THE DEFINITION OF HEALTH GIVEN BY “WHO”IN 1948 IS NOT ONLY WRONG

BUT ALSO OPPOSITE TO REALITY.

• WHO definition of Health:- (1948)• “Health is a state of complete physical, mental

and social well being and not merely absence of disease of infirmity.”

WHY- “WHO” definition of Health is wrong and opposite to reality.

1. Health is not- a state of complete. But it should be relative and dynamic state.

2. It is impossible to be an individual in a state of -absence of disease or infirmity.” health can be isolated from disease only after death.

3. “WHO” CAN NOT ABLE TO GIVE DEFINITION OF DISEASE AND IMMUNITY –OFFICIALLY- it’s a great weakness of “WHO”

4. IF ONE CAN GIVE SCIENTIFIC DEFINITION OF HEALTH-THEN IT COMES DEFINITION OF DISEASE AND IMMUNITY FROM THE DEFINITION OF HEALTH.

5. BECAUSE- DISEASE IS OPPSITE OF HEALTH; AND IMMUNITY IS DIRECTLY PROPORTIONAL TO HEALTH. ITS SO EASY TO DEFINE DISEASE AND IMMUNITY AFTER DEFINING HEALTH.

6. SO THE DEFINITION OF HEALTH GIVEN BY “WHO”IN 1948 IS NOT ONLY WRONG BUT ALSO OPPOSITE TO REALITY.

Latest- philosophical(dialectical) concept of health and disease

• Dimensions of health1. Health is a relative/ dynamic-process ( not a complete or absolute thing

but WHO said that – complete )2. Health can not be isolated from disease.( but WHO said that – health is

isolated from disease- absence of disease or infirmity; which is impossible )

3. Health as a human right of individual and society.4. Health as a matter of social justice.5. Health as a globally talking matter and related to global environment.6. Health as opposite of disease. and related to immunity.7. Health as psycho-social-economic-political mirror.8. Health relates as a general with types of philosophy( dialectical –

materialism or idealism ) of an individual or society. All these above basic dimensions of health are latest and scientific concept

of health- and it is summarized- as a newer definition of health- according to dialectical concept of health which is opposite of the definition of health given by WORLD HEALTH ORGANIZATION in 1948.

WEL-COME TO ALL THE GUESTSIN BREAKTHROUGH PRESENTATION

PRESENTER AND AUTHOR →

DIALECTICAL CONCEPT OF HEALTH ANDDISEASE. FOR RE-DEFINING HEALTH.

DR. RAJ KUMAR DHAUGODA

• MBBS, MD (FAM MED), PGT IN SONOGRAPHY, • DIALECTICAL –MATERIALIST• MEDICAL SCIENTIST.• WORKING ON RKDHAUGODA’S GENERAL

THEORY OF VASCULITIS SINCE FIVE YEARS.

MY NEPAL ,MY EVEREST,MY THEORY,MY PRIDE.

Anti-stress factorVasculitis=------------------------------ TNF- α ( stress-factor)

(GENERAL THEORY OF VASCULITIS )

NEPAL

Mt. EVEREST

GALAXYCONCEPTUNDERSTANDINGWAY OF LOOKING

Philosophy – a way of looking /understanding of universe and its content. Dialectical materialism _ its a fundamental PHILOSOPHY and science .

Philosophy

• Philosophy :-is the way of looking or understanding of universe and its contents.

• It may be idealistic, metaphysics and dialectical materialistic philosophy.

• It depends upon the answer of the question to the existence of matter in this universe is primary (dialectical materialism)or secondary to consciousness(idealism) or undecided one( metaphysical philosophy).

X↑

A ←---------- DIALECTICS ----------→B ↓

Y Dialectics is a method of thinking and interpreting the world of both

nature and society.• It is a way of looking at the universe, which sets out from the

axiom that everything is in change and motion.

• But not only that. Dialectics explains that change and motion involve contradiction and can only take place through contradictions.

Dialectical logic

• The dialectics is a science of the forms of our thinking

• Dialectics is the method of reasoning which

aims to understand things concretely in all their movement, change and interconnection, with their opposite and contradictory sides in unity.

DEFn. of CONCEPT

• Concept is a reflection of individual/society to some thing, which is depended on most available scientific knowledge and practice of an individual or society. • Hence concept can be variable according to

thought, Philosophy and level of scientific knowledge and practice of people and society.

FORMAL /DIALECTICAL CONCEPT• It is definitely true that the right Philosophy or right scientific

thought, which is more scientific and more practical, can have more clear and true concept regarding a particular subject or system.

• According to the theory of dialectics, there is nothing stable except change and development.

• So our present medical concept in our society, should be changed towards more scientific and practical form, from which we can solve the problem regarding health as far as possible, because by present existing concept we are not able to solve health problem in our practice mostly.

(A=A ) , (A≠ A )

DEVELOPMENT OF SCIENTIFIC COGNITION

• The powerful inductive force for developing of scientific cognition is the laws of dialectics.

• Dialectics is the area where conscious, intentional coincidence of the inductive and the deductive moments takes place,

• linked ,and mutually assuming moments of question/enquiry investigation for breakthrough thinking .

• Dialectics teaches us for making questions or breakthrough thinking on rationality and effectiveness of current systems,events,knowledge, practices and problems.

DEVELOPMENT OF SCIENTIFIC COGNITION

• The definition of Health given by WHO( developed by metaphysical groups of health experts in 1948) ,

• “IS NOT A OBJECTIVE REALITY AND VERY NARROW AND UNSCIENTIFIC ,BUT ALSO JUST OPPOSITE OF REALITY”.

• This is a sort of development of scientific cognition, a scientific abstract which may be real concrete ,after multi-axial methodological analysis of current medical practices and its background philosophy.

The methodology of scientific cognition

• -Thinking differently/questioning is the core thing.• -Breakthrough thinking( creative thinking)• -Elaboration of perceptual( general ) knowledge( 1st stage

of knowledge)• -Review of perceptual knowledge in view with problems

using strong guideline theory ( use of dialectical method)• -Making inferences / Assumption for new solution (rational

knowledge- 2nd stage )• -Testing of hypothesis –doing research (on practice 3rd

stage of knowledge of getting knowledge)• -New result proved by practice will be next advanced

perceptual knowledge

“WHO” DEFINITION OF HEALTH→is old CONCEPT –should be revised

• WHO definition of Health:- (1948)• “Health is a state of complete physical, mental and

social well being and not merely absence of disease of infirmity.”

• This WHO definition of health has been criticized - As that health can not be defined as a state OF COMPLETE at all most be seen as a process of continuous adjustment to the changing demands of living and of the changing meanings we give to life. It is a dynamic concept: -

WHO

practical- analysis of “WHO” DEFINITION OF HEALTH

• PROBLEMS------------------------SOLUTIONS STATE OF COMPLETE---→DYNAMIC/RELATIVE ABSENCE OF DISEASE--------→H and D interchangeable(ISOLATED FROM DISEASE) ( OPPOSITE BUT UNITED)

PHILOSOPHY FORMAL LOGIC -→ DIALECTICAL LOGIC

NO-DEFn OF DISEASE/IMMUNITY---→ YES ,DEFn OF D/INOT UPDATED SINCE 1948-→ RECENTLY DEFINED H/D/I

Practical problems of “WHO” DEFINITION OF HEALTH

• PROBLEMS------------------------→SOLUTIONS• HIV/AIDS-----------------→DEFn OF IMMUNITY ( ↓ CD4 LEVELS ) ( OPTIMUM LEVEL OF CD4 )- IMMUNITY ?----→INTEGRATED ,BRAOD,SPCFC DEFn- DISEASE ?-----------→ OPPOSITE OF HEALTH- HEALTH ?-------------→ SCIENTIFIC BROAD DEFn.- AUTOIMMUNE DISEASE---→IMMUNE MODULATION- TUMORS/CANCERS--------→ IMMUNE MODULATION- CHRONIC DISEASE-----------→PREVENTIVE,CURATIVE- INTEGRATION WITH AMS ?---- → SCIENTIFIC INTEGRATION-GENERALIZATION ?→( INDV.↔PARTICULAR↔UNIVERSAL)

THE OLD CONCEPT-“WHO” DEFINITION OF HEALTH

• The WHO has not defined disease because disease has many shades (spectrum) ranging from sub-clinical to severe manifest illness. also has not defined immunity officially yet.

• We can find, the suitable scientific concept of disease and immunity .

• only after defining the health philosophically and scientifically.

Formal logic (A = A)

• The formal logic represents mathematics (the Aristotelian logic of simple syllogism) that the proposition, A is equal to A.

• This postulate is accepted as an axiom for a magnitude of practical human actions and elementary generalizations.

• But in reality A is not equal to A.

(A=A ,1+1=2 ) Formal logic→doesn’t workIN BIOLOGICAL AND SOCIAL SCIENCE

• The Axiom A is equal to A signifies that a thing is equal to itself if it does not change, that is, if it does not exist, that means A is equal to A itself only ‘at a given moment’ relatively.

• Again the physical law is that every course of movement is characterized by inevitable changes.

• Hence, the formal logic; (in mathematics) there are errors, that is the

overlooked to moment of inevitable changes for anything (uninterrupted process of transformation, time is fundamental element of existence).

The key law of Dialectics RK Dhaugoda’s basic law of dialectics

• Any external event, system or unit contains opposite phenomena which are

also connected relatively by means varying degree of reciprocal association dynamically with internal other sets of opposite phenomena again.

• (It is a new law - explored by R.K.Dhaugoda in the field of dialectics:- called RK Dhaugoda’s basic law of dialectics) i.e. opposite phenomena within opposite phenomena, systems, which are interdepended each other as four dimensional certain reciprocal associations dynamically and primarily.

• In short-dialectics is law of dynamic unity of opposites within opposites-according to R.K.Dhaugoda-this law is applied practically in many instances in the book( R.K.Dhaugoda’s General theory of Vasculitis)

Application of RK Dhaugoda’s basic law of dialectics

• The health and disease are opposite phenomena, are connected dynamically with another opposite phenomena• i.e. stress factors(cytokines-TNF-alpha) and anti-stress factor in the body of an individual.

Anti-stress factor ↑ │ │ Health ←----------------------------------------------------→Disease │ │ ↓ TNF-alpha ( cellular stress- factor )• • •

DAY AND NIGHT OPPOSITE PHENOMENA-( dialectical phenomena)

daynight

earth rotates in its won axis

West to east

Sun sets -west

Sun arises from east

Application of RK Dhaugoda’s basic law of dialectics

• likewise day and night are opposites related with other sets of opposite phenomena, rotation of Earth from west to east in its own axis, and sun arise from east / sets from west.

Rotation of earth from west to east in its own axis ↑ │ │ Day←---------------------------------------------------------------→Night │ │ ↓ Sun arise from east and sets from west

DFFERENCE BETWEEN THE OLD “WHO” CONCEPT AND RKDHAUGODA’S NEW CONCEPT OF HEALTH AND DISEASE

Current “WHO “concept of health and disease

Rkdhaugoda’s new concept of heath and disease

DYNAMIC RELATION, INTERCHANCHABLE

IMMUNITY (ASF )

DISEASE ( OPPOSIT

E OF HEALTH )

STRESS FACTORS (I/E )TNF-

α

HEALTH

HEALTH = ? ISOLATED

FROM DISEASE AND

IMMUNITY

DISEASE ?

IMMUNITY ?

DFFERENCE BETWEEN THE OLD “WHO” CONCEPT AND RKDHAUGODA’S NEW CONCEPT OF HEALTH AND DISEASE

BASED ON FORMAL LOGIC /STATISTICAL

1 1 2

BASED ON DIALECTICAL LOGIC

HEALTH

I/E STRESS FACTOR

ASF (IMMUNITY )

DFFERENCE BETWEEN THE OLD “WHO” CONCEPT AND RKDHAUGODA’S NEW CONCEPT OF HEALTH AND DISEASE

Current “WHO “concept of health and disease

• THIS OLD CONCEPT IS NARROW, isolated UNSCIENTIFIC AND IMPRACTICABLE.COMPLICATED TO UNDERSTAND.

Rkdhaugoda’s new concept of heath and disease

• THIS NEW CONCEPT IS BROAD , UNIVERSAL, PHYLOSOPHICAL AND MORE SCIENTIFIC PRACTICABLE. SIMPLE TO UNDERSTAND.

DFFERENCE BETWEEN THE OLD “WHO” CONCEPT AND RKDHAUGODA’S NEW CONCEPT OF HEALTH AND DISEASE

Current “WHO “concept of health and disease

THE CORE CONCEPT OF DISEASE CAUSATION IS THE ,

MOSTLY OUTER STRESS FACTORS AND SO CALLED

UNSPECIFIC AUTOIMMUNE ANTIBODY.

THERE ARE NO CLEAR FINAL CAUSATIVE

FACTORS. E.G. BACTERIA CAN NOT DIRECTLY CAUSE

TISSUE DAMAGE .

Rkdhaugoda’s new concept of heath and disease

THE CORE CONCEPT OF ANY DISEASE ,

WHATTEVER THE OUTER OR INNER CAUSATIVE

AGENTS ,

THE FINAL CAUSATION IS THE IMBALANCE OF ANTI-STRESS FACTOR IN-COPARISION TO STRESS-FACTOR ( TNF-ALPHA)

INTO THE BODY.

• Philosophy ?

• Formal logic

• Intregration=?

• Int.stressfactor-tnf-alpha

• Ext. stress facotor--idintified

Immunity/host factor

?Disease?

common pathology

?Health ?

Immunity ? NO DEFINATION. IMMUNITY = HOST FACOR ? WHAT FACTOR ENFLUENCES

IMMUNITY ? NO SOLUTION FOR HIV/AIDS

↓ CD4 , ↓ IMMUNITY HIV/ AIDS=↑ STRESS FACTOR ( TNF-α ) ↑ VIRAL LOAD

HOW TO INCREASE IMMUNITY ( CD4 –LEVEL ) ? no answer

Current “WHO “concept of health and disease

DYNAMIC

RELATION

DIALECTICAL

THOUGHT/ ANTISTRES

-FACTOR

DISEASE

VASCULITIS

STRESS-FACTOR

TNF-ALPHA

HEALTHNORMAL VASCULRFUNCTIO

N

• INTRINSIC (TNF-ALPHA)/EXTRINSIC STRESS FACTORS – INTERDEPENDENT WITH ANTISTRESS FACTOR ( IMMUNITY )

• IMMUNITY IS A CONNECTOR OF HEALTH AND DISEASE STATUS OF A PERSON.E.G.

TNF-ALPHA-STRESSFACTOR ( DISEASE MEDIATOR ) ↨ VASCULITIS =←-----------→HEALTH (DISEASE ) ↨IMMUNITY ( OPTIMUM -CD4 )( INTRINSIC ANTISTRESS FACTOR)

Rkdhaugoda’s new concept of heath and disease

RKDHAUGODA’S GENERAL THEORY OF VASCULITIS

TNF-ALPHA-STRESS-FACTOR ( DISEASE MEDIATOR ) VASCULITIS =------------------------------------------ (DISEASE ) IMMUNITY ( INTRINSIC ANTISTRESS FACTOR)

THE SOLUTION OF HIV/AIDS = SUPPLIMENT OF ANTI-STRESS FACTORHIV—Utilises ASE of CD4 cell→-apoptosis--causes- AIDS

( cd4 decreased less than 200/dl )Dissociation of HIV-DNA from host cell DNA .BY UVBI .

The new definition of HEALTH,DISEASE.AND IMMUNITY according to

Rkdhaugoda’s new concept of heath and disease

HEALTH ,DISEASE and IMMUNITY are defined on the background of,

• R.K.Dhaugoda’s basic law of dialectics• R.K.Dhaugoda’s general ratio of health and

disease ( health: disease = 4:1 )• R.K.Dhaugoda’s general theory of vasculitis ) • For more detail:- www.drdhaugoda.blogspot.com

THE-OPTIMUM HEALTHOPTIMUM

HEALTH

4:1 4:1OPTIMUM HEALTH OF AN INDIVIDUAL

THE COMBINATION OF 3-THEORIES

The new definition of HEALTH, according toRkdhaugoda’s new concept of heath and disease

"Health is defined as the relative balance level of the dialectical materialistic thought and practice in comparison to idealistic thought and practice of an individual with high self esteem; and Relative balance level of cellular anti-stress factors (IkBa and X-factor) in comparison to cellular stress factors (TNF -α / active NFkB) in the body of an individual”.

---By DR. RKD

The new definition of HEALTH, according toRkdhaugoda’s new concept of heath and disease

• Health is defined as “the relative dynamically balance STATE of optimum level of dialectic materialistic thought and practice in relation to idealistic thought and practice of an individual; and relative reciprocal association of intracellular level of ANTI-STRESS ELEMENT in relation to stress factors(TNF-alpha) in the body of an individual”.

---By DR. RKD

DEFINITION OF DISEASE

• "Disease is defined as the relative low level of the didactical materialistic thought and practice in comparison to idealistic thought and practice of on individual with low self esteem; and relative low level of cellular anti-stress factors (IkBα and X-factor ) in comparison to cellular stress factors (TNF-α and activated NFkB) in the body of an individual".

- Dr. rkdhaugoda

Scientific And Revolutionary Definition of Immunity

• WHO is the co-coordinator or contractor or organizer or monitor or authority of world health, hasn’t define immunity and disease officially yet.

• That’s why there are a lot of problems in the management of world health effectively. WHO has defined health in 1948, and has not updated up to now,

• This WHO definition of health also a non realistic , impracticable and unscientific one.

Scientific And Revolutionary Definition of Immunity

• Officially WHO has not given the definition of immunity yet. • Up to now no one has given any satisfactory definition of immunity yet.• According to dialectics, we know that health is directly proportional to immunity. • So the best definition of immunity is equivalent to the sort form definition of health.• According to Rkdhaugoda's key law of dialectics, we can define Immunity as

• "Immunity is defined as relative balance level of dialectical materialistic thought and practice; and cellular anti stress factors (IkBa & X-factor) in an individual with high self esteem".

• This definition of immunity- describes the health and immunity from the molecular level to grand surrounding factors of human and nature simultaneously.

• Disease is indirectly proportional to immunity

---BY DR. RKD

• Before this, no one has been defined immunity in molecular level as well as natural, philosophical and psychological level yet.