plenary 10 18-12 final
TRANSCRIPT
Goals
Introduce new project at PSHMC Discuss ethnography and field site
projects Review and discuss assignment 3
Community garden at PSHMC
CHNA Study Area
– Significant socio-economic barriers
– Lowest level of socio-economic barriers
http://www.ers.usda.gov/data-products/food-desert-locator/go-to-the-locator.aspx
USDA Food Desert Locator
How do we work with community organizations to improve access to healthy foods and education/information?
Prevention Produce
Prevention Produce
“Prescription produce”
“Farm Fresh” menu
Ethnography
An empirical research method for learning about cultural phenomena and discovering the nature of peoples
Physical geography and climate
Learning the culture of the group under study before deriving explanations of their attitudes/behavior
Ethnographic data collection
Historical research Active field notes Participant observation Interviews Questionnaires Geography/topography
Medical anthropology
Medical anthropology and health interventions
Application of medical anthropology to field experience
Build a rich history of your site Develop relationships & trust Identify key informants Take rigorous notes & cross-check
with informants› Quote your informants
Understand your biases and assumptions
Keep an open mind
Assignment 3
Final assignment
Value of ethnography at your field site
Give voice to an underserved population Contextualize your observations Identify themes and patterns that can inform
effective intervention strategies Determine variables for future research and
develop a testable hypothesis Propose more culturally-sensitive plans for
project implementation Identify key questions about existing
programs and policies
Final thoughts…
You are not a consultant, you are a learner
We are not expecting you to ‘save’ the organization or its clients
Think long-term about your involvement with the organization
There will be many opportunities for leadership/action in medical school
Questions or concerns? [email protected] – Diversity Office
Healthy People 2020http://www.healthypeople.gov/2020/default.aspx
Goals:› Eliminate preventable disease, disability, injury,
and premature death› Achieve health equity, eliminate disparities, and
improve the health of all groups› Create social and physical environments that
promote good health for all. Goals (cont.)
› Promote healthy development and healthy behaviors across every stage of life.
Objectives› 37 focus areas
26
Planning Models Models serve as frames from which to
build; Provide structure & organization for the planning process
Many different models, common elements, but different labels.
A Generalized Model for Program Planning
27
Needs Assessment –Part IAssignment #3
Biology/ Genetics Behaviors Social
Environment Physical
Environment Policies and
Interventions Access to
Quality Health Care/ Services
Health Problem: Statement of Problem
Assessments• Social• Environmental• Behavioral
What are the behaviors that impact health problem?
• Risk and Protective Factors Associated with/Influence Behaviors
Summary (III)• Justify need for an
intervention/program• Identify possible solutions
(interventions) to health problem
Next Paper: The Program/Intervention
28
The way it is…
DescribeI
Analyzingtargetedbehavior
II IIIIII
29
Introduction and Statement of the Problem: A brief summarization of the health problem that you have chosen to address based upon one or two HP 2020 goals.
Example: Obesity
Talk briefly about epidemiological data available to justify the health problem in your specific target population (or geographical region). Please describe the incidence/prevalence among different groups (i.e. race/ethnics, ages, etc.) to emphasize the significance of the problem among the target group.
Obesity – What is the definition? To what degree does obesity impact your target population?
What is the incidence/prevalence rate of Obesity nationwide?What is the incidence/prevalence rate of Obesity locally?What is the incidence/prevalence rate of Obesity among your target population?
?
30
Social Assessments: A description of the geographic, age, social, educational, racial, economic, crime, etc., characteristics of your target population. Who?
1. Who is the target population? – Describe demographic characteristics including socio-economic indicators and other relevant information. 2. Where does this population live? – Describe the city, town, school, neighborhood, etc.3. What are the social implication (quality of life) resulting from the health problem? – Describe any juvenile offense, school disciplinary incidences, crime, discrimination, unemployment, welfare, etc.4. What are the existing resources that may be useful for your program? – Describe any community, organizations and/or school resources and assets that can be used to solve the problem.
Environmental? Policy? Access to Care?
31
Environmental Influences Radiation Exposure Workplace Hazards Home Hazards Contaminants Media Political Systems Migration Global Warming Recreational space
Infectious Agents Auto/Road Design Speed Limits Medical Care Access Product Design (e.g., handgun) Noise War/Civil Conflict Deforestation Adequate Surveillance Systems
Social InfluencesIncome + Occupation + Education = SES Geography Age Race Education Crime Income Unemployment Roles
Discrimination Residence Literacy Isolation Family Composition Faith/Spirituality Culture Gender
32
Policy/Access Influences
Access to care Quality of care Access to interventions Representativeness in
policy development Equity and justice
33
34
Behavioral Assessment: A description and analysis of behavioral factors that put your population at risk for the health problem. Rank the causal strength (i.e. relative risk) and changeability of each factors based on your target group.
What are the behaviors associated with the health problem, Obesity, present in your target population
Are we talking about high fat food intake?Are we talking about inactivity?Are we talking about low levels of fruit and vegetable intake?
To what degree are these behaviors present among your group? – You need to get national/state/local data and infer the incidence/prevalence rate (percentage) to your population.
Which behavioral factors are most important in addressing your health problem? – You should be able to justify the importance of each behavior and the likelihood for change.
High fat food intake? 3Inactivity? 1Low levels of fruit and vegetable intake? 2
Hi! I’m the Literature!
35
Assessment of Risk and Protective Factors (Educational and Organizational Assessment): An analysis of the determining (predisposing, enabling and reinforcing) factors that influence the chosen behavior(s) and obesity. Rank each factor based on its importance and your ability to change it.
Inactivity
What are the Factors that impact this behavior? Rank each factor…
What are the risk and protective factors associated with the Inactivity and Obesity identified in the previous sections? – Describe the positive and the negative factors.
Which predisposing, reinforcing, and enabling factors are most important in addressing your behaviors? – Describe each of these categories of factors separate and justify the importance and likelihood for change of each factor
1. PREDISPOSING FACTORS
2. REINFORCING FACTORS
3. ENABLING FACTORS
Behaviors and Factors
Behavior = What people do or don’t do Factors = influence behavior
An analysis of the determining (predisposing [facilitate or hinder person’s motivation to change, e.g., knowledge, attitudes, beliefs, etc.], enabling [barriers or vehicles created by society or system, e.g., access to hl, resources, rules,
etc.], and reinforcing [feedbacks & rewards by peers, relatives, employers, etc.]) factors that influence the chosen behavior and health problem.
37
38
Predisposing Factors
Awareness and Knowledge Beliefs, Values, and Attitudes Perceptions of Susceptibility,
Seriousness, Benefits, & Cost Personal Histories Behavioral Intentions Existing Skills
Health Belief Model/Theory
39
40
Enabling Factors Health Care Environment.
› Facilities, clinics, providers, etc.› Cost, distance, transportation, hours, etc.
Other Environmental Conditions.› Availability of fast food, cigarettes, billboard,
alcohol , sports, laws, etc. Skills – ability to perform task.
41
Reinforcing Factors
Social Support Family and Peer Influences Advise/Feedback from Providers Benefits of the Treatment/Action Social and Economical Benefits Adverse Consequences
Theories & Models: Used to Understand Behavior
Theory - “a set of interrelated concepts, definitions, and propositions that present a systematic view of events or situations by specifying relations among variables in order to explain and predict the events of the situations” (Glanz, Lewis, & Rimer, 2002, p. 25)
Concept - primary elements of theories or building blocks of theory (Glanz et al., 2002)
Why use theories & models? “A theory based approach provides direction and
justification for program activities and serves as the basis for processes that are to be incorporated into an intervention/program (Cowdery et al., 1995, p. 248)
“Theories can provide answers to program developers’ questions regarding why people aren’t engaging in a desirable behavior of interest, how to go about changing their behaviors, and what factors to look at when evaluating a program’s focus” (van Ryn & Heaney, 1992, p. 326).
Health Belief Model/Theory
Perceived Susceptibility – is he/she vulnerable to health problem?
Perceived Seriousness – how serious is the the illness/problem?
Perceived Benefits – anticipated value of the recommended action.
Perceived Barriers – cost involved in taking a particular action.
Motivation/Cues to Action & Self-efficacy.
Transtheoretical Model/Theory
Stages of Changes› Precontemplation.› Contemplation.› Preparation.› Action.› Maintenance.› Termination. *Relapse
Decisional Balance – pros vs. cons.
Theory of Reasoned Action Attitudes – toward performing the behavior. Subjective Norm – influence of other people
(i.e., parents, friends). Intentions – probability of performing. Behavior – the actual action.