quarterly meeting minutes march 27, 2014

23
Phone: (512) 936-7700 Fax: (512) 936-7714 6330 E Highway 290 STE 200 Austin TX 78723-1035 TEXAS COMMISSION ON LAW ENFORCEMENT Kim Vickers Executive Director Quarterly Meeting Minutes March 27, 2014 On Thursday, March 27, 2014, at 9:30 a.m. the quarterly meeting of the Texas Commission on Law Enforcement (TCOLE) was held at the J.J. Pickle Research Campus, The Commons Learning Center, 10100 Burnet Road, Bldg 137, Austin, Texas. Commissioners attending were Sheriff Joel W. Richardson, Presiding Officer; Ms. Patt Scheckel-Hollingsworth, Assistant Presiding Officer; Dr. Johnny E. Lovejoy II, Secretary; Major Jason Hester; Constable Ron Hood; Mr. James Oakley; Senior Police Officer Joe Pennington; and Chief Ruben Villescas. Mr. Rob Kyker was absent. Raymond Winter, Veena Mohan, and William Van Shellenbeck from the Office of the Attorney General were present. TCOLE staff members attending were Executive Director Kim Vickers, Director Agency Operations John Helenberg, Legal Counsel John Beauchamp, Finance Director Brian Roth, Laurie Abernathy, Michael Antu, Lynn Beard, Gary Connella, Thurman Felder, Lisa Fontenot, Dennis Graffious, Richard Gutierrez, Nicole Hendrickson, Mike Hobbs, Carey McKinney, Kenneth Merchant, Ken Mobley, Amita Patel, Candice Simon, Jessica Teseny, Janice Washington, and Kaye Wilson. Agenda item #1, Call to order. Presiding Officer Richardson called the meeting to order. Randall County Sheriff’s Office Honor Guard members, Lt. Tommy Bushek, Sgt. Tegan Tupin, Sgt. Raymond Gibbons, Cpl. Marcos Woods, Cpl. Cody Weavers, and Deputy Jay Claxton, presented the colors. Commissioner Hester led the pledge of allegiance and the invocation. Kaye Wilson called the roll and announced that there was a quorum present and that Commissioner Rob Kyker was absent. Agenda item #2, Reading of peace officer/jailer deaths since the December meeting. Deputy Sheriff Adam J. Davis, Bell County Sheriff’s Office, End of Watch Wednesday, December 11, 2013 Deputy Sheriff Adam Davis was killed in a single vehicle crash near Troy while responding to a report of a subject brandishing a gun. His patrol car left the roadway and rolled over several times. He was transported to the hospital, but succumbed to his

Upload: hathu

Post on 02-Jan-2017

216 views

Category:

Documents


1 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Quarterly Meeting Minutes March 27, 2014

Phone: (512) 936-7700 Fax: (512) 936-7714 6330 E Highway 290 STE 200 Austin TX 78723-1035

TEXAS COMMISSION ON

LAW ENFORCEMENT

Kim Vickers Executive Director

Quarterly Meeting Minutes

March 27, 2014

On Thursday, March 27, 2014, at 9:30 a.m. the quarterly meeting of the Texas

Commission on Law Enforcement (TCOLE) was held at the J.J. Pickle Research

Campus, The Commons Learning Center, 10100 Burnet Road, Bldg 137, Austin, Texas.

Commissioners attending were Sheriff Joel W. Richardson, Presiding Officer; Ms. Patt

Scheckel-Hollingsworth, Assistant Presiding Officer; Dr. Johnny E. Lovejoy II,

Secretary; Major Jason Hester; Constable Ron Hood; Mr. James Oakley; Senior Police

Officer Joe Pennington; and Chief Ruben Villescas. Mr. Rob Kyker was absent.

Raymond Winter, Veena Mohan, and William Van Shellenbeck from the Office of the

Attorney General were present. TCOLE staff members attending were Executive

Director Kim Vickers, Director Agency Operations John Helenberg, Legal Counsel John

Beauchamp, Finance Director Brian Roth, Laurie Abernathy, Michael Antu, Lynn Beard,

Gary Connella, Thurman Felder, Lisa Fontenot, Dennis Graffious, Richard Gutierrez,

Nicole Hendrickson, Mike Hobbs, Carey McKinney, Kenneth Merchant, Ken Mobley,

Amita Patel, Candice Simon, Jessica Teseny, Janice Washington, and Kaye Wilson.

Agenda item #1, Call to order.

Presiding Officer Richardson called the meeting to order. Randall County Sheriff’s

Office Honor Guard members, Lt. Tommy Bushek, Sgt. Tegan Tupin, Sgt. Raymond

Gibbons, Cpl. Marcos Woods, Cpl. Cody Weavers, and Deputy Jay Claxton, presented

the colors. Commissioner Hester led the pledge of allegiance and the invocation. Kaye

Wilson called the roll and announced that there was a quorum present and that

Commissioner Rob Kyker was absent.

Agenda item #2, Reading of peace officer/jailer deaths since the December meeting.

Deputy Sheriff Adam J. Davis, Bell County Sheriff’s Office, End of Watch Wednesday,

December 11, 2013

Deputy Sheriff Adam Davis was killed in a single vehicle crash near Troy while

responding to a report of a subject brandishing a gun. His patrol car left the roadway

and rolled over several times. He was transported to the hospital, but succumbed to his

Page 2: Quarterly Meeting Minutes March 27, 2014

TCOLE Minutes

March 27, 2014

Page 2

injuries. Deputy Davis had served with the Bell County Sheriff's Office for six years,

and had previously served with the Troy Police Department and Rogers Police

Department. He is survived by his wife and 10-year-old son.

Sergeant Investigator Fredrich Adam Sowders, Burleson County Sheriff’s Office, End of Watch

Thursday, December 19, 2013

Sergeant Investigator Adam Sowders was shot and killed as he and seven other officers

attempted to serve a warrant at a rural home near Somerville. As the team made entry

into the home, they were met with gunfire, and Sergeant Sowders suffered fatal

gunshot wounds. One suspect was taken into custody at the scene. Sergeant Sowders

had served with the Burleson County Sheriff's Office for seven years and had

previously served with the Somerville Police Department.

Police Office Robert C. Deckard, San Antonio Police Department, End of Watch Friday,

December 20, 2013

Police Officer Bobby Deckard succumbed to a gunshot wound sustained on December 8

while pursuing two robbery suspects in Atascosa County. The suspects, who had

committed 15 robberies in San Antonio over the past several days, were driving a

distinctively painted vehicle that Officer Deckard had spotted. He attempted to stop the

vehicle, but the suspects fled. Officer Deckard was pursuing the suspects when one of

the men in the vehicle opened fire on him. One of the rounds passed through the

cruiser's windshield and struck Officer Deckard, causing his vehicle to crash. He was

transported to San Antonio Military Medical Center where he remained in grave

condition until succumbing to his wounds. Both subjects were arrested in Wilson

County later in the day after attempting to kill a Poth Police Department officer. Officer

Deckard had served with the San Antonio Police Department for seven years. He is

survived by his wife and two children.

Police Officer Marc Uland Kelley, Trinity University Police Department, End of Watch Friday,

March 14, 2014

Police Officer Marc Kelley suffered a fatal heart attack while responding to a fire alarm

call at Verna McLean Hall on the Trinity University campus. While checking the

building, he began to experience trouble breathing and activated his radio's emergency

button. Responding officers initiated CPR and he was transported to the hospital,

where he passed away two days later. Officer Kelley had served with the Trinity

University Police Department for three years. He is survived by his mother, brother,

and niece.

Page 3: Quarterly Meeting Minutes March 27, 2014

TCOLE Minutes

March 27, 2014

Page 3

Agenda item #3, Approval of the minutes of the December 4, 2013, strategic planning

meeting at Austin, Texas.

Commissioner Lovejoy made a motion to approve the meeting minutes of December 4,

2013. Commissioner Hollingsworth seconded the motion. The motion passed

unanimously.

Agenda item #4, Approval of the minutes of the December 5, 2013, quarterly

commission meeting at Austin, Texas.

Commissioner Oakley made a motion to approve the meeting minutes of December 5,

2013. Commissioner Lovejoy seconded the motion. The motion passed unanimously.

Agenda item #6, Receive Executive Director’s Report. Take action, if necessary.

Executive Director Vickers introduced the newest staff member at TCOLE, Amita Patal. Ms. Patel has almost 15 years of state government accounting experience. She has worked in many facets of accounting including auditing, budgeting, encumbrances, accounts receivable, accounts payable, coding, reporting,

reconciliations, and travel reimbursement.

Agenda item #7, Receive reports, items to discuss, follow-up items from previous

meetings. Take action, if necessary.

Discuss and take action on the Resolution – Division of Responsibilities

Presiding Officer Richardson reminded the Commission that the resolution was

discussed at the December 4, strategic planning meeting. Commissioner Lovejoy

made a motion to approve the Resolution – Division of Responsibilities and

Commissioner Oakley seconded the motion. The motion passed unanimously.

Agenda item #8, Discuss and take action on the 2013 Law Enforcement Achievement

Awards.

Executive Director Vickers directed the commission to the confidential list of names of

those being presented for approval to receive the 2013 Law Enforcement Achievement

Awards. Commissioner Lovejoy made a motion to approve the list of names.

Commissioner Hollingsworth seconded the motion. The motion passed unanimously.

Page 4: Quarterly Meeting Minutes March 27, 2014

TCOLE Minutes

March 27, 2014

Page 4

Agenda item #9, Discuss and take action on final orders of amendments to existing

TCOLE rules.

John Beauchamp reviewed each of the rules set for final vote. Discussion followed.

Final Amendment #1 Rule 211.30, Chief Administrator Responsibilities for Class A and B

Waivers.

Mr. Beauchamp stated that this rule will allow for a waiver of a Class A

misdemeanor permitting an agency administrator to apply for a waiver for an

individual with a deferred adjudication or conviction after five (5) years. The

waiver is specific to the agency of the chief administrator. If the licensee is separated

from the agency, the licensee would have to seek another Class A waiver to work at

another agency. Additional public comment on this rule was received late yesterday

and has been provided to the Commission this morning.

Should the rule pass, is the waiver for an agency or a chief administrator, asked

Presiding Officer Richardson. In other words, if the agency administration changes,

is the waiver for the agency? Executive Director Vickers noted that the waiver is for

the agency.

Commissioner Hollingsworth asked how many Class A’s qualify for the waiver to

which Executive Director Vickers said additional Class A’s could affect the approval

of the waiver. Mr. Beauchamp reiterated that the waiver belongs to the sponsoring

agency.

Robert Armbruster, Houston Police Officer’s Union, asked two questions: (a)is an

individual eligible for only one waiver request; and (b)if an individual separates

from employment, may s/he seek another waiver from another agency? Mr.

Beauchamp explained that if an agency seeks a waiver and it is denied, the agency

cannot submit another waiver request for the same individual. If an individual

seeks employment with another agency, the new agency may seek another waiver.

Chief Andrew Walters, Oak Ridge North Police Department, commented on the

success that he has had hiring individuals with a Class A misdemeanor.

Commissioner Villescas asked if the required list of items (Rule 211.30(c)) must be

submitted with each request. Executive Director Vickers confirmed that all items

listed in the rule must be included with the request. Commissioner Villescas then

asked if a waiver request would be considered if any of the items listed in the rule

Page 5: Quarterly Meeting Minutes March 27, 2014

TCOLE Minutes

March 27, 2014

Page 5

were not made available. Executive Director Vickers stated that we need to be able

to look at all aspects of the case and it would be more difficult to consider if any of

the items were not made available. Commissioner Villescas asked if letters of

recommendation were not submitted, would the application be considered to which

Executive Director Vickers noted that an application for a waiver can be submitted

without the letters of recommendation, but it would be more difficult to obtain the

waiver. Mr. Beauchamp noted that the current Class B waiver list of items is the

same as it has always been and no new items have been added. If any submitted

request is missing items, the chief administrator will be notified.

Commissioner Pennington asked if TCOLE will hire someone with a Class A

misdemeanor to be an investigator or field agent. Executive Director Vickers noted

that he is in favor of this rule and would entertain the idea of hiring someone, but

someone would have a difficult time meeting his standards. This rule empowers a

chief administrator. They do not have to consider hiring someone with a Class A.

He restated that this rule change is not a TCOLE initiative, but one that was brought

forward after receiving numerous requests from chief administrators.

At this point the Presiding Officer called for a motion to determine the need to

continue the discussion. Commissioner Lovejoy made a motion to approve final

amendment #1 Rule 211.30, Chief Administrator Responsibilities for Class A and B

Waivers. Commissioner Oakley seconded the motion.

The Presiding Officer called for additional discussion. Commissioner Hollingsworth

noted that the North Texas Chiefs supported the initial proposed rule when the

waiting period was ten years. The final proposed rule calls for a five year waiting

period, and she doesn’t know if these chiefs would support it.

Commissioner Villescas asked if the East Central Police Chiefs Association, who sent

an email dated March 24, had been informed of the requirements to request a

waiver, and had changed their position on the proposed rule. Executive Director

Vickers stated that he called Chief Buske, president of the association, and explained

the filters that are in place. Chief Buske relayed this information to his members, but

didn’t have sufficient input to withdraw the letter.

Commissioner Hester asked Executive Director Vickers to discuss the comments

that were received at the regional workshops. The comments ranged from those

vehemently against the waiver to those that were in favor of it. Commissioner

Page 6: Quarterly Meeting Minutes March 27, 2014

TCOLE Minutes

March 27, 2014

Page 6

Hester noted that the Commission sets minimum standards, and asked Executive

Director Vickers to repeat the safeguards that are in place for this waiver. The filters

include: (1)agency administrator must apply for the waiver, individuals cannot

apply; (2) TCOLE executive director reviews all applications, and filters the

applications such as a felony pled down to a Class A, a family violence conviction,

or an offense of a sexual nature; (3) chief administrator is required to appear before

the Commission; and (4) a waiver is for one agency only.

Commissioner Oakley concurred with Commissioner Hester’s statement that

minimum standards are set by the Commission and he has confidence in the filter

process. He asked if there is a common thread among those opposed to the rule

change. Executive Director Vickers noted that most audiences have been mid- to

small-sized agencies. There doesn’t seem to be a commonality.

Mr. Beauchamp reminded the commission that a Class A is still a permanent

disbarment from licensing. The only change with this rule is that a chief

administrator has the option of bringing a Class A waiver request to the

Commission after five years.

Commissioner Pennington referred the Commission to the Executive Directors

Report, Attachment B, Criminal Misconduct Quarterly Report. He is concerned that

criminal behavior of currently licensed officers is already being addressed, and now

it’s being considered to put a subjective standard in place allowing for a Class A

waiver to solve an employment problem or any other problem.

Commissioner Villescas asked if those licensed with a Class A would be able to

access CJIS, to which Executive Director Vickers said CJIS has been contacted and

they base their restrictions on TCOLE standards.

The Presiding Officer called for a hand vote. The motion passed with

Commissioners Hood, Oakley, Villescas, Lovejoy, and Hester voting in favor and

Commissioners Pennington and Hollingsworth voting against.

Final Amendment #2 Rule 217.2 Minimum Standards for Telecommunicators.

Commissioner Lovejoy made a motion to adopt final amendment #2 Rule 217.2

Minimum Standards for Telecommunicators. Commissioner Hollingsworth

seconded the motion. The motion passed unanimously.

Page 7: Quarterly Meeting Minutes March 27, 2014

TCOLE Minutes

March 27, 2014

Page 7

Final Amendment #3 Current Rule 217.11 (Proposed Rule 218.3) Legislatively Required

Continuing Education for Licensees. Repeal of Rule 217.11 and renumbering it to Rule

218.3, conforming to statutory amendments.

Commissioner Hollingsworth made a motion to adopt Rule 217.11 , Final

Amendment #3, Legislatively Required Continuing Education for Licensees.

Commissioner Lovejoy seconded the motion. The motion passed unanimously.

Final Amendment #4 Rule 219.5 Examinee Requirements

Commissioner Lovejoy made a motion to approve final amendment #4 Rule 219.5

Examinee Requirements. Commissioner Hollingsworth seconded the motion. The

motion passed unanimously.

Agenda item #10, Discuss and take action on the Request for Waiver of TCOLE Rules

217.1 Minimum Standards for Initial Licensure and 217.23 Basic Licensing

Enrollment Standards. (Contingent on the passing of agenda item 9, Rule 211.30,

Chief Administrator Responsibilities for Class A and B Waivers)

Washington County Sheriff’s Office for Mark Anthony Morales

Executive Director Vickers noted that the documents for the Class A waiver were

provided to the Commission at the December 2013 quarterly meeting, and that the

sheriff and Mr. Morales appeared before the Commission. Knowing that all

documents were presented at the December meeting with the sheriff and Mr.

Morales present and addressing the Commission, and not knowing if the rule

change for the Class A would pass, Executive Director Vickers, with the consent of

the Presiding Officer, approved for the sheriff to not return to the March meeting.

Commissioner Hester made a motion to approve the Class A waiver for Mark

Anthony Morales. Commissioner Lovejoy seconded the motion. The Presiding

Officer allowed further discussion.

Commissioner Villescas asked if letters of recommendation from those working

within the agency are acceptable. Executive Director Vickers confirmed that these

letters would be accepted. The Commissioner mentioned that the victim sited two

episodes and asked if the other episode, either dismissed or dovetailed into the first

episode, was taken into consideration. Executive Director Vickers confirmed that all

was taken into consideration. Commissioner Pennington asked if the victim in this

case was notified of the rule change. Executive Director Vickers assumes so or the

letter requesting the waiver would not have been submitted.

Page 8: Quarterly Meeting Minutes March 27, 2014

TCOLE Minutes

March 27, 2014

Page 8

The Presiding Officer called for a vote on the motion. The motion passed with

Commissioners Hood, Oakley, Lovejoy, and Hester voting in favor, and

Commissioners Pennington, Villescas, and Hollingsworth voting against.

Agenda item #11, Discuss and take action on the fee schedule.

John Beauchamp reviewed the few changes to the fee schedule. Major changes to the

schedule include: Proprietary training contract is $2500 for a 3 year contract; School

Marshal license will be $50; Master telecommunicator certificate has been added with a

fee of $35; Crime Prevention Specialist and Court Security Specialist proficiency

certificates are $35 each; and Renewal application to be an exam site is $500 for a 4 year

contract.

Kathleen Bannon asked to address the Commission. Ms. Bannon noted that she is one

of 17 for-profit training providers. She believes it is unfair to have an across the board

fee for the for-profit training providers and asked for a sliding fee based on percentage

earned from training. Commissioner Oakley asked for an explanation to the change in

the fee for the for-profit providers. Executive Director Vickers noted that the fee for the

for-profit providers has been the same as the non-proprietary providers. He has

received comments across the state asking why for-profit providers are at the same rate

as the not-for-profit. Currently there seems to be an influx of for-profit vendors.

Commissioner Oakley asked what the change in fee was for the for-profit training

providers. Executive Director Vickers explained that the fee was the same as the not for

profit providers, $1,000 for a 5 year contract. There are many non-proprietary contract

providers that struggle to provide a good program. For many years, most of training

providers in Texas were non-profit. There seems to be an inequity of charging the same

amount to a non-profit as a for-profit. Commissioner Oakley asked why TCOLE is

charging a fee for the school marshals to which Executive Director Vickers explained

that this is statutory. Consideration was given to the amount that would be charged to

peace officers, jailers, and telecommunicators should a licensing fee be required in the

future. Commissioner Oakley asked if the fees have remained the same, increased, or

reduced. Executive Director Vickers stated that the fees have remained the same for

quite some time. Additional questions about a possible sliding scale were asked.

Executive Director Vickers noted that he is willing to look for a fee method that will be

equitable. Commissioner Lovejoy suggested the fee schedule be passed subject to the

Executive Director returning to the Commission with a particular grant program that

may help reduce the fee. Presiding Officer Pennington asked if each for-profit could be

Page 9: Quarterly Meeting Minutes March 27, 2014

TCOLE Minutes

March 27, 2014

Page 9

billed based on the amount of work that they create for staff. The Presiding Officer

asked if there is a reason to rush to approve the fee schedule. Executive Director

Vickers said that the Master Telecommunicator certificate is a new certificate that needs

to be considered today.

Commissioner Lovejoy made a motion to pass the entire fee schedule with the

exception of the line item for training contractor proprietary fee. Commissioner Oakley

seconded the motion. The motion passed unanimously.

Agenda item #12, Discuss and take action on proceedings for revocation, suspension,

and other disciplinary actions.

Agreed Suspension Orders Quintanilla, Hector A. 11-04-0633LS Mission Police Department

Mr. Beauchamp asked that this item be pulled from consideration.

Raymond Winter with the Attorney General’s office addressed the Commission.

Proposal for Decision Orders Braziel, Christopher A. 12-09-0020LS McLennan County Sheriff’s Office

Mr. Winter explained that Mr. Braziel has a Class B misdemeanor DWI and failed to

appear at the State Office of Administrative Hearing (SOAH) proceedings. The

Administrative Law Judge (ALD) issued a default proposal of decision and

recommended that the license be suspended for ten (10) years. The Executive Director

agrees with the ten (10) year suspension.

Commissioner Hollingsworth made a motion that the Commission accept and adopt

the recommendations of the Executive Director to enter a final agreed suspension order

for Christopher A. Braziel. Commissioner Hester seconded the motion. The motion

passed unanimously.

Bryant, Julius R. 11-02-0328LS Dallas City Marshall’s Office

Mr. Bryant was convicted of a Class B misdemeanor DWI. He failed to appear at the

requested SOAH hearing. The ALJ dismissed the case from the SOAH docket and

remanded it to TCOLE for entry of a default order. The Executive Director asks that the

Page 10: Quarterly Meeting Minutes March 27, 2014

TCOLE Minutes

March 27, 2014

Page 10

Commissioners enter the default order suspending Mr. Bryant’s license for a period of

ten (10) years.

Commissioner Hollingsworth made a motion to accept and adopt the recommendation

of the Executive Director to enter a final default suspension order for Julius R. Bryant.

Commissioner Lovejoy seconded the motion. Presiding Officer Richardson clarified

that this would be for a period of ten (10) years.

Commissioner Oakley asked Mr. Winter to explain why one Administrative Law Judge

would recommend a suspension of a license and another would dismiss the case and

remand it back to TCOLE. Mr. Winter noted that there have been recent changes to the

SOAH procedural rules which allow a Judge three ways to handle a case, but the

outcome will be the same. If the respondent fails to appear, there will be a default.

Presiding Officer Richardson called for a vote. The motion passed unanimously.

Jackson, Fred 09-03-0365LS Dallas County Constable Pct. 5

Mr. Jackson had two DWI convictions within a one year time frame. The

Administrative Law Judge recommended a five (5) year suspension with two (2) years

hard suspension and the remaining three (3) years probated. The Executive Director

filed exceptions and recommends a ten (10) year suspension with eight (8) years hard

suspension and the remaining two (2) years probated. Commissioner Oakley asked if

an individual is charged with a second DWI, would this be a Class A. Mr. Beauchamp

noted that a second DWI should be a Class A, but for unknown reasons, this one was a

Class B.

Commissioner Hollingsworth made a motion to accept and adopt the recommendations

of the Executive Director and decline to adopt the recommendations of the ALJ and

impose a ten (10) year suspension to Fred Jackson, eight (8) years active suspension and

two (2) years probated. Commissioner Lovejoy seconded the motion.

Commissioner Hester stated that he was in total disagreement with the findings of the

ALJ and wanted to make it clear for the record that there were several findings that he

did not agree with.

The Presiding Officer called for a vote. The motion passed unanimously.

Page 11: Quarterly Meeting Minutes March 27, 2014

TCOLE Minutes

March 27, 2014

Page 11

Sanchez, Jr., Joe F. 13-10-0149LS Port Lavaca Police Department

Mr. Sanchez was placed on deferred adjudication for Class A assault/family violence.

He failed to appear at his SOAH hearing. The ALJ issued a default order for a ten (10)

year suspension of the license. The Executive Director concurs with the ALJ.

Commissioner Hollingsworth made a motion to accept and adopt the recommendation

of the Executive Director to enter a default suspension order for Joe F. Sanchez, Jr. for

ten (10) years. Commissioner Lovejoy seconded the motion. The motion passed

unanimously.

Steen, James F. 11-03-0500LS Dallas Police Department

Mr. Steen received a Class B misdemeanor for DWI. He requested a SOAH hearing.

The Administrative Law Judge recommended a two (2) year suspension with one (1)

year hard suspension and one (1) year probated. The Executive Director filed

exceptions and recommends a ten (10) year suspension with 2 years hard suspension

and eight (8) years probated. Certain mitigating factors militated against a hard ten (10)

year suspension, but he believed the ALJ’s recommendation was inadequate.

Commissioner Hollingsworth made a motion to accept and adopt the recommendation

of the Executive Director’s exception to the ALJ’s decision and enter a recommendation

that James F. Steen receive a ten (10) year suspension with two (2) years hard

suspension and eight (8) years probated. Commissioner Lovejoy seconded the motion.

The motion passed unanimously.

For Information Only Mr. Winter said the remaining items require no action from the Commission.

Statutory Revocations Alcocer, Ismael 14-11-2179LR Kemah Police Department

Evans, Derick D. 11-12-0203LR Dallas County Constable Pct. 1

Jones, Jr., Jimmie W. 11-05-0946LR Lewisville Police Department

Nutt, Jr., Richard B. 11-12-0240LR Harris County Sheriff’s Office

Taylor, Jr., Sterling 14-11-2180LR Brazos County Constable Pct. 4

Trevino, Jonathan C. 14-11-2181LR Hidalgo County Sheriff’s Office

Valencia, Derrick 14-11-2182LR Wallis Police Department

Page 12: Quarterly Meeting Minutes March 27, 2014

TCOLE Minutes

March 27, 2014

Page 12

Statutory Suspensions Bowles, Edward J. 13-04-0634LS Gonzales Police Department

Jordan, Jerry L. 12-10-0080LS Montgomery County District Attorney’s

Office

Reyna, Michael A. 12-07-1071LS Willacy County Sheriff’s Office

Permanent Surrenders Allen, Jerry D. Collingsworth County Sheriff’s Office

Bracey, Tramel R. Killeen Police Department

De La Torre, Dez A. Baylor Healthcare System Police

Department

Dumas, Miles S. Houston Police Department

Edwards, Timothy R. Mexia Independent School District

Police Department

Ellis, David W. Deaf Smith County Sheriff’s Office

Espinoza, Edgardo N. Harris County Sheriff’s Office

Forgue, Tommy B. Harris County Constable Pct. 5

Fuentes, Jason C. Bexar County Sheriff’s Office

Gutierrez, Jr., Steven Bexar County Sheriff’s Office

Harris, Richard J. Bexar County Sheriff’s Office

Hashaway, Roderick L. Winnsboro Police Department

Jefferson, William C. Buffalo Police Department

Johnson, Malinda A. Harris County Constable Pct. 6

Kelley, Jennifer A. Anderson County Sheriff’s Office

Lewis, Tony E. Liberty County Sheriff’s Office

Lovel, Justin B. Sweeny Independent School District

Police Department

Martinez, Maria N. Dallas County Sheriff’s Office

Mendoza, Eric Live Oak County Sheriff’s Office

Middaugh, Kathleen Hutchinson County Sheriff’s Office

Moody, John A. Texas Attorney General’s Office

Quarles, Jr., Johnny F. Dallas County Sheriff’s Office

Sanchez, Lorenzo J. Sundown Police Department

Wells, Carol F. Milam County Constable Pct. 3

Reprimands for Failing to Complete Legislatively Required Continuing Education Abad, Felipe J. 14-10-1101 Nueces County Sheriff's Office

Page 13: Quarterly Meeting Minutes March 27, 2014

TCOLE Minutes

March 27, 2014

Page 13

Abernathy, Brent A. 14-10-1103 Chambers County Sheriff's Office

Agee, Anthony D. 14-10-0107 Wortham Police Department

Aguilera, Martin G. 14-10-0108 Indian Lake Police Department

Akin, Norris L. 14-10-0109 Wise County Sheriff's Office

Alaniz, Andres T. 14-10-1106 Travis County Sheriff's Office

Alexander, Kenneth 14-10-0114 Wilbarger County Sheriff's Office

Allyn, Bruce R. 14-10-1109 Travis County Sheriff's Office

Almeida, Anthony J. 14-10-0118 El Paso County Sheriff's Office

Almendarez, Rudy 14-10-1112 Montgomery County Sheriff's Office

Alvarez, Armando 14-10-1114 El Paso County Sheriff's Office

Amos, Jerry L. 14-10-1115 Polk County Sheriff's Office

Anderson, Jeffery 14-10-1121 Travis County Sheriff's Office

Anderson, Jr., James G. 14-10-1117 Travis County Sheriff's Office

Arias, Antonio R. 14-10-1129 El Paso County Sheriff's Office

Ariola, Kenneth W. 14-10-1130 Montgomery County Sheriff's Office

Ayala, Janie 14-10-0139 Edinburg Consolidated Independent

School District Police Department

Aycock, Andrew D. 14-10-0140 Hollywood Park Department of Public

Safety

Azwell, Christopher H. 14-10-1137 Montgomery County Sheriff's Office

Barrera, David 14-10-1145 Bexar County Sheriff's Office

Barrera, James E. 14-10-1148 Stephens County Sheriff's Office

Bautista, Samuel 14-10-1153 San Juan Police Department

Beard, Sherry R. 14-10-0161 McLennan County Sheriff's Office

Beltran, Daniel 14-10-1159 El Paso County Sheriff's Office

Benoy, Steven J. 14-10-1162 Bexar County Sheriff's Office

Best IV, Andrew L. 14-10-0172 La Marque Police Department

Blackmon, Rodney K. 14-10-1169 Travis County Sheriff's Office

Blair, Sr., Robert 14-10-1170 Grayson County Sheriff's Office

Blanco, Juan A. 14-10-1172 Kinney County Sheriff's Office

Boring, Dale A. 14-10-1173 Travis County Sheriff's Office

Bouldin, Forrest M. 14-10-1175 Travis County Sheriff's Office

Bozell, Michael R. 14-10-1177 Travis County Sheriff's Office

Bradshaw, Jacob N. 14-10-0185 Wilson County Sheriff's Office

Broadwater, James T. 14-10-0186 Brenham Police Department

Brown, Carlton B. 14-10-1185 Travis County Sheriff's Office

Brown, Rex E. 14-10-0191 Frankston Police Department

Page 14: Quarterly Meeting Minutes March 27, 2014

TCOLE Minutes

March 27, 2014

Page 14

Bruhn, Bobbie C. 14-10-0193 Randall County District Attorney's

Office

Bukvic, Marko 14-10-0197 Travis County Sheriff's Office

Bustamante, Gabriel J. 14-10-1193 El Paso County Sheriff's Office

Byrum, Jeremy M. 14-10-0211 Tyler County Sheriff's Office

Cameron, Allan R. 14-10-0213 Gregg County Sheriff's Office

Cantu, Edward L. 14-10-1205 Cameron County Sheriff's Office

Cardenas, David A. 14-10-0223 United Independent School District

Police Department

Carraza II, Jose G. 14-10-0229 Edinburg Consolidated Independent

School District Police Department

Castaneda, Jennifer J. 14-10-0241 Jacinto City Police Department

Castillo, Federico M. 14-10-1221 El Paso County Sheriff's Office

Castro, Juan A. 14-10-1222 El Paso County Sheriff's Office

Cave, Michael M. 14-10-0244 Crandall Police Department

Cerda, Jeanette M. 14-10-1225 Karnes County Correctional Center

Chapman, Jeremy L. 14-10-0248 San Juan Police Department

Chavez, Francisco X. 14-10-1233 El Paso County Sheriff's Office

Chavez III, Rafael 14-10-1231 El Paso County Sheriff's Office

Christensen, Teresa I. 14-10-1238 Bexar County Sheriff's Office

Cogdill, Ronnie D. 14-10-0263 Hansford County Sheriff's Office

Cordero, Victor R. 14-10-1251 El Paso County Sheriff's Office

Cordova, Christopher 14-10-1252 Travis County Sheriff's Office

Cordova, Mauricio V. 14-10-0273 Brewster County Sheriff's Office

Correa, Mario A. 14-10-1253 El Paso County Sheriff's Office

Cortez, Enrique 14-10-1254 El Paso County Sheriff's Office

Cotton, Suzanne M. 14-10-0277 Coldspring-Oakhurst Consolidated

Independent School District Police

Department

Courson, Sr., Mark A. 14-10-0278 Denton Police Department

Cruz, Eddie 14-10-0285 Kenedy County Sheriff's Office

Cundiff, Owen M. 14-10-0286 Coryell County Sheriff's Office

Dalley, Stanley E. 14-10-1266 Travis County Sheriff's Office

Davis, Ronald L. 14-11-1969 Harris County Constable Pct. 1

Davis, Jr., Lawrence L. 14-10-0293 Austin Police Department

De Anda, A Rueben 14-10-0300 Ector County Sheriff's Office

Dloughy III, Felix 14-10-1282 Harris County Sheriff's Office

Dobbins, Freddy L. 14-10-0315 Travis County Sheriff's Office

Page 15: Quarterly Meeting Minutes March 27, 2014

TCOLE Minutes

March 27, 2014

Page 15

Dominguez, David 14-10-1284 El Paso County Sheriff's Office

Edgington, Rodney 14-10-1295 Travis County Sheriff's Office

Edwards, Lakeisha C. 14-10-0328 Fort Bend County Sheriff's Office

Escandon, Lorenzo P. 14-10-1302 El Paso County Sheriff's Office

Faulkner, Jr., Mark M. 14-10-0341 Seven Points Police Department

Favela, Jr., Juan M. 14-10-1308 El Paso County Sheriff's Office

Flanagan, James W. 14-10-0347 Dallas/Fort Worth Airport Department

of Public Safety

Flores, Inocencio C. 14-10-1317 Travis County Sheriff's Office

Forson, Walter W. 14-10-0356 Limestone County Sheriff's Office

Franklin, Alvin E. 14-10-1327 Polk County Sheriff's Office

Frausto, Ruben 14-10-1329 El Paso County Sheriff's Office

Gailey, Patrick J. 14-10-1336 El Paso County Sheriff's Office

Garcia, Angel F. 14-11-1992 Harris County Constable Pct. 7

Garcia, Joel C. 14-10-0373 Reeves County Sheriff's Office

Garcia, Ralph L. 14-10-0375 Galveston County Sheriff's Office

Garcia, Veronica 14-10-1351 El Paso County Sheriff's Office

Garza, Robert 14-10-0386 Runnels County Sheriff's Office

Gayhardt, David A. 14-10-0389 Fritch Police Department

Gibson, Larry D. 14-10-0393 Hood County Sheriff's Office

Gisler, Craig A. 14-10-1361 Bee County Sheriff's Office

Givens, Jeffrey 14-10-1362 Travis County Sheriff's Office

Glendening, Rodney R. 14-10-0402 Fort Bend County Sheriff's Office

Goad, Mark A. 14-10-1363 Harris County Sheriff's Office

Goerner, John H. 14-10-1364 Travis County Sheriff's Office

Gomez, Adam D. 14-10-0404 San Juan Police Department

Gonzales, Jr., James O. 14-10-1367 Travis County Sheriff's Office

Gonzales, Michael 14-10-1368 El Paso County Sheriff's Office

Gonzalez, Federico 14-10-1373 Nueces County Sheriff's Office

Gonzalez, Juan J. 14-10-0416 Kleberg County Sheriff's Office

Gonzalez, Rosbel 14-10-0418 La Grulla Police Department

Gray, Christopher L. 14-10-1378 Travis County Sheriff's Office

Greer, John H. 14-10-0428 El Paso County Sheriff's Office

Greer, John H. 14-10-1382 El Paso County Sheriff's Office

Griever, Jr., Glenn R. 14-10-1383 Parker County Sheriff's Office

Guerrero, Natividad 14-10-1388 El Paso County Sheriff's Office

Gutierrez, Marc G. 14-10-0438 Travis County Sheriff's Office

Gutierrez, Jr., Eduardo 14-10-1392 El Paso County Sheriff's Office

Page 16: Quarterly Meeting Minutes March 27, 2014

TCOLE Minutes

March 27, 2014

Page 16

Gurley, Christopher B. 14-10-1390 Franklin County Sheriff's Office

Gurtler, Alan L. 14-10-1391 El Paso County Sheriff's Office

Guzman, Jose L. 14-10-1395 El Paso County Sheriff's Office

Haack, Stephen W. 14-10-1396 El Paso County Sheriff's Office

Hall, Jason A. 14-10-1399 Travis County Sheriff's Office

Hamilton, Bernard J. 14-10-0444 Travis County Sheriff's Office

Hammack, James K. 14-10-0448 Travis County Sheriff's Office

Hanner, Jr., Charles G. 14-10-0450 Quitman Police Department

Hardeman, Timothy G. 14-10-0451 Fort Worth Fire Department

Hargrove, David E. 14-10-1402 El Paso County Sheriff's Office

Haro, William J. 14-10-1404 Travis County Sheriff's Office

Harper, William C. 14-10-0455 Seymour Police Department

Harpool, M'Lisa L. 14-10-0456 Travis County Sheriff's Office

Harris, Justin R. 14-10-1408 Fort Bend County Sheriff's Office

Hart, Darryl L. 14-10-0461 Gonzales County Sheriff's Office

Hart, Samuel R. 14-10-1412 Travis County Sheriff's Office

Hays, Samuel D. 14-10-0464 Grayson County College Police

Department

Hendricks III, Arthur D. 14-10-1422 Bosque County Sheriff's Office

Hernandez, George 14-10-0469 Travis County Sheriff's Office

Hernandez, Jose G. 14-10-1430 Cameron County Sheriff's Office

Hernandez, Jose L. 14-10-1431 El Paso County Sheriff's Office

Hernandez, Julio A. 14-10-1432 Travis County Sheriff's Office

Hernandez III, Jose 14-10-1425 Fort Bend County Sheriff's Office

Hill, Jr., Tommy L. 14-10-0476 Reagan County Sheriff's Office

Hodge, Arika N. 14-10-0479 Meadows Place Police Department

Hollaway, Barbara J. 14-10-1439 Bell County Sheriff's Office

Holt, Mark W. 14-10-0486 Walker County Sheriff's Office

Horst, Michael P. 14-10-1442 Travis County Sheriff's Office

Horstman, Robert E. 14-10-1443 El Paso County Sheriff's Office

Houck, Calvin G. 14-10-0491 Bloomburg Police Department

Howland, Jr., James 14-11-2024 Rockwall County Constable Pct. 3

Hricko, Matthew R. 14-10-1447 Fort Bend County Sheriff's Office

Huber, Yvonne A. 14-10-1448 Lipscomb County Sheriff's Office

Hughes, Jacob E. 14-10-0497 Decatur Police Department

Hurlburt, Jr., Darrel F. 14-10-1451 Coryell County Sheriff's Office

Iacono, Nathan J. 14-10-1454 Travis County Sheriff's Office

Isbell, Michael W. 14-10-0505 Brown County Sheriff's Office

Page 17: Quarterly Meeting Minutes March 27, 2014

TCOLE Minutes

March 27, 2014

Page 17

Jackson, Joseph C. 14-10-0509 Houston Independent School District

Police Department

James, Scott D. 14-10-1457 Travis County Sheriff's Office

James, Vernon L. 14-10-0511 Harris County Sheriff's Office

Jaramillo, Raymond C. 14-10-0512 Menard County Sheriff's Office

Jewert, Jason M. 14-10-1464 Travis County Sheriff's Office

Jimenez, Javier A. 14-10-1466 El Paso County Sheriff's Office

Johnson, Frank N. 14-10-1468 Taylor County Sheriff's Office

Johnson, George G. 14-10-1470 El Paso County Sheriff's Office

Johnson, Kevin D. 14-10-1472 Harrison County Sheriff's Office

Jones, Charles L. 14-10-1474 Travis County Sheriff's Office

Jones, Clayton F. 14-10-0519 Travis County Sheriff's Office

Jones, Jackson 14-10-1475 Travis County Sheriff's Office

Jones, Mark D. 14-10-1476 Travis County Sheriff's Office

Jones, Timothy E. 14-10-1478 Johnson County Sheriff's Office

Jurgajtis, Randall C. 14-10-1481 Karnes County Correctional Center

Kelly, Curtis R. 14-10-1483 Travis County Sheriff's Office

Kelly, Patrick D. 14-10-1484 Travis County Sheriff's Office

Kelley II, Robert C. 14-10-0527 Angelina County Sheriff's Office

Kim, Gerald S. 14-10-1487 Travis County Sheriff's Office

King, Terry G. 14-10-0538 Ward County Sheriff's Office

Kinikin, Preston 14-11-2041 Nueces County Constable Pct. 4

Kinnard, Byron Keith 14-10-1491 Travis County Sheriff's Office

Kirkpatrick, Neil D. 14-10-0541 Fort Bend County Sheriff's Office

Kitchens, James L. 14-10-0542 Coryell County Sheriff's Office

Klaerner, Bradley W. 14-10-1494 Travis County Sheriff's Office

Kluge, Irvin W. 14-11-2042 Liberty County Constable Pct. 1

Knighten, Randolph 14-10-1496 Dallas County Sheriff's Office

Kobert, John E. 14-10-0544 Wilson County Sheriff's Office

Kobryn, Anthony F. 14-10-1497 Bexar County Sheriff's Office

Kolbe, Timothy P. 14-10-0547 Comal County Sheriff's Office

Koschak, Brian L. 14-10-0549 Quitman Police Department

Kovalcik, Jason F. 14-10-1499 Travis County Sheriff's Office

Kraemer, Kurt R. 14-10-0550 Travis County Sheriff's Office

Krenek, Jason D. 14-10-1501 Travis County Sheriff's Office

Krieger, Daniel A. 14-10-0552 Jamaica Beach Police Department

Kry, Makara M. 14-10-1502 Travis County Sheriff's Office

LaCroix, David J. 14-10-0557 Nolanville Police Department

Page 18: Quarterly Meeting Minutes March 27, 2014

TCOLE Minutes

March 27, 2014

Page 18

Laine, Laura C. 14-10-0558 Parker County Sheriff's Office

Lane, Ricky P. 14-10-1504 Travis County Sheriff's Office

Lawless, Laurette H. 14-10-1510 Travis County Sheriff's Office

Lawrence, Charles R. 14-10-1511 Angelina County Sheriff's Office

Lawson, William C. 14-10-0565 McLennan Community College Police

Department

Lbsraouri, Deborah L. 14-10-1514 Swisher County Sheriff's Office

Leal, Diana M. 14-10-0566 Bexar County Sheriff's Office

Leal, Salvador J. 14-10-0568 Duval County Sheriff's Office

Leanhart, Zulema P. 14-10-1517 Nueces County Sheriff's Office

Leatherwood, Adrian S. 14-10-0570 Hartley County Sheriff's Office

LeBlanc, Jr., Alred B. 14-10-1518 Travis County Sheriff's Office

Lee, Keith J. 14-10-0572 Aubrey Police Department

Lee, Jr., Edward J. 14-10-1520 Cameron County Sheriff's Office

Levy, John M. 14-10-1524 El Paso County Sheriff's Office

Lewis, Jimmy L. 14-10-0577 Travis County Sheriff's Office

Licon, Alberto 14-10-1528 El Paso County Sheriff's Office

Liguez, Jesse J. 14-10-1530 Travis County Sheriff's Office

Lockhart, John C. 14-10-0584 Donley County Sheriff's Office

Long, Darren S. 14-10-1533 Travis County Sheriff's Office

Long, Jr., Ronald D. 14-10-0589 Real County Sheriff's Office

Lopez, Angel S. 14-10-1540 El Paso County Sheriff's Office

Lopez, Edward 14-10-1541 Harris County Sheriff's Office

Lopez, Osvaldo 14-10-0594 Dimmit County Sheriff's Office

Lopez, Raymond T. 14-10-0595 Bexar County Sheriff's Office

Lopez, Jr., Ramon P. 14-10-1539 Travis County Sheriff's Office

Loren, John V. 14-10-0596 Hall County Sheriff's Office

Lowe, Jr., Henry C. 14-10-1545 Montgomery County Sheriff's Office

Lowers, Deborah B. 14-10-1546 Polk County Sheriff's Office

Lugo III, Enrique 14-10-1548 El Paso County Sheriff's Office

Maldonado II, Henry 14-10-1553 Travis County Sheriff's Office

Manley, Stephen C. 14-10-1555 Travis County Sheriff's Office

Mardis, Jr., Robert B. 14-10-0609 Travis County Sheriff's Office

Marek, Chad C. 14-10-1556 Milam County Sheriff's Office

Marquez, Mario 14-10-1560 El Paso County Sheriff's Office

Martinez, Armin 14-10-0623 Raymondville Police Department

Martinez, David G. 14-10-0625 Gregory Police Department

Martinez, Guillermo T. 14-10-1566 Travis County Sheriff's Office

Page 19: Quarterly Meeting Minutes March 27, 2014

TCOLE Minutes

March 27, 2014

Page 19

Martinez, Oscar 14-10-1568 El Paso County Sheriff's Office

Martinez, Pablo 14-10-1569 El Paso County Sheriff's Office

Martinez, Jr., Pete 14-10-0619 Edcouch Police Department

Martinez, Jr., Raul J. 14-10-1563 Dimmit County Sheriff's Office

Martinez, Rosanne 14-10-0630 Midland County Sheriff's Office

Mattingly, William G. 14-10-0632 Bartonville Police Department

McCain, William R. 14-10-0635 Gregg County Sheriff's Office

McCauley, Anthony R. 14-10-1572 Travis County Sheriff's Office

McFarlin, Paula 14-10-0643 Dallas County Sheriff's Office

McLain, Tuck M. 14-10-0648 Grimes County District Attorney's

Office

McGaha, Cody B. 14-10-0644 King County Sheriff's Office

McGill, Darron W. 14-10-1576 Smith County Sheriff's Office

McMullin, William D. 14-10-0649 Travis County Sheriff's Office

McNatt, Rodney S. 14-10-0650 Chambers County Sheriff's Office

McNulty, Sullivan K. 14-10-0651 Dallas/Fort Worth Airport Department

of Public Safety

Melero, Jose R. 14-10-1587 El Paso County Sheriff's Office

Mendoza, Robert G. 14-10-0657 Dimmit County Sheriff's Office

Mettlen, Kyle D. 14-10-0660 Angelina County Sheriff's Office

Meyer, Christopher J. 14-10-1592 Travis County Sheriff's Office

Michael, William D. 14-10-1593 Sabine County Sheriff's Office

Michaud, Douglas J. 14-10-1594 Travis County Sheriff's Office

Miller, Jr., Bryce V. 14-10-1597 Travis County Sheriff's Office

Mitchell, Eugene 14-10-0667 Travis County Sheriff's Office

Mitchell, Kenneth D. 14-10-0668 Kaufman Police Department

Mitchell, Robert R. 14-10-1603 Rockwall County Sheriff's Office

Molina, Jacob 14-10-0670 Kleberg County Sheriff's Office

Molleda, Christopher 14-10-1605 Bexar County Sheriff's Office

Montgomery, Ricky L. 14-10-1606 Parker County Sheriff's Office

Moore, Robert L. 14-10-1609 Parker County Sheriff's Office

Moore, Steven D. 14-10-1610 Travis County Sheriff's Office

Moore, Jr., Daniel E. 14-10-0673 Dickens County Sheriff's Office

Morgan, Ronald W. 14-10-0677 Coryell County Sheriff's Office

Morris, Phillip W. 14-10-0684 Jamaica Beach Police Department

Morris, Timothy P. 14-10-0685 Upshur County Sheriff's Office

Morton, Michael L. 14-10-1618 Travis County Sheriff's Office

Mouton, Aaron R. 14-10-0689 Bridge City Police Department

Page 20: Quarterly Meeting Minutes March 27, 2014

TCOLE Minutes

March 27, 2014

Page 20

Mulryan, John A. 14-10-1621 Chambers County Sheriff's Office

Nelson, James B. 14-10-0694 Bowie County Sheriff's Office

Nelson, Kelly M. 14-10-0695 Little Elm Fire Department

Northington, Steven W. 14-10-0703 Sherman Police Department

Pacatte, Robert L. 14-10-0722 Howard Payne University Department

of Public Safety

Pace, Patrick S. 14-10-0723 Jonestown Police Department

Palermo, James 14-10-0726 San Marcos Police Department

Pantoja, Marc 14-10-0728 Travis County Sheriff's Office

Pantoja, Marc 14-10-1652 Travis County Sheriff's Office

Parker, David G. 14-10-0729 Dallas Baptist University Police

Department

Pathak, Rebecca D. 14-10-1656 Johnson County Sheriff's Office

Peel, James 14-10-0733 Travis County Sheriff's Office

Penfold, Larry A. 14-10-0739 Hutchinson County Sheriff's Office

Peoples IV, Albert 14-10-0741 Itasca Police Department

Perales, Benjamin 14-10-1663 El Paso County Sheriff's Office

Perez, Andrew P. 14-10-1666 Williamson County Sheriff's Office

Perkins, Brian D. 14-10-0744 Lubbock County Sheriff's Office

Perkins, Lloyd G. 14-10-0745 Haltom City Police Department

Perron, Shawn J. 14-10-0746 Port Arthur Police Department

Peterson, Daniel J. 14-10-1670 Taylor County Sheriff's Office

Philen, Steve T. 14-10-0750 Harker Heights Fire Department

Pickerill, Kevin S. 14-10-1672 Montgomery County Sheriff's Office

Pitts, Gregory S. 14-10-0756 Coryell County Sheriff's Office

Poppenhusen, Nicole E. 14-10-0759 Harris County Sheriff's Office

Pothen, P. Paul 14-10-0761 Midlothian Police Department

Pratt, Donald R. 14-10-0765 Taylor County District Attorney's Office

Provencio, Tony 14-10-1681 El Paso County Sheriff's Office

Quintanilla, Alejandro 14-10-0772 Bexar County Sheriff's Office

Radcliff, Bryan K. 14-10-0773 Cherokee County Sheriff's Office

Ramos, Fernando 14-10-1687 Webb County Sheriff's Office

Ray, Alicia D. 14-10-1692 Dallas County Sheriff's Office

Reddick, Nancy L. 14-10-0783 Aransas County Sheriff's Office

Reeves, Brenda K. 14-10-0784 Wood County Sheriff's Office

Resendez, Juan R. 14-10-0789 Alice Police Department

Reyna, Leonel E. 14-10-0795 Palmview Police Department

Reynolds, Rick R. 14-10-0796 Travis County Sheriff's Office

Page 21: Quarterly Meeting Minutes March 27, 2014

TCOLE Minutes

March 27, 2014

Page 21

Riebschlager, Kris M. 14-10-0801 Murphy Police Department

Rodriguez, Gabriel G. 14-10-0822 Crane County Sheriff's Office

Rodriguez, John H. 14-10-1727 El Paso County Sheriff's Office

Rodriguez Jr., Mario A. 14-10-0819 Socorro Police Department

Rodriguez, Rube F. 14-10-0826 38th Judicial District Attorney's Office

Rodriguez, Ruben 14-10-0827 Kleberg County Sheriff's Office

Roe, Lewis R. 14-10-1730 El Paso County Sheriff's Office

Rollins, Anthony M. 14-10-1732 El Paso County Sheriff's Office

Rosales, Abel 14-10-0834 Yoakum Police Department

Rucks, Kelvin 14-10-0839 Travis County Sheriff's Office

Ruiz, Joseph J. 14-10-1738 Travis County Sheriff's Office

Runner, Suzanne P. 14-10-0842 Fulshear Police Department

Ryan, Meghan N. 14-10-0846 Bexar County Sheriff's Office

Saldivar Sr., Mario 14-10-0848 Humble Independent School District

Police Department

Sampson, Anthony M. 14-10-0854 Travis County Sheriff's Office

Sampson, Anthony M. 14-10-1748 Travis County Sheriff's Office

Sanchez, Adan 14-10-0856 Weslaco Police Department

Sanchez, Eddie R. 14-10-0857 Travis County Sheriff's Office

Sanchez, Michael R. 14-10-0858 Combes Police Department

Sandoval, Sr., Juan M. 14-10-0861 Jim Hogg County Independent School

District Police Department

Schustereit, Brandon W. 14-10-0871 Shenandoah Police Department

Searle, Jr., Robert M. 14-10-0872 Washington County Sheriff's Office

Serrato, Israel 14-10-1760 Cameron County Sheriff's Office

Shaw, Neal A. 14-10-0880 Seagraves Police Department

Shedd, Andrew J. 14-10-0881 Josephine Police Department

Sherill, James A. 14-10-0884 University Park Police Department

Simms, Morgan B. 14-10-0891 Fort Worth Fire Department

Smith, Brandon A. 14-10-0901 Mexia Police Department

Smith, Mark D. 14-10-0904 Falls County Sheriff's Office

Smith, Michael R. 14-10-0905 Collin County Fire Marshal's Office

Spears, Robert M. 14-10-0913 Desoto Police Department

Stallings, Frank D. 14-10-1784 Taylor County Sheriff's Office

Stephenson, John M. 14-10-0928 Montgomery County Sheriff's Office

Tabbutt, Randolph M. 14-10-1793 El Paso County Sheriff's Office

Taub, Marc S. 14-10-1796 Travis County Sheriff's Office

Taylor, Brandi M. 14-10-0943 Lamar County District Attorney's Office

Page 22: Quarterly Meeting Minutes March 27, 2014

TCOLE Minutes

March 27, 2014

Page 22

Taylor, Jr., Willie J. 14-10-1797 Travis County Sheriff's Office

Terrazas, Melissa 14-10-1803 Bexar County Sheriff's Office

Thompson, Roy D. 14-10-0957 Travis County Sheriff's Office

Thomson, Ellen M. 14-10-1806 El Paso County Sheriff's Office

Thornton, Joe F. 14-10-0958 Sam Houston State University Police

Department

Tijerina, Thomas E. 14-10-0961 Yorktown Police Department

Tiner, James H. 14-10-0963 Angelina County Sheriff's Office

Tipton, Shane R. 14-10-1807 Somervell County Sheriff's Office

Tovar, Jose H. 14-10-0966 Travis County Sheriff's Office

Tull, Stuart L. 14-10-1820 Coryell County Sheriff's Office

Turack, Jr., John M. 14-10-1822 Bexar County Sheriff's Office

Turner, Brian K. 14-10-1823 Travis County Sheriff's Office

Turner, Randle A. 14-10-0975 San Jacinto County Sheriff's Office

Tynes, Jr., Carlos R. 14-10-0977 Caldwell County Sheriff's Office

Urbantke, Ardeen R. 14-10-0980 Round Rock Police Department

Varesic, Paul V. 14-10-0983 Surfside Beach Police Department

Vickers, George P. 14-10-0989 Hudspeth County Sheriff's Office

Vidouria, Phillip 14-10-0990 Travis County Sheriff's Office

Villanueva, Gloria 14-10-1841 Jim Wells County Sheriff's Office

Walker III, Bobby R. 14-10-0998 Center Police Department

Walker, Jerry D. 14-10-1001 Jeff Davis County Sheriff's Office

Wallace, Blakely D. 14-10-1847 Travis County Sheriff's Office

Wallen, Jr., James T. 14-10-1003 Edcouch Police Department

Watt, Kenneth C. 14-10-1852 El Paso County Sheriff's Office

Waxler, Jerry W. 14-10-1008 San Jacinto County Sheriff's Office

West, Linda L. 14-10-1015 Hardin County District Attorney's

Office

Wharton, Katherine M. 14-10-1857 El Paso County Sheriff's Office

White II, Terry L. 14-10-1861 Polk County Sheriff's Office

Whitney, Valerie A. 14-10-1023 Travis County Sheriff's Office

Williams, Michael C. 14-10-1878 Dallas County Sheriff's Office

Williamson, Joseph 14-10-1882 El Paso County Sheriff's Office

Wilson, Jr., Billy R. 14-10-1037 Village Fire Department

Wilson, Ina M. 14-10-1039 McAllen Independent School District

Police Department

Wright, Dewey R. 14-10-1052 Coryell County Sheriff's Office

Yancey, Bradley E. 14-10-1056 Teague Police Department

Page 23: Quarterly Meeting Minutes March 27, 2014

TCOLE Minutes

March 27, 2014

Page 23

Young, Michael D. 14-10-1061 Gainesville Police Department

Young, Timothy S. 14-10-1062 Plainview Police Department

Younts, Dirk M. 14-10-1063 Duncanville Police Department

Zamarripa, Dezi 14-10-1064 Edinburg Consolidated Independent

School District Police Department

Zavala, Jose L. 14-10-1891 El Paso County Sheriff's Office

Agenda item #13, Receive public comment on any topic, without action.

Presiding Officer Richardson opened the meeting to public comment. No one came

forward.

Agenda item #14, Executive session to discuss matters authorized by Texas

Government Code section 551.071 et seq., including pending litigation and settlement

offers, attorney-client consultation, and the executive director’s performance

evaluation.

There being no items to discuss, the Commission moved to adjourn until June 19.

Dr. Johnny E. Lovejoy, II, Secretary

JL/kw