polsci report
DESCRIPTION
okTRANSCRIPT
7/21/2019 PolSci Report
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/polsci-report 1/34
ARTICLE VSUFFRAGE
SECTION 1. Suffrage may be exercised by all citizens of the
Philiines not other!ise dis"ualified by la!# !ho are at least
eighteen years of age# and !ho shall ha$e resided in the Philiines
for at least one year and in the lace !herein they roose to $ote
for at least six months immediately receding the election. No
literacy# roerty# or other substanti$e re"uirement shall be
imosed on the exercise of suffrage.
7/21/2019 PolSci Report
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/polsci-report 2/34
Suffrage
Is the right and obligation: to vote of qualified citizens in the election
of certain national and local officers of the government and in the
decision of public questions submitted to the people.
Is the right to $ote gained through the democratic process
The right to run for office is sometimes called candidate eligibility,
and the combination of both rights is sometimes called full suffrage.
In many languages, the right to vote is called the active right tovote and the right to run for office is called the passive right to vote.
In English, these are sometimes called active suffrage and passive
suffrage.
7/21/2019 PolSci Report
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/polsci-report 3/34
Suffrage is often conceived in terms of elections for representatives.
Hoever, suffrage applies equally to initiatives and referenda.
Suffrage describes not only the legal right to vote, but also the
practical question of hether a question ill be put to a vote. The
utility of suffrage is reduced hen important questions are decidedunilaterally by elected or non!elected representatives.
In most democracies, eligible voters can vote in elections of
representatives. "oting on issues by initiative may be available in
some #urisdictions but not others. $or e%ample, hile some &.S. states
such as 'alifornia and (ashington have e%ercised theirshared sovereignty to offer citizens the opportunity to rite, propose,
and vote on referendums and initiatives, other states have not.
)eanhile, the &nited States federal government does not offer any
initiatives at all. *n the other hand, many countries, such as
Sitzerland, permit initiatives at all levels of government.
7/21/2019 PolSci Report
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/polsci-report 4/34
Suffrage is granted to qualifying citizens once they have reached the
voting age. (hat constitutes a qualifying citizen depends on the
government+s decision, but most democracies no longer e%tend
different rights to vote on the basis of se% or race. esident aliens can
vote in some countries, and other countries ma-e e%ceptions forcitizens of countries they have close lin-s to e.g., some members of
the 'ommonealth of /ations and members of the European &nion0.
7/21/2019 PolSci Report
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/polsci-report 5/34
N ature of suf frage
1. % mere ri$ilege
! Suffrage is not a natural right of the citizens but merely a privilege
to be given or ithheld by the lama-ing poer sub#ect to constitutional
limitations. Suffrage should be granted to individuals only upon the
fulfillment of certain minimum conditions deemed essential for the
elfare of society.
1. % olitical right
! In the sense of right conferred by the 'onstitution, suffrage isclassified as a political right, enabling every citizen to participate in the
process of government.
7/21/2019 PolSci Report
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/polsci-report 6/34
Scope of suf frage
1. Election - strictly speaking, it is the means by whichthe people choose their ofcials or denite and xedperiods and to whom they entrust, or the time being astheir representatives, the exercise o powers ogovernment.
2. Plebiscite - t is the name given to a vote o the peopleexpressing their choice or or against a proposed law orenactment submitted to them, n the !hilippines, theterms is applied to an election at which any proposed
amendment to, or revision o, the "onstitution issubmitted to the people directly a#ected beore certainproposed changes a#ecting local government units maybe implemented $%rt. &, 'ec. 1(, 11, 1).*+
. Referendum - t is the submission o a law or part
7/21/2019 PolSci Report
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/polsci-report 7/34
Q ualifications of voters.
He must be:
2. 3 citizen male or female0 of the 4hilippines5
1. /ot otherise disqualified by la5
6. 3t least eighteen 270 years of age5 and
8. Have resided in the 4hilippines for at least one 20 year and in the place herein he proposes to vote for at least si% 90 months preceding
the election.
7/21/2019 PolSci Report
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/polsci-report 8/34
Age Q ualification
2. &inimum age ! *bviously, there must be some minimum age forvoting. /o one, no matter ho ardent his belief in democracy, has ever
contented that human beings must be permitted to participate in the
selection of public officials from the day of their birth.
1. 'asis ! This suffrage qualification is based on the assumption thatunder a certain age, human beings do not have the maturity, e%perience,
education, and sense of #udgment the ill enable them to vote ith any
reasonable degree of intelligence.
6. No maximum age limit ! /o general e%ists as to the e%act age at
hich the individual supposedly attains the maturity sufficient for
political participation. (hile there is a minimum voting age in every
state, no country, hoever, has as yet seen fit to set a ma%imum age limit.
7/21/2019 PolSci Report
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/polsci-report 9/34
Residence Q ualification.
2. Period of residence 3 voter must have been a permanent resident
of the 4hilippines for at least one 20 year preceding the election and
si% 90 months in the province, city, or municipality here he is a
voter.
1. Imortance ! Si% 90 months residence in a province, city or
municipality is considered the minimum length of time ithin hich a
person can adequately familiarize himself ith the needs and
conditions and the personalities of the locality. ;iving him a right to
vote before that period, it contented, ill result in unpurposive and
mechanical voting.
7/21/2019 PolSci Report
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/polsci-report 10/34
Persons disualified to
vote.The responsibility of determining ho may be <disqualified by la< and
therefore, may be precluded from e%ercising the right of suffrage is left
by the constitution to 'ongress. 3s to ho are disqualified to vote, the
la enumerates them as follos5
2. 3ny person ho has been sentenced by final #udgment to suffer
imprisonment for not less than one 20 year, such disability not having
been removed by plenary pardon or granted amnesty. =ut such person
shall automatically reacquire the right to vote upon e%piration of five >0
years after service of sentence5
7/21/2019 PolSci Report
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/polsci-report 11/34
1. 3ny person ho has been ad#udged by final #udgment by competent
court of tribunal of having committed any crime involving disloyalty to
the duly constituted government such as rebellion, sedition, violation of
the anti!subversion and firearms las, or any crime against national
security, unless restored to his full civil and political rights in accordanceith la. Such person shall li-eise automatically regain his right to vote
upon e%piration of five >0 years after service of sentence5 and
6. Insane or incompetent persons as declared by competent authority.
The above persons are not qualified to vote even if they have the
qualifications.
7/21/2019 PolSci Report
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/polsci-report 12/34
Argum ents Justifying the lowering ofvoting age from 21 to 18
The $olloing have been given:
2. It has the effect of broadening the base of democratic participation in
the political process5
1. The voting age of 12 years is as old as the oman Empire5 therefore,it is obsolete5
6. It is the alleged0 findings of midical science that today?s 27!year!old
is physically at least 6 years ahead of an 27!year!old of 2@AA5
8. The communication media e%plosion has resulted in ma-ing 27!year!
old citizens better informed that their parents5>. The 4hilippines is becoming an increasingly young country and the
youth are more idealistic and are more change!oriented that their
elders5
7/21/2019 PolSci Report
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/polsci-report 13/34
9. The ob#ection that 27!year!old citizens lac- the maturity to e%ercise an
important political right idely is at best a debatable question5
B. If at the age of 27 one is mature enough to fight in defense of his
country, he is old enough to be given a voice in the determination of its
public policy5
@. =y including those under 21 but aleast 27 to vote ill ma-e them feel
that they are part of the decision!ma-ing process and thereby at least
increase their loyalty to our institutions5 and
2A. "oting is the ma#or if not the sole participation of common citizens in
the political process of the state. It is, under present circumtances, the
most effective medium for securing consent to or re#ection of government
short of e%tra constitutional remedies. The smaller the number of electorsin a particular community, the more limited the basis of consent.
The reduction of voting age is consent ith the theory of popular
sovereignty hich is one of the funadamental premises of our
government.
7/21/2019 PolSci Report
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/polsci-report 14/34
Agum ents justifying rem oval of
literacy requirem ent The 2@B6 'onstitution removed the requirement under the 2@6>
'onstitution on ability to read and rite such that then as no an
illiterate person has the right to vote. The illiterate voter is not
necessarily an ignorant voter.
7/21/2019 PolSci Report
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/polsci-report 15/34
Property Requirem ent
Prohiite!'ongress cannot also impose property requirement for
the e%ercise of suffrage
Sec 20
C 4roperty onership not a test of an individual
capacity.
C 4roperty requirement inconsistent ith concept of
republicangovernment.
C 4roperty requirement inconsistent ith social #ustice
principle
7/21/2019 PolSci Report
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/polsci-report 16/34
2. 4roperty oonership not a test of an individual
capacity.
C The #ustification for the abolition of property qualification that
onership of property, per se, neither add to nor detracts from aman?s capacity to function properly and fully as a social and political
being.
C Today, the argument that only property holders have Da sta-e in the
community is consider obsolete.C It is the human person, not property, that is to be represented, and
given primacy in the hierarchy of values.nership not a test of an
individual capacity.
7/21/2019 PolSci Report
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/polsci-report 17/34
1. 4roperty requirement inconsistent ith concept of republican
government.
C The imposition of property qualifications on the voters ould be
inconsistent ith the very nature and essence of our republican
system of government ordained in our 'onstitution.
C 4olitical system is premised upon the tenet that sovereignty resides
in
the people and all governmental authority emanates from 3rt II, Sec
20.
C The right to vote and to be voted shall not be dependent upon the
ealth of the individual concerned.
7/21/2019 PolSci Report
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/polsci-report 18/34
6. 4roperty requirement inconsistent ith social
#ustice principle
C Social #ustice presupposes equal opportunity for all, rich and poor
ali-e.
C /o person shall, by reason of poverty, be denied the chance to vote
and to be elected to public office.
C In a case, Supreme 'ourt declared as unconstitutional a la requiring
all candidates for public offices to post a surely bond equivalent to
the 20 year salary or emoluments of the position for hich they are
candidates hich shall be forfeited if the candidates, e%cept, hen
declared inner, fail to obtain at least 2AF of the votes cast for the
office to hich they have filed their certificates of candidacy.
7/21/2019 PolSci Report
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/polsci-report 19/34
"ther #ustantive
Requirem ent Prohiite!
0 "ongress is prohibited by the"onstitution to impose additionalsubstantive $not procedural*reuirements or voting similar innature to literacy or ownership o
property $'ec. 1*0 ducation
0 'ex
0 3axpaying ability
7/21/2019 PolSci Report
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/polsci-report 20/34
2. Education
C The more education a man has, the better and more valuablemember of society he ill be.
C $ormal education itself is no guarantee of good citizenship or of
intelligent voting.
C The requirement of a high school or even an elementary
education
ould disenfranchise large segments of the poorer classes of our
population.
7/21/2019 PolSci Report
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/polsci-report 21/34
2. 'ex
0 3he antagonism in the past to emalesu#rage stemmed in some degree rom thebelie that a woman4s place was in the homeand that the perormance o public duties was
the unction o the male members o the amily.
0 5nless one is willing to contend that women,simply by virtue o their womanhood, are
incapable o ree and intelligent social andpolitical activity.
7/21/2019 PolSci Report
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/polsci-report 22/34
. 3axpaying ability
0 3his restriction is to propertyreuirement or voting.
0 "ongress cannot by law deny to anindividual the right to vote on the ground
that he is exempted rom taxation or isnot liable to pay tax or the taxes paid byhim or or which he is liable during theyear are below a specied amount.
7/21/2019 PolSci Report
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/polsci-report 23/34
Co! pulsor" Suf frage.
3he 167 "onstitution made registering and voting amandatory obligation o every ualied citien.89oteworthy is the act that 'ection 1 uses the word8may: as in the 16; "onstitution in place o the world
8shale: in the 167 "onstitution. n view in permissivelanguage o the "onstitution, it is doubtul whether theailure to perorm the obligation to register and votecan be criminally punished.
7/21/2019 PolSci Report
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/polsci-report 24/34
Should voting be made compulsory?
1. Arguments against compulsory surage.
3hose who are against any system o coercive voting saythat is not only undemocratic but that no useul purposewould be served by dragging the people to the polls againsttheir will. 3hey maintain that is not the sie but the uality othe vote cast that is important, and that individuals orced toexercise su#rage might do real inury to the public good by
voting blindly and unintelligently. 3here is no means ocompelling a person to vote intelligently or to study thepersonalities and issues involved in an election.
ven assuming that the voter has the right to invalidate his
ballot by leaving it blank, still it would prevent those who eelstrongly against the candidates or the particular manner oholding an election rom expressing their moral indignationby openly boycotting the election and persuading others toollow suit.
7/21/2019 PolSci Report
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/polsci-report 25/34
2. Arguments in faor of compulsory surage.
3he proponents o compulsory su#rage, on the otherhand, contend that a reuirement that would orce anapathetic individual to the polls would make him awareo the responsibility that rest on him and wouldencourage him to become acuainted with the issueand personalities involved in the election. =nce interestis awakened by actual participation, the matter ocoercion, they eel, would become a secondary motive.
7/21/2019 PolSci Report
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/polsci-report 26/34
n the !hilippines or instance, it is not uncommon to
see political leaders dragging their constituents to thepolls on lection >ay. 3his shameul spectacle will nottake place i su#rage were an obligation. t should benoted that people are more prone to sell their votes ithey depend on politicians to bring them to the polling
places. ?urthermore, compulsory su#rage is the onlyway o assuring the accurate representation o the willo the people. su#rage were not exercise then, thetheory o popular sovereignty would become a myth.
7/21/2019 PolSci Report
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/polsci-report 27/34
n the long run, the participation o the people in thegovernment through the ballot is more important than
the result o an election or plebiscite. % deaultingmaority will make possible a government installed onlyby a voting minority.
5nortunately, no dene study has as yet been made othe e#ects o compulsory voting in any o the countrieswhich employ it. @ence, there is no way o actuallydetermining whether the obligatory ranchise improvesor detracts rom representative government.
7/21/2019 PolSci Report
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/polsci-report 28/34
SE"#$%& 2. #'e congress s'all proide a systemfor securing t'e secrecy and sanctity of t'e
ballot as (ell as a system for absentee oting by)uali*ed Filipinos abroad.
#'e congress s'all also design a procedure for
t'e disabled and illiterates to ote (it'out t'eassistance of ot'er persons. Until t'en+ t'eys'all be allo(ed to ote under e,isting la(s andsuc' rules as t'e "ommission on Elections maypromulgate to protect t'e secrecy of t'e ballot.
7/21/2019 PolSci Report
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/polsci-report 29/34
1. Untrammeled e,ercise of t'e rig't to ote.
3he right to vote has reerence to a constitutionalguarantee o the utmost signicance. t is a rightwithout which the principle o sovereignty sin he peoplebecomes nugatory. t is essential then to ensure thatthe others shall exercise their right reely 8uninAuencedby threats, intimidation or corrupt motives: and 8tosecure a air honest count o the ballots.: 3o accomplishthis aim, "ongress is directed by the "onstitution 8toprovide a system or securing the secrecy and sanctityo the ballot.:
S"ste! for securing t#esecrec" and sanctit" of t#e$allot.
7/21/2019 PolSci Report
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/polsci-report 30/34
(. )oting by the disabled and illiterates.
(ith the enfranchisement of illiterates and the e%istence of manydisabled voters, this responsibility of the legislative body assumes
more importance. The sanctity of the electoral process requires
secrecy of the vote.
3. 'ongress ill have to enact a la prescribing procedures that illenable the disabled and the illiterate to secretly cast their ballots ithout
requiring the assistance of other persons, to prevent them from being
manipulated by unscrupulous politicians to insure their victory at the
polls. 4erhaps, a method of voting by symbols may be devised to ma-e it
possible for disabled and illiterate citizens to e%ercise the right ofsuffrage.
7/21/2019 PolSci Report
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/polsci-report 31/34
=. &ntil 'ongress provides for the appropriate procedure, they shall be
alloed to vote under the e%isting la such rules as the 'ommission on
elections may promulgate to protect the secrecy of the ballot. This
prevents their disenfranchisement hile the la referred to has not yet
been enacted by 'ongress.
7/21/2019 PolSci Report
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/polsci-report 32/34
#ystem for Asentee voting y
qualifie! $ilipinos aroa!.
Section 1 e%tends the right of suffrage even to $ilipinos abroad
provided they possess all the qualifications mentioned therein andnone of the disqualifications provided by la.
7/21/2019 PolSci Report
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/polsci-report 33/34
?ilipinos who orce o circumstanceBs $e.g., the need toearn a living* have to temporarily work and resideabroad but maintain their love and loyalty to their
native land are still part o our Cepublic. 3hey are alsoa#ected by the uality o public ofcials and thepolicies o the government. 3hey remain liable to paytaxes, and are subect to many o its law. @ence, theyshould also be given the constitutional right to vote.
"ongress is mandated to provide a system o absenteevoting by ualied ?ilipinos abroad. t is bound to setaside unds and other reuirements or the purpose andto provide saeguards to ensure that elections overseasare held in a ree , clear and orderly manner.
7/21/2019 PolSci Report
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/polsci-report 34/34
%&A'( )"*+
'ubmitted byD
/hemissaa Eope Ceverente
'ocia, >ominic %.%nmuloc 9ivla Fram
Fevin Gamorte
!age, Coss inrebFyle Gichelson