market, state, regulation & yellow submarine iaee · 2017. 9. 27. · regulation: a lego to...
TRANSCRIPT
![Page 1: Market, State, Regulation & Yellow Submarine IAEE · 2017. 9. 27. · Regulation: a Lego to play… • Seam(2): Coordinating zonesof infrastructures + Designing zonesof market At](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022060516/60495d6f5ca4b709f17b4c6e/html5/thumbnails/1.jpg)
Market, State, Regulation & Yellow Submarine
IAEEVienna – Tuesday 5th September 2017
Jean-Michel GlachantDirector Florence School of Regulation
European University Institute (Florence, Italy)
![Page 2: Market, State, Regulation & Yellow Submarine IAEE · 2017. 9. 27. · Regulation: a Lego to play… • Seam(2): Coordinating zonesof infrastructures + Designing zonesof market At](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022060516/60495d6f5ca4b709f17b4c6e/html5/thumbnails/2.jpg)
2
I was born…
In the city where…
![Page 3: Market, State, Regulation & Yellow Submarine IAEE · 2017. 9. 27. · Regulation: a Lego to play… • Seam(2): Coordinating zonesof infrastructures + Designing zonesof market At](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022060516/60495d6f5ca4b709f17b4c6e/html5/thumbnails/3.jpg)
3
Yesterday, where’s yellow vs Black & White?
![Page 4: Market, State, Regulation & Yellow Submarine IAEE · 2017. 9. 27. · Regulation: a Lego to play… • Seam(2): Coordinating zonesof infrastructures + Designing zonesof market At](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022060516/60495d6f5ca4b709f17b4c6e/html5/thumbnails/4.jpg)
4
Yellow’s a governance issue = Institutional economics
Institutional EconomicsYou know…
Ronald Coase 1991…
Douglass North 1993…
Elinor Ostrom…
& Oliver Williamson 2009
A la French!
![Page 5: Market, State, Regulation & Yellow Submarine IAEE · 2017. 9. 27. · Regulation: a Lego to play… • Seam(2): Coordinating zonesof infrastructures + Designing zonesof market At](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022060516/60495d6f5ca4b709f17b4c6e/html5/thumbnails/5.jpg)
Fasten your seat belt:Take-off
5
Now please…
![Page 6: Market, State, Regulation & Yellow Submarine IAEE · 2017. 9. 27. · Regulation: a Lego to play… • Seam(2): Coordinating zonesof infrastructures + Designing zonesof market At](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022060516/60495d6f5ca4b709f17b4c6e/html5/thumbnails/6.jpg)
State, Market & Regulation Lego• Old governance: Integrated Infrastructure Monopoly +
“GrandPa” Public Service1- Old roots & bones are “infrastructure monopoly” (“essential facility” pricing) (J. Dupuit 1840, A. Marshall 1880, A. Pigou 1920)
2- But real flesh is Integrated “Mass Market” regulated services framed by “Political economy”Olie Williamson: asset specificity > “fundamental transformation” Doug. North: monopoly assets are trapped > General Institutions set basic rules> industry contracting align(Universal Service + Postal Stamp) + (Social Tariff + Labourworking conditions + Coal miners jobs + Peripheral territories) + ?
6
![Page 7: Market, State, Regulation & Yellow Submarine IAEE · 2017. 9. 27. · Regulation: a Lego to play… • Seam(2): Coordinating zonesof infrastructures + Designing zonesof market At](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022060516/60495d6f5ca4b709f17b4c6e/html5/thumbnails/7.jpg)
State, Market, Regulation Lego
• New Governance: Double unbundling + incentive regulation 1- Unbundling “Infrastructure facility” from “final services”> credibility to market opening for technology choices & final services 2- Unbundling “Regulation” from “Political economy” > credibility to regulatory ruling outside political deals
3- Power Sector two times unbundled > you can go to “Incentive Regulation”, … and face its “seams”
7
![Page 8: Market, State, Regulation & Yellow Submarine IAEE · 2017. 9. 27. · Regulation: a Lego to play… • Seam(2): Coordinating zonesof infrastructures + Designing zonesof market At](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022060516/60495d6f5ca4b709f17b4c6e/html5/thumbnails/8.jpg)
Regulation: a Lego to play…• Seam(1): Coordinating the unbundled Industry + Then designing (= ruling)
the market1- Rules for Infrastructures access & usage interact with “final services market” via “system operation” (Olie Williamson)
2- “System operation neutrality” is extremely “market design” sensitive
3- To get infrastructure operation right you have to design the market rules
8
![Page 9: Market, State, Regulation & Yellow Submarine IAEE · 2017. 9. 27. · Regulation: a Lego to play… • Seam(2): Coordinating zonesof infrastructures + Designing zonesof market At](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022060516/60495d6f5ca4b709f17b4c6e/html5/thumbnails/9.jpg)
Regulation: a Lego to play…• Seam(1): Coordinating the unbundled Industry + Then designing (= ruling)
the market4 - Revenge of Ronald Coase: markets need trade infrastructures; private order or public law; but Rules: transaction <> coordination
Hard fact – Comprehensive “Electricity Transaction” is made of: a- Trading Energy “day-Ahead” in wholesale marketb- Looking if grid can deliver Energy Equilibrium > network capacity, or congestionc- Keeping Energy balanced “Real Time”> balancing with Power Reserve
“Real” electricity made of 3 goods: Energy, Power, Network. Energy only is “incomplete market”
9
![Page 10: Market, State, Regulation & Yellow Submarine IAEE · 2017. 9. 27. · Regulation: a Lego to play… • Seam(2): Coordinating zonesof infrastructures + Designing zonesof market At](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022060516/60495d6f5ca4b709f17b4c6e/html5/thumbnails/10.jpg)
Regulation: a Lego to play…
• Seam(2): Coordinating zones of infrastructures + Then designing zones of the market
1- Rules for each infrastructure “zone” interact with “final services market” in other zones via “system operation zonal rules” (Olie Williamson)2- “System operation neutrality” at continental scale is extremely “System operation seams“ and “market design seams” sensitive3- BUT coordinating (“zone” to “zone”) is (“country” to “country”) AND THIs is not unbundled from national governments and legislators
Revenge of Douglas North: in zonal domain of X-B interactions, the zonal governments & legislators hold the national keys. How to rebundle (at EU level) the “nationally bundled”?
10
![Page 11: Market, State, Regulation & Yellow Submarine IAEE · 2017. 9. 27. · Regulation: a Lego to play… • Seam(2): Coordinating zonesof infrastructures + Designing zonesof market At](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022060516/60495d6f5ca4b709f17b4c6e/html5/thumbnails/11.jpg)
Regulation: a Lego to play…
• Seam(2): Coordinating zones of infrastructures + Designing zones of market
At EU level? … EU has no regulatory power to issue EU regulations & no agencies to implement them
EU Commission NOT a federal government with fed.agencies (as FERC or EPA)- > NO EU system operation regulation till 2017!- > NO EU market design till… 2017 (hidden into System Operation Guidelines)
*Tricks 3dPackage 2009 (NRAS> ACER)> Guidelines; (TSOs> ENTSO-E)>Codes
**SOFTWARE: 1st System Operation EU regulation 2015; input for drafting; coop. for methodologies & implementation
***HARDWARE: 1st Infrastructure EU Regulation 2013; but cut from ENTSO-E11
![Page 12: Market, State, Regulation & Yellow Submarine IAEE · 2017. 9. 27. · Regulation: a Lego to play… • Seam(2): Coordinating zonesof infrastructures + Designing zonesof market At](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022060516/60495d6f5ca4b709f17b4c6e/html5/thumbnails/12.jpg)
I won’t do… C02 & RES pushC02 mitigation as another brand new public policy; with 2 faces
1- Hard economic approach: pricing carbon# Carbon Tax (Jo Stiglitz) or Cap & Trade (Jean Tirole)# Read EEEP “Economics of Energy & Environmental Policy” IAEE Journal, September 2015
2- Political Economy & Industrial Policy approach: pushing renewables # RES obligation vs Feed-In; # FiT vs FiP# (RES new Political Economy) vs (Coal mines old Political Eco.)12(
![Page 13: Market, State, Regulation & Yellow Submarine IAEE · 2017. 9. 27. · Regulation: a Lego to play… • Seam(2): Coordinating zonesof infrastructures + Designing zonesof market At](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022060516/60495d6f5ca4b709f17b4c6e/html5/thumbnails/13.jpg)
Let’s take RES push as given…Does RES push delete or amplify “Industry-Market Seam(1)” and “Zonal vs EU Regulation Seam (2)” issues?
• Seam(1): Coordinating the unbundled Industry + Then designing the market1- Rules for Infrastructures access & usage interact with “final services market” via “system operation” (Olie Williamson) 2- “System operation neutrality” is extremely “market design” sensitive 3- To get infrastructure operation right you have to design the market rules
(Reinhard Haas & Richard Green this morning >>>) + Karsten Neuhoff right now
Need to go to EU MarketDesign 2.0 Then too EU NetworkCodes 2.0 (Karsten Neuhoff)
13
![Page 14: Market, State, Regulation & Yellow Submarine IAEE · 2017. 9. 27. · Regulation: a Lego to play… • Seam(2): Coordinating zonesof infrastructures + Designing zonesof market At](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022060516/60495d6f5ca4b709f17b4c6e/html5/thumbnails/14.jpg)
Let’s take RES push as given…Does RES push delete or amplify “Zonal vs EU Regulation”Seam (2) issues?
• Seam(2): Coordinating zones of infrastructures + Then designing zones for market
1- To tackle massive EU RES integration we need full X-B congestion management X-B balancing (… postponed 2023) Market Bidding Zones review X-B Network planning
>> stronger Europeanisation of TSOs and of NRAs• 4th package? Fierce national resistance!
14
![Page 15: Market, State, Regulation & Yellow Submarine IAEE · 2017. 9. 27. · Regulation: a Lego to play… • Seam(2): Coordinating zonesof infrastructures + Designing zonesof market At](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022060516/60495d6f5ca4b709f17b4c6e/html5/thumbnails/15.jpg)
Let’s take RES push as given…RES also create new “Seams issues”: distributed generation, distribution grids, distributed systems
• Seam(3): Coordinating deeper the unbundled Industry + Then designing deeper the market
1- Rules for Distribution Infrastructures access & usage interact with rules for transmission 2- Markets for network services at distribution & transmission levels interact “final services market” via “distrib. system operation” (Olie Williamson)
Need to go to deeper EU MarketDesign 2.0 & deeper EU NetworkCodes 2.0 (Reinhard Haas) (Karsten Neuhoff)
Infra-national only? Or supra-national too?
15
![Page 16: Market, State, Regulation & Yellow Submarine IAEE · 2017. 9. 27. · Regulation: a Lego to play… • Seam(2): Coordinating zonesof infrastructures + Designing zonesof market At](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022060516/60495d6f5ca4b709f17b4c6e/html5/thumbnails/16.jpg)
Schumpeter wave: Decentral. + Digital.
FORGET that RES are Green see them only as Yellow! !!“Decentral. / Digital” to change Governance needs & options? OF COURSE
1/ Industry Unbundling 1990-2010 did create “modular” elec. Industry which did spread into “modular” Market Design(s)Generation decentralization + Consumption decentralization push this to new limits as “Self-governed individual Prosumers”
2/ (Digitalization + Massive data processing) injected in Decentralization of Operation brings “Internet & Smart Tools” inside Electricity world 4th Industrial revolution. You don’t believe it? Electrical & self-driven “Google cars”
16
![Page 17: Market, State, Regulation & Yellow Submarine IAEE · 2017. 9. 27. · Regulation: a Lego to play… • Seam(2): Coordinating zonesof infrastructures + Designing zonesof market At](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022060516/60495d6f5ca4b709f17b4c6e/html5/thumbnails/17.jpg)
Schumpeter wave: Decentral. + Digital.
4th Indus Revolution accelerates all “micro-micro” = nano? changes: # micro modularity of industry (say RES > Prosumers); # modularity of “Transaction Designs” (Say > New Intermediaries as aggregators, alternative Transaction Platforms, etc.); # it opens too “Users modularity” (Say> Active Block-chain Communities)
17
![Page 18: Market, State, Regulation & Yellow Submarine IAEE · 2017. 9. 27. · Regulation: a Lego to play… • Seam(2): Coordinating zonesof infrastructures + Designing zonesof market At](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022060516/60495d6f5ca4b709f17b4c6e/html5/thumbnails/18.jpg)
How to conclude such amount of novelties? #Pa &GrandPa both dead? #To see-smell corpses in 2022?
18
![Page 19: Market, State, Regulation & Yellow Submarine IAEE · 2017. 9. 27. · Regulation: a Lego to play… • Seam(2): Coordinating zonesof infrastructures + Designing zonesof market At](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022060516/60495d6f5ca4b709f17b4c6e/html5/thumbnails/19.jpg)
Schumpeter wave Digitiz.Decentriz.?Governance “innovation” through decentralization & digitalization
Brave new world made of Industry strong Decentralization & Modularity + Pioneer newEntrepreneurs + Pioneer Users Communities If regulation follows, it can open 5 new worlds: 1-Forums (Open debate for new coordination rules)
~2-Innovation Zoos (“Sand boxes” for advanced innovators put outside common regulation)~3-Communities (“Users & Prosumers Clubs” : self-regulated users-producers close-shop)~4-Roaring Cow-Boys (NewYork “plug-and-play” infrastructures open to new entrants)~5-Big e-Sisters (Google, Apple, Amazon,etc. creating “Re-Integrated” alternative worlds. Irony: universal access; “postal stamp” or “Social tariff” as basic service for free)19
![Page 20: Market, State, Regulation & Yellow Submarine IAEE · 2017. 9. 27. · Regulation: a Lego to play… • Seam(2): Coordinating zonesof infrastructures + Designing zonesof market At](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022060516/60495d6f5ca4b709f17b4c6e/html5/thumbnails/20.jpg)
www.florence-school.eu 20
Thank you for your attentionEmail contact: [email protected]
Follow me on Twitter: @JMGlachant +/- 32 000 tweets
My web site: http://www.florence-school.eu