sr-33 public disclosure authorized - world...

79
1818 H Street, NW , , 20433 18 , 2010 Pandion Systems, Inc. 102 NE 10th Avenue , FL 32601 011.352.372.4747 www.pandionsystems.com SR-33 Public Disclosure Authorized Public Disclosure Authorized Public Disclosure Authorized Public Disclosure Authorized Public Disclosure Authorized Public Disclosure Authorized Public Disclosure Authorized Public Disclosure Authorized

Upload: others

Post on 02-Mar-2020

4 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

1818 H Street, NW , , 20433

18 , 2010

Pandion Systems, Inc. 102 NE 10th Avenue

, FL 32601 011.352.372.4747 www.pandionsystems.com

SR-33 P

ublic

Dis

clos

ure

Aut

horiz

edP

ublic

Dis

clos

ure

Aut

horiz

edP

ublic

Dis

clos

ure

Aut

horiz

edP

ublic

Dis

clos

ure

Aut

horiz

edP

ublic

Dis

clos

ure

Aut

horiz

edP

ublic

Dis

clos

ure

Aut

horiz

edP

ublic

Dis

clos

ure

Aut

horiz

edP

ublic

Dis

clos

ure

Aut

horiz

ed

:

Pandion Systems, Inc. 2010 1

1818 H Street, NW , , 20433

:James R. Newman, Stephen A. Nesbitt, Pandion Systems, Inc. 102 NE 10th Avenue

, FL 32601 011-352-372-4747 www.pandionsystems.com

:. . ,

700095

18 , 2010

:

Pandion Systems, Inc. 2010 2

:� � ...............................................................................................................................3

..................................................................................................................4 1 .............................................................................................................................................5 2 � � - � ........................................................7 

2.1  - ...................................................................................7 2.2  ......................................................................................................7 2.3  .........................................................................................17 

2.3.1  , ......................................................17 2.3.2  .....................................................................................18 2.3.3  ..................................................................................................................18 2.3.4  .....................................................................................19 2.3.5  ................................................................................19 

2.4  ..........................................Error! Bookmark not defined. 2.4.1  ...............19 2.4.2  ......................................................................................20 2.4.3  ....................................................22 

2.5 .............................................................................23 

2.6  ...................25 3 � �

� .....................................................................................................................29 3.1  ..............................................................................................................29 3.2  ...........................30 

3.2.1  .................................................................................30 3.2.2  ......................................................................................................36 3.2.3  ..................................................................................39 

3.3  ............................................................................46 3.4  ............................................................................66 3.5  ................................................................................................71 3.6  ...................................................................75 

3.6.1  ( ) ....................75 3.6.2 .........................................................................................75 3.6.3 ...................................................................................77

4 (� ) ...................................................78 5 ........................................................................79 

:

Pandion Systems, Inc. 2010 3

- ( ) (NBT 2010), 500

. ,

.( )

( ) .

/

.:

• , - “ ”.

• 218 .

• ( , ,, ) ,

( ) ..

• , , ,- , ,

, - ,, , ,

-,

.•

() .

, ,( , ( )

) .•

( )

. -

:

Pandion Systems, Inc. 2010 4

-,

- , ,.

( , , . .)

.•

“”

.•

,.

• -- ( ,

;)1

,.

• ,–

,.

.

Pandion Systems .

,, ,

– 1, 850 ( ) 500 , 6200 220 15300 110 – - ,

.“ ”

- ( ) : :– - ( )

. , “ ” ,

1 ; , ( )

.

:

Pandion Systems, Inc. 2010 5

,( ) 500

.

( ) .- ( )(NBT 2010), 500

.–

( ) .( ) , ,

, , , , , ,,

(UNEP / CMS 2009). ( )

( ).

( )/

.. ( )

.- ( ) , ,

- ( ) .( ) (131 )

(87 )( ) (218 ) 500. ( )

.- ( )

. ( )1- .

:

Pandion Systems, Inc. 2010 6

1- . - ( ) – 500– 500

1. -2.1

434 (85% ) ,

, 10% - 15% .2

2.2 ( )

, ( )320 . 25

2 . . ,, ( ) :

( ) -, 2010 .

500

:

Pandion Systems, Inc. 2010 7

( ) .

/( ) . ,

1-. ( )

,27

. 1-( )

,-

( . . , 2010) 3.

1- .,

,

()

:/

*

(,

)

( )

(Aegypius monachus)

1) 14,000–20,000

2) 7,200–10,000 /

1,700–1,900 5,500–

8,000

1) ( ,

,),

,

2) (

)

1) B. U. Meyburg. 1994.

. 2-. 128- J. del

Hoyo, Elliott, J. Sargatal Lynx Edicions

, .

2) http://www.birdlife.org/index.html (9-25-2010)

-(Falco cherrug)

1) 35,000 - 40,000 (1994) 2) 19,200–34,000 ;(2,000–5,000 ) .

1) 2)

( )

1) A. C. Kemp. 1994.

. 2-. 273–274- .

J. del Hoyo, A. Elliott, J. Sargatal

Lynx Edicions , .

3 .

:

Pandion Systems, Inc. 2010 8

()

:/

*

(,

)2) http://www.birdlife.org/index.html (9-25-2010)

(Anser erythropus)

1) 100,000 (1980-), 20

.

2) 20,000–25,000

1)

2)

.,

,,

()

.

1) C. Carboneras. 1992.

. 1-. 582- J. del

Hoyo, A. Elliott, J. Sargatal Lynx Edicions

, ..

2) http://www.birdlife.org/index.html (9-26-10)

(Aquila heliaca)

1) 2,000 (1994) 2) 5,200–16,800 ;

(900-1000 )

(750-800 ) .

1) ,, ,

,

.2)

.

1) B. U. Meyburg. 1994.

. 2-. 194- . J. del

Hoyo, A. Elliott, J. Sargatal Lynx Edicions

, .

2) http://www.birdlife.org/index.html (9-25-2010)

(Haliaeetus leucoryphus)

1) 2,500–9,999

1)

.

2)

.

1) http://www.birdlife.org/index.html (9-26-10) 2) A. C. Kemp. 1994.

. 2-. 122- . J. del

Hoyo, A. Elliott, J. Sargatal Lynx Edicions

, .

1) 1926–2710 (1991) 20

1) 1) F. Jutglar. 1992.

:

Pandion Systems, Inc. 2010 9

()

:/

*

(,

)(Pelecanus crispus)

.2) 10,000–13,900 ;

(2,700–3,500 )

,

.

,,

.2)

(),

( ).

. 1-. 310- . J. del

Hoyo, A. Elliott, J. Sargatal Lynx Edicions

, ..

2) http://www.birdlife.org/index.html (9-26-10)

-(Aythya

nyroca)

1) 57,000–70,000 (1980–1991) 2) 160,000–257,000 .

1)

.2)

-

,

.

1) A Jutglar. 1992.

. 1-. 617- J. del

Hoyo, A. Elliott, J. Sargatal Lynx Edicions

, ..

2) http://www.birdlife.org/index.html (9-26-10)

-

(Chlamydotis undulate)

1) 40,000–60,000 , ,

.2) 49,000–62,000 ; 1990-

C. u.macqueenii 39,000–52,000

1)

( )( ),

( ).2)

1) N. J. Collar. 1996.

. 3-. 264-265- .

J. del Hoyo, A. Elliott, J. Sargatal

Lynx Edicions , .

.

:

Pandion Systems, Inc. 2010 10

()

:/

*

(,

), 75%

15%

.

( )

( )

2) http://www.birdlife.org/index.html (9-26-10)

-(Anthropoides virgo)

1) 200,000–240,000 .

2) 230,000–280,000 .

1) (

),

()

1) Archibald, G. W. C. W. Meine. 1996.

. 3-. 83-84- . J.

del Hoyo, A. Elliott, J. Sargatal Lynx Edicions

, ..

2) http://www.birdlife.org/index.html (9-26-10)

( )

(Grus grus)

1) 9,000–11,000 .

2) 360,000–370,000 .

1)

( )

2)

( )(

),

,( ,

),

-

(

).

1) Archibald, G. W. C. W. Meine. 1996.

. 3-. 88- . J. del

Hoyo, A. Elliott, J. Sargatal Lynx Edicions

, ..

2) http://www.birdlife.org/index.html (9-26-10)

( ) 1) 150,000 (1980- 1) 1) A. Elliott. 1992.

:

Pandion Systems, Inc. 2010 11

()

:/

*

(,

)(Ciconia

ciconia) )

2) 500,000 - 520,000 (

),

/

.

.

( )

.2)

,

.( )

( ;)

.

. 1-. 460-461- . J.

del Hoyo, A. Elliott, J. Sargatal Lynx Edicions

, ..

2) http://www.birdlife.org/index.html (10-12-10)

(Pandion haliaetus)

1) 500,000 .

-.

http://www.birdlife.org/index.html (9-25-2010)

:

Pandion Systems, Inc. 2010 12

()

:/

*

(,

)

(Aquila nipalensis)

1) 40,000–60,000 .

2) 10,000 .

1) "

".

2) “

.

,“

.

1) B. U. Meyburg. 1994.

. 2-. 194- . J. del

Hoyo, A. Elliott, J. Sargatal Lynx Edicions

, .

2) http://www.birdlife.org/index.html (9-26-10)

(Aquila chrysaetus)

1) 4,500–5,000

(1980-),

70,000 (1980-

)

2) 170,000 .

1)

. "

,

[ ] "

1) J. Orta. 1994.

. 2-. 197- . J. del

Hoyo, A. Elliott, J. Sargatal Lynx Edicions

, .

2) http://www.birdlife.org/index.html (9-26-10

(Haliaeetus albicilla)

1) 9,000–11,000 (2008 )

2) 20,000–39,600 ; 2004

5,000–6,600 .

1) :,

,

.

1) J. Orta. 1994.

. 2-. 122- . J. del

Hoyo, A. Elliott, J. Sargatal Lynx Edicions

, .

2) http://www.birdlife.org/

:

Pandion Systems, Inc. 2010 13

()

:/

*

(,

)index.html (9-26-10)

-

(Falco columbarius)

1) “. . . 1980-

10,000 .”

2) 1,300,000 .

1)

()

.

1) A. C. Kemp. 1994.

. 2-. 167- . J. del

Hoyo, A. Elliott, J. Sargatal Lynx Edicions

, .

2) http://www.birdlife.org/index.html (9-26-10)

,

(Falco tinnunculus)

1), 1,000,000–2,000,000 .

2) 5,000,000 .

1)

.

1950 1960-

()

,

.

1) R. O. Bierregaard. 1994.

. 2-. 259- . J. del

Hoyo, A. Elliott, J. Sargatal Lynx Edicions,

.

2) http://www.birdlife.org/index.html (9-26-10)

(Accipiter nisus)

1) 1,500,000 .

2)

1950 1960-

()

,

.

1) http://www.birdlife.org/index.html (9-26-10) 2) J. Orta. 1994.

. 2-. 158- . J. del

Hoyo, A. Elliott, J. Sargatal Lynx Edicions

, .

(Circus pygargus)

1) 7,000 .

2) 100,000 .

1)

(1990)

1) A. C. Kemp. 1994.

. 2-. 140–141- .

J. del Hoyo, A. Elliott, J. Sargatal

:

Pandion Systems, Inc. 2010 14

()

:/

*

(,

)

(

).

Lynx Edicions , .

2) http://www.birdlife.org/index.html (9-26-10)

(Circus macrourus)

1) 1990-� 20,000

.2) 18,000–30,000 ;1970–1990

,30%

( ,

),

. ,

.

1)

2)

(

) ,,

).

1) A. C. Kemp. 1994.

. 2-. 140- . J. del

Hoyo, A. Elliott, J. Sargatal Lynx Edicions

, .

2) http://www.birdlife.org/index.html (9-26-10)

(Circus aeruginosus)

1. 93000-140000

,279000-420000

(BirdLife International 2004). 2.

25-49% ,

500000-2000000

,

.

.

http://www.iucnredlist.org/apps/redlist/details/144370/0/print

,(Neophron percnopterus)

-,

: 2,600-3,100 , <2000

1.

.

http://www.iucnredlist.org/apps/redlist/details/144347/0

:

Pandion Systems, Inc. 2010 15

()

:/

*

(,

),

,1000

,,

<7500 –30,000-40,000

.

,,

( )

.2. ,

()

.

(Gyps fulvus)

, 100.000

.

, ,

.( ,

)

.

http://www.iucnredlist.org/apps/redlist/details/144353/0

http://www.europeanraptors.org/raptors/eurasian_griffon_vulture.html

http://www.birdlife.org/datazone/speciesfactsheet.php?id=3378

:

Pandion Systems, Inc. 2010 16

()

:/

*

(,

)

-(Aquilla pennata)

10,000 - 100,000 .

,

,,

.

http://www.birdlife.org/datazone/speciesfactsheet.php?id=3543

http://eagleconservationalliance.org/discussions/

(Aquilla heliacal)

5,200 - 16,800 . (

),

(),

,

,,

, ,

,,

,.

http://eagleconservationalliance.org/discussions/

(Circaetus gallicus)

51,000 - 156,000 .

.

http://www.birdlife.org/datazone/speciesfactsheet.php?id=32257

http://www.ornisfennica.org/pdf/vol86-3/2Bakaloudis.pdf

( )(Buteo rufinus)

100,000 .

1.

2.

http://www.birdlife.org/datazone/speciesfactsheet.php?id=32592

http://www.europeanraptors.org/raptors/long_legged_buzzard.html

:

Pandion Systems, Inc. 2010 17

()

:/

*

(,

)

.

.

* ( ) ; ( )( );

( )

2.3

2.3.1. � , �

- -:

• “ ” (1992) —,

.;

• “ ” (1997) —, ,

( /) , ,

( ).

-

:• 1998 1 139- “ -

- ” .-

,

:

:

Pandion Systems, Inc. 2010 18

• - (1995 ); • (1997 ); • (1998

); • ,

- – ( 2001 );

• -( 2003 );

• – -( ) (1994 .);

• -( ) (1996 .).

2.3.2. � � �-

( ) () .

( ) IV .

: ,,

– .–

. ( )( ) , .

( ).

2.3.3.

(1987, 2003, 2006 ). .

. ( ) 2010 . : 0 =

“ ” (EX) or “” (REW); 1 = “ ” (CR) or “ ”

(EN); 2 = “ ” (VU:R,4 VU:D5); 3 = “ -

4 R = ( )

5 D = ( )

:

Pandion Systems, Inc. 2010 19

” (NT). (2006 )48 , 23 ( ) - .

(2- : , , ,, , , , Chinor Enk , 2006)

, ,, , , , , ,

, - .

2.3.4. (� )

.(Grus leucogeranus), (Vanellus gregarious), (Oxiura

leucocephala), (Glareola nordmani) (Platalea leucorodia), (Falco cherrug) (Neophron

percnopterus) .

2.3.5.

() ,

( ); (MAWR) ,

,.

( )

.

2.4.

2.5. � � �

, ( )

.

. , ,, “ ” (

) “ ” ( ). ,

“ ” , 230 “ ” ,

:

Pandion Systems, Inc. 2010 20

, , “ ” . ,( )

.

1980- , -

, “ ”

. 90% , ( , 1982

.). . (1985) , --

..

-.

,. ( ,

) .-

( ) - .

( , 1967 .).

(2- ). , (/ , – )

. , ( )

“ ” .

:

Pandion Systems, Inc. 2010 21

1- .

2010 () ,

500 ; .

2.5.1. � �-

. - ( ,, , , )

., . -

,.

3 3,5 ,. ,

., ,

, .,

,, . ,

( ) ,

:

Pandion Systems, Inc. 2010 22

( , 1979 .; ., 1982 .). (“ ” )

, ,-

, ,. , ,

( , - , ) , , ,. ,

, - ( , , )( ., 1982 .). ,

- , –- ( , 1985 .).

,( )

, –

,( , 2010 .). ,

,.

, ,

. ,, ,

,- .

, , ,

, , , ,.

.: -

(Anthropoides virgo) (Grus grus) ( , 2002 .). .

( ) - ,- ,

, .- ,

,( , 2004 .).

,.

( , 2002 .).

:

Pandion Systems, Inc. 2010 23

( )

, ,( ) 150 (

, 2008 .). , ,. ,

( ) 200 22,000 . (2008

.), 23,000 (Anthropoides virgo) .

,( ) .

( )( )

15 . (Falco cherrug), (F. columbarius), (F. tinnunculus),

(Accipiter nisus), (Circus pygargus), (C. macrourus), (C. aeruginosus), (Milvus corshun), (Haliaeetus leucoryphus), (Neophron percnopterus), (Gyps fulvus),

(Aegypius monachus), (Aquilla pennata), (A. heliacal), (Buteo rufinus) (Circaetus gallicus)

( , 1967 .). ( ).

(Buteo rufinus).

- .(1987 .), (Falco

cherrug). (1990

.), 40% 33% . ,

,, , ,

( ) ( , 1990 .). - .

.

2.5.2. �( )

. , , ,, ,

.. -

.

:

Pandion Systems, Inc. 2010 24

, ,.

( ).

. ,, ,

,( )

.

(Aythya nyroca) (Anser erythropus)(

, IWC). , 20,000

.( ) (IBA)

(Critical Site Network [CSN]). 10 - . ,

, , , () .

, ,, , , ( ) ( , 2008

.) (IWC, ).

( )10 .

, , . 20,000 , , . ,

, ( ) ., , ,

( , 2008 .).

2.6.

. ,,

.

.. ,

,, , , , ,

:

Pandion Systems, Inc. 2010 25

– , , ( , 1987 .; , , 1994 .).

( ,) , , , , ,

. ,

50 ( , ), 300 5,000 ( , , ,

– , ) 200 500 ( , , , , ) .

, .(6–10 )

(1987 .) ( ) 1981–1984 : 30 3

– (Pandion haliaetus), 16 (Aquila nipalensis), 1 (Aquila heliacal), 1 (Aquila chrysaetus) 3

(Circaetus gallicus). 1989 26 ( ) 64, 12 .

: 1 –, 2 (Haliaeetus albicilla), 2 , 11 , 1 , 1

2 (Falco cherrug). ( ) ( )

220 ( ,

). 2004

( , ,).

. ( ,, ) -

. ,,

( , 2007 .). , ,

( ), , ( ), ( ); . (1987 .),

( ,) .

1997 2007 , (2009 .) , , .

71 14 :- (Accipiter gentilis), (Buteo buteo),

:

Pandion Systems, Inc. 2010 26

(Buteo rufinus), (Circus cyaneus), (Circus aeruginosus), (Aquila chrysaetos), - (A. heliaca),

(A. nipalensis), (A. clanga), (Aegypyus monachus),(Gyps fulvus), (Neophron percnopterus), (Circaetus gallicus), (Falco tinnunculus) ( , ).

2007 ,,

. , , -( , 2007 .;

, 2007 .). .( . . )

, ,. , ,

.

2.7. 218 (ROW)

. , ,, 2010 .

36 , 14 , .

9261180 , - 827 1105 , , ( (600–620 ), , 220 - .14 21

, . 21 31,

21 22 ,7-8 .

23 24 ,33 - .

, -. 38 39

.

( ), .

• ,,

2, 3, 4, 5, , ,200- .

:

Pandion Systems, Inc. 2010 27

8.8 4 .• 5, - ,

,2.2 .

. 7

.• 350 7

.19.5 , 2.2 - .

• 7 14 -

, ,. .

, - 0.5-1.0 100 .

, ; .17.0 .

• 14, .

15, 16, 17 , 0.5 .

.• 17 18

, - ,, 220 - .

18 - , 400 .

19 20- , -

,1.5–2.0 , ,

10 .• 21 22

,7-8 . .

• 22 (23) -

; ( ). •

60.5 , 1, . ,

:

Pandion Systems, Inc. 2010 28

87.0 ; 483.0 - .

•, ,

(3 ), 35 , ,10 , , .

, .- , 110 - ,

.• - - ,

. 8 ,–

– 3 , ,.

•, 35 , , 110 ,

2 , 10, -

, - , - ,220 - .

• (10-15 ), ,

0.5 . 3, 4 – , 3 – ,

, 10 ,.

• 6.2, ,

10 .• 9.5

220 – 3 ,- , - ,

.• OSG 500

, 500 -, , 20

, 110 ., .

. ,

:

Pandion Systems, Inc. 2010 29

500 , .30 35 ,

– 25 30 , – 10 15 ..

. ,.

60 .( 17.9 24.2 ;

, 2008 .) .. ,

, (Grus leucigeranus) (Aythya nyroca), URB ( ) (Phalacrocorax

pygmaeus), (Platalea leucorodia), (Pandion haliaetus), –(Haliaeetus albicilla), (Pterocles alchata).

, , .(Anser anser) .

60-70- . .

20,000 .(Anser erythropus), (Crex crex),

(Aythya nyroca). , .

.45 - ,

.10 .

( ., 2007 .; , 2008 .). , , – (

) . (Anser anser, A. albifrons, A. fabalis)(Grus grus) .

.50,000 .

,, 36 , ,

., , , ,

.( , [ – ]).

3. .

3.1. ., ,

, ., ( 1998)

:

Pandion Systems, Inc. 2010 30

( ) ., , ,

,- ( , ) ,

.;

,( , , ,

) , . -

, ,.

.,

. -.

( . 3).

:

Pandion Systems, Inc. 2010 31

: EPA 1998

:,

,

3- . 5.

3.2 :

3.2.1 ,

.- - ( ,

, )( , ,

, , . .) –( , , .)

. –, ( ,

IUCN),

:

Pandion Systems, Inc. 2010 32

.. « » –

, ,.

,( . 4).

4- . .

,,

., :

,-

-

:

: EPA 1998

��

��

��

3.

1.

3.

2b.

2a.

3.

:

Pandion Systems, Inc. 2010 33

( . 4, )

, APLIC (1994, 2005), (1998), ( 2001), (2010) .

( )

, , , , ,

( . 2). , ,

/ . ,

. , : , ,

, , , . , .

, - , / , :

- :

(Pelecanus crispus)

(Pelecanus onocrotalus)

:

- (Anser albifrons)

(Anser erythropus)

- (Anser Anser)

- (Aythya nyroca)

-

- (Ciconia Ciconia)

-

-

- (Gyps fulvus)

- (Aegypius monachus)

- - (Neophron percnopterus)

- - (Haliaeetus albicilla)

- - (Haliaeetus leucoryphus)

- (Pandion haliaetus)

- (Aquila chrysaetus)

- (Aquila heliaca)

- (Aquila clanga)

- (Aquila nipalensis)

:

Pandion Systems, Inc. 2010 34

- (Grus Grus)

- - - (Anthropoides Grus)

- (Chlamydotis undulate)

- (Buteo rufinus)

- - - (Aquila pennata)

- (Circaetus gallicus)

- (Milvus corshun)

- (Circus aeruginosus)

- (Circus cyaneus)

- (Circus pygargus)

- (Circus Macrourus)

- - - (Buteo Rufinus)

( ) - (Buteo Buteo)

- (Pernis apivorus)

- (Accipiter Nisus)

, - (Falco tinnunculus)

- (Falco naumanni)

- - (Falco subbuteo)

- - - (Falco Peregrinus)

(Falco columbarius)

(Falco cherrug)

.

, , . . ,

- , : •

• , ,

• ,

- , , 6, 7,

.

:

Pandion Systems, Inc. 2010 35

6 , ( , ) , , . –

, . 7 – , . .

( . . / ,

, , )

, 8,

, ,

(APLIC 2005). , -

. ,

, .

5 .

, .

8 – 69

, . – , , 69 . ,

, , , .

:

Pandion Systems, Inc. 2010 36

5- . .

. –

. , ,

,

,

/

/

, ,

/ -

, ,

/ ,

,

: , 10-9-2010

:

Pandion Systems, Inc. 2010 37

(EPA 1998). , .

• , ,

. •

, .

3.2.2 . – , ( ),

( .6)

6- . .

- .

-

:

��

��

:

��

��

:

Pandion Systems, Inc. 2010 38

. , ,

. ,

( ) . .

( . .6) •

• , , .

• - , - ,

( 1998)

- - ( , )

( ). , ,

-.

, ( , ),

, .

: 1. ( ,

) 2. ( ) 3. ( , - ) 4. ( ) 5. ( , ,

) 6. ,

( , , , )

:

Pandion Systems, Inc. 2010 39

– , , ,

. ,

. ,

(EPA 1998) :

• ?

• ?

• ? ?

• ?

• ?

• , ?

, .

. , :

• ?

• ?

• ?

• ( )?

• ?

• ?

• , ?

, , , ,

.

• / , , .

:

Pandion Systems, Inc. 2010 40

• / , .

• , .

• ( ), -

. • ( )

. ,

.

3.2.3

. ( ) . , "

, 30% , ".

, ,

, , . .

- , , ,

. , ( .7)

:

Pandion Systems, Inc. 2010 41

7- .

. , ,

, , , .

. , ,

( , ) , , .

- , . ,

, .

, ,

9. 9 , , 2007 http://www.nationalwind.org/workgroups/wildlife/era.pdf

Ecological Risk Assessment Steps

Source: Adapted from EPA 1998

: EPA ,1998

:

��

��

:

��

��

:

Pandion Systems, Inc. 2010 42

. , ,

. , ,

.

, , .

. . , : ,

. . , . ( , )

, , ,

, , . .

.

, ; ; ( ,

) . -

( , ,

) ,

. .

, .

, . , ,

; , , (

2009). : , , ,

, . ( .2)

:

Pandion Systems, Inc. 2010 43

, , , .

, . ,

.

2- .

, ( ), - .

.

.

, , -

-

.

.

, / - .

.

, -

. .

.

, / -

, , .

:

Pandion Systems, Inc. 2010 44

.

. (2009)

, ( .8 9). , .

( , , , ) .

( )

:

Pandion Systems, Inc. 2010 45

:

Pandion Systems, Inc. 2010 46

8- . .

9- . .

3.3

PROJECT

,

,

-

/ ,

: . 2010

:

Pandion Systems, Inc. 2010 47

: • ( ,

- ) • ( - ) • ( ) • ( , - ) • ( , ,

) .

, , , – .

, .

3 , / , , ,

, , . ,

( , - Aegypius monachus, - Pelecanus crispus) ( - - Anthropoides virgo, - Pandion haliaetus). ,

. ,

, , , - , ,

.

:

Pandion Systems, Inc. 2010 48

( - ) 3- . .

( *)

**

(Aegypius monachus)

1) 14,000-20,000 .

2) 7,200-10,000 / 1,700-1,900

5,500-8,000 .

"1980 80 , ,

75-80 . - ”.

(Falco cherrug)

1) 35 000 40.000 (1994).

2) 19,200-34, 000 , 2,000-5,000 .

"1990

. - 120-150

; 500-700 , 100-150 .

-

(Anser erythropus)

1) 100 000 (1980- ), 20

.

2) 20,000-25,000 .

“ , 200 2000

”.

(Aquila heliaca)

1) 2000 (1994).

2) 5,200-16,800 , (

900-1000 ) (750-800 )

" . 15

".

(Haliaeetus leucoryphus)

1) 2,500–9,999 . “ , , ”.

(Pelecanus crispus)

1) 1926-2710 (1991), 20 .

2) 10,000-13,900 .

(2,700-3,500 ).

“250 ,

1000 ”.

( )

(Aythya nyroca)

1) 57,000–70,000 (1980–1991). 2) 160,000–257,000

.

“3,000 4,000 7000

”.

(Chlamydotis undulate)

1) – 40,000-60,000 , ,

.

2) 49,000-62,000 , 1990-

39,000-52,000 ,

.

:

Pandion Systems, Inc. 2010 49

75% 15% .

-

(Anthropoides virgo)

1) 200,000–240,000 .

2) 230,000–280,000

.

.

(Grus grus)

1) 9,000–11,000 . 2) 360,000–370,000

.

.

(Ciconia ciconia)

1) 150,000 (1980- ). 2) 500,000 - 520,000 .

“1500 (95% )

”.

:

.

( )

(Pandion haliaetus)

1) 500,000 . “ .

”.

(Aquila nipalensis)

1) 40,000–60,000 . 2) 10,000 .

.

;

”.

(Aquila chrysaetus)

1) 4,500-5,000 (1980-

), 70000 (1980 ).

2) 170 000 .

“ . 1970-80- 80-100

”.

(Haliaeetus albicilla)

1) 9,000–11,000 (2008). 2) 20,000–39,600 ; 2004

5,000–6,600 .

“ ,

. -

. 300-400 ”.

(Falco columbarius)

1) "…1980- - - 10000 ".

2) 1300000 .

.

(Falco tinnunculus)

1) 1,000,000–2,000,000 . 2) 5,000,000 .

.

1) 1,500,000 . .

:

Pandion Systems, Inc. 2010 50

(Accipiter nisus)

(Circus pygargus)

1) 7,000 . 2) 100,000 .

.

(Circus macrourus)

1) 1990 � 20000 .

2) 18,000-30,000 ; 1970-1990

, 30% ,

( , ),

. , .

« .

”.

(Pelecanus onocrotalus)

1) 7,350–10,500 . 2) 270,000 - 290,000

.

“500-700 , ,

”.

(Neophron percnopterus)

- ,

: 2,600-3,100 , <2000

,

, 1000 ,

, <7500 – 30,000-40,000

.

.

(Gyps fulvus)

, 100,000 .

“1980- 140 ;

.

- ”.

-

(Aquilla pennata)

10,000 - 100,000 .

“ ”.

-

(Aquilla heliacal)

5,200 - 16,800 . .

(Circaetus gallicus)

51,000 - 156,000 .

“1970-80- 20

50 ;

30-40 .

:

Pandion Systems, Inc. 2010 51

”.

(Buteo rufinus)

100,000 . .

10 . (IUCN 2001), . , .

* . .

** .

, ( . .3 ) , ,

, , . .

,

. ,

, , , /

. , , , /

. , /

, ,

, , (APLIC 2005)

, , .

500 100 1000 550 620 .

:

Pandion Systems, Inc. 2010 52

, , ,

. « »

. – , . ,

, . (APLIC 2006)

, ,

, , , . –

( ) . 500 ,

. 28 29,2 .

218 .

,

, . 4

, .

4- .

.

( ) ( )

(Aegypius monachus) 250–295

(Falco cherrug) 102–129

- (Anser erythropus) 120–135

(Aquila heliaca) 180–215

(Haliaeetus leucoryphus) 180–205

(Pelecanus crispus) 310–345

(Ciconia ciconia) 150-155

:

Pandion Systems, Inc. 2010 53

(Aythya nyroca) 60-70

- (Chlamydotis undulate) 140–160

- - (Anthropoides virgo) 150–170

- (Grus grus) 180–200

- (Pandion haliaetus) 145–170

- (Aquila nipalensis) 160–200

- (Aquila chrysaetus) 190–227

- - (Haliaeetus albicilla) 200–245

- (Falco columbarius) 50–67

- (Falco tinnunculus) 65–82

- - (Accipiter nisus) 60–75

- (Circus pygargus) 97–115

- (Circus macrourus) 95–120

- (Circus aeruginosus) 110–130

- (Milvus corshun migrans) 135–155

, - (Neophron percnopterus) 155–170

- (Gyps fulvus) 240–280

- (Aquila chrysaetus) 180–234

- - (Haliaeetus albicilla) 182–244

(Falco columbarius) 61–69

, - (Falco tinnunculus) 60–65

:

Pandion Systems, Inc. 2010 54

4 , , (4.5 )

. , , , , , ,

.

, : , ,

, – , .

300 350 100 1000 . .

550 620 . 500 , , 17-36

, , . 500

, . 28 - 29,2

, ( . . 10 11)

10- . .

:

Pandion Systems, Inc. 2010 55

11 . .

2.5 .

, ( . . ) 9 ( ,

) 29+ ( ).

, .

, .

, , , , ,

. , .

, .

.

- . , (

) : 12 - , 4

. ( ) , .

:

Pandion Systems, Inc. 2010 56

5 , . 5- . ,

.

( )

(? = )

(Aegypius monachus) ,

. , , .

2, 4, 5, 6, 8, 9, 14

(Falco cherrug)

( ), , , , .

( , ); .

2, 4, 5, 6, 8, 14

- (Anser erythropus) .

.

3?, 4, 5, 8(?), 9, 10, 11, 12, 13

(Aquila heliaca) . ,

.

2, 3, 4, 5, 10, 11, 12, 14

(Haliaeetus leucoryphus)

, - , , ,

.

11, 16

(Pelecanus crispus)

, , ( ) .

( , ,

) . .

11(?), 16

(Ciconia ciconia)

, , - , , - , , , , .

, , .

3, 7, 9, 10, 11, 12, 13, 15, 16

, (Ayta nyroca)

11(?), 16

:

Pandion Systems, Inc. 2010 57

. , .

(Chlamydotis undulate)

, .

.

2?, 4, 5, 6, 8, 9, 14

- (Anthropoides virgo)

- , , , , ;

. .

- .

3, 4(?), 5, 6, 8, 9, 10, 11, 12, 13, 14, 16

(Grus grus) . –

- .

3, 4 (?), 8, 9, 10, 11, 12, 13, 14, 16

- (Pandion haliaetus)

( , ), ,

. . ,

11, 15, 16

(Aquila nipalensis) , . , . , ,

. 2, 4, 5, 6, 8, 14

(Aquila chrysaetus) ( , , );

.

; .

2, 4, 5, 6, 8, 9, 14

(Haliaeetus

albicilla)

- , , ; ,

. – - ,

, , .

11, 16

(Falco columbarius) , , , , –

. 2, 5, 8, 11, 14(?)

, (Falco tinnunculus)

– , ,

, , ,

. – ,

, .

1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 7, 8, 9, 10, 11, 12, 13, 14, 16

(Accipiter nisus)

( , , ), .

. 1, 2, 8, 14

(Circus pygargus)

; .

( , , , )

. , .

2, 3, 4, 5(?), 7, 8, 9, 10, 11, 12, 13, 14

:

Pandion Systems, Inc. 2010 58

(Circus macrourus)

, - ,

, . , , ,

, - . .

.

2, 4, 5, 7, 8, 9, 14

(Circus aeruginosus)

, ( ) ,

, , . - .

( ) ; .

7, 8(?), 11(?), 12(?), 15, 16

(Milvus corshun migrans) , , -

, . , ,

, , .

1, 2, 4, 5, 7, 8, 9, 12, 13, 14

, (Neophron percnopterus)

, , ; , , , . .

4, 5(?), 6, 10, 12

(Gyps fulvus) ; , , , , ;

. 4, 5, 6, 8, 14

.

, . .

. ( ) ( -

) , , , . ,

, , .

. ,

, , . 6 , , , , . , ,

, , .

:

Pandion Systems, Inc. 2010 59

6- . /

.

, .

(Pelecanus crispus)

(Ciconia ciconia)

( ) (Anser albifrons) - (Anser erythropus)

(Anser anser)

, .

(Aythya nyroca)

(Gyps fulvus) - (Aegypius monachus) -

, (Neophron percnopterus) (Haliaeetus albicilla)

(Haliaeetus leucoryphus) - - (Pandion haliaetus)

(Aquila chrysaetus) (Aquila heliaca)

(Aquila clanga) (Aquila nipalensis)

(Circaetus gallicus) - (Aquilla pennata)

(Milvus corshun) (Circus aeruginosus)

(Circus cyaneus) (Circus pygargus) - (Circus macrourus) - - (Buteo rufinus)

(Buteo buteo) (Pernis apivorus) - (Accipiter nisus)

(Falco tinnunculus) , (Falco naumanni)

(Falco subbuteo) (Falco peregrinus)

(Falco columbarius) (Falco cherrug)

(Grus grus)

- (Anthropoides virgo) (Chlamydotis undulate)

,

,

:

Pandion Systems, Inc. 2010 60

. , , . , , (Mycteria Americana) (2001), , 500 ,

. , 87% (639 , ) ; 82%

(34,546 , ) – . , , , .

, ( , 1994 , 1998; 2000 ;

2005). (1988), (1998), :

, , , , , . , ,

( ) , " ", , ,

. " " ( . ., , ).

- , , , . ,

, , , , , , , , ,

, . , , , . ,

. - , , -

, , ( , ). , . ,

, , - ,

. , , ,

, ( 1998 ; 2000 ; 2002 ; 2008).

, , , ( 1993)

, . (1998), (2008) ,

, . (2000), (2002) ,

, . . (1972), (1979) ,

:

Pandion Systems, Inc. 2010 61

(Sturnus vulgaris) (Chen caerulescens). , , , - , .

. (> 400 )

, 17 36 . ,

. – ,

. ,

, . .

, ,

. , - . ,

, , , .

11 . , ,

. , , .

. 7

. , - ,

. , , , ,

, , , , , .

11 , .

- SS – 18 , 55,5 - , 800-1200 14 600 , 14 18. - 15 (III ). - 690 A, :

+40°C, -30° , +10°C, -5°C. - 20 . 25 .

, (IV 20 ).

:

Pandion Systems, Inc. 2010 62

- 18 - 16,1 600 - 400 . - 10 (II ). - 540 .

: +40° , -30° , +10°C, -5°C. - 20 . - 25 .

7- . .

-

( -

)

.

.

, -

.

( )

500

550 – 620 .

100 1000

,

,

.

( - )

500

4,5 ,

, 3

.

,

.

( - ,

)

.

– ,

– .

.

,

,

. -

(

,

)

, .

,

,

. 8 .

, .

:

Pandion Systems, Inc. 2010 63

( ,

), , . 8- .

( -

).

.

.

.

( ).

(

300 ) 5

; 218 9

36 .

.

.

,

.

( - ).

( )

. ( , ),

,

.

.

( - ,

).

( )

. ,

– . .

, ,

.

- (

, ).

, - .

, ,

.

- , -

.

.

:

Pandion Systems, Inc. 2010 64

3.4 .

, :

• ?

• ?

• ?

• ( )?

• ?

• ?

• , ?

, ,

, ( . 2.4).

, -

. , ( . 12).

. , - ,

.

:

Pandion Systems, Inc. 2010 65

12- . 12000 , ( ) ( )

. ( : . (2010), (1998))

, ,

. ,

(APLIC 2006). , , (<69-

). ,

, , , , .

, , ,

– , . ,

( , , ) - - - ,

. (APLIC 2006). , , –

138- (1994 APLIC, 2006). , ( ,

) (APLIC 1994).

- , ( ) .

:

Pandion Systems, Inc. 2010 66

- ( , ) / / ,

( , ). , ( , , , , , , ),

, .

. . .

,

, . ,

, . ,

( ). , , ,

.

, , . ,

, ( , ).

, ,

( (Grus Americana)) ( . 2010).

, -

, , . ( ,

) 1970 (APLIC 2006, 1998 , 1999; . 2010.).

, , .

, , 100 (APLIC 1994 , 2010; 1998

, 1999;. . 2010). ,

, , .

. , , ,

, .

,

:

Pandion Systems, Inc. 2010 67

, , .

9

. 9- .

,

( )

/ .

, ,

/ .

?

– , ,

.

, ,

.

?

,

.

, , ,

.

,

;

. ,

.

?

,

,

:

Pandion Systems, Inc. 2010 68

( ,

).

(

).

( )?

, ,

, .

.

( )

?

100

.

70

.

-

?

( , ),

. ,

.

( , ),

. ,

.

?

,

,

.

. ,

,

.

,

.

. ,

,

.

3.5

( ) . ,

. 3.2, .

, , , , . ,

( , ,

:

Pandion Systems, Inc. 2010 69

, , ), ( . 2).

, " ". -

– - , , , .

, ,

- , .

, ,

, – . ,

. , « »,

, , ,

. - ,

. ( . 1)

( , - ), - .

, , , ,

, , , . .

. .

( . 3.6.2) , «

».

, " " , , , .

, , ,

50% ( . 2010) . , ,

. - .

, ,

, ,

:

Pandion Systems, Inc. 2010 70

. ( . 3.6.2)

, . ,

, .

, , , .

( ) , ,

, , . ,

.

, - . , , .

. , ,

, ,

. .

, , .

, . ,

. .

( 1995 ; 2005), (

1991).

( 2008). (Grus leucogeranus),

. ( ) . 4000

: - . ( ) ; ( 200 ) (

). . ,

, , , . ,

. 2007 ,

:

Pandion Systems, Inc. 2010 71

. , , ,

. , ( " ")

.

. , . , ,

( ) .

, . , ,

( ) . , ,

, , , .

, , . , ,

, . -

. (

) .

, . .

, .

• ,

, .

• ,

, .

, ,

, « », , . 3.6

3.6.1

:

Pandion Systems, Inc. 2010 72

. , , ,

. ,

, , ,

. ,

/ , .

, , . ,

. «

» , , , . ,

, , TOTL.

3.6.2 :

. ( )

, ( . 5). , ,

, . ,

/ .

, ,

. , , , ,

. , -

. ,

, .

, , ( , - ,

) , . ( .

:

Pandion Systems, Inc. 2010 73

2.6, , ).

, . , ,

" "12. , , , ,

. , .

( , , . .) .

, , .

.

, , ,

. , .

_________

12 .

,

. , , , .

. .

, .

, . , ( .

3.6.3, ).

.

, , , .

. 3.6.3

, , .

,

:

Pandion Systems, Inc. 2010 74

. ,

, ,

( , , , , ).

, , , .

, , .

, , , .

, , ,

. , .

II .

4. ( )

(APLIC) : 1994. . . , , . 78.

(APLIC) : 2006.

. , APLIC, . , , .

., 1998 , : . 86:67–76.

., 1998 , . , 1 .

. . . ( ). : , .

. . . . .

23:217–227 . . 2000. ,

. , . . . . . . 2002.

. ,

. . , . . , , , .

:

Pandion Systems, Inc. 2010 75

., . , 2001. , , .

24:419-424. . . . . 1979. , . , . . . 2000 :

. . . 95:353-359. . ., . . . 2010.

: . 20: 263–275.

. . . . 1991. . 19:442–

449. . . 2005. :

1978. 9:155–165 . . . 2008.

: . 10:25-36.

( / ). 2009.

, . / , ,

. 68 . ( ). 1998.

. , , , ,

/630/ 095/002 . 5.

B.B. . . 411. , , 1987, . 11

B.B. . . . 3-

. , . 1990, . 15-18. . . , . , .

. . . . , . . . . . . . , 2008, . 140-141.

. . . . - . 1979, . 256.

. . . // . 17, 1982, . 13-17

. . . . (“ ”).//

. . 1985, . 260-294.

:

Pandion Systems, Inc. 2010 76

. . . - .

. 3- . , . 1990, . 83-85.

. . , . . , . . . // . , “ ,” 1982.

, 2007, . 8. . 2. . , 2006.

. . . – “ ” . , 2007, . 5.

. . , E.A. . . . . , 2002, . 178-182.

. . , . . . // . . . . , . . . . . . . ,

2008. . 145-147. . . , A.K. , . . .

. 3- . , , 1990, . 77-78.

. . , A.K. , . . , . . , . , E.A. .

// – . , 2007, . 98-109.

. . . //

. . . , 2009. .169-172.

. . . - // . . . . , . . . . . . . ,

2008. . 144-145. . . , . . . . . 1.

. , 1987, . 123-246. A.P. , . . .

. . , 1989, . 147-154.

. . , . . // , . , 1967, . 76-128.

A.K. . // . . . . , . . . . . . . , 2008, .

106-107. E. , . . .

. 32-35. “ -

». , 1994.

. . , , . . , K.T. , . . , . , . .

:

Pandion Systems, Inc. 2010 77

. . 17. , 1982, . 8-12.

., ., , - (Anthropoides Virgo) // . 12.

. - , . 6-27. IUSN , – 2010, www.iusn.org

- . Foglar over land och hav. En global oversikt av faglarnas flyttning. . . – / ? #23? 2007.

.41-45. ( ) - - ( ) ( ) - ( ) ( ) - ( )

( ) ; ( )

( ); ( )