survey of electronic games that teach ms. diane gaither and dr. carol l. redfield computer science...
TRANSCRIPT
Survey of Electronic Games that Teach
Ms. Diane Gaither and Dr. Carol L. Redfield
Computer Science DepartmentSan Antonio, Texas
www.wingz2fly.com/GameSurvey
AACE/SITE Conference in Orlando, Florida March 2006
Overview
• Games of Old
• Games of Today
• Research Performed
• Research Findings
• Further Research
Games of Old
• Musical Chairs• Letter recognition
– Jingles– Rhymes
• Number recognition– Counting fingers & toes– Number blocks– Adding/Subtracting sticks/marbles/jacks
• We didn’t even know we were learning!
Games of Today• Arcades• Laser tag
– LaserQuest• Handheld
– GameBoy• Consoles
– GameCube, Xbox, PS2• Internet games• Computer Games
– Reader Rabbit– Math Blaster– World of Warcraft– Star Wars Galaxies– Starfleet Academy– Age of Empires– Civilization
Research Performed• Addressing
– What educational games are out there and what do they teach?
– What effectiveness studies are available?
• What we did– Designed database
• determined game characteristics we wanted to find
– Collected the data– Created the database– Populate the database– Created a website
• www.wingz2fly.com/GameSurvey
Where we looked
• Commercial stores
• Educational facilities– Home school co-ops– Public schools– Private schools
• Internet
• Catalogs
• Personal libraries
What games are out there?
• Catalogued over 1000 games
• Multiple platforms
• Wide content range
• Variety of teaching methods
• All grade levels
Game Platforms
700, 71%
133, 14% 130, 13%
15, 2%
WINMACWEBWIN & MAC
• None for game consoles• were some for older consoles
Educational Content322
290
258241
223
141114
101
6048 46
28 25 17 13 8 60
50
100
150
200
250
300
350
Teaching Methods
74, 9%
97, 11%
20, 2%
89, 10%114, 13%
471, 55%
Creative ActivityDrill & PracticeGuided PraticeInteractiveRole PlayingSimulation
Major Grade Differences
• Toddler – Elementary
• Middle School
• High School - Adult
Toddler - ElementaryElementary
289247
175
0
100
200
300
400
500
600
700
800
Mathematics Language Arts Science
Middle School
Middle School
24
6
38
0
10
20
30
40
50
60
70
80
Mathemadics Language Arts Science
High School - Adult
High School
42
22
0
5
10
15
20
25
30
35
Mathematics Language Arts Science
Effectiveness of the Games
• Study done in 1999 presented at AACE/SITE International Conference*– The Learning Company
• Reader Rabbit
• As of summer 2005, no effectiveness studies were found on any games– Some anecdotal references
* Redfield, C.L. (1999). “Sky’s the Limit Charter School: Offering a Tutor-based Curriculum,” Proceedings of the 1999 Society for Information Technology and Teacher Education (SITE) International Conference, San Antonio, March 1999: Association for the Advancement of Computing in Education.
Further Research
• Perform an Effectiveness Study– Select Game– Select test group– Select control group– Perform study– Analyze data
• Apply findings to new games
Research Contribution• Data is available for existing games
• The data can be used as a resource for further study
• The site can be used to query a specific search request by parents, teachers and administrators – www.wingz2fly.com/GameSurvey
www.wingz2fly.com/GameSurvey
www.wingz2fly.com/GameSurvey