minnesota power – energy & engineeringsburns/ee1001fall2012/umd_ee_1001_9-27-12[1]re… ·...

62
Minnesota Power – Energy & Engineering Introduction to technical aspects of renewable (Wind & Water) energy systems and discussion of skills and abilities to achieve as engineers. MP Background & My Role UMD Engineering Graduates – MP Employees Al Rudeck (ChemE) – VP of Generation *Caleb Siffring (EE) – Engr Svcs Bob Ardren (EE) – Telecomm Thomas Connolly (EE) – Boswell MP Engineering Shadow Rob Toland – Central HS (Duluth) *Kris Wiire (EE) – Telecomm MP Engineering Intern Quinten Johnson – Engr Svcs

Upload: hoangcong

Post on 22-May-2018

217 views

Category:

Documents


2 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Minnesota Power – Energy & Engineeringsburns/EE1001Fall2012/UMD_EE_1001_9-27-12[1]Re… · Minnesota Power – Energy & Engineering. Introduction to technical aspects of renewable

Minnesota Power –

Energy & EngineeringIntroduction to technical aspects of renewable (Wind & Water) energy systems

and discussion of skills and abilities to achieve as engineers.

MP Background & My Role

UMD Engineering Graduates –

MP EmployeesAl Rudeck (ChemE) –

VP of Generation *Caleb Siffring (EE) –

Engr

SvcsBob Ardren (EE) –

TelecommThomas Connolly (EE) –

Boswell

MP Engineering ShadowRob Toland –

Central HS (Duluth)

*Kris Wiire

(EE) –

Telecomm

MP Engineering InternQuinten Johnson –

Engr

Svcs

Page 2: Minnesota Power – Energy & Engineeringsburns/EE1001Fall2012/UMD_EE_1001_9-27-12[1]Re… · Minnesota Power – Energy & Engineering. Introduction to technical aspects of renewable

MP’s oldest Generation – 1895

Operation –Run of River/Ponding

Dam Safety

Mechanical/Electrical Protections

Water Power

Minnesota Power –

Energy & Engineering

Page 3: Minnesota Power – Energy & Engineeringsburns/EE1001Fall2012/UMD_EE_1001_9-27-12[1]Re… · Minnesota Power – Energy & Engineering. Introduction to technical aspects of renewable

Minnesota Power –

Energy & Engineering

Thomson Hydro

Page 4: Minnesota Power – Energy & Engineeringsburns/EE1001Fall2012/UMD_EE_1001_9-27-12[1]Re… · Minnesota Power – Energy & Engineering. Introduction to technical aspects of renewable

Minnesota Power –

Energy & Engineering

Thomson Hydro

Page 5: Minnesota Power – Energy & Engineeringsburns/EE1001Fall2012/UMD_EE_1001_9-27-12[1]Re… · Minnesota Power – Energy & Engineering. Introduction to technical aspects of renewable

Minnesota Power –

Energy & Engineering

Thomson Hydro

Page 6: Minnesota Power – Energy & Engineeringsburns/EE1001Fall2012/UMD_EE_1001_9-27-12[1]Re… · Minnesota Power – Energy & Engineering. Introduction to technical aspects of renewable

Minnesota Power –

Energy & Engineering

Thomson Hydro

Page 7: Minnesota Power – Energy & Engineeringsburns/EE1001Fall2012/UMD_EE_1001_9-27-12[1]Re… · Minnesota Power – Energy & Engineering. Introduction to technical aspects of renewable

-

Development Studies

-

Land Acquisition

- Site Suitability

-

Turbine Supplier & TSA

- Select WTG Platform & OptionsEnergy = 1/2 * p * A * v^3

Minnesota Power –

Energy & EngineeringWind Power

Page 8: Minnesota Power – Energy & Engineeringsburns/EE1001Fall2012/UMD_EE_1001_9-27-12[1]Re… · Minnesota Power – Energy & Engineering. Introduction to technical aspects of renewable

-

Site Layout

-

Roads, Turbine Siting

& Foundations

- Collection System & Communication

-

Substation & Transmission

-

Logistics

Minnesota Power –

Energy & EngineeringWind Power

Page 9: Minnesota Power – Energy & Engineeringsburns/EE1001Fall2012/UMD_EE_1001_9-27-12[1]Re… · Minnesota Power – Energy & Engineering. Introduction to technical aspects of renewable

- Contracts

- Sitework

-

Foundations

-

Electrical Infrastructure

-

Turbine Erection

Minnesota Power –

Energy & EngineeringWind Power

-

Commissioning & Operation

Tac

Ridge Overview…

Page 10: Minnesota Power – Energy & Engineeringsburns/EE1001Fall2012/UMD_EE_1001_9-27-12[1]Re… · Minnesota Power – Energy & Engineering. Introduction to technical aspects of renewable
Page 11: Minnesota Power – Energy & Engineeringsburns/EE1001Fall2012/UMD_EE_1001_9-27-12[1]Re… · Minnesota Power – Energy & Engineering. Introduction to technical aspects of renewable
Page 12: Minnesota Power – Energy & Engineeringsburns/EE1001Fall2012/UMD_EE_1001_9-27-12[1]Re… · Minnesota Power – Energy & Engineering. Introduction to technical aspects of renewable

Regulatory & Environmental Benefits

MN Energy Act 2007 - Minnesota Power must provide renewable energy in proportion to retail electric sales:

12% by 2012

17% by 2016

20% by 2020

25% by 2025

Help Reduce MP’s Carbon (CO2) Footprint

Page 13: Minnesota Power – Energy & Engineeringsburns/EE1001Fall2012/UMD_EE_1001_9-27-12[1]Re… · Minnesota Power – Energy & Engineering. Introduction to technical aspects of renewable

Build & Expand Upon MP Core Competencies

MP has many of the necessary core competencies to own, maintain and operate the wind farms

Most viable option to achieve growth in renewable energy for MP.

MP will pursue other renewable options (Wind, Water, Wood)

Page 14: Minnesota Power – Energy & Engineeringsburns/EE1001Fall2012/UMD_EE_1001_9-27-12[1]Re… · Minnesota Power – Energy & Engineering. Introduction to technical aspects of renewable

Clipper Wind Turbine Technical Highlights

Liberty Series 2.5 MW

2.5 MW Total, 4 - 625 KW Generators - DC→AC

96 m Rotor Diameter (315 feet)

80 m Tower Height (262 feet) – 4 Sections, Tapered 14.5’ to 10’ Diameter

Cut-in velocity – 4 m/s, Cut-out Velocity – 25 m/s

2 metric ton jib hoist / roll-up door

Service lift

Cold weather package (-40 C)

Oil containment at the yaw deck

Page 15: Minnesota Power – Energy & Engineeringsburns/EE1001Fall2012/UMD_EE_1001_9-27-12[1]Re… · Minnesota Power – Energy & Engineering. Introduction to technical aspects of renewable

Clipper Wind Turbine Components

Page 16: Minnesota Power – Energy & Engineeringsburns/EE1001Fall2012/UMD_EE_1001_9-27-12[1]Re… · Minnesota Power – Energy & Engineering. Introduction to technical aspects of renewable

Clipper Wind Turbine Components

Page 17: Minnesota Power – Energy & Engineeringsburns/EE1001Fall2012/UMD_EE_1001_9-27-12[1]Re… · Minnesota Power – Energy & Engineering. Introduction to technical aspects of renewable

Project Pictures

Page 18: Minnesota Power – Energy & Engineeringsburns/EE1001Fall2012/UMD_EE_1001_9-27-12[1]Re… · Minnesota Power – Energy & Engineering. Introduction to technical aspects of renewable

Project Pictures

Page 19: Minnesota Power – Energy & Engineeringsburns/EE1001Fall2012/UMD_EE_1001_9-27-12[1]Re… · Minnesota Power – Energy & Engineering. Introduction to technical aspects of renewable

Project Pictures

Page 20: Minnesota Power – Energy & Engineeringsburns/EE1001Fall2012/UMD_EE_1001_9-27-12[1]Re… · Minnesota Power – Energy & Engineering. Introduction to technical aspects of renewable

Project Pictures

Page 21: Minnesota Power – Energy & Engineeringsburns/EE1001Fall2012/UMD_EE_1001_9-27-12[1]Re… · Minnesota Power – Energy & Engineering. Introduction to technical aspects of renewable

Project Pictures

Page 22: Minnesota Power – Energy & Engineeringsburns/EE1001Fall2012/UMD_EE_1001_9-27-12[1]Re… · Minnesota Power – Energy & Engineering. Introduction to technical aspects of renewable

Project Pictures

Page 23: Minnesota Power – Energy & Engineeringsburns/EE1001Fall2012/UMD_EE_1001_9-27-12[1]Re… · Minnesota Power – Energy & Engineering. Introduction to technical aspects of renewable

Project Pictures

Page 24: Minnesota Power – Energy & Engineeringsburns/EE1001Fall2012/UMD_EE_1001_9-27-12[1]Re… · Minnesota Power – Energy & Engineering. Introduction to technical aspects of renewable

Project Pictures

Page 25: Minnesota Power – Energy & Engineeringsburns/EE1001Fall2012/UMD_EE_1001_9-27-12[1]Re… · Minnesota Power – Energy & Engineering. Introduction to technical aspects of renewable

Project Pictures

Page 26: Minnesota Power – Energy & Engineeringsburns/EE1001Fall2012/UMD_EE_1001_9-27-12[1]Re… · Minnesota Power – Energy & Engineering. Introduction to technical aspects of renewable

Project Pictures

Page 27: Minnesota Power – Energy & Engineeringsburns/EE1001Fall2012/UMD_EE_1001_9-27-12[1]Re… · Minnesota Power – Energy & Engineering. Introduction to technical aspects of renewable

Project Pictures

Page 28: Minnesota Power – Energy & Engineeringsburns/EE1001Fall2012/UMD_EE_1001_9-27-12[1]Re… · Minnesota Power – Energy & Engineering. Introduction to technical aspects of renewable

Project Pictures

Page 29: Minnesota Power – Energy & Engineeringsburns/EE1001Fall2012/UMD_EE_1001_9-27-12[1]Re… · Minnesota Power – Energy & Engineering. Introduction to technical aspects of renewable

Project Pictures

Page 30: Minnesota Power – Energy & Engineeringsburns/EE1001Fall2012/UMD_EE_1001_9-27-12[1]Re… · Minnesota Power – Energy & Engineering. Introduction to technical aspects of renewable

Project Pictures

Page 31: Minnesota Power – Energy & Engineeringsburns/EE1001Fall2012/UMD_EE_1001_9-27-12[1]Re… · Minnesota Power – Energy & Engineering. Introduction to technical aspects of renewable

Project Pictures

Page 32: Minnesota Power – Energy & Engineeringsburns/EE1001Fall2012/UMD_EE_1001_9-27-12[1]Re… · Minnesota Power – Energy & Engineering. Introduction to technical aspects of renewable

Project Pictures

Page 33: Minnesota Power – Energy & Engineeringsburns/EE1001Fall2012/UMD_EE_1001_9-27-12[1]Re… · Minnesota Power – Energy & Engineering. Introduction to technical aspects of renewable

Project Pictures

Page 34: Minnesota Power – Energy & Engineeringsburns/EE1001Fall2012/UMD_EE_1001_9-27-12[1]Re… · Minnesota Power – Energy & Engineering. Introduction to technical aspects of renewable

Clipper Wind Turbine Components

Page 35: Minnesota Power – Energy & Engineeringsburns/EE1001Fall2012/UMD_EE_1001_9-27-12[1]Re… · Minnesota Power – Energy & Engineering. Introduction to technical aspects of renewable

Clipper Wind Turbine Components

Page 36: Minnesota Power – Energy & Engineeringsburns/EE1001Fall2012/UMD_EE_1001_9-27-12[1]Re… · Minnesota Power – Energy & Engineering. Introduction to technical aspects of renewable

Clipper Wind Turbine Components

Page 37: Minnesota Power – Energy & Engineeringsburns/EE1001Fall2012/UMD_EE_1001_9-27-12[1]Re… · Minnesota Power – Energy & Engineering. Introduction to technical aspects of renewable

Project Pictures

Page 38: Minnesota Power – Energy & Engineeringsburns/EE1001Fall2012/UMD_EE_1001_9-27-12[1]Re… · Minnesota Power – Energy & Engineering. Introduction to technical aspects of renewable

Project Pictures

Page 39: Minnesota Power – Energy & Engineeringsburns/EE1001Fall2012/UMD_EE_1001_9-27-12[1]Re… · Minnesota Power – Energy & Engineering. Introduction to technical aspects of renewable

Project Pictures

Page 40: Minnesota Power – Energy & Engineeringsburns/EE1001Fall2012/UMD_EE_1001_9-27-12[1]Re… · Minnesota Power – Energy & Engineering. Introduction to technical aspects of renewable

Project Pictures

Page 41: Minnesota Power – Energy & Engineeringsburns/EE1001Fall2012/UMD_EE_1001_9-27-12[1]Re… · Minnesota Power – Energy & Engineering. Introduction to technical aspects of renewable

Project Pictures

Page 42: Minnesota Power – Energy & Engineeringsburns/EE1001Fall2012/UMD_EE_1001_9-27-12[1]Re… · Minnesota Power – Energy & Engineering. Introduction to technical aspects of renewable

Project Pictures

Page 43: Minnesota Power – Energy & Engineeringsburns/EE1001Fall2012/UMD_EE_1001_9-27-12[1]Re… · Minnesota Power – Energy & Engineering. Introduction to technical aspects of renewable

Project Pictures

Page 44: Minnesota Power – Energy & Engineeringsburns/EE1001Fall2012/UMD_EE_1001_9-27-12[1]Re… · Minnesota Power – Energy & Engineering. Introduction to technical aspects of renewable

Project Pictures

Page 45: Minnesota Power – Energy & Engineeringsburns/EE1001Fall2012/UMD_EE_1001_9-27-12[1]Re… · Minnesota Power – Energy & Engineering. Introduction to technical aspects of renewable

Project Pictures

Page 46: Minnesota Power – Energy & Engineeringsburns/EE1001Fall2012/UMD_EE_1001_9-27-12[1]Re… · Minnesota Power – Energy & Engineering. Introduction to technical aspects of renewable

Project Pictures

Page 47: Minnesota Power – Energy & Engineeringsburns/EE1001Fall2012/UMD_EE_1001_9-27-12[1]Re… · Minnesota Power – Energy & Engineering. Introduction to technical aspects of renewable

Project Pictures

Page 48: Minnesota Power – Energy & Engineeringsburns/EE1001Fall2012/UMD_EE_1001_9-27-12[1]Re… · Minnesota Power – Energy & Engineering. Introduction to technical aspects of renewable

Project Pictures

Page 49: Minnesota Power – Energy & Engineeringsburns/EE1001Fall2012/UMD_EE_1001_9-27-12[1]Re… · Minnesota Power – Energy & Engineering. Introduction to technical aspects of renewable

Project Pictures

Page 50: Minnesota Power – Energy & Engineeringsburns/EE1001Fall2012/UMD_EE_1001_9-27-12[1]Re… · Minnesota Power – Energy & Engineering. Introduction to technical aspects of renewable

Project Pictures

Page 51: Minnesota Power – Energy & Engineeringsburns/EE1001Fall2012/UMD_EE_1001_9-27-12[1]Re… · Minnesota Power – Energy & Engineering. Introduction to technical aspects of renewable

Project Pictures

Page 52: Minnesota Power – Energy & Engineeringsburns/EE1001Fall2012/UMD_EE_1001_9-27-12[1]Re… · Minnesota Power – Energy & Engineering. Introduction to technical aspects of renewable

-

Turbines & Engineers

-

How is the Energy Produced?

-

Storage?

-

How Operate?

-

Maintenance

-

Worldwide Industry

Minnesota Power –

Energy & EngineeringWind Power

-

Current Generation & Future Plans

Page 53: Minnesota Power – Energy & Engineeringsburns/EE1001Fall2012/UMD_EE_1001_9-27-12[1]Re… · Minnesota Power – Energy & Engineering. Introduction to technical aspects of renewable

Rising from the Ashes: Redeveloping the Prairie River Project

Page 54: Minnesota Power – Energy & Engineeringsburns/EE1001Fall2012/UMD_EE_1001_9-27-12[1]Re… · Minnesota Power – Energy & Engineering. Introduction to technical aspects of renewable

The Prairie River Project

A little project background…–

Prairie River Hydro•

Built in 1920 by Blandin

Paper Company•

Total capacity 1084 kW•

Operator’s residence –

upper level

MP Purchased in 1982•

Partially automated –

run from Thomson Hydro

Routine maintenance until 2008 when…

Page 55: Minnesota Power – Energy & Engineeringsburns/EE1001Fall2012/UMD_EE_1001_9-27-12[1]Re… · Minnesota Power – Energy & Engineering. Introduction to technical aspects of renewable

The Prairie River Project

A little project background…–

Prairie River Hydro•

Built in 1920 by Blandin

Paper Company•

Total capacity 1084 kW•

Operator’s residence –

upper level

MP Purchased in 1982•

Partially automated –

run from Thomson Hydro

Routine maintenance until 2008 when…

Fire destroyed the powerhouse

Page 56: Minnesota Power – Energy & Engineeringsburns/EE1001Fall2012/UMD_EE_1001_9-27-12[1]Re… · Minnesota Power – Energy & Engineering. Introduction to technical aspects of renewable

The Prairie River Project – Rebuild Study

Original Project Background ––

Selected HDR Engineering•

Study included 4 Options•

Option 1 –

Rebuild “like-kind”

no T1 work–

Only for insurance settlement negotiation•

Option 2 –

Rebuild same generation, least cost structure & crane including T1 overhaul

Additional generation with turbine efficiency improvements, approximately 10% more MWh

Option 3 –

Rebuild at most efficient generation for watershed–

Not practical –

licensing, reconstruction, lower generation

Option 4 –

Decommission/Sell–

Non-rate base, shareholder responsibility, negative public relations

Page 57: Minnesota Power – Energy & Engineeringsburns/EE1001Fall2012/UMD_EE_1001_9-27-12[1]Re… · Minnesota Power – Energy & Engineering. Introduction to technical aspects of renewable

Recommendation and Decision -–

Rebuild the facility•

“Least cost”

powerhouse with overhead crane•

Improved Safe Work Practices•

Overhaul Turbine 1•

Arc Flash Compliance•

Modern Equipment/Automation/PDM/Reliability•

Security Enhancements

Benefits•

Increased renewable generation over “as was”

condition•

Positive impact on shareholders, ratepayers maintain renewable energy diversity

Lower ongoing operational costs•

Positive public relations•

Construction jobs

The Prairie River Project – Rebuild Study

Page 58: Minnesota Power – Energy & Engineeringsburns/EE1001Fall2012/UMD_EE_1001_9-27-12[1]Re… · Minnesota Power – Energy & Engineering. Introduction to technical aspects of renewable

Expanded ‘Least Cost’

Structure -–

Design & Engineering•

SHPO•

Exterior Aesthetics

The Prairie River Project – Powerhouse

Security -

Access•

Crane –

Truck Bay•

Switchgear, Generator & Mezzanine Levels

Page 59: Minnesota Power – Energy & Engineeringsburns/EE1001Fall2012/UMD_EE_1001_9-27-12[1]Re… · Minnesota Power – Energy & Engineering. Introduction to technical aspects of renewable

Rebuilding the Powerhouse

The Prairie River Project – Out of the Ashes

Page 60: Minnesota Power – Energy & Engineeringsburns/EE1001Fall2012/UMD_EE_1001_9-27-12[1]Re… · Minnesota Power – Energy & Engineering. Introduction to technical aspects of renewable

Rebuilding the Powerhouse

The Prairie River Project – Out of the Ashes

Page 61: Minnesota Power – Energy & Engineeringsburns/EE1001Fall2012/UMD_EE_1001_9-27-12[1]Re… · Minnesota Power – Energy & Engineering. Introduction to technical aspects of renewable

Engineering

-

Problem Solvers

- Experts?

-

Responsibility

- Team

-

Knowledge & Information Seekers

-

Continuous Improvement

Main Ingredient to be successful??

COMMUNICATION

-

Black Box Thinkers?

Minnesota Power –

Energy & Engineering

Page 62: Minnesota Power – Energy & Engineeringsburns/EE1001Fall2012/UMD_EE_1001_9-27-12[1]Re… · Minnesota Power – Energy & Engineering. Introduction to technical aspects of renewable

Questions or Thoughts from the Audience?