submission to sarpa - vdwweb.vdw.co.za/portals/25/documents/papers/2010... · submission to sarpa:...
TRANSCRIPT
1
SUBMISSION TO SARPA:
Topic Name Revenue Management & Enhancement, a
methodology to enhance revenue and ensure that
strategic decisions are taken to protect revenue by
thinking out of the box
Description A case study of the Revenue Management &
Enhancement Programme undertaken by Ekurhuleni Metropolitan Municipality (EMM),
describing the need for this programme, the
factors and drivers considered and our vision. EMM
has taken bold steps to run a comprehensive
programme focused on revenue; however along
the stages we have discovered that revenue has
provided a burning platform for us to re-engineer
our processes and adopt a new operating model to
ensure that we not only enhance revenue but also
take very bold decisions to protect revenue. EMM has chosen to drive revenue enhancement by
establishing a programme with projects focused on
revenue generation, management, protection and
enhancement.
Author Miyelani Holeni
Prepared For SARPA Conference 2010
Date 29 June 2010
2
Contents 1. BACKGROUND ......................................................................................... 3
2. CURRENT SITUATION................................................................................ 4
3. STATEMENT OF VISION ............................................................................. 6
3.1 Vision .................................................................................................. 6
3.2 Context ............................................................................................... 6
3.3 Overarching principles and goals .............................................................. 6
3.4 Financial Sustainability ........................................................................... 7
4. METHODOLOGY ....................................................................................... 9
4.1 Tripod methodology ............................................................................... 9
4.2 Goals .................................................................................................10
5. REVENUE MANAGEMENT AND ENHANCEMENT PROGRAMME ............................11
5.1 The Programme ...................................................................................11
5.2 Programme Objectives ..........................................................................11
5.3 Programme Structure ............................................................................11
5.4 Programme Scope ................................................................................12
6. IMPLEMENTATION ...................................................................................13
6.1 Projects in the programme .....................................................................13
6.2 Implementation ...................................................................................14
7. OUTCOMES AND IMPACT ..........................................................................16
7.1 Outcomes ...........................................................................................16
7.2 Impact ...............................................................................................16
7.3 The journey going forward .....................................................................16
8. CONCLUSION .........................................................................................17
3
1. BACKGROUND
The Ekurhuleni Metropolitan Municipality was established in 2000. It covers an
extensive geographical area, from Germiston in the west to Springs and Nigel in the in
the east. Ekurhuleni is one of six metropolitan municipalities resulting from the
restructuring of local government.
The former local administrations of the nine towns in the East Rand – Alberton,
Benoni, Boksburg, Brakpan, Edenvale/Lethabong, Germiston, Kempton Park/Tembisa,
Nigel and Springs – were amalgamated into the new Metropolitan Municipality, along
with two other councils – the Khayalami Metropolitan Council and the Eastern Gauteng
Services Council.
In recent times, EMM found itself in a precarious position with respect to financial
sustainability. This was in part due to the level of debt having grown over the years
and the recent unfavourable economic conditions that resulted in the country facing
sliding into a recession. The high rate of consumer default on payments left EMM in a
position where the operating income was inadequate to meet all the financial
obligations and commitments.
EMM made a decision that it will face the difficult circumstances with a measured
approach that will ensure that it emerges with a strong balance sheet. This
necessitated that EMM applies unconventional strategic thinking to revenue
management and enhancement which must be remarkably different from current
practice. EMM developed and adopted a financial suitability model that would not only
result in the improvement revenue levels but would also reduce cost and find creative
ways of funding large project through alternative sources of funding.
4
2. CURRENT SITUATION
The Finance (Income Division) is responsible for collecting revenue for the main
services offered by a municipality of water, electricity, rates, and solid waste. The
Income Section has 20 Customer Care Areas (CCA) for customers to pay their
municipal bill and for general enquiries. The CCA is main points of contact with
customers supported by a call centre. The call centre is outsourced and currently is
responsible for taking calls for reporting electricity and water related incidents.
Billing and Credit Control functions carried out at the CCA level in nine different
databases which align to the former Town Councils (e.g. Brakpan, Boksburg,
Germiston etc.) incorporating the with respective “townships” of (e.g. Brakpan
incorporates Tsakani and Geluksdal). The billing and credit control functions are
performed by internal staff.
Meter reading is outsourced to one meter reading company (MRC) and the oversight
role for meter reading is carried out by the Water and Electricity Meter Management
Companies (WEMMC). The WEMMCs are responsible managing the MRC and for the
maintenance of meters.
Debt collection has been outsourced to debt collectors and each CCA manages its
own debt collection process and debt collectors. The disconnection of services
(electricity) has been outsourced to contractors and is allocated to the CCA.
The Income Division is but one of the revenue collection centres within Ekurhuleni
Metro, with Metro Police and Licensing, Housing Department, Fresh Produce Market
being others. The collection of revenue is therefore fragmented according to the
service or product consumed leaving departments to own their revenue collection
processes and by default have ownership of the customer. With fragmentation come
inherent weaknesses, inefficiency, duplication, complexity and lack of ownership of
end to end processes.
EMM has an operating income budget of R19 billion which is derived from 19 sources
ranging from services rendered to grants from National Treasury. The over reliance on
income from the sale of electricity, water and property rates raises concerns of
financial sustainability.
5
Figure 1: Operating Income Budget of EMM
The Regional Electricity Distribution model, AARTO legislation and the equitable share
formula used to allocate budgets to municipalities but a few instruments that are
outside of the sphere of control of local government. These may be subject to change
and revisions from time to time thereby impacting on the source of income for EMM
and other municipalities. In the case of EMM, the income from the sale of electricity is
both a welcome source of income an Achilles heel. If this income were to be lost or
even be reduced, EMM would be left vulnerable and at its “wits end” with closing the
gap created in the income.
6
3. STATEMENT OF VISION
3.1 Vision
EMM differentiates itself from all organisations by choosing to be The Smart, Creative
and Developmental City. This vision drives the all the functions and activities of EMM
including the financial aspects.
3.2 Context
Ekurhuleni is the manufacturing hub of South Africa; it is often referred to as “Africa’s
Workshop”. The OR Tambo International Airport is situated in Ekurhuleni, and some
14 million passengers pass through the airport every year. Some of the Blue IQ
projects are being implemented in Ekurhuleni include the Wadeville- Alrode Industrial
corridor linkages to the largest logistical hub, the City Deep Container terminal.
Ekurhuleni holds enormous potential and has the ability supported by strong
capabilities of becoming the fastest growing economic hub and certainly the biggest
contributor to the GDP of Gauteng and South Africa.
3.3 Overarching principles and goals
EMM has adopted principles that will be central to the establishing of specific goals for
financial sustainability. These principles define our intent, a statement of work and
outline what success looks like. The principles are articulated by the following points:
We must provide services to all customers and bill them without fail
For every R1.00 levied we must collect 93 cents all the time
We must develop alternative sources of funding and diversify our income base
There must be a single owner of revenue!
There must me a single owner of the customer!
The must be a single view of the customer!
There must clear owners of end to end business processes!
There must be clear owners of services and products rendered by EMM!
Technical department own the services, products, skills and associated people
There must a clear owner of the systems
7
3.4 Financial Sustainability
EMM has developed a model to manage the two drivers of financial sustainability
namely revenue and cost. A balance must be achieved between the two drivers that
must see costs coming down significantly to boost the revenue and this must be in
tandem with all initiatives aimed at enhancing revenue.
The financial sustainability model is a holistic approach to ensuring that EMM will not
only be able to meet its obligations but will have a healthy balance sheet. The key to
financial sustainability is the understanding that revenue is the fuel that drives the
engine and the cost is the oil that ensures that the engine does not cease. The cost
side of the model begins with a budgeting model that is accurate and is supported by
well defined prioritisation criteria. The management of cash is also crucial to ensure
that all the cash reaches the account of EMM sooner to fund the cash flow and allow
for investing activities to be undertaken.
Figure 2: Financial Sustainability Model
The activity that will have a significant and ongoing impact on revenue is the adoption
of alternative funding sources either than the current ones of rates, equitable share
and grants. A new strategy of attracting capital from development agencies and private
companies with funding is currently being developed to ensure that EMM does not
have to use its own money to implement programmes. This is in line with the Public
Private Partnership (PPP) model that is being debated at different levels of
government. The rationale behind this is to use “freely” available funds to implement
8
revenue generating projects and rather share the “upside” with the funder(s), we would
have gained more financially and reduced risks in the process.
EMM has to be good at generating and managing revenue and this in a non-
negotiable issue. In driving the financial sustainability model, revenue protection has
been shifted from being an operational activity to a strategic one. Revenue protection
activities and initiatives are now gaining momentum and recognition within the
organisation. Revenue protection is now the agenda of senior management and is
discussed as part of the key performance indicators.
Figure 3: Revenue Model
EMM is moving towards revenue and is aligning all the departments and function to
achieve this. Revenue enhancement will be institutionalised to become part of the
functions that have to be carried out in the course of doing our work.
9
4. METHODOLOGY
4.1 Tripod methodology
The Tripod methodology integrates the products and service that we render to our
customers with the revenue that we receive. The customer is at the top of the tripod
because they are the initiator of all activities when they interact with us. EMM is
responsible for the execution based on the needs and requirements. The customer
interacts with the soft and hard elements designed to meet their needs. By initiating
the interaction with EMM, the customer:
Talks to our staff,
Request a service governed by a policy and follow a process,
Submit information that is captured in a system,
Pay for the service and
Receive the service
Figure 4: Tripod Methodology
The customer will then continue to follow the model with future interactions where the
emphasis may be on making a payment of services every month. The interaction
between the customer and EMM is currently under review and is subject to change
with a view of ensuring that EMM continues to receive the payments for ongoing
services rendered. To this effect, EMM is making more options of payment available to
the customer which range from physical to electronic channels. The channels are
designed to follow the behaviour of our customers i.e. when they go shopping at the
10
grocery store or surf the internet or at the ATM they can also pay their account with us
and buy an electricity voucher.
Business process management is one of the key areas which require work. It is our
belief that once the processes are fixed and aligned, this will provide the “tipping point”
for EMM as this will cover the customer service, revenue collection, maintenance and
reporting of faults amongst others. Business process management will create an
internal capability and readiness to deliver services to the citizens of EMM.
4.2 Goals
EMM has set itself a goal of enhancing revenue over a five year period from 2010/11
financial year to 2015/16. It is expected that in the year 2015/16 EMM will have raised
revenue to the amount of R5 billion of which 40% to 60% will remain part of the
operating income.
Figure 5: Projected revenue for a period of 5 years
11
5. REVENUE MANAGEMENT AND ENHANCEMENT PROGRAMME
5.1 The Programme
The Revenue Management and Enhancement Programme (RMEP) is an
ORGANISATIONAL WIDE programme
It is a MEDIUM TO LONG TERM programme
It will help us to achieve FINANCIAL SUSTAINABILITY
This programme will assist us in BREAKING DOWN SILOS
This programme is a PLATFORM + CATALYST for developing a model for
prioritising the allocation of resources
5.2 Programme Objectives
Reduction of consumer debt through appropriate credit control and debt
collection to improve revenue
Improved, Consistent and Accurate /Integrative property value chain
Improved Customer Services
Monitoring and Evaluation of consumption processes and efficiencies
Revenue Collection
5.3 Programme Structure
The Revenue Management and Enhancement Programme shall be managed through
a programme management office. The programme management office (PMO) will be a
dedicated unit that has been established within the Department of Finance to house
the programme. A full time Programme Manager shall be responsible for managing the
PMO and will be assisted by various key resources. The resource will be responsible
for 6 key areas as illustrated below.
12
Figure 6: Programme Roadmap
5.4 Programme Scope
As result of the decision from the Strategic Management Team meeting held that
resolved on the following critical matters to be considered for the realization of the
Revenue Management & Enhancement Unit, namely:-
Project based approach should be adopted in establishing the revenue
management & enhancement unit;
Stabilize the current service delivery environment;
Work towards refining the situation to ensure effective planning;
Gradual implementation of change management and transformation of internal
processes of service delivery;
Setting-up of project streams, for example finance, city development, ict, legal
and administration etc;
Identify projects based on the criticality, i.e. Without successful implementation
revenue will be compromised severely;
Practical short, medium and long term projects that need to be achieved with
strict timelines and clear milestones;
Detailed project plans should be developed to ensure effective project
monitoring and evaluation;
Sourcing of human resources both internally and externally to ensure
realization of the project;
The project plan will be designed to illustrate the required actions, resource
requirement, timelines and estimated costs where possible given the time
constraints;
Advisable to have a dedicated programme manager to manage the
implementation of improving the revenue of the EMM.
13
6. IMPLEMENTATION
6.1 Projects in the programme
The Revenue Management and Enhancement Programme has a number of high
profile projects geared at addressing all the areas of EMM. The projects are divided to
into those that will deal with “house-keeping” issues, those that will put processes and
system of managing the functions better, and those that that will lead EMM into the
new dynamics of the new world.
Figure 7: Programme Roadmap
The house keeping projects are about accurate meter reading, correct billing, applying
credit control policy consistently, answering the customer queries and providing
resolution. In order to put in place effective processes and systems in place to manage
various functions, we will implement business process management, implement credit
control and debt management systems, have a single view of the customer and
develop a performance management framework for teams. The new world requires of
EMM that it harnesses methane gas and channels it to power, reduces the carbon
footprint and earn carbon credit in the form of money, manage customers in a way that
14
seeks first to understand their needs than out constraints and to be able to break down
are services or functions into components.
The new world dynamics recognises that components are building blocks for functions
and processes that produce a set of outcomes. EMM will isolate components such as
a property, meter, customer, location, suppliers of services and allow the flexibility of
combining the components to form various building blocks and outcomes. The
components will be managed within a specialised system that is capable of interacting
with any related system. For instance a customer is the common denominator and can
own a property with a location; a property can have a meter and other services. The
services are the variables that will differ from customer to customer and possibly from
area to area. The extent to which we understand all the components that we have at
our disposal will determine how we can generate, manage, protect and enhance
revenue.
6.2 Implementation
The implementation of the projects is designed to fit the requirement and to protect
revenue going forward.
For big consumers, a key accounts management unit will be implemented and
capacitated to deal with all the big customers. Automated meter reading (AMR)
technology will be implemented to send in reading every 15 minutes to a central server
thereby improving the accuracy of reading and billing. A project to audit of big
customers, bill them accordingly and sell new services has been launched and one of
our biggest customers has already been audited with success. EMM will realise R10
million from the audit and increase monthly levies by up to five times. Meters that were
buried underground have been unearthed and raised above ground.
For household consumers, our vending system is currently being interfaced with the
billing system to enable the collection of arrears before the purchase of electricity.
EMM is the process of selling the debtors book to get cash up front to commit to
capital projects. This will be run in tandem with the implementation of credit control
strategies and systems to ensure that the debt book never grows to the proportions it
has reached.
15
A business process management tool will be implemented to automate and integrate
our processes end to end. EMM is currently working towards creating a single view of
the customer and driving collaboration between all the departments to get a single bill.
This will be run alongside the project to launch an electronic bill presentment and
payment platform thus increasing our payment channels and technology.
EMM has developed a campaign that is the mouth piece of the initiatives currently
underway to drive revenue management and enhancement. Siyakhokha Siyathuthuka
is an educational programme for our customers and a call to action to pay for services
received. This covers
The eradication of illegal consumption of services by connection to water and
or electricity sources illegally,
Encouraging the indigents to come forward and register for subsidies,
Demonstrating how EMM uses the monies paid to it by the customers
EMM is currently working towards the enforcement of Municipal By-Laws by putting in
place urban monitoring supported by the Metro Police and the Magistrates Courts.
16
7. OUTCOMES AND IMPACT
7.1 Outcomes
We have identified that the current projects will deliver potential revenue of R415
million in the current financial year.
7.2 Impact
Manage to integrate the organisation and break silos
Identified bottlenecks and are fixing them
Identified new projects to enhance revenue and influence the strategic path of
EMM
Developed an internal consulting competency to ensure financial sustainability
7.3 The journey going forward
EMM is finalising projects that will enhance revenue and will work with companies or
individuals who are willing to work at risk to share the upside with EMM. We are
looking for R5 billion in five years.
17
8. CONCLUSION
The Revenue Management and Enhancement Programme will run for a minimum
period of 3 years within which it will be presiding over large projects which will have an
impact on the revenue of EMM. The Programme Management Office will take on the
role of initiating new projects over and above the current ones. The new projects will
be carefully thought through and well researched. These projects will from the onset
be geared to deliver revenue.
The Revenue Management and Enhancement Programme will therefore leave a
lasting legacy for the organisation and introduce a new way of managing and
collecting revenue through conducting analysis and applying diagnostic measures.