1

Tackling the Gender Pay Gap: What Can Ireland Learn from the UK?

1.0 Introduction A briefing for politicians and industry stakeholders took place at Leinster House on Wednesday, 4th July, on the topic of ‘Tackling the Gender Pay Gap: What Can Ireland Learn from the UK?’. The briefing was organised by the new cross-party group on workplace equality, and hosted by Senator Lorraine Clifford-Lee, working in partnership with Dress for Success Dublin. Two UK experts on workplace diversity, inclusion and gender pay reporting addressed the event:

• Emer Bucukoglu of Innecto Reward Consulting, the largest independent pay and reward consultancy in the UK;

• Hayley Barnard, Managing Director of MIX Diversity Developers, a consultancy that specialises in delivering diversity and inclusion audits and gender equality initiatives for workplaces across the UK.

Senator Clifford-Lee and Sonya Lennon, founder of Dress for Success Dublin, also spoke at the event. Politicians in attendance included:

• Maria Bailey TD

• Dara Calleary TD

• Lisa Chambers TD

• Senator Lorraine Clifford-Lee

• Stephen Donnelly TD

• Micheál Martin TD

• Jim O’Callaghan TD

• Kate O’Connell TD

• Fiona O’Loughlin TD

• Senator Grace O’Sullivan

• Roisin Shortall TD

• Niamh Smyth TD

• Robert Troy TD Organisations in attendance included:

• AIB

• 30% Club

• BDO

• Boots

• Carr Communications

• CC Solicitors

• Coeliac Society of Ireland

• Communicorp

• Computerology

• Davy

• Dept. Of Justice & Equality

• Dress for Success Dublin

• eir

2

• Fórsa Trade Union

• Grant Thornton

• Higher Education Authority

• Ibec

• Innecto Reward Consulting

• Invesco

• JP Morgan

• McCann Fitzgerald

• MIX Diversity Developers

• NWCI

• Oracle

• Permanent TSB

• RCSI

• RSA

• Social Innovation Fund

• SOLAS

• The Bar of Ireland

• Tilman Brewin Dolphin

• TUI

• Young Fine Gael

3

2.0 Presentations by Guest Speakers 2.1 Emer Bucukolgu, Manager and Reward Consultant at Innecto Reward Consulting Email: emer.bucukoglu@innecto.com Twitter: @BucukogluEmer

4

5

6

2.2 Hayley Barnard, Managing Director at MIX Diversity Developers Email: hayley@mixdiversitydevelopers.co.uk Twitter: @hayleybarnard

7

8

9

10

11

3.0 Dress for Success Dublin Gender Pay Gap Infographic

12

4.0 Event Photographs

13

5.0 Event Press Release

PRESS RELEASE

Wednesday, 4th July 2018

UK experts highlight lessons for Ireland on implementing gender pay gap laws

– Dress for Success Dublin launches cross-party parliamentary group on workplace equality – Gender pay gap reporting will transform the workplace for women in Ireland and change how companies recruit, retain and evaluate staff. That’s according to Emer Bucukoglu, a UK expert on Reward, who is addressing a special briefing in Leinster House today (04.07.18) on the lessons Ireland can learn from the UK’s experience of implementing gender pay gap legislation. The briefing was organised by a new cross-party parliamentary group on workplace equality, established by the Dress for Success Dublin charity and chaired by Senator Lorraine Clifford-Lee. Today’s event marks the official launch of the cross-party group, with representatives from industry and trade unions in attendance, as well as Senators and TDs. Commenting today, Mrs. Bucukoglu, who works with Innecto Reward Consulting, the largest independent pay and reward consultancy in the UK, said: “Gender pay gap reporting – once in force – will become a very powerful piece of employment legislation and will make a hugely positive change for women across Ireland. “In the UK, we have seen first-hand how gender pay gap legislation has been a game-changer in terms of workplace culture and practices. In its first year alone, we have seen how employers are changing the way they look at their policies and practices, conducting deeper analytics around pay processes, promotional activity, as well as reviewing their recruitment policies, mentoring schemes and career progression frameworks. On top of this, many are reaching out to schools and universities to challenge the make-up of gender across many fields that, to date, were predominantly occupied by males.” Mrs. Bucukoglu, who has over 20 years’ experience in Reward and more recently in gender pay and equal pay audits, outlined a number of lessons for Ireland from the UK’s experience of implementing gender pay gap legislation. These included:

1. Educate well in advance: “It’s not about unearthing pay discrimination,” she said. “That’s already illegal in Ireland. Rather, it’s about highlighting pay gaps in a bid to understand the main contributors to these gaps, be it sectoral bias, unfair pay mechanisms, discriminatory working policies, or lack of equal opportunities to advance. We need to make sure employers, policymakers and the general public are clear about the difference between the gender pay gap and equal pay.”

2. Keep compulsory reporting and compliance requirements: “Reporting by company is crucial in driving change,” according to Mrs. Bucukoglu. “In the UK, companies that fail to provide their headline pay gaps face legal action, including court orders and fines.”

3. Require a narrative accompanying the data, which must be signed by senior figures – typically the CEO and Chair – from the workplace in question. “This narrative requirement has driven big change,” said Mrs. Bucukoglu. “It’s simply not enough to acknowledge the gap; the reasons behind it must be explained. Employers must provide context and insight into any recruiting challenges they face. Importantly, they must also move beyond the negative:

14

articulate the good work they’re doing to challenge the gender pay gap and to promote inclusion and diversity. The most compelling narratives were the ones that were honest in holding their hands up to the gap, explaining the reasons but – more importantly – explicit in terms of what they planned to do to change the picture.”

The business case for diversity is being highlighted during today’s briefing – with an input from Hayley Barnard, Managing Director of MIX Diversity Developers, a consultancy that specialises in delivering diversity and inclusion audits and gender equality initiatives for workplaces across Europe. “The business case for greater gender balance is indisputable,” said Ms. Barnard. “Multiple studies from the likes of McKinsey, Gallup, Credit Suisse and Catalyst have reported that gender diversity in leadership is strongly correlated with higher returns, profitability and share price. Whilst gender balance is absolutely the right thing to strive for from an ethnical perspective, companies see greater success when they also have clarity around the business case, such as improved innovation, collaboration, staff retention or enhanced decision-making, and when this business case is aligned with their growth strategy. “In a recent survey of 10,000 global leaders by Deloitte, two-thirds said greater inclusion of diversity, particularly in management positions, is important to business success – but many struggle with how to achieve this. What’s clear is that those businesses that invest time and resources into a culture shift programme see the best results. Having a compelling vision for gender diversity, clearly communicated from the CEO, with targets and accountability in place, are features of the most successful businesses when it comes to gender inclusion.” Plans to challenge inequality at work Senator Lorraine Clifford-Lee, chair of the new cross-party group on workplace equality, and designer and entrepreneur Sonya Lennon – who founded Dress for Success Dublin – are addressing today’s event. “Our aim with the cross-party group is to raise awareness of the inequalities that persist in Irish workforces,” said Senator Clifford-Lee. “We’ll be holding a range of briefings for elected representatives, policymakers and sectoral stakeholders over the coming months, and we’ll look at introducing legislation early next year to address some of the obstacles to workplace equality. “In the meantime, we welcome the Government’s commitment to introduce gender pay gap legislation in the months to come. This is an important first step in tackling inequality at work, and we will be monitoring the development of the legislation closely.” Sonya Lennon said: “The cross-party group has emerged from the Equal Pay campaign run by Dress for Success Dublin for the past three years. Through our service provision, we encounter first-hand many of the obstacles women face when entering and progressing in the workplace. “One of the striking things we’ve noticed is that there are a lot of gender pay gap ‘deniers’ in Ireland: many individuals and workplaces refuse to acknowledge that a pay gap exists and that there are positive steps companies can take to address this. “At the same time, there are many companies going above and beyond already – to promote diversity and inclusion, and to prepare for the introduction of gender pay gap laws here. We had huge interest from industry in today’s event, as well as from trade unions, education and training

15

bodies, and wider civic society. We can learn valuable lessons from analysing the UK’s experience before we introduce our own gender pay gap laws in Ireland.” Further information about Dress for Success Dublin and the new cross-party group on workplace equality is available at www.dressforsuccessdublin.org. ENDS Contact: Martina Quinn / Darragh McGirr, Alice PR & Events, Tel: 01-5582151 / 087-6522033 / 086-2599369, Email: media@alicepr.com. Notes to Editors: The briefing event takes place at 4pm today, Wednesday, 4th July, in the AV Room at Leinster House. Media wishing to attend must register in advance by contacting Alice PR using the contact information above. About Dress for Success Dublin Dress for Success Dublin works with women to help them enter or re-enter the workforce and establish sustainable careers. Services include suiting appointments, a career centre, sectoral workshops, mentoring programmes and ongoing career support. A national outreach service is being piloted this year. The organisation is a registered charity and part of a worldwide network of Dress for Success affiliates. Follow Dress for Success Dublin on Twitter, Instagram and Facebook: @DFSDublin, #WorkEqual.

16

6.0 Media Coverage Highlights Irish Independent Thursday, 5th July 2018

RTÉ Radio 1: ‘Drivetime’ package by Della Kilroy Thursday, 5th July 2018

17

7.0 Support the Work of Dress for Success Dublin Dress for Success Dublin is a charity that works to support women to enter the workforce and establish sustainable careers. There are many ways you can support our work, including: Helping to fund our services:

• Just €800 will support a woman back to work! This amount funds a full Dress for Success development programme for one woman, including a bespoke, needs-based employment consultation; professional styling services; interview support; and the opportunity to avail of mentoring and ongoing career development programmes.

• From our base in Dublin, we have expanded to offer outreach services nationwide. €2,000 will fund an outreach event and help us support women across Ireland. At our outreach events, groups of women are given the skills and tools they need to succeed at interviews, including a professional styling consultation. They leave with an interview outfit and a new-found sense of confidence.

Becoming a ‘Pay Disclosure Pioneer’: We are bringing together a small group of businesses that – facilitated by Dress for Success Dublin – will commit to early pay disclosure and advancement towards gender equality before legal requirement under Ireland’s new gender pay gap laws. If your organisation is interested in becoming a ‘Pay Disclosure Pioneer’ or finding out more, please contact Martina Quinn, Tel: 087-6522033, Email: martina@dressforsuccessdublin.org.

18

8.0 Further Information Visit the Dress for Success Dublin website at: www.dressforsuccessdublin.org. Follow Dress for Success Dublin at:

@DFSDublin @DFSDublin dfsdublin Sign up to our mailing list to hear more about our work here.

You can also watch a video of the full Gender Pay Gap briefing here.