symposium 2016 : conf. 401 jonathan shriqui evm: go beyond the numbers
TRANSCRIPT
1
EVM: Go Beyond the Numbers
Jonathan Shriqui, PMP
2
3
WHAT IS THE PURPOSE OF EVM?
To establish a common standard of project performance measurement & stakeholder
management, regardless of program size or industry.
To provide early warning signs of deviation from plan.
4
WHAT IS EVM?
Not a single processGrouping of 32 guidelines (EIA-748-C)Management technique:• Establish a time phased budget of the SOW• Captures the progression of work• Provide reliable & timely information for
project management analysis & actions
5
3 Key components to EVMPMI Talent Triangle:
LeadershipStrategic and Business
Management Technical Project
Management
6
Role of Leadership with EVM
Leadership is the foundation of EVM:Set the organizational toneFosters a culture of EVMTailors business process to support EVMUtilizes EVM info to support leadership
decisions
7
EVM Challenges to Leadership
Leadership must accept that EVM:May be lengthy to implementRequires tools & trainingMay be process heavyRequires a business rhythm Acceptance that EVM requires TIME.
8
EVM Benefits to Leadership
Leadership should receive the following benefits:Provide early warning signs of potential
project issuesIntegration of scope, schedule & costCredibility of program controlStakeholder CommunicationEnhanced Risk Management
9
Strategic and Business Management
Business MaturityBusiness OperationsCustomer Relationship
10
Strategic & Business Management
Business Maturity • Capability Maturity Model Integration• CMMI Rating from 1 to 5
The CMMI principal is that “the quality of a system or product is highly influenced by the
process used to develop and maintain it”*
11
Business Maturity
EVMS will most likely be effective
in a org. that reflects a CMMI rating of 3 or
above
12
Strategic & Business ManagementBusiness Operations
- Reporting- Cash Flow Forecasting- Resource Forecasting- Risk Management
13
Strategic & Business Management
Business Operations / Reporting• EVM Culture• EVM lingo & metrics in review meeting• EVM understood/used by senior management• EVM data should remain constant throughout the
various level of reporting
14
Strategic & Business Management• Business Operation
- Cash Profiling- Resource Reqs.
Your ETC is yourForecast.
USE INPUT FROM YOUR CAMs.
15
Strategic & Business Management• Business Operations / EVM &Risk Management
– Both work cohesively, not in silos
Mgmt Reserve > Risk Register + VACIf not, engage in stakeholder awareness
16
Customer / Stakeholder Relationship
The outputs of EVM process (variance reporting) should be the source of data for stakeholder mgmtThe project is:
Over/under cost because…Late/ahead of schedule because…The key risks are…Our mitigation/enhancement plan is…
Program Control InstillsStakeholder Confidence
17
Technical Project Management
EVM BasicsSmall Project
18
Business world: “Cash Is King”
EVM world: “Schedule Is King”
A realistic, achievable & logical schedule is key with EVM
WHO IS KING?
EVM 101
Time
Budget versus Actual
2D Project (Business) Management
$’s
Budget
Actual
Time Now
Under spent ?
BehindSchedule ?
$’s
3D Project Management
Time
Plan
Costs
Time Now
Budget versus Actual
Earned
Schedule
Cost
7. Reporting- CAM reports (e.g. one page reports,
SWOT, SOFT)- Variance Reports (by exception)- Recovery Plans
2. Schedule- Work & Planning packages- Resource- Time-phased budget
1.Scope- Contract / SOW- WBS, OBS, RAM &
WBS Dictionary- Control Accounts
5. Costs- Booking / charge numbers- Actual costs / bookings
6. Analysis- Trend analysis- Variance analysis- TCPI, IEAC- Other PM analysis (e.g.
Critical Path Analysis)
8. Risk & Opportunity- Exposure (financial, schedule & performance)- Costed Mitigation / Realisation actions
9. Change- Change Requests- Change Log- Baseline
maintenance- Re-planning- Formal control of
scope & budget changes
4. Status Data (Progress) & Forecasts- Achievements (earned value)- Estimates to complete
3. EV “Engine”- PMB- Performance data- EVM reports (CPR1-5,
trends & SPA graph)
21
Bathroom Renovation
22
Our Budget - BACItem BAC
Flooring $1,600Vanity $1,900Shower $2,000Bathtub $1,500Total $7,000
23
BCWSBudgeted Cost of Work Scheduled
23
The BCWS is your time phased BAC∑BCWS = BAC = YOUR DOLLARIZED PLAN
Week 1 Week 2 Week 3 BAC
Flooring $1,600 $1,600
Vanity $1,000 $900 $1,900
Shower $1,000 $1,000 $2,000
Bathtub $1,000 $500 $1,500
Period Total $2,600 $2,000 $2,400 $7,000
24
BCWSBudgeted Cost of Work Scheduled – Week 1
Our PLAN is to perform $2,600 of defined scope in week 1.• Old Floor Removal = 6hrs @ 50$/h = $300• Purchase materials (tiles, grout, etc) = $500• Tile Installation = 16hrs @ 50$/h = $800• Purchase & delivery of bathtub = $1,000
$2,600 BCWS Week1
25
ACWPActual Cost of Work Performed
ACTUAL cost of the EARNED scope.BAC:• Planned Direct Cost• Planned Indirect Cost• Planned Material Cost
No expenditures to unplanned scope
ACWP:• Actual Direct Cost• Actual Indirect Cost• Actual Materials Cost
26
Our Cost – ACWP – Week 1BCWS W1 ACWP W1
Removal $300 VS $100
Material $500 VS $500
Installation $800 VS $700
Bathtub $1,000 VS $1,000
Period Total $2,600 VS $2,300
But what did we accomplish?
27
BCWPBudgeted Cost of Work Performed
What did we “earn” in relation to our plan?What did we accomplish?What did we start/finish?
What is the status of the scope?
28
What was accomplished in week 1?
Earned / Planned– Removal 100% completed – we earned $300/$300– Purchased 100% of materials – we earned $500/$500– Installed 25% of the tile – we earned $200/$800– Purchased & installed bathtub - we earned $1,500/ $1,000
$2,500/$2,600
BCWPBudgeted Cost of Work Performed – Week 1
29
The key to good EV is proper “statusing”A realistic and achievable schedule Selecting appropriate EV Technique:• LOE, % complete, 50/50, Milestone, units complete,
apportioned (0-100, 50-50, 20-80, etc)
Be honest and objective!
BCWPBudgeted Cost of Work Performed
30
SVP - S
SPIP / S
CVP - A
CPIP / A
$0 1.0 +$200 3.0
$0 1.0 $0 1.0
($600) 0.25 ($500) 0.28
+$500 1.5 +$500 1.5
($100) 0.96 +$200 1.09
BCWS W1
BCWP W1
ACWP W1
Removal $300 $300 $100
Material $500 $500 $500
Installation $800 $200 $700
Bathtub $1,000 $1,500 $1000
Period Total $2,600 $2,500 $2,300
EV Metrics – Week 1
SV = BCWP – BCWS SPI = BCWP/BCWSCV = BCWP – ACWP CPI = BCWP/ACWP
Time Now
BCWS 100 100 100 100 100 100 100 100 BCWS 400
BCWP 0 400 0 0 0 0 0 0 BCWP 400SPI 1.0
BCWS 100 100 100 100 100 100 100 100 BCWS 400
BCWP 0 200 0 200 0 0 0 0 BCWP 400SPI 1.0
BCWS 100 100 100 100 100 100 100 100 BCWS 400
BCWP 100 100 100 100 0 0 0 0 BCWP 400SPI 1.0
“My SPI is 1.0, but my project is late!?”
32
SPI, CPI, EAC, TCPI, iEAC, BEI, VAC, BAC, BCWR,
UB, MR, PMB, etc. So What? I need
information, not data!
33
BCWS W1
BCWP W1
ACWP W1
Installation $800 $200 $700
SVP - S
SPIP / S
CVP - A
CPIP / A
($600) 0.25 ($500) 0.28
Why SV? Inspection determined that the grading of the existing subfloor was out of tolerance. Leveling of the subfloor
was required for proper tile installation. Why CV? Due to the unleveled subfloor, the purchase of self-leveling cement and extra labour was required to level subfloor.
Variance Analysis
Why SV?
Why CV?
Contracts Management
34
BCWS W1
BCWP W1
ACWP W1
Installation $800 $200 $700
Impact AnalysisSV
P - SSPI
P / SCV
P - ACPI
P / A($600) 0.25 ($500) 0.28
Schedule Impact: Delays due to releveling the subfloor may affect the start date of the vanity installation. Tile installation is
now on the critical path.Cost Impact: Extra material and extra labour effort will
increase the estimate at complete (EAC). Will incur storage costs for the vanity (offsite) if floor is not finished on time.
Schedule Management
Supply Chain Management
Risk Management
35
BCWS W1
BCWP W1
ACWP W1
Installation $800 $200 $700
SVP - S
SPIP / S
CVP - A
CPIP / A
($600) 0.25 ($500) 0.28
Schedule : Consider diverting resources to minimize schedule delays and getting off the critical path.
Cost: Recommend absorbing the cost of additional resources to avoid paying storage and transportation costs
Schedule Management
Cost Growth
Mitigation Plan
36
Importance of CAM trainingCAM training & experience will affect the quality of: • Performance Assessment • Variance Analysis• Impact Analysis• Mitigation plans• Ultimately the data used influence the outcome.
37
Lets go 15 years into the future…
38
Vertical EV
38
$’000 BCWS BCWP ACWP Foundation $300 $300 $100
Framing $500 $500 $800
Electrical $800 $200 $700
Plumbing $1,000 $1,500 $1000
Period Total $2,600 $2,500 $2,600
SV SPI CV CPI$0 1.0 +$200 3.0
$0 1.0 $(300) 0.6
($600) 0.25 $(500) 0.28
+$500 1.5 +$500 1.5
($100) 0.96 $(100) 0.96
Labour $800 $400 $600
Material $600 $500 $400
Subcontract $1,200 $1,600 $1,600
Period Total $2,600 $2,500 $2,600
$(400) 0.5 $(200) 0.7
($100) 0.8 +$100 1.25
+$400 1.3 $0 1.0
($100) 0.96 $(100) 0.96
But my schedule is late!
39
3939
Resources BCWS BCWP ACWP
Labour $800 $400 $600
Material $600 $500 $400
Subcontract $1,200 $1,600 $1,600
Period Total $2,600 $2,500 $2,600
SV SPI CV CPI
$(400) 0.5 $(200) 0.7
($100) 0.8 +$100 1.25
+$400 1.3 $0 1.0
($100) 0.96 $(100) 0.96
Vertical EV
LOE $400 $400 $500
Discrete $400 $0 $100
Period Total $800 $400 $600
$0 1.0 $(100) 0.7
($400) 0.0 $(100) 0.0
($100) 0.5 $(200) 0.7
40
Horizontal EV
Date SPI
CUR - SPI 0.90
CUM - SPI 0.94
3 Month 0.856 Month 0.869 Month 0.89
• Trends without graph• Shifts in program momentum• Labour vs Material• Discrete Labour Only
𝟗𝒎𝒐𝒏𝒕𝒉𝑺𝑷𝑰= 𝑩𝑪𝑾𝑺𝒄𝒖𝒎−𝑩𝑪𝑾𝑺𝒄𝒖𝒎𝟗𝒎𝒐𝒏𝒕𝒉𝒔 𝒂𝒈𝒐
𝑩𝑪𝑾 𝑷𝒄𝒖𝒎−𝑩𝑪𝑾 𝑷𝒄𝒖𝒎𝟗𝒎𝒐𝒏𝒕𝒉𝒔𝒂𝒈𝒐
41
Integrate them with:• Risk Management Strategy• Business’ Internal Processes• Forecasting Processes•Schedule/Baseline Management
EVM Outputs
Program Control
Earned Value Management System
Data EVMS Information
• Quantitative Data • SPI, CPI
• Qualitative Information• We were late because…• We spent more because…• Our mitigation plan is…
42
EVM is NOT a quality tool!You must PLAN for quality WITHIN your project.
43
Another 15 years later…
44
EVMS: Contractual Requirement Customer
Contractor
Expectation of Program ControlCommon Knowledge & Lingo
45
• Customer:• Ability to understand & assess
EVM data• Ability to conduct audit• Define your reporting reqs
(CDRL/SDRL)
EVMS: Contractual Requirement• Contractor:
– Ability to produce EVM data (CDRL/SDRL)
– Ready to be audited– Adhere to an EVM
culture / processes
46
EVM SOWAn improper or too vague EVM SOW may result in an EVMS that is:- Contractually compliant- But has little or zero value added- May cause more “pain” than gain
47
Refine your EVM SOW• EVMS that complies with a standard (EIA 748-C)
• % of LOE labour shall not be greater then X%• EVM as a SDRL to subcontractors• A task shall not have a duration longer then X days• Reporting shall be at the X level of the WBS or CA.• Expectation EVM analysis and recovery.
48
Always remember…
Good decisions are based on knowledge and not on numbers.
- Plato
49
For more information…
• Thank you for your participation today!
• For more information on the contents of this presentation, please feel free to contact me as follows:
o Jonathan Shriqui, PMPo [email protected] 613-255-6520o www.fleetech.com
50
Time Permitting…
EVM Practical Uses