stanford aesthetics 23

8/4/2019 Stanford Aesthetics 23

1/20

Conceptual ArtElisabeth Schellekens

T g v j. F v g , w v x f , w v , v g w x gg . T , wv, w -g . A g. A , v -g v g :

.

1. C A W I I? 674

1.1 I

1.2 T L A R A

1.3 A M

1.4 A I

1.5 S R2. T P C A W ? 674

3. Fv P T 679

3.1 T Df A

3.2 T Og M A

3.3 T A V A

3.4 T I A

3.5 T Cgv V A

4. F Q 689

Bg 690

Conceptual Art Cg 2009 E S


2/20

1. Concepul Ar Wha I I?

1.1 Introduction

Fw v v - . F v v x . A , w f v -g v w, g, , -, wg , , , .C , , g w v .

T vv , wv, . M v v g w w gv . I , vg g v w g , w w , w vv, w w . I , , vx v g w g . I g g w , w, g g .

T f vg

w g j x, g j . I w P W,

[] w w, w w w . L w, g Lw C C , vg w g g: w v w T g, g , g g w . (W 2002, 6)

O g, x v- w 1966 1972 (L 1973).1 Ag g w f J K, RM, J B M R, w. W w- v D, S, S, A Ex Fx g, M-

Elisabeth Schellekens674

1. T , wv, v 1961 Nw Y

H F gg Fx G(W 2002: 8).


3/20

g. M , , g v - g w g g. A, , .Y v , -1960 1970 g, . Tj g v g , , x.

W g g w g fv x g, v w v w g . F g w g g g -

v - - , v v v w w-f , w TE Unmade Bed, D H The Physical Impossibility o Death in the Mind oSomeone Liing, T C BMy Family.

T g v x g gg w f - g v , -g g v v . T x,w , f v g -. I g v , , Lw C v . C , J B D H, - g eery w. F , g f v g g g w f w , , f w.

Nv, , g , g g, () .

1.2 The Limits o Art and the Role o Artists

F , g g w w . T , w g g ,

x w . I , , -g v x j w, ,

675Conceptual Art


4/20

, g g g .

A w w x w

g w g. Cg M D Fountain, Bottlerack, vw w j w . T w process material thing, g g g g, g -g . T agency -g - . I , -g w g, w g f w w v . C , v

M D P (1968), H A I (1969), V W, , rapprochementw -g g v v . T w J K, x - , - . (G 1999, 39).

1.3 Artistic Media

A x w gv w j, j -

v g . I, -v x, g , g, f, v,v, , , w - w x . I , , -g wv , , x, R Lg g g wg; BN f g v w w-g ; P Mz gg w .

1.4 Art as Idea

T v w w : j w v ideas objects.A , - , w . I w K, [] w (L 1973, 25). F , w (LW 1967, 166). A -;

g . I - , , , .



5/20

T w f w -

-g f. I g w -g j-. Mv, g vw w w w v, gg - w. F , - v w

g v.1.5 Semantic Representation

F , w , v, gg , , v. I , w g semantic illustratie. T , v v g g , v. I - v w

gg g on w , -g g, vg g. S v w w

677Conceptual Art

Richard Long,A Line Madeby Walking, 1967.

Piero Manzoni, Sculturavivente, 1961.

Bruce Nauman,Playing a Note onthe Violin While I Walk around theStudio, 1968.


6/20

v , g -v , g g w . Ag, - g g-.

2. The Philosophy o Conceptual Art What is it?

T v w -g. F, f w , w j v . P vg g j g, w g v. F x-, w v g g, v

w g ?Mv, v w g ( ) w g ?

S, w v, g x v w , , x. I , - v w , -w, gg g v . F

, g g g (.. w g)?C , v, v w , x? I , w f , g v xw w g v ?

I w v w , ,

w w v gf w . A v , w v w w -w.

O v-g w , , w v f . W vg g - vg w, w - g v f ,

, x, g w w



7/20

.

Pzg , , zg -f . I zg v ,

w g . L w fv f g .

3. Five Philoophicl Teme

3.1 The Defnition o Art

T fg w . T - w : f, g v -g ; , , vw w f v

w. O , f g v w gx F, , x, v () g () v w. O , , f g v f g (g) w .

T v g f g .M , gg g f

, , g,x w xgv x (.g., B 1958). Nwg gg (w vw 3.3), v v v g f all x. I , , -Wg 1950 1960 w, v -- gg, x g , v, (G 1948; Wz 1956). T , w

gg g g , g w f . I w M Wz,

. Nw v w ; w , w v w g, w w w x . (Wz 1956, 32)

Df g x , -v N-Wg Wz g - x w w g - amily

679Conceptual Art


8/20

resemblance ( Wg 1953, 66-71). F w IX w?,w w w g w. I gf g v,w g j w .

T , g g, w w . O , x w , v g v g - . A , , notg f w g . W j could be w , notg v j is w .M , xg w , g -,

A WBrillo Boxes, , -, vg, -Wg f.

Pg , A D gg - g w v - (D 1981). T , w v g v , g, , w (D1974).T g w g w x, g w . A w , - g x .2

Rg x w v, w g f f w v -g () g - . I g g w g ( 3.4). A w g

, w w g , j w v ( )


2. Tw : () Gg D' I T A;() J Lv' H Df A. F (), X w X w g ( w) g . F (), X w w g ( v) v , , , g v - w . T w

x w, z .F , D 1973 Lv 1979.


9/20

x g . S w , , xv vg g g wv j w. T x A WBrillo

Boxes g, - j j j w w g .

I w j , f w g g. F v w , f ( v , w v g x w).S, g f ?

A vw , v Dv Dv , f w v g g ( ) j, - (Dv 2004). I , , g w g f , w v g wg . P w w v v g.

3.2 The Ontology and Media o ArtC v g w - w g , , v, gv x g . T j , -g w - j, w v- v -g x,

W w ?, I g ( g) w v ?, I

x w v ?.I f , v vw gg w w vv f- x . T , F S w,

[] v see g w, hear v z , notice g ,eel w v, , . T , v vwg, g, g, w . B v v, j, -, jg g , , . (S1965, 137).

681Conceptual Art


10/20

T , g, g w gg g , x, L VLaGioconda, g jg w - x . B g g f- x , v . I , g, g gg w , w W D M Vertical Earth Kilometre (1977)3, w w x ? M , w w gg w w ?

T g, wv, w x w w - -- . D -- gg

j , -

g g? O w g w Dv w

physical medium ehicular medium (Dv 2004). Ig, j ( g , ) , v, g x gw -j. I Dv w, [] v w ehiclew T v- , P Guernica, j, , Cg Kubla Kahn, g -, , g D Fountain, . (Dv 2004, 59). Ag v , w w , jg , all .

C, f g g . A , , aant-garde, gw . I , w w -


3. T g , g, w w .

Walter De Marias Vertical Earth Kilometre(1977)


11/20

, , v w v w , w g w v w w w (.g., Dv 2001; Ig 1973; W- 1980) Bg gg w w v , vw w w w, allw, . M f, v v- - (C 1988). Ag , w g , , w w v g w.

W g v g v g g- g v j,

w f w - (C. 3.1), g v f vw w v - g g v . I , Dv v, v-. T g gf v g w v v .

Hvg , v g , g v - j. M v, , w , , ( ) g() do w? W, w, w j ( v-g) w, , g w? I , , g x- gv w g g , , v w . I v v w, , w x w --

?3.3 The Aesthetic Value o Art

Ug w v x w -w v w g x.T gaesthetic, vg x w vv (.. per se, g -

g wg ).

683Conceptual Art


12/20

Hwv, gg , g v w , v v w v.C : cognitie aestheticv. I w T B, w x x w , w vg x v w (B 1977, 271).

W w x v w g w vv g w x g -. I x-

w, w v w g . P w x gv ggw w x ( S 2007)

T gg x, , : D ?. I B , - , v v w , w f j. I g -g j v (B 1977, 273).

Hwv, v vw w (C. 3.1)7. I vg v,w, g g, w -? T , vg v g , w x w ?

W vw v w g

f. I w f x, f - w, . T w- , wv, w w g, , v g gvg x. I w v vw, , -


7. F B (1914) F (1920) g gf . A, B (1958) f g w gvg

.8. F v g, B 1995.


13/20

g, w . O ,, v one v , g w , -g, , f v w v .8

Nw, v g , good ( ) x. T, , w v j g, wg. Sg , x, M Cg-Mn Oak Tree g w gv v j . C , w ww, vg g g v , v w x , , . A

g v .3.4 The Interpretation o Art

A v , w :() w w w?, () w w?I , w () w v - v v (.g. g,, x x, , .); (.. -g g); w w w w g. D-

g g ( , , - ), w x -v .

I g (), wv, w v v w v x (.g. g, ); w g . T , w j , j (, , w), ? I

w f w v (C. 3.2) , I v v w , w?.

Tw g x . F, w - v ? M , w x artists intention w - ? Vw w . I , T IF, W B g

v v w

685Conceptual Art


14/20

w . (W & B 1946). A g v gf, v , . F w w g w WBrillo Boxes, w v w f , w w W x vw qua .

Nw, v w g w w , - . M , w decisie must w vv? G- g, w v. O , w

w g, v (.g., C 1992). O , vw (.g., Lv 1992).

A f g, g f , w v g , , w R B ll the Things I know

But o which I am Not at the Moment Thinking(1969). Nv, - , g v . Hw w , , fw g ; wv ?

T v g , w - w. Ag, v -v g . O gg vg - w w g

(.g., Mg 1991; G 1990).I vw, wv, w g w (.g., B 1970). T , , Mw K w, v-g g w. (K 1996, 239). W g v f vw, v w , . A , g w, w w ?

T g v



15/20

gv , vw. T wg . I w , g w gg (w w ). I w, w - , w w - w v the w.

Hvg , w g vx w , , v w v v . W , w, w w , , v w w g w, f,

w g. S, , w w v? I , , gv -w g , v vw.

3.5 The Cognitive Value o Art

I g v g v , v gv v. B gv v,

w v w v v g -g wg g , v. Ig, - v gv v w w v x-v (S 2007).

T gv vgvv . I v f K ritique o the Powero Judgement - w gv ( g-

) jg. Hwv, w v v v w v , gv v , x . I , gv g only v -g gv v.

C, v gv v v gv v in addition v w g w w f wg g wg. T , w v, g

,

687Conceptual Art


16/20

g. A g w jg g g g g g -. I g, g x g g w.

Uv , v v v gv v. M , xv Cv B Rg F x (B 1914; F 1920). M , J Yg vw waant-

garde gf wg g(Yg 2001, 77).

Yg g xf w

gv v w . Exf ( x). A x [-, ] g (Yg 2001, 72). I - , w xf . S, x, T MThe ct o Drinking Beer with Ones Friends is the Highest Form o rt(1970) vvg g g x w, g w g - . T w . Hwv, Yg , w g x g gfgv v. I , Yg g , w w gv v v , , v .

T g fg x w v . N w , g , v g v .

W, , g ?


Walter De Marias Vertical Earth Kilometre

(1977)


17/20

I w , w w v x w ( ) wg g . T w wv w : content wg, kind wg . F, wg w , w , , g g w v. S, wg wg . W f wg gv w w (.g. wg E Mx- x) w (.g. wg g v), wg - g w w ,

z, v xg w w v x f- (.g. w w x E).

T wg gv v, w v j, g - w. P xf v g vg gg w w g-v w; w w w ? P -

v gg w w, g- gg w . Exg v w -v gv v g.

4. Furter Quesion

Many more questions centred around fv x . W g fg, w g w w x w w

g -, w ( ) w . T , - g - vg g ( ) w, v w -. S, j g ?

F g v, v ggvv: g w g , w, g w, w w ? C v w w v j w ?

689Conceptual Art


18/20

I , v -, , w ( ) v . F - , w w g g jg w . A , w interpretation?

F, w w w gv v v x-v? I v g gv, w v f g v.A, w v , v w w , .

C vv j vg w w g gg v x, w .C v g-vg, g g, , .

Bibliogrphy

A, Ax & S B (.). 1999. onceptual rt: ritical nthology.Cg: MIT P.

B, M. 1970. The Possibility o riticism. D: W S UvP.

B, Cv. 1914.rt. L.

B, T. 1977. P: C A.Journal o esthetics and rt riti-cism 35, 265-277.

B, M. 1995. Values o rt: Painting, Poetry, and Music. L: Pg.

C, N. 1992. A, I, Cv. Intention and Interpretation.Ig, G. (.). P: T Uv P, 97-131.

C, M (.). 2004. onceptual rt: Theory, Myth, and Practice. Cg:Cg Uv P.

C, Gg. 1988.n Ontology o rt. Nw Y: S M P.

Dv, Dv. 2004.rt as Perormance. Ox: Bw.

Dv, S. 2001.Musical Works and Perormances: Philosophical Exploration.

Ox: Ox Uv P.



19/20

D, A C. 1964. T Aw.Journal o Philosophy 61, 571-584.

. 1981. The Transfguration o the ommonplace. Cg M.: Hv U-v P.

D, Gg. 1973. T I C A. I Tg, Bj(.).Language and esthetics. Lw: Uv P K.

F, R. 1920. Vision and Design. L.

G, T. 1998. onceptual rt. L: P P.

G, P & S, E (.). 2007.Philosophy and onceptual rt. Ox-: Ox Uv P.

G, A. 1990. Ig A L.Journal o esthetics and rtriticism 48, 205-14.

H, C. 1991.Essays on rt and Language. Cg, M.: MIT P.

Ig, R. 1973. The Literary Work o rt. T. Gwz, G. G. Ev,I.: Nw Uv P.

K, Mw. 1996. I D C P. British Journal o esthetics36, 239-251.

K, J. 1969.rt ter Philosophy and ter: ollected Writings, 1966-1990.Cg, M.: MIT P.

Lw, S. 1967. Pg C A.rtorum

5, . 10 (1967), 79-83.. 1969. S C A.rt-Language: The Journal o onceptualrt1 (M 1969), 11-13. R O, 2002.

Lv, J. 1979. Dfg .British Journal o esthetics 19, 232-250.

. 1992. I I: A L L.Intention and Interpretation.Ig, G. (.). P: T Uv P, 221-256.

L, L. 1973. Six Years: The Dematerialization o the rt Object 1966-1972. Nw

Y: Pg.Mg, J. 1991. The Truth bout Relatiism. Ox: Bw.

M, U. 1972. onceptual rt. Nw Y: D P.

Mg, R C. 1996.rt into Ideas: Essays on onceptual rt. Cg: C-g Uv P.

O, P (.). 2002. onceptual rt: Themes and Movements. L & NwY: P P.

Nw, M. & J. B (.). 1999.Rewriting onceptual rt. L: R B.

P, A. 1993.Flash rt26, 56-58.

691Conceptual Art


20/20

S, E. 2005. Sg Bvg Bvg Sg .cta n-alytica 20, 10-23.

. 2007. T A V I. Philosophy and onceptual rt. Ox:

Ox Uv P.S, J. 2003. T P N-P A.British Journal o esthetics,V.43, 363-78.

S, F. 1965. A N. Philosophical Reiew, V. 74, 1965,. 13559

Yg, J. 2001.rt and Knowledge. L: Rg.

W, K. 1970. Cg A.Philosophical Reiew , V. 79, . 334-67.

Wz, M. 1956. T R T A.Journal o esthetics and rt

riticism,V. 15, . 27-35.W, W. K. & M. C. B. 1946. T I F. Sewanee Reiew,V. LIV, . 468-488.

W, R. 1980.rt and Its Objects. Cg: Cg Uv P.

W, P. 2002. onceptual rt. L: T Pg. S: Mv M A.


stanford aesthetics 23

Documents