russia relations da mndi

8/10/2019 Russia Relations DA MNDI

1/30

Russia Disad- Practice Debate

MNDI ASK

Russia Relations Disad- Practice Debate

1NC Russia Relations DA...................................................................................................2

1NC Russia Relations DA...................................................................................................3

Uniqueness- US- Russia Relations High.............................................................................4

Uniqueness- US Russia Relations High..............................................................................5

AT: START Uniqueness !e"#hel$s..............................................................................%

AT: START Uniqueness !e"#hel$s..............................................................................&

AT: Uniqueness !e"#hel$s the 'in(................................................................................)

'in(s- Relations...................................................................................................................*

'in(s- Relations.................................................................................................................1+

'in(s- Relations.................................................................................................................11

S,ae oo,e"ation (e to /ilate"al Relations....................................................................12US Russia Relations 0oo Te""o"is$ oule...............................................................13

US Russia Relations goo- "an oule...........................................................................14

US Russia Relations 0oo- isal oule....................................................................15

US Russia Relations 0oo- Russia- China Conlit..........................................................1%

US Russia Relations 0oo Hege....................................................................................1&

AT: Relations Resilient......................................................................................................1)

AT: S,ae Rae ne!itale.................................................................................................1*

AT: S,ae Rae ne!itale Sel 6ulilling 7"o,he......................................................2+

AT :S,ae Rae ne!itale Hu$an Natu"e.....................................................................21

***Affirmative

A Relations Resilient....................................................................................................22

A S,ae Not 8e To Relations....................................................................................23

A Uniqueness !e"#hel$s the 'in( - START............................................................24

A- Relations 'o#............................................................................................................25

A- AT: "an 7"oli $,at................................................................................................2%

A AT: Nulea" Te""o"is$ $,at..................................................................................2&

A AT: Nulea" 7"oli $,at........................................................................................2)

A AT: Nulea" 7"oli $,at........................................................................................2*

****IF YO AR! AFFIRMA"I#! DO NO" SAY R!$A"IONS $O% AND

NI&!N!SS O#!R%'!$MS "'! $INK- MS" PI(K ON! OR "'!

O"'!R****1


2/30


MNDI ASK

2


3/30


MNDI ASK

)N( Russia Relations DA

S-Russia relations imrovin+- $ib,a S"AR" Iran

Financial "imes ./)0/11 96o"eign "elations: $,"o!e US ties ,oint to a ne# e"a;a?@@17$aT,/&The sight o a "ela?e7"esient D$it" e!ee! hattingo!e" ha$u"ge"s #ith his US ounte",a"t/a"a( a$a

on a !isit to the US last ea" #as a sign o Bust ho# $uh "elations et#een the t#o ount"ies 1ave 2armedin the ,ast th"ee ea"s.A $o"e tangile sign o the i$,"o!e$ent sine the US "eset< o "elations; anoso#s shit to a $o"e ,"ag$ati o"eign ,oli; #as oso#s astention at the UN Seu"it Counil ina"h on a $otion allo#ing #este"n inte"!ention in 'ia. n as gone ; it $ight ha!e een e?,ete to e?e"ise its !eto. That #asthe latest in a se"ies o on"ete a!anes. These ha!e inlue: the ne# Sta"t t"eat on "euing st"ateginulea" #ea,ons Russian a(ing o" a UN "esolution tightening santions on "an an a eal ,e"$ittingNato shi,$ents to Aghanistan a"oss Russian te""ito".

Plan collases S-Russia relations

Kreon 2+3497"esient e$e"itus o the Hen" '. Sti$son Cente"; is the autho" o S,ae Assu"ane o"S,ae Do$inaneE The Case Against Fea,oni@ing S,ae #ith Ch"isto,he" Cla"; Coo,e"ati!e Th"eatReution; issile Deense; an the Nulea" 6utu"e an eito" o Nulea" Ris( Reution in South Asia9Hen" '. Sti$son Cente"; S,ae Assu"ane o" S,ae Do$inaneE;

htt,:==###.sti$son.o"g=i$ages=u,loas="esea"h-,s=s,aeoo(.,; %=24=11U.S. initiati!es to sei@e< the high g"oun o s,ae a"e li(el to e ounte"e as$$et"i anunon!entional #a"a"e st"ategies a""ie out a" #ea(e" statesGin s,ae an to a g"eate" e?tent on a"th. naition; U.S. initiati!es assoiate #ith s,ae o$inane #oul li(el alienatelongstaning allies; as #ell as Chinaan Russia; #hose assistane is "equi"e to eeti!el ounte" te""o"is$ an ,"olie"ation;the t#o $ost ,"essingnational seu"it one"ns o this eae. No U.S. all has e?,"esse su,,o"t o" s,ae #a"a"e initiati!es. To the ont"a"; U.S.initiati!es to #ea,oni@e s,ae #oul li(el corrode bilateral relations an oalition-uiling eo"ts. nstea;the initiation o ,"ee$,ti!e o" ,"e!enti!e #a"a"e in s,ae the Unite States ase on asse"tions o an i$$inent th"eatGo" a th"eatthat annot e a$elio"ate in othe" #asGis li(el to e $et #ith ee, an #ies,"ea s(e,tiis$ a"oa.

Increasin+ S Russia Relations 5e, to solve rolif nuclear terrorism and nuclear use

Perr, and Sco2croft 637IFillia$ an "ent; Chai"s C6R; a,"il; US Nulea" Fea,ons 7oli


4/30


MNDI ASK

)N( Russia Relations DA

Proliferation causes nuclear 2ar

Kito" t+off; Su$$e" 9339; Su"!i!al; !ol 44; no. 2; 7"oLuestn su$; #ies,"ea ,"olie"ation is li(el to lea to an oasional shoot-out #ith nulea" #ea,ons; an that suh

shoot-outs #ill ha!e a sustantial ,"oailit o esalating to the $a?i$u$ est"ution,ossile #ith the #ea,onsat han. Unlessnulea","olie"ation is sto,,e; #e a"e heae to a #o"l that #ill $i""o" theA$e"ian Fil Festo the late 1)++s. Fith $ost; i not all; nations #ea"ing nulea" Msi?-shoote"s on thei" hi,s; the #o"l $a e!en e a $o"e ,olite ,laethan it is toa; ut e!e" one in a #hile #e #ill all gathe" on a hill to u" the oies o ea ities o" e!en #hole nations.

"errorism leads to e:tinction

Sid-A1med 3;


5/30


MNDI ASK

ni>ueness- S- Russia Relations 'i+1

Relations 1i+1- S"AR" Af+1anistan Iran

Nola ./9)=11 INe# "leans usiness ne#s; U.S. an Russia a"e st"engthening thei" "elationshi,;A$assao" sas;< htt,:==###.nola.o$=usiness=ine?.ss=2+11=+%=usOanO"ussiaOa"eOst"engthenin.ht$lJThe a$a a$inist"ation has e?,e"iene a ,ositi!e "eset in U.S.-Russian "elations oth ,olitiall an

eono$iall; U.S. A$assao" to the Russian 6ee"ation Pohn /e"le sai u"ing a s,eeh in Ne# "leans on Tuesa. QThis"elationshi, has een "eset o!e" the last t#o to th"ee ea"s;Q /e"le sai at an e!ent at the Fo"l Fa" useu$s,onso"e the Fo"l T"ae Cente" o Ne# "leans an othe" o"gani@ations. QFe"e on the th"eshol o a ne# an ette" ,e"io o

"elations.Q /e"le note "eent U.S.-Russia ao$,lish$ents suh as the signing o the START T"eat to"eue nulea" a"$s in oth ount"ies; in"easing Russian su,,o"t o" NAT t"oo,s in Aghanistan anin"ease oo,e"ation an oo"ination #ithin the Unite Nations Seu"it Counil to u" "ans nulea","og"a$.The a$assao" also e$,hasi@e that "elations #ith Russia a"e not onl ,olitiall a!antageous o" the Unite States; utalso eono$iall essential. Q0oo ,olitial "elations a"e not enough; an #e nee $o"e soli ounations o t"ae an usiness. u"

,"os,e"it is losel inte"t#ine #ith Russia; sine its a $aBo" $a"(et o" U.S. goos an se"!ies;Q he sai u"ing the lunheon,"og"a$; #hih #as alle QThe Cu""ent State o U.S.-Russia Relations.Q Fhile t"ae et#een the Unite States an Russia has ouleo!e" the ,ast ou" ea"s; the so,e o eono$i oo,e"ation et#een Russia an Ne# "leans has also e?,ane. Qu" e?,o"ts to Russia"o$ Ne# "leans g"e# e?,onentiall et#een 2++% an 2+1+;Q sai ao" ith 'an"ieu. QThe"es a g"eat ,a"tne"shi, et#een Ne#

"leans an Russia.Q A$e"ian o$,anies ha!e ta(en the "eset to hea"t; ae /e"le. Q U.S. o$,anies a"e no# #ell-estalishe in Russia an a"e "eating Bos ;Q he e?,laine; iting the "eent ati!ities o 6o"; 0ene"al oto"s; an high-tehentities suh as i"osot; Ciso an /oeing. De$o"ati e!elo,$ent in ,ost-So!iet Russia has also ha ,ositi!e i$,liations o"

Unite States tou"is$.QRussia is no# $o"e o,en an in"easingl onnete #ith the #o"l;Q the a$assao" sai. QRussians "eentliso!e"e the A$e"ian South; an no# the"e a"e i"et lights to an "o$ Houston an Atlanta.Q

S-Russian Relations 'i+1 no2 ? increased cooeration and suort8

@ood une 9)11 IAlison; U.S. an Russia a"e st"engthening thei" "elationshi,; A$assao" sas; Ne#"leans /usiness Ne#s;htt,:==###.nola.o$=usiness=ine?.ss=2+11=+%=usOanO"ussiaOa"eOst"engthenin.ht$l; Date Aesse%=2%=11JThe a$a a$inist"ation has e?,e"iene a ,ositi!e "eset in U.S.-Russian "elations oth ,olitiall aneono$iall; U.S. A$assao" to the Russian 6ee"ation Pohn /e"le sai u"ing a s,eeh in Ne# "leans on Tuesa. QThis"elationshi, has een "eset o!e" the last t#o to th"ee ea"s;Q /e"le sai at an e!ent at the Fo"l Fa" useu$ s,onso"e the Fo"l

T"ae Cente" o Ne# "leans an othe" o"gani@ations. QFe"e on the th"eshol o a ne# an ette" ,e"io o "elations.Q/e"le note "eent U.S.-Russia ao$,lish$ents suh as the signing o the START T"eat to "eue nulea"

a"$s in oth ount"ies; in"easing Russian su,,o"t o" NAT t"oo,s in Aghanistan an in"easeoo,e"ation an oo"ination #ithin the Unite Nations Seu"it Counil to u" "ans nulea" ,"og"a$.

5
http://www.nola.com/business/index.ssf/2011/06/us_and_russia_are_strengthenin.htmlhttp://www.nola.com/business/index.ssf/2011/06/us_and_russia_are_strengthenin.html


6/30


MNDI ASK

ni>ueness- S Russia Relations 'i+1

S-Russia relations 1i+1 ? 8S8 and Russia collaborate on multile issues

@ood 3.-9)-)) ?Reorter for "imes-Pica,une 9Ne# "leans /usiness Ne#s;htt,:==###.nola.o$=usiness=ine?.ss=2+11=+%=usOanO"ussiaOa"eOst"engthenin.ht$l; U.S. an Russia a"est"engthening thei" "elationshi,; A$assao" sas; Aesse Pune 2%

The a$a a$inist"ation has e?,e"iene a ,ositi!e "eset in U.S.-Russian "elations oth ,olitiall aneono$iall; U.S. A$assao" to the Russian 6ee"ation Pohn /e"le sai u"ing a s,eeh in Ne# "leans onTuesa.QThis "elationshi, has een "eset o!e" the last t#o to th"ee ea"s;Q /e"le sai at an e!ent at the Fo"l Fa" useu$

s,onso"e the Fo"l T"ae Cente" o Ne# "leans an othe" o"gani@ations. QFe"e on the th"eshol o a ne# an ette",e"io o "elations.Q/e"le note "eent U.S.-Russia ao$,lish$ents suh as the signing o the STARTT"eat to "eue nulea" a"$s in oth ount"ies; in"easing Russian su,,o"t o" NAT t"oo,s in Aghanistan anin"ease oo,e"ation an oo"ination #ithin the Unite Nations Seu"it Counil to u" "ans nulea","og"a$.

8S8-Russian relation6s 1i+1- S"AR" Iran Af+1anistan

@ood .-9)9Allison; "e,o"te" at The Ti$es 7iaune; 2+11; nola.o$; U.S. an Russia a"e st"engtheningthei" "elationshi,; A$assao" sas


7/30


MNDI ASK

A"C S"AR" ? ni>ueness Over21elms

S"AR" 2as s,mbolic ? doesn6t sillover to relations

Boot 93)3 o"eign ,oli analst 9a?; Peane P. 8i"(,at"i( Senio" 6ello# in National Seu"it Stuiesat the Counil on 6o"eign Relations in Ne# o"(; Ne# START T"eat: uh Ao Aout Nothing;

russia relations da mndi

Documents