sasamartlo monitoringis angarishi n4 2014

7/26/2019 Sasamartlo Monitoringis Angarishi n4 2014

1/82


2/82

4

: 2014

, 2014 .

,

, (USAID)

.

.USAID-

, , -(EWMI)

.


3/82

2

................................................................................................................... 3

.............................................................................................................................. 4

....................... 8

.................................................................................................................................. 10

.......................................................... 12

...................................................................................................................... 14

............................................................ 17

................................................. 18

............................................................................................................... 18....................................................................................................... 23

............................................................................................................... 24

........................................................... 29

............................................................................................................... 30

()................................................. 42

............................................................................................................... 43

................................................... 47

............................................................................................................... 48

.......................................................................................................................................... 57


4/82

3

-

, ,

, ,

.

-

, , ,

.

, ,

- (EWMI)

,

,

,

.

- ,

.

.

-

.


5/82

4

-

. 2014

- , , ,

.

, -

. 683

268.

,

:,

, ,

,

.

:

.

,

,

35%- .

, ,

53% (268-141).

-

.

,

. ,

67%,


6/82

5

, 35%-

. , ,

29% ,

,

50%-.

. : 86%

;

;

33% ,

.

, ,

. ,

,

.

,

, :

. ,

,

:

; ;

;

,

,

; ,

.

,

, ,

.


7/82

6

,

.

: ,

/ ,

.

,

.

,

,

. ,, 78% -

90%-

,

.

66% 77% ,

. ,

. , ,

4%-16%-,

33% 50% ,

.

.

,

,

,

, 26% 33%

;

,

.

,

, 60% ,


8/82

7

. ,

23%-.

,

. ,

,

. ,

,

.

-

.

,

, ,

,

.

,

:

. ,

. ,

49% 71 %

.

, ,

, .

30 . ,

.

,

.


9/82

8

-

,

,

. , -

, ,

,

. -

,

,

. , ,

,

.

2014-, , , .

-

268 ,

.

. 683

. : 459 (189 )

, 98 (30 )

, 97 (37 )

, 12 (6 )

17 (6 )

.

.

, -

241 ,

, ,

, . 32 , 15 , 67


10/82

9

, 127 .1

,

,

.

1. 1, 1.2.

189

30 376 6

459

98 97

12 17

1.

,


11/82

10

,

-

(. 9). 148 ,

.2

,

.

,

. , -

,

.

.

.

-

22 : 12

; 5 ; 3

, 1

1 .

,

.

,

.

2 ,

.

,

;

.

,

,

2 , , 23/07/1999, 2352-;

, , 14/11/1997, 1106-I.


12/82

11

,

.


13/82

12

.

3 ,

.

-

,

, ,

.

-

,

.4.

, ,

. ,

. , , ,

, ,

3:www.tcc.gov.ge;

: http://batumi.court.gov.ge/;

: http://gori.court.gov.ge/;

:

http://court.gov.ge/courts/quTaisis_saqalaqo_sasamarTlo/?page=17 ;

http://court.ge/courts/rustavis_saqalaqo_sasamartlo/4 (), 2012 ,

http://gyla.ge/geo/news?info=842, 31/01/2013; , ,

,,

, 2012 . ,

http://www.greenalt.org/webmill/data/file/publications/Stripped_Property_Rights_April2012_Eng.pdf,

31/01/2013; ,

, 2011 . ,

http://transparency.ge/en/post/report/problems-related-protection-property-rights-case-gonio-march-2011 ,

31/01/2013;

, 2011 . , http://transparency.ge/en/post/report/problems-related-protection-

property-rights-case-mestia-july-2011, 31/01/2013; GNS-

, ,http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ioAZneCQ1nw,31/01/2013.
http://www.tcc.gov.ge/http://www.tcc.gov.ge/http://court.gov.ge/courts/quTaisis_saqalaqo_sasamarTlo/?page=17http://court.gov.ge/courts/quTaisis_saqalaqo_sasamarTlo/?page=17http://transparency.ge/en/post/report/problems-related-protection-property-rights-case-gonio-march-2011http://transparency.ge/en/post/report/problems-related-protection-property-rights-case-gonio-march-2011http://transparency.ge/en/post/report/problems-related-protection-property-rights-case-mestia-july-2011http://transparency.ge/en/post/report/problems-related-protection-property-rights-case-mestia-july-2011http://transparency.ge/en/post/report/problems-related-protection-property-rights-case-mestia-july-2011http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ioAZneCQ1nwhttp://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ioAZneCQ1nwhttp://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ioAZneCQ1nwhttp://transparency.ge/en/post/report/problems-related-protection-property-rights-case-mestia-july-2011http://transparency.ge/en/post/report/problems-related-protection-property-rights-case-mestia-july-2011http://transparency.ge/en/post/report/problems-related-protection-property-rights-case-gonio-march-2011http://court.gov.ge/courts/quTaisis_saqalaqo_sasamarTlo/?page=17http://www.tcc.gov.ge/


14/82

13

- ,

.

-

,

. (. 2)

31%

21%11%

7%

5%

4%

4%

4%

3%

10%

2.

,

,

,

,

/


15/82

14

, 268

. - ,

.

,

,

27% .

61% . (116

189-).

27% (830-) .

30% (1137-).

33% (26-).

67% (4 6-),

.5

,

53% (141 268-).

58% (147253-). - 79% (112 142-);

- 85% (92108-).

5. 8


16/82

15

84% 80%

64% 61%

#1

#2

#3

#4

3.

.

87%74%

46%

27%

#1

#2

#3

#4

4.

.


17/82

16

49%

30%

#3

#4

5.

.

64%

33%

#3

#4

6.

.

67%

#4

7.

.


18/82

17

:

. , ,

,

.6

, -

. :

; ;7

;8

;9

.10

, ,

,11 ,

, ,

.

-

,

.12

6. , ., . , . ,

, , 2008, . 19.7, , 24/08/1995, 786-, 85-;

, , 04/11/1950, -6 ;

, , 04/12/2009, 2257-II, -13

.8. , . 27.9 , -4 ; .

, . 25.10, -14 ;, -4

-5 .11, -4;12

. , . 27.


19/82

18

,

. ,

.

. ,

.

,

.

.13

,

.

.14

-

,

.

, .

, ,

, .

, .

.

:71% .

13 .

,, . 80.14 , 1- -2 ;

, 59--3 .


20/82

19

65%

33% 31%

20%

#1

#2

#3

#4

8. .

71%

46%

24% 24%

#1

#2

#3

#4

9. .


21/82

20

10 ,

( 14% 6%).

(41%) (17%)

. 71% (12 17-

) 10 ,

.

36%

49%

#3

#4

10.

.

63%

33%

#3

#4

11.

.

71%

#4

12. 8.

.


22/82

21

, -

,

,

.

30

, - 44 , - 31 ,

- 22, - 20. ,

,

. ,

,

.

8 ,

17 ,

30 . ,

.

. , -2013 571 , 2014

414 163 .

2013 316 , 2014

339 242

. ,

,

.


23/82

22

.

, 29 % .

- ,

, ,

, , 10 .

, . ,

.


24/82

23

, ,

.15 ,

,

.16

, ,

.17 -6

,18

Ringeisen v. Austria Knig v. Germany

, -6

, ,

.19 ,

, ,

.20

,

, .21

,

,

.

15, 85-.16, -13 .17, , 04/11/1950, -6

.18.27, , . 40.19Ringeisen v Austria(1971), , 94-;Knig v

Germany(1978), , 89-90-.20

, 16/12/66,23/03/67-, -14 1-.21,-12 .
http://hudoc.echr.coe.int/sites/eng/pages/search.aspx?i=001-57565http://hudoc.echr.coe.int/sites/eng/pages/search.aspx?i=001-57565http://hudoc.echr.coe.int/sites/eng/pages/search.aspx?i=001-57565http://hudoc.echr.coe.int/sites/eng/pages/search.aspx?i=001-57512http://hudoc.echr.coe.int/sites/eng/pages/search.aspx?i=001-57512http://hudoc.echr.coe.int/sites/eng/pages/search.aspx?i=001-57512http://hudoc.echr.coe.int/sites/eng/pages/search.aspx?i=001-57512http://www.osce.org/odihr/elections/14304http://www.osce.org/odihr/elections/14304http://www.osce.org/odihr/elections/14304http://www.osce.org/odihr/elections/14304http://www.osce.org/odihr/elections/14304http://www.osce.org/odihr/elections/14304http://www.osce.org/odihr/elections/14304http://www.osce.org/odihr/elections/14304http://hudoc.echr.coe.int/sites/eng/pages/search.aspx?i=001-57512http://hudoc.echr.coe.int/sites/eng/pages/search.aspx?i=001-57512http://hudoc.echr.coe.int/sites/eng/pages/search.aspx?i=001-57565


25/82

24

,

,22

.23

,

, , , , , ,

,

. , ,

,

.

-

.

,

, 8

. , -

.

.

.

, . , ,

.

22.27, , . 43.23 . 8, , . 67; Van

Meurs v. The Netherlands, 215/1986, UN Doc

CCPR/C/39/D/215/1986 (1990), 6.2 .
http://www.bayefsky.com/pdf/116_netherlands215vws.pdfhttp://www.bayefsky.com/pdf/116_netherlands215vws.pdfhttp://www.bayefsky.com/pdf/116_netherlands215vws.pdfhttp://www.bayefsky.com/pdf/116_netherlands215vws.pdfhttp://www.bayefsky.com/pdf/116_netherlands215vws.pdf


26/82

25

-

/ .

,

.

,-

. -

.

-

.

66%-

(6598-) .

99%- (96 97-)

. 83%-(1012-

) . (17)

.

. ,

. -

,

6%- (30 459-)

.

5% (16299-) , - 16% (24147-

). ,13% .

11%-(11

98-) . ,

.

2013

.

-

. ,


27/82

26

. -

, , ,

,

.

, ,

,

, .

,

. 24

-

,

.

3%-(5

189-) ,

.

6%-

(9 157-) ,

30%(2788-).

30% (9

30-). 44% (20

44-).

,

, , .

22% (8 37-).

, 67%

(2233-).

24

-

. ,.


28/82

27

,

.

,

, -

, ,

.

.

, ,

, .

,

, ,

, .

. -

,

100%

34%

1%

17%

0

13.


29/82

28

.

,

-

.


30/82

29

,

,

,

.

.25

,

. ,

,

,

, ,

.

,

,

.26

.27

.

, ,

,

,

.

25. , . 28.26

, 210-, 211-, 214-, 217-, 218- 257-.27. , . 28.


31/82

30

,

.,

, ,

, , : ,

,

,

.

, , ,

.28 , ,

, .

.

,

.29

- ,

. , , , ,

,

, ,

( ,

,).

. ,

.

5%- (7 138-)

6%- (10 175-) .

28,

, ,

, ., 205-.29, 203-, 205-, 207-210-.


32/82

31

, 13% (12 90-)

, 6% (8 141-)

. , ,

13% 8%.

89%- (24 27-)

71%- (15 21-) .

, 77%-(24

31-) 67%- (18 27-)

.

64%- (18 28-)

70%- (26 37-) . , ,

33%- (3 9-)

34%- (11 32-) .

.

,

39%- (5 13-) 43%- (3 7-

) . 25% (1 4-)

7 .

,

,

.

21

16 ; ,

1 (5%) (6%)

.

14

10 ;

2 (14%)

.

,

, .

,


33/82

32

,

.

, .

2 (67%) .

.

,

, .

, ., ,

78%

(95122-) 78% (122156-

).

,

. ,

, ,

26,20

(5%).

4%

(128-) 17%

(6 36-) .

20% (1 5-)

33% (1 3-).

11.


34/82

33

73% 76% 70%78%

94%

54%

11%

5%

#1

#2

#3

#4

14.

(

)

53%

17%

#3

#4

15.

()

100%

#4

17.

()

57%

33%

#3

#4

16.

()


35/82

34

-

,

, .

,

,

.

,

.

,

. ,

66% (91

138-) . ,

72% (65 90-),

.

53% (16 30-) .

39% (69 175-).

(31 80-).

18% (26 141-).

( -

), .

15% (4 27-)

14% (3 21-) .

, ,

.

,


36/82

35

7% (2 31-)

4% (127-).

, ,

28

, 3% (1

37-) .

,

.

33%(26-)

33% (13-).

,

13- .

50% (2

4-)86%(6

7-) .

, .

39%

14%

3%

33%

86%

18.

(

)


37/82

36

.

8% (11 157-),

18

%- (33 189-).

,

-

. 60% (18 30-)

. 33% (2 6-)

. 37 , -

83% (5 6-).

, ,

,

, .

66%

15%

0

33%

50%

19.

()


38/82

37

,

.

16%-(16102-)

.

, 8% (12 157-) .

86% 86%92%

82%

45%

80%

36%40%

#1

#2

#3

#4

20. .

17%

#4

23.

.

42%

0

Court Monitoring

#3

Court Monitoring

#4

21. .

.

79%

67%

Court

Monitoring #3

Court

Monitoring #4

22.

.


39/82

38

,

.

6-,

.

- ,

.

.

:

;30

;31

.32

.

43%- ,

50%- . ,

, ,

.

, ,

,

.

. 33

.

96%- (189- 182 )

30. 5, 5.1

31. 5, 5.232. 5, 5.5

33. 5, 5.7, 5.8, 5.9.


40/82

39

. - 97% (29 30-). ,

- 100%.

,

,

, .

.

99% (187 189-). , ,

.

,

98%- (157- 154 ) ,

- 44 ,

97%- (33- 32 ) .

: 96% (8488-), 89%

(3135-).

,

99%- (189- 187 )

, , ,

.

.

96%- (157-

151), - 100%, - 97%.

, , ,

26%- (189-

49 ) ,

.

,

.

60% (18 30-)

; - 100%, - 33%.


41/82

40

28%-(44157-),

- 83% (3844-), - 97% (3334-), - 100%.

,

, ,

-

41%-.

,

83%- (38 44-).

,

23% . ,

97% (33

34-), - 100%. ,

,

.

,

97% (183 189-

) . ,

- , - 97% (3637-

). .

.

,

, , .

,

.

.

, ,

,


42/82

41

- ,

.

, ,

,

.

,

.

,

,

,

.

,

,

, .

,

,

.

.

,

.

, ,

, ,

.

.


43/82

42

)

,

.

, ,

.34

.

.

, ,

,

,, /

, ,

. ,

.

. -4

, ,

.35

, ,

. ,

.

, ,

34

David Jackson: Adversarial and Inquisitorial Systems Medico-Legal Society of NSW Inc ScientificMeeting, 2009 , . 1.35, -4 .


44/82

43

. ,

,

.

, .

, ,

.36

,.37

, ,

.

,

, /,

,

,

,

.

-

.

, ,

, .

, ,

.

36. , . 27.37, Resolution78 (8),on Legal Aid and Advice, 1978 2

; Van der Mussele v Belgium (1983), , 29- 30- ; . 27,

, . 59.
https://wcd.coe.int/com.instranet.InstraServlet?command=com.instranet.CmdBlobGet&InstranetImage=596380&SecMode=1&DocId=662254&Usage=2https://wcd.coe.int/com.instranet.InstraServlet?command=com.instranet.CmdBlobGet&InstranetImage=596380&SecMode=1&DocId=662254&Usage=2https://wcd.coe.int/com.instranet.InstraServlet?command=com.instranet.CmdBlobGet&InstranetImage=596380&SecMode=1&DocId=662254&Usage=2http://cmiskp.echr.coe.int/tkp197/view.asp?action=html&documentId=695468&portal=hbkm&source=externalbydocnumber&table=F69A27FD8FB86142BF01C1166DEA398649http://cmiskp.echr.coe.int/tkp197/view.asp?action=html&documentId=695468&portal=hbkm&source=externalbydocnumber&table=F69A27FD8FB86142BF01C1166DEA398649http://cmiskp.echr.coe.int/tkp197/view.asp?action=html&documentId=695468&portal=hbkm&source=externalbydocnumber&table=F69A27FD8FB86142BF01C1166DEA398649https://wcd.coe.int/com.instranet.InstraServlet?command=com.instranet.CmdBlobGet&InstranetImage=596380&SecMode=1&DocId=662254&Usage=2


45/82

44

313

26-(15 11 ) ,

- 65- 4 (1 3

). , ( 37

31 ) - .

,

: 231- 10 (8

2 );

- 58-3(1 2

); - 41-3 (2

1 ), - 20-2.

15%- , (

, ),

18% .

,

(683).

. 38

,

/ (

). ,

/

, ,

. 24

(21 3 ) 12

(9 3 ). - 20

(11 9 ) 2

( ). - 4 /

3

. - 3 3 (1

2 ) .

.

/

38. 6. 6.2


46/82

45

( ) 90- 15

141-16 . -

33- 12 27-4 . -

41-9. - 20-4.

, -

, , ,

. ,

. ,

.

, , 5

,4 - ,6 - ,

3 - 2 - .

, : 4 , - 6,

- 6, - 8.

8

5, . -

5 6.

,

.

85%- (158- 134 ) , ,

,

, .

,

.

,

,

.

,

.


47/82

46

, ,

,

, : ;

, / .

- ,

,

.

, ,

,

.


48/82

47

.

- .

, ,

.

,

39

,40

.41

.

,

. ,

, ,

. ,

, , - .42

,

.43

, ,

,

,

39,Recommendation on Judges: Independence, efficiency,

responsibility ( : ,

, ); The European Charter on the Statute for Judges (

), , 810

, 1998, DAJ/DOC (98) 23.40Kyiv Recommendations on Judicial Independence in Eastern Europe, South Caucasus and Central Asia

( ,

).41

.27, , . 29.42. . 63.43, . 72.
https://wcd.coe.int/ViewDoc.jsp?id=1707137&Site=CMhttps://wcd.coe.int/ViewDoc.jsp?id=1707137&Site=CMhttps://wcd.coe.int/ViewDoc.jsp?id=1707137&Site=CMhttps://wcd.coe.int/ViewDoc.jsp?id=1707137&Site=CMhttp://www.osce.org/odihr/71178http://www.osce.org/odihr/71178http://www.osce.org/odihr/71178https://wcd.coe.int/ViewDoc.jsp?id=1707137&Site=CMhttps://wcd.coe.int/ViewDoc.jsp?id=1707137&Site=CM


49/82

48

,

.44

,

, , ,

,

,

. ,

. , , ,

,

, ,

, .

,

(

),

(

).45

,

. .

, , ,

, . ,

, ,

, .

44

Schuler-Zgraggen v Switzerland (1993), , 50-52-.45.27, , . 63.
http://cmiskp.echr.coe.int/tkp197/view.asp?action=html&documentId=695717&portal=hbkm&source=externalbydocnumber&table=F69A27FD8FB86142BF01C1166DEA398649http://cmiskp.echr.coe.int/tkp197/view.asp?action=html&documentId=695717&portal=hbkm&source=externalbydocnumber&table=F69A27FD8FB86142BF01C1166DEA398649http://cmiskp.echr.coe.int/tkp197/view.asp?action=html&documentId=695717&portal=hbkm&source=externalbydocnumber&table=F69A27FD8FB86142BF01C1166DEA398649http://cmiskp.echr.coe.int/tkp197/view.asp?action=html&documentId=695717&portal=hbkm&source=externalbydocnumber&table=F69A27FD8FB86142BF01C1166DEA398649


50/82

49

.

,

. , -

,

(, ),

. , ,

,

14%-,

.

,

62% (76122-) -

76% (3850-). - 86% (2529-) 96% (24 25-) . - 81% (35

43-) 84% (26 31-)

. 12

, 50% , - 5 ,

2 (40%). ,

6,67% ,

.

2% 16%

98% 100%84%

100% 100%

24.


51/82

50

69%

50%

66% 62%67% 61%

77% 76%

#1

#2

#3

#4

25.

( )

63%72%

81% 86%

56%

75%68%

96%

#1

#2

#3

#4

26.

()

73%

50%

80%

40%

#3

#4

28.

().

79% 81%

64%

84%

#3

#4

27.

()


52/82

51

. - ,

, ,

. ,

.

189 7 ,

189- 3 . .

137-- 437-

. - . - .

6% (148-9 )

1% (148- 2 ) .

, 1 .

12%

(33- 4 ) 6% (33- 2

) .

29% (14- 4 ) ,

.

15%

4% ,

67%

0

#4

29.

()


53/82

52

6%

3%,

11% 5%.

, ,

, ,

,

. ,

,

. -

, ,

.


54/82

53

,

2014 - , -

. ,

,

.

,

.

, -

,

,

. -

,

,

. .

,

. ,

:

,

, , ,

, ,

,

.

.

, ,

:


55/82

54

,

,

;

,

.

, , ,

,

. ,

, - :

.

.

.

,

, ;

.

-

,

. ,

, ,

, : ;

/ ,

.

,

,

.

,

. ,


56/82

55

. ,

.

,

. ,

,

.

. ,

.

.

.

.

,

-

:

.

,

;

,

;

.

, .


57/82

56

,

.

, , ;

;

,

;

.

; ,

,

;

, ,

10 .


58/82

57

1.

1.1

189 459 138 71 175 75

30 98 27 23 21 27

37 97 28 5 37 27

6 12 6 3 3 0

6 17 3 2 7 5

268 683 202 104 243 134

1.2

80

3 7 36

36 4 2 9

11 9 4 19

0 16 2 3

0 0 0 0


59/82

58

2.

2.1

,

,

.

46 16 7 4 1

,

31 9 9 1 3

8 0 2 0 0

10 0 1 0 0

/

8 2 0 0 0

24 0 3 0 0

,

16 1 2 0 0

46 2 13 1 2

189 30 37 6 6


60/82

59

3.

3.1

/

):

459 98 97 12 17

366

(79.7%)

75

( 76.5%)

50

( 51.5%)

8

(66.7%)

5

(29.4%)

93

(20.3%)

23

(23.5%)

47

(48.5%)

4

(33.3%)

12

(70.6%)

3.2 10

(

):

459 98 97 12 17

10

66

(14%)

6

(6.1%)

40

(41.2%)

2

(16.6%)

12

(70.6%)


61/82

60

3.3 10

?

10

66 6 40 2 12

26

(39.3%)

2

(33.3%)

16

(40%)

1

(50%)

0

(0%)

40

(60.7%)

4

(66.7%)

24

(60%)

1

(50%)

12

(100%)

3.4 10

:

10

66 6 40 2 12

21

(31.8%)

1

(16.7%)

13

(32.5%)

1

(50%)0

-

5

(7.6%)

1

(16.7%)

1

(2.5%)0 0

3

(4.5%) 0 0 0 0

37

(56.1%)

4

(66.6%)

26

(65%)

1

(50%)

1

(100%)


62/82

61

3.5

30 44 21 22 20

338 198 106 50 56

1 1 1 1 1


63/82

62

4.

4.1 :

4.2 :

459 98 97 12 17

429

( 93.5%)

87

(88.8%)

97

(100%)12

(100%)

17

(100%)

30

(6.5%)

11

(11.2%)0 0 0

459 98 97 12 17

0

(0%)

65

(66,3%)

96

(99%)

10

(83.3%)

17

(100%)

459

(100%)

33

(33.7%)

21

(1%)

2

(16.7%)

0

( 0%)


64/82

63

4.3 -

.

4.4 -

?

189 30 37 6 6

98.4%

186

90%

27

97.3%

36

100 %

6

100%

6

-

1.6%

3

10%

3

2.7%

1

0%

0

0

0%

2.7%

5

97.3%

184

30%

9

70%

21

21.6%

8

78.4%

29

0%

0

100%

6

0%

0

100%

6


65/82

64

5.

5.1 ?

130

(94.2%)

8

(5.8%

)

27

(100%)

0

(0%)

28

(100%)

0

(0%)

5

(%83.3

)

1

(16.7%

)

4

(100

%)

0

(0%)

170

(97.1%)

5

(2.9%

)

21

(100%)

0

(0%)

36

(97.3%)

1

(2.7%)

3

(100%

)

0

(0%)

7

(100

%)

0

(0%)

5.2

)?

125

(90.6%

)

13

(9.4%)

27

(100%)

0

(0%)

28

(100%

)

0

(0%)

6

(100%

)

0

(0%)

4

(100%

)

0

(0%)

164

(93.7%

)

11

(6.3%)

21

(100%)

0

(0%)

36

(97.3%

)

1

(2.7

%)

3

(100%

)

0

(0%)

6

(85.7%

)

1

(14.3

%)


66/82

65

5.3

?

5.4

?

47

(34.1%)

91

(65.9%)

23

(85.2%)

4

(14.8%

)

28

(100%)

0

(0%)

4

66.7%)

2

(33.3%)2 (50%)

2

(50%)

106

(60.6%)

69

(39.4%)

18

(85.7%)

3

(14.3%

)

36

(97.3%)

1

(2.7%

)

2

(66.7%

)

1

(33.3%)

1

(14.2%)6 (85.8%)

19

(13.8%)

119

(86.2%)

27

(100%)

0

(0%)

27

(96.4%)

1

(3.6%)3 (50%)

3

(50%)

4

(100%)0

38

(21.7%)

137

(78.3%)

19

(90.5%)

2

(9.5%)

31

(83.8%)

6

(16.2%)

3

(100%)

0

(0%)

6

(85.7%)

1

(14.3%)


67/82

66

5.5

?

5.6 -

?

110

(79.7%)

28

(20.3%)

27 (100

%)

0

(0%)

28

(100%)

0

( 0%)

2

(33.3%)

4

(66.7%)

4

(100

%)

0%

0

155

(88.6%)

20(11.4

%)

21

(100%)0 (0%)

37

(100%)

0

( 0%)3 (100%)

0

(0%)

3

(42.9

%)

4

(57.1% )

109

(80%)

29

(20%)

27

(100%)

0

(0%)

28

(100%)

0

(0%)

3

(50%)

3

(50%)

4

(100%)0 (0%)

150

(85.7%)

25

(14.3%)

21

(100%)

0

(0%)

35

(94.6%)

2

(5.4%)0 (0%)

3

(100%)

6

(85.7%)

1

(14.3%


68/82

67

5.7

?

5.8 -

) )

?

19

(13.8%)

119

(86.2%)

26

(96.3%)

1

(3.7%)

28

(100%)

0

(0%)

4

(66.7%)

2

(33.3%)

0

(0%)

4

(100%)

22

(12.6%)

153

(87.4%)

21

(100%)

0

(0 %)

35

(94.6%)

2

(5.4%)

2

(66.7%)

1

(33.3%)

0

(0%)

7

(100%)

10 (7.2%)128

(92.8%)

21

(77.8%)

6

(22.2%)

28

(100%)

0

(0%)

1

(16.7%)

5

(83.3%)

0

(0%)

4

(100

%)

11 (6.3%)

164

(93.7%)

16

(76.2%)

5

(23.8%)

37

(100%)

0

(0%) 0 (0%)3

(100%) 0 (0%)

7

(100%)


69/82

68

5.9 -

?

5.10 -

?

15

(10.9%)

123

(89.1%)

20

(74.1%)

7

(25.9%)

28

(100%)

0

(0%)

1

(16.7%)

5

(83.3%)0 (0%)

4

(100

%)

14 (8%)

161 (92

%)

16

(76.2%)

5

(23.8%)

37

(100%)

0

(0%) 0 (0%)

3

(100%) 0 (0%)

7

(100%)

10

(7.3%)

128

(92.7%

)

20

(74.1%

)

7

(25.9%

)

28

(100%

)

0

(0%)0 (0%)

6

(100%)

0

(0%)

4

(100

%)

12

(6.9%)

163

(93.1%

)

16

(76.2%

)

5

(23.8%

)

36

(97.3

%)

1 (2.7%) 0 (0%)3

(100%)

0

(0%)

7

(100

%)


70/82

69

5.11 -

?

5.12 -

?

16

(11.6%)

122

(88.4%)

20

(74.1%)

7

(25.9%)

28

(100%)

0

(0%)

1

(16.3%)

5

(73.7%)

0

(0%)

4

(100%)

11

(6.3%)

164

(93.7%)

16

(76.2%)

5

(23.8%)

36

(97.3%)

1

(2.7%)0 (0%)

3

(100%)

0

(0%)

7

(100%)

7

(5.1%)

131

(94.9%)

20

(74.1%

)

7

(25.9%)

28

(100%)

0

(0%)0 (0%)

6

(100%

)

0 (0%)4

(100%)

13

(7.4%)

162

(92.6%)

16

(76.2%

)

5

(23.8%)

35

(94.6%)2 (5.4%) 0 (0%)

3

(100%

)

0 (0%)7

(100%)


71/82

70

5.13 -

?

5.14

?

1.6%

3

0%

0

98.4%

186

33.3%

1

0%

0

96.7%

29

2.7%

1

0%

0

97.3%

36

0%

0

0%

0

100%

6

0%

0

0%

0

100%

6

7

(5.1%)

131

(94.9%)

24

(88.9%)

3

(11.1%)

18

(64.3%)

10

(35.7%)

0

(0%)

6

(100%)

1

(25%)

3

(75%)

10

(5.7%)

165

(94.3%)

15

(71.4%)

6

(28.6%)

26

(70.3%)

11

(29.7%)

0

(0%)

3

(100%)

0

(0%)

7

(100%)


72/82

71

5.15 -

?

5.16

?

5.17

?

56.4%

22

43.6%

17

66.7%

10

33.3%

5

80%

12

20%

3

- - - -

189 30 37 6 6

2

(1.1%)

187 (98.9

%)

0 (0%) 30

(100%)

0

(0%)

37

(100%)

0

(0%)

6 (100%) 0

(0 %)

6

(100%)

189 30 37 6 6

187 (98.9%)

2(1.1%)

0 (0%) 30(100%)

0(0%)

37(100%)

0(0%)

6 (100%) 0(0 %)

6(100%)


73/82

72

5.18 -

?

5.19 - ?

45.5%

86

8.5%

16

87

100%

280%

02

100

%

23

0%

014

100%

60%

00

83.3%

5

16.7%

10

17.5%

33 cases

82.5%

156 cases

60%

18

cases

40%

12

cases

100%

37

cases

0%

0

cases

33.3%

2

cases

66.7%

4

cases

83.3%

5 cases

16.7%

1 cases


74/82

73

5.20 ?

5.21

,

?

5.22 //

?

96.3%

182

3.7%

7

96.7%

29

3.3%

1

100%

37

0%

0

100%

6

0%

0

100%

6

0%

0

1.6%

3

98.4%

186

0%

0

100%

30

0%

0

100%

37

0%

0

100%

6

0%

0

100%

6

1.1%2

98.9%

187

0%0

100%30

0%0

100%37

0%0

100%6

0%0

100%6


75/82

74

5.23

?

5.24

, ?

5.25

?

96.8%

183

3.2%

6

100%

30

0%

0

97.3%

36

2.7%

1

100%

6

100%

0

100%

6

0%

0

25.9%

49

74.1%

140

60%

18

40%

12

100%

37

0%

0

100%

6

0%

0

33.3%

2

66.7%

4

54%

102

56%

87

66.7%

29

33.3%

1

100%

37

0%

0

100%

6

0%

0

66.7%

4

33.3%

2


76/82

75

5.26 ?46

-

-

19.6%

27

hearings

68.8%

95

hearings

11.6%

16

hearings

19.4%

34

hearings

69.7%

122 hearings

10.9%

19 hearings

96.3%

26

hearings

0%

0

hearings

3.7%

1 hearings

90.5%

19

hearings

4.8%

1 hearings

4.7%

1 hearings

96.4%

27

hearings

3.6%

1

hearings

0%

0 hearings

81.1%

30

hearings

16.2%

6 hearings

2.7%

1 hearings

66.6%

4 hearings

16.7%

1

hearings

16.7%

1 hearing

66.7%

2 hearings

33.3%

1 hearings

0%

0 hearing

0%

0 hearings

75%

3

hearings

25%

1 hearings

0%

0 hearing

100%

7 hearings

0%

0 hearings

46,

.


77/82

76

6.

6.1 ?

6.2

/?

6.3

/?

15

(10.9

%)

153

(89.1%

)

0

(0%)

27

(100%)

0

(0%

)

28

(100%)

0

(0%)

6

(100%)

0

(0 %)

4

(100%)

11

(6.3%

)

164

(93.7%

)

0

(0%)

21

(100%)

0

(0%

)

27

(100%)

0

(0%)

3

(100%)

0

(0%)

7

(100%)

17

(12.3%)

121

(87.7%)

4

(14.8%)

23

(85.2%)

4

(14.3%)

24

(85.7%)

1

(16.7%)

5

(83.3%)

0

(0

%)

4

(100%)

11

(6.3%)

164

(93.7%)

1

(4.8%)

20

(95.2%)

8

(29.6%

19

(70.4%)

0

(0%)

3

(100%)

0

(0%)

7

(100%)

24

(17.4%)

114

(82.6%)

20

(74.1%)

7

(25.9%)

8

(28.6%)

20

(71.4.%)

6

(100%)

0

(0%)

0

(0

%)

4

(100%)

12

(6.9%)

163

(93.1%)

2

(9.5%)

19

(90.5%)

3

(11.1%)

24

(88.9%)

3

(100%)

0

(0%)

0

(0%)

7

(100%)


78/82

77

6.4

-

///?

6.5-

?

6.6-

?

5

(3.6%)

133

(96.4%)

0

(0%)

27

(100%)

2

(7.1%)

26

(92.9%)

0

(0%)

6

(100%)

0

(0%)

4

(100%)

4

(2.3%)

171

(97.7%)

0

(0%)

21

(100%)

0

(4.5%)

27

(95.5%)

0

(0%)

3

(100%)

0

(0%)

7

(100%)

33 (17.5%) 156(82.5%)

18 (60%) 12 (40%) 37 (100%) 0 (0%) 2 (33.3%) 4 (66.7%) 5(83.3%)

1(16.7%)

84.8%

134

15.2%

24

100%

30

0%

0

100%

37

0%

0

100%

6

0%

0

100%

6

0%

0


79/82

78

6.7- ?

6.8:

58.7%

111

41.3%

78

66.7%

20

33.3%

10

97.3%

36

2.7%

1

66.7%

4

33.3%

2

0%

0

100%

6

5 4 6 3 2


80/82

79

7. )

7.1

?

7.2

?

122

29

43

12

6

62.3%

(76

)

86.2%

(25

)

81.4%

(35

)

50%

(6

)

66.7%

(4

)

37.7%(46

)

13.9%(4

)

18.6%(8

)

50%(6

)

33.3%(2

)

50

25

31

5

-

76%

( 38

)

96%

(24

)

83.9%

(26

)

40%

(2

)

-

24%

(12

)

4%

(1

)

36%

(16.2

)

60%

(3

)

-


81/82

80

7.3

?

7.4 ?

3.7%

7

1.6%

3

94.7%

179

0%

0

0%

0

100%

30

2.7%

1

10.8%

4

86.5%

32

0%

0

0%

0

100%

6

0%

0

16.7%

1

83.3%

5

0%

0

100%

189

0%

0

100%

30

0%

0

100%

37

0%

0

100%

6

0%

0

100%

6


82/82

8.

8.1 :

8.2

?

1.6%

3

0%

0

16.2%

6

0%

0

0%

0

98.4%

186

100%

30

83.8%

31

100%

6

100%

6

61.4%

116

26.7%

8

29.7%

11

33.3%

2

66.7%

4

24.3%

46

50%

15

16.2%

20

33.3%

2

33.3%

2

14.3%

27

23.3%

7

54.1%

6

33.3%

2

0%

0

sasamartlo monitoringis angarishi n4 2014

Documents