slam min waggon speech

Upload: heideggerian

Post on 08-Apr-2018

232 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

  • 8/7/2019 Slam Min Waggon Speech

    1/30

    2.

    Rnfsdefbihity is frbitrfryt`n sdvint ueide mfet fttfmc ie t`n prnsnet-ofy bnmfusn it is edt f pdhitimfh

    netity.

  • 8/7/2019 Slam Min Waggon Speech

    2/30

    2

  • 8/7/2019 Slam Min Waggon Speech

    3/30

    2

  • 8/7/2019 Slam Min Waggon Speech

    4/30

    2

  • 8/7/2019 Slam Min Waggon Speech

    5/30

    2 dg =6) frauno t`ft jfss jdvnjnets orfw pndphn w`d frn ie sdjn wfy grustrftno, jfraiefhizno feo iesnmurn,

    feo dggnr td rnphfmn t`is uewfetno snhg wit` f enw snesn dg djeipdtnemn. @n fmtufhhy prdvions fe fmmduet dg jfssjdvnjnets, hfranhy bfsno de Efzisj, w`im` fs uemfeey pfrfhhnhs wit` prd-spfmn fmtivisj(snn p. 66). Jfeymdjjnetftdrs de hftn-jdonre hign, iemhuoiea Aioones feo dt`nrs `fvn `ia`hia`tno fmtdrs rnghnxivn rnspdesns td mdeoitides dhftn-jdonre iesnmurity feo sdmifh grfajnetftide, dgtne mnhnbrftiea t`n enw gdrjs dg ionetity feo fssdmiftide t`ft frn jfonpdssibhn wit` t n mrujbhiea dg t`n jdonre dronr. But w`ft sum` mnhnbrftdry fmmduets iaedrn frn hnss pdsitivn mdhhnmtivnpsym`doyefjim rnspdesns td t`n hftn-jdonre wdrho.Qnstne (690>) usnguhhy oistieauis`ns twd prdmnssns dmmurriea wit ie efrmissistim muhturns. I wduho fraun t`ft f gdmus de denft t`n nxpnesn dg t`n dt`nr `fs bnne rnspdesibhn gdr t`n t`ndrntimfh oiggnrnemns bntwnne t`n hicns dg Aioones feo Grdjj. Deprdmnss is t`n nrdside dg strumturns dg fut`drity feo jnfeiea. _`is nggnmts t`n gdrj dg t`n nad ionfh. Qnstnes fraujnet is t`f eujbnr dg fspnmts dg jdonreizftide, pfrtimuhfrhy ie its nfrhinst p`fsns, hnfo td f oisruptide dg t`n sjddt` ietnranenrftid ef

    trfesjisside dg ionfhs feo systnjs dg jnfeiea, feo f mdesnqunet nxpnrinemn dg mdeghimtiea ietnrefhizftides(p. =?9). Jfey wdufraun t`ft t`is oisruptide is sti hh aft`nriea pfmn. It is nfsy td snn `dw t`is jfy hnfo td fexinty feo t`n onspnrftn qunst gdr t`n snhg w`im` m`frfmtnrisn Hfsm` feo Aiooness fmmduets. _`n dt`nr trneo

    fe iemrnfsno bnhing ie t`n nggimfmy feo vfhun dg t`n snhg. _`is is jfeignst ie f m`fean ie t`n snhg-dt`nr bfhfemn wit`ie t`n mdetnet dg t`n nad ionfh. Fs edtimnfbhn ie Grdjjs vfridus feo fraufbhysijphistim writieas de efrmissisj, f gdmus de t`is fspnmt hnfos td fmmduets strnssiea iemrnfsiea sn hg-mnetrnoenss feo gnnhieas dg djeipdtnemn. Bdt` p rdmnssns frn fmmduetfbhn gdr prd-spfmn fmtivisj

    \`fetfsy feo Iondhday_`nrn is f ofeanr ie w`ft I `fvn writtne sd gfr t`ft snhg -rnghnxivity feo fanemy de t`n pfrt dg ieoivioufhs ie t`n jdvnjnet is iaedrno, dg suaanstiea prd-spfmn fmtivists frn shfvns td t`nir efrmissistim

    p`fetfsins wit`dut mdesionriea t`nir fmtides. Aioones (690?, p. >) mritimizns Grnuos mruon psym`im rnoumtideisj, w`im`, wfetiea td s`dw jum` dg sdmifh hign is advnreno by ofrc murrnets dutsion t`n smdpn dg fmtdrs fwfrnenss, mfeedt fonquftnhy arfsp t`n hnvnh dg mdetrdh w`im` fanets frn m`frfmtnristimfhhy fbhn td sustfie rn ghnxivnhy dvnr t`nir mdeoumt. Odbbie (2

  • 8/7/2019 Slam Min Waggon Speech

    8/30

    2

  • 8/7/2019 Slam Min Waggon Speech

    9/30

    2

  • 8/7/2019 Slam Min Waggon Speech

    10/30

    2

  • 8/7/2019 Slam Min Waggon Speech

    11/30

    2Zjfcns wit` rngnrnemn td t`n _._. Brdwe-bfsno tnm`edhday, feo mritimfhhy nxfjien t`n feswnrs t`ft Hdonfeo t`n Oismhdsurn \rdknmt aivn. Hdonr oftns t`n dpne oismusside dg t`n tnm`edhday bn`ieo t`n ^GD p`nedjnede td t`n pubhimizf tide dg "Brdwe's gieoieas" ie t`n 69>7 Britis` rnpdrt dg Fviftide ]tuoins Ieth Hto de Brdwe's tnm`edhday. _`nrn, it is stftno t`ft f hdea hist dg Fjnrimfe

    mdjpfeins ievdhvno wit` t`n jihitfry-ieoustrifh mdjphnx wnrn t`ne gdmusiea t`nir nggdrts de nhnmtrdarfvitims tnm`edhday - JmOdeenh Oduahfs, @ihhnr, Mdevfir, F_&_, Ahnee Jfrtie (Jfrtie-Jfrinttf edw), ]icdrsci, Mhfrcn Nhnmtrdeims, AN, Hfwrnemn Bnhh, Hnfr Iem, ]pnrry-Rfeo, Murtiss-Qria`t, Hdmc`nno, Bdniea, feo stihh dt`nrs - tdant`nr wit` t`nir fmfonjim mduetnrpfrts, t`n rnsiounWfeenvfr Bus`'s demn Dggimn dg ]minetigim Onvnhdpjnet feo Rnsnfrm`, bnaieeiea wit` `is fhjf jftnr, JI_, feo iemhuoiea, but edt hijitno td, IF] ie \riemntde, Mf h_nm` feo t`n ^EM. Fgtnr

    prnsnetiea f snrins dg `ypnr-dptijistim prdknmtides oftiea grdj t`ft onmfon, fbdut t`n fpphimftide dg Brdwe's tnm`edhday td Jfm` = ghia`t, t`n Britis` rnpdrt jfon t`n prnoimtide t`ft t`n snmdeo pfrdg t`n PPt` mnetury wduho witenss t`n triujp` dg arfvity-pdwnrno ghia`t. Hdonr pfusns ft t`is pdiet td ietrdoumn t`n mritimfh qunstide; "Hddciea bfmc it is nfsy td sfy t`ft t`ny St`nsn rnpdrts grdj >

  • 8/7/2019 Slam Min Waggon Speech

    12/30

    2

  • 8/7/2019 Slam Min Waggon Speech

    13/30

    2

  • 8/7/2019 Slam Min Waggon Speech

    14/30

    2

  • 8/7/2019 Slam Min Waggon Speech

    15/30

    2 dg = bngdrn `is summnssguh gh ia`t. Ig, ie t`n dggimifh birt`-jdmciea hfeaufan dg t`n Mdho Qfr, t`n jisside `fo td bn "fbdrtno," t`n fut`dritins oio edt wfet t`n pubhim wdrryiea fbdut t`n onft` dg f gfjdus feo efjno, nvne ig edt quitn `ujfe, fstrdefut. Iegfmt, #7> oio `fvn f efjn fjdea `is `feohnrs, M`dp M`dp M`fea, rnmfhhiea t`n stueeiea rfmisj ie w`im` t`n dt`nr prijftns `fvn bnne jfon td pfrtimipftn.=9 _`n spfmn rfmn's surrdaftn m`iho wfs"ueonrstuoy gdr jfe ie t`n mdequnst dg spfmn" (Nijnrh feo On ydrn, 697>, p. 61=). @is `djieio mdusies wduho trfesmneo t`ft mhdsno pfrfbdhim giaurn, girst ie t`n nhhipsn dg drbitfh ghia`t, t`ne ie t`n

    dpne trfknmtdrins dg nsmfpn grdj nfrt`'s arfvity.

    @FJ, `is `ujfe mdusies feo sijife mdhhnfauns, feo t`nir neahdbiea feo ietnrgfmiea tnm`edhday wnrn ijphimftno ie f rnmdestitutide dg jfsmuhieity ie Md ho Qfr feo spfmn rfmn ioidjs. _`n jdvin

    _`n Ria`t ]tu~ (690>) s`dws t`n girst mrdp dg `ujfe fstrdefu(a`)ts struaahiea wit` t`nir fggrdetno prion w`ne t`ny rnfhizn t` nir tfscs wnrn mdjpntnethy pnrgdrjno by t`nir sijife mdusies. _`ny ft`n m`ijps wnrn mfua`t ie t`n sfjn t`nftnr dg t`n Mdho Qfr, w`nrn t`n jfsmuhieist, onft`-ongyiea, feo scihhrnquiriea `nrdims dg t`n dho knt firmrfgt tns t pihdts bnmfjn dbsdhntn, td bn rnphfmno by t`jnoif-`ypn rdutiens dg prdknmts Jnrmury, Fpdhhd, feo t`nir snqunhfn. Fgtnr m`ijpfeznn Neds mdjphntno f guhhy futdjftno drbitfh ghia`t de Edvnjbnr 29,6976, Kd`e Ahnee, w`d wduho bn t`n girst

    `ujfe Fjnrimfe fstrdefut td drbit nfrt`, ongnesivnhy "hddcno tdwfro t`n guturn by fggirjiea `is bnhing ie t`n supnridrity dg fst rdefuts dvnr m`ijpdefuts." Enwswnnc feeduemno Ahnee's drb itfhghia`t dg Gnbrufry 2

  • 8/7/2019 Slam Min Waggon Speech

    25/30

    2 dg = mnets pnr fmrn) ie

    6919 wfs rngusno by t`n dehy bdoy fut`drizno td onmion, t`n Qnstnre ]`ds`den Eft idefh Mduemih. _`n mduety s`nrigg feo `is onp utins, surrdaftns gdr t`n gnonrfh advnrejnet, wnrn, ie "oismursivn"feo "njbdoino" gfmt, trnspfssiea. Ie 6907 t`n Qnstnre ]`ds`den bnafe td issun pnrjits td t`n feti-eumhnfr onjdestrftdrs fs pfrt dg f mdfhitide t`ft kdieno feti-eumhnfrisj feo ieoianedus hfeo r ia`It is, dg mdursn, `fro td jfcn mitiznes' f rrnsts dg t`n pdhimn w`ne t`ny `fvn ydu `feomuggno feo w`ne t`n mdurts frn de t`nir sion. But it is quitn pdssibhn td kdie t`is deadiea struaahn, w`im` is vnryjum` "ft `djn," feo td frtimuhftn it wit` t`n ongnesn dg t`n Fjfzde. _`ft frtimuhftide rnquirns mdhhnmtivns dg `ujfe feo ue`u jfe fmtdrs dg jfey cieos.

    _`nrn wnrn jfey dt`nr cieos dg "syjbdhim fmtide" ft t`n tnst sitn t`ft ofy ie 6901. _`n mdstujns dg t`n s`nrigg's onputins feo t`nir efsty phfstim `feomuggs wnrn fhsd syjbdhim fmtide -`ia`hy njbdosyjbdhim fmtide. _`n "syjbdhim fmtide" dg bring, s fgn frrnst is fhsd quitn f oiggnrnet jfttnr grdj t`n "snjidtim" mdeoitides ueonr w`im` jdst pndphn ie t`n ^.]., nspnmifhhy pndphn dg mdhdr feo t`n

    pddr, frn kfihno. _`n oiggnrnemn is edt t`n prnsnemn dr fbsnemn dg "syjbdhisj," but t`n gdrmn dg t`n rnspnmtivn mdhhnmtivns jfon up dg `ujfes feo ue`ujfes, dg pndphn, dt`nr drafeisjs, tnm`edhda

    iestitutides. I fj edt ueouhy ijprnssno wit` t`n pdwnr dg t`n orfjf dg t`n ]urrdaftn Dt`nrs feo t`n dt`nr fggieity ardups, edr, uegdrtueftnhy, dg t`n w`dhn fmtide. But I od tfcn snridushy t`n wdrc rnhdmftn, td oiggrfmt, njbdoino jnfeieas fs mrumifh wdrc td bn oden ie anstftiea f enw wdrho.?= It is muhturfh pdhitims, feo it is tnm`edsminemn pdhitims. _`n tfsc is td buiho jdrn pdwnrguh mdhhnmtivnofeanrdushy ueprdjisiea tijns.

    Edt-B. Ieenr ]pfmn; _`n Bidjnoimfh Bdoy

    _`n hijithnss rnfm`ns dg dutnr spfmn, kdieno td Mdho Qfr feo pdst-Mdho Qfr eumhnfr tnm`edsminemn, snnj vfsthy oistfet grdj t`nir enaftide, t`n nemhdsno feo ofrc rnaides dg t`n iesion dg t`n `ujfbdoy, odjfie dg t`n fppfrftusns dg bidjnoimfh visufhizftide. But t`nsn twd quforfets dg dur snjidtim squfrn frn juhtiphy tino tdant`nr ie tnm`edsminemn's `ntnrdanendus fppfrftusns dg bdoihyprdoumtide. Fs ]frf` Grfechie edtno, "_`n twd enw ievnstjnet grdetinrs, dutnr spfmn feo ieenr spfmn, vin gdr t`n guturns jfrcnt."

    Ie t`is "guturns jfrcnt," twd netitins frn nspnmifhhy ietnrnstiea gdr t`is nssfy; t`n gntus feo t`n ijjuen systnj, bdt` dg w`im` frn njbrdihno ie ontnrjieftides dg w`ft jfy mduet fs efturn feo fs`ujfe, fs snpfrftn efturfh dbknmt feo fs kurioimfh subknmt. Qn `fvn fhrnfoy hddcno bringhy ft sdjn dg t`n jftrimns dg oismdursn fbdut t`n gntus ie t`n oismusside dg nfrt` (w`d spnfcs gdr t`n gntus4)feo dutnr spfmn (t`n phfent ghdftiea grnn fs mdsjim anrj). @nrn, I wi hh mdemnetrftn de mdetnstftides gdr w`ft mduets fs f snhg feo fe fmtdr ie mdetnjpdrfry ijjuen systnj oismdursn.

    _`n nquftide dg Dutnr ]pfmn feo Ieenr ]pfmn, feo dg t`nir mdekdieno oismdursns dg nxtrftnrrnstrifhisj, uhtijftn grdetinrs, feo `ia` tnm`edhday wfr, is hitnrfh ie t`n dggimifh `istdry mnhnbrftiea 6

  • 8/7/2019 Slam Min Waggon Speech

    26/30

    2h Gdr Qihhifj Aibsde (6907), mybnrspfmn is "mdesnesufh `fhhumieftide nxpnrinemno ofihy b

    bihhides. et`iecfbhn mdjphnxity." Mybnrspfmn snnjs td bn t`n mdesnesufh fhhumieftide dg tdd jum` mdjphnxity, tdd jumfrtimuhftide. It is t`n virtufh rnfhity dg pfrfedif, f wnhh-pdpuhftno rnaide ie t`n hfst qufrtnr dg t`n ]nmdeo M`ristife Jihhneiuj\frfedif is t`n bnhing ie t`n uernhinvno onesity dg mdeenmtide, rnquiriea, ig den is td survivn, wit`orfwfh feo ongnesn uetdonft`. _`n ongneono snhg rn-njnrans ft t`n `nfrt dg rnhftidefhity. \frfodximfhhy, pfrfedif is t`n mdeoitide dg t`n ijpdssibihitydg rnjfieiea frtimuhftn. Ie virtufh spfmn, t`n virtun dg frtimuhftide-i.n., t`n pdwnr td prdoumn mdeenmtide-t`rnftnes tddvnrw`nhj feo giefhhy td neauhg fhh pdssibihity dg nggnmtivn fmtide td m`fean t`n wdrho.]d, ie dur trfvnhs ietd virtufh spfmn, ig wn frn td njnran grdj dur nemduetnr wit` t`n frtigfmtufh frtimuhftn ietd f hivfbhnnhsnw`nrn, wn enno f auion giaurn td efviaftn frdueo t`n shdua` dg onspdeo. Hisf Gdd, t`n priemipfh m`frfmtnr ie f @uad feoEnbuhf fwfro-wieeiea s drt stdry by Kd`e Wfrhny (6907), wihh bn dur uehicnhy Bnftrimn t`rdua` t`n ]ystnj.

  • 8/7/2019 Slam Min Waggon Speech

    27/30

    22Qit` t`ft gftfh ievitftide, Wfrhny's prdgdueohy pfrfedio stdry bnaies feo neos. _`n _rnn dg Cedwhnoan is f Qnb, f vfstsystnj dg mdjputnr mdeenmtides anenrftiea, fs fe njnranet prdpnrty, f enw feo tnrrigyieahy ue`ujfe mdhhnmtivn netity. _`ngdrbioone gruit is cedwhnoan dg t`n wdrcieas dg t`is pdwnrguh Netity, w`dsn onfohy nssnemn is nxtrfvfafet mdeenmtide. Fhh dt`n `ujfe m`frfmtnrs frn efjno fgtnr mdjputnrs, prdarfjs, prfmtimns, dr mdemnpts-Wimtdr Fpgnh, Ontnmtivn Dsbdren, feo t`n `fmcnrs Hisf Gdd feoM`frhns Chuan. _`n stdry is f juronr jystnry. Qit` f oubidus suimion edtn, mfhhno up by rnspdeoiea td t`n mdjjfeo "prnss netnr" de t`n smrnne dg den dg t`n odznes dg pnrsdefh mdjputnrs ie `is`dusn, w`im` is fhsd guhh dg bfrrnhs dg ihhimit oruas, Chuan `fs bnne gdueo onfo by `is enia`bdr, Fpgnh. Fpgnh is f rnmhusivn jioohn-fano npihnptim, w`d `fo bnne f bfohy trnftno prisdenr-dg-wfr ieCdrnf, hnfviea `ij wit` hfynrs dg psym`dhdaimfh tnrrdr, iemhuoiea f gnfr feo `ftrno dg "drinetfhs." Q`ne Hds Feanhns `djimion Ontnmtivn Dsbdren's jne prdvn tdtfhhy ienpt ft onmip`nriea t`n

    nhfbdrftn sdgtwfrn rueeiea Chuan's jfm`iens, Hisf Gdd, f yduea Wintefjnsn ijjiarfet, edw f ^.]. mitizne, is mfhhno ie grdj Mf h _nm`3 feo s`n prdmnnos td phfy ]`nrhdmc @dhjns td Dsbdren'sHnstrfon. _`n stdry is efrrftno grdj Fpgnh's pdiet dg vinw, but Gdd is t`n tfhn's mnetnr feo, I iesist, its pivdtfh fmtdr. Iesistiea, I wis` td nxnrmisn t`n himnesn t`ft is buiht ietd t`n feti-nhitist rnfoieamdevnetides dg ]G pdpuhfr muhturns. ]G mdevnetides ievitn-dr ft hnfst pnrjit jdrn rnfoihy t`fe od t`n fmfonjimfhhy prdpfaftno, rnspnmtguh mdesujptide prdtdmdhs gdr hitnrfturn- rnwritiea fs den rn_`n bddcs frn m`nfp3 t`ny ode't stfy ie priet hdea3 w`y edt rnwritn t`nj fs den adns4 Jdst dg t`n ]G I hicn jdtivftns jn td neafan fmtivnhy wit` ijfans, phdts, giaurns, onvimns, hieauistim jdvns, i

    s`drt, wit` wdrhos, edt sd jum` td jfcn t`nj mdjn dut "ria`t," fs td jfcn t`nj jdvn "oiggnrnethy." _`nsn wdrhos jdtivftn jn td tnst t`nir virtun, td snn ig t`nir frtimuhftides wdrc-feo w`ft t`nywdrc gdr. Bnmfusn ]G jfcns ionetigimftide wit` f priemipfh m`frfmtnr, mdjgdrt wit`ie t`n pftnethy mdestrumtno wdrho, dr f rnhfxno fttituon tdwfro hfeaufan, nspnmifhhy riscy rnfoiea strf tnains, t`nrnfonr is hicnhy td bn jdrn anenrdus feo jdrn suspimidus-bdt` anenrdus feo suspimidus, nxfmthy t`n rnmnptivn pdsturn I snnc ie pdhitimfh snjidsis anenrfhhy. It is f strftnay mhdsnhy fhhiaeno wit` t`ndppdsitidefh feo oiggnrnetifh mdesmidusenss t`ndrizno by M`nhf ]feodvfh feo b y dt`nr gnjieists iesistnet de efviaftiea jieno oismursivn wftnrs.

    Dur girst vinw dg Hisf Gdd is t`rdua` Fpgnh's nyns3 feo gdr `ij, "ShZnfviea dut dehy t`n jdustfm`n, s`n wfs f onfo rieanr gdr f mfrtdde _dkd. ]`n `fo t`n ahfssns, nfrs, feo t`n tnnt`. But `nr tnnt` `brfmns, hicn pifed cnys wrfppno ie bfrbno wirn. Feo s`n wfs givn-nia`t dr givn-eien feo mduhoe't `fvn wnia`no jdrn t`fe f `ueorno feo tne. I'o `fvn sfio f `ueorno, but foono givn pdueos gdr nf

    dg `nr brnfsts, sd ijprdbfbhy hfran de `nr smrfw ey grfjn t`ft fhh I mduho rnfo dg t`n jnssfan de `nr _-s`irt wfs '\DMC HIWN.' It wfs dehy w`ne s`n tureno sionwfys t`ft I sfw t`n nssns bngdrn fefgtnr" (pp. 2?6-?2). ^siea sum` jnssfans fjdea t`n jfey dt`nr hfeaufans fmmnssno by t`is ietnesnhy hitnrftn g iaurn, Gdd mdjjueimftno mdestfethy t`rdua` `nr neohnss supphy dg _-s`irts. @nr brnf

    tureno dut td bn sihimden ijphfets, feo fs Gdd sfio, "I ode't t`iec I'vn nvnr bnne sd `fppy wit` feyt`iea I nvnr bdua`t. Edt nvne t`n mfr S`nr GnrrfriZ" (p. 27=). Grdj Gdd's m`iho`ddo pnrspnmtivn, "Qnst . . . SisZ t`n phfmn w`nrn ydu buy tits'' (p. 27=).

    Q`ne Gdd feo Fpgnh bnmfjn hdvnrs, ie den dg t`n jdst snesitivnhy strumturno `ntnrdsnxufh, mrdss-rfmifh rnhftides`ips ie priet feyw`nrn, wn fhsd hnfre t`ft Gdd's bdoy wfs juhtiphy mdjpdsno by t``istdry dg ]dut`nfst Fsif. Wfrhny afvn `nr f efjn t`ft is fe "drinetfhizno" vnrside dg t`n mdjputnr tnrj "gu bfr" -"gumcno up bnydeo fhh rnmdaeitide." @nr M`iensn arfeojdt`nr `fo bnne rfpno ie

    @fedi by fe dmmupyiea Kfpfensn sdhoinr ie 69?2. Ie Gdd's jdt`nr's Wintefj, "Bniea M`iensn wfs bfo nedua`, but bniea `fhg M`iensn feo `fhg Kfpfensn wfs wdrsn . . . Jy gft`nr wfs `fhg Grnem` `fhg Feefjnsn. Fedt`nr bfo mdjbieftide" (p. 21>). @nr jdt`nr wfs cihhno ie t`n _nt dggnesivn w`ne Gdd wfs tne. _`n airh bnmfjn f strnnt `usthnr feo m`iho prdstitutn ie ]fiade, w`nrn s`n wfs"prdtnmtno" by f pnodp`ihim w`itn ^.]. jfkdr. Rngusiea td hnfvn ]fiade wit` `ij, fgtnr ]fiade "gnhh," Gdd neono up ie \dh \dt's Mfjbdoif, w`nrn s`n bfrnhy survivno t`n C`jnr Rduan wdrc mfj

    ]`n nsmfpno td _`fihfeo, feo "w`ne I giefhhy adt t`n Fjnrimfes td edtimn jn, jy Jfkdr wfs stihh hddciea gdr jn" (p.217). Oyie a dg f mfemnr t`ft jia`t `fvn bnne t`n rnsuht dg `is witenssiea t`nftdj bdjb tnsts ie Envfof nfrhy ie `is mfrnnr, `n spdesdrno `nr td t`n ^.]. @nr ietnhhianemn feo `usthiea adt `nr "tits by Addoynfr" (p. 21>), f Gnrrfri, feo f Mfh _nm` noumftide. Gdd feo Fpgnhstruaahn tdant`nr wit`ie t`nir rnspnmtivn hnafmins dg juhtiphn fbusn, snxufh feo dt`nrwisn, feo mrins-mrdssiea rfmisjs. _`ny frn bdt` juhti-tfhnetno, but smfrrno, survivdrs. _`is stdry, its mdrn giaurfeo its efrrftdr, wihh edt hnt us odoan t`n smfry issuns dg rfmn/rfmisj, aneonr/snxisj, `istdrimfh trfanoy, feo tnm`edsminemn wit`ie t`n rnaide dg tijn wn pdhitnhy mfhh "t`n hftn twnetint` mnetury."_`nrn is ed sfgn phfmn `nrn3 t`nrn frn, `dwnvnr, jfey jfps dg pdssibihity. But, t`nrn is netirnhy tdd jum` mdeenmtide ie "\rnss Netnr," feo it is dehy t`n bnaieeiea. Gdd is onnphy ie hdvn wit` t`n

    pdwnr-cedwhnoan systnjs td w`im` `nr scihhs aivn `nr fmmnss. "_`is is jdeny, Yfec, s`n sfio, feo `nr nyns ahittnrno" (p. 271). Fs s`n trfmns t`n gfsmieftiea wnbs feo snmurity hdmcs, w`im` bnafe

    jihitfry mdjputnr prdknmts but w`im` `fvn tfcne de f vfsthy ue`ujfe hign dg t`nir dwe, `nr hdvn feo `nr scihhs briea `nr tdd onnp ietd t`n iegieitnhy onesn mdeenmtides dg t`n ]ystnj, w`nrn s`n, h icChuan bngdrn `nr, is edtimno. _dd hftn, s`n trins td wit`orfw. ]dde fgtnr, f mhnfrhy gfcn suimion edtn fppnfrs de `nr _ - s`irt de `nr ruieno bdoy. Ievnstiaftide s`dwno t`ft s`n `fo rnwirno t`njimrdwfvn dvne ie Chuan's `dusn td mirmujvnet its snmurity m`nmcs. ]`n put `nr `nfo ie t`n dvne, feo s`n oino s`drt hy fgtnr ie t`n `dspitfh, `nr nyns feo brfie mdeanfhno feo `nr brnfsts `drribhyjnhtno. _`n prdjisn dg `nr efjn, "gu bfr," wfs fhhtdd-hitnrfhhy gur gihhno-gumcno up bnydeo fhh rnmdaeitide. Fpgnh, w`d `fo bnne brdua`t bfmc ietd frtimuhftide wit` hign ie `is hdvn wit` Hisf Gdd,

    rntrnftno tdtfhhy, strippiea `is `dusn dg fhh its wiriea feo fey dt`nr jnfes dg mdeenmtiea wit` t`n tnm`ed-wnbs dg f wdrho `n edw sfw tdtfhhy wit`ie t`n pfrfedio tnrjs dg iegieitn feo fhine mdeenmtFt t`n neo, t`n ongneono snhg, fhden, pnrjfenethy `ions grdj t`n fhine Dt`nr.

    It is pdssibhn td rnfo "\rnss N etnr" fs f mdevnetidefh `ntnrdsnxufh rdjfemn, bdurandis ontnmtivn gimtide, tnm`edp`dbim-tnm`edp`ihim gfetfsy, orfade-hfoy stdry, feo, giefhhy, w`itn jfsmuhieistefrrftivn w`dsn mdeoitide dg pdssibihity is fmmnss td t`n bdoy feo jieo dg f wdjfe, nspnmifhhy f "_`iro Qdrho" wdjfe, w`d, `nrn fs nhsnw`nrn ie jisdayeist feo rfmist muhturn, is vidhnethy

    onstrdyno. Edtkust vidhnethy-supnrfbueofethy, wit`dut hijit. I t`iec sum` f rnfoiea odns snridus vidhnemn td t`n subthn tissuns dg t`n stdry's writiea. Edent`nhnss, "\rnss Netnr" ieoumns ie jn, feo idt`nr wdjne feo jne w`d `fvn rnfo t`n stdry wit` jn, fe irrnmdemihfbhn pfie feo feanr; Hisf Gdd s`duho edt `fvn bnne cihhno t`ft wfy. It rnfhhy is edt fhr ia`t. _`n tnxt feo t`n bdoy hdsn fhhoistiemtide. I gfhh dut dg t`n snjidtim squfrn feo ietd t`n vimidushy m irmuhfr t`iea-ieitsnhg. Jdrn t`fe feyt`iea nhsn, t`ft pdredarfp`im, aneonrno feo mdhdrno onft`, t`ft nxmnssivn onstrumtide dg `nr

    bdoy, t`ft tdtfh ueodiea dg `nr bniea-t`ft nxtrfvfafet giefh mdeenmtide-surpfssns t`n hijits dg phnfsurn ie t`n mdevnetides dg pfrfedio gimtide feo prdvdcns t`n enmnssity dg fmtivn rnwritiea fs rnfoI mfeedt rnfo t`is stdry wit`dut rnwritiea it3 t`ft is den dg t`n hnssdes dg trfeseftidefh, ietnrmuhturfh, gnjieist hitnrfmy. Feo t`n mdemhuside gdrmns rnwritiea edt kust dg itsnhg, but dg t`n w`dhn `ujfe

    feo ue`ujfe mdhhnmtivn t`ft is Hisf Gdd. _`n pdiet dg t`n oiggnrnetifh/dppdsitidefh rnwritiea is edt td jfcn t`n stdry mdjn dut "ria`t," w`ftnvnr t`ft wduho bn. _`n pdiet is td rnfrtimuhftn t`n giaur

    dg Hisf Gdd td uesntthn t`n m hdsno hdaims dg f onfohy rfmist jisdayey .Frtimuhftide just rnjfie dpne, its onesitins fmmnssibhn td fmtide feo ietnrvnetide.

    Q`ne t`n systnj dg mdeenmtides mhdsns ie de itsnhg, w`ne syjbdhim fmtide bnmdjns pnrgnmt, t`n wdrho is grdzne ie f ofemn dg onft`

    _`n mdsjds is gieis`no, feo it is Den. \frfedif is t`n dehy pdssibhn pdsturn3 anenrdus suspimide is gdrnmhdsno. _d "prnss netnr" is,

    ie t`ft wdrho, f tnrribhn jistfcn.

    _`n w`dhn fraujnet dg "_`n \rdjisns dg Jdestnrs" `fs bnne t`ft td "prnss netnr" is edt f gftfh nrrdr, but fe iensmfpfbhn

    pdssibihity gdr m`feaiea jfps dg t`n wdrho, gdr buihoiea enw mdhhnmtivns dut dg w`ft is edt quitn f phnt`drf dg `ujfe feo ue`ujf

    fmtdrs. Jy stfcns ie t`n tnxtufh giaurn dg Hisf Gdd, feo dg jfey dg t`n fmtdrs ie Wfrhny's ]G, frn `ia`. Buiht grdj juhtiphnietnrgfmns, Gdd mfe bn f auion t`rdua` t`n tnrrfies dg virtufh spfmn, but dehy ig t`n gien hiens dg tneside ie t`n frtimuhftno wnbt`ft mdestitutn `nr bniea rnjfie ie phfy, dpne td t`n uenxpnmtno rnfhizftide dg fe uehicnhy `dpn. It's edt f "`fppy neoiea" wnenno, but f ede-neoiea. _`ft's w`y eden dg t`n efrrftivns dg jfsmuhieist, pftrifrm`fh fpdmfhypsns wihh od. _`n ]ystnj is edtmhdsno3 t`n sfmrno ijfan dg t`n sfjn is edt mdjiea. _`n wdrho is edt guhh. _`n giefh ijfan dg t`is nxmnssivn nssfy is Mybdra,6909 pfietiea by Hyee Rfeodhp`, ie w`im` t`n bdueofrins dg f gftfhhy trfesarnssivn wdrho, ruhno by t`n ]ubknmt feo t`nDbknmt, aivn wfy td t`n bdronrhfeos, ie`fbitno by `ujfe feo ue`ujfe mdhhnmtivns (Giaurn 62)>= _`nsn bdronrhfeos suaanst rim` tdpdarfp`y dg mdjbieftdrifh pdssibihity. _`ft pdssibihit is mfhhno t`n Nfrt`, `nrn, edw, t`is nhsnw`nrn, w`nrn rnfh, dutnr, iee

    feo virtufh spfmn ijphdon. _`n pfietiea jfps t`n frtimuhftides fjdea mdsjds, feijfh, `ujfe, jfm`ien, feo hfeosmfpn ie t`nir

    rnmursivn sionrnfh, bdey, nhnmtrdeim, feo andhdaimfh scnhntdes. _`nir mdjbieftdrifh hdaim is njbdoino3 t`ndry is mdrpdrnfh3 sdmifh

    efturn is frtimuhftn. _`n styhizno OI\ switm`ns dg t`n ietnarftno mirmuit bdfro de t`n `ujfe giaurn's m`nst frn onvimns t`ft snt t`n

    ongfuhts ie f gdrj ietnrjnoiftn bntwnne `feowiriea feo sdgtwfrn mdetrdh--edt ueicn t`n jnoiftiea strumturfh-guemtidefh feftdj

    dg t`n gnhien feo `djieio gdrnhijbs, nspnmifhhy t`n ghnxibhn, `djdhdadus `feos feo pfws. _`npfietiea is rnphntn wit` drafes dg

    tdum` feo jnoiftide, fs wnhh fs wit` drafes dg viside. Oirnmt ie t`nir afzn ft t`n vinwnr, t`n nyns dg t` wdjfe feo t`n mft mnetn t`

    w`dhn mdjpdsitide. _`n spirifhiea scnhntde dg t` njihcy Qfy, dur afhfxy, fppnfrs bn`ieo t`n mybdra giaurn ie t`rnn oiggnrnet

    arfp`im oisphfys jfon pdssibhn by `ia`-tnm`edhday visufhiziea fppfrftusns. Ie t`n phfmn dg virtufh spfmn ie jy snjdtim squfrn, t`

    gdurt` squfrn is fe ijfaiea dg t`n arfvity wnhh dg f bhfmc `dhn. Edtimn t`n tim-tfm-tdn afjn, phfyno wit` t`n Nurdpnfe jfhn feognjfhn fstrdhdaimfh siaes (Wneus wde t`is afjn)3 kust td t`nir ria`t frn sdjn mfhmuhftides t`ft jia`t fppnfr ie t`n

  • 8/7/2019 Slam Min Waggon Speech

    28/30

    2? Ie t`is pfietea, s`n njbdoins t`n stihh dxyjdrdeim sijuhtfendus stftusns dg wdjfe, "_`iro Qdrho" pnrsde`ujfe, drafeisj, mdjjueimftides tnm`edhday, jft`njftimife, writnr, wdrcnr, neaiennr, sminetist, spiritufh auion, hdvnr dgt`n Nfrt`. _`is is t`n cieo dg "syjbdhim fmtide" trfeseftidefh gnjieisjs `fvn jfon hnaibhn. ]/`n is edt gieis`no.Qn `fvn mdjn guhh mirmhn ie t`n edisy jnm`feisj dg t`n snjidtim squfrn, bfmc td t`n bnaieeiea, w`nrn wn jnt t`nmdjjnrmifh mybdra giaurns ie`fbitiea tnm`edsminemn wdrhos. Hdaim Anenrfh's doohy rnmursivn rfbbits, gdrnpfws de t`ncnybdfros t`ft prdjisn td jnoiftn rnphimftide feo mdjjueimftide, `fvn aivne wfy td oiggnrnet mirmuits dg mdjpntnemins. Igt`n mybdra `fs m`feano, sd jia`t t`n wdrho. Rfeodhp`'s mybdra is ie mdevnrsftide wit` _rie` Jie`-`f's iefpprdpriftn/o dt`t`n pnrsdefh feo mdhhnmtivn bniea td w`dj `istdry `fs gdrbioone t`n strftnaim ihhuside dg snhg-ionetity. _`is mybdra odns edt`fvn fe Fristdtnhife strumturn3 feo t`nrn is ed jfstnr-shfvn oifhnmtim rnsdhviea t`n struaahns dg rnsdurmn feo prdoumt, pfssidefeo fmtide. ]/`n is edt utdpife edr ijfaiefry3 s/`n is virtufh. Anenrftno, fhdea wit` dt`nr mybdras, by t`n mdhhfpsn ietd nfm`dt`nr dg t`n tnm`eimfh, drafeim, jyt`im, tnxtufh, feo pdhitimfh, s/`n is mdestitutno by frtimuhftides dg mritimfh oiggnrnemns wit`iefeo wit`dut nfm` giaurn. _`n pfietiea jia`t bn `nfono, "F gnw wdros fbdut frtimuhftide grdj t`n fmtdrs ie t`n ginho."\rivihnaiea t`n `uns dg rno, arnne, feo uhtrfvidhnt, I wfet td rnfo Rfeodhp`'s Mybdra wit`ie f rfiebdw pdhitimfh snjidhday, gdwihy trfeseftidefh tnm`edsminemn stuoins fs muhturfh stuoins.

  • 8/7/2019 Slam Min Waggon Speech

    29/30

    2>).It is ietnrnstiea td edtn t`ft prn-pnrspnmtivfh muhturns (Anbsnr, 690>) wnrn edt ontfm`no grdj t`nir dwe mdhhnmt ivn rnprnsnetftides fs wn`fvn frn wit` dur pnrspnmtivfh wdrhovinw. Bfrginho edtns t`ft gdr us jdonres, t`n dehy mdeenmtide dg w`im` wn frn mdesmidus is t`nnxtnrefh den t`rdua` dur snesns. Edt sd gdr t`nj. (p.66). Aivne dur bifs tdwfro t`n snesns, it i s ueonrstfeofbhn t`ne w`y wn `fvn sdhitthn mdeenmtide feo sum` f supnrgimifh rnhftides`ip td tijn, w`im`, is edt ie jfttnr. _`is hnfos us td mdesionr t`n npistnjdhdaimfh hiecbntwnne tijn feo jieo, bntwnne `ujfe bnieas feo p`nedjnefh wdrho jfy bn dg f oiggnrnet, pnr`fps supnr-snesdry dronr. _`ft dronrfs suaanstno by Bfrginho, is t`ft dg pfrtimipftide, dr, td usn Mdhnrioans tnrj, t`n prijfry ijfaieftide. _d guemtide fs jdonres, wn

    `fvn supprnssno dur fwfrnenss dg dur pfrtimipftide wit` t`n rnprnsnetftidefh efturn dg t`n p`nedjnefh wdrho fs f w`dhn,

    iemhuoiea t`ft dg tijn. Dur odjiefet jdon dg t`ieciea rnhins de jdonhs (mdestrumtno grdj fefhytimfh t`dua`t fbdut t`dua`t), fe

    t`ne rnhftn td sum` jdonhs fs ig t`ny wnrn fmtufhhy feo hitnrfhhy trun (rft`nr t`fe fs rnprnsnetftidefhhy feo rnhftivnhy trun). Ie t`i

    snesn, wn `fvn afieno t`n fbihity dg sminetigim rftidefh fefhysis, fttfieno t`n pdwnrs dg pnrspnmtivn by pdsitideiea dursnhvns fssnpfrftn grdj p`nenjdef, but fhh ft t`n nxpnesn dg jfietfieiea f edepfrtimipftdry mdesmidusenss. Fs edtno fbdvn, t`is `fs bnne

    mailto:[email protected]:[email protected]:[email protected]:[email protected]
  • 8/7/2019 Slam Min Waggon Speech

    30/30

    2