model based yearly air quality evaluation on piemonte region · ece 04 ece 03 ece 02 ece 00-01 pre...
TRANSCRIPT
1
10th International Conference on Harmonisation within Atmospheric Dispersion Modelling for Regulatory Purposes Sissi (Malia), Crete, Greece 17-20 October, 2005
Model based yearly air quality evaluation on Piemonte region
Camillo Silibello1, Giuseppe Calori1, Giorgio Arduino2, Carla Contardi2 and Franca Sordi2
1 ARIANET s.r.l., Milano, Italy
2 Regione Piemonte – Direzione Tutela e Risanamento Ambientale, Torino, Italy
The Framework Directive (1996/62/EC) and the first Daughter Directive (1999/30/EC) introduce, for the first time in European air quality directives, the combined use of monitoring data, emission inventories and modelling techniques in assessment and management of air quality.
HARMO-10 C
rete 2
005
2
100% measurementMeasurement, no interpretationMeasurement+interpretationMeasurement+interpolationMeasurement+model fitted to measurementData assimilationModel validated by measurement in the same zoneModel validated elsewhereUnvalidated model100% modelling
Assessment under EU Air Quality Directives
Combining models with measurement
…there is an almost continuous spectrum of combination of measurements and otherassessment methods (mathematical techniques and models)From: Guidance on Assessment under the EU Air Quality Directives, EEA 2002
modelling
measurement
350 400 450 500UTM x [km]
4900
4950
5000
5050
5100
5150
UTM
y [k
m]
0
10
20
40
50
Measurement, no interpretation
Measurement+interpolation
350 400 450 500UTM x [km]
4900
4950
5000
5050
5100
5150
UTM
y [k
m]
0
10
20
40
50
350 400 450 500UTM x [km]
4900
4950
5000
5050
5100
5150
UTM
y [k
m]
Combining models with measurementExample: NO2 yearly averages
Model validation using measurement in the same zone
0 20 40 60 80meas. (ug/m3)
0
20
40
60
80NO2
HARMO-10 C
rete 2
005
3
MAIN GOALTo give an example of air quality assessment over PiemonteRegion using an atmospheric modelling system validated by measurements in the same zone.
CONTENTS
• Piemonte Region Air Quality Assessment methods;
• The Italian national-scale MINNI Project;
• Air Quality Assessment for 1999 (Downscaling of MINNI data);
• Related works:• Air Quality Management
(two examples);• Air Quality Assessment for 2004
(highlights);• Smaller scale study;
• Conclusions
10th International Conference on Harmonisation within Atmospheric Dispersion Modelling for Regulatory Purposes Sissi (Malia), Crete, Greece 17-20 October, 2005
HARMO-10 C
rete 2
005
4
Piemonte Region Air Quality Assessment methods
Piemonte Region Air Quality Assessment methods
Emission inventory (INEMAR)
EMISSIVE INPUT FORDISPERSION MODELS
EMISSION MANAGER
METEOROLOGICAL FIELD
3D WIND ANDTEMPERATURE
TURBULENCEPARAMETERS
MINERVE
SURFPRO
IC and BC
POLLUTANT CONCENTRATION FIELDS
3D EULERIANPHOTOCHEMICAL
MODEL
FARM
METEOROLOGICAL ANDGEOGRAPHICAL DATA SETS
EMISSIVE INPUT FORDISPERSION MODELS
EMISSION MANAGER
METEOROLOGICAL FIELD
3D WIND ANDTEMPERATURE
TURBULENCEPARAMETERS
MINERVE
SURFPRO
3D WIND ANDTEMPERATURE
TURBULENCEPARAMETERS
3D WIND ANDTEMPERATURE
TURBULENCEPARAMETERS
MINERVE
SURFPRO
IC and BCIC and BC
POLLUTANT CONCENTRATION FIELDS
3D EULERIANPHOTOCHEMICAL
MODEL
FARM
3D EULERIANPHOTOCHEMICAL
MODEL
FARM
METEOROLOGICAL ANDGEOGRAPHICAL DATA SETS
Atmospheric Modelling System
68 stations28 O3 stations
Air Monitoring Network
HARMO-10 C
rete 2
005
5
FARM (Flexible Air quality Regional Model)
3D Eulerian model, derived from STEM-II (Carmichael et al.)
• Diffuse sources & LPS with plume rise• Horizontal adv.-diff.: Blackman cubic polynomials (Yamartino, 1993) • Vertical adv.-diff.: hybrid semi-implicit Crank-Nicolson / fully implicit scheme
(Yamartino et al., 1992)
• Actinic flux reduction effect from clouds
• SOx-NOx-NH3 simplified scheme (EMEP)• Photochemistry: SAPRC-90 chemical scheme • PM: Models-3/CMAQ aero-3 module (Binkowski, 1999); aero-0 simplified bulk
module
• One- or two-way nesting
The Italian national-scale MINNI Project
HARMO-10 C
rete 2
005
6
National-scale MINNI Project
GOALDevelopment of an Integrated Assessment Modelling System, supporting the international negotiation concerning the air pollution and the development of environmental policies at national level.
AMS ItaliaDealing with the air pollution dynamics (transport and dispersion) and multiphase chemical transformations, able to quantify concentrations and deposition flux of air pollutants (SOx, NOx, NH3, PM and O3), with a spatial resolution of 20 x 20 km2
RAINS ItaliaInheriting the valuable features of RAINS-Europe model, but fed by the coefficients of the Atmospheric Transfer Matrix (ATM) calculated with the AMS-Italia at a higher spatial resolution.
MINNI ProjectMeteorological sub-systemECMWF fields
Re-analysis
SYNOPs
RAMS1 | 2 grids, 4DDAHARMO-10
Cret
e 200
5
7
MINNI ProjectEmission sub-system
0%
20%
40%
60%
80%
100%
CH4 CO CO2 NMCOV N2O NH3 NOx SOx
NATUREAGRICULTURE
WASTE TREATMENT & DISP.OTHER MOBILE SOURCESROAD TRANSPORT
SOLVENT AND OTHER PRODUCT USEEXTR. AND DISTRIB. OF FOSSIL FUELS
PRODUCTION PROCESSESCOMBUSTION IN MANUFACT. INDUSTRYNON-INDUSTRIAL COMBUSTION
COMBUSTION IN ENERGY
Model input(hourly, gridded,
speciated)
“Input emissions”
(NUTS2, RAINS sectors)
Ref. inventory
(NUTS3, SNAP3)
TU & sector partition
Grid disaggregation
Thematiclayers
0
0.2
0.4
0.6
0.8
1
1.2
1 3 5 7 9 11 13 15 17 19 21 23
hour
00.20.40.60.8
11.21.41.61.8
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12
month
Modulation profiles
(yearly, weekly, daily)
Time modulation
Speciationprofiles
0 5 10 15 20 25
A-PINENEACETALDEHYDEACETALDEHYDE
ACETIC ACIDACETONE
ACETYLENEACID
ALCOHOLSALDEHYDES
ALKANESALKENES
ALKIYNESAMIDESAMINES
ANHYDRIDESANILINESARENES
B-PINENEBENZENE
CARBOXYL ESTERSESTERSETHANE
ETHYL ACETATEETHYL ALCOHOL
ETHYLAMINEETHYLBENZENE
ETHYLENEFORMALDEHYDE
PROPRIONALDEHYDEFORMIC ACID
GLYCOLSGLYOXAL
HEPTENEHEXENEHEXYNE
ISOPRENEKETONES
METHYL ALCOHOLN-BUTANE
OLEFINSOTHERS
PARAFFINESPENTYNEPHENOLSPROPANE
PROPYLENESTYRENE
TERPENESTOLUENE
UNIDENTIFIED
NMVOC, PM speciation
MINNI ProjectChemical-transport sub-system
NO2 concentrations on 1 October 1999 hr. 1920 km resolution
HARMO-10 C
rete 2
005
8
Air Quality Assessment for 1999 (Downscaling of MINNI data)
Downscaling of MINNI national data
The basic idea is to use emissions, meteorology and pollutant (primary and secondary) concentrations hourly fields produced within the MINNI project to perform nested simulations over the Piemonte region for the year 1999.
HARMO-10 C
rete 2
005
9
From: K.D. van den Hout, Air Quality Assessment Requirements Under The New EU Air Quality Directives
from 15 m to30 km
from 1 hr to1 year
Temporal and spatial aspects of limit values under EU Air Quality Directives
FARM has been applied to whole 1999, on hourly base, over Piemonte region with:a spatial resolution of 4 km (56x72x12) cells;simplified aerosol module (aero0).
State-of-the-art models (as FARM) require so much calculation time that a high spatial resolution and a full coverage of calendar year is impossible!
INEMARLombardia
APAT 2000
INEMARPiemonte
EMEP
EMISSION SUB-SYSTEMIntegration of local inventories
HARMO-10 C
rete 2
005
10
Gridded area sources Point sources
EMISSION SUB-SYSTEMSpatial disaggregation (NOx)
MINNI – ITALY (20 KM) PIEMONTE (4 KM)
SPATIAL RESOLUTION EFFECTSOzone at ground
HARMO-10 C
rete 2
005
11
MINNI – ITALY (20 KM) PIEMONTE (4 KM)
SPATIAL RESOLUTION EFFECTSNitrogen dioxide at ground
0 20 40 60 80meas. (ug/m3)
0
20
40
60
80NO2
30 40 50 60 70 80 90meas. (ug/m3)
30
40
50
60
70
80
90
O3
0 4 8 12meas. (ug/m3)
0
4
8
12
calc
. (ug
/m3 )
SO2
Assessment under EU Air Quality Directives
Model validation by measurement in the same zone (yearly averages)
HARMO-10 C
rete 2
005
12
NOx SO2
Yearly average: limit 30 μg m-3 Yearly average: limit 20 μg m-3
Assessment of the Limit Values for the protection of ecosystems
350 400 450 500UTM x [km]
4900
4950
5000
5050
5100
5150
UTM
y [k
m]
0
5
10
20
30
50
350 400 450 500UTM x [km]
4900
4950
5000
5050
5100
5150
UTM
y [k
m]
0
5
10
15
20
50
Yearly average: limit 40 μg m-3
Assessment of the Limit Values for the protection of human health (NO2)
200 μg m-3 not to be exceeded more than18 times a calendar year (hourly base)
350 400 450 500UTM x [km]
4900
4950
5000
5050
5100
5150
UTM
y [k
m]
0
5
10
15
18
50
350 400 450 500UTM x [km]
4900
4950
5000
5050
5100
5150
UTM
y [k
m]
0
10
20
30
40
50HARMO-10
Cret
e 200
5
13
Yearly average: limit 40 μg m-350 μg m-3 not to be exceeded more than
35 times a calendar year (daily base)
Assessment of the Limit Values for the protection of human health (PM10)
350 400 450 500UTM x [km]
4900
4950
5000
5050
5100
5150
UTM
y [k
m]
0
10
20
30
40
50
350 400 450 500UTM x [km]
4900
4950
5000
5050
5100
5150
UTM
y [k
m]
0
5
15
25
35
50
120 μg m-3 not to be exceeded more than 25 times a calendar year (maximum daily 8-hour mean)
Assessment of the Limit Values for the protection of human health (O3)
350 400 450 500UTM x [km]
4900
4950
5000
5050
5100
5150
UTM
y [k
m]
0
5
10
20
25
50HARMO-10
Cret
e 200
5
14
Air Quality Management
…air quality models have an important place in air quality management. They are essential tools in the development of action plans for improving air quality, which is the ultimate goal of the Member States and local authorities in order to fulfil their obligations under the directives.
From: Guidance on Assessment under the EU Air Quality Directives, EEA 2002
Impact of year 2008 vehicles fleet
Fleet projectionExample: COPERT classes of gasoline cars > 1400 cc
E URO IVE URO III
E URO IIE URO I
ECE 04E CE 03E CE 02
E CE 00 -0 1P RE ECE
0%
10%
20%
30%
40%
50%
60%
70%
80%
90%
1 00%
20 03 2 008
2003 2008
[t/year]
Variation of NOx emissions
Variation of NO2yearly avg.
concentrations
-6
-5.5
-5
-4.5
-4
-3.5
-3
-2.5
-2
-1.5
-1
-0.5
ug/m3
HARMO-10 C
rete 2
005
15
Impact of future buildings heating sector
Example:decrease of PM10 emissions
Decrement of PM10 avg. concentrations in cold
season
Changes of:• fuels• boilers• buildings• district heatingover 10 years
[t/year]
-14.8%-1.8%-4.2%Winter totals
-8.2%-0.9%-2.2%Yearly totals
-73%-21%-39%Macrosector 2
SO2PM10NOx
Changes in regional emissions
Air Quality Assessment update at 2004
Most significant changes from 1999 assessment:use of local meteorological data;nesting on CHIMERE continental-scale model.
HARMO-10 C
rete 2
005
16
wind ground stations temperature ground stations
radiosoundings
synop stations
METEOROLOGICAL NETWORKGround level stations
AIR QUALITY MONITORING NETWORKPM10 stations (with almost 90% of valid data)
HARMO-10 C
rete 2
005
17
PM10 Yearly average (2004)
Model
Yearly average: limit 40 μg m-3
Data assimilationSuccessive correction scheme (ADAS)
Smaller scale study(500 m resolution)
HARMO-10 C
rete 2
005
18
0
10
20
30
40
60
80
11249 51IvreaIvrea
LocalLocalDomainDomain
Province Domain
2 km resolution 500 m resolution
1999Measured values: 2000
Ivrea monitoring site
SPATIAL RESOLUTION EFFECTSIvrea, NO2 yearly average
CONCLUSIONS
• Piemonte Region has implemented the Framework directive and daughter legislations using measurements (regional air quality network), emission inventories (INEMAR) and modelling techniques;
• the Air Quality Assessment for 1999 (downscaling of MINNI data) shows exeedances for ozone in large portions of the regional basin and for NOxand PM10 within Turin urban area;
• The use of the modelling system has permitted to estimate the impact of future emission scenarios (Air Quality Management);
• The Air Quality Assessment for 2004 year is terminated and 2005 is in progress;
• Simulation results claim for the use of a more complete aerosol module (aero3) and a better representation of PM10 phenomenology
10th International Conference on Harmonisation within Atmospheric Dispersion Modelling for Regulatory Purposes Sissi (Malia), Crete, Greece 17-20 October, 2005
HARMO-10 C
rete 2
005
19
Acknowledgements
This work has been supported by Regione Piemonte (Direzione Tutela e Risanamento Ambientale).
Thanks also to:• A.R.P.A. Piemonte people (Roberta De Maria, Monica Clemente, Cinzia
Cascone, Federica Motta, Stefano Bande, Massimo Muraro, Maria Elena Picollo, Francesco Lollobrigida) for their relevant contribution to the development of the Regional Air Quality Assessment and Management system;
• Gianluigi Truffo for his contribution to the preparation of the regional emission inventory
• ENEA for providing MINNI data used in this work (contact person: Dr. Gabriele Zanini: [email protected]);
• EMEP for providing data (emission, concentrations) used in this work .
10th International Conference on Harmonisation within Atmospheric Dispersion Modelling for Regulatory Purposes Sissi (Malia), Crete, Greece 17-20 October, 2005
HARMO-10 C
rete 2
005