pas ho in john 3:16 as proof of particular redemption

Upload: michael-senders

Post on 01-Jun-2018

216 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

  • 8/9/2019 pas ho in John 3:16 as Proof of Particular Redemption

    1/18

    pavß o ̊in John 3:16 as Proof of Particular Redemption

     by Michael Senders

    Part 1: A Petition for a More Consistent Interpretation of pavß o + verb Passages

    Many preachers and teachers have made much of the traditional English

    translation of pavß o ̊in John 3:16 as “whosoever 1.” In recent times, some have goneso far as to host entire conferences revolving around this passage. It is the intent of

    this paper to show that the Greek construction “pavß o ̊+ verb” has been translated byEnglish Bible versions inconsistently throughout the various passages in which it

    occurs, most famously in John 3:16. The author will attempt to prove that thisconstruction can, and should, be translated more consistently, and in a way that does

    not import an outside thought not present in the construction.2 

    The construction pavß o˚3 + verb is found thirty-nine times within the NewTestament. Twenty-eight times the verb takes the present active participle form (Matt

    5:28, 5:32, 7:21, 7:26; Luke 14:11, 16:18, 18:14; John 3:15, 3:16, 4:13, 6:40, 8:34,

    11:26, 12:46; Acts 13:39; Rom 2:1, 10:11; 2 Tim 2:19; 1 Jn 2:29, 3:3, 3:4, 3:6 (twice),

    3:15, 4:7, 5:1 (twice); 2 Jn 9), once in the present participle (Jn 18:37), three times in

    the present middle participle (Matt 5:22; Luke 6:47; 1 Jn 2:23), three times in theaorist active participle (Luke 20:18; John 6:45, 16:2), once in the aorist middle

     participle (Gal 3:13), and three times in the perfect middle participle (John 3:8; 1 Jn3:9, 5:18). Three more uses can be added for the form

    pavn o˚ + verb: John 6:37

    (present active indicative), 6:39 and 17:2 (perfect active indicative). It is interesting tonote that twenty-six of the forty-one uses are Johannine, with ten uses in the short

     book 1 John alone.

    First we will discuss the lexical meaning of pavß. Pavß has the genericmeaning of “all,” “each,” or “every.” When grouped with the article and a participle,

    it means “every one who,” or “whoever.”4 The article, in this case acts as an

    impersonal pronoun, meaning, “the [one].” When grouped with a participle, it

    “receives the meaning of a relative clause,” to which BAG adds, “esp. after pavß,” andsuggests the translation, “everyone who becomes angry,” for pavß o ̊oṙgizo/menoß atMatt 5:22.

    5 Thus, any time pavß o ̊occurs with a verb, it should be viewed as a phrase,

    and should not be broken apart during exegesis. Special attention should be given tothose of the Arminian theological persuasion, who on occasion, draw attention to pavß within these phrases by separating it from the rest of the phrase to underline the

    [assumed] unlimited nature of pavß when it occurs alone. Within the phrase, pavß is

    1 More modern translations, such as the NASB, use the cognate “whoever.” 

    2 It should be noted that the author has no intention of speculating about why the versions noted havechosen to translate in the ways they have; such speculation is mere conjecture and is entirely fruitless.

    The author’s purpose is merely to point out that an inconsistency exists, and then to find an appropriate

    solution. 3

     This paper will limit its discussion to singular usage.

    4  BAG, 637. 5  Ibid., 553. 

  • 8/9/2019 pas ho in John 3:16 as Proof of Particular Redemption

    2/18

    limited only to those people participating in the action of the following verb. For

    example, in John 3:16 according to the KJV, “…that He gave his only begotten Son,

    that whosoever believeth in Him…,” the emphasis may be put on “whosoever,” and

    then explained that the Greek word behind it is pavß, and that it therefore means thatthe Son was given for all without exception. This is a clear case of dividing a phrase,

    and a good reason for dropping “whosoever” from all modern translations. Within theGreek phrase, pavß is limited to its verbal participants. Hence, in John 3:16, themonogenhv was sent so that “all those believing in him might be saved.” Pavß therefore is only describing the group of believers, not the whole of humanity.

    When it comes to translation options, there are a variety of acceptable possibilities, and choice has more to do with how fluid of a reading one is hoping to

    achieve. We will use John 3:16 as an example. pavß o ̊pisteu/wn in its most rigidliteral translation could read, “all the [ones] believing.” Also acceptable may be,

    “everyone believing,” “all those believing,” “everyone who believes,” etc. The most

    rigid literal translation is unnecessary, as “everyone that believes” seems to be anacceptable, readable translation that doesn’t import foreign ideas and yet is true to the

    intention of the Greek text.So why this rigid adherence to “whosoever,” which imports a connotation that

    the action of believing is open to anyone, an idea not  present in the Greek text? John3:16 and its surrounding context say nothing about the cause of one’s faith, only that

     believing is the necessary condition for the promise of eternal life. We will now look

    at the full list of verses mentioned above in several popular versions for comparison,

    to prove that the continued adherence to “whosoever,” or “whoever,” is forced, and

    unnecessary.

    Matt 5:22

    Greek (NA27) KJV NIV NASB ESV

    eġw\ de\ le/gwu˚mivn o¢ti pavß o˚ o˙rgizo/menoß twv   ̂a˙delfwv   ̂au˙touv e¡noxoß e¡stai thv   ̂

    kri/se˙i\... 

    But I say unto

    you, That

    whosoever is

    angry with his

     brother without a

    cause shall be in

    danger of the

     judgment…

    But I tell you that

    anyone who is

    angry with his

     brother will be

    subject to

     judgment.

    But I say to you

    that everyone 

    who is angry with

    his brother shall

     be guilty before

    the court…

    But I say to you

    that everyone 

    who is angry with

    his brother will be

    liable to

     judgment…

    Matt 5:28

    eġw\ de\ le/gwu˚mivn o¢ti pavß o˚ ble/pwn

    gunaivka pro\ßto\ eṗiqumhvtai

    au˙th\n h¡dheṁoi/xeusenau˙th\n e˙n thv   ̂

    kardi/a auṫouv. 

    But I say untoyou, That

    whosoever

    looketh on a

    woman to lust

    after her hath

    committed

    adultery with her

    already in his

    heart. 

    But I tell you thatanyone who 

    looks at a woman

    lustfully has

    already

    committed

    adultery with her

    in his heart.

    …but I say to youthat everyone

    who looks at a

    woman with lust

    for her has

    already

    committed

    adultery with her

    in his heart.

    But I say to youthat everyone

    who looks at a

    woman with

    lustful intent has

    already

    committed

    adultery with her

    in his heart.

    Matt 5:32

    eġw\ de\ le/gwu˚mivn o¢ti pavß o  ̊

    But I say unto

    you, That

    But I tell you that

    anyone who 

    …but I say to you

    that everyone

    But I say to you

    that everyone

  • 8/9/2019 pas ho in John 3:16 as Proof of Particular Redemption

    3/18

    aṗolu/wn th\ngunaivka auṫouv parekto\ß lo/goupornei/aß poieiv 

    au˙th\nmoiceuqhvnai…

    whosoever shall

     put away his wife,

    saving for the

    cause of

    fornication,

    causeth her to

    commitadultery… 

    divorces his wife,

    except for marital

    unfaithfulness,

    causes her to

     become an

    adulteress…

    who divorces his

    wife, except for

    the reason of

    unchastity, makes

    her commit

    adultery…

    who divorces his

    wife, except on

    the ground of

    sexual

    immorality,

    makes her commit

    adultery…

    Matt 7:21

    Ou˙ pavß o  ̊le/gwn moi:

    ku/rie ku/rie,eiṡeleu/setai

    eiß̇ th\nbasilei/an twvn

    ou˙ranwvn…

     Not every one 

    that saith unto

    me, Lord, Lord,

    shall enter into the

    kingdom of

    heaven… 

     Not everyone

    who says to me,

    ‘Lord, Lord’ will

    enter the kingdom

    of heaven…

     Not everyone

    who says to Me,

    ‘Lord, Lord,’ will

    enter the kingdom

    of heaven…

     Not everyone

    who says to me,

    ‘Lord, Lord,’ will

    enter the kingdom

    of heaven…

    Matt 7:26

    Kai\ pavß o˚ ak̇ou/wn moutou\ß lo/gouß

    tou/touß kai\ mi\ poiwvn auṫou\ßom̊oiwqh/setaia˙ndri\ mwrwv  ,̂

    o¢stißw˙  k̂odo\mhsenau˙touv te/n

    oik̇i/an eṗi\ th\na£mmon…

    And every one

    that heareth these

    sayings of mine,

    and doeth them

    not, shall be

    likened unto a

    foolish man,

    which built his

    house upon the

    sand: 

    But everyone

    who hears these

    words of mine…

    “Everyone who

    hears these words

    of Mine and does

    not act on them,

    will be like a

    foolish man who

     built his house on

    the sand.

    And everyone

    who hears these

    words of mine…

    Luke 6:47

    Pavß o˚ eṙco/menoß pro/ßme kai\ ak̇ou/wn

    mou twvnlo/gown kai\ 

    poiwvn auṫou/ß,u˚powdei/xw um̊ivn

    ti/ni eṡti\nom̊oioß…

    Whosoever

    cometh to me, and

    heareth my

    sayings, and doeth

    them, I will shew

    you to whom he is

    like…

    I will show you

    what he is like

    who comes to me

    and hears my

    words and puts

    them into

     practice.

    Everyone who

    comes to Me and

    hears My words

    and acts on them,

    I will show you

    whom he is like…

    Everyone who 

    comes to me and

    hears my words

    and does them…

    Luke 14:11

    o¢ti pavß o  ̊u˚ywvneåuto\n

    tapeinwqh/setai…

    For whosoever

    exalteth himself

    shall be abased… 

    For everyone

    who exalts

    himself will be

    humbled…

    For everyone

    who exalts

    himself will be

    humbled…

    For everyone

    who exalts

    himself will be

    humbled…

    Luke 16:18

    Pavß o˚ aṗolu/wn th\n

    gunaivka auṫouv 

    kai\ gamwvne˚te/ran

    Whosoever

     putteth away his

    wife, and marrieth

    another,committeth

    Anyone who 

    divorces his wife

    and marries

    another womancommits

    Everyone who 

    divorces his wife

    and marries

    another commitsadultery…

    Everyone who 

    divorces his wife

    and marries

    another commitsadultery…

  • 8/9/2019 pas ho in John 3:16 as Proof of Particular Redemption

    4/18

    moiceu/ei…  adultery… adultery…

    Luke 18:14

    … o¢ti pavß o˚ u˚ywvn eåuto\n

    tapeinwqh/setai…

    … for every one

    that exalteth

    himself shall beabased…

    … For everyone

    who exalts

    himself will behumbled…

    … for everyone

    who exalts

    himself will behumbled…

    …For everyone

    who exalts

    himself will behumbled…

    Luke 20:18

    pavß o˚ pesw\n e˙p’ek̇eivnon to\n li/qon

    sunqlasqh/setai…

    Whosoever shall 

    fall upon that

    stone shall be

     broken… 

    Everyone who 

    falls on that

    stone will be

     broken to

     pieces…

    Everyone who 

    falls on that

    stone will be

     broken to

     pieces…

    Everyone who 

    falls on that

    stone will be

     broken to

     pieces…

    John 3:8

    to\ pneuvmao¢pou qe/lei pneiv kai\ th\n qwnh\nau˙touv ak̇ou/eiß,al̇l! ou˙k oi™daßpo/qen e¡rcetaikai\ pouv u˚pa/gei: ou¢twßeṡti\n pavß o  ̊gegennhme/noßek̇ touv pneu/matoß. 

    The wind bloweth

    where it listeth,

    and thou hearest

    the sound thereof,

     but canst not tell

    whence it cometh,

    and whither it

    goeth: so is everyone that is born

    of the Spirit. 

    …So it is with

    everyone born of

    the Spirit.

    “The wind blows

    where it wishes

    and you hear the

    sound of it, but do

    not know where it

    comes from and

    where it is going;

    so is everyone

    who is born of the

    Spirit.

    …So it is with

    everyone who is

     born of the Spirit.

    John 3:15

    i¢na pavß o˚ pisteu/wn eṅ

    au˙twv   ̂e¡chˆ zwh\naiẇ/nion. 

    That whosoever 

     believeth in him

    should not perish,

     but have eternal

    life. 

    …that everyone 

    who believes in

    him may have

    eternal life.

    …so that

    whoever believes

    will in Him have

    eternal life.

    …that whoever

     believes in him

    may have eternal

    life.

    John 3:16

    ou¢twß ga\rh˙ga/phsen o ̊

    qeo\ß to\n

    ko/smon, w¢steto\n u˚io\n to\nmonogenhv 

    e¡dwken, i¢napavß o  ̊

    pisteu/wn eiß̇au˙to\n mh\ 

    aṗo/lhtai al̇l’e¡chˆ zwh/naiẇ/nion. 

    For God so loved

    the world, that he

    gave his only

     begotten Son, thatwhosoever 

     believeth in him

    should not perish,

     but have

    everlasting life. 

    For God so loved

    the world that he

    gave his one and

    only Son, thatwhoever believes

    in him shall not

     perish but have

    eternal life.

    For God so loved

    the world, that He

    gave his only

     begotten Son, thatwhoever believes

    in Him shall not

     perish, but have

    eternal life.

    For God so loved

    the world, that he

    gave his only Son,

    that whoever  believes in him

    should not perish

     but have eternal

    life.

    John 4:13

    a˙pekri/qh ˙Ihsouvß

    kai\ ei™pen auṫh        "  :̂pavß o  ̊pi/nwn ek̇

    Jesus answered

    and said unto her,

    Whosoever 

    Jesus answered,

    “Everyone who 

    drinks this water

    Jesus answered

    and said to her,

    “Everyone who 

    Jesus said to her,

    “Everyone who 

    drinks of this

  • 8/9/2019 pas ho in John 3:16 as Proof of Particular Redemption

    5/18

    touv u¢datoßtou/tou diyh/sei

    pa/lin: 

    drinketh of this

    water shall thirst

    again: 

    will be thirsty

    again…”

    drinks of this

    water will thirst

    again…”

    water will be

    thirsty again…”

    John 6:37

    pavn o§ di/dwsi/nmoi o ̊path\r

    pro\ß eṁe\ h¢xei…

    All that theFather giveth me

    shall come to

    me… 

    All that theFather gives me

    will come to

    me…

    All that theFather gives Me

    will come to

    Me…

    All that theFather gives me

    will come to

    me…

    John 6:39

    touvto de/ eṡtinto\ qe/lhma touv pe/myanto/ß me,

    i¢na pavn o  § de/dwke/n moi mh\ 

    aṗole/sw eẋ

    au˙touv, a˙lla\ aṅasth/swau˙to\ [eṅ] thv   ̂

    eṡca/thˆ h˚me/ra. 

    And this is the

    Father’s will

    which hath sent

    me, that of all

    which he hath

    given me I should

    lose nothing, butshould raise it up

    again at the last

    day. 

    And this is the

    will of him who

    sent me, that I

    shall lose none of

    all that he has

    given me, but

    raise them up atthe last day.

    This is the will of

    Him who sent

    Me, that of all

    that He has given

    Me I lose nothing,

     but raise it up on

    the last day.

    And this is the

    will of him who

    sent me, that I

    should lose

    nothing of all that 

    he has given me,

     but raise it up onthe last day.

    John 6:40

    touvto ga/reṡtin to\ qe/lema

    touv parto/ßmou, i¢na pavß o  ̊

    qeorwvn to\nuio̊\n kai\ 

    pisteu/wn eiß̇au˙to\n e¡chˆ zwh\naiẇ/nion…

    And this is the

    will of him that

    sent me, that

    every one which 

    seeth the Son, and

     believeth on him,

    may have

    everlasting life…

    For my Father’s

    will is that

    everyone who 

    looks to the Son

    and believes in

    him shall have

    eternal life…

    For this is the will

    of My Father, that

    everyone who 

     beholds the Son

    and believes in

    Him will have

    eternal life…

    For this is the will

    of my Father, that

    everyone who 

    looks on the Son

    and believes in

    him should have

    eternal life…

    John 6:45

    … pavß o  ̊ak̇ou/saß para\ touv patro\ß kai\ maqw\n e¡rcetai

    pro\ß e˙me/. 

    …Every man 

    therefore that 

    hath heard, and

    hath learned of

    the Father,

    cometh unto me. 

    …Everyone who 

    listens to the

    Father and learns

    from him comes

    to me.

    …Everyone who 

    has heard and

    learned from the

    Father, comes to

    Me.

    …Everyone who 

    has heard and

    learned from the

    father comes to

    me…

    John 8:34

    aṗekri/qhau˙toivß

    o ̊İhsouvß: aṁh\naṁh\n le/gw um̊ivn

    o¢ti pavß o  ̊poiwvn th\n

    a˚mari/andouvlo/ß e˙stin

    thvß am̊arti/aß. 

    Jesus answered

    them, Verily,

    verily, I say unto

    you, Whosoever 

    committeth sin is

    the servant of sin. 

    Jesus replied, “I

    tell you the truth,

    everyone who 

    sins is a slave to

    sin.

    Jesus answered

    them, “Truly,

    truly, I say to you,

    everyone who 

    commits sin is the

    slave of sin.

    Jesus answered

    them, “Truly,

    truly, I say to you,

    everyone who 

    commits sin is a

    slave to sin.

    John 11:26

    kai\ pavß o  ̊zwvnkai\ pisteu/wn

    And whosoever 

    liveth and

    …and whoever 

    lives and believes

    …and everyone

    who lives and

    …and everyone

    who lives and

  • 8/9/2019 pas ho in John 3:16 as Proof of Particular Redemption

    6/18

    eiß̇ eṁe\ ou˙ mh\ aṗoqa/nhˆ eiß̇to\n aiẇvna. …

     believeth in me

    shall never die. … in me will never

    die. …

     believes in Me

    will never die. …

     believes in me

    shall never die. …

    John 12:46

    eġw\ fwvß eiß̇ to\nko/smonel̇h/luqa, i¢na

    pavß o  ̊pisteu/wn eiß̇

    eṁe\ eṅ thv   ̂skoti/aˆ mh\ 

    mei/nhˆ. 

    I am come a lightinto the world,

    that whosoever 

     believeth on me

    should not abide

    in darkness. 

    I have come intothe world as a

    light, so that no

    one who believes

    in me should stay

    in darkness.

    I have come as Light into the

    world, so that

    everyone who

     believes in Me

    will not remain in

    darkness.

    I have come intothe world as light,

    so that whoever 

     believes in me

    may not remain in

    darkness.

    John 16:2

    a˙posunagw/goußpoih/sousinu˚mavß: al̇l’

    e¡rcetai w¢ra i¢napavß o˚ 

    aṗoktei/naßum̊avß do/xhlatrei÷an

    prosfe/rein twv   ̂qewv  .̂ 

    They shall put

    you out of the

    synagogues: yea,the time cometh,

    that whosoever 

    killeth you will

    think that he

    doeth God

    service. 

    They will put you

    out of the

    synagogue; infact, a time is

    coming when

    anyone who kills

    you will think he

    is offering a

    service to God.

    They will make

    you outcasts from

    the synagogue, but an hour is

    coming for

    everyone who 

    kills you to think

    that he is offering

    service to God.

    They will put you

    out of the

    synagogues.Indeed, the hour

    is coming when

    whoever kills you

    will think he is

    offering service to

    God.

    John 17:2

    kaqw\ß e¡dwkaßau˙twv   ̂eẋousi/anpa/shß sarko/ß,

    i¢na pavn o§ de/dwkaß auṫwv   ̂dw/shˆ au˙toivßzwh\n aiẇnion. 

    As thou hast

    given him power

    over all flesh, that

    he should giveeternal life to as

    many as thou hast

    given him. 

    For you granted

    him authority

    over all people

    that he might giveeternal life to all

    those you have

    given him.

    …even as You

    gave Him

    authority over all

    flesh, that to allwhom You have

    given Him, He

    may give eternal

    life.

    …since you have

    given him

    authority over all

    flesh, to giveeternal life to all

    whom you have

    given him.

    John 18:37

    pavß o  ̊w£n ek̇thvß al̇hqei/aß

    ak̇ou/ei mou thvßfwnhvß. 

    Every one that is

    of the truth

    heareth my voice. 

    Everyone on the

    side of truth

    listens to me.”

    Everyone who is

    of the truth hears

    My voice.

    Everyone who is

    of the truth listens

    to my voice.”

    Acts 13:39

    e˙n tou/twˆ pavß o  ̊pisteu/wn

    dikaiouvtai. 

    And by him all

    that believe are

     justified… 

    Through him

    everyone who 

     believes is

     justified …

    …and through

    Him everyone

    who believes is

    freed…

    …and by him

    everyone who

     believes is

    freed…

    Rom 2:1

    Dio\ a˙napolo/ghtoßei™, w™ a¡nqrwpepavß o  ̊kri/nwn: 

    Therefore thou art

    inexcusable, O

    man, whosoever 

    thou art that

     judgest: 

    You, therefore,

    have no excuse,

    you who pass

     judgment on

    someone else…

    Therefore you

    have no excuse,

    everyone of you 

    who passes

     judgment…

    Therefore you

    have no excuse, O

    man, every one of

    you who judges.

  • 8/9/2019 pas ho in John 3:16 as Proof of Particular Redemption

    7/18

    Rom 10:11

    le/gei ga\r h˚ grafh/:pa               !ß o  ̊pisteu/wn

    eṗ’ auṫwv   ̂ou˙ kataiscunqh/setai. 

    For the scripture

    saith,

    Whosoever 

     believeth on him

    shall not beashamed. 

    As the Scripture

    says, “Anyone

    who trusts in

    him will never

     be put toshame.”

    For the Scripture

    says,

    “WHOEVER  

    BELIEVES IN

    HIM WILL NOTBE

    DISAPPOINTED.”

    For the Scripture

    says, “Everyone

    who believes in

    him will not be

     put to shame.”

    Gal 3:13

    …eṗikata/ratoß,pavß o˚ 

    krema/menoß eṗi\ xu/lou, 

    …Cursed is every

    one that hangeth

    on a tree: 

    … “Cursed is

    everyone who is

    hung on a tree.”

    … “CURSED IS

    EVERYONE

    WHO HANGS

    ON A TREE” —

    … “Cursed is

    everyone who is

    hanged on a

    tree”-…

    2 Tim 2:19

    … a˙posth/twaṗo\ a˙diki/aß

    pavß o  ̊o˙noma/zwn to\ o¡noma kuri/ou. 

    … Let every onethat nameth the

    name of Christ

    depart from

    iniquity.

    … “Everyonewho confesses the

    name of the Lord

    must turn away

    from

    wickedness.”

    … “Everyonewho names the

    name of the Lord

    is to abstain from

    wickedness.

    … “Let everyonewho names the

    name of the Lord

    depart from

    iniquity.”

    1 Jn 2:23

    pavß o˚ a˙rnou/menoß to\nuio̊\n ouḋe\ to\npate/ra e¡cei…

    Whosoever 

    denieth the Son,

    the same hath not

    the Father… 

    No one who 

    denies the Son has

    the Father…

    Whoever denies

    the Son does not

    have the Father…

    No one who 

    denies the Son has

    the Father…

    1 Jn 2:29

    … pavß o˚ poiwvnth\n

    dikaiosu/nhn eẋau˙touv 

    gege/nnhtai. 

    … every one that 

    doeth

    righteousness is

     born of him. 

    …everyone who 

    does what is right

    has been born of

    him.

    … everyone also

    who practices

    righteousness is

     born of Him.

    … everyone who 

     practices

    righteousness has

     been born of him.

    1 Jn 3:3

    kai\ pavß o  ̊e¡cwnth\n e˙lpi÷da

    tau÷thn eṗ! au˙twv   ̂ag̊ni/zei

    eåuto/n, kaqw\ße˙keivnoß ag̊no/ß

    eṡtin.

    Whosoever 

    committeth sin

    transgresseth also

    the law: for sin is

    the transgression

    of the law.

    Everyone who 

    has this hope in

    him purifies

    himself, just as he

    is pure.

    And everyone

    who has this hope 

     fixed  on Him

     purifies himself,

     just as He is pure.

    And everyone

    who thus hopes in

    him purifies

    himself as he is

     pure.

    1 Jn 3:4

    Pavß o˚ poiwvnth\n a˚marti/an

    kai\ th\naṅomi/anpoieiv…

    Whosoever 

    committeth sin

    transgresseth also

    the law… 

    Everyone who 

    sins breaks the

    law…

    Everyone who 

     practices sin also

     practices

    lawlessness…

    Everyone who 

    makes a practice

    of sinning also

     practices

    lawlessness…

    1 Jn 3:6

  • 8/9/2019 pas ho in John 3:16 as Proof of Particular Redemption

    8/18

     

    pavß o  ̊eṅ auṫwv   ̂me/nwn ouċ

    a˚marta/nei: pavßo  ̊am̊arta/nwnou˙c e˚w/rraken

    au˙to\n ouḋe\ e¡gnwken auṫo/n.

    Whosoever 

    abideth in him

    sinneth not:

    whosoever 

    sinneth hath not

    seen him, neitherknown him.

    No one who lives

    in him keeps on

    sinning. No one

    who continues to

    sin has either seen

    him or knownhim.

    No one who 

    abides in Him

    sins; no one who 

    sins has seen Him

    or knows Him.

    No one who 

    abides in him

    keeps on sinning;

    no one who keeps

    on sinning has

    either seen him orknown him.

    1 Jn 3:9

    Pavß o˚ gegennhme/noßek̇ touv qeouv a˚marti/an ou ̇

    poieiv…

    Whosoever is

     born of God doth

    not commit sin… 

    No one who is

     born of God will

    continue to sin…

    No one who is

     born of God

     practices sin…

    No one born of

    God makes a

     practice of

    sinning…

    1 Jn 3:15

    pavß o  ̊miswvnto\n a˙delfo\nau˙touv 

    aṅqrwpokto/noßeṡti/n… 

    Whosoever hateth his brother

    is a murderer…

    Everyone whohates his brother

    is a murderer…

    Everyone who hates his brother

    is a murderer…

    Anyone who hates his brother

    is a murderer…

    1 Jn 4:7

    …kai\ pavß o˚ a˙gapwvn e˙k touv 

    qeouv gege/nnhtai kai\ ginw/skei to\n

    qeo/n.

    …and every one

    that loveth is

     born of God, and

    knoweth God.

    …Everyone who 

    loves has been

     born of God and

    knows God.

    …and everyone

    who loves is born

    of God and knows

    God.

    …and whoever 

    loves has been

     born of God and

    knows God.

    1 Jn 5:1

    Pavß o  ̊pisteu/wn o¢ti

    !Ihsouvß eṡtin o ̊Cpristo\ß, ek̇

    touv qeouv gege/nnhtai, kai\ pavß o  ̊aġapwvn

    to\ngennh/santaaġapav ø [kai\]

    to\ngegennhme/non

    eẋ auṫouv. 

    Whosoever 

     believeth that

    Jesus is the Christ

    is born of God:

    and every one

    that loveth him

    that begat loveth

    him also that is

     begotten of him. 

    Everyone who 

     believes that Jesus

    is the Christ is

     born of God, and

    everyone who 

    loves the father

    loves his child as

    well.

    Whoever believes

    that Jesus is the

    Christ is born of

    God, and

    whoever loves

    the Father loves

    the child born of

    Him.

    Everyone who 

     believes that Jesus

    is the Christ has

     been born of God

    and everyone

    who loves the

    Father loves

    whoever has been

     born of him.

    1 Jn 5:18

    Oi¡damen o¢tipavß o  ̊

    gegennhme/noßek̇ touv qeouv 

    ou˙cam̊arta/nei… 

    We know that

    whosoever is

     born of God

    sinneth not…

    We know that

    anyone born of

    God does not

    continue to sin…

    We know that no

    one who is born

    of God sins…

    We know that

    everyone who 

    has been born of

    God does not

    keep on sinning…

    2 Jn 9

  • 8/9/2019 pas ho in John 3:16 as Proof of Particular Redemption

    9/18

    Pavß o˚ proa/gwnkai\ me\ me/nwn eṅthv   ̂didachv   ̂touv Cristou        " qeo\n

    ou˙k e¡cei. 

    Whosoever 

    transgresseth, and

    abideth not in the

    doctrine of Christ,

    hath not God.

    Anyone who runs

    ahead and does

    not continue in

    the teaching of

    Christ does not

    have God.

    Anyone who goes

    too far and does

    not abide in the

    teaching of Christ,

    does not have

    God.

    Everyone who 

    goes on ahead and

    does not abide in

    the teaching of

    Christ, does not

    have God.

    Even a cursory reading of the above list will alert the reader to the wide swath

    of interpretations that have been offered for the exact same construction in the Greek

    text. The most shocking part is that each Bible version is largely consistent with one

    interpretation. The most common interpretation for pavß o ̊in the KJV is “whosoever,”used 27 times, and from this we can assume that for the translators of the KJV,

    “whosoever” was the most appropriate translation at that period of time. The NIV,

     NASB, and ESV each have the highest uses of “everyone who,” used 20, 27, and 27

    times respectively. One immediately begins to question why so many varying

    translations exist- 17 total translations plus variants of each- when it is apparent that

    the translators see at least some need for consistency- a consistency not found in thetranslation “whoever.” On the other hand, “whoever,” was only used by the NIV

    twice, the NASB 7 times, the ESV 4 times, and in these uses, only 3 times is

    “whoever” used in a non-salvific context; once in the NASB at 1 John 2:23, and twice

    in the ESV at John 16:2 and 1 Jn 4:7. “Whoever” is evidently not  the preferred

    translation of pavß o.̊ It also seems that its usage is intentional in salvific contexts,and that there is an adherence to unnecessary translational traditions in those contexts

    against the preferred consistent translation.

    Even more stunning is seeing the changes in translation of the same phrase.

    Pavß o ̊gegennhme/noß is used only 3 times in scripture, and yet has 8 differenttranslations between the four versions, none showing any consistency in translation.

    Pavß o ̊pisteu/wn is used 6 times, and has 6 different translations, though they doshow consistency. This many variant translations is entirely unnecessary, as all the

     passages together are capable of being translated consistently, as will be presently

    shown.

    Following is another table, similar to the above, containing each verse in

    question. The Greek text is given, followed by a rigid translation, and then the

    author’s suggestion according to a consistent translation of the whole.

    Matt 5:22

    Greek (NA27) Rigid Suggested

    eġw\ de\ le/gw um̊ivn o¢ti pavß o˚ oṙgizo/menoß twv   ̂a˙delfwv   ̂au˙touv e¡noxoß e¡stai thv   ̂

    kri/se˙i\...

    But I say that all those being

    angry with their brother, he is

    guilty with the judgment…

    But I say that everyone that is

    angry with their brother is guilty

     before the court…

    Matt 5:28

    eġw\ de\ le/gw um̊ivn o¢ti pavß o˚ ble/pwn gunaivka pro\ß to\ 

    eṗiqumhvtai auṫh\n h¡dheṁoi/xeusen auṫh\n eṅ thv   ̂

    kardi/a auṫouv. 

    But I say to you that all those 

    looking at a woman with desire

    for her has now committedadultery with her in his heart.

    But I say to you that everyone

    that looks at a woman with lust

    for her has already committedadultery with her in his heart.

  • 8/9/2019 pas ho in John 3:16 as Proof of Particular Redemption

    10/18

     

    Matt 5:32

    eġw\ de\ le/gw um̊ivn o¢ti pavß o  ̊aṗolu/wn th\n gunaivkaau˙touv parekto\ß lo/gou

    pornei/aß poieiv au˙th\nmoiceuqhvnai…

    But I say to you that all those 

    sending away their woman,

    except for the reason of

    immorality, makes her commit

    adultery…

    But I say to you that everyone

    that divorces his wife, except

    for immorality, causes her to

    commit adultery…

    Matt 7:21

    Ou˙ pavß o  ̊le/gwn moi: ku/rieku/rie, eiṡeleu/setai eiß̇ th\nbasilei/an twvn ouṙanwvn…

     Not all those saying to me:

    Lord, Lord, will enter into the

    kingdom of heaven…

     Not everyone that says to me,

    “Lord, Lord,” will enter the

    kingdom of heaven.

    Matt 7:26

    Kai\ pavß o˚ ak̇ou/wn moutou\ß lo/gouß tou/touß kai\ 

    mh\ poiwvn auṫou\ßo˚moiwqh/setai aṅdri\ mwrwv  ,̂o¢stiß w˙  k̂odo\mhsen auṫouv 

    te/n oik̇i/an eṗi\ th\n a£mmon…

    And all those hearing these

    words of mine and not doing

    them, will be like a foolish man,

    who built his house upon the

    sand.

    And everyone that hears these

    words of mine and does not do

    them will be like a foolish man,

    who built his house on the sand.

    Luke 6:47

    Pavß o˚ eṙco/menoß pro/ß mekai\ a˙kou/wn mou twvn

    lo/gown kai\ poiwvn auṫou/ /ß,up̊owdei/xw um̊ivn ti/ni eṡti\n

    om̊oioß…

    All those coming to me and

    hearing my words and doing

    them, I will show you what he is

    like…

    Everyone that comes to me and

    hears my words and does them,

    I will show you what he is

    like…

    Luke 14:11

    o¢ti pavß o  ̊u˚ywvn eåuto\ntapeinwqh/setai…

    For all those exalting himself

    will be humbled…

    For everyone that exalts

    himself will be humbled…

    Luke 16:18

    Pavß o˚ aṗolu/wn th\ngunaivka auṫouv kai\ gamwvn

    et̊e/ran moiceu/ei…

    All those putting away their

    woman and marrying another

    commits adultery…

    Everyone that divorces his wife

    and marries another commits

    adultery…

    Luke 18:14

    …o¢ti pavß o˚ u˚ywvn eåuto\ntapeinwqh/setai…

    …for all those exalting himself

    will be humbled…

    …for everyone that exalts

    himself will be humbled…

    Luke 20:18

    pavß o˚ pesw\n e˙p’ ek̇eivnon

    to\n li/qonsunqlasqh/setai…

    All those falling upon that stone

    will be broken…

    Everyone that falls upon that

    stone shall be shattered…

  • 8/9/2019 pas ho in John 3:16 as Proof of Particular Redemption

    11/18

     

    John 3:8

    to\ pneuvma o¢pou qe/lei pneiv kai\ th\n qwnh\n auṫouv 

    ak̇ou/eiß, al̇l! ou˙k oi™daß

    po/qen e¡rcetai kai\ pouv u˚pa/gei: ou¢twß eṡti\n pavß o  ̊gegennhme/noß ek̇ touv 

    pneu/matoß. 

    The wind blows where it wills

    and you hear the sound of it, but

    you do not know where it comes

    and where it goes; in this way isall those already born of the

    Spirit.

    The wind blows where it wills

    and though you hear its sound,

    you do not know from where it

    comes or to where it goes; so itis with everyone that is born of

    the Spirit.

    John 3:15

    i¢na pavß o˚ pisteu/wn eṅau˙twv   ̂e¡chˆ zwh\n aiẇ/nion. 

    In order that all those believing

    in him might have life

    everlasting.

    …so that everyone that 

     believes in him might have

    eternal life.

    John 3:16

    ou¢twß ga\r h˙ga/phsen o ̊qeo\ßto\n ko/smon, w¢ste to\n u˚io\nto\n monogenhv e¡dwken, i¢napavß o  ̊pisteu/wn eiß̇ auṫo\nmh\ a˙po/lhtai al̇l’ e¡chˆ zwh/n

    aiẇ/nion. 

    For in this way God loved the

    world, that he gave the Son, the

    unique one, so that all those 

     believing in him might not be

    destroyed but have life

    everlasting.

    For in this way God so loved the

    world, that he gave his unique

    Son, so that everyone that 

     believes in him might not

     perish, but have everlasting life.

    John 4:13

    aṗekri/qh ˙Ihsouvß kai\ ei™pen

    au˙th        "

      :̂ pavß o  ̊pi/nwn ek̇ touv u¢datoß tou/tou diyh/seipa/lin: 

    Jesus answered and said to her,

    “All those drinking from thiswater will thirst again.”

    Jesus said to her, “Everyone

    that drinks this water will thirstagain.”

    John 6:37

    pavn o§ di/dwsi/n moi o ̊path\rpro\ß eṁe\ h¢xei…

    All those the Father has given

    me, to me he will come…

    Everyone given to me by the

    Father will come to me…

    John 6:39

    touvto de/ eṡtin to\ qe/lhmatouv pe/myanto/ß me, i¢na pavno  § de/dwke/n moi mh\ aṗole/sweẋ auṫouv, a˙lla\ aṅasth/swau˙to\ [e˙n] thv   ̂eṡca/thˆ h˚me/ra. 

    And this is the will of he whosent me, that all those given me

    from him, I might not lose, but

    raise it up on the last day.

     Now this is the will of the onewho sent me, that everyone 

    given to me I should lose none

    of it, but raise it up on the last

    day.

    John 6:40

    touvto ga/r e˙stin to\ qe/lematouv patro/ß mou, i¢na pavß o  ̊

    qeorwvn to\n uio̊\n kai\ pisteu/wn eiß̇ auṫo\n e¡chˆ 

    zwh\n aiẇ/nion…

    For this is the will of my father,

    that all those seeing the son and

     believing on him might have life

    unending…

    For this is the will of my Father,

    that everyone that sees the son

    and believes on him might have

    everlasting life…

  • 8/9/2019 pas ho in John 3:16 as Proof of Particular Redemption

    12/18

     

    John 6:45

    …pavß o  ̊ak̇ou/saß para\ touv patro\ß kai\ maqw\n e¡rcetai

    pro\ß e˙me/. 

    …all those heard from the

    father and learned comes to

    me…

    Everyone that has heard and

    has learned from the Father

    comes to me…

    John 8:34

    …aṁh\n a˙mh\n le/gw um̊ivn o¢tipavß o  ̊poiwvn th\n a˚mari/an

    douvlo/ß e˙stin thvß a˚marti/aß. 

    “Truly, truly, I say to you, that

    all those doing sin is a slave to

    sin.”

    “Truly, truly, I say to you, that

    everyone that sins is its slave.”

    John 11:26

    kai\ pavß o  ̊zwvn kai\ pisteu/wn eiß̇ eṁe\ ou˙ mh\ 

    aṗoqa/nhˆ eiß̇ to\n aiẇvna…

    And all those living and

     believing in me will with

    absolute certainty not dieforever…

    And everyone that lives and

     believes in me will certainly

    never die…

    John 12:46

    eġw\ fwvß eiß̇ to\n ko/smonel̇h/luqa, i¢na pavß o  ̊

    pisteu/wn eiß̇ eṁe\ eṅ thv   ̂skoti/a ̂mh\ mei/nhˆ. 

    I came as light into the world,

    that all those believing in me

    might not remain in darkness.

    I have come as light into the

    world, that everyone that 

     believes in me might not remain

    in darkness.

    John 16:2

    aṗosunagw/goußpoih/sousin um̊avß: al̇l’e¡rcetai w¢ra i¢na pavß o˚ aṗoktei/naß um̊avß dw/shlatrei÷an prosfe/rein twv   ̂

    qewv  .̂ 

    They will make you apart from

    the synagogue, but the hour is

    coming that all those killing

    you will think they are offering

    service to God.

    They will banish you from the

    synagogue, but the hour is

    coming that everyone that kills

    you will think they are offering

    service to God.

    John 17:2

    kaqw\ß e¡dwkaß au˙twv   ̂eẋousi/an pa/shß sarko/ß,

    i¢na pavn o§ de/dwkaß auṫwv   ̂dw/shˆ au˙toivß zwh\n aiẇnion. 

    Inasmuch as you gave him

    authority over all flesh, that all

    those given to him he mightgive to them life unending.

    Just as you gave him authority

    over all flesh, that to everyone

    that you have given to him hemight give them everlasting life.

    John 18:37

    …pavß o  ̊w£n ek̇ thvßal̇hqei/aß ak̇ou/ei mou thvß

    fwnhvß. 

    …all those being of the truth

    hear my voice.

    …everyone that is of the truth

    hears my voice.

    Acts 13:39

    eṅ tou/tw ̂pavß o  ̊pisteu/wndikaiouvtai. 

    In him all those believing are

     justified…

    By him everyone that believes

    is justified.

  • 8/9/2019 pas ho in John 3:16 as Proof of Particular Redemption

    13/18

     

    Rom 2:1

    Dio\ aṅapolo/ghtoß ei™, w™ a¡nqrwpe pavß o  ̊kri/nwn…

    Therefore you are without

    apology, O man, all those 

     judging…

    Therefore you have no excuse,

    O man, everyone that passes

     judgment…

    Rom 10:11

    le/gei ga\r h˚ grafh/: pa               !ß o  ̊pisteu/wn eṗ’ auṫwv   ̂ou˙ kataiscunqh/setai. 

    For the Scripture says, “All

    those believing in him shall not

     be dishonored.”

    For the Scripture says,

    “Everyone that believes in him

    shall not be put to shame.”

    Gal 3:13

    eṗikata/ratoß, pavß o˚ 

    krema/menoß eṗi\ xu/lou…Cursed are all those hanging on

    a tree…

    Cursed is everyone that hangs

    on a tree…

    2 Tim 2:19

    a˙posth/tw aṗo\ aḋiki/aß pavßo  ̊o˙noma/zwn to\ o¡noma

    kuri/ou. 

    Depart from unrighteousness,

    all those naming the name of

    the Lord.

    Depart from unrighteousness,

    everyone that names the name

    of the Lord.

    1 Jn 2:23

    pavß o˚ aṙnou/menoß to\n uio̊\nou˙de\ to\n pate/ra e¡cei, 

    All those denying the son,

    neither does he have the father.

    Everyone that denies the Son

    does not have the Father either.

    1 Jn 2:29

    …pavß o˚ poiwvn th\ndikaiosu/nhn eẋ auṫouv 

    gege/nnhtai 

    …all those doing righteousness

    has been born of him.

    …everyone that practices

    righteousness has been born of

    him.

    1 Jn 3:3

    kai\ pavß o  ̊e¡cwn th\n e˙lpi÷da

    tau÷thn eṗ!

     au˙twv   ̂a˚gni/zeie˚auto/n, kaqw\ß ek̇eivnoßa˚gno/ß eṡtin. 

    And all those having this hope

    in him purifies himself, just ashe is pure.

    And everyone that has this

    hope in him purifies himself,even as he is pure.

    1 Jn 3:4

    Pavß o˚ poiwvn th\n a˚marti/ankai\ th\n a˙nomi/an poieiv, kai\ h˚ am̊arti/a eṡti\n h˚ a˙nomi/a. 

    All those doing sin even does

    lawlessness, and sin is

    lawlessness.

    Everyone that practices sin also

     practices lawlessness, for sin is

    lawlessness.

    1 Jn 3:6

  • 8/9/2019 pas ho in John 3:16 as Proof of Particular Redemption

    14/18

    pavß o  ̊eṅ auṫwv   ̂me/nwn6 ou˙cam̊arta/nei: pavß o  ̊

    am̊arta/nwn ouċ e˚w/rrakenau˙to\n ouḋe\ e¡gnwken auṫo/n. 

    All those remaining in him do

    not sin, all those sinning has not

    seen him, neither has he known

    him.

    Everyone that remains in him

    does not sin; everyone that sins

    continually has not seen him,

    nor has he known him.

    1 Jn 3:9

    Pavß o˚ gegennhme/noß ek̇ touv qeouv am̊arti/an ou ̇poieiv, 

    All those already born of God,

    does not do sin…

    Everyone that has been born of

    God does not practice sin…

    1 Jn 3:15

    pavß o  ̊miswvn to\n a˙delfo\nau˙touv aṅqrwpokto/noß

    eṡti/n…

    All those hating his brother is a

    murderer.

    Everyone that hates his brother

    is a murderer.

    1 Jn 4:7

    …kai\ pavß o˚ aġapwvn e˙k touv qeouv gege/nnhtai kai\ ginw/skei to\n qeo/n. 

    …and all those loving have

     been born of God and knows

    God.

    …and everyone that loves has

     been born of God and knows

    God.

    1 Jn 5:1

    Pavß o  ̊pisteu/wn o¢ti!Ihsouvß eṡtin o ̊Cristo\ß, ek̇touv qeouv gege/nnhtai, kai\ 

    pavß o  ̊aġapwvn to\ngennh/santa aġapav ø [kai\]

    to\n gegennhme/non eẋ auṫouv. 

    All those believing that Jesus is

    the Christ, is born of God, and

    all those loving the one bearing

    [also] love the one born of him.

    Everyone that believes that

    Jesus is the Christ, is born of

    God; and everyone that loves

    the Father loves those born of

    him.

    1 Jn 5:18

    Oi¡damen o¢ti pavß o  ̊gegennhme/noß ek̇ touv qeouv 

    ou˙c a˚marta/nei…

    We know that all those born of

    God do not sin…

    We know that everyone that 

    has been born of God does not

    sin…

    2 Jn 9

    Pavß o˚ proa/gwn kai\ me\ 

    me/nwn eṅ thv   ̂didachv   ̂touv Cristou        " qeo\n ouk̇ e¡cei.

    All those going ahead and not

    remaining in the teaching ofChrist does not have God.

    Everyone that goes ahead and

    does not remain in the teachingof Christ does not have God.

    At this point it is the author’s belief that his point has been proven; every use

    of pavß o ̊+ verb may be translated in a way that is consistent with all other uses. Thetranslations suggested are fluid, and consistent with not only the Greek, but also with

    the other Bible versions for fluid transition from version to version. The most

    important point is this: all connotations brought on by the more traditional English

    renderings have evaporated. The more consistent translation has provided neutrality in

    6 me/nwn is in boldface to show that it belongs to the construction, though it is separated by eṅ auṫwv  .̂ 

  • 8/9/2019 pas ho in John 3:16 as Proof of Particular Redemption

    15/18

    regards to the origin of the condition, effectively avoiding eisegetical importations to

    the English rendering.

    In conclusion to the first part of this study, the word “whosoever,” or

    “whoever,” is unwarranted in any modern translation. It imports a foreign thought

    into the construction and should be translated in a way that is consistent with its otheroccurrences. In the case of John 3:16, the “offer” of salvation to “whoever believes”

    is an eisegetical import not supported by the Greek. Instead, John 3:16 is neutral

    regarding the cause of belief- it simply does not state why one believes. In the nextsection, the author will attempt to prove a rule concerning the usage of pavß o ̊+ verb,and demonstrate that through this rule the cause of belief in John 3:16 may be

    ascertained.

    Part 2: Identifying a Rule Concerning the Use of pavß o ̊+ Verb and the Argument forParticular Redemption

    After proving that it is possible to consistently translate the pavß o ̊+ verbconstruction, the most obvious question is, “To what end?” What is the purpose ofretranslating some of the Bible’s most well known passages? The purpose is simple:

     by removing a connotation that is not truly present, the true purpose of theconstruction may be demonstrated. Each author makes use of pavß o ̊+ verb todemonstrate that if a certain condition exists (independent of the cause of the

    condition), then a certain outcome will occur, or is occurring. The next table will

    demonstrate this.

    Verse If Then

    Matt 5:22 Angry with your brother Guilty before the court

    Matt 5:28 Looking at a woman with lust Has committed adultery

    Matt 5:32 Divorces wife Makes her commit adultery

    Matt 7:21 Saying “Lord, Lord” (but not

    doing his will)

    Will not enter the kingdom of

    heaven

    Matt 7:26 Hearing my words but not doing

    them

    Will be like a foolish man

    Luke 6:47 Coming to me and hearing my

    words

    Builds his house on bedrock

    (v48)

    Luke 14:11 Exalts himself Will be humbled

    Luke 16:18 Divorces wife and marries

    another

    Commits adultery

    Luke 18:14 Exalts himself Will be humbled

    Luke 20:18 Falling on that stone Will be shattered

    John 3:8 Born of the Spirit Is like the wind

    John 3:15 Believing on Him Has eternal life

    John 3:16 Believing on Him Shall not perish; have eternal

    life

    John 4:13 Drinks of this water Will thirst again

    John 6:37 Given by the Father Will come to ChristJohn 6:39 Given by Father to Christ Christ will not lose (any); he

  • 8/9/2019 pas ho in John 3:16 as Proof of Particular Redemption

    16/18

    will raise it up on the last day

    John 6:40 Looking and believing on Christ Will have eternal life

    John 6:45 Heard and learned of the Father Comes to Christ

    John 8:34 Sin Is slave to sin

    John 11:26 Lives and believes in Christ Will never die

    John 12:46 Believes in Christ Will not remain in darkness

    John 16:2 Kills you Will think they are offering aservice to God

    John 17:2 Given by God to Christ Christ gives eternal life

    John 18:37 Of the truth Hears the voice of Christ

    Acts 13:39 Believes Justified

    Rom 2:1 Passing judgment Has no excuse

    Rom 10:11 Believes Will not be disappointed

    Gal 3:13 Hangs on a tree Is cursed

    2 Tim 2:197  Names the name of the Lord Depart from unrighteousness!

    1 John 2:23 Denies the Son Does not have the Father

    1 John 2:29 Practices righteousness Is born of the Father

    1 John 3:3 Has this hope (that we will be

    like him, v2)

    Purifies himself

    1 John 3:4 Practices sin Practices lawlessness

    1 John 3:6a Abiding in him Does not sin

    1 John 3:6b Sinning Has not seen him and does not

    know him

    1 John 3:9 Born of God Does not practice sin

    1 John 3:15 Hates his brother Is a murderer

    1 John 4:7 Loving Is born of God

    1 John 5:1 Believing that Jesus is the Christ Is born of God

    1 John 5:18 Born of God Does not sin

    2 John 9 Does not abide in the teaching Does not have God

    The author believes he has identified an exegetical rule: In every instance that

    pavß o ̊+ verb is used, it occurs within a conditional statement. By conditional, theauthor is not in any way insinuating that the “if” is conditioned upon the individual

    who is taking part in the action of the verb; rather, in a neutral fashion, the authors are

    simply stating that when the condition is met, the effect is definitely applied.

    This brings a whole new emphasis to John 3:16 apart from the repeated

    unlimited atonement emphasis on “whosoever.” The emphasis turns from an offer  into

    a promise- those believing on him will  have eternal life. Everlasting life is the effectof believing; it will certainly occur. Upon this fact can every Christian in every place

    and at every time place the full of his or her hope. The Unique One of God was sent

     by the Father not to make salvation an offer that may or may not be accepteddepending upon the free will choice of every individual at all times and at all places,

     but to secure salvation for a certain people- those that believe. But what is that belief

    contingent upon?

    Based on the conclusion above, that pavß o ̊+ verb is always includes aconditional statement, we can find the answer for the question of the cause of belief in

    John 3:16 within the table above. There is a string of pavß o ̊+ verb passages in John

    7

     This may be the only exception, as it is the only example where the effect appears in the imperative.Yet, it can still be understood in the prescribed notion if it is understood that Paul’s command

    definitely applies to those “naming the name.” The author believes his conclusion stands. 

  • 8/9/2019 pas ho in John 3:16 as Proof of Particular Redemption

    17/18

    6 there are indications that God himself is the cause of each respective effect. This

    fact makes it certain that the only acceptable cause for belief is God himself.

    In John 6:36, Jesus addresses the crowd at the Sea of Galilee in regards to

    their disbelief. Why do they not believe? The answer is found in the first of four pavßo ̊+ verb passages. In verse 37, Christ states why they do not believe: “Everyone

    given [pavn o ̊de/dwke/n] to me by the Father will come to me…” The plain meaningof the conditional factor here is that the primary reason one will come to Christ is

     because the Father has given that one to Christ. The only argument against thisinterpretation is to say that there may be some who come to Christ that are not given

     by the Father, which is preposterous. The argument that being given by the Father isfirst conditioned upon the free will choice of the moral agent is to turn the conditional

    construction exactly backwards, and is an argument even more devoid of value than

    the previous argument. The only way one can come to the Father is by being given to

    Christ by the Father first. Verse 65 makes this explicit, “And he was saying, ‘For this

    reason I said to you that no one is able to come to me unless it is given him from the

    Father.’”

    The next occurrence is in verse 39, “Now this is the will of the one who sentme, that everyone given [pavn o ̊de/dwke/n] to me I should lose none of it, but raisehim up on the last day.” The latter promise here has a parallel in verse 40, “For this isthe will of my Father, that everyone that sees [pavß o ̊qewrw/n] the Son and believes[kai\ pisteu/wn] on him might have eternal life, and I will raise him up on the lastday,” and 44, “No one is able to come to me unless the Father who sent me draws

    him, and I will raise him up on the last day.” Every one of these passages refers to the

    same group, that is, those that are raised up on the last day, the day when the dead inChrist will rise again (John 11:24). There will not be any person who will be raised up

    “on the last day” who does not fit all three conditions. Once again, coming to Christin faith is conditioned upon action by the Father.

    The final occurrence is in verse 45, “It is written in the prophets: ‘And theyshall all be taught of God.’ Everyone that has heard [pavß o ̊ak̇ou/saß] and haslearned [kai\ maqw\n] from the Father comes to me.” It has already been establishedthat those being raised up on the last day are given by the Father, and come to Christ.

    Coming to Christ is a condition for being raised up. Therefore, in verse 45 we must

    accept that the “they” are the same individuals in the previous passages because

    “comes” in verse 45 corresponds with “to come” in verse 44, making “comes” in

    verse 45 contingent upon being drawn by the Father. Those who have “heard and

    learned” are the same as those that have been drawn and given by the Father.

    In John 3:16, it is said that the Monogenes was sent to give eternal life to those

    that believe in him. It has been established that coming to Christ is conditioned upon

     being given to Christ by the Father. In John 6:40 the same idea as in John 3:16 isexpressed in nearly the exact same language:

    3:16- i¢na pavß o  ̊ pisteu/wn eiß̇ auṫo\n 6:40- i¢na pavß o  ̊qeorwvn to\n uio̊\n kai\ pisteu/wn8 eiß̇ auṫo\n 

    8

     Pavß o˚ does not occur with pisteu/wn in John 6:40, but should be supplied. kai\ connects pisteu/wn with qeorwvn, making the group of those believing the same as those seeing, and the Greek author(John) does not repeat pavß o˚ because it should be understood.

  • 8/9/2019 pas ho in John 3:16 as Proof of Particular Redemption

    18/18

    3:16-  mh\ aṗo/lhtai al̇l’ e¡ch ̂zwh/n aiẇ/nion. 6:40-  e¡ch ̂zwh\n aiẇ/nion 

    If in John 6:40, those receiving eternal life are raised up on the last day, and those

     believing on him in 3:16 also receive eternal life, and those raised up on the last day

    in 6:40 are the same group as those given by the Father to the Son in 6:37, 39 anddrawn by him in 6:44, then it is necessary to conclude that those believing in him in

    John 3:16 do so because they were first given to him and drawn by the Father.

    Therefore, it has been established that Christ came to save a particular people who

    were predetermined by the Father and given to Christ. Christ did not come to make

    salvation a possibility, but he came to “do the will of [the] Father,” which was to

    definitely save a particular people.

    In conclusion, we have established the following points:1.

      pavß o ̊+ verb constructions have been inconsistently translated in popularBible versions.

    2. 

    It is entirely possible to consistently translate pavß o ̊+ verb constructions.3.  A consistent translation of pavß o ̊+ verb constructions removes the “free

    will” connotation of “whoever” in John 3:16 and similar passages.

    4.  pavß o ̊+ verb constructions occur in conditional statements in every use.5.

     

    The pavß o ̊+ verb conditional statements in John 6 render aninterpretation of John 3:16 that defines the cause of believing as being

    given to Christ by the Father.