pm - pmi vs sdlc
TRANSCRIPT
Som Gollakota, August 10, 2009
A non-profit organization whose sole purpose is to develop and monitor Project Management as an Art and Science, and set forth standards that govern the discipline of Project Management
Agreed by millions world-wide to be “the standard” in project management – regardless of the industry of application
Most prestigious certifications issued to professionals that commit to Project Management as their chosen field
PMI Website – http://www.pmi.org
Deals with managing Information Technology project Standards and Principles of the PMI still apply Technical knowledge is a “nice to have” and not a
“must have” – thanks to PMI’s standardization
Often governed by Software Development Lifecycle (SDLC) methodologies
Multitude of such methodologies exist and are followed by various corporations’ IT Organizations
Methodology choices depend on the type of project, business need, environment, and demand
Agile – Sequential in phases with short iterative cycles Most effective to deliver ever changing and increasing business needs Most suited for highly competitive market and business demands RUP provides a popular, well-defined Agile process (personal favorite)
Waterfall – Definitive phases run sequential with each phase starting after the
previous phase Most effective with fixed set of requirements Still used in about 70% of software development organizations,
according to a 2007 survey
ASAP – Defined by SAP Labs for effective SAP implementations Provides step-by-step instructions and tools to effectively deploy SAP
Review PMI Standards, Phases and processes for Project Management
Review three IT Project Management Methodologies (SDLC Methodologies) mentioned earlier
Align SDLC Phases with PMI Phases Provide a list of PMI Processes, and how they align
with PMI Phases, RUP Phases, Waterfall Phases and ASAP Phases
New Project
PMI
PMI Vs. SDLC – Phase Comparisons
Monitoring and Control
TransitionConstructionElaborationInception Go Live
Go LiveFinal Prep
RealizeBusiness Blueprint
Project Preparation
RUP
ASAP
Changes and their color-coded impacts to the project
Impl. & Depl
Go Live
Integration and Testing
Dev.DesignReq.PlanningSystem
ConceptsWaterfall
ClosingExecutingPlanningInitiating
PMI – Defines Five Phases of a Project Initiating – Is where the project is identified and defined Project Objectives, constraints, assumptions, Stakeholders, any
historical information Dividing large projects into smaller projects and build project charter
Planning – Plan project through final delivery Project management plan, Scope, Requirements, team, WBS,
Activities, Estimates, Schedule, Resources, Budgets, Risks, Quality –everything to do with planning, and project Kickoff
Executing – Is where the chunk of work occurs Final team comes in, works towards meeting the business need
identified in planning and ensuring quality of the deliverable, verifying scope
Monitoring and Control – Requires a slide for itself (see next slide) Closing – Is where the project is delivered, verified, accepted, and
closed A key activity is Lessons Learned and archiving for historic purpose
PMI Phases (Continued) Monitoring and Control (M & C)– Is where the Project Manager’s
prowess (skill and experience) comes handy M & C plans, budgets, scope, schedule, resources, quality, risks,
stakeholders expectations, changes Team building, resource, expectations, performance, reporting etc.
A continuous endeavor in a project through the lifecycle The sooner M & C starts the smoother the project executes
Changes and Change Management The late-breaking changes are very expensive to implement Today’s Reality – Changes occur throughout the project lifecycle Relevant Changes occurred in Planning – Include in current project Closing – Float another, or next version of the, project Changes occurred in early Execution – Relatively less expensive Changes occurred mid- or end of Execution – More expensive (better
to redirect them to new project (next product version)
Rational Unified Process (RUP) – Defines Four Phase Inception Is where most of the PMI-Initiating and PMI-Planning work occurs Planning occurs throughout the project (review, update, and rewrite plans)
Elaboration PMI-Planning tasks (elaborating on requirements, final budget, revising/creating
plans) PMI-Executing tasks (developing prototypes, building any high-risk
requirements, etc) Construction PMI-Executing tasks (building all requirements, verifying them for quality and
scope, etc) Transition Plans written, reviewed and agreed
Transition PMI-Executing tasks scope verification, quality assurance All the PMI-Closing tasks (final scope verification and acceptance, delivery, Go
Live, Lessons Learned, Close contracts, Close project, archive records…) RUP – PMI-Monitoring and Control Because of the iterative nature, all the M & C activities occur through the project
Waterfall – Defines a total of 10 product lifecycle processes System Concepts Phase (PMI-Initiating, PMI-Planning) Project Charter, initial scope/objectives, cost/benefit analysis, risk
management plan, Planning Phase (PMI-Planning) Project planning occurs in this phase including project management plan
Requirements Analysis Phase (PMI-Planning) Gather and define requirements, resource assessments, WBS, Activities,
Cost, Budget Design Phase (PMI-Planning, PMI-Executing) Activities include analyzing requirements for design and system architecture
Development Phase (PMI-Executing) Chunk of the project work (development and white box testing)
Integration and Testing (PMI Executing, PMI-Closing) Integrating developed components, verifying (QA), and final user acceptance
Implementation/Deployment (PMI-Closing) Migrate the new system to production (Go Live) and close the project
Waterfall (Cont…) – Defines three additional phases Not included in PMI’s Project Management processes For a good reason – these relate to Product Lifecycle (not Project) Initiation Phase (First Phase, Occurs before System Concepts) Typically occurs before project comes into existence An idea/opportunity/concept is identified and agreed for undertaking
Operations and Maintenance (After Go Live) Post deployment (Go Live), beyond project closure Monitor and maintain the final result of the project
Disposition (last phase of the lifecycle) End of product lifecycle – defines how the product is decommissioned This activity itself could be a “project” of its own (based on PMI’s
definition of a Project)
ASAP – Accelerated SAP – with Five Phases Project Preparation (PMI-Initiating, PMI-Planning) Blueprint (PMI-Planning and PMI-Executing) Requirements, Scope, “As Is” and “To Be” systems (Design), Gap
Analysis, and build a project blueprint (complete project plan with schedule, tasks, activities, WBS, Resources – the whole nine yards)
Realization (PMI-Executing) Development and implementation of the blueprint Management of scope, stakeholder expectation, schedule,
quality, team building, budget, risks etc. Final Preparation (PMI Executing, PMI-Closing) Testing, verification and user acceptance
Go Live (PMI-Closing) New system is migrated to live production, and project is closed
PMI Process PMI Phase
RUP Phase Waterfall Phase ASAP Phase
Develop Project Charter Initiating Inception System Concepts Project Preparation
Identify Stakeholders Initiating Inception System Concepts Project Preparation
Develop PM Plan Planning Inception Planning Project Preparation
Collect Requirements Planning Inception Requirements Analysis Blueprint
Define Scope Planning Inception Planning, Requirements Analysis
Blueprint
Create WBS Planning Inception Requirements Analysis Blueprint
Define Activities Planning Inception Requirements Analysis Blueprint
Sequence Activities Planning Inception Requirements Analysis Blueprint
Estimate Activity Resources
Planning Inception Requirements Analysis Blueprint
Estimate Activity Duration Planning Inception Requirements Analysis Blueprint
Develop Schedule Planning Inception Requirements Analysis Blueprint
Estimate Costs Planning Inception Requirements Analysis Blueprint
Determine Budget Planning Inception Requirements Analysis Blueprint
Plan Quality Planning Inception Planning Project Preparation
Develop H R Plan Planning Inception Planning Project Preparation
PMI Process PMI Phase
RUP Phase Waterfall Phase ASAP Phase
Plan Communication Planning Inception Planning Project Preparation
Plan Risk Management Planning Inception Planning Project Preparation
Identify Risks Planning All Phases Planning Blueprint
Plan Qualitative Risk Analysis
Planning Inception Planning Blueprint
Plan Quantitative Risk Analysis
Planning Inception Planning Blueprint
Plan Risk Responses Planning Inception Planning Blueprint
Plan Procurements Planning Inception Planning, Requirements Analysis
Blueprint
Direct & Manage Project Execution
Executing All except Inception Design, Development Realization
Perform Quality Assurance Executing Transition System Integration and Testing
Final Preparation
Acquire Project Team Executing Inception Planning, Requirements Analysis
Project Preparation
Develop Project Team Executing Inception, Elaboration
All Phases from Requirements Analysis
Blueprint
Manage Project Team Executing Elaboration, Construction
All Phases from Requirements Analysis
Realization
PMI Process PMI Phase
RUP Phase
Waterfall Phase ASAP Phase
Distribute Information Executing All Phases All Phases from Requirements Analysis Realization, Final PrepManage Stakeholder Expectation
Executing All Phases All Phases from Requirements Analysis Blueprint, Realization
Conduct Procurements Executing Construction Development RealizationMonitor and Control Project Work
Controlling All Phases Development, Integration and Test Realization
Perform Integrated Change Control
Controlling Construction, Transition
Development, Integration and Test Realization, Final Prep
Verify Scope Controlling Transition Integration and Test Final PreparationControl Scope Controlling All except
InceptionDesign, Development, Int. & Test Realization, Final Prep
Control Schedule Controlling All except Inception
Design, Development, Int. & Test Realization, Final Prep
Control Costs Controlling All Phases Development, Integration and Test Realization, Final PrepPerform Quality Control Controlling Transition Integration and Test Final PreparationReport Performance Controlling Transition Integration and Test Final PreparationMonitor and Control Risks Controlling Construction,
TransitionAll Phases from Requirements Analysis Realization, Final Prep
Administer Procurements Controlling Transition Integration and Test Final PreparationClose Project or Phase Closing Transition Go Live Go LiveClose Procurements Closing Transition Go Live Go Live
Thank You