msc. chem eng_thesis_report_2007_seelam prem kumar.pdf
DESCRIPTION
Synthesis, Characterization and Catalyst Testing of Metal Modified Zeolites forIsomerization of n-butane and Application in Fine ChemicalsTRANSCRIPT
-
Synthesis, Characterization and Catalyst Testing of Metal Modified Zeolites for
Isomerization of n-butane and Application in Fine Chemicals
Masters Thesis
SEELAM PREM KUMAR
Laboratory of Industrial Chemistry
Process Chemistry Centre
Faculty of Technology
Department of Chemical Engineering
bo Akademi University
Turku, Finland.
2007.
-
Preface
The present masters thesis was carried out at the Laboratory of Industrial
Chemistry, Process Chemistry Centre, Faculty of Technology, Department of
Chemical Engineering, bo Akademi University, Turku, Finland during the
academic year 2005-2006 as part of my graduation studies as an international
student from India. I would like to thank to bo Akademi University for giving me
the opportunity to study in Finland.
I wish to express my sincere thanks and gratitude to Prof. Tapio Salmi and Prof.
Dmitry Yu. Murzin, for giving me the opportunity to work in the top research
center in catalysis i.e. Laboratory of Industrial Chemistry. My special thanks to
my supervisor Docent Dr. Narendra Kumar who has been so helpful to me and
whose technical and moral guidance remained a source of research knowledge
in my life and I learnt so many things during interactions with N.Kumar. I would
like to express my gratitude to Laboratory of Inorganic Chemistry and Heat
Engineering Laboratory for giving me the opportunity to work during my studies.
I would like to thank the persons at the Laboratory of Industrial Chemistry, in
particular to Laboratory manager Dr. Kari Eranen for his help with the reactor
system. Special thanks go to Aton Tokarev for helping me in DCP
measurements, explanation of lactose oxidation results and also to Elena
Murzina for testing my catalysts in oxidation of lactose reaction. I am thankful to
Thomas Finnas for helping me in FTIR measurements and also to Jose Villegas
in catalyst testing. Finally, I am grateful to Ping Ping Lee for DCP and ICP
measurements at Laboratory of Analytical Chemistry.
I am very kind to my parents who made me a person with good character and
hard working; especially my elder brothers always encouraged me in the studies.
I wish to thank my friends for their valuable moral support in my life in
Hyderabad, India. And also special thanks to my friends in Denmark and Finland
for their valuable support in my life. Financial support from bo Akademi,
Laboratory of Industrial Chemistry is gratefully acknowledged.
i
-
ABSTRACT
Seelam Prem Kumar Synthesis, Characterization and Catalytic Testing of Metal Modified Zeolite Catalysts
For Application in Fine Chemicals and
Isomerization of n-Butane.
Masters Thesis Carried out under the supervision of Prof. Tapio Salmi, Prof. Dmitry Yu. Murzin and
Docent Narendra Kumar, Laboratory of
Industrial Chemistry, Process Chemistry
Centre, Department of Chemical
Engineering, Faculty of Technology,
bo Akademi University, 2005-2006.
Keywords Synthesis of zeolites, MCM-22, MCM-36, MCM-48, metal modification, Pd, Au,
ultrasound, n-butane isomerization,
lactose oxidation, deposition precipitation
method.
Iso-butane formed by isomerization of n-butane is an essential ingredient in
refinery production of alkylates and oxygenated compounds such as tertiary butyl
alcohol (TBA), methyl tertiary butyl ether (MTBE), isooctene, and polyisobutene
rubber. In recent years, the technology for the isomerization of normal butane (n-
C4) to isobutane (i-C4) has become increasingly important for motor fuel
applications. Isobutane is a primary feedstock for motor fuel alkylation processes,
which produces an excellent and environmentally superior gasoline-blending
component.
The modification of zeolites is of very great importance both from an industrial
and academic point of view because of the potential applications of metal and
ii
-
proton modified zeolite catalysts in the process of petroleum and in the chemical
industry.
The scope of the thesis was to investigate different catalysts preparation
methods. Proton forms of MCM-22 with varying acidities and palladium modified
MCM-22 catalysts with 28, 30, 50, and 70 (silica to alumina) ratios are
synthesized, characterized and tested at the laboratory. To investigate the
influence of acidity over isomerization of n-butane and lactose oxidation were
selected as test reactions. The effect of synthesis time of MCM-22-30 using
ultrasound irradiation method, and effect of palladium metal form of zeolites with
different catalyst preparation methods for applications in fine chemicals i.e.
oxidation of lactose had been investigated. Synthesis of MCM-36 with different
MCM-22 precursors and as well as preparation of MCM-48, which is difficult to
synthesize, and also its reproducibility are also investigated in this thesis work.
Acidity of MCM-22 catalytic materials which can be adjusted by silica to alumina
ratio was found to influence activity and yield of isobutane in n-butane
isomerization. H-MCM-22-30-R was found the most promising catalyst and more
active catalyst compared to Pd form catalysts in n-butane isomerization and in
the case of lactose oxidation, the Pd-impregnated catalysts i.e. MCM-22 exhibits
similar catalytic activity and Pd-H-MCM-22-30-IMP exhibits high active compared
to other preparation methods of Pd-H-MCM-22-30 in lactose oxidation.
The stability of the catalysts in the conversion of n-butane, yield and selectivity of
iso-butane were investigated with Pd-H-MCM-22-28-I.E catalyst with different
weight hourly space velocities and also effect of temperature.
iii
-
REFERAT
Seelam Prem Kumar Syntes, karakterisering och testning av metall- modifierade zeolitkatalysatorer fr
finkemika-lie applikation och isomerisering av
n-butan.
Diplomarbete Arbetet utfrdes under handledning av Prof. Tapio Salmi, Prof. Dmitry Yu. Murzin och
Docent Narendra Kumar, vid Laboratoriet fr
Teknisk Kemi, Processkemiska forskargrupp-
en, Kemisk-tekniska fakulteten, bo Akademi
2007.
Nyckelord Zeolitkatalysatorer, syntes, MCM-22, MCM-36, MCM-48, metallmodifiering, Pd, Au,
ultraljud, n-butan isomerisering, laktos
oxidering.
Isobutan, en isomeriseringsprodukt av n-butan, r en viktig frening fr
produktion av alkylat och syrehaltiga komponenter, s som tertirbutylalkohol
(TBA) och metyltertir butyleter (MTBE), samt iso-okten och polyisobutengummi.
Under de senaste ren har teknologin fr isomerisering av n-butan till isobutan
blivit alltmer viktig. Isobutan r en viktig rvara fr alkyleringsprocesser som
producerar utmrkta och miljvnliga bensinkomponenter. Modifiering av zeoliter
genom protonering eller metalltillsats r viktig ur srl ur industriell som
akademisk synvinkel.
Avsikten med diplomarbetet var att underska olika metoder fr syntes av
katalysatorer. Protonerade MCM-22 med olika surhets grad, kisel till aluminium
frhllande 28, 30, 50 och 70 syntetiserades och modifierades med palladium.
iv
-
Drefter karaketeriserades och testades katalysatorerena i laboratoriet. Till
testreaktioner fr att studera effekten av surhet valdes isomerisering av n-butan
och oxidering av laktos. Syntestidens effekt studerades med hjlp av
ultraljudsbehandling av MCM-22-30. Olika palladiumtillsatsmetoder p zeoliter
studerades med hjlp av laktosoxidation som exempel p finkemikalieapplikation.
Syntesen av MCM-36 utfrdes frn olika MCM-22 material. Den ytterst krvande
syntesen av MCM-48 samt reproducerbarheten av denna, ingr ven i detta
diplomarbete.
Olika surheter av MCM-22 katalysatormaterial pverkade aktiviteten och utbytet
av isobutan och isomeriseringen av n-butan. Den protonerade formen av H-
MCM-22-30-R hade hgre aktivitet n Pd-formen i isomeriseringen av n-butan.
Bda formerna uppvisade liknande aktiviteter i oxidationen av laktos.
Katalysatorstabiliteten, konversionen av n-butan, utbytet av och selektiviteten till
isobutan studerades med Pd-H-MCM-22-28-I.E under olika fldeshastigheter och
olika temperaturer.
v
-
PUBLICATION RELATED TO THE TOPIC 1. A.V.Tokarev, E.V. Murzina, Prem k. Seelam, A.J. Plomp, J.H.Bitter, N.Kumar, D.Yu.
Murzin, Influence of support nature on the catalytic activity of Pd catalysts in lactose
oxidation 2006 (submitted).
2. N. Kumar, O. Russu, P. Seelam, T. Heikkil, V.-P. Lehto, H. Karhu, T. Salmi, D.Yu.
Murzin, Pt modified MCM-22, ZSM-5 and beta zeolite catalysts for n-butane
isomerization: influence of structure, acidity and Pt modification, Studies in Surface
Science and Catalysis (TOCAT-5) (accepted).
vi
-
CONTENTS Preface ........ i Abstract .......... ii Referat......................................................................................................................... iv Publication related to the topic................................................................................. vi Contents .................... vii 1. Introduction ...... 1
1.1 Isomerization of n-butane........1
1.2 Fine chemicals ........ 4
1.3 Oxidation of lactose ........... 5
2. Background and theory ........ 6 2.1. Introduction to zeolites ........... 6
2.1.1 Definition ........ 6
2.1.2 Framework and structure..... ....... 6
2.1.3 History ........... 8
2.1.4 Classification of zeolites ...... 9
2.1.5 Shape selectivity ............. 11
2.1.6 Acidity .... 14
2.1.7 Synthesis of zeolites: pre and post synthesis methods...... 15
2.1.8 Mesoporous molecular sieves .... 19
2.1.9 Zeolite pore structure and active sites... 22
2.1.10 Zeolites in industrial applications ....... 24
3. Catalyst preparation methods............. 26 3.1 Ion exchange method ...... 26
3.2 Impregnation method ....... 28
3.3 In-situ method ....... 30
4. Characterization methods ............ 31 4.1 Surface area measurement method...................................... 31
4.2 X-ray powder diffraction method .............. 32
4.3 Scanning electron microscopy.......... 33
4.4 Fourier transform infra red spectroscopy..........34
vii
-
4.5 Direct current plasma....... 36
5. Overview on MCM-22 and MCM-36 ............. 36 6. Overview on MCM-48 ............. 41 7. Overview on Ultra sound irradiation method .............. 42
7.1 Introduction ....... 42
7.2 Applications ...... 43
8. Experimental Procedure ........... 44 8.1 Catalysts ....... 44
8.2 Synthesis of catalysts ..... 47
8.3 Proton form catalysts........... 50
8.4 Metal modification .......... 51
8.5 Catalysts characterization . 54
8.5.1 Surface area measurement .... 54
8.5.2 X-ray powder diffraction... 55
8.5.3 Scanning electro micrograph...... 55
8.5.4 Direct current plasma... 55
8.5.5 Fourier transform infrared spectroscopy ...... 55
9. Catalytic Testing ........... 56 9.1 Isomerization of n-Butane ..... 56
9.2 Oxidation of lactose ........ 59
10. Results and Discussions ............ 60 10.1 Catalyst synthesis and characterization results ....... 60
10.2 Catalyst testing in n-butane isomerization and lactose oxidation....... 79
10.2.1 Influence of acidity in isomerization of n-butane .......... 79
10.2.2 Influence of palladium form of H-MCM-22
in isomerization of n-butane ....... 80
10.2.3 Effect of temperature......................................................................... 84
10.2.4 Effect of space velocity on isomerization of n-butane ... 87
10.2.5 Influence of catalysts preparation methods on lactose oxidation.. 90
10.2.6 Influence of SiO2/Al2O3 ratio on lactose oxidation.....93
viii
-
11. Conclusion ............... 96 12. References ............ 98
APPENDIX-I--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------102
ix
-
REFERAT
Seelam Prem Kumar Syntes, karakterisering och testning av
metallmodifierade zeolitkatalysatorer fr
finkemikalieapplikation och isomerisering av
n-butan
Diplomarbete Arbetet utfrdes under handledning av Prof.
Tapio Salmi, Prof. Dmitry Yu. Murzin och
Docent Narendra Kumar, vid Laboratoriet fr
Teknisk Kemi, Processkemiska forskargruppen,
Kemisk-tekniska fakulteten, bo Akademi
2007.
Nyckelord Zeolitkatalysatorer, syntes, MCM-22, MCM-36,
MCM-48, metallmodifiering, Pd, Au, ultraljud,
n-butan isomerisering, laktos oxidering
Isobutan, en isomeriseringsprodukt av n-butan, r en viktig frening fr produktion av
alkylat och syrehaltiga komponenter, s som tertirbutylalkohol (TBA) och
metyltertirbutyleter (not sure) (MTBE), samt iso-okten (not sure) och
polyisobutengummi. Under de senaste ren har teknologin fr isomerisering av n-butan
till isobutan blivit alltmer viktig. Isobutan r en viktig rvara fr alkyleringsprocesser,
som producerar utmrkta och miljvnliga bensinkomponenter. Modifiering av zeoliter
genom protonering eller metalltillsats r viktig ur srl industriell som akademisk
synvinkel.
Avsikten med diplomarbetet var att underska olika metoder fr syntes av katalysatorer.
Protonerade MCM-22 med olika surhets grad, Si/Al (is Si/Al correct?) frhllande 28,
30, 50 och 70 syntetiserades och modifierades med palladium. Drefter karaketeriserades
och testades katalysatorerena i laboratoriet. Till testreaktioner fr att studera effekten av
-
surhet valdes isomerisering av n-butan och oxidering av laktos. Syntestidens effekt
studerades med hjlp av ultraljudsbehandling av MCM-22-30. Olika
palladiumtillsatsmetoder p zeoliter studerades med hjlp av laktosoxidation som
exempel p finkemikalieapplikation.
Syntesen av MCM-36 utfrdes utgende frn olika MCM-22 material. Den ytterst
krvande syntesen av MCM-48 samt reproducerbarheten av denna, ingr ven i detta
diplomarbete.
Olika surheter p MCM-22 katalysatormaterial pverkade aktiviteten och utbytet av
isobutan och isomeriseringen av n-butan. Den protonerade formen av H-MCM-22-30-R
hade hgre aktivitet n Pd-formen i isomeriseringen av n-butan. Bda formerna
uppvisade liknande aktiviteter i oxidationen av laktos.
Katalysatorstabiliteten, konversionen av n-butan, utbytet och selektiviteten till isobutan
studerades med Pd-H-MCM-22-28-I under olika fldeshastigheter och olika
temperaturer.
-
1
1. Introduction 1.1. Isomerization of n-Butane
Transformation of hydrocarbons is of prime economic importance in the
petrochemical industry. Generally, the transformation occurs under strong acidic
conditions. For example, liquid super acids such as SbF5/HF or SbF5/HSO3F can activate alkanes at temperatures below 273 K. However, the drawback of liquid
acids is that they are corrosive and difficult to recover and reuse. As a
replacement of liquid acids, solid acids exhibit a promising alternative because of
their environmental friendly characteristics (non-corrosiveness, ease of handling,
and easy to recover and reuse) [1]. Butane can be obtained from catalytic and
steam crackers of oil refineries and petrochemical plants. The isomerization of n-
butane to isobutane is an important reaction for the production of alkylates and
oxygenated compounds such as tertiary butyl alcohol (TBA), methyl tertiary butyl
ether (MTBE), isooctene, polyisobutene (PIB) and polyisobutene rubber.
In the petrochemical industry, halogenated alumina and comparable catalysts
containing precious metals, as well as organic chlorides have been used for this
reaction in order to reach the necessary acidic strength. Unfortunately, these are
non-environmental-friendly catalysts and, therefore, there is a great interest
among academic and industrial researchers to find and develop new active,
selective and resistant-to-deactivation catalysts. The main problem associated
with the use of strongly acid zeolites, e.g. H-Mordenite, as isomerization catalysts
is the fast deactivation [5, 6]. Zeolites such as ZSM-5, beta, and Mesoporous
molecular sieves as well a sulfated zirconia have been reported to be active
catalysts in the isomerization of n-butane. The stability and activity of the
catalysts have been improved by the introduction of metals combined with the
usage of hydrogen as a carrier [2]. Much discussion has been going on in the
literature whether the apparently simple isomerization of n-butane to isobutane
goes via a bi- or monomolecular mechanisms. The relative importance of these
-
2
mechanisms depends on the reaction temperature and the surface concentration
of reactants determined by temperature, reactant pressure and concentration of
acid sites. Skeletal isomerization of n-butane over zeolite catalysts is proposed
(see Figure 1) to proceed via a bimolecular dimerization-cracking route. The first step is the formation of the butylcarbenium ion from butane by: (i) protonation of
butane by a Brnsted acid site to form a penta-coordinated butylcarbocation eq.
(1) and subsequent abstraction of H2, eq. (2), (3) (ii) hydride abstraction by a
Lewis acid site eq. (3) and (iii) protonation of trace olefins formed eq, (4). The
butyl carbenium ion reacts with a olefin (butene) forming an octylcarbenium ion,
which yields n- and isobutane after isomerization and beta-scission. Byproducts,
mainly propane and pentanes, are obtained from the C8 intermediates after
disproportionation. The formation of olefin species is important for the skeletal
isomerization of n-butane, since they are needed in the dimerization step [3].
However, the possibility of the n-butane isomerization also via a monomolecular
mechanism has been proposed by Tran et al. [4]. The bimolecular mechanism
shown below is a simplified version of that used to describe n-butane
isomerization.
n-C4H10 C4H9+ + H .. (1)
C4H9+ C4H8 + H+. (2)
H+ + H H2 .. (3)
C4H8 + H+ C4H9+ (4)
C4H9+ + C4H8 C8H17+ i-C4H10 ..... (5)
Figure 1. Reaction mechanism of isomerization of n-butane (68).
-
3
The primary reactions (1.1-1.4) in butane conversion may involve cracking
of butane into propylene and methane or ethylene and ethane, disproportionation
of butane into pentane and propane, and isomerization of n-butane into iso-
butane. Butane disproportionation is more dependent on strong acid site density
of a catalyst than butane cracking (mono-molecular reaction) since two adjacent
acidic sites are needed to start disproportionation (bi-molecular reaction) [81].
Ethylene, propylene, propane and pentanes formed from the primary reactions
may undergo further reactions. The secondary reactions (1.5-1.12) may involve
oligomerization, isomerization, cracking, hydrogen transfer, dehydrocyclization,
aromatization, and coking (which leads to catalyst deactivation), etc. At low
conversions, the primary reactions will be predominant.
Primary reactions: n-C4H10 C3H6+CH4 (cracking) ................................. 1.1a
n-C4H10 C2H4+ C2H6 (cracking) ................................. 1.1b
2 n-C4H10C5H12+C3H8 (disproportionation) ............... 1.1c
n- C4H10i-C4H10 (isomerization) ................................. 1.1d
Secondary reactions: i- C5H12 C3H8 + C2H4 (cracking) ................................ 1.1e
C3H8 C2H4+CH4 (cracking) ........................................ 1.1f
2 C2H4n-C4H8 (oligomerization) ................................. 1.1g
C2H4+C3H6i-C5H10 (oligomerization) ...........................1.1h
i-C4H8 +i- C5H12i- C4H10+i-C5H12 (hydrogen transfer)...1.1i
n- C4H8i-C4H8 (isomerization).......................................1.1j
C6H12 C2H4+ C4H8 (cracking) .......................................1.1k
Olefins Aromatics + H2 (dehydrocyclization) ................1.1l
In the temperature range, except for cracking reactions (Reactions 1.1a,
1.1b, 1.1e, 1.1f, 1.1k) that are very endothermic; the other reactions are
exothermic or have small heats of reaction. Oligomerizations (Reactions 1.1g
-
4
and 1.1h) have large exothermic heats of reaction. The effect of temperature on
the equilibria of the reactions is different. For cracking reactions, a high
temperature is favored; while for oligomerization, a low temperature is favored.
For hydrogen transfer reactions and isomerization reactions, the effect of
temperature on reaction equilibrium is not as significant as on the other reactions
[81].
The zeolites to be used in skeletal isomerization of n-butane should have at least
10-membered-ring channels (0.45-0.6 nm), if the molecular sizes of reactant n-
butane (critical diameter 0.49 nm) and the product isobutane (critical diameter
0.56 nm) are taken into consideration. The channels of 8-membered-ring
zeolites (0.35-0.45 nm) are too small to allow branched molecules to diffuse with
any considerable rate, which results in a rapid deactivation of the catalyst.
1.2. Fine Chemicals Zeolites are important catalysts in a multitude of contemporary chemical
production processes. A continually increasing number of applications is
emerging in the production of organic intermediates and fine chemicals. In drug
manufacture, fine chemicals are pure, single chemical substances that are
produced by chemical reactions. Examples of fine chemicals are intermediates
for drug production and bulk active pharmaceutical ingredients ready to be
compounded with inert pigments, solvents and excipients and made into dosage
forms [7]. Most of the fine chemicals are used in the manufacturing of life saving
drugs; in order to prepare the fine chemicals we need catalysts with high activity
and selectivity towards desire product.
-
5
1.3. Oxidation of Lactose
Lactose oxidation is a consecutive reaction, resulting first in lactobionic acid, and
then in 2-keto-lactobionic acid (Figure 2). From industrial viewpoint this reaction is interesting because lactobionic acid possesses useful properties and can,
thus, be used as acidulant, complexing agent or antioxidant in food, pharmacy
and medicine. Lactose, an abundant disaccharide, is a by-product of dairy
industry available in big amounts [26-28].
Figure 2. Reaction of lactose oxidation.
Oxidation of sugars is very sensitive to several factors such as pH of reaction
media, since the formation of corresponding carbohydrate acids results into big pH
OO
O
OH
OH
OH
OH
OH
OH
OH
H
OH
OOCOONa
OH
OH
OH
OH
OH
OH
OH
OOCOONa
OH
OH
OH
OH
OH
OH
OH
OH
OOOH
OH
OH
OH
O
O
HO
OH
OH
Lactose Lactobionic acid (LBA), sodium salt
Lactulose 2-keto-Na-Lactobionate
IsomerizationOH-
O2
O2
OH
-
6
change. Another important parameter is the oxygen feed rate, since the reaction
rate can be retarded either due to the lack or due to oversupply of oxygen (i.e.
oxygen poisoning) at high oxygen feed rate.
2. Background and Theory
2.1 Introduction to zeolites
2.1.1. Definition
Zeolites are crystalline aluminosilicates characterized by a structure that
comprises a three-dimensional and regular framework formed by linked TO4
tetrahedral (T= Si, Al, etc), each oxygen being between two T-elements. This
tetrahedron is the fundamental building unit of all zeolites. These simple
tetrahedra are combined in a complex way to form secondary building units
(SBU), forming the building block of the different framework structures of zeolite
crystals [27].
Classical zeolite structures are composed from primary units of AlO4 and SiO4
and polyhedra with secondary units to form frame network with Si-O-Al atoms. At
the movement there are over 170 types of zeolites in which 50 are naturally
occurring zeolites. The aluminum atoms, particularly in high silica zeolites, may
not be uniformity distributed, often zoning effect is observed.
2.1.2. Framework and Structure
A defining feature of zeolites is that their frameworks are made up of 4-
connected networks of atoms (see Figure 3). One way of thinking about this is in terms of tetrahedra, with a silicon atom in the middle and oxygen atoms at the
-
7
corners. These tetrahedra can then link together by their corners (see illustration)
to from a rich variety of beautiful structures. The framework structure may contain
linked cages, cavities or channels, which are of the right size to allow small
molecules to enter - i.e. the limiting pore sizes are roughly between 3 and 10 in
diameter.
In all, over 130 different framework structures are now known. In addition to
having silicon or aluminum as the tetrahedral atom, other compositions have also
been synthesized, including the growing category of microporous
aluminophosphates, known as ALPOs [34].
Figure 3. Frame work of aluminosilicates in zeolites (78).
Figure 4. Zeolite structure (77) (ZSM-5). Figure 5. Zeolite cage (77).
The structure has channels and cavities with molecular sizes (Figures 4 and 5) that can host the charge-compensating cations, water or other molecules and
salts. A schematic representation of a chain of tetrahedral is shown in Fig. 3. In a real crystal, however, all four oxygen atoms are bridging atoms except where the
macromolecule terminates at the crystal faces, in which case a proton
-
8
coordinates to the non-bridging oxygen atom. Each tetrahedron containing
aluminum formally has one unit of negative charge because the aluminum atom
has a formal charge of +3 and each oxygen atom has a formal charge of -2.
There are enough metal cations, such as Na+, K+, Ca+2, Mg+2 or Sr+2, present in
the interstices of the aluminosilicate framework to make the crystal electrically
neutral. These cations are usually mobile and are responsible for the ion
exchange with another metal.
2.1.3. History of zeolites
The discovery of zeolite catalysts in the late 1950s stimulated the interest of
chemists, physicists, and engineers in the study of zeolite catalysts and reactions
catalyzed by them and before the discovery of zeolites in catalysis, there is much
information in the history (see Table 1) which tells about the application of zeolite materials.
Table 1. History of Zeolites (38).
Date Facts of zeolite History
1756 Zeolite mineral identified
1850 Ion-exchange properties
1858 Reversible adsorption/Desorption of water
1862 Synthetic zeolite
1926 Molecular sieves defined
1929 Modern concepts of zeolite structure identification
1948 Synthetic zeolite without natural occurrence
1953 Synthetic zeolite commercialized
1967 First International Conference on Zeolites, foundation of IZA
1972 High silica zeolites
1979 Pillared clays
1982 Aluminophosphates
1991 Mesoporous molecular sieves
-
9
2.1.4. Classification of zeolites
The natural or synthetic zeolites are hydrated micro porous molecular sieves
(
-
10
several purposes, such as oil dewaxing and ethylbenzene production. In 1980s
and 1990s, zeolites and molecular sieves were used for several petroleum-
refining applications particularly for hydrocarbon cracking and production of
octane-enhancement additives. The zeolites are also classified into different
groups depending upon the silica to alumina ratio as mentioned in Table 2.
Table 2. Zeolites classification (74) (depends on silica to alumina ratio).
Si/Al ratio Zeolite Properties
Low(1-1.5) A,X Relatively low stability of
framework, low stability in acids,
High stability in bases ,
High concentration of acid groups
with moderate acid strength
Hydrophilic
Intermediate(2-5) Erionite,
Chabazite,
Clinoptilolite,
Mordenite
High(10-infinite) ZSM-5, Erionite,
Mordenite,MCM-
41,MCM-22,MCM-
36, etc.
Relatively high stability of frame
work, high stability in acids and
low stability in bases.
The effect of silica to alumina ratio on physicochemical properties of the zeolites
as explained:
a. Increasing SiO2/Al2O3 ratio affects the following physical properties of the
zeolite:
-
11
Increases acid resistance Increases thermal stability Increases hydrophobicity Decreases affinity for polar adsorbents Decreases cation content.
b. Decreasing SiO2/Al2O3 ratio affects following physical properties of the
zeolite:
Increases hydrophilicity Increases cation exchange properties Decreases the pore size for same numbering ring, as Al has
lower atomic radius than Si.
2.1.5. Shape selectivity
The shape selectivity provided by the microporous crystalline structures of
zeolites is of crucial importance in hydrocarbon transformation. The rate of
deactivation by coke largely depends on the shape selectivity. The crystalline
structures of zeolites can be altered to a large extent achieving desired shape
selective properties. Three different types of shape selectivity are observed over
zeolites (shown in Figure 6) and summarized shortly here [32].
1. Reactant selectivity occurs when some of the molecules in the reactant
mixture are too large to diffuse through the catalyst pores.
2. Product selectivity occurs when some of the products formed within the
pores are too bulky to diffuse out. The bulky molecules are either converted to
less bulky molecules or coked, that eventually deactivates the catalyst.
3. Restricted transition-state selectivity occurs when certain reactions are
prevented because the corresponding transition-state would require more space
-
12
than the available in the cavities or in the pores. Neither the reactant nor the
products are prevented from diffusing through the pores.
The most important type of shape selectivity in the skeletal isomerization of n-
butane is the restricted transition-state selectivity (Figure 6). Concerning the restricted transition state-type selectivity, the lower transition state molecule is
easier to accommodate in the cavities than the upper one.
Figure 6. Schematic representation of the three types of shape-selectivity (70).
-
13
The Figure 7 gives the idea of the shape selectivity of the molecules entering into the zeolite pores which depends upon the size and shape selectivity of the
molecules. There are in principle as many different shapes, as shown in Figure 7,
and dimensions of intracrystalline cavity or channels, as there are zeolite
topologies. All molecular sieves are classified according to their dimensions (pore
diameter) into microporous (pore mouth less than 2 nm) and macroporous (pore
mouth more than 2 nm) materials. Zeolites are microporous molecular sieves and
are also divided in small, medium or large pores.
Figure 7. Shape-selective environments in different zeolite structure types (71): (a) large molecules have access to interrupted cavities and channel intersections
for pore mouth catalysis; (b) molecules are plugged into the pore aperture; (c)
molecules are converted in multiple pore mouths according to key-lock catalysis;
(d) molecules are converted in the intra-crystalline shape-selective environment.
-
14
2.1.6. Acidity
Zeolites and zeolite-type catalysts are usually acidic according to both definitions
of acidity e.g. Brnsted (proton donor) and Lewis (electron pair acceptor) acidity.
In hydrocarbon transformation, Brnsted acid sites (Figure 8) are considered to be more important. The proton form of a molecular sieve containing Brnsted
acid sites can easily be obtained from the ammonium form by calcination.
However, Brnsted acid sites can be present already in the as-synthesized
molecular sieves, as determined by the choice of the template [1]. The number of
acid sites is proportional to the concentration of the framework trivalent T-atoms.
There are, however, factors that affect the acid strength, like the nature of
trivalent T-atom and the Si/T-atom ratio in the framework. The acidity decreases
in the order: Al>Ga>Fe>>B. Brnsted acid sites in zeolites account for their
catalytic properties and can be investigated by NMR, FTIR or TPD
measurements.
Figure 8. Brnsted acid site as present in a zeolite (72).
-
15
2.1.7. Synthesis of zeolites
Zeolites are crystalline aluminosilicates with the general formula Mn/2.O.Al2O3
.ySiO2. By varying the "template" molecule added to an aqueous solution of
mineralized silica (and co metal) nearly 100 different zeolites have been
synthesized. Other synthetic variables including the source of the inorganic
precursors, the mineralizing agent (OH-, or F-) and the reactant concentrations
have also resulted in new crystalline materials. Various zeolites are synthesized
with varying the Si/Al ratio with minute value 1 to infinite.
a. Pre-synthesis Method
Aluminosilicates zeolites are formed by hydrothermal synthesis, typically under
mild conditions. Zeolites are synthesized by mixing a silica source (SiO2), an
alumina source (Al2O3), organic template, mineralizing agent (OH- anion, NaOH)
and water as solvent to form an aluminosilicate gel.
The nucleation and crystallization of the gel takes place in an autoclave (shown
in Figure 11). The zeolite crystals that are formed are filtered, washed and dried. Washing is required to reduce the alkalinity because of the addition of NaOH.
In order to remove the organic template, zeolites are typically calcined after
drying. Different calcinations techniques have an effect on the properties of the
synthesized zeolite. After calcinations the zeolite is in the so called sodium form,
denoted by Na at the beginning of the e.g. Na-ZSM-5 because it contains sodium
ions to balance the framework charge induced by Al as T-atoms.
Zeolite crystallization mainly depends on the sources of silica and alumina,
temperature, pressure, synthesis time, solution pH, composition of the gel and
the nature of the organic templates, pretreatment of the reactants, inclusion of
-
16
special additives, homogeneity or heterogeneity of the reactant mixture as well
as seeding effects.
The pH of the solution is an important parameter in the zeolite synthesis.
Increasing the alkalinity at constant temperature influences the kinetics of zeolite
crystallization in the same way as increasing the temperature at constant
alkalinity does. The induction time decreases strongly and the crystal growth is
accelerated with an increase in pH [14]. The decrease in the nucleation time and
enhanced rate of crystal growth with rising pH can be attributed to the much
greater concentrations of dissolved species. The induction time in zeolite
crystallization decreases rapidly with increasing temperature, up to a certain
point. Alkalinity also has effect on the Si:Al ratio of the zeolite [16]. Since OH-
ions serve as a mineralizing agent, the pH of the gel solution is of utmost
important. The OH ions bring the Si and Al oxides or hydroxides into the solution
at a particular rate. Crystallinity of zeolites increases with time and usually the as-
synthesized form of zeolite is not the most suitable for the catalytic purpose.
Template makes the stability, control the formation of a microporous framework
structure (see Figure 9) of the zeolite and then the template can be removed. Thereafter, the microporous voids channels and cavities are created by
calcination. A large number of organic molecules can be used as templates for
zeolites synthesis. Typical templates are alkyl ammonium cations R4N+, alkyl
phosphates (R4P+) and organic complexes, which act as structure directing
agents and help in the formation of the zeolite lattice. The templates contribute to
the stability by forming new bonds such as hydrogen and electrostatic bonds,
and assist in the formation of the particular structure through their form and size.
While choosing a template for the synthesis of a zeolite, important properties of
the template such as its solubility, stability during the synthesis, steric
compatibility, framework stabilization and removal of the template without
destroying the frame work structure of the zeolite must be taken into account.
The structure directing agents can be organic or inorganic compounds. They are
-
17
cations, ion pairs and neutral molecules. Of the three species, cations are the
most important because they not only acts as structure directing agents but also
affect the rate of zeolite crystallization. The mechanism of the zeolite synthesis is
illustrated in the Figure 11.
Figure 9. Zeolite pore structure formation (72).
Generally used silica, alumina and template sources for the synthesis of zeolites
as mentioned below.
1. Silica Sources: Tetra methyl orthosilicate (Si(OCH3)4), Tetra ethyl orthosilicate (Si(OC2H5)4), waterglass (Na2SiO3.9H2O), Na2O 11%, SiO2
29%, Ludox-AS-40 (colloidal silica), Fumed silica, Aerosil-200, etc.
2. Alumina Sources: sodium aluminate (NaAlO2) 54% Na2O, Al2O3,
Al (OH)3 aluminum hydroxide Gibbsite, etc.
-
18
3. Templates: Alkyl ammonium cations R4N+, alkyl phosphates (R4P+) and
organic complexes, and also inorganic cations like Na+, Li+, K+, etc.
b. Post synthesis method
The sodium form of zeolite is made to acidic form by ion-exchanging sodium
cations with NH4Cl or NH4NO3 to achieve an ammonium form (Figure 10). The ammonium form of zeolite is dried and calcined to obtain the proton form of
zeolite i.e. acidic form of zeolite.
Figure 10. Zeolite synthesis flow sheet (i.e. proton form).
Sodium form of zeolite formed (Na-zeolite form, parent zeolite)
Drying in order to remove water molecules at 100 oC and then calcination process to remove template or surfactant.
Nucleation and crystal growth takes place in autoclave at 150oC, 1-7 days
Sodium form to proton form with 1M NH4Cl sol. by ion exchange and then dried and calcined to remove ammonia molecules to get proton form.
Silica source + alumina source + NaOH (mineralizing agent) + Organic template ----------- leads to gel formation
-
19
Figure 11. Synthesis mechanism of zeolite (73).
c. Present day research on zeolites
Synthetic goals in research include the optimization of reported syntheses,
variation of the composition of zeolites with known topologies and understanding
the influence of synthetic conditions like synthesis time, silica to alumina ratio,
etc. that favor the formation of these low-symmetry crystalline phases and
moreover the high quality zeolites should be more feasible, high porosity, eco-
friendly, easy handling, easy recovery, less expensive, high thermal stable, high
activity, longer life and high selectivity.
2.1.8. Mesoporous molecular sieves
Mesoporous materials are those with pores in the range 2-50 nm in diameter.
They have huge surface areas, providing a vast number of sites where sorption
-
20
processes can occur. These materials have numerous applications in catalysis,
separation and many other fields. The synthesis of these materials is of
considerable interest and is constantly being developed to introduce different
properties. Molecular sieves are porous solids with pores of the size of molecular
dimensions, 0.3-2.0 nm in diameter or more. Examples include zeolites, carbons,
glasses and oxides. Some are crystalline with a uniform pore size delineated by
their crystal structure, e.g., zeolites, while others are amorphous carbon
molecular sieves. The most common commercial molecular sieves are zeolites. Mobile composite of matter (MCM) materials are mesoporous templated
molecular sieves (Figure 12). M41S are typically semi crystalline mesoporous silicates and aluminosilicates with pores 2-10 nm related to phyllosilicate
minerals, imogolite and alophane [19]. MCM-22, MCM-36, MCM-48 and MCM-50
are the members of mesoporous with high surface areas.
Figure 12. Ordered mesoporous materials
Amongst the current developments in the field of hierarchical pore structures, the
creation of mesopores in zeolite crystals is the most frequently employed way to
combine micropores with mesopores in one material. There are different
approaches to generate and characterize mesopores in zeolite crystals and
establish their impact on the catalytic action with better mass transport.
Mesopores can be created (see Figure 13) via several routes from which steaming and acid leaching are the most frequently applied. Novel approaches
using secondary carbon templates that are removed after syntheses have
recently been launched. For the characterization of mesopores, nitrogen
physisorption and electron microscopy are commonly used. More recently, it was
shown that electron tomography, a form of three-dimensional transmission
-
21
electron microscopy, is able to reveal the three-dimensional shape, size and
connectivity of the mesopores. The effect of the presence of mesopores for
catalysis is demonstrated for several industrially applied processes that make
use of zeolite catalysts in the cracking of heavy oil fractions and synthesis of fine
chemicals over zeolite Y, and the production of cumene and hydroisomerization
of alkanes over mordenite. For these processes, the mesopores ensure an
optimal accessibility and transport of reactants and products, while the zeolite
micropores induce the preferred shape-selective properties [38-39].
Figure 13. Schematic representation of the assembly of zeolite nanocrystals to a mesoporous structure (31).
The fundamental reagents used in the synthesis of mesoporous templated
molecular sieves are
1. The long chain quaternary ammonium ions used as surfactants form micelles or
liquid crystals in aqueous solutions.
2. The silicate or aluminosilicate species, reflecting the micellar array condense and
polymerize around the hydrophilic parts of the surfactant.
3. Condensed inorganic species aggregates to form the walls of the porous solid.
4. Calcination of the materials removes the organic templates. This procedure
improves the stability of the structure.
-
22
2.1.9. Zeolite pore structure and active sites
The adsorption and catalytic process is over zeolites involve diffusion of
molecules in the zeolites pores, only those with a minimum of 8 tetrahedral
atoms apertures allowing this diffusion are generally considered for the particular
reactions [12], for e.g.:
i. Small pore zeolite with eight membered ring pore aperture having free
diameters 0.3-0.45 nm.
ii. Medium pore zeolites with ten membered ring apertures 0.45-0.60 nm in free
diameter.
iii. Large pore zeolites with 12 membered ring apertures 0.6-0.8 nm as
represented in Figure 14.
Figure 14. Pore openings of common zeolites with 12, 10 and 8 member ring structures (74).
Active sites in zeolite pores act as an acid, acid base, or bifunctional catalysis.
For example in fluid catalytic cracking, a catalyst containing acid sites e.g., FAU
zeolite is applicable. Also methanol conversion to olefins reactions, acetylation
reactions etc, need acid sites. The hydrocarbon reactions as well as many
transformations functionalized compounds are catalyzed by protonic sites only.
-
23
The maximum number of protonic sites is equal to the number of framework
aluminum atoms. The number of protonic sites can be adjusted either during the
synthesis or during post synthesis pretreatment of the zeolite: dealumination, ion-
exchange, etc. The parameters determining the acid strength of the zeolite
protonic sites are important in catalytic applications. The first feature of zeolites is
their stronger acidity compared to amorphous aluminosilicates. A relation exists
between the T-O-T bond angles and the acid strength of the associated proton in
the zeolites. Hence, the greater the angle, the stronger the active sites in
zeolites. The protonic sites (bond angles) of the zeolites are influenced by the
basicity of the reactants and the temperature will also play a role. Some of the
zeolites catalysts acidity measurements using pyridine adsorption are presented
in Table 3. For example, an acid site giving surface hydroxyl groups (-OH groups) i.e. the Brnsted acid site, which are more selective property for a zeolite
in acid catalysis. The higher Al atoms content in zeolite framework is proportional
to higher Brnsted acid sites (maximum acidity at Si/Al = 9-12).
Table 3. Brnsted and Lewis acid sites of the different zeolite catalysts (74).
S.No Catalyst Brnsted acid
sites (mol/g.cat)
Lewis acid sites
(mol/g.cat)
1 H-Beta-11 183 128
2 Mordenite 294 109
3 H -Y 291 165
4 H-MCM-41 89 168
5 H-MCM-22 187 175
6 Silica 0 7
7 Alumina 7 156
-
24
2.1.10. Zeolites in Industrial Applications
Applications of zeolites are in three main areas [13]:
i. Ion exchange: It is one of the important properties of the zeolites. The most
important end application of synthetic zeolites is in detergents. Zeolites replaced
phosphates builders that are caused algae overgrowth and consequently oxygen
deficit in water resources. Zeolites in sewage waters accumulate and immobilize
phosphates etc.
ii. Adsorption: zeolites are important industrial adsorbents for the separation of
both gases and liquids. They possess excellent capacity to remove volatile
organic chemicals from air streams and to separate isomers and mixtures of
gases.
iii. Catalysis: with the use of X and Y zeolites in isomerization and cracking,
hydrocarbon transformation, etc. Many industrial applications are presented in
the Table 4.
-
25
Table 4. Application of zeolites in various industries (10).
Zeolite/microporous material
Process or application technology
LTA (A-type zeolites) Detergent builder, separation, desiccation
FAU(X-and Y-type
zeolites)
Catalytic cracking, hydrocracking, separation,
Purification and desiccation, aromatic alkylation.
BEA (Beta zeolite) FCC additive, cumene and ethylbenzene production.
MOR (Mordenite) Hydrocracking, hydroisomerisation, dewaxing, NOx
reduction, adsorption, cumene synthesis, transalkylation of
aromatics.
MWW (MCM-22) Ethyl benzene and cumene production, Isomerization etc.
MFI (ZSM-5) Dewaxing, hydrocracking, ethyl benzene (Mobil-Badger) and
styrene production, xylene isomerisation, methanol to
gasoline (MTG), benzene alkylation, adsorption, catalytic
aromatization, FCC additive, toluene disproportionation
ERI (Erionite) Selectoforming, hydrocracking
LTL (KL-type zeolites) Catalytic aromatization
CHA (SAPO-34) Methanol to olefins (MTO)
FER (Ferrierite) n-Butene skeletal isomerisation
TON (Theta-1, ZSM-22) Long-chain paraffin isomerisation
AEL (SAPO-11) Long-chain paraffin isomerisation
-
26
3. Catalyst preparation methods Methods of metal modification of zeolites and mesoporous sieves are ion
exchange, impregnation, and in-situ. New methods of metal modification are
direct metal introduction (in-situ), isomorphous substitution of metal in framework
of zeolite and chemical anchoring.
3.1. Ion-exchange method
After post synthesis method, an acidic form i.e. proton form zeolite catalysts is
obtained. To this metal precursor solution is added in order to get metal modified
form under continuous stirring for 24 h and measure the pH value then filtration,
drying, and step calcination are performed.
Ion-exchange method consists of replacing an ion in an electrostatic interaction
with the surface of a support by another ion species. The support containing ions
A is plunged into an excess volume (compared to the pore volume) of a solution
containing ions B. Ions B gradually penetrate into the pore space of the support,
while ions A pass into the solution, until equilibrium is established corresponding
to a given distribution of the two ions between the solid and the solution. For
example, using a proper salt solution at ca. 100 C (to increase the exchange
rate), it is possible to prepare the acid form of zeolite by exchanging NH4+ for Na+
and successive calcination.
Natural exchangers are composed of a framework bearing electric charges
neutral by ions of opposite sign. For zeolites, for example, these charges are
negative and are due to the particular environment of aluminum. Aluminum, just
like silicon, is effectively situated in the center of a tetrahedron of four oxygen
atoms, which provides it with four negative charges, whereas the aluminum itself
has only three positive charges. The tetrahedron (AlO4) is thus an overall bearer
of a negative charge distributed over the oxygen atoms, and this charge is
-
27
neutralized by the presence of various cations Na+, K+ etc. These cations are not
definitely linked to the framework but may be replaced by the other cations during
an ion exchange operation. Whatever the exchanger conditions, and in particular
the pH, zeolites are cation exchangers and have a constant number of exchange
sites, which is equal to the number of aluminum atoms in their framework.
There are natural ion exchangers other than zeolites. Clays and silicates are
cation exchangers, whereas hydrotalcites are anion exchangers. As in the case
of zeolites, the number of exchange sites is not pH dependent.
Oxide surfaces contacted with water are generally covered with hydroxyl groups
which can be schematically represented as S-OH, where S stands for Al, Si, Ti,
Fe, etc. Some of these groups may behave as Brnsted acids, whereas other
hydroxy groups may behave as Brnsted bases, giving rise to the following
equation:
S-OH = S-O- + H+ . (1)
S-OH + H+ = S-OH+2 (2)
The resulting surface charge which arises from an excess of one type of charged
site over the other, is a function of the solution pH. A given value of pH exists for
which the particle is not charged overall. This value is characteristic of the oxide
and is called the pristine point of zero charge (PPZC or ZPC). Alumina is
amphoteric and may adsorb cations as well as anions and it ranges between 7
and 9. Silica ZPC values range between 1.5 and 3 and silica may adsorb cations.
The general procedure to introduce cations into the zeolite framework consists of
exchanging the Na+ cations, which balance the negative charge born by AlO4
tetrahedra with a solution of metal salt of the ion-exchange method. It has been
found that the equilibrium of the exchange reaction depends on temperature and
-
28
the concentration of the exchanging metal salt solution [12]. Cation exchange
into the hydrogen form of the zeolite is more difficult than into the Na-form
because of the strong bonding of the protons with the lattice oxygen. The proton
exchange limitation can be overcome by transforming the H-form into the NH4-
form, which has an ion-exchange property similar to that of Na+-form zeolite.
Metal-modified zeolites can be obtained either by means of a multistage process
of ion-exchange with intermediate zeolite heating or by a single-stage process of
ion-exchange at high temperature in autoclaving conditions. The pH of the
exchange solution is important, firstly because it is known that acid solutions can
partially hydrolyze and dealuminate zeolite and secondly, because metal
solutions of different pH values can readily precipitate basic salts within a zeolite
matrix to various degrees. The theoretical ion-exchange capacity depends on the
chemical composition of the zeolite: the lower the Si/Al ratio in the lattice is, the
higher the ion-exchange capacity is [13].
Ion exchange is composed of a frame work bearing electric charges neutralized
by ions of opposite sign. For example, [PtCl6]2- (hexachloro planitinic acid-II) ion-
exchanged with H-ZSM-5 (proton form of ZSM-5).
3.2. Impregnation Method The impregnation method is used to obtain higher loadings and to apply active
precursors that do not adsorb on support easily. The solution of the precursor is
broken up into small discontinuous elements presented in the pore of the support
by gradually evaporating the solvent. Impregnation is the easiest method of
making a catalyst.
A carrier, usually porous, is contacted with a solution of one or more suitable
metallic compounds. The carrier is then dried, and the catalyst is activated as in
the case of precipitated catalyst. The active agent is never introduced into a
porous support in its final form but by the intermediary precursor, the choice of
-
29
which is very important for the quality of the final deposit. The size and the shape
of the catalyst particles are that of the carrier. The impregnation mechanism
which is shown in the Figure 15 gives the general idea about the process.
Two types of impregnation can be considered, depending on
i. If an interaction exits between the support and the precursors at the moment of
wetting, and
ii. If there is no wetting.
a. Impregnation with no interaction between support and catalyst
If the support does not have its own catalytic activity then it gives the fine catalyst
by adding the precursor solution in order to have contact with the support i.e.
metal-support non-bonding. This is a relatively rapid operation because the pores
are filled with the solution and forms air bubbles and then released after 10
minutes. The maximum amount of metal precursor that can be introduced will be
depending on the solubility of the precursor salt in the solvent and also the pore
volume of the support. The impregnation technique required less equipment
since the filtering and drying steps are eliminated and washing may not be
needed.
b. Impregnation with interaction between support and catalyst
Impregnation with interaction occurs when the solute deposited and establishes a
bond with the surface of the support at the time of wetting. Such interaction
results in a near atomic dispersion of the precursor's active phase. The
interaction can be as ion-exchange, adsorption, or a chemical reaction.
Impregnation is the preferred process in preparing supported noble metal
catalysts for which it is usually economically desirable to spread out the metal in
finely divided form. The noble metal is usually present in the order of 1 wt% or
-
30
less or 5 wt% of the total catalyst. This makes maximum use of a very expensive
ingredient, in contrast, to precipitated catalysts where some of the active
ingredient will usually be enclosed by other material present and thus unavailable
for reaction. This work mainly deals with incipient wetness impregnation, an
amount of solution is added to the support just enough to fill the pore volume.
The disadvantage of this method is broad particle size distribution.
Figure 15. Mechanism of impregnation method (74).
3.3. In-situ Method
Metal solution is added after preparing the gel solution of zeolites i.e. during pre-
synthesis, In-situ method is used to get higher metal loadings and highly metal
species dispersion into the zeolite support.
-
31
4. Characterization Methods For application of zeolites as shape selective property in catalysis and in order to
correlate the effect of the synthesis parameters with the catalytic and physico-
chemical properties, synthesized materials need to be characterized properly.
The important parameters, which were investigated in this thesis work, are the
specific surface area, phase purity, crystallinity, structure, morphology, the
presence and the amount of different acid sites, the amount of an introduced
metal in the ion exchanged and impregnation catalysts (i.e. metal loadings or
metal content). A brief description of the each of the methods used is given
below.
1. Surface area measurements (N2 adsorption)
2. X-ray powder diffraction (XRD)
3. Scanning electron microscopy (SEM)
4. Fourier Transform Infra Red spectroscopy (FTIR)
5. Direct Current Plasma (DCP)
4.1. Surface area measurements The surface area of zeolites catalysts were measured by nitrogen adsorption.
First, catalysts were dried over night at 373 K and out gassed in a burette at 473
K for three hours.
The most common method of measuring of surface area is N2 adsorption using
BET (Brunauer, Emmett and Teller) isotherm method for mesoporous materials.
00
)1(1)( CPV
PCCVPPV
Pmm
+= (1) where
-
32
V= Volume of the adsorbed gas at pressure P
Vm= Volume of the gas adsorbed in the monolayer
P0 = Saturation pressure of adsorbate gas at the experimental temperature
P= Experimental pressure
C= A constant related exponentially to the heat of adsorption and heat of
liquefaction of the gas
RTHH condadeC /)( = (2)
where,
Had= Heat of adsorption on the first layer
Hcond= Heat of liquefaction of adsorbed gas on all other layers
A graph from the nitrogen adsorption between P/V (P-P0) vs. P/ P0 gives a
straight line whose slope and intercept can be used to evaluate volume of the
gas adsorbed in the mono layer.
iSVm +=
1 Where, S is the slope and i is the intercept.
The execution of the experiment was carried out with help of surface area
measurement instrument i.e. Carlo Erba sorptomatic 1900 instrument using BET
for mesoporous and Dubinin isotherm for microporous materials.
4.1 . X-ray powder diffraction (XRD) The XRD or XRPD method gives elemental composition, catalyst structure
(phase purity) and particle size of the materials. Material should be sufficiently
crystalline to diffract X-rays (3-5 nm) and being present in desired amounts for In-
situ measurements.
-
33
For crystal size determination the following equation is used.
T=K / cos . (1)
T= is the thickness of crystal perpendicular to diffraction plane.
K= is a constant that depends on instrument
B = is the full width at half maximum (FWHM) of the diffraction peak
= angle of reflection
The purpose of XRD is to determine the unit cell parameters and thus unit cell
volume when the zeolitic structure is known, then one can determine if an
element has been introduced into the lattice framework position.
XRD method is also a measure of the purity of a compound, compared with
reference spectra. If there is no evidence of crystalline or amorphous
contaminants present, then one must compare the intensity of the reference with
the authentic sample to check for the same composition and crystal size.
The principle working of diffractometer is the divergence of the primary X-rays
beam which is limited by an automatic divergence slit (ADS) and a 15 mm mask.
The irradiated sample length was set to a fixed 12 mm length. On the diffracted
side, a 0.2 mm receiving slit and a 1 mm anti scatter slit is present. The diffracted
X-rays beam was filtered with a Ni Ka filter. The measured diffractograms were
analyzed using X pert high score software and the powder diffraction file (PDF)
database. The PDF database was used to identify the sample peaks and the
corresponding phases. All the samples were first screened through an angular
range 0.5-0.9(2theta) using 0.02 steps and 1s measuring time for each step.
-
34
4.3. Scanning electron microscopy (SEM analysis)
The morphology of zeolites catalysts was investigated by SEM analysis and SEM
of the samples were obtained by back scattering electrons. The purpose of using
back scattering electron was to observe relatively large crystalline materials. For
small crystalline catalysts SEM is not useful but high resolution transmission
electron microscope was used.
The pore shape, size, channels and small crystalline mesoporous molecular
sieves were investigated by high resolution transmission electron microscope
(TEM).
4.4 . Fourier transform infrared spectroscopy Infrared spectroscopy reveals information about molecular vibrations that cause
a change in the dipole moment of molecules. It offers a fingerprint of the
chemical bonds present within materials. FTIR (see Figure 16) is a very powerful analytical tool for examining both inorganic and organic materials. A
beam of radiation from the source is focused on a beam splitter, where half the
beam is reflected to a fixed mirror and the other half of the beam is transmitted to
a moving mirror which reflects the beam back to the beam splitter from where it
travels, recombined with the original half beam, to the detector. The IR intensity
variation with optical path difference (interferogram) is the Fourier transform of
the (broadband) incident radiation. The IR absorption spectrum can be obtained
by measuring an interferogram with and without a sample in the beam and
transforming the interferograms into spectra [21]. For example, the formation of
OH groups on the external and internal surface of Y-type zeolites as studied the
adsorption of small molecules such as ammonia and ethylene and later
employed pyridine as a probe molecule to discriminate Brnsted and Lewis acid
sites.
-
35
Figure 16. FITR spectrometer (75). Pyridine has extensively been used to probe Bronsted and Lewis acidity in
catalytic materials. Specific IR vibrations could be identified, depending on the
type of interaction of the molecule with surface sites. As an example, the
vibration mode ascribed to combined C-C stretching and N-H bending modes
was found at 1439 cm-1 for the gas phase, 1438 cm-1 for pyridine physically
adsorbed on silica alumina, 1450 cm-1 and 1545 cm-1 for pyridine chemically
sorbed respectively on Lewis and Brnsted acid sites. When adsorbed in HY
zeolite pores, pyridine was shown to form pyridinium ions (characterized by an
intense band at 1540 cm-1) by interaction with the so-called HF hydroxyls, siting
in the supercages and vibrating at 3640 cm-1. The HY zeolite structure presents a
second type of hydroxyls, the so-called LF hydroxyls, vibrating at 3550 cm-1 and
located in sterically less accessible cavities (sodalite cages and hexagonal
prisms). Although not accessible to pyridine because of too small cage opening,
LF sites have been shown to interact with pyridine, which suggested the mobility
of interacting LF sites toward positions accessible to pyridine, i.e. supercages.
The nature of the bonding between pyridine and LF hydroxyls was recently
clarified by Parker et al. a partial protonation of pyridine was suggested [17].
-
36
4.5 . Direct Current Plasma Direct Current Plasma Spectrometer (DCP) is used for efficient determination of
major and minor elements in sample solutions. A direct-current plasma (DCP) is
created by an electrical discharge between two electrodes. A plasma support gas
is necessary, and Ar is most common one. Samples can be deposited on one of
the electrodes, or conducting can make up one electrode. Insulating solid
samples are placed near the discharge in a way that ionized gas atoms sputter
the sample into the gas phase where the analyte atoms are excited. This
sputtering process is often referred to as glow-discharge excitation [23].
5. Overview on MCM-22 and MCM-36 zeolites
MCM-22 possesses a unique crystal structure and belongs to MWW group of
zeolites (Figure 17) containing two independent non-interconnected pore systems [51-53]. One of the channel systems contains two-dimensional
sinusoidal 10-MR (member ring) channels 0.55 nm 0.4 nm, while the other
system consists of large supercages (12-member ring) with dimensions 0.71
nm 0.71 nm 1.81 nm. The super cages stack one above another through
double prismatic six-member rings and are accessed by slightly distorted
elliptical 10-MR connecting channels. In general, the synthesized MCM-22
zeolites crystallized as very thin plates with an extremely large external surface
area, on which distributed the 12-member ring pockets. The protonic form of
MCM-22 is an active catalyst for many reactions requiring acidic sites such as
catalytic cracking, olefin isomerization, and conversion of paraffins to olefins and
aromatics, and alkylation of paraffins with light olefins. Indubitably, the acidity
(number, location, and strength of the acid sites) plays an important role in the
catalysis [54-56]. Many studies have revealed that MCM-22 behaves like both
10- and 12-member ring zeolites [15].
-
37
6 10-ring viewed normal to [001] 10-ring viewed normal to [001]
between layers within layers
7H 8H
10-ring viewed normal to [001] 10-ring viewed normal to [001] Within layers between layers
MCM-36 is a unique porous zeolitic material comprising microporosity inside its crystalline layers and slit-like mesoporosity in the interlayer space. The
mesopores are created by intercalation of the zeolitic layers with polymeric silica
species mentioned in [24] and formation of a structure similar to that of pillared
clays. MCM-36 can be prepared from an as-synthesized layered precursor of
zeolite MCM-22 by applying first a swelling treatment to expand the interlayer
distances and then a pillaring (intercalation) procedure to stabilize the expanded
structure with flat-shaped mesopores between the layers [57]. Note that the
consideration of the mesopores as flat-shaped slits can easily be an improper
simplification as we do not know the distribution or density of the pillars and also
their thickness. Besides the dual porosity, the material shows another dual
nature: the crystalline zeolitic layers form together an amorphous structure
resulting from irregular arrangement of the pillars, i.e., the Figure 18 gives the idea of distribution, dimensions, and internal ordering. Since the zeolitic layers
can be intercalated with various metal oxides, not only SiO2, MCM-36 has
-
38
become a family of materials with adjustable properties. The introduction of
various metal oxides as single or mixed composites is an effective tool for
adjusting the MCM-36 properties, being important for potential catalytic
applications, by: (a) tailoring mesoporosity, i.e., distance between the layers
mentioned in ref [24], (b) creating acidic and basic centres of various strength
due to the choice of proper metal and its amount and; (c) influencing the acid
base character of the materials via ion-exchange (d) changing mechanical and/or
thermal stability via formation of more stable oxide species (e) affecting
adsorption properties in a broad sense [24].
Figure 17. MWW group of materials and its structures (76).
Pillared layered structures which are shown in the Figure 18 (MCM-36) are built
of inorganic layers with inorganic or organic pillars appended on both sides of the
sheets. These materials are potentially most attractive for catalysis, because they
combine high specific surface areas and good accessibility for larger molecules
to a large number of catalytic sites. Traditionally the focus was on pillared clays,
but pillaring of other layered phases such as zirconium phosphates, silicas and
metal oxides has also been explored. The combination of their specific pore
structure and catalytic properties has been exploited in many commercial
applications. Most notably, however, these materials contain moderately strong
to weak acid sites, much weaker than the strong Brnsted acid sites (bridging
hydroxyl groups) in zeolites [25].
-
39
Figure 18. A schematic representation of the MCM-36 structure.
In the MCM-36 phase, the polymeric silica as pillars is formed during the
hydrolysis and condensation of silicates from tetraethylorthosilicate. The
hydrolysis reaction replaces an alkoxy group (OR) with a hydroxyl (OH) group.
Subsequent condensation reactions involving the silanol groups produce
siloxane bonds (SiOSi) and alcohol or water as byproducts, leading initially to
oligomeric and polymeric structures. Depending on the conditions, the final
structures of the polymeric SiO2 can be formed as nearly linear polymeric
structures or three-dimensional branched structures. Based on the MCM-22
precursor with different Si/Al ratio, MCM-36 was produced by swelling and
pillaring techniques. The resulting MCM-36 contains a mesoporous region
between the microporous layers and has the properties of a medium-pore zeolite.
With silica as a pillaring material, the surface area of MCM-36 is about 2.5 times
higher than that of MCM-22. Silica pillaring increased the concentration of
terminal SiOH groups compared with MCM-22, the number of Brnsted acid
-
40
sites, however, was lower in MCM-36 than in MCM-22. This is attributed to the
dealumination induced by the swelling and pillaring processes. Alkane sorption
reveals that the 10-membered ring channel system of MCM-22 persists
unperturbed in MCM-36. The major fraction of the acid sites, and thus the
favored sorption sites, is located in the 10-membered ring channel of these
layers. Only about 10% acid sites exist on the outer surface and are accessible
through the mesopores. Consequently, alkane sorption in MCM-22 and MCM-36
at low equilibrium pressures is dominated by the 10-membered ring channels in
the layers. Catalytic tests indicate that MCM-36 is an active, selective and stable
solid acid catalyst for alkylation of isobutane with 2-butene, demonstrating that
the open mesoporous structure is utilized successfully for sorbing and converting
larger molecules [25].
MCM-36 contains more mesoporous region and less microporous region
compared to MCM-22 and MCM-36 exhibits higher BET surface area than MCM-
22. The MCM-36 has more terminal Si-OH groups compared to MCM-22 due to
silica pillars. The Brnsted acid sites are less in MCM-36 compared to MCM-22.
The typical XRD patterns of the MWW group materials are shown in the Figure 19.
-
41
Figure 19. XRD patterns of MCM-22(P) and its derivatives MCM-36 [57].
6. Overview on MCM-48 (mesoporous molecular sieve)
MCM-48 is a member of M41S Mesoporous silica's. It has recently attracted
much attention for its three-dimensional mesoporous channel systems, which
can be used as a prospective catalyst, an adsorbent, and even a template for the
synthesis of nanostructures. A lot of work has been done in the synthesis of pure
silica MCM-48 [29] and the incorporation of its framework with various
heteroatoms. MCM-48 was usually synthesized using cationic surfactants as
supramolecular template materials. Cationic-neutral or cationic-anionic
surfactants were also used as its structure-directing agent. With almost no
exception, MCM-48 was prepared in basic solution, and its yields were usually
low. The product yield was only ca. 50% using cetyltrimethylammonium bromide
(CTAB) as a single surfactant. One can gain a yield of ca. 80% using cationic-
neutral surfactant mixture by adjusting the pH of the reaction mixture to 10 during
-
42
synthesis. It is important to identify procedures suitable for a cost-efficient
synthesis of MCM-48 with high yields. Herein, by adjusting the pH=5 of the
solution in a synthesis process, a high product yield of 98% was gained using
CTAB as a surfactant. Some of the comparison between MCM- 48 and MCM-41
[30] is given below.
1. Porosity of MCM-48 is similar to that of MCM-41.
2. Particles of MCM-48 are much better organized than MCM-41.
3. Three dimensional channel system in MCM-48 as opposed to a one
dimensional channel system in MCM-41.
4. Both have similar thermal stability.
5. MCM-48 is more difficult to synthesize than MCM-41.
6. MCM-48 is cubic and MCM-41 hexagonal structure.
7. Ultra Sound Irradiation Method for Catalyst Preparation 7.1. Introduction
Ultrasound is simply sound pitched above the frequency bond of human hearing.
It is a part of sonic spectrum that ranges from 20 KHz to 10 MHz and
corresponds to the wavelengths from 10 to 103 cm. The application of
ultrasound, in connection to chemical reactions, is called sonochemistry. The
range from 20 KHz to around 1 MHz is used in sonochemistry, since acoustic
cavitation in liquids can be efficiently generated within this frequency range [45].
The origin of sonochemical effects in liquids is the phenomenon of acoustic
cavitation. Ultrasound is transmitted through a medium via pressure waves by
inducing vibrational motions of the molecules, which alternately compress and
stretch the molecular structure of the medium due to a time-varying pressure [41,
42, and 43]. Molecules start to oscillate around their mean position and if the
strength of the acoustic field is sufficiently intense, cavities are created in liquids.
-
43
This will happen if the negative pressure exceeds the local tensile strength of the
liquid.
The cavities are also called cavitation bubbles and the process itself is referred to
as cavitation. Two types of cavitation are known: stable and transient. Stable
cavities are bubbles, which form and oscillate around their equilibrium position
over several rarefaction/compression cycles, before collapsing or never
collapsing at all.
7.2 . Applications
Ultrasound has proved extremely useful in the synthesis of a wide range of
nanostructured materials, including high surface area transition metals, alloys,
carbides, oxides and colloids [41, 42]. Sonochemical decomposition of volatile
organometallic precursors in high boiling solvents produces nanostructured
materials in various forms with high catalytic activities. Nanometer colloids,
nanoporous high surface area aggregates, and nanostructured oxide supported
catalysts can all be prepared by the general route. The mechanism of the rate
enhancements in reactions of metals has been unveiled by monitoring the effect
of ultrasonic irradiation on the kinetics of the chemical reactivity of the solids,
examining the effects of irradiation on surface structure and size distributions of
powders and solids, and, determining depth profiles of the surface elemental
composition.
Ultrasonic irradiation of liquid-powder suspensions produces another effect: high
velocity inter-particle collisions [41-44]. Cavitation and the shockwaves it creates
in slurry can accelerate solid particles to high velocities. The resultant collisions
are capable of inducing dramatic changes in surface morphology, composition,
and reactivity. Heterogeneous catalysts often require rare and expensive metals.
The use of ultrasound offers some hope of activating less reactive, but also less
costly, metals. For example, the effects of ultrasound on hydrogenated catalyst
-
44
i.e. Ni powder, with the chemical consequence of enormously increasing the
catalytic rates of hydrogenation by Ni powder (>105-fold) [44].
8. Experimental Procedure 8.1. Catalysts
This work mainly deals with three mesoporous materials i.e. MCM-22, MCM-36,
and MCM-48 which were prepared using different methods as explained in the
sections 2.1.8, 3.1, 3.2 and 3.3. The main focus was on MCM-22 materials with
different silica to alumina ratios which were prepared as explained below,
characterized and tested in catalytic reactions i.e. isomerization of n-butane and
oxidation of lactose. Synthesis of MCM-36 with MCM-22 (with different silica to
alumina ratios) as precursors and synthesis of MCM-48 mesoporous materials
were also prepared in the lab.
All sodium forms MCM-22, MCM-36 and MCM-48 are characterized by nitrogen
adsorption method, X-ray powder diffraction method, and SEM which is
explained in detail in the theory part 4.
Catalysts nomenclature which was used during the work and the list of prepared
catalysts are given below.
Na-MCM-22-30-R means sodium form of MCM-22 with silica to alumina ratio equal to 30 prepared by the rotation mode. The rotation mode was used for all
MCM-22 based catalysts.
Na-MCM-36-22-30-R means sodium form of MCM-36, as MCM-22 precursor (no-
calcined) with silica to alumina ratio equal to 30 prepared by the rotation mode.
H-MCM-22-30-R means a proton form of MCM-22 with silica to alumina ratio equal to 30.
-
45
Pd-H-MCM-22-30-R-IE stands for palladium modified proton form of MCM-22
with silica to alumina ratio equal to 30 prepared by ion-exchange method.
Pd-H-MCM-22-30-R-IMP stands for palladium modified proton form of MCM-22
with silica to alumina ratio equal to 30 prepared by impregnation method.
Pd-H-MCM-22-30-R-IS stands for palladium modified proton form of MCM-22 with silica to alumina ratio equal to 30 prepared by in-situ method.
Pd-H-MCM-22-30-R-SSIE stands for palladium modified proton form of MCM-22 with silica to alumina ratio equal to 30 prepared by solid state ion-exchange
method.
Au-H-MCM-22-30-R-DP stands for gold modified proton form of MCM-22 with silica to alumina ratio equal to 30 prepared by Deposition Precipitation Method.
The catalysts which are synthesized, characterized and tested are listed below.
Proton forms
1. H-MCM-22-30-R
2. H-MCM-22-50-R
3. H-MCM-22-70-R
4. H-MCM-22-28-R
Ion-exchange catalysts
5. Pd-H-MCM-22-30-R-IE
6. Pd-H-MCM-22-28-R-IE
7. Pd-H-MCM-22-50-R-IE
8. Pd-H-MCM-22-70-R-IE
Impregnation catalysts
9. Pd-H-MCM-22-30-R-IMP
-
46
10. Pd-H-MCM-22-50-R-IMP
11. Pd-H-MCM-22-70-R-IMP
12. Pd-H-MCM-22-28-R-IMP
In-situ catalyst
13. Pd-H-MCM-22-30-R-IS
Solid state ion-exchange catalyst
14. Pd-H-MCM-22-30-R-SSIE
Deposition precipitation catalyst
15. Au-H-MCM-22-30-R-DP
The Na-form of catalysts which are synthesized and characterized in
laboratory is mentioned in the list below.
1. Na-MCM-22-28-static
2. Na-MCM-22-28-96 h-R
3. Na-MCM-22-30-R
4. Na-MCM-22-28-R
5. Na-MCM-22-50-R
6. Na-MCM-22-70-R
7. Na-MCM-36-22-30-R
8. Na-MCM-36-22-28-R
9. Na-MCM-36-22-50-R
10. Na-MCM-22-30-30 h-USI
11. Na-MCM-22-30-40 h-USI
12. Na-MCM-22-30-48 h-USI
13. Na-MCM-22-30-30 h-without USI
14. Na-MCM-22-30-40 h-without USI
15. Na-MCM-48-A and Na-MCM-48-B
-
47
Figure 20. Catalysts in powder form (sieved 150 m-250 m).
Proton forms of MCM-22 with different silica to alumina ratios i.e. 30, 50, 70 are
characterized by infrared spectroscopy for acidity measurement which is an
important method in order to determine active sites in the sample.
Palladium forms of catalysts were characterized by Direct Current Plasma for
metal loading i.e. Pd wt% in the zeolites and four different preparation methods
were employed during this thesis work i.e. ion-exchange method, in-situ and
SSIE method with nominal loadings 2 to 3 wt% Pd (using palladium nitrate
solution) and 5 wt% Pd as nominal loading by impregnation method (finally the
catalysts are crushed and sieved to 150 m-250 m pellets, see Figure 20).
8.2. Synthesis of Catalysts
Na-MCM-22-30-R (Si/Al = 30)
The Na-MCM-22-30-R was synthesized as mentioned in article [30] with some modifications. 3.02 g of sodium aluminate was added to 345.73 g of water and
thereafter 4.16 g of sodium hydroxide was added. The mixture was stirred for 10
minutes and pH was measured. To this mixture 24.07 g of hexamethyleneimine
(HMI) and subsequently 28.82 g of fumed silica was added. The mixture was
stirred for 20 minutes and the pH measured. The gel was transferred to teflon
cups and then inserted to autoclaves. The synthesis is carried out in rotation
-
48
mode for seven days at 150oC. After the completion of synthesis, the material is
filtered, washed (pH neutralization) with distilled water, dried at 100oC for 24 h
and calcined at 550oC for 8 hours.
Na-MCM-2250-R (Si/Al = 50)
The Na-MCM-22-50-R was synthesized as mentioned in article [30] with some modifications. Sodium aluminate (1.64 g) was added to 351.60 g of water and
then 2.26 g of sodium hydroxide was added. The mixture was stirred for 10
minutes and pH measured. To this mixture 21.77 g of hexamethyleneimine (HMI)
and then 26.12 g of fumed silica was added. The mixture was stirred for 20
minutes and pH measured. The gel was transferred to teflon cups and then
inserted to autoclaves. The synthesis is carried in rotation motion at 150oC for 7
days.
After completion of synthesis material is filtered, washed (pH neutralization) with
distilled water, dried at 100oC and calcined at 550oC for 8 hours.
Na-MCM-2270-R (Si/Al = 70)
The Na-MCM-22-70-R was synthesized as mentioned in article [30] with some
modifications. Sodium aluminate (1.14 g) was added to 345.73 g of water and
then 4.16 g of sodium hydroxide was added. The mixture was stirred for 10
minutes and pH was measured. To this mixture 24.07 g of hexamethyleneimine
(HMI) was added and then 28.82 g of fumed silica. The mixture was stirred for 20
minutes and pH was measured. The gel was transferred to Teflon cups and then
inserted to autoclaves. The synthesis is carried in rotation motion and was
carried out at 150oC for 7 days.
After completion of synthesis material is filtered, washed (pH neutralization) with
distilled water, dried at 100oC and calcined at 550oC for 8 hours.
-
49
Na-MCM-36-22-30-R with MCM-22-30-R as precursor
The Na-MCM-36-22-30-R was synthesized as mentioned in article [28] with some modifications. First, CTMACL (25% sol) and TPAOH (20% sol) was added
to MCM-22 precursor (non-calcined MCM-22 dried) in the ratio 1:4:1.2 as
mentioned in [28] and pH was measured. The reaction mixture is kept under
heating up to 98oC to 102 oC for 68 h under stirring. This process is known as
swelling process. The swollen MCM-22 is added to tetraethyl orthosilicate
(TEOS) in the ratio 1:5 heated up to 78 oC under nitrogen pressure for 25 h. This
process is known as pillaring process. Finally, the swollen and pillared MCM-36
is hydrolyzed in the ratio 1:10 and the pH is adjusted to 8. Then the material is
heated up to 40 oC, filtered,