modelling echinostomes

1
example theileriosis (in cattle, sheep and goats in Spain) and filariasis, caused by Dirofilaria immitis, which is becoming an increasing problem in dogs in southern Europe, with human cases also having been reported. Despite the highly informative nature of this book and the fact that it is excellent with regards to contents and wording, the numerous errors in the setting, printing and spelling, blurred photos, as well as insufficiently marked figures, are certainly a disappointment in a book of this price. As errors can be found throughout the entire book, the fault does not appear to lie with the editors, and it is hoped that more careful proofreading sessions will be applied to the next edition. Torsten J. Naucke Institute for Medical Parasitology, University of Bonn, Sigmund Freud Strasse 25, D-53105 Bonn, Germany. e-mail: [email protected] Modelling echinostomes Echinostomes as Experimental Models for Biological Research by B. Fried and T. Graczyk (eds), Kluwer Academic Publishers, 2000. £88.00/$150.00/NGL263.00 (hbk) (273 pages) ISBN 0 7923 6156 3 Although nobody is likely to name the genus Echinostoma as the most important among digenetic trematodes, one might be inclined to include it with Schistosoma and Fasciola in a ‘Top 3’ list. True, echinostomes lack the medical and veterinary importance of the Fasciola, however, they could serve as ‘model’ trematodes. The current interpretations of the systematics of the Echinostomatidae both reflect and are hindered by a rich history of descriptive biology mirrored in other parasite taxa. Also, a great deal is known about the response elicited by a number of Echinostoma spp. upon infection of their first intermediate host snails. Finally, echinostome parasites are a component of an interesting and relatively tractable system for studying host–parasite relationships in the field. Naturally infected snails are ubiquitous and the life cycle is easily maintained in the laboratory. Echinostomes as Experimental Models for Biological Research sets out to compile the scattered information about developments in organismal and molecular parasitology that have been achieved through studies of echinostomes. For each of the topics covered, the book seems to serve this purpose. However, in attempting to cover each and every nuance of echinostome biology, some of the chapters feel like a personal research history of the author(s); in the most extreme case, the author was a contributor on 75% of the references. These chapters are not so much cases of self-aggrandizement as they are clear indications that some areas of echinostome biology have been essentially the intellectual territory of a single researcher. In fact, one could argue that the editors have done well to obtain contributions from the current experts in these areas, as they provide both a sense of history and unanswered questions for the future. Each of the selected topics is well covered with an ample supply of references, including some current advances, and descriptions of work-in-progress. Having said that, I was not entirely satisfied with the choice of topics. For a book that purports to demonstrate the applicability of echinostomes as model organisms in all areas of parasitology, too many of the chapters give just the opposite impression. In these sections, the description of what is known about echinostomes has been supported by admittedly little or no direct data, but is instead inferred from our understanding of Schistosoma or Fasciola spp. This leads the reader to believe that, far from being in the experimental vanguard, echinostome research simply involves the application of established techniques to yet another parasite taxon. There are, however, a few outstanding exceptions – in particular the chapter covering the immunobiology of echinostome-infected snails – that clearly demonstrate the utility of echinostomes in advancing our understanding of trematode biology. My strongest criticism of the book concerns the area of echinostome biology that was essentially ignored, that is, host–parasite ecology. The vast majority of echinostomatids are apparently only known from descriptive surveys but, for a few, we have detailed information about transmission in the field and the effects of the parasites on natural host populations. By not highlighting this facet of echinostomiasis, the editors have probably neglected an area of research with a bright and open future. For instance, what role do echinostome larvae play in the parasite community of their snail hosts? This question continues to have a direct and essential applicability in populations of planorbid snails infected by echinostomes and human schistosomes. Finally, for a book that will probably find its strongest audience among graduate and/or medical students with a specific interest in incorporating echinostomes into their research, it would seem prohibitively expensive. Also, the book has a slightly unpolished feel, as if it were 13 independent manuscripts that had been bound together without any attempt to provide continuity or a unifying theme other than a shared taxonomic bias (even the typeface and page formatting differ in a few of the chapters). In closing, this book does not make a strong case for the use of echinostomes in preference to any other taxa in biological research. Nevertheless, it does represent a comprehensive review of many aspects of echinostome biology, and demonstrates many areas where more research is needed to continue our understanding of these particular parasite taxa. Jason Curtis Biology/Chemistry Section, Purdue University North Central, Westville, IN 46391-9542, USA. e-mail: [email protected] TRENDS in Parasitology Vol.17 No.1 January 2001 http://parasites.trends.com 53 Forum Trends in Parasitology welcomes books Publishers: please send books or book details to: The Editor, Trends in Parasitology, Elsevier Science London, 84 Theobald’s Road, London, UK WC1X 8RR. Reviewers: if you would like to be considered as a book reviewer for Trends in Parasitology, please send your particulars, including your areas of expertise, to the above address.

Upload: jason-curtis

Post on 19-Sep-2016

213 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

example theileriosis (in cattle, sheep andgoats in Spain) and filariasis, caused byDirofilaria immitis, which is becomingan increasing problem in dogs insouthern Europe, with human cases alsohaving been reported.

Despite the highly informative natureof this book and the fact that it isexcellent with regards to contents andwording, the numerous errors in thesetting, printing and spelling, blurredphotos, as well as insufficiently markedfigures, are certainly a disappointmentin a book of this price. As errors can befound throughout the entire book, thefault does not appear to lie with theeditors, and it is hoped that more carefulproofreading sessions will be applied tothe next edition.

Torsten J. Naucke

Institute for Medical Parasitology,University of Bonn, Sigmund Freud Strasse25, D-53105 Bonn, Germany.e-mail: [email protected]

Modelling

echinostomes

Echinostomes as Experimental Models for

Biological Research

by B. Fried and T. Graczyk (eds), KluwerAcademic Publishers, 2000.£88.00/$150.00/NGL263.00 (hbk)(273 pages) ISBN 0 7923 6156 3

Although nobody is likely to name thegenus Echinostoma as the mostimportant among digenetic trematodes,one might be inclined to include it withSchistosoma and Fasciola in a ‘Top 3’ list.True, echinostomes lack the medical andveterinary importance of the Fasciola,however, they could serve as ‘model’trematodes. The current interpretationsof the systematics of theEchinostomatidae both reflect and arehindered by a rich history of descriptivebiology mirrored in other parasite taxa.Also, a great deal is known about theresponse elicited by a number ofEchinostoma spp. upon infection of theirfirst intermediate host snails. Finally,echinostome parasites are a componentof an interesting and relatively tractablesystem for studying host–parasiterelationships in the field. Naturally

infected snails are ubiquitous and the lifecycle is easily maintained in thelaboratory.

Echinostomes as Experimental Modelsfor Biological Research sets out tocompile the scattered information aboutdevelopments in organismal andmolecular parasitology that have beenachieved through studies ofechinostomes. For each of the topicscovered, the book seems to serve thispurpose. However, in attempting to covereach and every nuance of echinostomebiology, some of the chapters feel like apersonal research history of theauthor(s); in the most extreme case, theauthor was a contributor on 75% of thereferences. These chapters are not somuch cases of self-aggrandizement asthey are clear indications that someareas of echinostome biology have beenessentially the intellectual territory of asingle researcher. In fact, one couldargue that the editors have done well toobtain contributions from the currentexperts in these areas, as they provideboth a sense of history and unansweredquestions for the future. Each of theselected topics is well covered with anample supply of references, includingsome current advances, and descriptionsof work-in-progress.

Having said that, I was not entirelysatisfied with the choice of topics. For abook that purports to demonstrate theapplicability of echinostomes as modelorganisms in all areas of parasitology, toomany of the chapters give just the oppositeimpression. In these sections, thedescription of what is known aboutechinostomes has been supported byadmittedly little or no direct data, but isinstead inferred from our understandingof Schistosoma or Fasciola spp. This leadsthe reader to believe that, far from beingin the experimental vanguard,echinostome research simply involves theapplication of established techniques toyet another parasite taxon. There are,however, a few outstanding exceptions –in particular the chapter covering theimmunobiology of echinostome-infectedsnails – that clearly demonstrate theutility of echinostomes in advancing ourunderstanding of trematode biology.

My strongest criticism of the bookconcerns the area of echinostome biologythat was essentially ignored, that is,host–parasite ecology. The vast majorityof echinostomatids are apparently only

known from descriptive surveys but, for afew, we have detailed information abouttransmission in the field and the effectsof the parasites on natural hostpopulations. By not highlighting thisfacet of echinostomiasis, the editors haveprobably neglected an area of researchwith a bright and open future. Forinstance, what role do echinostomelarvae play in the parasite community oftheir snail hosts? This questioncontinues to have a direct and essentialapplicability in populations of planorbidsnails infected by echinostomes andhuman schistosomes.

Finally, for a book that will probablyfind its strongest audience amonggraduate and/or medical students with aspecific interest in incorporatingechinostomes into their research, it wouldseem prohibitively expensive. Also, thebook has a slightly unpolished feel, as if itwere 13 independent manuscripts thathad been bound together without anyattempt to provide continuity or a unifyingtheme other than a shared taxonomic bias(even the typeface and page formattingdiffer in a few of the chapters).

In closing, this book does not make astrong case for the use of echinostomes inpreference to any other taxa in biologicalresearch. Nevertheless, it does representa comprehensive review of many aspectsof echinostome biology, and demonstratesmany areas where more research isneeded to continue our understanding ofthese particular parasite taxa.

Jason Curtis

Biology/Chemistry Section, PurdueUniversity North Central, Westville, IN 46391-9542, USA.e-mail: [email protected]

TRENDS in Parasitology Vol.17 No.1 January 2001

http://parasites.trends.com

53Forum

Trends in Parasitology

welcomes books

Publishers: please send books or bookdetails to:The Editor, Trends in Parasitology, ElsevierScience London, 84 Theobald’s Road,London, UK WC1X 8RR.

Reviewers: if you would like to beconsidered as a book reviewer for Trends inParasitology, please send your particulars,including your areas of expertise, to theabove address.