mission: evaluation; result: evolution
DESCRIPTION
Magazine of the Training Course organized by Solidarity Tracks for the evaluation of the projects in the non-formal educationTRANSCRIPT
Magazine
INDEX
EditorialThe Training Course ‘Mission: evaluation, result:
evolution’ is a project organized by Solidarity
Tracks from 24th June to 4th July of 2013. It is
supported by the «Youth in Action» Program of
the European Commission through the Hellenic
«Youth and Lifelong Learning Foundation».
Thirty five participants from nineteen European
youth organizations from sixteen countries met
on Lefkada island, Greece, with a clear objective:
create an educational tool directed to youth lea-
ders and youth organizations which will allow
them to improve the evaluation and monitoring of
their non formal education projects.
This was the serious and hard part of the training
but we also made time to share unforgettable mo-
ments.
Different workshops, energizers, games, free
time, trip around the island or intercultural dinner
are just some of the examples of the activities we
carried out during the ten days of training course.
In this magazine, you will find how the process of
creating the educational tool was implemented
through the workshops and the intercultural ex-
change.
Getting to know!Learning activities
- What, why and how-Questionnaire -Visit - Evaluation matrix
Developing the toolTime to enjoy! Tale of the psycho dwarfOdyssey reloaded
3
4-5
6
7
89
This Training Course started with energizers
which enabled us to know each other. The objec-
tive of the first game was to learn and remember
the names of everyone.
Everyone was standing in a circle and the trainer
started saying his/her name and showing his/her
symbol. After him, the next participant had to say
the name of the previously one, his name and he
should make a new symbol. This action was re-
peated until the last participant.
In the next activity, the trainer presented the pro-
gram and agenda about the whole training
course and all the topics that would be included.
In this introductory activity participants shared
their experience about their work in the NGO and
they wrote down their hopes, contribution and
fears about the project.
Later on, the trainer held a presentation about
Youthpass and the eight key competences. He
explained the meaning and use of the Youthpass
certificate.
Moreover, the ‘Diary of the Training’ was presen-
ted, that is the evaluation tool method used du-
ring the seminar. «Diary» is an easy and practical
tool where the participants can write their advan-
cement and development during the training. It
has several parts: learning objectives, people that
can help you in your development, Youthpass,
skills and competences.
This activity was icebreaking: the participants got
to know each other and the trainer directed the
group into the way the course will be held.
Getting to know !
It was the 2nd day of seminar and the first serious
theme appeared. In the opinion of the partici-
pants: “Practically, we were thrown in the middle
of the jungle in order to understand the idea of
what evaluation is and its meaning.”
This activity was aimed to help us shape an idea
about the knowledge of the participants about the
topic.
Participants had to answer two questions: What
is evaluation and Why we evaluate.
This was realized through a hard brainstorming
in different working groups in order to gather the
points of view of participants.
Through conversations, debates and teamwork,
the different groups shared their ideas through
eloquent pictures, core essential or notion lists
related to the specific questions.
Afterwards, when participants understood what
evaluation is and why we evaluate, a new ques-
tion came into the working space.
Participants started working on How we can eva-
luate.
The participants had several presentations, workshops and group reflections which helped them to get a lot
of knowledge. The following were the most important for them
.......................................................What, Why and How?
On the 7th day of the seminar, the participants
had one session about the questionnaires as a
tool that can be used during the process of eva-
luation.
The main purpose of this session was to allow
participants to develop the correct techniques to
write and structure a useful questionnaire.
Divided in four groups, they had to analyze a “bad
questionnaire” which contained non appropriate
and wrong formulated questions.
Then, they discussed in groups, the participants
pointed out the mistakes in the “Bad question-
naire” and remade the questions in the better
way.
Afterwards, each small working group presented
the new questionnaire to the whole group.
The trainer finalized the session emphasizing the
good aspects of the questionnaires and showed
good examples of questionnaires as a tool for an
effective evaluation process.
......................................................................Questionnaire
Learning activities
....................................................................................Visit On the fifth day, the participants had an extraor-
dinary opportunity to meet with Cosmina, a Ro-
manian girl who is doing an European Voluntary
Service for 10 months in Solidarity Tracks.
Her main task during her EVS in Lefkada is to
lead workshops with Lefkadian children about en-
vironment and recycling, creating handmade ob-
jects.
She made a presentation about her EVS and
about the obstacles she faced at the beginning
of her work with kids.
Apart from this, she gave some examples of good
practices focusing on the difference of the eva-
luation process between grown-ups and kids with
emphasizing the qualitative and quantitative ap-
proaches.
On the last day of the seminar, Cosmina came
back. On this second visit, she presented the pro-
ject ‘Green O’clock’, a magazine focused in infor-
mation about sustainable development.
Another activity of this seminar was to plan an
‘evaluation matrix’.
The trainer made a presentation about the topic,
so the participants understood completely this
tool. The presentation covered several parts of
the matrix: project objectives, indicators, type of
indicators, source of data, sample, and methods
of data collecting.
Indicators are ingredients which say if the
objective is achieved or not.
There are three types of the indicators:
qualitative, quantitative and efficiency indicators.
Source of data is a store from where we
can draw precise information about what is plan-
ned to be evaluated.
Samples are the participants who will be
evaluated.
Methods of data collecting are a way of
gathering valid figures and information about the
project objectives.
Later on, the whole team was divided in four
groups. The groups got a real case study and had
to create their own example of matrix within 45
minutes. After that, each group presented their
outcomes and all participants discussed the re-
sults and provided comments and notifications.
Project
objective
Indicators Type of indi-
cators
Source of
data
Sample
(who)
Methods of
data
collecting
Criteria
Project name:
Evaluation goal:
.................................................................Evaluation matrix
It was the 8th day of that journey undertaken by
all participants as a team and they arrived to one
last big stop at the feet of the mountain. The
group still had to climb to reach the final goal, the
peak. This stop was not anything like recess.
First, they checked their maps to see if they were
still on the right path. They certainly had to re-
group and to check out the contents of their back-
packs to see if they lost something on the way,
what new things they had found and if they nee-
ded anything else essential for the climb.
Or, maybe, they had to throw out things that were
not going to be useful for them and which could
just slow down in anyway the ascent to the top.
Once the backpacks were scrutinized and opti-
mized, they joined the freshly formed travelling
groups. Each of these groups had a different
member for different tasks. They had a tracker, a
map specialist, a lead climber, and of course the
Sherpa for carrying the weight.
After finding the suitable track path that each
group was going to follow on this final attempt to
conquer the big mountain.
Everyone wished each other good luck and they
set off in hope and anticipation that in the end
everyone would meet each other on the top.
Developing the tool
Last night on Lefkada, a special dinner was or-
ganized with a happy ending. After the food was
eaten, trainers and organizers awarded to each
participant the Youthpass, which certificate their
participation in the seminar and the skills and
abilities they acquired during those days.
Youthpass
Colourful tables with drinks, sweets and food.
Traditional music and presentations about coun-
tries…High spirits.
The intercultural night started with Laszlo playing
the piano. Right after it, the host country, Gre-
ece, came with its presentations. Then, all the
participants introduced their countries, their food
and drinks. Everyone “tasted” the cultures.
Participants from Tunisia, Serbia and Armenia
had video materials. The participants from
Ukraine organized an interesting and informative
quiz.
All participants discovered a lot of new things
about other cultures and countries, some alre-
ady declared themselves as having the desire to
visit the countries that were presented. The at-
mosphere became more and more friendly with
people chatting, drinking and singing.
Besides the sessions, the participants were
given free time which they used for discovering
Lefkas, going to swim, having fun in the eve-
nings. This way they also managed to get to
know each other better, thus going deeper into
the participants’ cultural background, professio-
nal experience, future plans and their daily life.
The participants were excited to take part in
these groups and have this unique chance of
enjoying a non formal education.
Free time!
Time to enjoy!Intercultural night
Chapter 2:
The return of the dwarf
Once upon a time there was a small dwarf from
Bosnia who came in our community and wanted
to play games with us. His eyes were full of spar-
kles, we thought it would be funny but it was not
like that. He forced us both to tell lies and to be
honest, played with our minds and influenced our
answers. He asked us to say three things about
ourselves: two of them should be true and one
should be lie.
The observers should identify the false asking
three questions. The dwarf proved us that nobody
wants to say negative things about themselves
and how the form of the question influences our
answers. Half of the group chose to put the false
element as the last as he hypnotically sugges-
ted with the question. Then he flipped coins
in front us in amount of thirty cents and one
of the coins was not twenty cents. Can you
tell what the other coin was?
The dwarfs are very family-orientated creatures,
so he asked us to write a private letter to our be-
loved ones. It could be written in our native lan-
guage or in English. He didn’t want to tell us why
but we think it’s only
magic he wants to get
from us.
And his goodnight
kiss was an inspira-
tional visit to the world
of drawing the mea-
ning of evalua-
tion and
m o n i t o r i n g .
And why did
he choose
this way?
Tale of the psycho dwarf
The dwarf had a name. His name was SEA-DYCK
and he was so cynical. This time, he made us
cross the Onion sea, jumping on imaginary rocks
to reach the other side. Those rocks were disap-
pearing when anyone stepped on it. He was so
mean. If someone in the group made a mistake,
the whole group had to come back to the begin-
ning and start again with a new handicap.
First time, we failed. Without strategy, we were all
holding hands; some of us were carrying a
woman. Group was walking but rocks were disap-
pearing in the ‘sea’ and the last members could
cross to the other side. As a group, we were pu-
nished and one of our members became blind.
Now, we had to take care of our weak mem-ber.
The second time, we were a real group. Everyone
took care and helped other members to make a
save step. Succesfully, we reached the other side
of the sea
This whole experience taught us how to think us
a group. From now on, we will be looking back to
t h e
Onion
Sea, and
we can
say “Sea-DYCK, WE
DID IT!”
INVOCATION
Tell me, Muse, of that team of many sources, who wandered far and wide , after sacking the holy
citadel of Lefkas.
Many the cities which the team saw, and learned their ways. Many the sorrows the team suffered
at sea while trying to bring themselves and their friends back alive, they managed to save them,
thanks to their own wisdom, Tell us of these things, beginning where you will, Goddess, Daughter
of Zeus.
PART I: TROUBLES BEGIN
The sun is shinning Lefkas, the bus is going to Nidri, the team was on the bus. The folk was fee-
ling happy because they couldn't imagine what's was going to happen. But Gods prepared the
magic, the magic that Zeus put blessings into.
They passed from Lefkada island to Porto Katsiki, they passed the island Kefalonia, they stopped
at Ithaca island and the troubles begun
PART II : TROUBLES EXPLODED
Triangle was made. The bravest of the braves, Urban, the prettiest and purest of women, Maria,
and the wise of the wisest, teacher Sidik, were there to be put in action, trusting their skills and
highest intentions.
They swam in the nature, they enjoyed the turquoise waters, too much we can say, the boat was
missed, the captain heard not their desperate calls.
The phones were ringing, Mohamed first got the news: they were left on the island, no ferrie till
next day evening.
The team could not hide the worries: will there be workshops next day. No one to blame, the fee-
lings were happy, happy to get the beauty of rest.
PART III : TROUBLES RESOLVED
Where gods are playing, and Zeus command, there flowers are raining, and the lightness of
being appear.
Sidik got the message of gods, he checked with Mohamed, Urban said yes, Maria was smiling
her beauty on all.
The price was negotiated, no low no high, the decision was made of hiring a boat to rescue those
three, through unsettled waters. Gods lent a helping hand!
They came back to Nidri in the evening of the same day, Mohamed and his car were waiting, and
they took them to dinner directly.
EPILOGUE
No sacrifices are too much for things which are precious. Gods will help, Zeus will always bes-
tow.
The tool of evaluation the team is making will help, will help all of those who will use it.
Thanks to Zeus and his friends.
Odyssey Reloaded