québec court of appeal - mccarthy tétraultmccarthy.ca/pubs/qcca_appellate_cases_1113.pdf · three...
TRANSCRIPT
Page 1
The French version will be available soon.
Québec Court of Appeal Appellate Cases Argued by Active McCarthy Tétrault Lawyers
COURT CASE DATE CITATIONS LAWYER ACTED FOR REGION TYPE OF
APPEAL FURTHER HISTORY
LEGAL AND INDUSTRY FOCUS
QCCA Banque de Montréal/Bank of Montreal c. Banque de Nouvelle-Écosse/Bank of Nova Scotia
09/12/13 [2013] J.Q. no 11447 2013 QCCA 1548
Tremblay, Gérald R. Boodman, Martin
Respondent QC Final Appeal Banks and financial institutions – Civil liability – Customer of a bank engaged in fraudulent activities (“kiting”) – Duty of the bank to stop the illegal activities and not to benefit from the said activities
QCCA St-Arnaud c. C.L.
05/27/13 [2013] J.Q. no 5710, 2013 QCCA 981
Jarry, Claude M. Dufort-Langlois, Philippe
Appellant QC Final appeal Medical liability – child born premature – causation – damage caused by premature birth – discretionary power of the court to reserve the right of the creditor to apply for additional damages within three years (art. 1615 CCQ)
QCCA Enterprises R & G St-Laurent inc. C. Québec (Procureur général) (Ministère des Transports du Québec)
05/25/13 [2013] J.Q. no 5576, 2013 QCCA 953
Demers, Nancy DeMeyer, Pascale
Appellant QC Final Appeal Public call for tenders – lowest tender – No tender accepted – Equality of treatment of tenderers
QCCA Lévesque c. Hudon
05/22/13 2013 QCCA 920 Chénier, Robert-Jean Roberge, David
Appellant QC Final Appeal Medical malpractice - Orthopedic surgery - Alleged late diagnosis and treatment - Anterior cruciate ligament
Page 2
The French version will be available soon.
COURT CASE DATE CITATIONS LAWYER ACTED FOR REGION TYPE OF
APPEAL FURTHER HISTORY
LEGAL AND INDUSTRY FOCUS
Emmanuel injury - Causation
QCCA Hudon c. Carpentier
05/22/13 2013 QCCA 921 Chénier, Robert-Jean Roberge, David Emmanuel
Respondent QC Final Appeal Medical malpractice - Orthopedic surgery - Alleged late diagnosis and treatment - Anterior cruciate ligament injury - Causation
QCCA MacMillan c. Abbott Laboratories
05/15/13 [2013] Q.J. No. 5177, 2013 QCCA 906
Gagné, Michel Poupart, Emmanuelle
Respondent QC Final Appeal Class action - Medication - Meridia - Authorization stage - The facts alleged did not justify the conclusions sought
QCCA Lorrain c. Petro-Canada
03/15/13 [2013] J.Q. no 2432, 2013 QCCA 486
Roberge, David E. Gagnon, Isabelle
Respondent QC Final Appeal Medical malpractice - Erroneous diagnosis - Extinctive prescription - Moment at which prescription started
QCCA Lorrain c Petro Canada
02/21/13 [2013] J.Q. No. 1420, 2013 QCCA 332
Poupart, Emmanuelle Beauchesne-Paquette, Simon
Respondent QC Appeal Class action – Criteria for authorization – Calibration of gas pumps – Weights and measures
QCCA Consultants Aecom inc. C. Société du Québec
01/18/13 [2013] J.Q. no 162, 2013 QCCA 52
Demers, Nancy Germain, Isabelle de Meyer, Pascale
Respondent QC Appeal Contracts – Interlocutory injunction – Resiliation of a contract for professional services – Unsatisfactory performance evaluation
QCCA Canada (Procurer général) c. Impérial Tobacco Ltd.
11/14/12 [2012] J.Q. no 13162; 2012 QCCA 2034
Potter, Simon V. Bouchard, Pierre-Jérôme
Respondent QC Appeal Civil procedure – Dismissal of action – Class action against tobacco companies – Action in warranty against Federal Crown – Federal government policy – Stare deciss – Public law immunity
Page 3
The French version will be available soon.
COURT CASE DATE CITATIONS LAWYER ACTED FOR REGION TYPE OF
APPEAL FURTHER HISTORY
LEGAL AND INDUSTRY FOCUS
QCCA Centre commercial Les Rivières ltée c. Jean Bleu inc.
09/19/12 [2012] Q.J. No 8822; 2012 QCCA 1663
Tremblay, Gérald R.
Appellant QC Appeal Civil procedure – Contempt of Court – Oral judgment – Order to product documents – Proof of the actus reus and of mens rea for civil contempt – Availability of either remedies
QCCA Imperial Tobacco Canada Ltd. C. Conseil québécois sur le tabac et la santé
09/17/12 [2012] J.Q. no 8750; 2012 QCCA 1641
Potter, Simon V.
Appellant QC Interlocutory Civil procedure – Production of documents – Survey data – Class ction – Tobacco companies
QCCA Han c. Demers 09/17/12 2012 QCCA 1685 Moisan, Jérémie Nicolas
Respondent QC Appeal Medical malpractice – Ophthalmologist – Laser eye surgery – Myopia – Motion to dismiss the appeal granted
QCCA F.L. c. Lesage 07/11/12 [2012] J.Q. no. 6756, 2012 QCCA 1288
Chénier, Robert-Jean Moisan, Jérémie-Nicolas
Respondent QC Appeal Civil procedure – Parties acting in a quarrelsome manner – Dismissal of the appeal
QCCA Thibault c. Marina de la Chaudière inc.
07/03/12 [2012] J.W. no 6393, 2012 QCCA 1226
Demers, Nancy Respondent QC Appeal Civil procedure – Dismissal of the appeal – Injunction – Navigable Waters Protection Act
QCCA Bitton v. Apple Canada Inc.
06/01/12 [2012] Q.J. No 5120, 2012 QCCA 991, 2012EXP-2286, EYB 2012-207251
Potter, Simon V. Bisson, Donald Finn, Shaun
Respondent QC Appeal Class action – Authorization – Conditions precedent – Alleged false or misleading information conveyed by Apple in the marketing of iPod products regarding the memory capacity – The facts alleged did not justify the conclusions sought
Page 4
The French version will be available soon.
COURT CASE DATE CITATIONS LAWYER ACTED FOR REGION TYPE OF
APPEAL FURTHER HISTORY
LEGAL AND INDUSTRY FOCUS
QCCA N.F. c. Montréal (Ville de)
05/28/12 [2012] J.W. no 5132, 2012 QCCA 996
Desjardins, Sandra
Respondent QC Appeal Labour and employment law – Industrial accidents and occupational diseases – Jurisdiction of grievance arbitrator – Application of Weber v. Ontario Hydro
QCCA Masson c. Centre de santé et de services sociaux de St-Jérôme (CSSS)
05/14/12 [2012] J.Q. no 4660, 2012 QCCA 921
Moisan, Jérémie-Nicolas
Respondent QC Appeal Medical liability – Civil Procedure – Motion to dismiss the appeal – No chance of succeeding in appeal
QCCA Fortier c. Lavoie
04/23/12 2012 QCCA 754 Jarry, Claude M. Germain, Isabelle
Respondent QC Appeal Civil liability – Psychiatrist liability as an expert witness – “Biased and erroneous” report
QCCA Simard c. Gilbert
02/29/12 [2012] J.Q. no 1610, 2012 QCCA 383, 2012EXP-1072, 2012EXPT-533, J.E. 2012-586, D.T.E. 2012T-172, EYB 2012-202902
Rousse, Jacques
Respondent QC Appeal Labour and employment law – Labour relations – Jurisdiction of grievance arbitrator – Medical report – Forced retirement – Fundamental justice – Procedural safeguards
QCCA Matériaux de construction Oldcastle Canada Inc. c. St-Bruno-de-Montarville (Ville de)
02/28/12 [2012] J.Q. no. 1667, 2012 QCCA 404, 2012EXP-1014
Demers, Nancy Appellant QC Appeal Municipal law – land use planning and development – demolition order
QCCA Watters v. White
02/09/12 [2012] Q.J. No. 906, 2012 QCCA 257
Platts, David Griffin, Sean
Appellant QC Appeal Medical liability – rate genetic condition – obligation to inform – duty of confidentiality
Page 5
The French version will be available soon.
COURT CASE DATE CITATIONS LAWYER ACTED FOR REGION TYPE OF
APPEAL FURTHER HISTORY
LEGAL AND INDUSTRY FOCUS
– patient’s extended family
QCCA Guénard c. Oliver
01/30/12 [2012] J.Q. no. 868, 2012 QCCA 249, 2012EXP-726, J.E. 2012-401
Chénier, Robert-Jean Hudon, Marc-Alexandre
Respondent QC Appeal Medical liability – medical malpractice – anesthetist – Obligation to inform – risks – consent given orally – no obligation to disclose a very rare complication
QCCA Anvil Mining Ltd. v. Association canadienne contre l’impunité
01/24/12 [2012] J.Q. no. 368, 2012 QCCA 117, 2012EXP-513, J.E. 2012-277, EYB 2012-201106
Lehoux, Jean-François Bouchard, Pierre-Jérôme
Appellant QC Appeal Class actions – Private international law – international jurisdiction of Québec authorities – personal action – legal person having an establishment in Québec – dispute unrelated to the legal person’s activities in Québec
QCCA Organisme canadien de réglementation du commerce des valeurs mobilières (OCRCVM) c. Beaudouin
12/06/11 [2011] J.Q. no 18392 2011 QCCA 2247
Atkinson, William J. Griffin, Sean
Appellant QC Interlocutory Securities — self-regulatory organizations — jurisdiction ratione materiae — homologation of a disciplinary decision
QCCA Option Consommateurs v. Infineon Technologies AG
11/16/11 [2011] Q.J. No. 16769 2011 QCCA 2116
Renaud, Madeleine Legendre, Céline
Respondent QC Interlocutory Civil procedure — courts — jurisdiction and powers — territorial jurisdiction — declinatory exceptions — class action —- motion for authorization — damage suffered in Québec
QCCA Volailles du fermier inc c. Éleveurs de volailles du
09/27/11 [2011] J.Q. no. 13636 2011 QCCA 1772 2011 EXP-3012
Vendette, Isabelle
Respondent QC Appeal Obligations — contractual liability (breach of contract) — consent of the parties — fraud — concealment of vital
Page 6
The French version will be available soon.
COURT CASE DATE CITATIONS LAWYER ACTED FOR REGION TYPE OF
APPEAL FURTHER HISTORY
LEGAL AND INDUSTRY FOCUS
Québec inc. J.E. 2011-1686 EYB 2011-196351
information
QCCA Clouâtre c. Factory Mutual Insurance Company
09/19/11 [2011] J.Q. no 12829 2011 QCCA 1690
Lortie, Jean Russell, Marc-André
Respondent QC Appeal Insurance — legal subrogation — partial collapse of a roof — liability of construction contractors
QCCA Collège des médecins du Québec c. Genest
09/19/11 [2011] J.Q. no 12831 2011 QCCA 1683
Dufour, Marc Chamberland, Simon
Respondent QC Appeal Disciplinary law — physicians — re-entry on the roll of the order of physicians after being provisionally struck off the roll
QCCA Hébert c. Centre hospitalier affilié universitaire de Québec — Hôpital de l'Enfant-Jésus
07/27/11 [2011] J.Q. no 10708 2011 QCCA 1521 2011EXP-2700 J.E. 2011-1517 EYB 2011-194586
Jarry, Claude Boucher, Daniel
Appellant QC Appeal Medical malpractice — cerebral angiogram — apportionment of liability with the technologist — solidary liability
QCCA Caisse populaire Desjardins de Côte-des-Neiges c. Banque Toronto-Dominion
06/17/11 [2011] J.Q. no 7635 2011 QCCA 1148 2011EXP-2114 J.E. 2011-1152 EYB 2011-191973
Deschamps, Michel Perreault, Jocelyn
Respondent QC Appeal Bills of exchange — fraudulent alteration of bill — clearing system
QCCA Bombardier c. Éleveurs de volailles du Québec
06/03/11 [2011] J.Q. no 6757 2011 QCCA 1058 EYB 2011-191589
Renaud, Madeleine
Respondent QC Appeal Agri-food — chicken marketing — regulations by self-regulation organization — penalties — jurisdiction of the Régie des marchés agricoles et alimentaires du Québec
Page 7
The French version will be available soon.
COURT CASE DATE CITATIONS LAWYER ACTED FOR REGION TYPE OF
APPEAL FURTHER HISTORY
LEGAL AND INDUSTRY FOCUS
QCCA Ernst & Young, l.l.p. c. Weinberg
05/20/11 [2011] J.Q. no 5898 2011 QCCA 970 2011EXP-1841
Bergeron, Geneviève
Appellant QC Interlocutory Civil procedure — reconsideration of an interlocutory judgment proprio motu by the motions judge
QCCA Grenier c. Grenier
05/24/11 [2011] J.Q. no 5877 2011 QCCA 964 EYB 2011-191082 2011EXP-1782 J.E. 2011-982
Cantin, Philippe
Respondent QC Appeal Civil liability — medical malpractice — car accident — osteotomy
QCCA Greenberg c. Capital d'Amérique CDPQ inc.
05/20/11 [2011] Q.J. No. 5891 2011 QCCA 958 2011EXP-1807 EYB 2011-191159
Giroux, François
Respondent QC Appeal Commercial — contracts — agreement relating to the purchase of shareholdings — pre-contractual document
QCCA St-Eustache (Ville de) c. Régie intermunicipale Argenteuil Deux-Montagnes
02/07/11 [2011] J.Q. no 870 2011 QCCA 227 2011EXP-639 J.E. 2011-339
Atkinson, William J.
Appellant QC Interlocutory Civil procedure — powers of the court as to exceptions to dismiss action — premature judgment
QCCA Nechi Investments Inc. c. Autorité des marchés financiers
02/04/11 [2011] J.Q. no 774 2011 QCCA 214 2011EXP-693 J.E. 2011-370 EYB 2011-185915
Bourbonnais, Miguel
Respondent QC Interlocutory Securities — jurisdiction of Court of Québec — freezing orders
QCCA Sodexin Financement mercantile inc. c. Sport Maska inc.
01/25/11 [2011] J.Q. no 267 2011 QCCA 113
Tardif, Alain Kruger, Gene
Appellant QC Appeal Bankruptcy and insolvency — effects of the contract — shareholders — corporate personality
Page 8
The French version will be available soon.
COURT CASE DATE CITATIONS LAWYER ACTED FOR REGION TYPE OF
APPEAL FURTHER HISTORY
LEGAL AND INDUSTRY FOCUS
QCCA Soltani c. Desnoyers
12/08/10 [2010] J.Q. no 13347 2010 QCCA 2257 EYB 2010-183425 2011EXP-48 J.E. 2011-24
Laferrière, Rachel
Respondent QC Appeal Medical — civil liability — medical malpractice
QCCA R.K. v. Ackman (Succession d')
11/29/10 [2010] Q.J. No. 12461 2010 QCCA 2180 2010EXP-4078 J.E. 2010-2190 EYB 2010-182783
Platts, David E. Chamberland, Simon
Respondent QC Appeal Application for leave to appeal to the Supreme Court of Canada pending (Docket 34077, 28/01/2011)
Medical — medical malpractice — civil liability — duty to inform — disclosure of risks
QCCA Domtar Inc. c. Produits Kruger ltée
10/29/10 [2010] J.Q. no 10947 2010 QCCA 1934 2010EXP-3603 J.E. 2010-1964 EYB 2010-181157
Potter, Simon V. Kruger, Gene
Respondent QC Appeal Energy — hydroelectricity — sale of a factory — electricity supply to the factory
QCCA Conseil de la magistrature du Québec c. Dubois
10/08/10 [2010] J.Q. no 10428 2010 QCCA 1864 2010EXP-3409 J.E. 2010-1882 EYB 2010-180670
Tremblay, Gérald R. Bélanger, Marie-Eve
Respondent QC Appeal Application for leave to appeal to the Supreme Court of Canada pending (Docket 33973, 07/12/2010)
Discipline and ethics — legal professions — judges — inquiry by the Conseil de la magistrature du Québec
QCCA Forum Entertainment Center Company c. Pepsi Bottling Group
09/16/10 [2010] J.Q. no 9200 2010 QCCA 1652 2010EXP-3054 J.E. 2010-1688 EYB 2010-
Tremblay, Chantal
Respondent QC Appeal Real estate — transformation of the Montréal forum — contract — interpretation — ambiguous clause — destination of the immoveable
Page 9
The French version will be available soon.
COURT CASE DATE CITATIONS LAWYER ACTED FOR REGION TYPE OF
APPEAL FURTHER HISTORY
LEGAL AND INDUSTRY FOCUS
(Canada) Co. 179391
QCCA P.L. c. Benchetrit
08/24/10 [2010] J.Q. no 8067 2010 QCCA 1505 2010EXP-2900 J.E. 2010-1600 [2010] R.R.A. 606 [2010] R.J.Q. 1853
Brabander, Kristian Bertrand, Geneviève
Respondent QC Appeal Professional responsibility — medicine — plastic surgery — consent — expert evidence
QCCA Apple Canada Inc. c. St-Germain
07/28/10 [2010] J.Q. no 7327 2010 QCCA 1376 2010EXP-2564 J.E. 2010-1430 EYB 2010-177247 [2010] R.J.Q. 1627
Potter, Simon V. Bisson, Donald Finn, Shaun
Appellant QC Appeal Copyright — class action — iPod — royalties — proof — admission — necessity to establish that internal mechanism is a sufficient compensation
QCCA Château Drummond inc. c. 9171-8338 Québec inc.
05/20/10 [2010] J.Q. no 4746 2010 QCCA 1012
Schenke, Stephen G. Hillier, Ryan
Appellant QC Appeal Property law — servitude — parking lot
QCCA Nunez de la Torre Romero c. Lichtblau
04/23/10 [2010] J.Q. no 3551 2010 QCCA 804 2010EXP-1480 J.E. 2010-814 EYB 2010-172928
Platts, David E. Respondent QC Interlocutory Civil procedure — change of attorneys — disqualification — conflict of interest
QCCA Forest c. Raymor Industries inc.
03/24/10 [2010] J.Q. no 2439 2010 QCCA 578 2010EXP-1238
Tardif, Alain N. Perreault, Jocelyn
Respondent QC Appeal Bankruptcy and insolvency — companies' creditors arrangements — reorganization — dismissal of
Page 10
The French version will be available soon.
COURT CASE DATE CITATIONS LAWYER ACTED FOR REGION TYPE OF
APPEAL FURTHER HISTORY
LEGAL AND INDUSTRY FOCUS
J.E. 2010-673 EYB 2010-171471 66 C.B.R. (5th) 197 2010 CarswellQue 2474
appeal — lack of sufficient legal interest — mootness
QCCA Fabrikant c. Swamy
02/16/10 [2010] J.Q. no 1352 [2010] Q.J. No. 1352 2010 QCCA 330 EYB 2010-170047 2010EXP-896 J.E. 2010-492
Lehoux, Jean-François
Respondent QC Interlocutory Application for leave to appeal to the Supreme Court of Canada dismissed (Docket 33675, 08/07/2010)
Civil procedure — inherent power of superior court to punish abuse of process — right to be heard — fundamental right
QCCA Léger c. Bell Canada
12/08/09 [2009] J.Q. no 15181 2009 QCCA 2349 EYB 2009-167092
Laferrière, Rachel
Respondent QC Appeal Telecommunications — contracts — clause limiting the liability of a party
QCCA Richard c. Gougoux
12/03/09 [2009] J.Q. no 15088 2009 QCCA 2347
Bélanger, Marie-Eve
Respondent QC Appeal Civil liability — defamation — harassment — civil procedure — dismissal of the appeal
QCCA N.L. c. Sabbah 11/19/09 [2009] J.Q. no 12092 2009 QCCA 1995
Platts, David E. Respondent QC Appeal Medical — medical malpractice — dismissal of the appeal
QCCA Progistix-Solutions inc. c. Commission des normes du travail
10/26/09 [2009] J.Q. no 12538 2009 QCCA 2054 EYB 2009-165565 J.E. 2009-2045 [2009] R.J.D.T. 1103
Gagnon, Nathalie
Appellant QC Appeal Labour — labour standards — collective agreement — differences in treatment
Page 11
The French version will be available soon.
COURT CASE DATE CITATIONS LAWYER ACTED FOR REGION TYPE OF
APPEAL FURTHER HISTORY
LEGAL AND INDUSTRY FOCUS
QCCA 9152-7945 Québec inc. c. Canpages inc.
08/04/09 [2009] J.Q. no 8099 2009 QCCA 1520
Laferrière, Rachel
Respondent QC Appeal Professions — lawyers — disqualification of attorneys and law firms
QCCA Interinvest (Bermuda) Ltd. c. Herzog
07/24/09 [2009] J.Q. no 7463 2009 QCCA 1428 J.E. 2009-1451 EYB 2009-161934 179 A.C.W.S. (3d) 1088
Potter, Simon V., Brabander, Kristian
Respondent QC Interlocutory International private law — conflicts of jurisdiction — foreign corporation
QCCA Gestion Raymor inc. c. Ready Pac Canada Co.
04/08/09 [2009] J.Q. no 2973 2009 QCCA 679
Tardif, Alain Appellant QC Appeal Bankruptcy and insolvency — nanotechnology — safeguard order — interim receiver — intervention — proposition
QCCA Raymor Aerospace inc. c. Béliveau
04/08/09 [2009] J.Q. no 2972 2009 QCCA 678 EYB 2009-157156
Tardif, Alain Appellant QC Appeal Bankruptcy and insolvency — nanotechnology — safeguard order — interim receiver — intervention — proposition
QCCA Raymor Industries inc. v. Ready Pac Canada Co.
04/08/09 [2009] Q.J. No. 2974 [2009] J.Q. no 2974 2009 QCCA 680 J.E. 2009-813
Tardif, Alain Appellant QC Interlocutory Bankruptcy and insolvency — nanotechnology — safeguard order — interim receiver — intervention — proposition
QCCA Raymor Nanotech inc. c. Ready Pac Canada Co.
04/08/09 [2009] J.Q. no 2971 2009 QCCA 677
Tardif, Alain Appellant QC Interlocutory Bankruptcy and insolvency — nanotechnology — safeguard order — interim receiver — intervention — proposition
QCCA Gagné c. Fortin 04/06/09 [2009] J.Q. no 2877 2009 QCCA 659 EYB 2009-157100
Dufour, Marc Respondent QC Appeal Application for leave to appeal to the Supreme Court of Canada
Medical — medical malpractice — civil liability — psychiatrists — diagnosis — dismissal of the action — prescription
Page 12
The French version will be available soon.
COURT CASE DATE CITATIONS LAWYER ACTED FOR REGION TYPE OF
APPEAL FURTHER HISTORY
LEGAL AND INDUSTRY FOCUS
J.E. 2009-747 [2009] R.R.A. 447
dismissed (Docket 33197, 24/09/2009)
QCCA AP&C Revêtements & poudres avancées inc. c. Ready Pac Canada Co.
03/30/09 [2009] J.Q. no 2970 2009 QCCA 676
Tardif, Alain Appellant QC Interlocutory Bankruptcy and insolvency — nanotechnology — safeguard order — interim receiver — intervention — proposition
QCCA JTI MacDonald Corporation c. Canada (Procureur général)
01/23/09 [2009] J.Q. no 326 2009 QCCA 110 [2009] R.J.Q. 261 EYB 2009-153356 J.E. 2009-287
Solyom Ravary, Rachel
Appellant QC Appeal Civil procedure — costs — tariff of judicial fees of advocates — special fees for important cases — Crown attorneys
QCCA St-Arnaud v. C.L.
01/09/09 [2009] Q.J. No. 259 [2009] J.Q. no 259 2009 QCCA 97 [2009] R.J.Q. 239 EYB 2009-152692 J.E. 2009-284
Chénier, Robert-Jean Dufresne, Marie-Eve
Appellant QC Interlocutory Application for leave to appeal to the Supreme Court of Canada dismissed (Docket 33045, 18/06/2009)
Civil procedure — incidental proceedings — provision for costs
QCCA Option Consommateurs c. Bell Mobilité
11/19/08 [2008] J.Q. no 11736 2008 QCCA 2201 J.E. 2008-2293 EYB 2008-150743
Lortie, Jean Laferrière, Rachel
Respondent QC Appeal Telecommunications — class action — authorization — billing
QCCA Option Consommateurs c. Banque Nationale du
11/12/08 [2008] J.Q. no 11343 2008 QCCA 2128
Deschamps, Michel
Respondent QC Appeal Class action — authorization — banks — loan of money — interpretation of contracts
Page 13
The French version will be available soon.
COURT CASE DATE CITATIONS LAWYER ACTED FOR REGION TYPE OF
APPEAL FURTHER HISTORY
LEGAL AND INDUSTRY FOCUS
Canada
QCCA Syndicat national des travailleurs des pâtes et papiers de Port-Alfred c. Compagnie Abitibi-Consolidated du Canada, division de Port-Alfred
10/08/08 [2008] J.Q. no 9780 2008 QCCA 1887 72 C.C.P.B. 156 2008 CarswellQue 9740
Jolin, Pierre Respondent QC Appeal Labour — interpretation of a collective agreement — jurisdiction of arbitrator — retirement plan
QCCA Autorité des marchés financiers v. Panju
05/05/08 [2008] Q.J. No. 3642 2008 QCCA 832 EYB 2008-132929 J.E. 2008-1075 [2008] R.J.Q. 1233 172 A.C.W.S. (3d) 604
Legendre, Céline
Respondent QC Interlocutory Securities — civil procedure — production of exhibits by respondents — confidentiality — protection of the public interest
QCCA Ferland c. Ghosn
04/28/08 [2008] J.Q. no 3351 2008 QCCA 797 EYB 2008-132464 J.E. 2008-987 [2008] R.R.A. 295 172 A.C.W.S. (3d) 788
Bujold, Steeves
Respondent QC Appeal Medical — medical malpractice — civil liability — duty to inform
Page 14
The French version will be available soon.
COURT CASE DATE CITATIONS LAWYER ACTED FOR REGION TYPE OF
APPEAL FURTHER HISTORY
LEGAL AND INDUSTRY FOCUS
QCCA Baum c. Mohr 04/18/08 [2008] Q.J. No. 2978 2008 QCCA 718 EYB 2008-132239 J.E. 2008-937 [2008] R.R.A. 285 167 A.C.W.S. (3d) 813
Platts, David E. Respondent QC Appeal Application for leave to appeal to the Supreme Court of Canada discontinued (Docket 32688, 09/10/2008)
Medical — medical malpractice — civil liability — surgery
QCCA Latte des berges inc. (Syndic de)
04/08/08 [2008] J.Q. no 2657 2008 QCCA 617 EYB 2008-131952 J.E. 2008-858 172 A.C.W.S. (3d) 92
Lortie, Jean Laferrière, Rachel
Appellant QC Appeal Application for leave to appeal to the Supreme Court of Canada dismissed (Docket 33197, 04/12/2008)
Contracts — sale of assets — deposit
QCCA Consortium Promecan inc. (Syndic de)
12/18/07 [2007] J.Q. no 14713 2007 QCCA 1835
Poplaw, Mason Appellant QC Appeal Affirmed by Quebec (Revenue) v. Caisse populaire Desjardins de Montmagny, 2009 SCC 49, [2009] 3 S.C.R. 286
Insolvency and bankruptcy — taxation — collection of taxes on consumption — deemed trust — order of priority
QCCA Clennet c. Loto-Québec
12/06/07 [2007] J.Q. no 13702 2007 QCCA 1690 J.E. 2008-99 EYB 2007-126944 [2007] C.A.I. 603 167 A.C.W.S. (3d) 88
Atkinson, William J. Dufort-Langlois, Philippe
Respondent QC Appeal Statute interpretation — interpretation — access to information
Page 15
The French version will be available soon.
COURT CASE DATE CITATIONS LAWYER ACTED FOR REGION TYPE OF
APPEAL FURTHER HISTORY
LEGAL AND INDUSTRY FOCUS
QCCA Canada Post Corporation v. Lépine
08/10/07 [2007] Q.J. No. 8498 [2007] J.Q. no 8498 2007 QCCA 1092 [2007] R.J.Q. 1920 J.E. 2007-1615 EYB 2007-122903
Lortie, Jean Intervenor QC Appeal Confirmed by Société canadienne des postes c. Lépine, 2009 C.S.C. 16, [2009] 1 R.C.S. 549
International private law — foreign judgments — recognition procedure — class action — lifetime Internet service
QCCA 9026-9739 Québec inc. (Séquestre de) c. Roy, Métivier, Roberge inc.
04/11/07 [2007] J.Q. no 2924 2007 QCCA 526 [2007] R.J.Q. 828 J.E. 2007-825 EYB 2007-117894 164 A.C.W.S. (3d) 333
Bélanger, Philippe H.
Respondent QC Appeal Insolvency — bankruptcy — Farm Debt Mediation Act — lift of stay
QCCA Trudel c. Banque Toronto-Dominion
03/19/07 [2007] J.Q. no 2167 2007 QCCA 413 J.E. 2007-701 EYB 2007-116838 165 A.C.W.S. (3d) 987
Giroux, François M.
Respondent QC Appeal Class action — authorization — hypothecs — publication of rights — acquittance of a debt
QCCA Curateur public du Québec c. Centre hospitalier universitaire de Québec
01/11/07 [2007] J.Q. no 17 2007 QCCA 31
Cantin, Philippe
Respondent QC Appeal Persons — care — integrity of the person — confinement in an institution
QCCA Sheppard c. Royal Institution for
01/09/07 [2007] Q.J. No. 77 2007 QCCA 46
Atkinson, William J. Gagnon,
Respondent QC Appeal Labour — dismissal — just cause — contract of employment — resiliation
Page 16
The French version will be available soon.
COURT CASE DATE CITATIONS LAWYER ACTED FOR REGION TYPE OF
APPEAL FURTHER HISTORY
LEGAL AND INDUSTRY FOCUS
the Advancement of Learning (McGill University)
J.E. 2007-248 EYB 2007-112066 165 A.C.W.S. (3d) 286
Nathalie
QCCA Thibault c. Assurances générales des Caisses Desjardins
12/08/06 [2006] J.Q. no 13344 2006 QCCA 1599 EYB 2006-111820 165 A.C.W.S. (3d) 347
Cantin, Philippe
Respondent QC Appeal Insurance — insurance of goods — exclusion clause — waiver
QCCA JetsGo Corporation (Syndic de)
11/27/06 [2006] J.Q. no 13607 2006 QCCA 1521 J.E. 2006-2336 163 A.C.W.S. (3d) 1011 EYB 2006-111320
Poplaw, Mason Bourbonnais, Miguel
Appellant QC Appeal Bankruptcy and insolvency — trustee — letter of credit — bank
QCCA Fédération des infirmières et infirmiers du Québec c. Hôpital Laval
10/16/06 [2006] J.Q. no 11803 2006 QCCA 1345 [2006] R.J.Q. 2384 J.E. 2006-2090 EYB 2006-110652 165 A.C.W.S. (3d) 242
Jarry, Claude M.
Respondent QC Interlocutory Evidence — privileged documents — medical records
QCCA Aubin c. Moumdjian
10/03/06 [2006] J.Q. no 12186 [2006] Q.J. No. 12186 2006 QCCA 1264 J.E. 2006-2056
Dufour, Marc Appellant QC Appeal Medical — medical malpractice — civil liability — neurosurgeon — disc herniation
Page 17
The French version will be available soon.
COURT CASE DATE CITATIONS LAWYER ACTED FOR REGION TYPE OF
APPEAL FURTHER HISTORY
LEGAL AND INDUSTRY FOCUS
[2006] R.R.A. 827 42 C.C.L.T. (3d) 242 EYB 2006-110126 2006 CarswellQue 8720 164 A.C.W.S. (3d) 531
QCCA Poupart c. Sécurité nationale, compagnie d'assurances
09/12/06 [2006] J.Q. no 10309 2006 QCCA 1184 J.E. 2006-1895 152 A.C.W.S. (3d) 768 EYB 2006-109729
Cantin, Philippe
Respondent QC Appeal Civil procedure — jurisdiction of superior court — arbitration — compromissory clause
QCCA Kruger inc. c. Première nation des Betsiamites
04/28/06 [2006] J.Q. no 3932 [2006] Q.J. No. 3932 2006 QCCA 569 J.E. 2006-1004 [2006] 3 C.N.L.R. 19 149 A.C.W.S. (3d) 864
Potter, Simon V.
Appellant QC Appeal Application for leave to appeal to the Supreme Court of Canada dismissed (Docket 31025, 20/10/2005)
Aboriginal law — lands — logging — safeguard order
QCCA Québec (Procureur général) c. Première nation de Betsiamites
04/28/06 [2006] J.Q. no 3931 [2006] Q.J. No. 3931 2006 QCCA 567
Potter, Simon V.
Respondent QC Appeal Application for leave to appeal to the Supreme Court of Canada dismissed (Docket 31025, 20/10/2005)
Aboriginal law — lands — logging — safeguard order
Page 18
The French version will be available soon.
COURT CASE DATE CITATIONS LAWYER ACTED FOR REGION TYPE OF
APPEAL FURTHER HISTORY
LEGAL AND INDUSTRY FOCUS
QCCA Université de Montréal c. Commission des droits de la personne et des droits de la jeunesse
04/10/06 [2006] J.Q. no 3357 2006 QCCA 508 J.E. 2006-991 148 A.C.W.S. (3d) 69 EYB 2005-103827
Baril, André Appellant QC Appeal Labour — human rights — jurisdiction of grievance arbitrator and of Québec Human Rights Tribunal
QCCA TIP Investment Advisors Ltd. c. Gilbert
02/20/06 [2006] J.Q. no 1718 2006 QCCA 275
Bélanger, Philippe H.
Respondent QC Appeal Winding up — civil procedure — safeguard order
QCCA Syndicat national des employées et employés du Centre de soins prolongés Grace Dart (CSN) c. Holligin-Richards
02/07/06 [2006] J.Q. no 952 2006 QCCA 158 147 A.C.W.S. (3d) 721 EYB 2006-100971
Gagnon, Nathalie
Respondent QC Appeal Labour — grievance arbitration — dismissal — right to arbitration
QCCA Beaupré c. Lavoie
01/12/06 [2006] J.Q. no 109 2006 QCCA 36
Baril, André Hébert, Simon-Pierre
Respondent QC Appeal Labour — grievance arbitration — claim for loss of revenue and defamation — jurisdiction of arbitrator
QCCA Terreault c. Bigras
12/15/05 [2005] J.Q. no 18585 2005 QCCA 1243 [2006] R.J.Q. 126 J.E. 2006-125 145 A.C.W.S. (3d) 166 EYB 2005-99100
Poupart, Emmanuelle
Respondent QC Appeal Legal ethics — fee agreement — cancellation of the agreement — agreement giving to the legal profession a profit—seeking or commercial character
Page 19
The French version will be available soon.
COURT CASE DATE CITATIONS LAWYER ACTED FOR REGION TYPE OF
APPEAL FURTHER HISTORY
LEGAL AND INDUSTRY FOCUS
QCCA Ruffo (Re) 12/09/05 [2005] J.Q. no 17953 [2005] Q.J. No. 17953 2005 QCCA 1197 [2006] R.J.Q. 26 J.E. 2006-60 144 A.C.W.S. (3d) 863
Bélanger, Marie-Eve
Friend of the Court
QC Report of the Court of Appeal regarding a request for the removal of Judge Ruffo
Application for leave to appeal to the Supreme Court of Canada dismissed (Docket 31304, 18/05/2006)
Discipline and ethics — legal professions — judges — removal of a provincial court judge
QCCA Trikon Technologies inc. c. Panametrics inc.
09/07/05 [2005] J.Q. no 13267 2005 QCCA 796
Lortie, Jean Respondent QC Appeal Civil procedure — contract — arbitration clause
QCCA Imperial Tobacco Canada ltée c. Canada (Procureure générale)
08/22/05 [2005] J.Q. no 11174 2005 QCCA 725 142 A.C.W.S. (3d) 423
Potter, Simon V.
Appellant QC Appeal Reversed by Canada (Attorney General) v. JTI-Macdonald Corp., 2007 SCC 30; [2007] 2 S.C.R. 610
Constitutional — freedom of expression — advertising and promotion of tobacco
QCCA Rothmans, Benson & Hedges inc. c. Canada (Procureure générale)
08/22/05 [2005] J.Q. no 11175 2005 QCCA 727 142 A.C.W.S. (3d) 592
Tremblay, Gérald R.
Appellant QC Appeal Reversed by Canada (Attorney General) v. JTI-Macdonald Corp., 2007 SCC 30; [2007] 2 S.C.R. 610
Constitutional — freedom of expression — advertising and promotion of tobacco
QCCA Therrien c. Launay
07/06/05 [2005] J.Q. no 9043 2005 QCCA 665 J.E. 2005-1345 141 A.C.W.S. (3d) 669
Chénier, Robert-Jean
Respondent QC Appeal Application for leave to appeal to the Supreme Court of Canada dismissed
Medical — medical malpractice — civil liability — diagnosis
Page 20
The French version will be available soon.
COURT CASE DATE CITATIONS LAWYER ACTED FOR REGION TYPE OF
APPEAL FURTHER HISTORY
LEGAL AND INDUSTRY FOCUS
(Docket 31151, 16/02/2006)
QCCA Entreprises CJS inc. c. Construction R. Cloutier inc.
06/09/05 [2005] J.Q. no 7841 2005 QCCA 600 [2005] R.J.Q. 1682 J.E. 2005-1191 [2005] R.D.I. 486 47 C.L.R. (3d) 62 2005 CarswellQue 3573
Demers, Nancy Appellant QC Appeal Hypothecs — legal hypothec of construction — cancellation of a notice of hypothec — definition of unité d'exploitation
QCCA Jalbert c. Centre hospitalier universitaire de Québec, pavillon Hotel-Dieu de Québec
04/19/05 [2005] J.Q. no 4890 2005 QCCA 446
Jarry, Claude M.
Respondent QC Appeal Civil procedure — motion to dismiss the action
QCCA Association des chiropraticiens du Québec c. Office des professions du Québec
02/25/05 [2005] J.Q. no 1087 2005 QCCA 189 [2005] R.J.Q. 691 J.E. 2005-559 137 A.C.W.S. (3d) 1236
Jolin, Pierre Respondent QC Appeal Professions — chiropractors — interpretation of the Chiropractic Act — diagnosis
QCCA Tecsys inc. c. Société en commandite CDTI de Montréal
12/10/04 [2004] J.Q. no 13394 137 A.C.W.S. (3d) 191 2004 CanLII 46686
Potter, Simon V.
Appellant QC Appeal Application for leave to appeal to the Supreme Court of Canada dismissed (Docket 30753,
Lease — interpretation — determination of rights — rent — arrears
Page 21
The French version will be available soon.
COURT CASE DATE CITATIONS LAWYER ACTED FOR REGION TYPE OF
APPEAL FURTHER HISTORY
LEGAL AND INDUSTRY FOCUS
25/08/2005)
QCCA Citadelle, Coopérative de producteurs de sirop d'érable c. Régie des marchés agricoles et alimentaries du Québec
12/03/04 [2004] J.Q. no 13206 J.E. 2005-193 136 A.C.W.S. (3d) 981
Renaud, Madeleine
Appellant QC Appeal Application for leave to appeal to the Supreme Court of Canada dismissed (Docket 30771, 30/06/2005)
Agri-food — maple syrup — marketing control
QCCA Produits alimentaires Jacques et Fils inc. c. Régie des marchés agricoles et alimentaires du Québec
12/03/04 [2004] J.Q. no 13205 136 A.C.W.S. (3d) 980 REJB 2004-81157
Renaud, Madeleine
Respondent QC Appeal Application for leave to appeal to the Supreme Court of Canada dismissed (Docket 30772, 30/06/2005)
Agri-food — maple syrup — marketing control
QCCA Banque Amex du Canada c. Procureur général du Québec
09/28/04 [2004] J.Q. no 10130 135 A.C.W.S. (3d) 29
Tremblay, Gérald R. Bisson, Donald
Respondent QC Interlocutory Application for leave to appeal to the Supreme Court of Canada dismissed (Docket 30655, 10/03/2005)
Class action — authorization — civil procedure — joinder of actions — functus officioI
QCCA Banque canadienne impériale de commerce c. Procureur général du Québec
09/28/04 [2004] J.Q. no 10127 135 A.C.W.S. (3d) 24
Tremblay, Gérald R. Bisson, Donald
Respondent QC Interlocutory Application for leave to appeal to the Supreme Court of Canada dismissed (Docket 30646, 10/03/2005)
Class action — authorization — civil procedure — joinder of actions — functus officioI
Page 22
The French version will be available soon.
COURT CASE DATE CITATIONS LAWYER ACTED FOR REGION TYPE OF
APPEAL FURTHER HISTORY
LEGAL AND INDUSTRY FOCUS
QCCA Banque de Montréal c. Procureur général du Québec
09/28/04 [2004] J.Q. no 10133 135 A.C.W.S. (3d) 30 REJB 2004-70909
Tremblay, Gérald R. Bisson, Donald
Respondent QC Interlocutory Application for leave to appeal to the Supreme Court of Canada dismissed (Docket 30645, 10/03/2005)
Class action — authorization — civil procedure — joinder of actions — functus officioI
QCCA Banque Laurentienne du Canada c. Procureur général du Québec
09/28/04 [2004] J.Q. no 10129 135 A.C.W.S. (3d) 26 EYB 2004-70919
Tremblay, Gérald R. Bisson, Donald
Respondent QC Interlocutory Application for leave to appeal to the Supreme Court of Canada dismissed (Docket 30650, 10/03/2005)
Declaratory judgment — class action — joinder of actions — right to be heard — adjudication beyond the conclusions
QCCA Banque MBNA Canada c. Procureur général du Québec
09/28/04 [2004] J.Q. no 10134 J.E. 2004-1921 135 A.C.W.S. (3d) 31
Tremblay, Gérald R. Bisson, Donald
Respondent QC Interlocutory Application for leave to appeal to the Supreme Court of Canada dismissed (Docket 30647, 10/03/2005)
Class action — authorization — civil procedure — joinder of actions — functus officioI
QCCA Banque Nationale du Canada c. Procureur général du Québec
09/28/04 [2004] J.Q. no 10128 135 A.C.W.S. (3d) 28
Tremblay, Gérald R. Bisson, Donald
Appellant QC Interlocutory Application for leave to appeal to the Supreme Court of Canada dismissed (Docket 30648, 10/03/2005)
Class action — authorization — civil procedure — joinder of actions — functus officioI
QCCA Banque Royale du Canada c. Procureur général du
09/28/04 [2004] J.Q. no 10132 135 A.C.W.S. (3d) 27
Tremblay, Gérald R. Bisson, Donald
Respondent QC Interlocutory Application for leave to appeal to the Supreme Court of
Class action — authorization — civil procedure — joinder of actions — functus officioI
Page 23
The French version will be available soon.
COURT CASE DATE CITATIONS LAWYER ACTED FOR REGION TYPE OF
APPEAL FURTHER HISTORY
LEGAL AND INDUSTRY FOCUS
Québec Canada dismissed (Docket 30649, 10/03/2005)
QCCA Banque Toronto-Dominion c. Procureur général du Québec
09/28/04 [2004] J.Q. no 10123 135 A.C.W.S. (3d) 25
Tremblay, Gérald R. Bisson, Donald
Respondent QC Interlocutory Application for leave to appeal to the Supreme Court of Canada dismissed (Docket 30651, 10/03/2005)
Class action — authorization — civil procedure — joinder of actions — functus officioI
QCCA Fédération des producteurs acéricoles du Québec c. Citadelle, coopérative de producteurs de sirop d'érable
07/15/04 [2004] J.Q. no 7880 J.E. 2004-1583 134 A.C.W.S. (3d) 5 2004 CanLII 3284
Renaud, Madeleine
Respondent QC Appeal Agri-food — maple syrup — marketing control
QCCA Procureur général du Québec c. De Carufel
06/03/04 [2004] J.Q. no 7251 J.E. 2004-1258 133 A.C.W.S. (3d) 804
Hébert, Simon-Pierre
Appellant QC Appeal Labour — lawyers working for provincial Crown — transfer — resignation — period of uninterrupted service
QCCA Minc v. Québec (Attorney General)
05/31/04 [2004] J.Q. no 6626 [2004] Q.J. No. 6626 [2004] R.J.Q. 1475 J.E. 2004-1183
Atkinson, William J.
Appellant QC Appeal Affirmed by Provincial Court Judges' Assn. of New Brunswick v. New Brunswick (Minister of Justice); Ontario Judges' Assn. v. Ontario
Government — government boards and committees — salary parity of judges — constitution
Page 24
The French version will be available soon.
COURT CASE DATE CITATIONS LAWYER ACTED FOR REGION TYPE OF
APPEAL FURTHER HISTORY
LEGAL AND INDUSTRY FOCUS
(Management Board); Bodner v. Alberta; Conférence des juges du Québec v. Quebec (Attorney General); Minc v. Quebec (Attorney General), 2005 SCC 44, [2005] 2 S.C.R. 286
QCCA Quebec (Attorney General) v. Minc
05/31/04 [2004] J.Q. no 6625 [2004] Q.J. No. 6625 133 A.C.W.S. (3d) 791 133 A.C.W.S. (3d) 986
Atkinson, William J.
Respondent QC Appeal Affirmed by Provincial Court Judges' Assn. of New Brunswick v. New Brunswick (Minister of Justice); Ontario Judges' Assn. v. Ontario (Management Board); Bodner v. Alberta; Conférence des juges du Québec v. Quebec (Attorney General); Minc v. Quebec (Attorney General), 2005 SCC 44, [2005]
Constitutional law — judicial independence — judicial remuneration — nature of judicial compensation commissions and their recommendations — obligation of government to respond to recommendations — scope of judicial review of government's response — remedies
Page 25
The French version will be available soon.
COURT CASE DATE CITATIONS LAWYER ACTED FOR REGION TYPE OF
APPEAL FURTHER HISTORY
LEGAL AND INDUSTRY FOCUS
2 S.C.R. 286
QCCA Paquet c. Tardif
05/14/04 [2004] J.Q. no 6699 J.E. 2004-1248
Jarry, Claude M.
Respondent QC Appeal Application for leave to appeal to the Supreme Court of Canada dismissed (Docket 30457, 06/01/2005)
Medical — civil liability — civil procedure — communication of medical records
QCCA Perez c. Bank of Nova Scotia
05/07/04 [2004] J.Q. no 6451
Tremblay, Gérald R. Giroux, François M.
Respondent QC Appeal Private international law — declinatory exceptions — defendants' activities in Québec
QCCA Hrtschan c. Ville de Montréal
03/22/04 [2004] J.Q. no 2772 [2004] R.J.Q. 1073 J.E. 2004-799 [2004] R.R.A. 329 133 A.C.W.S. (3d) 708 REJB 2004-55545
Arpin, Sophie Respondent QC Appeal Application for leave to appeal to the Supreme Court of Canada dismissed (Docket 30354, 06/01/2005)
Municipal — civil liability — defamation — mayor
QCCA Ville de Montréal c. M.J. Oppenheim
03/22/04 [2004] J.Q. no 2773 J.E. 2004-767 [2004] R.R.A. 325 133 A.C.W.S. (3d) 539
Arpin, Sophie Appellant QC Appeal Insurance — insurance policy — defamation — civil liability
QCCA Ordre des dentistes du Québec c.
03/10/04 [2004] J.Q. no 3437
Dufour, Marc Appellant QC Appeal Medical — discipline committee — dentists
Page 26
The French version will be available soon.
COURT CASE DATE CITATIONS LAWYER ACTED FOR REGION TYPE OF
APPEAL FURTHER HISTORY
LEGAL AND INDUSTRY FOCUS
Forget
QCCA Wolofsky c. Gestion Kenmont inc.
02/03/04 [2004] J.Q. no 620 J.E. 2004-385 133 A.C.W.S. (3d) 364
Poplaw, Mason Appellant QC Appeal Property law — servitudes — servitude by destination of proprietor
QCCA Essaris c. Kiriazis
12/19/03 [2003] J.Q. no 19212 J.E. 2004-269 131 A.C.W.S. (3d) 1141
Lortie, Jean Respondent QC Appeal Real estate — leases — publication of rights — cancellation — safeguard order
QCCA SSQ Société d'assurance-vie inc. c. La Société des services dentaires (A.C.D.Q.) inc.
12/01/03 [2003] J.Q. no 17929
Jolin, Pierre Appellant QC Appeal Civil procedure — acquiescence in a demand — letter confirming the unconditional nature of the acquiescence
QCCA Alta Mura construction inc. c. Société des parcs de sciences naturelles du Québec
11/17/03 [2003] J.Q. no 16359 [2003] R.J.Q. 3067 J.E. 2003-2213 [2003] R.D.I. 727 131 A.C.W.S. (3d) 588
Demers, Nancy Appellant QC Appeal Hypothecs — legal hypothec of construction — cancellation of a notice of hypothec
QCCA UL Canada inc. c. Procureur général du Québec
10/01/03 [2003] J.Q. no 13505 [2003] R.J.Q. 2729 234 D.L.R. (4th) 398 J.E. 2003-1975 10 Admin. L.R.
Tremblay, Gérald R. Bisson, Donald
Appellant QC Appeal Affirmed by UL Canada Inc. c. Québec (Procureur général), 2005 CSC 10, [2005] 1 R.C.S. 143
Constitutional — distribution of legislative powers — colour of margarine — freedom of expression
Page 27
The French version will be available soon.
COURT CASE DATE CITATIONS LAWYER ACTED FOR REGION TYPE OF
APPEAL FURTHER HISTORY
LEGAL AND INDUSTRY FOCUS
(4th) 36
QCCA Dans l'affaire de la faillite de : Réjean St-Pierre c. Raymond Chabot inc.
09/09/03 [2003] J.Q. no 11751 J.E. 2003-1712 127 A.C.W.S. (3d) 400
Poplaw, Mason Respondent QC Appeal Bankruptcy and insolvency — proof of claim — cattle broker — seizure and sale of calves — preferential payments
QCCA Assurance-vie Desjardins Laurentienne c. Poirier-Wilson
08/29/03 [2003] J.Q. no 10949 J.E. 2003-1670 [2003] R.R.A. 1098 127 A.C.W.S. (3d) 1242
Jarry, Claude M.
Appellant QC Appeal Insurance — insurance on hypothecs — false statements — interpretation of the insurance contract
QCCA Labonté c. Tanguay
06/02/03 [2003] J.Q. no 6539 J.E. 2003-1218 [2003] R.R.A. 774 126 A.C.W.S. (3d) 1034
Jarry, Claude M.
Respondent QC Appeal Medical — civil liability — causation — faults of omission
QCCA Laforce c. Dumont
05/05/03 [2003] J.Q. no 4945 J.E. 2003-959 [2003] R.R.A. 422 125 A.C.W.S. (3d) 911
Platts, David E. Respondent QC Appeal Medical — medical malpractice — civil liability — vicarious liability — causation
QCCA Labrie c. Gagnon
04/28/03 [2003] J.Q. no 4362 J.E. 2003-917 [2003] R.R.A. 400
Dufour, Marc Respondent QC Appeal Medical — medical malpractice — civil liability — childbirth — caesarean
Page 28
The French version will be available soon.
COURT CASE DATE CITATIONS LAWYER ACTED FOR REGION TYPE OF
APPEAL FURTHER HISTORY
LEGAL AND INDUSTRY FOCUS
QCCA Bordeleau c. Lessard
04/17/03 [2003] J.Q. no 5510
Jolin, Pierre Appellant QC Appeal Professions — lawyers and attorneys — security — hypothecs — contracts
QCCA Bordeleau c. Lessard (appel par Flynn Rivard)
04/17/03 [2003] J.Q. no 5450
Jolin, Pierre Appellant QC Appeal Professions — lawyers and attorneys — security — hypothecs — contracts
QCCA Camirand c. Rossi
04/07/03 [2003] J.Q. no 3320 [2003] R.J.Q. 1081 J.E. 2003-828 REJB 2003-39879 125 A.C.W.S. (3d) 994
Tremblay, Gérald R. Giroux, François M.
Respondent QC Appeal Application for leave to appeal to the Supreme Court of Canada dismissed (Docket 29810, 09/10/2003)
Corporations — oppression remedy — unanimous shareholders agreement — referral to arbitration
QCCA Sabre inc. c. Air Canada
03/13/03 [2003] J.Q. no 4495 J.E. 2003-747
Dufresne, Marie-Ève
Appellant QC Appeal International private law — declaratory judgment — forum non conveniens — action in damages filed in Texas
QCCA Dumas c. Mutuelle des fonctionnaires du Québec (MFQ-Vie)
02/21/03 [2003] J.Q. no 984 J.E. 2003-472
Tremblay, Gérald R. Lortie, Jean
Respondent QC Appeal Application for leave to appeal to the Supreme Court of Canada dismissed (Docket 29199, 26/06/2003)
Insurance — class action — value of payment of annual premiums
QCCA 9007-7876 Québec inc. c. Jannock Ltd.
02/11/03 [2003] J.Q. no 669 J.E. 2003-493
Potter, Simon V.
Respondent QC Appeal Corporations — shareholders — unanimous shareholders agreement — sale of shares — dividends
QCCA Royal & Sun Alliance du Canada,
01/23/03 [2003] J.Q. no 4024 J.E. 2003-383
Cantin, Philippe
Respondent QC Appeal Insurance — subrogation — exception to the insurer's subrogatory claim
Page 29
The French version will be available soon.
COURT CASE DATE CITATIONS LAWYER ACTED FOR REGION TYPE OF
APPEAL FURTHER HISTORY
LEGAL AND INDUSTRY FOCUS
Société d'assurances c. Cie mutuelle d'assurance Wawanesa
[2003] R.R.A. 127
QCCA Krela c. Orthosoft inc.
12/04/02 [2002] J.Q. no 5287
Poplaw, Mason Respondent QC Appeal Application for leave to appeal to the Supreme Court of Canada dismissed (Docket 29567, 02/10/2003)
Corporations — receiver—manager — oppression — abuse of right by directors
QCCA Krela c. Orthosoft inc.
12/04/02 [2002] J.Q. no 5286
Poplaw, Mason Appellant QC Appeal Application for leave to appeal to the Supreme Court of Canada dismissed (Docket 29567, 02/10/2003)
Corporations — receiver—manager — oppression — abuse of right by directors
QCCA Krela c. Orthosoft inc. (appel par Sulzer Medica AG)
12/04/02 [2002] J.Q. no 5282 J.E. 2003-45 120 A.C.W.S. (3d) 768 REJB 2002-36022
Poplaw, Mason Respondent QC Appeal Application for leave to appeal to the Supreme Court of Canada dismissed (Docket 29567, 02/10/2003)
Corporations — receiver — manager — oppression — abuse of right by directors
QCCA Audet c. Cimatec Environmental Engineering Inc.
11/25/02 [2002] J.Q. no 5088 J.E. 2003-32 119 A.C.W.S. (3d) 260 REJB 2002-35845
Tremblay, Gérald R.
Appellant QC Appeal Labour — dismissal — senior manager — notice of termination
Page 30
The French version will be available soon.
COURT CASE DATE CITATIONS LAWYER ACTED FOR REGION TYPE OF
APPEAL FURTHER HISTORY
LEGAL AND INDUSTRY FOCUS
QCCA Banque nationale de Paris (Canada) c. 165836 Canada inc.
10/22/02 [2002] J.Q. no 4749 118 A.C.W.S. (3d) 57
Bélanger, Philippe H.
Appellant QC Appeal Reversed by Banque nationale de Paris (Canada) c. 165836 Canada Inc., 2004 CSC 37; [2004] 2 R.C.S. 45
Obligations — transaction — offer to settle
QCCA Banque nationale de Paris (Canada) c. 165836 Canada inc.
10/22/02 [2002] J.Q. no 4750
Bélanger, Philippe H.
Respondent QC Appeal Reversed by Banque nationale de Paris (Canada) c. 165836 Canada Inc., 2004 CSC 37; [2004] 2 R.C.S. 45
Obligations — transaction — offer to settle
QCCA Uni-Sélect inc. c. Acktion Corp. (anciennement Acklands Ltd.)
09/09/02 [2002] J.Q. no 3859 [2002] R.J.Q. 3005 118 A.C.W.S. (3d) 208 REJB 2002-33889 J.E. 2002-1693 2002 CanLII 41226
Tremblay, Gérald R. Potter, Simon V. Bisson, Donald
Appelant (Tremblay and Bisson)/Respondent (Potter)
QC Appeal Application for leave to appeal to the Supreme Court of Canada dismissed (Docket 29449, 12/06/2003)
Contracts — sale of business — distribution of auto parts — noncompetition agreement — assessment of damages
QCCA 146931 Canada inc. c. Pichette
08/23/02 [2002] J.Q. no 3571 [2002] R.R.A. 771
Tremblay, Gérald R.
Appellant QC Appeal Real estate — sale of land — professional liability — notary
QCCA Canty c. Hôpital St-Luc
06/14/02 [2002] J.Q. no 3141 REJB 2002-
Dufour, Marc Appellant QC Appeal Medical — civil procedure — action in warranty
Page 31
The French version will be available soon.
COURT CASE DATE CITATIONS LAWYER ACTED FOR REGION TYPE OF
APPEAL FURTHER HISTORY
LEGAL AND INDUSTRY FOCUS
32242
QCCA 94964 Canada inc. c. Réno-Dépôt inc.
06/04/02 [2002] J.Q. no 3086
Tremblay, Gérald R. Lortie, Jean
Appellant QC Appeal Corporate law — value of shares — interest
QCCA Loto-Québec c. Moore
05/28/02 [2002] J.Q. no 1200 J.E. 2002-1098 [2002] C.A.I. 460
Atkinson, William J.
Respondent QC Appeal Access to information — commercial secrets — risk or damage of revealing information —procedure — jurisdiction of civil law court to review
QCCA L.F. c. Villeneuve
05/08/02 [2002] J.Q. no 1057 [2002] R.R.A. 296 116 A.C.W.S. (3d) 126 REJB 2002-30304
Dufour, Marc Appellant QC Appeal Medical — medical malpractice — civil liability — duty to inform
QCCA Entreprises Immobilières du Terroir ltée c. Viel
05/08/02 [2002] J.Q. no 1056 [2002] R.J.Q. 1262 J.E. 2002-937 [2002] R.D.I. 241 [2002] R.R.A. 317 2002 CanLII 41120 116 A.C.W.S. (3d) 131 REJB 2002-31662 REJB 2002-34963
Poplaw, Mason Respondent QC Appeal Contracts — promise of sale — preference clause — assignment of rights — Paulian Action — damages — extrajudicial fees
Page 32
The French version will be available soon.
COURT CASE DATE CITATIONS LAWYER ACTED FOR REGION TYPE OF
APPEAL FURTHER HISTORY
LEGAL AND INDUSTRY FOCUS
QCCA Entreprises Immobilières du Terroir ltée c. Viel (appel par Lapointe)
05/08/02 [2002] J.Q. no 1058
Poplaw, Mason Respondent QC Appeal Contracts — promise of sale — preference clause — assignment of rights — Paulian Action — damages — extrajudicial fees
QCCA Picardie Construction inc. c. Blanchet
04/24/02 [2002] J.Q. no 2851
Jarry, Claude M.
Respondent QC Appeal Damages — abuse of process — assessment of evidence
QCCA Entreprises P.E.B. ltée c. Québec (Ville)
03/18/02 [2002] J.Q. no 464
Jolin, Pierre Respondent QC Appeal Municipal — contracts — liability — infrastructure project
QCCA Dumas c. Mutuelle des fonctionnaires du Québec
03/07/02 [2002] J.Q. no 696 J.E. 2002-543 REJB 2002-30825
Tremblay, Gérald R. Lortie, Jean
Respondent QC Appeal Application for leave to appeal to the Supreme Court of Canada dismissed (Docket 29199, 26/06/2003)
Insurance — class action — civil procedure — authorization — right of appeal
QCCA Holding action sociale Engelmajer Inc. c. Coopérants, société mutuelle d'assurance-vie (liquidateur de)
02/12/02 [2002] J.Q. no 194 [2002] R.J.Q. 328 J.E. 2002-402 112 A.C.W.S. (3d) 1014
Deschamps, Michel
Appellant QC Appeal Application for leave to appeal to the Supreme Court of Canada dismissed (Docket 29156, 27/03/2003)
Winding up — funds — loss of legal status
QCCA Canadian Union of Postal Workers v. Canada Post Corp.
02/05/02 [2002] J.Q. no 279 [2002] Q.J. No. 279
Gagnon, Nathalie
Respondent QC Appeal Labour — grievance arbitration — judicial review
Page 33
The French version will be available soon.
COURT CASE DATE CITATIONS LAWYER ACTED FOR REGION TYPE OF
APPEAL FURTHER HISTORY
LEGAL AND INDUSTRY FOCUS
QCCA Protégé Properties Inc. c. Provigo Distributions Inc.
01/23/02 [2002] J.Q. no 68 J.E. 2002-297 [2002] R.D.I. 36 113 A.C.W.S. (3d) 154
Tremblay, Gérald R. Dufour, Marc
Respondent QC Appeal Real estate — contracts — commercial lease — resiliation — assignment clause
QCCA Jodoin c. Deslauriers
01/17/02 [2002] J.Q. no 28 Poplaw, Mason Respondent QC Appeal Contracts — lease — eviction of the lessee — transaction
QCCA Roby c. Assurance-vie Desjardins inc.
11/16/01 [2001] J.Q. no 5776 [2001] R.R.A. 881
Jarry, Claude M.
Appellant QC Appeal Insurance — claim for benefits — assessment of medical evidence
QCCA Bélec c. Letellier
11/12/01 [2001] J.Q. no 5990
Tremblay, Gérald R.
Appellant QC Appeal Contracts — obligations — partnerships — law firm — partner leaving
QCCA Trust général du Canada et immobilière Natgen inc. c. Noël
11/04/01 [2001] J.Q. no 5001
Deschamps, Michel
Appellant QC Appeal Security — contracts — discharge of debtors
QCCA Baie d'Urfé (Ville) c. Québec (Procureur général)
10/16/01 [2001] J.Q. no 4916 27 M.P.L.R. (3d) 267
Tremblay, Gérald R. Bisson, Donald
Respondent QC Appeal Constitutional — municipal amalgamations — injunction
QCCA Baie D'Urfé (Ville) c. Québec (Procureur général)
10/16/01 [2001] J.Q. no 4821 [2001] R.J.Q. 2520 J.E. 2001-1961 27 M.P.L.R. (3d) 173 108 A.C.W.S. (3d) 980
Tremblay, Gérald R. Bisson, Donald
Appellant QC Appeal Application for leave to appeal to the Supreme Court of Canada dismissed (Docket 28869, 07/12/2001)
Constitutional — municipal amalgamations — injunction
Page 34
The French version will be available soon.
COURT CASE DATE CITATIONS LAWYER ACTED FOR REGION TYPE OF
APPEAL FURTHER HISTORY
LEGAL AND INDUSTRY FOCUS
QCCA Grace c. Martineau, Provencher & Associés Ltée
09/24/01 [2001] J.Q. no 4272 [2001] R.J.Q. 2414 J.E. 2001-1787 29 C.C.P.B. 214 108 A.C.W.S. (3d) 641 REJB 2001-26513
Bisson, Donald Respondent QC Appeal Application for leave to appeal to the Supreme Court of Canada dismissed (Docket 28900, 03/10/2002)
Corporations — shareholders — cancellation of a transaction
QCCA Vallée c. Assurance-vie Desjardins
07/13/01 [2001] J.Q. no 7614 [2001] R.R.A. 619
Jarry, Claude M.
Respondent QC Appeal Insurance — life insurance — suicide — exclusion clause
QCCA Bernier c. Décarie
06/12/01 [2001] J.Q. no 2783 J.E. 2001-1273 [2001] R.R.A. 567 REJB 2001-24643 107 A.C.W.S. (3d) 694 2001 CanLII 20632
Poupart, Emmanuelle
Respondent QC Appeal Medical — medical malpractice — civil liability — neurosurgeon — diagnosis — medical treatment
QCCA J.P. Lessard Canada inc. c. Casiloc inc.
05/03/01 [2001] J.Q. no 2228
Schenke, Stephen G.
Respondent QC Appeal Contracts — contract of enterprise — awarding of the contract — good faith — compliance of bid
QCCA Bouchard c. D'Amours
04/30/01 [2001] J.Q. no 1893 [2001] R.R.A. 310 2001 CanLII 14425
Chénier, Robert-Jean
Appellant QC Appeal Medical — civil liability — medical malpractice — diagnosis
Page 35
The French version will be available soon.
COURT CASE DATE CITATIONS LAWYER ACTED FOR REGION TYPE OF
APPEAL FURTHER HISTORY
LEGAL AND INDUSTRY FOCUS
QCCA Banque Nationale du Canada c. Caisse centrale Desjardins du Québec
04/09/01 [2001] J.Q. no 1446 [2001] R.J.Q. 846 J.E. 2001-812 [2001] R.R.A. 332 107 A.C.W.S. (3d) 287 REJB 2001-23520
Deschamps, Michel
Appellant QC Appeal Financial institutions — banks — negotiable instrument — clearing rules
QCCA Canadian Pacific Ltd. v. American Home Assurance Co.
02/19/01 [2001] Q.J. No. 592 [2001] R.R.A. 39
Schenke, Steve G.
Appellant QC Appeal All-risk insurance — claim for insurance indemnity — construction project — faulty design
QCCA Barreau du Québec c. Brousseau
02/01/01 [2001] J.Q. no 258 [2001] R.J.Q. 875 200 D.L.R. (4th) 470 J.E. 2001-424 2001 CanLII 17930 104 A.C.W.S. (3d) 784
Tremblay, Gérald R.
Appellant QC Appeal Application for leave to appeal to the Supreme Court of Canada dismissed (Docket 28479, 04/10/2001)
Professions — lawyers — eligibility for the profession
QCCA Québec (Commission des normes du travail) c. Beaulieu
01/09/01 [2001] J.Q. no 9 [2001] R.J.D.T. 10 J.E. 2001-259 102 A.C.W.S. (3d) 909 REJB 2001-21823
Jolin, Pierre Respondent QC Appeal Labour — labour standards — overtime — application of the Labour Standards Act — senior manager
QCCA 137578 Canada inc. c. Sun life
10/23/00 [2000] J.Q. no 3776 J.E. 2000-2005
Deschamps, Michel
Appellant QC Appeal Hypothecs — hypothecary remedies — taking in payment — emphyteusis
Page 36
The French version will be available soon.
COURT CASE DATE CITATIONS LAWYER ACTED FOR REGION TYPE OF
APPEAL FURTHER HISTORY
LEGAL AND INDUSTRY FOCUS
Assurance Co. of Canada
[2000] R.D.I. 563 48 R.P.R. (3d) 22 100 A.C.W.S. (3d) 890
QCCA Lacoste c. Gaudette
06/12/00 [2000] J.Q. no 1921 J.E. 2000-1258 99 A.C.W.S. (3d) 40 REJB 2000-18714
Lehoux, Jean-François
Appellant QC Interlocutory Medical — medical malpractice — civil procedure — medical examination — fees paid in part by the other party
QCCA Bergeron c. Breton
06/05/00 [2000] J.Q. no 1870 [2000] R.J.Q. 1692 J.E. 2000-1221 [2000] R.R.A. 633
Jarry, Claude M.
Respondent QC Appeal Insurance — life insurance — suicide — insurer's duty to indemnify — duty to inquire about the health of his client
QCCA Bergeron c. La Laurentienne vie inc.
06/05/00 [2000] J.Q. no 1909
Jarry, Claude M.
Appellant QC Appeal Insurance — life insurance — suicide — insurer's duty to indemnify — duty to inquire about the health of his client
QCCA Gouverneur inc. c. Morris Bailey Enterprises
05/01/00 [2000] J.Q. no 1548 [2000] R.D.I. 202 98 A.C.W.S. (3d) 927
Tremblay, Gérald R.
Appellant QC Appeal Contractual obligations — sale and delivery of immoveable property — forced execution — permanent injunction — transfer of title
QCCA Wilson & Lafleur ltée c. Société québécoise d'information juridique
04/17/00 [2000] J.Q. no 1215 [2000] R.J.Q. 1086 J.E. 2000-856 98 A.C.W.S. (3d) 809
Tremblay, Gérald R.
Respondent QC Appeal Publishing and publications — legal publications — access to court decisions in Québec
Page 37
The French version will be available soon.
COURT CASE DATE CITATIONS LAWYER ACTED FOR REGION TYPE OF
APPEAL FURTHER HISTORY
LEGAL AND INDUSTRY FOCUS
QCCA Monopro Ltd. c. Montreal Trust
04/04/00 [2000] J.Q. no 1040 J.E. 2000-777 98 A.C.W.S. (3d) 1108 REJB 2000-17480 2000 CanLII 7400
Tremblay, Gérald R.
Appellant QC Appeal Application for leave to appeal to the Supreme Court of Canada dismissed (Docket 27953, 25/01/2001)
Extra-contractual liability — prescription — real estate — purchase of immoveable — lease agreement — option to renew
QCCA Bergeron c. Faubert
03/02/00 [2000] J.Q. no 6184
Chénier, Robert-Jean
Respondent QC Appeal Medical — medical malpractice — civil liability — post-operative follow-up
QCCA Fortier auto (Montréal) ltée c. Brizard
01/05/00 [2000] J.Q. no 8 Alarie, Anouk Appellant QC Interlocutory Civil procedure — quashing of subpoena
QCCA Fortier Auto (Montréal) ltée c. Brizard
01/05/00 [2000] J.Q. no 5 J.E. 2000-177
Alarie, Anouk Respondents QC Interlocutory Evidence — objections — communication of exhibits — privileged documents — inquiry report from an investigation agency
QCCA Caisse populaire St-Zacharie c. J.G. Allen Industries inc.
12/14/99 [1999] J.Q. no 5502 [2000] R.J.Q. 58 J.E. 2000-126 REJB 1999-15659
Poplaw, Mason Respondent QC Appeal Movable hypothec — hypothecary remedies — sale by judicial authority
QCCA Perras c. Masson (mandataire de)
10/04/99 [1999] J.Q. no 4446 J.E. 99-2033 [1999] R.R.A. 817
Poplaw, Mason Appellant QC Appeal Reversed in part by Prévost-Masson v. General Trust of Canada, 2001 SCC 87, [2001] 3 S.C.R. 882
Contracts — obligations — obligations in solidum — professional liability —chartered accountant
Page 38
The French version will be available soon.
COURT CASE DATE CITATIONS LAWYER ACTED FOR REGION TYPE OF
APPEAL FURTHER HISTORY
LEGAL AND INDUSTRY FOCUS
QCCA Assoc. des policiers provinciaux du Québec c. Québec (Sûreté)
09/30/99 [1999] J.Q. no 4998 [1999] R.J.Q. 2590 J.E. 99-2012 [1999] R.J.D.T. 1537 91 A.C.W.S. (3d) 666
Atkinson, William J.
Respondent QC Appeal Application for leave to appeal to the Supreme Court of Canada dismissed (Docket 27619, 11/05/2000)
Judicial review — standard of review — employment — police inquiry — request for information — refusal to follow orders from superior — right to silence — arbitration
QCCA O'Neill c. Sirois 06/03/99 [1999] J.Q. no 1790 J.E. 99-1343 89 A.C.W.S. (3d) 281 D.T.E. 99T-598 REJB 1999-12823
Tremblay, Gérald R. Gagnon, Nathalie
Appellant QC Appeal Application for leave to appeal to the Supreme Court of Canada discontinued (Docket 27464, 10/22/2000)
Labour — dismissal — just cause — senior director
QCCA Savoie c. Assurance-vie Desjardins inc.
05/20/99 [1999] J.Q. no 4293 [1999] R.R.A. 441 REJB 1999-13936
Jarry, Claude M.
Appellant QC Appeal Insurance — life insurance — death of insured
QCCA Assurance-vie Desjardins inc. c. Lacroix
04/26/99 [1999] J.Q. no 6870
Jarry, Claude M.
Appellant QC Appeal Insurance — life insurance — total disability — benefits
QCCA Gilday v. McGill University
03/01/99 [1999] Q.J. No. 572
Gagnon, Nathalie
Respondent QC Appeal Labour — wrongful dismissal — sufficient cause
QCCA Loto-Québec c. Moore
02/17/99 [1999] J.Q. no 378 [1999] C.A.I. 571 88 A.C.W.S. (3d) 730
Atkinson, William J.
Appellant QC Appeal Access to information — disclosure — minimum standard of disclosure — commercial contracts — state monopoly — non-profit organisations
Page 39
The French version will be available soon.
COURT CASE DATE CITATIONS LAWYER ACTED FOR REGION TYPE OF
APPEAL FURTHER HISTORY
LEGAL AND INDUSTRY FOCUS
QCCA Hamel c. Haché
01/19/99 [1999] J.Q. no 31 [1999] R.R.A. 12 86 A.C.W.S. (3d) 996
Tremblay, Chantal C.
Respondent QC Appeal Medical — medical malpractice — civil liability — incomplete abortion — ectopic pregnancy
QCCA Université McGill c. Union des employé-e-s de service, local 800
12/02/98 [1998] J.Q. no 3667 J.E. 99-253 [1999] R.J.D.T. 9 84 A.C.W.S. (3d) 902
Baril, André Appellant QC Appeal Labour — unions — certification — sale of undertaking
QCCA Bressani c. Alta ltée
10/29/98 [1998] J.Q. no 3165
Tremblay, Gérald R.
Appellant QC Appeal Contract — formation and execution — sale of land — damages — loss of profits — reimbursement of expenses — damage to reputation — evidence — admissions
QCCA Holding Tusculum B.V. c. S.A. Louis Dreyfus & Cie
06/15/98 [1998] J.Q. no 1944 [1998] R.J.Q. 1722 J.E. 98-1462 82 A.C.W.S. (3d) 244
Giroux, François M.
Respondent QC Appeal Civil procedure — partial annulment of an arbitration award — service of proceedings
QCCA Roxboro Excavation inc. c. 9004-6673 Québec inc.
06/15/98 [1998] J.Q. no 1946 [1998] R.J.Q. 1731 J.E. 98-1463 82 A.C.W.S. (3d) 282 REJB 1998-06799
Poplaw, Mason Respondent QC Interlocutory Application for leave to appeal to the Supreme Court of Canada dismissed (Docket 26815, 04/03/1999)
Bankruptcy and insolvency — civil procedure — recusal of a judge — reasonable apprehension of bias
QCCA Latulippe c. Collège des médecins
06/05/98 [1998] J.Q. no 1866 80 A.C.W.S. (3d) 1108
Chénier, Robert-Jean
Appellant QC Appeal Medical — discipline committee — judicial review — rules of natural justice
Page 40
The French version will be available soon.
COURT CASE DATE CITATIONS LAWYER ACTED FOR REGION TYPE OF
APPEAL FURTHER HISTORY
LEGAL AND INDUSTRY FOCUS
J.E. 98-1367 REJB 1998-06604
QCCA Léveillé c. Blanchette
04/29/98 [1998] J.Q. no 1257 [1998] R.R.A. 385
Dufour, Marc Appellant QC Appeal Medical — medical malpractice — civil liability — surgery — post-operatory follow-up
QCCA Chubb du Canada cie d'assurance c. Montréal (Communauté urbaine)
02/26/98 [1998] J.Q. no 470 [1998] R.J.Q. 759 J.E. 98-582 REJB 1998-04956 78 A.C.W.S. (3d) 952
Alarie, Anouk Respondent QC Interlocutory Application for leave to appeal to the Supreme Court of Canada dismissed (Docket 26611, 15/10/1999)
Evidence — objections — communication of exhibits — internal reports
QCCA L.K. v. R.B. 02/17/98 [1998] Q.J. No. 373 J.E. 98-518 [1998] R.D.F. 183 REJB 1998-04774
Gagnon, Nathalie
Respondent QC Appeal Family law — custody and access to children — interest of child paramount
QCCA Confédération, cie d'assurance-vie c. Lareau-Lacroix
12/19/97 [1997] J.Q. no 3946 [1998] R.R.A. 63 78 A.C.W.S. (3d) 410
Bisson, Donald Appellant QC Appeal Insurance — indemnity — restitution of payments not due
QCCA Dominion Bridge Corp. c. Knai
12/05/97 [1997] J.Q. no 3923 [1998] R.J.Q. 321 J.E. 98-235 77 A.C.W.S. (3d) 298
Bisson, Donald Appellant QC Appeal Labour — dismissal — employment contract — arbitration — undertaking to arbitrate
QCCA ABN Amro Bank Canada c. Performance
12/02/97 [1997] J.Q. no 4040
Tremblay, Gérald R.
Appellant QC Appeal Application for leave to appeal to the Supreme
Evidence — solicitor-client privilege
Page 41
The French version will be available soon.
COURT CASE DATE CITATIONS LAWYER ACTED FOR REGION TYPE OF
APPEAL FURTHER HISTORY
LEGAL AND INDUSTRY FOCUS
Guarantees (Quebec) Inc.
Court of Canada dismissed (Docket 25547, 29/05/1997)
QCCA Johnson c. Forcier
11/24/97 [1997] J.Q. no 4132 [1998] R.R.A. 1
Chénier, Robert-Jean
Respondent QC Appeal Medical — medical malpractice — civil liability — neurosurgeon
QCCA Des Marais c. Des Marais
09/29/97 [1997] J.Q. no 3204 [1997] R.J.Q. 2663 156 D.L.R. (4th) 376 J.E. 97-1866
Tremblay, Gérald R.
Appellant QC Appeal Successions — administration — trusts — termination of trust — production — annual accounts
QCCA 2903113 Canada Inc. c. Québec (Régie des marchés agricoles et alimentaires)
06/09/97 [1997] J.Q. no 2125 J.E. 97-1356 79 C.P.R. (3d) 403 73 A.C.W.S. (3d) 189 REJB 1997-01073 1997 CanLII 10706
Renaud, Madeleine
Intervenor QC Appeal Application for leave to appeal to the Supreme Court of Canada dismissed (Docket 26256, 30/04/1998)
Agri-food — hog sale — modification of regulation — jurisdiction of Régie des marchés agricoles et alimentaires du Québec
QCCA Fédération des médecins résidents du Québec c. Université de Montréal
06/02/97 [1997] J.Q. no 1823 [1997] R.J.Q. 1832 J.E. 97-1257 73 A.C.W.S. (3d) 256
Atkinson, William J.
Appellant QC Appeal Application for leave to appeal to the Supreme Court of Canada dismissed (Docket 26163, 12/03/1998)
Motion for declaratory judgment — procedure — education — tuition increase — credits — medical residents — education subsidy — standard form contract
Page 42
The French version will be available soon.
COURT CASE DATE CITATIONS LAWYER ACTED FOR REGION TYPE OF
APPEAL FURTHER HISTORY
LEGAL AND INDUSTRY FOCUS
QCCA Tremblay c. Pourvoirie de l'ours brun (1984) Inc.
05/29/97 [1997] J.Q. no 2295 J.E. 97-1431 [1997] R.R.A. 687
Jarry, Claude M.
Appellant QC Appeal Civil liability — hunting accident — act or fault of another
QCCA Tardif c. Cie d'assurance Provinces-Unies
05/27/97 [1997] J.Q. no 1914 [1997] R.R.A. 314
Jarry, Claude M.
Respondent QC Appeal Insurance — house insurance — coverage — secondary house
QCCA Placements Marcel Lauzon Ltée c. Bolduc
05/14/97 [1997] J.Q. no 1603 [1997] R.R.A. 310
Bélanger, Philippe H.
Respondent QC Appeal Application for leave to appeal to the Supreme Court of Canada dismissed (Docket 26144, 18/12/1997)
Civil liability — investments — kiting — financial situation of corporations
QCCA Cie Montréal Trust c. Terdev Corp. Inc.
05/07/97 [1997] J.Q. no 1586
Bélanger, Philippe H.
Respondent QC Appeal Hypothecs — hypothecary remedies — description of the immoveable
QCCA Dubois-Arciero, succession c. Marotte
03/11/97 [1997] J.Q. no 796
Gagné, Michel Respondent QC Appeal Medical — civil liability — medical malpractice
QCCA Éthier, succession c. Assurance-Vie Desjardins
03/10/97 [1997] J.Q. no 792 J.E. 97-575 [1997] R.R.A. 275
Jarry, Claude M.
Appellant QC Appeal Application for leave to appeal to the Supreme Court of Canada dismissed (Docket 25986, 06/11/1997)
Insurance — loans — accuracy of declarations by the insured
QCCA Guss v. Royal Victoria Hospital
03/10/97 [1997] Q.J. No. 692 J.E. 97-611
Lehoux, Jean-François
Respondent QC Appeal Medical — medical malpractice — dismissal of the action — prescription
Page 43
The French version will be available soon.
COURT CASE DATE CITATIONS LAWYER ACTED FOR REGION TYPE OF
APPEAL FURTHER HISTORY
LEGAL AND INDUSTRY FOCUS
QCCA Guss v. Tannenbaum
03/10/97 [1997] Q.J. No. 693
Lehoux, Jean-François
Respondent QC Appeal Medical malpractice — dismissal of the action — extinctive prescription
QCCA Entreprises Ralph Eid Ltée c. Banque de crédit et de commerce (Canada) (liquidateur de)
02/25/97 [1997] J.Q. no 575
Bélanger, Philippe H.
Appellant QC Appeal Banks — winding up — irrevocable letter of credit
QCCA Pellerin c. Thérien
02/21/97 [1997] J.Q. no 513 [1997] R.J.Q. 816 148 D.L.R. (4th) 255 J.E. 97-588 71 A.C.W.S. (3d) 71 1997 CanLII 10409
Tremblay, Gérald R.
Appellant QC Appeal Application for leave to appeal to the Supreme Court of Canada dismissed (Docket 25848, 16/10/1997)
Elections — contestation — illegal or corrupt practice
QCCA Proulx c. Québec (Procureur général)
01/20/97 [1997] J.Q. no 72 [1997] R.J.Q. 419 145 D.L.R. (4th) 394 J.E. 97-422 [1997] R.R.A. 79 69 A.C.W.S. (3d) 552 REJB 1997-00038
Atkinson, William J.
Respondent QC Appeal Public inquiry — powers of investigation — immunity — Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms — right to reputation — natural justice
QCCA Entreprises Raymond Guy (1975) Inc. c. B.D.C. Ltée
12/16/96 [1996] J.Q. no 4136
Poplaw, Mason Respondent QC Appeal Contracts — installation of fuel tanks — paving — leak
Page 44
The French version will be available soon.
COURT CASE DATE CITATIONS LAWYER ACTED FOR REGION TYPE OF
APPEAL FURTHER HISTORY
LEGAL AND INDUSTRY FOCUS
QCCA Caisse populaire Desjardins de Cartierville c. Sixgraph Informatique Ltée
05/31/96 [1996] J.Q. no 1342
Jarry, Claude M.
Respondent QC Appeal Civil procedure — production of documents
QCCA Fertek Inc. c. Acier Mutual Inc.
03/06/96 [1996] J.Q. no 524 J.E. 96-602 EYB 1996-71808 61 A.C.W.S. (3d) 1083
Jolin, Pierre Appellant QC Appeal Construction — call for tenders — bid depository system — conformity of bid
QCCA Cadillac Fairview Corp. c. Bigi Canada Ltd.
02/21/96 [1996] J.Q. no 339 [1996] R.D.J. 193
Tardif, Alain N. Appellant QC Interlocutory Bankruptcy and insolvency — proposal — commercial leases — rents — stay
QCCA Cerescorp Inc. c. Crédit Bail Commerce Ltée
02/12/96 [1996] J.Q. no 293
Tremblay, Gérald R.
Appellant QC Appeal Contracts — interpretation — leasing agreement — price provision
QCCA Cerescorp Inc. c. Crédit Bail Commerce Ltée
02/12/96 [1996] J.Q. no 293
Tremblay, Gérald R.
Appellant QC Appeal Interpretation of contract — fixed lease rate — layman
QCCA Lefebvre c. Madore
12/12/95 [1995] J.Q. no 1140 J.E. 96-126 [1996] R.R.A. 25
Dufour, Marc Respondent QC Appeal Medical — medical malpractice — civil liability — duty to inform
QCCA K.R. c. C.L.S. 12/12/95 [1995] J.Q. no 1112 J.E. 96-121 [1996] R.D.J. 62 59 A.C.W.S. (3d) 1033
Tremblay, Gérald R.
Appellant QC Appeal Civil procedure — uncontested — judicial authorizations — executor — request for dismissal — s.885 Code de procédure civile — statutory interpretation
Page 45
The French version will be available soon.
COURT CASE DATE CITATIONS LAWYER ACTED FOR REGION TYPE OF
APPEAL FURTHER HISTORY
LEGAL AND INDUSTRY FOCUS
QCCA Gignac c. Banque nationale du Canada
12/08/95 [1995] J.Q. no 1134 60 A.C.W.S. (3d) 536 EYB 1995-57615 J.E. 96-130
Atkinson, William J.
Appellant QC Appeal Individual employment relations — unjust dismissal — notice period — trial period — non-pecuniary damages — absence of bad faith
QCCA Domaine de la Rivière Inc. c. Aluminium du Canada Ltée
11/22/95 [1995] J.Q. no 931 J.E. 96-2 EYB 1995-57702 [1996] R.D.I. 6
Tremblay, Gérald R.
Respondent QC Appeal Servitude — perpetuity — immoveable — electricity — transmission and telephone lines
QCCA Syndicat des chauffeurs de la Société du transport de la Ville de Laval (CSN) c. Québec (Conseil des Services Essentiels)
10/06/95 [1995] J.Q. no 727 [1995] R.J.Q. 597 [1995] R.D.J. 597
Atkinson, William J. Renaud, Madeleine
Respondent QC Appeal Application for leave to appeal to the Supreme Court of Canada dismissed (Docket 25029, 05/12/1995)
Labour — work stoppage — essential public services — bus service — power of council to order return to work
QCCA Leblanc c. Conseillers en placements Pemp Inc.
08/28/95 [1995] J.Q. no 663 J.E. 95-1727 57 A.C.W.S. (3d) 754 EYB 1995-56924
Tremblay, Gérald R.
Appellant QC Appeal Securities law — commission fees — public order — validity of contracts — jurisdiction — prescription — actions in warranty
QCCA Gordon Capital Corp. c. Laurentienne Générale, Cie d'assurance
08/08/95 [1995] J.Q. no 529 J.E. 95-1631 [1995] R.D.J. 537 57 A.C.W.S. (3d) 738
Tremblay, Gérald R.
Respondent QC Appeal Insurance policy — jurisdiction — lis pendens — forum non conveniens — prescription
QCCA Caisse populaire de Valleyfield c.
05/31/95 [1995] J.Q. no 475 J.E. 95-1225
Jarry, Claude M.
Appellant QC Appeal Civil procedure — discontinuance — transaction — offer to settle
Page 46
The French version will be available soon.
COURT CASE DATE CITATIONS LAWYER ACTED FOR REGION TYPE OF
APPEAL FURTHER HISTORY
LEGAL AND INDUSTRY FOCUS
Proulx, succession
[1995] R.D.J. 479 55 A.C.W.S. (3d) 1262
QCCA Irwin Management Consultants Ltd. c. Thorne, Riddell
05/18/95 [1995] J.Q. no 445 J.E. 95-1183 [1995] R.R.A. 589 55 A.C.W.S. (3d) 432
Deschamps, Michel
Appellant QC Appeal Civil liability — professional liability — auditor
QCCA Pellerin c. Thérien
04/21/95 [1995] J.Q. no 420 [1995] R.J.Q. 1329 J.E. 95-1091 55 A.C.W.S. (3d) 769
Tremblay, Gérald R.
Respondent QC Appeal Application for leave to appeal to the Supreme Court of Canada dismissed (Docket 24729, 29/06/1995)
Canada Election Act — contestation of election — presentation of notice — time frame — statute interpretation
QCCA McCracken c. Cégep Lévis Lauzon Inc.
04/06/95 [1995] Q.J. No. 334
Jarry, Claude M.
Respondent QC Appeal Damages — limits of compensatory damages — prohibition against double recovery — bars — payment by manufacturer
QCCA R. c. Fontaine 03/24/95 [1995] J.Q. no 295 J.E. 95-853
Atkinson, William J.
Appellant QC Appeal Application for leave to appeal to the Supreme Court of Canada dismissed (Docket 24734, 07/09/1995)
Criminal law — jurisdiction — criminal charges against a member of the house of commons — house of commons jurisdiction vs. judicial courts
QCCA 2523-9326 Québec Inc. (Alma Mazda) c. Hyundai Auto Canada
02/23/95 [1995] J.Q. no 184
Dufour, Marc Appellant QC Appeal Contracts — contract of adhesion — no legal relation between the parties
Page 47
The French version will be available soon.
COURT CASE DATE CITATIONS LAWYER ACTED FOR REGION TYPE OF
APPEAL FURTHER HISTORY
LEGAL AND INDUSTRY FOCUS
Inc.
QCCA Québec (Sûreté) c. Assoc. des policiers provinciaux du Québec
01/24/95 [1995] J.Q. no 68 J.E. 95-434 67 Q.A.C. 260 53 A.C.W.S. (3d) 77
Atkinson, William J.
Appellant QC Appeal Application for leave to appeal to the Supreme Court of Canada dismissed (Docket 24627, 06/07/1995)
Employment — police — termination — jurisdiction of arbitrator
QCCA Banque de Nouvelle-Écosse c. Exarhos
01/16/95 [1995] J.Q. no 25 [1995] R.J.Q. 63 J.E. 95-222 [1995] R.R.A. 4 52 A.C.W.S. (3d) 1013
Tremblay, Gérald R.
Appellant QC Appeal Application for leave to appeal to the Supreme Court of Canada dismissed (Docket 24608, 27/05/1999)
Line of credit — security — respondent seizure — loss of profits — prescription
QCCA Montréal (Communauté urbaine) c. Québec (Bureau de
11/28/94 [1994] J.Q. no 1000 J.E. 95-19 EYB 1994-55894
Dufour, Marc Respondent QC Appeal Administrative law — real estate assessment — judicial review — powers of superior court
QCCA Syndicat des travailleurs de l'information du Journal de Montréal c. Le Journal de Montréal, une division du Groupe Québécor Inc.
11/28/94 [1994] J.Q. no 999 J.E. 95-87 67 Q.A.C. 1 [1995] R.D.J. 33 51 A.C.W.S. (3d) 1075 EYB 1994-28943
Tremblay, Gérald R.
Appellant QC Appeal Union grievance — dismissal — arbitration — admissibility of evidence — hearsay — burden of proof
Page 48
The French version will be available soon.
COURT CASE DATE CITATIONS LAWYER ACTED FOR REGION TYPE OF
APPEAL FURTHER HISTORY
LEGAL AND INDUSTRY FOCUS
QCCA Québec (Sûreté) c. Lussier
08/31/94 [1994] J.Q. no 610 J.E. 94-1456 [1994] R.D.J. 470
Atkinson, William J.
Appellant QC Appeal Discipline — police — judicial review —discretion
QCCA Uni-Sélect Inc. c. Acklands Ltd.
08/31/94 [1994] J.Q. no 611 [1995] R.D.J. 118 49 A.C.W.S. (3d) 1305
Potter, Simon V.
Respondent QC Interlocutory Civil procedure — interlocutory injunction — sale of business — noncompetition clause
QCCA Assicurazioni Generali S.p.A. c. Calvi
06/02/94 [1994] J.Q. no 458 [1994] R.J.Q. 1269 J.E. 94-979 48 A.C.W.S. (3d) 292
Tremblay, Gérald R.
Respondent QC Appeal Application for leave to appeal to the Supreme Court of Canada dismissed (Docket 24314, 01/12/1994)
Insurance — enforcement of foreign judgement — executory/final judgment — cross-claim
QCCA Ordre des chiropraticiens du Québec c. Thomas
06/01/94 [1994] J.Q. no 526
Atkinson, William J.
Respondent QC Appeal Professional code — chiropractic — administrative committee powers — procedure — request for judicial review
QCCA F.L. c. R.G.L. Droit de la famille - 1777 (SOQUIJ)
05/24/94 [1994] J.Q. no 447 [1994] R.J.Q. 1493 J.E. 94-1074 48 A.C.W.S. (3d) 907 EYB 1994-59173
Tremblay, Gérald R.
Appellant QC Appeal Civil procedure — costs — abuse of procedures — specific orders — legal fees —criteria to condemn lawyer for costs
QCCA Québec (Commission des droits de la personne) c. Commission scolaire
05/20/94 [1994] J.Q. no 417 [1994] R.J.Q. 1196 J.E. 94-926 64 Q.A.C. 31
Jarry, Claude M.
Appellant QC Appeal Application for leave to appeal to the Supreme Court of Canada dismissed
Human rights — discrimination — intellectual disability — right to free public education
Page 49
The French version will be available soon.
COURT CASE DATE CITATIONS LAWYER ACTED FOR REGION TYPE OF
APPEAL FURTHER HISTORY
LEGAL AND INDUSTRY FOCUS
régionale Chauveau (Re Rouette)
48 A.C.W.S. (3d) 157 21 C.H.R.R. 189
(Docket 24291, 21/11/1996)
QCCA Émond c. Citadelle Cie d'assurance générale
03/18/94 [1994] J.Q. no 218 [1994] R.R.A. 230
Jarry, Claude M.
Appellant QC Appeal Insurance contract — interpretation — exclusions clause — insurer's duty to indemnify
QCCA Sinclair c. Québec (ministère de l'Énergie et des Ressources)
01/24/94 [1994] J.Q. no 48 [1994] R.J.Q. 289 J.E. 94-250 60 Q.A.C. 50 45 A.C.W.S. (3d) 673
Tremblay, Gérald R.
Respondent QC Appeal Crown immunity — senior civil servant — dismissal — injunction
QCCA Boyer c. Barreau du Québec
12/23/93 [1993] J.Q. no 2222 [1994] R.J.Q. 29 J.E. 94-88 61 Q.A.C. 307 44 A.C.W.S. (3d) 1020 EYB 1993-64306 1993 CanLII 4401
Tremblay, Gérald R.
Appellant QC Appeal Civil procedure — mandamus — Barreau du Québec — judicial review
QCCA Atelier d'Usinage G.D. Inc. c. Produits d'Énergie du Canada Inc.
12/17/93 [1993] J.Q. no 2254 J.E. 94-193 60 Q.A.C. 168 [1994] R.D.J. 172 44 A.C.W.S. (3d) 1199 EYB 1994-64491
Arpin, Sophie Appellant QC Interlocutory Civil procedure — interlocutory — examination on discovery after defence
QCCA Coopérants, Mutual Life Insurance Society (Provisional
07/30/93 [1993] J.Q. no 1204 [1993] Q.J. No. 1204 [1993] R.J.Q.
Tremblay, Gérald R. Deschamps, Michel
Respondent QC Appeal Application for leave to appeal to the Supreme Court of Canada
Winding up — registered pension plans — deposit administration contracts — priority
Page 50
The French version will be available soon.
COURT CASE DATE CITATIONS LAWYER ACTED FOR REGION TYPE OF
APPEAL FURTHER HISTORY
LEGAL AND INDUSTRY FOCUS
Liquidator of) (Re)
2070 J.E. 93-1420 58 Q.A.C. 161 42 A.C.W.S. (3d) 75
dismissed (Docket 23850, 10/02/1994)
QCCA Coopérants, société mutuelle d'assurance-vie (liquidateur provisoire de) (Re) (C.A. Qué.)
07/30/93 [1993] J.Q. no 1203 [1993] Q.J. No. 1203 J.E. 93-1419 58 Q.A.C. 211 [1994] R.L. 268 42 A.C.W.S. (3d) 76
Tremblay, Gérald R. Deschamps, Michel
Intervenor QC Appeal Application for leave to appeal to the Supreme Court of Canada dismissed (Docket 23851, 10/02/1994)
Winding up — mutual life insurance society — provisional liquidator — priority claim
QCCA Brissette c. Aubin
07/06/93 [1993] J.Q. no 1201 [1994] R.D.J. 13 EYB 1993-59194 41 A.C.W.S. (3d) 799
Dufour, Marc Appellant QC Interlocutory Civil procedure — dilatory exceptions — particulars
QCCA J.E. Verreault & Fils Ltée c. Commission des écoles catholiques de Québec
05/19/93 [1993] J.Q. no 632 J.E. 93-874 56 Q.A.C. 215 [1994] R.L. 126 39 A.C.W.S. (3d) 1120
Jolin, Pierre Respondent QC Appeal Application for leave to appeal to the Supreme Court of Canada dismissed (Docket 23633, 23/09/1993)
Contracts — attribution of a contract by a public body — call for tenders — injunction — declaratory judgment
QCCA Cie d'assurance Bélair c. Bissonnette
05/14/93 [1993] J.Q. no 844 J.E. 93-1032 [1993] R.R.A. 338
Atkinson, William J.
Appellant QC Appeal Insurance — fire — autonomous act of the thing
QCCA Vanhoutte c. Trust Général du Canada
03/11/93 [1993] J.Q. no 436
Jolin, Pierre Appellant QC Appeal Civil liability — mandate — securities management agreement — duty to inform
Page 51
The French version will be available soon.
COURT CASE DATE CITATIONS LAWYER ACTED FOR REGION TYPE OF
APPEAL FURTHER HISTORY
LEGAL AND INDUSTRY FOCUS
— negligence
QCCA Coopérants, société mutuelle d'assurance-vie (liquidateur provisoire de) (Re)
02/24/93 [1993] J.Q. no 282
Tremblay, Gérald R.
Respondent QC Interlocutory Application for leave to appeal to the Supreme Court of Canada dismissed (Docket 23850, 10/02/1994)
Winding up — provisional execution of a superior court judgment
QCCA Coopérants, société mutuelle d'assurance-vie (liquidateur provisoire de) (Re)
02/24/93 [1993] J.Q. no 283
Tremblay, Gérald R.
Intervenor QC Interlocutory Application for leave to appeal to the Supreme Court of Canada dismissed (Docket 23851, 10/02/1994)
Winding up — motion for directions — stay — priority claims
QCCA Assn. québécoise des pharmaciens propriétaires Cumberland Drugs (Merivale) Ltd. c. Canada (Procureur général)
02/22/93 [1993] J.Q. no 275
Renaud, Madeleine
Respondent QC Appeal Constitutional — Competition Act — declaratory judgment
QCCA RJR-Macdonald Inc. v. Canada (Attorney General)
01/15/93 [1993] J.Q. no 1 [1993] Q.J. No. 1 [1993] R.J.Q. 375 102 D.L.R. (4th) 289 J.E. 93-329
Potter, Simon V.
Respondent QC Appeal Affirmed by RJR - MacDonald Inc. v. Canada (Attorney General),
Constitutional — freedom of expression — advertising and promotion of tobacco — stay — relief from compliance with regulations
Page 52
The French version will be available soon.
COURT CASE DATE CITATIONS LAWYER ACTED FOR REGION TYPE OF
APPEAL FURTHER HISTORY
LEGAL AND INDUSTRY FOCUS
53 Q.A.C. 79 48 C.P.R. (3d) 417 38 A.C.W.S. (3d) 55
[1994] 1 S.C.R. 311
QCCA René-Poulin c. Fabrique Notre-Dame de Québec
08/27/92 [1992] J.Q. no 1445
Jarry, Claude M.
Respondent QC Appeal Civil liability — personal injury — fall
QCCA Ordre des optométristes du Québec c. Cumberland Drugs (Merivale) Ltd.
04/02/92 [1992] J.Q. no 611 [1992] R.J.Q. 923 J.E. 92-632 32 A.C.W.S. (3d) 843
Atkinson, William J.
Respondent QC Appeal Application for leave to appeal to the Supreme Court of Canada dismissed (Docket 23028, 24/09/1992)
Professional code — usurpation of profession — optometry — drugstore sales
QCCA Balestreri c. Robert
03/30/92 [1992] J.Q. no 495 [1993] R.L. 4 32 A.C.W.S. (3d) 1071
Potter, Simon V.
Appellant QC Appeal Corporations — directors and officers — right to indemnification
QCCA Verret c. Confédération des syndicats nationaux
03/23/92 [1992] J.Q. no 461 [1992] R.J.Q. 975 J.E. 92-635 32 A.C.W.S. (3d) 759
Atkinson, William J.
Respondent QC Appeal Application for leave to appeal to the Supreme Court of Canada dismissed (Docket 23016, 19/11/1992)
Procedure — labour law — collective agreement — preliminary exception — jurisdiction of civil law court vs. arbitrator
QCCA Verret c. Syndicat des travailleuses et travailleurs de la CSN
03/23/92 [1992] J.Q. no 460 [1992] R.J.Q. 979 J.E. 92-636 46 Q.A.C. 128 32 A.C.W.S. (3d)
Atkinson, William J.
Respondent QC Appeal Application for leave to appeal to the Supreme Court of Canada dismissed
Procedure — labour law — collective agreement — preliminary exception — jurisdiction of civil law court vs. arbitrator
Page 53
The French version will be available soon.
COURT CASE DATE CITATIONS LAWYER ACTED FOR REGION TYPE OF
APPEAL FURTHER HISTORY
LEGAL AND INDUSTRY FOCUS
735 (Docket 23018, 19/11/1992)
QCCA Comité d'environnement de la Baie Inc. c. Société d'électrolyse
03/16/92 [1992] J.Q. no 447 95 D.L.R. (4th) 644 J.E. 92-596 46 Q.A.C. 21 [1992] R.D.J. 333 32 A.C.W.S. (3d) 699
Tremblay, Gérald R.
Appellant QC Interlocutory Environmental law — class action — civil procedure — motion to strike paragraphs — modification of the nature of the remedy
QCCA Blumer's Ltd. c. York-Hannover Developments Ltd.
01/29/92 [1992] J.Q. no 76 J.E. 92-336 [1992] R.D.J. 358 31 A.C.W.S. (3d) 539
Poplaw, Mason Respondent QC Interlocutory Civil procedure — cross-demand — connectivity between the causes of action
QCCA Poirier c. Soucy
12/30/91 [1991] J.Q. no 2310 J.E. 92-136 44 Q.A.C. 271 [1992] R.R.A. 3 31 A.C.W.S. (3d) 162
Chénier, Robert-Jean
Respondent QC Appeal Medical — civil liability — medical malpractice — diagnosis — prescribed medication
QCCA General Accident, Cie d'assurance du Canada c. Corp. des concessionnaires d'automobiles du Québec
09/18/91 [1991] J.Q. no 1669 J.E. 91-1553 42 Q.A.C. 125 [1992] R.L. 336 6 C.C.L.I. (2d) 209 29 A.C.W.S. (3d) 550
Jarry, Claude M.
Respondent QC Appeal Contracts — sale of a stolen good — claim of a stolen good — action in warranty — subrogation — good faith
QCCA Hydro-Québec c. Radmore
07/30/91 [1991] J.Q. no 1264 [1991] R.J.Q.
Tremblay, Gérald R.
Appellant QC Interlocutory Expropriation — jurisdiction of Court of Québec (expropriation chamber) —
Page 54
The French version will be available soon.
COURT CASE DATE CITATIONS LAWYER ACTED FOR REGION TYPE OF
APPEAL FURTHER HISTORY
LEGAL AND INDUSTRY FOCUS
1852 J.E. 91-1270 40 Q.A.C. 200 28 A.C.W.S. (3d) 470
assessment of damages
QCCA Entreprises Grutman Inc. c. L'Archevêque & Rivest, Ltée
06/07/91 [1991] J.Q. no 1025 J.E. 91-1034 [1991] R.L. 646 47 C.L.R. 213 27 A.C.W.S. (3d) 399
Tremblay, Gérald R.
Respondent QC Appeal Application for leave to appeal to the Supreme Court of Canada dismissed (Docket 22641, 06/02/1992)
Construction — defect — architects — civil liability
QCCA Entreprises Grutman Inc. c. L'Archevêque & Rivest, Ltée
06/07/91 [1991] J.Q. no 1026
Tremblay, Gérald R.
Respondent QC Appeal Application for leave to appeal to the Supreme Court of Canada dismissed (Docket 22641, 06/02/1992)
Construction — defect — architects — civil liability
QCCA Gervais Dubé Inc. c. Construction Champoux Inc.
06/06/91 [1991] J.Q. no 1068 [1992] R.D.J. 1 27 A.C.W.S. (3d) 797 EYB 1991-57899 J.E. 91-1114
Jolin, Pierre Respondent QC Interlocutory Civil procedure — incidental proceedings — illegal amendment — extinctive prescription
QCCA Dubeau c. Technisol Inc.
06/03/91 [1991] J.Q. no 1002 J.E. 91-1029 51 Q.A.C. 107 [1991] R.D.J. 466 27 A.C.W.S. (3d) 610
Jolin, Pierre Respondent QC Appeal Application for leave to appeal to the Supreme Court of Canada dismissed (Docket 22623, 16/01/1992)
Company law — sale of shares — warranty — claim for shares ownership
Page 55
The French version will be available soon.
COURT CASE DATE CITATIONS LAWYER ACTED FOR REGION TYPE OF
APPEAL FURTHER HISTORY
LEGAL AND INDUSTRY FOCUS
QCCA Entreprises P.E.B. Ltée c. Québec (Procureur général)
04/10/91 [1991] J.Q. no 630 J.E. 91-672 EYB 1991-94675
Jolin, Pierre Appellant QC Appeal Contracts — public contracts — infrastructure works — execution on contractual obligations
QCCA Executive Investments Canada Ltd. c. Rourke Bourbonnais & Associates Ltd.
11/30/90 [1990] J.Q. no 2124 J.E. 91-94 [1991] R.D.I. 36
Poplaw, Mason Appellant QC Appeal Real estate — lease — municipal taxation — taxes payable by the landlord
QCCA Giguère c. Parenteau
11/21/90 [1990] J.Q. no 2140 J.E. 91-55 [1990] R.D.J. 598 EYB 1990-58105 24 A.C.W.S. (3d) 548
Gagné, Michel Respondent QC Appeal Medical — medical malpractice — civil liability — extinctive prescription
QCCA Centre Hospitalier de Verdun c. Descôteaux
11/07/90 [1990] J.Q. no 2018
Rousse, Jacques
Respondent QC Appeal Labour — grievance arbitration — discipline — dismissal — reinstatement
QCCA Renvoi relatif à la Loi sur l'Instruction publique (Qué.)
09/21/90 [1990] J.Q. no 1662 [1990] R.J.Q. 2498 J.E. 90-1492 32 Q.A.C. 1 ext 23 A.C.W.S. (3d) 351
Renaud, Madeleine
Intervenor QC Reference Affirmed by Reference re Education Act (Que.), [1993] 2 S.C.R. 511
Constitutional - education - linguistic school boards
QCCA Banque Royale du Canada c. 125258 Canada Inc. (syndic)
06/19/90 [1990] J.Q. no 1062 [1990] R.J.Q. 1547 J.E. 90-1033
Tremblay, Gérald R.
Appellant QC Appeal Application for leave to appeal to the Supreme Court of Canada dismissed
Bankruptcy and insolvency — trustee — proof of claim
Page 56
The French version will be available soon.
COURT CASE DATE CITATIONS LAWYER ACTED FOR REGION TYPE OF
APPEAL FURTHER HISTORY
LEGAL AND INDUSTRY FOCUS
(Docket 22101, 07/02/1991)
QCCA Banque Nationale du Canada c. Commission scolaire régionale de Tilly
04/26/90 [1990] J.Q. no 688 [1990] R.J.Q. 1536 J.E. 90-724
Atkinson, William J.
Appellant QC Appeal Loan — assignment of accounts receivable — school buses
QCCA Newman c. Maxtemp Thermo Comfort Inc.
03/13/90 [1990] J.Q. no 424 [1990] R.D.J. 249
Poplaw, Mason Appellant QC Interlocutory Civil procedure — evidence — examinations on discovery after defence — communication of exhibits
QCCA Placements H.D.B. Inc. c. Djurovic
02/23/90 [1990] J.Q. no 280
Poplaw, Mason Respondent QC Appeal Contracts — real estate broker — sale of an immoveable — promise of sale
QCCA Tremblay c. Claveau
02/22/90 [1990] J.Q. no 278 J.E. 90-495 [1990] R.R.A. 268 19 A.C.W.S. (3d) 1259
Chénier, Robert-Jean
Respondent QC Appeal Medical — civil liability — medical malpractice — diagnosis
QCCA Comité d'environnement de La Baie Inc. c. Société d'électrolyse et de chimie Alcan Ltée
02/06/90 [1990] J.Q. no 216 [1990] R.J.Q. 655 J.E. 90-422 29 Q.A.C. 251 6 C.E.L.R. (N.S.) 150 1990 CanLII 3338
Tremblay, Gérald R.
Respondent QC Appeal Application for leave to appeal to the Supreme Court of Canada dismissed (Docket 21891, 05/07/1990)
Environment — class action — air pollution — bauxite — alumina
Page 57
The French version will be available soon.
COURT CASE DATE CITATIONS LAWYER ACTED FOR REGION TYPE OF
APPEAL FURTHER HISTORY
LEGAL AND INDUSTRY FOCUS
QCCA Midland Doherty Ltd. c. Banque Royale du Canada
01/09/90 [1990] J.Q. no 10 [1990] R.J.Q. 121 J.E. 90-132 18 A.C.W.S. (3d) 1212
Potter, Simon V.
Respondent QC Appeal Bills of exchange — cheques — banks — negligence
QCCA Trust Général du Canada c. Placements Racine Inc.
09/05/89 [1989] J.Q. no 1606 [1989] R.J.Q. 2287 J.E. 89-1416 29 Q.A.C. 199
Jolin, Pierre Appellant QC Appeal Application for leave to appeal to the Supreme Court of Canada dismissed (Docket 21653, 01/02/1990)
Suretyship — contract of personal suretyship — liberation of debtor
QCCA Trust Général du Canada c. Placements Racine Inc.
09/05/89 [1989] J.Q. no 1605
Jolin, Pierre Appellant QC Appeal Application for leave to appeal to the Supreme Court of Canada dismissed (Docket 21653, 01/02/1990)
Suretyship — contract of personal suretyship — liberation of debtor
QCCA Imperial Tobacco Ltée c. Canada (Procureur général)
04/25/89 [1989] J.Q. no 696 [1989] R.D.J. 209
Potter, Simon V.
Respondent QC Interlocutory Evidence — testimony — objections — declaratory remedy — trial judge's discretion
QCCA Segal c. Québec (Sous-ministre du Revenu)
04/20/89 [1989] J.Q. no 680 J.E. 89-1567 [1989] R.D.F.Q. 138 [1989] R.L. 361 15 A.C.W.S. (3d) 45
Gagnon, Guy A.
Appellant QC Appeal Tax — appeal of tax assessments — income — commission on sales
Page 58
The French version will be available soon.
COURT CASE DATE CITATIONS LAWYER ACTED FOR REGION TYPE OF
APPEAL FURTHER HISTORY
LEGAL AND INDUSTRY FOCUS
QCCA G.M.M. v. C.K.L.
03/21/89 [1989] Q.J. No. 453 J.E. 89-696 21 Q.A.C. 161 [1990] R.L. 128 14 A.C.W.S. (3d) 358
Tremblay, Gérald R.
Respondent QC Appeal Family law — divorce — accessory measures — compensatory allowance
QCCA RJR-Macdonald Inc. c. Canada (Procureur général)
03/13/89 [1989] J.Q. no 429 [1989] R.J.Q. 820 59 D.L.R. (4th) 743 J.E. 89-628 25 Q.A.C. 201 42 Admin. L.R. 175 14 A.C.W.S. (3d) 167
Potter, Simon V.
Respondent QC Interlocutory Application for leave to appeal to the Supreme Court of Canada dismissed (Docket 21376, 08/06/1989)
Civil procedure — appeal — conservatory intervention
QCCA Middleton c. Montreal Standard
02/09/89 [1989] J.Q. no 218 [1989] R.J.Q. 1101 J.E. 89-723 34 Q.A.C. 36 14 A.C.W.S. (3d) 67
Rousse, Jacques
Appellant QC Appeal Labour — labour standards — notice — layoffs — differences in treatment
QCCA Bourassa c. Forum de Montréal Inc.
02/01/89 [1989] J.Q. no 200
Lehoux, Jean-François
Respondent QC Appeal Civil liability — security guards — injuries
QCCA Cournoyer c. Institut national de la recherche scientifique (C.A.Q.)
12/05/88 [1988] J.Q. no 2212 [1989] R.J.Q. 251 J.E. 89-284
Atkinson, William J.
Respondent QC Appeal Individual employment relations — unjust dismissal — unilateral resiliation of contract — stipulation of new employment conditions
Page 59
The French version will be available soon.
COURT CASE DATE CITATIONS LAWYER ACTED FOR REGION TYPE OF
APPEAL FURTHER HISTORY
LEGAL AND INDUSTRY FOCUS
QCCA Cie d'assurance Guardian du Canada c. Desrosiers
09/30/88 [1988] J.Q. no 1719
Jarry, Claude M.
Respondent QC Appeal Insurance — civil liability — fire — worker
QCCA Thibault c. Centre Commercial Lebourgneuf Ltée
09/29/88 [1988] J.Q. no 1715
Jolin, Pierre Appellant QC Appeal Real estate — commercial lease — resiliation of lease
QCCA Petitpas c. Cousineau
09/28/88 [1988] J.Q. no 1704 J.E. 88-1270 [1988] R.D.J. 580 12 A.C.W.S. (3d) 53
Tremblay, Gérald R.
Respondent QC Interlocutory Application for leave to appeal to the Supreme Court of Canada dismissed (Docket 21150, 23/02/1989)
Municipal — municipal councillors — quo warranto — right of appeal
QCCA Bourassa c. Entreprises de Stoneham Inc.
09/15/88 [1988] J.Q. no 1650 [1988] R.J.Q. 2605 J.E. 88-1229 28 Q.A.C. 228 [1988] R.D.I. 593
Jolin, Pierre Appellant QC Appeal Property law — application of the constitution or Tenure System Act — mobile home
QCCA St-Denis c. Cie de finance Household du Canada
05/24/88 [1988] J.Q. no 896 J.E. 88-831 EYB 1988-58859
Tremblay, Gérald R.
Respondent QC Appeal Loans — small loans — class action
QCCA Kruco Inc. c. Kruger Inc.
04/29/88 [1988] J.Q. no 695
Tremblay, Gérald R.
Appellant QC Interlocutory Corporations — civil procedure — evidence — objection — right to be heard
QCCA R. c. Bellavance
04/29/88 [1988] J.Q. no 696 J.E. 88-660
Tremblay, Gérald R.
Respondent QC Appeal Tax — tax evasion — prescription
Page 60
The French version will be available soon.
COURT CASE DATE CITATIONS LAWYER ACTED FOR REGION TYPE OF
APPEAL FURTHER HISTORY
LEGAL AND INDUSTRY FOCUS
14 Q.A.C. 295 [1988] R.L. 249 [1988] 2 C.T.C. 64 88 D.T.C. 6267
QCCA Société de Gestion Grenier et Vaillancourt Inc. c. J.A. Madill
09/09/87 [1987] J.Q. no 2220 [1988] R.R.A. 124
Jarry, Claude M.
Respondent QC Appeal Insurance — property insurance — stolen goods — insurer's duty to indemnify
QCCA Québec (Commission des normes du travail) c. Chantiers Davie Ltée
09/08/87 [1987] J.Q. no 1627 [1987] R.J.Q. 1949 19 Q.A.C. 7
Atkinson, William J.
Respondent QC Appeal Labour law — dismissal — failure to give notice — recourse under collective agreement — exhausting available recourses
QCCA Labonté c. Sadler
06/11/87 [1987] J.Q. no 1032 8 Q.A.C. 283
Chénier, Robert-Jean
Respondent QC Appeal Medical — civil liability — transaction — opinion as to the ability to return to work
QCCA Spino Construction Cie c. Québec (sous-ministre du Revenu)
05/19/87 [1987] J.Q. no 836 8 Q.A.C. 19 [1987] R.L. 388 4 A.C.W.S. (3d) 442
Jolin, Pierre Respondent QC Appeal Tax — retail sales tax — assessments
QCCA J.H. Dupuis Ltée c. Résidence Jean-de-la-Lande Inc.
05/12/87 [1987] J.Q. no 825
Tremblay, Gérald R.
Respondent QC Appeal Civil procedure — arbitration — homologation of an award
QCCA Kruco Inc. c. Kruger Inc.
02/07/86 [1986] J.Q. no 273
Tremblay, Gérald R.
Respondent QC Interlocutory Oppression remedy — payment of dividends — civil procedure — dilatory
Page 61
The French version will be available soon.
COURT CASE DATE CITATIONS LAWYER ACTED FOR REGION TYPE OF
APPEAL FURTHER HISTORY
LEGAL AND INDUSTRY FOCUS
exception — joint conclusions
QCCA Communauté urbaine de Montréal c. Association des gymnastes amateurs de Montréal
01/17/86 [1986] J.Q. no 2835
Tremblay, Gérald R.
Respondent QC Appeal Municipal taxation — real estate assessment — interpretation
QCCA Artisans, Société coopérative d'assurance-vie c. Madore
11/15/85 [1985] J.Q. no 553 J.E. 85-1055
Tremblay, Gérald R.
Respondent QC Appeal Insurance — life insurance — additional benefit in case of accidental death — exclusion clause
QCCA Hôtel de la Grande Allée inc. c. Canada Permanent Trust Co.
09/23/85 [1985] J.Q. no 592 [1985] R.D.J. 608 J.E. 85-960
Tremblay, Gérald R.
Appellant QC Interlocutory Civil procedure — examination on discovery after defence — third parties
QCCA Labranche c. Cie pétrolière impériale ltée Esso
09/18/85 [1985] J.Q. no 519
Tremblay, Gérald R.
Respondent QC Appeal Competition — consumer protection — class action — oil companies — price-fixing
QCCA Cie d'assurances Provinces-Unies c. Lorent
05/01/85 [1985] J.Q. no 556
Jarry, Claude M.
Appellant QC Appeal Insurance — fire — civil liability — landlord and tenant relation
QCCA Domaine de la rivière inc. c. Aluminium du Canada ltée
01/25/85 [1985] J.Q. no 96 J.E. 85-249 [1985] R.D.J. 30
Tremblay, Gérald R.
Respondent QC Interlocutory Property law — evidence — right to hear expert evidence and to file an expert report
QCCA Télémédia communications Inc. c.
12/14/84 [1984] J.Q. no 759 J.E. 85-81
Jarry, Claude M.
Appellant QC Appeal Obligations — contracts — interpretation of contract — penal clause
Page 62
The French version will be available soon.
COURT CASE DATE CITATIONS LAWYER ACTED FOR REGION TYPE OF
APPEAL FURTHER HISTORY
LEGAL AND INDUSTRY FOCUS
Samson [1985] R.D.J. 478
QCCA Réserves du Nord (1973) Ltée (In re): Hôtel Pilma sur le Lac Inc. et Bertrand
09/04/84 [1984] J.Q. no 741 J.E. 84-729 [1984] C.A. 500
Tremblay, Gérald R.
Respondent QC Appeal Application for leave to appeal to the Supreme Court of Canada dismissed (Docket 19071, 20/12/1984)
Bankruptcy and insolvency — fraudulent transaction — setting aside
QCCA Gérard Nolin Ltée (In re): Banque canadienne nationale c. Bellavance
02/08/79 [1979] J.Q. no 317 J.E. 79-235 [1979] C.A. 168
Deschamps, Michel
Appellant QC Appeal Insolvency — bankruptcy — cancellation of transactions prior to bankruptcy — novation
QCCA Bean c. Langlois
12/21/ 67 [1967] J.Q. no 4 [1968] B.R. 135
Drouin, Richard
Appellant QC Appeal Civil liability — damages — dismissal of appeal
QCCA Total Appeals: 316