marcia s. wagner, esq. custom solutions: legal, compliance and disclosure
TRANSCRIPT
Marcia S. Wagner, Esq.
Custom Solutions: Legal, Compliance and Disclosure
2
IntroductionTarget-Date and Target-Risk Funds
◦ Popular default investments for DC plans.◦ Many are “prepackaged” funds.◦ One size fits all.
Next Phase of Evolution - Custom Solutions ◦ Tailored to advisors’ investment strategies.◦ Greater investment flexibility.◦ Eliminate potential conflicts.◦ Access to lower costs.
3
Model PortfoliosDiscretionary Model Portfolios◦Model portfolio applied to participant’s account.◦Similar to managed accounts.◦Plan’s regular menu is used to create model
portfolio with target-date, target-risk strategy.◦Example: Target-Date Model Portfolio◦Customary for advisor to serve as “investment
manager” under ERISA 3(38).
4
Model Portfolios (cont’d)Plan sponsor may manage Model Portfolios.
◦ Financial advisor serves as co-fiduciary.◦ Plan sponsor makes ultimate investment decisions.◦ Arrangement preferred by institutional plans.
Investment Manager for Model Portfolios◦ Plan Sponsor must select advisor prudently.◦ But is not responsible for advisor’s individual actions.◦ Arrangement utilized by plans of all sizes.
5
Bank Collective Investment FundsCollective Investment Funds (CIFs)
◦ Maintained by bank trustee.◦ Pooled vehicle for plan investors.
Regulatory Framework◦ IRS rules for “group trust”◦ DOL fiduciary requirements◦ Bank regulations (such as OCC Reg. 9.18)◦ Exemption from SEC registration
6
CIFs and Third-Party AdvisorsCIF’s bank trustee may partner with third party
advisors (e.g., RIA firm).◦ For example, RIA advises plan clients on their DIAs.◦ CIF is created, using same DIAs as custom solution.◦ RIA advises bank trustee on CIF’s underlying portfolio.
SEC Exemption◦ Requirements under ICA Section 3(c)(11) and Securities
Act Section 3(a)(2).◦ Requires bank trustee to exercise “substantial
investment responsibility.”◦ Bank trustee must have final authority over following
RIA’s advice.
7
Model Portfolios vs. CIFsModel Portfolios
◦ Plan sponsor must have internal resources to coordinate investment management services.
◦ May manage Model Portfolios with assistance from advisor, or appoint advisor to manage them.
CIFs◦ Convenience of an investment product.◦ Bank trustee can assist with implementation,
operational issues and participant disclosures.
8
Purpose of QDIA RulesImpact of QDIA Rules on Default Investments
◦ For auto-enrolled participants whose contributions are transferred to default investment.
◦ Pension Protection Act of 2006 created “safe harbor” fiduciary protection for Plan’s default investment.
◦ Default investment must qualify as QDIA.◦ If safe harbor applies, defaulted participants alone are
responsible for their passive investment decisions.
9
QDIA DefinitionQDIA Conditions (for Non-mutual Funds)
◦ Target-date or balanced strategy◦ Must be managed by “3(38)” investment manager, or
bank trustee meeting requirements of ERISA 3(38).◦ Plan sponsor can also manage QDIA.
ERISA Section 3(38) Definition◦ Must have investment power.◦ Must be a bank, insurance company or RIA.◦ Must acknowledge fiduciary status in writing.
10
Custom Solutions and QDIA DefinitionQDIA definition impacts structure of custom
solutions.◦ QDIA rules require target-date or balanced strategy.◦ Must be managed by RIA or bank trustee.
Custom solutions satisfy QDIA definition.◦ CIFs are managed by bank trustee.◦ Model Portfolios are managed by investment
manager, or plan sponsor with advisor’s assistance.◦ Non-discretionary model portfolios do not meet QDIA
requirements.
11
Other QDIA ConsiderationsTarget-Date Investment Strategy
◦ Asset mix must be consistent with age, retirement or life expectancy.
◦ Must become more conservative over time.
Balanced, Target-Risk Strategy◦ Asset mix must be consistent with target risk for plan.
General Investment Requirements◦ Generally accepted investment theories.◦ Long-term appreciation and capital preservation.◦ Diversified to minimize risk of large losses.
12
General Fiduciary Standard Under ERISAQDIA safe harbor does not relieve all fiduciary
responsibilities.◦ QDIA must be prudent default investment.◦ Fiduciary Duties of Prudence and Loyalty
Prudence Standard◦ Fiduciary must act with “the care, skill, prudence, and
diligence under the circumstances…”◦ “…that a prudent man acting in a like capacity and
familiar with such matters would use…”
13
Unique Fiduciary ConsiderationsIndependent Investigation of Target-Date,
Target-Risk Strategies◦ “All in One” Investment◦ For Less Sophisticated Participants◦ Selection of Underlying Funds◦ Target Asset Allocations (such as TDF glide path)
14
Fulfilling the Duty of Prudence
Application to General Investments◦ Procedural in nature.◦ Requires independent investigation of merits of
investment.◦ Fiduciary must give “appropriate consideration” to
relevant facts and circumstances.◦ Investment must be reasonably designed to further
plan purposes.
Application to Target-Date, Target-Risk Strategies
15
Potential Conflicts Relating to Underlying Funds
Asset allocation solutions may be susceptible to conflicts of interest.◦ Conflicts may arise due to manager’s incentive to
invest in proprietary funds.◦ Proprietary funds may have poor performance or
excessive fees.◦ May create bias in target allocations, affecting level of
risk for participants.
16
Permissible Conflicts in Mutual Funds
Mutual funds permitted to invest in prepackaged set of proprietary funds.◦ Mutual fund’s manager is exempt from ERISA.◦ But plan’s selection of mutual fund itself is subject to
ERISA prudence standard.◦ One or more bad underlying funds could potentially
taint mutual fund.
Custom strategies are designed to avoid conflicts.◦ Custom strategy’s manager is subject to ERISA.◦ Must not invest in any proprietary funds.
17
Fiduciary Advantages of Custom Strategies
Providers of custom strategies typically do not sponsor proprietary funds.◦ No conflict of interest.◦ Ability to select “best in breed” underlying funds.◦ Ability to replace underlying funds as necessary.◦ No conflicts in selection of underlying funds or
in determining target allocations.
18
Using Plan’s Menu of DIAs as Underlying Funds
Custom strategy can use Plan’s existing DIAs.◦ Advantage for both Model Portfolios and CIFs.◦ CIFs may also include investments not in plan menu.
Fiduciary oversight may be streamlined.◦ For plans where 3(21) or 3(38) fiduciary provides
plan menu advice.◦ Can leverage fiduciary findings for Plan’s DIAs when
considering custom strategy.◦ Consider using existing DIAs as “starting point” for
Plan’s custom solution.
19
Duty to Consider Custom SolutionsDOL Guidance on TDFs (Feb ‘13)
◦ Target Date Funds – Tips for ERISA Plan Fiduciaries◦ Mostly covered core fiduciary concepts.◦ Also advised plan fiduciaries to inquire about “custom
and non-proprietary” solutions.◦ In sum, plan sponsors and advisors should inquire
about availability of Model Portfolios and CIFs.
20
Flexibility in Investment StrategiesAdvisors can develop custom asset allocation
solutions for their plan clients.◦ Plan clients can turn to advisors for non-proprietary
alternatives.
Glide path is critical aspect of any target-date strategy.◦ May be customized to reflect advisor’s investment
philosophy.◦ Advisor can determine if strategy should glide “to” or
“through” a participant’s retirement date.
21
Cost Advantage of Custom SolutionsModel Portfolios and CIFs do not have “retail”
cost structure.◦ No 12b-1 fees.◦ Participants can enjoy “institutional” pricing.◦ No proprietary funds with excessive fees.◦ Passively-managed underlying funds may be used to
reduce costs further.◦ Small- and mid-sized plans can enjoy cost savings.
22
Fee ConsiderationsFee-related Duties Under ERISA
◦ Fees must be reasonable in light of services.◦ Excessive fees will result in fiduciary breach and
violation of ERISA’s prohibited transaction rules.
Fee for Model Portfolios◦ Fees are payable to third party fiduciary.◦ May be paid by plan sponsor or charged to plan.
23
Fee Considerations (cont’d)Fee for CIFs
◦ Cost structure is part of investment product.◦ Fees customarily reflected in “unit” value of
ownership interests in CIF.◦ Bank trustee may share its compensation with
investment firm (e.g., RIA firm).◦ No amount deducted at participant-account level.
24
Fee Disclosures for Plan Sponsor408(b)(2) Fee Disclosures for Custom Strategy
◦ Third party fiduciary must provide disclosures “reasonably in advance” of commencing services.
◦ For Model Portfolios, 408(b)(2) disclosures are included in service agreement.
◦ For CIFs, 408(b)(2) disclosures typically included in participation agreement and disclosure statement.
25
Lessons from 401(k) Fee LitigationParticipant Claims Relating to Excessive Fees
◦ Alleged that fiduciaries failed to protect participants.◦ Also alleged that retail mutual funds were used, when
cheaper institutional funds were available.
Potential Future Allegations◦ May allege that retail TDFs were used, when custom
solutions with cheaper pricing were available.◦ For liability protection, plan fiduciaries should
investigate availability of custom solutions.
26
Overview of Participant-Level Fee Disclosures
404a-5 Regulations◦ Plan sponsor must provide quarterly and annual
disclosures to participants.◦ Plan’s DIAs must be included in comparative chart.◦ Quarterly performance updates and other data for
DIAs must be posted on website.◦ Other information must be provided upon request.
27
Participant-Level Disclosures for Model Portfolios
Field Assistance Bulletin 2012-02R◦ Model portfolio is not a DIA for purposes of 404a-5
Regulations.◦ May be included in comparative chart on voluntary
basis, but not required.◦ Participant’s “individual expense” must be explained
annually and disclosed in quarterly statements.
28
Participant-Level Disclosures for CIFsRequired Disclosures
◦ CIFs are viewed as DIAs under 404a-5 Regulations.◦ Must be included in comparative chart.
Selection of Bank Trustee◦ Consider trustee’s expertise and experience in
delivering participant-level disclosures.◦ Advisors should only partner with a qualified bank
trustee.
29
QDIA DisclosuresQDIA Regulations
◦ Separate set of disclosures required for participants.◦ Rules cover both Model Portfolios and CIFs.◦ Initial notice must be provided 30 days in advance,
and annually thereafter.
Required Content for QDIA Notice◦ Default investment arrangement.◦ Participant’s right to direct investments.◦ QDIA.◦ Participant’s right to transfer out of QDIA.◦ Obtaining information about Plan’s other DIAs.
30
Concluding ThoughtsCustom solutions may include Model
Portfolios or CIFs.◦ Model Portfolios are a type of investment service. ◦ Model Portfolios are managed by investment
manager, or plan sponsor with assistance of advisor.◦ CIFs offer convenience of investment product.◦ Advisors can partner with bank trustee to develop
custom CIFs for plan clients.◦ Safe harbor protection available under QDIA rules.
31
Concluding Thoughts (cont’d)Plan fiduciary has duty to select default
investment prudently.◦ Must conduct independent investigation of QDIA, and
give appropriate consideration to relevant factors.◦ “Best in breed” funds can be used in custom strategy,
eliminating potential conflicts of interest.◦ Cheaper institutional pricing is available.◦ Plan sponsors should inquire about availability of
custom solutions to ensure compliance with ERISA.
32
Important InformationThis presentation is intended for sponsors of 401(k) plans and other types of defined contribution retirement plans with participant-directed investments that are subject to the Employee Retirement Income Security Act of 1974, as amended (ERISA), as well as the service providers that work with such plans.
This information is intended for general informational purposes only, and it does not constitute legal, tax or investment advice on the part of The Wagner Law Group or its affiliates.
Marcia S. Wagner, Esq.q.
99 Summer Street, 13th FloorBoston, MA 02110
Tel: (617) 357-5200 Fax: (617) 357-5250 Website: www.wagnerlawgroup.com
A0104060
Custom Solutions: Legal, Compliance and Disclosure