the economic significance of licence-exempt spectrum to the future of the internet

8/12/2019 The Economic Significance of Licence-Exempt Spectrum to the Future of the Internet

1/115

The Economic Significance of Licence-

Exempt Spectrum to the Future of the

Internet

2012


2/115

2

About the AuthorAbout the AuthorAbout the AuthorAbout the Author

R T 2009 P A

T

H R W PD

I C S S U

S.

P P A

U I

S B. R S A O U

.

AcknowledgementsAcknowledgementsAcknowledgementsAcknowledgements

I P G P V S S W W

B C B R F

.

T

.

@.


3/115

3

ContentsContentsContentsContents

1 I O ........................................................................................................ 6

1.1 C ................................................................................................... 7

1.2 C .................................................................................................. 10

1.3 B ......................................................................... 12

1.4 I ....................................................................................................... 13

2 A ....................................... 16

2.1 T .............................................................................. 16

2.2 T ......................................................................... 18

3 C ......................................................................................................... 23

3.1 T .................................................... 23

3.2 C ................................. 26

3.3 L

.............................................................................................. 31

3.4 F ............................................ 44

3.5 T ................................................................... 47

4 C ...................................................................................................... 49

4.1 W ? ......................................................................................... 49

4.2 T ............................. 56

4.3 T ...................................................... 59

4.4 T ........................... 64

4.5 T E

........................................................................................................................................ 65

5 C

.............................................................................................................................................. 74

5.1 T

74

5.2 T ....................................................... 75

5.3 T ......... 80

5.4 T ...................................................... 87

6 P ............................................................. 89


4/115

4

6.1 T TV ..................... 89

6.2 F

........................................................................................ 90

6.3 B .................. 91

R ........................................................................................................................................... 95

A 1 B ......................................... 101

A 2 V WF .......................................................... 107

A 3 V WF ............................................................................. 112


5/115

5

Table of figuresTable of figuresTable of figuresTable of figures

F 1 F ...................................................... ........................... 7

F 2 T (PB ) .................. 8

F 3 T U WF 3G .................................................................................................................................................................. 8

F 4 T USA ....................................................... .................................. 17

F 5 T ................. 18

F 6 T 24 B C R .......................... 19

F 7 T IS ITU R 2 ........................................................... ......................... 21

F 8 T 1900 ..................................................... ..... 24

F 9 .......................................... 26

F 10 T ...... 28

F 11 T (PB ) .............. 34

F 12 C WF .............. 35

F 13 E WF ........... 36

F 14 B WF ............................................. 37

F 15 T . ................. 37

F 16 E WF ................................................. 38

F 17 C WF ............................... 39

F 18 T TV ............ 44

F 19 T WF ...................................................... .................................. 46

F 20 S 1990 .................................. ............................................ 50

F 21 S ........................................................................................ ..... 52F 22 D .......................................................... .................................. 53

F 23 .................................. ............................................ 54

F 24 C . 57

F 25 A ................................... 58

F 26 T

......................................................................................................................................................... 61

F 27 T ....................................................... ............................................ 66

F 28 T S G ....................................... 68

F 29 T Q1 2011 .............................. 69

F 30 T ................................ ........................ 70

F 31 A PLC

.............................................................................................................................................................................. 71

F 32 T ........................................... 72

F 33 T WF ................. 78

F 34 C .................................. 83

F 35 A

................................................................................................................................................ 84

F 36 T ...................... 85

F 37 T ............................................................................... 92


6/115

6

1111 IntroductionIntroductionIntroductionIntroduction andandandand OverviewOverviewOverviewOverviewO

. I

.

. T

.

T

. T :

(1) D ; (2) E

; (3) E

. T

( )

.

. A

.

T .

1GH TV . T

. A TV

.

C 1000H . F

. A

. A

. I

.


7/115

Introduction and Overview

7

1.11.11.11.1 Connecting all the peopleConnecting all the peopleConnecting all the peopleConnecting all the peopleF 3.9 61

. B 8 E

90 A. L

2.6 F 1.

1

I . T

1.2

. 45 .

A

.

H

. T

.

1.1.11.1.11.1.11.1.1 The role being played by licenceThe role being played by licenceThe role being played by licenceThe role being played by licence----exempt spectrumexempt spectrumexempt spectrumexempt spectrum

A WF F 2

.

100%

0%


8/115


8

2 1

I WF 69 . F

PC WF 57

E 3G . A

C 3 WF

3G 4G .

WF

. 439

25 WF . E WF 118 225

52 99 . W WF

50 114

.

I WF .

C WF

. F F 3

WF 3G U.

1T C VI S A ITU.

T WF. F

WF A E L A (

). F PC

.

105

236

Smartphones and TabletsSmartphones and TabletsSmartphones and TabletsSmartphones and Tablets

350

12,166

8,949

Traditional PCs andTraditional PCs andTraditional PCs andTraditional PCs and

laptopslaptopslaptopslaptops

Cellular

Wi-Fi

Wired

connection


9/115


9

I WF

. W 150000 450000

WF. WF

30 93 .

A 40 2016

115000 4 . H

WF 1.4 43

. T

250 (PV)

. E

45 60 .

I WF

.

I WF

R J

C 150000 .

0%

2%

4%

6%

8%

10%

00:0002:0004:0006:0008:0010:0012:0014:0016:0018:0020:0022:00

Percenta

geoftotal

Percenta

geoftotal

Percenta

geoftotal

Percenta

geoftotal

Time of dayTime of dayTime of dayTime of day

Scaled Wi-Fi

Scaled Cellular


10/115


10

1.1.21.1.21.1.21.1.2 The future potential of licenceThe future potential of licenceThe future potential of licenceThe future potential of licence----exempt spectrumexempt spectrumexempt spectrumexempt spectrumT

. E

2012 WF . WF

. F WF

. T WF

.

E

;

. T

. T TV

1GH . I

WF

TV .

1.21.21.21.2 Connecting all the thingsConnecting all the thingsConnecting all the thingsConnecting all the thingsT .

H

. T

.

A

.

T

.

.

T

. T

.


11/115


11

F C 4

100 20202.

. T

4

100 2020 25 625 . T

2020 1.4 2.2 .

1.2.11.2.11.2.11.2.1 The role being played by licenceThe role being played by licenceThe role being played by licenceThe role being played by licence----exempt spectrumexempt spectrumexempt spectrumexempt spectrum

A IOT . I

1 2.5

2020. W 95

97.5 . I

. L

.

I

. S

50 560 870

2020. T

.

1.2.21.2.21.2.21.2.2 The potential imThe potential imThe potential imThe potential importance of licenceportance of licenceportance of licenceportance of licence----exempt TV white space spectrumexempt TV white space spectrumexempt TV white space spectrumexempt TV white space spectrumT TV

. T 1GH

TV

; . A

TV .

2A IB

1 .


12/115


12

T 1GH

E . I U S

900H

. IE E

. E

. F E

6

37 56 2020.

1.31.31.31.3 Building resilient and flexible networksBuilding resilient and flexible networksBuilding resilient and flexible networksBuilding resilient and flexible networksI

. D

. I

.

T

. F

WF

. I

.

.

T

. A

. T

.

I . S


13/115


13

. T

. O WF

. T

H I O .

T TV

. H

( ). W

. I

.

1.41.41.41.4 Implications for policImplications for policImplications for policImplications for policyyyyA

. A

.

T

.

1.4.11.4.11.4.11.4.1 Taking advantage of the unique opportunity afforded by the TV white spacesTaking advantage of the unique opportunity afforded by the TV white spacesTaking advantage of the unique opportunity afforded by the TV white spacesTaking advantage of the unique opportunity afforded by the TV white spacesA

1GH

. I

.


14/115


14

T U S

.

1.4.21.4.21.4.21.4.2 Finding the right balance between licenFinding the right balance between licenFinding the right balance between licenFinding the right balance between licences and licenceces and licenceces and licenceces and licence----exempt spectrum to serve theexempt spectrum to serve theexempt spectrum to serve theexempt spectrum to serve theeverevereverever----growing demands for datagrowing demands for datagrowing demands for datagrowing demands for data

A

. H

:

. I

.

H .

I W

F . A

; 2.4GH

30 .

T

. P

. A

.

1.4.31.4.31.4.31.4.3 RevisitRevisitRevisitRevisitinginginging fundamental notions about spectrum and its managementfundamental notions about spectrum and its managementfundamental notions about spectrum and its managementfundamental notions about spectrum and its managementI

3. H

. T

4.

3F G 5 .

4F

. T


15/115


15

T

. T

. H

. I

.

. I

.


16/115

16

2222 A brief introduction toA brief introduction toA brief introduction toA brief introduction to the radio spectrumthe radio spectrumthe radio spectrumthe radio spectrum and its managementand its managementand its managementand its managementT

. A IT

.

A

.

. W

. A

. B .

A

. I

. I

.

T . T .

2.12.12.12.1 The nature of radio communicationsThe nature of radio communicationsThe nature of radio communicationsThe nature of radio communicationsT

() ()5. H

() ()

. E

. T

. I

5I TV

. I

.


17/115

A brief introduction to the radio spectrum and its management

17

.

A 6. H

. T ( ) .

T (

)

. A

.

4 A

T . A

1GH

(

6T

( ) (

). T

.


18/115


18

). A

F 5.

5

A . A 5H

5H

. H

;

. B

.

2.22.22.22.2 The methods of spectrum managementThe methods of spectrum managementThe methods of spectrum managementThe methods of spectrum managementS

. H

.

2.2.12.2.12.2.12.2.1 Spectrum licencesSpectrum licencesSpectrum licencesSpectrum licencesT

.

T . I

. I

.


19/115


19

.

H . P

. T :

. I

7 B

C R8 F 6 .

6 24 , C

I . T

. F ( F 4 )

9.

R C

195910. H

. C

. C

7S H (2011) I (2006) H (2006).

://../

8F S R H C B. 2012.

9T .

. I

LTE .

10C R. H. T . (1959).


20/115


20

50 . A

.

. I

. S

11. P

. I

.

P S CTO S B US

W H S

B S? A B B P E L

S H U S

.12

2.2.22.2.22.2.22.2.2 LicenceLicenceLicenceLicence----exempt spectrumexempt spectrumexempt spectrumexempt spectrumI 1985 FCC IS (I S )

. T

.

T

. T IS ITU 2 F

7 .

11F V

W ://.//

//203879

12B . O W . L S: E A (2011).


21/115


21

7 2

T FCC

. I

. F .

T

.

. F

.

H . I

. T

.

T 25

. B 2008

. T

. T

WF B RFID

.

V

. T

. T

. A

0 1 10 100 1,000 10,000 100,000Radio frequency (MHz)Radio frequency (MHz)Radio frequency (MHz)Radio frequency (MHz)

0.13 MHz 0.14 MHz 6.8 MHz 13 MHz 27 MHz 40 MHz 915 MHz 2.4 GHz 5 GHz 24 GHz 60 GHz


22/115


22

. C

.

T :

.

T . G

? A

?


23/115

23

3333 Connecting all the peopConnecting all the peopConnecting all the peopConnecting all the peopleleleleT .

C

. I

. U

.

H .

. F

. B :

. T

.

U

. WF

. I

. WF

. I

WF

R J

C.

T

. T

. L 1GH TV

. C

TV

.

3.13.13.13.1 TheTheTheThe reachreachreachreach and economic significanceand economic significanceand economic significanceand economic significance of thof thof thof the interne interne interne internetetetetF 8

1900.


24/115

Connecting all the people

24

8 1900

T . T 3.6

2.4

1.1 13. T

.

I .

3.1.13.1.13.1.13.1.1 CommercialCommercialCommercialCommercial impacts of the internetimpacts of the internetimpacts of the internetimpacts of the internetT .

T 8

50 14. T B A

. O . .

13T ... T

://..//

/.

14R D J E H J B C. I : T

. , (2011).

0

1,000

2,000

3,000

4,000

5,0006,000

7,000

8,000

190019101920193019401950196019701980199020002010

Millions

Millions

Millions

Millions

YearYearYearYear

Fixed Telephone lines

Mobile subscribers

Internet users

World population


25/115


25

T . B

. T

15. S US

2020.16

A

. T

AL

. I L C

.

3.1.23.1.23.1.23.1.2 SocialSocialSocialSocial impact of the internetimpact of the internetimpact of the internetimpact of the internetF . G

. F

845 Q 480 T 300 17. T

3.1 18. A

SS

S R.

T

. I

. S W

. T

. G

.

15S J. B . 2012.

16 R. B 2020 . 2011.

17://..//L.

18R S P A Q H. E S R 20112015.

44 . 0 (2011): 03.


26/115


26

3.1.33.1.33.1.33.1.3 The economic value of the internetThe economic value of the internetThe economic value of the internetThe economic value of the internetT

. A 19

; . P

2011 G I20. T

3.4 GDP 13

. I 1.5

GDP. H GDP ;

240 370 .

3.23.23.23.2 Costly existing delivery methods and tCostly existing delivery methods and tCostly existing delivery methods and tCostly existing delivery methods and the underserved billionshe underserved billionshe underserved billionshe underserved billionsI

. T

F 9.

9 21

19S W B P (2008) G A P J (2006)

D J O. (2009).

20R (2011)

21I.

0

10

20

30

40

50

60

70

8090

100

2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011

Internetusersper100people




YearYearYearYear

Developed

World

Developing


27/115


27

T

. H

.

3.2.13.2.13.2.13.2.1 Limited aLimited aLimited aLimited affordabiffordabiffordabiffordabilitylitylitylity of broadbandof broadbandof broadbandof broadbandT . T I

T U (ITU) 2015

5 22. A

.

U ITU . T

.

ITU

. H . I

23. T

.

F F 10 .

22ITU. 2011 (2011).

23T I G T W B T CIA W

F L C .

A . S B

E. I D P U A D G A (2001).

T ITU

2011


28/115


28

10

F 3.9 61

5 . B

8 E 90 A.

U ITU

2011. H

1GB 81

. T

50 80

2.6 3.5 .

A A 1

.

3.2.23.2.23.2.23.2.2 LLLLimitimitimitimitedededed rollrollrollroll----out of broadbandout of broadbandout of broadbandout of broadbandT

. T

L D S24. S S

J .

24F P T ://.

100%

0%


29/115


29

E E A

. F E 4.7

23.5 18 . 90

E 3G

. I USA 4 11 .25

I . T 1.2

201026 80

1.5

. A

. W ITU 3

3.5G 45 27.

3.2.33.2.33.2.33.2.3 The high costs ofThe high costs ofThe high costs ofThe high costs of existingexistingexistingexisting models ofmodels ofmodels ofmodels of broadbandbroadbandbroadbandbroadband deliverydeliverydeliverydeliveryT (

ADSL) ( 3G 4G ).

B .

3.2.3.13.2.3.13.2.3.13.2.3.1

Fixed netFixed netFixed netFixed networksworksworksworks

I

TV ADSL

DOCCIS .

.

T . T

. L

7.5 150 28. O

. E

.

25E C. D A S 2011 (2011).

26C I A. T . 2010.

27ITU. ICT F FI (2011).

28B . I . 2012.


30/115


30

T

. I

. A

.

3.2.3.23.2.3.23.2.3.23.2.3.2 Mobile networksMobile networksMobile networksMobile networks 3G ( HSPA

EVDO) 4G ( LTE WAX). T

. I

29.

H

.

.

.

T

.

P

. I

. T

:

H

C .

T

.

29F 3G . T LTE 50

T C L. 2012 (2011).


31/115


31

I

. T

. C 2010

. T

30.

3.33.33.33.3 LLLLicenceicenceicenceicence----exemptexemptexemptexempt technologtechnologtechnologtechnologiesiesiesies decrease the costs ofdecrease the costs ofdecrease the costs ofdecrease the costs of deliveringdeliveringdeliveringdelivering broadbandbroadbandbroadbandbroadband andandandandincrease the quality of the productincrease the quality of the productincrease the quality of the productincrease the quality of the product

A

. B

. L

. I

.

3.3.13.3.13.3.13.3.1 The properties of technologiesThe properties of technologiesThe properties of technologiesThe properties of technologies using theusing theusing theusing the licencelicencelicencelicence----exempt spectrumexempt spectrumexempt spectrumexempt spectrumT

. T

.

T

. A

.

D

. T

30I US AT&T

T US T O U

E C

H3G.


32/115


32

. F 7500 1500031

WF 200032. T

WF 5 3G

3033.

A

. I

. T W

F . I

WF34.

T

.

I .

3.3.23.3.23.3.23.3.2 WiWiWiWi----FiFiFiFi is central to our broadband networksis central to our broadband networksis central to our broadband networksis central to our broadband networksT

WF. I

;

. WF

TV .

3.3.2.13.3.2.13.3.2.13.3.2.1 WiWiWiWi----Fi is ubiquitous and delivers most of theFi is ubiquitous and delivers most of theFi is ubiquitous and delivers most of theFi is ubiquitous and delivers most of the worldsworldsworldsworlds datadatadatadataT WF

. S A

2011 439 WF

85 25 35. T

31PA C G. 2010.

32A R 7762

33L S. AT&T WF . 2012.

34T R. .

, 2009.

35B A. R: WF H A 800 2016. ..

://../8002016/.


33/115


33

800 2016 45

.

WF

. T 14 WF OECD 36.

T 4.5

FO. A 1.3 WF

WF . I

5.8 201537. I

38.

WF

. I WF 69 .

F PC WF 57

. T

! ..

36A OECD

US (L 1997) 2000 (F 2011)

70 .

37WBA. 2011.

38T STR G

13 8 WF

1 .


34/115


34

11 9

A WF WF . T

WF 16500

. I 3G 4G

600 . B F 12 I

.40

39T C (2011) S A (2012)

ITU (2011). T WF. F

I WF A E L

A ( ). F PC I

.

40T . F WF

85 802.11 10 802.11 2.4GH 5 802.11 5GH

27 72 150 . F I 4

2 35H

2.5 /H. T

.

105

236

Smartphones and TabletsSmartphones and TabletsSmartphones and TabletsSmartphones and Tablets

350

12,166

8,949

Traditional PCs andTraditional PCs andTraditional PCs andTraditional PCs and

laptopslaptopslaptopslaptops

Cellular

Wi-Fi

Wired

connection


35/115


35

12 C

3.3.2.23.3.2.23.3.2.23.3.2.2 WiWiWiWi----Fi greatly increases the value of fixed broadbandFi greatly increases the value of fixed broadbandFi greatly increases the value of fixed broadbandFi greatly increases the value of fixed broadbandO 85 WF;

.

A 2009 P A

US .

U I 41.

T W

F 52 99 . W

50 114 .

I F 13 .

41T WF U

ITU S A

WF 85 . F I

WF US

GI US. F I

. T

:

US .

0

200

400

600

800

1000

1200

1400

1600

Tbps

Tbps

Tbps

Tbps

Total Wi-Fi bandwidth

Total cellular bandwidth


36/115


36

1

$

$

C

A 69 901 0.5 1A 10820 41516 21.2 48.2

21657 30164 15.4 35

A 17769 19952 10.2 23.2

1049 1217 0.6 1.4

A 782 4772 2.4 5.5

A A 2.

I WF 42

43.

3.3.2.33.3.2.33.3.2.33.3.2.3 WiWiWiWi----Fi provides substantial costFi provides substantial costFi provides substantial costFi provides substantial cost----savings for cellular operatorssavings for cellular operatorssavings for cellular operatorssavings for cellular operatorsI 3G

WF. T WF. U

WF .

E 2:1 WF 44 45.

H 2012 600000

. I 46

94 WF . E C I W

F 70 WF47.

42T 2009

.

43T C 1.

44C (2011)

45 P J L. T . (2011).

46 H U S G C F.

47T I

2.5 WF

.


37/115


37

T WF 6

WF . F 14

.

14

U

F 2F 15 .

15 .

A WF . A

WF . A WF

15.

51%63% 68%

81% 82% 82%

49%37% 32%

19% 18% 18%

0%

10%

20%30%

40%

50%

60%

70%

80%

90%

100%

Singapore US Hong Kong UK Germany Spain

Cellular data

Wi-Fi

0%

1%2%

3%

4%

5%

6%

7%

8%

9%

00:00 02:00 04:00 06:00 08:00 10:00 12:00 14:00 16:00 18:00 20:00 22:00

Scaled Wi-Fi

Scaled Cellular


38/115


38

I WF

. T

. A

WF .

A

WF

48. T F 16.

16

4

8

4 $ 8

$

A 85500 306400 17600 63100 31600 82000 6500 16900

A 22100 39900 4500 8200

A 4600 8400 900 1700

A 3400 7400 700 1500

2600 8200 500 1700

149800 452300 30700 93100

A 149000 452000

WF 30 93 .

48A O U

A

(O 2009). T

I ITU

TS . T I

U W U P 2011. F I G RU P 1 (GRUP1) C

U O . O

(S O U

D ) I

U. I 4

2 15 H 2.1GH . T

( 2.1GH ) WF

. O

80000

8000. A PV 10 .


39/115


39

I

WF. F . I

. I

. S

WF . T

49. P

. TS

50.

U I

WF. T :

WF

40 51. T F 17

.

17 C

W WF 75 115000

4. H

WF ;

1.4 43 . T

49T .

://.../////.

50TS. TS 2012.

51T TS AT&T US

2012.

-

1.0

2.0

3.0

4.0

5.0

2012 2013 2014 2015 2016

Totalglobalcells

ite

srequired

Totalglobalcells

ite

srequired

Totalglobalcells

ite

srequired

Totalglobalcells

ite

srequired

(millions)

(millions)

(millions)

(millions)

Sites with Wi-Fi

Sites without Wi-Fi


40/115


40

250 (PV)

.

. I

; 75 60 . O .

H 75 WF

45 . I .

I

WF. A

. T

. I

.

O WF

.

D A 3.

3.3.33.3.33.3.33.3.3 A range of licenceA range of licenceA range of licenceA range of licence----exempt technologies are being used to deliverexempt technologies are being used to deliverexempt technologies are being used to deliverexempt technologies are being used to deliver broadbandbroadbandbroadbandbroadbandS WF

. H WF

.

3.3.3.13.3.3.13.3.3.13.3.3.1 Rural wRural wRural wRural wireless internet service providers (WISPs)ireless internet service providers (WISPs)ireless internet service providers (WISPs)ireless internet service providers (WISPs)L

. T

. T WISP US

3 . T

52. B W

52T

.


41/115


41

:

WISP

. T 6 . B

. T

. T 5 10 15

20 . T

. I T

.53

WISP . I

54. WF

.

150000 55 L 150

56 A J WF

H57.

3.3.3.23.3.3.23.3.3.23.3.3.2 UUUUrban broadbandrban broadbandrban broadbandrban broadband provisionprovisionprovisionprovisionT WF

. H WF

. A

WF . T

WF :

53W B. W ISP (WISP) . 2011.

54F :

://../.?=WS

55S ://./

56O A. H L 2012.

57S ://../


42/115


42

WF ( T C U WWF 58

P O R J59)

60. A

T

. I

.

I

. P

T I ISP W

F . I I

220000 1 .

S

.61

58S ://../.

59S ://../?=8AHQ54

60W J CEO C W C 2012 W

F 1 WF 2014. J DDI

100000 .

61A W E I

S F B A US. I

. F

24GH . U

W E 45 100 200

1000 .

W //

. S ://...//


43/115


43

3.3.3.33.3.3.33.3.3.33.3.3.3 BottomBottomBottomBottom----up community built mesh networksup community built mesh networksup community built mesh networksup community built mesh networksT WISP

WF

WF . H

.

T

. E /

. I

W 300 .

A O 62

. H

G C S.

B G

WF

. F 2004 1000

2006 9000 2009 25000

30000 50000 . O .

.

T FFTF (

) B G

.63I

.

62O J B. W C

. 2010 (J 2010): 457465.

63G.. T FFTF (2011).


44/115


44

3.43.43.43.4 Future changes concerning licencFuture changes concerning licencFuture changes concerning licencFuture changes concerning licenceeee----exempt technologiesexempt technologiesexempt technologiesexempt technologies

T .

3.4.13.4.13.4.13.4.1 The addition ofThe addition ofThe addition ofThe addition of tttthe television white spaceshe television white spaceshe television white spaceshe television white spacesA C 1

. H 1GH

. T

.

T TV

F 18

.

18 ,

T

1GH. T

US

. A TV

100H

2.4GH .

T

. A

1980


45/115


45

. H 64.

I TV

US U S S

A P . S B TS

W C USA. L T A

C V.

T .

I

WISP .

F

100H

25065. E

500 5

66. I

VOIP

.

I

. U

.

I

. F

WF . B

. A

64I I

.

65B C RC

6 H (L (2012)).

66G 125 20:1 ADSL

.


46/115


46

. T

. F WF

2.4GH 5GH

.

3.4.23.4.23.4.23.4.2 Trends inTrends inTrends inTrends in licencelicencelicencelicence----exemptexemptexemptexempt technologytechnologytechnologytechnologyW

.

T WF

2001 F 19.

19

I

5GH IO (

) (

). W

WF.

O WF . A

WF

WF . S

. S

.

0

200

400

600

800

1000

1996 1998 2000 2002 2004 2006 2008 2010 2012

Speed(Mbps)

Speed(Mbps)

Speed(Mbps)

Speed(Mbps)

Speed


47/115


47

T

R W WF .

H WF .

B WF P67 G H 68 SI

. O W

F

. B 2012.

3.53.53.53.5 The eThe eThe eThe evolving modelvolving modelvolving modelvolving model ofofofof broadbandbroadbandbroadbandbroadband deliverydeliverydeliverydeliveryL

. I

. T

.

E WF .

T

. I WF

E A L C R. L

69. T

.

L . F

WF

70

TV . T

67A WF A

68D W B A

69T (7095 GH ) (60 GH

BW; 5GH R B C )

70S T C U T C T I


48/115


48

71.

T

.

F

72

73. T

74

71I

5 WF

. U 5H

.

72T W S F USA 50

200 .

73T I

74S

. F E 2011

2011 18 (R 2012) US

25 (R 2012). T

6080 (B 2011).


49/115

49

4444 Connecting everything elseConnecting everything elseConnecting everything elseConnecting everything elseT

. H

. A

.

.

B . E

. H

. T

. I

.

T

. T

. I

.

T

. A 95

100 2020. T

..

4.14.14.14.1 What is the internet of things?What is the internet of things?What is the internet of things?What is the internet of things?T

.

. H

. T

.


50/115

Connecting everything else

50

A

. F :

.

T

.

F .

F . S

. T

. T

.

4.1.14.1.14.1.14.1.1 The human terminalThe human terminalThe human terminalThe human terminalT :

PC. I

TV . F 20

.

20 1990

0

200

400

600

800

1,000

1,200

1,400

1,600

1,8002,000

Unitsales(millions)

Unitsales(millions)

Unitsales(millions)

Unitsales(millions)

Smartphones

Tablets

Notebook

Desktops


51/115


51

U 2000 PC . H

2002 . S

. S

: 2011 . O

100 2001 900 2011.

T .

P :

. T

. T 2000

WF . T

.

I

75.

I 1.8

2015 .

4.1.24.1.24.1.24.1.2 FFFFutureutureutureuture machine possibilitiesmachine possibilitiesmachine possibilitiesmachine possibilitiesPC .

H

.

A PC

. I

PC ;

. T

.

U PC

75T ;

A .


52/115


52

. I

CPU / . T

1 .

F 21 S .

21

A

. I 2011 15 . I 2015 AR

H 30

PC .

4.1.34.1.34.1.34.1.3 Identifying the future membersIdentifying the future membersIdentifying the future membersIdentifying the future membersF 22 :

0

5,000

10,000

15,000

20,000

25,000

30,000

Unitsales

(millions)

Unitsales

(millions)

Unitsales

(millions)

Unitsales

(millions)

Microcontroller sales

Computer and

smartphone sales


53/115


53

22

T

. H

.

IP .

W

. F

.

T . I

.

S 76

77 F 23.

76X X. D F D I C S B B W S

. I D L L

C.

77S . P. S H B U W S

In comms networksIn comms networksIn comms networksIn comms networks

Mobile phones

Fixed line phonesFax machines

Routers

Switches

In PCs and smartphonesIn PCs and smartphonesIn PCs and smartphonesIn PCs and smartphones

Monitors

TouchscreensWi-Fi chipsets

Hard drives

Peripherals

In the homeIn the homeIn the homeIn the home

TVs, DVD players

Games consolesCameras

Toys

Appliances

In medicineIn medicineIn medicineIn medicine

Dialysis machines

Defibrillators

Ventillators

Pacemakers

In vehiclesIn vehiclesIn vehiclesIn vehicles

Antilock brakes

Air bags

Keyless entry

Fuel injection

Climate control

In the militaryIn the militaryIn the militaryIn the military

Aircraft

Armoured vehicles

Missiles

Radios

Artillery

In citiesIn citiesIn citiesIn cities

Street lighting control systems

Parking meters

Toll booths

In the environmentIn the environmentIn the environmentIn the environment

Pollution/air quality monitors

Weather stations

Water level monitors

In industryIn industryIn industryIn industry

Control circuitry

Machine tools

Monitors/sensors


54/115


54

2

T

.

4.1.44.1.44.1.44.1.4 The size of the internet of thingsThe size of the internet of thingsThe size of the internet of thingsThe size of the internet of things .

E 50 202078. A

: 3

510 1.5

( ) 3 100

. I

PC .

C 50 79.

IB RFID

1 201480.

I & 2010 H T.

78E. 0 2011.

79 R. C: 50 B T I 2020. 2011.

80W A. IB: A W 1 T C D. 2010.

Connected Grape Vine

Sensors to check soil moisture,temperature and light intensityinformation

Actuators to control drip irrigationsystem

Trialled and described by Xiang2011

Connected Bridge

Wireless sensors monitors thepressure and vibrations in thestructure

Products already in use fromMotorola, Innodev, Microstrain etc.

Systems described by Xu 2004,Pakzad 2008, Harms 2010

Connected Heart

Modern pacemakers and internaldefibrillators constantly monitorheart activity

Can upload information and beprogrammed wirelessly

Developed by Elmqvist 1958,Mirowski 1978


55/115


55

U

50 2015

5 I

100 2020; C E .

S . I 10

. H

F 23 :

T 30 81. I 650

82 500 83

84.

T 9 85.T 900 1800

86. I

.

T 2020 2 ICD 87

20 . S

81S ://./.

82S 300 (://..//.)

46

(://..//636/DD.?PID=636#)83S ://..//A

84I. W S A O G 2009.

://../.

85T U.S. B T S 600000 U

S ( A).

86R. O R S H S (2012).

87ASDR. T G C D F R 43.4B 2017 2012.

://../.?=289. CAGR 4 2017

10000


56/115


56

88

89.

A

IB .

4.24.24.24.2 TheTheTheThe applications and economic potentialapplications and economic potentialapplications and economic potentialapplications and economic potential of theof theof theof the iiiinternet ofnternet ofnternet ofnternet of tttthingshingshingshingsT

IP . T

.

4.2.14.2.14.2.14.2.1 Understanding the scale ofUnderstanding the scale ofUnderstanding the scale ofUnderstanding the scale of the economicthe economicthe economicthe economic possibilitiespossibilitiespossibilitiespossibilitiesI

. H

?

O

B 198090. H

(

). I

. I

B

.

88. D I P E G W D S

E 2009.

89V.. I 2012.

90 L

. H R H C

US F C C L L

.


57/115


57

T

. T F 24.

24 A

Today Cisco andEricsson

predictions

This reports

predictionIBM's

prediction

Number of connected devices 4 bn 50 bn 100 bn 1 tn91

Forecast Year 2012 2020 2020 2014

Number of connections 8 1018 1.25 1021 5 1021 5 1023

Ratio against today 1 156 625 62500

A 100 625

,

.

1997 ( 95,

, F) 80 ,

2 ( )92.

I , ,

. , M

. MK $20 $370 . I

,

8 1018 . ,

93 ,

2020 $1. $2.2

.

91IBM FID

92

93 , ,

.


58/115


58

4.2.24.2.24.2.24.2.2 Illustrative applicationsIllustrative applicationsIllustrative applicationsIllustrative applicationsA , . F ,

. ,

I

A , ( ),

A F 25 .


59/115


59

.

.

, .

I , , , . A

L, Y, , ,

J F9 . ABI $8.1

2010, 2016

$39.5 95.

M

L . ,

. ,

,

.

96.

$6 201597.

.

4.34.34.34.3 The roThe roThe roThe rolelelele beingbeingbeingbeing played byplayed byplayed byplayed by licencelicencelicencelicence----exemptexemptexemptexempt spectrumspectrumspectrumspectrumF,

I

IO. I , , , ,

. I ,

, ,

() .98 F

94See Osborne (2012), Hosaka (2010), Kamau (2011), Tweed (2010), Payton (2012), Falk (2012)

95ABI. $39.5 B B 2016, ABI (2011).

96, . B D F .

, 2012

97C, . S $6 2015 (2011).

98F, . I ? A . (2010).


60/115


60

ABI , , 2016 365

, 99. B

800 2020. C,

M , , 2.3

2020100. M , 50 100

2% 5% . I

1%.

101.

.

4.3.14.3.14.3.14.3.1 TechnicalTechnicalTechnicalTechnical considerationsconsiderationsconsiderationsconsiderations

, , ,

F . M

(

) 102.

. ,

F, B L B103.

99L, S. C M2M C S M $35 B 2016, L

A S

100, M. MM 12 2020 , 71

(2011)

101 , ,

.

102F , , ,

. I,

C . A

.

103I HA, .


61/115


61

.

F 26

0

0 00

Wi-Fi

Very high speeds (>5 Gbps)

30-100 metre range

Moderate power consumption

Rich network architectures

Consumer electronics,industrial and scientific uses

Bluetooth Low Energy

Medium speed (1 Mbps)

10 metre range

Very low power consumption

Simple network architecture

Designed for mobiletelephones and subsidiarysensor based devices,

ZigBee

Low speed (250 Kbps)

30-100 metre range

Low power consumption

Rich network architecture

Widely used in automation,mission-critical industrial, smartmetering


62/115


62

05

06

4.3.24.3.24.3.24.3.2 CCCCommercial considerationsommercial considerationsommercial considerationsommercial considerations

07 A

0

A

05 M : A M A (2009).

106A C (2010)

107S

. .

,

.

108L (2012)


63/115


63

. A ,

, . F

.

L

. F

,

. I

B .

4.3.34.3.34.3.34.3.3 The economic contribution of licenceThe economic contribution of licenceThe economic contribution of licenceThe economic contribution of licence----exempt spectrumexempt spectrumexempt spectrumexempt spectrumI

, 95% .

?

F .

. I

109. H,

.

F ,

50%

. .

I

.

,

$560 $870 2020.

30%

109A

. ,

. ,

.


64/115


64

: 2020

.

,

. H :

. A

,

.

4.44.44.44.4 The roThe roThe roThe rolelelele that could be played by newthat could be played by newthat could be played by newthat could be played by new licencelicencelicencelicence----exemptexemptexemptexempt technologiestechnologiestechnologiestechnologies 2.H, 5H 60H . A

F 802.11 5H 802.11 60H

2.H.

. H,

.

, 1H ,

.

, 110.

.

I ,

. ,

.

I F 2., 5 60H

. H,

,

:

C , C

110C 1H ,

.


65/115


65

C B C D ,

,

. I .

, :

, , .

I , , , , , .

C , , , . L ,

M ,

,

F B111

,

K 112.

4.54.54.54.5 TTTThe economiche economiche economiche economic repercrepercrepercrepercussionsussionsussionsussions of spectrumof spectrumof spectrumof spectrum ununununavailabilityavailabilityavailabilityavailability the example ofthe example ofthe example ofthe example ofEuropes smart gridEuropes smart gridEuropes smart gridEuropes smart grid

A ,

. F,

.

. H, , .

. S,

111 10 S 1H 1 ,

. S L, J . (2007)

112 S ..


66/115


66

1H . M

.

4.5.14.5.14.5.14.5.1 The smart gridThe smart gridThe smart gridThe smart grid 20

C

. :

,

,

.

D . M ,

,

. F 27

.

T :

113I EPI. E C B S G (2011).

:..CFECSG..

Today's grid The smart grid


67/115


67

. A

.

E ,

.

E ,

E , , C2 .

S . I ,

.

H,

:

A M I C S S D D M SD A E A AS D E I C I

S N E L

F 28, .


68/115


68

4

A . I,

.

A . F

,

. ,

520%115. F,

,

.

.

4.5.24.5.24.5.24.5.2 Advanced meteringAdvanced meteringAdvanced meteringAdvanced metering different US and EU trajectories caused by spectrumdifferent US and EU trajectories caused by spectrumdifferent US and EU trajectories caused by spectrumdifferent US and EU trajectories caused by spectrum availabilityavailabilityavailabilityavailability E N A

.

1 2011

.

11I NEL. M G B (2010).

115D, S. E F E C: A DEFA

L M, B D D. (2006)


69/115


69

I S

E

S

.

S

900MH , 26MH

1GH . A

LAN .

F 30 .

116B (2011)

77.6

%

17.5

%

1.9%3.0%

USUSUSUS

15.0%

85.0%

EuropeEuropeEuropeEurope

Licence-exempt

mesh

Licensed mesh

Licensed cellular

Power line carrier


70/115


70

S :

. C 900MH .

,

.

100 1M. (

, ,

) .118

, .

H, E ( I 1 3) 900MH

119. , E

117I S S N

:..

118A B E , SA: ,

.

,

. G BED (

) .

119F , ZB 15 S, E

.


71/115


71

, . E

.

()

A ,

D

(


72/115


72

D

. I EPI

S E 12. A

F 32 ,

E .

($)

37 56

76 120

15 21

I E

6

. E $37 56

E . S

: $15 $21 .

E

125. I , E

, A A,

.

J

920MH ,

126. A E

, E

12I . F, EPI S E. I S

E.

,

100%.

, . E

.

125, ,

.

126KI. KI D J F 920MH F B M C

S S C (2012).


73/115


73

.

, , .


74/115

74

5555 CreatingCreatingCreatingCreating robustrobustrobustrobust and adaptaband adaptaband adaptaband adaptablelelele networksnetworksnetworksnetworksI

. A

. ,

,

. H,

. I, ,

,

.

.

. H,

( ).

. I

.

5.15.15.15.1 TheTheTheThe importance ofimportance ofimportance ofimportance of robustnessrobustnessrobustnessrobustness and fand fand fand flelelelexibilityxibilityxibilityxibility inininin our global communicationsour global communicationsour global communicationsour global communicationssystemssystemssystemssystems

.

, F . H,

, .

I , .

. A C 0,

,

. F, C 3,

.


75/115


76/115

Creating robust and adaptable networks

76

H,

. I

, ,

.

5.2.15.2.15.2.15.2.1 The challenges of lThe challenges of lThe challenges of lThe challenges of life in a noisy environmenife in a noisy environmenife in a noisy environmenife in a noisy environmentttt

. H,

( ) ()

,

. F

.

.

. H

127.

,

.

, . I ,

.

,

.

5.2.25.2.25.2.25.2.2 The benefits of life in a noisy environmentThe benefits of life in a noisy environmentThe benefits of life in a noisy environmentThe benefits of life in a noisy environment

127D ,

. I ,

. F , SA

N FCC

: :..FCC0

168A1.


77/115


77

I

.

.

5.2.2.15.2.2.15.2.2.15.2.2.1 Control overControl overControl overControl over network structurenetwork structurenetwork structurenetwork structureF

.

. E

. M,

,

128

G ,

.

A

. .

P, . F

. F

.

,

. A

.

I

.

;

.

.

128

.


78/115


78

5.2.2.25.2.2.25.2.2.25.2.2.2 A faster evolution of roA faster evolution of roA faster evolution of roA faster evolution of robust intelligent equipmentbust intelligent equipmentbust intelligent equipmentbust intelligent equipmentL ISM

. D

, . H, ,

2.GH

.

C

, .

F

. L F

. F FDM

. M

F,

129.

F 33 F

.

Wi-Fi Cellular

Digital signal encoding 1985 1991

Spread spectrum 1991 1995

OFDM 1999 2006

MIMO/Adaptive beamforming 2004 N/A

F

.

: ,

129I , FA ( )

.

F , ,

.

130 (2009)


79/115


79

. H, F

. I 2000 A

F K

0 131.

. A 2008 F 2,000 L. F

132. L

25,000 133(

21,000).

,

. I ,

, ,

13. I ,

.

5.2.35.2.35.2.35.2.3 CCCCriticalriticalriticalritical uses ofuses ofuses ofuses of licencelicencelicencelicence----exemptexemptexemptexempt linkslinkslinkslinks

.

135, 136

137 .

131L, H, H, C M, J B, C M. D

2.GH ISM B (2000). ://...//ISM2..

132S A (2012)

133 LP 67,98 ,

P 1.75 ( ://..////_8125__29896__1878) WF F 71.6%

(S A, 2012).

13S , ,

.

135F , D E P WF N O R. , 2008.

A W I. , 2007.

136A N R R F Q 2012 F R., 2012.

137R, P., . E

B 37, . 2 (2012).


80/115


80

5.35.35.35.3 TheTheTheThe robustness and adaptabilityrobustness and adaptabilityrobustness and adaptabilityrobustness and adaptability ofofofof networksnetworksnetworksnetworks built withbuilt withbuilt withbuilt with llllicenceicenceicenceicence exemptexemptexemptexempt linkslinkslinkslinksA ,

. N

,

. E

,

.

. A

.

5.3.15.3.15.3.15.3.1 The importance of architectureThe importance of architectureThe importance of architectureThe importance of architecture and bottomand bottomand bottomand bottom----up constructionup constructionup constructionup construction to robustnessto robustnessto robustnessto robustness andandandandadaptabilityadaptabilityadaptabilityadaptability

I

, ?

F ,

.

, . I ,

. A J W L B,

.

H,

. ,

138 139,

, 10 M11. I

138S W, J M. D: ,

. 7, . 6 (2010).

139E . S L, S A.

E B C A S.

(1998): 3136.

10F , I

B, C. L . 59, . 1

(2009).


81/115


81

.

O /

12.

P . D

,

( ) DNA

. H,

. S

, ,

.

O :

, ,

( ) ( ),

.

A ,

13 1, ,

.

11 M 200,000

. I

. S H, L. A B . , 2002.12E, G M, J A G. D .

98, . 2 (2001): 1376313768.

, .

13G ,

, . H, ,

, .

1

. H,

.


82/115


82

:

,

. I . F ,

. W

, ,

.

15.

I

.

,

. I,

.

5.3.25.3.25.3.25.3.2 TheTheTheThe architecture ofarchitecture ofarchitecture ofarchitecture of our communicationsour communicationsour communicationsour communications and its fragilityand its fragilityand its fragilityand its fragility

.

. P

;

.

A ,

, ,

.

A

, .

F ,

15W (2010) ()


83/115


83

. S,

.

1965 , A C I N , C A16. H

:

, :

.

. W

,

.

F 3 .

4

A

, . A

16A, C. A . (197).

://..///.1050153./A C ..

A

R, I, .

A

N, E. A

.


84/115


84

. 17, 18

19. , 150,

.

A . .

,

.

5.3.35.3.35.3.35.3.3 The robustness enhancing effects of licenceThe robustness enhancing effects of licenceThe robustness enhancing effects of licenceThe robustness enhancing effects of licence----exempt operationexempt operationexempt operationexempt operation

.

17I

18C

19A .

150A .

( 009) 66

.


85/115


85

A C 0,

. ,

.

: E ,

, .

, ,

.

. ,

.

, .

. E

AN .

,

.

A 36 ,

, .


86/115


86

5.3.45.3.45.3.45.3.4 The adaptabilityThe adaptabilityThe adaptabilityThe adaptability----enhancing effects of licenceenhancing effects of licenceenhancing effects of licenceenhancing effects of licence----exempt operationexempt operationexempt operationexempt operation

.

I

. , . A

,

. A

.

.

.

.

.

I ,

, .

.

, , .

.

J 151, K15 153.

, , . I

( ,

151N 500,000 J

.

15 M, M, K . , 005.

153, . , 010.


87/115


87

). A IM (

C 0)

.

5.45.45.45.4 The role of upcoming liceThe role of upcoming liceThe role of upcoming liceThe role of upcoming licencencencence----exempt technologiesexempt technologiesexempt technologiesexempt technologiesA

,

.

N ,

, ,

. I , 60, . E

, , ,

, .

,

. ,

.

.

, C 0

.

. I ,

C 1,

. I ,

.

. A

,

. ,

. . I

.

J K,


88/115


88

.


89/115

89

6666 Policy implications and directions for further workPolicy implications and directions for further workPolicy implications and directions for further workPolicy implications and directions for further work

.

, 95

,

.

. I :

1) ;

)

;

3) , , .

6.16.16.16.1 The overwhelming case for licenceThe overwhelming case for licenceThe overwhelming case for licenceThe overwhelming case for licence----exempt access to TV white spacesexempt access to TV white spacesexempt access to TV white spacesexempt access to TV white spaces :

,

, . I

:

1 .

N

. .

. ,

. , 1

1

. ,


90/115

Policy implications and directions for further work

90

. I E

900M

A. E

. .

, 1

.

1 .

.

, .

6.26.26.26.2 Finding an efficient balance of new licensed and licenceFinding an efficient balance of new licensed and licenceFinding an efficient balance of new licensed and licenceFinding an efficient balance of new licensed and licence----exempt allocations toexempt allocations toexempt allocations toexempt allocations tomeet the worlds growing demand for datameet the worlds growing demand for datameet the worlds growing demand for datameet the worlds growing demand for data

A

. ,

, :

( A A15).

,

: . I

;

, , .

, :

/ /

?

15M

://....//////AA.


91/115


91

. C,

.

.

. 30 155. .

. I ,

.

I

156.

,

AA,

.

C

. IM

.

A , 1

.

6.36.36.36.3 Building economic theory around aBuilding economic theory around aBuilding economic theory around aBuilding economic theory around a better understandingbetter understandingbetter understandingbetter understanding of spectrumof spectrumof spectrumof spectrum

155 , M ( 85 M

. ) (

10 M .1 ) . .1 . .

.

, .

.

156 .

.

, .

,

.

.


92/115


92

I C 1959

:

1)

) , :

,

. , 37 .

I , A , 100M . I

100M

. 1 M A, 1 M .

1

157. , . 3

,

. I

157I


93/115


93

. .

.

M

. 1158.

. A

.

,

.

.

, ,

159, 160,

161.

,

, 16.

158,

;

, ,

,

.

159I

. 1968. I

.

160I

.

161A

.

16

, J A 1 . N

.


94/115


94

I

163.

163

, J . :

N A (008)


95/115

95

ReferencesReferencesReferencesReferences

AI. $39.5 C 016, AI (011).

://..//011/09/08/00870+08011+0110908 .

A. C M $3. 017, 01.

://../.?=89.

A, C. A . (197). ://..///.1050153./A C

..

A, , , , M . M

N. I , 200. 0. 42 , 17, 009.

A N 01 ., 01.

://..//01

010517 .

, N. E C M : A M S I N A. (2009).

B, C. L . 59, . 1 (2009).

B, . O W . L S: E M A (2011).

://../O_W__L_S_M_A_..

B, M, M W, C G. NG F L L

S R. , 2011.

://..///_____/.

B, C. W . , 2009.

://..//2009/03/..

B, N. I . , 2012.

://..//.

B, A. R: WF H A 800 2016. , ..

://../8002016/.

C I A. I GINI . , ..

://../////2172..

. . , 2010. ://..///

//2150..

C. C N I: F M , 2011 2016 (2011): 20112016.C, O. S $6 2015 (2011).

://../S/////6///2015.

C, R. H. . (1959).


96/115

References

96

C . G R M P, 1, 2012.

C, M. S M (2010).

://.

.////FSR_HOME/ENERG/P_E/W/2010/S_M/P

_C..

D, S. E F E C: A RE DEFRA L

M, B D D. , . A

(2006). ://..//

/.

D E P WF N O R. , 2008. ://.

.//3325..

D, M, J O. S .

(2009). ://.//

/CONSMER_BENEFIS_OF_BROADBAND..

EPRI. E C B S G (2011).

://../C/F/ECSGR..

E, G M, J A G. D .

98, . 2 (2001): 1376313768.

://..//98/2/13763..

E. 0 , 2011.

E C. D A S 2011 (2011).

://../_/////..

F, . , 2012.

F, E. W I ? W I A E P. (2010).

F, J. W LAN D G H D C E H E (2011):

11.

F, S, R H, C B. , 2012.

://../_///_/__//

__2012/_____20120210..

G, E, C P, L S. H E .,

2012. ://../////_/EPNG/PDF/MK

/MSG_E_F..

G, A, P J K. C P S : A

A I. 96, . 2 (M 2006): 108113.

://..///10.1257/000282806777212521.

G.. FFF (2011).

://.../?=&=&=&=&=&=3&=0CGIQFAC&=%3A%2F%2F..%2F_%2F%2F%2F1009%2F.%3F_%3

D15527&=NW_P52DG0QWJC&=AFQCNHDLS5_LS3B1JDXIJQ.


97/115

References

97

H, L. A B . , 2002.

H, , R C, M B. L

. 011 ()(M

2011): 8389. ://..//03/.?=5936272.

H, A. J (2010). ://../

/.?=///2010/10/10/BFK1FPLC.DL .

I. IC F FI (2011). ://../ID///2011//ICFF2011..

. M , 2011 (2011).

://..//////5..

. W /IC I D, 2012. ://../ID///.

I. W S N A O G, 2009.

://../.

I, MH, CL K, SW O, X Q. S S: O

. (2008): 713. ://..//_.?=56257.

KAMA, MACHARIA. IBM N , 2011.

://...//IP.?=2000053863&=56& .

KB, E. I D P M A D G A,

. (2001). ://..//PS_N_..

K, R. B 2020, . , 2011.

://./2011/12/08/2011/.

L, S. A& WF . , M 2012.

://...///335680//.

. H WF , 2010.

://..///915758/H_W_F____.

L, J, S, C S. A C S W P: (2007): 651.

L, H, P H, C M, J B. D 2.GH ISM B (2000).://...//ISM2..

L, S A. E B C A S.

(1998): 3136.

L, P. D ? (1997).

L, S. G C M2M C S M R $35 B 2016, L

A S E

the economic significance of licence-exempt spectrum to the future of the internet

Documents