rock art stability index overall panel scoring ron dorn arizona state university ron dorn arizona...

29
Rock Art Stability Index Overall Panel Scoring Ron Dorn Arizona State University

Post on 21-Dec-2015

216 views

Category:

Documents


1 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Rock Art Stability Index Overall Panel Scoring Ron Dorn Arizona State University Ron Dorn Arizona State University

Rock Art Stability Index

Overall Panel ScoringRon DornArizona State University

Ron DornArizona State University

Page 2: Rock Art Stability Index Overall Panel Scoring Ron Dorn Arizona State University Ron Dorn Arizona State University
Page 3: Rock Art Stability Index Overall Panel Scoring Ron Dorn Arizona State University Ron Dorn Arizona State University
Page 4: Rock Art Stability Index Overall Panel Scoring Ron Dorn Arizona State University Ron Dorn Arizona State University
Page 5: Rock Art Stability Index Overall Panel Scoring Ron Dorn Arizona State University Ron Dorn Arizona State University
Page 6: Rock Art Stability Index Overall Panel Scoring Ron Dorn Arizona State University Ron Dorn Arizona State University
Page 7: Rock Art Stability Index Overall Panel Scoring Ron Dorn Arizona State University Ron Dorn Arizona State University
Page 8: Rock Art Stability Index Overall Panel Scoring Ron Dorn Arizona State University Ron Dorn Arizona State University
Page 9: Rock Art Stability Index Overall Panel Scoring Ron Dorn Arizona State University Ron Dorn Arizona State University

Scale and ConsistencyScale and Consistency

Page 10: Rock Art Stability Index Overall Panel Scoring Ron Dorn Arizona State University Ron Dorn Arizona State University
Page 11: Rock Art Stability Index Overall Panel Scoring Ron Dorn Arizona State University Ron Dorn Arizona State University

Excellent Condition: Why?Excellent Condition: Why?

Basalt talus tends to display very little evidence of weathering and erosion

Basalt talus tends to display very little evidence of weathering and erosion

Largest issues are plant growth near panel, some scaling of the rock, and detachment of the rock varnish

Step 6 (Vandalism) is of minor concern because site is at the Deer Valley Rock Art Center

Largest issues are plant growth near panel, some scaling of the rock, and detachment of the rock varnish

Step 6 (Vandalism) is of minor concern because site is at the Deer Valley Rock Art Center

Page 12: Rock Art Stability Index Overall Panel Scoring Ron Dorn Arizona State University Ron Dorn Arizona State University
Page 13: Rock Art Stability Index Overall Panel Scoring Ron Dorn Arizona State University Ron Dorn Arizona State University

Good Condition: Why?Good Condition: Why?

Silicified dolomite bedrock has few weaknesses for weathering to get a foothold

Silicified dolomite bedrock has few weaknesses for weathering to get a foothold

Largest issues are plant growth near panel, some scaling of the rock, and detachment of the rock varnish

Step 6 (Vandalism) is of minor concern because site is on private land with a site steward

Largest issues are plant growth near panel, some scaling of the rock, and detachment of the rock varnish

Step 6 (Vandalism) is of minor concern because site is on private land with a site steward

Page 14: Rock Art Stability Index Overall Panel Scoring Ron Dorn Arizona State University Ron Dorn Arizona State University

Score 28

Score 28

Page 15: Rock Art Stability Index Overall Panel Scoring Ron Dorn Arizona State University Ron Dorn Arizona State University

Good Condition

Why?

Good Condition

Why?

Largest issues are fissures that are from lava flow generation and cooling, and collapse of tumuli separating the top layers from the rest of the flow

Scaling, anthropogenic activity also issues

Largest issues are fissures that are from lava flow generation and cooling, and collapse of tumuli separating the top layers from the rest of the flow

Scaling, anthropogenic activity also issues

Page 16: Rock Art Stability Index Overall Panel Scoring Ron Dorn Arizona State University Ron Dorn Arizona State University
Page 17: Rock Art Stability Index Overall Panel Scoring Ron Dorn Arizona State University Ron Dorn Arizona State University

Problems: Why?Problems: Why? Despite strong

granite rock, abundant fissures (joints)

Despite strong granite rock, abundant fissures (joints)

Largest issues are granular distintegration, fissuresol wedging, undercutting, and lichens

Step 6 (Vandalism) is a substantial concern because site is in a metropolitan area and is receives heavy visitation

Largest issues are granular distintegration, fissuresol wedging, undercutting, and lichens

Step 6 (Vandalism) is a substantial concern because site is in a metropolitan area and is receives heavy visitation

Page 18: Rock Art Stability Index Overall Panel Scoring Ron Dorn Arizona State University Ron Dorn Arizona State University

Stage 6could

add20 pointsto reflect vandalis

mconcern

Stage 6could

add20 pointsto reflect vandalis

mconcern

30 (raw score)

+ 20 = 50

30 (raw score)

+ 20 = 50

Page 19: Rock Art Stability Index Overall Panel Scoring Ron Dorn Arizona State University Ron Dorn Arizona State University
Page 20: Rock Art Stability Index Overall Panel Scoring Ron Dorn Arizona State University Ron Dorn Arizona State University

Problems: Why?Problems: Why?

Largest issues are weakness of the sandstone, development and then flaking of the weathering rind, and splintering along bedding planes

Largest issues are weakness of the sandstone, development and then flaking of the weathering rind, and splintering along bedding planes

Page 21: Rock Art Stability Index Overall Panel Scoring Ron Dorn Arizona State University Ron Dorn Arizona State University

Problems – Score 33Problems – Score 33

Page 22: Rock Art Stability Index Overall Panel Scoring Ron Dorn Arizona State University Ron Dorn Arizona State University

Why problems with this panel?

Why problems with this panel?

Also flaking, granular disintegration, salt efflorescence, detachment of the pictograph paint

Also flaking, granular disintegration, salt efflorescence, detachment of the pictograph paint

Large issues are scaling, undercutting

Site manager might put this site in “great danger” because of visitor use abrade panels

Large issues are scaling, undercutting

Site manager might put this site in “great danger” because of visitor use abrade panels

Page 23: Rock Art Stability Index Overall Panel Scoring Ron Dorn Arizona State University Ron Dorn Arizona State University
Page 24: Rock Art Stability Index Overall Panel Scoring Ron Dorn Arizona State University Ron Dorn Arizona State University

Great Dangers: Biggest Issues

Great Dangers: Biggest Issues

Fluvial AbrasionFluvial Abrasion

Salt EfflorescenceSalt Efflorescence

Flaking of Weak SandstoneFlaking of Weak Sandstone

Page 25: Rock Art Stability Index Overall Panel Scoring Ron Dorn Arizona State University Ron Dorn Arizona State University
Page 26: Rock Art Stability Index Overall Panel Scoring Ron Dorn Arizona State University Ron Dorn Arizona State University

Severe Dangers: A host of issues

Severe Dangers: A host of issues

Lots of fissures, weak rock, wedging by fissuresols, plant growth, scaling, splintering, undercutting, development and erosion of weathering rinds, crumbling of rock under lichens, granular disintegration, flaking, detachment of rock coatings, scaling, chalking, graffiti, and salt efflorescence

Lots of fissures, weak rock, wedging by fissuresols, plant growth, scaling, splintering, undercutting, development and erosion of weathering rinds, crumbling of rock under lichens, granular disintegration, flaking, detachment of rock coatings, scaling, chalking, graffiti, and salt efflorescence

Page 27: Rock Art Stability Index Overall Panel Scoring Ron Dorn Arizona State University Ron Dorn Arizona State University
Page 28: Rock Art Stability Index Overall Panel Scoring Ron Dorn Arizona State University Ron Dorn Arizona State University

Display Information

Display Information

Page 29: Rock Art Stability Index Overall Panel Scoring Ron Dorn Arizona State University Ron Dorn Arizona State University

Rock Art Stability Index

Overall Panel ScoringRon DornArizona State University

Ron DornArizona State University