europe ... · (New York, Praeger, 1996), “Comparing Media Systems. Three Models of Media and Politics” with Dan Hallin (Cambridge

"tempesta sulle borse" "storm on

stock markets" 1 ,1

"tempesta" "storm" 18 1,9

"tension" "tension" 1 ,1

"Titanic" 1 ,1

"tossici bond" "toxic bonds" 1 ,1

"tragedia greca" "greek tragedy" 1 ,1

"tregua" "truce" 1 ,1

"trincea dell'euro" "Euro trench" 1 ,1

"trincea" "trench" 2 ,2

"tsnunami" 1 ,1

"tunnel" 1 ,1

"turbolenze" "turbulences" 4 ,4

"ultima chance" "last chance" 1 ,1

"una bella minestra fatta dei debiti

altrui" "a good soup made of other's

debts"

1 ,1

"valanga" "avalanche" 2 ,2

"vasi di coccio" "earthenware jar" 1 ,1

"vedere la luce" "to see the light" 1 ,1

"vittima" "victim" 1 ,1

Totale 947 100,0