non~opa roga ~ a 3 a g . nocne nyrra, y MHor,?x R MMpe B O ~ H M K ~ ~ M ~ ~ I O ~ M R Toro, OlTO KOMMYHMCTML(~CKM~ C T P O ~ M ~0~af lMTap~bl f i !Jer(MM pa3pyWeH Be3fle. BKntO'iafl

;'OCCMK), ' iTO Kr6 nMKBMflMPOBaH, clTO nOCne CH;i;!fl,Q C nbeAeCTafla naMflTHMKa oe- nMKCy ~ ~ ~ ~ X M H C K O M Y 3Ta CTPylO)'Pa B npeXHe%C B1:'Ae yXe HMKOrAa He B03POflMT-

CR. Tenepb, BcTpeqaacb c 3 a n a ~ ~ b i ~ ~ ~O~M~VII;!.V~M, M ~ I B M ~ M M OnpeAeneHHym

paCTepflHHOCTb OT TOTO, clTO IlPOMCXOAMT. VYBC'YV"M MX nOflO3peHMfl B OTHOWeHMM

B03MOXHOCTM peanM3auMM H O ~ M ~ I ~ ~ H O ~ f l e ~ ~ i c p a i r l ' i e ~ ~ ~ i MOAenM 3AeCb B POC- CMM, OlUJl&3eM flOA03PWTenbHOCTb no OTHOWEHMO K POCCMM CO CTOPOHbl CTpaH

CHr M Boc~o.c~oi7 Esponb~. M H O ~ M ~ M3 HMX, Cnf ;.ijF 3a HaWMMM HauMOHan-flaTpH0-

TiiMM, HaLIMHaK)T 3aAaBaTbCR BOnpOCOM: a Moll -.? hb l~b Anfl POCCMM HyXHa KaKaR-

-10 APYrafl MOAenb AeMOKPaTMM, KaKaR-TO a3M. "':LiR MOAenb AeMOKPaTMM, COBMe-

CTKMaR C peIlpeCCMBHblMM CTPyKTyPaMM, C HE; ' . : ! 'O~MMPOB~HHI>IM Kr6, B claCTH0-

C ~ M ? f l nyMalo, \{TO 3 ~ a TeMa M ~ T M corntieHun ..r . ; :OTCR cepbe7~0i;l ~ P M C I M H O ~ nlln ilpMOCTaHosltb1 066uaHHl,lx 3anaAliblX KpefiMTOi3. r;:iTOpble T a K HYMHbl CerOnlifl l ia-- Ulei;l Tpati(;J~clp~~.lpyl~weG~n 3KOHOMMKe. KoHc~~H!:,, TO, qTO Mbl nePC.)l(L?BaeM MnM

fiomocbl 6 b 1 r 1 ~ nepewi-rt, nocne nyrcla. - t i ~ , i ~ i i npouecc ~ ~ K O M M ) I I { M ~ ~ L \ M M -

n o l l o 6 c ~ npoueccy ~ ~ ~ H ~ U L I ~ J M I ( ~ L ( M H u nocne-j, - . :t\oi;l Ccp~atirzfi. 3~1.1 npo\AeccL,\

ot-leHb ~ p y g ~ o p e a n ~ 3 o ~ a ~ b ~06po~or ' l l ,~o , noc~.::. ,ky H ~ U I Hapofi Ire npouen Ire- pe3 nepMOA nOKaRHMR nOCnf? RPMFITMR TOTanM .(f.'g,;.3Ma, M CKOpee paCnpOCTpaHeH0

ouyuetiue, r ~ o Bce 6 b l n ~ xeprsaMM p e x m a LY~~OMMCTP ropoda UJ~y-rrapi-a rocnoAMt: ?::wenb, C ~ I H M ~ B ~ C T H O ~ O Oenb.4-

MapUana P O M M ~ ~ R HeAaBHO nOKa3an MHe I ' 4MM MarMCTpaTa naMRTHMK 6e- 3blMflHHOMY aMePMKaHCKOMY o @ M ~ ~ ? P Y , o @ M ~ ' :KynaqMOHHblX B O ~ C K , KOTOPOMY

Tenepb B ~ ~ P M ~ H M M 6nar0flapHbl 3a nOMOLL(b I . . ~ ~ M @ M K ~ ~ M M M B YTBePXfleHMM

j[eMOKpaTMLieCKOrO PeXMMa, rlYCTb n0p0k UaW. -1OTMB BOnM TeX, KOMY AeMOKpa-

TMK) npMBMsanM. He HanoMMliaeT 1 . 1 ~ TO saM , .~III,HOCT~ B POCCMM s a n a ~ t ~ ~ ~ a

l l e ~ p a I, snporeM 6 o p o ~ u e r o c ~ c sapBapc > A , no BblpaxeHMto K.Map~ca,

((BapBapCKMMM MeTOAaMM),. Cero~Hf l YflMBIleHHble HaPOflbI 3anafla M r . : C O ~ C T B ~ H H ~ I ~ HaPOfl C HeRoy-

IgltiHMeM ~ i l ~ l l 1 0 ~ a l O ~ ~ ~ ~ e t l ~ i l d l y p ~ b l b ? peBaHLI . KdT 01 6b1~lo 3a8OeBdtitiblX

~ ~ O C T M X ~ H M ~ AeMOKpaTMM, a nMAepbl Kf lCC kl ((ec ~ ; Y W . ~ : I I ~ I \ U t j OI.PHAa)), nOllb-

3yflcb npeMMyuiecTsaMM rocnoAcTsa B npounoM nonomLiliiju. LIHMM~OT ceroBt-1H KntOLiC?Bble n03MIAMM M B 3KOHOMMKe, M B IlOIlMTMKe. CORC~II!CIIIIO CCTeCTBeHHO BO

Bcex upatlax, KoTopble nepexMBam HacneAMe ToTarlwTapHoro pexMMa B ~ o i HnM

M H O ~ @ O P M ~ BO3HMKlla MfleR H ~ O ~ X O ~ ~ M M O C T M nK)CTpauMM, Mnefl H ~ O ~ X O ~ ~ M M O C T M

npo@eccclo~anb~b~x o ~ p a ~ ~ . c e ~ ~ i Ann 6blelu~x amMBMcroe ToTanMTaptioro p e w - Ma.

f l e p ~ b r i ~ ~ K O H o g e c o s e s ~ 3 a q ~ ~ Bsena ~ M T B ~ , ewe B Maple 1990 rona cpa3y

nOCne nPMHflTMR aKTa 0 He3aBMCMMOCTM. BC ~ M T B ~ I CAellan COOTBeTCTByIOuee 3a-

RBneHMe, B qaCTHOCTM 3aflBneHMe n0 nOBOAY AeRTenbHOCTM K O M M T ~ T ~ roc6e3onac-

HOCTM, npeflflMCaB PaCueIiMBaTb fleflTellbHOCTb 3TOrO KOMMTeTa B ~ M T B ~ BnpeAb

KaK aHTMrOCyAapCTBeHHylo. ~ ~ K o H o ~ ~ o ~ K T CTaBMn B ~ M T B ~ C B O ~ ~ UeRblO CO3flaHMe

MeXaHM3Ma 6b lc~pe iue ro CnOMa TeX rOCy,&3pCTBeHHblX MHCTMTYTOB, KOTOPble B

AOKyMeHTe Ha3blBalOTCR OKKYnaqMOHHblMM, 'iepe3 KOTOPble COB~TCKMM C003 yn- pasnfln J ~ M T B O ~ . f l n ~ 3 ~ 0 r o npemaranocb nMuMTb CPOKOM Ha 5 neT onpeneneH- Hble KaTerOpMM I1MU flpaBa 3aHMMaTb PyKOBOAR~Me AOnXHOCTM, nPMcleM He TOnbKO

B rOCYflaPCTBeHHblX C T P ~ K T Y ~ ~ X , HO M B TeX aKuMOHePHblX ~ ~ ~ C ? C T B ~ X , rfle 3HallM-

TellbHafl WCTb ~ K L ( M ~ flpMHameXMT rOCyAapCTBy. B I ~ ~ o ' ~ ~ M , ~ ~ K o H AOnyCKall npaB0

AenaTb ~cKntocletiMe nnfi mu, BHecwMx 60nbuoM BmaA B geno ynporetim ~ e 3 a -

BMCMMOCTM ~ M T B ~ I . O ~ ~ H ~ K O IlepBble Xe o ~ c Y X ~ ~ ~ H M R B IlapnaMeHTe 0 6 ~ a p y x ~ n ~

3 b 1 6 ~ 0 ~ ~ b KPMTePMeB, KOTOPble 6 b l n ~ 3anOXeHbl B 3aKOHOnPOeKTe. Bb l f l ~HMn~~b .

'{TO O W H ~ :pyj(t~o onpcnencl-rt, Kawe ~ O ~ M H O ~ T M cneAyeT cwTaTb P Y K O B O A R ~ M - -

MM, K a K i i C CTPYKIYPLI OTHOCRTCR K OpraHaM rocynpasnctim, KTO nonaAaeT no4 on- pe,l\C?Iletlkltl <<dl eHl' l(rb)) M 1.. fl. 1/1 B PE3)UlbTaTE. npoi,qn HeCKOllbKO c n y u l a ~ ~ f i B

rlaF)liZIMetiTC, 3JtiOtIOnF)OeKT Tau M He 6b1f1 np1ItiRT. B M ~ C T O 3TOrO 6b1n0 flPMHHTO

[)C!LUCblMC 0 flp0uepKe h4aiii(aTOB AenlJTaTOB, flOfl03pCBaeMblX B CO3HaTellbHOM CO-

ipylltiliLlecrue co c n e u c l l y ~ 6 a ~ ~ ApyrMx rocyfiapcm. TOT 3auo~ 6bln ~ P M H R T B

j(erta6pe 199 1 rOna M RBIlRn C O ~ O ~ KaK 6b1 y~e'ieHHblM BaPMaHT 3aKOHa 0 OeCOBe-

T W ~ L ~ I M . 00 M ~ O H M M cyj\t,6b1 asTopoM 3 ~ 0 r o 3 a ~ o ~ o n p o e ~ ~ a 6b1n ~ ~ Y ~ ~ ~ M U M C T M nM- TepaTop B ~ p r ~ n ~ y c Yanairec, KOTOP~IM M cTa1.l n e p ~ o i x e p ~ ~ o l l ~ T O ~ O 3 a ~ o ~ a . OH BCKOpe BblHyXLleH 6bln Bbl6bl~b He TOnbKO I43 I ~ o ~ ~ M T M ' ~ ~ c K o ~ ~ >KM3HM, HO AaXe 3ape-

rMCTPMPOBaTbCR Ha 6 ~ p ~ e TPYfla K a K 6e3pa60~~b l i . A H ~ ~ M T M K M 0TMeclaK)l. TaKXe,

C~TO TOT ~ ~ K O H M 3 ~ a KaMnatiMR ((no npocserMsanMto)) Aeny-raToo aana pe3ynbia~,

06par~bl i i xenaeMoMy. OH^ nsMnacb O A H O ~ ~3 npM4Mti nopaHetiMR Ha sbl60pax s c e M ~ ccCamnmcaw M BMTayraca J l a ~ ~ c 6 e p r ~ c a . n o c ~ o n b ~ y fleRrelibHocTb napna- M ~ H T C K O ~ KOMMCCMM ~I,ICTPO np~06pena WCTO n o n ~ ~ ~ ~ i e c t i ~ i xapatcrep: npexjle Bcero npoceeLIMeaticllo nodseprarwtcb Te fienylarbl. KoTopble npMtiaAnexanM K on- n03MUMM. ~ K O H MCflOnb30BaIlCfl H ~ O ~ ~ ~ K T M B H O M B pe3yllbTaTe B03HMKnM 60n1,tl~~e

COMHeHMR B TOM, K a K M K ~ K O ~ 3aKOH 0 nK)CTpaUMM Ha40 9PMMeHRTb. Bnpo l i e~ ,

MexyiyHapofltible n p a s o 3 a u ~ ~ ~ h l e o p r a ~ ~ 3 a 1 y ~ n p ~ 3 ~ a n ~ . ({TO ~ M T B ~ RsnRercfl

23

-- --

' I IMI-ICTB~HHO~ c r p a ~ o l l Ha TeppMTopMM ~I , IBLU~I . ; ..,CP, roe tc non~ioM Mepe co- i i l~ lonalo~cn npaea LlenoseKa. E C T ~ onbn M npyr1; . gal l , K O T O ~ ~ I ~ 6tm 0606uuet1 B

?.,la rep~anax ra3e- r~ ((MOCKOBCKM~ ~ o s o c - r ~ ) , (@er-., ..-:it, 1993 r.)

X P ~ C T O M ~ T M ~ H ~ I M flPMMePOM MCnOflb30BaHMR : ti;$eTOB H a ~ P o C ~ ) ~ C C M M AIlW pe- (~)OPMM~)OB~HMR ~ O C Y ~ ~ P C T B ~ H H O ~ ~ CMCTeMbl RBI. 'CR nOClleBOeHHaH rep~atiMR.

6pe~eHliaR aAMMHMCTpayMR COD3HMKOB, K0TOPP.i ; r:YLL(eCTBllRfla @YHKL~MM rOCy-

flapCTBetiHOr0 yIlpaBfleHMR H a ee TePPMTOPMM bu ; '49 rOAa, flpMHRIla tiOPMaTMB-

til,le aKTbl, 3anpelL(aloqMe ~ ~ I B W M M OTBeTCTBet+ib!rd nMuaM pefixa, COlpYAHMKaM

dnflapaTa M cneycnyx6 3aHMMaTb pa3nM1IHble rC.?ySdpCTBeHHble flOflXHOCTM. 6~11- AecTar OPT noATsepAMn ~ T M a m l . A nocne : 1?0~~6eprc~oro npoyecca 3anpe.r

6b1n pacnpocTpaHeH M Ha p y ~ o n o ~ c ~ ~ o ~ a ~ ~ ~ : ~ ~ a r : - - c o ~ ~ a n ~ c ~ w e c ~ o ~ p a 6 o r e l nap-rw T e p ~ a t 1 ~ ~ . no3f l~ee, B aBrycTe 1956 r o i : ~ , a~anor~1IwblM 3anpe~ 6bln

paCflpOCTpaHeH K O H C T M T ~ ~ M O H H ~ I M CyflOM QPr Z ?3 aKTMBMCTOB KOMMYHMCTMLle-

CKOM napTMM. B ~ ~ ~ O H M M napnaMeHT Bsen B 1948 :nm orpaHwieHMR Ha ~ P O @ ~ C C M M

AnR flMu, CBR3aHHblX C MMnepaTOpCKMM peXMMO!vf ." BPeMR B O ~ H ~ I . CPOK OrpaHM- i i t l ~ ~ M He 6bln OrOBOpeH, HO OHM KaCanMCb npaca 3 a 6 0 ~ a ~ b TOllbKO BO BIlaCTHblX

CTpyKlypaX. B CLUA B 1950 rOhy 6bln flPMHRT 3 <1<0si 06 ~ H T M ~ M ~ F ) M K ~ I ~ C K O ~ neH-

TeJlbHOCTM, K ~ c ~ ~ O ~ M M C H KOMMYHMCTOB M rpalttfl-lii, 4MeBUJMX B rO,Qbl BOiHbl TeC-

Hble KOHTaKTbl C COBeTCKMMM BnaCTRMM. B OKTH~?!' 1987 rOAa BepxostiblM C Y j I

CWA npM3t-lan 3aKOH HeKOtIClM~~MOI~HblM, OAH-lK(! aAMMHMCTpJIJM>I Pt%r;lkla tle

nonnMcana y ~ a 3 a 06 ero oTMeHe (M 10 HeAaBbeiij BpeMetiM, ecnM B ~ I nonyClajiM B M ~ Y B C U A , TO B atiKeTe wac 0 6 ~ 3 a ~ e n b ~ o cnp.:! .;tsanM, cocronllrd IIM B ~ I CIrletioM

/<flee, KOMCOMOlla M TOMY n 0 ~ 0 6 H b l ~ 0praHM3al:~!i.l) 8 C ~ H T ~ ~ ~ P C 1991 rOAa B b- M ~ I H M M cetiaT noAtiMMan Bonpoc o 3 a n p e q e ~ ~ ~ z : : q . ? a n ~ c ~ ~ ~ e c ~ o i napm.11.c spylia,

K a K npaB0flpeeMHMubl K O M M ~ H M C T M ~ ~ ~ C K O ~ , HO 1:2I<Oil H e 6~111 IlpMtiHT, nOTOMy .IT0

pyKOBOACTB0 CflT 3aHBMn0, 'IT0 3Ta CTpyKlypF HE gBflRflaCt, aHTMAeMOKpaTMLle-

CKOG. B 6blB~eM L ~ ~ X O C ~ O R ~ K M M 3aKOH 0 IIIOCTPayI.i14 ?,'.!n rIpMltH1- I3 o m - $ 1 6 ~ ~ 199 1 10

) la, OH 3 a ~ p a r ~ s a r i Mt4Tepect.i npMMeptio 250 TL>l(.>lti BIJICOKMX I\OIIMIIOCTHI,IX IIMU

~ ~ K O H nOflBepraflCR pe3KC~i KPMTMKe CO CT0pOH':l r!, !aB03aLL(MTHMKOB. KaK tlCCOOT-

B~TCTBY~OLL(MM MeX,4yHaPOfiHblM aKTaM 0 npaBaX t!f2"OBeKa. H e ~ 0 ~ 0 p b l e KOMMYHM-

CTbl ~ e ~ 0 ~ 1 1 0 ~ a ~ M 1 . 1 06pa~MnM~b B OPraHM3auMW ( ~ ~ ~ ~ x A Y H ~ P o ~ ~ H ~ H aMHMCTMR)) C

x a n o 6 a ~ ~ Ha MX npecnenosatiMe, M n p e 3 ~ a e ~ r Raqnae T-a~en t i a c ~ a ~ s a n Ha 13-

MetieHMM 3aKOHa, YKa3blBaFI H a O U J M ~ K M M pai it:'! ::i20pHble CrIyraM B XOne KaApO- BLIX npoeepo~. L ~ ~ B ~ C T H O , ~ I T O atianorwiible ouic.~(>l.;~: 6blnM AonyulcHbl M npu ny6- I l M K a y M M CnMCKOB COTPYAHMKOB ((UTa3M)) M M3Be,.:klt:, ?paMaTMtieCKMe CnYClaM, npM- uenuJMe K pacKony c e ~ e i B F ~ ~ M ~ H M M nocne ny!,iiw ayclM arc tc iyp~~oi cew . B (la- CTHOCTM, CTaf lO M3BeCTH0, ClTO MYXbH flOHOCMfll CBOMX XeH, HCCMOTPR Ha TO,

qT0 MMeflM 0 6 4 ~ ~ f l e ~ e i M T.A. B ~0R6pe npOlE.. . rOUa IlpaBMTeflbCTBO Cn0Ba-

KMM flpMOCTaHOBMfl0 ~ ~ M C T E M ~ 3aKOHa Ha CnOBa . 4 TePPMTOPMLI. TeM He Metlee

24

ecTb cny.caM, KorAa rpaxAatie OPT, noneeprwecn npec:IIcj\uBdtilKi CorllacHo 3aKOHY 0 flIOCTpauMM, 06pauan~cb B MeH(4yHapOAHble ap6M.lrpdMtible OpraHMX-

UMM, B esponefic~we C Y A ~ I . I4 ~ T M MticTatiyMM n p ~ 3 t i a n ~ , C~TO ~ ~ K O H ~ I o 3anpe~e Ha

npo@eccnw He tiapywam MewtiapoAtiblx K O H B ~ H ~ M M o npasax IierloseKa. 6b1no

ABa TaKMX CflyqaR. M ~ B ~ C T H O , C(T0 B OAHOM CflY'iae o 6 p a ~ ~ n c ~ ~ ~ I B U I M ~ HauMCT.

~pe6yR 3aqMTMTb er0 OT npeCfleflOBaHMR, B ApyrOM Cnyrae - 6blBLUM; KOMMYHL4CT.

06a 3TM CflY' iaR ~ P O @ ~ C C M O H ~ ~ ~ ~ H ~ I X O T P ~ H M C ~ ~ H M ~ 6 b l l l ~ nPM3HaHbl COOTBeTCTBY-

IOUMMM MeWHaPOAHblM ~ B P O ~ ~ ~ K M M npaBOBblM HOPMaM.

K O H ~ ~ H O , A0 CMX nOp B POCCMM MHOrMe YnPaBfleH'ieCKMe CTPYwPbl B ~ P ~ Y D T C R

nO-npeXHeMiny M3 C T ~ ~ O M <(060i~bl)>. 1/1 R H e XOqY CKa3aTb, ClTO Mbl AOnXHbl KaK-TO

3TOMY npenRTCTBOBaTb M 1ITO Mbl He MOXeM nOBepMTb B Te M3MeHeHMR, KOTOPble

MOW nPOMCXOAMTb C flDAbMM. L/1HaCle Mbl 6 y n e ~ 01IeHb 6 1 1 ~ 3 ~ ~ K Te3MCY 0 TOM, ClTO

BCe, KT0 XMfl B Te BpeMeHa - B 10Abl CTaflMHM3Ma, Mf lM B rOAbl 3aCTOfl, BCe OHM

I l f lOXMe nDAM. C ~ p y r o i CTOPOHbl, Mbl He MOXeM He @ M K C M P O B ~ T ~ HblHeUIHei CM-

TYauMM IlPMOCTaHOBKM pe@op~bl npeMHMX CMflOBblX M PenpeCCMBHblX CTpylcryp. 0 6 TOM 3 ~ e c b yxe cerofitifi rosop~nocb. R c G O ~ ~ U I M M ysaxetiMeM O T H O W Y C ~ K TOM pa60~e, KOTOPYK) nPOBOnMIlM B ~ A M M BMKTOPOBMCI ~ ~ K ~ T M H , BMKTOP B ~ ~ ~ ~ H T M H O B M ~ H B ~ H ~ H K O no pe@Op~e Kr6, HO 3TM JlWflM CerOAHR OKa3aflMCb He

B O C T P ~ ~ O ~ ~ ~ H H ~ I M M rOC)IAaPCTBOM; 6onee TOrO, R AyMatO, 9TO OtlM CerOAHR HyXAa-

tOTCH B ~0yMarlb~0L.1 3aqMTe CO CTOPOHbl ljeMOKpaTMqeCKMX Bllac~eM. Ha~6onee n p ~ @ e ~ ~ M ~ H a f l b H b l e KaApbl aHaflMTMKOB, TaKMe ntOAM, K a K BflaflLlMMp A ~ c ~ H T ~ ~ B M . ~ P ~ ~ ~ H o B , KaK rOBOpMfl npe,Qbl~yLl&4M AOKnaflClMK, npOCT0 6blflM ((BblflaBfleHbl)) M3

CMCTeMbl. L/1 3T0 t ia~6onee np~@e~~M~Haf lbHb le KaApbl Kr6 . Atian~rMClHbl~ np0-

yecc npoMcxoAMT w B T ~ ~ B H O M p a 3 s e ~ b l e a ~ e n b ~ o ~ ynpasrleHMM. K ~ K M3BeCTH0, aPXMB Kr6 OKa3anCR CnPRTaHHblM. TOT aPXMB HeflOCTyneH TO-

CyAapCTBeHtiOMy KOMMTeTY 110 AeflaM apXMBOB. B HeM eCTb MtiOFO npo6enos, HO R

JlyMatO, ClTO COOTBeTCTBytO~Me AOKYMeHTbl M 6 1 1 0 ~ ~ ,QOK)lMeHTOB nPOCTO HanelKHO

cnpnTaH1,I. Cpa3y noclie cMepTM Atinpen N M M T P M ~ B M ~ ~ Caxapo~a 8 Haqane 1990 rona R M CepreM Ceprees~r Asep~tiues cAenanM o @ ~ y ~ a n b ~ b ~ M ~ e n y a ~ c ~ ~ i 3a-

npoc p y ~ o o o ~ c ~ s y KT6 o nepenaqe KOMMCCMM no HacnenMtO A. A. Caxaposa M ero Baose a p x ~ s a aKaAeMMKa. R pa3rosap~eana nocne 3 ~ 0 r o c BblcoKonocTaBnetitibl-

MM AOnXHOCTHblMM flML(aMM M, B ClaCTHOCTM, C BMKTOPOM M M x ~ ~ ~ o B M W M Ye6pMKO- B ~ I M , KOTOP~IM, npasAa, y x e He 6b1n Torna H a nocry rnaobl BenoMcTsa, HO Y e 6 p ~ - KOB, r n ~ ~ n MHe B rna3a, c~a3an, TO B KT6 Ha Caxaposa HMK0rp.a ~ 0 0 6 y e He 3a-

BOnMllOCb Aena. Bnpol-le~, MHe flOTOM npMLLlnOCb H e pa3 CTanKMBaTbCR C CMva- y ~ e f i , KOrAa B.A.Kpo~i~os, rflRAR B rfla3a, flrafl B OTHOLUeHMM CfleXKM 3a Pa3HblMM

fllOAbMM (M 3a M H O ~ , B C ~ ~ C T H O C T M ) 3a HeCKOIlbKO A H ~ M A0 flYT'ia.

Tenepb Mbl 3HaeM, ClTO COTHM TOMOB CaXapOBCKOrO Aena 6 b l n ~ BblBe3eHbl. H ~ M rOBOpRT, ClTO OHM YHMClTOXeHbl. B . ~ M P O ~ K O B , 3aMeCTMTenb B.KptOv~osa, O @ M ~ M -

ant,Ho tiamcan m e , CITO Bce, CITO 6blfl0 C B R ~ ~ H O c Caxapoeb~~, y x e ~ 0 3 s p a ~ e ~ o .

2 5

HO Mbl-TO 3HaeM, 'iTO 3TM COTHM TOMOB BblBe3eHbl M rAe-TO CYUeCTBYIOT. OHM H e -

AOCTYflHbl CerOAHR HM HaCneAHMKaM C a x a p o B a , HM K ~ K o G - - ~ M ~ o O ~ ~ ~ C T E ~ H H O ~ ~

OpraHM3auMM.

TO npOCTO n p M M e p , ~ o B o ~ R U J ~ ~ 0 TOM, ClTO Y HaC A0 CMX n O p HeT ~ @ @ ~ K T M B H O - ro r p a x A a H c K o r o KoHTponR tian Kr6. 3 a ~ o ~ 06 o p r a H a x 6 e 3 o n a c ~ o c ~ ~ . H a KOTO-

pb~M C c b l n a n M c b 3 ~ e c b . ~ p a G ~ e H e c o e e p l u e H e H . FI H a A e i o c b , l i ~ o npo@ecclro~anb- H b l e DPMCT~I n p o B e a y r c n e ~ ~ a n b ~ b ~ i a ~ a n ~ 3 3~0ro 3 a ~ o ~ a . P a 3 y ~ e e ~ c ~ 1 , OH HYX-

AaeTCf l B COBepWeHCTBOBaHMM, KaK M BCR H a W a 3aKOHOAaTenbHaR Aef lTenbHOCTb.

O ~ ~ C H ~ I M M AOflOnHeHMRMM K 3TOMY 3aKOHY CTanM &KOH 06 OflepaTMBHO-P03blCK-

H O ~ A e u T e n b H o c T M 1.1 npoem 3 a ~ o ~ a o r o c y f i a p c ~ s e t i ~ o i T ~ G H ~ . y x e npoure4~~1~M nepsoe cnyurawe B n a p n a M e H T e . 06a p a 3 ~ ~ 3 b l ~ a t o ~ p y ~ ~ Per l peccMBHb lM CTPYW- p a M .

B CBR3M C 3TMM BCTaeT BOnPOC, KaK He H a M IlPOBOflUTb 3KOHOMMLleCKMe M n0n- MTM'reCKMe p e @ ~ p ~ b l A a f l b W e , n p M OTCYTCTBMM r f laCHOrO r p a W a H C K O r 0 KOHTPOnR

3 a cnetlcnym6a~~. H e ~ 0 ~ 0 p b t e n p e m a r a l o T nOAOXf laTh HeCKOnbKO ~ o K o ~ ~ H M ~ ~ . n o K a M ~ M ~ H M T C R C O ~ H ~ H M ~ H a u e r o H a p o g a , noua n p o ~ 3 o i ~ e ~ n o c T e n e H H o e 0 6 -

MOBfleHMe KaApOB 3 ~ 0 i c n y ~ 6 b 1 . Benb cnym6a ~ ~ ~ O ~ ~ C H O C T M RBnReTCR3neMeHTOld

c y e e p e H M T e T a nlo6oro r o c y n a p c T s a , M HMKTO ~3 n p a t m ~ l r e c K M x ~OIIMTMKOB y H a c ni! rOBOpMT 0 TOM. ClTO OHa ~ 0 0 6 4 e H e A O l l X H a CYUeCTBOBaTb. HO OHa H e A O n X H a Cy-

UeCTBOBaTb B H b l H e U H e M B M A e M €3 H b l H e W H e M COCTaBe ee YWCTHMKOB. kl Y HdC I4

tia 3anane c e r o A H n p a c n p o c T p a H e i i o MHeHMe, IJTO H ~ O ~ X O A M M O T e p n e w e . TOT xt? Ba~inas Fasen c ~ a 3 a n H e A a s H o , L ~ ~ o M ~ I H a y w n M c b p a 3 p y w a ~ b , M ~ I Hayl iMI iMcb CO-

3MAaTb, H a M OCTaIlOCb TOflbKO HaYL(MTbCR X A a T b .

RO~YCTMM, HacLleMy 0 6 u e c ~ ~ y tie x u a T a e r T e p n e n m , no B C ~ - T ~ K M H a n o no.- MOClb TeM, KT0 X n e T , M f lOMOllb, B '4aCTHOCTM. TOG MOnOnelKM, KOTOPaR rOTOBa

OC03HaTb H a U Y 064ym OTBeTCTBeHHOCTb - nOMOLib OC03HaTb MCTOPMK). ~ / K O B O ~ -

C T B Y A C ~ JTMMM C O O ~ ~ ~ X ~ H M ~ \ M M , I l l cae3p . ABMX~HMR c ( A e ~ o ~ p a . r ~ l i e c ~ a ~ Pocc~n)) n p e n n o x c l n 3 a ~ o ~ o n p o e m o 3 a n p e ~ e H a npocteccw~ A n n n p o o o A t i M K o s ToTanMTap.- H o r o pexma. KTO A o n x e w , no MHeHMm aBTopoB npoema, n o A n e p r a T b c a 3 a n p e ~ j

H a n p o @ e c c c l ~ ?

f l ~ e ~ , Q e E C H O O n p e A e I l e H H b l M ~ ~ O @ ~ C C L I O H ~ ~ ~ H ~ ~ M OrPaHM'ieHMRM H a BpeMf l

n e p e x o A H o r o nepuona. T. e. H a c p o ~ 5-10 n e T , AOIIXI~~I n o A e e p r a r b c f i c n e n y o - -

U M e nwa: - B C e O C B O ~ O H ( ~ ~ H H ~ I ~ CeKpeTapM f l a p ~ ~ i ~ b l x , flPOM3BOnCTHeHHblX M TePPMTO--

PManbHblX 0 p r a ~ M 3 a q M M KtlCC; - f l e p B b l e , BTOPble M T p e T b i l CeKpeTapM ~ ~ G K O M O B , rOpKOMOB, 0 6 ~ 0 ~ 0 6 M KpaM-

KOMOB Kl lCC; - P ~ ~ O T H M K M (~KlltO'iaR c e ~ p e ~ a p e i COOTBeTCTBy~LUMX UK, HO 3 a MCKfltOCleHM-

e M TeXHMCleCKOrO f l e p ~ ~ ~ a ~ l a ) UeHTpanbHblX. ~ ~ c I ~ ~ ~ ~ M K ~ H c K M x M BCeCOD3HblX KO-

MMTeTOB KOMMYHMCTM'leCKMX ~ B P T M ~ , ~ ~ ~ ~ ; ( C T B O B ~ B U H X A 0 6 ~ 0 8 6 ~ ~ 1991 r O n a .

~ ~ M ~ T M M , TO, C o r n a c H o npoelcry, B c e n e p e w c n e H H b l e KaTeropMM n M q no, BepratOTCR ~ ~ O @ ~ C C M O H ~ ~ ~ ~ H ~ I M OrPaHMCleHMRM B CneQK)uMX CnYClaRX: - e c n M B 0 6 q e ~ TP~BOM c T a H e H a x o W e t i M e MX H a Y K ~ ~ ~ H H ~ I X f i o n x w o c T 8 x

c y M M e c o c T a s n R e T 10 M 6onee n e T ;

- e C n M H a 21 aBryCTa 1991 r0Aa OHM 3aHMManM OAHY M3 YKa3aHHblX flOnXt+(

c ~ e i . K ~ o M ~ TOrO, 3TM OrPaHWCleHMFl PaCflPOCTPaHRKlTCR H a ,Q~~CTBYK)U(MX WTaTHb

COTPYAHMKOB M AaB l l lMX n o A n M c K y 0 COTpyAHMreCTBe C Op raHaMM HKBR, MTE Kr6. MLP, MC6 n ~ 6 0 p a 6 0 ~ a s w ~ x B 3TMX O p r a H a x H a npoTRxeHMM 10 nocne f i t i v

n e T , a l cn toqa f i pesepe. H 3 KHMrM E. M. AnbGau, KOTOPafl IlpMCyTCTBYeT 3fleCb. Mbl 3HaeM, 'fTO B O O ~ I L [ ~

TO M3 K T 6 H e YXOART, ~ M T M O W A a Henb3R, nO3TOMy p e 3 e p B C n e W e T PaCCMaTpM

BaTb KaK ~ K T M B H ~ I ~ p e 3 e p B .

n 0 ~ OrpaHMCleHMeM H a f l p o @ e c c M ~ Nfl YKa3aHHblX n M 4 IlOHMMaeTCR B p e M e H

H ~ I R 3 a n p e T m R HMX 3aHMMaTb n0 Ha3HaWHHtO HIlH B pe3yJlbTaTe HenpRMbl; B ~ I ~ O P O B OTBeTCTBeHHble AOflXHOCTM T ~ P P M T O P M ~ ~ ~ H O - M C ~ ~ O ~ H M T ~ ~ ~ H O ~ BnaCTM

H ~ ~ M H ~ R C r f l a B ~ A M M H M C T ~ ~ ~ M ~ ~ ~ ~ O H O B , rOpOAOB, 06 f lac~e i M BnflOTb A0 MMHM-

c~pos pecny6n1.1~ M P o c c ~ i c ~ o F ~ O e ~ e p a u ~ ~ B U e n o M ( s ~ n t o q a ~ ~ ~ ~ M ~ ~ P - M M H M C T -

~ 0 8 ) . Ha CPOK A0 10 n e T m9nR T e X Xe JlMq A O f l X H a 6 b l ~ b 3 a f l p e u e H a AeRTenbHOCTb

C B R ~ ~ H H ~ R c n p e n o A a s a H M e M B c p e A H M x M B ~ I C W M X y q e 6 ~ b 1 x 3 a e e ~ e ~ u ~ x . flpyr~qi: BMAbl ~ ~ P O @ ~ C C M O H ~ J ~ ~ H O G AeRTenbHOCTM, BKfllo'iaR C l a ~ T ~ b l 6 ~ L I ~ H ~ C , MIlM pa601j r! r o c c e t m o p e , B TOM wcne M H a P Y K O B O A R ~ M X AO~XHOCTRX, ~e B O ~ ~ P ~ I ~ H ~ T C R .

Y ~ a 3 a ~ ~ b l e OrPaHMCleHMfl H e PaCflPOCTPaHRlOTCfl H a nMU, I lOnYqMBWMX AOJ lX -

HOCTM 0 CMCTeMe n p e f i c ~ a B ~ ~ e f l b ~ 0 ~ MflM M C ~ O ~ ~ H M T ~ ~ ~ H O M BJlaCTM B pe3yJlbTaTe

nPRMblX C B O ~ O A H ~ I X B ~ I ~ O P O B , KaK ~ $ O P M ~ I BOneM3bRBneHMfl HapO,4a. T ~ K r T 0 ,

BMAMTe, eCTb CyweCTBeHHOe OTnMClMe 3TOr0 3aKOHOflpOeKl i3 OT TOrO, K O T O P ~ I ~ 6bln nPMHRT B ~ M T B ~ M ~ ~ X O C ~ ~ O B ~ K M M , MnM OT H e npMHnTOr0 B n 0 f l b U J e . n 0 ~ ~ 0 I l b K y BOnR

tiapoua - rnae~blc MCTO~HMK BnacTM. TO ( ~ Q e ~ o ~ p a ~ ~ r e c ~ a n POCCMR), A o n y c K a e T B b l 6 0 p b l AenyTaToB , C O T p y n H M W B U M x C Kr6, M H e CqMTaeT, r T 0 A e f l y a T b l MnM

n p e 3 M A e H T A O n X H b l nPf lMO n 0 n B e p r a T b C R TaKOMY flPOCBeLIMBaHMIO, T ~ K O G JltOCTpa-

qMM. 6 K O H u e KOHL\OB M b l A O I I X H b l OCTaBMTb m f l H a p o f l a B03MOXHOCTb ewe p a 3

f lpOrOflOCOBaTb 3 a T O T ~ ~ M T ~ ~ H ~ I ~ P e X M M , HO R y B e p e H a , L(T0 C HaWMM HaPOAOM Ta-

K O ~ 6 e ~ b 1 yXe H e n p 0 ~ 3 0 i f l e ~ . ~ ~ O C T O H a p O A M O X e T YBMAeTb r f l y 6 0 ~ M e M3MeHt'.

HHA B T e X ntOARX, KOTOPble 6b1W nPOBOAHMKBMM TOTaJlMTapHOrO p e X M M a . M C l i 0 t . i

AOBepMTb 3TMM ntOfiZIM CBOD ~ y f l b 6 ~ . k l ~ a r e rosopfi, ~ ( A e ~ o ~ p a ~ w t e c ~ a ~ P o c c c l r l ~ n o t t m a e r B c e T P Y ~ H O C T M , CBR-

3aHHb le C 0 6 c y X f l e ~ M e ~ M B03MOXHOCTbtO nPMHRTMR 3aKOHa 0 nK)CTpaUMM. HO 3TO

f lO f lXeH 6bl~b 3aKOH, H e 3HatOUJ4h M c w I K ) L ( ~ H c ~ ~ , a H e MHCTPYKUMR RJlR n e f l T e I l b H 0 -

CTM K ~ K M X - n M 6 0 O ~ ~ ~ C T B ~ H H ~ I X KOMMCCM~, ClTO 6 b l n o 6 b l Of laCHblM nOBTOPeHMeM

~ ~ O T M B O ~ ~ ~ ~ R H O ~ nPaKTMKM 30-x TOAOB. TUI ,a~enbH0 ~ b l ~ e p e ~ ~ b l i bl B ~ B ~ W ~ H H ~ I ~

27

O ~ ~ ~ C T B O M . H e X ~ C T O K M ~ , H e ~ y p 0 B b l i . gbl BMAMTe, t i aK MI;TkM MvDb .b: Lir.I:!

f l p e m a r a e T C R n P M M e H R T b K aKTMBHblh1 nPOBOnHMKaM TOTanMTaPHGTO ~ ~ ? , * . ~ q t J ~ ! 'Yt?

M C W l l O r e H O , '-IT0 n O C f l e HOBblX B ~ I ~ O ~ O B , ?CnM 13 E a P i i a M e H T e C ' iOhMiCZ ,*C!.q: r . , , . : -

T M r e C K O e ~ O ~ ~ W M H C T B O . n 0 ~ 0 6 ~ b i M 3aKOH M O M e T 6 b i T b IlPMHRT. T ~ M 6onee. '{TO

TOT ~ O T O B ~ I R np0eK- r H e n p e a n o n a r a e T ~ O H ~ H M ~ HM ~ ~ O T M B Aenyraios. HM n p o i - b r s

n p e 3 M f l e H T a MnM A p y r M X f l M q , e C n M OHM B b l 6 p a ~ b l f l p R M b l M B C P H a p O A H b l M ronoco- s a H M e M . f l pegc~asn~e~cn, C~TO n p e g o x e ~ ~ b ~ f i ( (Ae~pocc~e i i ) ) np0eK-r H e A a e T

O C H O B ~ H M ~ ~ MJIR Y n p e K a B n p M 3 b l B a X K M H M M O ~ ~ ((OXOTe H a B e A b M s MnM B OTPMqaHMM

f l p a B a H a MHaKOMblCnMe. Ha CaMOM nene BblCOKOflOCTaBneHHaR KOMMYHMCTMqe-

CKaR H0MeHKnaT)'pa (6 TOM LrMCne M f l p M r a C T H a R K aHTMKOHCTMT)4JMOHHOMy f l y ~ c l ? ) .

KaK M P ~ ~ O T H M K M K a p a T e f l b H b l X ODraHOB (B TOM '-IMCfle f lpRMO flpM'-IaCTHblX K f lb lTKaM.

MCTR3aHMRM M r M 6 e f l M H a W M X GeflMKMX COOTeCleCTBeHHMKOB - SCflOMHMM C f l e a O B a -

T e f l R H.H.Ba~~nosa A . X B a T a , H a n C M M e p , MnM MyclMTeflR A . f l . C a x a p o s a A.OSyxa) - flpaKTMqeCKM HM B O A H O M C n y c l a e H e n 0 H e C n M HM M O p a n b H b l X , HM M a T e p M a n b H b l X

f l O T e p b . M H O ~ M ~ M3 (cflpe>t<HMX>) 9CTaOTCR Y KOpMMna BnaCTM, B TO B p e M R K a K fie- MOKPaTb l ( O C O ~ ~ H H O M B apMM1.l. MBA M Kr6) n O B C t o n y B C T p a H e W e f l b M y t o T C R , H e -

P e n K O flO,4BepratOTCR TOHeHMRM 1". )IBOflbHeHMRM.

Haao c ~ a 3 a ~ b . TO BO B c e x c T p a H a x . me M ~ I B L ~ A ~ ~ M H e r a T M B H y t o n p a K r M K y

n p u M e H e H M R 3 a ~ o ~ a o n t o c T p a U w , KaK npasmo. H e n p o w 3 o w n o o ~ ~ a 3 a OT C ~ M O ~

WAPM. Hano, H a B e p H O e , nOCTapaTbCR ~ 3 6 e x a ~ b TeX 0 ~ ~ 6 0 ~ . KOTOPble C n e n a n M

H a w M K o n n e r M ~3 B O C T O ~ H O ~ B ~ O ~ ~ ~ C V O ~ ~ 6no~a. H a q a B u K e p e a n ~ 3 a q ~ t o TOM IA!l?u D 3 Y b U e .

. . . . .. ~ ~ . . . . . rl :.A,; ,- - ~ K C LO? L.5 , i t $ , j t i 'R i - ihg ?..!.,'i t w - r .''.-.?.,:- . , . . ..- . aeropawi npoema o r p a w e -

.. . . .~ - . ~,,::r i:; :;$'..+<.;,:., L. ; , &.,c':[;,,*+.?.-:..:~ ,. , .. ' .. . . . + . r . , - . - ' . . : w ~ H M ~ ~ a w e r o 06tuec~ea M cdenais 0 6 ~ o s n e t i ~ e ~ e o G p a r ~ : , r ~ i , + \ - KOTFI T'bl ~ ~ C ? ~ U C T B C M tiaclana O ~ C ~ X A ~ ~ - H M R

TOG ~ o I I ~ ~ H ~ H H o ~ ~ T e M b l . e C n M :jTOAHO. B BOCEMTaTei ibHblX U e n R X .

3To tie 0 3 ~ a q a e ~ , C~TO OTBeTcTBeHt iocTb 3 a MCTOPMO ( (~~~MPOCCMR,) ~ 0 3 n a r a e ~

n M u b H a Y~KMLI cnoR n p a e ~ ~ e n e f i . BC~OMHMM onmt, c n o B a Ba~nasa rasena: (( ... B C e M b l 6e3 MCKqKICleHMR Y C n e n M CnMTbCR C TOTaf lL lTapHb lM P e X M M O M , npMHflnM

er0 K a K H e M 3 M e H R e M y K l P e a n b H O C T b L! T e M C a M b l M jlf lLiHMnM eTO Cy t4eCTBOBaHLle ... HMKTO M3 H a C H e M O X e T CClMTaTbCR B C e r O G M W b er0 H ~ P T B O i... Y H a C H e T f l p a B a 80

B C e M O ~ B M H R T ~ BO B C e M Ha lL lMX npaBMTeneG. . . ROTOMy, .IT0 3TO Y M a f l M n O 6b1 M e p y

TO^ OTBeTCTBeHHOCYM, KOTODaf l cefi'iac T ~ ~ ~ Y ~ T C R OT B C e X H a C - 3 T 0 OTBeTCTBeH-

HOCTb, nPOMCTeK2tOd.laR M3 B03MOXHOCTH OTHbiHe , : E ~ C T B O B ~ T ~ CaMOCTORTenbHO,

p a 3 Y M H O M ~ ~ I C T P C ) )

BO~MOXHOCT~ TaKOrO CO~MO~OrM' ieCKOrO O ~ C ~ ~ ~ O B ~ H M R POCCMR i l O P y q f i n a

TOf lbKO B 1989 T O N . HO M 3a 3M HeCKOnbKO n e T cleTKO r ip0CneXMBaeTC; l Q l l H a M f i K a

p o c T a H e A o s e p M g K CI IYX~~M ~ € ? ~ O ~ I ~ C H O C T M c p e n M eacenewfi POCCMM. 3 0 ~ no- C n e A H H e g a H H b l e , KOTOPble BC~POCCMRCKMG U e H T P M3YCleHMR O ~ L Q ~ C T B ~ H H O T O M H e -

HMR n m 6 e 3 ~ 0 n p e a o c T a s M n ~ a u e R K O H @ ~ D ~ H U H M .

Onpoc 6bln n p o ~ 3 a e n e ~ B cepenwtie @e~pann 1993 rona cpem r o p o A c K o r o

i iacenewn POCCMM. Onpotue~o o~ono nonyropa T b l c R r q e n o B e K .

Ha BOflpOC, n p 0 A O n l K a e T f lM H b l H e U H e e MMHMCT~PCTBO ~ ~ ~ O ~ ~ C H O C T M 5 b l ~ b

T ~ ~ H O G B l l a C T b t o B POCCMM, O n P a l L l M B a e M b l e OTBeTMflM Cnef lYK)UMM 0 6 ~ 2 3 0 ~ : 42 f l p O u e H T a C O r n a C H b l C 3TMM, 28 - tie COr f laCHb l , 30 f lpOUeHTOB H e CMOrPM il,aTb

O f l p e n e f l e H H O r O OTBeTa. TO. qTO 6 b l ~ L U M i KrL OCTaeTCR T a i ~ 0 i BnaCTbIC ' 4 3 U e

P y r M X Cl lMTaIoT He3a3L lCMMble n p e A n p M H M M a T e n M . I ) ~ ~ O T H M K M TOPrOBblX i" ::'Or',?-

MMcleCKMX C T P Y W P , BHOBb CO3f laBaeMblX B POCCMM. b l 3 061.~(ero C(MCJla O n P O W e H H b l X Y 58 r iDOueHTOB MMHMCT~PCTBO ~ ~ . ' , O E ~ C U ~ C T V

POCCMM H e ~ b 1 3 b l ~ a e ~ A o B e p w K ce6e a j ~ o ~ o n ~ ~ e n l r y . r p e ~ 4 e ~ ~ G . npennp~i;i~~; y n p a s n e w e c K M e ~ ~ ~ O T H M K M c o c T a s n R i o T 52 npoqetira OT wcna T e x , KTO H e 0 0 ~ 2 - P R e T Hb lHeLUHeMY MMHMCT~DCTBY ~ ~ ~ O ~ ~ C H O C T M . Cpe4Ll COC?t !HOCP) :X~~L lX , 7353~ -

HMKOB MBn M I lPOKYPaTYPb l 48 f l P O U e H T 0 8 TeX. KT0 RO-r lpeXHeh4V OTMOCL!-y? C O n a c ~ o f i K 3TOMY Y' lPeXQeHMK). L13 T e X C n P O U l e H H b l X . LCIC O T p M u a T e n b H O CT?::.-i!.Q

~a TOT tjonpoc. 6onee r;onoeMrlb l c o c T a n n n t o T Te. '-Iefi noxon n p e w l w a e i 7 -6 ;w pyEr~eG B M e c q H a ogroro r e n o s e K a B c e M b e . Bce OHM pajnenmor TO.IK~ ~?.=uI?R.

ClTO MMHMCTC?PCTBO 6 e 3 0 l i a c ~ o c ~ M H e O ~ @ O D M M D O B ~ ~ ~ O C ~ B T ~ K O ~ CTWl?blN. - ~ ? 5 b .

M O X H O 6 ~ 1 n o rOBOPMTb C P r o CTPYKTYpe. KaK O CTPYKTYPC?. KOTOPaFI 0 6 e ~ e i a Y U a -

3)'. 3 H e CBOtO 6 e 3 0 n a c ~ c ; c ~ b .

Ll3 28 n p o u e H T o s O n p o w e H H b l x . H e c o r n a c H b l x c MHetcMeM, ?TO M5 n o - g x r - He?ny R s n R e T c R ~ a i 7 ~ o i S i laCTbKl B POCCMM. nlozei c T a n w e r o VoKoneHMFi - sc. is;- CTZ 50-59 n e T - 36 n p o u e H T o s OT o6uei-o wcna, s o 3 p a c ~ a 60 n e T M c ~ 2 c ; ~ ~ -- 40 TlpOlJeHTOB.

q-." ,(,.a" -T.,\. . . . , . . - - - - , , . . -,; l}.;<,; h j$ !.,? ,;;,dp<:,b: ,,%, ,: .,.: c, .:;j . , -,:.,a - ,

: . <. c' ; .b: . .I. . U ' A .:.<, ~',,:. ' ;+ ' , . - : , , j 3 : l ( ! ,q?' . , ;x l,: .,'l>k;,,h> 8,,y -.;,

29