materialism - our forgotten foundation

7/25/2019 Materialism - Our Forgotten Foundation

1/56

!"#$%&"'&()*+% -.%/.##$0 -.+01"#&.0

23$ 4&.0$$%( 56$"7


2/56

!"# %&'%()# (* +",) -((./#+ ,) +( -',01 +( +"# 2++#0+,(0 (* +"# 345#0+%#(%/#6 -(+" 7,0,)+#') 204 /28%#')(0) 2/,.#6 (0# (* +"# (*+ *('1(++#0

*(&042+,(0) (* (&' *2,+"9 +"2+ -#,016 72+#',2/,)7: ;0 )"('+6 (&' *2,+" 2),+",0 +"# *'27#>('. (*7#+2%"8),?2/ 72+#',2/,)76 +"# -#/,#* +"2+ 2// +",01) ,0 +"# &0,5#')# 2'#?(7%()#4 (* (0/8 (0# +8%# (* *&0427#0+2/ )&-)+20?# @ 72++#': !",))+204) ,0 ?(0+'2)+ >,+" ,4#2/,)+,? %",/()(%",#)6 >",?" )&-7,+ +"2+ 2//+",01) 2'# &/+,72+#/8 0(0=%"8),?2/6 204 4&2/,)+,? %",/()(%",#)6 >",?"#)%(&)# +"# #A,)+#0?# (* -(+" +"# %"8),?2/ 204 +"# 0(0=%"8),?2/:

B#'#,0 8(& >,// C04 2 0(0=#A"2&)+,5# ?(7%,/2+,(0 (* D&(+2+,(0) *'(7 +"#>',+,01) (* +"#


3/56

O2+#',2/,)7 @ P&' Q('1(++#0 Q(&042+,(0 G

"##$% &'()$ *% +(*%$$, -$.)(/*%0

L# 2'# 0(> +( &04#')+204 >"2+ +"# %,//2') (* (&' *2,+" 2'#6R+"#+'&+") +"2+ "25# 724# &) 2) 2 %#(%/# >"2+ ># 2'#6 /#24,01 &) (0 )+#%-8 )+#%: = S//#0 L",+#6!"#$"% '() *"+',)-O28 IT: GUMT6 %2': IJ

L"#0 7#0 ?(7# ,0 >"( >(&/4 7(5# (0# %,0 (' %,//2' *'(7 +"#*(&042+,(0 >",?" V(4 "2) #)+2-/,)"#4 -8 B,) B(/8 ('. )%#2. %/2,0/86 204 /#+ +"()# >"(

2'# 4#24 )%#2. 2/)( -8 '#%',0+,01 (* +"#,' 2'+,?/#) ,0 (&' %#',(4,?2/):V2+"#' &% +"# '28) (* 4,5,0# /,1"+ +"2+ V(4 "2) 1,5#0 2) B# "2) /#4B,) %#(%/# (0 )+#% -8 )+#% ,0 +"# >28 (* +'&+": !",) +'&+" >,// )+204 +"#+#)+ (* +,7# 204 +',2/: = S//#0 L",+#6 O)NI=GUMT

1232 4*55(%.

O3!SW;3X;",?" #A?,+#) 7('# (%%(),+,(0 ,0 +"# %'(*#))#4K"',)+,20 >('/46 +"20 +"# )&-Y#?+ 2+ +"# "#24 (* +",) 2'+,?/#: ;+ ,) ?2//#4,0C4#/,+8 204 2+"#,)76 >",/# ,+) -#/,#5#') 2'# /((.#4 &%(0 >,+")&)%,?,(0 204 ?(0+#7%+: 3 7,0,)+#' (* 78 2?D&2,0+20?# >"( 2 *#>7(0+") 21( >2) *25('2-/# 204 %&-/,?/8 ?(77,++#4 ",7)#/* +( +"#


4/56

I O2+#',2/,)7 @ P&' Q('1(++#0 Q(&042+,(0

#?)+2),#) >,+" >",?" ,+ ,) ,7%()),-/# +( )87%2+",_#:]!"# "(/4#') (* +",) ,721,02+,(0 *('1#+ 2// +"# >",/# +"2+ '#2//8

+"#'# ,) 0( #))#0+,2/ ?(00#?+,(0 -#+>##0 72+#',2/,)7 204 ),09 +"2+ +"#>('/4 >",?" ># 0(> ,0"2-,+ "24 2// +"# 27%/,+&4# 204 )(/,4,+8 (* ,+)%'#)#0+ 72+#',2/,)7 -#*('# ),0 #0+#'#4 ,0+( ,+9 +"2+ V(4 )( *2' (0 +"2+2??(&0+ *'(7 /((.,01 )/,1"+/8 &%(0 ,+ 2*+#' ,+ "24 '#?#,5#4 +"# /2)++(&?" (* ",) ?'#2+,01 "2046 '#5,#>#4 +"# #2'+" 204 2// +"# 1'##0"#'-21#6 >,+" +"# /,5,01 ?'#2+&'#) 204 +"# 720 >"(7 "# "24 '2,)#4 ,04(7,0,(0 (5#' +"#76 204 "# )2> #5#'8 +",01 +"2+ "# "24 724#6 204-#"(/4 ,+ >2) 2// 5#'8 1((4:

]!"#8 *('1#+ 2// +"# >",/# +"2+ (0 +"# -,'+" (* 72+#',2/,)76 >"#0 ,+)+((4 (&+ ,0 +"# *'#)"0#)) (* +"()# 1/(',#) >",?" +"# 1'#2+ 3'?",+#?+ (*02+&'# "24 ,7%'#))#4 &%(0 ,+6 +"2+ +"#0 +"# `7('0,01 )+2') )201+(1#+"#'6 204 2// +"# )(0) (* V(4 )"(&+#4 *(' Y(8:`

]!"#8 *('1#+ +"# 2%%#2/) +"2+ 2'# 724# #5#'8>"#'# ,0 +"# Z,-/# +(+",) 72+#',2/ >('.720)",%6 204 "(> *'(7 +"# *2?# (* +"#)# 5,),-/#"#25#0)6 204 +"# 12'0,+&'# (* +",) #2'+" &%(0 >",?" ># +'#246 +"#

1'#2+0#)) 204 1((40#)) (* V(4 2'# '#^#?+#4 (0 +"# 5,#> (* ",)>(')",%#'):]a(6 +"# (-Y#?+ (* +"# 247,0,)+'2+,(0 ># 2'# &04#'6 ,) +( #A+,'%2+#

),06 -&+ 0(+ +( )>##% 2>28 72+#',2/,)79 +"# C'#) (* +"# /2)+ 428 7287#/+ ,+) )(/,4 #/#7#0+) &0+,/ +"#8 2'# &++#'/8 4,))(/5#46 -&+ (&+ (* +"#'&,0) (* +",) )#?(04 ?"2() 20(+"#' #2'+" >,// 2',)# 2 0#> 72+#',2/,)7,0 -#2&+8 204 7210,C?#0?# 2 `0#> "#25#0) 204 0#> #2'+" >"#'#,04>#//#+" ',1"+#(&)0#)):`

Z&+ 2 Z,-/# 5,#> (* +",) )&-Y#?+ 72.#) ,+ %/2,0 204 ?/#2'9 *(' 2 Z,-/#*2,+" ,) *(&04#4 &%(0 1/(',(&) '#2/,+,#)6 204 0(+ &%(0 72+#',2/)"24(>):

B#-: GGEG ]a(> *2,+" ,) +"# )&-)+20?# (* +",01) "(%#4 *('6 +"##5,4#0?# (* +",01) 0(+ )##0:] B#'# +' *2,+" ,) CA#4 &%(0 +",01)6 &%(0+",01) )&-)+20+,2/9 204 "(%# /((.) *(' 2 )&-)+20?#6 204 0(+,772+#',2/,+8: !",) ,) #5,4#0+ >"#0 ># ?(0),4#' +"# (-Y#?+ (* *2,+" 204"(%# 2) 7#0+,(0#4 -8 b2&/ ,0 +",) ?"2%+#'9 *(' -8 *2,+" S0(?" 204

a(2" 204 3-'2"27 >,+" ;)22? 204 c2?(- +"# "#,') >,+" ",7 (* +"#)27# %'(7,)#6 ]/((.#4 *(' 2 ?,+8 >",?" "2+" *(&042+,(0)6 >"()#-&,/4#' 204 72.#' ,) V(46] +"# )27# ?,+8 >",?" ;)2,2" %'(%"#),#4 (*,0 +"# NT+" ?"2%+#'6 204 +"2+ c("0 )2> 204 4#)?',-#4 ,0 ,+) /,+#'2/672+#',2/ 1/(',#)6 2) ?(7,01 4(>0 *'(7 V(4 (&+ (* "#25#0: b2&/ )28)2/)( ,0 B#-: GGEGd=GN6 ]Q(' +"#8 +"2+ )28 )&?" +",01) F+"2+ +"#8 2'#


5/56

O2+#',2/,)7 @ P&' Q('1(++#0 Q(&042+,(0 J

%,/1',7) 204 )+'201#')H 4#?/2'# %/2,0/8 +"2+ +"#8 )##. 2 ?(&0+'8: 304+'&/8 ,* +"#8 "24 -##0 7,04*&/ (* +"2+ ?(&0+'8 *'(7 >"#0?# +"#8 ?27#

(&+ +"#8 7,1"+ "25# "24 (%%('+&0,+8 +( '#+&'0: Z&+ 0(> +"#8 4#),'# 2-#++#' ?(&0+'86 +"2+ ,)6 20 "#25#0/89 >"#'#*('# V(4 ,) 0(+ 2)"27#4 +(-# ?2//#4 +"#,' V(49 *(' "# "2+" %'#%2'#4 *(' +"#7 2 ?,+8:] B#'# +"#*2,+" (* +"# 20?,#0+ >('+",#)6 +"# 7(4#/ *2,+" *(' 2// -#/,#5#')6 CA#4,+)#/* &%(0 '#2/,+,#)9 204 "(%# /((.#4 *(' 2 ?(&0+'8 204 2 ?,+86,7%/8,01 72+#',2/,)7:

Z&+ 20(+"#' #5,4#0?# +"2+ 72+#',2/,)7 #0+#') ,0+( +"# *2,+" 204"(%# (* +"# +' -#/,#5#'6 ,) +"# %'(7,)# (* ]0#> "#25#0) 204 0#>#2'+" >"#'#,0 4>#//#+" ',1"+#(&)0#)):] !"# %'(7,)# ,) ,0 ;)2,2" NTEGU6#+?6 ]Q(' -#"(/4 ; ?'#2+# 0#> "#25#0) 204 2 0#> #2'+"6] #+?: !"# 0#>#2'+" ,0 +",) %'(7,)# ,) +"# ?(&0+'8 /((.#4 *(' -8 b2&/`) >('+",#)6 204,) 72+#',2/9 -#?2&)# ,0 5#')# IG ,+ )28)6 ]304 +"#8 )"2// -&,/4 "(&)#)204 ,0"2-,+ +"#76 +"#8 )"2// %/20+ 5,0#82'4) 204 #2+ +"# *'&,+ (* +"#76]#+?:

; .0(> +"2+ +"# %(%&/2' *2,+" (-Y#?+) +( +",) %'(%"#?8 2) 4#)?',%+,5#

(* +"# >('/4 +( ?(7#9 -&+ +"# 2%%/,?2+,(0 (* +"# %'(7,)# -8 +"# 2%()+/#)#++/#) +"# D)+,(0 +( 78 7,046 204 ; /#25# +"# ?(0+'(5#')8 -#+>##0+"#7 204 +"# 2%()+/#: B# )28)6 2*+#' 2*C'7,01 +"# 4,))(/&+,(0 (* +"#"#25#0) 204 +"# #2'+" >",?" 2'# 0(>6 ]a#5#'+"#/#)) ># 2??('4,01 +(",) %'(7,)# /((. *(' 0#> "#25#0) 204 2 0#> #2'+" >"#'#,0 4>#//#+"',1"+#(&)0#)):] I b#+#' JEGJ: c("0 )28)6 ]; )2> 2 0#> "#25#0) 204 20#> #2'+"6] #+?: ]304 ; "#2'4 2 1'#2+ 5(,?# (&+ (* "#25#0 )28,016Z#"(/4 +"# +2-#'02?/# (* V(4 ,) >,+" 7#06 204 "# >,// 4>#// >,+"

+"#76] #+?: W#5: IGEG=J: ]304 +"#'# )"2// -# 0( 7('# ?&')#6 -&+ +"#+"'(0# (* V(4 204 +"# X27- )"2// -# ,0 ,+:] W#5: IIEJ: B#'#72+#',2/,)7 ,) "(0('#4 204 1/(',C#4 +( -#?(7# +"# 4>#//,01 %/2?# (*+"# 1/(',(&) V(46 204 +"# )#2+ (* ",) '#12/ 2&+"(',+8 204 %(>#':

312,09 72+#',2/,)7 ,) 20 #))#0+,2/ #/#7#0+ ,0 +"# *2,+" 204 "(%# (*+"# +' -#/,#5#' ,0 '#12'4 +( +"# '#)&''#?+,(0 *'(7 +"# 4#24: ",?" ,) 0(> )%'#24

2-'(24 (5#' +"# >"(/# "&720 *27,/8: !"# (/4 *2-',? 7&)+ -# +2.#04(>0 204 '#2'#4 20#>6 204 +"2+ 0(+ (* (+"#' 72+#',2/)6 -&+ (* ,+) (>072+#',2/) (0/8 4#/,5#'#4 (* 2// ,7%&',+8: ;+ ,) +"&) +"2+ >"2+ ,) `)(>0 ,0>#2.0#)) ,) '2,)#4 ,0 %(>#':` `;+ ,) )(>0 ,0 ?(''&%+,(0 F(' (* ?(''&%+,-/#72+#',2/H6 ,+ ,) '2,)#4 ,0 ,0?(''&%+,(0 F(' ,0?(''&%+,-/# 72+#',2/H:` O2'.6,+ ,) +"# )27# ,+9 `;+ ,) )(>0 ,0 4,)"(0('6 ,+ ,) '2,)#4 ,0 1/('8:` `Q(' +",)


6/56

d O2+#',2/,)7 @ P&' Q('1(++#0 Q(&042+,(0

?(''&%+,-/# F>"2+e +",) 72+#',2/,+8[H 7&)+ %&+ (0 ,0?(''&%+,(06 204 +",)7('+2/ 7&)+ %&+ (0 ,77('+2/,+8: !"#0 >,// -# -'(&1"+ +( %2)) +"#

)28,01 >",?" ,) >',++#06 \#2+" ,) )>2//(>#4 &% ,0 5,?+('8:`] B#'# +"#0+"# #5,4#0?# ,) ?(0?/&),5#: !",) ?(''&%+,-/# 72+#',2/,+8 ,) +( -#,0?(''&%+,-/# (' ,77('+2/6 204 +"# ?",/4'#0 -('0 ,0 +"# '#)&''#?+,(02'# +( %())#)) *('76 +201,-,/,+8 204 ,4#0+,+8:

Z&+ +"#'# ,) 2 ?'(>0,01 1/('8 +( 72+#',2/,)7 (5#'/((.#4 -8 (&'(%%(0#0+)6 204 4#0,#4 -8 7208 (* +"#79 c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c#)&) #5#'8 .0## 7&)+ -(>6 204 #5#'8+(01 ?(0*#)) +( +"# 1/('8 (* V(4 +"# Q2+"#':

f#)6 204 +"2+ "&720,+86 +"2+ #7-(4,#4 204 )&-)+20+,2/ "&720,+86>,// -# +"# ?#0+#' (* &0,5#')2/ %'2,)# 204 24('2+,(0 *'(7 2// ?'#2+&'#)6*(' #5#' 204 #5#': 37#0:

a(> ># 2).6 \(#) +",) /((. /,.# +"# 2-(/,+,(0 (* 72+#',2/,)7 2*+#'+"# %'#)#0+ )8)+#7 (* ,+ ,) 4#)+'(8#4[ \(#) ,+ 0(+ '2+"#' %'(5# +"2+ ,0+"# >('/4 +( ?(7# ,+ >,// -# %'#*#''#4 +( ?#/#)+,2/ "(0(')6 204%'(/(01#4 ,0 ,77('+2/,+8 +( 2// #+#'0,+8[

a(> +( 7#6 +"# ?"2'1#) 212,0)+ &) -8 (&' (%%(0#0+) )( +#02?,(&)/8

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

,0+#'%'#+2+,(06 204 +"&) +"#,' 5,#>) -#?(7# 2 7#'# ?(0Y#?+&'#6 +",01)(* 7#'# *20?8 204 ,721,02+,(0 >,+"(&+ 208 *(&042+,(0 *(' *2,+"6 (')&'# 1'(&04 *(' "(%#:

K"##'*&//8 +"#0 >,// ># %2+,#0+/8 )&-7,+ +( +"# ,7%&+2+,(0) 204)?('0 (* (&' (%%(0#0+): !"#8 0(> "25# +"# %(>#'6 204 +"#,' ,0^?#728 2*CA +"# -'204 (* ,0C4#/,+8 ,0 +"# #)+,72+,(0 (* +"# &0+",0.,01


7/56

O2+#',2/,)7 @ P&' Q('1(++#0 Q(&042+,(0 T

7&/+,+&4# &%(0 &)9 -&+ (&' *2,+" ,) +"# )27# 2) +"2+ (* +"# 20?,#0+>('+",#) >",?" >2) 2%%'(5#4 204 "(0('#4 -8 +"# ,// C02//8 -# *(&04 &0+( %'2,)# 204 "(0(' 204 1/('8 2+ +"#2%%#2',01 (* c#)&) K"',)+: 37#0:G

6272 8*9:'5*,*9:'

!"# C')+ 7#0+,(0 724# (* 720 ,0 +"# Z,-/# ,) ,0 +"# 2??(&0+ (* +"#/2-(' (* +"# ),A+" 4286 V#0: GEIN: ]304 V(4 )2,46 /#+ &) 72.# 720 ,0

(&' ,721#6 2*+#' (&' /,.#0#))9 204 /#+ +"#7 "25# 4(7,0,(0: #+?:6] g#')#Ih6 ],+"(&+ -(48 (' %2'+)6] 204 )(7# )28 >,+"(&+ %2)),(0): ;* +",) -# +"#?2)#6 +"#0 720`) -#,01 ,0 +"# ,721# (* V(46 7&)+ "25# )(7# (+"#'

#A%/202+,(06 +"20 +"2+ ",) *('7 >2) /,.# V(4: ;+ "2) -##0 ?/2,7#4 +"2++",) >2) 2 7('2/ ,721#9 +"2+ ,)6 720 >2) *('7#4 >,+" 2 ?"2'2?+#' /,.#V(49 204 2) V(4 ,) ,77('+2/6 7206 +( -# /,.# ",7 7('2//86 7&)+ 2/)(-# ,77('+2/: O('2/ %#'+2,0) +( ?"2'2?+#': 3/+"(&1" +"# >('4 )+2+#)6V(4 %'(0(&0?#4 2// ",) >('. 5#'8 1((46 8#+ 7206 2) ># )"2// )"(>6>2) /#*+ +( *('7 ",) (>0 ?"2'2?+#':

Z&+ ,0 ?2''8,01 (&+ +",) 72++#' ># >,)" +( ,0D&,'# *&'+"#' ,0 '#12'4+( 720`) ?'#2+,(0: V#0: IEh )+2+#)6 ]304 +"# X('4 V(4 *('7#4 720 (*

+"# 4&)+ (* +"# 1'(&046 204 -'#2+"#4 ,0+( ",) 0()+',/) +"# -'#2+" (* /,*#9204 720 -#?27# 2 /,5,01 )(&/:] ;* +"# ,721# (* V(4 '#*#''#4 +( ,0?"2%+#' C')+ ,) 2 7('+2/ ,721#6 +"#0 +"# 4&)+ (* +"# 1'(&04 >2) ,0 +"#7('2/ ,721# (* V(4: O20 >2) ,0 +"# ,721# (* V(4 -#*('# +"# -'#2+"(* /,*# >2) -'#2+"#4 ,0+( ",79 2*+#'>2'4) "# ,) ?2//#4 2 /,5,01 )(&/: L#)## 2+ (0?# +"2+ +",) ,721# (* V(4 ,0 >",?" 720 ,) *('7#4 ?200(+ -# 27('2/ ,721#9 *(' ,+ >(&/4 ,05(/5# +"# 2-)&'4,+8 +"2+ ,020,72+# 72++#'%())#))#4 2 ?"2'2?+#' /,.# V(4: ;* ,+ -# 2 *2?+ +"2+ 720 >2) 724#

/,+#'2//8 ,0 +"# ,721# (* V(46 ># "25# -##0 +2&1"+ >'(01 ,0 '#12'4 +(+"# 02+&'# (* +"2+ V(4:

!",) /#24) &) +( +"# ,05#)+,12+,(0 (* +"# 0#?#))2'8 ,0D&,'86

;< VP\ 3 bSW


8/56

N O2+#',2/,)7 @ P&' Q('1(++#0 Q(&042+,(0

L"2+#5#' 728 -# +"# +'&+" ,0 +",) 72++#'6 ,+ ?#'+2,0/8 ?200(+ -#>'(01 *(' &) +( #A27,0# >"2+ +"# L('4 )28) '#)%#?+,01 ,+: O208 +"#'#

2'# +"2+ >(&/4 '#*'2,0 *'(7 +"# ,05#)+,12+,(0 (* &0%(%&/2' +'&+")-#?2&)# +"# ?'8 (* "#'#)8 ,) '2,)#4 212,0)+ +"#7: L# )"2// 0(+ ?(0),4#'(&')#/5#) )&-Y#?+) (* +"# 2%%#//2+,(06 0#,+"#' 2'# ># %'8,01 ,0+( +"#)#?'#+) (* +"# 3/7,1"+86 2) ># %&') +"# ,05#)+,12+,(0 (* +",) 72++#':!"# Z,-/# ?#'+2,0/8 ?(0+2,0) +#)+,7(08 &%(0 +",) %(,0+6 204 ># 212,0'#%#2+6 ]!",01) >",?" 2'# '#5#2/#4 -#/(01 +( &):] L# ,0D&,'# +"#06L"2+ )2,+" +"#


9/56

O2+#',2/,)7 @ P&' Q('1(++#0 Q(&042+,(0 h

+( *&/C// +",) ?(77,)),(0: Z&+ ",) ",?""# >('.): ]Z&+ ,* +"# ##0 +"# 2) ?'&?,C#46 4#246 204 -&',#46 >2) '2,)#4 *'(7 +"#4#246 2)?#04#4 &% +( "#25#06 204 ,) 0(> 2+ +"# ',1"+ "204 (* V(4:c#)&) >2) %())#))#4 (* ^#)" 204 -(0#) 2*+#' ",) '#)&''#?+,(0: X&.#

IdEJU: ]Z#"(/4 78 "204) 204 78 *##+6 +"2+ ,+ ,) ;6 78)#/*9 "204/# 7#6204 )##9 *(' 2 )%,',+ "2+" 0(+ ^#)" 204 -(0#) 2) 8# )## 7# "25#:] ;*c#)&) ,) +"#'# ,0 "#25#0 >,+" 2 /,+#'2/ -(48 (* ^#)" 204 -(0#)6 728 0(+"#25#0 2*+#' 2// -# 2 /,+#'2/ %/2?#6 2 "2-,+2+,(0 *(' 2 /,+#'2/ V(46 2/,+#'2/ ",?" ,) -('0 (* +"#


10/56

i O2+#',2/,)7 @ P&' Q('1(++#0 Q(&042+,(0

*'(7 +"# +#A+ >",?" )28) ]V(4 ,) 2 +#A+) >",?" %'(5# +"2+ V(4 ,) 2 %#')(0:

SA: JJEGi6 IJ: ]304 "# FO()#)H )2,46 ; -#)##?" +"## )"#> 7# +"81/('8:] g#')# IM: ]304 "# )2,46 !"(& ?20)+ 0(+ )## 78 *2?#6 *(' +"#'#)"2// 0( 720 )## 7# 204 /,5#:] g#')#) IG=IJ: ]304 +"# X('4 )2,46Z#"(/4 +"#'# ,) 2 %/2?# -8 7#6 204 +"(& )"2/+ )+204 &%(0 2 '(?.E 204 ,+)"2// ?(7# +( %2)) >",/# 78 1/('8 %2))#+" -86 +"2+ ; >,// %&+ +"## ,0 2?/#*+ (* +"# '(?.9 204 >,// ?(5#' +"## >,+" 78 "204 >",/# ; %2)) -89 204; >,// +2.# 2>28 7,0# "2046 204 +"(& )"2/+ )## 78 -2?. %2'+)9 -&+ 78*2?# )"2// 0(+ -# )##0:] ;* V(4 ,) 20 ,772+#',2/ # 2'# +(/4 2 )%,',+ ?200(+ -# )##0 -8 02+&'2/#8#): !"#'# >(&/4 +"#0 -# 0( %'(%',#+8 *(' V(4 +( )28 "# >(&/4 %&+",) "204 (5#' O()#)` *2?# >",/# "# %2))#4 -86 F)##7,01/8 +( %'#5#0+",7 *'(7 )##,01 ",) *2?#6H *(' "# ?(&/4 0(+ )## ",7: a#,+"#' 4( >#?(0?#,5# "(> 20 ,772+#',2/ "204 ?(&/4 (-)+'&?+ +"# '28) (* /,1"+ *'(7%2)),01 +( O()#)` #8#): Z&+ ,* +"# %(),+,(0 -# +' +"2+ V(4 ,),772+#',2/6 204 ?200(+ -# )##0 -8 +"# 02+&'2/ #8#6 +"# +#A+ 2-(5# ,) 2//

)&%#'^&(&): L"2+ )#0)# ,) +"#'# ,0 )28,01 V(4 %&+ ",) "204 (5#'O()#)` *2?#6 +( %'#5#0+ ",7 *'(7 )##,01 +"2+ >",?" ?(&/4 0(+ -# )##0:# ?200(+ "2'7(0,_# +"# 72++#' 208 (+"#' >286

+"2+ +"2+ +"#'# >2) 2 /,+#'2/ -(48 )##0 -8 O()#)9 -&+ +"2+ >2) 0(+V(4`) (>0 -(486 ,+ >2) 2 -(48 "# +((. +"2+ "# 7,1"+ )"(> ",7)#/* +(O()#): O()#) ?(&/4 *('7 0( Y&)+ ?(0?#%+,(0) (* V(4 &0/#)) "#2))&7#4 2 *('7: #0+ &% O()#) 204 32'(06 a242- 204 3-,"&6204 )#5#0+8 (* +"# #/4#') (* ;)'2#/9 204 +"#8 )2> +"# V(4 (* ;)'2#/E 204+"#'# >2) &04#' ",) *##+ 2) ,+ >#'# 2 %25#4 >('. (* 2 )2%%",'# )+(0#6204 2) ,+ >#'# +"# -(48 (* "#25#0 ,0 ,+) ?/#2'0#)):] !"#8 >#'#

%#'7,++#4 +( )## ",) *##+6 -&+ 0( 720 ?20 )## ",) *2?# 204 /,5#: a(7('+2/ #8# ?20 -#2' +"# 42__/,01 -',1"+0#)) (* +"# 1/('8 (* +"# *2?# (*V(4: ;+ *2' #A?##4) +"# /,1"+ (* +"# )&0: Q(' +"# %'(%"#+ )28)6 ]!"#/,1"+ (* +"# 7((0 )"2// -# 2) +"# /,1"+ (* +"# )&06 204 +"# /,1"+ (* +"#)&0 )"2// -# )#5#0 *(/46 2) +"# /,1"+ (* )#5#0 428)6 ,0 +"# 428 +"2+ +"#X('4 -,04#+" &% +"# -'#2?" (* ",) %#(%/#6 204 "#2/#+" +"# )+'(.# (*


11/56

O2+#',2/,)7 @ P&' Q('1(++#0 Q(&042+,(0 U

+"#,' >(&04:] ;)2: JMEIN: a(+>,+")+204,01 +",) )#5#0=*(/4 /,1"+ +"2+ ,)+"#0 +( )",0#6 +"# %'(%"#+ )%#2.,01 (* +"# )?#0# )28)6 ]!"#0 +"# 7((0

)"2// -# ?(0*(&04#46 204 +"# )&0 2)"27#46 >"#0 +"# X('4 (* "()+))"2// '#,10 ,0 7(&0+ n,(06 204 ,0 c#'&)2/#76 204 -#*('# ",) 20?,#0+)1/(',(&)/8:] ;)2: IdEIJ: !"# +#)+,7(08 (* c("0 ,) lW#5: IGEIJ:m ]304+"# ?,+8 "24 0( 0##4 (* +"# )&06 0#,+"#' (* +"# 7((06 +( )",0# ,0 ,+E *('+"# 1/('8 (* V(4 4,4 /,1"+#0 ,+6 204 +"# X27- ,) +"# /,1"+ +"#'#(*:]

;0C4#/) ?/2,7 +"2+ +"#'# ,) 2 ?(0+'24,?+,(0 ,0 +"# +#)+,7(08 (*O()#)6 -#?2&)# "# )2,46 "# +2/.#4 >,+" V(4 *2?# +( *2?#: L# '#%/86+"#'# >2) 2 ?/(&4 -#+>##0 +"#76 -&+ V(4 +(/4 O()#)6 ]a( 720 )"2/+)## 7# 204 /,5#:] !"# !#)+,7(08 (* +"# a#> !#)+27#0+ ,) ,0 "2'7(08>,+" +"2+ (* +"# P/4 &%(0 +",) )&-Y#?+: ]Q(//(> %#2?# >,+" 2// 7#06204 "(/,0#)) >,+"(&+ >",?" 0( 720 )"2// )## +"# X('4:] B#-: GIEGd:L"( >,+" 7('+2/ #8#) ?(&/4 -#"(/4 2 /,1"+ +"2+ *2' (&+)",0#) )#5#0*(/4 +"# -',1"+0#)) (* +"# )&0[ # ?200(+ )## V(4 0(> 204 /,5#6 +"# %'(7,)# ,)6 +"2+

+"# %&'# ,0 "#2'+ )"2// )## ",7: O2++: TEJ: ]Z/#))#4 2'# +"# %&'# ,0"#2'+6 *(' +"#8 )"2// )## V(4:] W#5: IIEd: ]304 +"#8 )"2// )## ",) *2?#6204 ",) 027# )"2// -# ,0 +"#,' *('#"#24):]

b2&/6 lK(/: GEGT:m )%#2.,01 (* K"',)+6 )28)6 ]L"( ,) +"# ,721# (* +"#,05,),-/# V(46 +"# C')+ -('0 (* #5#'8 ?'#2+&'#:] B#'# K"',)+ ,) )2,4 +(-# ]+"# ,721# (* +"# ,05,),-/# V(4:] L# "25# 2/'#248 )"(>06 +"2+K"',)+ "2) 2 -(48 ?(7%()#4 (* )&-)+20?#6 ^#)" 204 -(0#)9 204 "# ,))2,4 +( -#6 ]+"# ,721# (* +"# ,05,),-/# V(4:] L#//6 )28) (0#6 ># 247,+

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

b2&/`) +#)+,7(08 ,0 b",/: IET6 N6 )"(>) %/2,0/8 >"2+ 728 -# &04#'=)+((4 -8 +"# )+2+#7#0+6 +"2+ K"',)+ ,) +"# ,721# (* V(4: ]X#+ +",) 7,04-# ,0 8(& >",?" >2) ,0 K"',)+ c#)&)E >"( -#,01 ,0 +"# *('7 (* V(46+"(&1"+ ,+ 0(+ '(--#'8 +( -# #D&2/ >,+" V(4:] B(> ?20 K"',)+ -# )2,4+( -# ,0 +"# *('7 (* V(46 ,* V(4 "2) 0( *('7e W(7: iEJ: ]V(4 )#04,01",) (>0


12/56

GM O2+#',2/,)7 @ P&' Q('1(++#0 Q(&042+,(0

204 ,0 +"# *('7 (* 7#0: !",) 2+ (0?# '#5#2/) +( &) +"# *('7 (* V(4:\20,#/ )%#2.,01 (* V(46 ?2//) ",7 +"# 30?,#0+ (* 428): \20: hEU:

]304 +"# 30?,#0+ (* 428) 4,4 ),+6 >"()# 12'7#0+ >2) >",+# 2) )0(>6204 +"# "2,' (* ",) "#24 /,.# +"# %&'# >((/:] !",) %#')(021# ,) )2,4 +("25# 2 "#246 204 "2,'9 +",) ?#'+2,0/8 ?(&/4 0(+ -# )2,4 (* ",7 ,* "# >2),772+#',2/ 204 "24 0( *('7: Z&+ b2&/`) +#)+,7(08 ,0 B#-: ,6 J6 (&1"++( )#++/# #5#'8 ?204,4 7,04 ,0 '#12'4 +( +"# %#')(02/,+8 (* V(4:2)",) (>0 *2+"#'9 *(' >"#0 "# %'28#4 "# 244'#))#4 ",) Q2+"#' 2) 20(+"#'%#')(0 >"( "24 )#0+ ",7 ,0+( +"# >('/4: B# )+8/#4 ",7)#/* +"# ",?" 720 >2) *('7#46 "24 2 ?"2'2?+#' /,.# V(4: L#0(> )## +"#


13/56

O2+#',2/,)7 @ P&' Q('1(++#0 Q(&042+,(0 GG

+"2+ 3427 >2) 0(+ ?'#2+#4 ,77('+2/6 8#+ ; -#/,#5# ># 2'# ,77('+2/:L# ,0D&,'#6 *'(7 >"2+ )(&'?# 4( ># 4#',5# (&' ,77('+2/,+8[ ;+ 7&)+

-# #,+"#' ,0"#'#0+6 4#',5#4 *'(7 34276 (' #/)# ,+ ?(7#) +( &) 4,'#?+/8*'(7 V(4: L# '#%/86 ># 4,4 0(+ 1#+ ,+ *'(7 34279 *(' "# 4,4 0(+ "25#,+ ",7)#/*: ;* "# "24 ,77('+2/,+86 204 ,7%2'+#4 ,+ +( &)6 ",) %()+#',+86+"#0 +"# )(&/ ?200(+ -# ,772+#',2/ 2) ?/2,7#4 -8 +"# 245(?2+#) (*02+&'2/ ,77('+2/,+8: ;772+#',2/ ,) +"# (%%(),+# (* 72+#',2/: O2+#',2/ ,))(7#+",019 72++#'9 "2) /#01+"6 -'#24+" 204 +",?.0#))9 204 (0# (* ,+)%'(%#'+,#) ,) )2,4 -8 b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

204 &0/#)) +",) )(&/ >2) ,7%2'+#4 +"#'# >(&/4 -# 0( /,*#: !"&) ># )##+"2+ V(4 ,) ?"2'1#4 >,+" 1,5,01 )(&/) +( #5#'8 -#,01 +"2+ /,5#)6 0(72++#' "(> 7,)#'2-/# +"#,' -,'+": 304 212,06 +"#8 +#// &) +"# )(&/ ,) +"#7,04E +"#0 )(7# (* +"#)# )(&/) 7&)+ -# 5#'8 /,7,+#4 ,0 ,0+#//#?+ >"#0*('7#46 2) 2%%#2') -8 +"# ,4,(+,? %('+,(0 (* +"# ?(77&0,+8:

P0# 1'#2+ '#2)(0 &'1#4 +"2+ 720 ,) ,0 %())#)),(0 (* )(7# %',0?,%/#(* 2 ",1"#' 02+&'# +"20 72++#'6 ,) +"2+ 720 +",0.)9 204 >,+" 2// ?204('># 2'# +(/4 +"2+ 72++#' ?200(+ +",0.6 "2) 0(+ +"# %(>#' (* )#/*=7(+,(06

204 >(&/4 #+#'02//8 '#72,0 ,02?+,5#6 >#'# ,+ 0(+ *(' +"# ,77('+2/%(>#' (* 5(/,+,(0 >",?" 720 %())#))#): L# #0D&,'#: \( -#2)+) %())#))20 ,77('+2/ >,//[ !"#8 ?#'+2,0/8 "25# +"# %(>#' +( >,// 204 7(5#+"#,' -(4,#) 2-(&+: b",/()(%"#') "25# (0/8 1,5#0 &) +"# %'(%#'+,#) (*&0('120,_#4 72++#'9 -&+ #5#'8 (0# 7&)+ 247,+6 +"2+ -8 ?(7-,02+,(0(* 72++#'6 '#)&/+) 2'# %'(4&?#46 204 %'(%#'+,#) 724# 720,*#)+6 >",?"4,4 0(+ #A,)+ ,0 +"# (',1,02/ 72++#' &0('120,_#4: P'120,_#4 ,0 2?#'+2,0 *('76 72++#' ,) 724# +( %'(4&?# 7&),?6 204 8#+ 7&),? ,) 0(+ 2

%'(%#'+8 (* 72++#'6 -&+ ,) +"# '#)&/+ (* 2 %#?&/,2' ('120,_2+,(0 (*72++#': Z&+ )28) (0#6 ]!"# 7&),? ,) 0(+ ,0 +"# 72+#',2/ ,0)+'&7#0+6 -&+,0 +"# 7,04:] Z&+ +"# 7,04 4(#) 0(+ %'(4&?# +"# )(&04E )(&04 ,)%'(4&?#4 2) +"# '#)&/+ (* +"# ('120,_2+,(0 (* +"# 72+#',2/) (* +"#,0)+'&7#0+6 +"# 2,' -#,01 +"# 7#4,&7 +"'(&1" >",?" ,+ ,) ?(05#8#4 +(+"# 0,?# ('120,)7 (* +"# #2'6 204 +"#'# +"# 7,04 +2.#) ?(10,_20?# (*


14/56

GI O2+#',2/,)7 @ P&' Q('1(++#0 Q(&042+,(0

+"()# )(&04):Z&+ )28) +"# (-Y#?+('6 O20) '#2)(06 ,) ?2%2-/# (* ?"((),01 204

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

># >,// 2)),10 (&' '#2)(0) -',#^8: G)+: !"# 7,04 ,) 4#5#/(%#4 ,0%'(%('+,(0 +( +"# 5(/&7# (* -'2,06 204 +#7%#'27#0+ (* +"# -(48: !"#-'2,0 (* 20 ('4,02'8 720 ,) 2-(&+ (0# +>#0+,#+" %2'+ +"# ),_# (* +"#-(486 >",/# +"2+ (* +"# "(')# ,) (0/8 (0# +>(="&04'#4+" %2'+:

;* +"# 7,04 >2) ,77('+2/6 204 0(+ +"# '#)&/+ (* +"# 2?+,(0 (* +"#-(486 >"8 )"(&/4 #2'0#)+ )+&48 ?2&)# >#2',0#)) (* -(48[ ;* +"#?(0+'2'8 >#'# +"# ?2)#6 +"2+ +"# 7,04 #A,)+) ,04#%#04#0+ (* +"# -(486204 +"2+ +"# -(48 >2) 2) 2 ?/(1 +( +"# %(>#') (* +"2+ )%,',+6 2) "2)

-##0 ?/2,7#46 +"#0 ># )"(&/4 #A%#?+ +"# 0#2'#' 4#2+" ># ?27#6 +"#-',1"+#' +"# ,0+#//#?+ >(&/4 -#9 -&+ ># C04 ,+ +"# '#5#')#: 3 )(&047,04 ,0 2 )(&04 -(48 #A%'#))#) +"# +'&+" (* +",) 72++#':

!"#'# ,) (0# *2?+ +"2+ ?200(+ -# #A%/2,0#4 ,0 "2'7(08 >,+" +"#+"#('86 +"2+ +"# 7,04 ,) 0(+ 4#%#04#0+ &%(0 72++#' *(' ,+) #A,)+#0?#:L"#0 +"# ).&// (* 720 -#?(7#) *'2?+&'#46 204 4#%'#))#4 &%(0 +"#-'2,06 +"# )&**#'#' ,) ,77#4,2+#/8 &0?(0)?,(&)6 204 8#+ +"# -'#2+" (*/,*# ,) ,0 ",7: O208 ?&',(&) ?,'?&7)+20?#) 7,1"+ -# '#/2+#46

,//&)+'2+,5# (* +",) %(,0+6 (* ,04,5,4&2/) >"( '#72,0#4 &0?(0)?,(&) *('428)6 204 2*+#' -#,01 '#)+('#4 +( +"#,' )#0)#) 212,06 >#'# 0(+ ?(0)?,(&)+"2+ 208 +,7# "24 #/2%)#4: L# '#*#' +"# '#24#' +( O#0+2/ b",/()(%"8*(' +#)+,7(0,#) &%(0 +",) )&-Y#?+: L"2+ *(//8 +( +2/. (* +"# 7,04 (* 720-#,01 ,77('+2/6 204 ,04#%#04#0+ ,0 ,+) #A,)+#0?#6 ,* 4,)#2)# (* +"#-(48 ?20 2**#?+ ,+: L"2+ 2 )#0+,7#0+ +( +#2?"6 +"2+ 2 720 ,) ?(0)?,(&)


15/56

O2+#',2/,)7 @ P&' Q('1(++#0 Q(&042+,(0 GJ

2*+#' 4#2+"6 >"#0 +"# *2?+) 2'#6 ,0Y&'8 (* +"# -'2,0 72.#) 2 720&0?(0)?,(&) >",/# /,5,01:

Z&+ ># '#+&'0 +( +"# Z,-/#: P&' '#2)(0,01 >(&/4 -# -&+ 52,06#A?#%+ ,+ >#'# ,0 "2'7(08 >,+" +"# L('4 (* ,0)%,'2+,(0: L# "25#2/'#248 )##0 +"2+ +"#


16/56

Gd O2+#',2/,)7 @ P&' Q('1(++#0 Q(&042+,(0

'#>2'4#4 >,+" ,772+#',2/,+86 (' >,+" >"2+ "2) -##0 ?(77(0/84#)?',-#4 2) "#25#0: "#0 %'(0(&0?,01 -/#)),01) &%(0 4,**#'#0+ ?"2'2?+#')6]Z/#))#4 2'# +"# 7##.E *(' +"#8 )"2// ,0"#',+ +"# #2'+":]d

L"#'# )"2// ># /#2'0 +"2+ 208 ,772+#',2/ %2'+ "2) #5#' -##0 1,5#0+( 720[ !"#'# ,) ?#'+2,0/8 0( +#A+ ,0 +"#


17/56

O2+#',2/,)7 @ P&' Q('1(++#0 Q(&042+,(0 GT

)(7#+",01 >",?" "2) )&-)+20?#9 ,+ "2) /#01+"6 -'#24+"6 204 +",?.0#))9,+ (??&%,#) )%2?#9 ,+ ?20 -# 7#2)&'#46 )##06 *#/+6 204 "204/#4: ;+ ,)

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

!( ,//&)+'2+#6 )## K(/: JEGE ];* 8# +"#0 -# ',)#0 >,+" K"',)+6 )##.+"()# +",01) >",?" 2'# 2-(5#6 >"#'# K"',)+ ),++#+" (0 +"# ',1"+ "204 (*V(4:] !",01) 2-(5#e L"2+e 2'# +"#'# +",01) 2-(5#[ a(6 )28) +"#'2'#C#4 +"#(/(18 (* +"# %'#)#0+ 4289 +"#'# ,) ,772+#',2/,+8 2-(5# 204

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

!"#'# )##7) +"#0 +( -# 0( '#2)(0 *(' +"# 7#20,01 +"2+ ,) 2++2?"#4 +(+"# >('4 +",01) >"#0 2%%/,#4 +( (-Y#?+) 2-(5#6 )25# +"# 78)+#',(&)-#/,#* +"2+ )&-)+20?# 204 '#2/,+8 2'# ,0?(7%2+,-/# >,+" +"# )+2+# (* +"#-/#))#49 204 0( '#2)(0 ?20 -# 1,5#0 *(' +",) -#/,#* #A?#%+ +"# *2?+ (* ,+)(>0 #A,)+#0?#9 -&+ -#",04 +",) *2?+ ,+ +"&) #0+'#0?"#) ,+)#/*9 204 >",/#,+ *('-,4) 2// D)+,(0,01 2) +( +"# ',1"+ (* ,+) #A,)+#0?#6 ,+ "(/4) +"#+"#(/(1,?2/ >('/4 ,0 )/25#'8 +( ,+) 78)+,?2/ 4#7204):

b#'"2%)6 "(>#5#'6 +",) +"#('8 ,) >'(016 204 +"# Z,-/# ',1"+:

b#'"2%) +"# >('4 +",01)6 >"#0 *(&04 ,0 +"2+ -((.6 >,+" 0(?(0?#,52-/# '#2)(0 +( 2**#?+ ,+) ),10,C?2+,(06 728 7#20 +"# )27# 2) ,0208 (+"#' -((.: !"# 2'-,+'2'8 ?/2,7 (* +"# %(%&/2' 5,#> ,) )#+ *('+")+,// 7('# )+',.,01/8 ,0 +"# *(//(>,01 5#')#6 >",?" '#24)E ]


18/56

GN O2+#',2/,)7 @ P&' Q('1(++#0 Q(&042+,(0

#2'+"[ 308+",01 ,772+#',2/ 204 ,05,),-/#[ a(0# >,// )( ?/2,79 -&++",01) '#2/ 204 +201,-/#: Z8 >"2+ %',0?,%/#6 +"#'#*('#6 ?20 +",01)

2-(5#6 ,0 +"# 20+,+"#+,?2/ %('+,(0 (* +"# )#0+#0?#6 -# ?(0)+' +(7#20 Y&)+ +"# '#5#')#[ L"#0 +",01) 7#20) )(7#+",01 ,0 (0# %/2?#6"(> ?20 ,+ ,0 Y&)+ +"'## >('4) *'(7 >"#'# ,+ ,) )( &)#46 7#20 0(+",012+ 2//: X#+ #5#'8 /(5#' (* ?(0),)+#0?8 >"( ,) +'(&-/#4 >,+" +"#78)+,?,)7 +"2+ "2) -##0 +"'(>0 (5#' +"# >('4 (* V(46 ?(0),4#' +",)%(,0+:

P+"#' )?',%+&'#) -#2' +#)+,7(08 +( +"# '#2/,+8 (* "#25#0/8 +",01):b#+#'6 ,0 ",) C')+ #%,)+/# GEd6 )%#2.) (* 20 ,0"#',+20?# ,0?(''&%+,-/# 204&04#C/#46 '#)#'5#4 ,0 "#25#0 *(' &): ;0 B#-: UEJd6 b2&/ )28)6 ]Q(' 8#"24 ?(7%2)),(0 (* 7# ,0 78 -(04)6 204 +((. Y(8*&//8 +"# )%(,/,01 (*8(&' 1((4)6 .0(>,01 ,0 8(&')#/5#)6 +"2+ 8# "25# ,0 "#25#06 2 -#++#'204 20 #04&',01 )&-)+20?#:] !",) /201&21# ,) &07,)+2.2-/#E ># "25#,0 "#25#0 0(+ ,772+#',2/,+8 204 0(0#0+,+86 -&+ 2 )&-)+20?#: 304 >"#0b2&/ >(&/4 )#+ -#*('# &) +"# "(%# +"2+ ,0)%,'#4 +"# >('+",#) (* (/46 "#)%#2.) (* ,+ ,0 ?(0+'2)+ >,+" +",) #2'+"6 2) ]2 ?(&0+'86] 2 ]-#++#'

?(&0+'86] 2 ]"#25#0/8 ?(&0+'8:] ",?" 2 )?',%+&'2/6 )(-#'6 204,0+#//,1#0+ *2,+" ?20 /28 "(/46 20 ,0"#',+20?# 2) /,+#'2/ 2) +"# #2'+" &%(0

>",?" ># 0(> +'#246 1/(',C#4 2) ,0C0,+# %(>#'6 #A#'+#4 ,0 ,0C0,+#>,)4(7 ?20 2/(0# 4( ,+6 >"#'# ># )"2// .0(> 2) ># 2'# .0(>06 204>,+" +"# C0# )+'&01 )#0),-,/,+,#) (* +"# '#4##7#46 -# #02-/#4 +(2%%'#?,2+# +"# #AD&,),+# Y(8) +"2+ 4>#// ,0 +"# %'#)#0?# (* V(46 204 2+",) ',1"+ "204 *('#5#'7('#:

!",01) 2-(5#: Z&+ %#'"2%) )(7# (0# 728 2).6 O28 +"#'# 0(+ -#+",01) )(7#>"#'# 2-(5#6 204 8#+ "#25#0 ,+)#/* -# +"# ,0+201,-/#6)%,',+&2/ %/2?# ,+ ,) ?(77(0/8 )&%%()#4[ X#+ +"# 2%()+/# 20)>#': B#

+#//) &) ,0 +"# 5#'8 +#A+ &04#' 0(+,?#6 +"# 4#C0,+# /(?2+,(0 (* +"#)#+",01)9 "# +#//) &) Y&)+ >"#'# +"#8 2'#E ]",?" 2'#2-(5#6 >"#'# K"',)+ ),++#+" (0 +"# ',1"+ "204 (* V(4:] !"2+ ,))&*C?,#0+: !"# +",01) 2-(5#6 2'# Y&)+ >"#'# V(4 204 K"',)+ "25# +"#,'1/(',(&) 2-(4#: !"#'# ,) +"# "(/8 ?,+8: a#> c#'&)2/#76 >,+" ,+)'2,0-(> (* %'#?,(&) *(&042+,(0 )+(0#) &04#'/8,01 ,+) Y2)%#' >2//9 +"#'#


19/56

O2+#',2/,)7 @ P&' Q('1(++#0 Q(&042+,(0 Gh

2'# ,+) 12+#) (* %#2'/6 204 ,+) )+'##+) (* 1(/49 +"#'# ,) +"# +'## (* /,*#6 204+"# ',5#' (* +"# >2+#' (* /,*#9 +"#'# ,) +"# +' +2-#'02?/#6 %,+?"#4 0(+

-8 7206 -&+ -8 +"# /,5,01 V(46 >"#'# (&' 1'#2+ B,1" b',#)+ ,) 0(>7,0,)+#',01 *(' &)9 +"#'# ,) +"# 1'#2+ (',1,02/ (* +"# 2'.6 +"# 7#'?8=)#2+6204 +"# +2-/#) (* +#)+,7(086 ,0)?',-#4 >,+" +"# 1'#2+ /2> (* c#"(52"9+"#'# ,) +"# +"'(0# (* V(4 204 +"# X27-6 204 +"#'# +"# 7208720),(0) (* +"# Q2+"#'`) "(&)#6 724# '#248 *(' +"()# >"( 2'# *(&04%'#%2'#4 >"#0 +"# X('4 )"2// '#+&'06 +( -# +2.#0 >,+" ",7:

;+ ,) +"# +",01) 2-(5# +"2+ ># 2'# +( )##.: B(> )"2// ># )##. +"#7[!"# 0#A+ 5#')# #A%/2,0)E # >,// +&'0 (&' 2++#0+,(0 +( +"#7[ a(+ >"#0 *2,+" ,0 +"# '#2/,+8 204?#'+2,0+8 (* +"#)# +",01) ,) /,5#/8 204 )+'(01: X('46 ,0?'#2)# (&' *2,+"6

204 1,5# &) 20 #2'0#)+ (* +"# ,0"#',+20?# %'#%2'#4 *(' +"8 *2,+"*&/*(//(>#'):N

;+ ,) )&%%()#4 -8 )(7# +"2+ +"# #A%'#)),(0) &)#4 ,0 ?(00#?+,(0 >,+"+"# '#?('4 (* 720`) ?'#2+,(06 2'# )&?" 2) +( )"(> +"2+ "# "2) 20,77('+2/ )(&/6 (' ,) 20 ,77('+2/ -#,01: X#+ &) ?204,4/8 #A27,0# +"#7+( )## ,* )&?" ,) '#2//8 >"2+ +"#8 +#2?":

!"# C')+ (* +"#)# #A%'#)),(0) ,) +"# (%#0,01 +#)+,7(08 (* +"# Z,-/#

?(0?#'0,01 7206 >",?" 2))#'+) +"2+ "# >2) +( -# 724# ,0 +"# ,721# (*V(4: V#0: GEIN6IhE ]304 V(4 )2,46 X#+ &) 72.# 720 ,0 (&' ,721#62*+#' (&' /,.#0#))E 204 /#+ +"#7 "25# 4(7,0,(0 (5#' +"# C)" (* +"# )#26204 (5#' +"# *(>/ (* +"# 2,'6 204 (5#' +"# ?2++/#6 204 (5#' 2// +"# #2'+"6204 (5#' #5#'8 ?'##%,01 +",01 +"2+ ?'##%#+" &%(0 +"# #2'+": # 7&)+ ?(0C0# ,+ +( +",)[ ;) 0(+

N .)#"(/ !"#$"% '() 0'11'/2 *"+',)6 \#?: GM6 GiNG


20/56

Gi O2+#',2/,)7 @ P&' Q('1(++#0 Q(&042+,(0

V(4 (70,%(+#0+[ = f#): ;) 720[ = a(E ;) 0(+ V(4 (70,%'#)#0+[ = f#):;) 720[ = a(: ;) 0(+ V(4 (70,)?,#0+[ = f#): ;) 720[ = a(: ;) 0(+ V(4

,04#%#04#0+ 204 )#/*=#A,)+#0+[ = f#): ;) 720[ = a(: ;) 0(+ V(4,0*2//,-/#[ = f#): ;) 720[ = a(: !"#0 >"8 ),01/# (&+ +"# (0# 2++',-&+#(* ,77('+2/,+86 204 72.# +"# /,.#0#)) (* 720 +( V(4 ?(0),)+ >"(//8 ,0+",)[ ;0 +"# *('7 (* 2 )8//(1,)76 +"# %(%&/2' 2'1&7#0+ )+204) +"&)E=O2Y(' b'#7,)#E V(4 ,) ,77('+2/: G !,7: GEGh: O,0(' b'#7,)#E O20 ,)?'#2+#4 ,0 +"# ,721# (* V(4: V#0: G:Ih: K(0?/&),(0E !"#'#*('# 720 ,),77('+2/:

!",) ,) #2),/8 D&2)"#4 -8 20(+"#' )8//(1,)7 #D&2//8 )(&046 +"&)E=G: V(4 ,) (70,%(+#0+:I: O20 ,) 724# ,0 +"# ,721# (* V(4:J: !"#'#*('# 720 ,) (70,%(+#0+:

!",) ?(0?/&),(06 -8 -#,01 -'(&1"+ >,+",0 +"# ?(10,_20?# (* (&'(>0 )#0)#)6 -#?(7#) 7('# (-5,(&)/86 +"(&1" ,+ ,) 0(+ 7('# #))#0+,2//862-)&'4: ;+ )"(> #2'/,#' +"2+ +"# 2'1&7#0+ *(' ,77('+2/,+8 4'2>0 *'(7+"# ],721#] (* V(46 ,) &0D&2/,C#4 2))&7%+,(06 (' +"2+ %&08 204 C0,+#

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

!#)+27#0+:!"# )#?(04 +,7# +"# >('4 ],721#] ,) &)#46 ,+ ,) &)#4 +( )"(> +"#

'#/2+,(0 #A,)+,01 -#+>##0 )(0 204 *2+"#'6 204 ,) 2 1((4 ?(77#0+ (0+"# '#/2+,(0 >",?" V#0: GEIN6Ih 2))#'+) +( #A,)+ -#+>##0 720 204V(4: V#0: TEJE ]304 3427 /,5#4 20 "&04'#4 204 +",'+8 8#2')6 204-#12+ 2 )(0 ,0 ",) (>0 /,.#0#))6 2*+#' ",) ,721#:] S5#'8 (0# >(&/4 2+


21/56

O2+#',2/,)7 @ P&' Q('1(++#0 Q(&042+,(0 GU

(0?# &04#')+204 -8 +",) /201&21#6 %"8),?2/ '#)#7-/20?#6 204),7,/2',+8 (* 02+&'#: a(> %&+ +"# +>( %2))21#) +(1#+"#': O()#) C')+

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

;+ 728 -# )2,4 +"2+ +"# >('4 ],721#] ,) &)#4 ,0 2 4,**#'#0+ )#0)# ,0+"# a#> !#)+27#0+6 2)6 *(' #A27%/#6 ,0 K(/: JEU6GME ]X,# 0(+ (0# +(20(+"#'6 )##,01 +"2+ 8# "25# %&+ (** +"# (/4 720 >,+" ",) 4##4)9 204"25# %&+ (0 +"# 0#> 7206 >",?" ,) '#0#>#4 ,0 .0(>/#41# 2*+#' +"#

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

,77('+2/,+8 2) &)#4 -8 O()#)6 +",) +#A+ >(&/4 )"(> +"2+ +"2+,77('+2/,+8 >2) 0(+ 2-)(/&+# -&+ ?(0+,01#0+6 204 "25,01 -##0 /()+ -87206 ?20 -# '#12,0#4 (0/8 +"'(&1" K"',)+:

S%": dEId )"(>) "(> +",) 0#> 720 ,) ?'#2+#4E ]304 +"2+ 8# %&+ (0+"# 0#> 7206 >",?" 2*+#' V(4 ,) ?'#2+#4 ,0 ',1"+#(&)0#)) 204 +'"(/,0#)):] a(+",01 ,) )2,4 2-(&+ ,77('+2/,+8 #5#0 ,0 ?(00#?+,(0 >,+"+"# 0#> 720: ;+ ,) ),7%/8 2 0#> 7('2/ 02+&'#:

312,0E +"# >('4 "#'# +'20)/2+#4 ,721# ,) 4#C0#4 -8 V'##0C#/4 2)

7#20,016 -8 7#+(08786 ]20 #A#7%/2'6 7(4#/6 %2++#'06 )+2042'49 K(/:JEGM:] a( )&?" 4#C0,+,(0 2) +",) ,) 1,5#0 -8 V#)#0,&) +( +"# >('4 ,0V#0#),):


22/56

IM O2+#',2/,)7 @ P&' Q('1(++#0 Q(&042+,(0

!"# )27# '#2)(0,01 >,// 2%%/8 +( G K(': GTEdU6 >"#'# +"# ],721#(* +"# "#25#0/86] >",?" ,) %'(7,)#4 +( +"# ',1"+#(&)6 ,) )(7#+",01

>",?" ,) 0(+ ,0 %())#)),(0 (* +"# 02+&'2/ 7206 -&+ >,// -# 2++2,0#4+"'(&1" +"# '#)&''#?+,(0E ]L# )"2// 2/)( -#2' +"# ,721# (* +"#"#25#0/8:] ;+ ?200(+6 +"#'#*('#6 '#*#' +( +"# ,721# )+27%#4 &%(0 7202+ ",) ?'#2+,(06 &0/#)) ,+ -# 247,++#4 +"2+ +"2+ ,721#6 >,+" 2// ,+),0?/&4#4 D&2/,+,#)6 "2) -##0 /()+ -8 +"# "&720 '2?#6 = 20 247,)),(0*2+2/ +( +"# "8%(+"#),) (* +"# -#/,#5#') ,0 +"# 02+&'2/ ,77('+2/,+8 (*720:

;0 G K(': GGEh ># '#24 +"2+ 7206 2) ?(0+'2)+#4 >,+" >(7206 ,) ]+"#,721# 204 1/('8 (* V(4:] !( 72.# +"# #A%'#)),(0 ],721# (* V(4]"#'# 7#20 ,77('+2/,+86 ,) +( ?(0C0# ,+ +( 7206 204 '(- +"# -#++#' %2'+(* +"# "&720 *27,/8 (* +",) ",1" %'#'(12+,5#:

;0 V#0: UEN ># '#24E ]L"()( )"#44#+" 720`) -/((46 -8 720 )"2//",) -/((4 -# )"#4E *(' ,0 +"# ,721# (* V(4 724# "# 720:]"2+ +"# ,721# ,) "#'# ?/2,7#4 +( 7#206 ># )"(&/4 "25#+",) 5#'8 ),01&/2' '#24,01E ]L"()( )"#44#+" 720`) -/((4 l(' +2.#+"

720`) /,*#m6 -8 720 )"2// ",) -/((4 -# )"#4 l*(' ",) /,*# -# +2.#0mE *(',77('+2/ 724# "# 7206] )( +"2+ ",) /,*# ?(&/4 0(+ -# +2.#0: S5,4#0+/8+"# '#*#'#0?# ,0 2// )&?" %2))21#) ,) 0(+ (0/8 +( ]+"# "&720 *2?#4,5,0#6] -&+ +( +"# >"(/# %"8),?2/ *'27#6 >,+" ,+) 7#0+2/ 204 7('2/?2%2-,/,+,#)6 >",?"6 ,0 ?(7%2',)(0 >,+" 2// (+"#' *('7) (* 20,72+#4#A,)+#0?#6 ,) &%',1"+ 204 1(4/,.#:

Z&+ "#'# +"# 78)+,?2/ ,0+#'%'#+2+,(0 (* (&' ?&''#0+ +"#(/(18 "2)+"'(>0 &% >"2+ ,) ?(0),4#'#4 20 ,0)&%#'2-/# (-Y#?+,(0 +( +",) 5,#>9

*(' "(> ?20 720 -# %"8),?2//8 ,0 +"# ,721# (* V(46 >"#0 V(4 ,) 0(+2 %#')(06 ,) >,+"(&+ *('76 204 "2) 0#,+"#' -(48 0(' %2'+)[ ;0 '#%/8 >#2).6 L"#'# 4(#) +"# Z,-/# )28 +"2+ V(4 ,) 2 *('7/#))6 ,7%#')(02/-#,016 "25,01 0#,+"#' -(48 0(' %2'+)[ \(#) ,+ 0(+ )28 +"2+ "# ,) 2 )%,',+Fc("0 dEIdH[ = f#)9 204 ># ,0D&,'# 212,06 \(#) ,+ 0(+ )28 +"2+ +"#201#/) 2'# )%,',+)[ B#-: GEh6Gd: 304 2'# 0(+ +"# 201#/)6 )28,01 0(+",01(* +"()# ,0)+20?#) ,0 >",?" +"#8 "25# 2%%#2'#4 +( 7#0 ,0 -(4,/8 *('76204 2/>28) ,0 "&720 )"2%# FV#0: GiEG=i6 GN=II9 JIEId9 B(): GIEd9

a&7: IIEJG9 c&41: GJEN6GJ9 X&.# GEGG6GJ6Ii6IU9 3?+) GIEh=U6 #+?:6#+?:H6 = 2'# 0(+ +"# 201#/)6 ># )286 2/>28) )%(.#0 (* 2) -#,01) "25,01-(4,/8 *('7[ 3 )%,',+6 (' )%,',+&2/ -#,016 2) V(4 ,)6 ,0 +"# ",1"#)+ )#0)#6)( *2' *'(7 0(+ "25,01 2 -(4,/8 *('76 7&)+ %())#)) ,+6 2) +"#,0)+'&7#0+2/,+8 *(' +"# 720,*#)+2+,(0 (* ",) %(>#'): G K(': GTEdd:

312,0E ,+ ,) &'1#4 +"2+ V(4 ,) (70,%'#)#0+9 204 "(> ?20 +",) -#6 ,*


23/56

O2+#',2/,)7 @ P&' Q('1(++#0 Q(&042+,(0 IG

"# ,) 2 %#')(0[ 30)>#'E B# "2) 2 '#%'#)#0+2+,5#6 ",) B(/8 ",?" 2'# ])#0+ *('+" ,0+( 2// +"# #2'+":] W#5: dET9 TEN:

L# 0(> ,05,+# +"# 2++#0+,(0 (* +"# '#24#' +( 2 /,++/# (* +"# #5,4#0?#+"2+ 728 -# %'#)#0+#4 +( )"(> +"2+ V(4 ,) 2 %#')(06 204 )( +"2+ 7206+"(&1" (* ?(&')# ,0 20 ,7%#'*#?+ 204 C0,+# 4#1'##6 728 -# 20 ,721#6(' /,.#0#))6 (* ",76 2) +( ",) -(4,/8 *('7:

G: V(4 "2) 724# 5,),-/# +( 7('+2/ #8#) %2'+) (* ",) %#')(0: O()#))2> +"# V(4 (* ;)'2#/: SA: JJEIG=IJ: 30 ,772+#',2/ -#,016 ,* )&?" 2+",01 ?20 -# ?(0?#,5#4 (*6 >,+"(&+ -(48 (' %2'+)6 ?200(+ -# )##0 >,+"7('+2/ #8#): !( )28 +"2+ V(4 2))&7#4 2 -(48 204 )"2%# *(' +",)(??2),(06 %/2?#) +"# ?(77(0 5,#> ,0 2 >(')# /,1"+ )+,//9 *(' ,+ ,)5,'+&2//8 ?"2'1,01 V(4 >,+" 2 4(&-/# 4#?#%+,(0E C')+6 1,5,01 O()#) +(&04#')+204 +"2+ "# >2) 2 -#,01 >,+" -(48 204 %2'+)9 204 )#?(04/86

&04#' +"# %'(7,)# (* )"(>,01 ",7)#/*6 )"(>,01 ",7 )(7#+",01 +"2+>2) 0(+ ",7)#/*: 304 "# +(/4 O()#) +"2+ "# >(&/4 %&+ ",) ]"204] (5#'",7 2) "# %2))#4 -86 204 +"#0 +2.# ,+ 2>286 +"2+ "# 7,1"+ )## ",)]-2?. %2'+)6] -&+ 0(+ ",) ]*2?#:] B2) "# "204)[ "2) "# -2?. %2'+)[ "2)"# 2 *2?#[ ;* 0(+6 >"8 +'8 +( ?(05#8 ,4#2) -8 7#20) (* /201&21#[

312,0E O()#)6 32'(06 a242-6 3-,"&6 204 )#5#0+8 (* +"# #/4#') )2>+"# V(4 (* ;)'2#/: SA: IdEU=GG: ]304 +"#'# >2) &04#' ",) *##+ 2) ,+>#'# 2 %25#4 >('. (* 2 )2%%",'# )+(0#:] B2) "# *##+[ P' ,) +"# '#?('4

+"2+ +"#)# %#')(0) )2> +"#7 2 *2-',?2+,(0[ a( 7206 +( -# )&'#6 "2))##0 ",) *2?#6 0(' ?(&/4 "# 4( )( 204 /,5#6 2) V(4 "2) 4#?/2'#4: SA:JJEIM9 c("0 GEGi:

I: K"',)+6 2) 720,*#)+#4 27(01 7#06 ,) 4#?/2'#4 +( -# +"# ],721#](* V(46 204 ,0 ",) ]*('7:] K"',)+ )"(>#46 2*+#' ",) '#)&''#?+,(06 +"2+",) ,77('+2/6 +"(&1" 0(+ +"#0 1/(',C#46 -(48 "24 ^#)" 204 -(0#):X&.# IdEJU: Z(4,/8 "# 2)?#04#4 ,0+( "#25#06 >"#'# 0(0# ?20 %'#)&7#+( 4#08 ",7 2 /(?2/ "2-,+2+,(0: 3?+) GEU=GG9 S%": GEIM9 B#-: iEG: Z&+

b2&/6 )%#2.,01 (* +",) )27# c#)&)6 )28)6 ]L"( ,) +"# ,721# (* +"#,05,),-/# V(46 +"# C')+=-('0 (* #5#'8 ?'#2+&'#:] K(/: GEGT: B#'# +"#20+,+"#),) #A%'#))#4 ,) -#+>##0 V(46 >"( ,) ,05,),-/#6 204 ",) ],721#],0 +"# %#')(0 (* K"',)+6 >",?" >2) 5,),-/#: ;+ *(//(>)6 +"#'#*('#6 +"2+>"2+ (* K"',)+ +"# 4,)?,%/#) ?(&/4 )##6 >",?" >2) ",) -(4,/8 *('76 >2)+"# ,721# +( 1,5# +"#7 20 ,4#2 (* V(4 >"(7 +"#8 ?(&/4 0(+ )##: !",)


24/56

II O2+#',2/,)7 @ P&' Q('1(++#0 Q(&042+,(0

(* ?(&')# >(&/4 0(+ #A?/&4# +"# 7('2/ 2++',-&+#) 720,*#)+#4 -8 c#)&)6-&+ >",?" ?(&/4 0(+ -# 720,*#)+#4 >,+"(&+ )(7# -(4,/8 ('120,_2+,(0:

312,0E ]X#+ +",) 7,04 -# ,0 8(& >",?" >2) 2/)( ,0 K"',)+ c#)&)E>"(6 -#,01 ,0 +"# *('7 (* V(46 +"(&1"+ ,+ 0(+ '(--#'8 +( -# #D&2/>,+" V(4:] b",/: IET6N: ;+ '#72,0) +( -# +(/4 "(> K"',)+ ?(&/4 -# ,0+"# ]*('7] (* V(46 204 8#+ V(4 "25# 0( *('7:

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

,04,?2+,(0 1,5#0 ,0 +"# Z,-/# (* >"2+ +"2+ )"2%# ,)6 ,) +"# "&720 *('7:!"# #5,4#0?# 2/'#248 %'#)#0+#4 )"(>) +"2+ +"#'# ,) 0( 0#?#)),+8 *(')&%%(),01 +"2+ +"# ,721# (* V(46 ,0 >",?" 720 >2) ?'#2+#46 ?(0),)+)(* ,77('+2/,+89 204 b2&/6 ,0 ",) +#)+,7(08 +( +"# W(720)6 *('#5#'4#)+'(8) +"# %()),-,/,+8 (* 72.,01 ,+ 2%%/8 +( ,77('+2/,+8: B# )28)FW(7: GEII6IJHE ]b'(*#)),01 +"#7)#/5#) +( -# >,)#6 +"#8 -#?27# *((/)6204 ?"201#4 +"# 1/('8 (* +"# &0?(''&%+,-/# V(4 ,0+( 20 ,721# 724#/,.# +( ?(''&%+,-/# 7206 204 +( -,'4)6 204 *(&'=*((+#4 -#2)+)6 204

?'##%,01 +",01):] !"# >('4 "#'# '#04#'#4 ]&0?(''&%+,-/#] ,) +"# )27#>('4 +"2+ ,) +'20)/2+#4 ],77('+2/6] 204 )&%%/,#4 +( V(4 ,0 G !,7:GEGh: a(> ,* V(4 -8 72.,01 720 ,0 ",) ,721#6 )+27%#4 ",7 >,+",77('+2/,+86 720 ,) Y&)+ 2) &0?(''&%+,-/# 2) V(4 ",7)#/*: Z&+ b2&/)28) +"2+ "# ,) 0(+ )(9 +"2+ >",/# V(4 ,) &0?(''&%+,-/#6 (' ,77('+2/6720 ,) ?(''&%+,-/#6 (' 7('+2/: !"# ,721# (* V(4 4(#) 0(+6 +"#'#*('#6?(0*#' ,77('+2/,+86 +"(&1" ,+ 4(#) ,04,?2+# +"# ",1" ('120,_2+,(0 2041(4/,.# 02+&'# (* 720:h

3/+"(&1" ># 0(+#4 ,0 +"# (&+)#+ +"2+ +"# /,1"+ (* 02+&'# 204 '#2)(0,) ,0)&*C?,#0+ +( 4#?,4# +"# ,77('+2/,+8 (* +"# )(&/6 8#+ 2) +"#'# 2'# 2*#> %(,0+) +( >",?" )(7# 728 -# *(04/8 ?/#25,016 ,0 +"# -#/,#* +"2+ +"#4(?+',0# ?20 -# *2,'/8 4#7(0)+'2+#4 +"#'#*'(76 ,+ 728 0(+ -# 27,)) +(

h *"+" '() *"+"'7/"+6 %%: IU:G=JN:I


25/56

O2+#',2/,)7 @ P&' Q('1(++#0 Q(&042+,(0 IJ

-',#^8 0(+,?# +"#7: !"# C')+ ,) +"# 2'1&7#0+ 4'2>0 *'(7,772+#',2/,+8: !"# )(&/6 ,+ ,) ?/2,7#46 ,) ,772+#',2/6 204 "#0?#

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

Z&+6 2//(>,01 +"# &+7()+ /2+,+&4# +( +",) 5,#>6 ,+ #D&2//8 %'(5#) +"#)(&/) (* 2// 20,72/)6 C)"#)6 '#%+,/#) 204 ,0)#?+) ,772+#',2/9 *(' +"#8'#7#7-#'6 *#2'6 ,721,0#6 ?(7%2'#6 720,*#)+ 1'2+,+&4#6 201#'6 )(''(>64#),'#6 #+?: Z,)"(% L2'-&'+(0 #A%'#))/8 )28)6 ]; +",0. ,+ 728 -# )+',?+/84#7(0)+'2+#4 +"2+ 720 "2) 20 ,772+#',2/ )(&/9 -&+ +"#06 +"# )27#

2'1&7#0+) >",?" %'(5# +"2+6 %'(5#6 /,.#>,)#6 +"2+ +"# )(&/) (* 2// /,5,0120,72/) 2'# ,772+#',2/:] L"(#5#'6 +"#'#*('#6 2*C'7) +"# ,77('+2/,+8(* 720 *'(7 +"# ,772+#',2/,+8 (* ",) )(&/6 ,) -(&04 +( 2*C'7 +"# )27#60(+ (0/8 (* +"# 0(-/#' 20,72/)6 -&+ 2/)( (* 2// +"# /(>#' ('4#') (* +"#-'&+# ?'#2+,(0: B#'#6 212,06 -#/,#5#') ,0 02+&'2/ ,77('+2/,+8 2'#?'&)"#4 -#0#2+" +"# >#,1"+ (* +"#,' (>0 2'1&7#0+): ;* ,+ -# )2,4 +"2+V(4 ?206 ,* "# ?"(()#6 -/(+ *'(7 #A,)+#0?# +"# ,772+#',2/ )(&/ (* +"#-##+/# 204 +"# +,+7(&)#6 ># '#%/86 )( ?20 "# +"2+ (* 7209 204 +"#0 ,+)

,77('+2/,+8 ,) 2+ 20 #046 204 +"# >"(/# 2'1&7#0+ 2-204(0#4:i

!"# (%%(),+,(0 %'#2?",01 "2) +&'0#4 204 #)+2-/,)"#4 )(7# ,0 +"#%'#)#0+ +'&+": L# #0+#'+2,0 0( *#2') (* +"()# ]1((4 1'(&04] "#2'#')>"( /#2'0 (* (&' *2,+" >,+" 2 *&// 4#+#'7,02+,(0 +( /,5# ,+ (&+6 -#,01]+&'0#4 *'(7 +"# "(/8 ?(772047#0+ 4#/,5#'#4 &0+( +"#7:] F+"#0 *2+"#'6 "#25#0 -#8(04 )%2?#6 +"2+ ,) 0(>"#'#6 >,+" 20 ,772+#',2/,77('+2/ )(&/ Y&)+ /,.# V(46 -#,01 %2'+ (* V(4 ",7)#/*6 1(,01 +("#25#0 (' "#// 2+ 4#2+"6 +"2+ ,)6 2 %2'+ (* V(4 1(,01 +( "#//6 +"#0 +( -#?2//#4 (&+ (* "#// +( -# &0,+#4 >,+" +"# -(48 +( -# )#0+ -2?. 212,0 +(

i @6+/', 6+ D556+/',E F2$82E6 %: Id:I=Id:J


26/56

Id O2+#',2/,)7 @ P&' Q('1(++#0 Q(&042+,(0

'#72,0 +( 2// #+#'0,+8 +( 4,# +"# 4#2+" +"2+ 0#5#' 4,#)6 >",/# +"#',1"+#(&) 728 /,5# +"# /,*# +"2+ 0#5#' /,5#):U

>2-2 6*%$.

]; VP +( %'#%2'# 2 %/2?# *(' 8(&:] L"#'# 4,4 c#)&) 1([ X&.# +#//)&) +"2+ (0 +"# 428 (* B,) 2)?#0),(06 ];+ ?27# +( %2))6 >",/# "# -/#))#4+"#76 "# >2) %2'+#4 *'(7 +"#76 204 ?2'',#4 &% ,0+( B#25#0:] X&.#IdETG: P0 +"# )27# (??2),(0 O2'. )28)E ],01 ,0 8(&')#/5#) +"2+ 8#"25# ,0 B#25#0 2 -#++#' 204 20 #04&',01 )&-)+20?#:] B#-: GMEJd:!"#'# ,) +"#0 ,0 B#25#0 2 )&-)+20+,2/ %/2?# *(' +"# -#/,#5#') ,0 V(4204 ,0 K"',)+:GM

?$*,:$ =)*,,.

L"2+ ,) ,772+#',2/,+8[ ('4) = ,+ ,) 0(+ )&-)+20?#: L"2+ ,) +"2+ >",?" "2) 0()&-)+20?#[ = L"2+ .,04 (* ?'#2+,(0 ,) ,+[ ;* +"# K'#2+(' *('7#4 ]2//+",01) (&+ (* 0(+",016] ,+ >(&/4 )##7 +"2+ 720`) )(&/ "2) +2.#0 +"#*('7 (* ,+) (',1,02/6 204 ,) 0(+",01 )+,//9 *(' ,+ ,) 0(+ 72++#'6 ># 2'# +(/4:;* ,+ ,) )2,4 = ];+ ,) 2 )%,',+&2/ )&-)+20?#] = ; 2).6 L"2+ .,04 (* )&-)+20?#,) +"2+6 ,* ,+ ,) 0(+ 72++#'[ ; ?200(+ ?(0?#,5#6 204 ; 4( 0(+ )## "(> ,+ ,)

%()),-/# +( ?(0?#,5#6 (* )&-)+20?# >,+"(&+ 72++#'6 ,0 )(7# *('7E ,+728 -# #A?##4,01/8 '#C0#4: ; '#12'4 +"# %"'2)#6 ,772+#',2/6 2) (0#>",?" %'(%#'/8 -#/(01) +( +"# +",01) >",?" 2'# 0(+E 2 )(&04 >,+"(&+)#0)# (' 7#20,01E 2 7#'# ?/(2. +( ",4# +"# 02.#40#)) (* +"# +"#('8 (*

U .)#"(/ !"#$"% '() 0'11'/2 *"+',)6 c&/8 II6 GiTiGM 0$?(< 67 /2" ;$5"


27/56

O2+#',2/,)7 @ P&' Q('1(++#0 Q(&042+,(0 IT

20 ,77('+2/ )(&/ ,0 7209 2 %"'2)# (* >",?" ,+) 2&+"(') 2'# 2)%'(*(&04/8 ,10('20+ 2) +"# 7()+ &0/#2'0#4 (* +"#,' %&%,/):GG

62@2 &


28/56

IN O2+#',2/,)7 @ P&' Q('1(++#0 Q(&042+,(0

#+? : !"# >"(/# 4#)?',%+,(0 ,04,?2+#) 20 2?+&2/ -(4,/8 #A,)+#0?#=2 -(48"25,01 "204)6 *##+6 >,01)6 #+?:

;0 V#0: GiEG=i ># '#24E ]304 +"# X('4 2%%#2'#4 &0+( ",7l3-'2"27m ,0 +"# %/2,0) (* O27'#9 204 "# )2+ ,0 +"# +#0+ 4((' ,0 +"#"#2+ (* +"# 4286 204 "# /,*+#4 &% ",) #8#) 204 /((.#46 2046 /(6 +"'##7#0 )+((4 -8 ",79 204 >"#0 "# )2> +"#76 "# '20 +( 7##+ +"#7 *'(7+"# +#0+ 4(('6 204 -(>#4 ",7)#/* +(>2'4 +"# 1'(&046 204 )2,46 O8/('46 ,* 0(> ; "25# *(&04 *25(' ,0 +"8 ),1"+6 %2)) 0(+ 2>286 ; %'28 +"##6*'(7 +"8 )#'520+9 /#+ 2 /,++/# >2+#'6 ; %'28 8(&6 -# *#+?"#46 204 >2)"8(&' *##+6 204 '#)+ 8(&')#/5#) &04#' +"# +'##9 204 ; >,// *#+?" 2 7(')#/(* -'#246 204 ?(7*('+ 8# 8(&' "#2'+)9 2*+#' +"2+ 8# )"2// %2)) (09 *('+"#'#*('# 2'# 8# ?(7# +( 8(&' )#'520+: 304 +"#8 )2,46 ",?"

"# "24 4'#))#46 204 )#+ ,+ -#*('# +"#79 204 "# )+((4 -8 +"#7 &04#'+"# +'##6 204 +"#8 4,4 #2+:]B#'# ,+ ,) )2,4 +"2+ +"#8 4,4 #2+ +"# *((4 >",?" 3-'2"27 %'#%2'#4

*(' +"#7: !"2+ +"#8 >#'# 201#/)6 ># /#2'0 *'(7 >"2+ *(//(>)E ]304+"# 7#0 '()# &% *'(7 +"#0?#6 204 /((.#4 +(>2'4 28:] !>( (* +"#7>#0+ (0 +( ,+" ",) *2?# +(>2'4 +"# 1'(&049 204 "#)2,46 Z#"(/4 0(>6 78 /('4)6 +&'0 ,06 ; %'28 8(&6 ,0+( 8(&' )#'520+`)"(&)#6 204 +2''8 2// 0,1"+6 204 >2)" 8(&' *##+6 204 8# )"2// ',)# &%#2'/86 204 1( (0 8(&' >28): 304 +"#8 )2,46 a289 -&+ ># >,// 2-,4# ,0+"# )+'##+ 2// 0,1"+: 304 "# %'#))#4 &%(0 +"#7 1'#2+/89 204 +"#8+&'0#4 ,0 &0+( ",76 204 #0+#'#4 ,0+( ",) "(&)#9 204 "# 724# +"#7 2*#2)+6 204 4,4 -2.# &0/#25#0#4 -'#246 204 +"#8 4,4 #2+:] V#0: GUEG=J:

B#'# +"()# >"( 7#+ 3-'2"27 2'# ?2//#4 201#/): !"#8 2'#

'#%'#)#0+#4 2) "25,01 "204) 204 *##+9 204 ,+ ,) )2,4 +"#8 4,4 #2+72+#',2/ *((46 >",?" )"(>) +"2+ +"#8 >#'# 72+#',2/ -#,01): ;+ )##7)62/)(6 +"2+ 201#/) "25# *((4 #A%'#))/8 %'#%2'#4 *(' +"#,' &)#: \25,4)28)E ]!"(&1" "# "24 ?(77204#4 +"# ?/(&4) *'(7 2-(5#6 204(%#0#4 +"# 4((') (* "#25#06 204 "24 '2,0#4 4(>0 72002 &%(0 +"#7+( #2+6 204 1,5#0 +"#7 (* +"# ?('0 (* "#25#0: O20 4,4 `#2+ 201#/)`


29/56

O2+#',2/,)7 @ P&' Q('1(++#0 Q(&042+,(0 Ih

*((4:] b): hiEIJ=IT: O2002 ,) "#'# ?2//#4 +"# 1'2,0 (* "#25#06 204 +"#*((4 (* 201#/): !"#'#*('#6 201#/) 4( #2+ *((46 204 2'# 72+#',2/ -#,01):

L# ?(&/4 0(+ ,721,0# +"2+ ,772+#',2/ -#,01) )"(&/4 #2+ 72+#',2/*((46 )&?" 2) +"# 72002 >",?" V(4 )#0+ *'(7 "#25#0:

!",) ,4#2 ,) *&'+"#' )&)+2,0#4 -8 +"# *2?+ +"2+ c#)&)6 2*+#' B,)'#)&''#?+,(06 "24 ^#)" 204 4,4 #2+: 3+ B,) 2%%#2',01 +( B,) 4,)?,%/#)6B# )2,4E ]Z#"(/4 O8 "204) 204 O8 *##+6 +"2+ ,+ ,) ; O8)#/*9 "204/#O#6 204 )##9 *(' 2 )%,',+ "2+" 0(+ ^#)" 204 -(0#)6 2) 8# )## O# "25#:]X&.# IdEJN=dJ:

Z&+ c#)&) ,) +"# C')+ *'&,+)6 +"# #A27%/# (* +"# )2,0+) ,0 +"#'#)&''#?+,(0: B# 2+# >,+" B,) 4,)?,%/#)9 204 )( B# %'(7,)#4 +"#7 +"2++"#8 )"2// #2+ 204 4',0. >,+" B,7 ,0 B,) .,014(7: "#'#+"# ,77('+2/ )2,0+) )"2// 4>#//6 +"# X('4 )28)9 ]Q'(7 (0# ,// -# ?2//#4 ^#)" ,0 +"# .,014(7 (* V(4: 304 2) K"',)+ ,)6 204+"# ,77('+2/ )2,0+) >,// -#6 72+#',2/6 )( 2/)( ># ?(0?/&4# +"2+ +"#

201#/) 2'# 72+#',2/ -#,01):;0 +"# ",)+('8 (* Z2/227 ># "25# 20 ,0+#'#)+,01 ,0?,4#0+ -#2',01&%(0 +",) %(,0+: !"&) ># '#24E ]304 V(4`) 201#' >2) .,04/#4 -#?2&)#"# >#0+9 204 +"# 201#/ (* +"# X('4 )+((4 ,0 +"# >28 *(' 20 245#')2'8212,0)+ ",7: a(> "# >2) ',4,01 &%(0 ",) 2))6 204 ",) +>( )#'520+)>#'# >,+" ",7: 304 +"# 2)) )2> +"# 201#/ (* +"# X('4 )+204,01 ,0 +"#>286 204 ",) )>('4 4'2>0 ,0 ",) "2046 204 +"# 2)) +&'0#4 2),4# (&+ (*+"# >286 204 >#0+ ,0+( +"# C#/49 204 Z2/227 )7(+# +"# 2))6 +( +&'0

"#' ,0+( +"# >28:] ]!"#0 +"# X('4 (%#0#4 +"# #8#) (* Z2/2276 204 "#)2> +"# 201#/ (* +"# X('4 )+204,01 ,0 +"# >286 204 ",) )>('4 4'2>0 ,0",) "204:] a&7: IIEII=JG: !"# 201#/ 2%%#2'#4 +( Z2/227 >,+" 2)>('4 4'2>0 ,0 ",) "204: ('46 *(' +"# (??2),(06 (&+ (* +"# 72+#',2/) >",?")&''(&04#4 ",76 72.,01 ,+ 2%%#2' /,.# 2 -(48 204 2 )>('4 >"#0 +"#'#>2) 0(0#: !"#0 +"# 201#/ '#2//8 4#?#,5#4 Z2/2276 /#24,01 ",7 +(+",0. +"2+ "# "24 2 -(48 204 2 )>('4 >"#0 "# "24 0(0#9 204 +"#

'#?('4 4#?#,5#) +"# '#24#' ,0 +"# )27# 7200#': Z&+ ,+ >,// -# (-)#'5#4+"2+ +"# '#?('4 )28)6 ]!"#0 +"# X('4 (%#0#4 +"# #8#) (* Z2/2276 204"# )2> +"# 201#/6] 204 0(+ +"2+ +"# 201#/ ?'#2+#4 20 2%%#2'20?# +"2+7,1"+ -# )##0:

3) )((0 2) Z2/227`) #8#) >#'# (%#0#46 "# )2> +"# 201#/: !"# ,4#2,) ?(05#8#4 ?/#2'/8 +"2+ +"# 201#/ >2) Y&)+ +"# )27# -#*('# Z2/227 )2>


30/56

Ii O2+#',2/,)7 @ P&' Q('1(++#0 Q(&042+,(0

",7 2) "# >2) 2*+#'>2'4): !",) ,) *&'+"#' #5,4#0+ *'(7 +"# *2?+ +"2+ +"#-#2)+ ?(&/4 )## +"# 201#/6 >",/# Z2/227 ?(&/4 0(+ )## ",7: L,+"

'#12'4 +( +",) (??&''#0?#6 (0# (* +>( +",01) ,) +' #,+"#' +"# 201#/"24 2 72+#',2/ *('7 -#*('# +"# #8#) (* Z2/227 >#'# (%#0#4 )( +"2+ "#?(&/4 )## ",76 (' +"# 4&7- -'&+# )2> 20 ,772+#',2/ )%,',+: !"# /2)+>,// )?2'?#/8 -# ?/2,7#49 +"#'#*('# ,+ 7&)+ -# 2?.0(>/#41#4 +"2+ +"#201#/ >2) +"#'# ,0 ",) (>0 -(4,/8 *('7 -#*('# Z2/227 )2> ",7:

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e B#'# ,) 2 %,#?# (* ,?#6 204 +"#'# ,) 2 Y#+ (* +"# "(++#)+)+#27: S2?" )##7) +( -# #A2?+/8 +"# (%%(),+# (* +"# (+"#'9 8#+ +"#8 2'#

(0/8 4,**#'#0+ ?(04,+,(0) (* +"# )27# 72++#': P0# ,) >2+#' *'(_#09 +"#(+"#' ,) >2+#' ",1"/8 "#2+#4: ,// -# )%,',+&2/ -(4,#):

];+ ,) )(>0 2 02+&'2/ -(489 ,+ ,) '2,)#4 2 )%,',+&2/ -(48:] G K(': GTEdd:P0 +",) %(,0+ \': g: Z224#'6 30+"'(%(/(1:


31/56

O2+#',2/,)7 @ P&' Q('1(++#0 Q(&042+,(0 IU

4232 A*)),$##

O20 O24# ,0 +"# ;721# (* V(4L# +2.# +>( %/2,0 204 %(),+,5# )+2+#7#0+) (* +"# >('4 (* V(46

%/2?# +"#7 ),4# -8 ),4#6 204 4'2> 2 ),7%/#6 /#1,+,72+# ?(0?/&),(0:G: ]V(4 *('7#4 720 (* +"# 4&)+ (* +"# 1'(&04:]I: ]V(4 ?'#2+#4 720 ,0 ",) (>0 ,721#6 ,0 +"# ,721# (* V(4

?'#2+#4 "# ",7:]KPaKXo,)" +( -# &04#')+((4 +"2+ "# /()+ +"# ,77('+2/,+8 (* +"# )(&/:

a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

-&+ ,+ ,) #5,4#0+ +"#8 >#'# 0(+ ?'#2+#4 ,0 +"# ,721# (* V(4: O20`),00(?#0?#6 +"#06 >2) 0(+ >"2+ 4,)+,01&,)"#4 ",76 2) -#,01 ,0 +"#,721# (* V(4:

]347,++#46] )28) 20 (-Y#?+('9 ]-&+ +"# ,721# (* V(4 >2) *(&04 ,0+"# 02+&'2/ 2++',-&+#) (* +"# )(&/: !"&)E

G: O20 >2) 724# ,0 +"# ,721# (* V(4: I: Z&+ V(4 ,) ,77('+2/: J:!"#'#*('# 720 >2) 724# ,77('+2/:

a(>6 78 *',#046 ,* +"2+ 2'1&7#0+ ,) 1((4 204 )(&046 20(+"#'

*('7#4 &%(0 +"# )27# %/20 >(&/4 -# #D&2//8 1((4: Z&+ -8 *('7,01)8//(1,)7) 2*+#' 8(&' %2++#'0 ># 7,1"+ 72.# ,+ 2%%#2' +"2+ 720 ,)(70,%(+#0+6 (70,)?,#0+ 204 (70,%'#)#0+9 8#)9 204 *&'+"#'6 +"2+ 720](0/8 "2+" ,77('+2/,+86] *(' +",) ,) 2*C'7#4 (* V(4:

!",) 7(4# (* 2'1&,01 %'(5#) +(( 7&?"9 +"#'#*('# ,+ %'(5#)0(+",01: B#0?#6>#7&)+ +2.# +"# 7()+ ),7%/# 204 (-5,(&) ?(0?/&),(06


32/56

JM O2+#',2/,)7 @ P&' Q('1(++#0 Q(&042+,(0

027#/89 +"2+ 720 >2) 724# ,0 +"# *('7 (* V(4: K"',)+ >2) ,0 +"#]*('7 (* V(46] 204 ,) +"# ]#A%'#)) ,721# (* ",) Q2+"#'`) %#')(0:] K(/:

GEGT9 b",/: IEN9 B#-: GEJ: ;0 V#0: UEN6 ># '#246 ]L"()( )"#44#+"720`) -/((46 -8 720 )"2// ",) -/((4 -# )"#49 *(' ,0 +"# ,721# (* V(4724# "# 720:] 304 20 2%()+/# )28)6 +"2+ 7#0 ]2'# 724# 2*+#' +"#),7,/,+&4# (* V(4:]

\20,#/ )28) (* +"# Q2+"#'6 ]!"# 30?,#0+ (* 428) 4,4 ),+6 >"()#12'7#0+ >2) >",+# 2) )0(>6 204 +"# "2,' (* ",) "#24 /,.# %&'# >((/9",) +"'(0# >2) /,.# +"# C#'8 ^27#6 204 ",) >"##/) 2) -&'0,01 C'#:K"2%: hEU: c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


33/56

O2+#',2/,)7 @ P&' Q('1(++#0 Q(&042+,(0 JG

>(')",% V(4 ,0 )%,',+ 204 ,0 +'&+"[ (')",%#') )"2// >(')",% +"#Q2+"#' ,0 )%,',+ 204 ,0 +'&+":] L# 0##4 0(+ -#?(7# ,772+#',2/ ,0('4#' +( >(')",% V(4 2',1"+:Gd

!"# K'#2+,(0 (* O20;Q 720 "2) 20 ,77('+2/ )(&/6 ,+ >(&/4 -# '#2)(02-/# +( /((. *('

)(7# ,0*('72+,(0 ?(0?#'0,01 ,+ ,0 +"# 2??(&0+ 1,5#0 (* ",) ?'#2+,(0:L# ?(&/4 0(+ +",0. +"2+ +"# 7()+ ,7%('+20+ %2'+ (* 720 = +"2+ >,+"(&+>",?" 720 >(&/4 0(+ -# 720 = )"(&/4 -# /#*+ #0+,'#/8 (&+ (* +"2+2??(&0+: !"#0 /#+ &) '#24 +"# '#?('4:

]304 +"# X('4 V(4 *('7#4 720 (* +"# 4&)+ (* +"# 1'(&046 204-'#2+"#4 ,0+( ",) 0()+',/) +"# -'#2+" (* /,*#E 204 720 -#?27# 2 /,5,01)(&/:] V#0: IEh:

b#'"2%) +"#'# ,) 0( 2'1&7#0+ 7('# '#/,#4 (0 +( %'(5# +"#,77('+2/,+8 (* +"# )(&/ F*(' +"# Z,-/# 0(>"#'# 2))#'+) ,+H6 +"20 +"2+

>",?" ,) 4'2>0 *'(7 ,+) ,772+#',2/,+8: ;+ ,) "#/4 +"2+ +"2+ >",?" ,)6%'(%#'/8 )%#2.,016 +"# 7206 ,) ,772+#',2/6 +"2+ ,)6 ?(7%()#4 (*0(+",016 204 +"2+ +"2+ >",?" ,) ,772+#',2/ ?200(+ 4,#6 +"#'#*('# 720,) ,77('+2/: L"#'# 4,4 +"#8 1#+ +",) )( 52/&2-/# ,0*('72+,(0[ Q'(7>"2+ )(&'?# 4,4 +"#8 /#2'0 +"2+ ,772+#',2/,+8 ?(&/4 0(+ 4,#[ a(+ *'(7+"# Z,-/#6 *(' ,+ )28) 0(+",01 2-(&+ ,+: \( 8(& )286 W#2)(0 +#2?"#) ,+[B(> 4,4 "&720 '#2)(0 4,)?(5#' +"2+ +"2+ >",?" ,) ,772+#',2/ ?20/,5#6 -&+ ?200(+ 4,#[ +"2+ V(4 "2) ?'#2+#4 -#,01) 72+#',2/ 204

,772+#',2/6 +"2+ "# ?20 4#)+'(8 (0# ?/2))6 -&+ ?200(+ 4#)+'(8 +"#(+"#'6 -#?2&)# ,+ ,) ,772+#',2/[

Z&+ ,* +"# '#2/ 7206 +"# )(&/6 ,) ,772+#',2/6 (0/8 4>#//,01 ,0 272+#',2/ "(&)#6 +"# 2&+"(' (* +"# +#A+ 2-(5# D&(+#4 724# 2 1'#2+7,)+2.#9 *(' "# )28)6 V(4 *('7#4 720 (* +"# 4&)+ (* +"# 1'(&04: 304"# *&'+"#' 4#?/2'#) +"2+ +"# 720 +"&) *('7#4 (* 4&)+6 >"#0 +"# -'#2+"(* /,*# >2) 244#46 -#?27# F0(+ 20 ,772+#',2/ 204 ,77('+2/6 -&+H 2/,5,01 )(&/: ;* +"# 720 %'(%#' ,) ,772+#',2/6 +",) ,) 2 5#'8 ,7%'(%#'

2??(&0+ (* ",7E *(' ,+ 0(+ (0/8 0#1/#?+) +( +#// &) +"2+ "# >2),772+#',2/6 -&+6 (0 +"# ?(0+'2'86 )+2+#) +"# 72+#',2/ (* >",?" "# >2)*('7#4: 304 ,0)+#24 (* +#//,01 &) +"2+ 20 ,772+#',2/ )(&/ >2) %&+ ,0+(+",) 4&)+6 ,+ 4#?/2'#) +"2+ +"# 720 +"&) *('7#4 (* 4&)+6 -#?27# 2 /,5,01)(&/ >"#0 /,*# >2) 1,5#0: !"# )(&/ >2) +"# 7206 204 +"# 720 >2) +"#

Gd .)#"(/ !"#$"% '() 0'11'/2 *"+',)6 a(5: h6 GiNT


34/56

JI O2+#',2/,)7 @ P&' Q('1(++#0 Q(&042+,(0

)(&/E 204 +"# 720 >2) *('7#4 (* +"# 4&)+:V(4 .0(>) +"# #04 *'(7 +"# -#1,00,01: 304 +"# '#2)(0 "#

,0)%,'#4 O()#) +( >',+# +",) 2??(&0+ (* +"# *('72+,(0 (* 7206 >2)64(&-+/#))6 +"2+ "# *('#)2> +"2+ 7#0 >(&/4 -# 4#?#,5#4 >,+" +",)4(?+',0# (* ,772+#',2/,+86 204 ^2++#'#4 >,+" +"# ,4#2 (* ",) 02+&'2/,77('+2/,+86 204 +"&) -# %'#%2'#4 *(' +"# )#4&?+,(0) (* +"# \#5,/6 204/#4 (06 +"'(&1" )%,',+&2/,)76 +( '#Y#?+ +"# >('4 (* V(4 204 +"# "(%# (*+"# 1()%#/ = ,77('+2/,+8 +"'(&1" K"',)+: !"# ,0)%,'#4 2??(&0+ (*720`) ?'#2+,(0 %&+) 20 #5#'/2)+,01 5#+( (0 +",) 4(?+',0# (*,772+#',2/,+86 >,+" +"()# >"( -#/,#5#6 >,+" *&// 2))&'20?#6 +"# >('4 (*+"# X('4: P6 +"2+ 7#0 >(&/4 -#/,#5#e ;+ >(&/4 )25# +"#7 *'(7 -#,01%&**#4 &% >,+" +"# ,4#2 +"2+ +"#8 2'# 02+&'2//8 ,77('+2/6 >2'0 +"#7(* +"# 2>*&/ >",'/%((/ (* )%,',+&2/,)7 >",?" +"'#2+#0) +( #01&/* +"#76204 72.# +"#7 >,//,01 +( 2??#%+ (* ,77('+2/,+8 +"'(&1" c#)&) K"',)+6+"# (0/8 027# 1,5#0 &04#' "#25#0 >"#'#-8 +"#8 ?20 -# )25#4:GT

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

%",/()(%",_# 2>28 +"# 4'#24 '#2/,+8 (* 4#2+"6 +'20)*('7 ,+ ,0+( 2*',#04=2 7()+ -#0,1020+ 2''201#7#0+ +( -'#2. +"# 7(0(+(08 (* #2'+"=/,*#6 204 2**('4 +"#7 2 4#/,1"+*&/ +'20),+,(0 +( 2 ",1"#' /,*# (0 +"#%#2?#*&/ )"('#) (* ,772+#',2/,+86 >"#'# %/#2)&'#) 0#5#' ?/(8 204>"#'# +"# *'##4 )%,',+6 >",?" ,) 0(> %&**#4 &% 0,1" +( -&')+,01 >,+"%',4#6 728 #A%204 +( 2// #+#'0,+8 >,+"(&+ 4201#' (* #5#' ?(7,01 ,0?(0+2?+ >,+" 208+",01 #/)#e

L",/#


35/56

O2+#',2/,)7 @ P&' Q('1(++#0 Q(&042+,(0 JJ

'#2)(0 >"8 7#0 2'# &0>,//,01 +( "#2' +"# Z,-/# (0 +",) D)+,(0:!"#,' )#/*=?(0?#,+ 72.#) +"#7 &0>,//,01 +( /#2'0 +"# *2?+ +"2+ +"#8 2'#

]-&+ 7#06] -&+ ]4&)+ 204 2)"#)6] >"()# ]428) 2'# 2) 1'2)):] >"()# /,*#,) ]2 52%(' +"2+ 2%%#2'#+" *(' 2 /,++/# +,7#6 204 +"#0 520,)"#) 2>28:]!"#8 +",0. +"#8 2'# 4#1'24#4=-'(&1"+ 4(>0 +( 2 /#5#/ (* +"# -'&+#)6=>"#0 +"#8 2'# +(/4 +"2+ +"#8 "25# 0( ,77('+2/,+8 (&+ (* K"',)+E 204+",) *2?+6 2%%#2',01 7('# 204 7('# 2%%2'#0+ +( +"# Z,-/# )+&4#0+6*&'0,)"#) 2 0#> %'#+#A+ *(' 4,)?2'4,01 +"2+ )2?'#4 Z((.:

;0C4#/,+86 >",?" >2) >(0+6 ,0 +,7# %2)+6 +( 4#08 +"# #A,)+#0?# (*V(4 204 ?(0),10 7206 2+ 4#2+"6 +( -/20. 0(+",010#))6 4#08,01 2*&+&'# /,*# 2/+(1#+"#'6 "2)6 ,0 +"#)# /2)+ 428)6 )#,_#4 &%(0 +"# %(%&/2'*2-/# (* +"# 02+&'2/ ,77('+2/,+8 (* +"# )(&/6 204 ,) -2++/,01 212,0)+ +"#Z,-/# 204 ,+) \,5,0# 3&+"('6 >,+" 2// +"# 2))&'20?# 204 2&42?,+8 (*?(0)?,(&) ,77('+2/,+8 ,04#%#04#0+ (* K"',)+ 204 +"# '#)&''#?+,(0:;0)+#24 (* 4#08,01 +"# #A,)+#0?# (* V(46 0(> #5#'8+",01 ,) V(46 ('+"#'# ,) 2 ?#'+2,0 )(7#+",01 (' 0(+",01 ?2//#4 ,772+#',2/,+86 >",?"%#'524#) #5#'8 %2'+ (* +"# &0,5#')#6 204 +",) ,) +"#,' V(4=#5#'8>"#'#

,0 1#0#'2/ 204 0( >"#'# ,0 %2'+,?&/2'=2 +",01 (* 0(&1"+=0(0#0+,+8: ;+27(&0+) +( +"# 4(?+',0# (* 0( V(4:Z&+ +"#8 +"#7)#/5#)6 ,0 +"#,' *20?,#4 ,77('+2/,+86 2'# +"# 1'#2+#)+

1(4) +"#8 .0(> (* (' ?2'# *('9 204 +"#8 -,4 4#C20?# +( #5#'8 %(>#'+"2+ >(&/4 -',01 +"#7 +( 20 2??(&0+: 2) 0(+,0+#04#4 *(' +"2+ ?/2)) (* ,0C4#/) 1#0#'2//8 ?2//#4 O2+#',2/,)+)6 -&+ *('+"# #)%#?,2/ -#0#C+ (* "(2'# ,0 4201#' (* -#?(7,01 )&?": P* >"2+ "# ,) %/#2)#4 +( ?2//

72+#',2/,)76 "# )28)6 ];+ ,) 2+ +"# -2),)6 +"# 5#'8 ?('0#'=)+(0#6 (* +"#?'##4 (* 2 >"(/# 4#0(7,02+,(0 (* K"',)+,20) '2%,4/8 1'(>,01 &% ,0+",) ?(&0+'89 204 *(' %2/%2-/# '#2)(0)6 1'(>,01 7('# '2%,4/8 "#'# ,0+"# L#)+ +"20 #/)#>"#'#6 204 )##.,01 -8 ?#'+2,0 2*C0,+,#) +( /,0.+"#7)#/5#) >,+"


36/56

Jd O2+#',2/,)7 @ P&' Q('1(++#0 Q(&042+,(0

,)# 2-(5# +"2+ >",?" ,)>',++#09 204 +"#06 *'(7 )&?" #A%'#)),(0) (* +"#,') 2) +"#)#E ]O20 ,)#0+,'#/8 4#%#04#0+ &%(0 ",) F%"8),?2/H ('120,_2+,(0 *(' 2// ",)+"(&1"+)6] 204 +"# ]7,04] ,) 20 ]2++',-&+# (* /,5,01 ('120,_#4 4&)+6] "#)##7) +( ,0*#' 2 %'(%(),+,(0 >",?" 0(0# (* +"#)# >',+#') 2*C'76 5,_E]3// 7#0+2/ %"#0(7#02 2'# +"# '#)&/+ (* ('120,_2+,(0:] B# +"#0%'(?##4) +( ?(7-2+ +",) ?'#2+&'# (* ",) (>0 ?'#2+,(0 ,0 +"# *(//(>,0172)+#'/8 )+8/#:

]X#+ &) %&') +",) >(04#'*&/ 7#+"(4 (* +"(&1"+=%'(4&?,01 ,0+( ,+)/2-('2+('86 204 )## ,* ># ?20 ?2+?" 2 1/,7%)# (* +"# %'(?#)) -8 >",?"+"(&1"+ ,) %'(4&?#4: B#'#6 +"#06 ,) 2 "&720 -(0# +( -# ('120,_#4: ;+"2) ?2'-(02+# (* /,7#6 %"()%"('2+# (* /,7#6 1#/2+,0#6 #+?:6 ,0 ,+)?(0)+,+&+,(0: ;0 +"# ?2'-(02+# (* /,7# 2'# +"'## ),7%/# #/#7#0+)6?2'-(06 (A81#06 204 ?2/?,&7: !( %'(4&?# +"# /,7#6 +"# (A81#0 204

?2/?,&7 7&)+ &0,+#9 +",) +"#8 4( -8 +"# )+'(01 2*C0,+8 (* +"# (0# *('+"# (+"#': !",) ,) ('120,_2+,(0=+"2+ %'(?#)) >",?" (',1,02+#) 2// 7#0+2/%"#0(7#026 2??('4,01 +( +"# "8%(+"#),) &04#' ?(0),4#'2+,(0: a(>/((. (&+ *(' 2 +"(&1"+e b#'"2%) +"# ,77('+2/ ;//,24 >,// ?(7# *('+"6 *('2 %2'+,?/# (* (A81#0 ,) 1(,01 +( &0,+# >,+" (0# (* ?2/?,&7 +( 72.# 2-(0#: !"# >(04#'*&/ &0,(0 ,) ?(0)&772+#46 204 /,7# ,) ('120,_#4:\,4 8(& )## +"# +"(&1"+ +"2+ >2) %'(4&?#4[ \,4 8(& )## +"# /,7#+",0.[ !"#'# >2) ('120,_2+,(06 204 `2// 7#0+2/ %"#0(7#02 2'#

?(0)#D+ &%(0 ('120,_2+,(06` )28) +"# O2+#',2/,)+:]!"# O2+#',2/,)+ )28) )(6 *(' 2&1"+ ; .0(>6 -&+ ; "25# "24 0(

2?D&2,0+20?# (' ?(00#?+,(0 >,+" ",7: 304 ; 5#0+&'# +"# 2))#'+,(0 +"2+0( %'(*#))#4 K"',)+,20 ?20 -# *(&046 >"( "(/4) +"2+ +"# ]%'(?#))] (*('120,_2+,(0 ](',1,02+#) 2// 7#0+2/ %"#0(7#026] (' #5#' %'(4&?#4(0# +"(&1"+: \,4 0(+ (&' #))28,)+ .0(> +"2+ "# >2) -#2+,01 0(+ )(7&?" 2) +"# 2,'6 -&+ 2 %"20+(7 (* ",) (>0 ,721,02+,(0[ 304 8#+ "#'#%'#)#0+) +"2+ 2 4#0(7,02+,(0 (* ]K"',)+,20)] "(/4 )&?" 5,#>)9 204

(0# 7,1"+ ,0*#' +"2+ "# +"(&1"+ ",) (>0 4#0(7,02+,(0 -24/8 ,0*#?+#4>,+" )&?" ,4#2)9 *(' "# )28)6 ]3 1'()) 72+#',2/,)7 ,) )2%%,01 +"#*(&042+,(0 (* (&' )%,',+&2/ /,*#6 204 )",5#',01 4(>0 +"# )(&/ (* 720 +(,+) (>0 #2'+"=-('0 02+&'#:]

a(>6 Z,-/# K"',)+,20) -#/,#5# +"2+ +"# C')+ 720 (* (&' '2?# >2)%#'*#?+/8 204 ?(7%/#+#/8 ('120,_#46 ",) -'2,0 2) >#// 2) +"# '#)+6 204


37/56

O2+#',2/,)7 @ P&' Q('1(++#0 Q(&042+,(0 JT

8#+ +"2+ "# "24 0(+ 2 +"(&1"+ +,// +"# >,// 204 /,*#=1,5,01 %(>#' (* ",)K'#2+(' 724# ",7 2 /,5,01 )(&/: !"# *2,+" (* )&?" 4(#) 0(+ )+204 ,0

+"# >,)4(7 (* 7#06 0(' ,0 +"# >('.,01) (* 02+&'2/ 2*C0,+,#) (* 4#2472++#'6 -&+ ,0 +"# %(>#' (* V(4: P&' ?'##4 )28)6 ]V(4 *('7#4 720 (*+"# 4&)+ (* +"# 1'(&046 204 -'#2+"#4 ,0+( ",) 0()+',/) +"# -'#2+" (* /,*#9204 720 -#?27# 2 /,5,01 )(&/:] X,5,01 )(&/) 2'# ?2%2-/# (* +"(&1"+9+"(&1" 0(+ 2/>28) +"# -#)+: Z&+ (&' ?'##4 *&'+"#' )28) (* 7206 ]B,)-'#2+" 1(#+" *('+"6 "# '#+&'0#+" +( ",) #2'+"9 ,0 +"2+ 5#'8 428 ",)+"(&1"+) %#',)":] P&' #))28,)+ 724# -&+ +"# )/,1"+#)+ 2//&),(0 +( +",)?'##49 ",) 2'1&7#0+ >2) 2/+(1#+"#' >"2+ ,) +#'7#4 %",/()(%",?2/:

; >,// 0(+,?# (0# (* ",) ?",#* 2'1&7#0+)6 204 ?(0?/&4# 78 '#72'.):; ?2// ,+ ",) %',0?,%2/ 2'1&7#0+6 -#?2&)# "# )##7) +( +",0. ,+ +"# 7()+,7%('+20+6 "25,01 %&+ ,+ ,0 +"# *('7 (* 2 )8//(1,)7 ]*(' +"# -#0#C+ (*208 >"( 728 >,)" +( ?(7-2+ ,+:] B# )28)6

G: "()# %"#0(7#02 2'# 4,**#'#0+6 2'# +"#7=)#/5#) 4,**#'#0+9

I: !"# %"#0(7#02 (* 72++#' 204 7,04 2'# 4,**#'#0+9

J: !"#'#*('# 72++#' 204 7,04 2'# 4,**#'#0+:]L"2+#5#'6 +"#06 72++#' ,)6 7,04 ,) )(7#+",01 #/)#6 (' 0(+ 72++#':]a(>6 ),0?# +"# 72Y(' %'#7,)# ,) -2)#4 (0 2 /2> *&0427#0+2/ ,0 2//

%",/()(%"86 ,* +"# '#2)(0,01 -# *2&/+86 ,+ 7&)+ -# ,0 +"# 7,0(' %'#7,)#:3'# +"# %"#0(7#02 (* 72++#' 204 7,04 4,**#'#0+6 +"#0[ ;* 8(& 2*C'7+"2+ +"#8 2'# 2/,.#6 +"#0 8(& 204 ; >,// 1( +( +"# /2-('2+('8 204 +#)++"#,' D&2/,+,#): ; >,// +2.# 20 2%%/#6 204 8(& )"2// +2.# 2 +"(&1"+: ;* +"#2%%/# 204 +"# +"(&1"+ 2'# 2/,.#6 ,: #:6 ,* +"#8 2'# -(+" 72++#'6 +"#0 +"#

)27# +#)+ >,// 2%%/8 +( -(+"9 +"#8 >,// "25# +"# )27# D&2/,+,#): a(>-#1,0: ; "(/4 +"# 2%%/# &% -#+>##0 78 +"&7- 204 C01#': a(> 8(&"(/4 8(&' +"(&1"+ &% -#+>##0 8(&' +"&7- 204 C01#': ; %'#)) +"#2%%/#6 204 C04 ,+ "2'4: \( )( -8 +"# +"(&1"+: ; )## +"# 2%%/#9 ,+ ,) '#4204 '(&04: L"2+ ?(/(' 204 )"2%# ,) 8(&' +"(&1"+[ ; -,+# +"# 2%%/#9 ,+,) )(&': B(> 4(#) 8(&' +"(&1"+ +2)+#[ ;/#+ 1( +"# 2%%/#6 204 ,+ *2//) +( +"# ^(('9 ,+ ,) "#258: a(> /#+ 1( 8(&'+"(&1"+9 ,) ,+ "#258[ P6 O2+#',2/,)+6 8(&' 72+#',2/,)7 ,) "#258: ;+ >,//

*2//6 >"#+"#' 8(& /#+ 1( (' 0(+:]L# "25# 0(> +#)+#4 +"# +'&+" (* 78 7,0(' %'#7,)#: !"(&1"+ ,) 2

%"#0(7#0(0 (* +"# 7,04: K(/('6 *('76 #+?:6 2'# %"#0(7#02 (*72++#'6 204 +"#8 2'# 2) &0/,.# 2) +",01) ?20 %()),-/8 -#9 204 +"#'#*('#7,04 204 72++#' 2'# 2) &0/,.# 2) +"#8 ?20 -#9 204 +"#'#*('# 72+#',2/=,)76 >",?" 2*C'7) +"2+ 7,04 ,) 72++#'6 ,) 2) &0+' 2) ,+ ?20 -#:


38/56

JN O2+#',2/,)7 @ P&' Q('1(++#0 Q(&042+,(0

]!"2+ %2'+ (* 7206 +"#06 >",?" +",0.)6 204 *##/)6 204 >,//)6 0(+-#,01 72++#'6 ,) ?(0)#D+/8 0#,+"#' 4#%#04#0+ &%(0 72++#' *('

#A,)+#0?#6 0(' )&-Y#?+ +( 208 (* +"# /2>) >",?" 1(5#'0 72++#': b"8),?2/4,))(/&+,(06 +"#06 (* +"# -(486 ?20 2**#?+ (0/8 +"# -(486 "25,01 0(#**#?+ >"2+#5#' &%(0 +"# 7,046 ,0 '#)%#?+ (* ,+) #))#0+,2/ #))#0?# ('D&2/,+,#): L"2+ ,+ >2) -#*('# +"# 4#2+" (* +"# -(486 ,+ 7&)+ '#72,02*+#' +"2+ #5#0+=#))#0+,2//8 2 +",0.,016 >,//,016 204 *##/,01 #0+,+8:]

3 52)+/8 /2'1# ?(0?/&),(0 +( 4'2> *'(7 )( )72// %'#7,)#): O8%(08`) +"(&1"+) 2'# 4,**#'#0+ *'(7 ",) -(489 +"#8 4( 0(+ %'#)#0+ +"#)27# %"#0(7#02: 304 )(7#+,7#) >"#0 "# ?(7#) +( ?'())='(24)6 "#?"(()#) 204 >,//) +( +2.# +"# '(24 +"2+ "# +",0.) /#24) +(>2'4 "(7#:f#+ ; 0#5#' +"(&1" (* ,0*#'',01 )&?" 2)+(0,)",01/8 /2'1# ?(0?/&),(0)*'(7 +"#)# *2?+): P&' *',#04) (* +"# (%%(),+# ),4# (* +"# D)+,(062/>28) *('1#+ +( +2.# +"# +"(&1"+) (* +"# ,0*#',(' 20,72/) ,0+( +"#/2-('2+('8 *(' 2 +#)+ 204 ?(7%2',)(0 >,+" "&720 +"(&1"+): L#6 2) 2%#(%/#6 ?200(+ 20)>#' *(' (+"#')6 -&+ (&' 72+#',2/,)7 0#5#' ]2*C'7)+"2+ 7,04 ,) 72++#'9] 204 ># 4(&-+ 5#'8 7&?" +"# %'(%',#+8 (*

%2?.,01 &) ,0 +"# )27# -(A >,+" ,0C4#/)6 204 +"#0 ?(04#70,01 +"# /(+:Z&+ +( 4,)?(5#' +"# *2//2?8 (* 78 *',#04`) '#2)(0,016 ; ,0D&,'#6 \(+"(&1"+) +",0.[ ; '#7#7-#' (* '#24,01 ,0 +"# (/4 )%#//,01=-((.6]!",0.#') +",0. +"(&1"+):] !",0.#') 204 +"(&1"+) 2'# +>( +",01):!2.# 2 +",0.#' +"#0 +( +"# /2-('2+('86 ,: #:6 (0# >"( +",0.)6 204 8(&>,// C04 ",7 %())#))#4 (* 2) 7208 %2/%2-/# D&2/,+,#) 2) 8(&' 2%%/#: ;),+ +"# 7,04 +"2+ +",0.)[ Z&+ >"2+ ,) 2 720`) 7,04 -&+ ",) +"(&1"+)[O8 *',#04 )%#2.) ?(''#?+/8: B# )%#2.) (* ]72++#' 204 7,046] 204 +"#0

2) 2 )%#?,7#0 (' )27%/# (* #2?"6 "# +2.#) 20 2%%/# 204 2 +"(&1"+: Z&+6)28) 78 *',#046 ]!"(&1"+ ,) 2 %"#0(7#0(0 (* +"# 7,04: K(/('6 *('76#+?:6 2'# %"#0(7#02 (* 72++#':] !"#0 ># "25# 0(+ "24 2 *2,' +#)+6 204># 7&)+ 1( 212,0 +( +"# /2-('2+('8: 3) ; "25# (0/8 2 +"(&1"+6 2%"#0(7#0(0 (* )(7#+",01 +"2+ "2) 0( 2%%#2'20?#6 8(& )"2// /#25#8(&' 2%%/# -#",046 204 +2.# (0/8 )(7# (* ,+) %"#0(7#02=,+) ?(/(' ('*('76 ,+) )(&'0#))6 ,+) "2'40#)) (' ,+) "#25,0#)): a(> "(/4 &% 8(&')"2%# (* 20 2%%/# -#+>##0 8(&' +"&7- 204 C01#': b'#)) ,+9 ,) ,+ "2'4[

X((. 2+ ,+6 +2)+# ,+6 )7#// ,+6 >#,1" ,+: L"2+ ,) +"# 4,**#'#0?# -#+>##0 ,+204 2 +"(&1"+[ ;* 8(& 2'# 4,))2+,)C#4 >,+" +",) +#)+6 204 7&)+ "25#8(&' 2%%/#6 ; >,// +2.# 2 7206 (0# (* >"()# 2++',-&+#) ,) 7,046 ('+"(&1"+6 204 +"#0 ># >,// "25# 2 *2,' +#)+: L# )"2// C04 +"2+ /,5,0172++#' ,) 4#?,4#4/8 ,0 24520?# (* 4#24 72++#' ,0 ,+) D&2/,+,#) 204?2%2-,/,+,#): ]3 /,5,01 4(1 ,) -#++#' +"20 2 4#24 /,(0:]


39/56

O2+#',2/,)7 @ P&' Q('1(++#0 Q(&042+,(0 Jh

L# "25# 0( ?(0+'(5#')8 >,+" (&' *',#04) (* +"# (%%(),+,(0 ,0'#)%#?+ +( +"#'# -#,01 2 4,**#'#0?# -#+>##0 7,046 (' +"(&1"+)6 204

72++#': L# 4( 0(+ ?/2,7 +"2+ 7,04 ,) 72++#'9 204 +"()# >"( >(&/4*2,'/8 (%%()# (&' 5,#>) )"(&/4 ?#2)# +( 7,)'#%'#)#0+ &): !"#?(00#?+,(0 -#+>##0 72++#' 204 7,04 ,) 2 78)+#'86 >",?" 0#,+"#' (&'*',#04) 0(' (&')#/5#) 2'# 2-/# +( #A%/2,0: a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

,772+#',2/ +"(&1"+) >,+" +"# )27#9 204 8#+ +"#8 "(/4 +"2+ +",) )(&/ ,)?(00#?+#4 >,+" 72++#'6 204 +"#8 "25# 0#5#' -##0 2-/# +( 4,)?(5#' (0#+"2+ >2) 0(+6 2/+"(&1" +"#8 ?/2,7 +( "25# Y&)+ )&?" 2 )(&/ +"#7)#/5#):

!"#8 /#25# (&+ (* +"# ?(0+'(5#')8 +"# >,)4(7 204 %(>#' (* V(46>",?" ?20 2) #2),/8 ?(00#?+ ,772+#',2/ +"(&1"+)6 2) 20 ,772+#',2/)(&/6 >,+" 72++#'6 204 %&') 2 ?(&')# (* '#2)(0,01 >",?"6 ,* 52/,46>(&/4 72.# ,+ Y&)+ 2) 0#?#))2'8 *(' "(')#) 204 4(1) +( "25# ,772+#',2/)(&/) +( ?(00#?+ +"#,' ,772+#',2/ ,0+#//,1#0?# >,+" +"#,' 72+#',2/

-(4,#)9 204 ,* ,772+#',2/,+8 ,) 2 %'((* (* ,77('+2/,+86 7206 >"( -(2)+)(* ",) ,77('+2/,+86 ,)6 ,0 +",) '#)%#?+6 0( -#++#' +"20 +"# -'&+#:

!"# >('/4 -8 >,)4(7 4(#) 0(+ 8#+ .0(> V(4: 3// +"2+ ># .0(> (*+"# 78)+#',(&) ?(00#?+,(0 -#+>##0 7,04 204 72++#'6 (' ?(0?#'0,01 2*&+&'# /,*#6 ,) >"2+ "# "2) )##0 C+ +( '#5#2/ +( &) ,0 ",) >('4: 304 ),0?#(&' >,)4(7 (' *(//8 ?200(+ ,7%'(5# +",) '#5#/2+,(06 ># )"2// 4( -#++#'+( 2??#%+ (* ,+ 2) ,+ ,): !"2+ >('4 +#//) &) %/2,0/8 +"2+ 720 >"( >2)724# (* 4&)+6 (0 '#?#,5,01 +"# -'#2+" (* /,*#6 -#?27# 2 /,5,01 )(&/: P*

+"# ,772+#',2/6 ,77('+2/ )(&/ ,+ )28) 0(+",01: P0 +"# ?(0+'2'86 ,+ ?2//)720 7('+2/6 >,+" 0( %2'+ #A?#%+#46 -&+ %'(7,)#) ",7 2 *&+&'# /,*# -87#20) (* 2 '#)&''#?+,(0 (* +"# 4#246 204 ,77('+2/,+8 (0 ?(04,+,(0 (*",) )##.,01 *(' ,+ ,0 +"# >28 (* *2,+" 204 (-#4,#0?#: P&' %",/()(%",?*',#04) 728 ,721,0# +"2+ +"#8 2,4 +"# -#/,#* ,0 2 *&+&'# /,*# +"'(&1" +"#'#)&''#?+,(06 -8 %'(5,01 +"2+ 720 ,) ,77('+2/ ,04#%#04#0+ (* ,+9 -&+


40/56

Ji O2+#',2/,)7 @ P&' Q('1(++#0 Q(&042+,(0

+"# #**#?+ (* +"#,' '#2)(0,01 7&)+ -# +( >#2.#0 *2,+" ,0 ,+6 -8 72.,01 ,+2%%#2' +"2+ +"#'# ,) 0( 0##4 (* ,+=+"2+ 720 ,) ,77('+2/ >,+"(&+ ,+6 204

?20 *#2)+ ",) ],77('+2/ 7,04] (0 2// +"# Y(8) (* b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

Z&+ >",/# ># 7(&'0 (5#' +"# *2?+ +"2+ (&' *',#04) 2'# &0>,++,01/82,4,01 +"# ?2&)# (* ,)4(76 #,+"#' 20?,#0+ (' 7(4#'06 -&+ ,0 +"#>('4 (* V(4: O28 B#25#0 2,4 +"# "(0#)+ ,0D&,'#' +( /28 2),4# "&720>,)4(76 204 '#?#,5# +"2+ >('4 ,0 ,+) 02+,5# ),7%/,?,+86 "2'7(086 204-#2&+86 204 +"&) #)?2%# +"# )&-+/# )02'#6 >",?"


41/56

O2+#',2/,)7 @ P&' Q('1(++#0 Q(&042+,(0 JU

p304 V(4 )2,46 X#+ &) 72.# 720 ,0 (&' ,721#6 2*+#' (&' /,.#0#))9q )( V(4 ?'#2+#4 720 ,0 ",) (>0 ,721#6 ,0 +"# ,721# (* V(4 ?'#2+#4

"# ",79 72/# 204 *#72/# ?'#2+#4 "# +"#7:r V#0: GEIN6 Ih: ;* 720 >2)724# ,0 +"# ,721# 204 /,.#0#)) (* V(46 +"#0 ># .0(> "(> V(4 /((.)6>"2+ )"2%# "# "2)9 "# ,) ,0 +"# )"2%# (* 720: 3 %((' #52),(0 ,)2++#7%+#4 "#'#6 -8 2))#'+,01 +"2+ ,+ ,) +"# )%,',+ (* 720 +"2+ ,) ,0 +"#,721# (* V(4: Z&+ +"# +#A+) )28) 0( )&?" +",01: ;+ )28)6 pX#+ &) 72.#720 ,0 (&' ,721#:r !"#0 ># 2'# +(/4 "(> +",) >2) 4(0#E p304 +"#X('4 V(4 *('7#4 720 ,0 +"# 4&)+ (* +"# 1'(&04:r V#0: IEh: P* >"2+4,4 V(4 *('7 720[ ;+ >2) 4,'#?+/8 )2,4 +"2+ "# >2) *('7#4 (* +"# 4&)+(* +"# 1'(&04: g#'8 >#//9 +"#0 +"2+ >",?" >2) *('7#4 (* +"# 4&)+ (*+"# 1'(&04 ,) ,0 +"# ,721# (* V(4: V#0: UEN ?(0C'7) +",) *2?+EpL"()( )"#44#+" 720`) -/((46 -8 720 )"2// ",) -/((4 -# )"#49 *(' ,0+"# ,721# (* V(4 724# "# 720:r

;* 2 720 .,//#4 2 -#2)+6 >2) "# +( 4,# *(' +"2+[ a(9 -&+ ,* "# )"#4+"# -/((4 (* 2 720 "# 7&)+ 4,#: !"# '#2)(0 ,) )+2+#4E pQ(' ,0 +"#,721# (* V(4 724# "# 7206r ,:#:6 "# "2) .,//#4 204 4#)+'(8#4 +"2+

>",?" ,) 724# ,0 +"# ,721# (* V(4: a(> +"# D)+,(0 ,)6 >"2+ "2) "#.,//#4[ a(+ 20 ,77('+2/ )%,',+ (* )(&/6 -&+ +"# -(486 +"2+ >",?" "24-/((46 +"2+ >",?" >2) ,0 +"# ,721# (* V(4: B#0?# ,+ ,) +"# -(48 >",?",) ,0 +"# ,721# (* V(4:

!"# >('4) ,721# 204 /,.#0#)) 2'# +"&) 4#C0#4 -8 L#-)+#'E=p;721#6 0: G: 3 '#%'#)#0+2+,(0 (' ),7,/,+&4# (* 208 %#')(0 (' +",01

*('7#4 (* 2 72+#',2/ )&-)+20?#E 2)6 20 ,721# >'(&1"+ (&+ (* )+(0#6>((4 (' >2A: I: 3 )+2+:r ;+) 7#20,01 ,) %/2,0: ;+ ,) 2 '#%'#)#0+2+,(0

(* )(7#+",01 #/)# ,0 +"# )27# *('7: pX,.#0#))6 0: W#)#7-/20?# ,0*('79 ),7,/,+&4#: !"# %,?+&'# ,) 2 1((4 /,.#0#)) (* +"# (',1,02/: I:W#)#7-/20?#9 *('7E #A+#'02/ 2%%#2'20?#: J: P0# +"2+ '#)#7-/#)20(+"#'9 2 ?(%89 2 ?(&0+#'%2'+:r b/2,0/86 +"#06 20 ,721# (' /,.#0#)) ,)+"2+ >",?" ,) ,0 +"# *('7 (*6 204 /((.) /,.#6 +"2+ >",?" ,+ ,) +('#%'#)#0+: O20 ,) ,0 +"# ,721# 204 /,.#0#)) (* V(49 "#0?# V(4 "2) 2-(48 ,0 *('7 /,.# +"2+ (* 2 720:

X#+ &) 0(> +&'0 +( +"# Z,-/#6 204 C04 +"# 7#20,01 (* +"# >('4

,721# 2) ,+ ,) +"#'# &)#4: ;+ >,// -# *(&04 +"2+ #5#'8 +,7# ,+ '#*#') +()(7#+",01 +"2+ "2) 2 *('76 2 '#2/ )&-)+20?#6 2 )"2%#:

pf# )"2// 72.# 8(& 0( ,4(/) 0(' 1'25#0 ,721#6 0#,+"#' '#2' 8(& &%2 )+204,01 ,721#6 0#,+"#' )"2// 8# )#+ &% 20 ,721# (* )+(0# ,0 8(&'/2046 +( -(> 4(>0 &0+( ,+9 *(' ; 27 +"# X('4 8(&' V(4:r X#5: INEG:p304 O,?"2/ +((. 20 ,721#6 204 /2,4 ,+ ,0 +"# -#4:r G


42/56

dM O2+#',2/,)7 @ P&' Q('1(++#0 Q(&042+,(0

p304 "# )#+ 2 ?2'5#4 ,721#6 +"# ,4(/ >",?" "# "24 724#6 ,0 +"# "(&)#(* V(4:r I K"'(0: JJEh p!"(&6 P .,016 )2>#)+6 204 -#"#/4 2 1'#2+

,721#: !",) 1'#2+ ,721#6 >"()# -',1"+0#)) >2) #A?#//#0+6 )+((4 -#*('#+"##9 204 +"# *('7 +"#'#(* >2) +#'',-/#:r \20: IEJG: pa#-&?"240#__2'+"# .,01 724# 20 ,721# (* 1(/46 >"()# "#,1"+ >2) +"'##)?('# ?&-,+)6204 +"# -'#24+" +"#'#(* ),A ?&-,+):r \20: JEG: p304 "# )2,+" &0+(+"#76 L"()# ,) +",) ,721# 204 )&%#')?',%+,(0[r O2++: IIEIM: pf# 7#0(* S%"#)&)6 >"2+ 720 ,) +"#'# +"2+ .0(>#+" 0(+ "(> +"2+ +"# ?,+8 (*+"# S%"#),20) ,) 2 >(')",%#' (* +"# 1'#2+ 1(44#)) \,2026 204 (* +"#,721# >",?" *#// 4(>0 *'(7 c&%,+#'[r 3?+) GUEJT: p; "25# '#)#'5#4 +(78)#/* )#5#0 +"(&)204 7#06 >"( "25# 0(+ -(>#4 +"# .0## +( +"#,721# (* Z22/:r W(7: GGEd: p#// (0 +"# #2'+"6+"2+ +"#8 )"(&/4 72.# 20 ,721# +( +"# -#2)+6 >",?" "24 +"# >(&04 -8+"# )>('46 204 4,4 /,5#:r W#5: GJEGd: pL"#'#*('# 8# )"2// 72.#,721#) (* 8(&' #7#'(4)6 204 ,721#) (* 8(&' 7,?# +"2+ 72' +"# /204:rG "( -#,01 ,0 +"# *('7 (* V(4:r B#'# ># )+(% +( 2). "(> K"',)+?(&/4 -# ,0 +"# *('7 (* V(46 ,* V(4 "24 0( *('7: Z&+ c#)&) >2) ,0 +"#*('7 (* V(49 "#0?# +"# 2'1&7#0+ ,) ?(0?/&),5# +"2+ V(4 "2) 2 *('7:pL"( -#,01 ,0 +"# *('7 (* V(46 +"(&1"+ ,+ 0(+ '(--#'8 +( -# #D&2/

>,+" V(49 -&+ 724# ",7)#/* (* 0( '#%&+2+,(06 204 +((. &%(0 ",7 +"#*('7 (* 2 )#'520+ F720H6 204 >2) 724# ,0 +"# /,.#0#)) (* 7#09 204-#,01 *(&04 ,0 *2)",(0 2) 2 7206 "# "&7-/#4 ",7)#/*6r #+?: B#'# ,+ ,)4#?/2'#4 +"2+ K"',)+ >2) ,0 +"# *('7 (* V(46 ,0 +"# *('7 (* 2 )#'520+6,0 +"# /,.#0#)) (* 7206 ,0 +"# *2)",(0 (* 720: L# .0(> +"2+ +",) >2)",) -(489 *(' K"',)+ >2) -(+" ,0 +"# *('7 (* V(46 204 ,0 +"# *('7 (*


43/56

O2+#',2/,)7 @ P&' Q('1(++#0 Q(&042+,(0 dG

720: !"#0 V(4 204 720 -(+" "25# +"# )27# *('7:P* c#)&) b2&/ )28)6 pL"( -#,01 +"# -',1"+0#)) (*

materialism - our forgotten foundation

Documents