pps: parking payment solution 2 november 2005 shawn melton, josh platon, marco carrion, marcus...

35
PPS: Parking Payment Solution 2 November 2005 Melton, Josh Platon, Marco Carrion, Marcus Still, Patrick Hines, Richard Med

Upload: allan-holt

Post on 28-Dec-2015

213 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: PPS: Parking Payment Solution 2 November 2005 Shawn Melton, Josh Platon, Marco Carrion, Marcus Still, Patrick Hines, Richard Medina

PPS: Parking Payment Solution

2 November 2005Shawn Melton, Josh Platon, Marco Carrion, Marcus Still, Patrick Hines, Richard Medina

Page 2: PPS: Parking Payment Solution 2 November 2005 Shawn Melton, Josh Platon, Marco Carrion, Marcus Still, Patrick Hines, Richard Medina

Presenter

Shawn Melton 4th year Computer Science Major Old

Dominion University Computer Engineering Minor Marketing Lead Assistant Webmaster

Green Group PPS 2 November 2005 2

Page 3: PPS: Parking Payment Solution 2 November 2005 Shawn Melton, Josh Platon, Marco Carrion, Marcus Still, Patrick Hines, Richard Medina

Introduction

Green Group PPS 2 November 2005 3

Page 4: PPS: Parking Payment Solution 2 November 2005 Shawn Melton, Josh Platon, Marco Carrion, Marcus Still, Patrick Hines, Richard Medina

Overview Team Elements Problem Elements Solution Elements Functionality Diagram Competition Risk Cost

Green Group PPS 2 November 2005 4

Page 5: PPS: Parking Payment Solution 2 November 2005 Shawn Melton, Josh Platon, Marco Carrion, Marcus Still, Patrick Hines, Richard Medina

Team ElementsTeam Elements

Green Group PPS 2 November 2005 5

Page 6: PPS: Parking Payment Solution 2 November 2005 Shawn Melton, Josh Platon, Marco Carrion, Marcus Still, Patrick Hines, Richard Medina

Team ElementsTeam Elements Expert: James Long

Director of Parking Services Matthew Botzler

Parking Services Appeals Committee Meeting twice a week Reporting to Janet Brunelle Patrick Hines is Project Manager

Green Group PPS 2 November 2005 6

Page 7: PPS: Parking Payment Solution 2 November 2005 Shawn Melton, Josh Platon, Marco Carrion, Marcus Still, Patrick Hines, Richard Medina

Problem Statement

Old Dominion University’s students, faculty and staff must go through a inefficient process in order to make Parking Services payments and appeals.

Green Group PPS 2 November 2005 7

Page 8: PPS: Parking Payment Solution 2 November 2005 Shawn Melton, Josh Platon, Marco Carrion, Marcus Still, Patrick Hines, Richard Medina

Problem Characteristics Long waiting lines exist No Student decal payment Forms must be filled out The building is small Hiring more employees doesn’t help Online purchasing allows automation

Green Group PPS 2 November 2005 8

Page 9: PPS: Parking Payment Solution 2 November 2005 Shawn Melton, Josh Platon, Marco Carrion, Marcus Still, Patrick Hines, Richard Medina

Survey Results

187 Students, Faculty, and Staff 71.7 % waited 15 min. or more 98.4 % wanted online purchasing 90.9 % have had parking decal 47.6 % have paid parking fine

Green Group PPS 2 November 2005 9

Student/Faculty/Staff Survey : Survey given out to 187 people between Friday October 14, 2005 to Monday October 29,2005

Page 10: PPS: Parking Payment Solution 2 November 2005 Shawn Melton, Josh Platon, Marco Carrion, Marcus Still, Patrick Hines, Richard Medina

Market

University Parking Services Specifically, those with Banner Beta testing at Old Dominion

Green Group PPS 2 November 2005 10

Page 11: PPS: Parking Payment Solution 2 November 2005 Shawn Melton, Josh Platon, Marco Carrion, Marcus Still, Patrick Hines, Richard Medina

Solution

PPS: Parking Payment Solution Allows online parking payments

Decals Citations

Appeals automated Registration online

Green Group PPS 2 November 2005 11

Page 12: PPS: Parking Payment Solution 2 November 2005 Shawn Melton, Josh Platon, Marco Carrion, Marcus Still, Patrick Hines, Richard Medina

Solution Characteristics

• Communication interface to Banner

• Decal printing• Reduce forms through automation• Receipts printed after purchase

Green Group PPS 2 November 2005 12

Page 13: PPS: Parking Payment Solution 2 November 2005 Shawn Melton, Josh Platon, Marco Carrion, Marcus Still, Patrick Hines, Richard Medina

Get PermitForm

RegisterYour vehicle

Wait for processing

Send forms and payment

Wait in line

New Decal is issued

Parking Services receives payment

Receipt is given

Green Group PPS 2 November 2005 13

Already registered

Through mail, faculty & staff only

Take to parking building

Page 14: PPS: Parking Payment Solution 2 November 2005 Shawn Melton, Josh Platon, Marco Carrion, Marcus Still, Patrick Hines, Richard Medina

User Log In

ID

Password

Select

Faculty

Staff

Student

Type of decal

Commuter

Resident

Enter Formof

Payment

SUBMITForm

-

Green GroupPPS 2 November 2005 14

Parking ServicesReceives form And payment

Print DecalAnd Receipt

Page 15: PPS: Parking Payment Solution 2 November 2005 Shawn Melton, Josh Platon, Marco Carrion, Marcus Still, Patrick Hines, Richard Medina

Client parks illegal

Ticket worker gives the illegal parking

car a ticket

Ticket worker inputs the ticket and the info into

the database

Client receive the ticket on the windshield

The database sends a red flag to the account and registrar’s office after 7 days and places a hold on the account.

Pays ticket through mail

Client waits in line.

Client writes out a check for

parking services.

Client mails payment through mail.

Pay ticket at parking servers’ office

Client has to go to the Parking Servers’ Office.

Parking services office

receives payment.

Parking services office removes the hold from the account

Parking service office enters

student information.

Parking service office enters

payment information.

Parking services office sends a

notice to registrar’s office

to remove the hold

Registrar’s office removes the hold from the account.

Green GroupPPS 2 November 2005 15

Page 16: PPS: Parking Payment Solution 2 November 2005 Shawn Melton, Josh Platon, Marco Carrion, Marcus Still, Patrick Hines, Richard Medina

Client parks illegal

Ticket worker gives the illegal parking

car a ticket

Ticket worker inputs the ticket and the info into

the database

Client receive the ticket on the windshield

The database sends a red flag to the account and registrar’s office after 7 days and places a hold on the account.

Client login to their account

Client chooses “Fine Payment

Option”

Client selects fine or fines.

Parking services office

receives payment.

Parking services office removes the hold from the account

Parking service office enters

student information.

Parking service office enters

payment information.

Parking services office sends a

notice to registrar’s office

to remove the hold

Registrar’s office removes the hold from the account.

Client chooses payment method.

Client enters payment

information.

Client prints or saves receipt

Green GroupPPS 2 November 2005 16

Page 17: PPS: Parking Payment Solution 2 November 2005 Shawn Melton, Josh Platon, Marco Carrion, Marcus Still, Patrick Hines, Richard Medina

O.D.U. database checked to verify credentials

User prompted to enter appeal request,decal request,

or fine information

ODU populates web forms to display ticket, permit or account

information

Information sent real-time to ODU database

User logs in with ticket number,account number, plate number,

or permit number

Confirmation numberand screen presented

Client must travel to parking services

Client turns in his appeal form

Client waits 10 business days for appeals committee

to meet, and decide on verdict of their ticket

Client waits in line

Client picks up an appeals form,fills out his name,address,

Ticket number, and reason for the appeal

Client must travel to parkingservices

Ticket is fully appealed

Client waits in line

Client pays ticket in full,or reduction given by

parking servicesReceipt given

Current AppealMethod

New appealMethod

Appealed Denied

Green GroupPPS 2 November 2005 17

Page 18: PPS: Parking Payment Solution 2 November 2005 Shawn Melton, Josh Platon, Marco Carrion, Marcus Still, Patrick Hines, Richard Medina

What our system can’t solve

Can’t reduce parking fees Can’t increase the success of

parking fine appeals Can’t make it easier to find a

parking space

Green Group PPS 2 November 2005 18

Page 19: PPS: Parking Payment Solution 2 November 2005 Shawn Melton, Josh Platon, Marco Carrion, Marcus Still, Patrick Hines, Richard Medina

Should it be done? Pros

Automated payment for fines or decals

Person doesn’t have to be on campus.

Automated interface with Banner.

Reduces paperwork.

Cons Parking Services

hires staff to update/track new system.

No big financial incentive.

Requires cooperation with OCCS.

Green Group PPS 2 November 2005 19

Page 20: PPS: Parking Payment Solution 2 November 2005 Shawn Melton, Josh Platon, Marco Carrion, Marcus Still, Patrick Hines, Richard Medina

Goals

• Set-up online payments• Ensure proper security• Make system user-friendly• Have automated appeal system• Offer online user tutorial

Green Group PPS 2 November 2005 20

Page 21: PPS: Parking Payment Solution 2 November 2005 Shawn Melton, Josh Platon, Marco Carrion, Marcus Still, Patrick Hines, Richard Medina

Functionality Diagram

Green Group PPS 2 November 2005 21

User Connection to Windows Secure Server

Java GUI Application

Third Party Credit Card Verification Software

Printed Receipt and Customer Pickup at Parking Services Center

Page 22: PPS: Parking Payment Solution 2 November 2005 Shawn Melton, Josh Platon, Marco Carrion, Marcus Still, Patrick Hines, Richard Medina

Sample GUI

ODU Parking Payment System

Welcome

User name :Password :

UIN (University ID Number)

7-10 characters composed of letters and numbers

Green Group PPS 2 November 2005 22

Page 23: PPS: Parking Payment Solution 2 November 2005 Shawn Melton, Josh Platon, Marco Carrion, Marcus Still, Patrick Hines, Richard Medina

Competition Matrix

Green Group PPS 2 November 2005 23

Company Online parking services

Payment of decals online

Payment of citations online

Automated appeals online

Interface website with Banner

Vehicle registration

User assistance

PPS: Parking Payment Solution

X X X X X X X

T2 Systems X X X        

Complus Data Innovations, Inc.

X X X        

EZ Permit X X          

http://www.t2systems.com/

http://www.govtech.net/magazine/story.php?id=95447&issue=10:1997

Page 24: PPS: Parking Payment Solution 2 November 2005 Shawn Melton, Josh Platon, Marco Carrion, Marcus Still, Patrick Hines, Richard Medina

Risk Rating System

Green Group PPS 2 November 2005 24

Page 25: PPS: Parking Payment Solution 2 November 2005 Shawn Melton, Josh Platon, Marco Carrion, Marcus Still, Patrick Hines, Richard Medina

Risks

Green Group PPS 2 November 2005 25

Risk # Risk Description Risk Mitigation

1 Losing Security on the Web Site SSL security certificate

2 Parking Services Rejection of Online Payment structure James Long desires online system

3* OCCS refuses to allow an interface to the Banner system Separate Database independent of Banner

4* Not meeting the budget Using strict scheduling

5 The web site is not user friendly  Online Tutorial

6* System goes down, back up data needed Separate back-up server

7 Privacy invaded Require secure accounts

8* Database interaction fails Separate back-up router

Page 26: PPS: Parking Payment Solution 2 November 2005 Shawn Melton, Josh Platon, Marco Carrion, Marcus Still, Patrick Hines, Richard Medina

Component Costs Windows Server : $89 per month

$89 * (6 months for initial setup) = $534

Sun Java Studio Standard (10 User Licenses) : $6950

Intellicharge 5 user license : $1195

http://www.managemore.com/intellicharge/http://store.sun.com/CMTemplate/CEServlet?

process=SunStore&cmdViewProduct_CP&catid=104023

Green Group PPS 2 November 2005 26

Page 27: PPS: Parking Payment Solution 2 November 2005 Shawn Melton, Josh Platon, Marco Carrion, Marcus Still, Patrick Hines, Richard Medina

Customer Costs

Team paid hourly Hourly rate of $16 6 members in group : $46080 Customers of Parking Services

$2 charge for PPS to use online payments

http://order.1and1.com/xml/order/ServerWindows;jsessionid=DFB54857A3E5265AC530866D9AD4F8E6.TC63a?__frame=_top&__lf=Static

Green Group PPS 2 November 2005 27

Page 28: PPS: Parking Payment Solution 2 November 2005 Shawn Melton, Josh Platon, Marco Carrion, Marcus Still, Patrick Hines, Richard Medina

University Study

No university in Virginia offers PPS James Madison’s system

Through T2 Systems VCU, UVA and VT have partial

payments

http://web.jmu.edu/parking/wptermsofuse.asp

Green Group PPS 2 November 2005 28

Page 29: PPS: Parking Payment Solution 2 November 2005 Shawn Melton, Josh Platon, Marco Carrion, Marcus Still, Patrick Hines, Richard Medina

Review Team Elements Problem Elements Solution Elements Functionality Diagram Competition Risk Cost

Green Group PPS 2 November 2005 29

Page 30: PPS: Parking Payment Solution 2 November 2005 Shawn Melton, Josh Platon, Marco Carrion, Marcus Still, Patrick Hines, Richard Medina

Conclusion

Green Group PPS 2 November 2005 30

Page 31: PPS: Parking Payment Solution 2 November 2005 Shawn Melton, Josh Platon, Marco Carrion, Marcus Still, Patrick Hines, Richard Medina

Works Cited Windows Server :

http://order.1and1.com/xml/order/ServerWindows;jsessionid=DFB54857A3E5265AC530866D9AD4F8E6.TC63a?__frame=_top&__lf=Static

Intellicharge Credit Card Verification Software :

http://www.managemore.com/intellicharge/

Sun Java Studio Standard :

http://store.sun.com/CMTemplate/CEServlet?process=SunStore&

cmdViewProduct_CP&catid=104023

Green Group PPS 2 November 2005 31

Page 32: PPS: Parking Payment Solution 2 November 2005 Shawn Melton, Josh Platon, Marco Carrion, Marcus Still, Patrick Hines, Richard Medina

Works Cited Survey of Old Dominion Students

Provided for you with slides

Parking Services/Online Processing http://www.odu.edu/webroot/orgs/af/ps/parkser.nsf/pages/home http://www.nacha.org/news/Stats/stats2004/3rd%20Quarter%202004.pdf http://www.shu.ac.uk/schools/cms/teaching/rh1/ebiz/online_payment_p

rocessing_basics.htm

HTTPS :

http://www.globalscape.com/products/ftp_servers.asp?CMP=KNCBC101504

Green Group PPS 2 November 2005 32

Page 33: PPS: Parking Payment Solution 2 November 2005 Shawn Melton, Josh Platon, Marco Carrion, Marcus Still, Patrick Hines, Richard Medina

Works Cited Universities’ Parking Services pages:

http://web.jmu.edu/parking/wptermsofuse.asp http://www.vims.edu/sms/catalog/catalog9697/stufac.html

#parking http://parking.cnu.edu/decals.html http://www.gmu.edu/univserv/parking/index.html http://www.umw.edu/publications/adjuncthbk_gp/cgps_adm

inistrative_inform/parking.php http://www.virginia.edu/parking/citations/pay.html http://facilities.vt.edu/ot/parking.asp http://www.bsv.vcu.edu/vcupark/studentrates.htm http://www.odu.edu/webroot/orgs/af/ps/parkser.nsf/pages/v

b_enforcement

Green Group PPS 2 November 2005 33

Page 34: PPS: Parking Payment Solution 2 November 2005 Shawn Melton, Josh Platon, Marco Carrion, Marcus Still, Patrick Hines, Richard Medina

Works Cited Competitors:

http://www.geotrust.com/ http://www.t2systems.com/ http://www.govtech.net/magazine/story.php

?id=95447&issue=10:1997 Resources cont’d:

http://www.globalscape.com/products/ftp_servers.asp?CMP=KNC-BC101504

Green Group PPS 2 November 2005 34

Page 35: PPS: Parking Payment Solution 2 November 2005 Shawn Melton, Josh Platon, Marco Carrion, Marcus Still, Patrick Hines, Richard Medina

Works Cited Interview with James Long : Conducted Monday

October 17, 2005 at approx 2:30 P.M.Old Dominion UniversityDirector : Parking and Transportation ServicesPhone : (757) 683-4004, Fax : (757) 683-3194Email : [email protected]

Student/Faculty/Staff Survey : Survey given out to 187 people between Friday October 14, 2005 to Monday October 29,2005

Green Group PPS 2 November 2005 35