The Monsters of The Mind in Horus Rising:The seeds of heresy are sown

Pinni B4113Wednesday, 4th of May 2016

01/05/2023 The Far Side of English 2

Presentation structure

1. The Grotesque2. Grotesque Incongruence and Disharmony3. Cognitive Dissonance4. References

01/05/2023 The Far Side of English 3

The GrotesqueIn Horus Rising, there are passages which fit Bakhtin’s concept of the “carnivalistic grotesque”.

The twisted old equerry [similar to an aide-de-camp], Maloghurst, has a distinctive, grotesque physical appearance. “[h]is back bulged with a kyphotic misalignment” and “waddings of synthetic skin-gel covered gashes upon his throat and the left side of his head” (Abnett 2006, 122).

“Maloghurst’s talents for intrigue and intelligence ideally served him in that role, and had long since earned him the title ‘twisted’” (Abnett 2006, 121).

“My body is broken, but my mind is not. I would take offence if the name was to be dropped out of politeness” (Abnett 2006, 125).

01/05/2023 The Far Side of English 4

Grotesque Incongruence and Disharmony

In general, people fear advanced technology, such as cyborgs and robots. The notion of genetic enhancement is a sensitive topic in current politics and such a concept does not appeal to most people. The basis of this fear lies in the concept of grotesque incongruence.

Grotesque incongruence entails the blending of elements that do not normally belong together, the dismantling of elements that are supposed to be inseparable from each other or even just excess of any sort.

01/05/2023 The Far Side of English 5

Grotesque Incongruence and Disharmony

“The man, if it were a man, lurked at the rail of the strategium deck, gazing out across the chasm of the bridge. He was a machine, it seemed, much more a machine than a man. Vague relics of flesh and muscle remained in the skeletal fabric of his mechanical body, a fabulously wrought armature of gold and steel” (Abnett 2006, 114).

01/05/2023 The Far Side of English 6

Grotesque Incongruence and Disharmony

01/05/2023 The Far Side of English 7

Grotesque Incongruence and Disharmony

"There is no truth in flesh, only betrayal.“"There is no strength in flesh, only weakness.“"There is no constancy in flesh, only decay.“"There is no certainty in flesh but death.“

— Credo Omnissiah

Do you think that technology will eventually be valued more than humanity?

01/05/2023 The Far Side of English 8

Cognitive DissonanceCognitive dissonance is the mental stress or discomfort experienced by an individual who holds two or more contradictory beliefs, ideas, or values at the same time, or is confronted by new information that conflicts with existing beliefs, ideas, or values. (http://www.exrx.net/Psychology/Dissonance.html)

“Superstition. We know this world has temples and fanes. They [the enemy] are dark-age in their beliefs. Bringing light to that ignorance is part of why we’re here” (Abnett 2006, 155).

“An Astartes draws his weapon and kills his own, whilst claiming to be a daemon from hell? Rationalise that, sir” (Abnett 2006, 187).

01/05/2023 The Far Side of English 9

Cognitive DissonancePeople engage in a process called dissonance reduction to bring their cognitions and actions in line with one another. Dissonance reduction can be achieved in four ways. In an example case could be a situation where someone has decided that he will avoid eating sweets, but has found himself eating a dessert. The four methods of reduction would be:

1. Change behaviour or cognition− "I will not eat any more of this dessert"

2. Justify behaviour or cognition by changing the conflicting cognition− "I'm allowed to cheat every once in a while"

3. Justify behaviour or cognition by adding new cognitions− "I'll spend 30 extra minutes at the gym to work this off"

4. Ignore or deny any information that conflicts with existing beliefs− "This dessert does not contain that much sugar"

How should Loken minimise his cognitive dissonance?

In this particular example, Loken changes his cognition by asking his mentor the following question. “I’m going to ask you this once. Are spirits real?” (Abnett 2006, 187).

01/05/2023 The Far Side of English 10

Cognitive DissonanceDespite the overwhelming evidence to the contrary, Loken's mentor is not convinced of the existence of daemons and refutes the information that conflicts with his beliefs. “’These marks,’ said Sindermann. ‘These vile signs of wasting. Could they be the traces of disease or infection?’” (Abnett 2006, 187).

Loken’s mentor, Sindermann, does not attempt to reduce dissonance and instead attempts to restore consonance. There are four ways of doing so:

1. Misperception2. Rejection or refutation of the information3. Seeking support from others who share the beliefs4. Attempting to persuade others

In what ways does Sindermann attempt to restore consonance?

Sindermann refuses to accept the existence of daemons, point 2 on the slide and instead attempts to persuade Loken that there is a rational explanation for the deaths, point 4.

This technique of coming to conclusions that are consistent to one’s belief system is an example of Confirmation Bias. This type of cognitive bias is stronger for deeply rooted or emotionally charged issues.

01/05/2023 The Far Side of English 11

ReferencesAbnett, Dan. 2006 Horus Rising: the seeds of Heresy are sown. Nottingham: Black Library.

“ExRx.net”. http://www.exrx.net/Psychology/Dissonance.html [Accessed 3 May 2016]

Haraway, Donna. 1991. “A Cyborg Manifesto: Science, Technology, and Socialist-Feminism in the Late Twentieth Century,” in Simians, Cyborgs and Women: The Reinvention of Nature. [Internet] New York: Routledge, pp.149–181. Available from http://www.egs.edu/faculty/donna-haraway/articles/donna-haraway-a-cyborg-manifesto/ [Accessed 28 September 2015]

McNally, David. 2014. DARPA's Warrior Web project may provide super-human enhancements. [Internet] RDECOM Public Affairs. Available from http://www.army.mil/article/125315/DARPA_s_Warrior_Web_project_may_provide_super_human_enhancements [Accessed 28 September 2015]

Perttula, Irma. 2011. “The Grotesque: Concept and Characteristics”. In The Grotesque and the Unnatural. Eds. Markku Salmela and Jarkko Toikkanen. Amherst, New York: Cambria Press.

“Simply Psychology”. http://www.simplypsychology.org/cognitive-dissonance.html [Accessed 3 May 2016]