south buffalo creek water quality and habitat improvement ... · south buffalo creek water quality...

23
South Buffalo Creek Water Quality and Habitat Improvement Project A Decade of Lessons Learned and Applied Using Adaptive Management and Design Jeremy McCall, P.E., CFM Greensboro, NC Water Resources Department [email protected] Jennifer Murphy, P.E. Kimley-Horn [email protected]

Upload: others

Post on 18-Jul-2020

0 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: South Buffalo Creek Water Quality and Habitat Improvement ... · South Buffalo Creek Water Quality and Habitat Improvement Project A Decade of Lessons Learned and Applied Using Adaptive

South Buffalo Creek Water Quality and Habitat Improvement ProjectA Decade of Lessons Learned and Applied Using Adaptive Management and Design

Jeremy McCall, P.E., CFMGreensboro, NC Water Resources [email protected]

Jennifer Murphy, P.E. [email protected]

Page 2: South Buffalo Creek Water Quality and Habitat Improvement ... · South Buffalo Creek Water Quality and Habitat Improvement Project A Decade of Lessons Learned and Applied Using Adaptive

Presentation Outline

• Project Background and Overview• Construction of Phases I-III• Repairs to Previous Phases• Phase IV• Lessons Learned

Page 3: South Buffalo Creek Water Quality and Habitat Improvement ... · South Buffalo Creek Water Quality and Habitat Improvement Project A Decade of Lessons Learned and Applied Using Adaptive

Project Background and Overview• History and Project Goals• Site Location and Acquisition• Greensboro’s Goals and Requirements• Design Approach and Objectives

Page 4: South Buffalo Creek Water Quality and Habitat Improvement ... · South Buffalo Creek Water Quality and Habitat Improvement Project A Decade of Lessons Learned and Applied Using Adaptive

Clean Water Management Trust Fund Grant

• Applied for grants in 2008, 2012, 2013, 2014, and 2015• Awarded a total of $1,467,350!

Page 5: South Buffalo Creek Water Quality and Habitat Improvement ... · South Buffalo Creek Water Quality and Habitat Improvement Project A Decade of Lessons Learned and Applied Using Adaptive

The Original Plan: Three Phases

§̈¦40 §̈¦85

§̈¦40

§̈¦85

South Buffalo Creek

UT3 UT2

Kersey Tributary

Piedmont Creek

UT1

"

Phase II - Construction Completed 2014

"

Phase III - Construction Completed 2015"

Phase I - Construction Completed 2013

W Meadwoview Rd

Farragut St

Phase Boundaries I-IIIWetland SloughBankfull BenchStructuresRestored Centerlines

Page 6: South Buffalo Creek Water Quality and Habitat Improvement ... · South Buffalo Creek Water Quality and Habitat Improvement Project A Decade of Lessons Learned and Applied Using Adaptive

Existing Floodplain Slough Wetlands

Page 7: South Buffalo Creek Water Quality and Habitat Improvement ... · South Buffalo Creek Water Quality and Habitat Improvement Project A Decade of Lessons Learned and Applied Using Adaptive

South Buffalo Constructed Slough

Early Spring 2014

Late Spring 2014 with sediment deposition

July 2018

Page 8: South Buffalo Creek Water Quality and Habitat Improvement ... · South Buffalo Creek Water Quality and Habitat Improvement Project A Decade of Lessons Learned and Applied Using Adaptive

Piedmont Creek Enhancement

MapSpring 2014

Piedmont Creek

Before construction

Page 9: South Buffalo Creek Water Quality and Habitat Improvement ... · South Buffalo Creek Water Quality and Habitat Improvement Project A Decade of Lessons Learned and Applied Using Adaptive

Kersey Tributary Relocation

South Buffalo Creek

Kersey Tributary

W Meadwoview Rd

Map

Before construction

3 months after construction

5 years after construction

Kersey

Page 10: South Buffalo Creek Water Quality and Habitat Improvement ... · South Buffalo Creek Water Quality and Habitat Improvement Project A Decade of Lessons Learned and Applied Using Adaptive

July 6, 2018

Piedmont Creek Repair During Phase IV

October 2016July 19, 2018

Page 11: South Buffalo Creek Water Quality and Habitat Improvement ... · South Buffalo Creek Water Quality and Habitat Improvement Project A Decade of Lessons Learned and Applied Using Adaptive

Kersey Tributary Repair During Phase IV

Damage from beaver activity

Immediately after repair

Page 12: South Buffalo Creek Water Quality and Habitat Improvement ... · South Buffalo Creek Water Quality and Habitat Improvement Project A Decade of Lessons Learned and Applied Using Adaptive

South Buffalo Creek

• Drainage area of 15 square miles• Highly urban• 30% to 35% impervious cover• On 303(d) list as impaired biology (fish and benthos)• Featureless bed form (poor habitat)• Eroding banks

Page 13: South Buffalo Creek Water Quality and Habitat Improvement ... · South Buffalo Creek Water Quality and Habitat Improvement Project A Decade of Lessons Learned and Applied Using Adaptive

Incision of South Buffalo CreekVegetated soil lift

from previous phase

Boulder once covered by stream invert

Approximately 1.5 feet of incision from Phase III construction to

Phase IV design

Page 14: South Buffalo Creek Water Quality and Habitat Improvement ... · South Buffalo Creek Water Quality and Habitat Improvement Project A Decade of Lessons Learned and Applied Using Adaptive

Phase IV!

§̈¦40 §̈¦85

§̈¦40

§̈¦85

South Buffalo Creek

UT3 UT2

Kersey Tributary

Piedmont Creek

UT1

"

Phase II - Construction Completed 2014

"

Phase III - Construction Completed 2015

"

Phase I - Construction Completed 2013

W Meadwoview Rd

Farragut StStructures - Phase IVPhase IV Project BoundaryPhase Boundaries I-IIIWetland SloughBankfull BenchStructures - Phases I-IIIRestored Centerlines

"

Phase IV - Construction Completed 2018

Page 15: South Buffalo Creek Water Quality and Habitat Improvement ... · South Buffalo Creek Water Quality and Habitat Improvement Project A Decade of Lessons Learned and Applied Using Adaptive

Incision of South Buffalo Creek

• Adjust profile with riffles and J-Hook structures• Tie in to existing structures and bedrock• Reduce channel width and construct benches

Page 16: South Buffalo Creek Water Quality and Habitat Improvement ... · South Buffalo Creek Water Quality and Habitat Improvement Project A Decade of Lessons Learned and Applied Using Adaptive

Inner Berm and Bankfull BenchBankfull bench

Inner berm bench

Page 17: South Buffalo Creek Water Quality and Habitat Improvement ... · South Buffalo Creek Water Quality and Habitat Improvement Project A Decade of Lessons Learned and Applied Using Adaptive

Rock Vane to Cross Vane with RiffleExisting vane Converted structure

Urban fish habitat

Page 18: South Buffalo Creek Water Quality and Habitat Improvement ... · South Buffalo Creek Water Quality and Habitat Improvement Project A Decade of Lessons Learned and Applied Using Adaptive

Toe Wood

South Buffalo Creek left bank looking downstream, immediately before construction of toe wood

Completed toe wood and bank grading

Toe wood under construction

Page 19: South Buffalo Creek Water Quality and Habitat Improvement ... · South Buffalo Creek Water Quality and Habitat Improvement Project A Decade of Lessons Learned and Applied Using Adaptive

Rock Toe ProtectionBefore Phase IV

Rock toe and bank grading

Page 20: South Buffalo Creek Water Quality and Habitat Improvement ... · South Buffalo Creek Water Quality and Habitat Improvement Project A Decade of Lessons Learned and Applied Using Adaptive

Log J-Hook with Constructed RiffleLog

Constructed riffle

Page 21: South Buffalo Creek Water Quality and Habitat Improvement ... · South Buffalo Creek Water Quality and Habitat Improvement Project A Decade of Lessons Learned and Applied Using Adaptive

Lessons Learned• It takes a lot of staff!• Don’t be afraid of the “big” channel• Include language for adjusting inverts in the field during

construction• Ensure structures are installed per the detail – or find another

way!• If you build it, they will come• Creative debris disposal….

Stump grave

Page 22: South Buffalo Creek Water Quality and Habitat Improvement ... · South Buffalo Creek Water Quality and Habitat Improvement Project A Decade of Lessons Learned and Applied Using Adaptive

Next Steps• Final plantings• Annual inspection by City• Invasive species program• Observation!

Page 23: South Buffalo Creek Water Quality and Habitat Improvement ... · South Buffalo Creek Water Quality and Habitat Improvement Project A Decade of Lessons Learned and Applied Using Adaptive

Questions?Jeremy McCall, P.E., CFMCity of Greensboro, NC Water Resources Department2602 South Elm-Eugene Street Greensboro, NC [email protected](336) 373-2527

Jennifer Murphy, P.E. Kimley-Horn 421 Fayetteville Street, Suite 600Raleigh, NC [email protected](919) 677-2072