technical seminar for cathodic protection to gogc design unit …. interferenceacdc_technical... ·...

50
Technical Seminar for Cathodic Protection to GOGC Design Unit Specialists Dr. Nick Kioupis, Cathodic & Lightning Protection Section Head, DESFA

Upload: others

Post on 29-Mar-2020

5 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Technical Seminar for Cathodic Protection to GOGC Design Unit …. interferenceacdc_Technical... · 2013-10-31 · Technical Seminar for Cathodic Protection to GOGC Design Unit Specialists

Technical Seminar for Cathodic Protection

to GOGC Design Unit Specialists

Dr. Nick Kioupis, Cathodic & Lightning Protection

Section Head, DESFA

Page 2: Technical Seminar for Cathodic Protection to GOGC Design Unit …. interferenceacdc_Technical... · 2013-10-31 · Technical Seminar for Cathodic Protection to GOGC Design Unit Specialists

Interference

• DC

–Constant (CP systems of third

parties)

–Fluctuating (e.g. railways, dc

sources, mines, welding machines

–Tellurics

2

Page 3: Technical Seminar for Cathodic Protection to GOGC Design Unit …. interferenceacdc_Technical... · 2013-10-31 · Technical Seminar for Cathodic Protection to GOGC Design Unit Specialists

Sources of dc stray current

Trolley-buses and dc traction

systems

HVDC transmission

systems

DC sources

Industrial equipment (e.g.

welding machines)

DC telephone network

Cathodic protection systems

Traffic light equipment - dc operated

3

Page 4: Technical Seminar for Cathodic Protection to GOGC Design Unit …. interferenceacdc_Technical... · 2013-10-31 · Technical Seminar for Cathodic Protection to GOGC Design Unit Specialists

Stray current corrosion from dc railways interference

Page 5: Technical Seminar for Cathodic Protection to GOGC Design Unit …. interferenceacdc_Technical... · 2013-10-31 · Technical Seminar for Cathodic Protection to GOGC Design Unit Specialists

Identification and measurement of dc stray currents

• Recording of potential

• Voltage gradients along the pipeline and perpendicular to it

• DC line current measurement/recordings

• Line current measurement by current clamp method

• Current to polarisation probe or corrosion coupon

• Interference between CP systems

• Stray Current Mapper

5

Page 6: Technical Seminar for Cathodic Protection to GOGC Design Unit …. interferenceacdc_Technical... · 2013-10-31 · Technical Seminar for Cathodic Protection to GOGC Design Unit Specialists

Criteria according to ΕΝ 50162

• Criteria for non cathodically protected pipelines

• Criterion for cathodically protected pipeline

– IR free potential to be within acceptable limits (e.g. -0,85V, cf. EN

12954)

– Criteria related to how long an anodic current exits from a

probe/coupon

– Cathodic interference >500mV on (IR included) or EiRfree<El

6

Page 7: Technical Seminar for Cathodic Protection to GOGC Design Unit …. interferenceacdc_Technical... · 2013-10-31 · Technical Seminar for Cathodic Protection to GOGC Design Unit Specialists
Page 8: Technical Seminar for Cathodic Protection to GOGC Design Unit …. interferenceacdc_Technical... · 2013-10-31 · Technical Seminar for Cathodic Protection to GOGC Design Unit Specialists
Page 9: Technical Seminar for Cathodic Protection to GOGC Design Unit …. interferenceacdc_Technical... · 2013-10-31 · Technical Seminar for Cathodic Protection to GOGC Design Unit Specialists
Page 10: Technical Seminar for Cathodic Protection to GOGC Design Unit …. interferenceacdc_Technical... · 2013-10-31 · Technical Seminar for Cathodic Protection to GOGC Design Unit Specialists
Page 11: Technical Seminar for Cathodic Protection to GOGC Design Unit …. interferenceacdc_Technical... · 2013-10-31 · Technical Seminar for Cathodic Protection to GOGC Design Unit Specialists
Page 12: Technical Seminar for Cathodic Protection to GOGC Design Unit …. interferenceacdc_Technical... · 2013-10-31 · Technical Seminar for Cathodic Protection to GOGC Design Unit Specialists

Practical example of a real case of potential dip due to

crossing with foreign pipeline

Page 13: Technical Seminar for Cathodic Protection to GOGC Design Unit …. interferenceacdc_Technical... · 2013-10-31 · Technical Seminar for Cathodic Protection to GOGC Design Unit Specialists

IFO method to detect coating defects

13

Page 14: Technical Seminar for Cathodic Protection to GOGC Design Unit …. interferenceacdc_Technical... · 2013-10-31 · Technical Seminar for Cathodic Protection to GOGC Design Unit Specialists

Typical pattern of voltage gradients around a coating defect

14

Page 15: Technical Seminar for Cathodic Protection to GOGC Design Unit …. interferenceacdc_Technical... · 2013-10-31 · Technical Seminar for Cathodic Protection to GOGC Design Unit Specialists

2 and 3 electrodes methods

15

Page 16: Technical Seminar for Cathodic Protection to GOGC Design Unit …. interferenceacdc_Technical... · 2013-10-31 · Technical Seminar for Cathodic Protection to GOGC Design Unit Specialists

Adding-up method

16

Mathematically expressed:

[1] UA1 - UA2 = 0

[2] UA1 = UA2

(considering remote

ground)

Thus:

[3] UB1 - UA1 = UB1 - UA2

[4] UB2 - UA2 = UB2 - UA1

Assumption:

[5] ΔU1 = UB1 - UA1

[6] ΔU2 = UB2 - UA1

resulting in equation (for UA1):

[7] ΔU1 - UB1 = ΔU2 - UB2

[8] 0 = ΔU1 + (UB2 - UB1) - ΔU2

Thus:

ΔU2 = UB2 - UB1 + ΔU1

Page 17: Technical Seminar for Cathodic Protection to GOGC Design Unit …. interferenceacdc_Technical... · 2013-10-31 · Technical Seminar for Cathodic Protection to GOGC Design Unit Specialists

Adding-up

17

Page 18: Technical Seminar for Cathodic Protection to GOGC Design Unit …. interferenceacdc_Technical... · 2013-10-31 · Technical Seminar for Cathodic Protection to GOGC Design Unit Specialists

Pipe locators and coating defects detection with A-

frame

18

Page 19: Technical Seminar for Cathodic Protection to GOGC Design Unit …. interferenceacdc_Technical... · 2013-10-31 · Technical Seminar for Cathodic Protection to GOGC Design Unit Specialists

Investigation with Stray Current Mapper

19

Page 20: Technical Seminar for Cathodic Protection to GOGC Design Unit …. interferenceacdc_Technical... · 2013-10-31 · Technical Seminar for Cathodic Protection to GOGC Design Unit Specialists

DCVG and Pearson Tecniques

20

Page 21: Technical Seminar for Cathodic Protection to GOGC Design Unit …. interferenceacdc_Technical... · 2013-10-31 · Technical Seminar for Cathodic Protection to GOGC Design Unit Specialists

• ΑC

–Short-term

during fault currents

–Long-term

during

normal operation

of the powerline

21

Interference

Page 22: Technical Seminar for Cathodic Protection to GOGC Design Unit …. interferenceacdc_Technical... · 2013-10-31 · Technical Seminar for Cathodic Protection to GOGC Design Unit Specialists

• ΑC

–Capacitive

–Conductive

– Inductive

22

Interference

Page 23: Technical Seminar for Cathodic Protection to GOGC Design Unit …. interferenceacdc_Technical... · 2013-10-31 · Technical Seminar for Cathodic Protection to GOGC Design Unit Specialists

AC corrosion from powerlines interference

Page 24: Technical Seminar for Cathodic Protection to GOGC Design Unit …. interferenceacdc_Technical... · 2013-10-31 · Technical Seminar for Cathodic Protection to GOGC Design Unit Specialists

• History

• End of 1980s: First cases of a.c. corrosion in several european countries

• 2001: Publishing of the CEOCOR a.c. corrosion booklet that summarized all

relevant European experiences

• 2006: Acceptance of CEN/XP TS 15280 based on activities within

CEOCOR

• 2013: Issue of EN 15280 Evaluation of a.c. corrosion likelihood of buried

pipelines applicable to cathodically protected pipelines

• Conclusion

• The current standard represents the European experience collected within

the last 25 years

• there is no fundamental additional information that was not already known

by 2004

• There is vast field experience for all of the used thresholds

AC corrosion

Page 25: Technical Seminar for Cathodic Protection to GOGC Design Unit …. interferenceacdc_Technical... · 2013-10-31 · Technical Seminar for Cathodic Protection to GOGC Design Unit Specialists
Page 26: Technical Seminar for Cathodic Protection to GOGC Design Unit …. interferenceacdc_Technical... · 2013-10-31 · Technical Seminar for Cathodic Protection to GOGC Design Unit Specialists
Page 27: Technical Seminar for Cathodic Protection to GOGC Design Unit …. interferenceacdc_Technical... · 2013-10-31 · Technical Seminar for Cathodic Protection to GOGC Design Unit Specialists
Page 28: Technical Seminar for Cathodic Protection to GOGC Design Unit …. interferenceacdc_Technical... · 2013-10-31 · Technical Seminar for Cathodic Protection to GOGC Design Unit Specialists
Page 29: Technical Seminar for Cathodic Protection to GOGC Design Unit …. interferenceacdc_Technical... · 2013-10-31 · Technical Seminar for Cathodic Protection to GOGC Design Unit Specialists
Page 30: Technical Seminar for Cathodic Protection to GOGC Design Unit …. interferenceacdc_Technical... · 2013-10-31 · Technical Seminar for Cathodic Protection to GOGC Design Unit Specialists
Page 31: Technical Seminar for Cathodic Protection to GOGC Design Unit …. interferenceacdc_Technical... · 2013-10-31 · Technical Seminar for Cathodic Protection to GOGC Design Unit Specialists
Page 32: Technical Seminar for Cathodic Protection to GOGC Design Unit …. interferenceacdc_Technical... · 2013-10-31 · Technical Seminar for Cathodic Protection to GOGC Design Unit Specialists
Page 33: Technical Seminar for Cathodic Protection to GOGC Design Unit …. interferenceacdc_Technical... · 2013-10-31 · Technical Seminar for Cathodic Protection to GOGC Design Unit Specialists
Page 34: Technical Seminar for Cathodic Protection to GOGC Design Unit …. interferenceacdc_Technical... · 2013-10-31 · Technical Seminar for Cathodic Protection to GOGC Design Unit Specialists

Practical examples from pipelines in Switzerland

Page 35: Technical Seminar for Cathodic Protection to GOGC Design Unit …. interferenceacdc_Technical... · 2013-10-31 · Technical Seminar for Cathodic Protection to GOGC Design Unit Specialists
Page 36: Technical Seminar for Cathodic Protection to GOGC Design Unit …. interferenceacdc_Technical... · 2013-10-31 · Technical Seminar for Cathodic Protection to GOGC Design Unit Specialists
Page 37: Technical Seminar for Cathodic Protection to GOGC Design Unit …. interferenceacdc_Technical... · 2013-10-31 · Technical Seminar for Cathodic Protection to GOGC Design Unit Specialists
Page 38: Technical Seminar for Cathodic Protection to GOGC Design Unit …. interferenceacdc_Technical... · 2013-10-31 · Technical Seminar for Cathodic Protection to GOGC Design Unit Specialists
Page 39: Technical Seminar for Cathodic Protection to GOGC Design Unit …. interferenceacdc_Technical... · 2013-10-31 · Technical Seminar for Cathodic Protection to GOGC Design Unit Specialists
Page 40: Technical Seminar for Cathodic Protection to GOGC Design Unit …. interferenceacdc_Technical... · 2013-10-31 · Technical Seminar for Cathodic Protection to GOGC Design Unit Specialists
Page 41: Technical Seminar for Cathodic Protection to GOGC Design Unit …. interferenceacdc_Technical... · 2013-10-31 · Technical Seminar for Cathodic Protection to GOGC Design Unit Specialists
Page 42: Technical Seminar for Cathodic Protection to GOGC Design Unit …. interferenceacdc_Technical... · 2013-10-31 · Technical Seminar for Cathodic Protection to GOGC Design Unit Specialists
Page 43: Technical Seminar for Cathodic Protection to GOGC Design Unit …. interferenceacdc_Technical... · 2013-10-31 · Technical Seminar for Cathodic Protection to GOGC Design Unit Specialists
Page 44: Technical Seminar for Cathodic Protection to GOGC Design Unit …. interferenceacdc_Technical... · 2013-10-31 · Technical Seminar for Cathodic Protection to GOGC Design Unit Specialists
Page 45: Technical Seminar for Cathodic Protection to GOGC Design Unit …. interferenceacdc_Technical... · 2013-10-31 · Technical Seminar for Cathodic Protection to GOGC Design Unit Specialists

Limit length Lgr or spacing of a pipeline when laid

parallel to a 50Hz three phase high voltage overhead line

Page 46: Technical Seminar for Cathodic Protection to GOGC Design Unit …. interferenceacdc_Technical... · 2013-10-31 · Technical Seminar for Cathodic Protection to GOGC Design Unit Specialists

Interference distance according to NPR 2760

46

Page 47: Technical Seminar for Cathodic Protection to GOGC Design Unit …. interferenceacdc_Technical... · 2013-10-31 · Technical Seminar for Cathodic Protection to GOGC Design Unit Specialists

Analysis of induced overvoltages on a distribution pipeline by

a nearby lightning strike

47

Page 48: Technical Seminar for Cathodic Protection to GOGC Design Unit …. interferenceacdc_Technical... · 2013-10-31 · Technical Seminar for Cathodic Protection to GOGC Design Unit Specialists

Electrical Interferences measurements

• Cathodic protection potentials recordings at least for 24h

• Current magnitude and direction measured on coupons,

• Line current recording,

• Comparison of patterns of recordings on the stray current

source and on the pipeline itself,

• Corrosion rate recording on ER probes.

– Other measurements referenced in ΕΝ 50443.

48

Page 49: Technical Seminar for Cathodic Protection to GOGC Design Unit …. interferenceacdc_Technical... · 2013-10-31 · Technical Seminar for Cathodic Protection to GOGC Design Unit Specialists

Interference distances (prΕΝ 50443:2011)

49

Page 50: Technical Seminar for Cathodic Protection to GOGC Design Unit …. interferenceacdc_Technical... · 2013-10-31 · Technical Seminar for Cathodic Protection to GOGC Design Unit Specialists