meeting documents city council cc - 8 2020

219
Wednesday, May 13, 2020 1:00 p.m. Regular Meeting Council Chambers 4 th Floor with Electronic Participation Closed Session following (See Item 22) Boardroom CH-6A 6 th Floor (Under Section 239 of the Municipal Act, 2001) Members: Mayor P. Brown Regional Councillor P. Vicente Wards 1 and 5 (Acting Mayor July) Regional Councillor R. Santos Wards 1 and 5 (Acting Mayor June) Regional Councillor M. Palleschi Wards 2 and 6 (Acting Mayor May) Regional Councillor M. Medeiros Wards 3 and 4 Regional Councillor P. Fortini Wards 7 and 8 Regional Councillor G. Dhillon Wards 9 and 10 City Councillor D. Whillans Wards 2 and 6 City Councillor J. Bowman Wards 3 and 4 City Councillor C. Williams Wards 7 and 8 City Councillor H. Singh Wards 9 and 10 For inquiries about this agenda, or to make arrangements for accessibility accommodations for persons attending (some advance notice may be required), please contact: Terri Brenton, Legislative Coordinator, Telephone 905.874.2106, TTY 905.874.2130 [email protected] Note: Meeting information is also available in alternate formats upon request. Notice: In consideration of the current COVID-19 public health orders prohibiting public gatherings of more than 5 people and requirements for physical distancing between persons, in-person attendance at this Special Council meeting will be limited to Members of Council and essential City staff only. Members of the public may watch the meeting live from the City of Brampton website at: https://www.brampton.ca/EN/City-Hall/meetings-agendas/Pages/Welcome.aspx or http://video.isilive.ca/brampton/live.html Correspondence related to agenda business to be considered at the Special Meeting may be submitted via email to the City Clerk at [email protected] up until the start of the meeting. During the Special Meeting, the public may submit questions regarding decisions made at the meeting via email to the City Clerk at [email protected], to be introduced during the Public Question Period section of the meeting. Agenda City Council The Corporation of the City of Brampton

Upload: others

Post on 25-Feb-2022

1 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Wednesday, May 13, 2020

1:00 p.m. – Regular Meeting Council Chambers – 4th Floor with Electronic Participation

Closed Session following (See Item 22) Boardroom CH-6A – 6th Floor

(Under Section 239 of the Municipal Act, 2001)

Members: Mayor P. Brown Regional Councillor P. Vicente – Wards 1 and 5 (Acting Mayor – July) Regional Councillor R. Santos – Wards 1 and 5 (Acting Mayor – June) Regional Councillor M. Palleschi – Wards 2 and 6 (Acting Mayor – May) Regional Councillor M. Medeiros – Wards 3 and 4 Regional Councillor P. Fortini – Wards 7 and 8 Regional Councillor G. Dhillon – Wards 9 and 10 City Councillor D. Whillans – Wards 2 and 6 City Councillor J. Bowman – Wards 3 and 4 City Councillor C. Williams – Wards 7 and 8 City Councillor H. Singh – Wards 9 and 10

For inquiries about this agenda, or to make arrangements for accessibility accommodations for persons attending (some advance notice may be required), please contact:

Terri Brenton, Legislative Coordinator, Telephone 905.874.2106, TTY 905.874.2130 [email protected]

Note: Meeting information is also available in alternate formats upon request.

Notice:

In consideration of the current COVID-19 public health orders prohibiting public gatherings of more than 5 people and requirements for physical distancing between persons, in-person attendance at this Special Council meeting will be limited to Members of Council and essential City staff only.

Members of the public may watch the meeting live from the City of Brampton website at: https://www.brampton.ca/EN/City-Hall/meetings-agendas/Pages/Welcome.aspx or http://video.isilive.ca/brampton/live.html

Correspondence related to agenda business to be considered at the Special Meeting may be submitted via email to the City Clerk at [email protected] up until the start of the meeting.

During the Special Meeting, the public may submit questions regarding decisions made at the meeting via email to the City Clerk at [email protected], to be introduced during the Public Question Period section of the meeting.

Agenda

City Council The Corporation of the City of Brampton

Agenda City Council

2020 05 13 Page 2 of 7

1. Call to Order

Note: The City Clerk will conduct a roll call at the start of the meeting.

2. Approval of Agenda

3. Declarations of Interest under the Municipal Conflict of Interest Act

4. Adoption of the Minutes

4.1. Minutes – City Council – Regular Meeting – April 29, 2020

5. Consent Motion All items listed with an asterisk (*) are considered to be routine and non-controversial by Council and will be approved by one resolution. There will be no separate discussion of these items unless a Council Member requests it in which case the item will be removed from the consent resolution and considered in its normal sequence on the agenda.

(10.2, 10.3, 10.4)

6. Announcements (2 minutes maximum)

7. Government Relations Matters

7.1. Staff Report re: Government Relations Matters.

8. Delegations (5 minutes maximum)

9. Reports from the Head of Council

9.1. Update from Mayor Brown re: COVID-19 Emergency.

Agenda City Council

2020 05 13 Page 3 of 7

10. Reports of Corporate Officials

Office of the Chief Administrative Officer

Legislative Services Operating

10.1. Staff Report re: Technology Options for Virtual Council and Committee Meetings (I 48/2020) To be received

* 10.2. Staff Report re: Housekeeping Amendments to Records Retention By-Law 272-2014 (R 26/2020). Recommendation

Corporate Support Services

* 10.3. Staff Report re: 2020 Final Tax Levy and By-law (R 71/2020). See By-law 77-2020 Recommendation

Planning and Economic Development

Community Services

Public Works

* 10.4. Staff Report re: Request to Begin Procurement – Reconstruction of Elizabeth Street and Elliott Street – Ward 3 (R103/2020) (Capital Works File Nos. 18-2683-231 & 18-2791-231).

Brampton Transit

Fire and Emergency Services

Agenda City Council

2020 05 13 Page 4 of 7

11. Reports of Accountability Officers

12. Committee Reports

12.1. Minutes – Audit Committee – Special Meeting – May 5, 2020 (Chair – Regional Councillor Medeiros) To be approved

12.2. Minutes – Committee of Council – May 6, 2020 Meeting Chairs: Regional Councillor Vicente, Economic Development and

Culture Section City Councillor Singh, Corporate Services Section Regional Councillor Vicente, Public Works and Engineering

Section Regional Councillor Santos, Community Services Section

To be approved

13. Unfinished Business

14. Correspondence

15. Resolutions

16. Notices of Motion

16.1. Notice of Motion – Proposed National Gun Buy Back Program and Assault Style Firearms Ban Moved by Councillor Williams Seconded by Councillor Medeiros Whereas, assault style firearms designed for the battlefield, have been used tragically to target women, students and worshippers because they are efficient in maximizing fatalities, and Whereas, residents of the City of Brampton have been victims of mass shootings, and

Agenda City Council

2020 05 13 Page 5 of 7

Whereas, the City of Brampton will be commemorating the 45th anniversary of the mass shooting of 15 people on May 28, 2020, and Whereas, in the words of Justice Minister David Lametti, weapons designed for the battlefield have no place on our streets or in our communities, and Whereas, the federal government has added 1500 assault style firearms to the list of prohibited firearms, and Whereas, in Canada, there are currently over 100,000 restricted firearms among the models that are now prohibited. This number does not include other newly-prohibited models that were not subject to registration requirements, and Whereas, a Criminal Code amnesty is in place until April 30, 2022, to protect lawful owners from criminal liability and to enable them to comply with the law. Under the amnesty, the newly prohibited firearms can only be transferred or transported within Canada for specific purposes, and Whereas, firearms owners should be fairly compensated for their property, and Whereas, the federal government has announced preliminary plans to compensate firearms owners through a national gun buy back plan Therefore be it resolved that Brampton City Council endorse the recently announced proposed national gun buy back program and assault style firearms ban.

16.2. Notice of Motion - Commemoration of the 45th Anniversary of the mass shooting at Brampton Centennial Secondary School Moved by Councillor Williams Seconded by Councillor Medeiros Whereas, May 28, 2020 marks the 45th anniversary of the mass shooting in Brampton, Centennial Secondary School and Whereas, the mass shooting of 15 people at the hands of a fellow student at Brampton Centennial Secondary school has scarred the lives of the surviving victims and their families, and Whereas, May 28, 1975 marked the first time in Canadian history that anyone had been killed in a mass school shooting in Canada, and Whereas, the healing process for many still continues, and

Agenda City Council

2020 05 13 Page 6 of 7

Whereas, the community banded together in 2017 to install a memorial called “the Healing Place” located on the grounds of Brampton Centennial Secondary School Therefore, be it resolved that the Brampton City Council proclaim May 28, 2020 as a Day of Healing in recognition of this solemn day of remembrance of a tragic day that occurred in our community.

17. Petitions

18. Other Business/New Business

18.1. Referred Matters List Note: In accordance with the Procedure By-law and Council Resolution, the

Referred Matters List will be published quarterly on a meeting agenda for reference and consideration. A copy of the current Referred Matters List for Council and its committees, including original and updated reporting dates, is publicly available on the City’s website.

19. Procurement Matters

20. Public Question Period 15 Minute Limit (regarding any decision made at this meeting) During the meeting, the public may submit questions regarding decisions made at the meeting via email to the City Clerk at [email protected], to be introduced during the Public Question Period section of the meeting.

21. By-laws

21.1. 77-2020 To provide for the levy and collection of property taxes for the Year 2020 (See Item 10.3)

21.2. 78-2020 To establish certain lands as part of the public highway system

(Commuter Drive) – Ward 6

Agenda City Council

2020 05 13 Page 7 of 7

21.3. 79-2020 To prevent the application of part lot control to part of Registered Plan 43M-2039 – west side of McLaughlin Road and south of Mayfield Road – Ward 6 (PLC-2020-0010)

21.4. 80-2020 To prevent the application of part lot control to part of Registered

Plan 43M-2050 – east side of Heritage Road and north of Steeles Avenue West – Ward 6 (PLC-2020-0011)

22. Closed Session Note: A separate package regarding this agenda item is provided to Members

of Council and senior staff only.

22.1. Minutes – Closed Session – City Council – Regular Meeting – April 29, 2020

22.2. Minutes – Closed Session – Committee of Council – May 6, 2020

23. Confirming By-law

23.1. To confirm the proceedings of Council at its Regular Meeting held on May 13, 2020

24. Adjournment Next Meetings: Wednesday, May 27, 2020 – 1:00 p.m.

Wednesday, June 10, 2020 – 1:00 p.m.

Wednesday, April 29, 2020

Members Present in Chambers:

Mayor P. Brown (after Closed Session, joined meeting via electronic participation)

Members Present via Electronic Meeting Participation:

Regional Councillor P. Vicente – Wards 1 and 5 Regional Councillor R. Santos – Wards 1 and 5 Regional Councillor M. Palleschi – Wards 2 and 6 Regional Councillor M. Medeiros – Wards 3 and 4 Regional Councillor P. Fortini – Wards 7 and 8 Regional Councillor G. Dhillon – Wards 9 and 10 City Councillor D. Whillans – Wards 2 and 6 City Councillor J. Bowman – Wards 3 and 4 City Councillor C. Williams – Wards 7 and 8 City Councillor H. Singh – Wards 9 and 10

Members Absent: nil Staff Present: D. Barrick, Chief Administrative Officer

R. Forward, Commissioner, Planning and Development Services J. Pittari, Commissioner, Legislative Services J. Raina, Commissioner, Public Works and Engineering D. Boyce, Acting Commissioner, Community Services C. Barnett, Director, Economic Development and Culture B. Boyes, Fire Chief, Fire and Emergency Services A. Milojevic, General Manager, Transit D. Soos, Acting City Solicitor, Legislative Services P. Fay, City Clerk C. Gravlev, Deputy City Clerk T. Brenton, Legislative Coordinator, City Clerk’s Office

Minutes City Council

The Corporation of the City of Brampton

4.1-1

Minutes City Council

2020 04 29 Page 2 of 16

Note: In consideration of the current COVID-19 public health orders prohibiting public gatherings of more than 5 people and requirements for physical distancing between persons, in-person attendance at this Council meeting was limited to Members of Council and essential City staff only. Physical distancing was maintained in Council Chambers at all times during the meeting.

The meeting was called to order at 1:05 p.m. and recessed at 3:34 p.m. Council moved into Closed Session at 3:45 p.m. and recessed at 4:04 p.m. Council reconvened in Open Session at 4:17 p.m. and adjourned at 4:25 p.m. 1. Approval of Agenda

As this meeting of Brampton City Council was conducted with electronic participation by Members of Council, the meeting started with the City Clerk calling the roll for attendance at the meeting, as follows:

Members present during roll call: Councillor Santos, Councillor Vicente, Councillor Whillans, Councillor Palleschi, Councillor Bowman, Councillor Medeiros, Councillor Williams, Councillor Fortini, Councillor Singh, Councillor Dhillon, Mayor Brown

Members absent during roll call: nil

Council discussion took place with respect to proposed amendments to the agenda.

The following motion was considered.

C136-2020 Moved by City Councillor Singh

Seconded by Regional Councillor Dhillon

That the agenda for the Regular Council Meeting of April 29, 2020, be approved as amended to add:

17.2. Discussion Item at the Request of Mayor Brown re: Active

Transportation;

17.3. Discussion Item at the Request of Regional Councillor Dhillon re Ethnic Media; and,

17.4. Discussion Item at the Request of City Councillor Singh re: Noise

By-law during Ramadan 2020. Carried

4.1-2

Minutes City Council

2020 04 29 Page 3 of 16

Note: Later in the meeting on a two-thirds majority vote to reopen the question, the Approval of Agenda was reopened and Item 17.4 was added.

The following item, related to a matter on the agenda, was published on the City’s web portal on April 27, 2020:

Re: Item 6.1 – staff report re: Government Relations Matters:

staff presentation entitled: “Government Relations Matters – Update on COVID-19 (April 2020)”

The following was received by the City Clerk’s Office after the agenda was published and related to published items on the agenda (Council approval was not required for addition of these items in accordance with Procedure By-law 160-2004, as amended). This material was published on the City’s web portal on April 29, 2020.

Re: Item 9.1 – staff report re: Application to Amend the Official Plan and

Zoning By-law and Draft Plan of Subdivision – Malone Given Parsons Ltd. – Shayma Dick Holdings Inc. – Kendalwood Land Development Inc. and 2570616 Ontario Inc. – North and South sides of Embleton Road, East of Heritage Road – Ward 6 (R 63/2020) (File C05W06.007):

correspondence: 1. Julie Harlow and Gavin Carrow, Brampton residents, dated

April 29, 2020 2. Anthony Melo, Brampton resident, dated April 29, 2020

2. Declarations of Interest under the Municipal Conflict of Interest Act – nil

3. Adoption of the Minutes 3.1. Minutes – City Council – Regular Meeting – April 22, 2020

The following motion was considered. C137-2020 Moved by City Councillor Singh

Seconded by Regional Councillor Dhillon

That the Minutes of the Regular City Council Meeting of April 22, 2020, to the Council Meeting of April 29, 2020, be adopted as published and circulated.

Carried

4.1-3

Minutes City Council

2020 04 29 Page 4 of 16

4. Consent Motion

The following motion was considered. C138-2020 Moved by Regional Councillor Vicente

Seconded by Regional Councillor Fortini

That Council hereby approves the following items and that the various Officials of the Corporation are hereby authorized and directed to take such action as may be necessary to give effect of the recommendations as contained therein:

9.2. 1. That the staff report titled: Traffic By-law 93-93 –

Administrative Update (R 60/2020), to the Council Meeting of April 29, 2020, be received;

2. That By-law 71-2020 be passed to implement administrative

updates to Traffic By-law 93-93, as amended.

9.3. 1. That the staff report titled: All-way Stop Review – McMurchy Avenue North and Railroad Street – Ward 1 (R 58/2020), to the Council Meeting of April 29, 2020, be received;

2. That By-law 72-2020 be passed to amend Traffic By-law 93-

93, as amended, to implement an all-way stop control at McMurchy Avenue North and Railroad Street.

9.4. 1. That the staff report titled: U-Turn Restriction – Monte Vista Trail – Ward 2 (R 59/2020), to the Council Meeting of April 29, 2020, be received;

2. That By-law 73-2020 be passed to amend Traffic By-law 93-

93, as amended, to implement a U-turn restriction on Monte Vista Trail between Richvale Drive North and Kerwood Place.

Carried

5. Announcements – nil

6. Government Relations Matters 6.1. Staff Report re: Government Relations Matters.

4.1-4

Minutes City Council

2020 04 29 Page 5 of 16

Gurdeep Kaur, Director, Corporate Projects and Liaison, Office of the Chief Administrative Officer, provided a presentation titled: “Government Relations Matters – Update on COVID-19 (April 2020)”.

Mikkel Marr, Director, Organizational Performance, Office of the Chief Administrative Officer, provided an update on the Regional Community Response Table.

Mayor Brown responded to questions from Council with respect to military support for and staffing levels at Brampton’s long term care facilities. The Mayor also provided a reminder of the statistical information available on the Region of Peel’s website, and noted that Members could direct their questions via e-mail to Dr. Lawrence Loh, Interim Medical Officer of Health, Peel Public Health.

Council consideration of this matter included a request that staff provide information on the following:

mental health and other supports for workers in long term care homes

status of City applications for federal funding programs for green initiatives, including the Community Energy Efficiency Program

The following motion was considered.

C139-2020 Moved by Regional Councillor Palleschi

Seconded by City Councillor Whillans

That the staff report titled: Government Relations Matters, to the Council Meeting of April 29, 2020, be received.

Carried

7. Delegations 7.1. Possible Written Delegations re: Proposed Amendment to Mobile Licensing By-

law 67-2014 to Provide Relief of Fees and Timelines During the COVID-19 Emergency. See Item 3.1 – Council Resolution C125-2020 – April 22, 2020 and By-law 75-2020

Mayor Brown announced that public notice regarding this matter was given on the City’s website on April 24, 2020, for which written delegations could be submitted.

4.1-5

Minutes City Council

2020 04 29 Page 6 of 16

Peter Fay, City Clerk, confirmed that no delegation requests were received for this meeting.

8. Reports from the Head of Council 8.1. Update from Mayor Brown re: COVID-19 Emergency.

Mayor Brown referenced the update provided at a press conference this morning (April 29, 2020), which included details about social services support efforts and the City’s ongoing collaboration with anchor organizations for this purpose, comments at the press conference by Dr. Lawrence Loh, Interim Medical Officer of Health, Peel Public Health, challenges being faced in long term care homes, ongoing enforcement of physical distancing, and the City’s Backyard Garden Program.

The following motion, moved by City Councillor Williams and seconded by City Councillor Bowman, was introduced.

Whereas, COVID-19 has created social and economic disruption to life in Brampton and beyond, and

Whereas, many Brampton homeowners have been financially affected by economic slowdown created by the COVID-19 pandemic, and

Whereas, there are over 160,000 residences in Brampton and

Whereas, the City of Brampton offered a tax deferral plan to lessen the burden to ratepayers as a compassionate means to help residents in their hour of need, and

Whereas, Brampton city staff have reported that only 500 people where able to meet the April 15, 2020 deadline to apply for the deferral plan, and

Whereas, this number represents less than one third of one per cent of residences in Brampton, and

Whereas, it has been widely reported in the media that unemployment may rise as much as 25 per cent, and Statistics Canada reported that 1-million jobs were lost in Canada during the month of March.

Therefore, be it resolved that Brampton City Council direct staff to extend the tax deferral application deadline to May 15, 2020, and Further any penalties that may have been incurred to new applicants be rescinded retroactively to April 15, 2020

4.1-6

Minutes City Council

2020 04 29 Page 7 of 16

Following Council discussion and clarification from City staff, Councillor Williams withdrew her motion, and requested that staff update the City’s website and issue additional communications about the Property Tax Deferral Program.

The following motion was considered.

C140-2020 Moved by City Councillor Whillans

Seconded by Regional Councillor Palleschi

That the update from Mayor Brown re: COVID-19 Emergency, to the Council Meeting of April 29, 2020, be received.

Carried

9. Reports of Corporate Officials Planning and Development Services 9.1. Staff Report re: Application to Amend the Official Plan and Zoning By-law and

Draft Plan of Subdivision – Malone Given Parsons Ltd. – Shayma Dick Holdings Inc. – Kendalwood Land Development Inc. and 2570616 Ontario Inc. – North and South sides of Embleton Road, East of Heritage Road (to develop the subject lands for approximately 538 dwelling units along with commercial uses, a public park, and a storm water management pond) – Ward 6 (R 63/2020) (File C05W06.007).

Item 13.1 was brought forward and dealt with at this time.

Staff responded to questions from Council on the subject application, with topics including timelines for road improvements, location of the park in relation to the tree canopy/woodlot, tree preservation, and proposed setbacks and buffers.

Council consideration of this matter included:

review of the correspondence outlined in Item 13.1

advisory regarding correspondence from resident Don Naylor

concerns about timelines for and sequence of road improvements, and the proposed setbacks and buffers

disposal of inappropriate materials in the Credit River and request to staff to issue communications about the negative environmental impacts as a result

request that staff extend the distance requirements for notice of this application to include residents on River Road

4.1-7

Minutes City Council

2020 04 29 Page 8 of 16

need for additional discussions between the applicant, City staff, area Councillors, Chair and Vice-Chair of the Planning and Development Committee, and area residents

A motion, moved by Regional Councillor Palleschi, was introduced to refer this matter back to staff. As the motion was procedural in nature, a seconder was not required.

The motion was considered as follows.

C141-2020 Moved by Regional Councillor Palleschi

That the following matters re: Application to Amend the Official Plan and Zoning By-law and Draft Plan of Subdivision – Malone Given Parsons Ltd. – Shayma Dick Holdings Inc. – Kendalwood Land Development Inc. and 2570616 Ontario Inc. – North and South sides of Embleton Road, East of Heritage Road (to develop the subject lands for approximately 538 dwelling units along with commercial uses, a public park, and a storm water management pond) – Ward 6 (R 63/2020) (File C05W06.007), be referred back to staff: 1. Staff report and associated by-laws; and, 2. Correspondence:

1. Julie Harlow and Gavin Carrow, Brampton residents, dated April 29, 2020

2. Anthony Melo, Brampton resident, dated April 29, 2020. Carried

Public Works and Engineering * 9.2. Staff Report re: Traffic By-law 93-93 - Administrative Update (R 60/2020).

See By-law 71-2020

Dealt with under Consent Resolution C138-2020

* 9.3. Staff Report re: All-way Stop Review – McMurchy Avenue North and Railroad Street – Ward 1 (R 58/2020). See By-law 72-2020

Dealt with under Consent Resolution C138-2020

4.1-8

Minutes City Council

2020 04 29 Page 9 of 16

* 9.4. Staff report re: U-Turn Restriction – Monte Vista Trail – Ward 2 (R 59/2020). See By-law 73-2020

Dealt with under Consent Resolution C138-2020

10. Reports of Accountability Officers – nil

11. Committee Reports – nil

12. Unfinished Business – nil

13. Correspondence 13.1. Correspondence re: Item 9.1 – Application to Amend the Official Plan and

Zoning By-law and Draft Plan of Subdivision – Malone Given Parsons Ltd. – Shayma Dick Holdings Inc. – Kendalwood Land Development Inc. and 2570616 Ontario Inc. – North and South sides of Embleton Road, East of Heritage Road (to develop the subject lands for approximately 538 dwelling units along with commercial uses, a public park, and a storm water management pond) – Ward 6 (R 63/2020) (File C05W06.007). 1. Julie Harlow and Gavin Carrow, Brampton residents, dated April 29, 2020 2. Anthony Melo, Brampton resident, dated April 29, 2020

Dealt with under Item 9.1 – Resolution C141-2020

14. Resolutions – nil

15. Notices of Motion – nil

16. Petitions – nil

17. Other Business/New Business 17.1. Referred Matters List – nil

17.2. Discussion Item at the Request of Mayor Brown re: Active Transportation.

A motion, moved by Mayor Brown and seconded by Regional Councillor Dhillon was introduced, with the operative clauses as follows:

4.1-9

Minutes City Council

2020 04 29 Page 10 of 16

Therefore Be It Resolved That City staff provide a Active Transportation lens, as set out in the Active Transportation Master Plan, to all new road construction and future road infrastructure capital projects; and

Wherever it is possible within the geographical space available within a road construction project, the City endeavour to accommodate Active Transportation initiatives to facilitate an integrated and connected system for the improved health of all Brampton residents.

Mayor Brown outlined the purpose of the motion.

Council consideration of the motion included:

Council’s previous consideration of this matter

suggestions about and benefits of the separation of bicycle lanes from traffic

details from staff about the current process for the review of City projects with an active transportation lens

The motion was considered as follows.

C142-2020 Moved by Mayor Brown

Seconded by Regional Councillor Dhillon

Whereas a 2019 Peel Public Health report titled “The Changing Landscape of Health in Peel” identified an exponential 182 per cent increase in the number of incident cases of diabetes in Peel Region between 1996 and 2015, due to an aging and growing population, and changes in diabetes risk factors including sedentary lifestyles; and

Whereas the increasing number of diabetes cases in Peel Region can be attributable to rising rate of obesity and changing demographics and lifestyle choices, with the projected costs associated with diabetes in the Region alone estimated to be $689 million by 2024, with over 100,000 new cases of diabetes in Peel Region; and

Whereas active lifestyle and healthy dietary choices provide opportunities to address the negative factors contributing to diabetes and cardiovascular disease facing Brampton residents; and

Whereas in September 2019, Brampton City Council endorsed an Active Transportation Master Plan to guide development of an integrated, attractive, and accessible system of sidewalks, cycling facilities and trails, to create a liveable city where all members of the community can safely and conveniently access places, goods and services and connect to transit using active modes of transportation; and

4.1-10

Minutes City Council

2020 04 29 Page 11 of 16

Whereas the Active Transportation Master Plan is organized around the themes of “Connecting the Network,” “Design for Safety and Comfort,” “Providing Year-round Mobility,” and “Developing a Walking and Cycling Culture” to achieve connectivity choices and promote healthy lifestyles;

Therefore Be It Resolved That City staff provide a Active Transportation lens, as set out in the Active Transportation Master Plan, to all new road construction and future road infrastructure capital projects; and

Wherever it is possible within the geographical space available within a road construction project, the City endeavour to accommodate Active Transportation initiatives to facilitate an integrated and connected system for the improved health of all Brampton residents.

Carried

17.3. Discussion Item at the Request of Regional Councillor Dhillon re Ethnic Media.

Regional Councillor Dhillon referenced a recent statement by Andrea Horwath, Leader, Ontario NDP, calling on the Provincial Government to provided support for ethnic and community media through the creation of a stabilization fund.

At the request of Council, staff provided a summary of the City’s media reach as a whole and how the ethnic media lens fits into this, which included information on methods (tv, radio and print ads, tele town halls, social, mainstream and ethnic media) and advertising costs.

The following motion, moved by Regional Councillor Dhillon and seconded by Mayor Brown was introduced.

That the City resources applied to Ethnic Media during the COVID-19 emergency response be doubled, with additional funds to be drawn from the Rate Stabilization Fund if and as required.

Mayor Brown and Councillor Dhillon highlighted challenges being faced by the City’s cultural and ethnic media during this emergency period, outlined the purpose of the motion, and responded to questions from Council.

Council consideration of this matter included varying opinions in support of and opposition to the motion.

A proposed amendment was introduced by City Councillor Williams to include a request for a staff report. The amendment was accepted as “friendly” by the mover.

4.1-11

Minutes City Council

2020 04 29 Page 12 of 16

Staff provided suggested amendments to the motion to clarify the funding components. These suggestions were accepted by the mover.

The motion, as amended, was as follows:

That the City resources applied to Ethnic Media during the COVID-19 emergency response be increased, with funds allocated to the COVID-19 account; and

That an information report from the Director, Strategic Communications be provided as expeditiously as possible with regard to the implementation (spending to-date and details of the expansion).

Regional Councillor Palleschi requested that the motion be split and the clauses be voted on separately. Following clarification from staff, Councillor Palleschi withdrew his request.

The motion, as amended, was considered as follows.

C143-2020 Moved by Mayor Brown Seconded by Councillor Dhillon

That the City resources applied to Ethnic Media during the COVID-19 emergency response be increased, with funds allocated to the COVID-19 account; and

That an information report from the Director, Strategic Communications be provided as expeditiously as possible with regard to the implementation (spending to-date and details of the expansion).

A recorded vote was taken, with the results as follows:

Yea Nay Absent Santos Bowman nil Vicente Whillans Palleschi Medeiros Williams Fortini Singh Dhillon Mayor

Carried 10 Yeas 1 Nays 0 Absent

4.1-12

Minutes City Council

2020 04 29 Page 13 of 16

17.4. Discussion Item at the Request of City Councillor Singh re: Noise By-law during Ramadan 2020.

The following motion, moved by City Councillor Singh and seconded by Mayor Brown was introduced:

That the matter (Noise By-law during Ramadan 2020) be referred to staff for consideration and a report thereon to the May 6, 2020 Committee of Council meeting.

An amendment was proposed by Mayor Brown and accepted by the mover to add the following additional clause to the motion:

That staff use discretion in the application of by-laws with respect to the matter in the interim.

Mayor Brown and City Councillor Singh outlined the purpose of the motion and responded to questions from Council.

Council consideration of the motion included:

actions taken on this matter by the City of Toronto and City of Mississauga

information from staff with respect to the City’s Noise By-law and Public Nuisance By-law

potential need for updates to the City’s by-laws as they relate to Places of Worship

The motion, as amended, was considered as follows.

C144-2020 Moved by City Councillor Singh Seconded by Mayor Brown

That the matter be referred to staff for consideration and a report thereon to the May 6, 2020 Committee of Council meeting; and

That staff use discretion in the application of by-laws with respect to the matter in the interim.

Carried

18. Procurement Matters – nil

19. Public Question Period

Members of the public were given the opportunity to submit questions via e-mail to the City Clerk’s Office regarding any decisions made at this meeting.

4.1-13

Minutes City Council

2020 04 29 Page 14 of 16

Peter Fay, City Clerk, confirmed that no questions were submitted regarding decisions made at this meeting.

20. By-laws

Note: By-laws 69-2020 and 70-2020 were not passed, as the associated staff report (Item 9.1) was deferred (see Resolution C141-2020 above).

The following motion was considered.

C145-2020 Moved by Regional Councillor Medeiros Seconded by City Councillor Bowman

That By-laws 71-2020 to 75-2020, before Council at its Regular Meeting of April 29, 2020, be given the required number of readings, taken as read, and signed by the Mayor and City Clerk, and the Corporate Seal affixed thereto.

69-2020 no by-law was assigned to this number

70-2020 no by-law was assigned to this number

71-2020 To amend the Traffic By-law 93-93, as amended – administrative update to schedules relating to through highways and fire routes (See Item 9.2)

72-2020 To amend Traffic By-law 93-93, as amended – schedules relating to through highways and stop signs – McMurchy Avenue North and Railroad Street – Ward 1 (See Item 9.3)

73-2020 To amend Traffic By-law 93-93, as amended – schedule relating to u-turns – Monte Vista Trail – Ward 2 (See Item 9.4)

74-2020 To establish certain lands as part of the public highway system (Creditview Road) – Ward 6

75-2020 To provide relief to fees and timelines under Mobile Licensing By-law 67-2014, as amended, during the COVID-19 emergency (See Item 7.1 and Item 3.1 – Council Resolution C125-2020 – April 22, 2020)

Carried

21. Closed Session

Council acknowledged Item 21.1 in Open Session, with the following motion considered for this purpose.

4.1-14

Minutes City Council

2020 04 29 Page 15 of 16

C146-2020 Moved by Regional Councillor Fortini Seconded by City Councillor Williams

That Item 21.1. – Minutes – Closed Session – City Council – April 22, 2020, be adopted.

Carried

The following motion was considered.

C147-2020 Moved by Regional Councillor Fortini Seconded by City Councillor Williams

That Council proceed into Closed Session to discuss matters pertaining to the following:

21.2. Litigation or potential litigation, including matters before administrative tribunals, affecting the municipality or local board – Local Planning Appeal Tribunal matter.

Carried

Note: In Open Session, the City Clerk reported on the status of Closed Session matters as follows:

21.1. these minutes were adopted in Open Session (see Resolution C147-2020 above)

21.2. this item was considered by Council in Closed Session and direction was given to staff, including direction to consider a motion in Open Session (see Resolution C148-2020 below)

The following motion, moved by Regional Councillor Palleschi and seconded by Regional Councillor Fortini, was introduced with respect to Item 21.2:

Whereas O.Reg. 171/20 made under the Planning Act, is a publicly available document, via e-laws.ca;

That the Commissioner of Planning and Development Services be directed to execute Minutes of Settlement in relation to an LPAT proceeding regarding Part of Lots 4 & 5, Concession 10 N.D., in the City of Brampton.

Councillor Palleschi outlined an amendment to his motion to include reference to “MZO” after “O.Reg. 171/20”.

The motion, as amended, was considered as follows.

C148-2020 Moved by Regional Councillor Palleschi

Seconded by Regional Councillor Fortini

4.1-15

Minutes City Council

2020 04 29 Page 16 of 16

Whereas O.Reg. 171/20 (MZO) made under the Planning Act, is a publicly available document, via e-laws.ca;

That the Commissioner of Planning and Development Services be directed to execute Minutes of Settlement in relation to an LPAT proceeding regarding Part of Lots 4 & 5, Concession 10 N.D., in the City of Brampton.

Carried

22. Confirming By-law

The following motion was considered.

C149-2020 Moved by City Councillor Bowman Seconded by Regional Councillor Medeiros

That the following by-law before Council at its Regular Meeting of April 29, 2020, be given the required number of readings, taken as read, and signed by the Mayor and the City Clerk, and the Corporate Seal affixed thereto:

76-2020 To confirm the proceedings of Council at its Regular Meeting held on April 29, 2020

Carried

23. Adjournment

The following motion was considered.

C150-2020 Moved by Regional Councillor Santos Seconded by Regional Councillor Vicente

That Council do now adjourn to meet again for a Regular Meeting of Council on Wednesday, May 13, 2020 at 1:00 p.m. or at the call of the Mayor.

Carried

_______________________________ P. Brown, Mayor

_______________________________ P. Fay, City Clerk

4.1-16

Report

City Council The Corporation of the City of Brampton

2020-05-13

Date: 2020-05-08

Subject: Government Relations Matters

Contact: Gurdeep Kaur, Director, Corporate Projects, Policy and Liaison, [email protected], 905-874-3694

Recommendations:

1. That the report titled: Government Relations Matters, to the City Council Meeting on May 13, 2020, be received.

Overview:

This report serves to update the Mayor and Members of Council on the following government relations matters:

o Update from the federal and provincial governments from May 4 to May 8, 2020.

o Key agenda items from the May 14, 2020 Regional Council Meeting.

The Regional Council Agenda is now available online at peelregion.ca/council. Any added agenda items and/or information, where indicated, will be provided when available.

o Update from the Association of Municipalities of Ontario and the Large Urban Mayor’s Caucus of Ontario.

1. Federal Government Update

i. COVID-19 Global Response

May 4, 2020: The Government of Canada joined other global leaders in launching the

Coronavirus Global Response, an online pledging event with the goal of raising $8B

(USD) to help researchers and innovators develop solutions to test, treat, and protect

people, and to prevent the further spread of COVID-19.

7.1-1

2

To date, the Government has announced investments of over $850M supporting this

initiative:

o mobilize Canadian researchers’ and life sciences companies’ coronavirus research and development of medical countermeasures;

o support accelerated vaccine development, including through the Coalition for Epidemic Preparedness Innovations and other partners;

o find a safe and effective treatment for COVID-19 through the World Health Organization (WHO) Solidarity Trial;

o coordinate a COVID-19 viral and host genome sequencing effort across Canada;

o help provide COVID-19 diagnostic support to more than 20 partner countries; and

o Create strategies to tackle misinformation, stigma, and fear.

ii. Supporting Canadian Farmers, Food Businesses and Food Supply

May 5, 2020: The federal government announced additional measures to support

farmers and businesses:

$77.5M in the Emergency Processing Fund to help food producers access more

personal protective equipment (PPE), adapt to health protocols, automate or

modernize their facilities, processes, and operations, and respond to emerging

pressures from COVID-19.

The National AgriRecovery initiative will provide up to $125M in funding to help

producers faced with additional costs incurred by COVID-19.

Increase the Canadian Dairy Commission’s borrowing limit by $200M to support

costs associated with the temporary storage of cheese and butter to avoid food

waste.

Working with provinces and territories to increase interim payments from 50 per

cent to 75 per cent through AgriStability, a federal, provincial and territorial

program that supports producers who face significant revenue declines.

iii. Providing Cost-Share Wage Top-Ups for Essential Workers with Provinces and

Territories

May 7, 2020: The federal government announced it will provide up to $3B in support to

increase the wages of low-income essential workers. This initiative will be cost shared

with provinces and territories.

Each province or territory will determine which workers would be eligible for

support, and how much support they will receive.

The Province of Ontario’s COVID-19: Temporary pandemic pay webpage

provides information on the temporary financial support for eligible frontline and

support workers fighting COVID-19

iv. Canada Emergency Wage Subsidy (CEWS)

May 8, 2020: the Prime Minister announced that the CEWS will be extended beyond

June. Further details are to come next week.

7.1-2

3

v. Industry Strategy Council

May 8, 2020: The Minister of Innovation, Science and Industry, announced the new

Industry Strategy Council.

This Council will serve as an advisory board to assess the scope and depth of

COVID-19’s impact on industries and inform government’s understanding of specific

sectoral pressures.

This approach is designed to bring the private sector to the table to directly share its

perspective on the scope of the challenges being faced across industries.

vi. Emergency Support Fund for Cultural, Heritage and Sport Organizations

May 8, 2020: The Minister of Canadian Heritage, shared further details regarding the

Government of Canada’s April 17th announcement of $500M in temporary relief measures

(see backgrounder) to support the culture, heritage and sport sectors as they manage the

challenges and impacts of the COVID-19 pandemic.

Partner organizations, the Canada Council for the Arts, the Canada Media Fund,

FACTOR, Musicaction, Telefilm Canada, will be contacted, to distribute the funds as

quickly as possible using existing channels.

The distribution of funding will include:

o Up to $326.8 million to be administrated by Canadian Heritage and divided

among select departmental programs and Portfolio agencies as well as key

delivery organizations. Specifically:

$198.3 million will be provided to the beneficiaries of arts and culture

funding via existing programs as well as other organizations with

demonstrated needs;

$72 million will be provided to the sport sector;

$53 million will be provided to the heritage sector via the emergency

component of the Museums Assistance Program; and

$55 million to be distributed by the Canada Council for the Arts;

$3.5 million will be provided for COVID-related projects under the

Digital Citizen Initiative.

$115.8 to support the Canadian audiovisual sector, to be distributed by

the Canada Media Fund ($88.8 million) and Telefilm Canada ($27

million).

Further information can be found on Canadian Heritage’s website.

vii. Providing Tariff Relief to Importers of Certain Medical Goods

May 6, 2020: The federal government is waving tariffs on certain medical goods,

including PPE such as masks and gloves.

Reducing the costs of imported PPE for Canadian businesses, which face tariffs

up to 18 per cent, help protect workers, and ensure supply chains can keep

functioning well.

7.1-3

4

viii. Labour Market Update

May 8, 2020: Following a drop in over one million jobs in March, employment fell by

nearly two million in April, bringing the total employment decline since the beginning of

the COVID-19 economic shutdown to over three million.

The April unemployment rate would be 17.8%, when adjusted to reflect those who

were not counted as unemployed for reasons specific to the COVID-19 economic

shutdown.

2. Provincial Government Update

i. Guidelines for Re-opening the Economy

May 6, 2020: the Province of Ontario announced it will begin easing restrictions on retail stores and essential construction:

As of Friday May 8th, all garden centres and nurseries will be allowed to re-open for in-store payment and purchases, under same guidelines as grocery stores and pharmacies

As of Saturday May 9th, hardware and safety supplies will be allowed to re-open, and people can shop in-store as long as these businesses follow strict health and safety measures

As of Monday May 11th, places of business which have not been deemed essential but have public entrances that open onto a street or exterior walkway can begin offering curbside pickup and delivery provided that no entrance inside the business by members of the public are permitted except under exceptional circumstances.

ii. Extension of Electricity Rate Relief and Emergency Orders

May 6, 2020: The Province extended the electricity rate relief for families, farms and small businesses through to May 31st, 2020, and extended Emergency Orders through to May 19th , 2020. These include:

Closure of establishments

Prohibition public events and gatherings of more than 5 people

Closure of outdoor recreation amenities

Work deployment measures for municipalities

*Ontario’s Declaration of Emergency is active until May 12th, 2020; Queen’s Park will be reconvening and could extend it at that time.

iii. Framework for Restarting Scheduled Surgeries and Elective Procedures

May 7, 2020: the Province released A Measured Approach to Planning for Surgeries and Procedures During the COVID-19 Pandemic, containing criteria that must be met before hospitals can resume scheduled surgeries and elective procedures.

7.1-4

5

Timelines will vary from hospital to hospital and be conditional on approval by regional oversight tables involved with planning and coordinating Ontario's response to COVID-19.

The approach considers ethical principles, the roles of Ontario health, the Regions, and hospitals.

It provides a framework for assessing the feasibility of, and planning for, service resumption.

iv. Mental Health Supports

May 5, 2020: As part of Mental Health Week, the Province highlighted the expansion of virtual mental health services from those experiencing anxiety and depression, including frontline workers.

Since the beginning of the pandemic, the Province has invested $12M in expanding virtual and online mental health support services to patients and front line workers including,

o Internet-based Cognitive Behavioral Therapy (iCBT): Clients can self-refer to programs through the various service providers listed and be guided through their client journey to find the appropriate supports they need. Online iCBT is supported by therapists and available in English and French.

o Supports for frontline health care workers: Online iCBT is available to frontline health care workers experiencing anxiety, burnout or post-traumatic stress disorder. Those requiring intensive levels of care could be referred to virtual face-to-face care, as well as weekly online peer discussion groups and access to confidential support from a clinician.

o Virtual mental health support services: These include BounceBack telephone coaching and workbooks, and Kids Help Phone for children and youth.

v. Additional Information

Flood Preparedness

As part of Ontario's flood preparedness planning, the Province has been working with the federal government, municipalities and First Nations partners to develop evacuation plans.

Ontario is taking the lead on identifying suitable locations to host evacuees and to minimize the reliance on municipal resources for various supports, including health care and social services.

7.1-5

6

3. Region of Peel Council Meeting – May 14, 2020

Please note the Regional Agenda was not publically posted at the time of preparing this

report.

i. Item 8.3: Update and Management of the Financial Impacts of COVID-19 Public safety measures implemented by the federal, provincial, regional and municipal governments have significant impact on the services and finances of the Region of Peel The impacts apply to three major areas:

Economic – Start of a Recession

2020 Fiscal Year – $36.0 million forecasted deficit for Region Controlled services o Increased Costs o Costs Avoided o Decreased Revenue o External Funding

Cash Flow – estimated loss of $400 million in Development Charges over next 2 years.

Report points out the need for additional funding from upper levels of government to fund the incremental costs related to COVID-19 and to stimulate the economy. Appendices I to IV contain detailed listings of increased costs, decreased revenues, costs avoided and impact on employment programs.

ii. Item 8.5: Approach to the Development of the 2021 Budget

On April 9 Council deferred report on development of the 2021 Budget with direction that the proposed timelines be revised to reflect the announcement of the Provincial budget

o Ontario Budget is currently scheduled for November 15, 2020.

A net Regional tax levy increase forecasted for 2021 was of 4.3% with recognition that Provincial grants and subsidies provide 25% of Regional revenues.

The report recommends that due to the economic uncertainty caused by the pandemic, there be no budget target at this time.

The 2021 budget will be deliberated with a proposed date of January 28, 2021 to enable staff to assess the Provincial budget

Staff comments: TBD

iii. Item 8.6: The 2020 Development Charges By-law Update and Timeline Extension

The Coronavirus (COVID-19) Support and Protection Act, 2020 (the “Amending Act”) came into force on April 14, 2020 and provides that Peel’s current Development

7.1-6

7

Charges By-law continues to be in effect during the current provincial emergency declaration period and for six months thereafter

The extension is a welcome measure allowing staff to better prepare the replacement of the 2015 By-law to accommodate current economic realities an legislative changes from Bill 108

Staff comments: There are no implications to the City of Brampton.

iv. Item 8.8: Contract Extensions for Adult and Youth Shelters

The Governing Council of the Salvation Army is under contract with the Region to manage and operate four Peel owned emergency shelters for adults, families and youth

New Request for Proposal (RFP) for the adult and youth shelters that were planned for release in April and June 2020 have been put on hold due to COVID-19

Report recommends an extension up to June 30, 2021 to allow for the proper transition between providers, with RFPs for both adult shelters and the youth shelters being issued as soon as the pandemic subsides and meaningfully engage in the procurement process is possible

v. Item 9.1: Letter form the Ontario Chief Medical Officer

Acknowledged the extraordinary and ongoing effort by public health units to monitor, detect and contain the pandemic

Reiterated the expectation the public health units continue to take all necessary measures to respond to COVID-19

Reassured that the province is aware of additional costs public health units are incurring du to the pandemic and requested that these costs be traced

Province has allocated $100 million for reimbursement of COVID-19 related costs

vi. Item 15.1 2019 Treasury Report

For the year ending December 31, 2019, the General Fund generated gross earnings of $78.2 million, representing a yield of 3.2%

As at December 31, 2019, net Region own source debt totalled approximately $1,288 million

The revenue generated through investment activities in 2019 was allocated to reserves (91%), operations (4%) and bank accounts related to PHC operations (5%).

Appendix I provides an overview of the Annual Treasury Report vii. Item 15.2: 2020 Tax Capping Policy – Selection of Options

Regional Council is required by legislation to pass a by-law each year to apply one or more of the optional tools in calculating the amount of property taxes for properties in the commercial, industrial and multi-residential (capped) property classes

A preliminary analysis shows that using the recommended optional capping tools/enhancements will result in 4 properties being capped, while 11 properties in the capped property class will have their tax decreases reduced or clawed back

7.1-7

8

Regional and local municipal Finance staff endorse the continued application of all applicable optional tools/enhancements to promote a fairer property taxation system by moving toward full Current Value Assessment (CVA) tax levels.

Staff comments: Preliminary analysis indicates that by adopting all of the optional tools, there will be only one property left in the capping program in Brampton. And only 15 total across the Region. This is significant progress and promotes fair taxation.

4. Municipal Sector Associations Update

Association of Municipalities of Ontario

2020 AMO Annual Conference (August 17th – 19th)

AMO released further information regarding its virtual conference, with full program details

expected to be made available in advance of the July 6th:

Keynote speakers, panels and breakout sessions on key issues

Engagement with the Premier and all-party leaders

Ministers’ speeches and virtual delegation meetings with Ministers

Virtual networking opportunities and tradeshow.

AMO has instituted a flexible transfer or refund policy that gives registrants the option to:

Transfer current registration automatically to the AMO 2020 Virtual Conference

Receive a full refund of registration fees paid without any penalties until 4:00 pm on July 6th, 2020

For accommodations made through the AMO hotel block, the City will receive a notice that

reservations has been automatically canceled and refunded, if a deposit was taken. It is

expected that all cancellations and refunds will be issued by June 30th, 2020. Staff will follow up

with Members of Council to confirm when refunds are completed.

Large Urban Mayor’s Caucus of Ontario (LUMCO) On May 8th, 2020 LUMCO Mayors had conversations with Federal Minister Ahmed Hussen, Families, Children and Social Development and Provincial Ministers Steve Clark, Municipal Affairs and Housing, Rod Phillips, Finance and Caroline Mulroney, Transportation. The discussions focused on a number of key areas related to addressing COVID-19 impact on municipalities, including:

As the Province continues to announce measures to slowly open up the economy,

municipalities should be provided with clear guidelines and timelines to properly plan for

their individual reopening

The urgent need for federal and provincial funding to offset the financial impact COVID-

19 is having on municipal budgets. LUMCO continues to be in support of FCMs

municipal operating emergency funding.

7.1-8

9

The intake for the federal Community Emergency Support Fund ($350M through United Way, Community Foundations of Canada, Canada Red Cross) will open shortly. Local agencies should be prepared to access funding through one of

Prepared by: _____________________________________ Gurdeep Kaur, Director, Corporate Projects, Policy & Liaison Office of the CAO

Submitted by: _____________________________________ David Barrick, Chief Administrative Officer

7.1-9

City CouncilMay 13, 2020

Government Relations MattersUpdate on COVID-19 (May 2020)

7.1 Presentation - 1

2

Federal Government Update

COVID-19 Global Response (May 4th)

• The Government of Canada joined other global leaders in launching the Coronavirus Global Response, an online

pledging event with the goal of raising $8B (USD) to help researchers and innovators develop solutions to test,

treat, and protect people, and to prevent the further spread of COVID-19.

Supporting Canadian Farmers, Food Businesses and Food Supply (May 5th)

• The federal government announced additional measures to support farmers and businesses:

o $77.5M in the Emergency Processing Fund

o The National AgriRecovery initiative will provide up to $125M in funding to help producers faced with

additional costs incurred by COVID-19.

o Increase the Canadian Dairy Commission’s borrowing limit by $200M

o Working with provinces and territories to increase interim payments from 50 per cent to 75 per cent through

AgriStability

Providing Tariff Relief to Importers of Certain Medical Goods (May 6th)

• The federal government is waving tariffs on certain medical goods, including PPE such as masks and gloves.

Labour Market Update (May 8th)

• Labour market data shows that employment fell by nearly two million in April, bringing the total employment decline

since the beginning of the COVID-19 economic shutdown to over three million.

• The April unemployment rate would be 17.8% when adjusted to reflect those who were not counted as unemployed

for reasons specific to the COVID-19 economic shutdown.

7.1 Presentation - 2

3

Federal Government Update

Canada Emergency Wage Subsidy (CEWS) (May 8th)

• CEWS will be extended beyond June. Further details are expected to be released soon.

Industry Strategy Council (May 8th)

• New Industry Strategy Council will serve as an advisory board to assess the scope and depth of COVID-19’s impact on

industries and inform government’s understanding of specific sectoral pressures.

Emergency Support Fund for Cultural, Heritage and Sport Organizations (May 8th)

• Originally announced on April 17th, further details were provided on the $500M in temporary relief measures to support the

culture, heritage and sport sectors as they manage the challenges and impacts of the COVID-19 pandemic.

• Administered by Canadian Heritage the funds will be divided among select departmental programs and key delivery

partners.

7.1 Presentation - 3

Provincial Government Update

Mental Health Supports (May 5th)• Online support services to patients and front line workers: Internet-based Cognitive Behavioural Therapy (iCBT),

Supports for frontline health care workers including virtual care, peer discussion groups and Virtual mental health

support services including BounceBack telephone coaching and workbooks, and Kids Help Phone for children and youth.

Re-opening the economy (May 6th)

• Began easing restrictions on retail stores and essential construction:

o As of Friday May 8th, all garden centres and nurseries were allowed to re-open for in-store payment and purchases,

under same guidelines as grocery stores and pharmacies.

o As of Saturday May 9th, hardware and safety supplies can re-open, and people can shop in-store as long as these

businesses follow strict health and safety measures.

o As of Monday May 11th, places of business which have not been deemed essential but have public entrances that

open onto a street or exterior walkway can begin offering curbside pickup and delivery provided that no entrance

inside the business by members of the public are permitted except under exceptional circumstances.

Extension of Electricity Rate Relief and Emergency Orders (May 6th)

• Extended emergency electricity rate relief to families, farms and small businesses until May 31st.

• Extended Emergency Orders through to May 19th (e.g. closure of establishments, work deployment measures for

municipalities etc).

Framework for Restarting Scheduled Surgeries and Elective Procedures (May 7th)

• Released A Measured Approach to Planning for Surgeries and Procedures During the COVID-19 Pandemic, contains clear

criteria that must be met before hospitals can resume scheduled surgeries.

* The Declaration of Emergency could be extended when the Legislature reconvenes on Tuesday May 12th.

7.1 Presentation - 4

5

8.3: Update and Management of the Financial Impacts of COVID-19

• The impacts from public safety measures implemented by all levels of government apply to three major areas:

o Economic – Start of a Recession

o 2020 Fiscal Year – $36.0 million forecasted deficit for Region controlled services

Increased costs, costs avoided, decreased revenue, and external funding

o Cash Flow – estimated loss of $400 million in Development Charges over next 2 years.

• Funding from upper levels of government is needed to fund the incremental costs related to COVID-19 and to stimulate the

economy.

8.5: Approach to the Development of the 2021 Budget

• On April 9th, Regional Council deferred report on development of the 2021 Budget directing that the proposed timelines be

revised to reflect the announcement of the Provincial budget currently scheduled for November 15 th, 2020.

• A net Regional tax levy increase forecasted for 2021 was of 4.3% with recognition that Provincial grants and subsidies

provide 25% of Regional revenues.

• Due to the economic uncertainty caused by the pandemic, the report does not recommend a budget target at this time.

• The proposed date for 2021 budget deliberations is January 28th, 2021 to enable staff to assess the Provincial budget

Staff comments to follow

Region of Peel May 14, 2020 Council Meeting 7.1 Presentation - 5

6

8.6: The 2020 Development Charges By-law Update and Timeline Extension

• The Coronavirus Support and Protection Act, 2020 came into force on April 14th, 2020 and provides that Peel’s current

Development Charges By-law stays in effect during the provincial emergency declaration period and for six months

thereafter.

• The extension allows staff to prepare the replacement by-law to accommodate current economic realities an legislative

changes from Bill 108.

Staff comments: There are no implications to the City of Brampton.

8.8: Contract Extensions for Adult and Youth Shelters

• The Governing Council of the Salvation Army is under contract with the Region to manage and operate four Peel owned

emergency shelters for adults, families and youth.

• New Request for Proposal (RFP) for the adult and youth shelters that were planned for release in April and June 2020 have

been put on hold due to COVID-19.

• An extension up to June 30th, 2021 will allow for the proper transition between providers, with RFPs for both adult shelters

and the youth shelters being issued once the pandemic subsides.

Region of Peel May 14, 2020 Council Meeting 7.1 Presentation - 6

7

9.1: Letter form the Ontario Chief Medical Officer

• Reiterated the expectation that the public health units continue to take all necessary measures to respond to COVID-19.

• Reassured that the province is aware of additional costs public health units are incurring du to the pandemic and requested that these

costs be traced.

• The Province allocated $100 million for reimbursement of COVID-19 related costs

15.1: 2019 Treasury Report

• For year ending Dec. 31/19, the General Fund generated gross earnings of $78.2 million, representing a yield of 3.2%

• As of Dec. 31/19, net Region own source debt totalled approximately $1,288 million

• The revenue generated through investment activities in 2019 was allocated to reserves (91%), operations (4%) and bank accounts

related to PHC operations (5%).

• Appendix I provides an overview of the Annual Treasury Report.

15.2: 2020 Tax Capping Policy – Selection of Options

• Regional Council is required by legislation to pass a by-law each year to apply one or more of the optional tools in calculating the

amount of property taxes for properties in the commercial, industrial and multi-residential (capped) property classes

• Regional and local municipal Finance staff endorse the continued application of all applicable optional tools/enhancements to

promote a fairer property taxation system by moving toward full Current Value Assessment (CVA) tax levels.

Staff comments: Preliminary analysis indicates that by adopting all of the optional tools, there will be only one property left in the capping

program in Brampton. And only 15 total across the Region. This is significant progress and promotes fair taxation.

Region of Peel May 14, 2020 Council Meeting 7.1 Presentation - 7

Association of Municipalities of Ontario Update

2020 AMO Annual Conference (AMO 2020)– Update

• AMO has confirmed their 2020 Annual Conference will be virtual and has released a preliminary program that includes virtual delegation meetings. Full program details are expected to be available by July 6th.

• A flexible transfer or refund policy has been made available that gives registrants the option to:o Transfer current registration automatically to the AMO 2020 Virtual Conference o Receive a full refund of registration fees paid without any penalties until 4:00 pm on July 6, 2020

• It is expected that all cancellations and refunds for accommodations made through the AMO hotel block will be issued by June 30th, 2020.

Large Urban Mayor’s Caucus of Ontario (LUMCO) – Update

• On May 8th, 2020, LUMCO Mayors had conversations with Federal Minister Ahmed Hussen, Families, Children and Social Development and Provincial Ministers Steve Clark, Municipal Affairs and Housing, Rod Phillips, Finance, and Caroline Mulroney, Transportation.

• Discussion focused on ensuring municipalities are engaged in conversations with the Province as it continues to announce measures to slowly open up the economy; the need for federal and provincial funding to offset impact COVID-19 is having on local communities.

• Funding through the Community Emergency Support Fund is expected to begin flowing to community agencies shortly.

7.1 Presentation - 8

Report

City Council The Corporation of the City of Brampton

2020-05-13

Date: 2020-04-29

Subject: Technology Options for Virtual Council and Committee

Meetings

Contact: P. Fay, City Clerk, Legislative Services, 905-874-2172

Recommendations:

1. That the report titled: Technology Options for Virtual Council and Committee

Meeting (I 48/2020), to the City Council Meeting of May 13, 2020, be received.

Overview:

At its second virtual Council meeting, held on April 8, 2020, Council

inquired about virtual meeting technology options available for possible use. Skype for Business, in combination with existing technology in the

Council Chambers, has been used to-date for hosting virtual meetings.

This report summarizes available options and advises of the City’s

acquisition of the WebEx application for use with future virtual meetings as of mid-May 2020.

Background:

City Council, at its April 8, 2020 meeting, inquired about technology options for hosting

virtual meetings of City Council and committees during the COVID-19 emergency. This report responds to Council’s request for information about virtual meeting

technology.

10.1-1

Current Situation:

Enabling Context for Virtual Meetings:

With the onset of the COVID-19 emergency in early March 2020, followed by a state of

emergency subsequently declared by the Province of Ontario and Mayor Brown, provincial legislation enabled municipal councils to convene meetings virtually with all members participating electronically during the period of the emergency affecting the

municipality. City Council passed implementing by-laws to amend Procedure By-law 160-2004, on March 25 and April 22, 2020, to enable virtual meetings by City Council

and its committees. During the COVID-19 emergency, to-date five (5) virtual Council meetings have been

held and as of May 2020, virtual meetings for some standing committees have also been scheduled, including the Audit Committee and Committee of Council. The

Planning and Development Committee is anticipated to start virtual meetings as of June 2020.

The enabling legislative provisions allowing virtual meetings, with participation by all Members of council (in both open and closed session), remains in effect only for the

duration of the emergency period declared by the Province or Mayor. After the emergency is over, the former provisions of the Municipal Act, 2001 will return which allow for electronic participation in meetings by Members of Council only under the

following conditions: 1. A quorum of the council must be present in-person.

2. Members are not permitted electronically during closed session of a meeting. If Council wishes to continue permitting electronic participation by Members under the

pre-COVID emergency provisions of the Municipal Act, 2001, then additional amendments to the Procedure By-law are necessary in the future.

Existing Virtual Meeting Technology:

At the outset of the COVID-19 emergency, staff from the City Clerk’s Office and Digital Innovation and Information Technology (DI&IT) assessed technology options available

for supporting virtual Council meetings, as required. The City already had in place, as part of its standard office productivity application suite, the Microsoft Skype for Business (Skype) application. Based on meeting environment testing undertaken by staff it was

determined that the Skype application could support a virtual Council meeting, and has been used since the first virtual meeting held on March 25. Staff also acquired and

installed a Unified Communications and Collaboration (UCC) computer to enable connectivity between the virtual meeting platform (Skype) and the City technology for streaming the meeting for public viewing. The virtual meeting remains produced through

the Council Chambers to enable livestreaming for public access.

10.1-2

The technology has worked reasonably well during virtual meetings, with few issues. Of note, was an audio hardware failure during the April 8 virtual Council meeting which necessitated diagnosis and repair while Council recessed for closed session. During the

April 29 virtual Council meeting, staff determined the integrated UCC computer went down momentarily on two separate occasions during the meeting. Otherwise, the Skype

for Business platform is relatively stable and serves the collaboration needs for the Corporation, particularly with the proliferation of virtual staff meetings.

The transition from in-person to virtual meetings has been a learning experience for many municipal councils and levels of government during the COVID-19 emergency,

Brampton included. Participant and support staff knowledge and experience with virtual meetings and comfort level with the technology is varied but is improving with each meeting.

Virtual Meeting Technology:

Since COVID-19, various virtual meeting platform technologies have become commonplace in these unique times. Virtual meeting platforms function basically in the

same manner with relatively similar features including allowance for multiple participants, instant messaging, participant chat rooms, video capabilities, security

features, and presentation functionality, among other attributes. At the outset of the COVID-19 emergency, staff from the City Clerk’s Office and Digital

Innovation and Information Technology (DI&IT) assessed technology options available for supporting virtual Council meetings, as required. The City already had in place, as

part of its standard office productivity application suite, the Microsoft Skype for Business (Skype) application.

Over the course of the COVID-19 emergency, some municipalities, including those within the Region of Peel have transitioned to WebEx for virtual council and board

meetings. The Region of Peel Council virtual meetings are now conducted using WebEx.

In consideration of the use, experience and apparent satisfaction of WebEx by the other Region of Peel municipalities, the City has acquired the WebEx virtual meeting platform

for City Council and committee meetings during the continuing emergency period. The technology may also be used for meetings of the Mayor’s various task forces coordinating community response efforts during the COVID-19 emergency.

The WebEx solution will be tested and implemented the week of May 4 with a plan to

start using WebEx for the scheduled virtual Council and committee meetings in mid-May. The solution may be used for the re-introduction of virtual delegations to future meetings, including statutory public meetings scheduled for the Planning and

Development Committee starting in June 2020.

10.1-3

For closed session virtual meetings, the City has been using a secure audioconferencing technology, solution that has met expectations in its use to-date.

Corporate Implications:

Financial Implications:

This technology will be acquired with City Clerk’s Office budgets and allocated to the

COVID-19 accounts for tracking during this emergency situation. Other Implications: nil

Term of Council Priorities:

This report supports the Term of Council Priority that Brampton is a Well-Run City by facilitating technology solutions to support Council decision-making and public access to City governance for accountability and transparency. Conclusion:

At the April 8 Council meeting, Council inquired about technology options to support virtual Council meetings. While the current virtual meeting platform in use, Skype for

Business is functional, the City has acquired the WebEx application for future Council and committee virtual meetings during the ongoing COVID-19 emergency period, starting in mid-May 2020.

Authored by: Reviewed and Approved by:

Peter Fay, City Clerk, Legislative Services

Joseph Pittari, Commissioner, Legislative Services

Submitted by:

David Barrick, Chief Administrative Officer

Report authored by: Peter Fay, City Clerk, Legislative Services, [email protected]

10.1-4

Report

City Council The Corporation of the City of Brampton

2020-05-13

Date: 2020-01-20

Subject: Housekeeping Amendments to Records Retention By-Law 272-

2014

Contact: Janice Adshead, Deputy Clerk, Records and Information Management,

Office of the CAO, [email protected], 905-874-2109 Recommendations:

1. That the report titled: Housekeeping Amendments to Records Retention By-

Law 272-2014 (R 26/2020 and GA.a), to the City Council meeting of May 13,

2020, be received; and,

2. That Records Retention By-Law 272-2014, as amended, be further amended

generally in accordance with the changes set out in Appendix A to this report.

Overview:

The City’s Records Retention By-Law 272-2014, was developed to reflect current

legal and regulatory requirements, best practices, and business requirements, to

manage the City’s records and information, and is a requirement of the Municipal

Act, 2001.

Some administrative changes are required to allow staff to properly classify

records, namely:

o Description of records

o Trigger events (i.e. when a records reaches an inactive state)

o Retention timeframes (increasing or decreasing timeframes resulting from

business requirements and combining Active and Inactive Retention into a

single column)

o Citations (legal requirements identifying retention requirements)

10.2-1

Background:

The Records and Information Management Program has recently completed a number

of initiatives related to managing physical and electronic records in a routine, well-

organized and standardized manner to support effective and efficient operations,

including: implementing an electronic document and records management system;

reviewing and publishing the Personal Information Banks; training employees on the

disposition process; etc. The Retention By-Law identifies the business rules that govern

how information is managed.

The current Retention By-Law that was enacted in 2014 forms the foundation of the

program, and:

Provides a streamlined yet comprehensive schedule which reflects the current

legislative obligations, as well as the business policies of the City of Brampton;

Allows for an automated retention and disposition process for electronic corporate

records and information;

Identifies and allows for better protection of personal information;

Facilitates eDiscovery and responses under the Municipal Freedom of Information

and Protection of Privacy Act; and,

Identifies and allows for information of historical value to be captured and

transferred to Peel Archives.

Current Situation:

In preparation for the management and disposition of physical and electronic

information, modifications have been identified by various departments. The

modifications are a requirement of business and/or operational requirements, as

opposed to legislative or regulatory requirements. The combining of the Active

Retention and Inactive Retention columns is the direct result of a shift in the Information

Management Program which now sees the majority of managed records maintained in

an electronic format.

Corporate Implications:

Financial Implications: nil

Other Implications: nil

Term of Council Priorities:

This report achieves the Term of Council Priority of a Well-Run Government by

maintaining a transparent, accountable and accessible records and information management system to support municipal government operations and administration.

10.2-2

Conclusion:

The Records and Information Management Program has recently implemented an

Electronic Document and Records Management System known as BRIMS. This tool will

ensure information is easily accessible; legal risks will be lowered; regulatory

compliance will increase; and end-user efficiency will rise. These proposed

amendments are part of a continuous improvement plan to ensure the Records

Retention By-law meets the business needs of the City.

Authored by:

Reviewed and Approved by:

Janice Adshead Deputy City Clerk, Records & Information Management

Peter Fay City Clerk

Submitted by:

David Barrick

Chief Administrative Officer

Attachments:

Appendix A: Records Retention By-Law 272-2014

10.2-3

Appendix A 10.2-4

10.2-5

10.2-6

10.2-7

10.2-8

10.2-9

10.2-10

10.2-11

10.2-12

10.2-13

10.2-14

10.2-15

10.2-16

10.2-17

10.2-18

10.2-19

10.2-20

10.2-21

10.2-22

10.2-23

10.2-24

10.2-25

10.2-26

10.2-27

10.2-28

10.2-29

10.2-30

10.2-31

10.2-32

10.2-33

10.2-34

10.2-35

10.2-36

10.2-37

10.2-38

10.2-39

10.2-40

10.2-41

10.2-42

10.2-43

10.2-44

10.2-45

10.2-46

10.2-47

10.2-48

10.2-49

10.2-50

10.2-51

10.2-52

10.2-53

10.2-54

10.2-55

10.2-56

10.2-57

10.2-58

10.2-59

10.2-60

10.2-61

10.2-62

10.2-63

10.2-64

10.2-65

10.2-66

10.2-67

10.2-68

10.2-69

10.2-70

10.2-71

10.2-72

10.2-73

10.2-74

10.2-75

10.2-76

10.2-77

10.2-78

10.2-79

10.2-80

10.2-81

10.2-82

10.2-83

10.2-84

10.2-85

10.2-86

10.2-87

10.2-88

10.2-89

10.2-90

10.2-91

10.2-92

10.2-93

10.2-94

10.2-95

10.2-96

10.2-97

10.2-98

10.2-99

10.2-100

10.2-101

10.2-102

10.2-103

10.2-104

10.2-105

10.2-106

10.2-107

10.2-108

10.2-109

10.2-110

10.2-111

10.2-112

10.2-113

10.2-114

10.2-115

10.2-116

10.2-117

10.2-118

10.2-119

10.2-120

10.2-121

10.2-122

Report

City Council The Corporation of the City of Brampton

2020-05-13

Date: April 15, 2020

Subject: 2020 Final Tax Levy and By-law

Contact: Martin Finnegan, Sr. Manager, Revenue 905-874-2201

[email protected]

Recommendations:

1. THAT the report titled: 2020 Final Tax Levy and By-law (R71/2020) to the

Council Meeting of May 13, 2020 be received; and

2. THAT a By-law be passed for the levy and collection of 2020 Final Realty Taxes.

Overview:

An annual By-law is required for the Final Levy and Collection of Realty Taxes.

This report details the background for 2020 tax year.

Background:

To provide for the levy and collection of annual realty taxes, a By-law is required each

year. The rates set out in the attached schedules for the City and Region are based on 2020 budget requirements while the Education rates are set by the Province through an

Ontario Regulation. Taxes are based on the current value assessments (CVA) as provided by the Municipal Property Assessment Corporation (MPAC). In 2016, MPAC undertook a re-assessment updating CVA to reflect the market as of a January 1, 2016

valuation date. Assessment increases from the previous base year of 2012 are to be phased in equally over the four taxation years 2017 to 2020. Any decreases in

assessment are reflected immediately and will apply for all four years.

10.3-1

Current Situation:

The attached Schedule “A” itemizes the total amount to be levied in each tax class for

City, Region and Education purposes based on the tax rates as listed.

The tax rates indicated in the schedule will generate the total 2020 levy of $1,191,651,772 from all the various property classes, allocated as follows:

City $482,649,416 40.5%

Region $410,096,493 34.4%

Education $298,905,863 25.1%

a) 2020 Property Taxes

The overall levy for 2020 will be distributed as follows:

1. Residential (includes pipeline, farm, managed forest)

City $373,976,510

Region $317,759,378

Education $134,518,767

2. Commercial / Industrial / Multi-Residential (“capped” property classes)

Property Class City Region Education

Commercial $75,146,668 $63,850,564 $127,207,613

Industrial $20,325,203 $17,269,912 $34,441,596

Multi-Residential $13,201,035 $11,216,639 $2,737,887

TOTAL $108,672,906 $92,337,115 $164,387,096

10.3-2

b) Downtown Brampton Business Improvement Area

The Tax Levy By-law has been prepared to include a special charge for the Downtown Brampton Business Improvement Area, pursuant to Section 208(2) of the Municipal Act,

2001, to be levied against the business classes of property in the improvement area defined in By-law 276-88. The total 2020 requirement is $354,104 which is less than the 2019 levy of $392,943. This levy shortfall is being financed through a City grant in the

BIA’s 2020 budget. The City has completed several property purchases in the downtown which has reduced the base business assessment for the BIA. As a result,

all businesses within the BIA boundary would be required to pay more to realize the previous year levy total. This temporary assistance provided by the City will be re-visited annually until re-development occurs in the downtown and the previous

assessment base is returned. The 2020 tax rate will be 0.218108%.

c) New Construction Tax Rates

Ontario Regulation 315/08 was filed on September 11, 2008 creating the “New Construction” classes to facilitate announced Business Education Tax (BET) rate

reductions. For 2020 taxation, the province has reduced the target maximum rate to 0.98% from the 2019 target level of 1.03%. Where a municipality’s BET rate is already below 0.98%, the lower education tax rate would continue for existing and newly

constructed properties.

The BET rate in Brampton for the commercial property class in the 2020 taxation year is

0.944727%, which is below the maximum BET rate. Newly constructed commercial properties would continue to be taxed at a BET rate of 0.944727%. However, in the industrial property class, the City’s 2020 BET rate (1.066032%) is above the maximum

rate. Therefore, newly constructed industrial properties deemed eligible will benefit from the lower BET rate of 0.98%.

In order to qualify for the New Construction BET rate, the following criteria must be met:

Application for the first building permit must be received by the municipality after March 22, 2007

Construction must be for either a commercial or industrial property

For additions or renovations to existing properties, the new construction must

increase the current value assessment (CVA) of the property by a minimum of 50%

The New Construction BET rate takes effect once construction is completed, eligibility requirements are met and the new construction commences to be used. Where the

municipality’s BET rate for the class is below 0.98%, the lower BET rate is to be used for New Construction properties in that class.

10.3-3

The new classes mirror the existing definitions for the commercial and industrial property classes but only apply to new construction. The New Construction property classes are:

New Construction Commercial

New Construction Shopping Centre New Construction Office Building

New Construction Industrial New Construction Large Industrial

The attached Schedule A includes any New Construction tax classifications assessed on the 2019 for 2020 assessment roll. The attached Schedule “B” details the tax rates

for all New Construction classes that may be subject to supplementary or omitted assessments in the future.

d) Tax Bill Production and Mailing

2020 Final tax bills will again be produced in the standardized format as required by the Province of Ontario. For residential and capped classes (Commercial, Industrial, and Multi-Residential), tax bills will be mailed by early July with due dates of September 23 rd,

October 21st, and November 18th 2020. Preauthorized tax accounts (PTP) will have the additional option of payment dates on the 1st or the 15th, or the next business day in the

event of a weekend or a statutory holiday, for a maximum of the four (4) months of September through December. The final levy instalment dates are scheduled for the autumn months to align with the adjustments provided in response to relief provisions

during the COVID-19 pandemic. Residents and businesses were given the option to defer interim due dates to August 19 before penalty and interest charges would be

charged. The new dates provide a month between the end of the deferral period and the first instalment for final taxes.

In accordance with Section 355 of the Municipal Act, the municipality may pass a by-law providing that where the total final tax levy to be imposed on a property would be less than the tax amount specified by the municipality, the amount of actual taxes payable

shall be zero. Therefore it is recommended that where the total final levy taxes to be imposed on a property would be less than twenty-five (25) dollars, the amount of actual

taxes shall be zero.

Corporate Implications:

Financial Implications:

The approval of this report and By-law is essential to support the budget requirements of

the City, Region of Peel, and the Province for education. An information brochure will

10.3-4

accompany the bills with details regarding the 2020 City Budget and the various payment options. In addition, the City will place an advertisement in local media advising residents of the instalment due dates for the 2020 final billing.

Other Implications:

N/A

Strategic Plan:

This report achieves the Strategic Plan Priority of Good Government by contributing to the Strategic Initiative of Continued Financial Stability and it promotes transparency in the reporting of the City’s financial affairs.

Term of Council Priorities:

This report fulfils the Council Priority of a Well-Run City through strict adherence to effective financial management policies and supports Brampton’s 2040 Vision by

ensuring sustainable financial revenues.

Conclusion:

This tax levy By-law supports the 2020 budget requirements as previously set by Council. The levy amounts for the Region of Peel and the Education portion are as directed by Regional By-law 30-2020, Ontario Regulation 6/20 and Section 257.12(5) of

the Education Act. The accompanying tax rates described in Schedule “A” and Schedule “B” will be utilized for all tax bill calculations and tax adjustments pertaining to

the 2020 tax year. The final levy instalment dates have been delayed to align to the adjustments provided in response to relief provisions during the COVID-19 pandemic.

10.3-5

Authored by:

Reviewed by:

Martin Finnegan, Senior Manager Revenue

David Sutton, Treasurer

Approved by:

Submitted by:

David Barrick, Acting Commissioner

Corporate Services

David Barrick, Chief Administrative Officer

Attachments:

Schedule A – 2020 Tax Rates and Levy

Schedule B – 2020 New Construction Tax Rates Schedule C – Downtown Brampton Business Improvement Area (BIA) Boundary

By-law – 2020 Final Tax Levy

10.3-6

Schedule "A"

Corporation of the City of Brampton

2020 Tax Rates and Levy

($000's)

Tax Class Description Tax Class CVALower Tier

Tax Rate

Upper Tier

Tax Rate

Education

Tax Rate

Total Tax

RateCity of Brampton Region of Peel Education Total

Residential & Farm RT 86,200,034,338 0.432673% 0.367633% 0.153000% 0.953306% 372,964 316,900 131,886 821,750

Residential (Education Only) RD 0 0.000000% 0.000000% 0.153000% 0.153000% 0 0 0 0

Residential Taxable (full rate, shared PIL) RH 0 0.432673% 0.367633% 0.153000% 0.953306% 0 0 0 0

Res. Farmland Awaiting Dev. Ph. I R1 3,514,800 0.129802% 0.110290% 0.045900% 0.285992% 5 4 2 10

Res. Farmland Awaiting Dev. Ph. II R4 0 0.432673% 0.367633% 0.153000% 0.953306% 0 0 0 0

Multi-Residential MT 1,789,468,544 0.737707% 0.626814% 0.153000% 1.517521% 13,201 11,217 2,738 27,156

New Multi-Residential NT 0 0.432673% 0.367633% 0.153000% 0.953306% 0 0 0 0

MR Farmland Awaiting Dev. Ph. I M1 0 0.129802% 0.110290% 0.045900% 0.285992% 0 0 0 0

MR Farmland Awaiting Dev. Ph II M4 0 0.737707% 0.626814% 0.153000% 1.517521% 0 0 0 0

Commercial Taxable Full Rate CT 7,457,911,980 0.561220% 0.476857% 0.944727% 1.982804% 41,855 35,564 70,457 147,876

Office Building New Construction: Full YT 66,233,200 0.561220% 0.476857% 0.944727% 1.982804% 372 316 626 1,313

Office Building New Construction: Excess Land YU 9,406,200 0.477037% 0.405328% 0.944727% 1.827092% 45 38 89 172

Shopping Centre New Construction: Full ZT 486,321,000 0.561220% 0.476857% 0.944727% 1.982804% 2,729 2,319 4,594 9,643

Shopping Centre New Construction: Excess Land ZU 12,507,400 0.477037% 0.405328% 0.944727% 1.827092% 60 51 118 229

Commercial Taxable (full rate, shared PIL) CH 23,461,000 0.561220% 0.476857% 0.944727% 1.982804% 132 112 222 465

Commercial Taxable - (no school taxes) CM 0 0.561220% 0.476857% 0.000000% 1.038077% 0 0 0 0

C.Farmland Awaiting Dev. Ph I C1 4,857,000 0.129802% 0.110290% 0.045900% 0.285992% 6 5 2 14

C.Farmland Awaiting Dev. Ph II C4 0 0.561220% 0.476857% 0.944727% 1.982804% 0 0 0 0

Commercial Small Scale On-Farm Business C7 45,800 0.140305% 0.119214% 0.245000% 0.504519% 0 0 0 0

Commercial Excess Land CU 156,724,359 0.477037% 0.405328% 0.944727% 1.827092% 748 635 1,481 2,863

Commercial Taxable (vacant land, shared PIL) CJ 0 0.477037% 0.405328% 0.944727% 1.827092% 0 0 0 0

Office Building DT 369,537,709 0.561220% 0.476857% 0.944727% 1.982804% 2,074 1,762 3,491 7,327

Office Building Taxable (full rate, shared PIL) DH 0 0.561220% 0.476857% 0.944727% 1.982804% 0 0 0 0

Office Building Excess Land DU 4,656,267 0.477037% 0.405328% 0.944727% 1.827092% 22 19 44 85

Shopping Centres ST 2,507,413,752 0.561220% 0.476857% 0.944727% 1.982804% 14,072 11,957 23,688 49,717

Shopping Centres Excess Land SU 3,800,984 0.477037% 0.405328% 0.944727% 1.827092% 18 15 36 69

Parking Lot GT 63,049,206 0.561220% 0.476857% 0.944727% 1.982804% 354 301 596 1,250

Commercial Vacant Land CX 286,319,809 0.477037% 0.405328% 0.944727% 1.827092% 1,366 1,161 2,705 5,231

Commercial New Construction : Full XT 1,984,018,418 0.561220% 0.476857% 0.944727% 1.982804% 11,135 9,461 18,744 39,339

Commercial New Construction : Excess Land XU 33,403,800 0.477037% 0.405328% 0.944727% 1.827092% 159 135 316 610

Commercial New Construction : Vacant Land XX 0 0.477037% 0.405328% 0.944727% 1.827092% 0 0 0 0

Industrial Taxable Full Rate IT 1,891,508,599 0.636029% 0.540421% 1.066032% 2.242482% 12,031 10,222 20,164 42,417

Industrial New Construction : Full JT 17,284,200 0.636029% 0.540421% 0.980000% 2.156450% 110 93 169 373

Industrial New Construction Vacant Land JX 437,000 0.540625% 0.459357% 0.980000% 1.979982% 2 2 4 9

Industrial Taxable (full rate, shared PIL) IH 32,004,800 0.636029% 0.540421% 1.066032% 2.242482% 204 173 341 718

Large Industrial New Construction : Full KT 23,338,100 0.636029% 0.540421% 0.980000% 2.156450% 148 126 229 503

I. Farmland Awaiting Dev. Ph I I1 10,250,200 0.129802% 0.110290% 0.045900% 0.285992% 13 11 5 29

I. Farmland Awaiting Dev. Ph II I4 0 0.636029% 0.540421% 1.066032% 2.242482% 0 0 0 0

Industrial Small Scale On-Farm Business I7 0 0.159007% 0.135105% 0.245000% 0.539112% 0 0 0 0

Industrial Excess Land IU 56,585,702 0.540625% 0.459357% 1.066032% 2.066014% 306 260 603 1,169

Industrial Vacant Land IX 161,470,700 0.540625% 0.459357% 1.066032% 2.066014% 873 742 1,721 3,336

Industrial Vacant land, Shared PIL IJ 2,422,800 0.540625% 0.459357% 1.066032% 2.066014% 13 11 26 50

Industrial Excess Land Shared PIL IK 7,938,400 0.540625% 0.459357% 1.066032% 2.066014% 43 36 85 164

Large Industrial Taxable LT 1,001,923,206 0.636029% 0.540421% 1.066032% 2.242482% 6,373 5,415 10,681 22,468

Large Industrial Excess Land LU 38,780,700 0.540625% 0.459357% 1.066032% 2.066014% 210 178 413 801

Pipelines PT 217,132,200 0.399747% 0.339656% 1.189049% 1.928452% 868 738 2,582 4,187

Farmland FT 127,748,400 0.108168% 0.091908% 0.038250% 0.238326% 138 117 49 304

Managed Forests TT 1,122,900 0.108168% 0.091908% 0.038250% 0.238326% 1 1 0 3

TOTAL 105,052,633,473 482,649 410,097 298,906 1,191,652

10.3-7

Schedule "B"

The Corporation of the City of Brampton

2020 New Construction Final Tax Rates

Tax Class DescriptionTax

Class

Lower Tier

Tax Rate

Upper Tier

Tax Rate

Education

Tax Rate

Total Tax

Rate

Industrial New Construction Shared (PIL for Ed) JH 0.636029% 0.540421% 0.980000% 2.156450%

Industrial New Construction - Water Intake System (PIL for Ed) JI 0.636029% 0.540421% 0.980000% 2.156450%

Industrial New Construction Vacant Land (PIL for Ed) JJ 0.540625% 0.459357% 0.980000% 1.979982%

Industrial New Construction Excess Land (PIL for Ed) JK 0.540625% 0.459357% 0.980000% 1.979982%

Industrial New Construction - Non-Generating Station (PIL for Ed) JN 0.636029% 0.540421% 0.980000% 2.156450%

Industrial New Construction - Generating Station (PIL for Ed) JS 0.636029% 0.540421% 0.980000% 2.156450%

Industrial New Construction JT 0.636029% 0.540421% 0.980000% 2.156450%

Industrial New Construction Excess Land JU 0.540625% 0.459357% 0.980000% 1.979982%

Industrial New Construction Vacant Land JX 0.540625% 0.459357% 0.980000% 1.979982%

Large Industrial New Construction Shared (PIL for Ed) KH 0.636029% 0.540421% 0.980000% 2.156450%

Large Industrial New Construction - Water Intake System (PIL for Ed) KI 0.636029% 0.540421% 0.980000% 2.156450%

Large Industrial New Construction Excess Land (PIL for Ed) KK 0.540625% 0.459357% 0.980000% 1.979982%

Large Industrial New Construction - Non-Generating Station (PIL for Ed) KN 0.636029% 0.540421% 0.980000% 2.156450%

Large Industrial New Construction - Generating Station (PIL for Ed) KS 0.636029% 0.540421% 0.980000% 2.156450%

Large Industrial New Construction KT 0.636029% 0.540421% 0.980000% 2.156450%

Large Industrial New Construction Excess Land KU 0.540625% 0.459357% 0.980000% 1.979982%

Large Industrial New Construction Vacant Land KX 0.540625% 0.459357% 0.980000% 1.979982%

Commercial New Construction - Lower Tier and Education Only XC 0.561220% 0.944727% 1.505947%

Commercial New Construction - Education Only XD 0.944727% 0.944727%

Commercial New Construction Shared (PIL for Ed) XH 0.561220% 0.476857% 0.944727% 1.982804%

Commercial New Construction Vacant Land (PIL for Ed) XJ 0.477037% 0.405328% 0.944727% 1.827092%

Commercial New Construction Excess Land (PIL for Ed) XK 0.477037% 0.405328% 0.944727% 1.827092%

Commercial New Construction - Upper Tier and Education Only XL 0.476857% 0.944727% 1.421584%

Commercial New Construction XT 0.561220% 0.476857% 0.944727% 1.982804%

Commercial New Construction Excess Land XU 0.477037% 0.405328% 0.944727% 1.827092%

Commercial New Construction Vacant Land XX 0.477037% 0.405328% 0.944727% 1.827092%

Office Building New Construction - Lower Tier and Education Only YC 0.561220% 0.944727% 1.505947%

Office Building New Construction - Education Only YD 0.944727% 0.944727%

Office Building New Construction Shared (PIL for Ed) YH 0.561220% 0.476857% 0.944727% 1.982804%

Office Building New Construction Excess Land (PIL for Ed) YK 0.477037% 0.405328% 0.944727% 1.827092%

Office Building New Construction - Upper Tier and Education Only YL 0.476857% 0.944727% 1.421584%

Office Building New Construction YT 0.561220% 0.476857% 0.944727% 1.982804%

Office Building New Construction Excess Land YU 0.477037% 0.405328% 0.944727% 1.827092%

Shopping Centre New Construction - Lower Tier and Education Only ZC 0.561220% 0.944727% 1.505947%

Shopping Centre New Construction - Education Only ZD 0.944727% 0.944727%

Shopping Centre New Construction Shared (PIL for Ed) ZH 0.561220% 0.476857% 0.944727% 1.982804%

Shopping Centre New Construction Excess Land (PIL for Ed) ZK 0.477037% 0.405328% 0.944727% 1.827092%

Shopping Centre New Construction - Upper Tier and Education Only ZL 0.476857% 0.944727% 1.421584%

Shopping Centre New Construction ZT 0.561220% 0.476857% 0.944727% 1.982804%

Shopping Centre New Construction Excess Land ZU 0.477037% 0.405328% 0.944727% 1.827092%

10.3-8

10.3-9

THE CORPORATION OF THE CITY OF BRAMPTON

BY-LAW Number ___________- 2020

A By-Law to Provide for the Levy and

Collection of Property Taxes for the Year 2020

_________________________

WHEREAS section 3 of the Assessment Act, R.S.O. 1990, c. A.31, as amended,

provides that all real property, with specific exceptions, is subject to assessment and

taxation;

AND WHEREAS the property classes have been prescribed by the Minister of

Finance under the Assessment Act, R.S.O. 1990, c. A.31, as amended, and the

regulations thereto;

AND WHEREAS it is necessary for the Council of The Corporation of the City of

Brampton, pursuant to the Municipal Act, 2001 to levy upon the whole of the

assessment for real property for the property classes according to the last revised

assessment roll for The Corporation of the City of Brampton the sums set forth for the

purposes in Schedule "A" and Schedule “B” hereto attached for the current year;

AND WHEREAS, the Regional Municipality of Peel has adopted estimates of all

sums required by The Regional Municipality of Peel during the year 2020 for the

purposes of the Regional Corporation and has provided for a general levy and special

levies on Area Municipalities;

AND WHEREAS the tax rates for school purposes are prescribed by Ontario

Regulation;

AND WHEREAS the Regional Municipality of Peel delegated to the Council of each

area municipality the authority to pass a By-law establishing tax ratios and setting out

a method by which the portion of Regional levies will be raised in each area

municipality for the 2020 taxation year;

10.3-10

By-law Number _________- 2020

2

Page 2 to By-law ________________________

AND WHEREAS the City of Brampton Tax Ratios By-law established the relative

amount of taxation to be borne by each property class;

AND WHEREAS it is expedient to provide for the levy and collection of taxes by

instalments and to impose penalties on all overdue current levies and interest on all

arrears of taxes pursuant to the Municipal Act, 2001;

AND WHEREAS an Interim levy was made by The Corporation of the City of

Brampton before the adoption of the estimates for the current year;

NOW THEREFORE the Council of The Corporation of the City of Brampton ENACTS

as follows:

1. For the year 2020, the tax rates shown on Schedule “A” and Schedule “B” to this

By-law shall be levied upon the whole of the assessment in each property class

shown on Schedule “A” and Schedule “B” to this By-law.

2. Any amounts levied by the interim levy for 2020 shall be deducted from the

amounts levied by this By-law.

3. (1a) Every property within the tax classes of Residential, Farm, Managed Forest

& Pipelines shall be taxed according to the tax rates shown on Schedule A to this

By-law, and the taxes levied shall be collected in three (3) instalments, (due

September 23rd, October 21st, and November 18th 2020 respectively) provided

that the first instalment shall be due not earlier than 21 days from the date of the

mailing of the tax notice.

(1b) Every property within the tax classes of Commercial, Industrial and Multi-

Residential shall be taxed according to the tax rates shown on Schedule A and

Schedule B to this By-law, and the taxes levied shall be collected in three (3)

instalments, (due September 23rd, October 21st, and November 18th 2020

respectively) provided that the first instalment shall be due not earlier than 21

days from the date of the mailing of the tax notice.

(2) Notwithstanding subsection 3 (1a) & (1b), the final levy for real property taxes

including local improvement assessments, for those properties subject to an

agreement for monthly payments under the City of Brampton Pre-Authorized Tax

Payment Program shall be due and payable to the Corporation of the City of

Brampton in four (4) instalments where practicable based on the withdrawal day

consisting of the option of payment dates on the 1st or the 15th, or the next

subsequent business day in the event of a weekend or a statutory holiday, during

the months of:

September 2020

October 2020

November 2020

December 2020

10.3-11

By-law Number _________- 2020

3

Page 3 to By-law ________________________

(3) For the year 2020, pursuant to Sections 208(2) of the Municipal Act, 2001, a

special charge or tax rate of 0.218108% shall be levied against the ratable

property in the improvement area as defined in By-law 276-88, that belongs to a

class of property prescribed under the Assessment Act as a business property

class for the purposes of Sections 204 to 215 of the Municipal Act, 2001,

sufficient to provide the sum of $354,104.21 for the purposes of the Brampton

Downtown Business Improvement Area, together with interest on the sum at

such rate as is required to repay any interest payable by the City on the whole or

any part of that sum.

(4) For Payments-in-Lieu (P.I.L.’s) of taxes due to the City, the actual amount due

to the City shall be based on the Assessment Roll and the tax rates for 2020,

unless otherwise required by regulation.

(5) That property taxes to be levied as a result of additions to the Tax Roll

pursuant to the Assessment Act, shall be due and payable in a minimum of three

(3) instalments, provided that the first instalment shall be due not earlier than 21

days from the date of the mailing of the tax notice.

(6) Notwithstanding subsection (5) where property taxes are levied as a result of

additions to the Tax Roll pursuant to the Assessment Act, at such points during

the year that it is impractical or otherwise not feasible for such taxes to be

payable in three instalments then these taxes shall be due and payable on such

dates as may be determined by the Treasurer of the Corporation of the City of

Brampton.

4. Notwithstanding section 1 and 3, where the total final levy taxes to be imposed

on a property would be less than twenty-five (25) dollars, the amount of actual

taxes shall be zero.

5. There shall be added to the Collector's Roll all or any Local Improvement or

Special Charges, arrears of charges, fees, costs or other expenses as may be

permitted by applicable Provincial legislation and such Local Improvement or

Special Charges, arrears of charges, fees, costs or other expenses shall be

deemed to be taxes, collected as taxes, or collected in the same manner as

municipal taxes, as may be specifically authorized by the applicable statute.

6. (1) Pursuant to Section 345(2) of the Municipal Act, 2001 the Treasurer shall add

a late payment charge as a penalty for non-payment of the instalment(s) of taxes

on the respective due date(s) of one and one quarter percent (1 ¼ %) of the

amount of taxes due and unpaid for the first day of default in the year in which

the taxes were levied.

(2) Pursuant to Section 345(3) of the Municipal Act, 2001 the Treasurer shall add

an interest charge of one and one-quarter percent (1 ¼%) for the non-payment of

taxes due and unpaid on the first day of each calendar month.

10.3-12

By-law Number _________- 2020

4

Page 4 to By-law ________________________

7. The Treasurer is hereby authorized to accept part payment from time to time on

account of any taxes due and to give a receipt for such part payment, provided

that acceptance of any such part payment does not affect the collection of any

late payment charges imposed and collectable under the provisions of

subsection 5(1) and 5(2) of this By-law, in respect of non-payment of any taxes

or any class of taxes or of any instalment thereof.

8. (1) That the following institutions are hereby authorized to collect instalments of

taxes to be credited to the Treasurer:

(1a) All Schedule I and Schedule II banks pursuant to the Bank Act;

(1b) Trust Companies incorporated under the laws of the Province of Ontario;

(1c) Credit Union and Caisses Populaires.

(2) The institutions shall provide a receipt to the taxpayer and the City shall credit

the taxpayer's account for the amount paid effective on the date of the

institution's receipt to the taxpayer.

9. (1) That the Treasurer is hereby authorized to mail every tax notice or cause the

same to be mailed to the address of the residence or place of business of the

person taxed unless directed otherwise by the taxpayer or agent of the taxpayer,

as provided by the Municipal Act, 2001 as amended.

(2) Immediately after sending a tax bill, the Treasurer shall create a record of the

date on which it was sent and this record is, in the absence of evidence to the

contrary, proof that the tax bill was sent on that date.

10. If any section or portion of this By-law is found by a court of competent

jurisdiction to be invalid, it is the intent of Council for the Corporation of the City

of Brampton that all remaining sections and portions of this By-law continue in

force and effect.

ENACTED and PASSED this 13th day of May, 2020

________________________________

Patrick Brown, Mayor

________________________________

Peter Fay, City Clerk

Approved as to form.

____/_____/____

______________

Legal

Approved as to

content.

04/17/2020

____D.S._____

Treasurer

10.3-13

Report

City Council The Corporation of the City of Brampton

2020-05-13

Date: 2020-04-20

Subject: Request to Begin Procurement

Reconstruction of Elizabeth Street and Elliott Street - Ward 3

(Agenda.NET Item R103/2020, Capital Works File Nos. 18-2683-231 & 18-2791-231)

Contact: Harry Persaud, P.Eng.

Senior Project Engineer

Public Works & Engineering 905-874-8573, [email protected]

Recommendations:

1. That the report titled Request to Begin Procurement – Reconstruction of Elizabeth Street and Elliott Street – Ward 3 (Agenda.NET Item R103/2020, Capital Works File Nos. 18-2683-231 & 18-2791-231), to the City Council

Meeting of May 13, 2020, be received; and,

2. That the Purchasing Agent be authorized to commence the procurement for the reconstruction of Elizabeth Street and Elliott Street.

Overview:

The City conducted a Condition Survey of several concrete surfaced local

roads to determine the condition of those roads including Elizabeth Street and Elliott Street.

The condition of Elizabeth Street was rated as fair and the condition of Elliott Street was rated as poor.

Both roads were recommended to be fully reconstructed and be replaced

with flexible asphalt pavement per current City’s standard for local roads.

Background:

The City completed condition surveys of several concrete surfaced local roads to determine their existing conditions and the need for rehabilitation and/or reconstruction

10.4-1

of these roads. The survey included Elizabeth Street from 250m south of Harold Street to Harold Street and Elliott Street from Craig Street to Fleming Avenue.

The condition of Elizabeth Street was rated as fair and the condition of Elliott Street was rated as poor. Both roads were recommended for full road reconstruction with flexible

asphalt pavement per the City’s current standard for the construction of local roads. Several of the concrete roads were recommended for reconstruction due to their

condition and the reconstruction of these roads is expected to be completed as part of an on-going reconstruction program over several years. Elizabeth Street was picked as

one of the first roads to be completed due to public complaints received on the condition and rideability of the road surface.

As part of the public consultation for the reconstruction of Elizabeth Street and Elliott Street, the City completed a Public information Centre in 2018.

Current Situation:

The detailed design and preparation of the tender documents for the road reconstruction

is expected to be finalized in early-May 2020. The anticipated project schedule is as follows:

Council Approval May 2020

Tender Call May 2020

Tender Closing June 2020

Start of Construction July/August 2020

Completion of Construction October 2020

Staff will work with Strategic Communications to develop a Communication Plan in order

to keep the residents in the area informed before and during the construction. Corporate Implications:

Financial Implications:

Sufficient funding is available within the Public Works & Engineering approved Capital Budget.

Purchasing Implications:

A public Procurement Process will be conducted and the lowest compliant Bid will be

eligible for contract award. Purchase approval shall be obtained in accordance with the Purchasing By-law.

10.4-2

All communication with Bidders involved in the procurement must occur formally, through the contact person identified in the Bid Document. Term of Council Priorities:

This reconstruction of Elizabeth Street and Elliott Street achieves the Term of Council Priorities for a Healthy and Safe City by building well-planned infrastructure and aligns with Brampton’s 2040 Vision – Transportation and Connectivity, and Health. Conclusion:

This report recommends that the Purchasing Agent be authorized to commence the procurement for the reconstruction of Elizabeth Street and Elliott Street.

Authored by:

Reviewed and Recommended by:

Harry Persaud, P.Eng. Senior Project Engineer Capital Works Public Works & Engineering

Jayne Holmes, P.Eng. Director Capital Works Public Works & Engineering

Approved by:

Submitted by:

Jasbir Raina, B.Eng., M.Tech., MBA, PMP, MIAM Commissioner Public Works & Engineering

David Barrick Chief Administrative Officer

Attachments: Appendix ‘A’ – Site Plan

10.4-3

10.4-4

Tuesday, May 5, 2020 Special Meeting

Members Present via Electronic Meeting Participation: Regional Councillor M. Medeiros – Wards 3 and 4 (Chair) Regional Councillor R. Santos – Wards 1 and 5 (Vice Chair) Regional Councillor M. Palleschi – Wards 2 and 6 Regional Councillor G. Dhillon – Wards 9 and 10 City Councillor J. Bowman – Wards 3 and 4 City Councillor D. Whillans – Wards 2 and 6 City Councillor H. Singh – Wards 9 and 10 Iqbal Ali Rishi Jain Abid Zaman

Staff Present: D. Barrick, Chief Administrative Officer

S. Kalkat, Director, Office of Internal Audit D. Sutton, Treasurer, Finance P. Fay, City Clerk C. Gravlev, Deputy City Clerk S. Pacheco, Legislative Coordinator, City Clerk’s Office

Minutes

Audit Committee Committee of the Council of

The Corporation of the City of Brampton

12.1-1

Minutes Audit Committee

2020 05 05 Page 2 of 5

Note: In consideration of the current COVID-19 public health orders prohibiting public gatherings of more than 5 people and requirements for physical distancing between persons, in-person attendance at this Audit Committee meeting was limited to Members of Council and essential City staff only. Physical distancing was maintained in Council Chambers at all times during the meeting.

The meeting was called to order at 9:30 a.m. and adjourned at 10:00 a.m. 1. Approval of Agenda

As this meeting of Audit Committee was conducted with electronic participation by Members of Council and Citizen Members, the meeting started with the City Clerk calling the roll for attendance at the meeting, as follows:

Members present during roll call: Councillor Medeiros, Councillor Santos, Councillor Palleschi, Councillor Dhillon, Councillor Bowman, Councillor Whillans, Councillor Singh, Citizen Members Iqbal Ali, Rishi Jain, Abid Zaman Members absent during roll call: nil The following motion was considered.

AU008-2020 That the agenda for the Special Audit Committee Meeting of May 5,

2020, be approved as published and circulated.

Carried 2. Declaration of Interest under the Municipal Conflict of Interest Act

3. Consent

The following items listed with an asterisk (*) were considered to be routine and non-controversial by the Committee and were approved at one time.

(nil)

4. Delegations/Presentations

4.1. Delegation from Mr. Kevin Travers, Partner, KPMG LLP Chartered Accountants, re: Draft 2019 Audited Consolidated Financial Statements for the City of Brampton.

12.1-2

Minutes Audit Committee

2020 05 05 Page 3 of 5

Kevin Travers, Partner, KPMG LLP Chartered Accountants, provided an overview of the Audit Findings Report prepared by KPMG for the year ended December 31, 2019 (Appendix C to Report Item 6.1). Mr. Travers advised that:

the audit was conducted in accordance with the Audit Plan previously presented to Committee

no uncorrected differences, adjustments or control deficiencies were identified

the reasonability of accounting estimates was satisfactory

management’s assessment of the financial impact of COVID-19 was reviewed

In addition, Mr. Travers provided information in regard to the following:

Audit risks and results – significant financial reporting risks

Technology in the audit

Significant and other accounting policies and practices – adoption of new standards

Current developments and audit trends

Mr. Travers and staff responded to questions from Committee with respect to the following:

Long-term investments o Investment portfolio o Purpose/use of funds o Level of information provided in the financial statements o Regulations for permitted municipal investments

Accounting of development charges in the financial statements

Information provided in reserve and capital status update reports to Council

City funding sources that can be used for the COVID-19 emergency o Staff advised there is currently no legislation in place requiring

municipalities to have an emergency fund

Accounting of potential funds from the Federal and Provincial Governments for the COVID-19 emergency

Review of the annual Audit Plan by KPMG The following motion was considered.

AU009-2020 That the delegation from Kevin Travers, Partner, KPMG LLP Chartered

Accountants, to the Special Audit Committee Meeting of May 5, 2020, re: Draft 2019 Audited Consolidated Financial Statements for the City of Brampton, be received.

Carried

12.1-3

Minutes Audit Committee

2020 05 05 Page 4 of 5

5. Reports – Internal Audit – nil

6. Reports – Finance

6.1. Staff Report re: Draft 2019 Audited Consolidated Financial Statements for the City of Brampton.

The following motion was considered.

AU010-2020 1. That the report titled: Draft 2019 Audited Consolidated Financial

Statements for the City of Brampton (R106/2020), to the Special Audit Committee Meeting of May 5, 2020, be received;

2. That the Draft 2019 Audited Financial Statements be received and

approved; and 3. That the KPMG LLP Audit Findings Report for the year ended

December 31, 2019, be received.

Carried

7. Other/New Business – nil

8. Member Question Period – nil

9. Public Question Period The public was given the opportunity to submit questions via e-mail to the City Clerk’s Office regarding any decisions made at this meeting.

P. Fay, City Clerk, confirmed that no questions were submitted regarding decisions made at this meeting.

10. Closed Session -nil

11. Adjournment

The following motion was considered.

12.1-4

Minutes Audit Committee

2020 05 05 Page 5 of 5

AU011-2020 That the Audit Committee do now adjourn to meet again on Tuesday, June 16, 2020 at 9:30 a.m. or at the call of the Chair.

Carried

___________________________________ Regional Councillor M. Medeiros, Chair

12.1-5

Wednesday, May 06, 2020

Members Present via Electronic Meeting Participation:

Regional Councillor R. Santos – Wards 1 and 5 Chair, Community Services Section Vice-Chair, Corporate Services Section Regional Councillor P. Vicente – Wards 1 and 5 Chair, Public Works and Engineering Section Vice-Chair, Economic Development and Culture Section Regional Councillor M. Palleschi – Wards 2 and 6 Regional Councillor M. Medeiros – Wards 3 and 4 Regional Councillor P. Fortini – Wards 7 and 8 Vice-Chair, Public Works and Engineering Section (left at 2:53 p.m. – personal – connectivity issue) Regional Councillor G. Dhillon – Wards 9 and 10 Chair, Economic Development and Culture Section City Councillor D. Whillans – Wards 2 and 6 City Councillor J. Bowman – Wards 3 and 4 City Councillor C. Williams – Wards 7 and 8 Vice-Chair, Community Services Section City Councillor H. Singh – Wards 9 and 10 Chair, Corporate Services Section

Members Absent: nil

Staff Present: D. Barrick, Chief Administrative Officer

R. Forward, Commissioner, Planning and Development Services J. Pittari, Commissioner, Legislative Services J. Raina, Commissioner, Public Works and Engineering D. Boyce, Acting Commissioner, Community Services A. Milojevic General Manager, Transit B. Boyes, Fire Chief, Fire and Emergency Services C. Barnett, Director, Economic Development and Culture D. Soos, Deputy City Solicitor, Corporate Services P. Fay, City Clerk C. Gravlev, Deputy City Clerk S. Pacheco, Legislative Coordinator, City Clerk’s Office

Minutes

Committee of Council The Corporation of the City of Brampton

12.1-1

Minutes Committee of Council

2020 05 06 Page 2 of 21

Note: In consideration of the current COVID-19 public health orders prohibiting public gatherings of more than 5 people and requirements for physical distancing between persons, in-person attendance at this Committee of Council meeting was limited to Members of Council and essential City staff only. Physical distancing was maintained in Council Chambers at all times during the meeting.

The meeting was called to order at 1:00 p.m. and recessed at 2:13 p.m. Committee moved into Closed Session at 2:31 p.m. and recessed at 2:53 p.m. Committee reconvened in Open Session at 3:02 p.m. and adjourned at 3:03 p.m.

1. Approval of Agenda As this meeting of Committee of Council was conducted with electronic participation by Members of Council, the meeting started with the City Clerk calling the roll for attendance at the meeting, as follows:

Members present during roll call: Councillor Santos, Councillor Vicente, Councillor Whillans, Councillor Palleschi, Councillor Bowman, Councillor Medeiros, Councillor Williams, Councillor Fortini, Councillor Singh, Councillor Dhillon, Mayor Brown

Members absent during roll call: nil

Council discussion took place with respect to proposed amendments to the agenda.

The following motion was considered.

CW089-2020 That the agenda for the Committee of Council Meeting of May 6, 2020

be approved as amended to add the following item:

10.3.2. Discussion at the request of City Councillor Whillans, re: Facility Operations.

Carried

The following items, listed on the agenda for distribution prior to the meeting, were published on the City’s web portal on May 4, 5 and 6, 2020:

8.2.3. Staff Report re: Community Benefits and Fair Wage Policy (RM 119/2019).

8.2.4. Staff Report re: Noise By-law during Ramadan 2020 (RM

26/2020).

12.1-2

Minutes Committee of Council

2020 05 06 Page 3 of 21

8.2.5. Staff Report re: Ethnic Media Advertising Information Report (RM 25/2020).

The following items, related to matters on the agenda, were published on the City’s web portal on May 4 and 6, 2020:

Re. Item 5.1

Staff Presentation entitled: Government Relations Matters Re. Item 8.2.2

8.4.1. Correspondence from Lynda Fishman, dated May 4, 2020, re: Item 8.2.2 – Purple Lilac Memorial Park – Air Canada Crash Site 50th Anniversary Commemoration – Ward 8 (R 105/2020).

Re. Item 8.2.4

8.4.2. Correspondence re: Item 8.2.4 – Noise By-law during Ramadan 2020 (RM 26/2020).

At this time in the meeting Regional Councillor Vicente, Chair, advised that meetings of Council and Committees are to be open to the public for transparency and accountability, with a few precautions and limitations. In-person attendance at meetings is severely restricted and options for public access and participation were outlined. Councillor Vicente added that important service and public health updates are available through the City’s website at www.brampton.ca. 2. Declarations of Interest under the Municipal Conflict of Interest Act – nil

3. Consent The following items listed with an asterisk (*) were considered to be routine and non-controversial by the Committee and were approved at one time.

(8.2.1, 8.3.1, 9.3.1, 10.3.1)

4. Announcements – nil

5. Government Relations Matters

12.1-3

Minutes Committee of Council

2020 05 06 Page 4 of 21

5.1. Staff Report re: Government Relations Matters. G. Kaur, Director, Corporate Projects and Liaison, Office of the CAO, provided a presentation entitled “Government Relations Matters – Update on COVID-19 (April/May 2020)”, which included updates on matters relating to:

Federal, Provincial and Regional Governments

Federation of Canadian Municipalities (FCM)

Association of Municipalities of Ontario (AMO) M. Marr, Director, Organizational Performance, Office of the CAO, provided an update on the COVID-19 Regional Community Response Table, and advised that financial support was approved by the Region of Peel for eligible not-for-profit agencies that support Peel’s vulnerable community. Committee discussions included the following:

Provisions for the re-opening and operation of garden centres

Request that a list of COVID-19 regional tables with City staff participation be provided to Members of Council

City Councillor Whillans outlined his interest in the nomination for the 2020 - 2022 AMO Board of Directors – Large Urban Caucus. The following motion was considered.

CW090-2020 1. That the staff report and presentation entitled: Government

Relations Matters, to the Committee of Council Meeting of May 6, 2020, be received; and

2. That the nomination of Councillor Whillans to the 2020 - 2022 AMO

Board of Directors – Large Urban Caucus be supported and endorsed by Brampton City Council.

Carried

5.2. Update from Mayor P. Brown re: COVID-19 Emergency.

Mayor Brown provided information on the “CONQUER COVID-19” t-shirt initiative, promoted by Canadian Actor Ryan Reynolds. He advised that all proceeds from t-shirt sales go towards the purchase of personal protective equipment (PPE) for Canada’s frontline workers. Mayor Brown thanked Members of Council who supported this initiative by purchasing and wearing this t-shirt. Mayor Brown also provided updates on the following topics:

12.1-4

Minutes Committee of Council

2020 05 06 Page 5 of 21

Response to the Backyard Garden Program o This program is now at full capacity and not accepting new

applicants

“Lean On Me” video led by Councillors Vicente and Santos

Results of physical distancing efforts in flattening the COVID-19 curve

May 6, 2020 Virtual Press Conference: City of Brampton update on response to COVID-19

The following motion was considered.

CW091-2020 That the update from Mayor P. Brown re: COVID-19 Emergency, to

the Committee of Council Meeting of May 6, 2020, be received.

Carried 6. Delegations

In response to a request from the Chair, P. Fay, City Clerk, outlined the process and options for public delegations at Council/Committee meetings. He added that staff are exploring options for real-time delegations via audio and/or video capabilities.

7. Economic Development and Culture Section (Regional Councillor P. Vicente, Vice-Chair)

7.1. Staff Presentations – nil

7.2. Reports – nil

7.3. Other/New Business

7.3.1. Update – Innovation and Post-Secondary Matters – nil

7.4. Correspondence – nil

7.5. Councillors Question Period – nil

7.6. Public Question Period – nil

12.1-5

Minutes Committee of Council

2020 05 06 Page 6 of 21

The public was given the opportunity to submit questions via e-mail to the City Clerk’s Office regarding any decisions made under the Economic Development and Culture Section of the agenda.

P. Fay, City Clerk, confirmed that no questions were submitted regarding decisions made under this section.

8. Corporate Services Section

(City Councillor H. Singh, Chair)

8.1. Staff Presentations – nil

8.2. Reports

* 8.2.1. Staff Report re: 2019 Council/Committee Meeting Attendance Record (I 6/2020) (File BC.x).

CW092-2020 That the staff report entitled: 2019 Council/Committee Meeting Attendance Record (I 6/2020) (File BC.x) to the Committee of Council Meeting of May 6, 2020 be received.

Carried

8.2.2. Staff Report re: Purple Lilac Memorial Park – Air Canada Crash Site 50th

Anniversary Commemoration – Ward 8 (R 105/2020).

Committee thanked staff for their efforts in communicating with the families and communities impacted by the Air Canada crash regarding the 50th Anniversary Commemoration of this tragic event. Committee discussion on this matter included the location and visibility of the park sign. The following motion was considered.

CW093-2020 1. That the staff report entitled: Purple Lilac Memorial Park – Air

Canada Crash Site 50th Anniversary Commemoration – Ward 8 (R 105/2020) to the Committee of Council Meeting of May 6, 2020 be received; and

2. That Purple Lilac Park be renamed to Purple Lilac Memorial Park.

Carried

12.1-6

Minutes Committee of Council

2020 05 06 Page 7 of 21

See Item 8.4.1 – Recommendation CW098-2020 8.2.3. Staff Report re: Community Benefits and Fair Wage Policy (RM 119/2019).

Committee discussion on this matter included the following:

Information on the Hammer Heads Program, which supports at-risk youth

The need for external expertise to support the creation of a Fair Wage Policy and Community Benefits at the City, and the proposed estimate for these services ($150,000)

Potential impacts of a Fair Wage Policy and Community Benefits

Stakeholder consultations

Work undertaken by the Region of Peel on Fair Wage Policy and Community Benefits, and a request for information on the cost allocation for the three regional municipalities

A motion to approve the recommendations in the staff report was introduced. The motion was split and clauses 1-3 and clause 4 were voted on separately and carried. The motion, in its entirety, carried as follows.

CW094-2020 1. That the staff report entitled: Community Benefits and Fair Wage Policy (RM 119/2019) to the Committee of Council Meeting of May 6, 2020 be received; and

2. That the Sustainable Procurement Framework as provided in this

report be endorsed and staff be directed to draft a Sustainable Procurement Strategy based on the Framework, for Council consideration;

3. That staff be directed to proceed with a feasibility assessment of

implementing a Brampton-focused Fair Wage Policy and Community Benefits in procurement at the City, and external expertise be engaged to conduct an analysis and develop options for Council consideration as part of a sustainable procurement strategy for the City; and

4. That a budget amendment be approved and a new capital project

be established in the amount of $150,000, with the funding of $150,000 to be transferred from Reserve #4.

Carried

12.1-7

Minutes Committee of Council

2020 05 06 Page 8 of 21

8.2.4. Staff Report re: Noise By-law during Ramadan 2020 (RM 26/2020).

Committee consideration of this matter included the following amendments to the recommendations in the staff report:

To amend clause 2 to provide that the one-time exemption be in place until May 24, 2020, and includes all faiths

To delete clause 3 The motion was considered as follows.

CW095-2020 1. That the staff report entitled: Noise By-law during Ramadan 2020

(RM 26/2020) to the Committee of Council Meeting of May 6, 2020 be received; and

2. That a one-time exemption until May 24, 2020, be made to allow for

the call to prayer (“Azan”), and all faiths, be permitted once per day at sunset for 3 minutes.

Carried

See Item 8.4.2 – Recommendation CW099-2020

8.2.5. Staff Report re: Ethnic Media Advertising Information Report (RM 25/2020).

Committee discussion on this matter included:

lack of information on ethnic media metrics and spending to-date

census data, which indicates a high percentage of Brampton residents speak English

success of town hall meetings in communicating with residents

clarification that a Council decision on ethnic media funding was made at the April 29, 2020 City Council meeting

process for media outlets to apply for advertising opportunities with the City

The following motion was considered.

CW096-2020 That the staff report entitled: Ethnic Media Advertising Information

Report (RM 25/2020) to the Committee of Council Meeting of May 6, 2020 be received.

Carried

8.3. Other/New Business

12.1-8

Minutes Committee of Council

2020 05 06 Page 9 of 21

* 8.3.1. Minutes – Accessibility Advisory Committee – March 10, 2020 CW097-2020 That the Minutes of the Accessibility Advisory Committee Meeting

of March 10, 2020, to the Committee of Council Meeting of May 6, 2020, Recommendations AAC001-2020 to AAC009-2020 be approved, as published and circulated.

Carried

The recommendations were approved as follows:

AAC001-2020 That the agenda for the Accessibility Advisory Committee meeting of March 10, 2020, be approved, as amended to add the following items:

6.6 Verbal update by Shant Goswami, Accessibility Coordinator,

re: Proclamation – June is National Deafblind Awareness Month

6.7 Verbal update by City Clerk’s Office, re: Resignation of the

following members of the Accessibility Advisory Committee

Bikki Singh

Vanessa Scott

AAC002-2020 1. That the delegation from Vasco Alcantara, Business

Development Specialist Accessibility Certification, Rick Hansen Foundation, to the Accessibility Advisory

Committee meeting of March 10, 2020, re: Accessibility Certification Program Accessibility be received; and,

2. That an Accessibility Advisory Committee meeting be

scheduled as required to assist with the process to rank the top twenty-five applications submitted by the Community to receive the complimentary Rick Hansen foundation Accessibility Certification rating.

AAC003-2020 1. That the delegation by Juliet Jackson, Director, Culture and

Inclusion, Region of Peel, and Raj Chopra, Region of Peel & Chair, Regional Accessibility Advisory Committee, to the Accessibility Advisory Committee meeting of March 10, 2020, re: Dynamic Symbol of Access be received; and,

12.1-9

Minutes Committee of Council

2020 05 06 Page 10 of 21

2. That the report to the Accessibility Advisory Committee meeting of March 10, 2020, re: Accessible Parking Space Identification - Dynamic Symbol of Access be received;

3. That the original International Symbol of Access, as set out

in Schedule XXXIX of Traffic By-law 93-93, be confirmed as the sole symbol to be used to indicate accessible parking, barrier-free facilities and amenities for all properties in the City Brampton until provincial legislation provides otherwise; and

4. That the City allow the use of the Dynamic Symbol of Access

on one or more Region of Peel properties in Brampton.

AAC004-2020 That the update by Ryan Maiss, Accessible Enforcement Officer,

Enforcement and By-law Services, to the Accessibility Advisory Committee meeting of March 10, 2020, re: Accessible Enforcement Quarterly Report - Q1-Q4 2019 be received.

AAC005-2020 That the update from Sylvia Ingham, Access Inclusion Diversity Clerk, to

the Accessibility Advisory Committee meeting of March 10, 2020, re: Changes to Accessibility Requirements in Ontario Building Code for 2020 be received.

AAC006-2020 1. That the update by the City Clerk’s Office staff regarding the

resignation of the following two members from the Accessibility Advisory Committee effective March 10, 2020, be accepted:

Bikki Singh

Vanessa Scott

2. That the City Clerk take the necessary steps to fill the two

vacancies in accordance with Clerks Office procedures. AAC007-2020 1. That the correspondence from S. Danton, Legislative

Coordinator, City Clerk's Office, dated January 6, 2020, to the Accessibility Advisory Committee meeting of March 10, 2020, re: Brampton Transit Advisory Committee – Appointment of Representative be received; and,

12.1-10

Minutes Committee of Council

2020 05 06 Page 11 of 21

2. That Franco Spadafora, Member, be appointed to the Brampton Transit Advisory Committee, as the representative from the Accessibility Advisory Committee for the term ending November 14, 2022.

AAC008-2020 1. That the correspondence from S. Pacheco, Legislative

Coordinator, City Clerk's Office, dated January 21, 2020, to the Accessibility Advisory Committee meeting of March 10, 2020, re: Appointment of Accessibility Advisory Committee Member Representative to the Vehicle-for-hire Advisory Committee be received; and,

2. That Franco Spadafora, Member, be appointed to the

Vehicle-for-hire Advisory Committee as the representative from the Accessibility Advisory Committee for the term ending November 14, 2022.

AAC009-2020 That the Accessibility Advisory Committee do now adjourn to meet

again on Tuesday June 9, 2020 at 6:30 p.m., or at the call of the Chair.

8.4. Correspondence

8.4.1. Correspondence from Lynda Fishman, dated May 4, 2020, re: Item 8.2.2 –

Purple Lilac Memorial Park – Air Canada Crash Site 50th Anniversary Commemoration – Ward 8 (R 105/2020).

The following motion was considered.

CW098-2020 That the correspondence from Lynda Fishman, dated May 4, 2020, re: Item 8.2.2 – Purple Lilac Memorial Park – Air Canada Crash Site 50th Anniversary Commemoration – Ward 8, to the Committee of Council Meeting of May 6, 2020, be received.

Carried

See Item 8.2.2 – Recommendation CW093-2020

8.4.2. Correspondence re: Item 8.2.4 – Noise By-law during Ramadan 2020 (RM

26/2020).

The following motion was considered.

12.1-11

Minutes Committee of Council

2020 05 06 Page 12 of 21

CW099-2020 That correspondence from the following individuals, to the Committee of Council Meeting of May 6, 2020, re: Item 8.2.4 – Noise By-law during Ramadan 2020 (RM 26/2020), be received:

1. Ayan Sani, dated May 6, 2020 2. Hasan Alam, dated May 6, 2020 3. Soumen Paul, dated May 6, 2020

Carried

See Item 8.2.4 – Recommendation CW095-2020

8.5. Councillors Question Period – nil

8.6. Public Question Period – nil The public was given the opportunity to submit questions via e-mail to the City Clerk’s Office regarding any decisions made under the Corporate Services Section of the agenda.

P. Fay, City Clerk, confirmed that no questions were submitted regarding decisions made under this section.

9. Public Works and Engineering Section

(Regional Councillor P. Vicente, Chair)

9.1. Staff Presentations – nil

9.2. Reports – nil

9.3. Other/New Business – nil

* 9.3.1. Minutes – Brampton School Traffic Safety Council – March 12, 2020 CW100-2020 That the Minutes of the Brampton School Traffic Safety Council

Meeting of March 12, 2020, to the Committee of Council Meeting of May 6, 2020, Recommendations SC020-2020 to SC032-2020 be approved, as published and circulated.

Carried

12.1-12

Minutes Committee of Council

2020 05 06 Page 13 of 21

The recommendations were approved as follows: SC020-2020 That the agenda for the Brampton School Traffic Safety Council

meeting of March 12, 2020, be approved, as published and circulated.

SC021-2020 That the presentation by Craig Kummer, Senior Manager, Traffic Services, to the Brampton School Traffic Safety Council meeting of March 12, 2020, re: Traffic Calming Mitigation Overview be received.

SC022-2020 1. That the correspondence from Sheryl Griffiths, School Council, to the Brampton School Traffic Safety Council meeting of March 12, 2020, re: Request to Review Park and Ride, Traffic Congestion school street/school property, School Bus Zones – St. Marguerite d'Youville Catholic Secondary School, 10815 Dixie Road – Ward 9 be received; and,

2. That a site inspection be undertaken.

SC023-2020 1. That the correspondence from Sheryl Griffiths, School Council, to the Brampton School Traffic Safety Council meeting of March 12, 2020, re: Request to Review Park and Ride – Goldcrest Public School, 24 Goldcrest Road – Ward 8 be received; and,

2. That a site inspection be undertaken.

SC024-2020 1. That the correspondence from Peter Beratiotis, Brampton resident, to the Brampton School Traffic Safety Council meeting of March 12, 2020, re: Request to Review Park and Ride, Accessibility Parking, Traffic Congestion school street/ school property, School Bus Zones – Grenoble Public School, 33 Greenbriar Road – Ward 8 be received; and,

2. That a site inspection be undertaken.

SC025-2020 1. That the correspondence from Deborah Falcao-Linton, Principal, to the Brampton School Traffic Safety Council meeting of March 12, 2020, re: Request to Review Park and Ride, Traffic Congestion school street/school property, School Bus Zones – Kingswood Drive Public School, 235 Kingswood Drive – Ward 1 be received; and,

12.1-13

Minutes Committee of Council

2020 05 06 Page 14 of 21

2. That a site inspection be undertaken. SC026-2020 That the update by Peter Bryson, Supervisor, Enforcement and By-law

Services, to the Brampton School Traffic Safety Council meeting of March 12, 2020, re: School Patrol Statistics – September 2019 – 2020 be deferred to the next meeting.

SC027-2020 That the site inspection report to the Brampton School Traffic Safety Council meeting of March 12, 2020 re: Request to Review Kiss and Ride, Traffic Congestion on School Street/Crossing Guard on Thursday, January 23, 2020 – Clark Boulevard Public School – 201 Clark Boulevard – Ward 7, be brought forward to the next meeting.

SC028-2020 1. That the Site Inspection report to the Brampton School Traffic

Safety Council meeting of March 12, 2020, re: Thorndale Public School, 133 Thorndale Road – Ward 10 be received; and,

2. That, in an effort to encourage Active Transportation to and from

school, the Principal contact their designated Peel Health Nurse to participate in the School Travel Plan Program in Peel;

3. That the Principal be requested to:

Encourage and educate the school community on safety around the school

Encourage and educate the school community to use the school crossing guard located at the intersection at Thorndale Road and Denim Drive

Advise staff on duty to cone off the area where buses arrive, in order to prevent other drivers from parking in the bus lane

Consider placing the “Kiss & Ride” and “Buses only” signage at the entrance of the property to prevent confusion;

4. That the Senior Manager of Traffic Services be requested to

arrange for the installation of “No-U-turns” restrictions on Thorndale Road, at the front of the school; and,

5. That the Manager of Enforcement and By-Law Services be

requested to arrange for the enforcement of restrictions on Thorndale Road, in the vicinity of the school during arrival and dismissal times.

12.1-14

Minutes Committee of Council

2020 05 06 Page 15 of 21

SC029-2020 1. That the Site Inspection report to the Brampton School Traffic Safety Council meeting of March 12, 2020, re: Sir Wilfrid Laurier Public School – Ward 3 be received; and,

2. That, in an effort to encourage Active Transportation to

and from school, the Principal be requested to contact their designated Peel Health Nurse to participate in the School Travel Plan Program in Peel;

3. That the Senior Manager of Traffic Services be requested

to arrange for:

The review of the “No Parking” restrictions that faces the on-coming traffic on the east side of Bartley Bull Pkwy at the front of the school.

The replacement of the missing School Area signage on Bartley Bull Pkwy south of the school; and,

4. That the Principal be requested to:

Ask the school board to install signage to identify the Kiss and Ride/Bus Loading area

Ask the school board to add pavement markings in the Kiss and Ride/Bus Loading area to help identify the operation

Continue to encourage and educate the school population to always use the crossing guard that is in place to cross Bartley Bull Pkwy

SC030-2020 1. That the Site Inspection report to the Brampton School

Traffic Safety Council meeting of March 12, 2020, re: McClure Public School / St. Jean-Marie Vianney Catholic School / James Potter Public School – Ward 5 be received; and,

2. That, in an effort to encourage Active Transportation to

and from school, the Principal contact their designated Peel Health Nurse to participate in the School Travel Plan Program in Peel;

3. That the Senior Manager of Traffic Services be requested

to arrange for a review of the pedestrian crossing interval times at this intersection to ensure the timing is sufficient for a safe crossing;

12.1-15

Minutes Committee of Council

2020 05 06 Page 16 of 21

4. That a site inspection be scheduled in October 2020, to review the intersection again when the buses have been removed; and,

5. That the Principals of James Potter Public School, St.

Jean-Marie Vianney Catholic School, and McClure Public School, continue to educate and encourage their student population to use this intersection properly.

SC031-2020 1. That the Site Inspection report to the Brampton School

Traffic Safety Council meeting of March 12, 2020, re: Jean Augustine Secondary School – 500 Elbern Markell Drive – Ward 5 be received; and,

2. That the Senior Manager of Traffic Services be requested to arrange for:

The installation of “No Stopping, Mon-Fri,8-5” restrictions on east side of Elbern Markell Drive, from Bovaird Drive to Banbridge Crescent.

A review of Elbern Markell Drive, in the vicinity of the school, with regards to pedestrian crossings

That the Capital Works Department be requested to do a temporary path on the east side of Elbern Markell Drive from Bovaird Drive to Lanark Circle;

3. That the Principal be requested to:

Remove the cones on Elbern Markell Drive at the entrance to the Bus Loading area.

Ask the school board to place signage to identify the Bus Loading and Kiss and Ride areas and educate the parents where they should be dropping off/picking up the students

Ask the school board to place “Buses Only” signage at the entrance to Bus Loading area

Continue to educate and encourage drivers to use the Kiss and Ride operation to pick up/ drop off students at the south end of the school.

4. That staff of the Public Works and Engineering Department be requested to install a sidewalk on the east side of Elbern Markell Drive from Bovaird Drive to Lanark Circle for students to cross Elbern Markell Drive at the intersection of Bovaird Drive and Elbern Markell Drive;

12.1-16

Minutes Committee of Council

2020 05 06 Page 17 of 21

5. That the Manager of Enforcement and By-Law Services be requested to monitor and enforce the “No Stopping” restrictions, once installed, on Elbern Markell Drive during arrival and dismissal times; and,

6. That Peel Regional Police be requested to enforce the “No U-turn” signage, once installed, on Elbern Markell Drive at arrival and dismissal times of the school.

SC032-2020 That the Brampton School Traffic Safety Council meeting of March

12, 2020 do now adjourn to meet again on April 2, 2020 at 9:30 a.m. 9.4. Correspondence – nil

9.5. Councillors Question Period – nil

9.6. Public Question Period – nil The public was given the opportunity to submit questions via e-mail to the City Clerk’s Office regarding any decisions made under the Public Works and Engineering Section of the agenda.

P. Fay, City Clerk, confirmed that no questions were submitted regarding decisions made under this section.

10. Community Services Section

(Regional Councillor R. Santos, Chair)

10.1. Staff Presentations – nil

10.2. Reports – nil

10.3. Other/New Business – nil

*10.3.1. Minutes – Brampton Sports Hall of Fame – March 12, 2020

12.1-17

Minutes Committee of Council

2020 05 06 Page 18 of 21

CW101-2020 That the Minutes of the Brampton Sports Hall of Fame Committee Meeting of March 12, 2020, to the Committee of Council Meeting of May 6, 2020, Recommendations SHF012-2020 to SHF017-2020 be approved, as published and circulated.

Carried

The recommendations were approved as follows:

SHF012-2020 That the agenda for the Brampton Sports Hall of Fame Committee meeting of March 12, 2020, be approved, as amended, to add the following:

7.4 Verbal update by Dean McLeod, Co-Chair, re:

Brampton Beast Game – April 5, 2020

7.5 Discussion at the request of Ziggy Musial, Member, re: Sports Hall of Fame Induction Event – 40th

Anniversary Logo

SHF013-2020 That the presentation by Derek Boyce, Interim Commission of Community Services, to the Sports Hall of Fame meeting of March 12, 2020, re: Sports Hall of Fame Relocation Project Update be received.

SHF014-2020 1. That the discussion at the request of Ziggy Musial, to the Sports Hall of Fame Committee meeting of March 12, 2020, re: Review of Sections 6.4-6.5 and 8.6 in Sports Hall of Fame Constitution be received;

2. That the draft report by Don Doan, Constitution Chair, to the

Sports Hall of Fame Committee meeting of March 12, 2020, re: Proposed Changes to the Sports Hall of Fame Constitution be received;

3. That Sections 3.8, 6.2, 6.4, 6.7 and 8.6 of the Constitution be

amended as outlined in the draft report; 4. That Section 6.5, 1st bullet, be amended, as follows:

Any athlete playing for Canada while representing Brampton who has been a medalist at a World, World Athletics or Olympic event shall be exempt from the three (3) year waiting period; and

12.1-18

Minutes Committee of Council

2020 05 06 Page 19 of 21

5. That the Sports Hall of Fame Constitution be amended as outlined in the recommendation and presented to a future Council meeting for approval.

SHF015-2020 1. That the verbal update by Teri Bommer, Coordinator, Sport

Liaison, to the Sports Hall of Fame Committee meeting of March 12, 2020, re: Options to Maximize Sports Hall of Fame Space at CAA Centre be received.

SHF016-2020 That the update and discussion at the request of Teri Bommer,

Coordinator, Sport Liaison, to the Sports Hall of Fame Committee meeting of March 12, 2020, re: Sports Hall of Induction Event – May 12, 2020 be received.

SHF017-2019 That the Brampton Sports Hall of Fame Committee do now adjourn

to meet again on Thursday, April 2, 2020 at 7:00 p.m. 10.3.2. Discussion at the request of City Councillor Whillans, re: Facility Operations.

City Councillor Whillans outlined the opportunity for staff to undertake general maintenance work at City facilities and parks during the COVID-19 closure, while adhering to physical distancing requirements. D. Boyce, Acting Director, Community Services, advised that staff are working with Human Resources to establish a plan for staff to return to work for this purpose.

10.4. Correspondence – nil

10.5. Councillors Question Period – nil

10.6. Public Question Period – nil The public was given the opportunity to submit questions via e-mail to the City Clerk’s Office regarding any decisions made under the Community Services Section of the agenda.

P. Fay, City Clerk, confirmed that no questions were submitted regarding decisions made under this section.

12.1-19

Minutes Committee of Council

2020 05 06 Page 20 of 21

11. Referred Matters List – nil

12. Public Question Period – nil The public was given the opportunity to submit questions via e-mail to the City Clerk’s Office regarding any decisions made at this meeting.

P. Fay, City Clerk, confirmed that no questions were submitted regarding decisions made at this meeting.

13. Closed Session

13.1. Information explicitly supplied in confidence to the municipality or local board by Canada, a province or territory or a Crown agency of any of them and a position, plan, procedure, criteria or instruction to be applied to any negotiations carried on or to be carried on by or on behalf of the municipality or local board.

The following motion was considered.

CW102-2020 That Committee proceed into Closed Session to discuss matters pertaining to the following:

13.1. Information explicitly supplied in confidence to the municipality or local board by Canada, a province or territory or a Crown agency of any of them and a position, plan, procedure, criteria or instruction to be applied to any negotiations carried on or to be carried on by or on behalf of the municipality or local board.

Carried

In Open Session, the Chair reported on the status of matters considered in Closed Session, as follows:

13.1 – This item was considered by Committee in Closed Session and no direction was given to staff with respect to this matter

14. Adjournment

The following motion was considered.

CW103-2020 That the Committee of Council do now adjourn to meet again on Wednesday, May 20, 2020 at 1:00 p.m. or at the call of the Chair.

Carried

12.1-20

Minutes Committee of Council

2020 05 06 Page 21 of 21

___________________________________ Regional Councillor P. Vicente, Chair Public Works and Engineering Section Acting Chair, Economic Development and

Culture Section

_________________________________ City Councillor H. Singh, Chair Corporate Services Section

___________________________________ Regional Councillor R. Santos, Chair Community Services Section

12.1-21

Page 1 of 4

Red Mile Complete Street Advocacy Group 1211 – 550 Riverfront Ave SE Calgary, AB T2G 1E5 www.redmilecsag.ca April 30, 2020 The Honourable Catherine McKenna Minister of Infrastructure and Communities 180 Kent Street Suite 1100 Ottawa, ON K1P 0B6 RE: National Urban Cycling Strategy and COVID-19 Economic Stimulus Minister McKenna, Over the last few decades urban cycling has been growing in popularity as a transportation mode in the world’s leading cities. Both Calgary and Edmonton have recently undertaken initiatives to create core networks of cycle tracks in their downtowns to encourage a greater number of people to consider cycling as a commuting option. Unfortunately a lack of dedicated funding at the municipal level limits the potential to encourage a shift in commuting habits in Alberta’s cities. A change in perspective on infrastructure priorities must begin at the top. With focus now turning towards stimulus spending to help the Canadian economy recover from COVID-19, the Red Mile Complete Street Advocacy Group strongly believes now is the time for the Government of Canada to implement an urban cycling strategy and support it by providing dedicated urban cycling infrastructure funding to Canadian municipalities. The Red Mile Complete Street Advocacy Group is made up of a small group of Calgarians and was formed to encourage the City of Calgary to further expand on its core urban cycling network to include Calgary’s main shopping and entertainment corridor, 17th Ave. Our advocacy efforts have led to discussions with other cycling advocacy groups in the region and what has become evident to us is that a lack of capital funding is a barrier to completing the existing network plan, let alone expanding on that vision. Unfortunately it seems that in many Canadian cities the planning work to make cycling infrastructure an integral part of the transportation network has been done but the capital funding to follow through with the planning quickly falls victim to austerity measures combined with infrastructure budgets designed to focus primarily on the automobile. While urban cycling infrastructure has typically been dealt with exclusively at the municipal level, the introduction of the Pan-Canadian Framework on Clean Growth and Climate Change by your government has created a clear set of priorities that can be best achieved by providing targeted funding to the municipalities that are responsible for a sizeable amount of Canada’s emissions. The Pan-Canadian Framework has been designed to support reducing emissions and accelerating the transition to a diversified lower carbon economy by investing in transit and infrastructure projects. The record amount of transit investment that has come from the plan should be applauded however investment in infrastructure to encourage urban cycling is low hanging fruit that can go a long way in accomplishing the goals of the Pan-Canadian Framework with a minimal amount of expenditure.

re. Item 18.2 - 1

Page 2 of 4

As our country begins its recovery from the COVID-19 pandemic, government stimulus spending will play a large role in helping the economy recover. Urban cycling infrastructure holds a distinct advantage in terms of infrastructure stimulus spending as projects can begin with little lead time and typically do not involve high levels of construction complexity, which opens up bidding to the largest number of contractors. Due to the fact urban cycling infrastructure uses more labour and less automated processes as well as a greater amount of locally produced materials a University of Massachusetts study found that bicycle infrastructure projects can create up to 46 per cent more jobs than automobile focussed road projects for every $1 million invested. Last but not least, as urban cycling infrastructure typically involves the modification of existing road space, these projects can continue later into the typical construction season allowing Canadians to keep working for as long as possible. As a complementary action to reduce emissions as outlined in the Pan-Canadian Framework as well as an important piece of economic stimulus to put Canadians to work post COVID-19, we are encouraging the Government of Canada to introduce an Urban Cycling Strategy that would deliver two years of targeted funding to Canada’s largest municipalities with the goal of increasing the amount of cycling infrastructure that is integrated in their transportation networks. We are proposing that the plan be structured in the following fashion: Proposed Canadian Urban Cycling Strategy and Two-Year Infrastructure Stimulus Fund: Funding provided to all Canadian cities with census metropolitan areas over 200,000 people. Estimated total program cost of $265 million ($132.5 million each year). Proposed breakdown of funding:

Population between 200,000 & 500,000: $2.5 million per year Population between 500,000 & 1,000,000: $5 million per year Population between 1,000,000 & 1,500,000: $10 million per year Population of 1,500,000+: $15 million per year

Proposed structure of funding: Funds are to be used for the creation of new cycling infrastructure or the upgrading of

existing cycling infrastructure that is designed to be a part of a city’s transportation network. Cycling infrastructure that is primarily for recreational use would not qualify.

Funds are to be used for construction costs only and may be applied towards ancillary projects such as required modifications to traffic signals but may not be used for related items outside the scope of the strategy such as public realm improvements.

Funding prioritization for projects would be done at the municipal level based on local planning needs with the caveat that the goal of the cycling strategy is to increase the size of the urban cycling networks as much as possible and that cycling infrastructure that separates users from automobile traffic (cycle tracks and multi-use pathways) should be prioritized over designs that mix users (painted on-street lanes and sharrows).

A relatively small investment in terms of national infrastructure funding of $265 million spread over two years can deliver over-sized results. In 2014 the City of Calgary started an 18 month pilot project that introduced a core network of cycle tracks in the downtown. The project cost was $5.45 million and created 6.5 km of new cycle tracks in the centre city. The results were impressive and highlight how the goals of the Pan-Canadian Framework can be partially accomplished through investments in urban cycling infrastructure. By structuring the funding as we have proposed, even the smallest municipalities involved in the urban cycling strategy will have the financial capacity to recreate something similar to Calgary’s network.

re. Item 18.2 - 2

Page 3 of 4

Results of Calgary’s cycle track pilot project: The creation of a core connected cycling network was seen as being critical to success. 1.2 million bicycle trips were made between June 18, 2015 and November 20, 2016. The percentage of women riding increased to 30% from 22% The number of Calgary communities where at least 4% of people commuted by bicycle went

from six in 2011 to forty-three in 2016 (shown in blue in the City of Calgary graphic below).

In terms of the impact the new cycle track network had on Calgary’s air pollution it is important to note that a study by the European Cyclists’ Federation found that every kilometer cycled avoids 250 grams of CO2 emissions being generated. Unfortunately further investment in Calgary’s core network has stalled. Edmonton has looked to Calgary’s success and introduced a new 7.8 km core network downtown at a cost of $7.5 million however funding for further expansion is not guaranteed. This pattern of a lack of sustained expansion funding after seeing success in initial urban cycling networks seems to repeat across our country. Creating a national funding strategy enables Canadian cities to move beyond the basic infrastructure that has been built to date and create urban cycling networks that have the critical mass to help drive a shift in commuting habits on an even larger scale than we have seen in Calgary. As the COVID-19 recovery emphasizes the importance of diversifying and boosting our economy it should be noted that cycling infrastructure can play a role in attracting new multi-national companies and the talent they require to Canadian cities. In Edmonton the creation of the new bike lanes was due in large part to the advocacy of engineering giant Stantec on behalf of its employees. Recently Calgary joined several other Canadian cities in competing for the new Amazon HQ2. As part of its competition process Amazon included the following request from applicants; “please also include transit and transportation options for commuting employees living in the region. For each proposed site in your region, identify all transit options, including bike lanes…” Both examples should be seen as proof that large modern corporations see cycling infrastructure as a critical aspect of attracting and retaining talent. Increasing its availability in Canadian cities should be seen as a priority.

re. Item 18.2 - 3

Page 4 of 4

Creating a national urban cycling strategy backed by funding for cycling infrastructure improvements will decrease the need for Canadians to make trips using vehicles, decrease the amount of greenhouse gas emissions, help attract top talent and companies to our cities, improve mobility for people who are working to join the middle class and improve the health and vitality of Canadians. Distributing an estimated $265 million in funding to Canadian cities with more than 200,000 people as part of COVID-19 economic recovery efforts is one of the best ways to rapidly put Canadians to work building projects that can be bid on by smaller firms and inject infrastructure stimulus money that will primarily remain at the local level. This is a win-win in achieving your government’s priorities. We welcome your feedback and any opportunities to discuss the topic further. Best Regards, Jeff Binks Lead Advocate Red Mile Complete Street Advocacy Group E: [email protected]

re. Item 18.2 - 4

May 13, 2020

Dear Mayor Patrick Brown,

As an arts industry professional, and director of a not-for-proft arts organizaton in the city of Brampton, I am constantly challenged to create, re-create, and market brands that are both highly creatie, as well as appealing for the community at large. On behalf of B-Jazzed, I was pleased to collaborate with Councillor Santos and Councillor Vicente in their recent musical tribute to Brampton’s frontline workers with their recording of Lean on Me. In this same spirit of engaging the community at large through the arts during this difcult tme, I am pleased to propose an idea that was born out of productie coniersatons with Councillor Whillans.

Councillor Whillans has an antiue upright grand piano that he was looking to donate to a group or possible church in need of an instrument. Unfortunately, the nostalgia of these instruments has worn of on the public and musicians in general due to the adiancements of digital instruments, portability, and cost. On a positie note, many cites across Canada in recent years haie launched a “Public Piano” initatie, where they take antiue instruments or those lef for disposal, and re-purpose them in parks, municipal spaces, at festials, etc.. A simple Google search will reieal many partcipatng cites, howeier the largest annual initatie is in Montreal, with multple pianos painted a iariety of colors scatered all around the city. They each haie names and indiiidual personalites, due to their eclectc designs and releiance to the neighbourhood in which they reside. Not only do they encourage public performance, but they become a community canias which allows the community to re-paint them at iarious tmes throughout the year, they garner their own hashtags and social media atenton, they contribute to the city’s public art display, and most of all, they contribute to establishing and/or adiancing arts and culture in their respectie municipalites, all initaties which Brampton is desperate for at this tme.

Not only does Councillor Whillans piano lend itself to be purposed in such an initatie, but upon further discussion, it has original roots not only to Brampton, but to our downtown. This instrument originally resided in Christ Church, at 4 Elizabeth St. N., and among its many performers oier the years, one regular pianist was Ken Whillans, Councillor Whillans father, and former Mayor of Brampton. How fing would this piano be as a fiture in the siuare named for one of its ancestors and beloied public seriants, returning home to the downtown core?!?!........and adoptng the name giien to it by Councillor Whillans.... “Kenny’s Keyboard!” residing in Ken Whillans Siuare!

My preliminary estmatons for the feasibility of this project are as follows:

that the piano should be secured either to a permanent structure or shall be secured semi-permanently from its underside or backside to ensure public safety and the preienton of unwanted moiement

that it be protected by a temporary coiering (roof) to prolong its life amidst the natural elements.

that it be displayed outdoors in Ken Whillans Siuare during the spring and summer months

that it be displayed indoors during the fall and winter months in municipal locatons boastng arts, culture, and community, including Rose Theatre lobby/rotunda/2nd foor, Ciiic Centre lobby, Lester B. Pearson Theatre, any library, City Hall

that it be aiailable as a community showpiece/canias during annual festials, including, but not limited to, Rib ‘n’ Roll, Carabram, World of Jazz Festial, Farmers Market, and/or any other eients agreed upon by council.

w ww.b-jazzed.ca www.worldofazz.ca

Item 14.1 - 1

I would like to thank Councillor Whillans for engaging me in such a wonderful initatie for arts and culture in Brampton. I am in full support of how this gesture contributes not only to the brand of Brampton, but also relates to the fabric of our city in a historic way. I hope that yourself as Mayor, along with your colleagues at city council, will agree to the releiance of this project with a majority iote. Atached you will fnd some pictures of eiamples of public pianos from iarious communites. Please know that you haie me at your disposal for any iuestons and/or concerns that you may haie.

Keep up the great work!

Sincerely,

Carmen Spada

Artstc Director

B-Jazzed

P.S. I am happy to accompany all members of council at any song reiuests that you may like to sing once the piano is installed.

Please fll in the blanks below with your faiourite songs!

Mayor Brown________________________________

Councillor Santos- Lean on Me

Councillor Vicente- Lean on Me

Councillor Palleschi____________________________

Councillor Whillans- Margaritaiille

Councillor Medeiros____________________________

Councillor Bowman____________________________

Councillor Fortni______________________________

Councillor Williams____________________________

Councillor Dhillon_____________________________

Councillor Singh______________________________

w ww.b-jazzed.ca www.worldofazz.ca

Item 14.1 - 2

w ww.b-jazzed.ca www.worldofazz.ca

Item 14.1 - 3

Sowing seeds of happiness: Emotional well-being while home gardening similar to

other popular activities,

As civic leaders and urban planners work to make cities more sustainable and livable by

investing in outdoor spaces and recreational activities such as biking and walking,

Princeton researchers have identified the benefit of an activity largely overlooked by

policymakers — home gardening.

The researchers found that, across the study’s population, the level of emotional well-

being, or happiness, reported while gardening was similar to what people reported while

biking, walking or dining out, according to a study published in the journal Landscape and

Urban Planning. Home gardening was the only activity out of the 15 studied for which

women and people with low incomes reported higher emotional well-being than men and

medium- and high-income participants, respectively.

“This has implications for equity in food action planning considering that people with

lower incomes tend to have less access to healthy food options,” said corresponding

author Anu Ramaswami, Princeton’s Sanjay Swani ’87 Professor of India Studies,

professor of civil and environmental engineering and the Princeton Environmental

Institute (PEI). “Gardening could provide the health benefits of fresh fruits and

vegetables, promote physical activity, and support emotional well-being, which can

reinforce this healthy behavior.”

The benefits of gardening on happiness were similar across racial boundaries and

between urban and suburban areas, said first author Graham Ambrose, a research

specialist in Princeton’s Department of Civil and Environmental Engineering. In

addition, whether people gardened alone or with others made no difference, and

people who kept vegetable gardens reported a higher level of average emotional

well-being than people who worked in ornamental gardens.

The findings came from a study of 370 people in the Minneapolis-St. Paul metropolitan

area for which people used a cellphone app called *Daynamica to report their emotional

well-being while engaged in any of 15 daily activities. The app was developed by study

co-author Yingling Fan, a professor of urban and regional planning at the University of

Minnesota, who led a larger emotional well-being study as a part of the National

Science Foundation-funded Sustainable Healthy Cities Network led by Ramaswami. Co-

author Kirti Das, a postdoctoral research associate in civil and environmental

engineering at Princeton, was instrumental in recruiting participants from a range of

communities and in implementing the survey.

As part of ongoing research into urban food systems in Ramaswami’s Sustainable Urban

Infrastructure Systems Lab, she and Ambrose contributed questions to the survey that

Item 14.2 - 1

specifically related to household vegetable gardening. While the social and

environmental benefits of community gardens are hot topics in urban research, available

data seem to fall short when it comes to gardening in individual households, Ambrose

said.

“People know where community gardeners garden, but it is hard to know who is

gardening at home, which our group uniquely identified,” Ambrose said. For example,

study authors found that 31% of participants engaged in home gardening for about 90

minutes per week on average, compared to 19% who engaging in biking (an average of

30 minutes each week) and 85% who walked (an average of one hour and 40 minutes

each week).

“Many more people garden than we think and it appears that it associates with

higher levels of happiness similar to walking and biking,” Ramaswami said. “In the

movement to make cities more livable, gardening might be a big part of

improving quality-of-life.”

The researchers found that home gardening was among the top five activities in

terms of how meaningful an activity felt to people while engaging in it.

“The high levels of meaningfulness that respondents reported while gardening

might be associated with producing one’s own food,” Ambrose said. “The boost to

emotional well-being is comparable to other leisure activities that currently get

the lion’s share of infrastructure investment. These findings suggest that, when

choosing future well-being projects to fund, we should pay just as much attention

to household gardening.”

A few cities have conducted pilot household gardening projects with promising

results. For example, a project operated by the Phipps Conservatory and Botanical

Gardens in Pittsburgh provided participants with materials and training to start a

garden at home. In 2017, three years after the project began, 70% of participants

were still actively gardening.

The researchers of the current study plan to replicate this work among community

gardeners in order to compare the emotional benefit of household gardens versus

community gardens, Ramaswami said. These results will be important for food action

planning in cities such as Minneapolis where Ramaswami has an ongoing project with

community members and organizations, as well as the City of Minneapolis, to develop a

food action plan.

The paper, “Is gardening associated with greater happiness of urban residents? A multi-

activity, dynamic assessment in the Twin-Cities region, USA,” was published in the June

2020 issue of Landscape and Urban Planning. This research was conducted as part of the

Sustainable Healthy Cities Network, a collaboration funded by the National Science

Foundation’s Sustainable Research Network (award number 1444745) between

universities, cities, governments, nongovernmental organizations and industry partners

Item 14.2 - 2

working together to develop the science and practical knowledge necessary for

achieving sustainable, healthy and livable cities.

The app was developed by study co-author Yingling Fan, a professor of urban and regional planning at the University of Minnesota, who led a larger emotional well-being study as a part of the National Science Foundation-funded Sustainable Healthy Cities Network led by Ramaswami. Co-author Kirti Das, a postdoctoral research associate in civil and environmental engineering at Princeton, was instrumental in recruiting participants from a range of communities and in implementing the survey.

Daynamica, Inc. is a University of Minnesota-backed start-up company that provides solutions for collecting, processing, and understanding human activity and travel behavior data. The smartphone application captures detailed daily activity and trip data with minimal user burden. The app allows researchers to collect more detailed, reliable, and longer-term data on human activity than traditional diary-based techniques.

Item 14.2 - 3