FREE ·

NEWSLETTER . - - .. --- · - ·

401 Main St, Vancouver V6A 2T7

I

MARCH 15, 2007 .

carnnews@vcn. be. ca www.carnnews.org 604-665-2289

L: .> (.., •

' . I

A drop in the bucket ... The first idea was to have a cover about Spring; a

few drawings of flowers, a broom sweeping off the dust and decay of o ld stuff to symbol ize a new start, fresh ideas, hope being kindled. But it seemed a little bit too much like a cheerleading chant for the golden ' 'good old days" which, truth be told, never were all that good.

It mirrors working people not even questioning their right to set hours, 5 days a week, coffee breaks, a living wage or good pay with vacations, maternity leave, paid s ick days and so on. But just ask any old worker about having to fight and, after fighting and even having buddies killed for forming a union, to have enough solidarity to strike for these now taken­for-granted rights.

The example refers to the stifling inertia people are up against in getting society in general to revolution­ize our economic system and make social housing an up-to-date reality. The Federal government just stopped paying for housing in 1993 and the decline in affordable housing gained momentum. Provinces stopped paying, making it more and more difficult for low-income and poor people to keep a decent, safe home.

It's become a publ ic relations exercise while the corporate and wealthy sector keep pressing to make any endeavour focused on profit above all else. The actual conditions in current low-income housing are often so dismal that only horror stories arise from disgruntled tenants. The illegality of landlord greed leaves each using various methods to get their prop­erties vacant for upgrades - ostensibly for the Olympics, but to maximize the value of the land & property for condo development, leaving people by

the hundreds either under-housed or homeless. [I 've never seen or heard of a condo for less than $200K]

The latest drop in the bucket is in a report by Ken Dobell (for which he was hired unilaterally and paid $300,000) in which the corporate and wealthy sector get to "donate" money to an endowment fund - for which they'll get huge tax exemptions- and the in­terest on this fund will be used to build housing. Do­ing the math shows that the result will be about $11 million a year. Translated, this becomes maybe 150 units a year. wow. The current need, in the lower mainland/Vancouver alone, is for at least 5000 units of all sizes a year.

Another PR thing about Dobell's report is that the call is for ' supportive' housing, meaning that you'd have to be disabled, mentally challenged, a senior and maybe even an immigrant to even be considered or put on a waiting list. The shit wages paid to such people, and the dismal welfare/pension incomes still keep from 40-70% of monthly cheques going to just keeping a shaky roof over their heads.

None of this is news and neither is anything in this report. It's another one in a long line that benefits the corporate and wealthy sector of society with profits, tax write-offs, and saddling the middle-class with the ongoing public costs. Look for a lot of cor­porate names on any units being built in this massive scam, while the Public Relations and media photo­op stories keep a lid on the hemorrhaging of home­less survivors and others left out in the cold.

Hurray for the g lobalization of greed. rah rah rah

By PAULR TAYLOR

PS: The above might read like a generic rant, but in the same room are the realities of people talking and planning to tum our ongoing defeats into victories. PPS: The opposite of fear and despair is hope. PPPS: Hope is the mother of honesty and belief. PPPPS: May the Force be with us.

'

Strippers' money not good enough By Sandra Thomas-Staff writer

Almost anyone can donate to the Breast Cancer Society of Canada -unless they take their clothes off for a living.

Local strippers who hold an annual event to raise money for cancer research were shocked this year to discover their offer to donate part of the proceeds to the society was turned down. Last year, the same group of dancers donated $3,000 to the society with­out incident.

Former stripper Trina Ricketts, an organizer with the Exotic Dancers for Cancer fundraising event, said they planned again this year to donate half of the money raised to the Breast Cancer Society, but when she contacted the society recently, she. was rejected.

In a letter to Ricketts, the society's executive direc­tor Rany Xanthopoulo, wrote: "Unfortunately we will have to decline your kind offer as we have cer­tain major donors that are not in favour of this con­nection. This decision came as a result of donor dis­gruntlement and together with the board of directors we have decided not to accept any donations from what donors consider controversial sources."

• • · • • • • • • • • [some daily]

Friday Morning Song Circle

You know, if you want to sing, or play guitar, learn some new songs, share your own or just listen, the Friday morning song circle in the [Carnegie] theatre is a great place to go. There are song books and gui­tars provided: we bring out the bass, I bring my banjo, and the two pianos and a small conga are right there for you.

The way it works is we go around the circle, and each person gets a chance to pick the song we all do. Even the listeners get to choose what comes next! There's never any pressure to join in, or drop out, for any individual tune. If you are looking for a particu­lar song, I can usually help you find a copy of it for the next session if I don't already have it. People of all abilities are very welcome, and there's generally a lot of laughter - which is always a great way to start Please come and join us every Friday morning from 10:30 to 12:30

Rachel Rosetta

....., ._)

Regarding the de over the Breast Cancer Society of Canada refusing to accept donations from the Vancouver "exotic dancers" group on "moral" grounds - the glaring fact is that other large medical associations and institutions quickly accept charita­ble donations from groups and individuals whose "morals" are much blacker and more s inister than an innocuous bunch of strippers!

For example let's look at the recent announcement by the BC Children's Hospital who happily accepted a large donation from Jimmy Pattison. Mr.Pattison, a billionaire (whom Premier Gordon Campbell calls his "idol") made some of his vast wealth from the sale of Triple-X rated porn magazines which shame­lessly exploited and degraded women for quick prof­its. Of course lots of other folks and associations (like one East Van church in particular) have readily accepted Jimmy Pattison's blood/conscience money, with no qualms what-so-ever! But then again maybe these churches and hospitals wouldn't accept any money from so sordid a group of people as exotic dancers?!

A.Hawley

April is Volunteer Recognition Month

It' s also decent for any of you reading this to write down praise and/or just thanks for one or more vol­unteers who participated in any incident deserving such in 2006-07. After that easy one, take on the task of getting it into the hot little hands of Ye Olde Carnegie Newsletter by April I 51

. .

There should be a calendar of events during the one week in April when Carnegie volunteers are espe­cially recognized in the Apri l 1 issue, mostly to ap-

• preciate the thousands of hours these people work to make the Carnegie Community Centre the most suc­cessful living room on the continent!

-----

Vancouver city council members.

It is very easy for me to sit at home in my warm townhouse and not worry about eviction notices that are going out to the people that live in the Down­town Eastside, and in particular, those currently fac­ing immediate eviction from the Picadilly buliding. It is easy to sit here and believe that someone else

will take care of it, or that these people will find an­other way, because in this blessed land and city, eve­rything is always okay. But reality gnaws at the back of my brain ..... compassion pulls at my heart strings ... and 1 have to I isten to them. If writing this letter

r----------------; r Taking It To The Streets: Street Drugs ! ! and HIV 1 t Thursday, March 22nd, 6:00 PM 1

Carnegie Centre Theatre I t

I I 1 1 Presenter: Dr. Ian Martin t Open to persons living with HIV and other inter-1 ested participants. (604) 893 2274 to RSVP. I

l I

helps anything for these people that are already liv­ing in conditions that are not even legally fit to live in, then it is worth the very small effort it takes.

I ask council to think of their own homes and their own salaries (btw ... city councillors make more money per year then i live on with my two children, and i pay a rent of $8 10 I mo and utilities are extra ... and I have ran for office before, and will run for city council in the next election probably.

As a radio-journalist with Co-op radio, being in the downtown eastside on a frequent basis, and having just completed our homelessness radio marathon ... and having done a couple of snippets of video re­garding what life on the streets are like ... I must say, that in this day and age, it is beyond my comprehen­sion that there are people facing these situations.

We have enough money to throw millions, if not billions on a big sporting event and party ... Perhaps then, we can buy a hotel complex and turn it into housing ... and on the interim, just fix up the place that currently houses these people so that they do not have to have their lives turned about face, just be­cause they are in the way of development. Which is what really seems to be occuring.

Well, that is about all I have to say. I trust in the good conscience of our council and hope you are all always warm and fed and safe.

Peace, Kelli Gallagher

TO ALL THOSE WHO GOT MARCH 1 's Carnegie News­letter with two sheets starting with Page 5 but no

sheet starting with Page 3: i.e. Pages 3, 4, 17 & 18 were missing but there were 2 each of 5, 6, 15 & 16. ALL IS NOT LOST! If you have had to suffer for the last 2 weeks not knowing what the hell you were missing, don't despair. A copy of the missing sheet is waiting for you in the Newsletter Office. Just bring 2 pieces of picture ID (one of which must be a passport) and a note from your grandmetker ...

FRIDAY AFTERNOON CONCERT Sleep, Dreams and Desire:

the Spring of Passion in Song

Join baritone singer and psychoanalyst, Dr. Cliff Ridley, with pianist, Danielle Marcinek, as they explore the deeper currents of our lives through music. Songs by the 20th century English composers Peter Warlock and E. J. Moeran are featured along with works by J.S. Bach, Gabriel Faure and the Ca­nadian composer Alexina Louie. Come and celebrate the awakening of the Easter season!

Carnegie Centre Theatre 401 Main Street

Friday, March 30 at 3 PM

God is Not an American God is not an American, but he could very well be. Neither is Christ a Canadian But it do have a nicer sound. Nowadays popular opinion is very Popular Always it was this A !ways will be ------- maybe. That pesky god question Who knows anything atall atall Pascal and his Principle appeals somewhat Though it may be just an elaborate ntellectual Cop out. (Is that one word?) A Cop out perhaps like Freud's- the recanting of his infamous Seduction Hypothesis He knew the truth but chose to keep it Wherein did the good lie? So, to this day, Jung (his spiritual , for want of a better word) Is popular among the undergrads Especially in Education Who defile Freud and, with the same breath, adore the man who stood on his shoulders ...

I was an avid acolyte of truth until I realized Not by any enlightenment But just plain old experience and age Some may deem is wisdom

a scary word dontcha think? Yeah man, duality is very tidy Nature never is. Disasters, apocalypses, holocausts are juxtaposed with beauty and order, Incredible.

Don't think about that too much. Thinking in general is overrated - like Truth Then again, thinking specifically is fine, Especially in Astronomy & Biology -The Big and the infinitesimal The whole story is not finished ,or it has been, over and over.. A Whale of a Tale!

So enough already-Theories abound - rocks & trees & skies & seas Lots of work to be done yet Keep in' us Busy Keep in' us Interested Keepin' us Sane --or what passes for it--­Keepin' us from givin' in to the simple Black and what-Orange and Green -Pink and blue - just coloured, n'est-ce pas? You say potato - I say potatoe And Mathus be darned. Mosquitoes would solve only one problem.

Nature will take care of population control It has been doing that all along Time is the key Space the final or semi-final frontier Considering the nanotech fie ld Matter can be manipulated. Democritus Democritus had an idea Maybe the first theory of atoms

but maybe not.

No one reads the old scholars in the original Sanskrit- or do they? Go figure.

Wilhelmina

I

Goodb9e m9 friend. I didn't know 9ou had gone. I had en9uired about 9ou before and was told 9ou

were fine .. or that I had just missed 9ou.

This time when I en9 ui red about 9ou, I tru l9 d id

and do miss 9ou. I am told now that 9ou passed

awa9last 9ear, onl9 a ~ew months ago.

I hadn't seen 9ou strolling along flastings Street

or sitting in figeon f ark S9uare.

I ponder whether !should've kept in closer touch

with 9ou and in9uired more tre9uentl9··· goodb.:3e.

Submitted anonymously.

The Pain of Paradox

Can you still recall when you appeared to have it all With the wind at your back, the sun in your eyes Would you have ever imagined, could you have ever realized that one day you'd Jose it all. ..

I've been there; I sympathize . . . . all swept away by a massive global locomotive. Don't bite your tongue and refuse to take the toll. We' ll rise up in numbers and become creative to harshly criticize unspeakable crimes of starvation and beings on the run - where to go, where to be, when in the sights of a humongous war machine: Industrial Complex Military created automatons, Kiler squads, desert dogs of war, quickly sinking in the shifting sands of foreign sovereign lands com­manded by decree. Who cares that millions vehe­mently and correctly disagreed .. saw through fabri­cated vicious deceptions spewed from the foul mouths of bunker busting boneheads appointed by some fixer of elections, a dumbbell who himself is wound quite tightly with a myriad of taut puppet strings pulled often and, most vigorously by the money-belted changers of plundered, illicit loot that's been ripped off, stolen and repossessed on the breaking backs of union busted, slaving, scraping minions who, in their multiplying millions, are seek­ing out a meager living of little substance and suste­nance yet much character and spiritual soil -only 'I

" have debt to pay, day by day' is not heard during Ct' budget time with millions, billions, "can I have

some? Anything for me? .. you selfish sons of guns ~ with your silver spoons. You know nothing of rags {_, and ruin and rage. You are all good at song and

dance, all singing from the same stale pages while 2to' shriekingly out of tune; hidden cash, Swiss vaults, " IMF, World Bank; steamrolling with control, power

cum hostile takeovers .. cutthroat high stakes poker but with vast stacks of house chips - pawns on the board of trade while bean counters assist in determin­ing whoever makes a gross, Olympic-size profit and keeps using the webbed shell game that's all about dehumanizing decent people's lives and eventual breaking of the close knit family. Any who dare to oppose their epic spectacle, the 14-day circus are decried while they gleefully, deceitfully, desperately care about the overflowing treasure-to-be. It's all claimed illicitly by way of blindsided robbery-from the Original People, the honest amateur garn­ers, the volunteers, the working poor with less not more- are shadily led and sucked down their unlit and obstacle-strewn, shaky, unstable yellow brick road of uneconomical excess.

Robyn Livingstone

KRIEGER'S VIEW

• ••

Homelessness Here you are without a home Sleeping on the sidewalk cold & alont=> A great big party is coming to town Not much fun when you 're so far down Lots of money to be spent But for us, not one red cent. Governments, developers & the rich don 't give a damn if we sleep in a ditch So to them I say One day soon you will have to pay. We are human beings too & deserve homes -

. . ' ...

7 •

Classicide ''for want of the price" - Pink Floyd

It takes a lifetime

for the free-market

to kill the poor.

It is murder nonetheless.

just like you. ....... ·: . -:.··-· .. ::.=/!f!f(·. ·.:. :··./://}· Are you earning a good living?

.::::_:::::.=:·: ::-·:· . . •;.__, M. Kelly .. .. ·· ·1- .• . . ..,. ............ ,:. · · .-.... .. ___ On "'-'U know who you ki lied today?

To the Editor, It's great working with Wendy on homeless issues . .....__-:.; ......,._ I was really upset at the Olympic Clock demonstra- .. , .... \>=:!: ... "-_

tion. When the young man got the mike on stage he _:. 0 .. · ·· .. yelled, "fucking cunt." How I wish he had yelled, . "Homes for the homeless" or "Homes Not Games"-<. .. . . . .. . ...... ··~ ...... anything but . · :·.:::::::- :·

As a woman I really take exception .. Our struggle is about poverty & homelessness, not "cunts".

Sheila Baxter -

Thank you to Paul the editor of the Carnegie News­letter, to all at the Carnegie Centre and to all the an­gels who appeared to lend me their hands while I was putting up my 151 solo art and poetry exhibition. The opening night was a stupendous success. The Guitar playing and singing by the lovely and tal­ented May and Rachel Davis, who has Friday morn­ing music sessions, set an ambiance of positive flow. We enjoyed lots of food, music, poetry readings and a bit of wiggling and giggling to belly dancing music and had lots of laughs. My exhibit will be up until April 14111 2007 on the 3rd floor at the Carnegie. See you there, Montana.

Stephen Belkin

Poem There's nothing funny Except that bunny Honey, it's cute The Bees have 'forgotten' Their way home What! NO HONEY Now I feel all sticky My hand's stuck in the

Bottom of the pot It won't come out I'm all stuck with sticky Goodness what am I to do? My hand has disappeared And I feel all ticky Goodness gracious me Here comes a Moose I hear its hoofs Crack the pot My hand has come loose Hay Ms. 'B' I got honey for our Cup of tea.

© Montana King

~---------------------

~ L. .

New Books Can you change the world by changing your cereal?

1 The Better World Shopping Guide (640 .73) rates everything from chocolate bars to soap to beer based

1 on the social and environmental practices of the ' companies that make them. U.S. in focus, you'll still find infonnation on many of the brands on Vancou-ver shelves. Solve it with Supplements ( 613 .28) looks at herbal and nutritional alternatives to treating disease, and how such supplements may prevent illness in the first place. Arranged by supplement and by condi­tion, you can easily look for alternative treatments or find out uses of a particular herb or supplement. Some of the ingredients are expensive, commercial supplements, but some are herbs and plants that you can find on the roadside. State of War: The Secret History of the CIA and the Bush Administration is Pul itzer Prize-winning author James Risen 's shocking account of abuses of power under George W Bush's administration. The L.A. Times called the book "damning and dismay­ing", the New York Times said it was "illuminating and disturbing."

We've also got some new ESL titles, including Speaking of Survival (428.34), which is great for new immigrants just learning how to use a bank ma-chine or find a doctor, and English Made Easy: Learning English Through Pictures (428.34).

Our third floor bookcase is damaged, so new books are in the display case in the library at the moment. Ask at the front desk of the library if you want to reserve one (or more) of them . Computer Down T ime Carnegie's computers will not be available between 6pm Saturday, March 24 and 12pm Sunday March 25 because of upgrading work.

Thanks to Mark for all his work while I was on mat leave. It's good to be back.

Beth, your librarian.

,Aeuopolitan Concert BaiJtl Repertoire will include a wide variety of music: Broad­way, classics, marches, ballads, jazz, movie themes ...

Come and enjoy the big band sound! Wednesday, March 21st

7:30PM . in Carnegie Theatre

In Memoriam, Gayle Robinson, May 1953 - February 2007

I still can't believe you' re gone Your smile recalled the morning dawn I look for you in every place In people, I search for your face

I wish I could see you once more I wish it were still like before We were going to exchange rings Now I yearn for the peace Spring brings

Now all I have left is just hope It' s difficult for me to cope Once inseparable lovers We who remain turn to others

There's solace in life immortal That is the saving of us all Knowing that with God's love you' re one Something you fought hard for and won

I treasure each moment I saw There is no unforgiving fl aw Some day we will be together And we' l1 stay that way forever

Rolf Auer (My fi rst poetry in over 10 years.

Gayle was my partner)

Carnegie Community Action Project (CCAP) Newsletter

March 15, 2007 I

CCAP Volunteers warn Burns Block buyers of hidden costs

Last week, CCAP volunteers went to the Holiday Inn on Broadway to give residential hotel buyers a warning. Jean made a great flyer for us to give to the Bums Block (18 W Hastings) auction goers. It said they'd have to pay a $15,000 fee per hotel room to demolish it or convert it to condos. And that Peter Ladner said in council on Feb 13 , 2007 that: "We don't want these buildings converted unless we can come up with one for one replacement." We wanted them to understand that they are causing homelessness and choose not to buy.

CCAP volunteers were asked to leave the auction but we managed to pass on our message as buyers waited for the

elevator. The hotel sold to a group of

~rdtl.Oit:.. ffDV}t~f no+ ~ttdos . -

North Shore Developers for $1.4 million. Chester, the City TV reporter watched the sale and told us the realtor was very disappointed by the sale amount. Regardless, the former owner of the Burns Block made $900,000 profit. Remember, this was the owner who cashed his tenants pay-cheques the day before they were evicted for a fire escape that was nailed shut.

1

The day of the auction, while taping warning signs to the windows below the Bums Block (W. Hastings),

I chatted with a formerly evicted tenant. He said he it took him 3 months to find a home. Living on the street was a better option than the shelter. He said PIVOT is still helping him sue for his stolen rent. - Wendy Pedersen

•

3 More Hotels give EVICTION Notices P&JRally to Buy Hotels!

Terrible news to pass on. Two weeks ago, the Carl Rooms (57 5 E Hastings) gave tenants notice to move out. Yesterday, we heard 2 more hotels have tenants with the notices too. The names of these hotels will be withheld until confinned. Where are these tenants expected to go?

To respond, CCAP is hosting a PUBLIC RALLY in front of the Carl Rooms next Monday, March 19 at 11 :00 a.m.

There will be sandwiches, a choir and MP Jenny Kwan will attend and take our demands back to the Provincial Legislature. Here is the message CCAP wants Kwan to take back: Use the Housing Budget's $250 million to buy all the DTES hotels. Hold people in place until full replacement housing dollars come in. Non-profits will do a better job managing and maintaining hotels in the meantime. Failure to do this will condemn thousands more of our neighbours to the streets. ---Wendy Pedersen

Build 3200 units of housing; lease or acquire 800 more before Olympics,

says diverse group A group of government, community,

and developer representatives has come up with good recommendations for what should be done to meet the housing commitments made by provincial, federal and city governments and the Olympic Organizing Committee. Before Vancouver "won" the 2010 Olympics, the 4 Olympic partners made 5 housing commitments:

•

• •

•

•

3

Provide an affordable housing legacy and start planning now; Protect rental housing stock; Provide many alternative forms of temporary accommodation for Games' visitors and workers; Ensure people are not made homeless as a result of the Garnes; Ensure residents are not involuntarily displaced, evicted or face unreasonable

( (lJvrh ~ued ot~~ N.J.- yx~ e)

I I

•

#

' e

~ Soon

511? f.. lAos \ S @\1 · '-JV"'Il

•

' d~

, ~

.., • ~<:; A ?rt~

A wf Jv\e?S~G t~ i\t)c 'P (oVi\t\~1 GCNl W.ll\ tt ~~

a& A' iofi

-2-

increases in rent as a result of the Games. Representatives of 25 groups, including

the Carnegie Community Action Project then formed the Inner City Inclusive (ICI) Committee Housing Table and can1e up with 25 recommendations to meet the commitments, including these:

• Build 3200 units of new affordable, mostly supportive housing;

• Lease or acquire 800 rental units; • End the barriers to getting on social

assistance like the 3 week wait, the online orientation, the 2-year independence rule, employment plans and the requirement for more than one appointment to complete an application;

• Increase social assistance rates by at least 50% and allow earning exemptions. Twenty-three of 25 recommendations

made by the group, including the ones listed above, were unanimous. This is astounding, given that some people on the committee represented BC Housing, the city, the federal government, the Urban Developers Institute, and the Apartment Owners and Managers Association.

The two recommendations that were not unanimous were for a moratorium on closure and conversion of hotels and rooming houses, and for changes to the

4

Residential Tenancy Act that would give more rights to tenants.

While the report was supposed to be released officially in the first week of March, it was instead leaked to the press and was the lead story in the Vancouver Sun that week. As of March 12, it still had not been released officially, leading some of us to speculate that the governments involved didn't like the recommendations their own staff had agreed to.

I think the report and its relatively strong recommendations are significant because it shows that a broad range of people know that ending homelessness is an urgent priority for Vancouver residents, and are not afraid to say it. Hurray for the government reps at the table who agreed to what their own governments are refusing to funq or change! And thanks to Dave Eby of Pivot for convincing CCAP not to boycott the committee. Now all we have to do is get governments to fund the report 's recommendations.

To see the entire report, go to http://raycam.vcn.bc.ca/20 10 inner­city inclusivity housing table or come to the CCAP office at Carnegie. --Jean Swanson ·

City report wants 1500 new units funded and 500 acquired or leased

A $300,000, 54 page glossy report for the city is recommending that a limited partnership and private foundation be set up to raise $60 million to build 1500 units of new supportive housing for homeless people. The report, by Ken Debell and Don Fairbairn, also wants the city to acquire 500 hotel and rooming house rooms in the Downtown Eastside and run them for 1 0 years.

The good thing about the report is that is recognizes urgent action is needed to deal with homelessness. But even implementing this report would require a commitment of about $48 million from the province for operating costs. The province hasn't agreed to or budgeted for this yet.

The Debell/Fairbairn report doesn' t deal with saving the Downtown Eastside from gentrification because it recommends building on city sites that are mostly outside the DE. It also doesn't deal with meeting the Olympic commitments as it will take more than 2000 units to end homelessness and make up for all the hotels that are being closed.

The report also recommends that people who donate to supportive housing

5

receive a larger tax break than people who donate to other charities? ls this what we really want? Is the report recommending a sort of food bank approach to housing when we need a big government commitment and a human rights approach instead? Will it take

-- ----- ----- --

pressure off government to fund housing or (as some city staff seem to think) put pressure on government to fund? While the report wants transition housing to be built, there is nothing in it ab_out what people who leave the transition housing will be able to move to. It recommends "pod" housing where people have 1 room and share a kitchen and bathroom.

On March 13th, city council is expected to approve a recommendation to spend 2 months consulting people in the community about the report. - Jean Swanson

•

-- ----~------------

Province's $250 million housing endowment plan may be an opportunity

In last month's budget the provincial government set aside $250 million for a housing endowment fund. They expect the fund to generate $1 0 million a year to be spent on "innovative" housing projects.

But, as Pivot Legal Society points out in its Cracks in the Foundation report, homelessness is costing government between $10.3 and $15.5 million a year. It would be cheaper, to say nothing of more hmnane, for the government to just

6

spend the $250 on housing, rather than collect interest on it and spend millions on services for the homeless!

In a report to city council the director of the city's Housing Centre, Cameron

CCAP Volunteers Plan for the rally

Gray, says this provincial proposal is "disappointing and perplexing." Gray says the $250 million would be enough to build housing on all 12 sites the city owns and has set aside for affordable housing. --Jean Swanson

Your Rights in the Downtown Eastside

What if you are homeless and can't get on welfare?

What if your landlord is trying to get rid of you?

Can your landlord raise your rent because of the new welfare shelter increase?

Tuesday, March 20 10:30 to noon

Carnegie Theatre, Hastings and Main On S~~e Child-minding

Muffins and Coffee I _. • •

Advice from:

DERA PIVOT

Carnegie Action BCPIAC

TRAC

7

•

I I I

1 '

, , . •

If •

0 •

Why won't the province and feds spend money on housing?

With report after report telling them its cheaper to house people than leave them in the streets, why are the provincial and federal governments refusing to spend the money needed to end the homeless crisis? They have billions in surpluses. The province is expected to have a surplus over $3 billion this year and next and the feds are expected to have $75 billion over the next 5 years according to the Canadian Centre for Policy Alternatives. Polls say that homelessness and affordable housing are the biggest issue in Vancouver and that voters are willing to pay more taxes to solve the problem.

I can only think of a couple of reasons these governments won ' t spend what' s needed on housing: they don' t believe

8

in public housing as a matter of ideology; or, they want to maintain the scarc.ity of housing so that apartment owners and builders will be able to

£,' ... . . . . . I .... ' :

I "1 •

I

l~'f iJ,It.t.j • . . .

- . . -~ -.. . . ~ - .... -. - . - --- ~:: .;,~ .

:-- ·- . - ----~~ --·-

1• ,--.... __ ~--.1,. •• -

~ ... ~ :::.--.··:.:--~

-, . . ' . . . ~ ~ . .. •

• l :

' -• •

charge higher rents. Anyone out there got any better ideas? --Jean Swanson CCAP is generously funded by:

Vanci "Support for this project does not necessarily imply Vancity's endorsement of the findings or contents of this report."

The Wind and the Stars

The dark and threatening afternoon sky matched the somber mood of the campground near Youbou on Vancouver Island where Jean and I had pitched our tent. "These ancient maple trees and thick ever­greens create a world of shadows," Jean said.

"Shadows that move with the wind and the flicker­ing light of Cowichan Lake," I added.

"The ferns are tall here, and moss hangs from every tree," Jean said. "Rain and sunlight," I said, " and the sound of waves

on a pebble beach." The sun appeared from behind a bank of clouds, and

streams of light entered the dark woods. A small evergreen burst into gold, and shimmered in the warm light. "A golden tree," Jean said. "Tree of fire," I said. "Goddess of poetry, goddess of the hearth." Then the light faded, and the vision was gone. We had seen it, though. "The first Christmas tree," Jean said.

In the nightthe wind blew stronger. It blew the clouds away, and stars appeared. "The stars are beautiful ," Jean said, "but the sound of trees falling in the wind is not beautiful."

"I agree, but I th ink we are safe at this campsite" I said. " I hope so," Jean replied . The wind whistled and roared. It sounded like a freight train coming. We could hear some of the o ld maple trees crashing down. " Maybe we should move away from this campground,' ' Jean said.

Jean: Sandy: Jean: Sandy: Jean: Sandy: Jean: Sandy:

" Where could we goT ' I asked. " We could find a fi eld somewhere." " In the middle of the night?'' " It 's not midnight yet." " Maybe the wind will d ie down." " Maybe it will get stronger.~'

"Some of the other campers are staying." "And others are leaving." "A tree could fall across the road:'

Jean: "A good reason to leave now.'· Then there was a huge crash close to our campsite.

The falling tree took smaller trees with it. and a thin sapling hit the front of our truck. It didn ' t do any damage, but its message was clear: " Get out of here while you st ill can." We grabbed our s leeping bags and a tarpaulin to put on the ground, and jumped into the truck. I drove slowly on the narrow cam p­ground road, and prayed that all would be well.

We reached the main road, and turned in the direc­tion ofYoubou. "Now what?" I asked. "We'll fi nd a place," Jean said.

And we did find a place. We found the Youbou baseball park, and we put our tarpaulin and sleeping bags between first base and second base. The wind, which had died down a little, had blown all the clouds away, and we could see more stars than we could ever see from the city. " We'll be safe here,'' Jean said. " I hope so," I replied.

" I see the seven stars of the Big Dipper," Jean said. "The seven grandfathers," I said . "Say thank you to the grandfathers," Jean said.

"There 's a shooting star," Jean said, "and there's another." " Yes," I said, and then I added, "We are made of stardust, you know." "Yes, I know," Jean said. "That makes us children of the universe."

"First Nations people use the expression 'A ll my relations' at the end of some of their ceremonies."

We watched the stars and listened to the silence of the night. Then the automatic sprinkler system clicked on, and the ball park became a fountain of water glistening in starlight.

Sandy Cameron

You may have heard talk about the success of deal­ing with homelessness in New York City, but this article from the NY T imes suggests otherwise-

Homeless Families in City Shelters Hit Record, Despite the Mayor's Efforts

By TRYMAINE LEE The number of homeless families living in New

York City shelters reached a record high last month, halfway into the Bloomberg administration's five­year plan to reduce homelessness by two-thirds, ac­cording to a report released yesterday by an advo­cacy group using city figures.

Last month 's total, 9,287 families, was the highest s ince the city started keeping and publicly releasing

. ~ ...... , . .. ·- .. ... . ' ... ·111..., ~ .. .., ,,....,. La~ · · I··· ro'\!. ~· · - ·• ........... -JLr.··.,..,. "'!' . ··" ·•: 'fltJ&~ IT- .. '""' "' ,. ... , . .. . :~ ') . . .. . . . ' ~JL&.·t ·. "'<!· .- :1'/ .. · . ' : .....

~··~ :{ . . f .:' . '1lla'f W.$ .. . '"·· . . ~~tUA'AH ' .~I ·~·~I . • • •

f. ~lfT4 . .. .. ; . :=t~~ I' . ' --~C'~ . n.~-~

such figures in 1979, according to the group, the Coalition for the Homeless. When Mayor Michael R. Bloomberg announced his plan on homelessness in August 2004, the number of homeless families was 8,850 and his goal was to lower that to 7,400 by this point. The data also showed that while more homeless

famil ies were seeking refuge in city shelters, the number being moved into permanent housing fell last year by 1 I percent compared with 2005. The report comes at a time when the amount of

housing affordable to low-income residents contin­ues to shrink and the gap between average income and rent continues to grow, advocates for the home­less said.

In preparing its report, the coalition used figures from the city's Department of Homeless Services. The agency did not dispute the data or the findings, but an agency spokeswoman said that the mayor' s plan was a work in progress and that it might need to be adjusted.

The spokeswoman, Tanya Yalle-Batista, also ac­cused the coalition of being more interested in seek­ing publicity than helping address the problem. "While the rest of the nonprofit community is work-

ing with the city to address these issues, the coalition

continues its opportunistic efforts to generate head­lines," Ms. Vaile-Batista said in a statement.

The figures show that the city should rethink its strategy to move people into permanent hous ing, the coalition said. Much of that strategy focuses on a city program started in 2004 that replaced many of the federally subsidized housing programs that had been used to shift homeless welfare recipients into permanent housing.

But a little more than two years into the plan, the number of homeless in shelters is up nearly across the board, exceeding 35,000. In February 2006, ac­cording to the report, the total number of homeless New Yorkers in shelters was 31,472 and rose 11.1 percent to 35,252 by last month, according to the report. The number of homeless families in February 2006 was 7,805, ris ing 17.6 percent to 9,287 by last month, the report said. The number of homeless children in February 2006 was 11,925, and went up 18.1 percent by last month, to 14,287. The one piece of good news cited by the report was

a decline last year, for the second year in a row, in single adults living in shelters.

Patrick Markee, senior policy analyst for the Coali­tion for the Homeless, said flaws in the mayor's program, called Housing Stability Plus, kept it from meeting its goals. "The flaws in the mayor's pro­gram have clearly made it hard for families in shel­ters to get safe and affordable housing," he said.

One major problem, he said, js the 20 percent annual reduction in housing subsidies, which is intended to encourage participants to find better-paying jobs. "This is a subsidy program that cuts the value of the housing subsidy by 20 percent each year, regardless of a family's circumstance," Mr. Markee said. " It serves as a work disincentive, anp effectively pro­hibits families from gaining employment income because that would cut them from welfare."

As a result, Mr. Markee said, some participants' jobs exclude them from being eligible for welfare. In the meantime, their hous ing subsidies are cut, leav­ing them unable to pay rent and, often, sending them back into shelters ..

The Department of Homeless Services is planning to make adjustments in its housing subsidy program, Ms. Vaile-Batista said. She said the coalition ' s find­ings on homeless families were accurate, but noted that, unlike other large cities, New York defines

I I

------

families as including single parents and couples with no children. She also said that the rise of homeless people in shelters meant, in one sense, that the city was doing its job by not turning people away.[!!]

Arnold S. Cohen, president and chief executive of Partnership for the Homeless, said that rather than simply being critical of the mayor, the coalition' s findings highlight the growing inequality in NYC. "This is the story about the other New York," he said, "another city of unimaginable poverty. I don ' t think we should ever look at this as a failure. This is an opportunity to learn from our past."

Forwarded by Susan Henry First Uni ted Church Mission

Remembering Harriett Nahanee- Reclaiming our Sacred Space, and Holding the Criminals Accountable

One of my proudest moments with Harriett Nahanee happened on a Sunday morning in Van­couver's downtown eastside, on November 16, 2003. On that day, Harriett led a score of aboriginal youth into an Anglican mass and took over that worship service, raising general hell among the shocked stuffed shirts who run St. James Anglican Church.

At the time, it seemed that the issue that led us to occupy that church for awhile was the dead and dis­appeared chi ldren ofthe Indian Residential Schools: the 100,000 souls whose fate and remains have never been accounted for by either the Anglicans or the Catholics or United Church. But later, it became clearer to me that Harriett was really reclaiming a place stolen by my culture, and reasserting the sa­credness of her peoples' way in the face of the very state religion that had tried to stamp it out.

It all started innocuously enough. A few of us thought it was time to confront the churches that had run the residential schools on their own turf, and Harriett happened to be within earshot. And so, in her usual manner, she dispensed with debate and took direct action: she began walking up and down east Hastings street on that Sunday morning, collect­ing our people in the ones and twos. Soon, we were a small army: uncertain, wary of what might happen, but led by Harriett's firm steps.

It's great when you catch the Beast napping, and occasionally you can surprise It by doing the unex­pected. Unlike nowadays, there were no security guards at the door of St. James Anglican Church that morning, and the twenty six of us poured into the sanctuary in the midst of the morning mass. fanning out into the throng of hymn singers, our group in­stinctively headed to the front of the church, where two robed priests were so engrossed in leading their multitude that they didn't seem to notice the bunch of scruffy Indians and assorted poor folks who took up position around the pulpit and communion table.

They were completely shocked. One of the priests actually stood with his mouth open, gaping at Harriett as she approached the pulpit. His colleague quickly motioned to the organist to continue playing, and the confused congregation kept singing the same

final verse over and over. The clerical machine started to hiss and sputter.

I stood at the back of the church, recording all that ha~pen~d, and from there I saw the older priest whispermg something to Harriett, who kept shaking her head. Later, she told me that he had said that we coul? all go to jail for two years for disrupting their service. (That's no lie, either: check out Section 176 of the Criminal Code of Canada). Harriett ignored the threat and literally seized the pulpit.

"This is. the place from where your people con­quered mme, and destroyed our religion. So now I'm going to use this place to take back our religion and our land.

"You're always telling us how we're the ones who need healing. But you're the people who are sick and who need healing, not us. You are the ones who murdered innocent children and who still refuse to say where you buried them. You need real healing and we're the only people who can give it to you ' because you tried to destroy us. But we're still h~re and so I've come to offer you that healing." ' That kind of turning-of-the-tables was too much for

the he~d P~!est, who quickly interrupted Harriett by declanng, !h~ Anglican Church has acknowledged the wrongs It did towards First Nations people and has begun a comprehensive healing program. We have apologized for the residential schools and ... " A sudden cry arose from the back of the church

close to me: "How do you apologize to a corpse?~' yelled one of the non-native protestors. "How do you say sorry to a murdered child?" And then all hell broke loo.se .. A general outcry arose from the white

.. ,...,....

folks in the pews, who began to call us all sorts of nasty names. A guy at the door started screaming into a cell phone, "Red! Code Red! Call the police!"

None of that fazed Harriett. With great dignity, she stayed put in the pulpit and kept trying to speak. But the older priest, tired of civility, started shoving her away, and a few of the younger native men moved to her defense. Some of the others in our group kept leaning non-chalantly against the front altar, smiling at all the chaos.

Suddenly, Harriett emerged from the maelstrom, gathering all of us in her wake, and leading our army out of the church as the insults and screams rained down on us. We left the building before the cop cars· arrived - all four of them - and our triumphant throng marched down east hastings street together. We were elated. We had made our statement re-

' claimed what had been stolen, and turned the tables on the criminals. And it was mostly due to Harriett. A triumph like that can never be re-created. It's true

that since then, we've basked in the knowledge that after our protest, the Anglicans hired a regular batch of security guards to monitor everyone coming into their churches in Vancouver. The sense of finally being noticed, of having an impact on the normally dead order of things, has always stayed with us since that beautiful day when people with so little made a powerful church become very afraid. And that seed will continue to grow and bear even stronger fruit.

But what I mostly carry with me from that day is the memory of a completely unafraid woman, tor­tured as a child by the very people she offered heal­ing to, and thereby showing the official Christians what Jesus really meant, and lived. Harriett was Christ for me that day, and Buddha, and the Great Spirit: the voice of truth ringing in ears clogged by corruption and babble. It's a voice that still speaks to me today, and to anyone who will listen. They haven't killed Harriett Nahanee at all. Don't

believe that judicial murder, or pneumonia, or a cross, ever silences the just souls among us. May they, and may Harriett, continue to make us restless and move us to act. '

...................... by Kevin Annett I Eagle Strong Voice Author's Note: You can see Harriett Nahanee in our new, award-winning documentary film on Geno­cide in Canada entitled UNREPENTANT Info: www. hiddenfromhistory. org .

l ~ .

I

• _,

I'M CRYIN6 DRYTEAQS

My child within weeps rain but I'm crying dry tears I'm crying dry tears, child within screams and fears He fears I ' ll never hold his hand and I'll become lost again When I'm lost in intoxication he cries and weeps in pain, My childhood stood still. I stopped growing 'cause I'm crying dry tears. I' m crying dry tears even though I was kicked, punched and became deaf in both ears.

My deafness was no accident: It came as a result of Indian Residential School abuse. Phyical, mental, emotional abuse. They didn't care about the nature of violence they used. The hurt, the pain, the shame stabs my heart, yet, still, I'm crying dry tears. I'm crying dry tears. Oh! Why can 't it spill like rain after 47 years? Perhaps it's because something/someone evil held my baby teardrops back ... It was them of the Indian Residential School. Oh! Imp, you were dressed in black. You! You! You were the one who took me away and never brought me back. I'm crying dry tears. I cannot forget what happened after all these years. What happened is unspeakable! I bite my tongue. That's why I'm crying dry tears. Lawyers, Prosecutors, Judges, etc. are cashing in on me for the last five years, They make big bucks through my litigation for my childhood of suffering; that's why I'm crying dry tears ..

All my relations, William Arnold Coombes

WANTED Artwork for the Carnegie Newsletter

• Small illustrations to accompany articles and poetry

• Cover art - Maximum size: 17cm (6-3/4") wide x 15 em (6'') high

• Subject matter relevant to issues pertaining to the Downtown Easts ide is preferred, but all work wi ll be considered.

• Black and white printing only • Size restrictions must be considered (i.e., if

your piece is too large, it will be reduced and/or cropped to fit)

• All artists will receive credit for their work. • Originals will be returned to the artist after

being copied for publication. • Renumeration: Carnegie volunteer tickets.

Please make submissions to: Paul Taylor, Editor Carnegie Newsletter

From Northwest BC to Carnegie Hall

I would like to extend appreciation and thanks to Carnegie centre on Main at Hastings (DTES); the atmosphere is relaxed, as opposed to the outer areas of the downtown eastside. There, in Carnegie, I find a reciprocal exchange of respect, and a community of people that cares. The programs and services, arts & education & recreational activities and functions make this a very unique establishment in 'The Hub' of Vancouver.

Anywhere outside of the hub is segregated and has an atmosphere of mistrust with an ingredient of in­tellectual bias, and extreme negative reactions from the so-called upper-middle class standards & values of the morally civilized people, people who veer around a problem or situation with people in need, rather than giving a helping hand.

In a meeting that suggests much of what your col­umnist points out regarding Mike McCardell' s Global TV report, we see the problem of segregation because of the negative perspective of these 'so­called' upper-class citizens defining the DTES as "slums, the ghetto, the skids, Skid Row." This three­prong perspective of the downtown eastside is sup­posed to depict the so-called upper-class citizens as people with moral standards vs. the stigma of cor­ruptible people? A big question that arises out of this is: "How do you define moral standards?" and an equal question on "the definition of community?"

I have a very strong sense that government agen­cies are going through an intellectual maze of ana­lysts, ones that supposedly define the psychological aspects of the people, generally, the populations that have introspective concepts of others they (the learned community) believe are urban DP's. This concept projects a community within a community displaced because of lower standards within the ur­ban communities, with questions as to why? and how did this come to pass?

Some of the interpretations become conclusive de­terminations from the academic community to the government, supposedly assisting the government in making positive decisions that w ill affect the com­munity as a whole . .. but the result is displacement, homelessness, lack of support, economic depriva­tion, poverty, lack of community standards.

It is unbelievable that scholars and intellectuals wi ll

conclude in many cases that there is 'ethnic con­tamination' which, to us, projects outright Racism! In this case I would challenge or suggest that the people on the downtown easts ide begin to collec­tively and actively clean up the streets, repatriate historic buildings, and expose the ' Hearts' of the Downtown Eastside community. This will result in a greater understanding of a real community.

There is heritage funding available that does not have to be transferred to other so-called upper-class communities.

This could prove to be a brand new beginning, en­hancing community involvement, building confi­dence and unity. It 's about time for a facelift of the deteriorating heritage structures and "Who you gonna call ... hey?" for the replenishment of a vi­brant and 'people with a heart' community upgrade? Of course the people within this part of town can

and will make it a good place of and for community and have enhanced commercial activities prior to the 2010 Olympics games.

Be encouraged to collectively make a stand to save the original 'core of Vancouver' and include work­shops with the community of the downtown eastside with no discrimination as to the make-up of the community. This will prove that without ethnic big­otry of upper-class citizens, the community of the downtown Eastside will flouri sh, so don't worry about giving someone a true welcome as the com munity does here at the Carnegie Centre.

Lloyd Austin Gitxsan Wetsuwet'en

- ---- - -

pOWNTOWN EASTSIDE YOUTH ACTIVITIES SOCIETY

NEEDLE EXCHANGE VAN- 3 Routes:

~

604-685-6561 City - 5:45pm - 11 :45pm

-r

Overnight - 12:30am -8:30am Downtown Eastside- 5:30pm - 1:30am

612 Main Street 604-251-3310

,... ~

- (C

t' •

NEWSLETTER

THIS NEWSU! I I ER IS A PUBLIC A TION OF TI IE CARNEGIE COMMUNITY CENTRE ASSOCIATION

Articles represent the views of individual contributors and not of the Association

2007 DONATIONS Libby D.-$100 Rolf A.-$50 Barry for Dave McC-$125 Christopher R.-$30 Margaret D.-$40 Penny G.-$50 Janice P.-$30 Wes K.-$50 Gram-$400 John S.-$60 Leslie S.-$20 Michael C.-$80 Sheila 8.-$20 Wilhelmina M.-$15 CEEDS -$50 Saman -$20 Phyllis L.-$200 Paddy -$125 Bob S.-$100 Barry M.-$125

•

"The job of the newlpaper is to comfort the af­flicted and afflict the comfortable."

· The famous quote is about a hundred years old and can be traced to the work of Finley Peter Dunne, one of the great journalists of the day

Editor: PauiR Taylor •

-------------------· · ~n the Life Cycle: Backpedaling like crazy!

· The most unfair thing about life is the way it ends. I mean, life is tough. It takes up a lot of your time­and what do you get at the end of it?

, A death. What's that, a bonus?

. I think the life cycle is all backwards. You should start out dead; get it out of the way.

1 You wake up in an old age home, feeling better

·every day. You eventually get kicked out for being

Submission deadline for next Issue: ~ ,; too healthy and go collect your pension. " When you're too young to be retired any more, you

Thursday, March 29

Jenny WaiChing Kwan MLA

~~~~itnilW get a job - and on your first day they give you a gold Centre watch.

You' ll work 40 years until you're young enough to enjoy your retirement You're promiscuous, you drink alcohol, you party -so that you'll know all the pitfalls and can be more responsible when you get to high school. You end high school as a freshman and get to make fun of all the seniors who are j ust starting. You go to primary school, you become a kid, you play, you have no responsibilities.

~ .

You become; a baby, and then get to spend your last nine months floating peacefully with all the luxuries of a fivestar hotel.. .- central heating, spa, room ser­vice on tap, and larger quarters everyday.

Working for You 1070-1641 Commercial Dr VSL JYJ

Phone: 775-0790 Fax: 775-0SRI

And fi nally you finish off as an orgasm. Doesn't this make more sense?

- on the web, from comedian Sean Morey !Submitted by Ms Kelly]