speech regulation: why an injunction should be permissible under

30
HIM 7=$$8# 6$*02&+(,)Y %#< &) F)@0)8+(,) 7#,02- ;$ Q$1A(''(;2$ P)-$1 %,1E=2&8$ h('81(A()&+(,) ;0+ F' Q1,;2$A&+(8 P)-$1 h$3&A&+(,) 7&1&# 7#<1 K"@1- )2 3)&(-&(# F> F)+1,-08+(,) >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>HIT FF> "#$ g(1'+ XA$)-A$)+ &)- 7=$$8# 6$*02&+(,)' >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>HI] X> h,8+1()$ ,3 Q1(,1 6$'+1&()+'>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>HI] c> 6$*02&+(,) ,3 S33$)'(5$ 7=$$8#>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> KUU FFF> F)@0)8+(5$ 6$A$-< () "?, G$? 4,)+$D+' >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>KUK X> R)@,()()* 7=$$8# P)-$1 %,1E=2&8$ h('81(A()&+(,)Y J'/%1"0 4A J4%# 5-&( J 3"0 6G#(->8 O&7A >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> KUK H> F)@0)8+(,) P)-$1 RA=2,<A$)+ h('81(A()&+(,) &' 4,)+$)+LG$0+1&2 6$'+1(8+(,) >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>KUN c> R)@,()()* 7=$$8# P)-$1 h$3&A&+(,)Y M"1@)" O#1"&+ <%11"'- O&&8 O&7A 4A ,->-& >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> KUI 4> h('+()*0('#()* X*0(2&1 31,A c&2;,& >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>KHJ H> 6$`0(1$- 7#,?()* ,3 X8+0&2 b&1A >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>KHJ K> h(33$1$)+ 7,018$' ,3 .&? >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>KH] O> X==2(8&;2$ g,10A' >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>KHI J> "<=$ ,3 6$'+1(8+(,)>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> KKU FV> %#$) &) F)@0)8+(,) 7#,02- c$ & Q$1A(''(;2$ 6$A$-< 3,1 h$3&A&+(,) >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>KKH FV> 4,)820'(,)>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>KKJ />h>B %&'#()*+,) &)- .$$ P)(5$1'(+< 78#,,2 ,3 .&?B KUUI[ c>7>B "$D+(2$' &)- X==&1$2 W&)&*$A$)+B 4,1)$22 P)(5$1'(+<B KUUT> F ?,02- 2(E$ +, $D=1$'' A< #$&1+3$2+ +#&)E' +, Q1,3$'',1 h,0* 6$)-2$A&) 3,1 #(' 8,)+()0$- *0(-&)8$ &)- ()'(*#+302 8,AA$)+' +#1,0*#,0+ +#$ ?1(+()* =1,8$''>

Upload: others

Post on 09-Feb-2022

1 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Speech Regulation: Why an Injunction Should be Permissible Under

HIM

7=$$8#!6$*02&+(,)Y!!%#<!&)!F)@0)8+(,)!7#,02-!;$!Q$1A(''(;2$!P)-$1!%,1E=2&8$!h('81(A()&+(,)!;0+!F'!Q1,;2$A&+(8!P)-$1!

h$3&A&+(,)!

7&1&#!7#<1

K"@1-*)2*3)&(-&(#*

! F>! F)+1,-08+(,)!>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>!HIT

! FF>! "#$!g(1'+!XA$)-A$)+!&)-!7=$$8#!6$*02&+(,)'!>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>!HI]! ! X>! h,8+1()$!,3!Q1(,1!6$'+1&()+'!>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>!HI]! ! c>! 6$*02&+(,)!,3!S33$)'(5$!7=$$8#!>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>!KUU

! FFF>! F)@0)8+(5$!6$A$-<!()!"?,!G$?!4,)+$D+'!>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>!KUK! X>! R)@,()()*!7=$$8#!P)-$1!%,1E=2&8$!h('81(A()&+(,)Y!

J'/%1"0*4A*J4%#*5-&(*J*3"0*6G#(->8*O&7A!>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>!KUK! ! H>! F)@0)8+(,)!P)-$1!RA=2,<A$)+!h('81(A()&+(,)!!! ! ! &'!4,)+$)+LG$0+1&2!6$'+1(8+(,)!>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>!KUN! c>! R)@,()()*!7=$$8#!P)-$1!h$3&A&+(,)Y!!M"1@)"*O#1"&+*<%11"'-*** * O&&8*O&7A*4A*,->-&!>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>!KUI! 4>! h('+()*0('#()*!X*0(2&1!31,A!c&2;,&!>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>!KHJ! ! H>! 6$`0(1$-!7#,?()*!,3!X8+0&2!b&1A!>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>!KHJ! ! K>! h(33$1$)+!7,018$'!,3!.&?!>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>!KH]! ! O>! X==2(8&;2$!g,10A'!>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>!KHI! ! J>! "<=$!,3!6$'+1(8+(,)!>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>!KKU

! FV>! %#$)!&)!F)@0)8+(,)!7#,02-!c$!&!Q$1A(''(;2$!6$A$-<!!! ! 3,1!h$3&A&+(,)!>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>!KKH

! FV>! 4,)820'(,)!>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>!KKJ

! />h>B! %&'#()*+,)! &)-! .$$! P)(5$1'(+<! 78#,,2! ,3! .&?B! KUUI[! c>7>B! "$D+(2$'! &)-!X==&1$2!W&)&*$A$)+B!4,1)$22!P)(5$1'(+<B!KUUT>!!F!?,02-!2(E$!+,!$D=1$''!A<!#$&1+3$2+!+#&)E'!+,! Q1,3$'',1! h,0*! 6$)-2$A&)! 3,1! #('! 8,)+()0$-! *0(-&)8$! &)-! ()'(*#+302! 8,AA$)+'!+#1,0*#,0+!+#$!?1(+()*!=1,8$''>!

Page 2: Speech Regulation: Why an Injunction Should be Permissible Under

HIT PQ*!J6RA*S*,CC*.A*3A*5A*6T3A*.U6KO3C*PYj*VWXXYZ

OA**O&(0)+/7(%)&*

lS)$!,3!+#$!=1$1,*&+(5$'!,3!XA$1(8&)!8(+(\$)'#(=!('!+#$!>!>!>!31$$-,A!+,!'=$&E! 3,,2('#2<! &)-! ?(+#,0+! A,-$1&+(,)>lH! ! "#$! g(1'+! XA$)-A$)+!*0&1&)+$$'!+#$!31$$-,A!+,!'=$&E!+#$!?,1-'!,)$!8#,,'$'>K!!"#('!31$$-,A!('!&!30)-&A$)+&2! 1(*#+! -$$=2<! ()*1&()$-! ()! +#$!XA$1(8&)! 8,)8$=+(,)! ,3! &! 31$$!',8($+<!&)-!('!'0;@$8+!+,!'+1,)*!2$*&2!'&3$*0&1-'>O! !"#('!30)-&A$)+&2!1(*#+B!#,?$5$1B! ('! ),+! &;',20+$! &)-!&! '+&+$!A&<!=0)('#! (+'!&;0'$>J! !c$8&0'$! lr&s!31$$!',8($+<!=1$3$1'!+,!=0)('#!+#$!3$?!?#,!&;0'$!1(*#+'!,3!'=$$8#!"2(-0!+#$<!;1$&E! +#$! 2&?! +#&)! +,! +#1,++2$! +#$A! &)-! &22! ,+#$1'! ;$3,1$#&)-BlM! '+&+$'!31$`0$)+2<!(A=,'$!'0;'$`0$)+!=0)('#A$)+'!()!+#$!3,1A!,3!8(5(2!2(&;(2(+($'!,1!81(A()&2! '&)8+(,)'! 3,1! &;0'$'! ,3! '=$$8#>T! ! "#('! 8,AA,)! 2&?! =1()8(=2$!1$32$8+'! +#$! g(1'+!XA$)-A$)+C'! #$&5<! =1$'0A=+(,)! &*&()'+! +#$! 5&2(-(+<! ,3!=1(,1! 1$'+1&()+'No&)<! @0-(8(&2! ,1-$1! 3,1;(--()*! '=$$8#! ;$3,1$! (+! ,8801'>]Q$1A&)$)+! ()@0)8+(,)'! +#&+! &8+0&22<! 3,1;(-! '=$$8#! &8+(5(+($'! &1$! l82&''(8!$D&A=2$'l!,3!=1(,1!1$'+1&()+'>I!!4,)'$`0$)+2<B!8,01+'!A&<!(''0$!()@0)8+(,)'!()!8$1+&()!8&'$'!3,1!$D+1$A$2<!)&11,?B!2(A(+$-!8&+$*,1($'!,3!'=$$8#>HU

! H>! c&0A*&1+)$1!5>!P)(+$-!7+&+$'B!OKK!P>7>!TTMB!TNOZTNJ!9HIJJ:>!! K>! 6--! P>7>! 4SG7">! XWRGh>! F! 9l4,)*1$''! '#&22! A&E$! ),! 2&?!>!>!>!&;1(-*()*! +#$!31$$-,A!,3!'=$$8#!>!>!>!>l:>!

OA* 6--*7,)&2(!h&'B!4,AA$)+B!6%1-&7%&'*6[--7$*%&*($-*!)0?[1"7-^**5-iC]">%&%&'*($-*U#-*)2*6[-7%2%7*6[--7$*O&=/&7(%4-*5-1%-2*2)0*K%(1-*<OO*R)#(%1-*C&4%0)&>-&(*!)0?*31"%>#B!OJ!/> WX67bX..!.> 6RV>!OKHB!OKH!9KUUU:!9'+1(E()*!-,?)!&''0A=+(,)'!+#&+!,)$!8&)!3,1;(-!8$1+&()!?,1-'! ?(+#,0+! &2',! 10))()*! &! '(*)(3(8&)+! 1('E! ,3! '0==1$''(,)! ,3! (-$&':! 98(+()*! 4,#$)! 5>!4&2(3,1)(&B!JUO!P>7>!HMB!KT!9HINH::>!

JA* 6--*G$&1!5>!W())$',+&B!K]O!P>7>!TINB!NU]!9HIOH:!9l.(;$1+<!,3!'=$$8#!&)-!,3! +#$!=1$''!('!>!>!>!),+!&)!&;',20+$!1(*#+B!&)-!+#$!'+&+$!A&<!=0)('#!(+'!&;0'$>l:>!

MA* 6--!Q1,A,+(,)'B!.+->!5>!4,)1&-B!JKU!P>7>!MJTB!MM]ZMI!9HINM:!9$A=#&'('!&--$-:>!TA* 6--*%+A*&+!MMI!9l"#$!=1$'0A=+(,)!&*&()'+!=1(,1!1$'+1&()+'!('!#$&5($1B!&)-!+#$!-$*1$$!

,3! =1,+$8+(,)! r('s! ;1,&-$1B! +#&)! +#&+! &*&()'+! 2(A(+'! ,)! $D=1$''(,)! (A=,'$-! ;<! 81(A()&2!=$)&2+($'>l:>!

NA* 6--* c&)+&A! c,,E'B! F)8>! 5>! 7022(5&)B! ONK! P>7>! M]B! NU! 9HITO:! 9'+&+()*! +#&+! &)<!'<'+$A!,3!=1(,1!1$'+1&()+'!,3!$D=1$''(,)!;$&1'!&!#$&5<!=1$'0A=+(,)!&*&()'+!(+'!8,)'+(+0+(,)&2!5&2(-(+<:>!! ]>! 6--* X2$D&)-$1! 5>! P)(+$-! 7+&+$'B! MUI! P>7>! MJJB! MMU! 9HIIO:! 9l"#$! +$1A! =1(,1!1$'+1&()+! ('! 0'$-! m+,! -$'81(;$! &-A()('+1&+(5$! &)-! @0-(8(&2! ,1-$1'! 3,1;(--()*!8$1+&()!8,AA0)(8&+(,)'! ?#$)! (''0$-! ()! &-5&)8$! ,3! +#$! +(A$! +#&+! '08#! 8,AA0)(8&+(,)'! &1$! +,!,8801>Cl!9`0,+()*!WR.VF..R!GFWWR6B GFWWR6!SG!g6RRhSW!Sg!7QRR4b!v!J>UOB!JZHJ!9HI]J::>!! I>! 6--* J1-]"&+-0B! ! MUI!P>7>! &+! MMU! 9l"$A=,1&1<! 1$'+1&()()*! ,1-$1'! &)-! =$1A&)$)+!()@0)8+(,)'o!>!>!>!8,01+!,1-$1'!+#&+!&8+0&22<!3,1;(-!'=$$8#!&8+(5(+($'o&1$!82&''(8!$D&A=2$'!,3!=1(,1!1$'+1&()+'>l:>! HU>! 6--!G$&1!5>!W())$',+&B!K]O!P>7>!TINB!NU]!9HIOH:!92('+()*!+#$!2(A(+$-!8&+$*,1($'!,3!'=$$8#!+#&+!&1$!),+!&;',20+$2<!=1,+$8+$-!;<!+#$!-,8+1()$!,3!=1(,1!1$'+1&()+'Y!!'=$$8#!1$2&+()*!+,!)&+(,)&2!'$801(+<!()!+(A$!,3!?&1B!()8(+$A$)+'!+,!5(,2$)8$B!&)-!,;'8$)(+<:>!

Page 3: Speech Regulation: Why an Injunction Should be Permissible Under

6\CC3R*5CcU,JKOT9^**O9.U93KOT9*\5TM,CDJKO3! HIN!

h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

! HH>! 6--*X*0(2&1! 5>! X5('! 6$)+! X! 4&1! 7<'+$AB! F)8>B! I]U! Q>K-! ]JTB! ]M]! 94&2>! HIII:!9=201&2(+<!,=()(,):!9#,2-()*!+#&+!&)!()@0)8+(,)!=1,#(;(+()*!&!=&++$1)!,3!'=$$8#!+#&+!#&-!;$$)!=1$5(,0'2<!3,0)-!0)2&?302!?&'!),+!&)!0)8,)'+(+0+(,)&2!=1(,1!1$'+1&()+!,)!'=$$8#:>!! HK>! 6--*c&2;,&!F'2&)-!V(22>!F))B!F)8>!5>!.$A$)B!HMT!Q>O-!OOIB!OJO!94&2>!KUUN:!9#,2-()*!+#&+! l&)! ()@0)8+(,)! (''0$-! 3,22,?()*!&! +1(&2! +#&+!-$+$1A()$-! +#&+! +#$!-$3$)-&)+!-$3&A$-! +#$!=2&()+(33!+#&+!-,$'!),!A,1$!+#&)!=1,#(;(+!+#$!-$3$)-&)+!31,A!1$=$&+()*!+#$!-$3&A&+(,)B!('!),+!&!=1(,1!1$'+1&()+!&)-!-,$'!),+!,33$)-!+#$!g(1'+!XA$)-A$)+l:>!! HO>! 6-- J'/%1"0B!I]U!Q>K-!&+!]J]!9lrXs!1$A$-(&2! ()@0)8+(,)!=1,#(;(+()*! +#$!8,)+()0$-!0'$!,3!1&8(&2!$=(+#$+'!()!+#$!?,1E=2&8$!-,$'!),+!5(,2&+$!+#$!1(*#+!+,!31$$-,A!,3!'=$$8#!(3!+#$1$!#&'! ;$$)! &! @0-(8(&2! -$+$1A()&+(,)! +#&+! +#$! 0'$! ,3! '08#! $=(+#$+'! ?(22! 8,)+1(;0+$! +,! +#$!8,)+()0&+(,)! ,3! &! #,'+(2$! ,1! &;0'(5$! ?,1E! $)5(1,)A$)+! &)-! +#$1$3,1$! ?(22! 8,)'+(+0+$!$A=2,<A$)+! -('81(A()&+(,)>l:[!M"1@)"B! HMT! Q>O-! &+! OJK! 9#,2-()*! +#&+! l&! =1,=$12<! 2(A(+$-!()@0)8+(,)!=1,#(;(+()*!r+#$s!-$3$)-&)+! 31,A!1$=$&+()*! +,! +#(1-!=$1',)'! '+&+$A$)+'!&;,0+! +#$!r-$3$)-&)+s! +#&+! ?$1$! -$+$1A()$-! &+! +1(&2! +,! ;$! -$3&A&+,1<! ?,02-! ),+! 5(,2&+$! r+#$s!-$3$)-&)+Ç'!1(*#+!+,!31$$!'=$$8#l:>!! HJ>! 6--*J'/%1"0B!I]U!Q>K-!&+!]J]!95&2(-&+()*!'08#!&)!()@0)8+(,):>!! HM>! 6--*M"1@)"B!HMT!Q>O-!!&+!OJK!95&2(-&+()*!'08#!&)!()@0)8+(,):>!! HT>! 6--*M"1@)"B!HMT!Q>O-!&+!KMN!9n$))&1-B!/>B!-(''$)+()*:!9l"#$!()@0)8+(,)!()!+#('!8&'$!'$15$'!),! '(*)(3(8&)+! =0;2(8! ()+$1$'+B! '08#! &'! $2(A()&+()*! ()5(-(,0'! 1&8(&2! -('81(A()&+(,)! ()!$A=2,<A$)+B!=1$5$)+()*!()8(+$A$)+!,3!(AA$-(&+$!5(,2$)8$B!,1!=1,+$8+()*!)&+(,)&2!'$801(+<>l:>!

Page 4: Speech Regulation: Why an Injunction Should be Permissible Under

HI] PQ*!J6RA*S*,CC*.A*3A*5A*6T3A*.U6KO3C*PYj*VWXXYZ

'+&+$A$)+'!(A=0+()*!#,A,'$D0&2(+<!&1$!-$3&A&+,1<!=$1!'$!()!8$1+&()!'+&+$'>HNg()&22<B! Q&1+! FV! &-5,8&+$'! +#$! =,'(+(,)! +#&+! &)! ()@0)8+(,)! '#,02-! ;$! &!=$1A(''(;2$! 1$A$-<! 3,1! -$3&A&+(,)! ,)2<! &3+$1! &! @01<! -$+$1A()&+(,)! ,3!-$3&A&+(,)! 3()-()*! &8+0&2! #&1A! &)-! &3+$1! $D#&0'+(,)! ,3! +#$! 1$A$-<! ,3!-&A&*$'>H]

OOA**K$-*;%0#(*J>-&+>-&(*"&+*6[--7$*5-'/1"(%)&#*

JA**F)7(0%&-*)2*\0%)0*5-#(0"%&(#*

"#$!+$1A!l=1(,1!1$'+1&()+l!('!&!@0-(8(&2!,1!&)!&-A()('+1&+(5$!,1-$1! +#&+!3,1;(-'! 8$1+&()! 8,AA0)(8&+(,)'! ;$3,1$! +#$! 8,AA0)(8&+(,)'! ,8801>HI! ! "#$!-,8+1()$! ,3! =1(,1! 1$'+1&()+'! ,1(*()&+$-! ()! +#$! 8,AA,)! 2&?! ,3! R)*2&)->KUP)-$1! +#$! R)*2('#! '<'+$A! ,3! 8$)',1'#(=! ()! +#$! '(D+$$)+#! &)-! '$5$)+$$)+#8$)+01($'B! +#$! *,5$1)A$)+! 1$*02&+$-! &22! =1()+()*! =1$''$'! &)-! =1()+$1'! ;<!1$`0(1()*!=1(,1!*,5$1)A$)+!,1!8#018#!&==1,5&2!;$3,1$!=0;2(8&+(,)>KH!!"#$'$!2(8$)'()*! 2&?'!?$1$! $5$)+0&22<! &;,2('#$-! &)-! l31$$-,A! ,3! +#$! =1$''! 31,A!2(8$)'()*! 8&A$! +,! &''0A$! +#$! '+&+0'! ,3! &! 8,AA,)! 2&?!,1! )&+01&2! 1(*#+>lKK

X88,1-()*2<B! lr+s#$!$2(A()&+(,)!,3!=1(,1! 1$'+1&()+'!?&'!&! m2$&-()*!=01=,'$C!()!+#$!&-,=+(,)!,3!+#$!g(1'+!XA$)-A$)+>lKO

! HN>! 32A X2;1(*#+!5>!W,1+,)B!OKH!g>!70==>!K->!HOUB!HOI!9h>!W&''>!KUUJ:!9lmh$3&A&+(,)!=$1! '$C! '#,02-!;$! 1$'$15$-! 3,1! '+&+$A$)+'! 2()E()*! &)! ()-(5(-0&2! +,! +#$! 8&+$*,1<!,3! =$1',)'!m-$'$15()*! ,3! ',8(&2! &==1,;&+(,)C! 2(E$! &! m+#($3B! A01-$1$1B! =1,'+(+0+$B! $+8>C! ",! '0**$'+! +#&+!#,A,'$D0&2'!'#,02-!;$!=0+!()+,!+#('!82&''(3(8&+(,)!('!),+#()*!'#,1+!,3!,0+1&*$,0'>l:!98(+&+(,)'!,A(++$-:>!! H]>! 6--*W&-'$)!5>!%,A$)C'!b$&2+#!4$)+$1B!F)8>B!MHK!P>7>!NMOB!NIO!9HIIJ:!978&2(&B!/>B!8,)8011()*! ()! =&1+! &)-!-(''$)+()*! ()! =&1+:! 9l"#$! 1(*#+! +,! 31$$! '=$$8#! '#,02-!),+! 2(*#+2<! ;$!=2&8$-!?(+#()!+#$!8,)+1,2!,3!&!'()*2$!A&)!,1!?,A&)>l:>!! HI>! 6--!G$&1!5>!W())$',+&B!K]O!P>7>!TINB!NU]!9HIOH:!92('+()*!+#$!2(A(+$-!8&+$*,1($'!,3!'=$$8#!+#&+!&1$!),+!&;',20+$2<!=1,+$8+$-!;<!+#$!-,8+1()$!,3!=1(,1!1$'+1&()+':>!! KU>! 6--*X2$D&)-$1!5>!P)(+$-!7+&+$'B!MUI!P>7>! MJJB!MMO!)>K! 9HIIO:! 9l"#$!-,8+1()$!,3!=1(,1! 1$'+1&()+! #&'! (+'! 1,,+'! ()! +#$! HT+#L! &)-! HN+#L8$)+01<! R)*2('#! '<'+$A! ,3! 8$)',1'#(=>!P)-$1! +#&+! '<'+$AB! &22! =1()+()*!=1$''$'! &)-!=1()+$1'!?$1$! 2(8$)'$-!;<! +#$!*,5$1)A$)+B! &)-!),+#()*!8,02-! 2&?3022<!;$!=0;2('#$-!?(+#,0+!+#$!=1(,1!&==1,5&2!,3!&!*,5$1)A$)+!,1!8#018#!8$)',1>l! 98(+()* "bSWX7! RWR67SGB 7d7"RW! Sg! g6RRhSW! Sg! RiQ6R77FSG! MUJ! 96&)-,A!b,0'$!HINH::>!! KH>! 6--* %+A! 9$D=2&()()*! *,5$1)A$)+! 8$)',1'#(=! ()! +#$! '(D+$$)+#! &)-! '$5$)+$$)+#!8$)+01($':>!! KK>! "#,A&'!RA$1',)B!K$-*F)7(0%&-*)2*\0%)0*5-#(0"%&(B!KU!.X%!a 4SG"RWQ> Q6Sc7>TJ]B!TMH!9HIMM:>!! KO>! 4&11,22!5>!Q1$'(-$)+!a!4,AAC1'!,3!Q1()8$''!X))$B!OIO!P>7>!HNMB!H]H!)>M!98(+()*!.,5$22!5>!j1(33()B!OUO!P>7>!JJJB!JMHZMK!9HIO]::>!

Page 5: Speech Regulation: Why an Injunction Should be Permissible Under

6\CC3R*5CcU,JKOT9^**O9.U93KOT9*\5TM,CDJKO3! HII!

F)!&!3&A,0'!=&''&*$B!%(22(&A!c2&8E'+,)$!=1,82&(A$-Y!"#$!2(;$1+<!,3!+#$!=1$''!('! ()-$$-!$''$)+(&2! +,!+#$!)&+01$!,3!&!31$$!'+&+$[!;0+!+#('!8,)'('+'!()!2&<()*!),![0-4%)/#!1$'+1&()+'!0=,)!=0;2(8&+(,)'B!&)-!),+!()!31$$-,A!31,A!8$)'01$!3,1!81(A()&2!A&++$1!?#$)!=0;2('#$->!!R5$1<!31$$! A&)! #&'! &)! 0)-,0;+$-! 1(*#+! +,! 2&<! ?#&+! '$)+(A$)+'! #$! =2$&'$'!;$3,1$!+#$!=0;2(8[! +,! 3,1;(-!+#('B! ('! +,!-$'+1,<!+#$!31$$-,A!,3!+#$!=1$''[!;0+! (3! #$! =0;2('#$'! ?#&+! ('! (A=1,=$1B! A('8#($5,0'! ,1! (22$*&2B! #$! A0'+!+&E$!+#$!8,)'$`0$)8$'!,3!#('!,?)!+$A$1(+<>KJ

b$)8$B! =1(,1! 1$'+1&()+'! &1$! +#$! lA,'+! '$1(,0'! &)-! +#$! 2$&'+! +,2$1&;2$!()31()*$A$)+r's!,)!g(1'+!XA$)-A$)+!1(*#+'>lKM

F)@0)8+(,)'! &8+0&22<! 3,1;(--()*! 30+01$! '=$$8#! &1$! 82&''(8! $D&A=2$'! ,3!=1(,1! 1$'+1&()+'>KT! ! F)@0)8+(,)'! l8&11<! *1$&+$1! 1('E'! ,3! 8$)',1'#(=! &)-!-('81(A()&+,1<!&==2(8&+(,)!+#&)!-,!*$)$1&2!,1-()&)8$'lKN!&)-!+#0'!,0*#+!+,!;$!'0;@$8+$-!+,!*1$&+$1!'&3$*0&1-'>K]!!P>7>!70=1$A$!4,01+!/0'+(8$!78&2(&!#&'!?&1)$-!+#&+!()@0)8+(,)'!&1$!+#$!l=1,-08+!,3!()-(5(-0&2!@0-*$'!1&+#$1!+#&)!,3!2$*('2&+01$'o&)-! ,3+$)! ,3! @0-*$'! ?#,! #&5$! ;$$)! 8#&*1()$-! ;<! =1(,1!-(',;$-($)8$!,3!+#$(1!,1-$1'>!!"#$!1(*#+!+,!31$$!'=$$8#!'#,02-!),+!2(*#+2<!;$!=2&8$-!?(+#()!+#$!8,)+1,2!,3!&!'()*2$!A&)!,1!?,A&)>lKI

V(,2&+(,)!,3!&)! ()@0)8+(,)!1$'02+'! ()!8,)+$A=+!,3!8,01+!=1,8$$-()*'>OUQ0)('#A$)+!3,1! +#$'$!=1,8$$-()*'!('!?(+#()! +#$!-('81$+(,)!,3!+#$!8,01+!&)-!A&<! ()5,25$! #$&5<! 3()$'! &)-! 0=! +,! '(D!A,)+#'! ,3! ()8&18$1&+(,)!?(+#,0+! &!@01<!+1(&2>OH!!"#$!+#1$&+!,3!81(A()&2!,1!8(5(2!'&)8+(,)'!&3+$1!=0;2(8&+(,)!8&)!;$!'&(-! +,! l8#(22l! '=$$8#B! ?#$1$&'! &)! ()@0)8+(,)! l31$$\$'l! (+! &+! 2$&'+! 3,1! +#$!

! KJ>! J1-]"&+-0B!MUI!P>7>!&+!MTNZT]!9`0,+()* %F..FXW!c.X4n7"SGRB!J!4SWWRG"X6FR7fHMHZHMK:>!! KM>! G$;>!Q1$''!X''C)!5>!7+0&1+B!JKN!P>7>!MOIB!MMI!9HINT:>!! KT>! 6--*X2$D&)-$1! 5>! P)(+$-! 7+&+$'B! MUI! P>7>! MJJB! MMU! 9HIIO:! 9),+()*! +#&+! l8,01+!,1-$1'!+#&+!&8+0&22<!3,1;(-!'=$$8#!&8+(5(+($'!&1$!82&''(8!$D&A=2$'!,3!=1(,1!1$'+1&()+'l:>!! KN>! W&-'$)!5>!%,A$)C'!b$&2+#!4$)+$1B!F)8>B!MHK!P>7>!NMOB!NTJ!9HIIJ:>!! K]>! 6--*%+A!&+!NIO!978&2(&B!/>B!8,)8011()*!()!=&1+!&)-!-(''$)+()*!()!=&1+:!9lrXs!1$'+1(8+(,)!0=,)!'=$$8#!(A=,'$-!;<!()@0)8+(,)!9?#$+#$1!),A()&22<!8,)+$)+!;&'$-!,1!),A()&22<!8,)+$)+!)$0+1&2:!('!"(*1-"#(!&'!-$'$15()*!,3!'+1(8+!'810+()<!&'!&!'+&+0+,1<B!8,)+$)+L;&'$-!1$'+1(8+(,)>l:>!! KI>! O+A! OU>! 6--*W&)$''! 5>!W$<$1'B! JHI! P>7>! JJIB! JM]! 9HINM:! 9lQ$1',)'! ?#,! A&E$! =1(5&+$!-$+$1A()&+(,)'!,3!+#$!2&?!&)-!1$30'$!+,!,;$<!&)!,1-$1!*$)$1&22<!1('E!81(A()&2!8,)+$A=+!$5$)!(3!+#$!,1-$1!('!02+(A&+$2<!102$-!()8,11$8+>l:>!! OH>! 6--*4#$33!5>!78#)&8E$);$1*B!O]J!P>7>!ONOB!ONIZ]U!9HITT:!9'+&+()*!+#&+!+#$!3$-$1&2!1(*#+!+,!@01<!+1(&2!&==2(8&;2$!+,!81(A()&2!8,)+$A=+!(3!=0)('#A$)+!()5,25$'!(A=1(',)A$)+!3,1!A,1$! +#&)!'(D!A,)+#':[!40))()*#&A!5>!7+&+$B!OJI!7,>K-!NUKB!NUJ!)>K! 9g2&>!h('+>!4+>!X==>!HINN:!9),+()*!+#&+!(3!+#$!-$3$)-&)+!('!),+!&33,1-$-!+#$!1(*#+!+,!&!+1(&2!;<!@01<B!+#$!A&D(A0A!'$)+$)8$!,3!(A=1(',)A$)+!('!,)$!-&<!2$''!+#&)!'(D!A,)+#':>!

Page 6: Speech Regulation: Why an Injunction Should be Permissible Under

KUU PQ*!J6RA*S*,CC*.A*3A*5A*6T3A*.U6KO3C*PYj*VWXXYZ

+(A$>OK! ! X'! R1?()! 4#$A$1()'E<! #&'! '088()8+2<! '+&+$-B! l5(,2&+(,)'! ,3! &)!()@0)8+(,)B! $5$)! &'! &)! 0)8,)'+(+0+(,)&2! ()@0)8+(,)B! &1$! =0)('#&;2$! ;<!8,)+$A=+B! ?#(2$! 5(,2&+(,)'! ,3! 0)8,)'+(+0+(,)&2! 2&?'! )$5$1! 8&)! ;$!=0)('#$->lOO! ! X88,1-()*2<B! +#('! lA,'+! $D+1&,1-()&1<! 1$A$-<l! A&<! ;$!(A=,'$-!,)2<!?#$1$!+#$!l$5(2! +#&+!?,02-!1$'02+! 31,A!+#$!1$=,1+&*$! ('!;,+#!*1$&+!&)-!8$1+&()!&)-!8&)),+!;$!A(2(+&+$-!;<!2$''!()+10'(5$!A$&'01$'>lOJ

MA**5-'/1"(%)&*)2*T22-&#%4-*6[--7$*

"#$! g(1'+! XA$)-A$)+! 1(*#+! +,! 31$$! '=$$8#! =1,+$8+'! -$1,*&+,1<! &)-!,33$)'(5$!'=$$8#B!$'=$8(&22<!?#$)!'=$$8#!8,)8$1)'!=0;2(8!3(*01$'!,1!=0;2(8!(''0$'>OM!!G,!A&++$1!#,?!+#,1,0*#2<!,33$)'(5$!,1!1$=1$#$)'(;2$!+#$!'=$$8#B!l+#$! 7+&+$! #&'! ),! 1(*#+! +,! 82$&)'$! =0;2(8! -$;&+$! +,! +#$! =,()+! ?#$1$! (+! ('!*1&AA&+(8&22<!=&2&+&;2$!+,!+#$!A,'+!'`0$&A('#!&A,)*!0'>lOT! !"#$!=01=,'$!,3!+#$!g(1'+!XA$)-A$)+!('!+,!l&''01$!0)3$++$1$-!()+$18#&)*$!,3!(-$&'!3,1!+#$!;1()*()*!&;,0+!,3!=,2(+(8&2!&)-!',8(&2!8#&)*$'!-$'(1$-!;<!+#$!=$,=2$>lON!!"#$!P>7>!70=1$A$!4,01+!#&'!$D=2(8(+2<!'+&+$-Y!

G,! ,)$! ?(22! -('&*1$$! +#&+! +#$! 30)-&A$)+&2B! =$1A&)$)+! &)-! ,5$11(-()*!=,2(8<! ,3! =,2(8$! &)-! 8,01+'! '#,02-! ;$! +,! =$1A(+! &)-! $)8,01&*$! 0+A,'+!31$$-,A! ,3! 0++$1&)8$>! ! F+! ('! +#$! 2$*&2! 1(*#+! ,3! &)<!XA$1(8&)! 8(+(\$)! +,!&-5,8&+$! =$&8$302! &-,=+(,)! ,3! 3&'8('A! ,1! 8,AA0)('AB! ',8(&2('A! ,1!8&=(+&2('A>!!b$!A&<!*,!3&1!()!$D=1$''()*!'$)+(A$)+'!?#$+#$1!=1,L'$A(+(8!,1! &)+(L'$A(+(8B! =1,L)$*1,! ,1! &)+(L)$*1,B! =1,L4&+#,2(8! ,1! &)+(L4&+#,2(8>!!b$! ('! 2$*&22<! 31$$! +,! &1*0$! 3,1! ',A$! &)+(LXA$1(8&)! '<'+$A! ,3!*,5$1)A$)+!+,!'0=$1'$-$!;<!8,)'+(+0+(,)&2!A$+#,-'!+#$!,)$!?$!#&5$>!!F+!('!,01!=#(2,',=#<!+#&+!+#$!8,01'$!,3!*,5$1)A$)+!'#,02-!;$!8,)+1,22$-!;<!&! 8,)'$)'0'! ,3! +#$! *,5$1)$->! ! "#('! =1,8$''! ,3! 1$&8#()*! ()+$22(*$)+!

! OK>! 6--*G$;>!Q1$''!X''C)!5>!7+0&1+B!JKN!P>7>!MOIB!MMI! 9HINT:! 9lX!=1(,1! 1$'+1&()+B!;<!8,)+1&'+!&)-!;<!-$3()(+(,)B!#&'!&)!(AA$-(&+$!&)-!(11$5$1'(;2$!'&)8+(,)>!!F3!(+!8&)!;$!'&(-!+#&+!&!+#1$&+!,3!81(A()&2!,1!8(5(2!'&)8+(,)'!&3+$1!=0;2(8&+(,)!m8#(22'C!'=$$8#B!=1(,1!1$'+1&()+!m31$$\$'C!(+!&+!2$&'+!3,1!+#$!+(A$>l!98(+()*!X2$D&)-$1!c(8E$2B!"bR!WS6X.F"d!Sg!4SG7RG"!TH!9HINM:::>!! OO>! R1?()!4#$A$1()'E<B!O&=/&7(%)&#*%&*F-2">"(%)&*3"#-#B!MN!7d6X4P7R!.> 6RV>!HMNB!HTM!9KUUN:>!!R1?()!4#$A$1()'E<!'$15$-!&'!8,0)'$2!+,!X))$!.$A$)B!+#$!-$3$)-&)+!()!M"1@)">! OJ>! 4c7B!F)8>!5>!h&5('B!MHU!P>7>!HOHMB!HOHN!9HIIJ:>!! OM>! 6--* 4&1$<! 5>! c1,?)B! JJN! P>7>! JMMB! JTN! 9HI]U:! 9l"#$! A&()+$)&)8$! ,3! +#$!,==,1+0)(+<!3,1!31$$!=,2(+(8&2!-('80''(,)!+,!+#$!$)-!+#&+!*,5$1)A$)+!A&<!;$!1$'=,)'(5$!+,!+#$!?(22! ,3! +#$! =$,=2$! &)-! +#&+! 8#&)*$'! A&<! ;$! ,;+&()$-! ;<! 2&?302! A$&)'B! &)! ,==,1+0)(+<!$''$)+(&2! +,! +#$! '$801(+<! ,3! +#$! 6$=0;2(8B! ('! &! 30)-&A$)+&2! =1()8(=2$! ,3! ,01! 8,)'+(+0+(,)&2!'<'+$A>l!98(+()*!7+1,A;$1*!5>!4&2(3,1)(&B!K]O!P>7>!OMIB!OTI!9HIOH:::>!! OT>! 4,#$)!5>!4&2(3,1)(&B!JUO!P>7>!HMB!KM!9HINH:!9`0,+()*!6,+#!5>!P)(+$-!7+&+$'B!OMJ!P>7>!JNTB!J]J!9HIMN::>!! ON>! G$?!d,1E!"(A$'!4,>!5>!7022(5&)B!ONT!P>7>!KMJB!KTI!9HITJ:>!

Page 7: Speech Regulation: Why an Injunction Should be Permissible Under

6\CC3R*5CcU,JKOT9^**O9.U93KOT9*\5TM,CDJKO3! KUH!

=,=02&1!-$8('(,)'!1$`0(1$'!31$$!-('80''(,)>!!b$)8$!?$!'#,02-!+,2$1&+$!),!2&?!,1!80'+,A!,3!8$)',1'#(=!,1!'0==1$''(,)>O]

X2+#,0*#!,33$)'(5$!'=$$8#!('!*$)$1&22<!=1,+$8+$-B!+#$!*,5$1)A$)+!A&<!(A=,'$!1$*02&+(,)'!;&'$-!0=,)!+#$!8#&1&8+$1!,3!+#$!3,10A!?#$1$!+#$!'=$$8#!('!$D=1$''$->OI!!"#$!'+&+$C'!=,?$1!+,!1$*02&+$!'=$$8#!('!$'=$8(&22<!2(A(+$-!()!=0;2(8! 3,10A'B!&1$&'! +1&-(+(,)&22<!-$5,+$-! +,!&''$A;2<!&)-!-$;&+$! '08#!&'!'+1$$+'!&)-!=&1E'>JU! !X!8,01+!A&<! (A=,'$!1$&',)&;2$B!8,)+$)+L)$0+1&2! +(A$B!=2&8$B! ,1! A&))$1! 1$'+1(8+(,)'! 3,1! '=$$8#! $D=1$''$-! ()! &! =0;2(8! 3,10A>JH

4,)+$)+L)$0+1&2!1$*02&+(,)'!A0'+!;$!)&11,?2<!+&(2,1$-!+,!'$15$!&!'(*)(3(8&)+!*,5$1)A$)+! ()+$1$'+B! &)-! A0'+! 2$&5$! ,=$)! ,+#$1B! &2+$1)&+(5$! 8#&))$2'! ,3!8,AA0)(8&+(,)>JK! ! 4,)+$)+L;&'$-! 1$*02&+(,)'o1$'+1(8+(,)'! ;&'$-! ,)! +#$!'0;@$8+! A&++$1! ,3! +#$! '=$$8#oA0'+! ;$! l)$8$''&1<! +,! '$15$! &! 8,A=$22()*!'+&+$! ()+$1$'+! &)-!)&11,?2<!-1&?)! +,! &8#($5$! +#&+! $)->lJO! ! F)! &!),)L=0;2(8!3,10AB! &! '+&+$!A&<! (A=,'$! 1$&',)&;2$! 1$'+1(8+(,)'! 0)2$''! +#$! 1$'+1(8+(,)! ('!5($?=,()+L;&'$->JJ

"#$! P>7>! 70=1$A$! 4,01+! #&'! '+&+$-! +#&+! =1(,1! 1$'+1&()+'! A&<! ;$!=$1A(++$-! 3,1! '=$$8#! 8,)'+(+0+()*! &! +#1$&+! +,! )&+(,)&2! '$801(+<B! ,;'8$)(+<B!&)-! ()8(+$A$)+'! +,! 5(,2$)8$>JM! ! F)! +#$! 8,)+$D+! ,3! #&+$! '=$$8#! +&1*$+$-! &+!A(),1(+($'B! &! 8,01+! A&<! $)@,()! '08#! '=$$8#! ()8(+()*! (AA()$)+! &8+'! ,3!5(,2$)8$>JT!!X!8,01+!A&<!=1,#(;(+!'=$$8#!l-(1$8+$-!+,!()8(+()*!,1!=1,-08()*!

! O]>! "$1A()($22,!5>!4(+<!,3!4#(8&*,B!OON!P>7>!HB!OK!9HIJI:>!! OI>! 6--*Q$11<!R-08>!X''C)!5>!Q$11<!.,8&2!R-08&+,1'C!X''C)B! JTU!P>7>! ONB!JJ! 9HI]O:!9l"#$!$D('+$)8$!,3!&!1(*#+!,3!&88$''!+,!=0;2(8!=1,=$1+<!&)-!+#$!'+&)-&1-!;<!?#(8#!2(A(+&+(,)'!0=,)! '08#! &! 1(*#+!A0'+! ;$! $5&20&+$-! -(33$1! -$=$)-()*! ,)! +#$! 8#&1&8+$1! ,3! +#$! =1,=$1+<! &+!(''0$>l:>!! JU>! 6-- %+A &+!JM!9'+&+()*!+#&+!'+1$$+'!&)-!=&1E'!l#&5$!(AA$A,1(&22<!;$$)!#$2-!()!+10'+!3,1! +#$! 0'$! ,3! +#$! =0;2(8!>!>!>!3,1! =01=,'$'! ,3! &''$A;2<B! 8,AA0)(8&+()*! +#,0*#+'! ;$+?$$)!8(+(\$)'B! &)-! -('80''()*! =0;2(8! `0$'+(,)'l!&)-! +#&+! +#$! *,5$1)A$)+! A&<! ),+! =1,#(;(+! &22!8,AA0)(8&+(5$!&8+(5(+<!()!+#$'$!`0()+$''$)+(&2!=0;2(8!3,10A'!98(+()*!b&*0$ 5> 4FSB!OUN!P>7>!JITB!MHM!9HIOI:::>!! JH>! 6--*%+A*9l"#$!7+&+$!A&<!>!>!>!$)3,18$!1$*02&+(,)'!,3!+#$!+(A$B!=2&8$B!&)-!A&))$1!,3!$D=1$''(,)!?#(8#!&1$!8,)+$)+L)$0+1&2!>!>!>!>l:A! JK>! 6--*%+A*9'+&+()*!+#&+!8,)+$)+L)$0+1&2!+(A$B!=2&8$B!&)-!A&))$1!1$*02&+(,)'!,3!'=$$8#!A0'+!;$!l)&11,?2<!+&(2,1$-!+,!'$15$!&!'(*)(3(8&)+!*,5$1)A$)+!()+$1$'+B!&)-!2$&5$!,=$)!&A=2$!&2+$1)&+(5$!8#&))$2'!,3!8,AA0)(8&+(,)l:>!! JO>! O+A! JJ>! 32A* %+A! &+! JI! 9'+&+()*! +#&+! (3! &! 1$'+1(8+(,)! -('8,01&*$'! ,)$! 5($?=,()+! ?#(2$!&-5&)8()*!&),+#$1B!(+!'#,02-!;$!'0;@$8+!+,!'+1(8+!'810+()<!1$*&1-2$''!,3!?#$+#$1!+#$!3,10A!('!),)L=0;2(8:>!! JM>! 6--*G$&1!5>!W())$',+&B!K]O!P>7>!TINB!NHT!9HIOH:!9$D=2&()()*!+#&+!=1(,1!1$'+1&()+'!#&5$!;$$)!&22,?$-!()!+#$!=&'+!+,!=1$5$)+!0++$1&)8$'!?#(8#!A(*#+!#()-$1!&!?&1!$33,1+B!()8(+$!&!1(,+!,1!&),+#$1!+<=$!,3!5(,2$)8$B!,1!,33$)-!+#$!=0;2(8!-0$!+,!+#$(1!,;'8$)(+<:>!! JT>! 6--*%+A*9l"#$!8,)'+(+0+(,)&2!*0&1&)+<!,3!31$$!'=$$8#!-,$'!),+!=1,+$8+!&!A&)!31,A!&)!

Page 8: Speech Regulation: Why an Injunction Should be Permissible Under

KUK PQ*!J6RA*S*,CC*.A*3A*5A*6T3A*.U6KO3C*PYj*VWXXYZ

(AA()$)+! 2&?2$''! &8+(,)! &)-! ('! 2(E$2<! +,! ()8(+$! ,1! =1,-08$! '08#! &8+(,)>lJN"#('!+$'+!('!&!'+1(8+!'+&)-&1-!&)-!-(33(802+!+,!A$$+[!()!)$&12<!$5$1<!8&'$!?#$1$!(+! #&'! ;$$)! &==2($-B! +#$! '=$$8#! #&'! ;$$)! =1,+$8+$->J]! ! X! 8,01+! A&<! &2',!$)@,()! l3(*#+()*! ?,1-'Bl! =$1',)&22<! &;0'(5$! $=(+#$+'! 2(E$2<! +,! =1,5,E$! &!5(,2$)+! 1$&8+(,)! ?#$)! -(1$8+$-! &+! +#$! ,1-()&1<! 8(+(\$)>JI! ! "#$! 4&2(3,1)(&!70=1$A$! 4,01+! &--$-! +?,! )$?! $D8$=+(,)'! 0)-$1! ?#(8#! '=$$8#! A&<!=,+$)+(&22<! ;$! $)@,()$-Y! ! 9H:!1&8(&2! $=(+#$+'! &3+$1! &! @0-(8(&2! -$+$1A()&+(,)!+#&+!'08#!$=(+#$+'!&A,0)+!+,!?,1E=2&8$!-('81(A()&+(,)MU!&)-!9K:!-$3&A&+,1<!'=$$8#!&3+$1!&!@0-(8(&2!-$+$1A()&+(,)!3()-()*!+#$!'=$$8#!+,!;$!-$3&A&+,1<>MH

OOOA**O&=/&7(%4-*5->-+G*%&*K:)*9-:*3)&(-](#*

JA**C&=)%&%&'*6[--7$*U&+-0*!)0?[1"7-*F%#70%>%&"(%)&^**X*0(2&1!5>!X5('!6$)+!X!4&1!7<'+$AB!F)8>

%,1E=2&8$! -('81(A()&+(,)! 82&(A'! &1$! ,)! +#$! 1('$>! ! F)! KUUNB! +#$! P>7>!R`0&2!RA=2,<A$)+!S==,1+0)(+<!4,AA(''(,)! 1$8$(5$-! +#$!#(*#$'+!5,20A$!,3! ?,1E=2&8$! -('81(A()&+(,)! 8,A=2&()+'! 3(2$-! ()! +#$! =&'+! 3(5$! <$&1'>MK! ! F+!1$8$(5$-! ]KBNIK! 8,A=2&()+'! 31,A! =1(5&+$! '$8+,1! ?,1E$1'! ()! +#$! P)(+$-!7+&+$'B!1$'02+()*!()!&!)()$!=$18$)+!()81$&'$!31,A!+#$!)0A;$1!,3!8,A=2&()+'!

()@0)8+(,)!&*&()'+!0++$1()*!?,1-'!+#&+!A&<!#&5$!&22!+#$!$33$8+!,3!3,18$>l:>!! JN>! c1&)-$);01*!5>!S#(,B!OIM!P>7>!JJJB!JJN!9HITI:>!! J]>! 6--* 6,;$1+! g(1$'+$1! a! n$)-&22! /,)$'B! 3"(7$%&N* ($-* R-"(* )2* ($-* M-"(^* * ;%0#(*J>-&+>-&(* J&"1G#%#* )2*D/#%7* 31"%>-+* ()* O&7%(-* <%)1-&(* M-$"4%)0B! KU! .Sd> .>X> RG"> .>6RV>!HB!HH!9KUUU:! 9),+()*! +#&+! 31,A!HION! +,!HIMHB! +#$!70=1$A$!4,01+!0'$-! +#$!l82$&1!&)-!=1$'$)+!-&)*$1!+$'+l!,)2<!+#1$$!+(A$'!+,!1$'+1(8+!'=$$8#B!&)-!+#&+!+#$!4,01+!#&'!)$5$1!()5,E$-!+#$!M0"&+-&@/0'! 3,1A02&+(,)! +,! 1$'+1(8+! '=$$8#! 98(+()*!",A!b$)+,33B!G,+$B!6[--7$8*R"0>*"&+*6-12ic)4-0&>-&(^* *U&+-0#("&+%&'*($-*J>@%(*)2*($-*31-"0*"&+*\0-#-&(*F"&'-0*K-#(B!IH!4S.PW> .> 6RV>!HJMOB!HJMN!9HIIH:::>!! JI>! 6--*4,#$)!5>!4&2(3,1)(&B!JUO!P>7>!HMB!KU!9HINH:!9l7+&+$'!&1$!31$$!+,!;&)!+#$!'(A=2$!0'$B!?(+#,0+! &! -$A,)'+1&+(,)! ,3! &--(+(,)&2! @0'+(3<()*! 8(180A'+&)8$'B! ,3! ',L8&22$-! m3(*#+()*!?,1-'BC!+#,'$!=$1',)&22<!&;0'(5$!$=(+#$+'!?#(8#B!?#$)!&--1$''$-!+,!+#$!,1-()&1<!8(+(\$)B!&1$B!&'! &!A&++$1! ,3! 8,AA,)! E),?2$-*$B! ()#$1$)+2<! 2(E$2<! +,! =1,5,E$! 5(,2$)+! 1$&8+(,)>l! 98(+()*!4#&=2()'E<!5>!G$?!b&A='#(1$B!OHM!P>7>!MT]!9HIJK:::>!! MU>! 6--*X*0(2&1!5>!X5('!6$)+!&!4&1!7<'>B!F)8>B!I]U!Q>K-!]JTB!]J]!94&2>!HIII:!9=201&2(+<!,=()(,):!95&2(-&+()*!'08#!&)!()@0)8+(,):>!! MH>! 6--* c&2;,&! F'2&)-! V(22>! F))B! F)8>! 5>! .$A$)B! HMT! Q>O-! OOIB! OJK! 94&2>! KUUN:!90=#,2-()*!&)!()@0)8+(,)!1$'+1(8+()*!'=$$8#!=1$5(,0'2<!-$+$1A()$-!+,!;$!0)2&?302:>! MK>! 6--! /&8`0$2()$!W8W&)0'B!F%#70%>%&"(%)&* %&* ($-*!)0?[1"7-B!WSG"R6Rd!4SPG"d!bR6X.hB!W&1>!KHB!KUU]!9lF+!('!+#$!#(*#$'+!5,20A$!,3!8,A=2&()+'!1$8$(5$-!;<!+#$!8,AA(''(,)!()!3(5$!<$&1'B!&)-!+#$!2&1*$'+!()81$&'$!'()8$!+#$!$&12<!HIIU'>l:>!

Page 9: Speech Regulation: Why an Injunction Should be Permissible Under

6\CC3R*5CcU,JKOT9^**O9.U93KOT9*\5TM,CDJKO3! KUO!

()!KUUT>MO!!"#$!A,'+!31$`0$)+!;&'('!3,1!+#$!&22$*$-!-('81(A()&+(,)!()5,25$-!1&8$B!1$+&2(&+(,)B!&)-!*$)-$1>MJ!4,)+()0()*!+#$!0=?&1-!+1$)-B!3,1!3('8&2!<$&1!KUU]B!&22!RRS4!8,A=2&()+'!?$1$!0=!;<!HM!=$18$)+!,5$1!KUUN>MM

4&2(3,1)(&!&)-!,+#$1!'+&+$'C!'+&+0+$'!A&E$!(+!0)2&?302!3,1!&)!$A=2,<$1!+,!-('81(A()&+$!&*&()'+! &)<! ()-(5(-0&2!?(+#! 1$'=$8+! +,! +#$(1! $A=2,<A$)+>MT

P)-$1!+#$!g&(1!RA=2,<A$)+!b,0'()*!X8+!9gRbX:B!4&2(3,1)(&!#&'!&!-0+<!+,!l=1,+$8+! &)-! '&3$*0&1-! +#$! 1(*#+! &)-! ,==,1+0)(+<! ,3! &22! =$1',)'! +,! '$$EB!,;+&()! &)-! #,2-! $A=2,<A$)+! ?(+#,0+! -('81(A()&+(,)l! ,)! &88,0)+! ,3! 1&8$B!8,2,1B!)&+(,)&2!,1(*()B!'$DB!,1!'$D0&2!,1($)+&+(,)>MN!!"#$!$D=1$''!=01=,'$!,3!+#$!gRbX!('!+,!$2(A()&+$!-('81(A()&+,1<!?,1E=2&8$!=1&8+(8$'!;<!=1,5(-()*!$33$8+(5$!1$A$-($'>M]! !X88,1-()*2<B!0)-$1!+#$!gRbXB!8,01+'!&1$!&0+#,1(\$-!+,!1$-1$''!=&'+!$A=2,<A$)+!-('81(A()&+(,)!&'!?$22!&'!=1$5$)+!&!1$8011$)8$!,3!'08#!A('8,)-08+>MI!!F)!()+$1=1$+()*!+#$!gRbXB!&!8,01+!A&<!8,)'(-$1!,+#$1!$A=2,<A$)+!-('81(A()&+(,)!8&'$'!&1('()*!0)-$1!"(+2$!VFF!,3!+#$!4(5(2!6(*#+'!X8+! ,3! HITJBTU! +#$! 3$-$1&2! 8,0)+$1=&1+! +,! +#$! gRbX>TH! ! 4,)'$`0$)+2<B!

! MO>! 6--*%+A*9lF)!KUUNB!(+!1$8$(5$-!]KBNIK!8,A=2&()+'!31,A!=1(5&+$!'$8+,1!?,1E$1'!()!+#$!P)(+$-!7+&+$'B!0=!31,A!NMBNT]!()!KUUTB!&!I!=$18$)+!()81$&'$>l:>!! MJ>! 6--* %+A* 9l6&8$B! 1$+&2(&+(,)! &)-! *$)-$1!?$1$! +#$!A,'+! 31$`0$)+2<! &22$*$-! ;&'$'! ,3!-('81(A()&+(,)!>!>!>!>l:>!! MM>! P>7> RkPX.! SQQS6"PGF"d! RWQ.SdWRG"! 4SWWF77FSGB 4bX6jR! 7"X"F7"F47! gdHIIN "b6SPjb! gd KUUIB! #++=Yee$$,8>*,5e$$,8e'+&+('+(8'e$)3,18$A$)+e8#&1*$'>83A! 92&'+!5('(+$-!/&)>!K]B!KUHU:!,)!3(2$!?(+#!%&'#()*+,)!&)-!.$$!/,01)&2!,3!4(5(2!6(*#+'!&)-!7,8(&2!/0'+(8$:>!! MT>! 6--8*-A'AB 4X.> jSVC" 4ShR!v!HKIJU9&:!9%$'+!KUUM:!9=1,#(;(+()*!-('81(A()&+(,)!()!$A=2,<A$)+:>!! MN>! 6-- %+>! v!HKIKU! 9lrFs+! ('! )$8$''&1<! +,! =1,+$8+! &)-! '&3$*0&1-! +#$! 1(*#+! &)-!,==,1+0)(+<!,3!&22!=$1',)'! +,! '$$EB!,;+&()B!&)-!#,2-!$A=2,<A$)+!?(+#,0+!-('81(A()&+(,)!,1!&;1(-*A$)+! ,)! &88,0)+! ,3! 1&8$B! 1$2(*(,0'! 81$$-B! 8,2,1B! )&+(,)&2! ,1(*()B! &)8$'+1<B! =#<'(8&2!-('&;(2(+<B! A$)+&2! -('&;(2(+<B! A$-(8&2! 8,)-(+(,)B! A&1(+&2! '+&+0'B! '$DB! &*$B! ,1! '$D0&2!,1($)+&+(,)>l:>!! M]>! 6--*X*0(2&1!5>!X5('!6$)+!X!4&1!7<'>B!F)8>B!I]U!Q>K-!]JTB!]MU!94&2>!HIII:!9=201&2(+<!,=()(,):! 9l"#$! $D=1$''! =01=,'$! ,3! +#$! gRbX! ('! +,! =1,5(-$! $33$8+(5$! 1$A$-($'! ?#(8#!?(22!$2(A()&+$!'08#!-('81(A()&+,1<!=1&8+(8$'>l:!9()+$1)&2!`0,+&+(,)!A&1E'!,A(++$-:>!! MI>! 6--* %+A! &+! ]MK! 9$D=2&()()*! +#&+! (3! +#$! gRbX! 3()-'! &)! $A=2,<$1! $)*&*$-! ()! &)!0)2&?302!=1&8+(8$B!(+!A&<!,1-$1!+#$!$A=2,<$1!+,!8$&'$!&)-!-$'('+!31,A!+#$!0)2&?302!=1&8+(8$!&)-!301+#$1!,1-$1!&33(1A&+(5$!,1!=1,'=$8+(5$!1$2($3!+,!=1$5$)+!+#$!1$8011$)8$!,3!+#$!0)2&?302!=1&8+(8$:>!! TU>! 6--* JK! P>7>4>! v!KUUU$LK9&:! 9HIIJ:! 9A&E()*! (+! 0)2&?302! 3,1! &)! $A=2,<$1! +,!-('81(A()&+$!&*&()'+!&)<!()-(5(-0&2!?(+#!1$'=$8+!+,!+$1A'!,3!$A=2,<A$)+!,)!+#$!;&'('!,3!1&8$B!8,2,1B! 1$2(*(,)B! '$DB! ,1! )&+(,)&2! ,1(*():>! ! 4,)*1$''! ,1(*()&22<! $)&8+$-! "(+2$! VFF! +,! &22,?!$A=2,<$$'! +,! '$$E! ()@0)8+(5$! 1$2($3! +,! 1$A$-<! =&'+! &)-! +,! =1$5$)+! 30+01$! ?,1E=2&8$!-('81(A()&+(,)>! !6-- %+>! v!KUUU$LM! 9),+()*! &! 8,01+!A&<! *1&)+! &)<! $`0(+&;2$! 1$2($3! (+! -$$A'!&==1,=1(&+$! +,!$2(A()&+$!?,1E=2&8$!-('81(A()&+(,):>! !4,)*1$''! 2&+$1!$D=&)-$-! +#$! 1$A$-($'!&5&(2&;2$!0)-$1!"(+2$!VFF!;<!&0+#,1(\()*!8,01+'!+,!&?&1-!-&A&*$'!()!&)!$33,1+!+,!8,A=$)'&+$!()@01<!+,!?,1E$1'>!!6--*"#$!4(5(2!6(*#+'!X8+!,3!HIIHv!KHB!JK!P>7>4>!v!KUUU$LM!9HIIJ:>!

Page 10: Speech Regulation: Why an Injunction Should be Permissible Under

KUJ PQ*!J6RA*S*,CC*.A*3A*5A*6T3A*.U6KO3C*PYj*VWXXYZ

4&2(3,1)(&!8,01+'!#&5$!&-,=+$-! +#$!'&A$!'+&)-&1-! ()!$5&20&+()*!?,1E=2&8$!-('81(A()&+(,)!82&(A'!0)-$1!+#$!gRbX>TK

F)!J'/%1"0* 4A* J4%#* 5-&(* J* 3"0* 6G#(->8* O&7AB! +#$! 4&2(3,1)(&! 70=1$A$!4,01+!#$2-!+#&+!&)!()@0)8+(,)!=1,#(;(+()*!+#$!8,)+()0$-!0'$!,3!1&8(&2!$=(+#$+'!-(1$8+$-!&+!$A=2,<$$'!()!+#$!?,1E=2&8$!-(-!),+!5(,2&+$!+#$!g(1'+!XA$)-A$)+!&3+$1!&!@0-(8(&2!&-@0-(8&+(,)!3()-()*!0'$!,3!'08#!$=(+#$+'!?,02-!8,)+1(;0+$!+,!$A=2,<A$)+! -('81(A()&+(,)! ()! 5(,2&+(,)! ,3! '+&+$! &)-! 3$-$1&2! '+&+0+$'>TOQ2&()+(33'B! .&+(),! -1(5$1'! ,3! X5('! 6$)+! X! 4&1B! 3(2$-! '0(+! &*&()'+! +#$(1!$A=2,<$1B!X5('B!&)-!+$)!()-(5(-0&2'!&22$*()*!$A=2,<A$)+!-('81(A()&+(,)!()!5(,2&+(,)! ,3! +#$! gRbX! &)-! ,+#$1! 8&0'$'! ,3! &8+(,)'>TJ! ! "#$<! 1$`0$'+$-! &)!()@0)8+(,)!&*&()'+! +#$(1!A&)&*$1B!.&?1$)8$B!=1,#(;(+()*!5$1;&2!#&1&''A$)+!&)-! &)! ()@0)8+(,)! &*&()'+! X5('! =1,#(;(+()*! +#$! &22,?&)8$! ,3! '08#!#&1&''A$)+>TM! ! "#$! 8,A=2&()+! &22$*$-! .&?1$)8$! l5$1;&22<! #&1&''$-!r=2&()+(33's! 8,)'+&)+2<>! ! b$! 1,0+()$2<! 8&22$-! )&1G! +#$! .&+(),! -1(5$1'!mA,+#$1308E$1'C! &)-! ,+#$1! -$1,*&+,1<! )&A$'B! &)-! 8,)+()0&22<! -$A$&)$-!+#$A!,)!+#$!;&'('!,3!+#$(1!1&8$B!)&+(,)&2!,1(*()!&)-!2&8E!,3!R)*2('#!2&)*0&*$!'E(22'>lTT

X!@01<!5$1-(8+! 3,0)-! +#$!-$3$)-&)+'C!8,)-08+!#&-!5(,2&+$-! +#$!gRbX!&)-! &?&1-$-! =2&()+(33'! A,)$<! -&A&*$'>TN! ! "#$! +1(&2! 8,01+! (''0$-! &)!()@0)8+(,)!=1,#(;(+()*!.&?1$)8$!31,A!0'()*!l&)<!-$1,*&+,1<!1&8(&2!,1!$+#)(8!$=(+#$+'! -(1$8+$-! &+B! ,1! -$'81(=+(5$! ,3B!b('=&)(8e.&+(),! $A=2,<$$'! ,3!X5('!6$)+!X!4&1!7<'+$AB!F)8>!&)-!>!>!>!&)<!0)()5(+$-!()+$)+(,)&2!+,08#()*!,3!'&(-!b('=&)(8e!.&+(),!$A=2,<$$'B!&'!2,)*!&'!#$!('!$A=2,<$-!;<!X5('!6$)+!X!4&1!

! TH>! 6--* J'/%1"0B! I]U! Q>K-! &+! ]MH! 9=201&2(+<! ,=()(,):! 9lV$1;&2! #&1&''A$)+! ()! +#$!?,1E=2&8$! &2',! A&<! 8,)'+(+0+$! $A=2,<A$)+! -('81(A()&+(,)! 0)-$1! "(+2$! VFF! ,3! +#$! 4(5(2!6(*#+'!X8+!,3!HITJB!+#$!3$-$1&2!8,0)+$1=&1+!,3!+#$!gRbX>l:!98(+&+(,)'!,A(++$-:>!! TK>! 6--* %+A! 98,)820-()*! +#&+! "(+2$! VFF! 8&'$'! A&<! ;$! 8,)'(-$1$-! ()! ()+$1=1$+()*! +#$!gRbX! 98(+()*! c$<-&! 5>! 4(+<! ,3! .,'! X)*$2$'B! NT! 4&2>! 6=+1>! K-! MJNB! MMU! 94&2>! 4+>! X==>!HII]:::>!! TO>! 6--*%+A!&+!]J]!95&2(-&+()*!'08#!&)!()@0)8+(,):>!! TJ>! 6--* %+A! &+! ]JI 9'+&+()*! +#&+! '$5$)+$$)! .&+(),! $A=2,<$$'! ,3! X5('! 6$)+! X! 4&1!7<'+$AB! F)8>! '0$-!X5('! &)-! +$)! )&A$-! ()-(5(-0&2'! &22$*()*! $A=2,<A$)+! -('81(A()&+(,)! ()!5(,2&+(,)!,3!+#$!gRbXB!?1,)*302!-('8#&1*$!()!5(,2&+(,)!,3!=0;2(8!=,2(8<B!&'!?$22!&'!)$*2(*$)+!&)-!()+$)+(,)&2!()32(8+(,)!,3!$A,+(,)&2!-('+1$'':>!! TM>! 6--* %+A! &+! ]JI! 9),+()*! +#&+! +#$! 2,?$1! 8,01+! (''0$-! &)! ()@0)8+(,)! =1,#(;(+()*! +#$!A&)&*$1! 31,A! 0'()*! -$1,*&+,1<! '=$$8#! -$'81(=+(5$! ,3! b('=&)(8! ,1! .&+(),! $A=2,<$$'! &)-!$)@,()()*!X5('!31,A!&22,?()*!+#$!A&)&*$1!+,!8,)+()0$!0'()*!'08#!2&)*0&*$:>!! TT>! O+A! TN>! O+A! &+! ]J]! 9),+()*! +#&+! +#$! 2,?$1! 8,01+! &?&1-$-! -&A&*$'! &*&()'+! X5('! ()! +#$!&A,0)+! ,3! _HMBUUU! $&8#! +,!b$1)&)-$\B!.&\,B!6&A(1$\B!6$<$'B! &)-!7$11&),B! &)-! -&A&*$'!&*&()'+!X5('!&)-!.&?1$)8$!@,()+2<!&)-!'$5$1&22<!()!+#$!&A,0)+!,3!_!KMBUUU!$&8#!+,!W,@(8&B!Q$1&\&B!&)-!6$8(),':>!

Page 11: Speech Regulation: Why an Injunction Should be Permissible Under

6\CC3R*5CcU,JKOT9^**O9.U93KOT9*\5TM,CDJKO3! KUM!

7<'+$AB!F)8>!()!4&2(3,1)(&>lT]!!"#$!4&2(3,1)(&!4,01+!,3!X==$&2!-(1$8+$-!+#$!+1(&2!8,01+!+,!1$-1&3+!+#$!()@0)8+(,)!+,!2(A(+!(+'!'8,=$!+,!+#$!?,1E=2&8$>TI!!F+!&2',!,1-$1$-!+#$!2,?$1!8,01+!+,!()820-$!()!+#$!()@0)8+(,)!&!2('+!,3!-$1,*&+,1<!1&8(&2! ,1! $+#)(8! $=(+#$+'! +#&+! ?$1$! &8+0&22<! 0'$-! ()! +#$! ?,1E=2&8$! ;<! +#$!-$3$)-&)+'>NU! ! h$3$)-&)+'! &==$&2$-B! &1*0()*! +#&+! +#$! ()@0)8+(,)! ?&'! &)!()5&2(-!=1(,1!1$'+1&()+!5(,2&+()*!+#$(1!1(*#+!+,!31$$!'=$$8#>NH

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l'?$=+! 0=!()8(-$)+&22<!?(+#()!+#$!1$&8#!,3!&!'+&+0+$!-(1$8+$-!&+!8,)-08+!1&+#$1!+#&)!&+!'=$$8#!&)-!+#0'!&1$!),+!8,)'+(+0+(,)&22<!=1,+$8+$->lNM!!"#$'$!8&'$'!'+&)-!3,1!+#$!&''$1+(,)!+#&+!+#$!g(1'+!XA$)-A$)+!=$1A(+'!(A=,'(+(,)!,3!8(5(2!2(&;(2(+($'!3,1!'=$$8#!+#&+!81$&+$'!&!#,'+(2$!?,1E!$)5(1,)A$)+>NT

"#$! 4&2(3,1)(&! 70=1$A$! 4,01+! &2',! $'+&;2('#$-! +#&+! +#$! g(1'+!XA$)-A$)+!=$1A(+'!+#$!(''0&)8$!,3!&)!()@0)8+(,)!+,!=1,#(;(+!-('81(A()&+,1<!8,)-08+>NN!!/0'+!&'!(+!('!82$&1!+#&+!l+#$!g(1'+!XA$)-A$)+!-,$'!),+!=1,+$8+!&)!()-(5(-0&2C'!1(*#+!+,!8,AA(+!+1$&',)!>!>!>!+#1,0*#!+#$!0'$!,3!+#$!'=,E$)!?,1-B!

! T]>! O+A!&+!]MU>!! TI>! O+A! NU>! 6--* %+A* 9,1-$1()*! +#$! 2,?$1! 8,01+! +,! =1,5(-$! l&)! $D$A=2&1<! 2('+! ,3! =1,#(;(+$-!-$1,*&+,1<! 1&8(&2! ,1! $+#)(8! $=(+#$+'B! '=$8(3<()*! $=(+#$+'! '08#! &'! +#,'$! &8+0&22<! 0'$-! ()! +#$!?,1E=2&8$!;<!.&?1$)8$l!()!+#$!()@0)8+(,):>!! NH>! O+A*&+!]J]>!! NK>! O+A!&+!]MK>!! NO>! 6--*%+A!&+!]MJ!9'+&+()*!+#&+!+#$!'+&+$!#&'!&!8,A=$22()*!()+$1$'+!()!=1$5$)+()*!'=,E$)!?,1-'B!()!8,)@0)8+(,)!?(+#!8,)-08+B!31,A!8&0'()*!$A=2,<A$)+!-('81(A()&+(,):>!!! NJ>! 6-- %+A*91$&',)()*!+#&+!+#$!#,2-()*'!()!+?,!"(+2$!VFF!8&'$'ob&11('!5>!g,1E2(3+!7<'>B!F)8>B!MHU!P>7>!HNB!KK!9HIIO:!&)-!W$1(+,1!7&5()*'!c&)E!5>!V()',)B!JNN!P>7>!MNB!NO!9HI]T:o&1$! ()8,)'('+$)+! ?(+#! &)<! '0**$'+(,)! +#&+! 1&8(&2! $=(+#$+'! &A,0)+()*! +,! ?,1E=2&8$!-('81(A()&+(,)!&1$!8,)'+(+0+(,)&22<!=1,+$8+$-:>!! NM>! O+A*98(+()*!6>X>V>!5>!4(+<!,3!7+>!Q&02B!MUM!P>7>!ONNB!O]I!9HIIK::>!! NT>! 6--*%+A!&+!]MM!91$&',)()*!+#&+!70=1$A$!4,01+!=1$8$-$)+!'0==,1+'!+#$!(A=,'(+(,)!,3!8(5(2!2(&;(2(+<!()!'08#!8&'$':>!! NN>! 6--*%+A!&+!]MT!9#,2-()*!+#&+!l+#$!()@0)8+(,)!&+!(''0$!('!),+!&)!()5&2(-!=1(,1!1$'+1&()+B!;$8&0'$!+#$!,1-$1!?&'!(''0$-!,)2<!&3+$1!+#$!@01<!-$+$1A()$-!+#&+!-$3$)-&)+'!#&-!$)*&*$-!()!$A=2,<A$)+! -('81(A()&+(,)B! &)-! +#$! ,1-$1! '(A=2<! =1$820-$-! -$3$)-&)+'! 31,A! 8,)+()0()*!+#$(1!0)2&?302!&8+(5(+<l:>!

Page 12: Speech Regulation: Why an Injunction Should be Permissible Under

KUT PQ*!J6RA*S*,CC*.A*3A*5A*6T3A*.U6KO3C*PYj*VWXXYZ

(+!('!$`0&22<!82$&1!+#&+!+#$!g(1'+!XA$)-A$)+!-,$'!),+!=1,+$8+!&)!$A=2,<$1C'!,1! $A=2,<$$C'! 1(*#+! +,! $)*&*$! ()! $A=2,<A$)+! -('81(A()&+(,)! +#1,0*#! +#$!0'$! ,3! +#$! '=,E$)!?,1->lN] ! "#0'B! &)! ()@0)8+(,)! &*&()'+! +#$! 0'$! ,3! 30+01$!$=(+#$+'!?&'!),+!&)!()5&2(-!=1(,1!1$'+1&()+!;$8&0'$!lr0s)-$1!?$22L$'+&;2('#$-!2&?!>!>!>!+#$!,1-$1!?&'!(''0$-!,)2<!&3+$1!+#$!@01<!-$+$1A()$-!+#&+!-$3$)-&)+'!#&-!$)*&*$-!()!$A=2,<A$)+!-('81(A()&+(,)>lNI!!X3+$1!&)&2<\()*!'$5$1&2!P>7>!70=1$A$!4,01+!-$8('(,)'B!+#$!8,01+!-$+$1A()$-!+#&+!()!$&8#!8&'$B!+#$!8,01+!1$8,*)(\$-!l+#&+!,)8$!&!8,01+!#&'!3,0)-!+#&+!&!'=$8(3(8!=&++$1)!,3!'=$$8#!('!0)2&?302B! &)! ()@0)8+(5$! ,1-$1! =1,#(;(+()*! +#$! 1$=$+(+(,)B! =$1=$+0&+(,)B! ,1!8,)+()0&+(,)!,3!+#&+!=1&8+(8$!('!),+!&!=1,#(;(+$-!m=1(,1!1$'+1&()+C!,3!'=$$8#>l]U"#0'B! +#$! 8,01+! &33(1A$-! +#$! @0-*A$)+!,3! +#$!8,01+!,3! &==$&2'! &)-!0=#$2-!+#$!()@0)8+(,)>]H

/0'+(8$!%$1-$*&1C'!8,)8011()*!,=()(,)!'+&+$-!+#$!=201&2(+<!'#,02-!#&5$!&--1$''$-! +#$! (''0$! ,3! ?#$+#$1! '=$$8#! +#&+! 81$&+$'! &! #,'+(2$! ?,1E!$)5(1,)A$)+! ('! =1,+$8+$-! ;<! +#$!g(1'+!XA$)-A$)+>]K! !4,)820-()*! +#&+! +#$!'=$$8#!?&'!),+!=1,+$8+$-B!'#$!&*1$$-!?(+#!+#$!=201&2(+<C'!#,2-()*!;$8&0'$!,3!+#$!3,22,?()*!3&8+,1'Y!!'=$$8#!,88011()*!()!+#$!?,1E=2&8$B!&)!0)?(22()*!&)-!8&=+(5$! &0-($)8$B! &! 8,A=$22()*! '+&+$! ()+$1$'+! ()! $2(A()&+()*! 1&8(&2!-('81(A()&+(,)!()!=1(5&+$!$A=2,<A$)+B!&)-!&A=2$!&2+$1)&+(5$!'=$$8#!5$)0$'!3,1!+#$!'=$&E$1>]O

"#$!-(''$)+()*!,=()(,)'!8#&1&8+$1(\$-!+#$!()@0)8+(,)!&'!&!=1(,1!1$'+1&()+!5(,2&+()*! ;,+#! '+&+$! &)-! 3$-$1&2! 8,)'+(+0+(,)'>]J! ! /0'+(8$!W,'E! &1*0$-! +#&+!

! N]>! O+A!&+!]MT!)>T>!! NI>! O+A*&+!]MT>!! ]U>! O+A!&+!]M]!9`0,+()*!n1&A$1!5>!"#,A=',)B!IJN!g>K-!TTTB!TNM!9O-!4(1>!HIIH::>!! ]H>! 6--*%+A*&+!]TO!91$A&)-()*!+#$!8&'$!?(+#!()'+108+(,)'!+,!1$-1&3+!+#$!()@0)8+(,)!',!&'!+,!2(A(+!(+'!'8,=$!+,!+#$!?,1E=2&8$!&)-!+,!=1,5(-$!&)!$D$A=2&1<!2('+!,3!=1,#(;(+$-!?,1-':>!! ]K>! 6--* %+A! 9%$1-$*&1B! />B! 8,)8011()*:! 981(+(8(\()*! +#$!=201&2(+<! ,=()(,)! 3,1! 3&(2()*! +,!&'E!l?#$+#$1!+#$!g(1'+!XA$)-A$)+!=$1A(+'!(A=,'(+(,)!,3!8(5(2!2(&;(2(+<!0)-$1!gRbX!3,1!=01$!'=$$8#!+#&+!81$&+$'!&!1&8(&22<!#,'+(2$!,1!&;0'(5$!?,1E!$)5(1,)A$)+l:>!! ]O>! 6--* %+A! &+! ]NM! 93()-()*! +#&+! l+#$! '$5$1&2! 3&8+,1'! 8,&2$'8()*! ()! +#('! 8&'$o'=$$8#!,88011()*!()!+#$!?,1E=2&8$B!&)!0)?(22()*!&)-!8&=+(5$!&0-($)8$B!&!8,A=$22()*!'+&+$!()+$1$'+!()!$1&-(8&+()*! 1&8(&2! -('81(A()&+(,)B! &)-! &A=2$! &2+$1)&+(5$! '=$$8#! 5$)0$'! 3,1! +#$! '=$&E$1o'0==,1+!+#$!8,)820'(,)!+#&+!+#$!()@0)8+(,)B!(3!'033(8($)+2<!)&11,?$-!,)!1$A&)-!>!>!>!B!?(22!=&''!8,)'+(+0+(,)&2!A0'+$1l:>!! ]J>! 6--* %+A! &+! ]N]! 9W,'EB! />B! -(''$)+()*:! 9lc,+#! +#$! g(1'+!XA$)-A$)+! ,3! +#$!P)(+$-!7+&+$'!4,)'+(+0+(,)!&)-!>!>!>!+#$!4&2(3,1)(&!4,)'+(+0+(,)!1$'+1(8+!+#$!0'$!,3!8,)+$)+L;&'$-!=1(,1!1$'+1&()+'!,)!'=$$8#>!!"#$!,1-$1!&+!(''0$!#$1$!>!>!>!8,)'+(+0+$'!@0'+!'08#!&!=1(,1!1$'+1&()+>l:[!%+A&+! ]]K! 9n$))&1-B! />B! -(''$)+()*:! 9lr"s#$! =&1+(802&1! 8,)+$)+L;&'$-! ()@0)8+(,)! &+! (''0$!#$1$!>!>!>!('! ()5&2(-! 0)-$1! +#$! 31$$! '=$$8#! *0&1&)+$$'! ,3! ;,+#! +#$! 3$-$1&2! &)-! '+&+$!4,)'+(+0+(,)'!>!>!>!>l:[! %+A!&+!]IJ!9c1,?)B!/>B!-(''$)+()*:!9lF!?,02-!-1&?!+#$!2()$!()!+#$!'&A$!=2&8$! &'! +#$! 4&2(3,1)(&! 4,)'+(+0+(,)! &)-! 3()-! +#$! ()@0)8+(,)! &+! (''0$! #$1$! +,! ;$! &)!0)8,)'+(+0+(,)&2!=1(,1!1$'+1&()+!,3!'=$$8#>l:>!

Page 13: Speech Regulation: Why an Injunction Should be Permissible Under

6\CC3R*5CcU,JKOT9^**O9.U93KOT9*\5TM,CDJKO3! KUN!

+#$! ()@0)8+(,)! =1,#(;(+$-! =1,+$8+$-! '=$$8#[! +#$1$3,1$B! &;'$)+! &! 1$&2! &)-!(AA$-(&+$! +#1$&+!,3! 30+01$!#&1AB! (+! 8,)'+(+0+$-!&)! ()5&2(-!=1(,1! 1$'+1&()+>]M

/0'+(8$!n$))&1-!3,0)-!+#$!()@0)8+(,)!+,!;$!8,)+$)+!&)-!5($?=,()+L;&'$->]T"#$! ()@0)8+(,)! ?&'! ()5&2(-! ;$8&0'$! (+! ?&'! 0))$8$''&1<! &)-! ),+! =1,=$12<!+&(2,1$->]N! ! /0'+(8$! c1,?)! $A=#&'(\$-! +#&+! +#$! 1$A$-<! ,3! -&A&*$'! ?&'!'033(8($)+!+,!-$+$1!&)<!1&8(&2!-('81(A()&+(,)>]]

PA**O&=/&7(%)&*U&+-0*C>[1)G>-&(*F%#70%>%&"(%)&*"#*3)&(-&(i9-/(0"1*5-#(0%7(%)&*

J'/%1"0! ',0*#+! +,! '+1(E$! +#$! &==1,=1(&+$! ;&2&)8$! ;$+?$$)! +?,!8,)'+(+0+(,)&2!1(*#+'Y!!"#$!1(*#+!+,!;$!31$$!31,A!$A=2,<A$)+!-('81(A()&+(,)!&)-! +#$! 1(*#+! +,! 31$$-,A! ,3! '=$$8#>! "#$! =1()8(=2$! +#10'+! ,3! +#$! 8,01+C'!1$&',)()*! ?&'! +#&+! &)! ()@0)8+(,)! ?&'! =$1A(''(;2$! ;$8&0'$! (+! =1,#(;(+$-!'=$$8#! +#&+! &A,0)+$-! +,! 0)2&?302! 7)&+/7(! =1,#(;(+$-! ;<! +#$! gRbX>]Ig01+#$1B! +#$!8,)8011()*!,=()(,)!$A=#&'(\$-!+#&+! +#$!#,2-()*!?&'!8,)3()$-!+,!&!=1(5&+$!3,10A!?(+#!&!8&=+(5$!&0-($)8$!+#&+!()5,25$-!&!8,A=$22()*!'+&+$!()+$1$'+>IU! !"#$'$!3&8+,1'!-$81$&'$-!-$3$)-&)+'C!8,)'+(+0+(,)&2!=1,+$8+(,)!+,!31$$! '=$$8#! ',! +#&+! +#$! ()@0)8+(,)! -(-! ),+! 5(,2&+$! +#$! g(1'+! XA$)-A$)+>IH

.&'+2<B!+#$!()@0)8+(,)!?&'!(''0$-!&3+$1!&!@0-(8(&2!-$+$1A()&+(,)!()5,25()*!&!

! ]M>! 6--* %+A* &+! ]]U! 9W,'EB! /B! -(''$)+()*:! 9lF! ?,02-! #,2-! +#&+! +#$! ()@0)8+(,)! 3&(2'! +,!,5$18,A$! +#$! #$&5<! =1$'0A=+(,)! &*&()'+! +#$! 8,)'+(+0+(,)&2! 5&2(-(+<! ,3! =1(,1! 1$'+1&()+'! ,)!'=$$8#>l:>!! ]T>! 6--* %+A! &+! ]]J! 9n$))&1-B! />B! -(''$)+()*:! 9$D=2&()()*! +#&+! +#$! ()@0)8+(,)! 1$'+1(8+'!'=$$8#! ;&'$-! ,)! 8,)+$)+! ;$8&0'$! (+! =1,#(;(+'! '=$$8#! 3,1! (+'! 8,AA0)(8&+(5$! (A=&8+B! &)-!1$'+1(8+'!'=$$8#!;&'$-!,)!5($?=,()+!;$8&0'$!(+!=1,#(;(+'!+#$!0++$1&)8$!,3!?,1-'!+#&+!8,)5$<!&)-!$A;,-<!&!=&1+(802&1!;(&':>!! ]N>! 6--*%+A!&+!]]K!93()-()*!+#$!()@0)8+(,)!()5&2(-!l;$8&0'$!+#$!1$8,1-!3&(2'!+,!$'+&;2('#!+#&+! &)! ()@0)8+(,)! 1$'+1(8+()*! 30+01$! '=$$8#! ('! )$8$''&1<! +,! =1$5$)+! 1$8011$)8$!>!>!>!>!!r&)-s!;$8&0'$!(+!('!),+!)&11,?2<!-1&?)IÉl:>!! ]]>! 6--*%+A!&+!]IOZIJ!9c1,?)B!/>B!-(''$)+()*:!9l"#$1$!('!&!A(--2$!*1,0)-Y!!$A=2,<$$'!8&)!'0$!&)-!1$8,5$1!-&A&*$'>l:>!! ]I>! 6--*%+A!&+!]MT!9=201&2(+<!,=()(,):!9lP)-$1!?$22L$'+&;2('#$-!2&?!>!>!>!+#$!()@0)8+(,)!&+!(''0$! ('! ),+! &)! ()5&2(-! =1(,1! 1$'+1&()+B! ;$8&0'$! +#$! ,1-$1! ?&'! (''0$-! ,)2<! &3+$1! +#$! @01<!-$+$1A()$-!+#&+!-$3$)-&)+'!#&-!$)*&*$-!()!$A=2,<A$)+!-('81(A()&+(,)!&)-!+#$!,1-$1!'(A=2<!=1$820-$-!-$3$)-&)+'!20)>*7)&(%&/%&'*($-%0*/&1":2/1*"7(%4%(G>l:!9$A=#&'('!&--$-:>!! IU>! 6--*%+A*&+!]NM!9%$1-$*&1B!/>B!8,)8011()*:!9lF!3()-!+#&+!+#$!'$5$1&2!3&8+,1'!8,&2$'8()*!()! +#('! 8&'$o'=$$8#! ,88011()*! ()! +#$! ?,1E=2&8$B! &)! 0)?(22()*! &)-! 8&=+(5$! &0-($)8$B! &!8,A=$22()*!'+&+$!()+$1$'+!()!$1&-(8&+()*!1&8(&2!-('81(A()&+(,)!>!>!>!'0==,1+!+#$!8,)820'(,)!+#&+!+#$!()@0)8+(,)!>!>!>!?(22!=&''!8,)'+(+0+(,)&2!A0'+$1>l:>!! IH>! 6--*%+A!&+!]NNZN]!98,)820-()*!+#&+!&!=1,=$12<!)&11,?$-!()@0)8+(,)!?(22!),+!5(,2&+$!+#$!g(1'+!XA$)-A$)+:>!

Page 14: Speech Regulation: Why an Injunction Should be Permissible Under

KU] PQ*!J6RA*S*,CC*.A*3A*5A*6T3A*.U6KO3C*PYj*VWXXYZ

@01<! +1(&2! &)-! &)! &?&1-! ,3! -&A&*$'B!?#(8#! =1,5(-$-! '033(8($)+! =1,8$-01&2!'&3$*0&1-'>IK

c$8&0'$! ,3! 5&1(,0'! 3&8+L'=$8(3(8! 3&8+,1'B! J'/%1"0C'! #,2-()*! ('!8,)'('+$)+!?(+#!+#$!g(1'+!XA$)-A$)+!()',3&1!&'!+#$!()@0)8+(,)!('!5($?$-!&'!&!8,)+$)+L)$0+1&2! 1$*02&+(,)! =1,#(;(+()*! 0)2&?302! 8,)-08+>! ! X)! ()@0)8+(,)!0)-$1!$A=2,<A$)+!-('81(A()&+(,)!$)@,()'!5$1;&2!#&1&''A$)+!,3!&)<!8,)+$)+!+#&+! ('! -('81(A()&+,1(2<! -(1$8+$-! &+! A$A;$1'! ,3! &! =1,+$8+$-! 82&''>IO! ! "#('!()@0)8+(,)!=1,#(;(+'!'=$$8#!),+!,)!+#$!;&'('!,3!(+'!8,)+$)+B!;0+!,)!+#$!;&'('!,3!0)2&?302!#&1&''A$)+!,3!&!=1,+$8+$-!82&''>!

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g01+#$1A,1$B!+#$!P>7>!70=1$A$!4,01+!#&'!'+&+$-!+#$!*,5$1)A$)+!A&<!&8+!&'!&!8$)',1!3,1!',A$!E()-'!,3!'=$$8#!,)!+#$!*1,0)-'!,3!+#$(1!,33$)'(5$!)&+01$!,)2<!?#$)!&!8&=+(5$!&0-($)8$!8&)),+!&5,(-!$D=,'01$>IT!!X88,1-()*2<B!&!=1,=$12<!+&(2,1$-!()@0)8+(,)! =1,#(;(+()*! $=(+#$+'! +#&+! #&5$! ;$$)! @0-(8(&22<! -$+$1A()$-! +,!8,)+1(;0+$! +,! 0)2&?302! ?,1E=2&8$! -('81(A()&+(,)! ('! ),+! &)! ()5&2(-! =1(,1!1$'+1&()+>!

! IK>! 6--* %+A* &+! ]MNZM]! 9=201&2(+<! ,=()(,):! 91$&',)()*! +#&+! @0-(8(&2! 3()-()*'! +#&+! +#$!'=$$8#!1$'+1(8+$-!('!0)2&?302!8,)'+(+0+$!'033(8($)+!=1,8$-01&2!'&3$*0&1-'!&*&()'+!()5&2(-!=1(,1!1$'+1&()+'!,)!'=$$8#!98(+()*!Q&1('!X-02+!"#$&+1$!F!5>!72&+,)B!JHO!P>7>!JIB!MM!9HINO:::>!! IO>! 6--! 4X.> jSVC" 4ShR! v!HKIKU! 9%$'+! KUUM:! 9'+&+()*! +#&+! -('81(A()&+(,)! ,)! +#$!;&'('!,3!,)$C'!A$A;$1'#(=!()!&!=1,+$8+$-!82&''!('!(22$*&2!0)-$1!gRbX:[!#--*"1#)!4#&12$'!6>!4&22$1,'B!X*0(2&1!5>!X5('!6$)+!X!4&1!7<'+$AB!F)8>^**K$-*3"1%2)0&%"*6/[0->-*3)/0(*K"?-#*"*F%4%+-+*;0--:"G* ()*3)&(-&(iT0%-&(-+*5-'/1"(%)&*)2*!)0?[1"7-*6[--7$B!OJ!P>7>g> .> 6RV>KONB!KNU!9KUUU:!9l"(+2$!VFF!'+&)-'!1$&-<!+,!&==2<!()!&!)$0+1&2!3&'#(,)!+,!5$1;&2!#&1&''A$)+!,3!&)<!8,)+$)+!+#&+!('!-('81(A()&+,1(2<!-(1$8+$-!+,!A$A;$1'!,3!&!=1,+$8+$-!82&''>l:>!! IJ>! 6--*J'/%1"0B!I]U!Q>K-!&+!]NO!9%$1-$*&1B!/>B!8,)8011()*:!9),+()*!+#&+!+#$!70=1$A$!4,01+!#&'!&+!2$&'+!,)8$!&==2($-!+#$!+(A$B!=2&8$!&)-!A&))$1!-,8+1()$!+,!8,)-08+!,88011()*!,)!=1(5&+$!=1,=$1+<:>!! IM>! 6--* %+A* &+! ]NJ! 91$&',)()*! +#&+! &! 1$'+1(8+(,)! =1,#(;(+()*! 1&8(&22<! #,'+(2$! '=$$8#!2(A(+$-! ()! '8,=$! +,! +#$! ?,1E=2&8$! 2$&5$'! &! =$1',)! 31$$! +,! '=$&E! &)<?#$1$! ,0+'(-$! +#$!?,1E=2&8$:>!! IT>! 6--! R1\),\)(E! 5>! 4(+<! ,3! /&8E',)5(22$B! JKK! P>7>! KUMB! KUI! 9HINM:! 9'+&+()*! +#&+!'$2$8+(5$!1$'+1(8+(,)'!,)!',A$!E()-'!,3!'=$$8#!#&5$!;$$)!0=#$2-!?#$)!+#$!-$*1$$!,3!8&=+(5(+<!A&E$'!(+!(A=1&8+(8&2!3,1!+#$!0)?(22()*!5($?$1!,1!&0-(+,1!+,!&5,(-!$D=,'01$:>!

Page 15: Speech Regulation: Why an Injunction Should be Permissible Under

6\CC3R*5CcU,JKOT9^**O9.U93KOT9*\5TM,CDJKO3! KUI!

MA**C&=)%&%&'*6[--7$*U&+-0*F-2">"(%)&^**c&2;,&!F'2&)-!V(22&*$!F))B!F)8>!5>!.$A$)

F)!M"1@)"*O#1"&+*<%11"'-*O&&8*O&7A*4A*,->-&BIN!+#$!4&2(3,1)(&!70=1$A$!4,01+! &--$-! &),+#$1! 8&+$*,1<! ,3! '=$$8#! 0)-$1! ?#(8#! '=$$8#! 8&)! ;$!$)@,()$-o-$3&A&+,1<! '=$$8#>I]! ! "#$! P>7>! 70=1$A$! 4,01+! #&'! <$+! +,!&--1$''! +#$! (''0$! ,3! ?#$+#$1! &)! ()@0)8+(,)! ('! &! =$1A(''(;2$! 1$A$-<! 3,1!-$3&A&+(,)>II! ! b,?$5$1B! M"1@)"! #$2-! +#&+! (3! &! =2&()+(33! =1$5&(2'! ,)! &!-$3&A&+(,)!82&(AB! +#$)!&!8,01+!A&<! (''0$!&)!,1-$1! 3,1$5$1!=1,#(;(+()*! +#$!1$=$+(+(,)! ,3! +#$! -$3&A&+,1<! '+&+$A$)+'>HUU! ! ",! =1$5&(2! ,)! &! -$3&A&+(,)!82&(AB! &! =2&()+(33! A0'+! -$A,)'+1&+$! +#&+! +#$! -$3$)-&)+! =0;2('#$-! &)!0)=1(5(2$*$-B! 3&2'$B! &)-!-$3&A&+,1<! '+&+$A$)+!?(+#! +#$! 1$`0('(+$!-$*1$$!,3!3&02+>HUH! ! F3! +#$! -$3$)-&)+! ('! &! =0;2(8! 3(*01$! ,1! +#$! '=$$8#! ('! &! A&++$1! ,3!=0;2(8! 8,)8$1)B! +#$)! +#$! =2&()+(33!A0'+! &2',! =1,5$! &8+0&2!A&2(8$B!A$&)()*!+#&+! +#$! -$3$)-&)+! &8+$-! ?(+#! E),?2$-*$! ,1! 1$8E2$''! -('1$*&1-! ,3!3&2'$)$''>HUK

F)!M"1@)"B! +#$! 4&2(3,1)(&! 70=1$A$!4,01+! 1$&',)$-! +#&+! ,)8$! &! 8,01+!#&'!&-@0-(8&+$-!'=$$8#!+,!;$!-$3&A&+,1<B!+#$!'=$$8#!('!),!2,)*$1!=1,+$8+$-!;<!+#$!g(1'+!XA$)-A$)+>HUO!!b$)8$B!&)!()@0)8+(,)!-,$'!),+!8,)'+(+0+$!&!=1(,1!1$'+1&()+! &)-! ('! &! =$1A(''(;2$! 1$A$-<>HUJ! ! .$A$)B! &! )$(*#;,1()*! =1,=$1+<!

! IN>! 6--* c&2;,&! F'2&)-! V(22>! F))B! F)8>! 5>! .$A$)B! HMT! Q>O-! OOIB! OJK! 94&2>! KUUN:!9-$8(-()*!+#&+!+#$!()@0)8+(,)!?&'!,5$12<!;1,&-!;0+!+#&+!&!=1,=$12<!2(A(+$-!()@0)8+(,)!?,02-!),+!5(,2&+$!-$3$)-&)+C'!1(*#+!+,!31$$!'=$$8#:>!! I]>! 6--* %+A! 9'+&+()*! +#&+! &! l=1,=$12<! 2(A(+$-! ()@0)8+(,)! =1,#(;(+()*! -$3$)-&)+! 31,A!1$=$&+()*!+,!+#(1-!=$1',)'!'+&+$A$)+'!&;,0+!+#$!V(22&*$!F))!+#&+!?$1$!-$+$1A()$-!&+!+1(&2!+,!;$!-$3&A&+,1<!?,02-!),+!5(,2&+$!-$3$)-&)+C'!1(*#+!+,!31$$!'=$$8#l:>!! II>! 32A!",1<!5>!4,8#1&)B!MJJ!P>7>!NOJB!NO]!9KUUM:!93()-()*!(+!0))$8$''&1<!+,!&--1$''!+#$!A$1(+'!,3!+#$!8&'$!;$8&0'$!+#$!()@0)8+(,)!#&-!2,'+!(+'!0)-$12<()*!1&+(,)&2$!0=,)!+#$!-$&+#!,3!+#$!-$3&A&+(,)!5(8+(A:>!! HUU>! 6--* M"1@)"B! HMT!Q>O-! &+! OJK! 9-$+$1A()()*! +#&+! &)! ()@0)8+(,)! =1,#(;(+()*! '=$$8#!+#&+! ?&'! =1$5(,0'2<! -$+$1A()$-! &+! +1(&2! +,! ;$! -$3&A&+,1<! ?,02-! ),+! 5(,2&+$! +#$! g(1'+!XA$)-A$)+:>!! HUH>! 6--8* -A'AB! 4&2>! 4(5>! 4,-$! X))>! vv!JJZJN! 9%$'+! HI]K:! 9-$3()()*! -$3&A&+(,)! &'!$33$8+$-!;<!2(;$2!,1!'2&)-$1B!&)-!2('+()*!+#$!$2$A$)+':>!! HUK>! 6--* G$?! d,1E! "(A$'! 4,>! 5>! 7022(5&)B! ONT! P>7>! KMJB! K]U! 9HITJ:! 9l"#$!8,)'+(+0+(,)&2! *0&1&)+$$'! 1$`0(1$!>!>!>!&! 3$-$1&2! 102$! +#&+! =1,#(;(+'! &! =0;2(8! ,33(8(&2! 31,A!1$8,5$1()*! -&A&*$'! 3,1! &! -$3&A&+,1<! 3&2'$#,,-! 1$2&+()*! +,! #('! ,33(8(&2! 8,)-08+! 0)2$''! #$!=1,5$'!+#&+!+#$!'+&+$A$)+!?&'!A&-$!?(+#!m&8+0&2!A&2(8$>Cl:>!! HUO>! 6--*M"1@)"B!HMT!Q>O-!&+!OMO!9-$+$1A()()*!+#&+!&)!()@0)8+(,)!=1,#(;(+()*!-$3$)-&)+!31,A! 1$=$&+()*! '+&+$A$)+'! -$+$1A()$-! +,! ;$! -$3&A&+,1<! &+! +1(&2! -,$'! ),+! 5(,2&+$! +#$!-$3$)-&)+C'!1(*#+!+,!31$$!'=$$8#:>!! HUJ>! 6--*%+A*&+!OJK!9'+&+()*!+#&+!&)!()@0)8+(,)!=1,#(;(+()*!-$3&A&+,1<!'=$$8#!?,02-!),+!5(,2&+$!-$3$)-&)+C'!1(*#+!+,!31$$!'=$$8#:>!

Page 16: Speech Regulation: Why an Injunction Should be Permissible Under

KHU PQ*!J6RA*S*,CC*.A*3A*5A*6T3A*.U6KO3C*PYj*VWXXYZ

,?)$1! ,3! c&2;,&! F'2&)-! V(22&*$! F))B! ?&'! =$1+01;$-! ;<! +#$! ),('$! &)-!()$;1(&+$-! ;$#&5(,1! ,3! =&+1,)'! ,3! +#$! F))>HUM! ! X3+$1! 8,A=2&()()*! +,! +#$!&0+#,1(+($'B! '#$! ;$*&)! 8,)-08+()*! 5&1(,0'! ()+10'(5$! &8+(5(+($'! &*&()'+! +#$!F))>HUT

g,1! ,5$1! +?,! <$&1'B! .$A$)! 5(-$,+&=$-! &)-! +,,E! 5&1(,0'! 32&'#!=#,+,*1&=#'! ,3! +#$! F))C'! 80'+,A$1'! &)-! $A=2,<$$'B! &)-! 8&22$-! +#$A!l-10)E'Bl! l?#,1$'Bl! &)-! &'',8(&+$-! +#$A!?(+#! 7&+&)>HUN! !%#(2$! 8,22$8+()*!'(*)&+01$'!3,1!&!=$+(+(,)!&*&()'+!+#$!F))B!'#$!+,2-!)$(*#;,1'!+#&+!+#$!F))!',2-!-10*'! &)-! &28,#,2! +,!A(),1'B! +#&+! '$D! +&=$'!?$1$! ;$()*! 3(2A$-! &+! +#$! F))B!&)-! +#&+! +#$! F))! ?&'! ()5,25$-! ?(+#! +#$! A&3(&! &)-! $)8,01&*$-! 2$';(&)!&8+(5(+($'>HU]! !g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

! HUM>! 6--*%+A*&+!OJH!9'+&+()*!+#&+!.$A$)!8,A=2&()$-!,3!$D8$''(5$!),('$!&)-!+#$!;$#&5(,1!,3!()$;1(&+$-!80'+,A$1':>!! HUT>! 6--*%+A!9'+&+()*!+#&+!.$A$)!5(-$,+&=$-!+#$!F))!&==1,D(A&+$2<!3(3+<!+(A$':>!! HUN>! O+A! HU]>! O+A!&+!OJK>!! HUI>! O+A*! HHU>! O+A! HHH>! c&2;,&!F'2&)-!V(22>! F))B! F)8>!5>!.$A$)B!HN!4&2>!6=+1>!O-!OMKB!OMN!94&2>!4+>!X==>!KUUJ:>!! HHK>! O+A*&+!OMNZM]>!! HHO>! c&2;,&!F'2&)-!V(22>!F))B!F)8>!5>!.$A$)B!HMT!Q>O-!OOIB!OJK!94&2>!KUUN:>!! HHJ>! 6--* %+A* 9=1,#(;(+()*! .$A$)! 31,A! $D=1$''()*! +#&+! =2&()+(33Y! ! 9H:!'$22'! &28,#,2! +,!A(),1'B! 9K:!'+&<'! ,=$)! 0)+(2! TYUU! &AB! 9O:!A&E$'! '$D! 5(-$,'B! 9J:!('! ()5,25$-! ()! 8#(2-!=,1),*1&=#<B!9M:!-('+1(;0+$'!(22$*&2!-10*'B!9T:!#&'!A&3(&!8,))$8+(,)'B!9N:!$)8,01&*$'!2$';(&)!&8+(5(+($'B!9]:!=&1+(8(=&+$'!()!=1,'+(+0+(,)B!&)-!9I:!'$15$'!+&()+$-!3,,-:>!! HHM>! O+A

Page 17: Speech Regulation: Why an Injunction Should be Permissible Under

6\CC3R*5CcU,JKOT9^**O9.U93KOT9*\5TM,CDJKO3! KHH!

=,1+(,)'! ,3! +#$! ()@0)8+(,)! 5(,2&+$-! .$A$)C'! 31$$! '=$$8#! 1(*#+'! 0)-$1! +#$!'+&+$!&)-!3$-$1&2!8,)'+(+0+(,)'>HHT

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

"#$!8,01+!)$D+!&--1$''$-!.$A$)C'!&1*0A$)+!+#&+!-&A&*$'!&1$!+#$!',2$!1$A$-<! 3,1! -$3&A&+(,)! ;$8&0'$! $`0(+<! 2&8E'! @01('-(8+(,)! +,! $)@,()! &!-$3&A&+(,)>HKU! ! F+! ),+$-! +#&+! (3! -&A&*$'! ?$1$! +#$! ',2$! 1$A$-<B! +#$)! &!-$3$)-&)+! #&1A$-! ;<! 8,)+()0,0'! -$3&A&+(,)! ?,02-! #&5$! +,! ;1()*! &!'088$''(,)! ,3! 2&?'0(+'! (3! &)! &?&1-! ,3! -&A&*$'! ?&'! &)! ()'033(8($)+!-$+$11$)8$>HKH!!b$)8$B!l&!@0-*A$)+!3,1!A,)$<!-&A&*$'!?(22!),+!&2?&<'!*(5$!+#$! =2&()+(33! $33$8+(5$! 1$2($3! 31,A! &! 8,)+()0()*! =&++$1)! ,3! -$3&A&+(,)>lHKK"#('! &''$1+(,)! ?&'! (220'+1&+$-! ;<! +#$! 3&8+! +#&+! =2&()+(33! ',0*#+! ,)2<!()@0)8+(5$! 1$2($3! &)-! ),+!A,)$<! -&A&*$'o+#$! F))! @0'+! ?&)+$-! .$A$)! +,!

! HHT>! O+A*! HHN>! 6--* %+A! &+! OJO! 9lh$3$)-&)+! ()! +#$! =1$'$)+! 8&'$! ,;@$8+'! +,! +#$! (A=,'(+(,)! ,3! &)!()@0)8+(,)! =1,#(;(+()*! #$1! 31,A! 1$=$&+()*! '+&+$A$)+'! +#$! +1(&2! 8,01+! -$+$1A()$-! ?$1$!'2&)-$1,0'B!&''$1+()*!+#$!()@0)8+(,)!8,)'+(+0+$'!&)!(A=$1A(''(;2$!=1(,1!1$'+1&()+>l:>!!! HH]>! 6--*%+A!&+!OJJZJM!9lQ1,#(;(+()*!&!=$1',)!31,A!A&E()*!&!'+&+$A$)+!,1!=0;2('#()*!&!?1(+()*! @-2)0-! +#&+! '+&+$A$)+! ('! '=,E$)! ,1! +#$! ?1(+()*! ('! =0;2('#$-! ('! 3&1! -(33$1$)+! 31,A!=1,#(;(+()*!&!-$3$)-&)+!31,A!0-[-"(%&'*&!'+&+$A$)+!,1!0-[/@1%#$%&'!&!?1(+()*! +#&+!#&'!;$$)!-$+$1A()$-!&+!+1(&2!+,!;$!-$3&A&+,1<!&)-B!+#0'B!0)2&?302>l:>!! HHI>! 6--* %+A! &+! OJT! )>J! 91$&',)()*! +#&+! &)! ()@0)8+(,)! $)@,()()*! &! -$3$)-&)+! 31,A!-('+1(;0+()*!-$3&A&+,1<!'+&+$A$)+'!&21$&-<!()!=1()+!('!),!A,1$!,;@$8+(,)&;2$!+#&)!=0)('#A$)+!,3!-$3&A&+(,)!;<!=0)(+(5$!-&A&*$!&?&1-'!&)-!81(A()&2!2(;$2!=1,'$80+(,)':>!! HKU>! 6--* %+A! &+! OJI! 9l.$A$)! &1*0$'! +#&+! -&A&*$'! &1$! +#$! ',2$! 1$A$-<! &5&(2&;2$! 3,1!-$3&A&+(,)B! '+&+()*Y! ! m"#$! +1&-(+(,)&2! 102$! ,3! X)*2,LXA$1(8&)! 2&?! ('! +#&+! $`0(+<! #&'! ),!@01('-(8+(,)!+,!$)@,()!-$3&A&+(,)>Cl:>!! HKH>! 6--*%+A*&+!OMH!9lX88$=+()*!.$A$)C'!&1*0A$)+!+#&+!+#$!,)2<!1$A$-<!3,1!-$3&A&+(,)!('! &)! &8+(,)! 3,1! -&A&*$'! ?,02-! A$&)! +#&+! &! -$3$)-&)+!>!>!>!?,02-! ;$! 1$`0(1$-! +,! ;1()*! &!'088$''(,)!,3!2&?'0(+'!(3!&)!&?&1-!,3!-&A&*$'!?&'!()'033(8($)+!+,!-$+$1!+#$!-$3$)-&)+!31,A!8,)+()0()*!+,1+(,0'!;$#&5(,1>l:>!! HKK>! O+A

Page 18: Speech Regulation: Why an Injunction Should be Permissible Under

KHK PQ*!J6RA*S*,CC*.A*3A*5A*6T3A*.U6KO3C*PYj*VWXXYZ

'+,=! #$1! &8+(5(+($'>HKO! ! "#0'B! +#$! 8,01+! #$2-! +#&+! -&A&*$'! &1$! ),+! +#$! ',2$!1$A$-<!3,1!-$3&A&+(,)>HKJ

g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

"#$!M"1@)"!8,01+!A,-(3($-!+#$!()@0)8+(,)!',!+#&+!(+!=1,#(;(+$-!.$A$)!31,A! '+&+()*! +#$! $)0A$1&+$-! 2('+! ,3! -$3&A&+,1<! '+&+$A$)+'! +,! +#(1-!=$1',)'o,+#$1!+#&)!*,5$1)A$)+&2!$)3,18$A$)+!,33(8(&2'o&)-!31,A!3(2A()*!?(+#()! +?$)+<L3(5$! 3$$+! ,3! +#$! F))>HKI! ! X3+$1! &33(1A()*! +#$! 2,?$1! 8,01+C'!102()*B!+#$!8,01+!#$2-!+#&+!&!=1,=$12<!+&(2,1$-!()@0)8+(,)!=1,#(;(+()*!'=$$8#!&21$&-<!&-@0-(8&+$-! +,!;$!-$3&A&+,1<!-(-!),+!5(,2&+$! +#$!-$3$)-&)+C'!g(1'+!XA$)-A$)+!1(*#+'!0)-$1!;,+#!'+&+$!&)-!3$-$1&2!8,)'+(+0+(,)'>HOU

/0'+(8$!n$))&1-C'! -(''$)+()*! ,=()(,)! #$2-! +#&+! +#$! ()@0)8+(,)!?&'! &)!0)8,)'+(+0+(,)&2! =1(,1! 1$'+1&()+! &)-! +#&+! +#$! &==1,=1(&+$! 1$A$-<! 3,1!

! HKO>! 6--*%+A*9l"#$!V(22&*$!F))!-(-!),+!'$$E!A,)$<!-&A&*$'!()!(+'!&A$)-$-!8,A=2&()+>!!"#$!F))!-(-!),+!?&)+!A,)$<!31,A!.$A$)[!(+!@0'+!?&)+$-!#$1!+,!'+,=>l:>!! HKJ>! O+A!&+!OMH!)>HU!9#,2-()*!+#&+!&)!&?&1-!,3!-&A&*$'!('!),+!+#$!',2$!1$A$-<!&5&(2&;2$!3,1!-$3&A&+(,):>!! HKM>! 6--*%+A!&+!OMO!9l.$A$)!&1*0$'!+#&+!'#$!8&)),+!;$!$)@,()$-!31,A!1$=$&+()*!+#$!'&A$!'+&+$A$)+'! 3,0)-! +,! ;$! -$3&A&+,1<B! ;$8&0'$! &! 8#&)*$! ()! 8(180A'+&)8$'! A(*#+! 1$)-$1!=$1A(''(;2$!&!'+&+$A$)+!+#&+!?&'!-$3&A&+,1<!>!>!>!>l:>!! HKT>! 6--*%+A*9lF3!'08#!&!8#&)*$!()!8(180A'+&)8$!,8801'B!-$3$)-&)+!A&<!A,5$!+#$!8,01+!+,!A,-(3<!,1!-('',25$!+#$!()@0)8+(,)>l:>!! HKN>! 6--*%+A!9lc<!+#$!'&A$!+,E$)B!+#$!V(22&*$!F))!8,02-!A,5$!+,!A,-(3<!+#$!()@0)8+(,)!(3! .$A$)! 1$=$&+$-! #$1! -$3&A&+,1<! '+&+$A$)+'! ()! &! A&))$1! ),+! $D=1$''2<! 8,5$1$-! ;<! +#$!()@0)8+(,)>l:>!! HK]>! 6--* %+A! 9c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lr"s#$! ()@0)8+(,)! A0'+! ;$! 1$5$1'$-! ()! =&1+! ;$8&0'$! (+! ('! ,5$12<!;1,&-B! ;0+! &! =1,=$12<! 2(A(+$-! ()@0)8+(,)! =1,#(;(+()*! -$3$)-&)+! 31,A! 1$=$&+()*! '+&+$A$)+'!&;,0+!=2&()+(33!+#&+!?$1$!-$+$1A()$-!&+!+1(&2!+,!;$!-$3&A&+,1<!?,02-!),+!5(,2&+$!-$3$)-&)+C'!1(*#+!+,!31$$!'=$$8#>l:>!

Page 19: Speech Regulation: Why an Injunction Should be Permissible Under

6\CC3R*5CcU,JKOT9^**O9.U93KOT9*\5TM,CDJKO3! KHO!

-$3&A&+(,)! ('! -&A&*$'>HOH! ! b$! &1*0$-! +#&+! +#$! A&@,1(+<C'! &1*0A$)+! ?&'!32&?$-! ;$8&0'$Y! ! 9H:!-$3&A&+,1<! '+&+$A$)+'! l8&)),+! ;$! -$+$1A()$-! ;<!5($?()*!+#$!'+&+$A$)+!()!(',2&+(,)!31,A!+#$!8,)+$D+!()!?#(8#!(+!('!A&-$BlHOK9K:!&!8#&)*$!()!8(180A'+&)8$'!8,02-!1$)-$1!0)=1,+$8+$-!'=$$8#!()+,!+10+#302B!=1,+$8+$-!'+&+$A$)+'BHOO!&)-!9O:!8#&)*$'!()!?,1-()*!8,02-!A&E$!(+!-(33(802+!+,! -$+$1A()$! ?#$+#$1! &! =&1+(802&1! '+&+$A$)+! 3$22! ?(+#()! &)! ()@0)8+(,)C'!=1,#(;(+(,)>HOJ! ! /0'+(8$! n$))&1-! &2',! 3,0)-! +#&+! +#$! ()@0)8+(,)! ?&'!0))$8$''&1<! +,! =1,+$8+! &)<! 8,A=$22()*! '+&+$! ()+$1$'+>HOM! ! g01+#$1A,1$B!;$8&0'$! =2&()+(33! #&-! ,)2<! &'E$-! 3,1! ()@0)8+(5$! 1$2($3B! +#$1$! ?&'! ),!-$A,)'+1&+(,)! +#&+! A,)$+&1<! -&A&*$'! ?,02-! #&5$! ;$$)! &)! ()&-$`0&+$!1$A$-<>HOT! !X88,1-()*2<B!#$!&1*0$-! +#$! ()@0)8+(,)!?&'!0)8,)'+(+0+(,)&2!&'!?$22!&'!0))$8$''&1<>HON

/0'+(8$! %$1-$*&1C'! -(''$)+()*! ,=()(,)! -('+()*0('#$-! +#$! 3&8+'! ()!J'/%1"0!?(+#! +#$! 3&8+'! ()!M"1@)">HO]! !"#$! 3,22,?()*! 3&8+,1'o&)!0)?(22()*!&)-!8&=+(5$!&0-($)8$B!&!8,A=$22()*!'+&+$!()+$1$'+B!&2+$1)&+(5$!'=$$8#!5$)0$'B!&)-! +?,!8,)'+(+0+(,)&2! ()+$1$'+'o'0==,1+$-!#$1!8,)820'(,)! ()!J'/%1"0B!;0+!+#$'$! 3&8+,1'! ?$1$! A(''()*! ()! M"1@)">HOI! ! lF)! +#$! &;'$)8$! ,3! &)<! ,3! +#$!0)0'0&2! 3&8+,1'! =1$'$)+! ()! J'/%1"0!>!>!>!,1! &)<! 8,A=$22()*! P)(+$-! 7+&+$'!70=1$A$! 4,01+! &0+#,1(+<B! (+! ('! ()$'8&=&;2$! +#&+! +#$! ()@0)8+(,)! #$1$! ('! &)!

! HOH>! 6--*%+A!&+!OMJ!9n$))&1-B!/>B!-(''$)+()*:!9lF!&*1$$!?(+#!+#$!4,01+!,3!X==$&2!+#&+!&)!()@0)8+(,)!=$1A&)$)+2<!=1,#(;(+()*!-$3$)-&)+C'!30+01$!'=$$8#!('!&)!0)8,)'+(+0+(,)&2!1$'+1&()+>!!X)-!>!>!>!F!?,02-!#,2-!+#&+!+#$!1$A$-<!3,1!-$3&A&+(,)!('!+,!&?&1-!A,)$+&1<!-&A&*$'>l:>!! HOK>! O+A!&+!OMT>!! HOO>! 6--* %+A* 9*(5()*! +#$! $D&A=2$! ,3! &)! &0-($)8$! A$A;$1! 3&2'$2<! <$22()*! l3(1$l! ()! &!81,?-$-!+#$&+$1!5$1'0'!&)!&8+,1!<$22()*!+#$!'&A$!?,1-!()!+#$!'&A$!81,?-$-!+#$&+$1!-01()*!&!=$13,1A&)8$!+,!(220'+1&+$!#,?!8,)+$D+!8&)!&33$8+!g(1'+!XA$)-A$)+!=1,+$8+(,):>!! HOJ>! 6--*%+A!9`0$'+(,)()*!?#$+#$1!,1!),+!.$A$)C'!'+&+$A$)+!+,!&!31($)-!+#&+!+#$!3,,-!&+!+#$!V(22&*$!F))!('!l;&-l!?,02-!(A=2<!+#&+!+#$!3,,-!('!l+&()+$-l!()!5(,2&+(,)!,3!+#$!()@0)8+(,):>!!! HOM>! 6--* %+A! &+! OMN! 9l"#$! ()@0)8+(,)! #$1$! ('! ),+! )$8$''&1<! +,! =1,+$8+! &)<! 8,A=$22()*!'+&+$!()+$1$'+!,1!&)<!(A=,1+&)8$!=0;2(8!=,2(8<>l:>!! HOT>! 6--*%+A!&+!OM]!9lX2+#,0*#!=2&()+(33!82&(A$-!(+!'033$1$-!&!KU!=$18$)+!2,''!()!;0'()$''!1$5$)0$! &3+$1! .$A$)! 8(1802&+$-! #$1! =$+(+(,)! &A,)*! +#$! 1$'(-$)+'! ,3! c&2;,&!F'2&)-!>!>!>!=2&()+(33! -(-! ),+! '$$E! &)<! A,)$+&1<! -&A&*$'! 31,A! .$A$)>! ! "#$! ,)2<! 1$2($3!=2&()+(33!',0*#+!?&'!&!=$1A&)$)+!()@0)8+(,)>l:>!! HON>! 6--* %+A! &+! OMI! 9lr"s#$! ()@0)8+(,)! ('! &! =1(,1! 1$'+1&()+! ,)! 30+01$! '=$$8#[! (+! ('!,5$1;1,&-!()!=1,#(;(+()*!),)-$3&A&+,1<!30+01$!'=$$8#[!&)-!(+!('!0))$8$''&1<!()!+#$!&;'$)8$!,3!=1,,3!+#&+!8,A=$)'&+,1<!-&A&*$'!?,02-!),+!;$!&)!&-$`0&+$!1$A$-<>l:>!! HO]>! 6--*%+A!&+!OTU!9%$1-$*&1B!/>B!-(''$)+()*:!9lP)2(E$!()!J'/%1"0B!?#$1$!?$!?$1$!8&22$-!,)! +,! ;&2&)8$! 8,0)+$15&(2()*! 8,)'+(+0+(,)&2! 8,)8$1)'! ?(+#! +#$! -$A&)-'! ,3! +#$! ;%0#(J>-&+>-&(! 31$$! '=$$8#! *0&1&)+$$B! +#$! =1$'$)+! 8&'$! ()5,25$'! &! *&1-$)L5&1($+<! -$3&A&+(,)!0)-$1!'+&+$!2&?>l:!9$A=#&'('!&--$-:>!! HOI>! 6--* %+A! &+! OTH! 93()-()*! +#&+! ),)$! ,3! +#$! 8,)'(-$1&+(,)'! +#&+! 1$)-$1$-!J'/%1"0! &)!0)0'0&2!8&'$!&1$!=1$'$)+!()!M"1@)":>!

Page 20: Speech Regulation: Why an Injunction Should be Permissible Under

KHJ PQ*!J6RA*S*,CC*.A*3A*5A*6T3A*.U6KO3C*PYj*VWXXYZ

(A=$1A(''(;2$! =1(,1! 1$'+1&()+! ,)! -$3$)-&)+C'! '=$$8#>lHJU! ! g01+#$1B! +#$!=2&()+(33!)$*2$8+$-! +,! '#,?! +#&+!-&A&*$'!,1!=0)(+(5$!-&A&*$'!?,02-!#&5$!3&(2$-!+,!A&E$!+#$!=2&()+(33!?#,2$!,1!+,!-$+$1!30+01$!-$3&A&+,1<!'=$$8#>HJH

3A**F%#(%&'/%#$%&'*J'/%1"0*20)>*M"1@)"*

M"1@)"C'!#,2-()*!81$&+$-! &!)$?!8&+$*,1<!,3! '=$$8#! +#&+! 3&22'!,0+'(-$!+#$! =1,+$8+(5$! =015$<&)8$! ,3! +#$! =1(,1! 1$'+1&()+! -,8+1()$>HJK! ! F+! $''$)+(&22<!&22,?'!&! 8,01+! +,!A&E$! 2&?!;<!0'()*!&!,)$L'(\$L3(+'L&22! 102$! +,! $)@,()! &)<!+<=$!,3!-$3&A&+(,)!&3+$1!&!@0-(8(&2!-$+$1A()&+(,)>!!M"1@)"!1$2($-!,)!J'/%1"0+,!'0==,1+!+#$!8,)+$)+(,)!+#&+!&)!()@0)8+(,)!&*&()'+!-$3&A&+(,)!(''0$-!&3+$1!&)!&-@0-(8&+(,)!-,$'!),+!&A,0)+!+,!&!=1(,1!1$'+1&()+>HJO!!b,?$5$1B*J'/%1"0!('!-('+()*0('#&;2$! 31,A!M"1@)"! ()! '$5$1&2! ?&<'! +#&+! '0==,1+! +#$! 8,)820'(,)!+#&+!M"1@)"C'! #,2-()*! ?&'! ,5$12<! ;1,&-! &)-! (+'! ()@0)8+(,)! 8,)'+(+0+$-! &)!()5&2(-!=1(,1!1$'+1&()+>!

PA**5-h/%0-+*6$):%&'*)2*J7(/"1*R"0>*

g(1'+B! 5(8+(A'!,3!-('81(A()&+,1<! $=(+#$+'! ()!#,'+(2$!?,1E=2&8$'B! 0)2(E$!5(8+(A'!,3!-$3&A&+,1<! '=$$8#B!A&<!=1$5&(2! ,)!&!?,1E=2&8$!-('81(A()&+(,)!82&(A!,)2<!0=,)!&!'033(8($)+!'#,?()*!+#&+!-('81(A()&+,1<!8,)-08+!8&0'$-!&!#&1A302! ?,1E! $)5(1,)A$)+>HJJ! ! "#$! '+&)-&1-! 3,1! $=(+#$+'! &A,0)+()*! +,!?,1E=2&8$! -('81(A()&+(,)! 0)-$1! +#$! gRbX! ('! +#$! '&A$! 0)-$1! "(+2$! VFF!82&(A'>HJM! ! c,+#! '+&+0+$'! 1$`0(1$! #&1&''A$)+! +,! ;$! '033(8($)+2<! '$5$1$! ,1!

! HJU>! O+A!&+!OTJ>!! HJH>! 6--*%+A!9lX2+#,0*#!=2&()+(33B!&!;0'()$''!,=$1&+()*!&!1$'+&01&)+B!82&(A'!(+!2,'+!A,)$<!&'!&!1$'02+!,3!&!-$3$)-&)+C'!-$3&A&+,1<!8,AA$)+'B!(+!#&'!),+!'#,?)!?#<!(+!8&)),+!;$!A&-$!?#,2$!;<!-&A&*$'>l:>! HJK>! 6--* %+A* &+! OJK! 9A&@,1(+<! ,=()(,):! 98,)820-()*! +#&+! &! =1,=$12<! 2(A(+$-! ()@0)8+(,)!=1,#(;(+()*!'+&+$A$)+'!=1$5(,0'2<!-$+$1A()$-!&+!+1(&2!+,!;$!-$3&A&+,1<!-,$'!),+!8,)'+(+0+$!&!=1(,1!1$'+1&()+:>!! HJO>! 6--* %+A* &+! OJI! 9lX88,1-()*2<B! ?$! #,2-! +#&+B! 3,22,?()*! &! +1(&2! &+! ?#(8#! (+! ('!-$+$1A()$-! +#&+! +#$! -$3$)-&)+! -$3&A$-! +#$! =2&()+(33B! +#$! 8,01+! A&<! (''0$! &)! ()@0)8+(,)!=1,#(;(+()*! +#$! -$3$)-&)+! 31,A! 1$=$&+()*! +#$! '+&+$A$)+'! -$+$1A()$-! +,! ;$! -$3&A&+,1<>l!98(+()*!X*0(2&1!5>!X5('!6$)+!X!4&1!7<'+$AB!F)8>B!I]U!Q>K-!]JTB!]M]!94&2>!HIII:::>!! HJJ>! 6--*X*0(2&1! 5>! X5('! 6$)+! X! 4&1! 7<'+$AB! F)8>B! I]U! Q>K-! ]JTB! ]MH! 94&2>! HIII:!9lm4,)-08+!+#&+!('!),+!'$5$1$!,1!=$15&'(5$!$),0*#!+,!81$&+$!&)!,;@$8+(5$2<!#,'+(2$!,1!&;0'(5$!?,1E! $)5(1,)A$)+o&)! $)5(1,)A$)+! +#&+! &! 1$&',)&;2$! =$1',)! ?,02-! 3()-! #,'+(2$! ,1!&;0'(5$o('!;$<,)-!"(+2$!VFFC'!=015($?>Cl!9`0,+()*!b&11('!5>!g,1E2(3+!7<'>B!F)8>B!MHU!P>7>!HNB!KHZKK!9HIIO:::>!! HJM>! 6--* %+A! 9lV$1;&2! #&1&''A$)+! ()! +#$! ?,1E=2&8$! &2',! A&<! 8,)'+(+0+$! $A=2,<A$)+!

Page 21: Speech Regulation: Why an Injunction Should be Permissible Under

6\CC3R*5CcU,JKOT9^**O9.U93KOT9*\5TM,CDJKO3! KHM!

=$15&'(5$! ',! &'! l+,! &2+$1! +#$! 8,)-(+(,)'! ,3! r+#$! 5(8+(AC's! $A=2,<A$)+! &)-!81$&+$!&)!&;0'(5$!?,1E()*!$)5(1,)A$)+lHJT!&)-!',!&'!+,!81$&+$!&!l8#&)*$!()!+#$! +$1A'! &)-! 8,)-(+(,)'! ,3! $A=2,<A$)+>lHJN! ! "#('! '+&)-&1-! 1$`0(1$'! &!'#,?()*! ,3! #&1A302! 8,)-08+! '+1,)*! $),0*#! +,! &8+0&22<! 8#&)*$! +#$!$)5(1,)A$)+!&)-!8,)-(+(,)'!,3!$A=2,<A$)+>HJ]

"#('! '+&)-&1-!?&'!A$+! ()!R)[-* 4A*3"1%2)0&%"* f)/($*J/($)0%(G>HJI! ! F)!R)[-B!b,=$B!&!*&<!A&)!?#,!#&-!?,1E$-!&'!&!8,,E!&+!&!8,11$8+(,)&2!3&8(2(+<B!;1,0*#+! &! 82&(A! &*&()'+! #('! 3,1A$1! $A=2,<$1! 3,1! '$D0&2! ,1($)+&+(,)!#&1&''A$)+!0)-$1!gRbX>!HMU!!"#$!8,01+!$A=#&'(\$-!+#&+!&8+'!,3!#&1&''A$)+!A&<!),+!;$!,88&'(,)&2!,1!(',2&+$-B!;0+!()'+$&-B!=2&()+(33!A0'+!'#,?!&!=&++$1)!,3! #&1&''A$)+! ,3! &! 1$=$&+$-! ,1! 1,0+()$! )&+01$>HMH! ! g01+#$1A,1$B! &8+'! ,3!#&1&''A$)+!A0'+! 3023(22! ;,+#! &)! ,;@$8+(5$! '+&)-&1-! ;&'$-! ,)! &! 1$&',)&;2$!=$1',)!()!+#$!5(8+(AC'!=,'(+(,)!&)-!&!'0;@$8+(5$!'+&)-&1-!;&'$-!,)!#,?!+#$!5(8+(A!=$18$(5$'!+#$!?,1E!$)5(1,)A$)+>HMK

b,=$!+$'+(3($-!+#&+!#('!(AA$-(&+$!'0=$15(',1!&)-!8,?,1E$1!1$=$&+$-2<!8&22$-!#(A!-$1,*&+,1<!)&A$'!'08#!&'!lA,+#$1!308E()C!3&**,+l!&)-!l#,A,l!-01()*! #('! 3(5$! <$&1'! ,3! $A=2,<A$)+! &+! +#$! 8,11$8+(,)&2! 3&8(2(+<>HMO! ! "#$!'$801(+<!,33(8$1!&2',!()'+108+$-!?&1-'!),+!+,!#$2=!b,=$!8,,E!&)-!82$&)!?#(2$!

-('81(A()&+(,)!0)-$1!+(+2$!VFF!,3!+#$!4(5(2!6(*#+'!X8+!,3!HITJ!>!>!>!+#$!3$-$1&2!8,0)+$1=&1+!,3!+#$!gRbX>l!98(+()*!W$1(+,1!7&5>!c&)E!5>!V()',)B!JNN!P>7>!MN!9HI]T:::>!! HJT>! O+A!9`0,+()*!<%&#)&B!JNN!P>7>!&+!TN!9HI]T::>!! HJN>! O+A!9`0,+()*!g&1&*#$1!5>!4(+<!,3!c,8&!6&+,)B!MKJ!P>7>!NNMB!N]T!9HII]::>!! HJ]>! 6--*%+A*93()-()*!+#&+!+#$!=2&()+(33!A0'+!=1,5$!+#&+!+#$!8,)-08+!?,02-!#&5$!()+$13$1$-!?(+#!&!1$&',)&;2$!$A=2,<$$C'!?,1E!=$13,1A&)8$B!'$1(,0'2<!&33$8+$-!+#$!='<8#,2,*(8&2!?$22L;$()*!,3!&!1$&',)&;2$!$A=2,<$$B!+#&+!'#$!?&'!&8+0&22<!,33$)-$-B!&)-!+#&+!+#$!#&1&''A$)+!?&'!1$=$&+$-!&)-!,3!&!1,0+()$!)&+01$:!98(+()*!g('#$1!5>!7&)!Q$-1,!Q$)()'02&!b,'=>B!KHJ!4&2>!X==>!O-!MIUB!TU]ZHU!94&2!4+>!X==>!HI]I::>!! HJI>! 6--*b,=$! 5>! 4&2>!d,0+#!X0+#>B! OT!4&2>! 6=+1>! O-! HMJB! HNU! 94&2>! 4+>!X==>! KUUM:!9&33(1A()*! +#$! @0-*A$)+!,3! +#$! +1(&2! 8,01+! 3()-()*! 3,1! +#$!=2&()+(33! ()!#('! '$D0&2!,1($)+&+(,)!#&1&''A$)+!'0(+!&)-!&?&1-()*!#(A!$8,),A(8!&)-!),)$8,),A(8!-&A&*$':>!! HMU>! O+A!&+!HMN>!! HMH>! 6--* %+A! &+! HTO! 9lF)! -$+$1A()()*! ?#&+! 8,)'+(+0+$'! m'033(8($)+2<! =$15&'(5$C!#&1&''A$)+B! +#$! 8,01+'! #&5$! #$2-! +#&+! &8+'! ,3! #&1&''A$)+! 8&)),+! ;$! ,88&'(,)&2B! (',2&+$-B!'=,1&-(8B! ,1! +1(5(&2B! 1&+#$1! +#$! =2&()+(33! A0'+! '#,?! &! 8,)8$1+$-! =&++$1)! ,3! #&1&''A$)+! ,3! &!1$=$&+$-B! 1,0+()$!,1!&!*$)$1&2(\$-!)&+01$>Cl! 9`0,+()*!;%#$-0B!KHJ!4&2>!X==>!O-!&+!THU!94&2>!4+>!X==>HI]I:::>!! HMK>! 6--* %+A! 9l"#$! #&1&''A$)+! A0'+! '&+('3<! &)! ,;@$8+(5$! &)-! &! '0;@$8+(5$! '+&)-&1->!!r"s#$!,;@$8+(5$!'$5$1(+<!,3!#&1&''A$)+!'#,02-!;$!@0-*$-!31,A!+#$!=$1'=$8+(5$!,3!&!1$&',)&;2$!=$1',)! ()! +#$!=2&()+(33Ç'!=,'(+(,)B!8,)'(-$1()*!l&22! +#$!8(180A'+&)8$'>! !X)-B!'0;@$8+(5$2<B!&)!$A=2,<$$!A0'+!=$18$(5$!+#$!?,1E!$)5(1,)A$)+!+,!;$!#,'+(2$>l:!9()+$1)&2!`0,+&+(,)!A&1E'!&)-!8(+&+(,)'!,A(++$-:>!! HMO>! O+A*&+!HTM>!

Page 22: Speech Regulation: Why an Injunction Should be Permissible Under

KHT PQ*!J6RA*S*,CC*.A*3A*5A*6T3A*.U6KO3C*PYj*VWXXYZ

,+#$1! 8,,E'! 8,)+()0$-! +,! #&5$! +#$! ?&1-'C! &''('+&)8$>HMJ! ! S)$! ,3! b,=$C'!'0=$15(',1'!$5$)!+$'+(3($-!+#&+!+#$!'$801(+<!,33(8$1!+1$&+$-!b,=$!()!&!l810$2l!A&))$1>HMM! ! %#$)! b,=$! 8,A=2&()$-! +,! #('! A&)&*$1B! '#$! 1$'=,)-$-B!l$5$1<,)$!+#()E'!<,0C1$!*&<>lHMT!!"#$!8,01+!3,0)-!+#&+!+#$!3&8+'!&22$*$-!;<!b,=$!#&-!$'+&;2('#$-!+#&+!#&1&''A$)+!?&'!'033(8($)+2<!'$5$1$!,1!=$15&'(5$!+,!81$&+$!&!#,'+(2$!?,1E!$)5(1,)A$)+>HMN! !"#$!R)[-! 8&'$! ('!&)!$D&A=2$!,3!+#$! #(*#! '+&)-&1-! &! =2&()+(33!A0'+!A$$+! +,! =1$5&(2! ,)! &! #&1&''A$)+! 82&(A!0)-$1! +#$! gRbX>! !"#('! #(*#! '+&)-&1-! $)'01$'! +#&+! +#$! =2&()+(33!A$$+'! +#$!l#$&5<!;01-$)!,3!@0'+(3(8&+(,)lHM]!;$3,1$!,;+&()()*!&!=1(,1!1$'+1&()+!,)!31$$!'=$$8#>!

h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

F)!D"E"0(* 4A* 6("(-BHTH! +#$! G$?! d,1E! 4,01+! ,3! 42&(A'! 3,0)-! (+! ?&'!2(;$2,0'!=$1!'$!3,1!&!0)(5$1'(+<!)$?'=&=$1!+,!=0;2('#!&!'+0-$)+L?1(++$)!2$++$1!+#&+!3&2'$2<!(-$)+(3($-!,+#$1!'+0-$)+'!&'!A$A;$1'!,3!+#$!*&<!8,AA0)(+<>HTK"#$! 8,01+! $A=#&'(\$-! +#&+! ?1(+()*! ('! -$3&A&+,1<! =$1! '$! (3! (+! $D=,'$'! &!=$1',)! +,! #&+1$-B! 8,)+$A=+B! ,1! 0)'&5,1<! ,=()(,)! ()! +#$! A()-'! ,3! &!

! HMJ>! O+A! HMM>! O+A! HMT>! O+A!&+!HTT>!! HMN>! 6--* %+A! &+!HTJ! 9l"#$!$5(-$)8$!'0==,1+'! +#$! @01<C'! (A=2($-! 3()-()*! +#&+!b,=$!?&'!#&1&''$-!&)-!+#&+!+#$!#&1&''A$)+!?&'!'033(8($)+2<!'$5$1$!)0!=$1'0&'(5$!+,!&2+$1!+#$!8,)-(+(,)'!,3!#('!$A=2,<A$)+!&)-!81$&+$!&!?,1E!$)5(1,)A$)+!+#&+!`0&2(3($'!&'!#,'+(2$!,1!&;0'(5$>l:>!!! HM]>! S1*>!3,1!&!c$++$1!X0'+()!5>!n$$3$B!JUK!P>7>!JHMB!JHI!9HINH:>!! HMI>! 6--8*-A'AB!78#,A$1!5>!7A(-+B!HNU!4&2>!6=+1>!TTKB!TTT! 94&2>!4+>!X==>!HI]U:! 9l%$!3()-!+#&+!&!3&2'$!(A=0+&+(,)!,3!+#$!8,AA(''(,)!,3!&!#,A,'$D0&2!&8+!('!'2&)-$1,0'!=$1!'$>l:>!! HTU>! 6--*%+>!9lr"s,!'+&+$!+#&+!,)$!8&11($'!,)!'$D0&2!8,)-08+!;$!(+!&2,)$B!?(+#!A$A;$1'!,3!+#$!,==,'(+$!,1!'(A(2&1!'$D!(A=0+$'!+,!+#$A!&!m?&)+!,3!8#&'+(+<BC!?#(8#!()!+#$!$<$'!&)-!A()-'!,3! +#$(1! =$$1'! A(*#+! &)-! 8,02-! '0;@$8+! +#$A! +,! -('*1&8$B! 1(-(802$B! -&A&*$! +,! 1$=0+&+(,)B!2&8E()*!5(1+0$!,1!1$2(&;(2(+<>l:>!! HTH>! 6--*W&\&1+! 5>! 7+&+$B! JJH! G>d>7>K-! TUUB! TUJ! 9G>d>! 4+>! 42>! HI]H:! 9#,2-()*! +#&+!0)(5$1'(+<!=0;2(8&+(,)!?#(8#!=0;2('#$-!2$++$1!()-(8&+()*!+#&+!82&(A&)+'!?$1$!lA$A;$1'!,3!+#$!*&<!8,AA0)(+<l!8,)'+(+0+$-!2(;$2!=$1!'$:>!! HTK>! O+A! &+! TUJ! 98,)820-()*! +#&+! +#$! 82&(A&)+'!?$1$! 2(;$2$-! &)-! +#&+! +#$! 2(;$2!?&'!),+!=1(5(2$*$-:>!

Page 23: Speech Regulation: Why an Injunction Should be Permissible Under

6\CC3R*5CcU,JKOT9^**O9.U93KOT9*\5TM,CDJKO3! KHN!

'0;'+&)+(&2!=&1+!,3! +#$!8,AA0)(+<>HTO! !c$8&0'$!&!)0A;$1!,3!&8`0&()+&)8$'!#&-! `0$'+(,)$-! +#$! '+0-$)+'! &;,0+! +#$(1! '$D0&2! ,1($)+&+(,)B! +#$! 8,01+!8,)820-$-!+#&+!+#$!2$++$1!#&-!&!)$*&+(5$!(A=&8+!,)!&!)0A;$1!,3!=$,=2$!()!+#$!0)(5$1'(+<! 8,AA0)(+<>HTJ! ! "#0'B! +#$! A$1$! `0$'+(,)()*! ,3! +#$! '+0-$)+'C!'$D0&2! ,1($)+&+(,)!?&'! '033(8($)+! +,! $'+&;2('#! +#&+! &! '0;'+&)+(&2! =&1+! ,3! +#$!8,AA0)(+<!#&-!3,1A$-!&!)$*&+(5$!,=()(,)!,3!+#$'$!'+0-$)+'>HTM

"#$! &;,5$! 5($?'B! l()! $33$8+B! 5&2(-&+$!>!>!>!r&)+(#,A,'$D0&2s!'$)+(A$)+r's! &)-! 2$*(+(A(\$! 1$2$*&+()*! #,A,'$D0&2'! +,! '$8,)-L82&''!'+&+0'>lHTT! ! X! @0-*$! 8,02-! (''0$! &)! ()@0)8+(,)! =1,#(;(+()*! &22! $D=1$''(,)'!(A=0+()*!#,A,'$D0&2(+<! +,!&)! ()-(5(-0&2! +#&+!8&)!;$!=1,5$)! 3&2'$>HTN! ! F)!&!'+&+$!?#$1$! +#$!A&@,1(+<! ,3! +#$! 2$*('2&+01$! =1$'0A$'! #,A,'$D0&2(+<! +,! ;$!#&1A302! +,! &)! ()-(5(-0&2C'! 1$=0+&+(,)B! &)! ()@0)8+(,)! '08#! &'! +#('! 8,02-B!$''$)+(&22<B! 31$$\$! &22! 30+01$! $D=1$''(,)'!A$)+(,)()*! +#$! #,A,'$D0&2(+<! ,3!+#('! ()-(5(-0&2>HT]! ! F)! +#('! 8(180A'+&)8$B! +#$! *,5$1)A$)+! ?,02-! ;$!l$33$8+(5$2<! -1(5r()*s! 8$1+&()! (-$&'! ,1! 5($?=,()+'! 31,A! +#$! A&1E$+=2&8$l!;&'$-!,)!+#$!-('3&5,1$-!'+&+0'!,3!&!A(),1(+<!*1,0=>HTI

4,01+'! #&5$! 1$=$&+$-2<! $A=#&'(\$-! +#&+! &)<,)$! '$$E()*! &! =1(,1!1$'+1&()+! ,)! +#$! 1(*#+! ,3! 31$$! '=$$8#! ;$&1'! &! #$&5<!;01-$)>HNU! !"#('! #$&5<!;01-$)! 1$`0(1$'! '#,?()*! +#&+! #&1A302! '=$$8#!?(22! l'01$2<! 1$'02+! ()! -(1$8+B!

! HTO>! 6-- %+>!&+!TUO!9lX!?1(+()*!('!-$3&A&+,1<!>!>!>!(3!(+!+$)-'!+,!$D=,'$!&!=$1',)!+,!#&+1$-B!8,)+$A=+! ,1! &5$1'(,)B! ,1! +,! ()-08$! &)! $5(2! ,1! 0)'&5,1<! ,=()(,)! ,3! #(A! ()! +#$!A()-'! ,3! &!'0;'+&)+(&2! )0A;$1! ,3! +#$! 8,AA0)(+<B! $5$)! +#,0*#! (+! A&<! (A=0+$! ),! A,1&2! +01=(+0-$! +,!#(A>l!9`0,+()*!W$)8#$1!5>!4#$'2$<B!KIN!G>d>!IJB!HUU!9HIJN:::>!! HTJ>! 6-- %+A!&+!TUJ!9),+()*!+#&+!+#$!3&8+!+#&+!lr-s$5(&)+!'$D0&2!()+$18,01'$!&)-!',-,A<!?$1$!81(A$'!()!+#$!7+&+$!,3!G$?!d,1E!&+!+#$!+(A$!+#$!2$++$1!?&'!=0;2('#$-l!&2',!8,2,1$-!+#$!8,AA0)(+<C'!,=()(,)!,3!+#$!'+0-$)+':>!! HTM>! 6-- %+A 9lr"s#$!4,01+!3()-'!+#&+!&!'0;'+&)+(&2!)0A;$1!,3!+#$!P)(5$1'(+<!8,AA0)(+<!?,02-! )&+01&22<! &''0A$! +#&+! +#$! 82&(A&)+'! $)*&*$-! ()! #,A,'$D0&2! &8+'! 31,A! '08#!(-$)+(3(8&+(,)>l:>!! HTT>! X2;1(*#+!5>!W,1+,)B!OKH!g>!70==>!K->!HOUB!HO]!9h>!W&''>!KUUJ:>!! HTN>! 32A* %+A!&+!HOI!9lmh$3&A&+(,)!=$1!'$C!'#,02-!;$!1$'$15$-!3,1!'+&+$A$)+'! 2()E()*!&)!()-(5(-0&2! +,! +#$! 8&+$*,1<! ,3! =$1',)'! m-$'$15()*! ,3! ',8(&2! &==1,;&+(,)C! 2(E$! &! m+#($3B!A01-$1$1B!=1,'+(+0+$B!$+8>C!!",!'0**$'+!+#&+!#,A,'$D0&2'!'#,02-!;$!=0+!()+,!+#('!82&''(3(8&+(,)!('!),+#()*!'#,1+!,3!,0+1&*$,0'>l:!98(+&+(,)'!,A(++$-:>!! HT]>! 32A*%+A!&+!HON!9lr"s#$!2&1*$!A&@,1(+<!,3!+#$!8,01+'!+#&+!#&5$!3,0)-!&)!&880'&+(,)!,3!#,A,'$D0&2(+<! +,!;$!-$3&A&+,1<!=$1! '$!$A=#&'(\$-! +#$! 3&8+! +#&+! '08#!&! '+&+$A$)+! (A=0+$-!81(A()&2!8,)-08+>l:>!! HTI>! 6>X>V>!5>!4(+<!,3!7+>!Q&02B!MUM!P>7>!ONNB!O]N!9HIIK:!9`0,+()*!7(A,)!a!78#0'+$1B!F)8>!5>!W$A;$1'!,3!+#$!G>d>!7+&+$!41(A$!V(8+(A'!c->B!MUK!P>7>!HUMB!HHT!9HIIH::>!! HNU>! 6--8*-A'AB!S1*>!3,1!&!c$++$1!X0'+()!5>!n$$3$B!JUK!P>7>!JHMB!JHI!9HINH:!9lX)<!=1(,1!1$'+1&()+! ,)! $D=1$''(,)! 8,A$'! +,! +#('! 4,01+! ?(+#! &! m#$&5<! =1$'0A=+(,)C! &*&()'+! (+'!8,)'+(+0+(,)&2!5&2(-(+<>l:>!

Page 24: Speech Regulation: Why an Injunction Should be Permissible Under

KH] PQ*!J6RA*S*,CC*.A*3A*5A*6T3A*.U6KO3C*PYj*VWXXYZ

(AA$-(&+$B! &)-! (11$=&1&;2$! -&A&*$>lHNH! ! "#$! A$1$! &-@0-(8&+(,)! ,3!-$3&A&+(,)! A&<! ),+! =1,5(-$! '033(8($)+! =1,8$-01&2! '&3$*0&1-'! ;$8&0'$! &!=2&()+(33! 8&)! =1$5&(2! ,)! &! -$3&A&+(,)! 82&(A! ?(+#,0+! #&5()*! +,! '#,?! &)<!&8+0&2!()@01<!'033$1$-!,1!&)<!-&)*$1!,3!30+01$!#&1A>!

WA*F%22-0-&(*6)/07-#*)2*,":*

7$8,)-B!+#$!J'/%1"0!&)-!M"1@)"!8,01+'!-$1(5$-!+#$(1!&0+#,1(+<!+,!(''0$!()@0)8+(,)'!31,A!+?,!-(33$1$)+!',018$'!,3!2&?Y! !&!'+&+$!'+&+0+$!9+#$!gRbX:!&)-! +#$! 8,AA,)! 2&?! 9-$3&A&+(,)! 2&?':>! !"#$!gRbX!$A=,?$1'! 8,01+'! +,!(''0$!&)!()@0)8+(,)!+,!=1$5$)+!0)2&?302!-('81(A()&+,1<!8,)-08+B!&)-!8,01+'!31$`0$)+2<! (A=,'$! ()@0)8+(,)'! &'! &)! $33$8+(5$! 1$A$-<! +,! =1$5$)+! +#$!1$8011$)8$! ,3! -('81(A()&+,1<! =1&8+(8$'! ()! +#$! ?,1E=2&8$>HNK! ! h$3&A&+(,)!2&?'B! ,)! +#$! ,+#$1! #&)-B! -$5$2,=$-! 31,A! +#$! 8,AA,)! 2&?! ?#$1$! +#$!+1&-(+(,)&2! 1$A$-<! ('! -&A&*$'>HNO! ! "#$! =1()8(=2$! -$1(5$'! 31,A! +#$!A&D(A!+#&+!$`0(+<!?(22!),+!$)@,()!&!-$3&A&+(,)!;$8&0'$!-&A&*$'!&1$!&)!&-$`0&+$!1$A$-<>HNJ! ! h&A&*$'! '$$E! +,! 1$-1$''! +#$! 1$=0+&+(,)&2! #&1A! '033$1$-! ;<!A&E()*!+#$!=2&()+(33!?#,2$!&)-!&8+!+,!-$+$1!30+01$!-$3&A&+,1<!'=$$8#>HNM!!F)!&!8,)8011()*!,=()(,)B!/0'+(8$!7+$?&1+!'+&+$-B!l&)!&8+(,)!3,1!-&A&*$'!('!+#$!,)2<! #,=$! 3,1! 5()-(8&+(,)! ,1! 1$-1$''! +#$! 2&?! *(5$'! +,! &! A&)! ?#,'$!1$=0+&+(,)!#&'!;$$)! 3&2'$2<!-('#,),1$->lHNT! !b$)8$B! +#$! +1&-(+(,)&2! 1$A$-<!3,1! -$3&A&+(,)! ('! -&A&*$'! ?#$1$&'! &! ?,1E=2&8$! -('81(A()&+(,)! 82&(A!()5,25$'!()@0)8+(5$!1$2($3>HNN

! HNH>! G$?!d,1E!"(A$'!4,>!5>!7022(5&)B!JUO!P>7>!NHOB!NOU!9HINH:>!! HNK>! 6--*X*0(2&1!5>!X5('!6$)+!X!4&1!7<'>B!F)8>B!I]U!Q>K-!]JTB!]MK!94&2>!HIII:!9'+&+()*!+#&+!0)-$1!+#$!gRbXB!l8,01+'!8&)B!&)-!,3+$)!-,B!(''0$!()@0)8+(,)'!=1,#(;(+()*!+#$!1$8011$)8$!,1!8,)+()0&+(,)!,3!$A=2,<A$)+!-('81(A()&+(,)l:>!!"#$!4&2(3,1)(&!.$*('2&+01$!#&'!-(1$8+$-!+#$!gRbX!l+,!;$!8,)'+10$-!m2(;$1&22<C!',!&'!+,!&88,A=2('#!(+'!=01=,'$'>l!!O+A*&+!]MU>!! HNO>! 6--8*-A'AB!MU!XW> /P6> Kh ,%@-1*S*61"&+-0!v!JOO!9KUU]:!9lP)-$1!+#$!8,AA,)L2&?!102$B!-&A&*$!('!=1$'0A$-!31,A!&!-$3&A&+(,)!>!>!>!>l:>!! HNJ>! 6--!6ShGRd!X> 7WS..XB .X%!Sg!hRgXWX"FSG!v!IY]M!9K-!$->!HIII:!9l"#$1$! ('!&!+1&-(+(,)&2!A&D(A!+#&+!m$`0(+<!?(22!),+!$)@,()!&!2(;$2>Cl:>!! HNM>! 6--! R'+$22&! j,2-B! F)-#* Ch/%(G* 6(%11* ,"7?* ./0%#+%7(%)&* ()* C&=)%&* "* ,%@-1* )0*61"&+-0oB! J]! c6SSn> .> 6RV>! KOHB! KMI! 9HI]K:! 9(-$)+(3<()*! +#1$$! E()-'! ,3! -&A&*$'! ()!-$3&A&+(,)! 8&'$'Y! ! 8,A=$)'&+,1<B! $A,+(,)&2B! &)-!=0)(+(5$! 98(+()*!6R7"X"RWRG"! 97R4SGh:Sg!"S6"7!v!TKO!9HINN:::>!! HNT>! 6,'$);2&++!5>!c&$1B!O]O!P>7>!NMB!IO!9HITT:!97+$?&1+B!/>B!8,)8011()*:>!! HNN>! 6--! JM4! XW> /P6> Kh .)@* F%#70%>%&"(%)&! v!KMJU! 9KUU]:! 92('+()*! ?,1E=2&8$!-('81(A()&+(,)!2&?'B!+#$!5(,2&+(,)!,3!?#(8#!$)+(+2$'!+#$!5(8+(A!+,!()@0)8+(5$!1$2($3:>!

Page 25: Speech Regulation: Why an Injunction Should be Permissible Under

6\CC3R*5CcU,JKOT9^**O9.U93KOT9*\5TM,CDJKO3! KHI!

pA**J[[1%7"@1-*;)0/>#*

"#(1-B! +#$! J'/%1"0! ()@0)8+(,)! &*&()'+! ?,1E=2&8$! -('81(A()&+(,)! ?&'!8,)3()$-!+,!+#$!?,1E=2&8$!?#$1$&'!+#$!M"1@)"!()@0)8+(,)!8,02-!=1,#(;(+!&)<!'=$$8#! $D=1$''$-! ()! &)<! +<=$! ,3! 3,10A>! ! X)! ()@0)8+(,)! 0)-$1!J'/%1"0! ('!&)&2,*,0'! +,!&! 1$&',)&;2$! +(A$B!=2&8$B!&)-!A&))$1! 1$'+1(8+(,)!;$8&0'$! +#$!()@0)8+(,)!('!2(A(+$-!,)2<!+,!+#$!?,1E=2&8$B!&!=1(5&+$!'$++()*!?#$1$!5&1(,0'!1$'+1(8+(,)'!,)!'=$$8#!&1$!=$1A(''(;2$>HN]

"#$!#,2-()*! ()!M"1@)"! -(-!),+! 2(A(+! +#$! ()@0)8+(,)! ()! +(A$B!=2&8$B! ,1!A&))$1>HNI! ! F)'+$&-B! +#$! -$3$)-&)+! ('! $)@,()$-! 31,A!0++$1()*! '+&+$A$)+'! ()!&)<!=2&8$!&)-!()!&)<!A&))$1>H]U!!"#$!M"1@)"!()@0)8+(,)!=1,#(;(+$-!.$A$)C'!'=$$8#B! ?#(8#! ?&'! '=011$-! ;<! '+&0)8#! 1$2(*(,0'! ;$2($3'B! +,,E! =2&8$! ()! &!=0;2(8!3,10AB!?&'!$D=1$''$-!()!&!=$&8$302!A&))$1B!&)-!8,)8$1)$-!&!A&++$1!,3!?(-$'=1$&-!=0;2(8! ()+$1$'+>H]H! ! F)! 3&8+B! l.$A$)C'! 2&?<$1'!=,()+!,0+! +#&+!'#$!A&-$!A&)<!,3!+#$!-('=0+$-!'+&+$A$)+'!&'!=&1+!,3!#$1!8&A=&(*)!&*&()'+!+#$! ;&1C'! $D=&)-$-! 2(8$)'$B! &! A&++$1! ,3! ?(-$'=1$&-! =0;2(8! ()+$1$'+>lH]K

M"1@)"C'!#,2-()*!-('8,0)+'! +#$!3&8+! +#&+!$5$)!3&2'$!&)-!,0+1&*$,0'!'=$$8#!$D=1$''$-!()!&!=0;2(8!3,10A!-$'$15$'!',A$!=1,+$8+(,)!;$8&0'$!(+!8&)!&''('+!=,2(+(8&2! &)-! ',8(&2! -$;&+$'! ;<! 8#&22$)*()*! ,1+#,-,D($'! &)-! $)#&)8()*!0)-$1'+&)-()*'>H]O! ! g01+#$1A,1$B! 1$2(&)8$! ,)! +#$! +$A=,1&2! $2$A$)+! ,3!3&2'$)$''! ('! +1,0;2()*! ;$8&0'$! &! 8#&)*$! ()! 8(180A'+&)8$'! 8,02-! 8#&)*$!0)=1,+$8+$-B!3&2'$!'+&+$A$)+'!()+,!=1,+$8+$-B!+10$!'+&+$A$)+'>H]J

! HN]>! 6--! X*0(2&1! 5>! X5('! 6$)+! X! 4&1! 7<'>B! I]U! Q>K-! ]JTB! ]NO! )>N! 94&2>! HIII:!9%$1-$*&1B!/>B!8,)8011()*:!9'+&+()*!+#&+!=1(5&+$!$A=2,<$1'!,3+$)!=2&8$!5&1(,0'!1$'+1(8+(,)'!,)!'=$$8#! ,3! $A=2,<$$'B! ()820-()*! 1$`0(1$A$)+'! +#&+! '&2$'=$1',)'! '=$&E! ?$22! ,3! $A=2,<$1C'!=1,-08+'B! 1$'+&01&)+! ?&(+! '+&33! ),+! +,! '=$&E! )$*&+(5$2<! ,3! 3,,-! +#$<! &1$! '$15()*B! &)-!$A=2,<$$'!E$$=!+1&-$!'$81$+'!8,)3(-$)+(&2:>!! HNI>! 6--* c&2;,&! F'2&)-! V(22>! F))B! F)8>! 5>! .$A$)B! HMT! Q>O-! OOIB! OTH! 94&2>! KUUN:!9%$1-$*&1B! />B! 8,)8011()*! ()! =&1+! &)-! -(''$)+()*! ()! =&1+:! 98,)820-()*! +#&+! l+#$! ()@0)8+(,)!=1,#(;(+()*!.$A$)!31,A!1$=$&+()*!#$1!-$3&A&+,1<!'+&+$A$)+'!('!),+B!&'!()!J'/%1"0B!&E()!+,!&!+(A$B!=2&8$!&)-!A&))$1!1$'+1(8+(,)l:>!! H]U>! 6--*%+A!&+!OMT!9-$'81(;()*!+#$!A&@,1(+<C'!&1*0A$)+!&'!&!l'<22,*('AY!!9H:!h$3&A&+(,)!('! ),+! 8,)'+(+0+(,)&22<! =1,+$8+$-! '=$$8#[! 9K:! (+! #&'! ;$$)! @0-(8(&22<! -$+$1A()$-! +#&+! .$A$)!-$3&A$-! =2&()+(33!>!>!>![! +#$1$3,1$! 9O:! -$3$)-&)+! A&<! ;$! $)@,()$-! 31,A! $5$1! &*&()! A&E()*!+#,'$!'+&+$A$)+'!>!>!>! +#$!&1*0A$)+!#&'!'0=$13(8(&2!&==$&2rB!;0+! 2s(E$!A&)<!&! '<22,*('AB! (+! ('!32&?$->l:!98(+&+(,)'!,A(++$-:>!! H]H>! 6--*%+A!&+!OJHZJK!9-$'81(;()*!.$A$)C'!81(+(8&2!'+&+$A$)+'!&*&()'+!+#$!F)):>!! H]K>! W&01&!h,2&)B!;0--*6[--7$*,%>%(#*K-#(-+*T/(#%+-*O&&B!.>X> "FWR7B!/&)>!KIB!KUUNB!&+!H>!! H]O>! 6--! 42(5$!%&2E$1B!5-2)0>%&'* ($-* 30%>-* )2* ,%@-1B! MU! G>d>.> 74b> .> 6RV>! HTIB!KUK!9KUUMZKUUT:!9lR5$)!3&2'$!&)-!20-(81,0'!'=$$8#!8&)!&''('+!&!',8($+<C'!=,2(+(8&2!&)-!',8(&2!-$;&+$'!;<!8#&22$)*()*!,1+#,-,D($'!&)-!'#&1=$)()*!&1*0A$)+'!&)-!0)-$1'+&)-()*'>l:>!! H]J>! 6--* %+A! 9),+()*! +#&+! l+#$! -$'(*)&+(,)! ,3! m+10+#C! &''0A$'! &)!>!>!>!0)8,)'8(,)&;2$!

Page 26: Speech Regulation: Why an Injunction Should be Permissible Under

KKU PQ*!J6RA*S*,CC*.A*3A*5A*6T3A*.U6KO3C*PYj*VWXXYZ

dA**KG[-*)2*5-#(0%7(%)&*

.&'+B! +#$! ()@0)8+(,)'! ()!J'/%1"0! &)-!M"1@)"! 8,)'+(+0+$!-(33$1$)+! +<=$'!,3!1$'+1(8+(,)'!1$`0(1()*!-(33$1$)+!2$5$2'!,3!@0-(8(&2!'810+()<>!!X'!=1$5(,0'2<!-('80''$-B! +#$! ()@0)8+(,)! ()!J'/%1"0! =1,#(;(+$-! #&1&''A$)+! ,3! &)<! 8,)+$)+!-(1$8+$-! &+! &! =1,+$8+$-! 82&''>H]M! ! b$)8$B! (+! ('! &! 8,)+$)+L)$0+1&2! 1$'+1(8+(,)!=1,#(;(+()*!'=$$8#!,)!+#$!;&'('!,3!0)2&?302!8,)-08+!1&+#$1!+#&)!,)!+#$!;&'('!,3!&)<!5($?=,()+!,1!,=()(,)>H]T! !4,)+$)+L)$0+1&2! 1$'+1(8+(,)'!&1$! '0;@$8+! +,!()+$1A$-(&+$!'810+()<!?#$1$!1$&',)&;2$!+(A$B!=2&8$B!&)-!A&))$1!1$'+1(8+(,)'!&1$! =$1A(++$->H]N! ! g01+#$1A,1$B! &! 8,A=$22()*! '+&+$! ()+$1$'+! $D('+'! ()!$1&-(8&+()*!()5(-(,0'!-('81(A()&+(,)!()!+#$!?,1E=2&8$>H]]!!"#0'B!$5$)!0)-$1!+#$!A,'+!$D&8+()*!@0-(8(&2!'810+()<B!&!)&11,?2<!+&(2,1$-!()@0)8+(,)!?,02-!),+!;$!&)!()5&2(-!=1(,1!1$'+1&()+!(3!)$8$''&1<!+,!=1$5$)+!30+01$!-('81(A()&+(,)>!

h$3&A&+,1<!'=$$8#!$D=1$''$-!()!&!=0;2(8!3,10A!('!&!+<=$!,3!'=$$8#!+#&+!('! 1$*02&+$-! ;$8&0'$! ,3! (+'! 8,)'+(+0+(,)&22<! =1,'81(;&;2$! 8,)+$)+>H]I! ! X)!()@0)8+(,)!&*&()'+!-$3&A&+(,)!('!8,)+$)+L;&'$-!&)-!+#0'!A0'+!;$!)$8$''&1<!+,! '$15$! &! 8,A=$22()*! '+&+$! ()+$1$'+! &)-! )&11,?2<! -1&?)! +,! &8#($5$! +#&+!$)->HIU! !"#$!P>7>!70=1$A$!4,01+!#&'!1$8,*)(\$-!&!2$*(+(A&+$!'+&+$!()+$1$'+!()! 8,A=$)'&+()*! 1$=0+&+(,)&2! &++&8E'>HIH! ! c0+B! (+! ('! #&'! )$5$1! '+&+$-! &)!()@0)8+(,)! +,! $)@,()! -$3&A&+,1<! '=$$8#! 8,)'+(+0+$'! &! 8,A=$22()*! '+&+$!()+$1$'+>! !M"1@)"!?,02-! &22,?! &! 8,01+! +,! (''0$! &! 8,)+$)+L;&'$-! ()@0)8+(,)!

-$*1$$!,3!>!>!>!()3&22(;(2(+<l:>!! H]M>! 6--*X*0(2&1! 5>! X5('! 6$)+! X! 4&1! 7<'>B! F)8>B! I]U! Q>K-! ]JTB! ]TKZTO! 94&2>! HIII:!9=201&2(+<!,=()(,):! 9l"#$! +1(&2! 8,01+! 3,0)-! +#&+! /,#)!.&?1$)8$C'!0'$!,3! 1&8(&2! $=(+#$+'!?&'!'033(8($)+2<! '$5$1$! ,1! =$15&'(5$! +,! 8,)'+(+0+$! $A=2,<A$)+! -('81(A()&+(,)>! "#$! +1(&2! 8,01+!301+#$1! 3,0)-! +#&+! ()@0)8+(5$! 1$2($3!?&'!)$8$''&1<! +,!=1$5$)+! &! 8,)+()0&+(,)!,3! +#$! &;0'(5$!?,1E!$)5(1,)A$)+>l:>!! H]T>! 6--*%+A*&+!]TO 9lc$8&0'$!.&?1$)8$C'!=&'+!0'$!,3!'08#!$=(+#$+'!()!+#$!?,1E=2&8$!#&-!;$$)! @0-(8(&22<! -$+$1A()$-! +,! 5(,2&+$! +#$! gRbXB! =1,#(;(+()*! #(A! 31,A! 8,)+()0()*! +#('!-('81(A()&+,1<!&8+(5(+<!-,$'!),+!8,)'+(+0+$!&)!()5&2(-!=1(,1!1$'+1&()+!,3!'=$$8#>l:>!! H]N>! 6--!Q$11<!R-08>!X''C)!5>!Q$11<!.,8&2!R-08&+,1'C!X''C)B! JTU!P>7>! ONB!JM! 9HI]O:!9$D=2&()()*!+#&+!'08#!1$'+1(8+(,)'!A0'+!;$!)&11,?2<!+&(2,1$-!+,!'$15$!&!'(*)(3(8&)+!*,5$1)A$)+!()+$1$'+!&)-!2$&5$!,=$)!&A=2$!&2+$1)&+(5$!8#&))$2'!,3!8,AA0)(8&+(,):>!! H]]>! 6-- J'/%1"0B!I]U!Q>K-!&+!]NJ!9%$1-$*&1B!/>B!8,)8011()*:!9&8E),?2$-*()*! +#&+! +#$!$2(A()&+(,)! ,3! 1&8(&2! -('81(A()&+(,)! #&'! ,3+$)! ;$$)! &! *,5$1)A$)+! ()+$1$'+! l,3! +#$! #(*#$'+!,1-$1l:>!! H]I>! 6--!6>X>V>!5>!4(+<!,3!7+>!Q&02B!MUM!P>7>!ONNB!O]O!9HIIK:!9),+()*!8$1+&()!&1$&'!,3!'=$$8#B!()820-()*!-$3&A&+(,)B!8&)!;$!1$*02&+$-!;$8&0'$!,3!+#$(1!8,)'+(+0+(,)&22<!=1,'81(;&;2$!8,)+$)+:>!! HIU>! \-00G*C+/7A*J##N&B!JTU!P>7>!&+!JM>!! HIH>! 6--!j$1+\!5>!6,;$1+!%$28#B!F)8>B!JH]!P>7>!OKOB!OJH!9HINJ:!9l"#$!2$*(+(A&+$!'+&+$!()+$1$'+!0)-$12<()*!+#$!2&?!,3!2(;$2!('!+#$!8,A=$)'&+(,)!,3!()-(5(-0&2'!3,1!+#$!#&1A!()32(8+$-!,)!+#$A!;<!-$3&A&+,1<!3&2'$#,,->l:>!

Page 27: Speech Regulation: Why an Injunction Should be Permissible Under

6\CC3R*5CcU,JKOT9^**O9.U93KOT9*\5TM,CDJKO3! KKH!

31$$\()*!'=$8(3(8!'=$$8#!?(+#,0+!#&5()*!+,!'#,?!(+!('!)$8$''&1<!+,!301+#$1!&!8,A=$22()*! '+&+$! ()+$1$'+>! ! "#$! M"1@)"! ()@0)8+(,)! ?&'! &)! ()5&2(-! =1(,1!1$'+1&()+!;$8&0'$!+#$!8,01+!3&(2$-!+,!'+&+$!&!8,A=$22()*!'+&+$!()+$1$'+>HIK!!"#$!8,01+! &2',! 3&(2$-! +,! $'+&;2('#! +#$! ()@0)8+(,)! ?&'! )$8$''&1<[! +#$1$! ?&'! ),!'#,?()*! +#&+! +#$! 1$A$-<! ,3! -&A&*$'! ?&'! ()&-$`0&+$! +,! =1$5$)+! 301+#$1!#&1A>HIO! ! g01+#$1A,1$B! 1&8(&22<! -$3&A&+,1<! '=$$8#! A&<! $D=1$''! &! 8$1+&()!5($?=,()+!,1!;(&'>HIJ! !X22,?()*!&!8,01+! +,!;<=&''!'+1(8+!@0-(8(&2!'810+()<!+,!(''0$! &! 8,)+$)+! ,1! 5($?=,()+L;&'$-! ()@0)8+(,)! ('! =1$'0A$-! +,! 5(,2&+$! +#$!g(1'+!XA$)-A$)+>HIM!!X88,1-()*2<B!&)<!'08#!()@0)8+(,)!?,02-!;$!&)!()5&2(-!=1(,1!1$'+1&()+>!

O<A*!$-&*"&*O&=/&7(%)&*6$)/1+*M-*"*\-0>%##%@1-*5->-+G*2)0*F-2">"(%)&*

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o&3+$1!&! @01<! -$+$1A()&+(,)! ?#$1$! =2&()+(33! $'+&;2('#$'! &8+0&2! #&1A! &)-! &3+$1!$D#&0'+()*!+#$!1$A$-<!,3!-&A&*$'>!

! HIK>! 6--* \-00G* C+/7A* J##N&B! JTU! P>7>! &+! JM! 91$`0(1()*! +#&+! 1$'+1(8+(,)'! ;&'$-! ,)! +#$!'0;@$8+! A&++$1! ,3! +#$! '=$$8#! ()! `0$'+(,)! A0'+! ;$! l)$8$''&1<! +,! '$15$! &! 8,A=$22()*! '+&+$!()+$1$'+!&)-!)&11,?2<!-1&?)!+,!&8#($5$!+#&+!$)-l:>!! HIO>! 6--* c&2;,&! F'2&)-! V(22>! F))B! F)8>! 5>! .$A$)B! HMT! Q>O-! OOIB! OM]! 94&2>! KUUN:!9n$))&1-B! />B! -(''$)+()*:! 981(+(8(\()*! +#$!A&@,1(+<! 3,1! *1&)+()*! ()@0)8+(5$! 1$2($3! -$'=(+$! +#$!2&8E!,3!&!'#,?()*!l+#&+!+#$!-$3$)-&)+C'!?1,)*302!&8+'!+#1$&+$)!+,!8&0'$!(11$=&1&;2$!()@01($'B!,)$'! +#&+! 8&)),+! ;$! &-$`0&+$2<! 8,A=$)'&+$-! ()! -&A&*$'l:! 9()+$1)&2! `0,+&+(,)! A&1E'!,A(++$-:>!! HIJ>! 6--8*-A'AB 5AJA<AB!MUM!P>7>!&+!OIK!98&0+(,)()*!&*&()'+!&--1$''()*!lA$''&*$'!m;&'$-!,)! 5(102$)+! ),+(,)'! ,3! 1&8(&2! '0=1$A&8<C!>!>!>!>!r;<s! '(2$)8()*! '=$$8#! ,)! +#$! ;&'('! ,3! (+'!8,)+$)+l:!98(+&+(,)'!,A(++$-:>!! HIM>! 6--8*-A'AB*%+A!&+!O]K!9l4,)+$)+L;&'$-!1$*02&+(,)'!&1$!=1$'0A=+(5$2<!()5&2(->l:>!! HIT>! 6--*M"1@)"B!HMT!Q>O-!&+!OM]!9n$))&1-B!/>B!-(''$)+()*:!981(+(8(\()*!+#$!A&@,1(+<!3,1!;<=&''()*!+#$!(11$=&1&;2$!()@01<!1$`0(1$A$)+!()!*1&)+()*!=2&()+(33!()@0)8+(5$!1$2($3:>!HINA* 6--* %+>! &+! OMN! 9l"#$! ()@0)8+(,)! #$1$! ('! ),+! )$8$''&1<! +,! =1,+$8+! &)<! 8,A=$22()*!

'+&+$!()+$1$'+!,1!&)<!(A=,1+&)+!=0;2(8!=,2(8<>l:>!

Page 28: Speech Regulation: Why an Injunction Should be Permissible Under

KKK PQ*!J6RA*S*,CC*.A*3A*5A*6T3A*.U6KO3C*PYj*VWXXYZ

c$8&0'$! l+#$! ()@0)8+(,)! ('! &! A08#! A,1$! =,?$1302! ?$&=,)! +#&)! &!'+&+0+$!>!>!>!r(+s!'#,02-!;$!'0;@$8+$-!+,!*1$&+$1!'&3$*0&1-'>lHI]!!X88,1-()*2<B!&!8,01+!'#,02-!(''0$!&)!()@0)8+(,)!,)2<!&3+$1!3()-()*!+#&+!+#$!=2&()+(33!'033$1$-!&8+0&2! #&1A! 31,A! -$3&A&+,1<! '+&+$A$)+'>! ! X! 1$`0(1$-! '#,?()*! ,3! &8+0&2!#&1A!?,02-! $)'01$! +#$! =1,#(;(+(,)! ,3! &)! ()-(5(-0&2C'! '=$$8#! ('! ),+! ;&'$-!',2$2<! ,)! 3&2'$! '+&+$A$)+'! ,3! 3&8+B! ?#(8#! &1$! l()$5(+&;2$! ()! 31$$! -$;&+$B!&)-!>!>!>! A0'+! ;$! =1,+$8+$-! (3! +#$! 31$$-,A'! ,3! $D=1$''(,)! &1$! +,! #&5$! +#$!m;1$&+#()*!'=&8$C!+#&+!+#$<!m)$$-!>!>!>!+,!'015(5$>ClHII

X!-$3&A&+(,)!&8+(,)!'#,02-!&2',! ()820-$!&! @01<! +1(&2! +,!-$+$1A()$! +#$!)&+01$!&)-!$D+$)+!,3!+#$!#&1A>KUU!!/01($'!&1$!&)!()+$*1&2!3&8+,1!()!+,1+!82&(A'!;$8&0'$! +#$<! 8#$8E! +#$! *,5$1)A$)+C'! =,?$1! ;<! -(20+()*! +#$! =,?$1! ,3! +#$!@0-*$>KUH! ! X)-! ),+$-! =1$5(,0'2<B! lr+s#$! 1(*#+! +,! 31$$! '=$$8#! '#,02-! ),+!2(*#+2<!;$!=2&8$-!?(+#()!+#$!8,)+1,2!,3!&!'()*2$!A&)!,1!?,A&)>lKUK!!c$8&0'$!&!@01<!('!8,A=,'$-!,3!A,1$!+#&)!,)$!()-(5(-0&2B!(+!('!A,1$!1$=1$'$)+&+(5$!,3!+#$! 5&20$'! ,3! +#$! 8,AA0)(+<>KUO! ! "#('! &'=$8+! ('! $'=$8(&22<! (A=,1+&)+! 3,1!-$3&A&+(,)!82&(A'!;$8&0'$!&)!$2$A$)+!,3!-$3&A&+(,)!3,1!+#$!@01<!+,!-$8(-$!('!?#$+#$1!+#$!=2&()+(33!'033$1$-!1$=0+&+(,)&2!#&1A!',!l&'!+,!2,?$1!#(A!()!+#$!$'+(A&+(,)!,3! +#$!8,AA0)(+<!,1! +,!-$+$1! +#(1-!=$1',)'! 31,A!&'',8(&+()*!,1!-$&2()*!?(+#!#(A>lKUJ!!b$)8$B!&!@01<C'!-$8('(,)!('B!(-$&22<B!A,1$!1$32$8+(5$!,3!+#$! 8,AA0)(+<C'! $'+(A&+(,)! ,3! ?#$+#$1! '=$$8#! &8+0&22<! 2,?$1$-! &)!()-(5(-0&2C'!1$=0+&+(,)!+#&)!+#&+!,3!&!'()*2$!@0-*$>!

X)! ()@0)8+(,)! 3,1! -$3&A&+(,)! '#,02-! ;$! =$1A(''(;2$! &3+$1! $D#&0'+()*!+#$! +1&-(+(,)&2! 1$A$-<! ,3! -&A&*$'! 3,1! -$3&A&+(,)>! !W,)$<! -&A&*$'!A&<!()820-$!=0)(+(5$!-&A&*$'! (3! +#$!=2&()+(33!8&)!'#,?!+#$!-$3$)-&)+!-$3&A$-!?(+#! &8+0&2! A&2(8$>KUM! ! c$8&0'$! 8,A=$)'&+,1<! -&A&*$'! A&<! ),+! -$+$1! &!

! HI]>! W&-'$)! 5>! %,A$)C'! b$&2+#! 4+1>B! F)8>B! MHK! P>7>! NMOB! NIO! 9HIIJ:! 978&2(&B! />B!8,)8011()*!()!=&1+!&)-!-(''$)+()*!()!=&1+:>!! HII>! G$?!d,1E!"(A$'!4,>!5>!7022(5&)B!ONT!P>7>!KMJB!KNH!9HITO:!9`0,+()*!GXX4Q>!5>!c0++,)B!ONH!P>7>!JHMB!JOO!9HITO::>!! KUU>! "#('!G,+$! '0**$'+'! +#&+! +#$!0)(`0$!)&+01$!,3!&!-$3&A&+(,)!&8+(,)!8,A=$2'!&! @01<!+1(&2! +,! -$+$1A()$! `0$'+(,)'! ,3! 3&8+>! ! F+! -,$'! ),+! &--1$''! +#$! (''0$! ,3! ?#$+#$1! +#$!-('+()8+(5$)$''! ,3! &! -$3&A&+(,)! 82&(A! '#,02-! =1$820-$! &)<! 1(*#+! +,! ?&(5$! &! @01<! +1(&2B! &'!=1$'81(;$-!;<!'+&+$!,1!3$-$1&2!'+&+0+$>!! KUH>! 6--!6XGhS.Qb!G> /SGXnXF"B!"bR!XWR6F4XG!/P6d!7d7"RW!KN!9KUUO:!9lr/s01($'!3(+!()+,!&)!,5$1&22!'8#$A$!,3!&!*,5$1)A$)+!,3!8#$8E'!&)-!;&2&)8$'>l:>!! KUK>! W&-'$)B!MHK!P>7>!&+!NIO!978&2(&B!/>B!8,)8011()*!()!=&1+!&)-!-(''$)+()*!()!=&1+:>!!! KUO>! 6--!/,)&E&(+B!#/[0"!),+$!KUHB!&+!TN!9lr"s#$!8,AA0)(+<rs!('!A,1$!1$=1$'$)+&+(5$!,3!+#$!-(5$1'$!()+$1$'+'!,3!+#$!=$,=2$!+#&)!&!@0-*$>l:>!! KUJ>! 6R7"X"RWRG"!97R4SGh:!Sg!"S6"7!v!MMI!9HINN:>!! KUM>! 6--!G$?!d,1E!"(A$'!4,>! 5>!7022(5&)B! ONT!P>7>! KMJB!KNIZ]U! 9HITJ:! 9'0**$'+()*!+#&+! &! =0;2(8! ,33(8(&2! =2&()+(33! A0'+! =1,5$! +#&+! &! '+&+$A$)+! ?&'! A&-$! ?(+#! &8+0&2! A&2(8$!;$3,1$!1$8,5$1()*!-&A&*$':>!

Page 29: Speech Regulation: Why an Injunction Should be Permissible Under

6\CC3R*5CcU,JKOT9^**O9.U93KOT9*\5TM,CDJKO3! KKO!

?$&2+#<! ,1! =$1'('+$)+! -$3$)-&)+B! +#$! =2&()+(33! '#,02-! =01'0$! =0)(+(5$!-&A&*$'! (3! +#$1$! ('! &! =,''(;(2(+<! ,3! =1,5()*! &8+0&2! A&2(8$>KUT! ! 70()*! 3,1!=0)(+(5$!-&A&*$'!$)'01$'! +#&+!A,)$<!-&A&*$'!&1$!$D#&0'+$-!&)-! +#&+! +#$!-$3$)-&)+! ?(22! ;$! ()$33$8+(5$! ()! +#$! 30+01$! (3! #$! 8,)+()0$'! +,! -$3&A$>KUNc$8&0'$! &! =0;2(8! 3(*01$! A0'+! &2?&<'! '#,?! &8+0&2! A&2(8$! +,! =1$5&(2! ()! &!-$3&A&+(,)!'0(+B!&!=0;2(8!3(*01$!A0'+!&2?&<'!=01'0$!=0)(+(5$!-&A&*$'!3(1'+!;$3,1$! &! 8,01+!?(22! 8,)'(-$1! &)! ()@0)8+(5$! 1$A$-<>KU]! ! F)! ',A$! 8&'$'! 93,1!$D&A=2$B!(3!+#$!-$3$)-&)+!('!()',25$)+:B!@0-*A$)+'!&*&()'+!#(A!?(22!),+!-$+$1!#('!-$3&A&+,1<!;$#&5(,1>!!b,?$5$1B!1$*&1-2$''!,3!+#$!-$3$)-&)+C'!3()&)8(&2!'(+0&+(,)B! &! =2&()+(33! '#,02-! ,;+&()! &! @0-*A$)+! 3,1!A,)$<!-&A&*$'! ;$3,1$!'$$E()*!&)!()@0)8+(,)>! !S+#$1?('$B!8,)-(+(,)()*!31$$-,A!,3!'=$$8#!0=,)!&!-$3$)-&)+C'! ?$&2+#! ?,02-! ;$! ()8,)'('+$)+! ?(+#! +#$! g(1'+! XA$)-A$)+C'!*0&1&)+$$>KUI

X3+$1!$D#&0'+()*!+#$!1$A$-<!,3!-&A&*$'B!(3!&!-$3$)-&)+!8,)+()0$'!#('!+,1+0,0'B! -$3&A&+,1<! ;$#&5(,1B! (+! ('! '033(8($)+! +,! '#,?! +#&+! &)! &?&1-! ,3!-&A&*$'!('! ()$33$8+(5$!1$2($3!&)-!+#&+!&)!()@0)8+(,)!('!)$8$''&1<!+,!=1$5$)+!30+01$B! (11$=&1&;2$! #&1A>! !j$)$1&2! $`0(+<! =1()8(=2$'! '+&+$Y! ! lrX! ()@0)8+(,)!(''0$'! ,)2<! (3! +#$1$! ('! &! '#,?()*! +#&+! +#$! -$3$)-&)+! #&'! 5(,2&+$-B! ,1!(AA()$)+2<!?(22! 5(,2&+$B! ',A$!=1,5('(,)!,3! '+&+0+,1<!,1! 8,AA,)! 2&?B! &)-!+#&+!+#$1$!('!&!m8,*)(\&;2$!-&)*$1!,3!1$8011$)+!5(,2&+(,)>ClKHU!!X88,1-()*2<B!&!=2&()+(33! A&<! A,5$! 3,1! &)! ()@0)8+(,)! +,! =1$5$)+! 1$8011()*! #&1A>! ! X+! +#('!=,()+B! &3+$1! -&A&*$'! ?$1$! =1,5$)! +,! ;$! ()&-$`0&+$! &)-! +#$! 2(E$2(#,,-! ,3!8,)+()0()*! #&1A! ('! (AA()$)+B! +#$1$! ('! &! 8,A=$22()*! '+&+$! ()+$1$'+! +,! -$+$1!30+01$B! #&1A302! -$3&A&+(,)>KHH! ! X! =1,=$12<! +&(2,1$-! ()@0)8+(,)! 3,1!

! KUT>! 6--8*-A'AB!c&2;,&! F'2&)-!V(22>! F))B! F)8>!5>!.$A$)B!HMT!Q>O-!OOIB!OTJ! 94&2>!KUUN:!9%$1-$*&1B! />B! 8,)8011()*! ()! =&1+! &)-! -(''$)+()*! ()! =&1+:! 9lF3B! &3+$1! =&<()*! -&A&*$'B!-$3$)-&)+!8,)+()0$'!+,!0++$1!-$3&A&+,1<!'+&+$A$)+'!&)-!(+!('!=1,5$-!'#$!-(-!',!()+$)+(,)&22<!&)-!A&2(8(,0'2<B!+#$!2&?!=1,5(-$'!3,1!=0)(+(5$!-&A&*$'>l:>!! KUN>! 6--* %+A* &+! OMH! 9A&@,1(+<! ,=()(,):! 9),+()*! +#&+! lA,)$<! -&A&*$'! ?(22! ),+! &2?&<'!*(5$!+#$!=2&()+(33!$33$8+(5$!1$2($3!31,A!&!8,)+()0()*!=&++$1)!,3!-$3&A&+(,)l:>!! KU]>! 6-- 9-:* f)0?* K%>-#* 3)AB! ONT! P>7>! &+! KNIZ]U! 9-$82&1()*! +#&+! &! =0;2(8! ,33(8(&2!=2&()+(33! A0'+! =1,5$! +#&+! &! '+&+$A$)+! ?&'! A&-$! ?(+#! &8+0&2! A&2(8$! ;$3,1$! 1$8,5$1()*!-&A&*$':>!! KUI>! 6--! %(22()*! 5>! W&\\,8,)$B! OIO! X>K-! HHMMB! HHM]! 9Q&>! HIN]:! 9'+&+()*! +#&+! +#$!8,)'+(+0+(,)&2! 1(*#+! +,! 31$$2<! $D=1$''! ,)$C'! ,=()(,)! '#,02-! ),+! ;$! 8,)-(+(,)$-! 0=,)! +#$!$8,),A(8!'+&+0'!,3!+#$!()-(5(-0&2!&''$1+()*!+#&+!1(*#+:>!! KHU>! W&-'$)!5>!%,A$)C'!b$&2+#!4+1>B! MHK!P>7>!NMOB! NTT!)>O! 9HIIJ:! 9`0,+()*!P)(+$-!7+&+$'!5>!%>">!j1&)+!4,>B!OJM!P>7>!TKIB!TOO!9HIMO::>!! KHH>! 32A! 4c7B! F)8>! 5>! h&5('B! MHU! P>7>! HOHMB! HOHN! 9HIIJ:! 9lr%s$! #&5$! (A=,'$-! +#('!mA,'+! $D+1&,1-()&1<! 1$A$-r<sC! ,)2<!?#$1$! +#$! $5(2! +#&+!?,02-! 1$'02+! 31,A! +#$! 1$=,1+&*$! ('!;,+#!*1$&+! &)-! 8$1+&()! &)-! 8&)),+! ;$!A(+(*&+$-!;<! 2$''! ()+10'(5$!A$&'01$'>l! 9`0,+()*!G$;>!Q1$''!X''C)!5>!7+0&1+B!JKN!P>7>!MOIB!MMI!9HINT:::>!

Page 30: Speech Regulation: Why an Injunction Should be Permissible Under

KKJ PQ*!J6RA*S*,CC*.A*3A*5A*6T3A*.U6KO3C*PYj*VWXXYZ

-$3&A&+(,)!('!)$8$''&1<!&)-!('!+#$!,)2<!=,''(;2$!1$2($3!&5&(2&;2$!+,!'$15$!+#('!8,A=$22()*!'+&+$!()+$1$'+>!

O<A**3)&71/#%)&*

J'/%1"0! &)-! M"1@)"* ;,+#! ',0*#+! +,! $)@,()! '=$$8#! -$'=(+$! +#$! g(1'+!XA$)-A$)+C'! #$&5<! =1$'0A=+(,)! &*&()'+! +#$! 5&2(-(+<! ,3! =1(,1! 1$'+1&()+'>!!J'/%1"0C'!()@0)8+(,)B!&!8,)+$)+L)$0+1&2!1$'+1(8+(,)!,)!'=$$8#!$D=1$''$-!()!&!=1(5&+$! 3,10AB! ?&'! ),+! &)! ()5&2(-! =1(,1! 1$'+1&()+>! ! b,?$5$1B! M"1@)"C'!()@0)8+(,)!?&'!,5$12<!;1,&-!;$8&0'$!(+!-(-!),+!1$`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