54

Original Appeal 43

Appeal with Motion for Reconsideration (MR) 9

Omnibus Motion to Reopen the Case 1

Motion to Withdraw Appeal 1

No. MAB CASE Date CASE TITLE NATURE OF THE CASE STATUS/REMARKS

No. Filed

1 006-96 11-Oct-96 Felimon Claudio For: Conflict of Mining Claims Under Review

versus

DENR Case Agustin C.Jimenez,Sr. and

No. 7237 Precious

Metals and Mining and Dev. Corp.

2 008-96 31-Oct-96 Emma Dee, et.al. For: Conflict of Mining Claims Under Review

versus

DENR Case Rodyerel Marble Corp., et.al.

No. 7500

3 011-96 5-Nov-96 Margarita Ferrer For: Overlapping of Claims Covered by Under Review

(V) versus Lode Lease Contracts

MNR Case Conrado Wabe

No. 6345

4 020-96 30-Jul-98 Carolina Ranada For: Conflict of Mining Claims Under Review

(V) versus

DENR Case Sta.Rosa Mining Co.and

No. 7125 Benguet Corp.

5 033-97 30-Jan-97 In Re:Special Use Permit For: What is the proper mode of tenement Under Review

(XI) (Prospecting Permit Applica- application over government reservation

INVENTORY OF PENDING CASES AS OF June 30, 2015

Pending Original Appeal - 45

MINES ADJUDICATION BOARD

Pending Appeal

DENR Case tion)of Elbinua Virginia areas

No. 8096

6 034-97 27-Jan-97 In the matter of the Rejection For: What is the proper mode of tenement Under Review

(XI) of Prospecting Permit Applica- application over government reservation

DENR Case tion No.999 areas

No. 8095 Amelita Josue

7 036-97 30-Jan-97 In the matter of the Rejection For: What is the proper mode of tenement Under Review

(XI) of Rejection of Prospecting application over government reservation

DENR Case Permit No.1003, areas

No. 8099 Francisco Talampas

8 042-97 9-May-97 Bulawan Mining Corporation For: Exclusion of "Ben-2" and "Fred-3" Mining Under Review

(VII) versus Claims from MPSA of the Respondent

Rojas,Mestre,Lopez,Mining Dev.

Corp.

9 043-97 16-May-97 Benguet Corp. For: Adverse Claim against the Mining claims of Under Review

(V) versus Benguet Corp.

MAC Case No. Marsman and Company, Inc.

DENR-V-1065

10 046-97 7-Jun-97 VTN-Agno River Gold Inc.,and For: Cancellation of Mines Operating Agreement Under Review

(V) Precious Metals Mining & Dev. Corp.

MAC Case versus

No. V-95-01 Golden Sands Mineral Dev.Corp.

11 075-98 21-May-98 In Re:Special Use Permit Dato, For: What is the proper mode of tenement Under Review

(IV) Romeo and Hizon, Victor Compostela, application over government reservation

DENR Case Davao del Norte, Rejection of Pros- areas

No. 6850 pecting Permit Application Nos.995 and 998

12 088-99 12-Nov-98 Baler Consolidated Mines,Inc. For: Protest/Adverse Claim Against the Published Under Review

(IV) versus Notice of Application for an Exploration Permit

POA Case Omni Mines Development Corporation

No. 95-12

13 094-99 Feb 29, 1999 Baler Gold Mining Corporation For: Declaration of Mining Claims as Cancelled/ Under Review

(IV) versus Abandoned

POA Case Baler Consolidated Mines,Inc.

No. 95-10

14 0115-00 10-Mar-00 VTN-Agno River Gold Mining,Inc., et al. For: Cancellation of the Declaration of Location Under Review

(V) versus of Mining Claims

MAC Case Yolanda Vidal-Laurel

No. V-M-91-06

15 0116-00 3-May-00 Valley Mining and Development Corp. For: Adverse Claim/Opposition to the MPSA Under Review

(XIII) versus Application

MSC No. Camarin Mining Corporation

POA-XIII-033

16 0120-00 13-Sep-00 Wilfredo M. Talag, Maria Talag For: Petition for Cancellation of Mining Lease Under Review

(IV) versus Contract Nos. MRD-99 and MRD-100

DENR Case Engracia Amberti registered in the name of Engracia B. Amberti

No. 7149

17 0128-02 7-Jan-02 Heirs of Bucal Gavino For: Opposition to the MPSA Application Under Review

(CAR) Protestants-Appellants

MAC Case versus

No. 012 Philex Mining Corporation

Protestee-Appellee

18 0149-06 7-Sep-06 Aspen Commercial Corporation, Repre- Under Review

(IV) sented by Enrico C. Borja and Manuel For: Conflict of Mining Claims

Tanglao,

Protestant-Appellee

versus

Paul D. Navarro

Protestant-Appellee

19 0154-07 10-May-07 San Juanico Resources Corporation, For: Cancellation of the Permit and Rejection of Under Review

(III) Represented by Pablo Canlaon Jr. and Application for Small-Scale Permit

(MSC No. III-03-05) Percival Andagan (ASSMPs)

Protestees-Appellants,

versus

Heirs of Pablo Pabilona, Jr. Represented

by Pablo Pabilona III and Heirs of Grego-

rio Martinez, Represented by Grespo B.

Martinez,

Claimants-Appellees

20 0155-07 19-Jun-07 Unirock Corporation For: Cancellation of the Memorandum of Under Review

(IV-A) Respondent-Appellant Agreement

(DENR Case versus

No. 2006-01) Hardrock Aggregates, Inc.,

Petitioner-Appellee

21 0159-07 Dec. 19, 2007 Emmanuel P Deloso, For: Adverse Claims/Opposition on the Denial Under Review

(XIII) Adverse Claimant-Appelant of the Application for Mineral Production

versus Sharing Agreement of Emmanuel P. Deloso

Mines Special Rosario Mining Development Company; denominated as APSA-000074-XIII

Case No. Rosario Consolidated Mining Corporation;

POA-045 Diamond Mining Company, all Represen-

ted by Jose H. Rodriguez; Philex Mining

Corporation; Philex Gold Phils., Inc., and

Philsaga Mining Corporation,

Respondent-Appellee

22 0165-08 18-Apr-08 Picop Resources, Inc., For: Adverse Claim/Opposition Under Review

(XIII) Oppostitor-Appellant

(Mines Special versus

Case No. 050) Col.Samuel P. Afdal,

Respondent-Appellee

23 0166-08 18-Apr-08 Provident Tree Farms, Inc. For: Adverse Claim/Opposition Under Review

(XIII) Oppositor-Appelant

(Mines Special versus

Case No. 048 & Makilala Mining Corporation,

049) Respondent-Appellee

Provident Tree Farms, Inc.

Oppositor-Appellant

versus

PDEP,Inc.,

Respondent-Appellee

24 0171-08 14-Oct-08 Holcim Philippines, Inc. For: Dispute over mining claims located in Under Review

(III) Protestant-Appellant San Ildefonso, San Miguel and Doña Remedios

versus Trinidad, Bulacan

MGB Case Neutron Construction & Marketing Corpo-

No. MSC-III-02-07 ration

Protestee-Appellee

25 172-08 30-Oct-09 PICOP Resources, Inc., For: Adverse Claim/Opposition against the mining Under Review

(XIII) Oppositor-Appellant application under MPSA No. XIII-039

versus

MSC Case Bernster Mining Exploration Agro-Indus-

No. POA-XIII-035 trial Corporation, by Alcorn Petroleum

and Mineral Corporation

Respondent-Appellee

26 0173-08 Nov. 15, 2008 Philippine Mining Development Corpora- For: Petition for Review of the letter-decision of the Under Review

(CAR) tion (PMDC), MGB-CAR dated August 21, 2007 denying the

Appellant Exploration Permit Application filed by

MGB-CAR versus Mr. Gumisa on behalf of BREC

Case No. 07-08 Balatoc Resources Exploration Corpora-

tion,represented by its President and

Attorney-In-Fact, Mr.VICTOR GUYANG

GUMISA

Appellee

27 0174-08 19-Dec-08 MT.Franz Mining Corporation In re: Rejection of Exploration Permit Application of Under Review

(CAR) Respondent-Appellant Balatoc Resources Exploration Corporation by

versus the Regional Director of MGB-CAR due to prior

MGB-CAR Balatoc Resources Exploration Corpora- mining applications and an allegedly issued

Case No. 07-07 tion,represented by its President and exploration permit covering the same area

Attorney-In-Fact, Mr.VICTOR GUYANG being applied for by "MMCI", "FMI", "APBMC",

Petitioner-Appellee and "MFMC"

28 0175-09 Dec. 22, 2008 Asia Pacific Basin Mining Corporation In re: Rejection of Exploration Permit Application of Under Review

(CAR) Docket Fee and Facets Mineral Incorporated Balatoc Resources Exploration Corporation by

paid on Respondents-Appellants the Regional Director of MGB-CAR due to prior

MGB-CAR 5-Jan-09 versus mining applications and an allegedly issued

Case No. 07-07 Balatoc Resources Exploration, Corp., exploration permit covering the same area

Petitioner-Appellee being applied for by "MMCI", "FMI", "APBMC",

and "MFMC"

29 0178-09 9-Jun-09 Cesar A. Ventura, Represented by Alice In re: Petition for Cancellation and/or rejection of Under Review

(I) R. Ventura and in her Behalf APSA SF No. 234 of Romulo D. Aguinaldo

Petitioner-Appellants located at Pasuquin, Ilocos Norte

(RPA Case # versus

2006-15-1) Romulo D. Aguinaldo

Oppositor-Respondent

30 0180-09 4-Sep-09 Picop Resources, Inc. For: Adverse Claim-Opposition filed by PICOP Under Review

(MAC No. POA Oppositor-Appellant for the DENIAL of OMEGA'S MPSA Application

2009-002 versus

[XI]) Omega Gold Resources Philippines, Inc.,

Respondent-Appellee

31 0183-09 8-Oct-09 Picop Resources, Inc. For: Adverse Claim-Opposition of PICOP Resources, Under Review

(XI) Oppositor-Appellant Inc. (PRI) to the Application for MPSA of

versus Boston Mining Resources Corporation

MAC No. Boston Mining Resources Corporation

POA-2009-001 Respondent-Appellee

32 0185-04 1-Jun-10 La Concepcion Construction Develop- For: Opposition to the Exploration Permit Application Under Review

(IV) ment Corporation, Represented by of Compania Minera Del Grande, Inc.

Engr. Pedro M. Robles,

Petitioner-Appellant

versus

Compania Minera Del Grande, Inc.,

Respondent-Appellee

33 0186-10 21-Jun-10 Cesar Guy, For: Cancellation of Exploration Permit/ Under Review

IV-A Petitioner-Appellant Adverse Claim-Opposition

CALABARZON versus

Suncorp Mines & Development Corp.

Respondent-Appellee

34 0187-11 5-Aug-11 Olpaten Resources Corporation, For: Adverse Claim and/or Opposition dated Under Review

(CAR) Adverse Claimant-Appellant April 12, 2010 filed by the Adverse Claimant

versus Olpaten Resources Corporation

Pacific Metals Canada Phils., Inc.,

Respondent-Appellee

35 0188-11 24-Aug-11 Green Valley Company, For: Protest Against an Exploration Permit Under Review

(III) Protestant-Appellant Application

versus

Earthmovers Mining Corporation,

Protestee-Appellee

36 0189-11 24-Aug-11 Camalca Mining Company, For: Protest Against an Exploration Permit Under Review

(III) Protestant-Appellant Application

versus

Earthmovers Mining Corporation,

Protestee-Appellee

37 0190-11 Rodrigo S. Blando, Sr., For: Exclusion from the Exploration Permit Under Review

(II) 5-Aug-11 Leticia B. Orpia,

Rovil Orpia,

Jayson A. Blando,

Rodrigo A. Blando, Jr.,

Protestant-Appellants

versus

MTL Phils., Inc.

Defendant-Appellee

38 0191-11 10-Nov-11 Hedlite Mining Company, For: Opposition to EXPA-000131-VIII Under Review

(VIII) Applicant-Appellee

versus

Minoro Mining & Exploration Corporation,

Oppositor-Appellant

39 0194-11 1-Dec-11 Protest of the Municipality of Hilongos, Leyte For: Opposition for Sand and Gravel Industrial Under Review

represented by Mayor Jose Emery F. Robles, Application (IPA-000138-VIII) for environmental

Protestant-Appellant, protection purposes

-versus-

Sand and Gravel Permit Application (IPA-000138

VIII) of Chandran Rama,

Applicant-Appellee.

40 0195-12 24-Jan-12 Manuel Diamante, herein represented in this For: Recovery of Possession of Mineral Land, Under Review

Complaint by Hadji Julhamri Ansah, Per a Annulment of Small-Scale Mining Permit,

Special Power of Attorney, Accounting, Collection of Royalties, Damages,

Complainant-Appellee Attorney's Fees and Litigation Expenses

-versus-

Montereal Mining Corporation, Represented by

Francisco Real and Jose Dy,

s Respondenst-Appellants

41 0196-12 24-Jan-12 Heirs of Dominador S. Almadrones, Sr., For: Protest for Overlapping Claim Under Review

Protestant, within the AMPSA of Dominador S. Almadrones, Sr.

-versus- denominated as MA-P-III-42-97

Neutron Construction & Marketing Corporation,

Protestee.

42 0197-12 18-Jul-12 Butan Mining Exploration Company, For: Compensation for the alleged use of the Under Review

(CAR) Complainant-Appellee 745ML Tunnel within the mining claims with an

-versus- Application for a Temporary Restraining Order

Philex Mining Corporation, and/or Preliminary Injunction.

Respondent-Appellant

43 0198-13 29-May-13 Ma. Lourdes R. Mendoza, Arlene G. Mendoza, For: Voluntary Arbitration Under Review

(III) Armin C. Mendoza, Evangeline Calimlim, Protest for award of Just Compensation

Rosario Agulay, Alvin Mendoza, involving OCT No. 001 (M) - CLOA

Marcela G. Braganza, Audrey Mendoza,

Ariel Mendoza, John Malagot, Rosario Ignacio,

Miguela Robles, Felipe Cruz, Pepito Magno,

Gregorio Bulas, Angela Cruz, Conrado Bueno,

Pedro Cunanan, Justina Llanesta,

Teodoro Santos and Ben Agulay, represented

by their attorney-in-fact Norma G. Mendoza,

Protestants-Appellees.

-versus-

Holcim Philippines, Inc., represented by

Roland Van Vijnen,

Protestee-Appellant

1 023-97 30-Oct-00 Shipside Incorporated For: Protest for the Annulment of 8 FTAA Under Review

(CAR) versus Applications of Newmont and grant of

Newmont Phils.Inc. preferential right to the MPSA of Shipside

2 066-98 17-Aug-07 Jose P. Sulit,for himself and his For: Petition for Cancellation of Mines Operating Undwer Review

(XIII) capacity as the Attorney-In-Fact Agreement

of Arceli Makilasulit and Eduardo

S. Sulit

versus

Surigao Consolidated Mining Co.,

Inc.(now Gotesco Land, Inc.)

4 0143-04 2-Aug-05 Blue Ridge Mineral Corporation For: Petition for Annulment and reversal of the Under Review

(IV) and Celestial Nickel Mining Exploration Decision of the Panel of Arbitratiors dated

Corporation September 1, 1997

versus

Infanta Mineral and Industrial Corporation

and Lebach Mining Corporation

5 0169-08 23-Jun-10 Makilala Mining Company, Inc. For: Petition to Annul and Set Aside Resolution

(CAR) Petitioner-Appellees and Order issued by the Panel of Arbitrators,

versus MGB-CAR Under Review

The Panel of Arbitrators (POA)- MGB-

CAR And Balatoc Resources Exploration

Corp.,

Respondents-Appellant

6 0176-09 23-Jun-10 Makilala Mining Company, Inc., For: Denial of the Exploration Permit Application Under Review

(CAR) Appellant of Balatoc Resources Exploration Corporation

versus

Balatoc Minig Corp.represented by its

Pending Motion for Reconsideration - 9

President, Attorney-In-Fact, Mr. Victor

Guyang Gumisa

7 0160-08 3-Feb-08 Mina-San & Co.,and/or Sandoval Santos, For: Protest for the Recognition of the mining Under Review

(III) Sr., claims

Petitioner-Appellee

MGB Case versus

No. III-01-00 Luzon Continental Land Corporation,

Respondent-Appellant

8 0181-09 8-Sep-09 Heirs of Antonio Nicolas,represented by For: Payment of Royalties, Overlapping of Claims Under Review

(MGB-CAR Juliet Camcam of Claims, Damages with Prayer for Preliminary

Case No. 08-01) Petitioners-Appellees Injunction

versus

Heirs of Baldomero Nevada, Sr., repre-

sented by Elmo Nevada and Philex

Mining Corporation,

Respondents-Appellants

9 0182-09 8-Sep-09 Heirs of Antonio Nicolas,represented by For: Payment of Royalties, Overlapping of Claims Under Review

(MGB-CAR Juliet Camcam of Claims, Damages with Prayer for Preliminary

Case No. 08-01) Petitioners-Appellees Injunction

versus

Heirs of Baldomero Nevada, Sr., repre-

sented by Elmo Nevada and Philex

Mining Corporation,

Respondents-Appellants

Omnibus Motion to Reopen the Case - 11 0164-08 31-Mar-08 Suncorp Mines and Development Corp., For: Denial of E/MPSA Applications denominated as Under Review

Petitioner-Appellee follows: MPSA-083-VIII; MPSA-084-VIII;

versus EPA-030-VIII; and EPA-031-VIII

Bethlehem Nickel Corporation,

Respondent-Appellee

x- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - X

17-Apr-08 Olympic Mines and Development Corporation/

Falcon Ridge Resources Management Corporation,

Petitioner-Intervenor

Motion to Withdraw Appeal - 1

1 0192-11 2-Dec-11 Agbiag Mining and Development Corporation For: Petition/Complaint against BCMC Under Review

Complainant-Appellant involving MPSA 211-2005-V and

versus MPSA 212-2005-V

Bicol Chromite and Manganese Corporation,

Respondent-Appellee