- the ao modes for harmoni - from classical to laser...

47
- The AO modes for HARMONI - From Classical to Laser-assisted tomographic AO systems Benoît Neichel, Thierry Fusco, Carlos M. Correia, Kjetil Dohlen, Leonardo Blanco, Kacem El Hadi, Jean-François Sauvage, Noah Schwartz, Yoshito Ono, Fraser Clarke, Emmanuel Hugot, Miska Le Louarn, Niranjan A. Thatte, Matthias Tecza, Hermine Schnetler, Ian Bryson, Angus M. Gallie, David M. Henry, Tim J. Morris, Richard M. Myers, Joël Vernet, Jérôme Paufique, Peter Hammersley, Jean-Luc Gach, Alexis Carlotti, Ariadna Calcines, Pascal Vola, Sandrine Pascal, Marc Llored, Dave Melotte, Olivier Martin, Arlette Pecontal, Andrew Reeves, James Osbron, Matthew Townson

Upload: others

Post on 12-Jul-2020

0 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: - The AO modes for HARMONI - From Classical to Laser ...research.iac.es/congreso/AO4ELT5/media/tuesday/ao4elt5_neichel.pdf · First light ELT instrument Workhorse instrument - visible

- The AO modes for HARMONI -From Classical to Laser-assisted tomographic AO

systems

Benoît Neichel, Thierry Fusco, Carlos M. Correia, Kjetil Dohlen, Leonardo Blanco, Kacem El Hadi, Jean-François Sauvage, Noah Schwartz, Yoshito Ono, Fraser Clarke, Emmanuel Hugot, Miska Le Louarn, Niranjan A. Thatte, Matthias Tecza, Hermine

Schnetler, Ian Bryson, Angus M. Gallie, David M. Henry, Tim J. Morris, Richard M. Myers, Joël Vernet, Jérôme Paufique, Peter Hammersley, Jean-Luc Gach, Alexis Carlotti, Ariadna Calcines, Pascal Vola, Sandrine Pascal, Marc Llored, Dave Melotte,

Olivier Martin, Arlette Pecontal, Andrew Reeves, James Osbron, Matthew Townson

Page 2: - The AO modes for HARMONI - From Classical to Laser ...research.iac.es/congreso/AO4ELT5/media/tuesday/ao4elt5_neichel.pdf · First light ELT instrument Workhorse instrument - visible

HARMONI Overview

Partner Associate Partner Responsibilities

University of Oxford STFC – RAL Space Spectrographs & Obs. Prep

STFC – UK ATC Edinburgh Univ. of Durham Cryostat, AIV, Rotator, LTAO

IAC, Tenerife Pre-optics & Electronics

CSIC – CAB (INTA), Madrid Calibration & Sec. guiding

CRAL, Lyon IPAG, GrenobleIRAP, Toulouse

IFU & Software

LAM, Marseille ONERA, ParisIPAG, Grenoble

SCAO, LTAO, High Contrast

HARMONI Consortium

Page 3: - The AO modes for HARMONI - From Classical to Laser ...research.iac.es/congreso/AO4ELT5/media/tuesday/ao4elt5_neichel.pdf · First light ELT instrument Workhorse instrument - visible

HARMONI Overview

Partner Associate Partner Responsibilities

University of Oxford STFC – RAL Space Spectrographs & Obs. Prep

STFC – UK ATC Edinburgh Univ. of Durham Cryostat, AIV, Rotator, LTAO

IAC, Tenerife Pre-optics & Electronics

CSIC – CAB (INTA), Madrid Calibration & Sec. guiding

CRAL, Lyon IPAG, GrenobleIRAP, Toulouse

IFU & Software

LAM, Marseille ONERA, ParisIPAG, Grenoble

SCAO, LTAO, High Contrast

HARMONI Consortium

Thanks for hosting us this week !!

Page 4: - The AO modes for HARMONI - From Classical to Laser ...research.iac.es/congreso/AO4ELT5/media/tuesday/ao4elt5_neichel.pdf · First light ELT instrument Workhorse instrument - visible

HARMONI Overview

First light ELT instrument

HARMONI = High Angular Resolution - Monolithic - Optical and Near-infrared - Integral field spectrograph

Page 5: - The AO modes for HARMONI - From Classical to Laser ...research.iac.es/congreso/AO4ELT5/media/tuesday/ao4elt5_neichel.pdf · First light ELT instrument Workhorse instrument - visible

HARMONI Overview

First light ELT instrumentWorkhorse instrument - visible and near-infrared spectroscopy (0.5–2.4 µm)Integral Field Spectrograph – providing ~ 30 000 spectra per exposure

3D data cube

HARMONI = High Angular Resolution - Monolithic - Optical and Near-infrared - Integral field spectrograph

Page 6: - The AO modes for HARMONI - From Classical to Laser ...research.iac.es/congreso/AO4ELT5/media/tuesday/ao4elt5_neichel.pdf · First light ELT instrument Workhorse instrument - visible

Bands Wavelengths

(μm)

R

“V+R” or “I+z+J” or “H+K”0.45-0.8, 0.8-1.35,

1.45-2.45~3000

“I+z” or “J” or “H” or “K”0.8-1.0, 1.1-1.35, 1.45-

1.85, 1.95-2.45~7500

“Z” or “J_high” or “H_high” or “K_high” 0.9, 1.2, 1.65, 2.2

(TBD)

~20000

HARMONI Overview

HARMONI = 3 resolving powers

3D data cube

Page 7: - The AO modes for HARMONI - From Classical to Laser ...research.iac.es/congreso/AO4ELT5/media/tuesday/ao4elt5_neichel.pdf · First light ELT instrument Workhorse instrument - visible

HARMONI Overview

6.42” x 9.12”

3.04” x 4.28”

1.5

2”

x 2

.14

21

4 x1

52

spaxe

ls

0.61” x 0.86”

60 x 30 mas

20 mas

10 mas

4 mas

HARMONI = 4 spatial scales

3D data cube

Page 8: - The AO modes for HARMONI - From Classical to Laser ...research.iac.es/congreso/AO4ELT5/media/tuesday/ao4elt5_neichel.pdf · First light ELT instrument Workhorse instrument - visible

HARMONI Overview

6.42” x 9.12”

3.04” x 4.28”

1.5

2”

x 2

.14

21

4 x1

52

spaxe

ls

0.61” x 0.86”

60 x 30 mas

20 mas

10 mas

4 mas

HARMONI = 4 spatial scales

Assisted with

Adaptive Optics

Page 9: - The AO modes for HARMONI - From Classical to Laser ...research.iac.es/congreso/AO4ELT5/media/tuesday/ao4elt5_neichel.pdf · First light ELT instrument Workhorse instrument - visible

HARMONI: Two AO modes

High-Performance – Low sky coverage High-Performance & sky coverage

Single Conjugated AO Laser Tomography AO

x6

Page 10: - The AO modes for HARMONI - From Classical to Laser ...research.iac.es/congreso/AO4ELT5/media/tuesday/ao4elt5_neichel.pdf · First light ELT instrument Workhorse instrument - visible

HARMONI

HARMONI, SCAO & LTAO implementation

Page 11: - The AO modes for HARMONI - From Classical to Laser ...research.iac.es/congreso/AO4ELT5/media/tuesday/ao4elt5_neichel.pdf · First light ELT instrument Workhorse instrument - visible

HARMONI

Nasmyth Platform

Relay

Light from telescope

Telescope Pre-Focal Station

HARMONI Cryostat

Seeing limited

Focal plane

Re-imaged focal plane

HARMONI, SCAO & LTAO implementation

Page 12: - The AO modes for HARMONI - From Classical to Laser ...research.iac.es/congreso/AO4ELT5/media/tuesday/ao4elt5_neichel.pdf · First light ELT instrument Workhorse instrument - visible

HARMONI

Nasmyth Platform

Relay

Light from telescope

Telescope Pre-Focal Station

HARMONI Cryostat

Seeing limited

SCAO WFS SCAOSCAO dichroic

Focal plane

HARMONI, SCAO & LTAO implementation

Page 13: - The AO modes for HARMONI - From Classical to Laser ...research.iac.es/congreso/AO4ELT5/media/tuesday/ao4elt5_neichel.pdf · First light ELT instrument Workhorse instrument - visible

HARMONI

Nasmyth Platform

Relay

Light from telescope

Telescope Pre-Focal Station

HARMONI Cryostat

Seeing limited

NGS Pick-off SCAOLGS (<0

.6u

m)

LGSWFSModule

LTAO

Truth Pick-off

Dichroic

HARMONI, SCAO & LTAO implementation

Page 14: - The AO modes for HARMONI - From Classical to Laser ...research.iac.es/congreso/AO4ELT5/media/tuesday/ao4elt5_neichel.pdf · First light ELT instrument Workhorse instrument - visible

From Telescope

LGSWFS

SCAO & NGS WFS

IFS

HARMONI

HARMONI, SCAO & LTAO implementation

Page 15: - The AO modes for HARMONI - From Classical to Laser ...research.iac.es/congreso/AO4ELT5/media/tuesday/ao4elt5_neichel.pdf · First light ELT instrument Workhorse instrument - visible

From Telescope

LGSWFS

SCAO & NGS WFS

IFS

HARMONI

HARMONI, SCAO & LTAO implementation

Page 16: - The AO modes for HARMONI - From Classical to Laser ...research.iac.es/congreso/AO4ELT5/media/tuesday/ao4elt5_neichel.pdf · First light ELT instrument Workhorse instrument - visible

HARMONI SCAO

SCAO system baseline is to use a pyramid WFS:

Page 17: - The AO modes for HARMONI - From Classical to Laser ...research.iac.es/congreso/AO4ELT5/media/tuesday/ao4elt5_neichel.pdf · First light ELT instrument Workhorse instrument - visible

HARMONI SCAO

SCAO system baseline is to use a pyramid WFS Better performance & better sensitivity

+2 mag.

Page 18: - The AO modes for HARMONI - From Classical to Laser ...research.iac.es/congreso/AO4ELT5/media/tuesday/ao4elt5_neichel.pdf · First light ELT instrument Workhorse instrument - visible

HARMONI SCAO

SCAO system baseline is to use a pyramid WFS Better performance & better sensitivity

Page 19: - The AO modes for HARMONI - From Classical to Laser ...research.iac.es/congreso/AO4ELT5/media/tuesday/ao4elt5_neichel.pdf · First light ELT instrument Workhorse instrument - visible

HARMONI SCAO

SCAO system baseline is to use a pyramid WFS Better performance & better sensitivity Managing the “Island” effect

Page 20: - The AO modes for HARMONI - From Classical to Laser ...research.iac.es/congreso/AO4ELT5/media/tuesday/ao4elt5_neichel.pdf · First light ELT instrument Workhorse instrument - visible

HARMONI SCAO

SCAO system baseline is to use a pyramid WFS Better performance & better sensitivity Managing the “Island” effect

50cm Spiders

See Noah Schwartz talk on Friday

Page 21: - The AO modes for HARMONI - From Classical to Laser ...research.iac.es/congreso/AO4ELT5/media/tuesday/ao4elt5_neichel.pdf · First light ELT instrument Workhorse instrument - visible

HARMONI SCAO

SCAO system baseline is to use a pyramid WFS Better performance & better sensitivity Managing the “Island” effect

See Noah Schwartz talk on Friday

Page 22: - The AO modes for HARMONI - From Classical to Laser ...research.iac.es/congreso/AO4ELT5/media/tuesday/ao4elt5_neichel.pdf · First light ELT instrument Workhorse instrument - visible

HARMONI SCAO

SCAO system baseline is to use a pyramid WFS Better performance & better sensitivity Managing the “Island” effect

Small modulation provides information on what’s behind the spider

+ Secret ingredient See Noah Schwartz talk on Friday

Page 23: - The AO modes for HARMONI - From Classical to Laser ...research.iac.es/congreso/AO4ELT5/media/tuesday/ao4elt5_neichel.pdf · First light ELT instrument Workhorse instrument - visible

HARMONI SCAO

SCAO system baseline is to use a pyramid WFS Better performance & better sensitivity Managing the “Island” effect

Small modulation provides information on what’s behind the spider

+ Secret ingredient See Noah Schwartz talk on Friday

Before After

Residuals less than

50nm

SCAO will provide a SR of >70% in K-band

Page 24: - The AO modes for HARMONI - From Classical to Laser ...research.iac.es/congreso/AO4ELT5/media/tuesday/ao4elt5_neichel.pdf · First light ELT instrument Workhorse instrument - visible

HARMONI SCAO

High Contrast :Spectral characterization of young Jupiters around nearby stars in H & K bands at R=3000-20000, with a 10-6 contrast at 200mas.

From A. Carlotti, A. Vigan, D. Mouillet, M. Bonnefois

Page 25: - The AO modes for HARMONI - From Classical to Laser ...research.iac.es/congreso/AO4ELT5/media/tuesday/ao4elt5_neichel.pdf · First light ELT instrument Workhorse instrument - visible

HARMONI SCAO

High Contrast :Simulated data of 4 planets w/ 10-6 planets contrast & 51 Eri b-like synthetic spectrum (2h exp. with H=6 star).

From A. Carlotti, A. Vigan, D. Mouillet, M. Bonnefois

Page 26: - The AO modes for HARMONI - From Classical to Laser ...research.iac.es/congreso/AO4ELT5/media/tuesday/ao4elt5_neichel.pdf · First light ELT instrument Workhorse instrument - visible

LGSWFS

SCAO & NGS WFS

HARMONI

HARMONI, SCAO & LTAO implementation

“High-Order Loop”

“Low-Order Loop”

Page 27: - The AO modes for HARMONI - From Classical to Laser ...research.iac.es/congreso/AO4ELT5/media/tuesday/ao4elt5_neichel.pdf · First light ELT instrument Workhorse instrument - visible

HARMONI LTAO

LTAO Top-Level Specifications:

Strehl K > 60%

Jitter < 2mas

Sky Coverage >10% at the Pole

60 x 30 mas20 mas10 mas4 mas

EE (20mas) > 40%

Jitter < 5mas

Sky Coverage of >50% at the Pole

EE (40mas) > 50%

Jitter < 10mas

Sky Coverage of >90% at the Pole

Page 28: - The AO modes for HARMONI - From Classical to Laser ...research.iac.es/congreso/AO4ELT5/media/tuesday/ao4elt5_neichel.pdf · First light ELT instrument Workhorse instrument - visible

HARMONI LTAO

LTAO Top-Level Specifications:

Strehl K > 60%

Jitter < 2mas

Sky Coverage >10% at the Pole

60 x 30 mas20 mas10 mas4 mas

EE (20mas) > 40%

Jitter < 5mas

Sky Coverage of >50% at the Pole

EE (40mas) > 50%

Jitter < 10mas

Sky Coverage of >90% at the Pole

Set requirements on the LGS High-Order Loop

Page 29: - The AO modes for HARMONI - From Classical to Laser ...research.iac.es/congreso/AO4ELT5/media/tuesday/ao4elt5_neichel.pdf · First light ELT instrument Workhorse instrument - visible

HARMONI LTAO

LTAO Top-Level Specifications:

Strehl K > 60%

Jitter < 2mas

Sky Coverage >10% at the Pole

60 x 30 mas20 mas10 mas4 mas

EE (20mas) > 40%

Jitter < 5mas

Sky Coverage of >50% at the Pole

EE (40mas) > 50%

Jitter < 10mas

Sky Coverage of >90% at the Pole

Set requirements on the LGS High-Order Loop

Set requirements on the NGS Low-Order Loop

Page 30: - The AO modes for HARMONI - From Classical to Laser ...research.iac.es/congreso/AO4ELT5/media/tuesday/ao4elt5_neichel.pdf · First light ELT instrument Workhorse instrument - visible

90km − ZA=0

130km − ZA=45

180km − ZA=60

20 40 60 80

0.2

0.4

0.6

LGS Radius (arcsec)

SR

(K

−B

an

d)

R0 scaled

HARMONI LTAO

Optimal LGS constellation between R=[15-40]”

“Small” constellation greatly helps for tomographic error

Laser constellation

See Thierry Fusco talk on Thursday

Page 31: - The AO modes for HARMONI - From Classical to Laser ...research.iac.es/congreso/AO4ELT5/media/tuesday/ao4elt5_neichel.pdf · First light ELT instrument Workhorse instrument - visible

HARMONI LTAO

Sensing on LGS

LLT

Sodium layer

Detectorplane

T ~ 20km

H ~ 80km

Distance from launch site

Pupilplane

Predicted spot elongation pattern

LLT

Page 32: - The AO modes for HARMONI - From Classical to Laser ...research.iac.es/congreso/AO4ELT5/media/tuesday/ao4elt5_neichel.pdf · First light ELT instrument Workhorse instrument - visible

HARMONI LTAO

LLT

Detectorplane

Distance from launch site

Pupilplane

Dealing with spot elongation

25”

1”

Ideally, we need subapertureswith 25x25 pixels of ~1”

For 80x80 subapertures, we need 2000 x 2000 pixels

Page 33: - The AO modes for HARMONI - From Classical to Laser ...research.iac.es/congreso/AO4ELT5/media/tuesday/ao4elt5_neichel.pdf · First light ELT instrument Workhorse instrument - visible

HARMONI LTAO

LLT

Detectorplane

Distance from launch site

Pupilplane

Dealing with spot truncation

Most likely, we will have no more than 10x10 pixels

Strong truncation

Page 34: - The AO modes for HARMONI - From Classical to Laser ...research.iac.es/congreso/AO4ELT5/media/tuesday/ao4elt5_neichel.pdf · First light ELT instrument Workhorse instrument - visible

HARMONI LTAO

Dealing with spot truncation

Truncation induces biases that are

projected on-axis by the Tomography

See Leo Blanco talk on Thursday

x6

Up to 300nm

Page 35: - The AO modes for HARMONI - From Classical to Laser ...research.iac.es/congreso/AO4ELT5/media/tuesday/ao4elt5_neichel.pdf · First light ELT instrument Workhorse instrument - visible

HARMONI LTAO

Dealing with spot truncation

One way to reduce this impact is to reject the

truncated measurements

See Leo Blanco talk on Thursday

x6

Down to 80nm

Page 36: - The AO modes for HARMONI - From Classical to Laser ...research.iac.es/congreso/AO4ELT5/media/tuesday/ao4elt5_neichel.pdf · First light ELT instrument Workhorse instrument - visible

Temporal frequency [Hz]10

-210

-110

010

110

2

|Y(f

)|2/H

z

10-10

10-5

Single-Sided Amplitude Spectrum of y(t)

PSD ATM

PSD WS

HARMONI LTAO

Sensing on NGS

Main offender is the telescope Windshake

Atmosphere = 15 masWindshake = 263 mas

But windshake is isoplanatic:

we can use the telescope WFS

to reduce it

Page 37: - The AO modes for HARMONI - From Classical to Laser ...research.iac.es/congreso/AO4ELT5/media/tuesday/ao4elt5_neichel.pdf · First light ELT instrument Workhorse instrument - visible

HARMONI LTAO

Sensing on NGS

2x2 Shack-Hartmann8 mas / pixel

125 pixel / subap.500 Hz

1.2 to 2.2 microns

Jitter control strategy:• Use “bright but far” stars to compensate windshake with

telescope WFS • Use “faint but close” star to compensate atmospheric jitter

Page 38: - The AO modes for HARMONI - From Classical to Laser ...research.iac.es/congreso/AO4ELT5/media/tuesday/ao4elt5_neichel.pdf · First light ELT instrument Workhorse instrument - visible

HARMONI LTAO

Sensing on NGS

2x2 Shack-Hartmann8 mas / pixel

125 pixel / subap.500 Hz

1.2 to 2.2 microns

Jitter control strategy:• Use “bright but far” stars to compensate windshake with

telescope WFS • Use “faint but close” star to compensate atmospheric jitter

0 5 100.0

0.2

0.4

0.6

0.8

jitter (mas)

Sky C

ov.

10% Sky Cov. for 2mas

South galactic Pole

50% Sky Cov. for 5mas

90% Sky Cov. for 10mas

Page 39: - The AO modes for HARMONI - From Classical to Laser ...research.iac.es/congreso/AO4ELT5/media/tuesday/ao4elt5_neichel.pdf · First light ELT instrument Workhorse instrument - visible

Sensing on NGS

HARMONI LTAO See Carlos Correia poster on Thursday

Page 40: - The AO modes for HARMONI - From Classical to Laser ...research.iac.es/congreso/AO4ELT5/media/tuesday/ao4elt5_neichel.pdf · First light ELT instrument Workhorse instrument - visible

Cosmos Field

LTAO 1NGS

−0.1 0.0 0.1 0.2

0.1

0.2

0.3

0

1

2

3

4

6

7

8

9

10

11

jitt

er

[ma

s]

RA + 150.05 [deg]

DE

C +

2.1

7 [

deg

]

Sensing on NGS

HARMONI LTAO

GoodS Field

LTAO 1NGS

Old ESO profile

0.0 0.1 0.20.0

0.1

0.2

0

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

9

10

11

12

13

14

15

16

jitt

er

[ma

s]

RA + 53.00 [deg]

DE

C +

−2

7.9

4 [

de

g]

See Carlos Correia poster on Thursday

The NGS strategy fulfills the science requirements for all observations

Page 41: - The AO modes for HARMONI - From Classical to Laser ...research.iac.es/congreso/AO4ELT5/media/tuesday/ao4elt5_neichel.pdf · First light ELT instrument Workhorse instrument - visible

Conclusion: HARMONI schedule

12/2017

PDR

2019

FDR

2023

MAIT

Page 42: - The AO modes for HARMONI - From Classical to Laser ...research.iac.es/congreso/AO4ELT5/media/tuesday/ao4elt5_neichel.pdf · First light ELT instrument Workhorse instrument - visible

2024: integration at the telescope

Dr. Frans Snik

2024: 1st light !

Conclusion: HARMONI schedule

12/2017

PDR

2019

FDR

2023

MAIT

Page 43: - The AO modes for HARMONI - From Classical to Laser ...research.iac.es/congreso/AO4ELT5/media/tuesday/ao4elt5_neichel.pdf · First light ELT instrument Workhorse instrument - visible

- The AO modes for HARMONI -

1 more slide beforeCoffee Break !

Page 44: - The AO modes for HARMONI - From Classical to Laser ...research.iac.es/congreso/AO4ELT5/media/tuesday/ao4elt5_neichel.pdf · First light ELT instrument Workhorse instrument - visible

Register now, for the 2 to 4 October 2017 in Padova, Italy

https://www.ict.inaf.it/indico/event/521/

Page 45: - The AO modes for HARMONI - From Classical to Laser ...research.iac.es/congreso/AO4ELT5/media/tuesday/ao4elt5_neichel.pdf · First light ELT instrument Workhorse instrument - visible

Register now, for the 2 to 4 October 2017 in Padova, Italy

https://www.ict.inaf.it/indico/event/521/

Marseille 2016

Page 46: - The AO modes for HARMONI - From Classical to Laser ...research.iac.es/congreso/AO4ELT5/media/tuesday/ao4elt5_neichel.pdf · First light ELT instrument Workhorse instrument - visible
Page 47: - The AO modes for HARMONI - From Classical to Laser ...research.iac.es/congreso/AO4ELT5/media/tuesday/ao4elt5_neichel.pdf · First light ELT instrument Workhorse instrument - visible

HARMONI SCAO

SCAO system baseline is to use a pyramid WFS Better performance & better sensitivity

151397 17